# 29. It's Not Allowed in the Church Courts (BCO 11)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 12 Mar 2024, 37 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/14671039-29-it-s-not-allowed-in-the-church-courts-bco-11.mp3

Let's discuss jurisdiction from BCO 11. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Welcome
- 0:41 Introduction to BCO 11
- 1:33 BCO 11-1
- 8:38 BCO 11-2
- 26:20 BCO 11-3
- 29:04 BCO 11-4
- 36:04 Conclusion

## Transcript

[0:07] SPEAKER_01: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:09] SPEAKER_01: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined as always by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg.
[0:15] SPEAKER_01: And today we are continuing our uh path through the Book of Church Order.
[0:19] SPEAKER_01: We are looking forward to General Assembly, and we see it coming, and we are uh spending some time in the chapters of the book that lay out the church courts and their jurisdiction and what happens, what they're responsible for, the officers involved.
[0:35] SPEAKER_01: Last week we discussed BCO chapter 10, uh church courts in general, and now we're discussing BCO 11, which is the jurisdiction of these church courts.
[0:46] SPEAKER_01: And so we we know what the courts are the session, the presbytery, the general assembly.
[0:50] SPEAKER_01: The questions left to answer are what's their relationship?
[0:53] SPEAKER_01: Uh, how do they work together?
[0:55] SPEAKER_01: Uh, how do they um balance each other out?
[0:58] SPEAKER_01: Where are their tensions between their relationships?
[1:01] SPEAKER_01: And how does the book deal with these?
[1:02] SPEAKER_01: And so that's what we're going to get into uh this afternoon with you.
[1:08] SPEAKER_01: Guys, how's it going?
[1:09] SPEAKER_01: Uh, anything on your mind as we get into chapter 11?
[1:12] SPEAKER_01: Any introductory thoughts?
[1:13] SPEAKER_01: Anything floating around in your brains?
[1:18] SPEAKER_01: Act like people.
[1:20] SPEAKER_01: Come on now.
[1:20] SPEAKER_01: Jared's been getting over the flu.
[1:22] SPEAKER_01: Scott's wearing t-shirts all of a sudden.
[1:25] SPEAKER_01: Uh, I guess I can just update y'all on what's going on with them as they both sip out of their coffee cups.
[1:31] SPEAKER_01: All right, well, let's just jump into 11-1.
[1:33] SPEAKER_01: This is awkward enough.
[1:35] SPEAKER_01: BCO 11-1 begins like this.
[1:38] SPEAKER_01: These assemblies are altogether distinct from the civil magistr magistracy and have no jurisdiction in political or civil affairs.
[1:46] SPEAKER_01: They have no power to inflict temporal pains and penalties, but their authority is in all respects moral or spiritual.
[1:53] SPEAKER_01: Guys, where do you want to start?
[1:54] SPEAKER_01: I'm sure you all have some thoughts on this.
[1:56] SPEAKER_01: Uh, let's work through that first sentence, uh, talking about these assemblies.
[2:00] SPEAKER_01: They're distinct from the civil magistrate, and they don't have jurisdiction in political or civil affairs.
[2:05] SPEAKER_01: What's the significance of this?
[2:06] SPEAKER_01: Why do we need to say this?
[2:07] SPEAKER_01: Uh, remind us of some of the things we've already read, to be quite honest.
[2:11] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, we we've already encountered this in preliminary principle number eight, in three, two, in three, four.
[2:18] SPEAKER_02: Um, it's reminding us again uh that there's a difference between ecclesial courts and civil courts.
[2:25] SPEAKER_02: Um ecclesial courts cannot fine or imprison or do corporal punishment or execution, as much as sometimes we think that somebody may deserve those things, it's not allowed in the church courts.
[2:37] SPEAKER_02: Um and so there's there's a different um sort of authority.
[2:42] SPEAKER_02: And it almost feels like some would think that that means that it really has no enforcement, but um it's declaring things that are are moral and spiritual.
[2:51] SPEAKER_02: And so if we respect the the um the weight of scripture and scripture being brought to bear on a matter, um, that's not a small thing to say that this is the way it is in um in terms of the the judgment of the court and uh to submit to that.
[3:07] SPEAKER_02: Um again, this is something that's different than you may find in the original Westminster Confession and how polity function there.
[3:15] SPEAKER_02: Um chapter 23 and 20 are a little bit different in that you have the civil government enforcing some of those things that the the ecclesial court says.
[3:23] SPEAKER_02: Uh, but for us, uh, I don't think you're gonna have that, except uh maybe if you trespass somebody on your property or something like that, the civil government might come in and and enforce something like that, but according to the civil government's laws, not because of the the ecclesial government's um pronouncements.
[3:40] SPEAKER_00: And it's good to know that ministerial and declarative is not weak.
[3:44] SPEAKER_00: Um, and in some ways, there is a higher gravity than even the civil court spiritually.
[3:50] SPEAKER_00: Um if a spiritual court, uh court of the church declares someone to be a non-believer because of their sin and their unrepentance, that is no small matter.
