# 68. Potentially Edifying (Ordination Questions with Groff)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 14 Jan 2025, 1 h 29 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/16433398-68-potentially-edifying-ordination-questions-with-groff.mp3

In this episode of Polity Matters, Ben Ratliff, Jared Nelson, Scott Edburg, and special guest Zachary Groff take a deep dive into the ordination vows for teaching elders in the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA). The conversation explores the significance of each vow, offering practical insights and theological reflections for ministers and members alike. Presbyterian Polity Greenville Presbyterian Theological Seminary The Christian Ministry 12 Ways Your Phone Is Changing You Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Transcript

[0:07] SPEAKER_00: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:09] SPEAKER_00: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined as always by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg, and today we're talking about ordination, the vows that teaching elders take upon their ordination.
[0:19] SPEAKER_00: We hit this in uh chapter 21 when Steve Tipton joined us not long ago, and we decided we thought that uh it was worth coming back, circling around to these eight questions again and spending a whole episode discussing.
[0:31] SPEAKER_00: And we needed some backup, and so we have uh oh, hold on.
[0:36] SPEAKER_00: I'm getting an error.
[0:38] SPEAKER_00: Do y'all see an error?
[0:40] SPEAKER_03: Uh yeah, I'm on the show.
[0:41] SPEAKER_03: That's your error.
[0:42] SPEAKER_03: My error.
[0:43] SPEAKER_00: Error in judgment.
[0:44] SPEAKER_00: Error.
[0:45] SPEAKER_00: Actual recording, actual recording, actual recording.
[0:47] SPEAKER_00: All right, well, everything seems to be working just fine.
[0:51] SPEAKER_00: All right.
[0:51] SPEAKER_00: I I guess as soon as I was about to say his name, everything on my screen went red and warned me against this, but we're gonna proceed nevertheless.
[0:59] SPEAKER_00: Zach Groff, welcome to the show.
[1:01] SPEAKER_00: Uh Ben, why don't you restart, dude?
[1:05] SPEAKER_00: No, no, stop the recording.
[1:07] SPEAKER_00: That's not that's not how we roll here at Polity Matters.
[1:10] SPEAKER_04: I want to re-record this.
[1:12] SPEAKER_04: It's one of these.
[1:12] SPEAKER_04: You do?
[1:13] SPEAKER_04: You want to re-record this?
[1:14] SPEAKER_00: This is great.
[1:15] SPEAKER_00: This is fantastic.
[1:16] SPEAKER_04: I mean, I don't want to re-record this because it doesn't record.
[1:20] SPEAKER_00: Welcome to the show, brother.
[1:21] SPEAKER_00: Why don't you uh I imagine some of our listeners probably know who you are.
[1:25] SPEAKER_00: They confuse your website and our podcast online often.
[1:30] SPEAKER_00: Uh so introduce yourself.
[1:32] SPEAKER_00: Who are you, where you're from, what you do, tell us about your family.
[1:34] SPEAKER_03: All you know the thing.
[1:36] SPEAKER_03: Thanks, Ben.
[1:37] SPEAKER_03: Um my name's Zach Groff.
[1:38] SPEAKER_03: I'm the pastor of Antioch Presbyterian Church down in Woodruff, South Carolina.
[1:43] SPEAKER_03: And that's uh, I guess up in Woodruff, South Carolina for Ben, but down in Woodruff uh when compared to Jared and Scott and where they're located.
[1:52] SPEAKER_03: But I've been here for a few years now, and it was originally a reorganization work for us.
[1:58] SPEAKER_03: This is an historic church founded in 1843, and I've had the privilege of being a part of an effort to basically replant it, but while keeping the history and respecting it and honoring those who've gone before us, this has been an old school Presbyterian church since the 1840s, even formally aligned with uh that party within the Southern Presbyterian Church and within the American Presbyterian Church called the Old School Contingent or Party.
[2:25] SPEAKER_03: So uh it's a real privilege to be here.
[2:27] SPEAKER_03: But uh I am married to Jocelyn.
[2:29] SPEAKER_03: We have six children, and um it is a wonderful thing to be on.
[2:36] SPEAKER_03: Polity Matters, as you mentioned, close affinity with a website that uh I run called um Presbyterian Polity, which is overseen by an editorial board um which includes Pastor Nelson, Jared here, but also uh overseen by a number of other PCA teaching and ruling elders as we produce content that we hope is helpful um for instructing, uh advising, and encouraging men who are either new to Presbyterianism or uh looking for additional insight from other brothers in different contexts around the country, particularly within the PCA at this point.
[3:20] SPEAKER_03: And so we have a running blog, we have some static content, which includes some case studies and links to other good resources, including Polity Matters.
[3:31] SPEAKER_03: Uh, it's a great podcast and really lines up with the mission of the Presbyterian Polity website as well.
[3:39] SPEAKER_03: So it's great to be here to see a confluence of uh of resources, you might say.
[3:45] SPEAKER_01: Now, Zach, are you like some of our other guests that this will be the first time that you've heard Polity Matters?
[3:52] SPEAKER_03: Um, no, I've listened to Polity Matters before.
[3:55] SPEAKER_03: I can't say I listen to every episode.
[3:57] SPEAKER_03: I can't say that about any podcast, but I have dipped in here and there, and I found your conversations uplifting, encouraging, much like K-Love with Christian radio.
[4:08] SPEAKER_03: Yep.
[4:09] SPEAKER_03: Uplifting and encouraging.
[4:13] SPEAKER_00: We're glad that Zach is here for his first uh guest appearance and last after the K-Love comment.
[4:22] SPEAKER_00: If um if you've ever been ordained as a teaching elder or have ever been to an installation service for a teaching elder, you've heard these questions that we're gonna talk about.
[4:32] SPEAKER_00: Um some of us uh I I think I I'm not the only one.
[4:35] SPEAKER_00: I have them printed and they hang on my office wall.
[4:38] SPEAKER_00: Um good reminders of what we what we do because the our vows are not just words.
[4:43] SPEAKER_00: Um it's not just a shibboleth that we have to utter in order to get into the church.
[4:47] SPEAKER_00: They're promises that we make, um promises to uphold the scriptures, um, promises to guard the gospel that we've been entrusted with, promises to live a life that um reflects Christ and the calling to which we've been called.
[5:01] SPEAKER_00: They they set the course for our whole ministry, um, and they bind us as ministers to the truth, and um especially in terms of the installation aspect of them, they bind us to our particular congregations.
[5:12] SPEAKER_00: So we're gonna go through the eight ordination questions from BCO 215.
[5:17] SPEAKER_00: So if you want to pull your BCO out, that's where you need to turn.
[5:20] SPEAKER_00: We're gonna talk about what they mean, um, why they're significant, how they guide ministers.
[5:25] SPEAKER_00: Uh really it's kind of up in the air where we might go with each one of these.
[5:28] SPEAKER_00: But before we get into question number one regarding the word of God as inerrant um and infallible, we want to talk about vows in general.
[5:37] SPEAKER_00: And so the Westminster Confession of Faith in 22.5 teaches that a vow is of like nature with an oath and should be made with all religious care and faithfulness.
[5:46] SPEAKER_00: And so the question I want to throw out to you guys is how does how does understanding um the nature of a vow shape the seriousness with which we take the the ordination vows?
[5:56] SPEAKER_00: Um, and and how do the promises of our vows differ from just generic statements that we would make in everyday life?
[6:06] SPEAKER_03: I think we need to define what a vow is.
[6:09] SPEAKER_03: You've sort of done that.
[6:10] SPEAKER_03: A vow is a promise, but it's a promissory oath.
[6:14] SPEAKER_03: Uh what is an oath?
[6:16] SPEAKER_03: If you look at paragraphs one through four of chapter twenty-two, you'll see that an oath is basically a promise made in the presence of God, taking God as witness and incurring therefore God's judgment on yourself if you break that promise with him as witness.
[6:32] SPEAKER_03: A vow is not only an oath made in the presence of God, but is a promise made to God, and that's really the key distinction there, and so it is a promise made in the prem pr uh presence of God to God, which makes it as well an act of worship, because anything we do in the presence of God, consciously so, is a conscious act of worship as well.
[6:58] SPEAKER_03: And so they're very serious.
[7:00] SPEAKER_03: And to break a vow is not only to be dishonest, but to be profane and blasphemous, and to call down judgment on yourself.
[7:09] SPEAKER_03: And so it's a very solemn occasion whenever we take a vow and promise to God that we will do such and such.
[7:17] SPEAKER_03: And this is true for membership vows, ordination vows, uh for teaching elders, ruling elders, deacons, and the like.
[7:25] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, maybe that isn't communicated to us enough.
[7:28] SPEAKER_01: I I was struck by uh Smith quotes um Samuel Miller and says, uh, to take these vows lightly or without the intent of living by them is, as Samuel Miller says, lying to the Holy Ghost.
[7:41] SPEAKER_01: So we know what happened in uh Acts 5 when that happened.
[7:45] SPEAKER_01: Um so uh it's it's something that perhaps even at the time you didn't realize the weight of it.
[7:51] SPEAKER_01: But vows are weighty things.
[7:52] SPEAKER_01: We we don't take them very often.
[7:54] SPEAKER_01: I point out to our congregation when they're hearing them, you take these when you get married, maybe when you join up to a military branch, you do oaths, you know.
[8:02] SPEAKER_01: But um vows like this, you you don't do very often, uh just membership, ordination, and um and marriage.
[8:11] SPEAKER_07: Mm-hmm.
[8:13] SPEAKER_03: And if we're ever making a vow regarding something that is religious in nature, so if we're making a promise to God about something that is religious in nature, it must be appointed in his word.
[8:25] SPEAKER_03: It can't be something that's not appointed in his word.
[8:29] SPEAKER_03: And if uh and this is a helpful point too, if we make a vow that's not about something explicitly religious or specifically religious, then um it must be either um it needs to be connected to some virtue that we should all be pursuing as Christians.
[8:49] SPEAKER_03: And this is a this is really the third feature of a vow, I would say, or requisite characteristic of a vow.
[8:56] SPEAKER_03: It needs to be something that is within our power to fulfill either according to nature or according to grace.
[9:03] SPEAKER_03: And so when we take, for example, vows of ordination, ordination vows, um, or even membership vows in the church, we're doing so in humble reliance upon God's grace, recognizing that according to our own nature, we can't do this, but we we can't take a vow to fly through the air like Superman, because that's not possible according to nature or grace.
[9:26] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[9:26] SPEAKER_03: And that's that's important as well, I think, when we're talking through the nature and requirements of vows.
[9:35] SPEAKER_00: And that's just encouraging to the man taking these vows, right?
[9:38] SPEAKER_00: That the they're not uh um inconsequential.
[9:42] SPEAKER_00: They're very weighty.
[9:43] SPEAKER_00: Any any man in his right mind before these questions is gonna feel um put on to some degree.
[9:49] SPEAKER_00: Uh they're they're they can feel burdensome on your own, but that that recognition that we we take them dependent on God's grace is extremely important.
[9:59] SPEAKER_07: We don't take them lightly.
[10:05] SPEAKER_07: Y'all alright?
[10:06] SPEAKER_07: Oh yeah.
[10:07] SPEAKER_03: So we might want to wonder why we take vows, like what's the use of it?
[10:13] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[10:14] SPEAKER_03: I mean, they're appointed in God's word.
[10:16] SPEAKER_03: It's very clear at different junctures that we're supposed to take vows because people do them by approved example.
[10:22] SPEAKER_03: But I think that there's uh some other things we can say about the utility of vows.
[10:26] SPEAKER_03: Um they uh they're really um helpful for strengthening our sense of duty and the bond of duty.
[10:37] SPEAKER_03: And so other people can even hold us accountable to the public vows we make to God, and and that's helpful.
[10:43] SPEAKER_03: Um they increase our sense of relationship and union to God.
[10:48] SPEAKER_03: I know when you take a membership vow or uh you make a vow to rear your children in the fear and admonition of the Lord as part of their baptism, you you feel like you're you're closer to God, you feel that sense not only of dependence, but of um co-laboring with the Father, as the Apostle Paul puts it.
[11:06] SPEAKER_03: And then I also think that making a practice on appropriate occasions, so not overdoing it, but making a practice on appropriate occasions of taking advantage of this particular act of worship contributes to um habituating specific virtues, making a habit of the virtues that we should be pursuing rather than seeing them as so many discrete instances of of doing good or or well doing.
