# The Deepest Mine Disaster in North America

An episode of [Scary Interesting Podcast](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1705969819), 2 Jun 2024, 18 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/60250593/the_deepest_mine_disaster_in_north_america.mp3

Ambient Songs: "The Dark Enigma" by CoAg https://www.youtube.com/@co.agmusic1823 Intro Theme by Swift Junai: https://www.instagram.com/swiftjunai/?hl=en https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC6hf5nMJ8s6LJJfFR4OQ3lg https://open.spotify.com/artist/1PoG2b18MHocWZA8zQgWjO Writers and researchers: Jay Adams https://instagram.com/jayadamsdigital?igshid=MzMyNGUyNmU2YQ== Rich Firth-Godbehere instagram.com/DrRichFG https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMGZs8swehdcCB0pi3V4vKQ Jordan Gottschick https://www.youtube.com/@DerpsWithWolves/playlists Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/scary-interesting-podcast--5945096/support.

## Transcript

[0:00] There is a terrifying phenomenon that occurs in the deepest and largest mines on Earth,
[0:05] and in nineteen fifty eight, this would occur in the deepest mine in
[0:08] North America and the results would be catastrophic for the miners over ten thousand feet
[0:13] underground. This is that horrifying story, and as always, viewer discretion is
[0:18] advised. Nova Scotia is one of Canada's thirteen provinces and territories, with a
[0:29] population of just more than one million in early twenty twenty four. Incredibly,
[0:33] among the country's provinces and territories, it's the second most densely populated, as
[0:37] well as the second smass by area. It's also home to a variety of
[0:41] natural resources, and so mining has been a central part of its economy for
[0:44] more than three hundred years. Over that time, the province has exported more
[0:48] than twenty different middle products all of the world. But beginning in the eighteenth
[0:52] century all the way through the better part of the twentieth century, coal was
[0:55] king in Nova Scotia. It's estimated that around four hundred million tons of it
[0:59] have been mined from more than three hundred coal deposits since seventeen twenty. One
[1:03] of the most abundant of these mines in Nova Scotia's history is located in spring
[1:07] Hill, which was a city of around seven thousand in the nineteen fifties.
[1:11] Digging at these spring Hill mines began in the nineteenth century and eventually became one
[1:15] of the deepest coal mines in North America and also one of the deepest in
[1:18] the world, with a depth of forty two hundred sixty feet or thirteen hundred
[1:21] meters. And during its heyday, the spring Hill mine saw its sheriff success
[1:26] and a couple of horrific disasters. The first one was on February twenty first,
[1:30] eighteen ninety one, when an explosion occurred in the Number one in Number
[1:34] two collieries, which was caused by an accumulation of coal dust that was blown
[1:37] through both shafts by the ventilation system. The dust then ignited and caused one
[1:41] of the worst disasters in Nova Scotia's history, with one hundred and twenty five
[1:44] miners losing their lives. Then, sixty five years later, another thirty nine
[1:49] miners were killed. In November of nineteen fifty six when another blast occurred with
[1:52] circumstances, Oddly similar to the first explosion, a large quantity of fine coal
[1:57] dust was being carried toward the exit of the mine by a rel car,
[2:00] and on its journey it passed through a strong gust from the ventilation system.
[2:04] This highly flammable dust then spread, which was then compounded when the train derailed
[2:07] and collided with the power line, and when it did, the electricity arked
[2:10] and lit the coal dust. Much like the first, this explosion in dram
[2:15] it was catastrophic for the community and the mine. Most of the number four
[2:19] shaft was destroyed, which trapped a handful of miners underground for some time until
[2:22] they were rescued. Then, once the survivors were out, the tunnels to
[2:25] the still raging fire were closed off with the bricks to choke off its auctions
[2:29] supply so it would burn itself out. By January of the following year,
[2:32] the bricks could finally be removed and the rest of the bodies recovered. However,
[2:36] the number four shaft would be closed permanently as results. Incredibly, this
[2:40] could have been much worse if not for changes that had been implemented after the
[2:44] eighteen ninety one disaster and new mining technology was credited with allowing eighty eight miners
[2:47] to escape with their lives. Part of the credit for that goes to a
[2:52] mining technique change that occurred about twenty years earlier. Mining coal can be done
[2:55] in a number of ways, using a variety of processes, and from when
[2:59] the Spring Helme mine and opened in the nineteen thirties, the coal deposit there
[3:01] was mine using something known as the rum and pillar technique. This is when
[3:06] long horizontal corridors are lined with timber supports that lead to different rooms where mining
[3:09] occurs. This is also done in a sort of grid pattern to help maintain
[3:14] the structural integrity of the mine. One of the disadvantages of this method,
[3:17] though, is that by leaving natural rock pillars to support the weight of the
[3:21] layer above, overall coal production couldn't reach its full potential because parts of the
[3:24] deposit quite literally supported the mine. Additionally, if the pillars and the tunnels
[3:29] weren't installed correctly, it could cause collapses. So eventually Spring Hill switch to
[3:32] something known as longwall miney. This is when miners go back and forth across
[3:37] the whole face of a deposit to remove everything as they move forward. As
[3:42] the coal is extracted, Hydraulic supports temporarily hold up the roof, and as
[3:45] the miners continue on the roof of the mine, sections behind them is allowed
[3:47] to collapse in a controlled way. Surprisingly, although this sounds more dangerous,
[3:52] this is actually considered safer than rum and pillar mining. In addition, the
[3:55] long wall techniqu would yield around eighty percent recovery rate compared to these sixty percent
[4:00] using room and pillar. However, even with a safer technique, and even
[4:04] with the best preparation, sometimes things happened that are entirely out of your control.
