# 4. Intentionally Cumbersome (BCO Preface III)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 26 Sep 2023, 40 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/13525197-4-intentionally-cumbersome-bco-preface-iii.mp3

Jared is turning 200 and Scott's having a baby! And then the guys discuss the final portion of the BCO Preface: the Constitution of the PCA. BCO online Michael Kruger's Canon Revisited "The Confession and Catechisms must be restored to their position as much more than theological shibboleths whose only function in our congregations and our sessions and presbyteries is to screen out doctrinal error." -- David Strain in "Good Faith Subscription?" on The Gospel Reformation Network Westminster Standards online The Didache is commonly found in publications of The Apostolic Fathers, like this volume from Baker Academic. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Welcome
- 2:35 Introduction
- 3:24 We are bound by the Constitution
- 7:13 Benefits of a Constitution
- 9:57 The Constitution and Scripture
- 13:22 The Westminster Standards
- 19:44 The Book of Church Order
- 23:47 Significance of the Constitution
- 26:36 Anomalies: Directory for Worship
- 33:37 Anomalies: RAO
- 36:56 Conclusion

## Transcript

[0:15] SPEAKER_02: Hello, and welcome to Polity Matters episode four.
[0:18] SPEAKER_02: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg.
[0:23] SPEAKER_02: On this episode, we're considering the final section of the preface to the PCA Book of Church Order, The Constitution Defined.
[0:30] SPEAKER_02: But before we jump into all of that, let's check in with the fellas.
[0:33] SPEAKER_02: Guys, how's it going?
[0:34] SPEAKER_02: What's going on?
[0:39] SPEAKER_02: I'm putting all of the silence into the episode.
[0:43] SPEAKER_02: All of it's going in.
[0:48] SPEAKER_02: Y'all are horrible.
[0:52] SPEAKER_02: You gotta do that again.
[0:58] SPEAKER_02: I mean, whatever.
[0:59] SPEAKER_02: Just hey, it's been a hard week, or hey, you know, it's I haven't done any work since Sunday afternoon.
[1:05] SPEAKER_02: Hey, uh, my kids are driving me crazy.
[1:07] SPEAKER_02: Jared, you could tell us about something fun you did yesterday.
[1:10] SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
[1:11] SPEAKER_02: Anything.
[1:12] SPEAKER_02: We could just get Scott to laugh without stopping.
[1:17] SPEAKER_00: Well, our church has actually been getting ready to have a 200-year anniversary.
[1:22] SPEAKER_00: Um, our church history goes all the way back to 1823, founded by the Associate Synod uh that came over.
[1:29] SPEAKER_00: Um, and uh so we've been getting ready for we have a Saturday uh kind of carnival type thing that we're doing, and then Sunday special services.
[1:38] SPEAKER_00: So um just getting ready to do uh that at our church takes a lot of energy and a lot of moving parts.
[1:43] SPEAKER_02: Are they gonna put you in a dunk tank by any chance?
[1:46] SPEAKER_00: They discussed it and then they they thought it was too Baptist.
[1:54] SPEAKER_02: Scott, anything quite so exciting going on with you?
[1:57] SPEAKER_01: Uh we're pregnant, we're pretty pregnant.
[1:59] SPEAKER_01: Uh we're having a baby within the next month, and so we're preparing for that.
[2:05] SPEAKER_01: Um this will be the first baby since we well, obviously since we moved here, but everything is packed away, and and we're going through things trying to find clothes and all of that.
[2:16] SPEAKER_01: And and so we're beginning transition.
[2:19] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so hey, everyone could be praying for us as we lose more sleep.
[2:24] SPEAKER_01: There'll be less sleep in the Edberg home for the next nine months.
[2:27] SPEAKER_01: Is this baby two or three for y'all?
[2:29] SPEAKER_01: Uh, this will be the third.
[2:31] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[2:32] SPEAKER_01: We have two boys and one on the way.
[2:35] SPEAKER_02: Well, good.
[2:36] SPEAKER_02: It's glad good to see y'all and um excited to talk about the constitution.
[2:40] SPEAKER_02: Um in the the the third part of the preface, the constitution defined, there's only one paragraph, and it um it reads like this The Constitution of the Presbyterian Church in America, which is subject to and subordinate to the scriptures of the Old and New Testaments, the inerrant word of God, consists of its doctrinal standards set forth in the Westminster Confession of Faith, together with the larger and shorter catechisms, and the Book of Church Order, comprising the form of government, the rules of discipline, and the directory for worship, all as adopted by the church.
[3:18] SPEAKER_02: And so as we get into this, I really just kind of want to open it up and ask you guys what um what stands out to you.
[3:23] SPEAKER_02: And I'll I can I'll start uh the conversation by pointing out that there are two documents that form our constitution, uh doctrinal standards on one side and the documents of church order on the other.
[3:34] SPEAKER_02: These have been adopted by our church, by our denomination, and they uh well they exist to to do several things for us.
[3:42] SPEAKER_02: In the first place, we see that these um these documents are binding upon the courts and officers of the church.
[3:50] SPEAKER_02: What this what this means is that these are uh the documents that that show us the way to go.
[3:55] SPEAKER_02: They they direct us in all that we do as officers in God's church.
