# 15. Interlopers or Conflicts, Etc. (BCO 8.5-8.10)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 5 Dec 2023, 43 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/14089253-15-interlopers-or-conflicts-etc-bco-8-5-8-10.mp3

The polity bros resume their discussion with PCA Grand Poobah Fred Greco on BCO 8: The Elder. Listen to Part 1 here BCO online Fred is the pastor of Christ Church Katy, TX. The Shepherd Leader by Timothy Witmer Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Introduction
- 0:35 BCO 8-5
- 8:33 BCO 8-6
- 19:07 BCO 8-7
- 25:42 BCO 8-8
- 30:52 BCO 8-9
- 34:04 BCO 8-10
- 38:49 Conclusion
- 41:18 Closing

## Transcript

[0:03] SPEAKER_01: Hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:05] SPEAKER_01: My name is Ben Ratliff, and you are tuned in to part two of BCO 8 on The Elder.
[0:11] SPEAKER_01: Last time we sat down with Fred Greco and began discussing BCO chapter 8 and got through section 4.
[0:17] SPEAKER_01: And today we're picking up right where we left off.
[0:19] SPEAKER_01: So if you missed the last one, it would greatly benefit you to go back and listen to the first part of the discussion in Polity Matters episode 13.
[0:27] SPEAKER_01: But if you're here for part two, I won't keep you any longer.
[0:30] SPEAKER_01: Enjoy the show.
[0:36] SPEAKER_01: So into paragraph number five.
[0:39] SPEAKER_01: When a man is called to labor as a teaching elder, it belongs to his order, in addition to those functions he shares with all other elders, to feed the flock by reading, expounding, and preaching the word of God, and to administer the sacraments.
[0:52] SPEAKER_01: As he is sent to declare the will of God to sinners and to beseech them to be reconciled to God through Christ, he is termed ambassador.
[0:59] SPEAKER_01: As he bears glad tidings of salvation to the ignorant and perishing, he is termed evangelist.
[1:04] SPEAKER_01: As he stands to proclaim the gospel, he is termed preacher.
[1:08] SPEAKER_01: As he dispenses the manifold grace of God and the ordinances instituted by Christ, he is termed steward of the mysteries of God.
[1:15] SPEAKER_01: Somebody just deleted all of the notes in it.
[1:18] SPEAKER_01: There it is.
[1:18] SPEAKER_01: Scott, are you messing with me?
[1:20] SPEAKER_01: Was it me?
[1:22] SPEAKER_03: My bad.
[1:22] SPEAKER_03: I was trying to my my OCD.
[1:25] SPEAKER_03: I saw that the font was a different size and different typeset, and so I had to fix it.
[1:30] SPEAKER_03: But in fixing it, I accidentally deleted it.
[1:32] SPEAKER_03: My bad.
[1:34] SPEAKER_01: My brain just exploded.
[1:36] SPEAKER_00: I print mine off because I'm old school.
[1:39] SPEAKER_01: All right.
[1:40] SPEAKER_01: I think I got it.
[1:41] SPEAKER_01: I might have to stitch a couple of things together for that gap.
[1:44] SPEAKER_01: But there's BCO85 expanding on paragraph one and paragraph three, speaking to the duties of elder, but now particularly to the teaching elder, separate and compared to the duties of a ruling elder.
[1:56] SPEAKER_01: Scott, you you've you've made the list for us.
[1:58] SPEAKER_01: Why don't you tease us out and explain kind of what's presented here?
[2:02] SPEAKER_03: Uh yeah.
[2:03] SPEAKER_03: So we have um the general nature of an elder, but there are additional responsibilities, as we see here, for those who labor um vocationally as the teaching elder, the pastors of the flock.
[2:13] SPEAKER_03: And and so we see uh definitively the idea of a teaching elder.
[2:17] SPEAKER_03: This is one who feeds the the flock with the word.
[2:20] SPEAKER_03: This is the the man who will be leading in your ordinary preaching.
[2:25] SPEAKER_03: This isn't to say that ruling elders won't exhort from time to time, but the the typical teaching elder is the one who's in pulpit from Sunday to Sunday.
[2:34] SPEAKER_03: Uh he is an ambassador.
[2:35] SPEAKER_03: Uh, he declares the will of God to sinners.
[2:37] SPEAKER_03: When we're thinking through the work of a prophet in the Old Testament, he represents God to people and the people to God.
[2:44] SPEAKER_03: And so as the teaching elder uh leads the flock, he does so as an ambassador, declaring God's will um to sinners and to his people.
[2:54] SPEAKER_03: He's also an evangelist, as uh Jared mentioned a few moments ago, that brings the good news of the gospel um to the flock.
[3:03] SPEAKER_03: One of my favorite pastors, Randy Thompson, um, at the end of his sermons, always is evangelistic.
[3:10] SPEAKER_03: And he quotes Hebrews chapter four, where it says, uh, do not harden your hearts today.
[3:17] SPEAKER_03: If you hear his voice, do not harden your hearts.
[3:19] SPEAKER_03: It's the work of an evangelist.
[3:21] SPEAKER_03: Um, the pastor is called to that.
[3:22] SPEAKER_03: He's a preacher proclaiming the word, and he's a steward of the mysteries of God.
[3:26] SPEAKER_03: He dispenses the grace of God and the ordinance of Christ, the commands of Christ uh to the people.
[3:32] SPEAKER_03: You think of the mysteries of God as it relates to the mystical nature of the sacraments that are dispensed to the people.
[3:40] SPEAKER_03: Each of these areas are areas, perhaps, as Fred talked about earlier, that are unique to the teaching elder, um, at least how they're manifested within the congregation.
[3:51] SPEAKER_00: It's interesting as you look at that list.
[3:53] SPEAKER_00: This is particularly for teaching elder.
[3:55] SPEAKER_00: I don't think this list is supposed to be you do one or two or three of these things.
[3:59] SPEAKER_00: All of these things should be somewhere in your ministry.
[4:02] SPEAKER_00: Um, but also this is focused on the teaching elder.