[4:10] It was mid afternoon on October twenty third, nineteen fifty eight, when
[4:13] forty five year old Maurice Ruddick, Levi Miley, and one hundred and seventy
[4:16] two other second Chief Spring Hill miners showed up for work. As the crew
[4:20] went to their various work areas, Maurice's mind was elsewhere. Earlier that day,
[4:25] he brought his wife and their brand new baby home from the hospital,
[4:28] which was the couple's twelfth child. With so many mouths to feed, Maurice
[4:31] couldn't afford to take much time off. So, even though he would much
[4:33] rather be at home helping his wife he had to keep minding to provide for
[4:36] his family while he daydreamed. The men stepped on two trolleys that took them
[4:41] to some of the deepest, darkest reaches of the mine. As was commonly
[4:45] the case on the long trip in side, the crew talked, joked,
[4:47] and even sang. Maurice was once in a quartet and loved the opportune to
[4:51] sing with the other men he shared the mine with now just as an aside.
[4:56] Although the depth of the mine was forty two hundred feet, the shafts
[4:58] were dug diagonally, and so many of the levels were assigned names based on
[5:01] their length instead of their depth. That's why the levels will have names that
[5:04] seem far longer than the total depth of the mine. Anyway, around the
[5:09] thirteen thousand foot level, or nearly four thousand meters into the mine, Maurice
[5:13] and Levi hopped off the trolley and began making their way to the gigantic wall
[5:15] they'd be chipping away at. When they reached their work site, Maurice found
[5:19] himself starving, so he opened his lunch box, grabbed a sandwich, and
[5:23] scarfed it down while prepared to move some coal with levi. For the next
[5:26] six hours, the pair worked tirelessly, blasting coal off the wall using compressed
[5:30] air chipper picks, and loading onto the conveyor, which took it all the
[5:32] way to the mine carts that would carry it to the surface. They would
[5:35] do this all the way into their shift end at eleven o'clock, when the
[5:39] night crew would come to relieve them. As they worked, Maurice's thoughts returned
[5:43] to his family. By the time he'd get home, the kids and his
[5:46] wife would be fast asleep, but that didn't mean he couldn't spend some time
[5:47] marveling at the family's new addition, and he was looking forward to that.
[5:53] Several hours later, at exactly eight or five pm, he was slammed back
[5:56] to his senses as the ground start to shake. This was a fear filling
[6:00] miners and spring Hill residents were all too familiar with. The mines were so
[6:03] massive and so deep that the rock inside was constantly under more and more pressure
[6:09] as coal was removed, so was the natural support the rock provided, which
[6:12] is why hydraulic supports and pillars were necessary to make up for that difference.
[6:15] Still, the amount of weight on the layer above was constantly growing, and
[6:18] even in the days leading up to that moment, the men noticed that the
[6:21] normally soft coal was hardening, making it much more difficult to remove. They
[6:26] knew that this meant something known as a bump was coming. This is a
[6:30] phenomenon that's generally only a problem for the largest of mines. A bump is
[6:33] literal seismic activity that's caused by the mind itself. Since weight is constantly shifting
[6:39] with the removal of rockin or stress starts to build, and eventually the mind
[6:42] starts to shift. This can eventually cause a sudden, violent failure of the
[6:46] supports and earthquakes of varying strength. In fact, between March and September of
[6:50] that year, six large bumps had been recorded, and even earlier that same
[6:54] day, a smaller bump was felt but mostly ignored. In that instant,
[6:58] though, Maurice and levite knew that this wasn't just an average bump. When
[7:00] the walls, floor, and ceilings started to collapse, shooting massive rocks in
[7:05] every direction. There were then three shockwaves that tore through the mud, closing
[7:10] exits with piles of heavy rock debris. Maurice had been standing near the top
[7:14] of the wall when it hit, and the sound was so deafening that it
[7:15] made him dizzy. Then, as quickly as it started, the bump came
[7:19] to an end as the noise from the shaken was replaced by the screams of
[7:23] men at nearly every level of the mine. As Maurice started to regain his
[7:28] wits, he found that he was buried up to his waist and coal.