[3:59] SPEAKER_02: But in the PCA, it's worth having a conversation here at the outset that these documents we've adopted, and we'll talk about them specifically here in a minute, um, but we're we are allowed to have differences, um, at least with our doctrinal standards.
[4:12] SPEAKER_02: Um officers are allowed to have differences with these.
[4:15] SPEAKER_02: And this may not be the place to have a conversation about good faith subscription and all the different um things connected to it, but I thought it was worthwhile asking a question.
[4:24] SPEAKER_02: Uh these standards are our constitution.
[4:27] SPEAKER_02: Can can a court of the church uh have a difference with these standards?
[4:32] SPEAKER_02: You know, before we even talk about the details in them, can a session, for example, have sort of a stated difference with a part of our constitution so that they don't have to abide by it in some way?
[4:45] SPEAKER_00: I think the quick answer to that would be no.
[4:48] SPEAKER_00: Certainly we talk about officers or particular people coming for ordination that are taking a difference with the exception that then is classified as some sort of an exception.
[4:57] SPEAKER_00: Uh, yet we're often told we can't take an exception to the BCO.
[5:01] SPEAKER_00: Uh, this is part of our practice.
[5:03] SPEAKER_00: So you can't say, you know, this this says I should do uh ordination in this way, but I'm gonna do it however I want to, or this is how it tells me to do the Lord's Supper, but I'll just do it however I want to.
[5:13] SPEAKER_00: Um, this is something that's regulating our practice.
[5:16] SPEAKER_00: And uh so we might have different agreements with it.
[5:19] SPEAKER_00: We might say, I think this would be a better way to do it, but the the way to address that is actually to change our constitution, uh, not just to ignore it or uh have, especially the the higher courts, just say we're not going to do this.
[5:31] SPEAKER_00: I think you've seen this sometimes at General Assembly where um there might be something that's a very common exception, such as something to do with images, but courts have been told that you can't mess around with uh having that uh, you know, as as something that's a practice that's different, um, even if a lot of uh your officers disagree with it.
[5:49] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, when you're thinking about this as well, you're talking about the court itself.
[5:53] SPEAKER_01: And for the court to diverge or to move away from the confession would bind the consciences of those under them.
[6:02] SPEAKER_01: And so, say if we as a court say um the Sabbath is your own personal thing, you do whatever you want.
[6:08] SPEAKER_01: We don't have a doctrine where Sunday is more uh set aside or something.
[6:13] SPEAKER_01: Uh that that would be binding to the consciences of those who are at your church, um, or say pictures of Jesus or something.
[6:21] SPEAKER_01: Uh so it's it's one thing for an individual to hold a view that is different um from the constitutional documents of our denomination, but it is another thing to have a court or an agency of the church, even.
[6:36] SPEAKER_01: And so if uh CDM starts, uh I I don't even I might speak something into reality here, uh, but CDM say they start publishing content that viol openly violates our standards.
[6:50] SPEAKER_01: Well, that they don't have the liberty to do that.
[6:53] SPEAKER_01: Maybe individually they could buy resources um that could violate the standards, but the idea of what does the church itself believe?
[7:01] SPEAKER_01: And so there's a difference between individual liberty and what the church um court um holds to.
[7:08] SPEAKER_01: And so a whole presbytery can't reject certain parts of the confession because they desire to.
[7:14] SPEAKER_02: Scott, what's the significance of having a constitution and and it and its uh its impact on the people in the church?
[7:21] SPEAKER_01: The benefits of a constitution, um, they frame uh your if you're not thinking uh theologically, perhaps in the church, but just societally, they they reveal guardrails, um, but also uh what you are agreeing to as a person to a government, whether that be a civil government or even an ecclesiastical government.
[7:42] SPEAKER_01: And so the benefit of a constitution is that it shows you the theological teachings of the church, if you think of the church context, it gives you the rules by which they play by.
[7:53] SPEAKER_01: There's nothing secret.
[7:54] SPEAKER_01: Uh, it gives you uh recourse.
[7:57] SPEAKER_01: Uh when something does go awry, what what can you do?
[8:00] SPEAKER_01: Uh or what do we uh what could we do?
[8:03] SPEAKER_01: Uh and and in maybe not our context, you know the worship of the church.
[8:07] SPEAKER_01: Uh when churches have binding documents uh and the directory of worship that are binding, you can you know the flavor of worship you'll have within your church.
[8:17] SPEAKER_01: And so all of these are benefits.
[8:19] SPEAKER_01: Um, you've maybe visited a church and you thought things would be one way and then they're a very different way.
[8:25] SPEAKER_01: Well, the constitution seeks to help us know what we're getting into when we visit a PCA church or a court.
[8:35] SPEAKER_00: And I think one of the things we're talking about here is a written constitution.
[8:38] SPEAKER_00: Um, so I'm glad that the PCA doesn't take the approach of, say, the British government of having an unwritten constitution because everything has a constitution, that is the framing of it and how it works.
[8:49] SPEAKER_00: But to actually put it down to say, we know the rules before we get into it, it's not just what has been done before, and only people that are really up on uh the history know what's going on.
[8:59] SPEAKER_00: Uh, in fact, having a written constitution uh has a uh almost a democratizing uh effect that anybody can read it and know what they're getting into.
[9:08] SPEAKER_00: Um and it's it's agreed upon uh beforehand, and we're not just kind of making it up as we go.
[9:14] SPEAKER_01: And you're not forced to join, right?