[11:35] SPEAKER_03: Um, but really being a man of your word involves making solemn promises and keeping them and living by them.
[11:43] SPEAKER_03: And so I think there's a real utility to vows that flows out of scripture and is presented to us, and certainly not anything I ever thought about before becoming reformed, reading the standards, and really wrestling with this chapter and the corresponding catechism questions, because I had a default Anabaptist setting where it's small, my yes is yes, my no is no, I shouldn't be making frivolous o's, vows, and promises.
[12:09] SPEAKER_03: And while it's true you shouldn't make frivolous promises, yet there is a a real usefulness and a biblical pattern for habituating your virtue by taking vows on appropriate occasions.
[12:23] SPEAKER_03: One of which being ordination, which is not a sacrament, lest there be any confusion.
[12:30] SPEAKER_00: Not a sacrament.
[12:31] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I mean not a sacrament.
[12:32] SPEAKER_03: Not a sacrament.
[12:33] SPEAKER_03: Our Roman Catholic friends think ordination taking orders is a sacrament, but it's not.
[12:39] SPEAKER_00: Friends?
[12:40] SPEAKER_00: Is that what you said?
[12:41] SPEAKER_00: Friends?
[12:41] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[12:42] SPEAKER_00: Is that all you have?
[12:43] SPEAKER_00: I thought Scott was about to go off.
[12:44] SPEAKER_03: No.
[12:45] SPEAKER_03: No, I just can't believe that's you don't have you don't have Roman Catholic friends?
[12:49] SPEAKER_00: Enemies.
[12:50] SPEAKER_00: They're all enemies.
[12:50] SPEAKER_03: Oh, come on.
[12:51] SPEAKER_03: I got I got some I got some very fine Roman Catholic friends.
[12:56] SPEAKER_00: Very fun.
[12:56] SPEAKER_00: There's very fine people on both sides.
[12:58] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, very fine people on both sides.
[13:02] SPEAKER_00: Well, let's uh let's take a look at some of these questions.
[13:10] SPEAKER_00: There's eight of them.
[13:12] SPEAKER_00: Really?
[13:13] SPEAKER_00: We should point out uh that that the whole matter of of elder parity comes into play when you look at ordination questions.
[13:20] SPEAKER_00: There's uh different questions and ordering of questions for ruling elder uh ordinations, and so that that may come up here uh in the course of discussion.
[13:31] SPEAKER_00: But uh listeners, you may want to go look at those ordination questions uh for ruling elders and see the comparison that you can you can make.
[13:38] SPEAKER_03: But um found in BCO 24-6.
[13:41] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, thank you.
[13:42] SPEAKER_03: You're welcome.
[13:43] SPEAKER_00: Um we released there was an episode released today as as we record, December 17th on BCO 24.
[13:49] SPEAKER_03: You're giving away trade secrets here, Ben.
[13:52] SPEAKER_03: Now people are gonna figure out how long it takes you to publish this stuff.
[13:55] SPEAKER_00: People people would be surprised um how how how much we time travel here on Polity Matters.
[14:02] SPEAKER_00: Uh we're gonna have an episode that comes out in February that I think it was recorded like three months ago right now.
[14:08] SPEAKER_00: So it's I mean, we're all over the place.
[14:10] SPEAKER_03: Note to listeners.
[14:11] SPEAKER_03: Hopefully things don't change.
[14:12] SPEAKER_03: Note to listeners, never vow to time travel.
[14:17] SPEAKER_03: That's not possible according to either grace or nature.
[14:22] SPEAKER_03: Or nature.
[14:22] SPEAKER_03: Okay.
[14:23] SPEAKER_03: Or nature.
[14:26] SPEAKER_00: Let's let's delve into number one.
[14:28] SPEAKER_00: Uh though it's speaking about the word of God.
[14:30] SPEAKER_00: So the question is do you believe the scriptures of the old and new testaments as originally given to be the inerrant word of God, the only infallible rule of faith and practice?
[14:40] SPEAKER_00: Yes.
[14:41] SPEAKER_00: So, yes.
[14:42] SPEAKER_00: I think all of us have said yes.
[14:44] SPEAKER_00: Aren't we happy?
[14:45] SPEAKER_00: Um Scott, you've been quiet.
[14:48] SPEAKER_00: I'm gonna I'm gonna ask you to jump in here.
[14:50] SPEAKER_00: What what does it mean to start off with to affirm the inerrancy of scriptures as originally given?
[14:57] SPEAKER_04: Well, we were thinking of perhaps um the constitution of the PCA, and we often remind those who listen that the scriptures are not a part of the constitution of the PCA.
[15:07] SPEAKER_04: And perhaps it's because of this question right here, is that we believe that the scriptures are inerrant.
[15:13] SPEAKER_04: There is no reason or need to amend the scriptures or to change the scriptures because they are without error.
[15:20] SPEAKER_04: And so if you're going to be an officer in the church of the Lord Jesus Christ, as in the PCA, you must uh attest that the scriptures are inerrant.
[15:28] SPEAKER_04: This is birthed out of the 20th century uh modernist controversy uh when the inerrancy of the scriptures um became something of a contentious debate in the main line where they viewed and thought that the scriptures had errors in them.
[15:44] SPEAKER_04: Uh oddly enough, uh, this is actually not merely an ordination vow for my congregation.
[15:50] SPEAKER_04: We actually make all of our members vow this exact question as well.
[15:54] SPEAKER_04: And so they go above and beyond.
[15:56] SPEAKER_04: Uh we have an inerrantist body at Providence Presbyterian.
[16:00] SPEAKER_04: Wait, is you have an additional membership question?
[16:03] SPEAKER_04: Yes.
[16:04] SPEAKER_04: You're not allowed to do that.
[16:05] SPEAKER_04: Are you allowed?
[16:06] SPEAKER_02: You're not allowed to do that.
[16:08] SPEAKER_04: You know, that's what everyone says.
[16:10] SPEAKER_04: Um, but I believe that the BCO in those sections say you may ask these questions, which you may add, I guess.
[16:18] SPEAKER_03: No.
[16:20] SPEAKER_03: No, seriously, you you really shouldn't be doing that.
[16:23] SPEAKER_03: I mean, you could ask them that question in a membership interview, but don't don't make them take that vow.
[16:28] SPEAKER_03: I mean, I guess it's okay, but don't call it a membership vow.
[16:31] SPEAKER_03: Just call it a I don't know, a vow.
[16:33] SPEAKER_03: Oh man.
[16:34] SPEAKER_03: Okay.
[16:34] SPEAKER_00: Well, the so the you're saying the members at Providence and you're in Troy, right, are better than the members anywhere else in the PCA because they affirm this as a listening membership question.
[16:47] SPEAKER_03: We're going to change the subject of our lesson.
[16:52] SPEAKER_04: You know, um, I can't do anything about it.
[16:54] SPEAKER_04: It's in our bylaws.
[16:56] SPEAKER_04: And wow, that makes it somehow.
[16:58] SPEAKER_04: What am I supposed to do, guys?
[17:00] SPEAKER_04: What am I supposed to do?
[17:00] SPEAKER_04: Tell my people to remove the inerrancy of scripture from our bylaws?
[17:04] SPEAKER_02: Listen, yes, we didn't we didn't make this problem for you, Scott.
[17:08] SPEAKER_02: Okay.
[17:09] SPEAKER_01: Well, don't shoot the messenger.
[17:11] SPEAKER_01: I will to to attempt to get us back on track here, I will point out that uh the the PCA did add this as part of the uh vow, uh the phrase as originally given to be inerrant, um uh out of what Scott was pointing out, uh the modernist controversy.
[17:29] SPEAKER_01: Though I do think uh Sproll had interesting thoughts on the fact that there's infallible and inerrant.
[17:36] SPEAKER_01: And if you're actually thinking about those words, inerrant means that it didn't make a mistake, and infallible means it's incapable of making a mistake.
[17:44] SPEAKER_01: So actually, infallible should be a stronger word, but somehow this controversy got caught up on inerrant.
[17:51] SPEAKER_01: Um, so uh we are both saying that the scriptures do not have error, but also cannot error uh in in what they are teaching, and so we're we're never going to revise them, I guess, is is one of the things we're we're valuing there.
[18:06] SPEAKER_03: So this actually brings up an interesting question.
[18:10] SPEAKER_03: Uh Scott's uh Scott's situation brings up an interesting question in light of what Jared just said.
[18:17] SPEAKER_03: And I'm serious, and and because there's at least one teaching elder in the PCA who has publicly stated that the doctrine of inerrancy is not a primary doctrine or first order doctrine of the Christian religion.
[18:32] SPEAKER_03: That is, someone can be a Christian and deny inerrancy.
[18:38] SPEAKER_03: That's that's been publicly stated by at least one PCA teaching elder of the media church.
[18:43] SPEAKER_03: Not a Scots church, no.
[18:45] SPEAKER_03: Um but but that guy could not be a member of my church.
[18:50] SPEAKER_03: Well, he can take the vow himself, he's not denying inerrancy, he's just he's just saying you can be a Christian without affirming inerrancy as a doctrine.
[18:58] SPEAKER_03: I I you know I that's an interesting question.
[19:02] SPEAKER_03: And technically, by our book of church order, not the bylaws of Scots Church in this case, but by our book of church order, um we are in substantial agreement with that statement prima fascia on the face of it, and that is even if you do not assent to or agree with or uh or fully understand the doctrine of inerrancy, you can still be a Christian and be a member of the visible church.
[19:28] SPEAKER_03: But but according to our book, you cannot be a minister in the PCA or an elder or a deacon in the PCA without affirming inerrancy.
[19:37] SPEAKER_03: That is how dear a doctrine it is to us.
[19:40] SPEAKER_03: And I would hope that in our training of covenant children and in our interview of in our interviewing of prospective members and in our membership classes, we would impress the importance with which we regard the doctrine of inerrancy uh both from our standards and our constitution and from the word of God, because the word of God certainly uh attests to its own infallibility, inspiration, inerrancy, and sufficiency for faith and life.
[20:13] SPEAKER_03: And so whether or not you think it's primary, secondary, tertiary, or you know, subtertiary or whatever, by whatever hacknade scheme you have of, you know, stacking up the doctrines of the Bible, I hope you would impress the importance of the doctrine of inerrancy and all the uh spiritual bloodshed over it in the twentieth century, anyway, through the controversies already cited.
[20:38] SPEAKER_03: Um, this is a doctrine that should be very near and dear to us and important for us to uphold and to impress upon the consciences of God's people according to the word of God.
[20:49] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I don't know how you would be a minister of the word without affirming this.
[20:53] SPEAKER_01: I mean, when I was going to seminary and I started taking preaching classes, one of the things I struggled with was I don't like to tell anybody to do anything or what they should be doing.
[21:03] SPEAKER_01: And uh it was pressed on me that you are not, the scriptures are, uh God is through his scripture.
[21:09] SPEAKER_01: That's right.
[21:10] SPEAKER_01: And so there's no basis for you to do any kind of ministry for the rest of the vows if you don't have an authoritative Bible that is telling you this is what people ought to believe and this is what they ought to do.
[21:20] SPEAKER_01: So really the first the first uh answer has to be yes, or the rest of them you really can't do anything else with.
[21:28] SPEAKER_01: Amen.
[21:29] SPEAKER_00: Well, and that's what drives our ministry in the long run.
[21:31] SPEAKER_00: You know, this this is this has so many implications for our ministry, not just what we do in our our you know, pulpit ministry, right?
[21:37] SPEAKER_00: We read the scriptures, we pray the scriptures, we preach them, we we see them in the sacraments, we sing it.
[21:42] SPEAKER_00: But but too, like this is why you carry a Bible with you to a hospital visit, right?
[21:46] SPEAKER_00: You you don't you don't take anything with you and of yourself when you walk into that room, but you can you take the scriptures.
[21:51] SPEAKER_00: Why?
[21:52] SPEAKER_00: Well, because we believe they're the infallible, the only infallible rule of faith and practice.
[21:56] SPEAKER_00: Um you can apply that to so many other scenarios in Everyday ministry as an elder.
[22:02] SPEAKER_00: And so this is Jared's spot on.
