# The Creepiest Cases of People Disappearing | Part 13

An episode of [Scary Interesting Podcast](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1705969819), 10 Apr 2024, 23 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/59390278/the_creepiest_cases_of_people_disappearing_part_13.mp3

On July 6th, 1940, a man was fishing on a Lake infamous in the mountains of Washington state. As he drifted along in his boat, he saw some sort of figure in the water. When he got closer, it looked to be something wrapped in a blanket. Then, when he reached in to grab whatever it was, he immediately recoiled in horror. What he just felt was unmistakably a human limb. These are the creepy disappearances and legends around Lake Crescent. Ambient Songs: "The End is Coming" by CoAg https://www.youtube.com/@co.agmusic1823 Intro Theme by Swift Junai: https://www.instagram.com/swiftjunai/?hl=en https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC6hf5nMJ8s6LJJfFR4OQ3lg https://open.spotify.com/artist/1PoG2b18MHocWZA8zQgWjO Writing and research of story 1 and 2 by Jay Adams: https://instagram.com/jayadamsdigital?igshid=MzMyNGUyNmU2YQ== Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/scary-interesting-podcast--5945096/support.

## Transcript

[0:00] On July sixth, nineteen forty, a man was fishing on a lake infamous
[0:04] in the mountains of Washington State. As he drifted along, he saw some
[0:08] sort of figure in the water. When he got closer, it looked as
[0:11] though it was something wrapped in a blanket. Then when he reached in to
[0:15] grab whatever it was, he immediately recalled in horror what he just felt was
[0:20] unmistakably a human limb. These are the creepy disappearances and legends around Lake Crescent.
[0:26] As always, viewer discussion is advised. There's something about lakes in the
[0:40] mountains, at least from the perspective of someone used to lakes on the East
[0:43] Coast. On the East Coast, the experience is very different. The lakes
[0:47] get far warmer in the summer and are often shallower. They're typically not at
[0:51] elevation, and the flow of water ends them isn't from glaciers and meltwater high
[0:55] above. Maybe the most visually striking thing, however, is that the water
[0:59] is so crystal clear in many of these mountain lakes. In fact, to
[1:03] really put the snow perspective, water clarity is measured by taking a black and
[1:06] white disk and lowering it into the water, and then measuring how far down
[1:08] it's still visible. Crater Lake in Oregon was measured to have a visibility of
[1:12] one hundred and thirty nine feet or forty two meters. This makes it the
[1:17] clearest anywhere on Earth. So at the shore of many of these mountain lakes
[1:21] you can look down and see the bottom as extends away from the shore for
[1:23] far longer. You can also see many of the massive similers, boulders,
[1:27] and fallen trees as outlines in the darkness below. For the same reason that
[1:33] many people have philosophobia in the ocean, the experience is similar. Many of
[1:37] these lakes were also gouged up by glaciers during the Last Ice Age, making
[1:41] them far deeper than you expect from their surface area. So similar to how
[1:45] the mountains rise around the lakes, they continue below the surface for hundreds,
[1:48] sometimes thousands of feet. That brings us to Lake Crescent. Inside Olympic National
[1:53] Park in Washington State, you'll find Lake Crescent, a lake that was once
[1:57] a deep, dry glacier foaming valley. Around eight thousand years ago, a
[2:01] massive landslide from the Olympic Mountains damned Indian Creek and as more and more water
[2:06] accumulated behind the wall of rock and forced to breathe, it began to spill
[2:08] into the valley. The lake has a measure depth of six hundred and forty
[2:12] eight feet or one hundred ninety eight meters, making it the second deepest in
[2:15] Washington. Its waters are also uncommonly clear too. Peering into the lake from
[2:20] a dock or boat, you can see deeper at Lake Crescent than just about
[2:23] any other body of fresh water in the United States. The Native Americans,
[2:27] who lived in the area much earlier had a different story to explain how Lake
[2:30] Crescent came to be. The story goes that two rivaled tribes had been battling
[2:34] for three days when the fighting disturbed the seat Coat living high above in the
[2:38] valley. In Native American lore from the region, the seat Coat is essentially
[2:40] what is more commonly known as Bigfoot, a large bipedal human like crypti the
[2:46] tribes used as one of their many gods. On top of a mountain called
[2:49] Storm King. The Secu became angry at the war going on below, so
[2:52] it broke off part of the mountain summit and tossed it into the valley.