[9:16] SPEAKER_01: Um, you get the information you need theoretically before you sign your name, before you make those vows.
[9:23] SPEAKER_01: And so it's important for when you're rearing little children, but also adult uh converts to teach them the constitution of the PCA.
[9:32] SPEAKER_01: What makes this, what makes Providence Presbyterian Church Providence Press.
[9:36] SPEAKER_01: Uh, you want to teach people that so they know what they're signing up for.
[9:39] SPEAKER_01: They you don't want them to be members for your in your church for five years, have a child, and then realize all of a sudden that they should be baptizing their child or something like that.
[9:49] SPEAKER_01: You want them to know that on the offset.
[9:51] SPEAKER_01: Um, yes, they can still join, but you don't want people to find out what you believe later.
[9:56] SPEAKER_01: And so Constitution helps that.
[9:58] SPEAKER_02: Anybody who's reading this paragraph in our preface uh probably notices that the Bible is omitted from our constitution.
[10:05] SPEAKER_02: There's several impactful um reasons for that, things that that are brought to bear as a result.
[10:12] SPEAKER_02: But one of my favorite questions to ask somebody when they're coming for licensure ordination, which is answered correctly about half the time, which is rather scary in my opinion, but is why is the Bible not a part of our constitution?
[10:24] SPEAKER_02: And I reckon one of my fellows here could probably answer that correctly.
[10:27] SPEAKER_01: The Bible is uh not amendable.
[10:29] SPEAKER_01: Uh your constitution is amendable and you can it and errors.
[10:33] SPEAKER_01: Uh our constitution errs.
[10:36] SPEAKER_01: Um that includes or could include our confession of faith may err, as well, and probably more commonly, our book of church order may err.
[10:44] SPEAKER_01: Uh and the scriptures do not err.
[10:46] SPEAKER_01: Um, they are not changeable.
[10:48] SPEAKER_01: Um, you can talk about the canonization of scripture and the process found therein with Michael Kruger's book on canon revisited is a great resource on it, but it is not amendable.
[11:00] SPEAKER_01: Uh it is what is over the constitution, but not part of the constitution.
[11:05] SPEAKER_01: And and so we talk about how the BCO can't contradict itself or the Westminster standards.
[11:13] SPEAKER_01: Well, all of those things, all of the Constitution cannot contradict the scriptures because they are over them.
[11:20] SPEAKER_00: We hope that the Constitution and the Confession and the BCO is not erring, but it can be amended if it does.
[11:27] SPEAKER_00: I'm I think of the distinction that R.
[11:29] SPEAKER_00: C.
[11:30] SPEAKER_00: Sproul had between inerrant and infallible.
[11:33] SPEAKER_00: And inerrant just means that it's it's not an error, uh, whereas infallible is means it's incapable of error.
[11:39] SPEAKER_00: And so actually, you could say you think that the uh Westminster confession is inerrant, but you shouldn't say that it's infallible.
[11:47] SPEAKER_00: Uh, whereas the scripture is infallible, and in fact, if we find that the confession is uh in error, we can amend it.
[11:54] SPEAKER_00: Uh, that's why it is uh in light of the uh of scripture, that is uh it's subordinate to and under the the scripture.
[12:02] SPEAKER_02: At this point in the conversation, I'm always confused that somehow in the minds of some, putting the Bible over to use Scott's word, our constitution somehow seems to bring the constitution so far down that just because it's not the Bible, to use your word, because it's not infallible means that it sort of can just be stepped on and ignored.
[12:24] SPEAKER_02: You know, there's this attitude that I mean, I'll confess that I developed a little bit in and right after seminary that thankfully was purged from my system.
[12:32] SPEAKER_02: You know, that the standards were sort of just um to use David Strain's term, sort of doctrinal shibboleths, right?
[12:39] SPEAKER_02: We just kind of had to nod at them in order to get ordained, and then they kind of fell down and we could make use of them if they happened to provide us with something beneficial.
[12:48] SPEAKER_02: But the truth is really that that the scriptures are above our standards, yes, but then our standards are still so far high above us um in guiding us towards the scriptures and summarizing them for us and and even the BCO as it leads us in our our polity that's been handed down from Christ.
[13:05] SPEAKER_02: And so just because they're not infallible, just because they're not the scriptures themselves, our standards are still uh very good and very necessary to our function as a church.
[13:18] SPEAKER_02: And so let's talk about the two different um documents that we have.
[13:21] SPEAKER_02: First, our doctrinal standards, the document that we're not talking about as much in this podcast, the Westminster standards, that is the Westminster Confession of Faith and the larger and shorter catechism.
[13:32] SPEAKER_01: Well, when you think about um, we were just talking about the Constitution itself um and amending it.
[13:39] SPEAKER_01: Uh the our Book of Church Order actually does give provision for amending our confession.
[13:45] SPEAKER_01: Um, it's not easy and I has not done and been done in our history and in very few places, even outside of our history.
[13:53] SPEAKER_01: Um, but that process looks like um uh amendment coming for the Westminster Confession by way of overture.
[14:01] SPEAKER_01: We'll probably discuss that at some point later um in a later episode.
[14:05] SPEAKER_01: Um, but it would have to be approved by three-quarters of the assembly, uh, and then it would have to receive three-quarters of Presbytery approval by simple majority, and then another three-quarters of our uh assembly.
