# Sub Sinks to Ocean Floor With Crew Inside

An episode of [Scary Interesting Podcast](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1705969819), 7 May 2024, 20 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/59884601/sub_sinks_to_ocean_floor_with_crew_inside.mp3

When submarines were first developed, they had an awful reputation, and for good reason. There had been many accidents and many sailors whose graves were on the bottom of the ocean. So much so that the submarine service had earned the nickname the coffin service. In 1939, one of the worst of these incidents would add to this reputation. This is that horrifying story. Ambient Songs: "The Dark Enigma" by CoAg https://www.youtube.com/@co.agmusic1823 Intro Theme by Swift Junai: https://www.instagram.com/swiftjunai/?hl=en https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC6hf5nMJ8s6LJJfFR4OQ3lg https://open.spotify.com/artist/1PoG2b18MHocWZA8zQgWjO Writing and research by Jay Adams: https://instagram.com/jayadamsdigital?igshid=MzMyNGUyNmU2YQ== Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/scary-interesting-podcast--5945096/support.

## Transcript

[0:00] When submarines were first developed, they had an awful reputation, and for good
[0:05] reason. There had been many accidents and many sailors whose graves were on the
[0:09] bottom of the ocean, so much so that the submarine service had earned the
[0:13] nickname the Coffin Service. In nineteen thirty nine, one of the worst of
[0:18] these instants would add this reputation. This is that horrifying story, and as
[0:23] always, viewer discretion is advised. Between the end of World War One and
[0:37] the first shots of World War Two, navies around the world were tirelessly developing
[0:41] and testing submarine technology. To that point, fighting a war under the sea
[0:45] was done by primitive means, but the early nineteen twenties marked a significant leap
[0:49] forward in submarine capabilities. Countries raised one another to build and deploy more advanced
[0:54] submarines, capable of diving deeper, faster, and for longer than ever before.
[0:58] Like other countries, the United States invested heavily in bolstering its navy was
[1:02] top of the line, state of the art subs and in nineteen thirty eight
[1:04] it launched its class of Sargo ships, which were equipped with a new lead
[1:07] acid battery that was resistant to battle damage. One of these was known as
[1:11] the USS Squalus, which was one of the first in its class and was
[1:15] capable of reaching depths of up to two hundred and fifty feet, surface speeds
[1:18] of up to twenty knots, and distances of eleven thousand miles on a single
[1:22] tank of fuel. Even by the growing standards of submarine technology, the Squalless
[1:26] and its sister ship, the USS Sculpin, were advanced beyond their years.
[1:30] They had been designed in the lead up to World War II for the task
[1:34] of cutting off Japanese trade and could escape enemy planes by fully submerging in less
[1:38] than a minute while operating at full speed, which was something that no other
[1:41] sub could do. Once the Squalus was completed, the Navy began a battery
[1:45] of test dives to ensure that its design was safe and its parts were capable
[1:48] of withstanding all that was expected of it. And this testing process was something
[1:52] that countries took incredibly seriously because a total of eight hundred and twenty five men
[1:56] from eighteen subs across multiple countries had been killed in subback between nineteen twenty one
[2:00] and nineteen thirty eight. Submarining as a result, had earned the Moniker at
[2:05] the coffin service by the median public, but the Sargo class of ships aimed
[2:08] to undo that reputation, and thankfully, by then in its test runs,
[2:13] the Squaluss was performing its functions and purpose to near perfection. On the morning
[2:16] of May twenty third, nineteen thirty nine, the Squalless left the mouth of
[2:21] the Piscataqua River for another test type with the crew that included fifty three officers
[2:24] and sailors. Also along for the ride were two civilian Navy engineers and a
[2:29] representative from General Motors who had designed the batteries. Then under the command of
[2:34] Rear Admiral Oliver F. Naquin, the sub was put on a course toward
[2:37] the coast of New Hampshire, just a few miles from the Isle of Shoals.
[2:40] The test for the day would include underwater maneuvers and several dives in resurfaces,
[2:45] and it would be as routine a test as the ship had faced.
