# Manmade Cave Collapses With People Inside

An episode of [Scary Interesting Podcast](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1705969819), 17 Jul 2024, 19 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/60713754/manmade_cave_collapses_with_people_inside.mp3

Ambient Songs: "The End is Coming" by CoAg https://www.youtube.com/@co.agmusic1823 Intro Theme by Swift Junai: https://www.instagram.com/swiftjunai/?hl=en https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC6hf5nMJ8s6LJJfFR4OQ3lg https://open.spotify.com/artist/1PoG2b18MHocWZA8zQgWjO Writers and researchers: Jay Adams https://instagram.com/jayadamsdigital?igshid=MzMyNGUyNmU2YQ== Rich Firth-Godbehere instagram.com/DrRichFG https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMGZs8swehdcCB0pi3V4vKQ Jordan Gottschick https://www.youtube.com/@DerpsWithWolves/playlists Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/scary-interesting-podcast--5945096/support.

## Transcript

[0:00] On August fifth, two thousand seven, dozens of miners entered the massive labyrinth
[0:05] that was the Crandall Canyon Mine. Unbeknownst to these miners, something terrible was
[0:11] waiting deep underground, and horrifyingly, for many of them, this would be
[0:15] the last time they would ever see the light of day. This is their
[0:19] story and has always Viewer discretion is advised. About one hundred and forty miles
[0:34] south of Salt Lake City, Utah, is where you'll find Monte LaSalle National
[0:38] Forest. This forest is a massive preservation of one point two million acres and
[0:43] also includes the state's second highest mountain range, which are the LaSalle Mountains.
[0:48] Right in the middle of all of it is the Crandall Canyon Mine. Unlike
[0:52] many mines, which often spur the development of nearby towns, the Crandle Canyon
[0:55] Mine is fairly remote. The nearest civilization is Huntington, which is the town
[1:00] of around two thousand people and sits about ten miles to the southeast of the
[1:03] mine. Mining there began in nineteen thirty nine. It continued all the way
[1:07] until nineteen fifty five, but it would then sit untouched until the early nineteen
[1:11] eighties. When it was bought out by two other companies. The new co
[1:14] owners contracted mining operations out to a coal company, which employed around seventy miners
[1:19] at any given time. Afterward, together they would also update the mine with
[1:23] modern equipment and transportation systems, and by nineteen ninety one, as much as
[1:26] one point five million tons of coal removed from the mine each year. As
[1:30] the summer of two thousand and seven were on the Crandall Canyon Mine had thousands
[1:34] feet of corridors that ran thousands of feet deep, providing more than enough work
[1:38] to keep mining going twenty four hours a day, seven days a week.
[1:42] In a week's time, miners there worked twelve hour shifts and were split into
[1:45] several groups. Two separate crews would handle the day and night shifts Tuesday through
[1:49] Thursday, and two more would mine from Friday to Sunday. Then on Mondays
[1:53] everyone worked either the day or night shift, two double production once a week.
[1:57] The night shift on Monday, August fifth, two thousand and seven,
[2:00] started no different than any other. Between the hours of six and seven pm,
[2:05] the day crew would be relieved and the night shift would take over.
[2:07] Maintenance mechanics like Jamison Ward and tim Harper, however, were to slightly offset
[2:12] hours from five pm to five am. Jamison entered the mine around five to
[2:15] ten that afternoon and made his way to an area called the South Barrier.
[2:20] In this section, a handful of shift miners were extracting or around fifteen hundred
[2:23] feet or four hund and fifty meters beneath the ground. He then approached the
[2:27] crew and asked if they were having a maintenance issues that he needed to check
[2:30] out, and they would tell him that. Earlier in the day, a
[2:31] scoop on a critical piece of equipment called a continuous mining machine broke and was
[2:36] in need of repair. After visiting with the men for a few more minutes,
[2:39] Jamison returned to his truck to grab some tools and headed over to begin
[2:43] repairing the scoop. In addition to getting the broken machine operational again, Jamison's
[2:47] task for that night shift was to install circuit breaker posts. These are installed
[2:52] because as the continuous mining machines advance into the mountain, conveyor belts that transport
[2:55] the coal out require power. These posts would now have to wait until the
[3:00] scoop was repaired, which was just as well considering that the machine need to
[3:02] advance further before he could start set in the posts. Anyway, Tim meanwhile
[3:07] started his shift, where they stop at the above ground warehouse to pick up
[3:09] some parts and supplies to set up a new charging station in the section three
[3:13] north on the complete opposite side of the mine. When he finally had everything
[3:16] he needed, he returned to his truck and headed into the tunnels. Now,
[3:21] the process of mining coal is obviously more complicated than simply drilling holes into
[3:23] a mountain. There are different ways to mine ore, and the Crandle Canyon
[3:28] mine employed a system known as room and pillar, which you may remember from
[3:30] the spring Hill Mind disaster video. In basic terms, miners dig out material
[3:36] to create underground rooms, which are really more like wide hallways. Between these,
[3:39] they leave unmined or in place to act as pillars that provide the support
[3:43] to keep the mind from caving in as the coal is extracted. And there
[3:46] are benefits and drawbacks to this style of mining, but the main drawback is
[3:50] that production is limited since it requires some of the coal to remain behind.