[4:01] SPEAKER_00: You are you are declaring by that by that evidence that they are not a believer, and because they are not a believer, um, they are doomed, they they are they will receive the impending doom of God.
[4:13] SPEAKER_00: And so sometimes we might think that ministerial and declarative is light.
[4:17] SPEAKER_00: You know, I wish we had the power of the sword.
[4:19] SPEAKER_00: I wish we could find people and find them and pr imprison them, but declaring someone to be outside of the kingdom by their sin and their unrepentance is no small thing.
[4:31] SPEAKER_00: And so we should rightly understand that the work of the civil court has a gravitas to it.
[4:37] SPEAKER_00: There is a gravity to that work that is done.
[4:40] SPEAKER_00: And in those declarations, there are consequences, at least what that court understands for the one who is guilty of various transgressions or sins.
[4:49] SPEAKER_01: Well, let's talk about the overlap here.
[4:51] SPEAKER_01: I mean, that you know, they're there are two distinct um spheres of authority, but but can the civil court and the ecclesiastical court at the same time deal with the same matter?
[5:02] SPEAKER_01: Uh I'll I'll present maybe a situation and have you guys think through it.
[5:06] SPEAKER_01: Um, you know, a friend of mine in the PCA, he had a member of his church involved in a uh an angry and potentially violent altercation with one of his neighbors.
[5:16] SPEAKER_01: It happened outside in their front yard in front of the other neighbors.
[5:20] SPEAKER_01: Uh, and so there were civil authorities involved.
[5:23] SPEAKER_01: The police were called in this particular matter, but there were also um ecclesiastical issues brought to bear, dealing with the anger and and you know, bringing him before the session and having a conversation, seeing if there was an investigation worth having.
[5:36] SPEAKER_01: Uh, what do you guys have to say or think about this overlap?
[5:39] SPEAKER_01: And, you know, is is one more significant than the other in these types of situations?
[5:44] SPEAKER_01: How does this play out or have you seen it play out?
[5:47] SPEAKER_02: Well, well, each realm has to know its role and what its function is there.
[5:51] SPEAKER_02: So the the civil government may have a fine for what he did or some sort of um uh imprisonment event.
[5:59] SPEAKER_02: Um, and the church government can't do those sorts of things, but um, the civil government would know that they can't uh bar him from the table for a while.
[6:07] SPEAKER_02: Uh that's not their role, just as the civil, uh just as the church courts are not going to say you're fined this number of dollars for this.
[6:14] SPEAKER_02: So it can be the same matter.
[6:16] SPEAKER_02: And in fact, you can even use some of the civil government proceedings in uh the ecclesial courts and say, hey, this is a police report and we're gonna act on it.
[6:25] SPEAKER_02: Uh they've already done the work for us, uh, but we're not giving them a fine.
[6:28] SPEAKER_02: We're saying, okay, this is something that needs some sort of church discipline, counseling, uh, perhaps if unrepentance, uh barring from the table and that process.
[6:37] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and when you're thinking about the relation, there there is overlap, um, but the tools are different.
[6:45] SPEAKER_00: And what I mean by that is that the the rule book is widely different between both courts.
[6:52] SPEAKER_00: Um the civil court seeks to uphold the laws of the land, whereas the ecclesiastical court seeks to uphold the law of scripture.
[6:58] SPEAKER_00: And so there might be in various instances where someone is in civil court, um, but they may not come under an issue with the ecclesiastical court.
[7:09] SPEAKER_00: And so there is an interesting play here.
[7:12] SPEAKER_00: And so we need to remember that uh the civil court does things in a civil manner by civil means, the ecclesiastical court does spiritual things by a scriptural mandate and manner.
[7:23] SPEAKER_00: And they, though they overlap, they are not the same.
[7:27] SPEAKER_00: And because they are not the same, uh, we need to perhaps be a little cautious in merging the courts together.
[7:35] SPEAKER_00: Um, there's perhaps some discussion of what is the role of church court within various trials and indictments um with abuse and things of that nature.
[7:46] SPEAKER_00: We need to be careful um not making this ecclesiastical court a civil court, and obviously not the civil court an ecclesiastical court.
[7:56] SPEAKER_00: There needs to be protected boundaries in order to ensure the liberty and freedom of each court.
[8:02] SPEAKER_01: And and you know, when we separate the two spheres and and talk about them distinctly uh in their own exercise of authority, it's important to remember as well that this this does not mean that the civil sphere is somehow outside of Christ's lordship.
[8:17] SPEAKER_01: Um, right?
[8:17] SPEAKER_01: The the the church is um you know where we talk about Christ much more than we talked about in the civil realm.
[8:24] SPEAKER_01: But you know, read through the scriptures, read to the end of Romans, uh especially those last several chapters, and you see that that these spheres, while separate and distinct, are all underneath uh Christ and have been established by God for our good and for the good of his people overall.
[8:39] SPEAKER_01: Well, 11.2 is uh is several paragraphs, and so we'll just read each paragraph one at a time and work our way through.