[7:31] Then, turning his head lamp on, he could see nothing but coal dust
[7:34] all around him, knowing that if it ignited, he would burn to death.
[7:39] It wasn't until it all settled that he saw that the once tall tunnel
[7:42] was now only about five feet or one and a half meters high. Maurice
[7:46] then began to check himself over, because the situation was so disorienting that he
[7:48] wasn't even sure if he was hurt badly or not. Initially, miraculously,
[7:53] other than a few small cuts and bruises, he was fine, and overall,
[7:56] considering the destruction around him, he was extremely lucky when many of his
[8:00] colleagues were not. After crawling out of the coal, Maurice came across another
[8:03] miner, a man named Percy Rector, whose arm had been squished between two
[8:07] large timber supports. Unfortunately, all the tools and equipment they had before the
[8:11] bump were now buried under the rubble, and there was no way to free
[8:15] him otherwise. So next Maury's gathered up every aspirin these seven men around,
[8:18] a hat on them and fed them to Percy. Then, once Percy's pain
[8:22] was addressed, Maurice looked around two side up their situation. The seven men
[8:26] were now locked into an area around fifty feet or fifteen meters long. Four
[8:31] feet were just over a meter wide and just high enough to stand up in.
[8:35] All of the exits were completely closed off otherwise, so with nothing to
[8:39] do but wait, the miners lay down on the ground, uncertain of when
[8:43] or if they could be rescued. Almost as soon as the bump dissipated,
[8:46] spring Hill citizens started riding at the mine. Everyone who lived there at least
[8:50] knew someone who worked at the mines, but the vast majority of the town
[8:52] was made up of mining families. Many of them would even joke that if
[8:56] the Springhill mines weren't there, the city of seven thousand at the time would
[9:00] have a population of just five hundred people. As mine officials started to assess
[9:03] the situation, they discovered that the phones to levels below seventy eight hundred feet
[9:07] were completely knocked out. George called her the manager of the number two shaft.
[9:11] The immediately ordered the train cars off the tracks and for charlleys to begin
[9:15] bringing men out of the mine. The rescue effort was going to need a
[9:18] lot of men on foot too, but when the ground erupted less than an
[9:20] hour earlier, dangerous levels of carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide were released and flooded
[9:26] the mine. However, this didn't matter to George and many of the uninjured
[9:30] miners, who were ready to get in there and rescue their fellow crewmen.
[9:33] With twenty volunteers, George told the rescue coordinator to summon the Dragonmen before the
[9:37] group he was leading began down the slope of the number two shaft. The
[9:41] Dragonmen were named for the company that manufactured their breathing equipment, and they were
[9:45] a specialized group of mine rescuers who were often responsible for clearing noxious gas from
[9:48] the tunnels. They carried two hours worth of air each, which gave them
[9:52] much more time in dangerous rescue situations. That first Groove rescuers led by George
[9:56] didn't have to go very far before the destruction inside the mine was clear,
[10:00] though floors and ceilings that multiple levels had collapsed, creating obstructions for rescuers trying
[10:05] to get to the further reaches. In fact, most of the shift that
[10:09] night was working on levels at thirteen thousand feet and thirteen thousand eight hundred feet.
[10:13] When George and his group reached the area where the majority of miners were
[10:16] supposed to be, they were greeted with a horrible sight. The levels were
[10:20] completely jammed up with debris, and getting beyond the rock falls was going to
[10:24] be a challenge, especially with gases at thirteen thousand feet starting to affect the
[10:26] rescuers. It took the better part of the next three hours for them to
[10:31] create enough of an opening to burrow through, and when they made it,
[10:33] they found thirteen miners trapped on the other side. By that time, only
[10:37] thirty six of one hundred and seventy four miners had made it out of the
[10:41] crumbling labyrinth below ground, and rescuers could hear the cries and groans of many
[10:45] in other sections they couldn't reach yet. As the sun rose over spring Hill
[10:48] the next morning, the Countess survivors who made it out reached eighty one.