[22:04] SPEAKER_00: It's it's foundational, not just to the authority that we appeal to, but but what we do in practice from moment by moment.
[22:12] SPEAKER_00: What else?
[22:13] SPEAKER_00: We'll move on.
[22:14] SPEAKER_03: I think it's helpful theologically just to say that because the word is inspired in its original manuscripts, it is infallible and thus it is inerrant.
[22:27] SPEAKER_03: The three I words here rise and fall together.
[22:32] SPEAKER_03: And to deny one is to deny all three.
[22:34] SPEAKER_03: To hold to one necessarily requires you to hold to all three.
[22:39] SPEAKER_03: And um that doesn't mean that we deny that typos creep in as manuscripts are copied and as printers mess up.
[22:47] SPEAKER_03: There's some you know somewhat comical examples of that in in church history.
[22:52] SPEAKER_03: But in their original manuscripts, which today, uh through s through excellent scholarship, we are uh very certain to know what was contained therein.
[23:02] SPEAKER_03: Um it was inspired by the Holy Spirit uh and infallible thereby and and inerrant, sufficient for faith and practice, including ministry.
[23:14] SPEAKER_04: And it's a good reminder that the just the breadth of how many manuscripts we have.
[23:19] SPEAKER_04: Uh there's over 9,000 manuscripts of the New Testament.
[23:23] SPEAKER_04: And when you take all of them together collectively, going back even to the earliest, it's a reliable script we have.
[23:29] SPEAKER_04: No one questions Pluto's writings as authentic or reliable, and we have only 100, 150 uh copies of those in existence, but everybody trusts those.
[23:41] SPEAKER_04: And so we have such a larger scope of data on the New Testament scriptures going all the way back to the lifetime just after the apostles.
[23:51] SPEAKER_04: And so it's really the those earliest manuscripts that we have access to, along with all of the other thousands of manuscripts, it's easy to uh engineer a very reliable scripture.
[24:03] SPEAKER_04: But but it is in the original manuscripts that we're talking, though we still think the ones we have today are are reliable based on that.
[24:11] SPEAKER_01: Eclectic or uh Textus Receptus.
[24:17] SPEAKER_01: Well it on this one.
[24:19] SPEAKER_03: I prefer I I prefer the Byzantine text type, but that in and of itself is a is an eclectic position because I'm not TR only.
[24:28] SPEAKER_03: Um it's not it's not my favorite pet controversy, but it is an important question.
[24:37] SPEAKER_05: You just love those editors, that's all I know.
[24:40] SPEAKER_03: I'm not a critical text guy, but I do use a new American Standard Bible.
[24:44] SPEAKER_04: Alright, before our listeners turn us off, let's uh Welcome to Reform Baptist Polity Matters, where we talk about DR issues.
[24:54] SPEAKER_04: They're not the only ones.
[24:57] SPEAKER_00: Reformed Baptists have polity?
[24:58] SPEAKER_00: Is that what you said?
[25:00] SPEAKER_00: Okay.
[25:00] SPEAKER_00: Um just locally.
[25:04] SPEAKER_00: The second question has to do with our uh confession of faith and catechisms, and I'll just refer listeners to I don't have the number in front of me, I'll put a link in the show notes to our interview with David Strain, where he came and uh discussed good faith subscription with us at length.
[25:19] SPEAKER_00: Um I'm not saying that so that we won't talk at length here, but we have had that conversation.
[25:23] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so that this is where a lot of that will come out of.
[25:27] SPEAKER_00: Um Question number two Do you sincerely receive and adopt the confession of faith and the catechisms of this church as containing the system of doctrine taught in the Holy Scriptures?
[25:36] SPEAKER_00: And do you further promise that if at any time you find yourself out of accord with any of the fundamentals of the system of doctrine, you will, on your own initiative, make known to your presbytery the change which has taken place in your views since the assumption of this ordination vow?
[25:50] SPEAKER_00: Uh Jared, just because you you've you you have been helpful for me, at least listening you talk about this.
[25:56] SPEAKER_00: What do we mean here when we talk about uh sincerely receiving and adopting the confession and catechisms as containing a system of doctrine taught in the scriptures?
[26:04] SPEAKER_00: Can can you kind of help us wrap our minds around that again?
[26:07] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it it is significant if you look at the first, second, and third questions.
[26:11] SPEAKER_01: The verbs are a little different.
[26:13] SPEAKER_01: We believe the scriptures, we receive and adopt the confession of faith, and we approve of the form of government.
[26:21] SPEAKER_01: Um when we receive and adopt the confession of faith, uh, we are saying this is going to be our public theology.
[26:29] SPEAKER_01: Um, the language there of containing the system of doctrine taught in the Holy Scriptures is very similar to the fact that we believe that the word of God is contained in the scriptures, and we're not bardying about our doctrine of scripture.
[26:41] SPEAKER_01: I'm not bardying about um the system of doctrine being in the um confession.
[26:46] SPEAKER_01: Uh we may have a little bit of a critique on how things are worded or exactly how they're applied, but we are agreeing that um the Westminster Confession, the Westminster Catechisms is a statement that we are able to publicly sign on to as what it is we believe and that the church teaches.
[27:05] SPEAKER_01: Um this gets a little bit into some questions about what can you teach and what can your presbytery restrict you on teaching.
[27:13] SPEAKER_01: And if this is your public theology, if you have a bit of a uh difference that you've let your presbytery know about, they might decide, well, okay, you can have that privately, but you either can't teach it or you have to teach it alongside the standards.
[27:28] SPEAKER_01: And that goes along with this vow.
[27:30] SPEAKER_01: We're we're vowing that this is going to be our public uh theology uh that we are saying, if you want to know what I believe, here it is.
[27:38] SPEAKER_01: If you want to know what's going to come out of this pulpit, um, just read through uh the Westminster standards and uh that if that changes at any point, it's incumbent on us to take that back to our presbytery, to our fellow uh ministers, to say, I've had a change of opinion on this.
[27:55] SPEAKER_01: And I think it's striking that if there's a change, really it's up to the presbytery to determine if that's a change that strikes at the vitals.
[28:03] SPEAKER_01: Um we don't determine that when we come in, we don't determine that later.
[28:06] SPEAKER_01: So if there's a change that happens, uh we're we are vowing to go back to the presbytery and say, I've had a change of mind about this, I need you guys to evaluate this again.
[28:15] SPEAKER_01: Um so this is taking very seriously what our public theology is going to be, and the fact that the Westminster standards, that's the system that we're publicly saying, this is what we're gonna teach, this is what we believe.
[28:26] SPEAKER_00: I I'm I want to I want to try to take it in two directions, if you guys will let me.
[28:29] SPEAKER_00: So first, and then uh what uh what's the significance of this as the the beginning place of our ordination as a teaching elder?
[28:37] SPEAKER_00: So this is we've established the word uh as as guiding us and sort of our trajectory for our ministry, and now the confession and catechisms are added to it.
[28:46] SPEAKER_00: So I want to talk about the significance of these in our ministry um as the basis of our system of doctrine, but then also want to talk about what it looks like if you do start to differ, maybe a little bit more detail if you guys have anecdotal things or um thoughts about that.
[29:01] SPEAKER_00: So, first, what's it look like for our ministry to be rooted in an adoption of the confession and catechisms?
[29:08] SPEAKER_00: Does it just mean that we I mean, David Strain famously calls it the, you know, are they just doctrinal shibbolets where we just agree with them sort of at the beginning and then we forget about them after we've gotten in the door?
[29:16] SPEAKER_00: Or do these have any bearing on our ministry longer longer term than that?
[29:22] SPEAKER_03: Well, I think that um there are two hermeneutical principles that are in play that are pretty helpful for us, considering how we handle the word of God affects every aspect of our ministry, since all theology is practical.
[29:37] SPEAKER_03: How we handle the word of God is very theological in and of itself.
[29:41] SPEAKER_03: The first principle, which is really hit on by the first question, which we've already gone over, is the uh analogia scriptura, the analogy of scripture, and that is that you interpret scripture with scripture, and that principle is laid out in chapter one of our confession as well.
[29:55] SPEAKER_03: And then the second principle, which really this question comes closer to, is the analogia fidee, that is the analogy of faith.
[30:04] SPEAKER_03: And so uh we when we are reading scripture, we're not reading texts out of the context of the whole Bible.
[30:13] SPEAKER_03: We're also not reading texts out of the context of the whole quote system of doctrine uh that is taught in the holy scriptures.
[30:21] SPEAKER_03: That is what we call sometimes the Christian faith, uh, the pattern of sound words that we've received, the confession of our hope, which we've received and in our case inherited from very competent, able, and most importantly, godly forefathers in the Presbyterian and Reformed tradition here.
[30:42] SPEAKER_03: And and so that that's really theologically what I think is behind these two opening questions and might help uh elucidate for us their usefulness and their importance.
[30:53] SPEAKER_03: Um, all you have to do is read five pages into any standard textbook on church history after the closure of the canon, and you realize, hmm, theological guardrails are really helpful.
[31:04] SPEAKER_03: What are those guardrails called?
[31:06] SPEAKER_03: Confessions of faith and catechisms and creeds.
[31:10] SPEAKER_03: And so if somebody asks you, What do you believe?
[31:14] SPEAKER_03: you can say, I believe in God the Father Almighty, maker of heaven and earth, and and so on, and recite the Apostles' Creed.
[31:19] SPEAKER_03: It's very helpful and useful in that sense.
[31:22] SPEAKER_03: But also as you're preaching and handling the Word of God and you come across a passage that's difficult to interpret and to think through how do I apply this to the people in front of me or in this counseling situation or in our evangelistic outreach or whatever, um you can go back not only to other clearer passages of scripture that deal with the same theme, but go back to those summary statements of our holy religion, of the faith, the Westminster Confession of Faith being one such summary statement, the catechisms being summary statements, and of course the Apostles' Creed, the Nicene Creed, um those other uh statements of truth, of biblical truth, which are more or less fleshed out by the Westminster standards.
[32:07] SPEAKER_03: And so I think there's a real practical utility to uh using them, and that's really hit upon in this question.
[32:15] SPEAKER_04: I find this uh this vow particularly to be the most transactional in that it actually calls you to something if something changes in your view.
[32:27] SPEAKER_04: Sometimes when we make vows, it's it is almost like, okay, we're, you know, I I vow to do this, and it's almost static outside of breaking away from it, I suppose.
[32:38] SPEAKER_04: But here there's actually a mechanism for what happens if something changes.
[32:43] SPEAKER_04: Uh it's not break the vow, it's report the change to the Presbytery.
[32:48] SPEAKER_04: And so there is a transactional element to this vow where if you you are promising that if you have a change in heart on any of the doctrines found in the confessional systems that you have vowed to, you will make that known to the body that you've made the vow in front of.
[33:04] SPEAKER_04: And so it's very transactional in that you you have to maintain it by active obedience to it.
[33:11] SPEAKER_04: And if there are changes, that you are promising to make those changes known.
[33:16] SPEAKER_00: It's kind of funny though, like uh I mean I've searched and looked for it, unless you guys know better than I've found, that there's this promise that you'll make known to your presbytery a change, but there's no instruction for the presbytery what to do with the man that comes with such a change.
[33:33] SPEAKER_00: Um I mean, uh most of my experiences and and what I've heard of is that men sort of back up to a judgment of a difference.
[33:41] SPEAKER_00: They they take it as a difference and try to judge it according to RO twelve.
[33:46] SPEAKER_00: Is it?
[33:47] SPEAKER_00: Uh so I guess where I'm trying to take us is how has this worked itself out in y'all's presbyteries um or any presbytery you've heard of before, where a man comes with this change that he's promised to bring?
[33:59] SPEAKER_00: How does the presbytery handle it?
[34:00] SPEAKER_03: Our presbytery is proactive in that we have an annual ministerial obligation form that we fill out, and part of that involves reaffirming um that our views haven't changed or at least substantially changed in any of the fundamentals.
[34:14] SPEAKER_03: Um one of the difficulties of this vow and how it's worded, and and and and I don't really know how to solve this difficulty, we can't see into men's hearts, is that the onus of reporting or the burden of reporting is on the man taking the vow.
[34:27] SPEAKER_03: And so this really is, and this goes back to just the nature of vows, which we've already discussed, this really is between the man and God.
