# 34. Live-Action BCO Interpretation (BCO 14)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 16 Apr 2024, 58 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/14896757-34-live-action-bco-interpretation-bco-14.mp3

We should have done our homework! Listen in as the guys work through BCO 14 on the General Assembly. Not everything is immediately clear, but we will rectify that in the years to come. Enjoy! Greensboro GA debate about images PCA on Wikipedia Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Welcome & Favorite GAs
- 4:21 BCO 14 Introduction
- 4:43 BCO 14-1
- 30:47 BCO 14-2
- 34:56 BCO 14-3
- 38:58 BCO 14-4
- 40:14 BCO 14-5
- 42:20 BCO 14-6
- 52:50 BCO 14-7
- 54:42 BCO 14-8
- 56:22 Conclusion

## Transcript

[0:07] SPEAKER_02: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:09] SPEAKER_02: My name is Ben Ratliff.
[0:10] SPEAKER_02: I'm joined today by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg, and we are excited to talk with y'all about uh BCO Chapter 14.
[0:19] SPEAKER_02: I don't know about you guys, but um I've really enjoyed our brief return to the BCO.
[0:23] SPEAKER_02: The structure that it brings to our show is is uh relieving in many ways.
[0:28] SPEAKER_02: Um but listeners, y'all remember uh in anticipation of the 51st General Assembly coming up in Richmond, Virginia, we uh begin a few weeks ago in BCO 10 and have been working slowly through addressing uh the courts in general and their jurisdictions, and then we hit sessions and presbyteries, and now we're at the Big Kahuna today, the General Assembly.
[0:47] SPEAKER_02: Um it's the highest court of our church.
[0:49] SPEAKER_02: A lot happens at that level, and so there's there's plenty to talk about.
[0:52] SPEAKER_02: And I'll go ahead and give sort of the caveat here.
[0:54] SPEAKER_02: There are some places in BCO 14 that we're it will feel like we're skipping, but it's because we're gonna spend some time in the next four to six weeks um really delving into some of the details of these uh parts of the General Assembly.
[1:08] SPEAKER_02: So you're you won't miss anything.
[1:10] SPEAKER_02: If anything, you'll get more information than you want in the future.
[1:13] SPEAKER_02: It just might not happen in this episode.
[1:15] SPEAKER_02: Um, before we get into it, I won I wanted to ask you guys, what's uh what's your favorite General Assembly that you've attended so far as a commissioner?
[1:23] SPEAKER_02: Or or maybe just in general.
[1:24] SPEAKER_02: Maybe maybe you vacationed at GA before you were ordained as a teaching elder.
[1:27] SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
[1:29] SPEAKER_02: Not everybody at once, please.
[1:32] SPEAKER_02: Sletting Scott go first.
[1:33] SPEAKER_01: Oh, you were.
[1:35] SPEAKER_01: Um, my favorite one so far has been Birmingham.
[1:39] SPEAKER_01: I was able to clerk the AC COC, and um my first that was my second general assembly.
[1:46] SPEAKER_01: My first general assembly was in St.
[1:48] SPEAKER_01: Louis, but I was um called home early because my wife went into labor during the assembly.
[1:54] SPEAKER_01: And so I I missed all of the enjoyable um overture debates on the floor.
[1:58] SPEAKER_01: And so, in some ways, Birmingham was my first actual assembly where I stayed the whole time and participated.
[2:06] SPEAKER_02: You're gonna hold that against her for the rest of your life.
[2:09] SPEAKER_01: No, I don't hold it against her.
[2:11] SPEAKER_01: Um, I I did say if we lost any vote by one, then then maybe, but those margins were not present.
[2:18] SPEAKER_02: Jared, you've been to what, 40 general assemblies now?
[2:21] SPEAKER_02: How old are you?
[2:23] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, since I was one year old, I was no.
[2:27] SPEAKER_00: Um, I've been to about 10 General Assemblies now.
[2:30] SPEAKER_00: Um probably my favorite was the last one, the 50th General Assembly.
[2:35] SPEAKER_00: Um, it was the least rancorous one.
[2:39] SPEAKER_00: Um, it was um one that I knew everything that was going on.
[2:42] SPEAKER_00: I'd been to enough GAs to know what was going on.
[2:45] SPEAKER_00: Um, it just it had a different feel.
[2:47] SPEAKER_00: Um, if I actually had to choose one that wasn't the 50th, it probably would be I don't know if it was the 47th.
[2:54] SPEAKER_00: The numbers got off because of COVID.
[2:55] SPEAKER_00: Uh, 2019 was the first time I'd ever been on the overtures committee.
[3:00] SPEAKER_00: And that was just a unique experience.
[3:02] SPEAKER_00: I feel like I had a different GA than everybody else because I was not out hanging out with people.
[3:08] SPEAKER_00: We were just working on whether or not we should constitutionalize uh BCO 15 or 59 on marriage and what that would look like.
[3:17] SPEAKER_00: And the process for that taught me so much.
[3:19] SPEAKER_00: And so I just really enjoyed um the 2019 uh General Assembly as well.
[3:26] SPEAKER_02: I my first General Assembly was in 2009.
[3:30] SPEAKER_02: Uh, I wasn't a commissioner, I visited as a seminary student, and um, I don't think I've attended 10 quite yet as a commissioner, probably seven or eight at this point.
[3:40] SPEAKER_02: Um, I I really enjoyed last year for some of the same reasons you said just 50th uh in Memphis was good.
[3:45] SPEAKER_02: But one of my more memorable GAs that sticks in my mind, and if I can find the picture, and if it's not offensive, I'll put it in our show notes.
[3:52] SPEAKER_02: But um there was a point in Greensboro, North Carolina where we were debating, and and it was back, they had written the debate topic up at the top so that people who were following along could know, and it's simply read at the bottom of the screen up front.
[4:03] SPEAKER_02: Uh, currently debating whether or not to keep an image of Jesus in the General Assembly minutes.
[4:09] SPEAKER_02: And just, I mean, I'm not even gonna go into the details right here for y'all because it was that ridiculous, and just the notion of it uh makes me laugh even now.
[4:16] SPEAKER_02: Um, if you're in Greensboro, you probably can figure out what was going on.
[4:20] SPEAKER_02: Anyway, uh, General Assembly is a lot of fun.
[4:23] SPEAKER_02: It's not just a conference where we go hang out.
[4:25] SPEAKER_02: Uh, there's a lot of business that is transacted, and that's what this chapter is all about.
[4:29] SPEAKER_02: Uh, chapter 14 of the BCO.
[4:31] SPEAKER_02: There's a lot of words here, guys, so you'll bear with me.
[4:33] SPEAKER_02: Uh, remember, this is just me working towards my audiobook version of the BCO.
[4:38] SPEAKER_02: Uh, we you can buy it in the future.
[4:40] SPEAKER_02: There will be uh annual updates.
[4:42] SPEAKER_02: Here we go.
[4:43] SPEAKER_02: BCO 14.1.
[4:44] SPEAKER_02: The General Assembly is the highest court of this church and represents in one body all the churches thereof.
[4:50] SPEAKER_02: It bears the title of the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church in America and constitutes the bond of union, peace, and correspondence among all its congregations and courts.
[4:59] SPEAKER_02: And we're going to deal with that paragraph first, and then we get into the principles for the organization, which uh have 15 uh items.
[5:06] SPEAKER_02: But uh, guys, just starting off, what's what's important for us to have in our minds as we begin this conversation, especially coming out of these first couple sentences.
[5:14] SPEAKER_01: Well, the General Assembly is the highest court, it is the largest court of the PCA.
[5:20] SPEAKER_01: Its jurisdiction is over the entire denomination.
[5:23] SPEAKER_01: And so while each of our courts maintain their their similar or the same rights and privileges, they differ in scopes of their own jurisdiction.
[5:33] SPEAKER_01: And so this has the largest jurisdiction in that it oversees the work of the entire denomination.
[5:40] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I think it's important to see the highest court isn't um necessarily something that is just like a hierarchical, as if there's bishops that are in that court, uh, but that it yeah, it it entails everything.
[5:53] SPEAKER_00: So I think Smith and uh Omquist both make notations on that.
[5:58] SPEAKER_02: So what follows in this paragraph is uh the section, I suppose we're gonna say, because it's like three pages in the book, um, are the principles for the organization of the assembly.
[6:06] SPEAKER_02: And there's 15 listed.
[6:07] SPEAKER_02: And uh Omquist in his commentary makes a good point.
