# 19. Before the Book (Witherow's Statement of the Question)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 2 Jan 2024, 33 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/14230566-19-before-the-book-witherow-s-statement-of-the-question.mp3

Welcome to Polity Matters: Before the Book. In this new series we will be reading and discussing The Apostolic Church by Thomas Witherow. Today we delve into chapter 1: The Statement of the Question. I Will Build My Church by Thomas Witherow The Apostolic Church, Which Is It by Thomas Witherow Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Welcome
- 2:06 Introduction
- 4:04 Essentials & Nonessentials
- 10:53 Necessity of Asking the Question
- 12:30 Forms of Church Government
- 14:36 Finally, the Question
- 17:47 The Way to Answer
- 18:16 "Church" in Scripture
- 21:25 Government of the Church
- 23:22 Difficulties
- 25:55 Principles
- 28:57 The Plan
- 29:58 Conclusion

## Transcript

[0:15] SPEAKER_01: Hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:17] SPEAKER_01: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I am joined as always by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg, and we are very pleased to welcome you to the first episode in our new series, Polity Matters Before the Book.
[0:28] SPEAKER_01: Before we tell you about that and what we're up to, want to catch up with the guys in this new series, uh, new time, new season, whatever word you may want to use, new year.
[0:37] SPEAKER_01: Uh guys, how are you?
[0:39] SPEAKER_01: Uh let's uh let's talk about what we've been reading lately.
[0:43] SPEAKER_01: How's that all going?
[0:44] SPEAKER_01: You guys still know how to read?
[0:46] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, we're reading mostly children's books to children, but also Confessing the Faith by Van Dixhorn.
[0:52] SPEAKER_02: Um, we've been doing some officer training and so been rereading that book.
[0:57] SPEAKER_02: I I've enjoyed it um in seminary, and it's a good reminder.
[1:02] SPEAKER_02: Um, and I think it's really well written.
[1:04] SPEAKER_02: There are some other um commentaries on the confession that are somewhat dated and historical relevance, uh, but this one seemed is is timeless enough to to carry on, and so uh I've been enjoying that.
[1:17] SPEAKER_00: I was going through Grace and Glory by Voss with uh a small group of people that were interested in reading through that.
[1:24] SPEAKER_00: Just interesting to see early 1900s, uh, what was going on at Princeton kind of have the beginnings of of liberalism and the denomination coming in that's kind of in the background.
[1:35] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but it was his uh sermons that he preached to the students there.
[1:39] SPEAKER_00: So that's been that's been interesting.
[1:42] SPEAKER_01: I've been working my way through uh David Gibson's The Lord of Psalm 23 at the recommendation of a good friend of mine, Josh Reagan.
[1:49] SPEAKER_01: He's he he sort of he he uh he instructed me to buy it and read it, and it's been uh very encouraging.
[1:55] SPEAKER_01: Uh a balm in a dry season.
[1:57] SPEAKER_01: And uh if anybody's uh wanting a fresh look on Psalm 23, it's it's really rather well written and encouraging.
[2:06] SPEAKER_01: Well, uh what is Polity Matters before the book?
[2:10] SPEAKER_01: Uh while one of our listeners might be interested in simply plotting through the BCO week after week, we do want to go a little bit deeper than just our blue binder.
[2:19] SPEAKER_01: Uh, you know, don't be worried though, we're gonna come back to the BCO in due time.
[2:23] SPEAKER_01: But for now, we're gonna take a break from it and look at polity from another angle.
[2:27] SPEAKER_01: You know, we've talked about this quite a bit that matters of church polity did not originate with our BCO or even its predecessors.
[2:34] SPEAKER_01: Um church government is rooted in the scriptures.
[2:36] SPEAKER_01: You know, we obey the edicts of our king.
[2:38] SPEAKER_01: And so we want to look before the book and see the origins of Presbyterian polity.
