# 28. Presbytery of Moderator (BCO 10)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 5 Mar 2024, 53 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/14627853-28-presbytery-of-moderator-bco-10.mp3

We’re back, baby! It’s BCO season again and we’re kicking it off in chapter 10: Church Courts! Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Welcome
- 1:41 Joint Presbytery Exam
- 6:53 BCO 10 Introduction
- 7:44 BCO 10-1
- 13:31 BCO 10-2
- 18:53 BCO 10-3
- 31:44 BCO 10-4
- 41:57 BCO 10-5
- 45:29 BCO 10-6
- 51:32 Conclusion

## Transcript

[0:07] SPEAKER_02: Hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:09] SPEAKER_02: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I am joined by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg.
[0:14] SPEAKER_02: We are glad to be with you today and are excited for a new direction in a new series of our show.
[0:21] SPEAKER_02: Benjamin Franklin was mostly correct when he once wrote that in this world nothing can be said to be certain except death and taxes.
[0:29] SPEAKER_02: We should add the unchallenged and universal certainty that General Assembly is always on the horizon.
[0:35] SPEAKER_02: And to that end, we are entering into a new series here on Polity Matters by returning to the tried and true Book of Church Order.
[0:42] SPEAKER_02: Before we spent time with Thomas Witherows the Apostolic Church, we had made our way through Book of Church Order Chapter 9, and today we're going to take it back up again in Calvin-like fashion, right where we left off.
[0:53] SPEAKER_02: In the Lord's providence, the 10th chapter of the BCO gives us a great place to begin our approach to the assembly this summer.
[1:00] SPEAKER_02: We'll plan to cover BCO chapters 10 through 14 over the next four to six weeks, and then we'll go through a walkthrough of the whole assembly.
[1:08] SPEAKER_02: Our goal at that point will be to give any newcomers to the assembly an impression of the whole week and what actually goes on from day to day.
[1:16] SPEAKER_02: We're going to bring on longtime GA attenders to walk us through what to expect on each particular day, how matters will proceed during business meetings, what overtures and COCs look like.
[1:27] SPEAKER_02: And since you come here for all the polity gossip and intrigue, we'll cover which social events you should be sure to attend as well as which famous GA faces to look out for.
[1:36] SPEAKER_02: But before we get into BCO 10, uh, we do have a game to play.
[1:41] SPEAKER_02: Gentlemen, I'd like to welcome you to Joint Presbytery Exam.
[1:46] SPEAKER_02: I know uh we have a handful of listeners who aspire to church office, and I thought we might give them a little help today and uh show them a sampling of questions they might find uh perhaps on a licensure or ordination exam.
[1:58] SPEAKER_02: Uh but but just so that y'all don't feel quite uh so burdened, this there's no competition between the two of you today.
[2:05] SPEAKER_02: Uh this is this is a joint affair.
[2:07] SPEAKER_02: We're gonna see if the two of you can answer some ordination questions correctly uh in combination.
[2:13] SPEAKER_02: So um I'm curious to gauge the how how confident either of you may feel about facing some some polity questions from an ordination exam.
[2:22] SPEAKER_00: It's a horrible idea.
[2:24] SPEAKER_02: Scott just adjusted his sunglasses in preparation for uh for the questions.
[2:28] SPEAKER_02: Well, here, let's just go.
[2:29] SPEAKER_02: We've got a handful of things to work through.
[2:31] SPEAKER_02: Uh first gentleman, uh, who are the members of a presbytery?
[2:34] SPEAKER_02: Do we ring in?
[2:35] SPEAKER_02: No, no, just y'all y'all are just contributing together.
[2:37] SPEAKER_02: You can discuss it amongst yourselves, whatever works.
[2:41] SPEAKER_00: The teaching elders and the uh churches of that region.
[2:46] SPEAKER_02: Yes.
[2:47] SPEAKER_02: Probably important to let anybody listening know that's often the one that people miss.
[2:50] SPEAKER_02: They usually say teaching elders, they forget that the the churches are members too.
[2:56] SPEAKER_02: What about um what are the censures that may be imposed by church courts?
[3:00] SPEAKER_02: I I'm gonna suggest that Scott begin the answer to this question.
[3:04] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, so um the first would be admonition.
[3:07] SPEAKER_01: So if someone is founded guilty of a sin, you could admonish them for that sin.
[3:11] SPEAKER_01: You could then suspend them from the sacraments.
[3:14] SPEAKER_01: Um, if the offense is um serious enough, if they hold office, you can indefinitely suspend them from office, and likewise you could depose them from the ministry and excommunicate them.
[3:29] SPEAKER_02: Either of you know why there's um why there's no uh definite suspension from the sacraments?
[3:35] SPEAKER_00: Right we have to show evidence of repentance, and so a time limit is not evidence of repentance.
[3:39] SPEAKER_02: That's right.
[3:40] SPEAKER_02: Well, here who has the power to do the following?
[3:43] SPEAKER_02: We've got a list of things.
[3:44] SPEAKER_02: You just you'll just answer who who can call a congregational meeting?
[3:47] SPEAKER_02: Congregation.
[3:49] SPEAKER_02: And come on in the session, you guys should know this stuff.
[3:52] SPEAKER_02: Who can approve a church budget?
[3:54] SPEAKER_02: Session.
[3:55] SPEAKER_01: The congregation has no say in the church budget, they merely elect the officers.
[4:00] SPEAKER_02: Scott always taking stances on things.
[4:02] SPEAKER_00: Um however, the deacons are involved in a joint committee that does review who can call our favorite of offices uh an assistant pastor session exclusively.
[4:12] SPEAKER_02: We don't need to explain that to anybody listening.
[4:14] SPEAKER_02: They're well aware of the matter of assistant pastors.
[4:16] SPEAKER_02: Uh, who can uh let's see, who can approve an elder nominee who who does have the power to approve an elder nominee?
[4:23] SPEAKER_00: I mean, these are all the same answers.
[4:24] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, but but but hold on, just just keep going with me.
[4:28] SPEAKER_00: The session uh yeah as qualified.
[4:30] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, but but who can decide how many elders to elect?
[4:33] SPEAKER_01: That would be the congregation.
[4:35] SPEAKER_01: The session makes a recommendation to the congregation of how many slots or vacancies to fill, and this uh congregation can override the session's recommendation on that.
[4:45] SPEAKER_02: And lastly, just in honor of Jared's chairing the nominations committee this year, um, I want to see between the two of you if you can name the 10 permanent agencies and committees of the General Assembly.
[4:55] SPEAKER_02: Well, there's 14 that we elect to, so you're saying that there's five permanent agencies and there's five permanent committees as listed in BCO 14.
[5:04] SPEAKER_02: Come on.
[5:05] SPEAKER_01: So not CCB, not the theological examination committee.
[5:10] SPEAKER_01: There you go.
[5:11] SPEAKER_00: So AC, that's one.
[5:14] SPEAKER_00: Um there is Covenant College and Covenant Theological Seminary.
[5:18] SPEAKER_00: Are those considered boards?
[5:20] SPEAKER_00: Are they considered agencies?
[5:22] SPEAKER_00: Um there is uh RUF, there is Geneva, there is um uh the Foundation, PCA Foundation, there's Ridgehaven, there is the SJC.
[5:37] SPEAKER_02: That one's not on on this list.
[5:39] SPEAKER_02: There's three more.
[5:39] SPEAKER_02: You've got three more.
[5:40] SPEAKER_01: M N A, N T W, and um last one's always the hardest.
[5:45] SPEAKER_01: I don't know what I said.
[5:46] SPEAKER_01: That's the one.
[5:47] SPEAKER_02: You've named 13 of the 14 that we that we have, right?
[5:50] SPEAKER_01: But uh oh, CDM.
[5:53] SPEAKER_02: There you go.
[5:54] SPEAKER_02: CDM.
[5:55] SPEAKER_02: I'm impressed.
[5:56] SPEAKER_02: Well, very good, gentlemen.
[5:57] SPEAKER_02: You uh you you could stand up to a uh probably at least a an easy licensure exam, maybe.
[6:03] SPEAKER_01: What defines a quorum for a congregational meeting, Mr.
[6:06] SPEAKER_01: Ratliff?
[6:08] SPEAKER_02: A quorum for a congregational meeting?
[6:10] SPEAKER_02: If you're under a hundred, it's one it's it's a quarter.