[34:36] SPEAKER_03: And if your views change and you you know they're striking at the fundamentals of the confession of faith, however, a presbytery understands that or whatever, and uh you don't report that because you're afraid of losing your job or whatever, well the Lord knows, even if none of your brothers in Presbytery know.
[34:56] SPEAKER_03: So that's something to consider.
[34:59] SPEAKER_03: Um but uh I've seen this, I've seen this handled nobly by uh or uh by men who are ordained, and even by licentiates in my presbytery when their views have changed or when they've solidified in something that they held with some openness, say their view of creation or whatever.
[35:16] SPEAKER_03: Uh they come back to our examining committee, because we have separate candidates and examining committees in Calvary.
[35:21] SPEAKER_03: We don't just have one credentials and candidates committee.
[35:24] SPEAKER_03: But um, they come back to the examining committee, report the change that's evaluated by the committee, and then a recommendation, if any, is brought to the presbytery uh as well as notice of what the man has communicated, and then we deal with it.
[35:38] SPEAKER_03: And I've seen that done very respectfully and and patiently and graciously.
[35:42] SPEAKER_00: Either you other guys never seen it?
[35:46] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, we just classified it uh according to how we would when somebody's first coming in with a difference, try to figure out which one of those classifications it's under uh semantic, more than semantic, but not striking at the vitals or striking at the vitals, and then you have to move from there.
[36:00] SPEAKER_01: If it's striking at the vitals, then you have to figure out is it is it something that's gonna have charges that come from it, which um sometimes it uh it does, uh or most of the time it probably would.
[36:11] SPEAKER_01: Um I think another element of this though is it's orienting you towards your your fellow ministers.
[36:18] SPEAKER_01: And so if you're starting to have a change in what you're thinking, hopefully the first time that your presbytery hears about it is not you on the floor saying, Hey, I changed my mind about this.
[36:28] SPEAKER_01: Uh hopefully you have other people in the presbytery that you're saying, I'm working through this, can you help me with it?
[36:33] SPEAKER_01: Um that it there would be several steps of uh making up your mind and and figuring things out before it got to the point in which you have to report it to Presbytery.
[36:42] SPEAKER_01: Um so this uh even if you never do this in your ministerial career, hopefully it orients you to I need to be forming my theology, not just me reading my Bible and preaching every Sunday, but in a community of other uh men, in a presbytery, in a group of elders.
[36:57] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[36:59] SPEAKER_00: Well, so we've covered scripture and now we've covered our doctrinal standards, and the third question has to do with our form of government and discipline.
[37:08] SPEAKER_00: Do you approve of the form of government and discipline of the Presbyterian Church in America in conformity with the general principles of biblical polity?
[37:14] SPEAKER_03: Yes, I do.
[37:17] SPEAKER_03: I hope all four of us do.
[37:19] SPEAKER_03: We actually need to, right?
[37:23] SPEAKER_00: I love that Zach is taking all of these vows that I read as a dis like as a discussion question.
[37:28] SPEAKER_03: Like, yeah, sure.
[37:29] SPEAKER_04: He's revowing.
[37:30] SPEAKER_04: He's vowing.
[37:31] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, we're just doing an altar call.
[37:33] SPEAKER_03: That's a profound statement.
[37:35] SPEAKER_03: That that's a profound statement, though, Scott, and and not really profound, Jared, about the altar call.
[37:40] SPEAKER_03: But the revowing statement is profound.
[37:42] SPEAKER_03: I I have had the privilege, even just since being ordained myself, of being involved in several ordination and installation services.
[37:52] SPEAKER_03: And every time I hear the vows uh propounded, and um in my heart, I I retake them myself.
[38:02] SPEAKER_03: But no, seriously, it's the same thing as when you witness a baptism uh and you hear those vows given, and it's or you see members brought into a church, you hear the vows given, and you have an opportunity there to take them again yourself, even if just silently and be reaffirmed.
[38:19] SPEAKER_03: Or you go to a wedding and you hear the marriage vows and you think of your own marriage, and you're like, Yes, this is what I'm committed to with my wife.
[38:26] SPEAKER_00: And so the only part of a wedding I like is hearing the vows.
[38:29] SPEAKER_00: That's all right.
[38:31] SPEAKER_00: I'm just saying weird weird flex.
[38:33] SPEAKER_00: Weird flex, but okay.
[38:34] SPEAKER_03: Hot takes.
[38:35] SPEAKER_03: No, oh, no flex.
[38:38] SPEAKER_03: So anyway, that's profound, Scott.
[38:40] SPEAKER_03: Even as we're going over this, I'm being reminded of what is required of each of us and what we joyously engage in.
[38:48] SPEAKER_00: So general principles of biblical polity just means that that you should be Presbyterian, right?
[38:52] SPEAKER_00: I mean that that has to be what it means.
[38:54] SPEAKER_01: Uh I I pointed out uh earlier the difference in verbiage.
[39:00] SPEAKER_01: And this is uh maybe a lesser verb than the first and second, but it still is that you approve of it and that you are going to abide by it.
[39:11] SPEAKER_01: So we can imagine somebody coming in from the ARP and in their church they had had women deacons, and they come into the PCA and they say, Well, the way that you do deacons is a bit differently.
[39:22] SPEAKER_01: You give them authority.
[39:23] SPEAKER_01: And so um within the PCA, I can abide by the fact that you guys don't have women deacons, and I can uh approve of that, even though I was okay serving in the ARP where they had that.
[39:33] SPEAKER_01: Um, but when you come in, you're not allowed to say, Well, I'm just gonna do it any way that I want to.
[39:39] SPEAKER_01: Um, and you don't come in and say, Look, the way that you guys do the Lord's Supper uh tells you to do this in the BCO, but I'm gonna do it my own way.
[39:46] SPEAKER_01: No, you abide by it.
[39:48] SPEAKER_01: You are saying I'm going to do it in in the way that I'm vowing here that the the BCO, uh your book of church order is is telling us to do things in in a certain way, and I can abide by those as not violating uh the scriptures and our inconformity uh thereto.
[40:03] SPEAKER_01: And if I think they should change, there's a process for that.
[40:08] SPEAKER_03: Right.
[40:09] SPEAKER_03: It's kind of the same thing in our membership class.
[40:11] SPEAKER_03: I have a whole session, it's the last session on what Antioch is not.
[40:15] SPEAKER_03: After 11 weeks of talking about what Antioch is, we have one session, it's very popular, people enjoy it, and it's very helpful.
[40:22] SPEAKER_03: Specifically, what we are not, and it's very popular.
[40:24] SPEAKER_02: Very popular, people love it, people love it.
[40:27] SPEAKER_02: I love our I love Italy.
[40:29] SPEAKER_02: Um the most popular class ever taught.
[40:32] SPEAKER_02: It's it's tremendous.
[40:34] SPEAKER_03: China.
[40:35] SPEAKER_03: Uh, but anyway, um, what Antioch is not, 35 points very specific of what what we don't do and what we're not gonna do.
[40:44] SPEAKER_03: And if you want us to do these things, well, there are a thousand churches in Greenville and Swartburg, and I'm sure a handful of them do it.
[40:51] SPEAKER_03: It's kind of the same thing here.
[40:52] SPEAKER_03: If you're coming into the PCA with an agenda to change the PCA uh as a minister, then what are you doing?
[41:01] SPEAKER_03: Like, you know, check yourself before you wreck yourself, bro.
[41:04] SPEAKER_03: But if you're coming in and you want to promote the faithfulness of the PCA to its own standards, doctrinal and polity-wise, well then Godspeed.
[41:12] SPEAKER_03: Join the ranks.
[41:13] SPEAKER_03: This is great.
[41:14] SPEAKER_03: We're glad to have you.
[41:15] SPEAKER_03: Um and then the statement of the general principles of biblical polity, I think, helps us understand this as you know, you're not gonna go die on the hill of having a three-quarters vote rather than a two-thirds vote on certain uh motions or occasions, but you're gonna recognize, well, there should be a supermajority on this one, whatever that majority is.
[41:37] SPEAKER_03: Uh, this is important to have a particular standard, and I agree with that and I'm okay with that.
[41:42] SPEAKER_03: But yeah, if you're coming in trying to impose women deacons or elders on the PCA, well, there's other places for you to go uh where you can render exemplary service to our God with that uh commitment in tow.
[41:54] SPEAKER_00: Scott, did you put a jacket on since we started?
[41:57] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, I have at least two more wardrobe changes.
[42:01] SPEAKER_04: He's chilly.
[42:02] SPEAKER_04: This is this is my night.
[42:04] SPEAKER_04: I'll change as many times as I want.
[42:06] SPEAKER_03: You know, I think a Supreme Court justice said that on Broadway recently.
[42:10] SPEAKER_03: First Supreme Court Justice on Broadway.
[42:12] SPEAKER_03: Um, we have a two months nobody will remember that.
[42:23] SPEAKER_00: Podcast on Paw, do you think of polity matters is lost.
[42:28] SPEAKER_03: Katanji Brown Jackson, she was in the uh the new Broadway production, and Juliet, first Supreme Court justice ever to be on Broadway.
[42:36] SPEAKER_03: Seems like a great use of of time for a Supreme Court Justice of the United States.
[42:41] unknown: Terrible.
[42:41] SPEAKER_03: It's like Pastor's Podcast.
[42:44] SPEAKER_01: What's up with that?
[42:46] SPEAKER_03: No, this is at least potentially edifying.
[42:50] SPEAKER_00: Potentially.
[42:51] SPEAKER_00: There's the name of the episode.
[42:53] SPEAKER_00: All right.
[42:54] SPEAKER_02: Anyway, potentially edifying edifying.
[42:58] SPEAKER_02: There we go.
[42:59] SPEAKER_00: Wow.
[43:01] SPEAKER_00: Usually usually Scott hits our titles, but that's a pretty good one.
[43:04] SPEAKER_00: I might not be able to top it.
[43:05] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, that that phrase does not occur in the what Antioch is not session of my membership class.
[43:11] SPEAKER_03: Potentially Antioch or potentially edifying.
[43:14] SPEAKER_03: No, Antioch is actually edifying.
[43:17] SPEAKER_03: Thank you.
[43:17] SPEAKER_00: I uh incidentally, I'd love to you said 35 points.
[43:21] SPEAKER_00: I'd really be curious to see that list.
[43:23] SPEAKER_02: I almost put them up on Twitter, but I was like, I better not do that.
[43:27] SPEAKER_03: But the uh the recording is on sermon audio and it's open, and a couple hundred people have listened to it.
[43:33] SPEAKER_03: So it's evidently an interesting huge, huge, huge, it's huge.
[43:39] SPEAKER_00: Number four.
[43:41] SPEAKER_00: Do you is this the shortest one?
[43:43] SPEAKER_00: I think this is the shortest one.
[43:44] SPEAKER_00: Do you promise subjection to your brethren in the Lord?
[43:48] SPEAKER_00: Uh this is a big deal.
[43:50] SPEAKER_00: Um I have heard I've heard people talk about and interpret this in different directions at every point.
[43:56] SPEAKER_00: I mean, guys saying it means opposite things from From church to church, Presbytery to Presbytery.
[44:02] SPEAKER_00: I I wonder if this is the most misunderstood question that we we take.
[44:06] SPEAKER_00: Um what's it mean?
[44:10] SPEAKER_03: Well, we know it doesn't mean you can't disagree.
[44:17] SPEAKER_03: Because we have provisions in our book where you can make protest, dissent, or even appeal decisions of courts in our judicial proceedings and in um and in other business of the church.
[44:32] SPEAKER_03: And so it doesn't mean that you can't disagree.
[44:34] SPEAKER_03: So it has to do with how we disagree.
[44:37] SPEAKER_00: So if the Presbytery comes up and and uh takes an action that you disagree with, and somebody says, Well, you promised subjection to your brethren in the Lord, you just gotta shut up and not do anything about it.
[44:45] SPEAKER_00: You can that that's actually not true.
[44:47] SPEAKER_00: False recourse, yeah.
[44:49] SPEAKER_00: You can you can complain, you can file a uh uh an a oh oh oh dissent.
[44:55] SPEAKER_00: There we go.
[44:55] SPEAKER_00: There's several different means uh for objecting to action.
[44:59] SPEAKER_00: So it doesn't mean that.