[8:46] SPEAKER_01: Uh pretty much the the first paragraph sets up uh a statement that we've already addressed a little bit and then divides up into three uh statements that are then each uh uh teased out in separate paragraphs on their own.
[9:00] SPEAKER_01: So if you if you've got the BCO in front of you, this is a good section to look at as we work our way through.
[9:06] SPEAKER_01: 11.2 begins like this the jurisdiction of church courts is only ministerial and declarative and relates to the doctrines and precepts of Christ, to the order of the church, and to the exercise of discipline.
[9:19] SPEAKER_01: So, guys, before we jump into each one of those three in their uh corresponding paragraphs, is there anything else we want to say on ministerial and declarative that we haven't said?
[9:29] SPEAKER_01: But maybe I'll just add this that just to give a pretty clear definition.
[9:32] SPEAKER_01: So when we say ministerial, we mean that we are acting on behalf of our king as his agents and servants in the church.
[9:40] SPEAKER_01: We're his ministers.
[9:42] SPEAKER_01: And when we talk about declarative, we mean that we are in all of this work and service simply proclaiming what the king has already given to us in his law.
[9:52] SPEAKER_01: Um and so we're we're limited by scripture and we're not serving in our own authority, but only by the authority of the Lord.
[10:00] SPEAKER_01: So let's jump into this first uh thought they have.
[10:04] SPEAKER_01: Uh the second paragraph of 11 2 says, first, they can make no laws binding the conscience, but may frame symbols of faith, bear testimony against error in doctrine and immorality in practice, within or without the church, and decide cases of conscience.
[10:20] SPEAKER_01: Maybe one of you guys wants to tease out for us what's here and and help us understand.
[10:25] SPEAKER_02: Anything that the church is declaring has to be based on scripture, has to be based on Ten Commandments, has to be based on uh our standards.
[10:33] SPEAKER_02: So if you ever see an indictment or charges laid out uh for a church court, um, they'll need to be citing something from scripture, something from our church standards.
[10:43] SPEAKER_02: Um, this is why it's saying there's no laws that can bind the conscience.
[10:46] SPEAKER_02: You can't make up new laws to follow.
[10:48] SPEAKER_02: We should listen to Matthew uh 15, you know, as as Jesus is rebuking uh the Pharisees, um, that there cannot just be an indictment because somebody didn't follow the laws of man or what by good and necessary consequence flows from that.
[11:02] SPEAKER_02: And there's a little bit of clearing that up in some of these other ones that they'll they'll talk about on that.
[11:06] SPEAKER_02: But mostly this is saying um it has to be something that's based on moral law that's set down uh in scripture.
[11:13] SPEAKER_00: And I know we're not in the rules of discipline yet, but uh it when when you're thinking through um this point, uh it's not helpful to be overly broad with an indictment.
[11:24] SPEAKER_00: Um when you're accusing someone of sin, you need to hone down.
[11:28] SPEAKER_00: And so, yes, they might violate, I don't know, the ninth commandment, but you can't merely leave it, they violated the ninth commandment that's too wide.
[11:35] SPEAKER_00: And so sometimes it's helpful when you're thinking through um 11.2, but also when you get into the rules of discipline is to also have the larger catechism in hand.
[11:43] SPEAKER_00: Well, in what way do they break the ninth commandment?
[11:46] SPEAKER_00: Uh, there's a litany of examples that we probably all break the ninth commandment every day in our thoughts, words, and deeds in various regards, but that grounds the indictment in reality.
[11:56] SPEAKER_00: Uh I mean, we can all say of one another that we've broken one of the ten pretty regularly uh in some capacity.
[12:03] SPEAKER_00: Um, but when you're thinking through enforcing the law, it's applying the Ten Commandments as our rule book, our law book, and using that uh more specifically, perhaps as an aid, the larger catechism to help explain.
[12:18] SPEAKER_00: Um when it indictments can go awry.
[12:22] SPEAKER_00: They're too vague and too wide.
[12:24] SPEAKER_00: You want to make sure that you're grounding them in the very um clear details of our confessional standards.
[12:30] SPEAKER_01: There's also an element here that that speaks to the the church's um uh authority to speak into the lives of its members uh across all of their lives, right?
[12:44] SPEAKER_01: So the the church can frame or should frame symbols of faith.
[12:47] SPEAKER_01: That meaning, you know, that we can we proclaim what what the scriptures teach, what we believe.
[12:52] SPEAKER_01: We also bear testimony against error and doctrine and immorality and practice.
[12:56] SPEAKER_01: And so we speak to what's false and what's what goes against God's law.
[12:59] SPEAKER_01: But then this phrase within or without the church, meaning, you know, it's not like you show up at church and the preacher can only tell you what to do or not to do based on God's word when you're inside the building.
[13:09] SPEAKER_01: It has to do with uh all of our life and practice.
[13:13] SPEAKER_01: Um what about this idea at the end of deciding cases of conscience?
[13:17] SPEAKER_01: Um what what's what's going on there?
[13:20] SPEAKER_01: What what what cases may there be reference to here?