[14:18] SPEAKER_01: And we were just talking about a moment ago the high regard we have for the confession.
[14:24] SPEAKER_01: It is the system of doctrine by high by uh which we interpret the scriptures from, and so this is how we understand the scriptures, and so since it's so uh highly viewed, it's really difficult to change, and in some ways has been unchanged because of that difficulty.
[14:42] SPEAKER_01: Um, the probably one of the most common uh exceptions we see are images and the Sabbath.
[14:49] SPEAKER_01: And I would not think that we could get those amended out of our our confession easily, even if a majority of PCAs uh profane the Sabbath uh to a sabbatarian.
[15:04] SPEAKER_01: Um, and uh the fun fact of this is that when you're amending this part, that this is the only part of the BCO that's actually uh would take that same sort of threshold to amend.
[15:15] SPEAKER_01: And so if you want to amend how to amend the Westminster Confession, you have to do it by those same parameters.
[15:21] SPEAKER_01: Um, but that that's kind of the nature of how to change the confession.
[15:24] SPEAKER_01: But perhaps we should also talk about the what is the confession that we subscribe to as well.
[15:31] SPEAKER_02: Well, you know, it's um forthcoming, Lord willing.
[15:35] SPEAKER_02: Per Almquist has a uh what is it, his dissertation that he's written on the Book of Church Order.
[15:42] SPEAKER_02: When he talks about the the standards that we have for our doctrine, he he says that these standards set forth the church's mutually shared understanding of what scripture teaches.
[15:53] SPEAKER_02: And I love that because it is a great one-sentence uh punch of of what the confession and catechisms are.
[16:01] SPEAKER_02: This is what we believe the scriptures teach.
[16:05] SPEAKER_02: Um our particular standards were written in the 1640s, were adopted uh by the American Presbyterian Church in 1729 in Philadelphia.
[16:14] SPEAKER_02: There were some amendments later on in the 1780s, but the 1788 version is what the PCA adopted back in 1973, with one amendment, which was removing the referral to the Pope as the Antichrist.
[16:28] SPEAKER_02: Now, we can debate here if we want whether that was a good move, but there have been no changes since then.
[16:33] SPEAKER_02: And so what to Scott's point about how difficult it is to change the confession of faith in the catechisms, it hasn't been done in the 50 years of our denomination.
[16:40] SPEAKER_02: Nobody's I actually don't know if anybody's tried.
[16:43] SPEAKER_02: It's probably a worthwhile um search to go find, but it but it hasn't happened.
[16:47] SPEAKER_00: Our our presbytery actually did try.
[16:50] SPEAKER_00: Um, they wanted to add in to um some of the elements of worship, the taking of offerings.
[16:56] SPEAKER_00: And uh there had been a disagreement, I think, within the Presbytery about whether or not that was an element of worship, and so they wanted to make it official.
[17:03] SPEAKER_00: And the rest of the PCA said, uh, we don't think that that's necessary.
[17:06] SPEAKER_00: And it's it's interesting if you see uh in the beginning of many of the published works of the PCA, uh, there's a copyright uh in the beginning of the hardcover version that's held by the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, uh, which may be why we have the exact form that we did, that we just wanted to take uh what the OPC had and have that for our standards, which also also would have made it easier for us to merge if that had happened in the couple times that we've tried, but uh one of us has always left the other one at the altar as we tried to get married in the past.
[17:38] SPEAKER_02: Why bother trying to constitutionalize something in the standards that's already not constitutional in the Book of Church Order?
[17:44] SPEAKER_02: I mean, come on.
[17:45] SPEAKER_02: Anything else on the standards?
[17:47] SPEAKER_01: I mean, it's probably good to note that not all Westminster, as Jared was just saying, not all Westminster confessions are equal.
[17:55] SPEAKER_01: Um, we were talking about revisions in 1788, but there have been more modern revisions in the mainline denomination.
[18:02] SPEAKER_01: I was looking at the PCUSA's Book of Confessions this past week, and they have over 50 revisions uh in in their Westminster Confession of Faith.
[18:11] SPEAKER_01: Uh, and they have two additional chapters, and so they have a chapter on the Holy Spirit and a chapter on the love of God.
[18:18] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so there are there have been attempts and successful attempts, at least in the main line, which is a much larger denomination than the PCA is, um, to change the confessional standards, and they have.
[18:31] SPEAKER_01: Um, I was actually surprised by how few changes um relatively uh the that the PCUSA has compared to us.
[18:40] SPEAKER_01: Um if I I would probably be able to almost live with their confession for the most part.
[18:45] SPEAKER_01: The changes are so minimal.
[18:47] SPEAKER_01: Their issue is that the constitutionally binding nature of the confession has lost all weight and significance.
[18:54] SPEAKER_01: Um, we could probably all live happily with if they actually we'd we would we would we would not debate whether the Christ has removed his lampstand from the PC USA if they actually upheld the standards that they have in their book of confessions.
[19:07] SPEAKER_01: Um but and so there are changes in in some areas.
[19:11] SPEAKER_00: And there's even differences in between Napark denominations.
[19:15] SPEAKER_00: If you go into the um RPCNA and you grab a copy of the Westminster Confession, you'll notice it's different from ours.
[19:23] SPEAKER_00: They haven't done some of those revisions.