[4:05] SPEAKER_00: So word and sacrament is particularly the domain of the teaching elder as a minister of the word, as a minister of word and sacrament.
[4:12] SPEAKER_00: Um, although Ari sometimes will exhort or fill the pulpit, uh, I would think about the way that this is um being discussed here.
[4:20] SPEAKER_00: Um, if you are preaching regularly, you're expected to be licensed.
[4:25] SPEAKER_00: And so I've known some ruling elders that have not become teaching elders but have been licensed to preach.
[4:29] SPEAKER_00: I wonder if anyone else has uh encountered that or if there's a good rule of thumb of what it means to regularly preach, if that's kind of in that bridge in the in the 2.5.
[4:39] SPEAKER_00: Um, if anybody has experience with that.
[4:42] SPEAKER_01: Our presbytery has a definition at some point in our sinning rules, I think, that that regular preaching is uh what do they say it?
[4:50] SPEAKER_01: More than six times in a six-month period.
[4:52] SPEAKER_01: So it's it's one time per month on average, I guess is the way they usually think about it.
[4:56] SPEAKER_01: Um and so if you're preaching more than that, you need to be licensed.
[5:00] SPEAKER_01: I've always wondered if a ruling elder didn't need to be licensed in order to preach, especially in his own pulpit, um, just to exhort on a regular basis, if he's if if we still call it exhortation, right?
[5:11] SPEAKER_01: A ruling elder is allowed to do that.
[5:13] SPEAKER_01: Um maybe you guys have that answer to that.
[5:16] SPEAKER_01: Is a ruling elder have to get licensed, or can he stand up and exhort in his pulpit every Sunday evening until the new associate minister is found, or whatever the case may be?
[5:25] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think he needs to be licensed.
[5:27] SPEAKER_02: I don't um I don't uh buy the exhortation versus preaching distinction that is a part of other denominations, especially more three office denominations.
[5:39] SPEAKER_02: Um, and I think chapter 19 buttresses that.
[5:43] SPEAKER_02: Um, here's more, there's a freebie you didn't ask for.
[5:47] SPEAKER_02: I think uh this whole discussion uh militates against the concept, uh, the statement that's been thrown out that a woman can do anything an unordained man can do.
[5:58] SPEAKER_02: According to our book, an unordained man can preach.
[6:02] SPEAKER_02: Just not regularly.
[6:04] SPEAKER_02: If he preaches regularly, he needs to be licensed.
[6:06] SPEAKER_02: That's the whole point of 19.
[6:09] SPEAKER_02: Um, and so I do think there's something particular about preaching.
[6:15] SPEAKER_02: Uh I think it's different than teaching, I think it carries a different authority.
[6:19] SPEAKER_02: And I think we would do well, especially in our day and age, not to flatten that distinction, but to retain it.
[6:28] SPEAKER_02: That it's a part of the office.
[6:31] SPEAKER_02: Um I think I I'm very uh thankful for the listing of these particulars here in 85.
[6:40] SPEAKER_01: For any listeners that are concerned about my personal view, I totally agree with what Fred just said.
[6:44] SPEAKER_01: Thank you.
[6:45] SPEAKER_03: I was just drafting some 312s to send a covenant presbytery.
[6:49] SPEAKER_03: Very, very tempting.
[6:51] SPEAKER_03: And I think it's part of the responsibility of the presbytery, right?
[6:55] SPEAKER_03: Um it's part of our accountability that we have both higher and lower.
[7:00] SPEAKER_03: Um, when a man is regularly filling pulpit, um, it is the duty of the presbytery to ensure and to safeguard um that pulpit.
[7:09] SPEAKER_03: And so it's part of the training.
[7:11] SPEAKER_03: Um, the presbytery has to check off those boxes, especially since uh I don't know how your churches are, but um usually ordination for your ruling elders is teared down quite a bit um as it relates to examination and evaluation.
[7:28] SPEAKER_03: And so I think it's helpful to have a presbytery do a thorough evaluation of a ruling elder as he seeks to fill the pulpit there on a regular basis.
[7:38] SPEAKER_02: I think there's just one final point that I would make is eight five fleshes out some of what's implied in eight four.
[7:46] SPEAKER_02: In other words, a a needful work is one that encompasses pastoral work for a teaching elder.
[7:57] SPEAKER_02: And eight five kind of describes what that is evangelizing, preaching, stewarding the mysteries of God, word and sacrament, we might say, um, being an ambassador to the world.
[8:09] SPEAKER_02: Um it's it's sort of laying out, you know, why the needful work would require ordination and a call as a teaching elder.
[8:19] SPEAKER_02: Because what's part and parcel of the work of a teaching elder is preaching, administering the sacraments, uh evangelizing, etc.
[8:28] SPEAKER_02: Um, so I think there's a there's a tight connection there between 8.4 and 85.
[8:34] SPEAKER_01: BCO eight six, when a teaching elder is appointed to the work of an evangelist in foreign countries or where there are no other PCA churches within a reasonable distance, he's commissioned for a renewable term of 12 months to preach the word, to administer the sacraments, to receive and dismiss members of mission churches, and to train potential officers.
[8:53] SPEAKER_01: By separate actions, the presbytery may, in extraordinary situations, commission him to examine, ordain, and install ruling elders and deacons and organize churches.
[9:03] SPEAKER_01: Um we're immediately putting a distinction between the general use of the word evangelist in 8.5, and now we've we're attaching to it more of an official um use here in 8.6.
[9:15] SPEAKER_01: Inside the order of teaching elder, there's a designation evangelist, a teaching elder who's called to these specific functions.
[9:22] SPEAKER_01: Uh, maybe church planning would be the sort of colloquial term we'd use for what's happening here.
[9:26] SPEAKER_01: Um, it comes with significant authority, as is listed here.
[9:30] SPEAKER_01: And so the qualifications are important, that it only takes place uh when an evangelist is ministering in foreign countries, which is implied to be a place where there's no other PCA church within a reasonable distance, and it's got a renewable term of 12 months.
[9:43] SPEAKER_01: So there's somewhat of a of a temporary um perspective on this.
[9:49] SPEAKER_01: How does this function?