[6:14] SPEAKER_02: Is that right?
[6:14] SPEAKER_02: If you go up, it it starts to the the fraction starts to get smaller.
[6:18] SPEAKER_02: Does that sound right to you?
[6:19] SPEAKER_00: Which which is great because like when you have 101 people, you need less people for a quorum than if you have 99 people.
[6:26] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[6:26] SPEAKER_01: Yes, I I have thought about this, and I I think I said something about that, but it is kind of hilarious that you need less of a quorum when you go up that one number.
[6:37] SPEAKER_01: Um, and it actually is residential um community members, and so those who are non-residential, those who might be at college or away in the military, they do not count towards that number for a quorum.
[6:49] SPEAKER_02: They can't send a proxy.
[6:50] SPEAKER_01: No, no proxies.
[6:52] SPEAKER_02: Let's get into BCO chapter 10.
[6:55] SPEAKER_02: You know, the the content before him was a bit different than what we have before us, but F.P.
[7:01] SPEAKER_02: Ramsey's 1898 summary of church courts in general is still a fairly accurate representation of our BCO chapter 10.
[7:09] SPEAKER_02: Ramsey writes After a paragraph on the gradation and nature of these courts, and another enumerating them, there come three paragraphs on their officers, two on the moderator and one on the clerk.
[7:21] SPEAKER_02: Then is added a paragraph on the devotional exercises that shall be observed in the sessions of the higher courts, and another prescribes the payment of the expenses of attendance on the higher courts.
[7:31] SPEAKER_02: And so that's what we're in for today.
[7:33] SPEAKER_02: This chapter is fairly similar to the chapters that preceded it in history.
[7:39] SPEAKER_02: Um, it hasn't changed a whole whole lot.
[7:41] SPEAKER_02: And so we'll get into BCO ten paragraph one.
[7:44] SPEAKER_02: And uh wow, it's been a long time since we've done this.
[7:46] SPEAKER_02: I'll read the paragraph and then we'll try to work through it.
[7:49] SPEAKER_02: Uh BCO 101, the church is governed by various courts in regular gradation, which are all, nevertheless, presbyteries as being composed exclusively of presbyters.
[8:00] SPEAKER_02: So, guys, we'll break this up a little bit.
[8:02] SPEAKER_02: First, we should talk about the idea of court in general and that word that's that we're using there, and then we can work our way through some of the other phrases that are here.
[8:10] SPEAKER_02: Uh, why why is court the word chosen to talk about these gatherings of elders?
[8:15] SPEAKER_01: Well, it's to safeguard the church from becoming a legislative body.
[8:20] SPEAKER_01: Um, we were reminded of earlier parts in the BCO where we talked quite extensively about the ministry of the church being ministerial and declarative.
[8:29] SPEAKER_01: That's that's the work of the church.
[8:30] SPEAKER_01: It is not legislative or punitive.
[8:33] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so when we think of courts, we don't think of enacting laws, but upholding the laws that are already written.
[8:40] SPEAKER_01: And so on the other side of that, we think of our church courts as they are um called by the Lord to both uh interpret and apply the meaning of God's law.
[8:52] SPEAKER_01: And so they do not create God's law, they um read God's law and seek to understand it and apply it in our ministry, and in the sense that we are also courts of the church.
[9:03] SPEAKER_01: There would be times where um, whether it be local sessions or general assemblies are dealing with judicial matters that need a judgment.
[9:13] SPEAKER_01: Um, sometimes perhaps you might think, well, the court of the church, it just sounds too much for me.
[9:17] SPEAKER_01: Um, but it is a good and right term to use when you're thinking about um how our our denomination is governed, that we are courts.
[9:27] SPEAKER_01: Um, everything we do seeks to apply the law of God um in its mission and work.
[9:32] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and some don't like the idea of the church being a court.
[9:36] SPEAKER_00: Um in the past, um, it was popular to call the the church a school, a school of holiness, a school of theology.
[9:44] SPEAKER_00: Um, and then it became more popular to call the church a hospital.
[9:48] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but I think it's worth saying that uh the church is not one of these things, but all of these things.
[9:53] SPEAKER_00: And it's important for it to be a court because it has to make decisions and judgments on certain things.
[9:58] SPEAKER_00: And that doesn't mean that it's not anything else, but it it certainly is a court, it's not less than a court.
[10:03] SPEAKER_02: Sometimes it feels like a circus, um, depending on where you are.
[10:06] SPEAKER_01: Is that an indictment of your Presbytery?
[10:09] SPEAKER_02: Not at all.
[10:09] SPEAKER_02: No, no.
[10:11] SPEAKER_01: Just kidding.
[10:12] SPEAKER_01: You're gonna have to cut that.
[10:15] SPEAKER_02: In addition to talking about uh courts right not being legislative, but being interpretive, um, and and app, you know, seeking to apply, that there's also this idea of of uh graduated courts.
[10:26] SPEAKER_02: Um, and most of the guys that that write on this, most of the commentaries you read on the BCO, you know, all like two and a half of them, uh, talk about uh Exodus 18, that Moses led the people out of enslavement in Egypt.
[10:38] SPEAKER_02: Uh, he began to take on many tasks as their as their leader.
[10:41] SPEAKER_02: One in particular was was uh judge and and arbiter of matters among the people.
[10:47] SPEAKER_02: And so we we actually read in one point in Exodus 18 that it was from morning until evening he would sit and deal with all the issues that people brought before him.
[10:54] SPEAKER_02: And it was his father-in-law Jethro uh that stepped in with that wise counsel.
[10:58] SPEAKER_02: Why why did you why are you doing this alone?
[11:00] SPEAKER_02: And so he implemented this um this advice from his father-in-law, and men were placed over varying sized groups of citizens in order to deal with them as Moses had been dealing with them uh for the whole nation.
[11:12] SPEAKER_02: Um, and and it's it's important that these courts are are not seen as independent but are are connected together.
[11:18] SPEAKER_02: Um they're they're really making up one in the same court, just uh spreading out some of the responsibility in these gradated, graded, graduated, gradatiated?
[11:28] SPEAKER_02: Anybody?
[11:29] SPEAKER_02: Nobody?
[11:30] SPEAKER_02: All right.
[11:30] SPEAKER_02: Um what's the significance of specifying that all of these courts are presbyteries?
[11:36] SPEAKER_02: I thought only one of them was a presbytery.
[11:38] SPEAKER_02: Somebody help me out.
[11:39] SPEAKER_01: I think this gets back to Witherow when we were talking about the Presbyterian nature of polity and being ruled by Presbyteries.
[11:46] SPEAKER_01: It's though we call the regional groups, the regional uh local jurisdictions, presbyteries, um, presbyteries are made up of ruling and teaching elders, and in that the lowest court, the local presbytery, is the church's session.
[12:02] SPEAKER_01: It's those who are called by God to rule over the local congregation.
[12:07] SPEAKER_01: And so it's helpful when you think that even the General Assembly is one large presbytery.
[12:12] SPEAKER_01: Um, when I when we're doing some study on this, um, there's this idea that um the only difference in the work, and I think we might get to this in a few minutes, is that there are it's just a larger amount of presbyters that are gathered together as you go up in the court system.
[12:29] SPEAKER_01: And so it's not so much that this presbytery or this local congregation has more authority than that presbytery or local congregation.
[12:37] SPEAKER_01: The the difference is the amount of of those who are involved within those jurisdictions.
[12:43] SPEAKER_01: And so the smallest then being um the session, the largest the assembly itself.
[12:49] SPEAKER_02: Along that lines, Almanquist is the one who who talks about um how how it's it's based on the the the group they represent, right?
[12:56] SPEAKER_02: So it's it's um higher courts are broader courts, and he says lower courts are narrower courts.
[13:02] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and you get that with Moses with the over setting these people over tens or over hundreds or over thousands.
[13:08] SPEAKER_00: Um you you get some of that even in Exodus 18.
[13:11] SPEAKER_00: Um, Presbyterianism is quite old.
[13:13] SPEAKER_01: Yes, it's not anachronistic, I assure you.
[13:15] SPEAKER_01: Presbyterianism has existed for 4,000 years.
[13:19] SPEAKER_02: I do think I threw some people off.
[13:20] SPEAKER_02: We pre- I preached through Exodus a few years ago here in the evening, and I think it threw some folks off when there was a whole sermon on Presbyterianism just in the middle of Exodus.