[19:24] SPEAKER_00: They have the old version uh regarding the uh civil magistrate.
[19:29] SPEAKER_00: Uh and the ARP used to have a lot that were similar with the PC USA, but they've slowly been taking those revisions out.
[19:36] SPEAKER_00: Um, but still uh OPC and PCA have similar ones, but if you go in into the ARP or the RPCNA, you'll see some slight differences there as well.
[19:45] SPEAKER_02: Well, let's talk about the Book of Church Order.
[19:47] SPEAKER_02: Uh, there's a sentence you'll hear on this podcast plenty of plenty of times.
[19:51] SPEAKER_02: Um, but in terms of it being a part of our constitution, what is there to say about the BCO?
[19:56] SPEAKER_01: It's easier to amend than a confession, and that's the major way by which we see change as it relates to practice and perhaps subtly theology of the denomination.
[20:07] SPEAKER_01: Um, it only takes a simple majority from an assembly to pass an amendment to it, and then it merely comparatively merely needs two-thirds of Presbytery approval before another simple majority.
[20:19] SPEAKER_01: And so it's easier to amend, and and it's the preferred route in some ways to make theological statements sometimes because of that possibility.
[20:29] SPEAKER_01: And so we've been dealing with sexuality issues and conduct.
[20:33] SPEAKER_01: Uh, and so the BCO, we've had many or a few revisions to it that clarify chastity and sexuality in the in the church.
[20:44] SPEAKER_02: You didn't say the line I really wanted you to say that you wrote it.
[20:47] SPEAKER_02: Why did you just say what happens at GA does not stay at G A.
[20:52] SPEAKER_02: Not saying it.
[20:53] SPEAKER_02: I was gonna make it the title.
[20:58] SPEAKER_00: I'm not making another title.
[21:05] SPEAKER_00: One other interesting historical note would be uh it's not just Reformed and Presbyterian churches that have some sort of a book of church order, although we are the ones that tend to talk about them a lot.
[21:16] SPEAKER_00: Um, but if you go all the way back to earliest days of the church, uh probably most people studied in their church history, or if they ever studied the Apostolic Fathers, uh, this document called the D Doc K, uh, which is something of a BCO of the early church and would tell you uh basic things like how to serve the Lord's Supper and uh some of the the suggested prayers for that.
[21:41] SPEAKER_00: Uh even the prayers that sometimes we still use of I lift up my heart.
[21:45] SPEAKER_00: Um, it has um it discusses the different offices, uh, which is also interesting because it lists two.
[21:52] SPEAKER_00: So they would be in agreement or the PCA would be in agreement with that and lists.
[21:57] SPEAKER_00: Would we?
[21:57] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, we'll see.
[21:59] SPEAKER_00: But uh Let's the overseer and the deacon uh and what they do.
[22:03] SPEAKER_00: And the interesting thing is it was probably written right around the same time that perhaps even some of the apostles were still alive.
[22:09] SPEAKER_00: You could date it back that early, but it was never part of the scriptures.
[22:13] SPEAKER_00: And then you see about a hundred years later, we have this other document on the apostolic tradition that does a lot of the same things, but seems to have been revised in some things that some circumstances have changed, some things have come up.
[22:25] SPEAKER_00: Uh, it makes some provision for uh differences between those who can speak for themselves and those uh that are being spoken for by their parents in baptism.
[22:34] SPEAKER_00: And so kind of getting down to some detailed uh descriptions of the differences there.
[22:38] SPEAKER_00: And so uh it's interesting to see even in the early church, they had something of a BCO and they would revise it uh as the years went on.
[22:47] SPEAKER_00: Uh so uh it's it's a good part of our Christian and church tradition to have some sort of a church policy or polity manual.
[22:55] SPEAKER_02: It sounds like another book that I've read called the Didache.
[22:58] SPEAKER_02: Is there must be some similarity to it?
[23:01] SPEAKER_02: Uh bocci.
[23:03] SPEAKER_01: That's what I've read as a kid.
[23:05] SPEAKER_01: I remember the BCO that uh I came to faith in the Dutch mainline.
[23:10] SPEAKER_01: We had the we had the orange book, so you guys had the blue book.
[23:13] SPEAKER_01: I think the orange book's a better color.
[23:15] SPEAKER_01: Um, but uh in our consistory room, which was like where the session and uh the elders and deacons met, uh it always remained on this high, inaccessible shelf uh that no one can reach.
[23:28] SPEAKER_01: And so they never seemed to reference it much.
[23:31] SPEAKER_01: And so I always thought it was just so unimportant uh and to be ignored almost.
[23:36] SPEAKER_01: But it was much smaller than ours, uh probably like a third of the size.
[23:40] SPEAKER_01: Um, and I don't think it was as thorough in many regards, but uh, we always just ignored it for the most part.
[23:48] SPEAKER_02: What about the significance of the constitution as a whole?
[23:50] SPEAKER_02: So we've we've we've kind of talked about it a little bit at the beginning and we've we've taken it apart.
[23:55] SPEAKER_02: Let's put it back together.
[23:58] SPEAKER_02: What's the significance of us having a constitution of substance of such substance?
[24:05] SPEAKER_00: If in particular we're thinking of the BCO, um having some set rules of how we do things and structures, I think helps us uh function as a church and as a group better.
[24:17] SPEAKER_00: Um we know going in uh how we're supposed to do something.