[6:10] SPEAKER_02: And he says, you know, I think implied, at least in his thought, is that there there wasn't uh we didn't, it wasn't necessary for us to put these principles for organization into the assembly, um, into the book of church order, except that we don't want these to change.
[6:23] SPEAKER_02: And so instead of putting them in the rules for assembly operation, for example, you know, that can get changed in one vote at General Assembly, these require the General Assembly votes, the presbyteries vote, the General Assembly comes back and votes in order to change.
[6:37] SPEAKER_02: And so the the point and the principles of the assembly are very difficult uh to get changed.
[6:42] SPEAKER_02: And if they do, it's probably for a good reason.
[6:45] SPEAKER_02: And so that's why these are enumerated here in 15 points.
[6:49] SPEAKER_02: Um guys, I guess I'll read one at a time.
[6:52] SPEAKER_02: And if we have comments, we can stop and chit-chat about them.
[6:55] SPEAKER_02: So, number one, principles for the organization of the assembly.
[6:58] SPEAKER_02: The church is responsible for carrying out the great commission.
[7:02] SPEAKER_02: So there's there's two thoughts here.
[7:03] SPEAKER_02: One, um, it's not the individual's responsibility to carry out the great commission.
[7:07] SPEAKER_02: You know, I grew up in you know broadly evangelical world until about seventh grade when we came into the PCA.
[7:13] SPEAKER_02: But before that, it was it's your job, always been it's your job and your friend's job next to you to go and and proclaim you know the gospel and fulfill the Great Commission.
[7:22] SPEAKER_02: Actually, the Great Commission was given to the church through the apostles.
[7:25] SPEAKER_02: Um, it's the church's responsibility to carry out the Great Commission.
[7:29] SPEAKER_02: And so it's a wonderful statement here.
[7:30] SPEAKER_02: This is the entire mission of the church is to disciple um and bring people in uh through the proclamation of the gospel predominantly.
[7:38] SPEAKER_00: Um and I don't think this means that we shouldn't have this doesn't mean that we shouldn't have individuals that are participating in evangelism and uh in elements of it.
[7:48] SPEAKER_00: But if you remember, part of the Great Commission is to go out and baptize.
[7:51] SPEAKER_00: That's not given to every individual.
[7:53] SPEAKER_00: And um another element to that is if you have somebody that comes into your church that says, look, you're sinning if you're not out on the street corner preaching.
[8:02] SPEAKER_00: Um, then you can say, look, not everybody's called to that, not everybody has the same gifts, but everybody should be supporting the Great Commission.
[8:10] SPEAKER_00: And that might be in helping to do hospitality and bringing people in.
[8:14] SPEAKER_00: It might be in financial and prayerful support.
[8:17] SPEAKER_00: So everybody should be committed to the Great Commission, but not everybody has the same part in it because it's given to the entire church to do.
[8:24] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, one of my mentors uh would do a yearly evangelistic um Sunday school with all the adults.
[8:31] SPEAKER_01: And the main premise of it was that we're not all called to be evangelists, but we're all called to bear witness.
[8:39] SPEAKER_01: Uh, and so every Christian uh in the congregation must bear witness to Christ.
[8:45] SPEAKER_01: Um, but not every Christian is called to be an evangelist, uh, in the in the understanding of how we understand that term.
[8:52] SPEAKER_01: Um, and I think that's helpful.
[8:54] SPEAKER_01: Um, and his basic plea was like, you don't have to know how to share the gospel message super articulately, but the least thing you can do is bear witness by inviting people to church.
[9:05] SPEAKER_01: Uh, let the pastor, let the elders, let them do the hard work.
[9:09] SPEAKER_01: Um, just invite people.
[9:11] SPEAKER_01: Um, and and so I always found that to be very helpful when you're thinking about uh the work of the Great Commission being the duty of the church.
[9:18] SPEAKER_01: Even if you don't have all the language or all the knowledge, you feel deficient, uh, you could at least invite people to the place where the Great Commission sees its responsibility responsibility outworking, and that's in the local church and the denomination itself.
[9:34] SPEAKER_02: That's good.
[9:35] SPEAKER_02: So, secondly, here is number two is the initiative for carrying out the Great Commission belongs to the church at every court level.
[9:41] SPEAKER_02: And the assembly is responsible to encourage and promote the fulfillment of this ministry by the various courts.
[9:47] SPEAKER_02: There may not be much more to say here because we're gonna get into a lot of these details as we move forward, but um, it it is responsibility of the church to carry out the Great Commission, and that responsibility and initiative belongs not just to the top level, which we're talking about today, the the assembly, but to every level of the courts of the church.
[10:04] SPEAKER_02: Um and the assembly is responsible to encourage and promote this, which again we're gonna see worked out here in a little bit.
[10:10] SPEAKER_02: Um y'all good to go to three.
[10:14] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, the the work, number three, the work of the church as set forth in the great commission is one work being implemented at the General Assembly level through equally essential committees.
[10:25] SPEAKER_02: What's this about?
[10:26] SPEAKER_00: So the work of the Great Commission is not just the work of MTW um or of MA.
[10:32] SPEAKER_00: Um, in fact, uh one of the things you'll notice is if you use the PCA's curriculum for Sunday school, it's called Great Commission Publications.
[10:41] SPEAKER_00: Why?
[10:41] SPEAKER_00: Because we are making disciples of our children too.
[10:44] SPEAKER_00: Um, all of the agencies of the General Assembly are meant to aid in some way um the work of the Great Commission.
[10:50] SPEAKER_00: And it's almost like in your church, right?
[10:52] SPEAKER_00: You don't, uh somebody that is not upfront as one of the elders or as the pastor, you don't say you're you're not really involved in the work of the Great Commission.
[11:00] SPEAKER_00: And you say you need to support this work, prayer, um, helping with hospitality.
[11:04] SPEAKER_00: You have a role to play in this.
[11:05] SPEAKER_00: And the same thing with the uh the different committees.
[11:08] SPEAKER_00: Like if we have a committee, it has to somehow serve the purpose of the Great Commission.
[11:13] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, and in light of that, this uh this section really helps frame the mission of the church.
[11:18] SPEAKER_01: You're thinking of what is the purpose and work of the church?
[11:21] SPEAKER_01: Well, the the main work is uh living out the great commission in our congregations.
[11:28] SPEAKER_01: And so I I find it helpful.
[11:30] SPEAKER_01: The third point is that it it frames what the mission of our denomination is.
[11:35] SPEAKER_01: Uh, and that mission is to make disciples, to preach the Christ that died for his people, um, so that they might believe and have life in him.
[11:45] SPEAKER_01: Uh, that is the work of the church.
[11:46] SPEAKER_01: And so it frames the our agencies.
[11:48] SPEAKER_01: What are their, what's their purpose?
[11:50] SPEAKER_01: Well, what are they serving?
[11:51] SPEAKER_01: They're serving the mission of the church.
[11:53] SPEAKER_01: And we'll get into how that is fleshed out in these later sections uh of this very long point.
[11:59] SPEAKER_01: Um, but it is all grounded uh in in that mission.
[12:03] SPEAKER_01: And so when you th when I think of the Great Commission in the context of these first three points, I think of this section framing the church's mission.
[12:12] SPEAKER_02: That's good.
[12:14] SPEAKER_01: Number four.
[12:14] SPEAKER_02: Oh, go ahead, Jared.
[12:16] SPEAKER_01: Did you just say an amen?
[12:18] SPEAKER_01: I just said amen.
[12:19] SPEAKER_02: Oh, sorry.
[12:19] SPEAKER_01: It listened to the- Can you read sections um four to six together?
[12:24] SPEAKER_02: I will.
[12:24] SPEAKER_02: At Scott's request, here's sections four through six.
[12:27] SPEAKER_02: It is the responsibility of every member and every member congregation to support the whole work of the denomination as they be led and their conscience held captive to the word of God.
[12:36] SPEAKER_02: Number five, it is the responsibility of the General Assembly to evaluate needs and resources and to act on priorities for the most effective fulfillment of the Great Commission.
[12:45] SPEAKER_02: And number six, the church recognizes the right of individuals and congregations to labor through other agencies in fulfilling the Great Commission.
[12:53] SPEAKER_02: Scott, why did I read all four, all three of those together just now?
[12:56] SPEAKER_01: Oh, the first three, and then even four, five, and six, uh, thematically, I think, all work together well.