[2:47] Around nine am, the horn sounded throughout this up, indicating a pending dive
[2:51] command from the captain. At this point the sub was on the surface and
[2:54] traveling at sixteen knots, and the Admiral stood behind a large board in the
[2:58] control room filled with light that would luminate red or green, depending on the
[3:00] status of different parts and pieces of the ship. The dive process relied heavily
[3:06] on the engine room crewmen, and at the sound of the horn they would
[3:08] need to cut the diesel powered engines quickly and then close the air vents before
[3:12] the ship submerged. Right before he gave the official dive order, the Admiral
[3:15] ensured the entire panel was lit up green, and then when everything appeared as
[3:19] it should, he gave the final order and the Squalis dipped beneath the surface.
[3:23] When it did, though, a fluttering of air pressure occurred in his
[3:25] ears just before the intercom blared with a sailor shouting to take the ship back
[3:30] up to the surface. Despite what the board indicated, one of the vents
[3:34] was still wide open and seawater was rushing into the engine rooms. Admiral Oliver
[3:38] just stared in disbelieve what was being reported by his crew was impossible based on
[3:43] what he was looking at, but either way, He then immediately ordered that
[3:46] the ballast tanks to be blown to get the squalls to the surface as quickly
[3:49] as possible. Horrifyingly, though, the sub took on water faster than it
[3:53] could surface, and after an initial rise, the Squalis slowed to a stop.
[3:58] Meanwhile, in the engine room, the crew was a torrent of water,
[4:00] just trying to survive as the ship tilted downward at a forty five degree
[4:03] angle and then begin a rapid descent to the seafloor. It was then that
[4:09] Oliver was faced with a decision no officer ever wants to make. He knew
[4:13] that the survival of anyone on the ship relied on the closure of the watertight
[4:16] doors between the control room and the engine room compartments. Doing this, however,
[4:21] would trap those who were still inside well they flooded completely, but at
[4:26] the same time, not locking off the compartments would ensure that everyone on board
[4:29] would die. Admiral Oliver was known as a strict, no nonsense discipline leader,
[4:34] and his tact had a very good reason behind it. In submarines,
[4:38] every single decision and action anyone on board can make can result in disaster.
[4:43] There was just no room for air, and at times like that, unfortunately,
[4:46] there was no room for humanity. Oliver then gave the order to seal
[4:49] off the control room compartment with the men inside. As the man responsible for
[4:54] this order, a man named Lloyd Menace, started to put all his weight
[4:57] into closing the two hundred pound door. He heard the screams of men begging
[5:00] him to wait, but there was no time. Water was already rushing toward
[5:03] the bulkhead behind them, so the compartment door had to be sealed immediately.
[5:08] As he pulled the door closed, several of those battling the water made it
[5:11] through to safety before its slam shut. He then cranked its wheel and ensured
[5:15] it was water tight, ultimately sealing the fate of those left in the subs
[5:17] four flooded compartments, including Sherman Shirley, who was Lloyd's best friend. Tragically,
[5:23] Sherman's wedding date was supposed to be the following Sunday, and Lloyd was
[5:26] supposed to be his best man. Among the others were seventeen crewmen who tried
[5:30] to seal themselves in the torpedo room and nine in the engine room. In
[5:33] rear battery rooms, one man even climbed a half sutter and tried to push
[5:38] open the door to the ocean outside, but the sea pressure was too strong.
[5:41] In the door to push it. The squalless then continued to fall toward
[5:44] the bottom as the batteries in the flood compartments were fried by the water.