[9:50] SPEAKER_01: You know, we've talked previously on this show that that we don't know very many evangelists in in the technical sense.
[9:56] SPEAKER_01: Scott uh seems to be friends with one, according to the notes that he's put in front of us.
[10:00] SPEAKER_01: Uh, I think we all know who that is.
[10:02] SPEAKER_01: But um what's the deal with evangelists, guys?
[10:07] SPEAKER_03: Well, this is the Episcopalian provision within our constitution, um, where uh we grant a reasonable amount of authority vested in a singular individual.
[10:19] SPEAKER_03: Um, it it's interesting in that it's a distinction of a teaching elder.
[10:24] SPEAKER_03: So it's almost like an additional office in some regards that a teaching elder or a different class of teaching elder, where he has the additional authority outside of the word and sacraments, is to also receive in himself to dismiss members and also to train uh potential officers as well.
[10:44] SPEAKER_03: And so they are granted, the individual is granted perhaps more authority than typical.
[10:50] SPEAKER_03: I I make fun of my friend in Utah who's um ordained as an evangelist.
[10:54] SPEAKER_03: So it was not easy for him to even get that as a man ordained in Utah to plan a church, but uh I call him often uh the the the bishop of Utah because of the types of work that he has uh that he's permitted to do there.
[11:08] SPEAKER_01: Oh, tell them who it is.
[11:10] SPEAKER_03: Oh, it's it's uh my friend Ben Coppers, um, the only evangelist I know in all the PCA, actually.
[11:16] SPEAKER_03: Uh maybe Fred has a bunch of evangelists he knows.
[11:19] SPEAKER_03: Uh what are your thoughts on this, Fred?
[11:22] SPEAKER_02: So I think that evangelist is a provision that was too often used in the PCA in the last 10 or 15 years.
[11:34] SPEAKER_02: It seemed like there was often the case, any church planter was given um the powers of an evangelist.
[11:43] SPEAKER_02: I think that is a massive mistake.
[11:47] SPEAKER_02: Uh, you know, this provision basically says if it's a foreign land or there are no PCA churches.
[11:52] SPEAKER_02: So, you know, I've known men that have been given powers of the evangelist when there are several PCA churches within 30 minutes of where they're planting.
[12:01] SPEAKER_02: Um, and it's uh it creates uh, I think a mess.
[12:06] SPEAKER_02: Uh I think it creates a mess for the man.
[12:09] SPEAKER_02: Um, you know, a church, what a church planter needs is not a lot of authority to run around by himself.
[12:15] SPEAKER_02: He needs men to help him, give him advice, protect him from potential interlopers or conflicts, etc.
[12:24] SPEAKER_02: I'm not just saying we need to put men around him to make sure he toes the line.
[12:29] SPEAKER_02: I mean we need to put men around him to protect him because it's very difficult to plant a church and um you know to do that.
[12:37] SPEAKER_02: So I think it should be used very sparingly.
[12:41] SPEAKER_02: Utah's probably the one state in America where you could do that because there's really not churches within any kind of reasonable driving uh distance.
[12:52] SPEAKER_02: Now, there are two aspects to this in this paragraph.
[12:55] SPEAKER_02: So I love the way it gives me a way to remember it.
[12:59] SPEAKER_02: My friend Howie uh talks about the junior varsity and the varsity evangelist.
[13:05] SPEAKER_02: And and the junior varsity evangelist is someone who's given the authority to preach, administer the sacraments, and receive and dismiss members of a mission church.
[13:16] SPEAKER_02: By separate action, it says.
[13:18] SPEAKER_02: So you have to take an affirmative separate action of presbytery.
[13:22] SPEAKER_02: He can be given the functions of a session, that is, to examine officers and organize churches.
[13:28] SPEAKER_02: I think that should be used incredibly rarely.
[13:31] SPEAKER_01: One of those is the power of a presbytery, not just a session, to organize churches.
[13:35] SPEAKER_02: Now, I'll give you an example.
[13:37] SPEAKER_02: Our presbytery actually has an evangelist, and we didn't even give him those further powers.
[13:43] SPEAKER_02: He's in Japan.
[13:45] SPEAKER_02: So he's a missionary in Japan where there are no other existent PCA works.
[13:51] SPEAKER_02: There are other churches, other denominations, there are other works.
[13:54] SPEAKER_02: There's a Japanese denomination, there are some OPC churches, there's some RPCNA churches that, you know, if there is no presbytery within thousands of miles.
[14:04] SPEAKER_02: Okay.
[14:05] SPEAKER_02: And so in order to perform the sacraments and to build up a mission church, we've given him those powers.
[14:11] SPEAKER_02: But we didn't give him the power to examine officers and organize churches because, especially in our day and age, you don't need to do that because our presbytery could examine officers over electronic video conference.
[14:25] SPEAKER_02: So it's not like it was 200 years ago or 100 years ago.
[14:28] SPEAKER_02: So I think you know that is uh that's very important.
[14:33] SPEAKER_02: The other thing is that presbyteries need to keep um accounts of this.
[14:41] SPEAKER_02: I've seen multiple presbyteries that have just forgotten to re-up an evangelist's powers, which tells me two things.
[14:50] SPEAKER_02: First of all, they didn't follow the book.
[14:51] SPEAKER_02: But secondly, they didn't view these powers as being restrictive and temporary because they just let them go on.
[14:58] SPEAKER_02: And so, I mean, I think the powers of an evangelist could be helpful in a foreign missions context, but I think in a normal PCA context, those powers are not needed.
[15:08] SPEAKER_00: I think it's worth noting that of the powers of the session that he's given, one of them is not discipline.
[15:14] SPEAKER_00: Um, there was this uh constitutional inquiry that was asking about uh the keeping of the rules.
[15:19] SPEAKER_00: And um, they asked these three questions.
[15:21] SPEAKER_00: Uh, can you grant requests for a transfer of membership?
[15:25] SPEAKER_00: Uh, number two, can you remove the name from the rules of those who indicate that they don't want to fulfill their vows anymore?
[15:30] SPEAKER_00: And number three, discipline those that are basically contumus, that they are they're not going to fulfill their their vows.