[13:28] SPEAKER_02: Uh I was glad for it.
[13:30] SPEAKER_02: Uh let's move on to uh paragraph two.
[13:33] SPEAKER_02: Nice and short, pretty clear sentence.
[13:35] SPEAKER_02: These courts that we've just been talking about.
[13:36] SPEAKER_02: These courts are church sessions, presbyteries, and the general assembly.
[13:41] SPEAKER_02: What is there to say here, guys?
[13:42] SPEAKER_02: We've talked about these things uh uh, you know, a handful of times.
[13:45] SPEAKER_02: There's going to be whole chapters on each of these coming up in the next several weeks.
[13:50] SPEAKER_02: Uh there's one, you know, sort of glaring omission as we think about uh historical matters.
[13:54] SPEAKER_02: I'm sure Jared has some thoughts on that.
[13:56] SPEAKER_02: Uh, where do you guys want to go with a sentence like this?
[13:59] SPEAKER_01: Well, just a general reminder that um the courts of the church are local.
[14:04] SPEAKER_01: That means that when you're thinking, sometimes I tend to think of the presbytery as the nuclei, but that's not the case.
[14:11] SPEAKER_01: The what the set local session is bound to the same BCO as the regional presbytery and the assembly itself.
[14:18] SPEAKER_01: And so we have to think of it in that nature.
[14:21] SPEAKER_01: We need to remember that our local sessions are courts of the church that do some of the same things, perhaps on a smaller scale, to the presbytery that does some of the same things, but to a smaller scale than the assembly itself.
[14:33] SPEAKER_01: And so um these courts escalate in their size and thus scope of their labors, though you see parts and facets of that within each of those courts, whether they be narrow, as you said a moment ago, or the broadest.
[14:47] SPEAKER_00: The the interesting omission here would be the original had um sessions, presbyteries, synods, and press and uh general assembly.
[14:57] SPEAKER_00: And originally in the PCUS and in the PC USA, the northern and the southern churches, they had uh synods, which were a level in between presbyteries and uh the general assembly that would recognize a uh a local area, be made up of several presbyteries.
[15:13] SPEAKER_00: In fact, when the PCA was formed, I think the entire synod of Mississippi uh pulled out of um the Southern Church.
[15:20] SPEAKER_00: Um, but when the PCA was formed, they deleted uh synods there.
[15:26] SPEAKER_00: And there's a little bit of a uh a mystery there.
[15:28] SPEAKER_00: It doesn't necessarily tell you why, although uh there was this line here from uh the Presbyterian Journal that Almquist cites that shows that it seems to be because uh basically size.
[15:41] SPEAKER_00: Um you didn't really need that intermediate step step when you had uh the PCA just starting off, um, which maybe has another question that comes up is when does the PCA get to a size that sentence start to make sense again?
[15:55] SPEAKER_00: Or are we there or nearly there?
[15:57] SPEAKER_02: Are we posing that question to ourselves or simply tossing it out there into the uh the ether for our listeners to do that?
[16:03] SPEAKER_01: That one's for Brian Chappell.
[16:05] SPEAKER_01: Um Ryan, we know you're a longtime listener, Brian, and can you get back to us that several of our guests haven't even listened to the podcast, I doubt Chapel.
[16:17] SPEAKER_00: Would you guys be uh what are you guys' thoughts on Senates?
[16:20] SPEAKER_00: Do you think that's generally a bad idea, or is it just kind of uh if you're big enough you have to?
[16:26] SPEAKER_01: I have a hot take.
[16:27] SPEAKER_01: It's a bad idea.
[16:28] SPEAKER_01: It's too much, it just adds to the bureaucracy.
[16:31] SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
[16:31] SPEAKER_02: Do you think you could uh again just thinking out loud, like could could you combine it with the popular idea that I hear a lot of guys that talk about uh uh a um a delegated assembly?
[16:40] SPEAKER_02: Could you could could you add synods as well?
[16:41] SPEAKER_02: And so you'd have a place where everybody goes that's a little bit bigger than your presbytery, and then you'd you delegate to the the the assembly.
[16:48] SPEAKER_02: Um I I'm not opposed to it.
[16:50] SPEAKER_02: I think think we could handle a lot of judicial things through synods, then you know so would we overture the synod, which would overture the assembly?
[16:58] SPEAKER_02: Hmm.
[16:58] SPEAKER_01: I Jared, do you know how they work?
[17:00] SPEAKER_00: There's a lot of details to work up.
[17:01] SPEAKER_01: Guys, it's a bad idea.
[17:03] SPEAKER_02: It's a bad idea.
[17:04] SPEAKER_02: How how would they work?
[17:05] SPEAKER_02: I mean, you know, presbyteries did presbyteries make up synods and synods made up the GA, or presbyteries made up synods and presbyteries also make up the general assembly?
[17:15] SPEAKER_02: Uh you know, because then you would have different things go to different places depending on how bureaucracy.
[17:20] SPEAKER_00: That's what I hear.
[17:21] SPEAKER_00: The synods did much other than being another level of appeal and to handle some things so that you didn't have to have general assembly every year.
[17:29] SPEAKER_00: I mean, it was um the PC USA only has a general assembly every other year uh because they have synods that will act.
[17:37] SPEAKER_00: Now, I don't know how much we want to look to the PC USA for a model or example, uh, but it would it would uh solve some of the problem that we have of getting a very large venue for general assembly.
[17:48] SPEAKER_00: I mean, you think about if there was a synod that could meet in the Georgia area um or Tennessee area, they could probably meet at Covenant College.
[17:56] SPEAKER_00: Um Covenant College probably could uh facilitate a synod where they couldn't uh General Assembly or Covenant Seminary or some places like that.
[18:03] SPEAKER_00: So it would solve some problems and would create other ones.
[18:06] SPEAKER_00: So that's I guess this is a much larger discussion than we're probably prepared to have right now.
[18:11] SPEAKER_02: For instance, one problem that that comes to mind is where would I go for my annual ice cream social?
[18:16] SPEAKER_02: I mean, I don't get them anywhere else.
[18:18] SPEAKER_02: And if we miss General Assembly, uh what are we supposed to do?
[18:22] SPEAKER_02: Needs to go in the book.
[18:23] SPEAKER_02: If you're gonna have a synod, you gotta have your ice cream socials.
[18:26] SPEAKER_01: Did we have an ice cream social for the 50th?
[18:28] SPEAKER_01: I don't remember that.
[18:30] SPEAKER_02: I don't remember getting ice cream.
[18:31] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
[18:32] SPEAKER_02: Uh we did not get ice cream.
[18:34] SPEAKER_02: You just weren't you weren't celebrating.
[18:36] SPEAKER_00: Between Pennsylvania, Illinois, and um Mississippi, would the three of us ever get together except at GDA then?
[18:42] SPEAKER_00: Like every two, three years.
[18:43] SPEAKER_02: Have we told our listeners that we haven't actually like been together in person ever since we started this?
[18:48] SPEAKER_02: We have none of us.
[18:49] SPEAKER_02: We've maybe been in the same room occasionally.
[18:52] SPEAKER_02: Let's move on to paragraph three, which is uh actually two paragraphs, as it turns out.
[18:57] SPEAKER_02: Let's uh we'll work through the first one and then come to the second one.
[19:00] SPEAKER_02: Uh paragraph or rather section three, 10 10 3 is about moderators as we think about these particular courts.
[19:07] SPEAKER_02: The first paragraph reads that the pastor is for prudential reasons moderator of the session.
[19:12] SPEAKER_02: The moderator of the presbytery may be elected at each stated meeting of the court, or for a period of time up to one year.
[19:19] SPEAKER_02: The moderator of the general assembly shall be chosen at each stated meeting.
[19:22] SPEAKER_02: He, or in case of his absence, the last moderator present, or the oldest minister, longest a member of the court, shall open the next meeting with a sermon unless it is impracticable.
[19:32] SPEAKER_02: Impracticable and shall hold the chair until a new moderator be chosen.
[19:38] SPEAKER_02: Uh words are hard, everybody.
[19:41] SPEAKER_02: Words are hard.
[19:42] SPEAKER_02: So let's break this down.
[19:43] SPEAKER_02: We're talking about moderators, uh, moderator of the session, Presbytery General Assembly.
[19:47] SPEAKER_02: Uh first, it may be worth even just getting a working definition of moderator.