[2:55] The massive boulder crushed the warriors and in the battle, and also damning the
[2:59] river, which then produced Lake Crescent. As a result of so many of
[3:02] their dead forever buried under hundreds of feet of water, tribes stayed away from
[3:06] Lake Crescent. This was the origin of a reputation the lake received that persists
[3:09] today, which is that Lake Crescent never gives up its dead. The legend
[3:14] says that the spirits of the Native Americans killed by the sea coat dragged to
[3:17] the bottom and hold captive anyone who dies in the lake. On July sixth,
[3:22] nineteen forty, freda Immenroth was enjoying a peaceful summer day in the lake
[3:25] in his boat with a line in the water. He patiently waited for a
[3:29] bite before snagging a fish and battling with it until he hauled it on board.
[3:32] Fred was in a hidden cove in the lake that surrounded by a tall
[3:35] sheer cliff, and as he got set to cast again, something just below
[3:38] the surface caught its attentionion He couldn't tell what it was, so he moved
[3:42] his boat closer to get a better look. It looked like a blank was
[3:45] wrapped around something, but he still couldn't identify it, so he reached into
[3:46] the water. He then immediately recalled when he grabbed what felt like a human
[3:52] limb beneath the blanket. He then gathered himself and, summoning all his strength,
[3:55] pulled the water log form onto his boat and unwrapped part of it.
[4:00] Inside was the body of a woman that was almost perfectly preserved. The face
[4:03] had become nothing but skull, but the rest of the body was in good
[4:06] condition. At the same time, it was easy to tell that she'd been
[4:10] under water for some time, and it was abundantly apparent that she was a
[4:13] victim of foul play. Wrapped tightly around her throat, waist, and ankles
[4:16] was a length of rope, the end of which appeared to be frayed.
[4:20] Fred's discovery made history. He had just pulled the first body ever recovered from
[4:25] Lake Crescent onto his boat. He then brought the woman into the dock and
[4:29] called the police, who hurried over to begin the investigation into who the wind
[4:31] was and why she was in the lake. At autopsy, the medical examiner
[4:35] determined that the woman died of strangulation, but not by the rope. They
[4:39] were clear bruises on her neck that could have only been caused by human fingers.
[4:43] She looked to be around thirty five years old, but that was as
[4:46] much Zeca glean from the examination of the body. Since the woman's face was
[4:49] gone from the lengthy time the body spent underwater, facial recognition wasn't possible.
[4:55] Initially, it was believed that the woman was Mary and Francis Stevens, a
[4:58] woman from Chicago who disappeared in National Park in nineteen thirty nine. Based on
[5:01] what Maren was said to have been wearing, the body seemed like a match
[5:04] except for one large issue. Maren was known to have fractured her neck in
[5:09] the past, but the body pulled from Lake Crescent showed no signs of any
[5:12] past neck injury. So next the medical examiner collected dental records of missing women
[5:15] from the air and set about to find a match. Afterward, it didn't
[5:18] take long to determine that the body belonged to a thirty five year old named
[5:23] Halle Illingworth. Halle was a waitress and bar maid at Lake Crescent Lodge and
[5:27] was well liked by her customers. Outside of work, she was known as
[5:30] a bit of a party girl, but then just before Christmas, in nineteen
[5:32] thirty seven, she suddenly vanished, but there was no effort to try to
[5:35] find her. This was because her husband, Monty, had told anyone who
[5:40] asked that Haley had run off to Alaska what the sailor she had met.