[3:53] This means profits are also far from maximized. Four mine owners. In any
[3:59] case, at six o'clock, the night shift replaced the day shift and five
[4:01] miners continued cutting through rock in the South Bearer section. Less than two hours
[4:06] later, as Jamison continued fixing the scoop and Tim installed a charging station on
[4:11] the other side of the mine, the mine around them started to rumble.
[4:14] Now, surprisingly, this is a relatively common occurrence inside mines, and this
[4:17] one was registered as a two point two on the Earthquake Richter Scale. At
[4:21] the same time, although it was little more than a minor tremor inside Crandell
[4:25] Canyon mine, it sounded like there may have been a cave in further into
[4:28] the work area of the south barrier. A quick inspection of the section by
[4:31] Don Erickson, who was a mine foreman, revealed nothing out of the ordinary,
[4:34] however, so mining continued some time later. At around eleven thirty that
[4:39] night, Jamison finished repairing the scoop and finally got to work installing breaker posts.
[4:44] Then, around two am on August sixth he received a call from Tim,
[4:46] and Tim went on to tell him that he was finished with his installation,
[4:48] but after he packed up his truck and went to drive back to the
[4:50] warehouse, the truck refused to start. He then asked Jamison to come pick
[4:55] him up. After the call, Jamison tracked Dawn down and asked him if
[4:59] he could go help Tim, but he told Jameson to get the breaker posts
[5:00] installed first, otherwise the mining operation in the South Bearer would have to stop
[5:05] because they wouldn't have power. The breaker posts took Jamison another forty five minutes
[5:10] to complete, and when he was finished, he gave timacall to let him
[5:12] know he was on his way. Three minutes later, at two forty eight
[5:15] am, as Jamison drove away from the South Barer, a violent crack echoed
[5:19] through the mine that originated near where he had just been working. Just then,
[5:24] the Mind started shaking for a second time during the shift. This time
[5:28] the movement came in at almost a four on the Richter scale, and it
[5:30] sounded once again like the seuth Bearer caved in, only this time it had
[5:35] coal and rock. Debris then poured from the ceiling of Mind, blocking every
[5:40] path to the South Barer and trapping five miners as well as Dawn in the
[5:43] section. The energy from the cave and also created a burst of wind that
[5:46] caught up to Jameson's truck in the main tunnel and was so forceful that it
[5:49] blew the truck sideways. When it finally came to a stop, he got
[5:54] out and looked back where he came from, only to see that the route
[5:57] to the celth Bear was now completely blocked. He then hopped back into his
[6:00] truck and drove to the main West Tunnel to a phone not too far from
[6:03] where his trucks get into a stop. Once again, he called Tim and
[6:06] then asked him if he heard or felt the rumble, and was surprised to
[6:10] learn that the same gust of wind that almost threw his truck into a wall
[6:13] made it all the way to Tim's location, along with a scattershot of small
[6:16] rocks. One of these rocks probably hit Tim's head so hard that it injured
[6:20] his right ear drum. Elsewhere in the mine and at the surface fore men
[6:24] were trying to get a sense of what happened. Attempts to reach down by
[6:27] phone were unsuccessful, meaning that the caven could have severed the South Bear phone
[6:30] lines or worse. As this was happening, Jamison picked up Tim and turned
[6:34] around to head back toward where the blast of aaron rock came from. Along
[6:39] the main West Tunnel and along this tunnel are individual sections called cross cuts.
[6:44] The five miners in don were trapped at cross Cut one for one, but
[6:47] when Jamison and Tim reached cross Cut one thirteen, a massive single piece of
[6:51] coal was blocking the tire remainder of the tunnel. Upon seeing this, the
[6:56] pair then rushed the near phone and called the mine superintendent to brief from on
[6:59] the situation. At three thirty am, so less than an hour after the
[7:02] caven, the mine rescue team and the Mind Safety and Health Administration or MSHA
[7:08] were informed of the incident began mobilizing. A call was placed to the Sheriff's
[7:11] office, and before long deputies and medics began showing up at the mine.