[45:01] SPEAKER_03: And you can even bring a motion at the very next meeting to do something completely different.
[45:07] SPEAKER_03: Uh I mean, at least not in a judicial case, usually, but in uh let's say there is a motion to uh allow for something in a mission church.
[45:16] SPEAKER_03: Well, the next meeting of session or presbytery, you can make a motion to disallow such action.
[45:22] SPEAKER_03: And uh perhaps it will prevail.
[45:23] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I would take this as being Scott, you're so quiet.
[45:28] SPEAKER_07: Scott's time to answer.
[45:31] SPEAKER_00: No, no, Jared, you you know, let's keep him quiet.
[45:33] SPEAKER_00: If he wants to be quiet, let him be quiet.
[45:35] SPEAKER_01: All right.
[45:35] SPEAKER_01: I I would take this as being the opposite of being uh quarrelsome.
[45:40] SPEAKER_01: Um it w when you're serving with other men, you should not be somebody that is always thinking that your brothers are wrong and that you're gonna do your own thing even when they decided to do something else.
[45:52] SPEAKER_01: And part of this too is just the attitude that we have, like in our second ordination vow, of bringing our changes of mind to our brothers and saying, I need some help with this, or there is a disagreement between you and another minister, or you and the church, or people in the church, and you are in the session in the church, and that you're promising to say, hey, we're gonna do this according to the procedures that we've agreed to.
[46:14] SPEAKER_01: And in fact, there may be some times in which you have to decide who's right and who's wrong, and I'm gonna abide by that decision.
[46:20] SPEAKER_01: Uh, not in the realm of uh disobedience to God, uh, if you think it's something that you're being uh told to disobey, uh what God has commanded, but then you have to think about your vows here versus uh loyalty to God, and it may be a point in which you can't be a minister anymore because you think that that's been violated.
[46:39] SPEAKER_01: But it does say that your first recourse is not just to say no and disobey, um, that this in some ways is also a blessing.
[46:47] SPEAKER_01: I have the blessing of having people that I'm in this with and that can evaluate things and can see things that I can't see, and that can give me some judgments uh on uh whether it's uh some things that have been taught or some uh disagreements between people uh and and weigh into that.
[47:06] SPEAKER_00: We talk about it on our s at the session level at our church.
[47:09] SPEAKER_00: Um say that I'm the one no vote on a particular action that we take.
[47:13] SPEAKER_00: I have I have the right to um complain or or any of the other uh opportunities afforded to me, but it it certainly means it certainly means that I'm not gonna walk out of the session meeting and voice my disagreement with the session to everybody that I can pull their ear toward me, right?
[47:29] SPEAKER_00: I'm gonna go tell the whole church that the session's doing this thing, but I'm totally against it, and I voted against it, and I'm gonna complain.
[47:35] SPEAKER_00: No, my my sub my promise to subject myself to the brethren is that this is the action we took, and I'm gonna I'm gonna be a part of the body and move in that direction with it and not not, as Jared, I like your word, not be quarrelsome, uh, especially publicly.
[47:50] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, I think of it when it's I think particularly helpful when thinking of men who serve on sessions um with other ruling elders, where it's I think the minister should have the regular word hour on his tongue when talking about the decision and work of the session.
[48:08] SPEAKER_04: This was our decision, even if the pastor degrees.
[48:11] SPEAKER_04: I I sometimes degree with my ruling, disagree with my ruling elders.
[48:15] SPEAKER_04: And when I go to talk to people in the congregation, I say this is was our decision.
[48:19] SPEAKER_04: This is our decision, and this is why we made that decision.
[48:23] SPEAKER_04: And so I'm trying to represent their position, even if I have minor scruples with it or something of that nature.
[48:29] SPEAKER_04: I am subjecting myself to our decision.
[48:31] SPEAKER_04: It is our decision, whether I agree with the decision or not.
[48:34] SPEAKER_04: And there are, as we've already talked about, adequate ways and vehicles to managing your descent without causing division and uh schism within the body.
[48:45] SPEAKER_04: And so I think that this vow is getting towards that end of sowing unity even in the midst of disdivision.
[48:53] SPEAKER_03: There's an identical question to this for ruling elders and deacons in uh in 24-6.
[49:00] SPEAKER_03: It's question number five for them, because they have a different question number four.
[49:04] SPEAKER_03: But what I've explained to our ruling elders and deacons, at least here at Antioch, and you know, every presbytery is gonna have different cultures and ways of applying this principle, but at least at our church, I've said sub being in subjection to your brethren in the Lord doesn't mean you cannot disagree.
[49:22] SPEAKER_03: It also doesn't mean you can't share with other people that you disagreed on a particular vote or action, but it does mean that you will support the work of the session regardless and not seek to disrupt it once a decision has been made.
[49:36] SPEAKER_03: Um so if if a member of the church approaches one of my elders about a particular decision we made and said, Well, you know, what did you decide?
[49:46] SPEAKER_03: And his first impulse is very good, the session did this or we did this, great.
[49:51] SPEAKER_03: And then if he follows up and says, Yeah, but what did you think?
[49:55] SPEAKER_03: Well, if he was a no vote, I want him to feel at liberty to say within his discretion, depending upon the situation, you know, whatever, I trust him, to say, Well, I'll be honest with you.
[50:05] SPEAKER_03: I voted no, but I'm in support of the session's action, and I'm I'm willing to abide by it, and I can live with it.
[50:12] SPEAKER_03: And and I would expect any reasonable person in our church can live with that, you know, and and kind of man up on it.
[50:19] SPEAKER_03: And that and that's really, I think, uh a matter of humility and of grace and just being on a team together.
[50:27] SPEAKER_03: So there's plenty of opportunities to voice your disagreement in healthy ways, and then there are also plenty of opportunities to do so in unhealthy, unhelpful ways.
[50:35] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, we had a recent congregational meeting like that where we were discussing a major movement and change in the direction vision for our congregation.
[50:43] SPEAKER_04: And the the question was asked, uh, is the is the session in diaconate unanimous in this decision?
[50:51] SPEAKER_04: And we said the nine, it's a nine-one thing.
[50:54] SPEAKER_04: There's one who disagrees with our decision, and I would like that one to stand up now and represent his position to the entire body.
[51:02] SPEAKER_04: There's so there's a sense of not silencing someone.
[51:05] SPEAKER_04: I I think it's unhealthy and only creates and stirs the pot to try to forcibly silence someone according to a vow like this.
[51:13] SPEAKER_04: But seeking to the best of your ability as a pastor, offering an outlet for that disagreement to be used in a healthy way.
[51:20] SPEAKER_04: And it could be even in a congregational meeting, as scary as that sounds, to let someone verbally in leadership state their disagreement.
[51:27] SPEAKER_04: If you do it so in an honoring way, it can be helpful for everyone.
[51:30] unknown: Right.
[51:31] SPEAKER_01: Keeping in mind there's still a subjection that's there.
[51:33] SPEAKER_01: So that's why, like even Robert's rules of order says in a temperate uh manner.
[51:38] SPEAKER_01: Uh you shouldn't be blasting your brothers, but you can also void voice a difference of opinion.
[51:45] unknown: Yeah.
[51:50] SPEAKER_03: And um, you know, and and even in our written correspondence, we should be in subjection to one another using temperate font faces, for example, and avoiding the use of all caps or greatest font I've ever seen.
[52:13] SPEAKER_03: Wearing outrageous clothing would be a way of of seriously of being not in subjection to the Lord.
[52:21] SPEAKER_03: What is outrageous clothing?
[52:22] SPEAKER_03: You all know what I'm talking about.
[52:24] SPEAKER_03: I mean, come on.
[52:25] SPEAKER_03: Come on.
[52:27] SPEAKER_00: You'll see in in Scott's next wardrobe change, we'll have an example of in intemperate clothing.
[52:33] SPEAKER_04: You'll see what I didn't say anything.
[52:35] SPEAKER_04: Like, I'm not even gonna say anything.
[52:36] SPEAKER_03: Like if I showed up, if I showed up at General Assembly dressed up like the Mandalorian or something, and and said, Well, look, it's a PCA logo on my head.
[52:44] SPEAKER_03: Like, that's outrageous.
[52:45] SPEAKER_03: That's not in subjection to the brethren.
[52:47] SPEAKER_03: That's distracting.
[52:48] SPEAKER_03: You show up in a very temperate example.
[52:50] SPEAKER_03: You show up in like a tank top with a wolf on the front of it.
[52:54] SPEAKER_03: I mean, that's intemperate.
[52:55] SPEAKER_00: Didn't know you were anti-Star Wars.
[52:57] SPEAKER_00: Man.
[52:57] SPEAKER_00: And anti-wolf clothing.
[52:59] SPEAKER_00: Anti-Dwight Shroot clothes?
[53:00] SPEAKER_00: Man, come on.
[53:01] SPEAKER_03: Definitely anti-Shroot clothes.
[53:03] SPEAKER_03: There are other denominations where you can fit in just fine wearing that stuff.
[53:07] SPEAKER_03: But yeah, I I am anti-Star Wars ever since they went woke.
[53:12] SPEAKER_04: So you shouldn't go up to a mic at a PCA General Assembly with a black suit and a black tie with a black shirt on.
[53:18] SPEAKER_03: That'd be weird, man.
[53:19] SPEAKER_03: Unless you're from Arkansas and you sound like Johnny Cash and it's cool.
[53:24] SPEAKER_03: Bolo.
[53:25] SPEAKER_03: Contextualized.
[53:26] SPEAKER_03: Oh man, I I would love to see a bolo tie at GA.
[53:30] SPEAKER_03: Man, that'd be that'd be epic.
[53:31] SPEAKER_03: Someone from Rio Grande Presbytery showing up in a bolo tie.
[53:35] SPEAKER_03: Or even North Presbytery or Hills and Plains, they could do it.
[53:39] SPEAKER_03: Any of those.
[53:40] SPEAKER_00: I'm thinking about editing this episode.
[53:42] SPEAKER_00: And my my mind is just going to it's never going to air.
[53:46] SPEAKER_00: That's that's just where my mind keeps.
[53:47] SPEAKER_00: I don't know.
[53:48] SPEAKER_00: We might not ever post this.
[53:49] SPEAKER_03: Listen, I'm just saying all this stuff that you guys can't say because I'm the guest.
[53:53] SPEAKER_03: So I'm protecting you.
[53:56] SPEAKER_00: We are moderate, temperate brothers here on Polity Matters, and we're glad to have uh Zach here.
[54:05] SPEAKER_00: Okay.
[54:06] SPEAKER_00: Uh let's go to five.
[54:08] SPEAKER_00: Have you been induced, as far as you know your own heart, to seek the office of the holy ministry from love to God and a sincere desire to promote his glory in the gospel of his son?
[54:20] SPEAKER_00: I love this one.
[54:21] SPEAKER_00: I was just gonna say, I love this question.
[54:24] SPEAKER_00: Um the the one part about it that is a little uh scary to me, just as I think about it, is as far as you know your own heart, that can be a hard thing uh sometimes to to think about your own intentions and motives, but that's the that's the substance of this question.
[54:38] SPEAKER_00: Is your motivation for ministry uh a good motivation?
[54:42] SPEAKER_00: Is it is it coming from the right place?
[54:45] SPEAKER_00: Um so so maybe the first question is as as a let's think about it as an ordinan coming for for to answer these questions for the first time as he's examining himself through the process of being called and examined by the Presbytery.
[54:58] SPEAKER_00: How how can he, and maybe we even stretch further back to seminary training, how can he discern whether his motivation is genuinely rooted in love for God and a desire to glorify him?
[55:09] SPEAKER_00: What what are we what what are some practices maybe to to to get at the heart of of that and to know your heart uh and if you're sincere?
[55:17] SPEAKER_03: I ask this question of potential ministers, I interact with a lot of seminary students, of potential members of our church as they go around the different Reformed churches in Greenville and look at them all and say, How in the world do I I pick one to go to?
[55:34] SPEAKER_03: There's so many good ones.
[55:36] SPEAKER_03: And and I say, Well, one thing that's helped me is I interrogate myself and I ask when I'm looking at reform churches or denominations or whatever, I ask, Am I attracted to this denomination because I'm attracted to the rigor and the discipline of its strictness, or because I'm attracted to its Christ?
[56:00] SPEAKER_03: And it's its Lord.