[19:51] SPEAKER_02: What's what's the point of having a moderator in these courts of the church?
[19:55] SPEAKER_00: Well, they help enforce Robert's rules, and you have to have somebody that enforces Robert's rules and moves the meeting along and is able to call for a vote and um rule on matters and get overruled by the people there.
[20:06] SPEAKER_00: So that's right.
[20:07] SPEAKER_02: I suppose I jumped the gun a little bit.
[20:08] SPEAKER_02: The question is really better asked in the next paragraph, isn't it, when we talk about the duties?
[20:12] SPEAKER_02: That's my bad.
[20:13] SPEAKER_02: Um but thanks for thanks for jumping in.
[20:16] SPEAKER_02: Um let's let's talk first.
[20:18] SPEAKER_02: The the session uh has a moderator in the pastor.
[20:21] SPEAKER_02: This is this could potentially be a long discussion.
[20:24] SPEAKER_02: Um what are the prudential reasons that we might attach to the pastor being the moderator of the session?
[20:30] SPEAKER_02: And what issues have come up as this has been considered over the years?
[20:33] SPEAKER_01: Well, it's just a natural kind of idea that the person who would lead the meeting would be the one who is the pastor of the church.
[20:40] SPEAKER_01: They are typically the most involved in making the docket and um have the most knowledge as it relates to uh leading a group of men through the docket.
[20:53] SPEAKER_01: And so, since they have the most information typically concerning the ministry of the church, it would make sense that they themselves would then guide the discussions of the men through the the business.
[21:04] SPEAKER_01: Um, and that's not to say ruling elders couldn't be in that position or assistants or associate pastors, but naturally the senior pastor who is overseeing and administrating the work of the church would have the best grasp on navigating people through that.
[21:20] SPEAKER_00: Uh Smith points out something interesting, which is the fact that the pastor is the uh is a member of presbytery.
[21:28] SPEAKER_00: And so there's something of a connection there between the the court of the session and the presbytery in the person of uh your your teaching elder, your pastor.
[21:36] SPEAKER_00: And um, he might be somebody to remind them actually, guys, we have to do this and then this, or I'm gonna have to tell Presbytery uh why our minutes are wrong, you know, and uh this just to have somebody that can remind them of uh their accountability to the next court up.
[21:49] SPEAKER_02: Almquist is the one that goes through and specifies that um at the first General Assembly in 73, there was an overture to amend this portion of the book to allow the session to elect from among their members.
[22:00] SPEAKER_02: A moderator to serve.
[22:02] SPEAKER_02: And that that was answered.
[22:04] SPEAKER_02: And this threw me off at first.
[22:05] SPEAKER_02: It was answered in the negative at the seventh general assembly.
[22:08] SPEAKER_02: So six years later, they got an answer to this overture.
[22:12] SPEAKER_02: Um and and they they answered it with what seemed to amount to basically be prudential reasons.
[22:18] SPEAKER_02: It's referenced there in the first sentence.
[22:20] SPEAKER_02: Um just to breeze through them real quickly.
[22:23] SPEAKER_02: There were five reasons.
[22:25] SPEAKER_02: One, that they point out that in Acts 15, it seems that a teaching elder was presiding over the court, namely James.
[22:31] SPEAKER_02: Uh, that seems a little witheroe-esque to me to kind of pull that out.
[22:35] SPEAKER_02: Um that that we need to follow that one example, but uh such as it is.
[22:40] SPEAKER_02: Uh secondly, uh they they point out that it's generally been the practice of Christian churches um that churches are church courts are overseen by their ministers.
[22:49] SPEAKER_02: Uh what Jared's already said, there's there's an aspect of the connection back to presbytery uh by the minister.
[22:57] SPEAKER_02: They also suggest that um there's there's a level of parity being being sought.
[23:01] SPEAKER_02: So there's more ruling elders on a session, and so you can you can balance the parody a little bit by letting a teaching elder serve as as a moderator.
[23:10] SPEAKER_02: Um and then the last one, boy, it's so many words.
[23:14] SPEAKER_02: When the teaching elder serves as a moderator of the local church's governing body, the connection between the government of the local church and the teaching of the word of God is emphasized.
[23:22] SPEAKER_02: Should the teaching elder cease to serve as moderator, there's a danger that in some places he would be regarded as the hired administrative secretary of the church rather than an officer of the session.
[23:31] SPEAKER_02: Uh so good connections there.
[23:35] SPEAKER_02: Lots of good trivia for all of us in that.
[23:36] SPEAKER_02: What about presbytery of moderator?
[23:38] SPEAKER_02: Um, nope.
[23:39] SPEAKER_02: What about moderator of presbytery?
[23:42] SPEAKER_02: Presbytery of moderator.
[23:44] SPEAKER_00: There's a title for us.
[23:46] SPEAKER_00: Well, it's it's interesting that the um it's specified who the moderator is supposed to be of session, but not a presbytery.
[23:53] SPEAKER_00: Basically, it could be anybody that is selected it there.
[23:55] SPEAKER_00: And um gives you two options every meeting.
[23:58] SPEAKER_00: You can pick a new moderator, or you can have a one-year term and uh and choose who your moderator is.
[24:05] SPEAKER_00: And I imagine that a lot of different presbyteries have different um approaches to this.
[24:10] SPEAKER_00: Um, I know in Ascension Presbytery, we do one-year terms and we switch between a ruling elder and a teaching elder.
[24:18] SPEAKER_00: Uh, we also have a vice moderator that's ready to step in, that usually is being trained for the next uh year.
[24:24] SPEAKER_00: Um, and I've heard of some that do the the back and forth, but then there's some that you hear about being moderator for four or five years at a presbytery.
[24:31] SPEAKER_00: So uh I think that one year is renewed quite often for some people.
[24:35] SPEAKER_02: Well, it wasn't Joshua Walker was on with us not long long ago, and isn't he in his third year of moderating the Arizona Presbytery?
[24:42] SPEAKER_02: Exactly.
[24:43] SPEAKER_02: We in Covenant, we rotate like you guys do.
[24:45] SPEAKER_02: We do a ruling elder, teaching elder with a vice moderator, and they serve a year and then uh bounce out.
[24:51] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think that that's the same for us and illy and I think Mississippi Valley, uh Presbytery in Mississippi Valley, I think they um they have every meeting it changes.
[25:00] SPEAKER_01: I don't think they have the same moderator for two meetings.
[25:03] SPEAKER_01: I think it alternates between REs and TEs every meeting, and it's kind of functions in a similar way as the General Assembly functions with its moderators, where at the beginning of the meeting you elect a moderator and then he assumes assumes that role.
[25:19] SPEAKER_02: I wouldn't be able to say for sure, but that seems to be more of an old school way to do things because I know if I look back in the the minutes of our Presbyterian Covenant, it seems that maybe you know 30 years ago there was a new moderator almost every meeting.
[25:33] SPEAKER_02: Um now you saw you saw them rotate, right?
[25:35] SPEAKER_02: So you'd see a guy come up again every couple years, but now we've moved to a annual rotation or election rather.
[25:43] SPEAKER_01: I think it's better for it to be annual, especially if you expect your moderator to do something other than merely moderating the meeting.
[25:50] SPEAKER_01: Um, often moderators are also tasked with planning.
[25:53] SPEAKER_01: Um, and that includes sometimes having to cancel um things, but also plan the logistics for them.
[26:01] SPEAKER_01: And if you're just doing that, I guess I'm doing that for this meeting.
[26:04] SPEAKER_01: Um, for the next guy, it's kind of less, it's more clunky.
[26:08] SPEAKER_01: And so getting guys on rotation seems to be a better approach, in my opinion.
[26:13] SPEAKER_02: And then General Assembly, there's some specifications made here about uh the moderator of the GA that he's chosen at each stated meeting.
[26:20] SPEAKER_02: Um, again, this would be serving on an annual basis unless you miss a general assembly, in which case was it Howie that served for two full years because of missing for COVID?
[26:30] SPEAKER_00: Well, that that's the next paragraph there in terms of uh authorization to delay.
[26:34] SPEAKER_00: Uh Howie is is the uh is the trivia answer to what moderator has actually served for two years rather than one, and that's how we because 2020 was delayed until 2021.