[2:44] SPEAKER_01: And to my knowledge, at least in my opinion, maybe, the single best way to do this is to read Thomas Witherow's The Apostolic Church, which is it?
[2:52] SPEAKER_01: Uh Thomas Witherow, uh not an uh Scottish Presbyterian, an Irish Presbyterian minister who uh wrote this book for the use in the church.
[3:01] SPEAKER_01: Uh, is uh it's a wonderful little tome, if you can pick it up and read it.
[3:05] SPEAKER_01: Um, that's what we're going to be doing in this new series.
[3:08] SPEAKER_01: We're going to be reading through Witherow.
[3:09] SPEAKER_01: He's going to take us to the scriptures first and show us what principles of church government are set up in the apostolic church, and then he'll lead us through an evaluation of the churches that currently exist and which one best employs those apostolic principles.
[3:22] SPEAKER_01: So we do want to encourage you to read along with us.
[3:24] SPEAKER_01: We'll have links in the show notes to various places you can find a copy of this work.
[3:29] SPEAKER_01: The best one that I'd recommend is Westminster Seminary Presses edition called I Will Build My Church.
[3:34] SPEAKER_01: It was edited by Jonathan Gibson and it's got uh some biographical material at the beginning and then three works, one of which is the Apostolic Church.
[3:43] SPEAKER_01: Uh, all three of the works in there are excellent, very useful uh if you're in Presbyterianism or interested in it.
[3:48] SPEAKER_01: Um, you can also find several uh freely available copies of the Apostolic Church online with a simple search in your Google bar um or your DuckDuckGo or wherever you go looking for searches.
[3:59] SPEAKER_01: We'll provide some links to some options that you may want to employ.
[4:03] SPEAKER_01: Um all that being said, we we do want to get into the contents of uh this first chapter, which is the statement of the question.
[4:12] SPEAKER_01: Um, and and pretty much Witherow is asking a question, why would anyone bother to consider church government?
[4:22] SPEAKER_01: And um to get to get us going in our discussion, I want to read just the first sentence of the chapter.
[4:28] SPEAKER_01: He writes, it is very common for professing Christians to draw a distinction between essentials and non-essentials in religion, and to infer that if any fact or doctrine rightly belongs to the latter class, that is of non-essentials, it must be a matter of very little importance and may in practice be safely set at naught.
[4:50] SPEAKER_01: So, guys, we want to we want to talk about this.
[4:52] SPEAKER_01: He's telling us that non-essentials are not as unimportant as we think they are, but let's let's walk through this.
[4:58] SPEAKER_01: What is the distinction, as Witherow is using the words, between essentials and non-essentials?
[5:03] SPEAKER_00: Well, I think one of the big things he's getting at is um, and he says it later, essential or non-essential to salvation.
[5:10] SPEAKER_00: And we actually make this sort of uh distinction in our mind all the time.
[5:15] SPEAKER_00: Uh, if you're trying to explain the gospel to somebody, you're going through a new member's class, there are certain things that you're not going to cover in the bulk of Revelation.
[5:24] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so you're trying to figure out what is it that they need, you know, what am I going to explain about Christology um in order to communicate the gospel?
[5:32] SPEAKER_00: And often um one of the things that you don't explain it early on in talking to somebody about Christianity is church government.
[5:39] SPEAKER_00: And so that causes some people to think uh maybe this is uh unimportant, uh, maybe this is less than um something that is worthy of our study.
[5:49] SPEAKER_00: Um and uh I I think that he has a good point here in terms of um we might need to do this.
[5:56] SPEAKER_00: We might need to make some of these distinctions for some of these things.
[5:59] SPEAKER_00: And there's a book by a guy named uh Gavin Ortland, uh, who um got a little bit of uh press for writing a book on this called uh Finding the Right Hills to Die On.
[6:09] SPEAKER_00: And he was trying to classify things as primary, secondary, tertiary, uh different tiers in which you would classify these uh doctrines.