[13:02] SPEAKER_01: Um, we could have repeated ourselves through the first three points because of how closely they relate to each other, but these also relate to each other, and that is that church members themselves have a responsibility to support and maintain the work of the denomination.
[13:16] SPEAKER_01: I I don't know how often we think about that in regards to how informed or how supportive our people are of the PCA particularly, but uh as we see in these three points, four, five, and six, that there is an individual and congregational responsibility um to the denomination itself.
[13:38] SPEAKER_01: And so we support our local church, we support our regional church in the presbytery, and then we also support the denomination itself in the General Assembly.
[13:49] SPEAKER_01: Um, and and these are all bound together.
[13:53] SPEAKER_00: It probably should be noted that number six has a little bit of controversy about it, because it seems implied there that it independent boards, say independent mission agencies or uh parachurch organizations, uh, are also worth um the same sort of recognition here.
[14:11] SPEAKER_00: Um Smith uh actually just outright says paragraphs three through five contradict or is inconsistent with uh the sixth one there.
[14:19] SPEAKER_00: And that's partly because of his Southern Presbyterian convictions.
[14:23] SPEAKER_00: Um, in fact, they weren't too happy with uh somebody like Machin starting up an independent board.
[14:27] SPEAKER_00: They thought he shouldn't have done that.
[14:29] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so there's a little bit of controversy there on six on how you understand the role of parachurch and independent boards.
[14:36] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but uh you can see where the PCA uh fell out with that, especially in kind of its broader identity as uh part of evangelicalism in America and realizing we're working with other uh churches and other organizations uh that is also um doing the work of uh evangelism and other things.
[14:55] SPEAKER_02: To that point, under under number six, we should remind everybody that um it it is your right to support our podcast if you'd like to.
[15:01] SPEAKER_02: Um just in case you want to.
[15:03] SPEAKER_02: Uh we're we're an alternative agency.
[15:05] SPEAKER_02: I'm sure most of us have Venmo.
[15:06] SPEAKER_02: You can Apple Cache me if you need to, just uh, you know, get in touch, uh, whatever suits you.
[15:11] SPEAKER_02: I just uh Scott, which ones do we read together next?
[15:15] SPEAKER_02: Seven through ten.
[15:16] SPEAKER_02: You have them all lumped together.
[15:17] SPEAKER_02: All right.
[15:18] SPEAKER_01: I lumped them all together for your sake.
[15:20] SPEAKER_02: Thank you.
[15:21] SPEAKER_02: The assembly's committees are to serve and not to direct any church judicatories, they are not to establish policy, but rather execute policy established by the General Assembly.
[15:30] SPEAKER_02: The committees serve the church through the duties assigned by the General Assembly.
[15:34] SPEAKER_02: The Assembly's committees are to include proportionate representation of all presbyteries wherever possible.
[15:39] SPEAKER_02: And number 10, the committees are to be established on the basis of an equal number between teaching and ruling elders.
[15:45] SPEAKER_02: So we're gonna get into the list of uh committees and agencies here shortly, but to start off with, they're they're sort of telling us that the committees serve at the pleasure of the General Assembly.
[15:55] SPEAKER_02: They don't they don't direct policy, but rather they they execute what's been given to them.
[15:59] SPEAKER_02: Uh, I don't know if I could do it off the top of my head, but maybe one of y'all can can remind us what's happened lately with um, I think it was MTW either two or three years ago, um, with the their policy manual and how we kind of we we send something back or we had them change something once they brought it to the GA.
[16:16] SPEAKER_01: I think there are three examples in recent history, uh at least.
[16:19] SPEAKER_01: Um, one is the M MN MTW policy manual change that came before the assembly.
[16:25] SPEAKER_01: Another is the RUF affiliation agreement that is currently being revised.
[16:30] SPEAKER_01: I believe there's a new revision actually that's going to be considered at the assembly.
[16:35] SPEAKER_01: So we're gonna have a new new affiliation agreement um because it has been reconsidered and I think massaged, and I think it's gonna be a good one.
[16:44] SPEAKER_01: Um, if I if I can trust the sources that have told me, uh it's good to be pre-pre pre-prepared.
[16:50] SPEAKER_01: So yeah, pre-pre pre-prepared for General Assembly.
[16:53] SPEAKER_01: Uh, and then the last one was at the last General Assembly with Overture 7, which dealt with what was a material change in policy that must be reported to the assembly.
[17:03] SPEAKER_01: Um, it was interesting watching our stated clerk uh run around the assembly because he assigned it, I think, to every um coc committee of commissioners to consider.
[17:13] SPEAKER_01: And so he hopped around all of the various uh agency meetings um with committee of commissioners in order to um speak to that amendment.
[17:23] SPEAKER_01: And so uh that doubt that we spent a lot of time, a lot more time on what seemed like a procedurally boring overture, um, but it was dealing with what sort of changes should be reported, if there's any that is according to policy to the assembly.
[17:38] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so I think these three examples fall within what we were just reading here, where the assembly, uh, these agencies serve the assembly.
[17:48] SPEAKER_01: They don't direct the assembly, they don't have authority in and of themselves.
[17:52] SPEAKER_01: They carry out the mission and the work that the assembly directs them to do.
[17:56] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I think it came up in one of those debates where um I think it was David Coffin actually got up to the mic and noted the fact that the General Assembly had to approve a change in um the SJC's manual, that they set the policy for the Standing Judicial Commission.
[18:12] SPEAKER_00: The Standing Judicial Commission even was not over the Assembly, it was um at serving at the best of the Assembly.
[18:19] SPEAKER_00: And so I I think that's an important thing to see there, that it's not inappropriate for the General Assembly to tell agencies what their policies are and how it is that they are to function, not down to every detail of exactly how you do housing allowances and insurance requests and things like that for employees, but to to big policy type things.
[18:38] SPEAKER_00: I think the other thing that's interesting down there is um the representation at General Assembly.
[18:45] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, you can see they did not want this just to be a regional or just controlled by one area of the country.
[18:51] SPEAKER_00: They when we're looking at um agencies um and the people that are going on there, because we'll talk about nominating committee in the next few days or next few weeks, um, that there is some sort of mind that's there to say we need to have something that's geographically diverse, that we actually have um many uh different presbyteries participating in the work of the agencies and the committees of uh the church, and even that parody that's that's noted there between teaching and ruling elders, so that our um uh our committees are are balanced in a lot of different ways, and there's a lot of different input that it's not just what uh the northeast wants to do or what the southeast wants to do, um, or just what teaching elders want to do, um, that they're getting the input of of the church in those actual committees.
[19:40] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, and we see that there is a parody, there is a parody in in number 10 where it's not merely um trying to balance, it must be balanced.
[19:50] SPEAKER_01: And so there is equal number teaching elders and ruling elders on all of our agencies and boards.
[19:57] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so it is a helpful reminder in order to preserve perhaps the the broader um the the broader unity of the church, where it's just not one part of the church, as Jared said a moment ago, ruling, um, but it also involves the laity heavily.
[20:16] SPEAKER_01: And you think of your ruling elders, um, not all Napark denominations have their laity serving well within the work of the assembly, ruling elders I'm speaking of here.
[20:27] SPEAKER_01: And even in the old mainline, this wasn't the case, where the agencies and boards were completely controlled by the clergy.
[20:35] SPEAKER_01: There is a clericalism in those denominations.
[20:38] SPEAKER_01: And so the PCA safeguards that by ensuring the proper role of the ruling elder within the life of the church, not merely locally, not merely regionally, but also uh denominationally.
[20:51] SPEAKER_02: Number 11 in this list points us to the responsibility of the nominating committee.
[20:57] SPEAKER_02: I'm gonna read it.
[20:58] SPEAKER_02: Um maybe there's a couple of comments we'll make, but just as a reminder, we're gonna get into nominating committee in detail with Jared in a few weeks when we come around to it in our GA preview material.
[21:11] SPEAKER_02: And number 11 reads a nominating committee shall be comprised of one representative elected by each presbytery in the following manner.
[21:17] SPEAKER_02: Each presbytery shall be assigned to a class by the stated clerk based on its date of formation.
[21:23] SPEAKER_02: The members shall serve in classes of three-year terms, alternating between ruling and teaching elders.
[21:28] SPEAKER_02: When necessary, unexpired terms shall be filled by an elder of the same class, teaching or ruling.
[21:33] SPEAKER_02: This committee is to present all nominations for which it is responsible to the next meeting of the assembly from a slate of men nominated by the presbyteries.