[7:15] Plans for what to do next were underway, using what was provided by Jamison
[7:18] and Tim once they exited the mine. It was then decided that rescuers were
[7:23] going to try to reach the trapmen from two angles, one horizontal and one
[7:26] vertical. While one crew was working inside the mine to clear debris from the
[7:30] entryways and route to the south barrier, another would go to the top of
[7:32] the mountain and drill straight down to where the men were last known to be.
[7:36] The intention of this, however, wasn't to remove the men from the
[7:40] mine vertically instead. The drilling was done in hopes of supplying the men with
[7:43] fresh air, food, and water. Now, it might be easy to
[7:46] assume that the crew working inside the mine would reach the trap miners before the
[7:49] vertical shaft was drilled, but removing the debris from the mine meant putting rescuers
[7:54] in the highly unstable environment. It was unclear at the time just how badly
[7:58] the mind had been damaged, so they have to work slowly and reinforce the
[8:01] main tune along the way to ensure it wouldn't caven again. Initial estimates put
[8:05] the time to complete the vertical could shaft at about one full week, meaning
[8:09] that not only did they expect the rescue efforts inside take longer than a week,
[8:13] but it also raised concerns about whether or not the men stuck inside could
[8:16] survive that long, if they even survived the collapse at all. By the
[8:20] afternoon of the day the collapse, communications still hadn't been established between rescuers and
[8:24] the trapped miners. In this type of scenario, one of the ways that
[8:28] those trapped could communicate with rescuers is to bang on the rock walls or pipes
[8:31] with a tool to indicate their location and status. If necessary. They could
[8:35] even communicate back and forth using Morse code, and with the phone lines to
[8:39] that section down, rescuers hoped to hear tapping, but it just never seemed
[8:41] to come. Work to reach the miners continued around the clock, but then
[8:46] on the night of August seventh, the seismic activity returned and the mine was
[8:48] evacuated. By then, the ordeal was quickly approaching forty eight hours in and
[8:52] now the effort to save them was forced to a standstill. That same night,
[8:58] a press conference was held by mine and county officials, including the crand
[9:01] O Canyon mine owner. In his initial statement, the co owner was adamant
[9:05] that the collapse was caused by an earthquake and that the trap miners had enough
[9:07] air and water to last them a few weeks. Throughout the press conference,
[9:11] though, it was impossible not to notice that as demeanor wavered between angry and
[9:15] contemptuous, and this may have been in part to the fact that seismologists openly
[9:20] disagreed with the executive. Instead, they believed that the miners didn't have nearly
[9:24] as much breathable air as he was letting on when Jamison and Tim first inspected
[9:28] the damage near the South Bear. They noticed that these stoppings in the Era
[9:31] had been destroyed. A stopping is a durable, incombustible wall constructed inside mines
[9:37] to separate intake air from return air. These are crucial since carbon monoxide and
[9:43] carbon dioxide are ever present dangerous inside mines. When the stoppings came down,
[9:48] the ventilation system that brings good air in and takes bad air was compromised.
[9:52] This meant that there was no telling how much air, if any, was
[9:54] getting to the trapped miners. Scientists were also the opinion that the Caven caused
[9:58] the side activity, not the other way around, and for good reason.
[10:03] An earthquake and seismic activity caused by mining have separate and distinct signatures on seismometer
[10:07] readings, and those from around the time of the Caven were not consistent with
[10:11] those of natural earthquakes. As you might have suspected, the co owner had
[10:16] reasons for pushing the earthquake narrative. As we've established, Crandall Canyon was mine
[10:20] using the room and pillar system. However, companies grew frustrated by this way
[10:24] of mining because of all the revenue that had to be left inside to keep
[10:26] the ceiling from collapsing, so over time a slight alteration to the Rouman pillar
[10:31] approach was developed to solve this problem. Using this new method, when a
[10:35] set of rooms was finished, the miners could start to remove pillars from the
[10:39] furthest point and let small section of the roof collapse. As the pillars are
[10:43] removed, small controlled cavens would occur, and those could be mine too.