[6:17] SPEAKER_00: And uh it started to get so detailed that I was I was wondering if what the use of it uh is, um, other than classifying and seem to say some parts of scripture are more important than other parts.
[6:28] SPEAKER_00: Um, although uh this may be something that the Ortlands need to do.
[6:31] SPEAKER_00: I think Gavin is Baptist, Dane is Presbyterian, and Eric is Episcopalian.
[6:36] SPEAKER_00: So maybe this is just so that you can get together at the dinner table if you're going to uh Thanksgiving or something like that uh to get to get along with your other family members.
[6:46] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it's helpful when you're thinking about essential and non-essential, as Jared said, is the nature of salvation found within.
[6:55] SPEAKER_02: But even bolstering the idea of the non-essential, I think we are tempted to think, well, if it's not essential, it therefore must be unimportant.
[7:03] SPEAKER_02: Um, but there are many non-essential things within the scripture for our salvation that are of vital importance.
[7:11] SPEAKER_02: And I like how Witherow talks about the non-essential uh on page 87, where he compares it to the screws and bolts that gird a ship.
[7:20] SPEAKER_02: That yes, like in and of themselves, that one bolt is non-essential.
[7:26] SPEAKER_02: Um, but you would like a ship to be held together by all its nuts and bolts.
[7:31] SPEAKER_02: You may think of what's most important are the mast or the various hull holding itself together.
[7:37] SPEAKER_02: Um, but uh there is a very important nature to those nails and screws.
[7:43] SPEAKER_02: Uh, you you will curse the man who forgot to nail the ship together if you go out sailing on that ship.
[7:50] SPEAKER_02: And so there is this sense that Witherow uh charts out that yes, essentials are as essential as they can be, but non-essentials are also very important to the life and longevity of the church and the illustration of the ship itself.
[8:07] SPEAKER_02: And so while we might in our current day minimize non-essentials in order to maximize uh relations with others, we must also remember the importance of non-essential doctrine.
[8:20] SPEAKER_02: Uh, maybe we don't die on those hills, but we are called and should have confident and perhaps even passionate defenses of those non-essential doctrines as well.
[8:32] SPEAKER_01: Because that really gets back to, and he makes his point, to your view of the scriptures themselves.
[8:37] SPEAKER_01: You know, he says it's dangerous to hold such a principle that it he says it wreaks havoc uh to our Christianity.
[8:43] SPEAKER_01: And in one place says, if speaking of all other truths besides the truth of salvation, if all other truths of revelation are unimportant because they happen to be non-essentials, it follows that the word of God itself is in the main unimportant.
[8:56] SPEAKER_01: Um your view of scripture is affected by how you treat these things, and we need to we need to keep this in front of our people, make sure they understand that that distinction.
[9:05] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, we can't write off passages like love your enemy as non-essential, right?
[9:10] SPEAKER_02: We can't say, well, you know, that's not essential to my salvation.
[9:14] SPEAKER_02: Um, so I'm just gonna that's not that important.
[9:17] SPEAKER_02: Well, Jesus makes loving your enemy one of the primary things he teaches his disciples first, um, as an outworking of their salvation.
[9:25] SPEAKER_02: This is an example of how to show others you've been touched by Christ.
[9:28] SPEAKER_02: And so just because it's not perhaps in like the nuclei of Jesus dying for your sins and ransoming you doesn't mean uh you should just disregard it or say, Yeah, I'll get around to loving my enemy some other day.
[9:40] SPEAKER_02: No, Jesus teaches it and commands us to love our enemies, and and so we are called to, and so that's an important part of our lives.
[9:49] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I think it's a good point that Scott made earlier of it makes things fit together like the nuts and bolts.
[9:55] SPEAKER_00: He also talks about, you know, um, there's large portions of scripture that are dealing with those non-essentials, but I love how he just kind of ends it.