[21:41] SPEAKER_02: Presbyteries shall utilize the nominating forms provided by the stated clerk for their nominations.
[21:46] SPEAKER_02: Each presbytery may present one teaching elder and one ruling elder for each committee or agency.
[21:51] SPEAKER_02: In addition to nominees for expired terms, a committee shall nominate for each permanent committee one ruling and one teaching elder as alternates to fill any vacancies that may occur during the year.
[22:00] SPEAKER_02: Each alternate should attend each meeting and fill any vacancy necessary to meet a quorum.
[22:04] SPEAKER_02: In addition to the new nominees from the presbyteries, alternates not assuming any vacancies during a year will be automatically considered by the nominating committee as candidates for nomination to that same committee.
[22:15] SPEAKER_02: This seems to be much larger than just a principle.
[22:19] SPEAKER_02: There's lots of detailed rules in these paragraphs.
[22:21] SPEAKER_02: But Jared, I think I'll just ask you and then we'll keep moving on.
[22:24] SPEAKER_02: Anything you want to say here before we get into the deeper discussion in a few more weeks?
[22:29] SPEAKER_00: I do think one thing that is worth noting here is it answers the question of uh maybe the Monty Python question, you know, uh saying you're king, who voted for you?
[22:39] SPEAKER_00: Um the people that are on the committees um do have to go through a process in which the General Assembly votes on them and chooses them.
[22:48] SPEAKER_00: Uh the first part of that being the nominating committee, then the nominating committee slate being voted on at General Assembly that is very open for floor nominations and should be.
[22:58] SPEAKER_00: Um and that enables us to have another layer of control and check on those that are in those committees.
[23:05] SPEAKER_00: Um, hopefully we're choosing people that are the most qualified, uh, that can give them some uh good perspectives.
[23:12] SPEAKER_00: And uh we'll get a little bit more into exactly how that happens.
[23:14] SPEAKER_00: But this is supposed to be a safeguard again.
[23:17] SPEAKER_00: Um, if we were an episcopal church, it would just be assigned by some archbishop somewhere of who's in these committees, and it's just one person's decision.
[23:25] SPEAKER_00: But this uh allows the General Assembly, even with as many people that show up as commissioners, uh, to have a role in saying who is on those committees.
[23:34] SPEAKER_02: Thank you.
[23:34] SPEAKER_02: Hey, Scott, while I'm reading number 12, can you go find number 15 and put it in our document?
[23:39] SPEAKER_02: Because I think it's missing here at the end.
[23:42] SPEAKER_01: Okay.
[23:42] SPEAKER_02: Here's number 12.
[23:44] SPEAKER_02: Y'all will probably want to get some popcorn and settle in.
[23:46] SPEAKER_02: Maybe you want to take a nap.
[23:47] SPEAKER_02: The assembly permanent committees are the administrative committee of general assembly, committee on discipleship ministries, committee on mission to North America, Committee on Mission to the World, and Committee on Reformed University Fellowship.
[23:58] SPEAKER_02: The Administrative Committee of General Assembly shall consist of 20 members, 11 members in classes elected through the standard nomination and election procedure, one member each from the following program committees or agencies.
[24:12] SPEAKER_02: Committee on Discipleship Ministries, Covenant College, Covenant Theological Seminary, Mission North America, Mission to the World, PCA Foundation, PCA Retirement and Benefits, Reformed University Fellowship, Ridgehaven Conference Center.
[24:24] SPEAKER_02: The 11 members at large shall serve a term of four years.
[24:27] SPEAKER_02: The chairman of the administrative committee shall be one of its members at large.
[24:31] SPEAKER_02: Each program committee and agency shall designate its member each year at the last meeting of the committee or board before the meeting of General Assembly.
[24:40] SPEAKER_02: The chief administrative officers of the program committees and agencies may attend any meeting of the administrative committee.
[24:45] SPEAKER_02: They shall be entitled to the privilege of the floor, but shall not have a vote and must be excluded when an executive session is called.
[24:52] SPEAKER_02: CDM, MA, MTW, and RUF shall consist of 15 men divided into five classes of three men each, with two men being TEs and one R E, or two men being REs and one TE on alternate years, elected to serve five-year terms.
[25:10] SPEAKER_02: CDM, MA, MTW, and RUF shall have one ruling and one teaching elder as alternates to fill any vacancy that may occur during the year.
[25:17] SPEAKER_02: Persons who have served for a full term or for at least two years of a partial term on one of the assembly's permanent committees or agencies shall not be eligible for re-election to an assembly committee until one year has elapsed.
[25:29] SPEAKER_02: Exceptions may be permitted in agency bylaws approved by the assembly.
[25:33] SPEAKER_02: If you all notice me chuckling a little bit towards the beginning of that, it's because both of my co-hosts got up and walked away when I started reading number 12.
[25:40] SPEAKER_02: Uh, this is a long one.
[25:41] SPEAKER_02: It uh it's saying just a few a handful of things really about uh how you serve on these permanent committees and agencies.
[25:49] SPEAKER_02: The biggest thing in this chapter that we refer to most often is the list of our permanent committees and agencies.
[25:55] SPEAKER_02: Um guys, is there anything here that stands out to y'all that we need to point out to our listeners?
[26:01] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, there is a bit of a distinction here between committees and agencies.
[26:06] SPEAKER_00: And um, some of the rules that you'll see in here for committees, if it doesn't say agency, doesn't apply.
[26:12] SPEAKER_00: So actually, earlier we were talking about proportional representation between TEs and REs.
[26:17] SPEAKER_00: That's true for committees.
[26:19] SPEAKER_00: It's not always true for agencies.
[26:20] SPEAKER_00: So um the people who serve on uh the boards for Covenant College and Covenant Theological Seminary don't necessarily follow that.
[26:30] SPEAKER_00: Um now I think one of the reasons we may call them agencies is because the Southern Presbyterian tradition really hates the idea of boards, of giving too much uh power to a group of people.
[26:42] SPEAKER_00: Anytime that we've talked about doing a commission, whether it's the standing judicial commission that had a bunch of debate, or whether it's even a commission to write the letter that we had at the 50th General Assembly, um, there there are some uh warning, at least yellow flags that go up for some people, because they don't like the idea of somebody doing the work for the General Assembly.
[27:02] SPEAKER_00: They want the General Assembly to do that work and be able to sign off on it.
[27:06] SPEAKER_02: I like 13.
[27:07] SPEAKER_02: The General Assembly establishes personnel salaries after hearing recommendations from the appropriate committee.
[27:14] SPEAKER_02: That's it.
[27:15] SPEAKER_00: That's helpful.
[27:16] SPEAKER_00: It's helpful that we know that there's not somebody that's just passing a motion in a secret board meeting to give themselves a million dollar salary and that the general assembly doesn't see those books.
[27:26] SPEAKER_02: Amen.
[27:27] SPEAKER_02: Number 14.
[27:29] SPEAKER_02: This is dealing with the theological examining committee.
[27:32] SPEAKER_02: The assembly shall elect a six-man theological examining committee, three teaching elders and three ruling elders of three classes of two men each.
[27:40] SPEAKER_02: Nominations for this committee will be presented by the assembly's nominating committee.
[27:44] SPEAKER_02: This committee shall examine all first and second level administrative officers of committees, boards, and agencies, and those acting temporarily in these positions who are being recommended for the first time employment.
[27:55] SPEAKER_02: They're to be examined in the areas of Christian experience, theology, sacraments, church government, Bible content, church history, and the history of the PCA.
[28:04] SPEAKER_02: No person will begin work or move on the field without prior examination and approval by the General Assembly's theological examining committee.
[28:11] SPEAKER_02: No first level administrative officer will be presented to the assembly for election who has not met the approval of this committee.
[28:18] SPEAKER_00: So Ben and I both serve on this sort of a committee at the uh presbytery level.
[28:25] SPEAKER_02: I was not sure where you were going there for a second.
[28:27] SPEAKER_02: Sorry.
[28:28] SPEAKER_00: I did what?
[28:29] SPEAKER_00: What did I yes?
[28:30] SPEAKER_00: Sorry.
[28:30] SPEAKER_02: Sorry.
[28:31] SPEAKER_00: So there is this committee that exists at the General Assembly level.
[28:35] SPEAKER_00: Uh, however, I think they really serve as a uh a committee that passes along things.
[28:41] SPEAKER_00: Um, you'll find this report when somebody becomes a new coordinator and you'll see in there the exceptions that they take.