[10:46] This is called retreat mining, and although it's more lucrative, it's kind of
[10:48] risky obviously. As pillars are removed, there are fewer and fewer supports sharing
[10:54] the weight of all the rock above, and that increases the stress on the
[10:56] remaining pillars. In fact, the MSA has regulations around retreat mining, and
[11:01] it's required that mines submit and have approved a roof support plan to keep their
[11:05] miner safe. And while the goal of retreat mining is to allow predictable portions
[11:09] of the ceiling to fall when a pillar is removed, it's not an exact
[11:13] science and things can go poorly quickly even with an approved plan. If too
[11:16] much weight is transferred to too few pillars, it can result in what's known
[11:20] as a coal outburst, which is exactly what it sounds like. Coal pillars
[11:24] become so compressed that they collapse and coal burst from the location of the break.
[11:28] Anyways, back inside the mine, the effort to reach the miners horizontally
[11:31] restarted, and late on August ninth, a second vertical hole about two and
[11:35] a half inches or six centimeters wide, was started. The smaller circumference of
[11:39] this second hole meant they'd penetrate the air and the trapped miners occupied quicker than
[11:43] the first vertical This was becoming more and more crucial to establish communication perform air
[11:48] readings to get a sense of what conditions were like where they were trapped.
[11:52] Then the following day, in August tenth, the drill broke through the ceiling
[11:56] of the section, having bored its way some eighteen hundred feet or about five
[12:00] one hundred and fifty meters into the mountain. This was the first glimmer of
[12:03] hope since the miners became trapped in the early moments of August sixth, but
[12:05] it wouldn't last long. Attempts to communicate with anyone who might be stuck in
[12:11] the section were unsuccessful, but the most telling and concerning development came from the
[12:15] air ratings taken at the borehole. The word air is often used interchangeably with
[12:20] the word oxygen, but the air we breathe is actually about seventy eight percent
[12:22] nitrogen on only twenty one percent oxygen. In minds. For a variety of
[12:28] reasons, carbon dioxide and carbonoxide are more plentiful, and the composition of the
[12:31] air can vary. But crucially, if oxygen concentration in the air drops to
[12:35] about fifteen percent, that's when things start to become more dangerous and the symptoms
[12:39] of hypoxia usually set in. If oxygen concentrations drop to a further seven point
[12:43] five percent, there's simply not enough to sustain life, and horrifyingly, at
[12:48] the top of the mountain, the readings from the air flowing out of the
[12:50] borehole registered just seven percent oxygen. When the news was announced at another press
[12:56] conference later in the day, the owner once again downplayed the significant the readings.
[13:01] He claimed that it was just indicative of the auction concentration in the borehole
[13:03] itself and not necessarily inside the mine. His agitation over the entire rescue process
[13:09] and how the developments were putting his company in a bad light, then boiled
[13:13] over. He then went on to criticize the effort to reach the miners through
[13:16] the mine, saying progress was far too slow. There was literally nothing that
[13:20] could be done to speed it up, though if they went any faster they
[13:22] would be putting the lives of the rescuers in danger. They had to proceed
[13:26] cautiously in the clearly unstable mind, taking care to install man made supports as
[13:31] needed. Almost a week passed after the coalburst trapped the six miners when a
[13:35] camera was put down the second borehol in hopes of getting eyes in the situation
[13:39] inside. The only thing that could be seen in the section, however,
[13:41] was a few feet of rubble covering the main floor. By then, only
[13:46] about twenty five percent of the length the main West tunnel had been cleared of
[13:48] rubble, and conditions only seemed to get worse for the rescue crews. Seismic
[13:52] events kept taking place inside the mine, and by August sixteenth, so ten
[13:56] days after the initial collapse, forty one were recorded. None of them,
[14:00] however, originated from the south barrier where the miners were trapped. They were
[14:03] all coming from a different area known as Entry Number one. Which is where
[14:07] the rescuers were working. In fact, on August fifteenth, the shaking us
[14:11] so bad that an expatter use in the rescue effort was mostly buried by coal
[14:15] breaking loose from the ceiling. This became such a concern from rescuers that twelve
[14:18] of them asked to be relieved from duty. Unfortunately, their sense of trepidation
[14:22] and the seismic events themselves were largely ignored. Something was still happening inside the
[14:28] mine, and the officials leading the rescue operation were doing their best not to
[14:31] confront the possibility that continuing to dig toward the trap miners was too dangerous.