[56:02] SPEAKER_03: And that's really what this question is after.
[56:04] SPEAKER_03: Are you attracted to the ministry because it promises an easy contemplative life, or because it promises a certain degree of pay or freedom, or because it promises, in the reformed context, uh a a legalistic kind of precision and its rules and doctrinal formulations and system of government, or are you attracted to the ministry because you love Christ?
[56:31] SPEAKER_03: And there's only one right answer.
[56:34] SPEAKER_03: That is Christ.
[56:37] SPEAKER_00: Men struggle to want to be in the ministry because they want to be standing up front, speaking and and talking and being heard.
[56:44] SPEAKER_00: Jared, I can tell you're contemplating this.
[56:47] SPEAKER_01: I just think of this question as a thumb, as a gut check question of what your motives are.
[56:54] SPEAKER_01: And uh this is a great question to ask about anything that you're doing in the church.
[56:58] SPEAKER_01: Um why do we do worship in the way that we do worship?
[57:01] SPEAKER_01: Do we worship God in the way that we want or the way that God wants?
[57:05] SPEAKER_01: Um, why are we thinking about either doing or not doing church discipline here?
[57:10] SPEAKER_01: Is it because of how I want things to go, or is it because of how we've been commanded to do these things?
[57:15] SPEAKER_01: So this is a good question, not just am I going into the ministry for the right reasons, but every decision within ministry um is this in accord with what glorifies God, or is this selfishly what I want?
[57:32] SPEAKER_00: And this is a question that that examining uh committees and Zach, our presbytery is the same as yours.
[57:38] SPEAKER_00: We have separate candidates and we call ours credentials, our examining committee.
[57:42] SPEAKER_00: That this is something a credentialing committee needs to press in on.
[57:46] SPEAKER_00: Um they may have a call in hand from a church, but you still need to search them out to see if this question is able to be answered affirmatively.
[57:55] SPEAKER_00: Are are they coming for the right motives?
[57:58] SPEAKER_00: Um, is their seeking of it appropriate?
[58:00] SPEAKER_00: Um, you know, as you think as we think about safeguards maybe to to how to how to um keep men from seeking the office of teaching elder out of selfishness um or vanity, we need to press in and and seek answers to these kinds of uh questions.
[58:17] SPEAKER_00: Um and it is this is this is a part of the character examination of a man.
[58:21] SPEAKER_00: Um and so it's good for him to affirm this before his congregation as he's installed, ordained and installed.
[58:27] SPEAKER_00: He he says it out loud.
[58:32] SPEAKER_03: And that's not to say that uh appreciating the the preciseness, the precision, or enjoying teaching and preaching, I mean and and and desiring to have time to really meditate on the word and to study the word or I mean, all of those desires are good in their proper order.
[58:52] SPEAKER_03: They all must be subservient to a sincere uh desire to serve Christ and his people and be willing to do whatever is required of you.
[59:01] SPEAKER_03: So one thing we've we've said to Greenville Seminary students is if you're not willing to clean toilets and to take out trash and to sweep floors, then you shouldn't be a minister.
[59:13] SPEAKER_06: Oh, sorry, my bad, my bad.
[59:14] SPEAKER_03: Then you shouldn't be a minister of the gospel.
[59:17] SPEAKER_03: But but but that's not what we're called to be doing, n not ordinarily, but sometimes it will be appropriate for you to be the one to do that while you know when you're able-bodied.
[59:27] SPEAKER_03: Um you must be willing, even if uh even if you are seeking to empower others to to do those things uh on a regular basis.
[59:36] SPEAKER_03: I mean, for a couple years here I was making the coffee every Sunday morning, and now I have uh two or three guys that that do it on rotation, I don't have to worry about it.
[59:44] SPEAKER_03: I don't even drink coffee, believe it or not.
[59:46] SPEAKER_03: But I was happy to do it until it became clear that it really wasn't the best use of my time and other guys were willing and and wanting to take that off my plate.
[59:55] SPEAKER_03: And um, you know, that's that's the kind of not to puff myself up by any stretch, it's just an example, but that's the kind of I think attitude that we're looking for here.
[1:00:07] SPEAKER_07: Scott, did you unmute for a purpose?
[1:00:10] SPEAKER_07: No.
[1:00:10] SPEAKER_07: I just decided I was done typing.
[1:00:14] SPEAKER_00: One of my most vivid memories of ministry uh as a teenager was our um one of our pastors, the the toilets actually had blocked up in part of our church building because there was a a rainstorm.
[1:00:27] SPEAKER_00: Um, and he called all the youth and we got together and we all dug sewage out of the church bathrooms and cleaned up, and the pastor led the whole charge, and it was uh gross, but a great example of that humility um that's required of a man and and his desire.
[1:00:44] SPEAKER_03: I hesitate to ask, did you guys uh eat pizza afterwards because it was a youth event?
[1:00:49] SPEAKER_03: Probably, yeah.
[1:00:50] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, almost certainly.
[1:00:52] SPEAKER_03: I hope you would fly with it.
[1:00:55] SPEAKER_07: A lot of people do it.
[1:00:58] SPEAKER_03: No one got sick, right?
[1:01:00] SPEAKER_00: Sewage, sewage and slices.
[1:01:02] SPEAKER_00: That was what that event was called.
[1:01:04] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[1:01:04] SPEAKER_02: Um, it's our next episode.
[1:01:08] SPEAKER_05: Sewage and slices.
[1:01:10] SPEAKER_05: Alright, that's going to do a two-part episode.
[1:01:13] SPEAKER_05: Let's go.
[1:01:17] SPEAKER_02: That's awesome, man.
[1:01:21] SPEAKER_02: Well done.
[1:01:22] SPEAKER_02: Well done.
[1:01:23] SPEAKER_02: High praise.
[1:01:24] SPEAKER_02: Well done.
[1:01:25] SPEAKER_00: Number five, uh, you know, it we didn't say this beforehand, but it it begins this.
[1:01:29] SPEAKER_00: I don't know if you'd call these sections or not, but these next several questions are are more of this sort of um personal orientation, not just about what we uh um approve of and adopt as our own, but but some more uh inward-facing things.
[1:01:43] SPEAKER_00: And so we talk about desire and and motivation.
[1:01:45] SPEAKER_00: And number six asks, do you promise to be zealous and faithful in maintaining the truths of the gospel and the purity and peace and unity of the church, whatever persecution or opposition may arise unto you on that account?
[1:01:58] SPEAKER_00: Well, my mind goes a lot of different places.
[1:02:00] SPEAKER_00: I don't want to take us too far off track right away.
[1:02:02] SPEAKER_00: So let me let me ask you guys generally uh what what stands out to you here?
[1:02:06] SPEAKER_00: What's the significance of this question about zeal and faithfulness?
[1:02:10] SPEAKER_04: I would actually connect this question in some regards to the first three questions.
[1:02:15] SPEAKER_04: Um, even the second question as it relates to our our scriptures, doctrinal standards, and our can and our book of church order.
[1:02:24] SPEAKER_04: Uh how is a minister to uh promote the peace, pure purity, and unity of the church?
[1:02:30] SPEAKER_04: Well, it's to teach the doctrines of the church, to teach the scriptures of the church, to teach the constitution of the church.
[1:02:35] SPEAKER_04: And so I think it perhaps zealously protects the very teaching of the church itself, and that the minister should be very careful with how it talks about our Bible, how it talks about our confessional standards, but also even our book of church order publicly in teaching and preaching settings.
[1:02:54] SPEAKER_04: And so the the way to you preserve purity, peace, and unity is by maintaining those three heads that we all are the first, we've already made vows to.
[1:03:03] SPEAKER_04: And so now you have to do the action of that, which is by teaching them in your local context.
[1:03:09] SPEAKER_04: I remind people, um, this in my own congregation, they ask something about second commandment violations in Sunday school.
[1:03:16] SPEAKER_04: Can I bring this babyfelt Jesus out or something like that?
[1:03:19] SPEAKER_04: And I remind them, you have to maintain the doctrines of the church.
[1:03:23] SPEAKER_04: You may disagree personally in some areas, but we want to, I'm not so much worried about the damage it would cause theologically to the kids, but the the peace, purity, uh, and unity of the church are at stake, even with something as minor as that.
[1:03:38] SPEAKER_04: And so think very carefully on how you differ from the scriptures and the ministry here or from the confession.
[1:03:45] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I go two places with this question.
[1:03:48] SPEAKER_01: One is the question as a minister, will you do the hard thing, which is to talk about sin in ways that are maybe offensive to somebody that is currently engaged in that sin and doesn't want to repent?
[1:04:00] SPEAKER_01: Will you rebuke somebody?
[1:04:02] SPEAKER_01: Um, will you preach the gospel, even like say in a funeral service where they tell you not to?
[1:04:09] SPEAKER_01: Um, you're not seeking persecution, but you're you're not running from it.
[1:04:13] SPEAKER_01: Um but the second thing that stands out to me here is it's also in the membership vows, putting peace and purity together.
[1:04:20] SPEAKER_01: And those things are intention sometimes.
[1:04:23] SPEAKER_01: You you need to be you need to maintain the purity of the church and its teaching and truth, but you also need to maintain peace uh in the way that you love one another.
[1:04:32] SPEAKER_01: And that's exactly how scripture tells us to do it, right?
[1:04:35] SPEAKER_01: Speak the truth and love.
[1:04:37] SPEAKER_01: And people may fall off on one side or the other.
[1:04:40] SPEAKER_01: They want peace at all costs, or they want purity at all costs.
[1:04:43] SPEAKER_01: And uh what you need to do is maintain both of those things in the way that you're approaching this when you do the hard thing, and uh when you're being a gospel minister, are you gonna maintain those two things together?
[1:04:54] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, you hear you hear folks toss peace and purity around a lot.
[1:04:57] SPEAKER_00: Um, you know, we're gonna maintain the peace and the purity.
[1:05:00] SPEAKER_00: I appreciate the unity um point here that that purity is important, peace is important, but equally important, at least according to our vow here, is is unity.
[1:05:09] SPEAKER_00: Um so I think what Scott said about using our our standards, our constitution and the scriptures um as as that unifying point um because you know we have agreed to do it a certain way.
[1:05:26] SPEAKER_00: We can have our differences, um, but we need to maintain a unity.
[1:05:30] SPEAKER_00: And so we we sh our churches are gonna look the same in a lot of respects in our denomination.
[1:05:35] SPEAKER_00: Um we we should seek to have you know similarities in what we teach uh because we've agreed to it.
[1:05:41] SPEAKER_00: And that that's an aspect of maintaining the purity, peace, and unity.
[1:05:45] SPEAKER_00: Um unity gets tossed out a lot.
[1:05:47] SPEAKER_00: I think probably because we hear peace and purity so much in the membership vows, and we don't hear ordination vows out loud as often, and so we've we forget about the unity word.
[1:05:55] SPEAKER_00: Um that admittedly is a harder one for me to swallow uh because uh I you know, like to lean my own ways.
[1:06:03] SPEAKER_00: But I have general trouble with subjection of the brethren anyway.
[1:06:06] SPEAKER_00: Uh that's not a discussion for this this podcast.
[1:06:10] SPEAKER_03: We all do.
[1:06:11] SPEAKER_03: And arguably the Presbyterian and Reformed tradition, it's uh it's it's a particular difficulty.
[1:06:17] SPEAKER_03: I mean we we we're kind of uh wedded to the Scotch-Irish temperament in a lot of ways, which is a very independent kind of temperament.
[1:06:26] SPEAKER_00: And I'm yeah, and I mean and there's there's a natural tension to the way that we do things in the PCA that's good and healthy for us to discuss things and it is.
[1:06:34] SPEAKER_03: One thing I'll I'll remark on on these three purity, peace, and unity, is um that while they're distinct, the same principles apply to each of them.
[1:06:46] SPEAKER_03: And and they don't rise and fall together.
[1:06:49] SPEAKER_03: You could have one without the other.
[1:06:51] SPEAKER_03: But all three of them require um humility in how we interact with one another as officers, but also require uh faithfulness in what we do as officers, both in our several powers and in our joint powers, individually and together.
[1:07:10] SPEAKER_03: And but particularly unity gets at the point that we don't operate as Marborough men ministers or as lone ranger ministers, just like no member of the church is a lone ranger Christian.