[28:48] SPEAKER_00: But I don't ever remember a theological examining committee like recommending against a coordinator.
[28:54] SPEAKER_00: They'll just pass along the information and let the GA make the decision on um these are the sort of exceptions they have.
[29:00] SPEAKER_00: This is we've examined them to make sure that there's no discipline going on or something like that.
[29:05] SPEAKER_00: Um and so yeah, they have a they have a similar role, but I think they're actually a little bit more restrained than the way they are, probably in some presbyteries.
[29:14] SPEAKER_01: How difficult are those exams on the TEC?
[29:20] SPEAKER_00: Excellent question.
[29:21] SPEAKER_00: We can ask uh Rich Leno, he chaired it at one point.
[29:24] SPEAKER_02: So Oh, there's number 15.
[29:27] SPEAKER_02: It showed up in my notes.
[29:29] SPEAKER_02: All business shall ordinarily come to the floor of the assembly for final action through committees of commissioners, except reports of the SJC, the CCB, the Committee on RPR, and the NOMCOM and ad interim committees, which shall come directly to the assembly.
[29:43] SPEAKER_02: Sorry, I said a lot of things there very quickly just because we're probably gonna address this in our very next episode.
[29:49] SPEAKER_02: Uh the these things typically are are what you see in the docket for the General Assembly, are a lot of these names, a lot of the committee of commissioners, uh, because this is how business gets to the floor of the assembly.
[29:59] SPEAKER_02: And so we're gonna deal with this uh in particular over the next probably one, two, three, four episodes uh coming up.
[30:06] SPEAKER_02: So, but I see Jared may be poised to jump in here.
[30:09] SPEAKER_00: So oh, I I just think it's worth noting this is pretty unique to PCA polity that we have a committee that meets at General Assembly to review the work of another committee of the General Assembly.
[30:22] SPEAKER_00: It's just another layer of review and control that um we really try to make sure that committees don't run away uh on their own on something and that they they have accountability to the GA.
[30:32] SPEAKER_00: This is a great provision.
[30:33] SPEAKER_02: Some of y'all probably wondering why we didn't mention overtures, and this is just a little bit of trivia.
[30:38] SPEAKER_02: Overtures is technically a committee of commissioners, so it's it's included in that phrase there.
[30:43] SPEAKER_02: Um and we'll get into that uh next week.
[30:47] SPEAKER_02: All right, guys.
[30:48] SPEAKER_02: We're uh well, we're this far in, we're only in 14-2, so we should probably cruise.
[30:55] SPEAKER_02: Um 14-2 deals with uh meetings and the membership of the assembly and reads like this the General Assembly, which is a permanent court, shall meet at least annually upon its own adjournment.
[31:07] SPEAKER_02: It shall consist of all teaching elders in good standing with their presbyteries and ruling elders as elected by their session.
[31:13] SPEAKER_02: Each congregation is entitled to two ruling elder representative representatives for the first 350 community members or fraction thereof, and one additional ruling elder for each additional 500 commuting members or fraction thereof?
[31:26] SPEAKER_02: So um, right away we see uh we have to meet at least once a year, and uh pretty much very, very similar to um to presbytery.
[31:37] SPEAKER_02: In fact, I think this is identical to presbytery, isn't it?
[31:39] SPEAKER_02: Uh every teaching elder and two ruling elders from each congregation as a starting point and moving on up.
[31:44] SPEAKER_02: My question to you guys is do ruling elders not have to be in good standing in order to be elected to serve at General Assembly?
[31:51] SPEAKER_02: Because it seems to say that teaching elders have to be in good standing, but it doesn't make the same specification for the ruling elder.
[31:57] SPEAKER_00: I think it assumes that a ruling elder will not be elected by their session to go to GA unless we're gonna be able to do that.
[32:02] SPEAKER_02: You know what assuming does, Jared?
[32:05] SPEAKER_02: Uh anything here?
[32:07] SPEAKER_02: Scott, you've got a lot of green writing in our notes.
[32:09] SPEAKER_02: Do you want to spell anything out?
[32:15] SPEAKER_02: You can say no.
[32:17] SPEAKER_01: I guess.
[32:18] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think at uh 14.2, it deals with just the general requirements.
[32:22] SPEAKER_01: And so um we see that as the court gets larger, the requirements for how often they meet get smaller.
[32:31] SPEAKER_01: And so at the sessional level, we're called to meet quarterly.
[32:35] SPEAKER_01: At the presbytery level, we meet at least twice a year, and then the general assembly once a year.
[32:40] SPEAKER_01: I I think most churches, though, uh they meet more than this, and presbyteries meet more than this, but the assembly typically does not.
[32:49] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so my my session meets once a month, my presbytery meets uh three times a year.
[32:55] SPEAKER_01: I think your guys' meet quarterly, and then our assembly just meets uh once a year.
[33:01] SPEAKER_01: The membership of the assembly, as you've already talked about, um, is outlined similar to the presbytery level, where it's all TEs, but RE's are two from every church plus one for every 500 members.
[33:14] SPEAKER_01: Um, and our assemblies tend to be the uh very large.
[33:18] SPEAKER_01: Um the past few years they've been over 2,000.
[33:21] SPEAKER_01: Um, they could be even larger than 2,000.
[33:24] SPEAKER_01: Um, I think I was looking at the Wikipedia numbers of our denomination, how many pastors, how many churches.
[33:30] SPEAKER_01: And if you take the baseline of that, there could be over 9,000 people at General Assembly, but our participation is much lower than that.
[33:38] SPEAKER_01: And even typically before the revoice controversy, I mean, we were at 12 to 1,500.
[33:44] SPEAKER_01: And so the assembly has gotten larger in the past five years than it has ever been.
[33:49] SPEAKER_01: Um, if you look back at those uh historical records, but we have about 5,000 pastors, and if you go by the numbers on the website or Wikipedia, we could have around 4,000 ruling elders if everyone came and showed up.
[34:04] SPEAKER_01: What's a Wikipedia?
[34:07] SPEAKER_01: We bought and paid for.
[34:09] SPEAKER_01: They are a sponsor of today's episode of Polity Matters.
[34:12] SPEAKER_01: Their segue to our sponsor.
[34:15] SPEAKER_00: Just a minor note.
[34:17] SPEAKER_00: It was a almost a minor controversy in 2020 because the General Assembly was delayed.
[34:23] SPEAKER_00: Uh, so we did not meet at least once annually in 2020.
[34:26] SPEAKER_00: And so this was where reality bumped up against our requirements that there was nowhere to meet.
[34:32] SPEAKER_00: Nobody would accommodate us uh for a gathering that large.
[34:36] SPEAKER_00: Um, so it does say shall, but um, the question is what if you just can't?
[34:42] SPEAKER_00: And so we encountered that in 2020.
[34:44] SPEAKER_01: Are you sending a complaint up?
[34:46] SPEAKER_01: It sounds like it.
[34:48] SPEAKER_01: There might be a statute of limitations issue.
[34:50] SPEAKER_01: It might be too long.
[34:52] SPEAKER_01: We had too long to complain.
[34:54] SPEAKER_01: I'm curious about 14.3 though.
[34:57] SPEAKER_02: Well, this is what it says.
[34:58] SPEAKER_02: When an emergency shall require a meeting of the General Assembly earlier than the time to which it stands adjourned, the moderator shall issue a call for a special meeting at the request or with a concurrence of 10% of the commissioners who had seats in the assembly at its preceding meeting, of whom at least 10 shall be teaching elders and at least 10 ruling elders, representing at least one third of the presbyteries.
[35:19] SPEAKER_02: Should the moderator for any reason uh be unable to act, the stated clerk shall under the same requirements issue the call.
[35:26] SPEAKER_02: The members of the special meeting shall be the commissioners elected to the preceding meeting of the assembly or their alternates.
[35:32] SPEAKER_02: A session, however, shall have the right to elect a commissioner or alternate in the stead of one who had died since the last meeting of the assembly, or of one who has notified the moderator of the session of his inability to serve.
[35:45] SPEAKER_02: Notice of the special meeting shall be sent not less than 20 days in advance to each commissioner and to the moderator of each presbytery.
[35:52] SPEAKER_02: In the notice, the purpose of the meeting is to be stated and no other business is to be transacted.
[35:58] SPEAKER_02: I'm sorry.
[36:01] SPEAKER_02: But if somebody died, or if there's another reason, sorry, that just got me tickled.