[5:44] When police went to Monte's home after her discovery, to their surprise, he
[5:46] wasn't living at his last known address. In fact, when they tracked him
[5:50] down, he was hundreds of miles away in Long Beach, California, immediately
[5:54] casting even more suspicion on him. Monty and Halle met while she worked at
[5:58] the Lake Crescent Lodge and as a beer truck driver. Monty made frequent stops
[6:01] there, but as a patron he was known as a regular. In nineteen
[6:04] thirty six, Halle was coming off two failed marriages when she decided to marry
[6:08] Monty at thirty five years old. She was young to be divorced twice already,
[6:12] especially during a time period when divorce was so she frowned upon in far
[6:15] less common. There was something she saw in Monty, though, that allowed
[6:18] her to believe that the third time around would be the charm. Monty was
[6:21] the tall, dark and handsome type, and Halle was a beautiful, available
[6:25] woman with raven colored hair and dark eyes. Outwardly they were a great match,
[6:30] but the reality was much different. Monty and Halle were known to have
[6:32] vicious arguments that often devolved into physical fights. Halle would take to hitting Monty
[6:38] and Heed at her back and had no concern for whether or not he was
[6:41] leaving visible bruises. It was actually common for Halle to show up to work
[6:45] with a black eye or bruises around her neck, and the whole town knew
[6:46] why. Monty was also known as a ladies man, and he was apparently
[6:50] not faithful to Halle. Not to be outdone, though Halle allegedly did the
[6:55] same, but at some point, Monty had taken a more than casual liking
[6:58] to a blonde woman named Eleanor, who just so happened to be the roommate
[7:00] of Halle's sister Lois. The last time Halle was seen by anyone was December
[7:04] twenty first, nineteen thirty seven, by Monty, who said the pair went
[7:08] their separate ways after an argument. He said he expected that she'd go to
[7:11] the bar and cool off before coming home, but he never saw her again.
[7:15] Halle threatened to leave him plenty of times, but it had always been
[7:17] in the heat of the moment, and she always came home. This time,
[7:20] it seemed like she had made good on her threat, at least according
[7:23] to him. On Christmas morning, just three days after the last setting of
[7:27] Halle, Monty knocked on the door of Eleanor Lois's apartment. When he came
[7:30] in, he sat down a raped gift he said was from Halle. That
[7:33] wasn't the reason for Monty's visit, though, he was apparently there to see
[7:36] Eleanor, which Lois found suspicious considering his wife had left him just days before
[7:42] then. Not long after Christmas, Eleanor moved out of the apartment she shared
[7:45] with Lois and into one with Monty, and they wouldn't stay there long before
[7:48] packing up and heading to Long Beach. When Halle's body was found in her
[7:51] cause of death determined, Washington State police went after him. He was picked
[7:56] up by California officers and brought back to Port Angele's, where he was a
[7:59] fixed under rest for Halle's murder. Monty, however, maintained his innocence and
[8:03] told authorities that he'd be more than happy to face charges because he didn't murder
[8:07] Halle. At trial, the prosecutor planned to present the jury a very simple
[8:11] and plausible theory that Monty strangled Halle in a fit of passion when the argument
[8:15] boiled over, then he disposed for it by tying weights to her body before
[8:18] dumping her into Late Crescent. Monty and the defense would relent, obviously,
[8:22] and their case would rest improving. Halley left Monty and ended up in the
[8:26] lake by someone else's hands. The first witness called by prosecution was Earl Enos,
[8:30] who managed the distributing company that employed Monty. Earl's testimony was perfect setting
[8:35] the prosecution's narrative, since he was with Monty on the night of the twenty
[8:37] first, the company was putting on a party for the soldiers at nearby Fort
[8:41] Warden. The prosecution claimed that this was the cause of the argument that led
[8:45] to Halley's murder, which likely took place between three and six am on December
[8:48] twenty second. Earl also said that months after Halley disappeared, Monty told him
[8:52] that she had been located in Alaska, and he served her divorce papers,
[8:56] essentially putting the situation to bed in his mind. Part of Earl's tenn estimony,
[9:00] however, included one important fact that could tie Manty to the murder of
[9:03] his wife. Some time before Halle vanished, Monty asser Elf he could borrow
[9:07] a portion of rope, which she agreed to, but Monty never gave it
[9:09] back. A pathologist then testified for the prosecution and showed magnified images of three
[9:15] different ropes. The first was the rope raptor on Halle, the second was
[9:18] what remained of the rope Monty borrowed from, and the third was a rope
[9:22] for sale at the store Earl bought it from. The microscopic images were identical.