[1:07:23] SPEAKER_03: We operate in the context of sessions and presbyteries and general assemblies, of church courts and judicatories or however you want to call them, of synods and classes uh of officers together, which means that we should always be thinking through how is what I'm doing fitting into the team approach or effort.
[1:07:44] SPEAKER_03: We're all pulling on the oars in the same direction, even if we disagree about this, that, or the other thing.
[1:07:50] SPEAKER_03: And there's a manner aspect and a content aspect to that.
[1:07:53] SPEAKER_03: Interestingly, it's worth remarking on here the corresponding question for uh ruling elders and deacons adds and edification after unity.
[1:08:02] SPEAKER_03: And I think that's because it uh it they don't have uh any questions that correspond to our number five or our number eight.
[1:08:13] SPEAKER_03: And so that helps us to understand what numbers five and eight get at for us is uh edifying the church, um, what's required, loving Christ, that being our primary motive, and also um what it means to to take charge of a church, and we'll get to that in just a moment.
[1:08:33] SPEAKER_07: Yeah.
[1:08:34] SPEAKER_00: Jared, you mentioned the the you referred to persecution, opposition, you know, certain scenarios, the I th I um the the funeral at which you've been requested not to uh proclaim the gospel too clearly, but you you have to do that in in instead, right?
[1:08:48] SPEAKER_00: You so you have to do that as you preach.
[1:08:51] SPEAKER_00: Guys, what other persecutions or oppositions uh come to mind as you think about your experience in ministry?
[1:08:57] SPEAKER_00: Um kind of kind of strange words, perhaps in our context.
[1:09:03] SPEAKER_01: I think people who are going to go onto the mission field may wrestle with this a bit more.
[1:09:08] SPEAKER_01: Um is what you're doing going to meet with opposition from civil magistrates.
[1:09:14] SPEAKER_01: Um maybe we deal with that some in in certain states more than others here, but um I think this would especially be something that a missionary is gonna have to wrestle with um as they're going to it.
[1:09:28] SPEAKER_01: For us, it's probably not civil magistrate.
[1:09:30] SPEAKER_01: It may be congregants, you know.
[1:09:32] SPEAKER_01: The congregant says you're not gonna do that.
[1:09:34] SPEAKER_01: Or if you preach something and you believe this is what the scripture is telling you to do and the the congregation says don't do that anymore, and you're saying, I'm sorry, this is what God's word says, I'm going to do that.
[1:09:45] SPEAKER_01: Um I don't know if you've ever had this before where you preach on something and people say, Don't don't talk about hospitality again, because I don't like that, or I don't I don't feel called to that, so therefore don't teach uh teach that to us.
[1:09:56] SPEAKER_01: Well, it says to do it right here, and the next time it says to do it in the text, I'm gonna have to say it again.
[1:10:01] SPEAKER_01: Um so some of your persecution actually might be from your own congregants.
[1:10:07] SPEAKER_07: Many such cases.
[1:10:10] SPEAKER_00: I used to preach at a little church in Western Mississippi, and it was uh there was no air conditioning, and so in the summertime all the windows were open.
[1:10:17] SPEAKER_00: Every uh we we met at around eight o'clock, so it was a little cooler generally, but there are points of Mississippi summer that get awfully hot, and so the windows are open, and there's a train track not ten yards from the front door of the church, and almost without fail, the middle of my sermon every week, the train would blow by such persecution and opposition to the proclamation of the gospel.
[1:10:41] SPEAKER_00: But we we persevered.
[1:10:43] SPEAKER_00: Everybody would sit and wait.
[1:10:45] SPEAKER_03: I'm speaking a little tongue-in-cheek, I apologize, but hey, those interruptions are a nuisance, and they are and they don't come from nowhere.
[1:10:53] SPEAKER_03: Interestingly, the town right next to where I minister is called Reedville.
[1:10:57] SPEAKER_03: It's named after uh the Reed family, and the patriarch of that family was Robert H.
[1:11:02] SPEAKER_03: Reed, a student of Benjamin Morgan Palmer and an eminent minister in Smartburg County for about fifty years.
[1:11:09] SPEAKER_03: And um, there's no train station in Reedville.
[1:11:12] SPEAKER_03: There's one in Greer, there's in Welford and Lyman and and everywhere else, but not in Reedville.
[1:11:17] SPEAKER_03: And the reason being is the Reed family opposed putting a train stop there, which would have been to their economic advantage to have it there, but they opposed it because they were sabbatarians and they didn't want trains running through their town on the Lord's Day.
[1:11:31] SPEAKER_03: Epic.
[1:11:32] SPEAKER_03: Epic win.
[1:11:34] SPEAKER_00: The seventh question Do you engage to be faithful and diligent in the exercise of all your duties as a Christian and a minister of the gospel, whether personal or relational, private or public, and to endeavor by the grace of God to adorn the profession of the gospel and your manner of life, and to walk with exemplary piety before the flock of which God shall make you overseer.
[1:11:56] SPEAKER_00: This just always makes me think of Robert Mary McShane.
[1:11:59] SPEAKER_00: You know, it's that line that gets tossed around.
[1:12:00] SPEAKER_00: I don't know how accurate the quote actually is, but the greatest need of my people is my own personal holiness or godliness.
[1:12:07] SPEAKER_00: Um we we are not um to act the fool.
[1:12:11] SPEAKER_00: We uh conduct ourselves appropriately in all sorts of circumstances, and and you guys may have different places you want to take this.
[1:12:18] SPEAKER_03: So I'm glad it doesn't rec it doesn't ask us to vow to be perfect in these things.
[1:12:25] SPEAKER_03: That that would not be possible according to either grace or nature, but um to call us to be faithful and diligent is possible only according to grace.
[1:12:35] SPEAKER_03: And we need to understand that we are fully dependent on the Lord in this pursuit of personal holiness and piety and ex of exemplary carriage in front of people and in public.
[1:12:46] SPEAKER_03: Uh, I think some of the language, and I don't know all the history of it, I don't have the the BCO history project in front of me right now, but some of the language is is interesting, whether personal or relational.
[1:12:56] SPEAKER_03: And I'm like, how can you be personal without being relational?
[1:13:00] SPEAKER_03: Uh how can you be relational without being personal?
[1:13:02] SPEAKER_03: This seems a little bit redundant, but it does underscore and emphasize the fact that our calling as ministers is a calling to read many books, as displayed behind me, but is even more even more profoundly a calling to commune with the three persons of the Godhead and with the individual persons and people and the manifold multitudes of those who rise up and call upon Christ as Lord, and our neighbors who are all persons made in God's image.
[1:13:32] SPEAKER_03: And so that's if you don't if you don't want to get involved with people, then don't become a minister.
[1:13:39] SPEAKER_04: And I think what we see, this is probably the toughest vow, and and even with the grace, even with the grace aspect of it, uh you we don't often our most often our discipline proceedings are not theological, they're moral, and they touch this.
[1:13:55] SPEAKER_04: The person who's being brought up with charges or issues of infidelity or moral issues, they've were unable to keep this vow.
[1:14:03] SPEAKER_04: Um and so most often in our own clergy core or or those who are ruling elders in our churches or deacons, the issue most of the time is not doctrinal.
[1:14:12] SPEAKER_04: It's this faithfulness aspect of a man not being faithful in his personal piety to the Lord.
[1:14:19] SPEAKER_04: And so I think it is a it is a difficult burden.
[1:14:22] SPEAKER_04: Even as I'm reading it now, I'm reminded of the exemplary nature that I'm called to as a minister.
[1:14:29] SPEAKER_04: And it's a tough calling outside of the grace that's offered to us in Christ.
[1:14:32] SPEAKER_01: Well, and I'm I'm struck by two things here.
[1:14:35] SPEAKER_01: Well, one, you you guys have been emphasizing the personal piety part of it, and that's a big part.
[1:14:40] SPEAKER_01: Um, but also just all of the duties you have as a minister of the gospel, that you don't just get to do the part that you like, like, oh, I like preaching.
[1:14:48] SPEAKER_01: Well, no, you also have to do hospital visits and you also have to go to Presbytery meetings and session meetings, you know.
[1:14:55] SPEAKER_01: And so this is a you don't get to just do the parts that you like, um, you have to do all the parts of it.
[1:15:00] SPEAKER_01: Um, but also how those have to comply with um your personal piety.
[1:15:06] SPEAKER_01: Um, one of my favorite books on ministry is The Christian Ministry by Charles Bridges.
[1:15:10] SPEAKER_01: And of course, the subtitles of books in those days were always great.
[1:15:14] SPEAKER_01: Um hit the subtitle of the Christian ministry is with an inquiry into the causes of its inefficiency.
[1:15:21] SPEAKER_01: And a big part of that is if you're not keeping that vow, you don't have the personal piety there, you're not doing all the duties that you're called to.
[1:15:27] SPEAKER_01: Um, things are going to come crashing down.
[1:15:29] SPEAKER_01: And we've seen so many examples of that, especially with personal piety, that it doesn't matter how many books you've written and how many you've sold and how big your your pulpit is and your congregation is, um, if you're not keeping this vow, it can all come crashing down, no matter your natural gifts and how well you talk.
[1:15:47] SPEAKER_01: Absolutely right.
[1:15:49] SPEAKER_00: In the midst of my uh ministry to the persecuted church in Weston, Mississippi, that um horrible train, it w this was always a great encouragement to me because uh our our duty as ministers is is not to get the numbers right, it's not to attract the biggest crowd.
[1:16:07] SPEAKER_00: Um, it's not even to Zach's point at the beginning to be perfect in these things, but our our duty is to be faithful and diligent.
[1:16:14] SPEAKER_00: Um and and so and and so that speaks to I tharred, you you made my mind go this way.
[1:16:20] SPEAKER_00: This we're we're ministers, it's not a job, it's a life.
[1:16:24] SPEAKER_00: Um being a pastor is not something you do on a clock, um, but that it involves our whole life.
[1:16:30] SPEAKER_00: But in your whole life, perfection's not what's required, and and meeting a certain standard of numerical um value is not required, but simply faithfulness and diligence in the things that you've been given.
[1:16:43] SPEAKER_00: Um diligence is difficult, but it is something we can aim for and do.
[1:16:49] SPEAKER_00: Uh we can be faithful and diligent by God's grace.
[1:16:52] SPEAKER_00: And it's a great encouragement to me in the midst of ministry.
[1:16:55] SPEAKER_00: Jared, you muted and unmuted several times.
[1:16:58] SPEAKER_00: I Y'all throw me off.
[1:17:01] SPEAKER_01: I was just gonna make the point that this is no matter where you're at.
[1:17:04] SPEAKER_01: I I think that's a great point that you were saying there is Yes, uh, you're a pastor, um no matter whether you're in your local congregation or you take a flight somewhere and you're on vacation or you are at General Assembly, um, there's not an excuse that there you get to be unpious and nobody will know.
[1:17:21] SPEAKER_01: No, you're you're still uh carrying that vow with you wherever you go.
[1:17:24] SPEAKER_00: Do you all have any thoughts?
[1:17:25] SPEAKER_00: I mean, I I think I have this question down here.
[1:17:27] SPEAKER_00: Um what what practically can can men do?
[1:17:32] SPEAKER_00: Uh maybe thinking about a young minister uh who's trying to figure out how to how to balance this in his life and how to how to think about all these aspects of his life.
[1:17:41] SPEAKER_00: What are practical steps you can take to balance your personal and your relational and your public and your private and your ministerial life?
[1:17:49] SPEAKER_00: What are the essential fundamental practices of a minister that that would uh meet this requirement?
[1:17:56] SPEAKER_03: It's really simple and not easy.
[1:17:59] SPEAKER_03: And that is this humility and prayer.
[1:18:05] SPEAKER_03: And humility means being in the word.
[1:18:07] SPEAKER_03: I find specifically reading the wisdom literature to be very humbling.
[1:18:11] SPEAKER_03: So reading James and Proverbs in particular, but also Matthew's gospel, which is has a wisdom theme to it, pronounced wisdom theme, reading Job and the Psalms pretty much on repeat, even in addition to your other Bible reading, is gonna it should cultivate humility in you if you're reading with your eyes open.
[1:18:28] SPEAKER_03: And then also um being in prayer is a humbling exercise because you'll realize much like golf, nobody's good at it, and and it takes a lot of effort and time, and um, but it's also really sweet and enjoyable.