[24:20] SPEAKER_00: Um it it also helps us address issues without attacking each other.
[24:25] SPEAKER_00: Um, so things don't become as personal.
[24:27] SPEAKER_00: And I think if you use it properly, that's that's what happens.
[24:29] SPEAKER_00: And if you either set them all aside and say, we're just gonna do this in a very personable way, um, issue disagreements turn into personality conflicts.
[24:38] SPEAKER_00: Um or if you just take the the rules very personally, that can happen too.
[24:42] SPEAKER_00: But what it's meant to do is to get the personalities out of some of the issues and allow us to say we do this because we have all agreed to do this uh in a certain way in our BCO.
[24:52] SPEAKER_00: And so we all know what we're signing up for coming in.
[24:54] SPEAKER_00: This is how we're going to do this process.
[24:59] SPEAKER_01: Um way it's easy to rest when you yourself don't have to be the arbiter for process.
[25:07] SPEAKER_01: Uh the buck doesn't stop uh with you.
[25:10] SPEAKER_01: And so whenever you're engaging in issues in the church, you there's there's something valuable saying, you know, this is just this is what we have to do because this is what is this is what we've all agreed to do.
[25:21] SPEAKER_01: And you don't have to you don't have to blame the pastor, you don't have to blame the session.
[25:25] SPEAKER_01: Uh that that this is the process outlined in our constitution.
[25:28] SPEAKER_01: Um, if you don't like that, um, we can change that.
[25:32] SPEAKER_01: Uh, but it it allows cover in many regards.
[25:36] SPEAKER_01: Uh, when you're especially when you're dealing with very personal discipline issues, if you just follow the process and follow it well, uh you you protect yourself, but also the church itself.
[25:48] SPEAKER_01: Um, it also protects the church, the broader church generally, uh protects us from some various uh theological fads in the broader church because we are so slow to change things that that causes us um to be more deliberative, to be more thoughtful.
[26:06] SPEAKER_01: Some might be encouraged or discouraged by the work of the last assembly, um, but it is intentionally deliberative, it is intentionally cumbersome, um, so that we aren't thrown to and fro by the whims of whatever's blowing in the air today.
[26:20] SPEAKER_01: And so the deliberative slow nature is to the benefit of the church.
[26:24] SPEAKER_01: I think it helped the PCA immensely over the past five years to have the structure that we had.
[26:30] SPEAKER_01: We would be in much worse shape if we didn't have the structure that we do have today.
[26:37] SPEAKER_02: Running through all of our discussion so far, there's there's been these um a couple of times we've said it outright, but then allusions to the binding nature of our constitution.
[26:48] SPEAKER_02: All of our constitution is is binding, meaning to use Jared's phrase earlier, it's guardrails.
[26:53] SPEAKER_02: We we can't go outside of what our constitution has established for us except for in certain circumstances.
[27:00] SPEAKER_02: All of our constitution is uh constitutionally binding, except for the directory of worship of the BCO.
[27:08] SPEAKER_02: The directory of worship is not constitutionally binding, and we have to say it again, except for three chapters plus a paragraph.
[27:16] SPEAKER_02: So there are several chapters in the directory of worship at the back end of our BCO that do not have constitutional authority.
[27:22] SPEAKER_02: There are three chapters that do, related to baptism, the admission to sealing ordinances, and the administration of the Lord's Supper, as well as one paragraph from chapter 59, paragraph three, related to marriage.
[27:36] SPEAKER_02: Other than that, the directory of worship is not binding in the same way that the rest of our constitution is.
[27:42] SPEAKER_02: And in a couple of places, this this can provide um well what we're at least calling sort of an anomaly.
[27:48] SPEAKER_02: Uh some it's it's kind of a strange place.
[27:51] SPEAKER_02: We're gonna get into this in detail when we get further along into the BCO next year when we enter into chapter 12, and and if we ever spend more time in the RAO, we'll have some of these discussions at length.
[28:01] SPEAKER_02: But just for the benefit of our listeners early on, as we're talking about the Constitution, um what do y'all think about these so-called anomalies?
[28:11] SPEAKER_01: Well, Jared, I have a question for you, perhaps, with one of these anomalies.
[28:14] SPEAKER_01: Why is only section three of 59 constitutionally binding?
[28:18] SPEAKER_01: Why not the whole chapter?
[28:19] SPEAKER_01: Perhaps like the previous few chapters uh in the BCO.
[28:25] SPEAKER_00: Well, there was an uh an overture back in 2018 to constitutionalize or make binding all of 59, and that overture was narrowed down to just the third uh section, so 59-3 uh being binding.
[28:42] SPEAKER_00: And um the original intent, I think, of that overture was to make the the parts on marriage binding in our constitution in light of O'Burgerfeld and uh same-sex marriage, um, uh also something of a help to uh chaplains that they would be able to say, look, this is in our constitution, you can't force me to do this, whether it's in a hospital or especially a military setting.
[29:03] SPEAKER_00: Um, but there was something in every section that somebody wanted to amend.
[29:06] SPEAKER_00: And having a group of a hundred people try to amend an entire chapter uh of a of the BCO together was not very fruitful.
[29:14] SPEAKER_00: So it got narrowed down to one uh sentence, and then uh a little bit was uh added to that uh about um those who perform marriages can perform none but those that are are constituted by our scriptures, which is for one man and one woman.