[9:26] Then, further complicating the defense's case was the estimate time of death and
[9:30] the state of Halley's remains. Unlike most bodies that spend a lot of time
[9:33] in water, Halley wasn't bloated, but her skin slid off when she was
[9:35] grabbed by the fisherman as a result of what little decomposition there was. Her
[9:39] skin, however, seemed to have a shiny glow to it, almost as
[9:43] if it had been covered in soap. This was because her body had undergone
[9:46] a process called suppotification. Suppotification could be summed up as the transformation of fat
[9:52] cells into a soapy substance. The depths of Lake Crescent are extremely cold,
[9:56] and this served to keep Halle's body from decomposing. The loss of her her
[10:00] face, fingers, and toes was a product of underwater scavengers, but if
[10:03] not for that, Halle would have been completely recognizable. So ponification also caused
[10:07] Halle's body to become buoyant, and if not for the weights, she would
[10:09] have floated into the surface sooner. Once the rope rotted and her body broke
[10:13] free, her body left the bottom. It had spent thirty one months,
[10:16] and because it had been so well preserved, they were able to determine her
[10:20] time of death to be roughly around the night Monty said she disappeared and not
[10:22] some time later afterward. The jury didn't need long to convict Monty for second
[10:28] agree murder. He was sentenced to life in prison, but only served nine
[10:31] years before being paroled. As for Halle, the discovery of her body marked
[10:35] her entry into Lake Crescent's lower She is known as the Lady of the Lake,
[10:39] and the locals belief she haunts the Lake Crescent Lodge and parts of the
[10:43] lake itself. Sightings of her have been reported all over the hotel, and
[10:46] those who have seen her say she looks as if she's moping around. Guests
[10:50] of the lodge have also reported loud clattering up and down the stairs at all
[10:52] times the night, and in the lounge the music suddenly blars with no explanation
[10:56] at all. Others have reported seeing her walking along the shore and even on
[11:00] the water, describing her as a glowing entity that appears to be covered soap.
[11:03] Notably, Hallie is not the only one to disappear nearly like Crescent under
[11:07] mysterious circumstances. On the afternoon of July third, nineteen twenty nine, thirty
[11:16] seven year old Russell Warren was in a good mood as he entered the last
[11:18] stretch of a long drive from Forks to Port Angele's in Washington State. His
[11:24] wife, Blanche had come down with an unknown illness a month earlier, and
[11:26] that day she was finally coming home. This was perfect timing because she promised
[11:31] her sons Frank and Charles, that she'd be back before the fourth of July
[11:33] so that she could celebrate it with them. For Russell, it was just
[11:35] gonna be nice having Blanche back and another set of hands and eyes to care
[11:39] for the boys. He was already known for not being particularly willing to take
[11:43] time out of his day for sleep, and for the month she was gone,
[11:46] Russell had the added responsibility of Blanche's role as homemaker. It's not that
[11:50] he didn't enjoy spending time with the boys, he just took providing for his
[11:52] family very seriously. The Warrens also lived out the land, and that type
[11:56] of lifestyle was time consuming in itself, so he compensated by sacrificing sleep instead
[12:01] of work. By trade, he was a logger and woodsman, and the
[12:03] log community of the family lived in was one of the more remote places in
[12:07] the area. He was also a hardened, rugged man for the most part,
[12:09] with the exception of when he was around Blanche. Soon enough, he
[12:13] arrived at the hospital and pulled his nineteen twenty seven Chevy Stand to the curb.
[12:16] Then, with a little help, Blanche climbed out of a wheelchair and
[12:18] into the car, smiling as she did. Russell clearly wasn't the only one
[12:22] who was happy, but the day Blanche was excited to see him and the
[12:26] boys, and they were just as eager to see her. She was a
[12:28] loving, attentive mother and just loved spending time with them. When Blanche was
[12:33] all settled, Russell got back in the driver's seat to begin to drive,
[12:35] but instead of going straight home, he had a surprise. He drove to
[12:39] an applying store in Port Angele's and bought Blanche a brand new washing machine,
[12:41] something they'd needed for some time. Then, because a month had passed since
[12:46] the last time anyone had shop for groceries, they headed to the market next
[12:48] to pick up the food they couldn't produce themselves. Then, with everything carefully
[12:52] loaded, the couple got back into the car, left the parking lot,
[12:54] and headed for home. This was the last time either of them was seen
[12:58] again. The boys were being watched by family, and when their pick up
[13:01] time had come and gone, concern grew. Russell was known to be prompt
[13:05] and often rigid and scheduling his day, so after some time, the police
[13:09] were notified, but there wasn't much they could do. Right from the beginning.