[5:47] And as if the uncontrolled descent wasn't terrifying enough, the lights flickered before going
[5:51] out, completely plunging the crew into complete darkness. This then led to a
[5:56] new problem. The chief electrician, Lawrence Gayner, than grabbed flashlight and climbed
[6:00] into the crawl space where the batteries were stored. Since the batteries lined the
[6:03] entire length of the ship's keel, many of them were already submerged, but
[6:06] the ones that weren't were wet and at risk of catching on fire. Lawrence
[6:11] also noticed that they were losing voltage fast, causing them to smolder, and
[6:14] if the heat reached the battery cell, there would be an explosion that would
[6:16] crack the hall wide open. Even by the time he reached the batteries,
[6:19] they were already smoking and well on their way to heating past the point of
[6:23] no return. He then flipped one of the disconnect switches and the flash of
[6:27] light completely blinded him, so next without his sight, he felt around the
[6:30] other remaining battery and managed to find the second switch to stop it from exploding
[6:33] narrowly, averting a much more serious incident. Back in the control room,
[6:39] they had no idea how far they were in a fall, and the sub
[6:41] was only rated for a maximum depth of two hundred and fifty feet or seventy
[6:44] six meters. If the ocean floor was much fur than that, there was
[6:47] a possibility the sub would implode before touching down. All they could do was
[6:51] wait in the silence and darkness as the sub growned its weight deeper and deeper
[6:56] in to the ocean. Then, fortunately, and with a heavy thud,
[6:59] the squalls impacted the bottom of the Atlantic at a depth of two hundred and
[7:02] forty feet or seventy three meters. When it did, it came to a
[7:05] rest, sticking straight up completely perpendiculates to the surface. The thirty three survivors
[7:11] were then trapped in the air pocket they had created by sealing off the restless
[7:14] sub. However, despite what should have been chaos, they didn't even need
[7:17] a moment to take in the reality of their situation. Their training kicked in
[7:20] and being trapped to the bottom of the ocean was a scenario they assimilated often,
[7:24] so each of them knew their roles and began to execute. The first
[7:27] task was for the sub two signal it's location by releasing a buoy that was
[7:30] attached to a cable. The buoi would not only help rescuers spot them,
[7:33] but it would also provide communication between the sub and the surface through the cable.
[7:38] Additionally, the squalls was able to shoot off flares and smoke bombs to
[7:41] grab the attention of anyone on the surface. As they went through these procedures,
[7:45] the men couldn't help but wonder if anyone in the other compartments ended up
[7:47] surviving. So one of them grabbed a hammer and began tapping on the airlines
[7:51] that ran to the back of the hall. If anyone was alive, they'd
[7:55] respawned by doing the same. So after several hammer taps from the control room,
[7:59] they held their so they could hear even the faintest tap in return,
[8:01] but there was no reply. It was a reality they didn't want to face,
[8:05] but it was confirmed that nearly half of them had died back in the
[8:09] control room. Oliver then ordered some of the men to grab the emergency applies,
[8:13] which included food, flashlights, auxygen stores, carbon dix, and absorbent
[8:16] blankets and coats. He knew they'd probably been for a weight and without power,
[8:20] so it was about to get very cold very quickly. With that being
[8:24] handled, Oliver turned his attention to the next threat to survival, which was
[8:26] their air supply. Taking into consideration the number of survivors, he asked me
[8:31] that there was probably forty eight hours worth of air before everyone died of suffocation.
[8:35] That seems like plenty of time to be rescued and back on dry land
[8:37] in New Hampshire, but the prudent course of action was to conserve everything that
[8:41] could possibly stretch that time. Oliver then split the men into two groups,
[8:45] placing ten of the healthiest and youngest in the colder torpedo room and keeping the
[8:48] twenty three remaining in the warmer control room. One of the men then started
[8:52] handing out devices called moms and lungs, which are a breathing apparatus that can
[8:56] be used from a reasonable depth to swim to the surface. The crew of
[9:00] the Squalus was forty feet or twelve meters deeper than the moms and lungs were
[9:03] rated for, and it was uncertain if they didn't even work at that depth,
[9:05] and even if they did work, no one knew if they'd have enough
[9:09] air to reach the surface, so these would have to be used as an
[9:11] absolute last resort. Then once those were handed out, Oliver and start the
[9:15] men to nap as much as they were able to prevent panic breathing. Before
[9:18] long, the temperature in the sub was thirty five fair night or two celsius,
[9:22] and the inner hall was beginning to form a layer of ice on it.
[9:24] Some of the men were able to fall asleep, but others weren't into
[9:26] stay calm. Some of them took too whistling a tune. They would just
[9:31] have to wait until rescue arrived or the air ran out, whichever came first.
[9:35] When the Squalas failed to return to the shipyard when expected, its sister
[9:39] ship, the Sculpin, was preparing to leave New Hampshire for Panama, but
[9:41] upon hearing that the Squaws was in trouble, the Sculpin left port and raced
[9:45] the coordinates the Navy gave them when they reached them, though the Sculpin's captain,
[9:48] Warren Wilkins, was puzzled not to see the emergency Buoi anywhere. This
[9:52] was because somewhere in the rush to get the search of the squals underway,
[9:56] The cordons were written down incorrectly and the sculpin was in the wrong area.