[29:31] SPEAKER_01: I guess that leads to another question.
[29:33] SPEAKER_01: Why isn't the directory of worship uh binding?
[29:38] SPEAKER_01: Why why just these three chapters?
[29:40] SPEAKER_01: Why why not the whole thing?
[29:43] SPEAKER_00: It's interesting to turn to part three and see a temporary statement that is 47 years old.
[29:51] SPEAKER_00: Um, there was a temporary statement that was added by the third General Assembly, uh, and this was as they were approving other parts to be uh constitutional in the BCO.
[30:01] SPEAKER_00: Uh, they still hadn't settled on some of these uh sections of uh the directory of public worship.
[30:07] SPEAKER_00: Um now there's I think there's some folk theories that are out there.
[30:10] SPEAKER_00: I'd once heard, well, the reason they did that was to allow a lot of variety and diversity of practice, uh, but they actually still had a committee that was set up to revise these.
[30:20] SPEAKER_00: And um they came back and and didn't report and eventually were dismissed, and then it was given to another group like in 1980, that they were supposed to finish it.
[30:28] SPEAKER_00: Um, I sometimes refer to this as the great unfinished work of the founding of the PCA, was they were intended to have a directory for public worship, uh, but it never came to a place in which everybody could agree on it.
[30:42] SPEAKER_00: Or uh what probably also was the case was there was other things that were uh pending, and this work got put to the back burner and was never actually uh finished.
[30:52] SPEAKER_02: Um surely they use temporary in the biblical sense that life is but a breath and everything is fleeting.
[30:58] SPEAKER_02: It's it's coaleth, isn't it?
[31:00] SPEAKER_02: I mean, it's just temporary.
[31:02] SPEAKER_00: Well, it's it's beyond a biblical generation now, right?
[31:05] SPEAKER_00: If that's supposed to be 40 years.
[31:06] SPEAKER_00: So um I I think Smith had an interesting note somewhere where he said, you know, it is interesting that the third general assembly said this, and can one assembly bind another one?
[31:16] SPEAKER_00: But um, in terms of this note, um, there's a there's another element of that that sometimes people will debate, and that is um the directory for worship is actually referenced, number one, here saying it is part of our constitution.
[31:29] SPEAKER_00: Um, secondly, in uh BCO 125E, giving instructions for what the uh session is supposed to do, one of the things that the session is charged with is maintaining the spiritual government of the church, uh for which purpose it has power.
[31:44] SPEAKER_00: And the quote is to exercise, in accordance with the directory for worship, authority over the time and place of the preaching of the word and the administration of the sacraments over all other religious services, over the music and the services and and etc.
[31:58] SPEAKER_00: So um actually the session is supposed to use uh the directory for worship.
[32:03] SPEAKER_00: Um, so even if it's said in our in our BCO not to be binding, it still has a lot of weight and authority, but this is what it's supposed to look like uh when it is when we come to worship.
[32:15] SPEAKER_01: So we'll will a son shouldn't be sending up 15 overtures, one for each of the non-binding chapters of the BCO.
[32:23] SPEAKER_00: That's it's kind of funny you say that.
[32:25] SPEAKER_00: I I remember having a conversation with another member of our um presbytery, uh T.
[32:30] SPEAKER_00: David Gordon.
[32:31] SPEAKER_00: Uh, this is one of his soapboxes that were one of the only um uh Presbyterian denominations, uh, or the only one that doesn't have a binding uh directory for worship.
[32:42] SPEAKER_00: And I said to him, I was like, so should we like overture to do that?
[32:45] SPEAKER_00: And his response was it would never happen.
[32:47] SPEAKER_00: Uh but I don't know.
[32:49] SPEAKER_00: It the unfinished business of uh the founding of the PCA uh and a temporary note, uh, hopefully by nature is temporary, and uh maybe this is some work of this generation or or a near generation to to get something we can agree on and um can actually use um to be to be binding and uh to give a greater sense of unity because what's the point of the constitution?
[33:12] SPEAKER_00: It actually is uh for us to have a sense of uh unity um in uh in our truth.
[33:18] SPEAKER_00: I mean, when when Jesus prays uh to the Father uh that we be one, uh he prays um that we be uh one in what?
[33:26] SPEAKER_00: In spirit and truth, and his word is truth.
[33:28] SPEAKER_00: And so um the the basis of our unity is agreeing uh with scripture into how we worship as well.
[33:36] SPEAKER_02: Preach.
[33:38] SPEAKER_01: Um, the other perhaps um may be viewed as an anomaly is that within our big blue book, there is uh a few other sections.
[33:47] SPEAKER_01: One would be the rules of assembly operation.
[33:50] SPEAKER_01: Uh the RAO is probably the the odd cousin of the BCO.
[33:55] SPEAKER_01: Um, I think perhaps few people have read the BCO, and even fewer have read the RAO.
[34:00] SPEAKER_01: And to my own chagrin, I I don't think I've read the whole RAO.
[34:04] SPEAKER_01: I only reference it when I need it.
[34:06] SPEAKER_01: Um, and and so perhaps uh how for Jared, how binding is the RAO?
[34:13] SPEAKER_00: Well, it does bind the assembly and how it operates, and so it's binding, but it's really easy to to change.
[34:20] SPEAKER_00: Uh, it's more like bylaws of a presbytery or a session or church uh rather than part of the constitution.