[13:11] They did manage to retrace the couple's movements from the hospital, but the
[13:15] trail went cold the moment they left the parking lot at the market. It
[13:18] would be another two weeks before the local newspaper picked up the story of their
[13:20] disappearance, but once word got out, it set off a firestorm of rumors.
[13:24] People in the town theorized that the Warrens abandoned their children and started a
[13:28] new life somewhere else, but there was absolutely nothing in their actions or words
[13:31] leading up to their disappearance to support this. Other people thought they were killed
[13:33] by drunks, and some even entertained the idea that they were bootleggers transporting moonshine
[13:37] over state lines when they ran across a gang of rivals who murdered them.
[13:41] A neighbor of the family. All supported what appeared to be a large patch
[13:45] of freshly disturbed dirt near their property, but when police dug it up,
[13:48] all they found was a dead cow. A little over a month after the
[13:50] disappearance, the most credible lead in the investigations surfaced. A man came forward
[13:54] to report the discovery of tire marks, broken glass, and a few torn
[13:58] branches on the western of Lake Crescent. These tracks were just off Highway one
[14:03] to one, more commonly called Olympic Highway. This stretch was notorious fir's hairpin
[14:07] turns, switchbacks, steep edges, and a complete lack of guardrails. Back
[14:11] then, the case foul noted that the tracks were right near a sharp curve
[14:15] next to Lake Crescent. Police then sent a dive team into Lake Crescent on
[14:18] the off chance the Warren somehow ended up there, but after descending to eighty
[14:22] feet or twenty four meters without finding the bottom, the dive was abandoned.
[14:26] Then, with no other leads to run down, the sheriff put the case
[14:28] found storage just two months later. Almost thirty years later, in nineteen fifty
[14:33] five, a long shoreman named Bob Castle began to pursue a bucket list item.
[14:37] As a longtime diver, Bob dreamed of discovering a sunken Spanish galleon one
[14:41] day and finding an old cannon himself. He spent lots of time researching the
[14:46] last known locations of gallons that had sunk, but none ever made it to
[14:48] the North Pacific Ocean. Then, one day, in his search, she
[14:52] came across a blurb about Russell and Blanche's disappearance. The story of how Frankencharles
[14:56] were orphaned broke Bob's heart, and that day it became a complete obsession for
[15:01] him. He then spent the better part of the next forty six years personally
[15:03] investigating the Warren's disappearance, trying to locate that one clue or tip that was
[15:07] overlooked. He also became an expert on Late Crescent through this process and spent
[15:11] almost every day at the library filling a binder with notes and newspaper clippings.
[15:16] In nineteen fifty six, Bob and a friend even spent the entire summer diving
[15:20] as much of the lake as they could, but eventually had to admit defeat.
[15:22] By then, Bob had nowhere to go with the case, and he
[15:26] too had to shelve it and move on with his life. In two thousand
[15:28] and one, Bob was seventy eight years old, and he realized his time
[15:31] was growing short. As he started getting his affairs in order, he came
[15:35] across that old binder. It brought back memories of the war and boys losing
[15:39] both their parents and how they never received any answers. Bob didn't want the
[15:43] case to die with him one day, so he organized the binder and walked
[15:45] it a few blocks from his apartment to the Olympic National Park office. At
[15:48] the main desk was Dan A park ranger, who had never heard of the
[15:52] Warren's case before. Bob then explained to Dan the reason for his visit and
[15:54] handed over the binder. Dan sat down after Bob left and opened the binder
[16:00] the first three pages and decided to pour over it later. When he finally
[16:03] did, though, he didn't put away until he read every last page.