[26:49] SPEAKER_02: I I did, you know, it's it's uh obviously I've read it before, but it's interesting to go back and think, you know, so it's it's expected for the the moderator to to preach and give a sermon at the next at the beginning of the next meeting of the General Assembly.
[27:01] SPEAKER_02: But if he's not there, it it should be the last moderator who was present, or this one, this is the one that baffles me, the oldest minister, longest a member of the court, you know.
[27:11] SPEAKER_02: So the weakest, frailest man in the room needs to climb up and give a sermon if you can't find any moderators around.
[27:16] SPEAKER_02: Uh it's just sort of silly sounding to me, but there it is.
[27:20] SPEAKER_01: There's also though it's not in here, um, some REs elect to nominate someone else in their stead to preach.
[27:28] SPEAKER_01: We can remember this with John Bice, who's not a preacher, who did a great job a few years ago at the assembly, and he asked Randy Thompson, a member of his own presbytery, who he thought would be the best candidate from Providence to preach.
[27:42] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so there are other avenues.
[27:45] SPEAKER_01: Um, I don't think we'll ever use that last uh recommendation, the oldest man in the room.
[27:51] SPEAKER_01: I mean, by golly, we would have to have like some sort of apocalyptic event for all the moderators to be absent, former moderators from the assembly.
[27:59] SPEAKER_02: What's that TV show where the the guy becomes president because he's like the lowest on the totem pole and uh designated survivor?
[28:04] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[28:05] SPEAKER_02: That's sort of what that is, I guess, isn't it?
[28:08] SPEAKER_01: The designated survivor class.
[28:11] SPEAKER_00: So, in doing the research, I thought this was an interesting bit of trivia.
[28:15] SPEAKER_00: Um, just a question that had come up.
[28:17] SPEAKER_00: Can a ruling elder that's not a delegate be the moderator?
[28:21] SPEAKER_02: We know the answer.
[28:22] SPEAKER_02: Do you want to tell the listeners?
[28:25] SPEAKER_00: Well, uh the the answer to that was yes.
[28:27] SPEAKER_00: He doesn't the moderator can be a ruling elder and doesn't have to be a delegate from the church.
[28:32] SPEAKER_00: They can have somebody else that's going to vote and participate as uh their delegate or two.
[28:37] SPEAKER_00: Um, but they did tell them that that does mean that he can't break any ties.
[28:41] SPEAKER_00: Uh he can't he can't enter into voting then.
[28:43] SPEAKER_02: And uh you did you say GA?
[28:45] SPEAKER_02: Because this could be a General Assembly or Presbytery, right?
[28:47] SPEAKER_02: Either one of those.
[28:48] SPEAKER_00: Well, it was at the Presbytery level.
[28:50] SPEAKER_00: I don't know how it would come into play at the GA level, but that would be interesting.
[28:54] SPEAKER_01: Nominating people that aren't a dial a commissioner.
[28:57] SPEAKER_02: You can moderate the meeting, but since you didn't pay your fee to be here, you're not allowed to vote.
[29:03] SPEAKER_02: Noted.
[29:04] SPEAKER_02: All right.
[29:05] SPEAKER_02: Well, here we've already referenced it a little bit, but the second paragraph of section three, the moderator has all authority necessary for the preservation of order and for the proper and expeditious conduct of all business before the court and for convening and adjourning the court according to its own ruling.
[29:20] SPEAKER_02: In any emergency, he may by circular letter change the time or place or both of meeting to which the court stands adjourned, giving reasonable notice thereof.
[29:30] SPEAKER_02: Um so some of the duties of of the moderator, he needs to make sure that everything's done decently and in order.
[29:36] SPEAKER_02: Uh he needs to uh convene the meeting when called upon, adjourn the meeting when called upon, and then he can uh in cases of emergency take action uh on the time and place of meeting.
[29:48] SPEAKER_02: And anything here of note, uh any more trivia?
[29:50] SPEAKER_02: There's lots of trivia in this chapter this this week.
[29:53] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, again, that's really only happened that we know of once, and that was 2020.
[29:57] SPEAKER_00: And in a sense, that assembly was not canceled, it was merely delayed to the next year.
[30:02] SPEAKER_00: Uh everything that was going to be considered was considered that next year uh because the moderator can't just cancel the assembly.
[30:09] SPEAKER_00: And um, some of that was COVID-related, but it was also even if everybody wanted to meet, nobody was going to host 2,000 people getting together uh in the middle in the summer of 2020.
[30:19] SPEAKER_00: So um it did become a necessity there just because unless we're gonna meet in a field, uh, I don't think we could have had GA that year.
[30:26] SPEAKER_02: And I still got COVID at the next General Assembly after that.
[30:29] SPEAKER_00: So I think we all did.
[30:31] SPEAKER_01: Did the location change at all for that one?
[30:33] SPEAKER_01: Uh, was it still was it, or did the did everything just get moved?
[30:37] SPEAKER_02: I think that it was supposed to be Birmingham the year that it got moved, it got canceled, and they kicked Birmingham like a a year down the road after that, right?
[30:45] SPEAKER_02: Because the wasn't it St.
[30:47] SPEAKER_02: Louis after COVID and then Birmingham?
[30:49] SPEAKER_02: I believe so.
[30:50] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[30:51] SPEAKER_01: It's kind of hard when you're thinking about this kind of stuff.
[30:53] SPEAKER_01: Um these these assemblies take a lot of work from the admin committee and the state of clerk's office and developing and planning.
[31:02] SPEAKER_01: Um, it's not easy just to say, hey, we're not meeting.
[31:05] SPEAKER_01: I remember Brian Chappell was answering questions of like, well, why can't we just do it in the fall of 2020?
[31:10] SPEAKER_01: And it's it's a logistics nightmare to try to plan within four months a whole new assembly at a different location with different, you know, restrictions and all of that.
[31:22] SPEAKER_01: And so it's just impossible to do that.
[31:24] SPEAKER_01: And so it's not easy uh for regional presbyteries, it's not that big of a deal.
[31:28] SPEAKER_01: You just change the church, change the day.
[31:31] SPEAKER_01: But for the assembly with all of its working pieces and the amount of people that are there, which is not merely 2,000 commissioners, but perhaps four to five thousand people total, it's not the easiest thing to move quickly.
[31:44] SPEAKER_02: 10-4 deals with um the other officer of court.
[31:48] SPEAKER_02: Is that the that of the clerk or stated clerk, depending on how you refer to him?
[31:52] SPEAKER_02: Uh beginning, there's two paragraphs here.
[31:54] SPEAKER_02: We'll start with the first.
[31:55] SPEAKER_02: A clerk or clerks shall be elected by the session Presbyterian General Assembly to serve for a definite period as determined by the court.
[32:04] SPEAKER_02: I I'll just, I mean, I can start by saying I I had not realized fully, I suppose, that even a session is called to uh elect their clerk for a definite period of time.
[32:15] SPEAKER_02: Uh, I don't know if I've ever been a part of a session that has done that.
[32:17] SPEAKER_02: I think we always just sort of elect a guy and we assume that he'll do it till he dies, since nobody else wants to usually this might be one of the most broken provisions, right?
[32:26] SPEAKER_00: Of uh 10-4 is uh for the definite period.
[32:30] SPEAKER_00: But this is why every year we actually have to vote on our clerk at General Assembly because uh he has a one-year term and he's renewable every uh general assembly.
[32:38] SPEAKER_02: Every October, Covenant Presbytery, we vote uh to re-elect, or or I suppose we vote to elect an uh our stated clerk who's been the same man for many, many years now.
[32:47] SPEAKER_01: But yeah, we have three-year rotations here in in Ileana.
[32:51] SPEAKER_01: What I find interesting about 10-4, yeah.
[32:54] SPEAKER_01: What is yours?
[32:54] SPEAKER_01: Yours is yearly.
[32:56] SPEAKER_02: Well, so we we elect every year, but there's not there's not an uh an intentional rotation.
[33:01] SPEAKER_01: It's the same man's the same guy has served Ileana Presbytery since like 2005 or something.
[33:08] SPEAKER_02: So he's elected for a three-year term.
[33:09] SPEAKER_02: Is that what you're saying?
[33:10] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, and the nominating committee puts his name forward typically every three years.
[33:14] SPEAKER_02: For some reason, what went through my head is that you were rotating the clerk every three years to a different person.
[33:18] SPEAKER_01: There are some presbyteries that do rotate clerks that can't afford a clerk, and so they it's like who volunteers as tribute kind of thing.