[34:27] SPEAKER_00: So it's not named there, um, which um makes it interesting because sometimes the RAO and the BCO cover similar territory.
[34:35] SPEAKER_00: Um so if you're trying to uh change something, it's much easier to change the RAO because you change it at one general assembly by a majority vote uh versus having to go through the presbyteries and all of these things.
[34:46] SPEAKER_00: Um, there's also the directory or the manual for um the standing judicial commission that's in our blue binders usually.
[34:54] SPEAKER_00: And um, that too has similar uh amendment process, although that's just binding on the SJC.
[35:00] SPEAKER_00: However, if you are creating a committee like that at the presbytery level or uh trying to conduct a trial, that can be a really helpful manual to say, well, how does the SJC do it?
[35:10] SPEAKER_00: We don't have to do it that way, but um they've they've done it a lot more often, so maybe they know what they're doing.
[35:16] SPEAKER_01: It it always seems so confusing at assembly whenever there's an RAO change.
[35:21] SPEAKER_01: It's never just a vote that is adopted quickly.
[35:24] SPEAKER_01: It usually 10-15 minutes goes by before the results are announced.
[35:28] SPEAKER_01: Could you tell me why that is?
[35:33] SPEAKER_01: Well, the the actual process for uh why it why it is, I'll answer my own question, I guess, is that it includes part of the whole assembly that is um that are commissioners, all who are registered.
[35:47] SPEAKER_01: And so I believe our RAO chapter 20 uh says that in order to amend this document, uh it needs to be two-thirds of votes cast must be in favor, but also 50% of those total registered commissioners, including those who are absence in favor.
[36:04] SPEAKER_01: And so they sit up there doing what seems to be odd math, um, trying to figure out well, how much is 50% of everyone here in majority of the votes cast?
[36:15] SPEAKER_01: It always seems like it takes an inordinate amount of time.
[36:18] SPEAKER_01: And I'm sitting there with my own calculator trying to figure out what the number needs.
[36:22] SPEAKER_01: And I think I've I've I'm terrible at it.
[36:25] SPEAKER_01: I never actually figure out the right number.
[36:26] SPEAKER_01: I'm like, oh, that amendment failed.
[36:28] SPEAKER_01: And then five seconds later, uh, Fred Greco says, it passed, everyone.
[36:32] SPEAKER_01: And I'm like, oh, I guess not.
[36:34] SPEAKER_01: So it's a confusing process compared to some of the other ones.
[36:38] SPEAKER_01: If you thought the other processes for amending things were confusing, the RAO always seems to stump the assembly for minutes on end.
[36:45] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and thanks for correcting that.
[36:47] SPEAKER_00: It isn't a simple majority, it it involves a lot of math.
[36:50] SPEAKER_00: And uh, when I first got into church polity, I was told there would be no math.
[36:56] SPEAKER_02: Well, is there anything else y'all want to add about our church's constitution?
[37:01] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I have one question for uh Ben since I'm now the the the host of the show.
[37:06] SPEAKER_01: Um I'm just kidding, I don't have any questions.
[37:11] SPEAKER_00: Oh, I was just gonna say I I think the constitution is uh should be seen not as something that's just restrictive or rules.
[37:18] SPEAKER_00: It's a great blessing to the church.
[37:20] SPEAKER_00: I I say this is when you become a church member, you have uh responsibilities but privileges, and part of it is the BCO.
[37:27] SPEAKER_00: You're protected uh in a sense from the whims of the officers of that church and the pastor.
[37:32] SPEAKER_00: Um I I will hand uh people a Westminster confession as they're becoming a new member and say, um, if I say this things that are not in here or that are against this, you can actually hold me accountable uh to this is what we are teaching, this is what we believe.
[37:46] SPEAKER_00: And that's such a great blessing and a protection to the people that you know you change pastors, you don't change your entire theology, you don't change your entire process.
[37:55] SPEAKER_00: Um, you have all of these protections, and it's not based on the whim of people, but it is based on uh your rights as a as a church member uh that's uh encapsulated in our in our constitution.
[38:07] SPEAKER_02: Well, with that, St.
[38:09] SPEAKER_02: Francis of Assisi would say this podcast is over.
[38:12] SPEAKER_02: If you're interested in learning more about anything we spoke about, check out the show notes in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org.
[38:19] SPEAKER_02: If you've enjoyed the show, consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters, and subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[38:27] SPEAKER_02: Scott Edberg is a senior minister of Providence PCA in Troy, Illinois, and you can find him on Twitter at SEDberg.
[38:34] SPEAKER_02: If you're looking for Jared, he's the pastor of New Life Presbyterian Church of Hopewell Township, and he's on Twitter at Brother Nelson.
[38:41] SPEAKER_02: He's also an editor over at Presbyterian Polity, and you can find him writing around the internet from time to time, so be on the lookout.
[38:48] SPEAKER_02: I serve as the associate pastor at Covenant Presbyterian Church in Cleveland, Mississippi.
[38:53] SPEAKER_02: I'm on Twitter at underscore Ben Ratliff and on Sermon Audio under Benjamin Ratliff.
[38:58] SPEAKER_02: We hope that you'll join us next time when we work through BCO Chapter One on the Doctrine of Church Government.
[39:03] SPEAKER_02: Y'all take care of it.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