[14:37] The removal of rebbel continued, and as it did, no one seemed to
[14:39] notice that more of the pillars that had become piles were compressed and therefore helping
[14:43] to support some of the weight above. This meant that as the rubbel was
[14:48] removed, it was actually contributing to the instability of the mine. Soon enough,
[14:52] those who hadn't begged to stop the rescue out of fear were about to
[14:54] find that out. As it approached seven PM on August sixteenth, the pillar
[15:00] between entries one and two suddenly and violently gave way as coal burst out in
[15:03] every direction like shrapnel from a grenade. When it did, it smashed into
[15:09] everything in the air, including rescue workers. So much coal collapsed that when
[15:13] the dust cleared, there was four feet or but a meter of rubble and
[15:16] debris piled up between the two entries. The coal burst alone killed two more
[15:20] monitors and one inspector, and another six suffered major but non life threatening injuries.
[15:24] Then, at that day's press conference, the owner announced that his company
[15:28] filed paperwork with the federal government to close and seal the Crandle Canyon mine forever.
[15:33] In his own preliminary assessment of what caused the true tragic accidents, he
[15:37] told reporters that the blame rested on the mountain itself because it was supposedly evil.
[15:41] The US Department of Labor, however, didn't share that opinion. An
[15:46] investigation into both incidents got underwagh and the final report that was issued found multiple
[15:50] causes, including some caused by corporate neglect. Here's what the MSHA determined.
[15:56] The coal outburst on August sixth, and the self Bears section was so significant
[16:00] that it took out around half a mile or eight hundred and five meters of
[16:03] coal pillars at the point of the outbursts where the six miners were working.
[16:07] Coal likely exploded from the broken pillars like pellets, spreading larger and larger as
[16:11] they traveled. It's believed that all six were killed instantly, likely before they
[16:17] knew it was happening. If any of them somehow survived the blast a debris,
[16:21] the destruction of the ventilation system would have caused air significantly deficient in auxygen
[16:25] to flood the trap section. Essentially, the workers were doomed the moment their
[16:29] shift began in the previous evening. The actual root cause of the tragedy,
[16:33] though, was traced back to the engineering analysis done by a separate company.
[16:37] Apparently, during the investigation, it was determined that all of the recommendations made
[16:41] by this analysis for safely retreat mining were extremely flawed. Unfortunately, then,
[16:45] from this incorrect analysis, a roof control plan was drawn up by the mine
[16:49] operator, which led to insufficient pillar dimensions and an overall incorrect design of the
[16:53] mine. And in fact, the August sixth and sixteenth incidents weren't even the
[16:57] first coal outburst the mind experienced either. In March of two thousand and seven,
[17:03] Just five months before those deadly events, coal burst started occurring and got
[17:06] more frequent over time, and one occurred just three days before the August sixth
[17:10] outburst. None of the bursts preceding the August sixth event were strong enough to
[17:14] cause any fatalities, but the mine operator should have taken these as signs of
[17:17] growing instability, the report concluded. Instead, it continued mining coal in conditions
[17:22] that were growing more and more and safe, when it was clear that the
[17:23] roof control plan was not adequate enough to ensure the safety of miners from coal
[17:27] bursts. But among the infractions the company committed, one of the most egregious
[17:32] was that the company failed to inform the MSAHA about several coalbursts, and they
[17:36] even misled the agency about the severity of one of them. Because of this,
[17:40] the MSAHA didn't have an opportunity to investigate these incidents, and had the
[17:44] agency been able to look into the outburst, it may have prevented the August
[17:47] strategy from occurring at all. As for the incident on August sixteenth, the
[17:51] removal of collapsed yet compact a coal in the effort to reach the trapped miners
[17:55] caused more and more instability in an already unsafe environment. The pressure from the
[17:59] w to the coal and the insufficient pillars continued to grow, and so the
[18:02] pillars between entries one and two couldn't bear the load anymore and gave way.
[18:07] In the end, the final report listed nine infractions committed by the company that
[18:11] directly led to the instants and won by the engineering company. The MSHA then
[18:15] levied the highest finds possible against the mining company, totally more than one point
[18:18] six million. The engineering company was also ordered to pay two hundred and twenty
[18:22] thousand dollars in fines. It's unclear if the mine owner was directly fined or
[18:26] if the company was responsible for paying some or all of the mine operator fines,
[18:30] as the final report did not point specific fault at either the owner or
[18:33] the Parrot company. And tragically, on September first, the rescue effort was
[18:38] called off after four weeks of attempts and two months after the tragedies. Inside
[18:42] Crandell Canyon mine, the main passages were sealed with bricks, leaving these six
[18:47] bodies still trapped inside with the hopes of one day being able to recover them.
[18:51] As of twenty twenty four, There have been no further attempts to recover
[18:53] the bodies left in the Crandell Canyon mines Seuth Barrier

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