[13:26] SPEAKER_01: Nobody Almquist in his in his treatment of this suggests that that deciding cases of conscience has to do with ethical and theological issues.
[13:37] SPEAKER_01: And so um if if an if an individual, I mean, I suppose that this could be taken vaguely, but we can make some some illustration of it.
[13:45] SPEAKER_01: You know, if an individual of our in our church comes and wants to know what the session or the pastor thinks about a particular issue they're struggling with, there's there's a place that's appropriate for a minister or uh or a group of elders to speak into the the person's life and help them decide cases of conscience when it comes to ethical and theological issues.
[14:07] SPEAKER_02: You see this in higher levels of the courts sometimes.
[14:09] SPEAKER_02: I mean, even study papers, right?
[14:11] SPEAKER_02: I mean, if you think of study papers on um, say, um, who may participate in combat or uh issues of abortion or uh moral issues that may plague a lot of people's consciences at any given time, um, you probably see that more often at higher levels of the church in terms of a formal study paper.
[14:32] SPEAKER_02: Although somebody could come to the session and say, I'm having this ethical dilemma.
[14:35] SPEAKER_02: Can you guys give me some sort of an opinion on this?
[14:38] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, ironically, we're dealing with that in some regard, um, with um the apostles' creed um and trying to understand descending into hell.
[14:47] SPEAKER_00: We have a uh a ruling elder that is not a ruling elder of our church, but attends our church and is a communing member of our church.
[14:54] SPEAKER_00: Um and he just sent us just a few days ago uh his own understanding of the Apostles' Creed and asking for guidance and whether we should do something different as a congregation in regards to understanding it or at least explaining it.
[15:09] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so I think that all plays in, uh plays into it as well.
[15:14] SPEAKER_01: So the jurisdiction um relates to the doctrines and precepts of Christ, and this next paragraph reflects on uh its relationship to the order of the church.
[15:23] SPEAKER_01: Secondly, it reads, they have power to establish rules for the government, discipline, worship, and extension of the church, which must be agreeable to the doctrines relating thereto contained in the scriptures, the circumstantial details only of these matters being left to the Christian prudence and wisdom of church officers and courts.
[15:43] SPEAKER_01: I think I got lost reading that if somebody wants to find our place.
[15:48] SPEAKER_02: Uh I think this is partly getting at that there are some circumstances, especially of worship, that it was is within the purview of the session to set.
[15:59] SPEAKER_02: And so somebody can't say the session is at fault because you call worship at 9 30, but I like to play PlayStation until two o'clock in the morning and I can't wake up that early.
[16:09] SPEAKER_02: Um, no, that's not the fault of the session, that's the fault of the person.
[16:13] SPEAKER_02: And they are within their right to have it at 9 30 rather than you know 1 a.m.
[16:17] SPEAKER_02: or 1 p.m.
[16:18] SPEAKER_02: or something like that uh in the afternoon.
[16:20] SPEAKER_02: So they're well within their rights to uh set times for worship, and and uh that's not the fault of the session if an individual can't um reasonably um make it to that.
[16:32] SPEAKER_00: I kind of think in terms of like bylaws, you you might have bylaws uh or standing rules depending on your court, and they may offer clarifications and establish rules that are not spoken to within our own constitution.
[16:47] SPEAKER_00: Um you can think of our even our rules of discipline, as long as it is and as thorough as it is, it doesn't give you like an A, B, C, D checklist.
[16:56] SPEAKER_00: It gives you general procedure, but there's a lot of um freedom within that general procedure on how to apply those rules.
[17:04] SPEAKER_00: And so this is in some regards allowing the freedom of the court to establish rules that are according to the scriptures, but not perhaps um established in the BCO or other parts explicitly.
[17:18] SPEAKER_00: And so I I think rules of discipline is a perfect example, and it's mentioned here as it relates to, okay, well, what is the evidence, uh deadlines, things of that nature that are almost circumstantial to the part and process of the court, but perhaps not um the ground that we just talked about, the grounding of the law itself in the Ten Commandments.
[17:40] SPEAKER_00: That's not negotiable, but how you uh adjudicate that is somewhat negotiable as the rules of discipline offer you the liberty therein.
[17:49] SPEAKER_00: And so you have to follow what we have in our constitution, but there's also more liberty, even though it says a lot of words, there's still a decent amount of liberty on how do you apply those rules locally.
[18:01] SPEAKER_01: And it's important along those lines, right, that that the BCO is saying the church has the authority to make these types of rules, and and by implication that church members have the um uh have the obligation to obey these rules.
[18:17] SPEAKER_01: So Almquist points this out.
[18:18] SPEAKER_01: He was very helpful this week.
[18:20] SPEAKER_01: Um, I'm sure you all will gather that because I'll say his name another time before we finish.
[18:24] SPEAKER_01: But he was he was talking about Ramsey's and he uh uh evaluation of this, and and Almquist writes, and yet though these rules are not found in Scripture, as far as they are agreeable to Scripture, and this is Ramsey's quote, Christ requires the individual to obey them, however unwisely they order circumstantial details.