[15:37] SPEAKER_00: And the answer to the first one, yes, you can grant uh the changing of rules, but to the other two, they said no, those are acts of discipline.
[15:44] SPEAKER_00: And in fact, uh evangelists may have lots of powers, but they they're not given that joint power that's only given to a session.
[15:50] SPEAKER_02: I've seen this firsthand, Jared.
[15:52] SPEAKER_02: I've seen a guy get in trouble because he thought he had those powers.
[15:57] SPEAKER_02: And the Presbytery wasn't aware that he didn't have those powers.
[16:01] SPEAKER_02: And so normally you'll see this in the removing the names from the role.
[16:07] SPEAKER_02: Not a lot of men are going to assume they could be a trial court and try someone and discipline them.
[16:12] SPEAKER_02: But normally, someone might think, well, you know, if someone said they're not going to be in the church anymore, I could just drop them.
[16:19] SPEAKER_02: You can't, according to this.
[16:21] SPEAKER_02: You have the the presbytery needs to drop them as a part of the mission church.
[16:26] SPEAKER_03: What would that process look like?
[16:28] SPEAKER_03: Uh, it seems like you can get yourself in a quagmire granting membership into your congregation.
[16:35] SPEAKER_03: All right, hey, bud.
[16:36] SPEAKER_03: You can't talk to me right now.
[16:38] SPEAKER_03: Sorry about that.
[16:40] SPEAKER_03: Uh, but what kind of uh quagmire does this lead to where you can receive members but never remove them?
[16:45] SPEAKER_03: Uh, what is the process for actually removing them?
[16:48] SPEAKER_02: So I think you can receive them and you can dismiss them if they leave.
[16:53] SPEAKER_02: If they need to be dropped from the roles, that's something the court needs to do.
[16:58] SPEAKER_02: The presbytery would need to do.
[17:00] SPEAKER_02: Because if you have an evangelist, you don't have a temporary system of government.
[17:03] SPEAKER_02: You don't have a borrowed session, so to speak.
[17:06] SPEAKER_02: And so the presbytery would have to be the one that would note that and would have to follow the procedures under um 38-4.
[17:15] SPEAKER_02: They'd have to send the letter, they'd have to tell people that they're being dropped, they'd have to give them an opportunity for a disciplinary hearing if they request it.
[17:24] SPEAKER_02: And so basically, it's saying that the presbytery can't cede those powers to an evangelist.
[17:31] SPEAKER_02: They would have to do it.
[17:32] SPEAKER_02: Now that sounds clunky, but that's why presbytery should appoint a commission to be a temporary system of government.
[17:39] SPEAKER_03: So are you gonna uh send up an amendment in order to reformat this and to correct it since we shouldn't have evangelists, Fred?
[17:46] SPEAKER_01: No, you're gonna do that, Scott.
[17:48] SPEAKER_02: Scott's just gonna track it.
[17:50] SPEAKER_02: No, what this is the this is the motivation for potentially writing the commentary on the BCO.
[17:55] SPEAKER_01: What does it look like?
[17:56] SPEAKER_01: I'm just I was thinking back to BCO five, which we covered a little while ago.
[18:00] SPEAKER_01: What were the the the options for oversight of a mission church is um well, the the two others are to have a session of a particular church being a mother-daughter relationship, and then one the the third one is a commission of the presbytery appointed to oversee them.
[18:15] SPEAKER_01: But the first option is to appoint an evangelist prescribed in BCO eight six, which is what we're talking about.
[18:20] SPEAKER_01: And then at the end of that list, there's a paragraph that seems to apply to all three of those options that the temporary system of government shall record and submit its records to presbytery for annual review in the same manner as sessions of particular churches.
[18:32] SPEAKER_01: So, would this mean to suggest that a an evangelist would just keep track of what he has singularly done and just give a list every year to the presbytery, like a session would turn in their minutes?
[18:42] SPEAKER_02: Yes.
[18:42] SPEAKER_02: So, for example, one of the things that a session is required to record in its minutes are baptisms.
[18:50] SPEAKER_02: And so even if that's all that he did as an evangelist, he should record those and submit them as records.
[18:57] SPEAKER_01: That's a lot of power and authority, man.
[18:59] SPEAKER_03: A lot of unanimous decisions, though.
[19:02] SPEAKER_01: I'll put a laugh track in right there when I'm editing.
[19:06] SPEAKER_01: Let's go on to BCO eight seven.
[19:08] SPEAKER_01: A presbytery may, at its discretion, approve the call of a teaching elder to work with an organization outside the jurisdiction of the Presbyterian Church in America, provided that he be engaged in preaching and teaching the word, that the presbytery be assured he will have full freedom to maintain and teach the doctrine of our church, and that he report at least annually on his work.
[19:29] SPEAKER_01: As far as possible, such teaching elder shall be a member of the presbytery within whose bounds he labors.
[19:34] SPEAKER_01: And it points us to BCO 21.
[19:37] SPEAKER_01: So we've already kind of alluded to this when we were talking about 8-4.
[19:40] SPEAKER_01: Uh, this is the the paragraph that's commonly referred to as a man having an out-of-bounds call.
[19:46] SPEAKER_01: I'm gonna let I'm gonna let Scott and Fred, maybe Jared wants to jump in, continue their conversation from before if there's anything more specific we need to add here about uh this out-of-bounds work that men are called to.
[19:58] SPEAKER_03: Well, just generally, this is uh perhaps a wider net, whereas the previous provision was somewhat narrower.
[20:05] SPEAKER_03: Um serving out of bounds typically is applied to serving outside of the not merely not geographical bounds, but the jurisdiction of that local presbytery.
[20:18] SPEAKER_03: And so these are men who are not under the authority of any PCA ministry or mission.
[20:25] SPEAKER_03: And so it is a different relation uh relation of sorts.
[20:29] SPEAKER_03: Uh a man might be serving a church in another denomination, whether that be even an APAC or or other, um, or some other type of ministry.
[20:39] SPEAKER_03: And so that that is not related to the PCA.