[33:26] SPEAKER_01: Um and they draw straws.
[33:29] SPEAKER_00: That that's another thing to ask a question on is are clerks paid?
[33:33] SPEAKER_00: I know our sessions clerk is not paid.
[33:36] SPEAKER_00: Uh, however, the GA level clerk is paid.
[33:39] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but then the question is, is your Presbytery clerk paid or not?
[33:44] SPEAKER_00: Ours is.
[33:45] SPEAKER_00: Ours is as well.
[33:46] SPEAKER_00: Not not full-time, it's a part-time job, but yeah, yeah.
[33:49] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, we give a little bit and we supply the the tools necessary.
[33:52] SPEAKER_02: So, like a computer, you know, or whatever it may be.
[33:55] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[33:56] SPEAKER_01: I I find interesting in 10-4 that clerk is also pluralized.
[34:01] SPEAKER_01: And so I don't think that I mean it's not typical at the assembly.
[34:06] SPEAKER_01: Well, maybe it is.
[34:06] SPEAKER_01: I mean, doesn't um Roy Taylor serve like in Brian Chapel's office in some capacity as like a assistant clerk or something?
[34:15] SPEAKER_02: Some of the older comments on it from Omquist, or not Omquist, uh Smith and even from Ramsey, they refer to recording clerks in that category.
[34:23] SPEAKER_02: So even your presbytery probably has a recording clerk.
[34:26] SPEAKER_02: Um, and then you know, all the timekeepers and recording clerks up on the on the uh I guess you're right.
[34:31] SPEAKER_02: That was a good point.
[34:32] SPEAKER_02: That that they fall into that those are not those are not typically elected.
[34:36] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, those are appointed by the the clerk.
[34:38] SPEAKER_00: So they probably are not seen as full clerks.
[34:41] SPEAKER_01: We need to ask a question to CCB.
[34:43] SPEAKER_01: That's what I'm learning from this discussion.
[34:47] SPEAKER_01: How many of your churches have had two clerks?
[34:50] SPEAKER_01: Zero.
[34:52] SPEAKER_02: The duties are enumerated in the second part of 10 4.
[34:56] SPEAKER_02: It is the duty of the clerk, besides recording the transactions, to preserve the records carefully and to grant extracts from them whenever properly required.
[35:05] SPEAKER_02: Such extracts under the hand of the clerk shall be evidenced to any ecclesiastical court and to every part of the church.
[35:13] SPEAKER_02: So the duties of a clerk are threefold.
[35:16] SPEAKER_02: Record transaction, preserve records, grant extracts.
[35:19] SPEAKER_02: Uh maybe we should walk through each of these and just make sure we know what we're talking about.
[35:23] SPEAKER_01: It is the responsibility of the clerk to maintain and develop the minutes from any given meeting of the court that he oversees.
[35:32] SPEAKER_01: And so he's the one that drafts the minutes and sends them to the rest of the body for approval.
[35:37] SPEAKER_01: Those are the transactions in mind.
[35:39] SPEAKER_01: So if there's an action of the court, they have to record it.
[35:42] SPEAKER_02: Which gets at the second aspect of it, right?
[35:44] SPEAKER_02: The preserving of records needs to make sure that they they keep them, that they're safe.
[35:48] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah.
[35:49] SPEAKER_01: They yeah, so in the second duty, you're thinking of the preserving of records as maintaining all of the transactions that the court has ever made.
[35:57] SPEAKER_01: Uh, when I was in Providence, I was the recording clerk.
[36:01] SPEAKER_01: And in order to try to help the Presbyterian, I tried to reorganize and compile all the minutes.
[36:06] SPEAKER_01: Well, we were missing a few.
[36:07] SPEAKER_01: You know, it's easy when you have a hundred meetings or so to miss some some meeting minutes.
[36:13] SPEAKER_01: And so we compiled those and put them in Dropbox and sought to maintain those.
[36:17] SPEAKER_01: And if someone of the uh court wanted uh meeting minutes from one meeting, they were able to get them.
[36:23] SPEAKER_01: And so uh it's the duty of the clerk to preserve those minutes and to make sure that uh that they could pass those minutes on to another clerk who succeeds then.
[36:34] SPEAKER_01: Uh, I like to think about it in the in the realm of history.
[36:37] SPEAKER_01: You're preserving not merely the minutes of the the court, but you're preserving the history of the court.
[36:42] SPEAKER_01: Um, when I was into Scumpia, you you look at 200-year-old minutes and you're like, what did the session do 200 years ago?
[36:48] SPEAKER_01: And you start reading the minutes and you have a line of history that is preserved in that local congregation, but that also applies to presbyteries and to the assembly itself.
[36:58] SPEAKER_01: If you can go to the PCA history site and get all the minutes that were ever recorded, and what do you get there?
[37:05] SPEAKER_01: You get a history of the PCA.
[37:06] SPEAKER_01: And so that's part of the preservation is preserving the history of the denomination through what it records in its minutes.
[37:14] SPEAKER_01: And so that doesn't mean that you merely do the bare minimum and only record actions, but you also want to make sure that you're recording parts of the meeting that impact and are helpful for the future history to be maintained.
[37:28] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, it's something that makes uh historians cry that um you start reading uh Charles Hodge and his uh constitutional history of the Presbyterian Church, and he discovers all of these GA minutes that are uh lost from the 1700s that he's not able to check things on.
[37:45] SPEAKER_00: And um he's probably burning an effigy, who whatever clerks were responsible for that.
[37:51] SPEAKER_02: And what about this idea of granting extracts?
[37:53] SPEAKER_02: Uh, have either of you experienced this where you've you've been requested to grant an extract from your minutes to a particular case or something?
[38:00] SPEAKER_01: I do this all the time.
[38:01] SPEAKER_01: Um, I'm I serve on the review and control committee, whatever we call it in Ileana, and we every meeting ask for the minutes of the lower courts from their clerks.
[38:12] SPEAKER_01: Um, and the same with RPR, they request the minutes from the regional presbyteries.
[38:18] SPEAKER_01: And so uh the the clerk has to grant that access by sending them up.
[38:23] SPEAKER_01: And there are repercussions if you don't, but they're the ones that transact upon that.
[38:28] SPEAKER_01: We expect our state of clerk to submit the minutes of Ileana Presbytery to the necessary agencies that request them.
[38:35] SPEAKER_00: And hopefully you're sending some of those to the PCA archivist Wayne Sparkman, uh, so that he can have them as well.
[38:41] SPEAKER_02: You guys are always uh, you know, offering your hot takes on things.
[38:44] SPEAKER_02: I figured I might pick up here about clerks since uh well, just some observations I've made.
[38:49] SPEAKER_02: But I've I've served in three presbyteries as an elder, and I was a candidate in a fourth.
[38:54] SPEAKER_02: Um I trust that my my thoughts here can be taken generally and and not um not a con not as a comment on a particular person or court.
[39:03] SPEAKER_02: But it seems to me that there can be um a temptation for a clerk to take upon himself the role of moderator in many cases.
[39:11] SPEAKER_02: Um that that would simply leave the the actual moderator as just sort of a warm body holding a gavel in in the lecture under the pulpit.
[39:21] SPEAKER_02: If it's not the clerk's job uh to move the meeting along, it's his duty to record the proceedings of the court.
[39:29] SPEAKER_02: Um he's not the leader of the church court, he's uh he's a secretary tasked with keeping records, as we've just seen.
[39:36] SPEAKER_02: But but instead of just saying that and then leaving it, I thought I wanted to follow up with two two sort of uh application ideas.
[39:44] SPEAKER_02: First, um, and maybe we can speak to the listeners, if if you're listening and if you enjoy the work of church courts, if you enjoy standing up on the floor and speaking to what's going on, if you enjoy debate and you want to influence the courts of the church in particular directions, um, my advice to you is that uh if the opportunity ever presents itself, you refrain from becoming a clerk in the courts of the church.
[40:06] SPEAKER_02: Because if you want to participate on an active level and not sit at a table and write, um, you know, stay on the floor, uh, get engaged there.
[40:14] SPEAKER_02: But on the other side of it, too, uh, in terms of moderator, if you aspire to be a moderator, make yourself ready to be a moderator so that your clerk doesn't have to step into that role um as often.