[18:44] SPEAKER_01: So you may have, well, this is just a kind of a crazy example in my own head, but like, you know, if you've got a church full of, you know, young families with lots of babies, but you insist on having worship at 8 a.m., you know, or at you know, 11:45 a.m.
[18:59] SPEAKER_01: in the morning, you know, you inter interfering with wake-ups or interfering with nap times or whatever it may be, but you decide that's when it's gonna be, regardless of the uh lack of wisdom perhaps in setting those circumstantial details, it's still incumbent upon the members of the church to to follow you and to seek to obey those rules.
[19:16] SPEAKER_00: In a positive sense, it it a young ruling elder at my previous church, um, as it relates to worship in that same regard in with morning and evening, if the session calls worship services in both morning and evening, it is incumbent in the expectation that the people are are by conscience bound to attend both morning and evening.
[19:39] SPEAKER_00: Um, and and that's how he ran his family.
[19:42] SPEAKER_00: The church calls us to worship.
[19:44] SPEAKER_00: I come to worship with my family.
[19:45] SPEAKER_00: Whether I like me evening worship or not, that's the session has thought it prudent for me to both worship in the morning and evening.
[19:52] SPEAKER_00: And so therefore I come with my family in the morning and evening.
[19:55] SPEAKER_00: And so there's the the session.
[19:58] SPEAKER_00: Uh I guess the thing you can learn from this is the session needs to be careful with how it establishes circumstances and calls various aspects of these rules because you are binding the people to both call them to worship in the morning and evening or any other thing uh within the life of the church.
[20:14] SPEAKER_00: You're binding their consciences to that because the court in its representative nature um is calling you to do that.
[20:21] SPEAKER_00: And so it's helpful um to think of uh a worship in those guidelines as the session works with those circumstances.
[20:31] SPEAKER_01: Before we move on, it it is uh we need to make note that this uh part of the the section has directly tied to Westminster Confession of Faith 1, paragraph six, um that towards the end reads that there are some circumstances concerning the worship of God and government of the church that are common to human actions and societies, which are being ordered by the light of nature and Christian prudence according to the general rules of the word, which are always to be observed.
[20:58] SPEAKER_01: So there's there's a couple of tent pegs down in the ground on this particular issue uh here in RBCO, but also uh in the early sections of our confession of faith.
[21:10] SPEAKER_01: The last paragraph of 11.2, uh speaking to uh the exercise of discipline uh in terms of jurisdiction, says thirdly, they possess the right to require obedience to the laws of Christ.
[21:23] SPEAKER_01: Hence they admit those qualified to sealing ordinances and to their respective offices, and they exclude the disobedient and disorderly from such offices or from sacramental privileges.
[21:35] SPEAKER_01: The highest censure to which their authority extends is to cut off the contumacious and impenitent from the congregation of believers.
[21:42] SPEAKER_01: Moreover, they possess all the administrative authority necessary to give effect to these powers.
[21:49] SPEAKER_02: The church has the right to exercise discipline, has the right to exercise discipline, especially in view here in in regards to the sacraments and in regards to the offices.
[21:58] SPEAKER_02: And um now I I Think this is an unlimited power.
[22:02] SPEAKER_02: Um, they can exclude somebody because they don't meet the qualifications for that office.
[22:07] SPEAKER_02: Um, they're quarrelsome, they don't run their household well.
[22:10] SPEAKER_02: Um, I think a church should be very cautious about saying, um, well, we want to exclude this guy from being an elder or deacon because he won't gel well with the other guys.
[22:19] SPEAKER_02: You know, he's he's a truck driver, they're all white-collar, so we're gonna exclude him.
[22:23] SPEAKER_02: I don't think it's giving them that power, but it is giving them the power on the basis of scripture to say if he doesn't actually meet the qualifications, he doesn't come in.
[22:31] SPEAKER_02: And same with uh excluding from the sacrament of the Lord's Supper.
[22:34] SPEAKER_02: I think there's a lot of people that think of um even the fencing of the table as just personal.
[22:40] SPEAKER_02: And to some degree it is, right?
[22:41] SPEAKER_02: When you're fencing the table, somebody may say, I'm I'm not in a position, I I probably shouldn't partake today, and they've made that decision, they could do that.
[22:48] SPEAKER_02: Um, but it is within the right of the session to say someone is excluded, and if they come into the service, they're sitting there to not give them the supper, skip that row or do something like that.
[23:00] SPEAKER_02: I mean, there's a story of uh Calvin, even when uh the libertines came in who uh didn't think they had to follow the laws of God and they came to take the supper, he physically jumped in front of the table in order to stop them from uh partaking of the supper.
[23:13] SPEAKER_02: Uh there's a there's a sense in which that's the session's uh responsibility.
[23:17] SPEAKER_02: Uh there is a jumping in front of the table.
[23:19] SPEAKER_02: There is an actual physical fencing of the table they can do and say, look, um, it's not just up to you.
[23:25] SPEAKER_02: The you know, 2 Corinthians 5, uh we're not to eat with such a one.