[16:07] One thing that jumped out in Bob's notes was that the shriff at the time
[16:10] strongly believed the car tracks belonged to the warrants, but that the couple were
[16:12] unreachable at the bottom of the lake. That was as good as starting point
[16:15] as any, and on the seventy two year anniversary of the Warren's disappearance,
[16:19] Dan led the first dive search for them since nineteen fifty six. Every weekend
[16:23] from that point, Dan in the Olympic National Park Dive Team searched for the
[16:26] couple but came up with nothing. Then, on the morning of December seventh,
[16:30] two thousand and one, they descend into about seventy feet or twenty one
[16:33] meters and came across a crevice in the rocky slope. Inside it, they
[16:37] found a black flower vase. It wasn't just any flower vase, though it
[16:41] was a very specific flower vase for a very specific location, which was the
[16:45] dashboard of a nineteen twenty seven Chevy Sedan. Then nearby a second item was
[16:49] found hanging off the underwater rock face, and that was the metal lid of
[16:52] a washing machine. The items were gathered and brought to the surface for study,
[16:56] but with winter fully setting in, the year would close with no for
[17:00] their discoveries. Searches for the Warrens resumed the next spring, and the biggest
[17:03] breakthrough came on April thirteenth, two thousand and two. Dan sent two divers
[17:07] into lake and told them if they discovered anything, to send a buoy up
[17:11] to the surface. It wasn't even fifteen minutes when a buoy came shooting out
[17:15] of the water in the dives support boat. The team then spent an agonizing
[17:18] hour for the divers to decompress on as sent before learning about what they found.
[17:22] When they were finally at the surface, they told Dan they found the
[17:26] Warrens nineteen twenty seven Chevy Sedan. The car was partially buried on a slope
[17:30] around one hundred and seventy one feet or fifty two meters deep and in great
[17:33] condition all things considered. After hearing the news, there was complete disbelief among
[17:37] them. Bob was even standing next to Dan on the boat when the news
[17:41] came from below, and his eyes immediately welled up. The moment he had
[17:45] worked so hard to make happen had finally come to fruition after forty six years.
[17:49] When the car was first discovered, there were no obvious signs of human
[17:52] remains, and before anything was disturbed, Dan wanted to make sure the family
[17:56] knew about the fire and ask for their blessing to look through the wreckage,
[18:00] and Dan received it shortly afterward and was part of the group of divers who
[18:02] went down to see what they could find inside the car. However, they
[18:06] found a woman's blouse but little outs, meaning it was possible the couple wasn't
[18:08] actually in the car when it went off the cliff. Even worse, every
[18:11] search after the car was found came up empty. As more and more weekends
[18:15] went by with nothing, Dan and the volunteers had to face the very real
[18:18] possibility that the Warrens might have been behind their own disappearance after all, or
[18:22] something else had happened to them. Still, the search went on for months
[18:26] and then for years. Two years later, on May twenty nine, a
[18:30] diver named John was among the divers meticulously searching Lake Crescent for any sun in
[18:33] the warrens. The original purpose of the dive was actually to return the personal
[18:37] effects that have been removed from the car back to their proper place in the
[18:41] wreck. While he was down there, John searched around for anything that may
[18:44] have been missed, and when he was sure nothing of interest was around,
[18:45] he started to ascend. During a decompression stop, at around one hundred and
[18:49] fifty feet, he spotted a massive cedar tree lying on the bottom, roots
[18:53] and all. It actually took his breathway it was that stunning. John couldn't
[18:57] get over how all the roots twisted and curl off the bottom of the tree,
[19:00] and just marveled at its size. He was so fascinated by it that
[19:03] he thought it was worth a close look, and as he swam its length,
[19:07] running his hand along the decayed bark, his eye was drawn to something
[19:10] just a few feet away. It was unmistakably a human femur bone. He
[19:14] then swam toward it to get a closer look and was just stunned, leaving
[19:18] it where he was he recorded his coordinates, and then just before he was
[19:21] about to begin as ascent again, he saw the cap of a human skull
[19:23] sticking out of the sand. For all the intentional thorough searches that had been
[19:29] performed over the years, John just by chance noticed this because he was distracted
[19:33] by a submerged tree. When he finally broke the surface of the water,
[19:36] he yelled to the sport boat and was quickly scooped up as he excitedly shared
[19:38] the news for the first time. The boat then sped back to the shore
[19:41] where Dan was with members of the dive to and descendants of Russell and Blanche.