[36:08] SPEAKER_02: Um, Scott, what was so uh what's so intriguing to you about this paragraph that you were eager to hear it?
[36:13] SPEAKER_01: Oh, I'm eager to hear it because I I mean this probably is the least used provision in all the BCO, I'd guess.
[36:20] SPEAKER_01: Uh, has there ever been a meeting called?
[36:23] SPEAKER_01: Um, yeah, I just I want to know, Jared, uh, with your uh polity expertise, what such a reason would warrant the usage of 14-3?
[36:35] SPEAKER_00: So um the PCA has not done this, but the ARP has done this in the past few years.
[36:41] SPEAKER_00: They had a controversy regarding uh Erskine and restructuring it, and they actually had another called meeting uh during the year for the general or for their synod to come together um to uh address some issues that have come up with that.
[36:56] SPEAKER_00: So they thought it was uh worth calling a special uh emergency meeting because of an issue in their seminary.
[37:03] SPEAKER_00: Um for us, I mean, we have uh standing judicial commission, we have uh agencies and commissions and committees that um are acting through the year.
[37:14] SPEAKER_00: I don't know what would constitute an emergency that you would have to have the General Assembly come back.
[37:20] SPEAKER_02: I mean, it what if just you know, what if a stated clerk passed away or something like that?
[37:26] SPEAKER_01: I mean, would we have to come back to elect somebody to jump into that position, or do we have I think there would be like what we did with um Brian Chapel, there'd be a clerk pro tem elected by the AC and they would serve for the eight months or whatever until the assembly would convene and elect a permanent position.
[37:45] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I I just don't see how this provision would ever be used.
[37:48] SPEAKER_01: I I I just don't, I mean, maybe it's because we're so bureaucratic in the PCA, where we have such a um we have so we have so many procedures and organizations doing things that I just don't see why I couldn't wait 10 months even.
[38:04] SPEAKER_01: Um maybe I guess if all of our 403B accounts exploded at once or something, where we all became impoverished instantaneously.
[38:13] SPEAKER_01: Uh I just don't see what would warrant uh the usage.
[38:19] SPEAKER_02: But there is a warrant for this paragraph, simply being that we had we're paralleling the other courts, right?
[38:24] SPEAKER_02: The all the courts have a mechanism to meet if they need to.
[38:28] SPEAKER_02: Um and so we have we have it if if we need to.
[38:32] SPEAKER_01: Can you imagine being called?
[38:33] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[38:34] SPEAKER_01: Oh man.
[38:34] SPEAKER_01: Like if we found out today that uh at the end of March we're gonna have a general assembly, and you're only invited if you were at the previous assembly.
[38:45] SPEAKER_02: You know what that means is that we would get two ice cream socials this year.
[38:48] SPEAKER_02: That's what it would mean.
[38:49] SPEAKER_02: I'm so excited.
[38:52] SPEAKER_02: See y'all in March.
[38:53] SPEAKER_00: Is that all right?
[38:57] SPEAKER_02: 14.4, pretty straightforward.
[38:59] SPEAKER_02: Each commissioner before his name shall be enrolled as a member of the assembly shall produce appropriate credentials.
[39:05] SPEAKER_02: Uh I don't remember ever having to show my credentials at the registration desk, except all I have to do is tell them my name, and then they hand me all the stuff that goes to Ben Ratliff.
[39:14] SPEAKER_00: So they need to have photo ID there.
[39:15] SPEAKER_02: I mean, if I if I tell them my name's Creed Bratton, do I get his stuff next year?
[39:19] SPEAKER_02: Or I mean, how's this gonna work?
[39:21] SPEAKER_01: I think they they develop this out of your registration online.
[39:25] SPEAKER_01: You give your church name, your Presbyterian name, and I think that's all at least in my mind, they cross-tabulate it with like making sure it's accurate.
[39:33] SPEAKER_01: But if they do that, that's you know, they could do that if they do.
[39:36] SPEAKER_01: That's another question.
[39:38] SPEAKER_01: That's what I would do.
[39:39] SPEAKER_02: You have an answer for everything, it's very frustrating.
[39:42] SPEAKER_01: Well, you know, that's what I would do.
[39:44] SPEAKER_01: I mean, it I mean, photo ID, I guess, would be helpful, or maybe we have to bring our like TE cards, you know, that we pay registration fees, and you can't be a commissioner unless you pay your TE fee.
[39:57] SPEAKER_02: You're gonna you're gonna enforce somebody to pay for something.
[40:00] SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
[40:01] SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
[40:03] SPEAKER_02: Or we could have a conversation about that.
[40:05] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think many would support TEs only coming to assembly if they paid their TE fees.
[40:10] SPEAKER_02: Oh, there's so much irony.
[40:12] SPEAKER_02: Oh man.
[40:14] SPEAKER_02: 14.5 deals with quorum.
[40:16] SPEAKER_02: Any 100 of these commissioners, of whom half shall be teaching elders and half ruling elders, representing at least one third of the presbyteries being met on the day and at the place appointed shall be a quorum in the transaction of business.
[40:29] SPEAKER_02: So, in order to do business, we've got to have these numbers met.
[40:32] SPEAKER_00: Uh at least 50 ruling elders.
[40:36] SPEAKER_02: Did anybody do any fancy math on this?
[40:38] SPEAKER_02: You did some math on something earlier, Scott.
[40:39] SPEAKER_02: Was there any any fun way to think about these numbers, or is it just pretty straightforward?
[40:44] SPEAKER_01: Uh well, since it's a bottom floor kind of thing, uh, it's not too difficult to reach.
[40:50] SPEAKER_01: Um, what was the year with the worst amount of RE participation?
[40:53] SPEAKER_01: Do you guys know?
[40:54] SPEAKER_01: I'm gonna look that up while you guys talk.
[40:56] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, while y'all are looking for that.
[40:58] SPEAKER_02: Um so does this mean that that 50 is the minimum for ruling elders?
[41:03] SPEAKER_02: So you it has to be a hundred.
[41:06] SPEAKER_02: Half of them have to be this and half of them have to be that.
[41:09] SPEAKER_02: And so anything beyond that on either side is inconsequential.
[41:14] SPEAKER_00: To being able to unless you don't have a third of the presbyteries showing up, right?
[41:18] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, which every every now and then, if if you look at who showed up, there's a couple of presbyteries that didn't have anybody that showed up.
[41:25] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but usually you don't have 20 or 30 presbyteries that haven't showed up.
[41:29] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[41:31] SPEAKER_02: Scott, should we linger long enough for you to find that information?
[41:34] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, so it seems that the lowest so far ruling elder participation has been 216.
[41:42] SPEAKER_01: And it has one closer than a lot of and that was in the early days of the PCA.
[41:47] SPEAKER_01: So even in the like 20 2000s and 2010s, there have been around at least 300.
[41:53] SPEAKER_01: But since the revoice um movement um sparked controversy, there has been almost double 300 every year, and so there was a great uptick in participation over the last um three or four, four or five years.
[42:10] SPEAKER_01: Now it's 700, which is more than the TEs uh involved within the first many general assemblies.
[42:19] SPEAKER_02: Well, as we get into 14.6, that's another one with with a list.
[42:23] SPEAKER_02: How do you guys want to handle this?
[42:24] SPEAKER_02: Um you mean to read the whole thing and we can touch on whatever stands out to us, or do we want to portion this off?
[42:30] SPEAKER_02: You don't you don't have them separated for me, Scott.
[42:32] SPEAKER_02: I don't know what to do.
[42:33] SPEAKER_01: I didn't get I I debated whether we would just skip this whole section, but maybe we should learn about the assembly, the power of the assembly.
[42:40] SPEAKER_01: I would just read uh we could do one by one, I guess.
[42:44] SPEAKER_01: Only seven or so.
[42:46] SPEAKER_02: There's only there's only K of them, so uh nine, whatever.
[42:52] SPEAKER_02: The General Assembly shall have power, A, to receive and issue all appeals, references, and complaints regularly brought before it from the lower courts to bear testimony against error and doctrine and immorality and practice injuriously affecting the church to decide in all controversies respecting doctrine and discipline.
[43:10] SPEAKER_02: We've heard this language before.
[43:12] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, from the Presbytery chapter.
[43:13] SPEAKER_02: Go ahead, Jared.
[43:15] SPEAKER_00: Some of this is done by the SJC, the complaints and appeals and discipline type matters, but some of this could also be done by pronouncements or study papers.