[20:42] SPEAKER_03: And so it's a it's a broader net where we were talking about narrow as it relates to like agencies of the church and papers of the church and seminaries of the church.
[20:52] SPEAKER_03: Now we're dealing with the wider of ministers laboring outside that jurisdiction totally.
[21:00] SPEAKER_00: I I think it's interesting that this is sometimes used to have somebody that's laboring maybe in an independent church or in a church of another denomination.
[21:09] SPEAKER_00: And it wasn't until studying this that I came across Smith's um uh line there that actually in the fourth General Assembly, uh, there was at least that General Assembly's opinion that the BCO does not envisage uh the ordination of a candidate candidate expressly to pastoral services in a church of another denomination.
[21:28] SPEAKER_00: And yet that seems to be what it's used for a lot.
[21:31] SPEAKER_00: I know it's been used for that in the past.
[21:32] SPEAKER_00: And in my presbytery, I wondered what your if your presbyteries had a particular um attitude towards that or if this is often used for uh for just that um occasion.
[21:44] SPEAKER_02: I don't want to overparse this because we can't ask Morton, but my experience has been not that men would be ordained to a work in an independent church, but someone who's already ordained might be given a call.
[22:00] SPEAKER_02: To an independent church, which I do think is a little bit different.
[22:04] SPEAKER_02: Um, because the idea is if someone is not ordained yet and he wants to pastor a Southern Baptist church, why doesn't he get ordained in the Southern Baptist or an OPC church or an EPC church?
[22:18] SPEAKER_02: You know, why shouldn't you just be ordained there?
[22:21] SPEAKER_02: But I could see that in some occasions, if someone's already ordained, it holds their credentials in the PCA, especially if they might be serving temporarily at an independent church.
[22:33] SPEAKER_02: That happens too, to do that.
[22:35] SPEAKER_00: Bringing that church into the PCA.
[22:37] SPEAKER_02: Right.
[22:38] SPEAKER_02: Exactly.
[22:39] SPEAKER_02: So I want to make clear here something that Scott mentioned.
[22:44] SPEAKER_02: This is laboring out of ecclesiastical bounds, not geographical bounds.
[22:49] SPEAKER_02: Geographical bounds you guys will cover in chapter 13, paragraph two.
[22:53] SPEAKER_02: And so a presbytery has complete authority over anyone laboring within their geographic bounds.
[23:02] SPEAKER_02: So you may remember that there was an instance several years ago when a prominent advocate of the federal vision moved to Alabama and wanted to labor outside of ecclesiastical bounds in what he thought was a needful work in Evangel Presbytery.
[23:22] SPEAKER_02: And because it was in Evangel Presbytery, they had to approve it under 87 and 8.4.
[23:31] SPEAKER_02: His existing presbytery could not, because that was geographically located in the northwest United States.
[23:39] SPEAKER_02: And so this is not a get out of jail free card.
[23:44] SPEAKER_02: So, for example, to do anything you want anywhere anywhere in the country, it's it's a layer on top of a layer of geography.
[23:55] SPEAKER_02: You have to be approved by the presbytery where you're located, and then if it is outside the jurisdiction of the PCA, you need to have that approved as an exception.
[24:05] SPEAKER_02: And there are some odd things that can happen here.
[24:08] SPEAKER_02: When I was much younger, and Great Lakes Presbytery comprised all of Michigan, most of Ohio, all of Indiana, and all of Kentucky.
[24:18] SPEAKER_02: We had a church in Indiana that wanted to call a man who was an OPC minister to fill their pulpit.
[24:27] SPEAKER_02: He did not want to give up his OPC credentials.
[24:31] SPEAKER_02: And so we approved him as a licentiate, and the OPC approved him to labor outside of their bounds at this church.
[24:40] SPEAKER_02: It's kind of the reverse of what 87 envisions.
[24:44] SPEAKER_02: That's the only occasion where that went on for several years.
[24:48] SPEAKER_02: And it's the odd was the oddest thing.
[24:50] SPEAKER_02: There was no turmoil that came out of it, but it was very odd because you had a PCA church and an OPC minister kind of in a semi-permanent mode.
[25:00] SPEAKER_02: And so um this is something else that requires wisdom by the presbytery.
[25:07] SPEAKER_02: Um, there was another instance that came up a few years ago where a PCA man wanted to stay in the PCA and pastor an EPC church.
[25:14] SPEAKER_02: And the presbytery said, no, there's another, there's no reason you can't be in the EPC.
[25:20] SPEAKER_02: It's an EPC church.
[25:21] SPEAKER_02: And if you want to come back into the PCA, you can come back into the PCA, or if the church wants to come into the PCA.
[25:27] SPEAKER_02: But this isn't independent.
[25:30] SPEAKER_02: That's where often you see 87 apply, is with independency.
[25:34] SPEAKER_02: Because if there's another valid denomination, the answer of a presbytery will usually be transfer.
[25:42] SPEAKER_01: BCO eight eight.
[25:44] SPEAKER_01: A presbytery may, at its discretion, approve the call of a teaching elder to work as a chaplain, whether military or civilian, with an organization outside the jurisdiction of the Presbyterian Church in America, provided that he be engaged in preaching and teaching the word, that the Presbytery be assured he will have full freedom to maintain and teach the doctrine of our church, and that he reports at least annually on his work.
[26:07] SPEAKER_01: The chaplain may be appointed to the work of an evangelist when serving as a chaplain.
[26:11] SPEAKER_01: Teaching elders ministering as paid or volunteer chaplains are strongly encouraged to seek and obtain their ecclesiastical endorsement from the endorsing agency authorized by the General Assembly for such purpose.
[26:24] SPEAKER_01: What I'm interested in here is for y'all to tell me, because I don't know, why we need a paragraph for this in particular, when it's in my mind could easily fit underneath an out-of-bounds call, or maybe even some of it underneath an evangelist call.
[26:38] SPEAKER_01: What's going on?
[26:39] SPEAKER_02: Well, I think you'll let me jump in here to say we needed it because I wrote it.
[26:45] SPEAKER_02: Um so this is one of these guilty as charged.