[19:45] As the boat came closer, Dan could see that John was screaming something,
[19:48] but he couldn't make out what it was. Dan's immediate fear was that
[19:52] one of the divers was in trouble, but when the boat slowed for its
[19:53] approach to the dock, he finally heard John loud and clear. John then
[19:57] told him that he had found Russell. At first, it was pure disbelief
[20:02] in silence among everyone on shore. Then the entire group broke out in tears.
[20:07] They had invested so much of their time and energy into solving the mystery
[20:10] of what happened to the warrants and had been met with so much disappointment.
[20:12] Still, Dan was cautiously optimistic using the coordinates, John noted. Police divers
[20:18] took over things from there and retrieved the bones from the lake. When the
[20:21] DNA from them was tested, beyond a shadow of a doubt, they belonged
[20:25] to Russell. Unfortunately, none of Blanche's remains have ever been found, but
[20:29] either way, the case was considered to be solved and investigators pieced together what
[20:32] they believed due the last moments of the couple. After picking up the groceries
[20:36] and port Angele's, the couple settled in for the drive home. Blanche was
[20:38] likely still worn down from her hospital stay and may have fallen asleep during the
[20:42] ride. Behind the wheel, Russell drove along the Olympic Highway, probably looking
[20:45] forward to getting back to the old routine he enjoyed before Blanche got sick.
[20:49] The month she was gone had taken a lot out of him, as he
[20:52] sacrificed what little sleep he usually got for the sake of work and taking care
[20:55] of the boys. Then with the consistent rumble of the road beneath them,
[20:59] as Blanche slip. Russell dozed off just before reaching Melgrum Point. Then just
[21:03] before the curve, he opened his eyes and slammed on the brakes, but
[21:07] it was too late. A moment later, the car was airborne and falling
[21:11] four hundred feet to the lake below. In fact, in their initial investigation
[21:15] in nineteen twenty nine, police had interviewed a family member who reported that Russell
[21:18] had dozed off and narrowly avoided a similar scenario. Outside of the deaths of
[21:22] Russell and Blanche, the greatest tragedy of the case was that Frank and Charles
[21:26] both died believing their parents abandoned them all because of the local rumor mill.
[21:32] Their lives were completely upended on July third, nineteen twenty nine, but beyond
[21:36] that, they had to endure the town gossip and merciless teasing from their classmates,
[21:38] mocking them for their parents not wanting them anymore. For a time,
[21:41] right after their disappearance, Frank and Charles stayed with a local tavern owner,
[21:45] but eventually they moved to Montana to stay with Blanche's mother. Since she didn't
[21:48] have much room to spare in the house, the boys were left to spend
[21:52] every night outside in an old chicken coop. They would eventually be removed from
[21:55] the house and split up between family members, but tragedy seemed to follow them
[21:57] throughout life as well. Charles was extremely forthcoming about the tragedy, talking about
[22:03] it with any one and everyone who would listen, just to get their theories
[22:06] on what happened. After he laid out all the facts, it came off
[22:08] as a bit of a compulsion he couldn't control until one day he'd just stopped
[22:11] talking about it. Any time he was asked about his parents afterward, Charles
[22:15] would shut down and refuse to say anything else. As an adult, he
[22:18] worked as a fisherman, and at the age of forty seven, he was
[22:21] lost at sea and was presumed dead. His body has never been found.
[22:26] Frank's life after his parents dispeard was one of extreme anger. The older he
[22:30] got, the more it seemed to grow. In adulthood, he was known
[22:33] to be arrogant and pompous, and there was little more he loved than picking
[22:36] fights. He would eventually die of acute alcoholism at age fifty seven. Russell
[22:41] and Blanche's eight grandchildren took a keen interest in what Dan was attempted to do,
[22:45] and one of Charles's sons would show up at Lake Crescent for every dive
[22:48] remaining on the shore and hope in a learn of some big find. When
[22:51] the grandchildren learned that some of Russell's remains were found, the Warren family finally
[22:55] got to experience peace for the first time in almost seventy five years.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