[10:00] If not for one of the ship's lookouts who spotted a flare further out,
[10:03] the Squalis may have never been found. Luckily, that wasn't the case,
[10:07] and warned then handed down orders to head in that direction, and as they
[10:09] drew close, they spotted the buoy and pulled up alongside it below the ocean.
[10:15] In the Squalis, they corre actually heard the sound of a sub engine
[10:16] above them, and morale inside skyrocketed, just knowing that help had found them.
[10:22] Moments later, Oliver's voice was heard inside the sculpin. He said hello,
[10:26] and one replied in kind, but then a second later the phone went
[10:28] dead. As the two captains were greeting one another, an ocean swell snapped
[10:33] the buoy cable and the sculpin quickly lost track of the location of the squalless
[10:37] then for hours afterward, the sculpin had to actually drag a hook along the
[10:39] bottom of the ocean, hoping to run into the sub. They would eventually
[10:43] find it again, but this costed the rescue for precious time. The sculpin
[10:46] then connected a new buoy and waited for reinforcements from other ships. Then,
[10:50] instead of using a direct communication, they used Morse code to communicate with one
[10:54] another, and the squallest communicate the number of survivors in the sub. The
[10:58] sculpin then tapped back code for the letters SRC. Oliver immediately knew what that
[11:03] meant, and he expected that he'd hear it at some point. SRC stood
[11:07] for submarine rescue chamber, and there was only one available anywhere on the East
[11:11] coast. In a stroke of good luck, it just so happened to be
[11:13] in Connecticut at the time of the sub sinking, and a ship called the
[11:16] Falcon was already head in the direction of the Squalis with it. This nine
[11:20] ton submarine rescue chamber resembles an upside down wineglass, and as this name suggests,
[11:24] it could transport survivors from disabled submarines back to the surface inside the chambers
[11:30] controlled by two crewmen who guide it down and connected its bottom to one of
[11:33] the submarine hatches using a watertight rubber gasket, and from there the hatch doors
[11:37] for both ships are opened and survivors simply climbed the ladder into the chamber,
[11:41] which takes them to the surface. At the time, however, this wasn't
[11:45] a tried and true method of rescuing crewman from subs. The SRC had only
[11:48] ever been used in testing, so this would be the very first true test
[11:52] of its function. Around four thirty the next morning, the Falcon arrived of
[11:56] the Squalos, and not a moment too soon. As survivors in the sub
[11:58] were approaching the twenty four hour mark, Oliver began rationing oxygen periodically. It
[12:03] ordered the release of stored emergency oxygen and let it run for a few moments
[12:07] before shutting it back down. By doing this, he hoped to stretch the
[12:09] supply as far as it could. But the impact of the survivors was also
[12:13] obvious. As the Falcon prepared to launch the SRC, the thirty three survivors
[12:18] were suffering from headaches and nausea, which are some of the earliest signs of
[12:20] hypercapnia or carbon diox at poisoning. If this went on long enough, it
[12:24] could end up being fatal. Eventually, a hypercapnea sufferer will simply drift into
[12:28] unconsciousness and not wake up again, unfortunately, putting himself and his men on
[12:33] the brink of hypercapney was what Oliver knew was going to keep them all alive
[12:35] as long as possible by then as well. The other major concern in the
[12:39] sub was hypothermia. Since some of the men had escaped the flooding compartments before
[12:43] they were sealed, they remained soaked through an in temptuous close to freezing on
[12:48] the surface. The falcon lowered the SRC into the water and the capsule began
[12:50] its descent along with a support diver. Part of the procedure for safely securing
[12:54] the SRC to a sub was attaching a cable from the rescue chamber to the
[12:58] hatch door, and as simple as it may sound, it was one of
[13:01] the more dangerous jobs for divers. In the nineteen thirties, the Navy Experimental
[13:05] Diving had just begun testing different mix of healing and auction that divers could breathe
[13:09] beyond one hundred feet or thirty three meters. These were supposed to lessen the
[13:13] onset of nitrogen and narcosis. If you've watched the many cave diving videos in
[13:18] the channel, you're probably all too familiar with this concept. But when this
[13:20] rescue was taking place. Much of this was barely in its infancy for those
[13:24] who aren't familiar. As a diver descends while breathing regular air, the increasing
[13:28] water pressure causes nitrogen to become narcotic. Divers can then become disoriented and e
[13:33] fork while losing motor skills and problem solving abilities. That far under water is
[13:37] obviously the last place you want to experience this, but by breathing a gas
[13:41] with a lower concentration of nitrogen at depths beyond one hundred feet, it can
[13:43] prevent or greatly reduce the impact of narcosis on a diver. Unfortunately, for
[13:48] the diver's assisting in these Squalis rescue, these gas mixes weren't used universalies.