[10:52] Among them, fifteen were injured enough to need medical attention, and many of
[10:56] those who had escaped were working on the thirteen four hundred foot levels and thirteen
[11:00] thou eight hundred foot levels, but a further ninety three men were unaccounted for
[11:03] on the thirteen thousand foot level. As the picture of the disaster became more
[11:09] and more clear, another terrifying discovery was made. Those who weren't working inside
[11:13] galleries or we hadn't been able to take appropriate shelter, had been completely crushed
[11:16] between the floors, ceilings, and walls that gave Wager and the bump,
[11:20] and rescuers began to find pieces everywhere as they continued. The number of those
[11:26] still lost was uncertain, but it was clear that the toll would be considerable,
[11:30] and at around five forty five on the morning of October twenty fourth,
[11:33] the body of the first dead miners removed the mine and taken to the morgue
[11:37] outside the mine. The crowd had grown to include nearly all of spring Hill,
[11:39] and they were joined by reporters from media outlets all over. Also arriving
[11:43] at spring Hill that morning was Harold Gordon, the coal chief of Dosco,
[11:46] which owned the company that ran the mine in the nineteen fifty six disaster two
[11:50] years earlier. It was actually Harold who led the rescue effort. As soon
[11:54] as he learned of this new instant, he jumped into his car and drove
[11:56] three hundred miles to the scene and arrived in the early hour was of October
[12:00] twenty fourth. Then once he was there, he wasted very little time and
[12:03] entered the mine with another group of rescuers to assess the situation. Nine hours
[12:09] later he returned with grim news. He believed all ninety three of the remaining
[12:13] missing men were dead, and he told reporters as much through a cracking voice.
[12:18] Harold was wrong, though, the seven men that included Maurice were still
[12:20] alive and waiting for rescue. They could hear what was going on around them,
[12:24] but it seemed like the noise never got much closer. Then, in
[12:28] another area where Levi was working, when the bump hit, he was putting
[12:31] wooden supports into the roof near the top of the thirteen thousand foot level.
[12:35] The force of the jolts threw him off his scaffold and onto the rock form
[12:37] blow, but somehow he scrambled into a small rock cove not much bigger than
[12:41] the one Maurice was trapped in, and just like Maurice, Levi wasn't alone.
[12:45] With him were eleven more miners, but one of which was badly hurt.
[12:48] The man's leg was trapped on a debris, almost certainly broken, and
[12:52] any movement of the rocks around him caused him agonizing pain. There was,
[12:56] unforcnately, nothing anyone could do for him, though he'd have to remain there
[12:58] until rescue arrived, whenever that would occur. For days afterward, only bodies
[13:03] were covered by the dejected rescuers coming out of the mine, and for those
[13:07] who were still alive and trapped below. The longer they were held captive,
[13:09] the more starvation and dehydration became a concern. Both Maurice and Levi's respective groups
[13:16] pooled all their food and water together and rashed them out. The supplies wouldn't
[13:20] last forever, but at least what they had would buy the rescuers more time
[13:22] to reach them. Maurice's group even divid up some chewing tobacco one of the
[13:26] men had, and while none of the trapped miners had much. They had
[13:30] a hope that was kept alive by the constant sound of rescuers feverishly working to
[13:33] reach them. Each of the mind's levels also had a series of pipes running
[13:37] through which Maurice's group pounded on and in effort to let the others know they
[13:41] were still live, but even after days of this they never received a response.
[13:45] A few of the survivors even tried to burrow out, but only made
[13:48] it about sixty feet or eighteen meters before they could go no further. Throughout
[13:52] it all, Maurice and a fellos vivors did what they could to keep spirits
[13:54] high. Monday, October twenty seventh was the twenty ninth birthday of one of
[13:58] the men trapped with, so they took a sandwich and divided up among each
[14:01] of them before singing Happy Birthday. But then tragically the next day, Percy
[14:07] succumbed to his devastating arm injury. For days before he passed, he begged
[14:11] the others to remove the arm, but no one had a knife. By
[14:15] that point as well, they were living in complete darkness. All the head
[14:18] lamps had died, and not long after it they ran out of food and
[14:20] water. In an attempt to stave off hunger, some of them even tried
[14:24] eating the dried bark off some of the timber, but this proved to be
[14:26] inedible when it quickly came back up, and six days after the bump,
[14:31] the high hopes of rescue had dwindled both inside and outside the mine. That
[14:35] was until it came rushing back on October twenty ninth. That day, a
[14:39] mining engineer was at the thirteen thousand foot level testing the levels of harmful gases
[14:43] when he thought he heard the faint sound of talking. There seemed to be
[14:46] no way that anyone could still be alive after all that time, but he
[14:50] stopped to listen anyway. Then, holding his breath, he didn't move a
[14:54] muscle to see if he could hear it again. As the engineer put his
[14:56] ear to the pipe, he could hear someone say they were alive and and
[15:00] that water was desperately needed. On the other end, as Levi and the
[15:03] others remained quiet, the response they were waiting for finally came. While rescuers
[15:07] concentrated on removing sixty feet of rock that stood between them and the trap miners,
[15:11] they were able to use the pipe to send supplies through to them.