[23:29] SPEAKER_02: And and you're one of those right now.
[23:32] SPEAKER_01: That's one of the greatest um reasons for staying in physically fit condition that I've ever heard before, by the way, is in case you need to literally jump in front of the communion table to keep people away.
[23:41] SPEAKER_01: Fantastic.
[23:43] SPEAKER_01: Sorry, Scott, go ahead.
[23:44] SPEAKER_00: Oh, no, I was just gonna say it this also establishes a decent um uh point where the session is the one administering the sacrament.
[23:54] SPEAKER_00: It is the session who has evaluated there might be all sorts of cases of discipline that the laity would be unaware of, even the diaconate would be unaware of, and only the session has knowledge of the details concerning it.
[24:06] SPEAKER_00: And so it is prudent and wise for a church body then to guard the table, to preserve the table, to fence the table by um only permitting officers to both as the pastor um administers the sacrament, but then also as the elders then distribute the sacrament.
[24:25] SPEAKER_00: They know, hey, that third person in the row, you can't have it.
[24:28] SPEAKER_00: Uh, whereas the lady might, you know, they're just, you know, the body of Christ for you, blood poured out for you.
[24:33] SPEAKER_00: They don't know.
[24:34] SPEAKER_00: Uh they don't know the inner workings of the details.
[24:36] SPEAKER_00: And so perhaps it's also a good encouragement and reminder that uh the officers should oversee these sacraments because they are in the know-how.
[24:45] SPEAKER_00: They they know they have they have details and knowledge that the ordinary congregant has no access to.
[24:51] SPEAKER_02: So, Scott, are you saying that you're against uh lay people distributing the elements in communion?
[24:56] SPEAKER_02: Do it, say it, do it.
[24:58] SPEAKER_00: Yes.
[25:00] SPEAKER_00: Is that gonna get me in trouble?
[25:01] SPEAKER_00: I I don't maybe an ascension up there.
[25:09] SPEAKER_01: There's a cool, there's a cool distinction here in this paragraph uh that honestly before studying for today I didn't see before that that uh this is a great place to go to see the positive and negative aspects of church discipline, right?
[25:22] SPEAKER_01: So this whole paragraph is about exercising discipline and the the right of the church to do so.
[25:26] SPEAKER_01: But you see, the the the positive side of it is admitting people to sealing ordinances and to their offices, and so it's it's allowing people into the fellowship of the church, which presumably comes with discipleship and teaching and all the other benefits of being a part of the covenant community.
[25:41] SPEAKER_01: But then there's also the negative aspect of church discipline, the one we think about more often, right, is excluding the disobedient and disorderly from office or the sacraments, um, and then it even going up to the highest centure, which is to cut people off from the congregation altogether.
[25:55] SPEAKER_01: Um it's it's it's so important to see that the the only means of discipline the church possesses is to bestow these things that Christ has given uh to his officers or to withhold them uh based on how we judge people um as they come to us, uh whether they're being obedient or disobedient, um, whether they're walking with the Lord or not.
[26:20] SPEAKER_01: Well, 113 begins.
[26:24] SPEAKER_01: Oh, it's just one paragraph.
[26:25] SPEAKER_01: It just goes like this All church courts are one in nature, constituted of the same elements, possessed inerrantly of the same kinds of rights and powers, and differing only as the Constitution may provide.
[26:37] SPEAKER_01: When, however, according to scriptural example and needful to the purity and harmony of the whole church, disputed matters of doctrine and order arising in the lower courts are referred to the higher courts for decision, such referral shall not be so exercised as to impinge upon the authority of the lower court.
[26:55] SPEAKER_02: In both 11.3 and 11.4, you see some of this principle of a great deference that's given to lower courts.
[27:04] SPEAKER_02: So when we speak of lower and higher courts, we shouldn't just have a hierarchy and higher courts good, lower courts bad.
[27:11] SPEAKER_02: Um, in fact, you'll see this a lot at hopefully at Presbytery level and at SJC level.
[27:16] SPEAKER_02: If something is referred up to there, they assume that lower courts have a lot more um power over the um the information of what's happening there, uh the circumstances in which it happened, the way in which certain things were meant.
[27:29] SPEAKER_02: And so you'll see a large amount of deference given to lower courts, and it's it's this principle here.
[27:34] SPEAKER_02: And that frustrates us sometimes because we think, well, obviously you said this, or obviously this is how it should have happened.
[27:41] SPEAKER_02: Um, but uh, I don't know, I've learned a lot from uh trying to follow courts uh and cases within the civil government that sometimes a verdict will come out and you say, that's weird.
[27:52] SPEAKER_02: Like everything I heard in the media leads me to believe that they should have decided differently.
[27:56] SPEAKER_02: And then once you look into some of the details, you realize, well, maybe the court actually had more in front of them that they knew about than I did.
[28:02] SPEAKER_02: Um doesn't mean they're always right.
[28:04] SPEAKER_02: Uh total depravity affects all levels of the court.