[26:48] SPEAKER_02: Um, I think for clarity's sake, and two, there are two issues here.
[26:52] SPEAKER_02: First, evangelists weren't dealt with under the book, and people were, excuse me, chaplains weren't dealt with under the book.
[26:59] SPEAKER_02: And so people were confused.
[27:01] SPEAKER_02: If you're a chaplain, are you automatically an evangelist?
[27:03] SPEAKER_02: Do you have to be an evangelist?
[27:05] SPEAKER_02: Can you never be an evangelist?
[27:07] SPEAKER_02: How does that work?
[27:08] SPEAKER_02: And so we tried to clarify here that being a chaplain doesn't make you an evangelist, but you could be given the powers of an evangelist by separate action.
[27:20] SPEAKER_02: Because there was confusion amongst the chaplains as to what that looked like.
[27:25] SPEAKER_02: Then, secondly, you'll note that the last sentence came about there was an overture that would have required all chaplains to be endorsed by the PCA's endorsing agency, the Presbyterian and Reform Commission.
[27:38] SPEAKER_02: On the one hand, I was very sympathetic to that.
[27:42] SPEAKER_02: I this language I developed in conjunction with the PCA's um chaplain guide, for lack of a better word.
[27:53] SPEAKER_02: I don't know what his exact title was, but the the man who is basically the top liaison for chaplains in the PCA.
[28:00] SPEAKER_02: And his point was this is the only endorsing agency that submits to our government that is reformed.
[28:09] SPEAKER_02: You know, we don't want people picking a Pentecostal endorsing agency just to be getting into the chaplaincy or to be doing something that's contrary to our system of government or our doctrine, just to get because the military doesn't care.
[28:27] SPEAKER_02: All the military cares about is do you have an endorsing agency?
[28:31] SPEAKER_02: But of course, that is quasi-discipline because if the military has a problem with a chaplain, they don't come to the presbytery, they go to the endorsing agency.
[28:40] SPEAKER_02: And so there's a little bit of a mix here.
[28:42] SPEAKER_02: So I have sympathy that if you're a PCA chaplain, you probably should be in a PCA endorsing agency.
[28:47] SPEAKER_02: However, by requiring it, that would limit the power of presbyteries.
[28:53] SPEAKER_02: You can't tell presbyteries what they must do.
[28:57] SPEAKER_02: And I ended up talking to the brother and saying, I think it's very wise.
[29:03] SPEAKER_02: And I think this is where we use our BCO language.
[29:07] SPEAKER_02: We don't use shall, we use should, or I suggest that we use something stronger than should, which is strongly encourage.
[29:14] SPEAKER_02: We send a shot across the bow to let chaplains know you should have a PCA um endorsement, a endorsing agency, because if you get in trouble with the military, you want an agency that is endorsed by the PCA and has the backing of the PCA behind you.
[29:32] SPEAKER_02: You don't want to be left out to dry.
[29:35] SPEAKER_02: And so we ended on this language.
[29:38] SPEAKER_02: And then it was just helpful because chaplains are mentioned, but they didn't have their own paragraph.
[29:46] SPEAKER_02: And so even though there is an aspect that they fit under 8-7, I think it's encouraging to chaplains, and I think it does answer that is a chaplain and evangelist question.
[29:56] SPEAKER_02: So that was kind of a compromise we worked out.
[29:58] SPEAKER_02: And I think after we did that, it passed like 98% in the assembly.
[30:04] SPEAKER_02: And then Scott could tell me the exact numbers of how it passed in presbyteries.
[30:07] SPEAKER_02: I don't have those on the top of my head.
[30:08] SPEAKER_02: I'm sure he's got that on uh written on his palm or something like that, that number, that vote.
[30:15] SPEAKER_03: No, I'm not that good.
[30:17] SPEAKER_03: They're there somewhere though.
[30:19] SPEAKER_00: Well, I think though, that last that's strongly encouraged.
[30:22] SPEAKER_00: If somebody's thinking about becoming a chaplain, they shouldn't look at that and say, well, I don't have to.
[30:26] SPEAKER_00: Um, like the PRCC will have your back in areas that other endorsing agencies will not.
[30:31] SPEAKER_00: They want you to perform an unbiblical wedding, or uh you get in trouble for preaching uh from scripture.
[30:37] SPEAKER_00: Some other um endorsing agencies will not have your back on that, will not help you with that.
[30:42] SPEAKER_00: The PRCC will.
[30:43] SPEAKER_00: So uh everybody who is a chaplain should go to the PRCC.
[30:47] SPEAKER_00: It's just you can't make it because of our of our polity.
[30:50] SPEAKER_00: Uh, it wouldn't be appropriate.
[30:51] SPEAKER_01: BCO89.
[30:53] SPEAKER_01: As there were in the church under the law, elders of the people for the government thereof, so in the gospel church, Christ has furnished others besides ministers of the word with gifts and commission to govern when called thereunto, who are called ruling elders.
[31:08] SPEAKER_01: Jared, what what's going on?
[31:11] SPEAKER_01: Elders are a New Testament office.
[31:13] SPEAKER_01: Why are they why are they referring to the church under the law?
[31:17] SPEAKER_00: Well, not if you preach through Exodus, you'd know Jethro suggests elders, and you see them, I think, sitting uh during the worship in Exodus 24.
[31:27] SPEAKER_00: So this is pointing out that in fact the office of elder has been around, or those that functioned in this office uh even before uh Paul wrote his pastoral epistles.
[31:37] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think if you go through this, you will see that elders are found throughout all of the Old Testament.
[31:41] SPEAKER_02: They're actually mentioned in accounts of Abraham in Genesis and down throughout all of the Old Testament.
[31:47] SPEAKER_02: I in a in a talk I gave at the first Gospel Reformation Network uh conference, I gave a talk with the scintillating title that was given to me, Rediscovering the Genius of Presbyterianism, Biblical Presbyterianism.
[32:02] SPEAKER_02: And I spent some time tracking that through the Old Testament.
[32:05] SPEAKER_02: I think that's important.
[32:07] SPEAKER_02: And one of the things I think, you know, you can look at eight nine as kind of a tack on to eight.