[40:25] SPEAKER_02: Because I don't think it's always the clerk's fault that he senses the sort of uh void in movement.
[40:33] SPEAKER_02: Sometimes the moderator is just not prepared.
[40:35] SPEAKER_02: And so you shouldn't take the gavel in your hand, you know, too carelessly.
[40:38] SPEAKER_02: You should you should study the book and study Roberts and study Gerber.
[40:42] SPEAKER_02: We'll we'll add him in there.
[40:43] SPEAKER_02: Um, study the docket and be ready to lead the meeting whenever the court meets and and and moves in a particular direction.
[40:50] SPEAKER_02: So I hope that comes across in the proper sense.
[40:53] SPEAKER_02: I'm not trying to get onto anybody.
[40:54] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and I think that that happens partly because clerks tend to have more institutional knowledge than whatever moderator is up there.
[41:03] SPEAKER_00: They're up there just that meeting or for a year term, whereas your clerk could have been there for years.
[41:08] SPEAKER_00: So this is partly why you see this happen in your presbytery.
[41:11] SPEAKER_00: You even see it happen at GA.
[41:13] SPEAKER_00: And it's not necessarily uh the the clerk's fault, it's just the moderator knows this meeting, but the the clerk can tell you, well, five meetings ago we did it this way.
[41:21] SPEAKER_00: So um some of that is practical, some of that is just uh Yeah, it's good.
[41:27] SPEAKER_02: Welcome back, Scott.
[41:28] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah.
[41:29] SPEAKER_01: Glad to be back.
[41:29] SPEAKER_01: I think your your take is bad, by the way.
[41:32] unknown: Cold.
[41:33] SPEAKER_02: Did you hear it or did you take your earbuds out?
[41:35] SPEAKER_01: I no, I heard it.
[41:36] SPEAKER_01: You you think that clerks should stay in their lane and let the meeting go down in a disastrous fashion when there is an inept moderator?
[41:44] SPEAKER_01: That's not I heard it.
[41:45] SPEAKER_01: That is not what I said.
[41:48] SPEAKER_01: Just let it burn.
[41:49] SPEAKER_00: I for one have been thankful for Roy Taylor's work in keeping us on schedule through good and bad moderator alike.
[41:56] SPEAKER_02: And five, we'll keep moving.
[41:58] SPEAKER_02: Every meeting of the session, Presbyterian General Assembly shall be opened and closed with prayer.
[42:03] SPEAKER_02: And in closing the final session, a psalm or hymn may be sung and the benediction pronounced.
[42:09] SPEAKER_02: This is encouraging, right?
[42:11] SPEAKER_02: Um, you know, sometimes the book, especially when we're talking about courts and things, can feel a little uh stale, a little static.
[42:18] SPEAKER_02: But here we're reminded of the spiritual nature of these courts and uh are reminded to keep our attention in the right place.
[42:23] SPEAKER_02: Uh, what's significant to you guys here in this paragraph um about prayer and singing and benedictions?
[42:29] SPEAKER_00: This is um perhaps the most um cited BCO section for why your minutes were wrong because you did not open and close your meeting in prayer.
[42:39] SPEAKER_00: But it's it's a good reminder, I mean, to not just be doing business of the church, but to realize there's a spiritual aspect to it.
[42:46] SPEAKER_00: And so I yeah, I love this section and the fact that it's in our BCO that you have to do this.
[42:50] SPEAKER_00: This is not just custom or tradition.
[42:52] SPEAKER_00: You you need to have a spiritual aspect to every bit of church business.
[42:56] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it's helpful to frame.
[42:57] SPEAKER_01: It frames your business when and it slows down your business when you have to think about praying for various parts of the business.
[43:05] SPEAKER_01: And so I think it's a helpful.
[43:07] SPEAKER_01: I'm glad there are not a lot of these sorts of provisions within the BCO where it, I mean, most churches get cited for this inadvertently from time to time.
[43:16] SPEAKER_01: And so it's a common uh issue of form, typically, um, unless they, I guess, hate praying, and then it becomes an issue of substance.
[43:24] SPEAKER_01: Um, but it is it is helpful to frame your discussion.
[43:27] SPEAKER_01: We do it all the time at General Assembly.
[43:29] SPEAKER_01: I mean, every single item of business is open and closed in prayer, and some might see that as mundane, but it is a reminder of the work that we do, is not merely a business meeting, but it's done in light of who God is.
[43:44] SPEAKER_02: Well, what do y'all make of this this the second half of the sentence talking about uh closing with a psalm or hymn and a benediction?
[43:52] SPEAKER_02: Is the is the idea of closing the final session a specific reference to General Assembly?
[43:56] SPEAKER_02: I suppose maybe to some Presbyteries who meet across Couple of sessions is this meant to be applied to a meeting of the local session in a congregation?
[44:06] SPEAKER_02: Uh, what's y'all's experience with this?
[44:08] SPEAKER_02: We don't close our session meetings with psalms and benedictions.
[44:12] SPEAKER_01: We haven't, I've never been in a meeting that has done that outside of General Assembly.
[44:16] SPEAKER_01: Uh have you done that in Presbytery at all?
[44:18] SPEAKER_01: I mean, when we sing, we have a worship service typically, um, and we have benedictions located therein.
[44:24] SPEAKER_01: But I don't know if I've seen either of those popular outside of the assembly itself.
[44:30] SPEAKER_00: I I've seen presbyteries that will have like a closing hymn.
[44:33] SPEAKER_00: Uh, perhaps there'll be some sort of a um a scriptural sending off.
[44:37] SPEAKER_00: Um, so I think it's probably more common at a presbytery level than a session level.
[44:41] SPEAKER_00: Session level, you're probably going to get your business done in a couple hours uh rather than having various sessions and having a worship service that starts it and ends it like presbytery or definitely general assembly.
[44:52] SPEAKER_01: And it's it's good to note that the magical word in this section is the word may.
[44:56] SPEAKER_01: It's not mandated.
[44:58] SPEAKER_01: Um, my favorite two words in the English language are ordinarily and may, because they allow me to get out of everything.
[45:05] SPEAKER_01: And so this is not a mandated thing.
[45:08] SPEAKER_01: It's saying here's a kind of a recommendation for how to conclude a meeting, but you won't be penalized if you decide to close it a different way.
[45:16] SPEAKER_02: That actually makes this this whole sentence a perfect example of both of those of shall and may, right?
[45:21] SPEAKER_02: They occur in the same sentence, um, mandating in one case and allowing in another case.
[45:25] SPEAKER_02: It's a good good place to go to show the differences.
[45:29] SPEAKER_02: 10 6 finishes the the chapter.
[45:31] SPEAKER_02: The expenses of ministers and ruling elders in their attendance on the courts shall be defrayed by the bodies which they respectively represent.
[45:39] SPEAKER_02: Um, in studying for this uh particular paragraph, I've learned that nobody seems to know where TEs actually belong.
[45:47] SPEAKER_02: Any uh it this just doesn't seem to have an answer out there.
[45:49] SPEAKER_02: There's a lot of suggestions.
[45:51] SPEAKER_02: What do you guys think?
[45:52] SPEAKER_02: Uh well let's deal with ruling elders first.
[45:54] SPEAKER_02: Uh ruling elders, uh, their their costs should be defrayed by the bodies which they respectively represent.
[45:59] SPEAKER_02: I mean, are we all on board that ruling elders always represent their local church?
[46:04] SPEAKER_02: And so they should defray the costs.
[46:06] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[46:07] SPEAKER_02: What about teaching elders?
[46:08] SPEAKER_02: I think that's oh well.
[46:09] SPEAKER_00: Actually, I think it's important for churches to hear that.
[46:12] SPEAKER_00: You you should be helping to defray the cost of sending your ruling elders to General Assembly.
[46:17] SPEAKER_00: That's probably one of the biggest reasons ruling elders do not go to General Assembly, is that they have to pay their own way.
[46:22] SPEAKER_00: Uh often they're taking time off uh and vacation.
[46:25] SPEAKER_00: Uh anyway, so having their local church, if they're able to, um, defray some of those costs, uh, the the fee, hotels, food, uh, I think is an important thing for local sessions to hear.
[46:37] SPEAKER_02: How far would you take that?
[46:38] SPEAKER_02: So let's say you've got a blue-collar guy who's serving as a ruling elder, and he has to miss, you know, 40 hours of work in order to attend General Assembly, doesn't have vacation days to take, just misses that income.