[28:07] SPEAKER_02: But there should be some, uh, even if they're making there's an appeal and they're they're making a different decision, it shouldn't be to say this court was stupid.
[28:15] SPEAKER_02: It is to say, here's something they didn't consider, here's a procedure they didn't follow.
[28:20] SPEAKER_02: And there's many times in which they say, How about you take another crack at this, you know, uh considering this.
[28:25] SPEAKER_02: So there's there should be a large degree of deference that's uh involved there.
[28:31] SPEAKER_01: What else?
[28:33] SPEAKER_02: Well, I think um it was onquist that had that great line that he ended the section with of saying a higher court intrudes on the authority of a lower court when it acts within the lower court's jurisdiction outside of the expect express provisions of the constitution.
[28:49] SPEAKER_02: So I I think that's part of what's what's happening there.
[28:52] SPEAKER_02: It impugns on their authority if they start doing things that the lower court should be doing, and the uh the upper court just decides to start doing that for them.
[29:00] SPEAKER_01: Well, do we feel like Jared's done due diligence on 11-3?
[29:03] SPEAKER_01: We can move on to 11-4.
[29:06] SPEAKER_01: Which is uh a couple of paragraphs on its own, so we'll take them one at a time.
[29:10] SPEAKER_01: Starts with uh for the orderly and efficient dispatch of ecclesiastical business, it is necessary that the sphere of action of each court be distinctly defined.
[29:22] SPEAKER_01: The session exercises jurisdiction over a single church, the presbytery over what is common to the ministers, sessions, and churches within a prescribed district, and the general assembly over such matters as concern the whole church.
[29:35] SPEAKER_01: The jurisdiction of these courts is limited by the express provisions of the Constitution.
[29:41] SPEAKER_01: So if we have three courts, we have to define the sphere of each one.
[29:46] SPEAKER_01: Most of us are aware session exercises jurisdiction over a single church.
[29:51] SPEAKER_01: Um there's really nothing that stands out there.
[29:54] SPEAKER_01: I don't know if there's anything worth talking about from y'all's perspective.
[29:57] SPEAKER_01: Uh usually the presbytery is the point in this paragraph that uh is gonna get attention.
[30:03] SPEAKER_02: Anything it doesn't seem to take into account though, and some have pointed this out um later on as Korean language presbyteries were given their own kind of borders.
[30:13] SPEAKER_02: And so there are presbyteries within presbyteries, uh, it seems like here.
[30:17] SPEAKER_02: Um, so that doesn't seem to be in view here, so it complicates things a little bit.
[30:22] SPEAKER_02: Otherwise, it's a pretty plain reading of we know the jurisdiction of a session of presbytery of general assembly.
[30:29] SPEAKER_02: Used to have synods in there as well in the PCUS, but again, we don't have synods.
[30:34] SPEAKER_01: We're still being sanctified.
[30:35] SPEAKER_01: Maybe there's hope one day.
[30:37] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, well, I don't think we've really m used much time to talk about jurisdiction um and the idea of it, but you know, we're at the end of this paragraph or this chapter.
[30:46] SPEAKER_00: Like, what is jurisdiction?
[30:48] SPEAKER_00: It's the limits by which the authority of a court has.
[30:51] SPEAKER_00: Uh, you can think of you could edit this all the way at the top of the episode.
[30:54] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[30:54] SPEAKER_00: Oh, where you you you think of perhaps in the civil sense, jurisdiction is dealing with uh you have two townships and their jurisdictions are independent of one another as it relates to like law enforcement.
[31:07] SPEAKER_00: That in Lansing, Illinois, where I grew up, uh those the municipalities there had no authority or um work outside of that town unless they were contracted to be somewhere else as well.
[31:20] SPEAKER_00: And so in Munster, Indiana, the Lansing Police Department has little authority.
[31:25] SPEAKER_00: And so if you could use that as a baseline for when we're talking about the idea of jurisdiction, even in the regional sense, it is the limits of where the bounds of where there is a Presbytery's authority.
[31:38] SPEAKER_00: Um it is over these uh churches, these particular churches within these geographical bounds as we understand it in the PCA.
[31:45] SPEAKER_00: And the same is when you get to the local session, uh, what is the jurisdiction?
[31:48] SPEAKER_00: It is over that local church.
[31:51] SPEAKER_00: And so if your church member has a problem with, let's say, a church member at another church in your presbytery, you can't bring charges against that other church's church member because they're outside of your jurisdiction, right?
[32:05] SPEAKER_00: And so you can maybe send a letter to that session and make them aware or known of an issue, but it's up to that session within their jurisdiction and prudence therein to exercise discipline or not.
[32:16] SPEAKER_00: And so it's sometimes, and when we're thinking about jurisdiction, that that's how it works.
[32:21] SPEAKER_00: Um Presbytery level is different as it deals with a group of churches with their officers, pastors uh in there, um, and the General Assembly is even larger, but there is limits to where that authority starts and ends.
[32:34] SPEAKER_00: And it's within those limits that these paragraphs are framed.