[13:52] The longest they could to stay at a depth like two hundred and forty feet
[13:54] was just twenty minutes either way. The diver then descended ahead of the srcs
[14:00] and began to suffer from narcosi's symptoms before he reached the sub. This caused
[14:03] him to collide hard with the Squalas, but despite this, he managed to
[14:07] get his bearings and successfully attached the cable behind him. The SRC was on
[14:11] its slow descent, and once it reached the vicinity of the sub. The
[14:13] two men controlling it inside maneuvered the chamber and settled it over the hatch.
[14:18] Once it was sealed tightly, the water was pumped out, and then when
[14:20] it was clear, the men inside the sub began turning the wheel and the
[14:24] hatch door as it popped open. Water poured in for a second, but
[14:28] thankfully that was just some of the residual from the connection point. Then a
[14:31] second later they saw the man inside the SRC standing there holding blankets and coffee.
[14:37] These supplies were much needed for the men who were wet and cold,
[14:39] and more importantly, finally, this seemed like clear indication that they would be
[14:43] able to leave the bottom of the ocean alive. Once the SRC was attached
[14:48] and communication was established, the men began to plan away to get everyone to
[14:52] the surface safely. There was only enough room for eight crewmen at one time,
[14:54] so Oliver split the men into groups based in their condition. The ones
[14:58] who were approaching severe high but they would go first, and the ones in
[15:01] the best condition would go last. Once that was clear, the hatch was
[15:05] unsealed and the SRC began returning to the surface. Now, despite being so
[15:09] close to safety, the period between the SEC departing and returning felt excruciatingly long,
[15:13] and the rationing of air didn't make the weight any more bearable. The
[15:16] men would reach a point where their heads were pounding so hard from hypercapnia they
[15:20] desperately waited for Oliver to switch the auction stores back on. In addition,
[15:24] one round trip for the SRC took about three and a half hours, one
[15:28] hour to descend, about an hour to attach and load the chamber, and
[15:31] then another hour and a half to the surface. By then as well,
[15:33] since the survivors have been trapped for more than twenty four hours, there was
[15:37] still a chance that the sub could run out of air before everyone was safe.
[15:41] After three successful trips, only ten remained in the final group, one
[15:43] of which was Admiral Oliver. When the time came, he and the others
[15:48] boarded the SRC, and once the hatches were secured, the chamber lifted off
[15:50] the squalls and began a final trip to the surface on a scent. However,
[15:54] one of these stabilizing cables jammed, causing the chamber to stop abruptly around
[15:58] the one hundred fifty footmark. At the same time, this caused the cable
[16:02] that went from the winch on the falcon to the top of the chamber to
[16:04] become freyed, and during this all but two of these seven strands that where
[16:08] the lifelines to the crew had snapped. One of the divers that had to
[16:11] re enter the water and descend to assess the situation, and it was realized
[16:15] that the stabilizing cable would need to be cut for the chamber to ascend.
[16:18] The problem was that this cable was crucial for both guiding the chamber to and
[16:22] from the sub, but also keeping it from swinging and spinning in the ocean.