[46:49] SPEAKER_02: Would that also be would would would reimbursing the the lost income fall into the category of defraying costs for such an individual?
[46:56] SPEAKER_02: I would say no.
[46:58] SPEAKER_01: I think that's probably a little too much.
[46:59] SPEAKER_02: Why do you hate blue-collar workers?
[47:01] SPEAKER_01: I I don't.
[47:02] SPEAKER_01: I think actually I would I I love uh 10-6.
[47:06] SPEAKER_01: It's the best provision for a ruling elders ever created.
[47:09] SPEAKER_01: Um, but I I for blue-collar workers certainly 10-6 is an asset just in itself.
[47:15] SPEAKER_01: Most of the white-collar workers I know, they don't they don't care.
[47:19] SPEAKER_01: They they don't even put their flights or anything like that on the church card.
[47:23] SPEAKER_01: They they pay for it themselves, even though 10-6 says don't do that.
[47:27] SPEAKER_01: Uh they have taken that as part of their perhaps offering to the church.
[47:32] SPEAKER_01: And so I'm not gonna jump ugly with them over that, but I think it does a it is a provision that allows enough latitude to involve perhaps ruling elders who are younger, um, who are less established in their careers, or who are blue-collar and do not have ordinary time off.
[47:49] SPEAKER_01: Um it's gonna be hard to get someone as it relates to vacation time and all of that.
[47:54] SPEAKER_01: Um, that's the sacrifice unfortunately, ruling elders have to make.
[47:58] SPEAKER_01: But we should pay, yes, we should pay for them to go and we should inform them that hey, don't not go because of money.
[48:06] SPEAKER_01: We will provide for you to go.
[48:08] SPEAKER_01: Um, but I think it offers a good balance.
[48:10] SPEAKER_01: I mean, you're not gonna pay someone four thousand dollars on top of the airfare and all that because they missed a week of work.
[48:17] SPEAKER_01: Um, it is a sacrifice to go to GA for all ruling elders in that regard.
[48:21] SPEAKER_02: Okay, so what about teaching elders?
[48:23] SPEAKER_02: So teaching elders are gonna attend presbytery and attend general assembly.
[48:26] SPEAKER_02: There, you know, there's maybe those two are sort of different looking uh to us.
[48:32] SPEAKER_02: Um where do these costs get covered for teaching elders?
[48:36] SPEAKER_00: Usually by the local church.
[48:37] SPEAKER_00: Um even though even at presbytery level, the TE doesn't necessarily represent the church, the local church.
[48:44] SPEAKER_00: Um it's usually a ruling elder that has to speak for the church as a delegate if there's some issue that happens with the church.
[48:51] SPEAKER_00: Um but usually it is the uh the local church that will defray the cost to go to presbytery and also to uh general assembly.
[48:59] SPEAKER_00: Um although I do know some presbyteries that if you volunteer to do something like be a floor clerk, that they will pay your registration or help uh pay some of your costs.
[49:09] SPEAKER_00: I know a guy that was the only way he could get to GA was he was a floor clerk.
[49:12] SPEAKER_00: They paid his registration and then he slept uh in a cot on somebody's uh floor in their hotel room.
[49:16] SPEAKER_00: And that's that's the way he was able to get to GA.
[49:19] SPEAKER_02: I know our presbytery will sometimes help.
[49:22] SPEAKER_02: Um I'm pretty I'm fairly certain this is still the case.
[49:24] SPEAKER_02: I know it was at one point.
[49:26] SPEAKER_02: Uh they'll they'll pay some mileage rates to gentlemen who have to travel for like especially for permanent committee meetings of the presbytery.
[49:31] SPEAKER_02: So you have to go to a credentials committee meeting or an MA meeting, uh, they'll help you get there and back, uh, which I suppose falls into this category.
[49:38] SPEAKER_02: I'd never really thought about it before now.
[49:40] SPEAKER_00: For others, though, like if you're thinking of permanent committees or special committees, uh the GA level will uh reimburse for that.
[49:49] SPEAKER_00: So if you're on nominations committee or review of Presbytery records and you have to fly to that meeting and you have to stay in a hotel room, uh they will pay for that flight and for that hotel room and for a certain number of meals up to a certain amount.
[50:02] SPEAKER_00: Um, so in in that regard, even though you're representing your presbytery, usually the General Assembly is taking care of those.
[50:08] SPEAKER_00: So um costs do get defrayed.
[50:11] SPEAKER_00: I I don't know how to the letter we are of 10-6 there, but uh usually if somebody is covering the cost to So, Jared, you would like the local presbytery to defray the costs of the local ministers.
[50:22] SPEAKER_01: Is that what you're saying?
[50:23] SPEAKER_01: Not necessarily.
[50:24] SPEAKER_00: Um, but it is the practice of some presbyteries to help, especially if they're doing something at General Assembly.
[50:32] SPEAKER_02: Does it really matter in the long run?
[50:34] SPEAKER_02: I mean, where's the presbytery's money coming from?
[50:36] SPEAKER_02: Right?
[50:36] SPEAKER_02: It's coming from their askings that they're presenting to the local churches who are supporting, right?
[50:39] SPEAKER_02: I mean, it it's it's all coming from the same place in some regard, whether the church gives money to the presbytery who then pays for the minister to get a GA, or if the church just sends his minister or minister to GA.
[50:50] SPEAKER_01: That'd be an interesting amendment to our constitution.
[50:53] SPEAKER_01: Funneling all of this, adding some like bureaucra bureaucracy to the whole mix of how to get a TE to General Assembly.
[51:01] SPEAKER_01: Like the church has to send so much money to the Presbytery, and then maybe the Presbytery could like book our flights and stuff.
[51:07] SPEAKER_01: That would be great.
[51:08] SPEAKER_01: They pay for all our flights.
[51:09] SPEAKER_01: Or they just rent a band and have you all pile in.
[51:12] SPEAKER_02: Presbytery travel agent.
[51:14] SPEAKER_01: Terrible, that'd be terrible.
[51:15] SPEAKER_01: All right, we're not doing your idea, Jared.
[51:17] SPEAKER_02: You could turn the presbytery clerk into a full-time job if you did that everywhere.
[51:21] SPEAKER_02: We'd have the we'd have the GA State of the clerk and 88 other full-time clerks.
[51:26] SPEAKER_02: Goodness.
[51:27] SPEAKER_02: It was Jared's idea.
[51:31] SPEAKER_02: Well, that that brings us to the end of chapter 10.
[51:34] SPEAKER_02: Uh, hope this has been fruitful.
[51:36] SPEAKER_02: Guys, do you have any concluding thoughts?
[51:38] SPEAKER_02: Uh we've covered everything.
[51:39] SPEAKER_02: I don't know if there's anything still lingering out there.
[51:41] SPEAKER_02: Jared's giving me he's done his his he's done look.
[51:45] SPEAKER_02: Scott, I'm not quite sure.
[51:46] SPEAKER_02: I'm researching how to say goodbye.
[51:48] SPEAKER_02: All right, I'll get us going then.
[51:50] SPEAKER_02: As uh Benjamin Franklin would say, this podcast is over.
[51:54] SPEAKER_02: Thank you for joining us.
[51:55] SPEAKER_02: We're glad to be with you.
[51:56] SPEAKER_02: Be sure to come back next time when we discuss BCO Chapter 11 on jurisdiction of church courts.
[52:02] SPEAKER_02: If you're interested in learning any more about what we have spoken about, check out the show notes in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org or pick up a copy of our favorite blue binder with all the innards.
[52:13] SPEAKER_02: Make sure you buy those together.
[52:15] SPEAKER_02: They don't uh they don't come together.
[52:17] SPEAKER_02: Uh if you enjoyed the show, please consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters and subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[52:24] SPEAKER_02: If you have questions or comments, you can reach out on social media.
[52:27] SPEAKER_02: You can also get with us via email by sending something to Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[52:33] SPEAKER_02: All three of us are on Twitter.
[52:34] SPEAKER_02: You can check the show notes for links there.
[52:37] SPEAKER_02: And uh until next time, thank you for spending time with us.
[52:40] SPEAKER_02: Say goodbye, gentlemen.
[52:42] SPEAKER_02: Goodbye, gentlemen.
[52:42] SPEAKER_02: T T Y L.
[52:43] SPEAKER_02: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