[32:39] SPEAKER_01: To be fair to ourselves, I I don't think it's just that we waited till the end to define jurisdiction.
[32:44] SPEAKER_01: I'm pretty sure the pair the whole chapter waited till the end to define jurisdiction, at least very clearly.
[32:50] SPEAKER_01: So if you need to return to the top of the episode and listen from the beginning, now's a good time to go do that.
[32:56] SPEAKER_00: It all makes sense now.
[32:58] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, right.
[32:59] SPEAKER_01: The last paragraph uh underneath 11.4, the last paragraph of the chapter, every court has the right to resolve questions of doctrine and discipline seriously and reasonably proposed, and in general to maintain truth and righteousness, condemning erroneous opinions and practices which tend to the injury of the peace, purity, or progress of the church.
[33:16] SPEAKER_01: Although each court exercises exclusive original jurisdiction over all matters especially belonging to it, the lower courts are subject to the review and control of the higher courts in regular gradation.
[33:27] SPEAKER_01: These courts are not separate and independent tribunals, but they have a mutual relation, and every act of jurisdiction is the act of the whole church performed by it through the appropriate organ.
[33:40] SPEAKER_01: Now, this reference to the organ, is that what everybody's afraid of with this directory of worship thing that that's been going on on social media, or is am I off?
[33:48] SPEAKER_01: Is that different?
[33:49] SPEAKER_01: Okay.
[33:50] SPEAKER_01: Maybe one of y'all should talk about this.
[33:52] SPEAKER_00: Well, when I think of this, when when we're drafting an indictment, we don't say in the name of Providence Presbyterian Church, but we say in the name of the Presbyterian Church in America, that's the one prosecuting the case.
[34:03] SPEAKER_00: And so it's in that sense that the that the or if we are one large body, uh, and when one court acts, it's in light of other courts.
[34:13] SPEAKER_00: And so uh there's not an a complete independency, um, in other words, with our jurisdictions.
[34:19] SPEAKER_00: Um, there is a mutual relation as one body.
[34:23] SPEAKER_02: In studying 11.3 and 11.4, I gained an appreciation for the whole debate over overture eight from a couple years ago, where we were looking at changing uh 33.1 and 34.1, which was um process against the minister.
[34:40] SPEAKER_02: This is uh 34-1, process against the minister minister shall be entered before the presbytery of which he is a member.
[34:46] SPEAKER_02: And so that's of course is the jurisdiction there.
[34:49] SPEAKER_02: It says, however, if the presbytery refuses to act in doctrinal cases or cases of public scandal, and two other presbyteries request the general assembly to assume original jurisdiction uh to first receive and initially hear and determine, the General Assembly shall do so.
[35:06] SPEAKER_02: And there was a big debate over changing some of this, what does refuse to act mean?
[35:11] SPEAKER_02: Uh, there's a provision for this at the session level in 33-1.
[35:15] SPEAKER_02: And um, there's a lot of difficulty in changing this.
[35:18] SPEAKER_02: And I think part of it was if you change it in such a way that you take away an issue from a session before it's had an opportunity to act on it.
[35:26] SPEAKER_02: You know, um, if you just uh take away the refuse to act language, and then you can just take in the middle of a trial um a an issue from a lower court, uh, you really are running afoul of some of these other BCO places.
[35:40] SPEAKER_02: They they need to have a first crack at it, right?
[35:43] SPEAKER_02: Uh either in acting on it or if they just completely ignore the matter, then you can take it.
[35:48] SPEAKER_02: But uh there's a lot that's that's in these sections that wants to preserve the right of that that court to figure that issue out first before there's any kind of a willful or or uh by force taking of an issue away uh from a lower court.
[36:04] SPEAKER_01: Well, as the Presbyterian Church in America would say, this podcast is over.
[36:08] SPEAKER_01: Thanks for joining us.
[36:09] SPEAKER_01: Be sure to come back next time when we discuss Book of Church Order chapter twelve on the church session.
[36:15] SPEAKER_01: If you're interested in learning more about anything we mention, check out the show notes in your podcast player or at politymatters.org.
[36:21] SPEAKER_01: If you enjoyed the show, consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters and subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[36:28] SPEAKER_01: If you have questions or comments, you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com, or you can find any of us on Twitter.
[36:35] SPEAKER_01: Uh, you can check the show notes for the proper links.
[36:37] SPEAKER_01: And I'll just add here, I'm not sure if I'll be on Twitter much longer.
[36:40] SPEAKER_01: I'm really feeling the tug, uh, the pull to get off.
[36:43] SPEAKER_01: So uh we'll we'll see.
[36:44] SPEAKER_01: We'll see.
[36:45] SPEAKER_01: Anyway.
[36:47] SPEAKER_01: I'll I'll look at X and see if that's any different.
[36:50] SPEAKER_01: Thanks again for spending your valuable time with us.
[36:52] SPEAKER_01: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[36:54] SPEAKER_00: Goodbye, gentlemen.
[36:55] SPEAKER_01: Sayanora.
[36:56] SPEAKER_01: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