[43:25] SPEAKER_00: So it's not exclusively the SJC that is in view in A.
[43:29] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, B B keeps the thoughts going to give its advice and instruction in conformity with the constitution in all cases submitted to it.
[43:36] SPEAKER_02: Uh same kind of thing there.
[43:38] SPEAKER_02: Everybody, everybody goes.
[43:39] SPEAKER_00: Sometimes it's a CCB.
[43:40] SPEAKER_00: Uh there'll be a question that's asked to them about um how do we do this?
[43:44] SPEAKER_00: And that actually is part of what we have for information and going through the BCO of how they've answered those questions in the past.
[43:50] unknown: Yeah.
[43:53] SPEAKER_02: C to review the records of the Presbyteries to take care that the lower courts observe the constitution to redress whatever.
[44:00] SPEAKER_02: They may have done contrary to order.
[44:02] SPEAKER_02: This is Review Presbytery Records, RPR, as you may hear it constantly referred to.
[44:06] SPEAKER_02: Uh, we're gonna deal with this in some degree in the next several weeks.
[44:09] SPEAKER_02: We'll talk to somebody about RPR, and um you'll learn more about it then, I suppose.
[44:15] SPEAKER_02: D, to devise measures for promoting the prosperity and enlargement of the church.
[44:20] SPEAKER_02: Uh and E, I'll put we'll pair these together to erect new presbyteries and unite and divide those which were erected with their consent.
[44:28] SPEAKER_02: Uh so the the the enlargement of the church, uh particularly related to presbyteries um and the the creation of them or the the unification or division of them.
[44:38] SPEAKER_02: Um we see this pretty often, actually.
[44:41] SPEAKER_02: There's even an overture coming this year, not not to split um uh presbyteries necessarily, but Covenant Presbytery and Mississippi are are shifting some of their property between the two of them.
[44:52] SPEAKER_02: And so this is similar there, at least.
[44:54] SPEAKER_02: Um, I can't remember the last time that something was split.
[44:57] SPEAKER_02: I believe that uh Hills and Plains was created by merging two portions of two separate presbyteries together because I know Covenant lost a chunk of northwestern Arkansas when Hills and Plains was created, so you see this happen from time to time, and the growing number of presbyteries obviously indicates that as well.
[45:14] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I believe uh uh Columbus Metro is a split from Ohio, Ohio Presbytery, and didn't like PD Presbytery split from like Eastern Carolina or one of those presbyteries.
[45:27] SPEAKER_01: So it does happen.
[45:28] SPEAKER_01: Um, I think there's guidelines um that we were what did we read those last week?
[45:33] SPEAKER_01: Um where how many churches should be involved?
[45:36] SPEAKER_01: A lot of our presbyteries are larger than they need to be.
[45:39] SPEAKER_01: Um, while some of them are, including maybe my own, smaller than they need to be.
[45:44] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so uh that's dealing with all of this.
[45:48] SPEAKER_02: Going out of F to uh to institute and superintend the agencies necessary in the general work of evangelization to appoint ministers of such labors as fall under its jurisdiction.
[45:58] SPEAKER_02: Uh, so that first part is something we've already talked about, dealing with agencies uh in the in the movement of the Great Commission and the work of the Great Commission uh under the church.
[46:06] SPEAKER_02: But what about this second line here, you guys?
[46:07] SPEAKER_02: Uh uh maybe you all know of something that exists in this uh point that appointing ministers of such labors as fall under its jurisdiction, it seems uh maybe strange to a listener to hear that the GA can appoint a minister to a certain labor in its jurisdiction.
[46:23] SPEAKER_02: What could this be referring to?
[46:25] SPEAKER_00: Those that are serving those agencies, um, those that need to have uh a call that are working outside of those presbyteries.
[46:33] SPEAKER_02: So, like um, I mean, I'm just so our stated clerk is a teaching elder, he would have he'd be a minister working.
[46:38] SPEAKER_02: Um you I'm trying to think the the the head of RUF for a long time, a couple of them were teaching elders.
[46:46] SPEAKER_02: Right now it's a ruling elder.
[46:47] SPEAKER_02: Um is that kind of what you're referring to?
[46:50] SPEAKER_02: Those types of positions.
[46:52] SPEAKER_02: Yes.
[46:53] SPEAKER_02: Both of my guys are looking at me like I'm an idiot.
[46:55] SPEAKER_02: So we're gonna go on.
[46:56] SPEAKER_02: F.
[46:56] SPEAKER_02: Nope.
[46:57] SPEAKER_02: G.
[46:58] SPEAKER_02: To suppress schismatical contentions and disputations according to the rules provided therefore.
[47:04] SPEAKER_02: Might be the most pretentious sounding sentence in this whole chapter.
[47:08] SPEAKER_02: Anybody?
[47:09] SPEAKER_02: Scott, you have a bow tie on.
[47:11] SPEAKER_02: You seem appropriately uh poised to deal with this sentence.
[47:14] SPEAKER_02: Yes.
[47:15] SPEAKER_02: Uh-huh.
[47:15] SPEAKER_01: It is the duty of the disputations.
[47:18] SPEAKER_01: It is the duty of the assembly to maintain the peace and purity of the church and to warn off all schismatic contentions within its assembly.
[47:27] SPEAKER_01: And I think that includes not only at the largest court, but I think that may means encouraging and fostering and maintaining the peace and purity in the regional courts as well.
[47:38] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so it is to suppress schismatic behavior.
[47:41] SPEAKER_01: Um, if you look at a Presbyterian church history map, you it's like you the um dispensational Baptist rapture maps or whatever, the end times maps, they're very convoluted, and you see mergers and splits all over our little part of the kingdom.
[47:58] SPEAKER_01: And so Presbyterians are known to split and unite.
[48:02] SPEAKER_01: That's one of the things we often do.
[48:04] SPEAKER_01: Um, but this provision seeks to suppress the schismatic behaviors that often lead to those sorts of splits.
[48:12] SPEAKER_02: H to enumer, uh nope, to receive under its jurisdiction with the consent of three-fourths of the presbyteries, other ecclesiastical bodies whose organization is conformed to the doctrine and order of this church, to authorize presbyteries to exercise similar power in receiving bodies suited to become constituents of those courts and lying within their geographical bounds, respectively.
[48:34] SPEAKER_00: Uh so I guess the last is why my church is in the PCA.
[48:38] SPEAKER_00: There we go.
[48:38] SPEAKER_00: Because of joining and receiving of uh the RPCES.
[48:43] SPEAKER_02: I kind of like for this too.
[48:45] SPEAKER_01: Oh well I I I wonder if in today's climate this provision will ever be used again.
[48:51] SPEAKER_01: It the in the 80s it perhaps was different.
[48:54] SPEAKER_01: I I just don't see three-fourths, three-quarters of presbyteries approving a merger.
[49:01] SPEAKER_01: I don't know.
[49:02] SPEAKER_01: Maybe it's the partisan age in my mind that if we had the OPC extend invitation or the EPC or the ARP or any other NAPARC denomination, like who would we receive that would have three-fourths consent from our regional presbyteries?
[49:17] SPEAKER_00: There are a few very small denominations in the uh in NAPARC um that perhaps it wouldn't change the nature of uh the denomination much, but that's why the OPC and the PCA have never gotten together.
[49:29] SPEAKER_00: There's trepidation on one side or the other that it's going to change the PCA or it's gonna change the OPC.
[49:35] SPEAKER_00: And so that's why really the only example you have of this that's major is the RPCES.
[49:41] SPEAKER_02: I is uh fairly clear to superintend the affairs of the whole church.
[49:45] SPEAKER_02: So it seems rather broad to me.
[49:48] SPEAKER_02: General.
[49:49] SPEAKER_02: Is this where we stick anything that doesn't fit somewhere else?
[49:53] SPEAKER_02: Just to correspond with other churches, to unite with other ecclesiastical bodies whose organization is conformed to the doctrines and order of this church, such union to be affected by a mode of procedure defined in BCO 26.
[50:09] SPEAKER_02: Is that different from H?
[50:11] SPEAKER_00: Well, to correspond, to have the authority to start the process to move towards that.
[50:16] SPEAKER_00: Napark originally, I think the idea was are we all going to end up in the same denomination?
[50:21] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[50:22] SPEAKER_02: I was just I it's this is probably gonna get cut because I'm not sure where my thought is going.