[15:15] This immediately lifted the spirits of the men inside. They may still have been
[15:18] trapped and sitting in complete darkness, but their ordeal was coming to an end,
[15:22] and they would enjoy their last few hours of the mine with hot soup,
[15:24] coffee, and cold water. Finally, after nearly twelve hours of continuous
[15:28] work, the last bit of rock was removed from a tunnel rescuers had created,
[15:31] and the men on both sides finally met in celebration and relief. News
[15:37] of the rescue then spread around the community quickly, and the crowds start to
[15:39] gather again to greet the newly found survivors when they finally exited the mine.
[15:43] The discovery and rescue was bittersweet, though there were still forty nine men unaccounted
[15:48] for, and the digging continued. In the early morning hours of November first,
[15:52] so nine days after the bump all but destroyed the mine, one of
[15:56] the rescuers heard rhythmic tapping coming from somewhere. He then hushed the men so
[16:00] we could listen to where it was coming from, and once again it was
[16:02] through a pipe that communication between the two sides was established. Every day of
[16:07] the ordeal the men in Maurice's group hammered on the pipe, hoping that someone
[16:10] would hear them, but receiving no response, just like Levi's group experienced.
[16:14] But then suddenly the men inside heard a voice through the pipe asking how many
[16:17] were still alive. The response from the trapped men was a mixture of tears
[16:22] and celebration, and hours later they were finally free. On their journey back
[16:26] to the surface, most of these seven rescue men were able to walk at
[16:29] least part of the way unto their own power, but all of them were
[16:30] still weak and severely dehydrated, despite the water sent through to them through the
[16:34] pipe. When they reached the surface around nine o'clock that morning, they were
[16:38] agreed with cheers from the gathered crowd before being brought to the hospital. All
[16:42] things considered, they were in surprise and the good shape, although each of
[16:45] them had lost about ten pounds or more. The six men who were trapped
[16:48] with Maurice also credited him with keeping spirits high and preventing the group from giving
[16:52] up hope. When things looked bleak, Maurice would lead the men in prayer
[16:56] or sing a hymn to take their minds off the predicament even for a moment,
[17:00] and they didn't know it at the time, but they were the last
[17:02] man to walk out of the mine alive. When that was confirmed, it
[17:06] was learned that seventy five men lost their lives, either during the bump or
[17:08] in the days afterward, and the process of getting the bodies that was painstaking
[17:12] on long due to the advanced state of decomposition from heat that far underground.
[17:17] Each of the bodies was brought back to the surface inside air tight aluminum coffins.
[17:22] During the ordeal as well, reporters spoke with a handful of miners,
[17:25] many of whom had been stuck inside for at least several days, and their
[17:26] were responses to questions about their experiences were vastly different. Levi's first words after
[17:32] six days inside the mine was that he needs to get home to ten,
[17:34] to his chickens. Another survivor was asked what he wanted most now that he
[17:37] was out of the mine, and he replied that he wanted a seven episoda.
[17:41] Upon hearing this interview, the Pepsi Cola company hired him as a spokesman.
[17:45] Another miner who spoke to the media, however, said that this was
[17:48] his last shift he was ever going to work in a mine, adding that
[17:51] being trapped was the worst experience of his life. Maurice, on the other
[17:55] hand, was unassuming about it all and tried his best to return to life
[17:57] as usual with his twelve children, But the story of his courage throughout the
[18:00] ordeal didn't remain secret for long, and he was eventually recognized as Canada's Citizen
[18:04] of the Year. The spring Hill Mines would continue to operate for another thirteen
[18:08] years before closing for good, and an inquiry fall in the nineteen fifty eight
[18:12] disaster cleared the apparent company of the mind of any wrongdoing. If you made
[18:18] it this far, thanks for tuning it, and hopefully I will see you
[18:21] in the next one.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