[1:18:42] SPEAKER_03: Um, I'm not an avid golfer, but I enjoy it.
[1:18:44] SPEAKER_03: I don't spend a lot of time on the on the golf course, but I do spend a significant amount of time in prayer as a minister of word, sacrament, and prayer.
[1:18:52] SPEAKER_03: So the as I've been preaching through Matthew's gospel, that's been impressed upon me more and more.
[1:18:57] SPEAKER_03: The fundamental lesson that Christ gives to his disciples in terms of practical Christianity, kingdom of heaven living, is this be humble and pray.
[1:19:08] SPEAKER_03: That's what watchfulness looks like, that's what wisdom looks like practically.
[1:19:12] SPEAKER_03: I mean, there's obviously more that Christ says, and even more essential lessons that he gives about the truth of the gospel, but in terms of what a minister should be doing, if you want to be a leader in Christ's church, you absolutely must be humble, and you absolutely must be uh constant and diligent in prayer.
[1:19:32] SPEAKER_04: I think in addition to that, we can't mistake the word faithful to meaning all-encompassing.
[1:19:37] SPEAKER_04: Um, that I'm gonna the only way to be a faithful minister is if I'm always on the clock, 120 hours a week, always working, always working.
[1:19:45] SPEAKER_04: Uh, there is a work and family balance.
[1:19:49] SPEAKER_04: Uh, it is not faithful for you to let your marriage and your relationship with your kids get destroyed by the ministry.
[1:19:55] SPEAKER_04: Absolutely.
[1:19:56] SPEAKER_04: And so there needs to be adequate boundaries set by the minister to carve out time for his family, uh, for his wife and his kids.
[1:20:06] SPEAKER_04: And uh my one of my mentors in the ministry previous prior to this, uh, he had the philosophy that uh I will not let the church pay for my phone because then I could have better control over who has access to my phone.
[1:20:19] SPEAKER_04: And his idea was that his ruling elders, his deacons, the secretary all have access to his phone, um, but it's more restrained than anyone always having access, blowing up his phone.
[1:20:30] SPEAKER_04: You could perhaps apply this in a different way of restraining what is on your phone at certain times, making sure that you're not checking your email for church-related things all day, every day, but actually allowing yourself to detach at certain times, not to abandon the ministry, but to be there with your family.
[1:20:46] SPEAKER_04: Your kids notice if you're stuck doing work at home.
[1:20:49] SPEAKER_04: Yeah.
[1:20:50] SPEAKER_04: Um, even when I'm not working, when my kids see me on my laptop, uh, when I'm home, they're like, Daddy, why are you working today?
[1:20:56] SPEAKER_04: Why are you working today?
[1:20:57] SPEAKER_04: And it's because they associate that stuff with the ministry.
[1:21:00] SPEAKER_04: And so in order to guard that, you have to carve out how you use technology and how you spend time with your family.
[1:21:10] SPEAKER_03: Good word.
[1:21:11] SPEAKER_03: Very good.
[1:21:12] SPEAKER_03: Tony, uh, how do you say his last name?
[1:21:14] SPEAKER_03: Ranky.
[1:21:15] SPEAKER_03: Yep.
[1:21:15] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, he has he has a good book on how your phone affects you.
[1:21:18] SPEAKER_03: It's very helpful.
[1:21:21] SPEAKER_00: His stuff is great, by the way.
[1:21:23] SPEAKER_00: If anybody needs like that kind of like uh administrative task-oriented, how your brain works, the things you use, his his stuff is fantastic.
[1:21:30] SPEAKER_00: He's got that technology book out too.
[1:21:33] SPEAKER_00: All of it's good.
[1:21:35] SPEAKER_00: Okay, last one.
[1:21:37] SPEAKER_00: Number eight.
[1:21:38] SPEAKER_00: Are you now willing to take char you now willing to take the charge of this church, agreeable to your declaration when accepting their call?
[1:21:46] SPEAKER_00: And do you relying upon God for strength, promise to discharge it discharge to it the duties of a pastor?
[1:21:54] SPEAKER_00: Sorry, I had trouble with that one.
[1:21:55] SPEAKER_00: I don't know why.
[1:21:56] SPEAKER_03: Um this one goes along pretty well with the third membership vow of being reliant upon the Holy Spirit uh to live in a manner that honors the Lord.
[1:22:07] SPEAKER_03: And uh truly it's a good good remember uh good reminder that we are not to be self-reliant.
[1:22:13] SPEAKER_03: Sometimes we're tempted to do that, especially if we have good health or you know, good uh strong mental gifts or intellectual gifts or gifts of presentation and communication.
[1:22:23] SPEAKER_03: But um we need to be relying relying upon God for strength, uh, which gets back to the humility and prayer uh dictum there.
[1:22:33] SPEAKER_00: It this this connects back to the call that a man's received, right?
[1:22:36] SPEAKER_00: So if you've ever read or heard read uh a call from a church, right?
[1:22:40] SPEAKER_00: They state they state what they want you to come and do, how they're gonna provide for you in your exercise of those duties, and this is in some sense your response to that written call.
[1:22:50] SPEAKER_00: Um they've asked you to come do this, they're gonna take care of you while you do it.
[1:22:53] SPEAKER_00: Are you agreeable to to do the things that you have said you'll do as they take care of you in that process?
[1:23:01] SPEAKER_00: And so you're it's a commitment to the church that's called you uh to the particular work you're serving.
[1:23:07] SPEAKER_00: What else?
[1:23:08] SPEAKER_01: I think it also reminds you of your call to the local church and the fact that that's where your primary duty is going to lie.
[1:23:17] SPEAKER_01: And so that's where you your focus needs to be.
[1:23:19] SPEAKER_01: And yes, you might be somebody that writes books or does some talks or serves uh elsewhere, but those things should not take away from the fact that you have a charge of a particular church.
[1:23:31] SPEAKER_01: And if you're never there because you're doing all these other things, um, that's a problem.
[1:23:35] SPEAKER_01: Uh so it it grounds you uh to where those sorts of things should flow out of your service to the local church, which is why I love people who are able to like turn their sermons and their Sunday school lessons into books and things like that for help for other people doing those things, uh, versus just taking off and and doing some other things over here and just neglecting their local church.
[1:23:56] SPEAKER_01: Uh it doesn't mean that you shouldn't be involved with those things, but it everything should be rooted in service to the local church.
[1:24:06] SPEAKER_05: Yeah, I had a friend tell me recently that it's hard to build the church if you're never at the church.
[1:24:12] SPEAKER_04: And uh he said it pithily in a way of you should guard your time with what you commit yourself to outside of the local church.
[1:24:20] SPEAKER_04: Yes, the ecclesiastical ministry at the at the Presbyterian General Assembly are important, but they are they are secondary incense to your primary calling to preach the gospel um to the people that you've been particularly called to.
[1:24:35] SPEAKER_04: And this vow reminds us of that, that we are willing to do that, and that's our main work, even as we do these other works to support the ministry.
[1:24:44] SPEAKER_00: It occurs to me that some some maybe listening or others who never listen uh to a podcast like this may suggest that we're doing something that doesn't abide by what we just described.
[1:24:55] SPEAKER_00: Um But I mean, just in a sense of reaffirming sort of what we've talked about on this show before, um, this this serves my church.
[1:25:03] SPEAKER_00: Um you know uh you listeners would be surprised how little time we put into preparing for this.
[1:25:09] SPEAKER_00: Uh so besides the actual report.
[1:25:11] SPEAKER_00: That doesn't give people confidence.
[1:25:14] SPEAKER_00: Well, all I all I mean to say is that so much of so much of what we're doing here is just is just overflow of our regular ministry in service to the local congregation and the presbytery and the general assembly.
[1:25:26] SPEAKER_00: Um you know, men men that probably more more men spend more time on social media than they need to.
[1:25:34] SPEAKER_00: But if you see a if you see a um your minister online, if you if he's doing extra stuff, uh, Lord willing, and I know many men that do this, it's flowing out of their regular ministry.
[1:25:45] SPEAKER_00: It's it's um, you know, the guys I see in front of me on the screen, and I know other PCM ministers that do a lot of things that serve the church outside of their local congregation, and for the most part, it is in uh it's flowing out of their regular ministry.
[1:25:58] SPEAKER_00: It's it's an extra hour a week that they give to something to kind of uh spur it on.
[1:26:04] SPEAKER_00: So um anyway, things like this aren't bad, even though we should focus on the local congregation.
[1:26:09] SPEAKER_00: I'm not trying to defend us.
[1:26:10] SPEAKER_00: It sounds like I'm trying to defend us.
[1:26:12] SPEAKER_00: I apologize.
[1:26:12] SPEAKER_03: A little bit, but you're not wrong.
[1:26:14] SPEAKER_03: And um there's another title, a little bit, but I'm not wrong.
[1:26:18] SPEAKER_03: I I mean I'm not basual about it.
[1:26:21] SPEAKER_03: I have a very active social media presence, um, but I really don't spend a whole lot of time posting or or preparing posts.
[1:26:29] SPEAKER_03: Most of it is uh reformatting or repackaging stuff I'm already doing, and I know it's an encouragement to people in my own church, and it's actually helped my church as people move into the area and and have visited and said, Oh yeah, I I really appreciate what you put up online.
[1:26:44] SPEAKER_03: And I said, Well, the the stuff you appreciate, I hope, is reflective of what's here.
[1:26:48] SPEAKER_03: And if there's anything you don't appreciate, well, just blame me.
[1:26:51] SPEAKER_03: Don't blame the church, please.
[1:26:52] SPEAKER_03: And then um, and I I really and I'm really grateful for what you all are doing.
[1:26:57] SPEAKER_03: And this is just to illustrate this, a lot of times we don't even think about how everything goes together.
[1:27:04] SPEAKER_03: When you asked me to sit down to discuss the ordination questions, I don't think you all knew that uh I've been involved almost every quarter in an ordination or an installation of either a pastor or a missionary or elders and deacons.
[1:27:23] SPEAKER_03: I've done everything I could have possibly done as a teaching elder in an ordination or installation service.
[1:27:30] SPEAKER_03: Not only have I been ordained and taken the vows, but I've given the charge to the congregation, I've given the charge to the minister, I've chaired the commission, I've preached the sermon and and and offered the ordination prayer.
[1:27:43] SPEAKER_03: I mean, I've done everything I could have because just in God's providence, I've had the opportunity to be uh a part of so many, not just here in Calvary Presbytery, but even elsewhere.
[1:27:52] SPEAKER_03: And it's been a real privilege and something that uh I'm just delighted to talk about.
[1:27:58] SPEAKER_03: And uh and so even my involvement today in this conversation, uh, however disruptive my involvement may have been, it actually does line up with uh something I've had some experience doing over the last few years.
[1:28:12] SPEAKER_00: Well, I'm gonna let that uh be our landing point and tell you that according to the 35 points in front of me, this podcast is over.
[1:28:19] SPEAKER_00: Thanks for joining us.
[1:28:20] SPEAKER_00: Be sure to come back next time when we discuss uh who knows what.
[1:28:24] SPEAKER_00: If you're interested in learning more about what we've talked about, anything that we brought up, I'll have some show notes uh down below for you.
[1:28:30] SPEAKER_00: Um, or you can go to Politymatters.org and find those links.
[1:28:33] SPEAKER_00: If you've enjoyed the show, do consider following us on Twitter or Facebook at Polity Matters, and be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[1:28:40] SPEAKER_00: If you have questions or comments, you can reach out to us on those socials or email us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[1:28:47] SPEAKER_00: And uh there's also a link below where you can support our work uh as we continue to produce week by week.
[1:28:53] SPEAKER_00: Uh Zach, we are glad that you joined us, brother.
[1:28:55] SPEAKER_00: Thank you for helping us out in this conversation.
[1:28:57] SPEAKER_00: It was very edifying to me, and I know to the other men as well.
[1:29:01] SPEAKER_00: Um listeners, thank you.
[1:29:04] SPEAKER_00: Listeners, thank you for spending time with us.
[1:29:06] SPEAKER_00: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[1:29:09] SPEAKER_00: Goodbye, gentlemen.
[1:29:10] SPEAKER_00: Goodbye.
[1:29:12] SPEAKER_00: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