[32:11] SPEAKER_02: You know, most of eight is about teaching elders, and so you know, we got to throw a bone to the ruling elders and give them a paragraph.
[32:18] SPEAKER_02: I think the BCO is actually set up that what makes a church a church is elders.
[32:26] SPEAKER_02: You can't particularize a church without ruling elders.
[32:31] SPEAKER_02: You can without a pastor, you can without deacons.
[32:37] SPEAKER_02: In some sense, you might even be able to particularize a church without members.
[32:43] SPEAKER_02: I think it would be unwise, but if you had two people, two men who were qualified to be elders, and they were the only members of the church, that could be a particular church.
[32:55] SPEAKER_02: It's elders that make a church a church.
[33:00] SPEAKER_02: So to give you a nice little Latin phrase, they are the sinequan known, without which it does not exist of churches.
[33:10] SPEAKER_02: And so elders are what make a church a church.
[33:13] SPEAKER_02: Um, this is, I think, really important.
[33:15] SPEAKER_02: Elders are not just, you know, useful, helpful, having them around.
[33:20] SPEAKER_02: Um, they are essential to the nature, not of it being a true church per se, but of it being a particular church.
[33:27] SPEAKER_02: You can have a mission church without elders, but you can't have a particular church.
[33:31] SPEAKER_03: I think that's a helpful distinction when you're thinking about our own culture.
[33:34] SPEAKER_03: When it's so common when thinking about the church, it's just merely a collection of believers.
[33:41] SPEAKER_03: And there's often very little thought uh within broad evangelicalism of leadership being one of the essential qualities of a particular church.
[33:53] SPEAKER_03: We tend to only think of the membership as what makes a church a church, but I think that's a helpful qualification when thinking through a particular church.
[34:04] SPEAKER_01: Last paragraph in the chapter, BCO 810.
[34:06] SPEAKER_01: Elders being of one class of office, ruling elders possess the same authority and eligibility to office in the courts of the church as teaching elders.
[34:15] SPEAKER_01: They should, moreover, cultivate zealously their own aptness to teach the Bible and should improve every opportunity of doing so.
[34:23] SPEAKER_01: Uh again, uh emphasizing that elders are of one office of two orders.
[34:28] SPEAKER_01: And I think I'll I'll try to kick us off here by just asking a question.
[34:33] SPEAKER_01: What what uh what are the best practices for ruling elders to zealously cultivate their own aptness to teach?
[34:40] SPEAKER_01: You know, and and maybe along with that, does teaching only look one way?
[34:44] SPEAKER_01: You know, is teaching just standing in front of a Sunday school classroom teaching adults, or or can we explain it in more ways than that?
[34:51] SPEAKER_01: Tell me about your experiences, guys.
[34:53] SPEAKER_01: Tell me about your practices.
[34:54] SPEAKER_01: How's this look in y'all's churches and experience?
[34:57] SPEAKER_02: I think it's very important not to pigeonhole this.
[35:01] SPEAKER_02: So again, if I can go back to kind of practices, in many churches, if a session thinks a man could have gifts of an being an elder and might be nominated to be an elder, the very first thing they say is, let's stick him in front of a Sunday school class and let him lecture.
[35:18] SPEAKER_02: Now, there's nothing wrong with that, but certainly teaching could be leading a small group, it could be teaching one-on-one with people.
[35:25] SPEAKER_02: Um, it could be um leading in the worship service in certain ways that are instructional.
[35:33] SPEAKER_02: Um, there are a lot of it could be, you know, a writing ministry.
[35:37] SPEAKER_02: Um, there could be a lot of aspects there.
[35:40] SPEAKER_02: And I think we need to remember this is where if PCA's two and a half offices, it leans toward two.
[35:48] SPEAKER_02: Ruling elders don't just rule, they teach.
[35:53] SPEAKER_02: They primarily rule, but they also teach.
[35:57] SPEAKER_02: Just like teaching elders don't just teach, they rule as well.
[36:03] SPEAKER_02: They primarily teach, but they also rule.
[36:05] SPEAKER_02: They have a vote typically on the session.
[36:08] SPEAKER_02: And so we need to understand that both of those aspects are there.
[36:12] SPEAKER_02: And I think uh, you know, one thing that we talked about before, uh, one of the things that we do at my church here in Cady is, especially in our evening service, um, we will occasionally have, you know, a staff sermon series.
[36:26] SPEAKER_02: We're doing that now through first and second Thessalonians.
[36:29] SPEAKER_02: And rather than me just preaching through uh, or one of the staff pastors preaching through the series, we assign out texts and there's you know, four, five, six of us to preach.
[36:38] SPEAKER_02: And I will actively ask my session, would one of you like to take an evening?
[36:43] SPEAKER_02: Uh, because you can.
[36:45] SPEAKER_02: You know, I'm not asking you to preach regularly.
[36:47] SPEAKER_02: I'm not asking you to take 10 in a row, but you can.
[36:51] SPEAKER_02: If you want to do that, you can do that.
[36:53] SPEAKER_02: And one of the ways that I help them to cultivate zealously those gifts is I say, start working through your outline, work through your notes, meet with me, I'll give you some thoughts, I'll give you some thoughts about application, you know, some pointers about preaching because I've been doing this now, you know, more than 20 years.
[37:10] SPEAKER_02: Um, and you know, try to help you cultivate that uh particular aspect.
[37:16] SPEAKER_02: So I think really developing these kinds of gifts in ruling elders is a function and a burden for teaching elders to carry.
[37:29] SPEAKER_02: It's the same way in which if you want your elders to be effective at Presbyterian General Assembly, you can't abandon them at the assembly meeting and go spend time with clock with alumni classmates.
[37:40] SPEAKER_02: You need to be there explaining what's happening, letting them know what's going on, introducing them to people, having them get uh a desire for this work.
[37:49] SPEAKER_02: And it's I think it's also true with teaching and preaching.
[37:51] SPEAKER_02: You need to help them to cultivate those gifts.
[37:55] SPEAKER_00: I think another way that they can be teaching is something that is sometimes neglected, which is discipling, uh, one-on-one.