[16:26] However, without any other options, this cable was then cut and the
[16:29] chamber began to spin uncontrollably. In order to reset and figure out what to
[16:33] do next, operators then lowered the SRC back down and set it on the
[16:36] ocean floor. This meant that the last few survivors had been less than two
[16:40] hundred feet from safety, but once again they were stuck in the bottom of
[16:41] the Atlantic. Back on the falcon, there were concerns that the final cable
[16:47] might be at risk of snapping, too, so after a brief discussion,
[16:48] reskers decided not to use the winch, and instead they pulled the bellop the
[16:52] full two hundred and forty feet by hand. This was an excruciating process that
[16:56] took four hours, but it worked. At about four forty hours after plunging
[17:00] to the bottom of the ocean, the surviving crewed the Squalish was saved.
[17:03] Many of them would require medical attention and some even stayed in the hospital for
[17:07] some time, but all of them survived the ordeal. Once the dust from
[17:11] the rescue had settled, the next order of business for the Navy was to
[17:14] figure out how to salvage the Squalers. It was a brand new, very
[17:17] expensive stub that was at a manageable depth, so the Navy didn't want to
[17:21] leave it there, but at the same time, a salvage operation like it
[17:22] had never been attempted. However, over the course of four months, the
[17:26] Navy would work almost around the clock to raise the sub in a series of
[17:30] trial and air attempts. The first idea was to attach deflated pont tunes together
[17:33] with long chains. Divers would then slip the chains underneath the squaliss before inflating
[17:37] the pontoons on the first try. Though once the pontoons were filled there,
[17:41] the Squalis began an uncontrolled ascent, and when it broke the surface of the
[17:45] ocean with slightly more speed than expected, it shot loose of the chains and
[17:48] began a second descent all the way back to the ocean floor. In the
[17:52] end, it took five different attempts using various methods of attaching those pontoons before
[17:56] the sub could be raised and towed back to the Navy shipyard. When it
[18:00] was secured there, the water was drained from the flooded compartments and twenty five
[18:03] of twenty six bodies were recovered. During one of these salvage attempts, one
[18:07] of the hatches shot open and one body drifted out of the submit into the
[18:11] depths, and it was never recovered. Once the squals were finally examined,
[18:15] to the relief of the sub's captain and crewed, the issue was a mechanical
[18:18] malfunction instead of a human error. This malfunction then prevented some of the events
[18:22] from closing properly, which was not indicated by the control board. Oliver was
[18:26] then commended for his outstanding leadership, bravery, and the handling of the disaster,
[18:30] but he gave the credit to the crewman under his command. In a
[18:33] report he wrote for the Navy. Oliver explained that he had witnessed a true
[18:36] example of camaraderie and brotherly love, and each of the crewman believed himself accountable
[18:40] for the life of the man next to him, and together they made it
[18:42] through by sharing blankets and huddling into groups to maintain body heat. Those who
[18:47] were better off sacrifice for those much worse shape, and even Oliver gave up
[18:49] his coat to one of the hypothem Mcruman. Oliver also devoted space as report
[18:53] to the selfless act performed by the electrician Lawrence. In the captain's mind,
[18:57] Lawrence's quick thinking, too, disabling the remaining batteries to prevent the explosion was
[19:02] what truly saved them, and this came at a cost for Lawrence too.
[19:04] When he disabled the first battery, it completed a circuit that sent in literal
[19:08] lightning bolts around the hull, so bright that he lived the rest of his
[19:11] life with vision issues. Once all of the investigations were finished, although the
[19:15] damage to the squass was extensive, it would ultimately be salvagable. After its
[19:19] repairs, it was recommissioned as the USS Sailfish, and three of the squall
[19:23] survivors even came back to serve as part of the crew. Among the others,
[19:27] four died in action during World War Two, and Admiral Oliver never commanded
[19:30] another submarine again. He instead opted to become an engineering officer on the USS
[19:36] California, which happened to be a target during Pearl Harbor, but fortunately he
[19:40] was ashore when the attack began and survived. Two years later, the Sculpon
[19:44] was sunk by a Japanese destroyer, and the sailfish returned the favor by sinking
[19:48] that destroyer. It then served admirably during World War Two and was eventually decommissioned
[19:52] shortly after and more than eighty years later, the rescue and recovery of the
[19:56] Squallessness crew is still one of the Navy's most challenging operations ever to this day.
[20:00] The incredible effort of Oliver and the crew is part of the Navy's official
[20:03] Handbook on submarine rescue. If you may it this far, thanks so much
[20:07] for watching, and hopefully I will see you in the next one.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