[50:26] SPEAKER_02: But is there a difference in J uniting with other ecclesiastical bodies versus H, which is to receive, I guess receive under jurisdiction.
[50:36] SPEAKER_02: I mean, what's is there what would be the distinction between these two?
[50:40] SPEAKER_02: I guess you gotta go to 26 to see what they're talking about.
[50:43] SPEAKER_01: 26 talks about the full organic union and consolidation between the Presbyterian Church and other ecclesiastical bodies.
[50:51] SPEAKER_01: So it seems like uh live action BCO interpretation.
[50:56] SPEAKER_02: This is what y'all come for.
[50:57] SPEAKER_01: Uh yeah, I don't see how this is any different from from H.
[51:01] SPEAKER_01: What is uh what does the great uh Morton Smith say?
[51:05] SPEAKER_00: I think the difference may be the difference between and and probably the RPCS would be better under J because H was to receive with no changes, really, the the constitution.
[51:17] SPEAKER_00: This has there would be some sort of changes, and this would be more of a uh a union.
[51:22] SPEAKER_00: And so joining and receiving was seen as a little bit more of a union, even though they took our constitution.
[51:28] SPEAKER_00: Um, but we received their study papers, and um, so probably RPCES is better fit under joining and receiving under J than H.
[51:38] SPEAKER_00: H would be more of absorbing some other small denomination that we they just take on our identity.
[51:44] SPEAKER_00: Should we have done our homework better?
[51:46] SPEAKER_00: Uh that's that's what I'm getting from Almquist.
[51:49] SPEAKER_01: I was just reading Almquist too.
[51:52] SPEAKER_02: Should we have done our homework better?
[51:54] SPEAKER_02: Uh, I think we could probably ask that all the time.
[51:56] SPEAKER_02: 26 is gonna be fun.
[51:58] SPEAKER_02: BCO26 has a whole section about full organic union and consolidation of the PCA with any other ecclesiastical body.
[52:07] SPEAKER_02: So that seems to indicate that there's potential for us to become move in with somebody else, basically, under their name, that we would be the RPCS and you know, we can like be absorbed into the PCUSA and reclaim it.
[52:20] SPEAKER_02: This is awesome.
[52:21] SPEAKER_02: Let's do it.
[52:22] SPEAKER_02: Trojan horse.
[52:24] SPEAKER_00: From what Omquist says, I don't know, we have to just like re-record this entire section.
[52:28] SPEAKER_00: Like, this would be like a really small group of churches within a presbytery is H.
[52:35] SPEAKER_00: And J would be more like joining and receiving.
[52:38] SPEAKER_02: I'll just get him to correct it next week.
[52:40] SPEAKER_02: The last one, K, in general, to recommend measures for the promotion of charity, truth, and holiness through all the churches under its care.
[52:47] SPEAKER_02: Anything to add there, guys?
[52:50] SPEAKER_02: 14.7.
[52:52] SPEAKER_02: Actions of the GA taken pursuant to the provision of BCO 14.6, such as deliverances, resolutions, overtures, and judicial decisions, are to be given due and serious consideration by the church and its lower courts when deliberating matters related to such action.
[53:06] SPEAKER_02: Judicial decisions shall be binding and conclusive on the parties who are directly involved in the matter being adjudicated, and may be appealed to in subsequent similar cases as to any principle which may have been decided.
[53:18] SPEAKER_02: And there's references to BCO3 and 6 and the Confession of Faith, chapter 31.
[53:24] SPEAKER_02: I might need one of y'all to help me out here.
[53:25] SPEAKER_02: I think I maybe have gotten lost in my reading there.
[53:28] SPEAKER_00: This was added in uh 86 in order to uh answer the question of what's the force of assembly actions?
[53:37] SPEAKER_00: What do the lower courts even have to pay attention to them?
[53:41] SPEAKER_00: And I think this answers the question is saying, look, if you try to do the same thing that you were told not to do before, you're going to have the same sort of um um result.
[53:52] SPEAKER_00: So so don't do that.
[53:53] SPEAKER_00: So, and and other deliverances that were uh passed down.
[53:57] SPEAKER_00: So I think of uh say study reports or judicial cases.
[54:02] SPEAKER_00: Uh, for instance, if you have somebody that is getting ordained that says that they don't subscribe to um just the ordinary day view of creation, okay.
[54:12] SPEAKER_00: But what is it that they believe?
[54:13] SPEAKER_00: If they believe in theistic evolution, just to say, well, we think that's okay, well, you're gonna have to look up to uh the the study report that said that that was not an option that was out there.
[54:24] SPEAKER_00: You're gonna have to look at judicial cases where, in fact, people were said, no, that's not in accord with our um our constitution, and say, um, we have to be informed by that when we make this decision.
[54:35] SPEAKER_00: And you're gonna throw that back at us if we try to do something that the assembly has told us repeatedly before should not be done.
[54:42] SPEAKER_02: And 14 8, the last paragraph, the last section of this whole chapter, the whole business of the assembly being finished and the vote taken for final adjournment, the moderator shall say from the chair, by virtue of the authority delegated to me by the church, I do now declare that the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church in America is adjourned to convene at a future date, after which he shall pray and return thanks and pronounce or cause to be pronounced on those present the apostolic benediction.
[55:08] SPEAKER_02: Now, my question is, does this mean if he's a ruling elder that he causes to be pronounced on those the apostolic benediction that he should get a teaching elder and sort of like raise the teaching elder's hands in like an Aaron and Moses kind of fashion, like cause it to be?
[55:22] SPEAKER_02: Is this maybe I'm delirious because we've been going so long.
[55:25] SPEAKER_02: I don't know what's happening.
[55:26] SPEAKER_01: So you're saying that BCO 14-8 does permit the ruling elder to pronounce benedictions.
[55:32] SPEAKER_02: I'm saying I think I think it permits the the ruling elder to cause the benediction to take place.
[55:38] SPEAKER_02: I don't know what that means.
[55:40] SPEAKER_02: And my question is, what's that mean in practice?
[55:42] SPEAKER_02: Uh I mean, I don't think I've ever seen anybody but Roy Taylor give the closing benediction.
[55:48] SPEAKER_01: Um last year.
[55:51] SPEAKER_02: Did Fred do it?
[55:52] SPEAKER_02: Okay, so maybe it's maybe when it teaches it.
[55:53] SPEAKER_01: I think it's the moderator.
[55:55] SPEAKER_02: I mean, it does say the moderator, but I I remember uh maybe Roy leads the uh the singing.
[56:00] SPEAKER_02: Does he lead us singing the psalm?
[56:02] SPEAKER_00: Roy has also been the moderator, so oh that's true.
[56:04] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah.
[56:05] SPEAKER_00: So maybe you're just remembering that.
[56:07] SPEAKER_00: Oh man.
[56:08] SPEAKER_00: I where is the provision in here that says that Mel Duncan is always the one that does the final uh committee effects?
[56:16] SPEAKER_02: We should add him to the permanent committees list.
[56:20] SPEAKER_02: Exactly.
[56:22] SPEAKER_02: Oh man.
[56:23] SPEAKER_02: Well, by virtue of the authority delegated to me by the internet and this microphone, I do now declare this podcast is over.
[56:29] SPEAKER_02: Thanks for joining us.
[56:30] SPEAKER_02: Be sure to come back next time when we're joined by uh modern BCO commentator Per Almquist, and we begin our discussion of what you should expect at General Assembly this year.
[56:39] SPEAKER_02: If you're interested in learning anything more about what we've mentioned, do check out the show notes in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org.
[56:46] SPEAKER_02: If you've enjoyed the show, consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters.
[56:51] SPEAKER_02: Although we might not be on Facebook anymore, I'm not really sure where that landed.
[56:54] SPEAKER_02: Um, I know a couple of us had vacated that social media platform and we don't know what happened to our page.
[56:59] SPEAKER_02: So uh you can subscribe in your podcast app of choice and you can get the get the show delivered every Tuesday morning when we release.
[57:05] SPEAKER_02: If you have questions or comments, anything you need to clarify, you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com or find us on Twitter.
[57:13] SPEAKER_02: Uh our show notes have links to the proper places where you can go.
[57:17] SPEAKER_02: That's all we have for you today.
[57:18] SPEAKER_02: Thanks again for spending time with us.
[57:20] SPEAKER_02: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[57:22] SPEAKER_00: Bye, gentlemen.
[57:23] SPEAKER_00: Have a good one.
[57:23] SPEAKER_02: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