[38:03] SPEAKER_00: I think of some of the best um teaching uh dialogues within scripture.
[38:08] SPEAKER_00: Jesus is one-on-one with Nicodemus or uh with one of the disciples, right?
[38:12] SPEAKER_00: There's there's this one-on-one part of teaching that you you may have somebody that is you want to have as a ruling elder that you would never stick them in front of the Sunday school class, but one-on-one, they can disciple somebody, and that can be a very valuable elder.
[38:25] SPEAKER_00: So that shouldn't be your determining factor.
[38:27] SPEAKER_00: I agree with that.
[38:28] SPEAKER_03: And I know uh a ruling elder that was not the greatest in in Sunday school settings, but was really good within the home and his own personal family, and able to catechize his kids well and and had the great discipline of doing that consistently.
[38:44] SPEAKER_03: And and so stuff like that is also within this purview, family and and church.
[38:49] SPEAKER_01: Well, that brings us to the end of the chapter.
[38:51] SPEAKER_01: Um, I'm gonna ask Jared to give us a final thought here in just a moment, but Fred, I wanted to ask you before we finish up if you have any lingering thoughts, anything that stands out to you.
[38:59] SPEAKER_01: I mean, here's a here's here's an open forum, whatever you want to say about elders or honestly anything else.
[39:05] SPEAKER_02: While we're talking about the elder, I want to just reiterate something that I'm very passionate about, and I think each of you has heard me talk about, and that is that part of being an elder is being a churchman.
[39:19] SPEAKER_02: That's being involved in your local church, in your presbytery, and in the general assembly.
[39:27] SPEAKER_02: Part of being an elder is to love the church and serve the church.
[39:31] SPEAKER_02: It's not an honorific, it's not a way that you can get things that you want in the church, it's not a thing that you do because other people think you should.
[39:40] SPEAKER_02: Being an elder is to love the church of Jesus Christ.
[39:45] SPEAKER_02: And every Christian should love the church of Jesus Christ because Jesus died for it.
[39:52] SPEAKER_02: He died for each believer and that the church would be established, that he would establish the church, but especially the elder.
[40:00] SPEAKER_02: And so I want to encourage men who are elders to take that seriously and to seek for ways they can serve the Lord in the church.
[40:10] SPEAKER_02: I want to encourage men who are younger to find ways that they can cultivate gifts so that they can serve the church and to take that seriously because if the church of Jesus Christ cannot be defeated by Satan, and that's what Jesus tells us until Jesus comes back, that means we need a next generation of elders, and we need a generation after that of elders, and we need to be pointing men to cultivate these gifts and to serve the Lord and to see him glorified in the midst of his church.
[40:52] SPEAKER_01: Jared, would we be foolish to let you follow that?
[40:54] SPEAKER_01: Or should we just let that should we let that be the end?
[40:57] SPEAKER_00: I'd be fine with that.
[40:58] SPEAKER_00: The only thing I was gonna say is if people are looking to um talk about these uh the duties that elders have in their session, studying chapter eight is a good idea.
[41:07] SPEAKER_00: Also, um buying uh The Shepherd Leader by Timothy Whitmer would be good to go through with your session just to think through how do we do uh these things as a session better.
[41:18] SPEAKER_01: Well, as Jack Williamson would say, this podcast is over.
[41:21] SPEAKER_01: Thank you for joining us.
[41:22] SPEAKER_01: Be sure to come back next time when we begin to discuss deacons in BCO chapter nine.
[41:27] SPEAKER_01: Uh, don't forget we're getting close to the end of our season in the book, and we're going to be talking about Thomas Witherow's work, The Apostolic Church, starting in January.
[41:36] SPEAKER_01: If you're interested in learning anything more about what we've spoken about, be sure to check out the show notes in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org.
[41:43] SPEAKER_01: If you've enjoyed the show, consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters, and be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[41:51] SPEAKER_01: If you have questions or comments, you can hit us up on social media.
[41:54] SPEAKER_01: You can also contact us directly at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[41:59] SPEAKER_01: I do want to uh keep reminding y'all we have chapter markers in our episodes.
[42:04] SPEAKER_01: So if you need to find content on a particular paragraph, you can get there quite easily by going to our website, Politymatters.org, and you can search uh for clips on each particular paragraph of the book that we've covered so far.
[42:17] SPEAKER_01: Uh many thanks to our guests uh today, Fred Greco, for being with us.
[42:21] SPEAKER_01: Uh Fred, you've been a wonderful encouragement to us as young elders, and we are so grateful for you.
[42:26] SPEAKER_01: We hope to continue this relationship as the years continue and as our church continues to grow.
[42:31] SPEAKER_01: Uh, Fred's the pastor of Christ Church in Katy, Texas, and he serves currently as the moderator of the PCA General Assembly.
[42:37] SPEAKER_01: We'll provide some links in our show notes to the various places on the internet that you can find him.
[42:42] SPEAKER_01: I am glad to have my co-host back this week.
[42:44] SPEAKER_01: Uh, Steve and I had a good time last time, but uh it's good to have Scott back.
[42:49] SPEAKER_01: He's now a father of three and the senior minister of Providence, PCA, in Troy, Illinois.
[42:54] SPEAKER_01: You can find him on Twitter at S.
[42:56] SPEAKER_01: Edberg.
[42:57] SPEAKER_01: If you're looking for Jared, he pastors New Life Presbyterian Church in Aliquiba, Pennsylvania.
[43:01] SPEAKER_01: He's on Twitter at Brother Nelson.
[43:03] SPEAKER_01: I serve as the associate pastor at Covenant Presbyterian Church in Cleveland, Mississippi.
[43:08] SPEAKER_01: And I'm on Twitter at underscore Ben Raliff.
[43:10] SPEAKER_01: We thank you again for spending time with us.
[43:12] SPEAKER_01: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[43:15] SPEAKER_00: Bye, gentlemen.
[43:15] SPEAKER_01: Ravedici.
[43:16] SPEAKER_02: Bye.
[43:17] SPEAKER_01: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