[10:02] SPEAKER_00: He's very quotable in this book, but how he ends it and also saying we have we have a doctrine of scripture, uh, that it is Christ's word.
[10:11] SPEAKER_00: And so he says, heaven and earth may pass away, but the words of Christ shall not pass away.
[10:16] SPEAKER_00: The seal of eternity is stamped on every verse of the Bible.
[10:20] SPEAKER_00: This fact is enough of itself to make every line of it important, even the ones on polity.
[10:25] SPEAKER_00: I added I added that last part.
[10:27] SPEAKER_01: I think he actually said polity matters is what is what he had.
[10:30] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[10:31] SPEAKER_00: Yes.
[10:32] SPEAKER_01: Um and so the the point stands, right?
[10:35] SPEAKER_01: There's really nothing non-essential in the scriptures at all.
[10:38] SPEAKER_01: Uh the Lord has given us the scriptures as they are, and we ought to give attention to every part of them.
[10:43] SPEAKER_01: And so he he starts with this distinction between essential and non-essential in order to show that while church government is not essential to salvation, technically speaking, it is very important.
[10:53] SPEAKER_01: And he gives two main reasons that why we should consider the biblical doctrine of church government.
[10:59] SPEAKER_01: Uh one is that the Holy Spirit has spoken about it, and two is that every Christian lives under a form of church government of some kind.
[11:06] SPEAKER_01: And so he he says, therefore, we must know what the Holy Spirit has spoken about church government.
[11:12] SPEAKER_01: And he leads into this sort of teasing out of the various forms of church government.
[11:17] SPEAKER_01: Uh, since every Christian lives under a form of church government, he tells us what they are, at least in the main.
[11:23] SPEAKER_01: And I don't know how y'all want to do it, but I'm going to hand it to you.
[11:26] SPEAKER_01: Can you guys walk us through the three forms of church government that Witherow sees as the main in uh the world today?
[11:34] SPEAKER_02: I think even before we define them, we have to remind uh those who would listen that the general culture of the modern church views this question in such a non-essential way that it's preference.
[11:49] SPEAKER_02: And we don't have that liberty.
[11:51] SPEAKER_02: Um we don't have the liberty to say my church government is just an afterthought.
[11:56] SPEAKER_02: I can go to any church, the government doesn't matter of that church.
[12:00] SPEAKER_02: I'll just find the one that I like most, maybe the best preacher, the best children's ministry, whatever the government is, that's non-essential, and therefore I can attend any.
[12:10] SPEAKER_02: Um and what we'll seek to do probably throughout this series is to show that it is not a mere preference to choose the government uh that we would have over us, but something that is outlined as Ben said by the Holy Spirit.
[12:24] SPEAKER_02: Um, and as we submit to any government, it should be conformed to the scriptures themselves.
[12:30] SPEAKER_02: And that kind of weds us into the three types of government.
[12:33] SPEAKER_02: Um, Jared, do you would you like to outline those?
[12:35] SPEAKER_00: Well, he uses language that we might not use.
[12:37] SPEAKER_00: This is not the three that I learned, but they're three of a different name.
[12:41] SPEAKER_00: Um, he has prelacy, uh, which he's referring to, what we would think of as episcopalian or rule by bishops, um, independency, we would usually say congregational form of government, and presbytery, presbyterian or even synodical uh forms of government that's ruled by elders, and then some sort of connectionalism between uh those uh those churches.
[13:04] SPEAKER_02: I passed the buck to you because I didn't want to see pr uh prelacy.
[13:07] SPEAKER_02: I thought I'd botch it, and so I I didn't even want to start down that road.
[13:12] SPEAKER_01: So so in the in the prelacy or the the episcopacy, you're gonna have churches like the Greek Church or the Church of Rome or the Church of England.
[13:19] SPEAKER_01: Uh the independent churches are gonna be mostly what we're gonna see are congregational Baptist churches, um community churches, bible churches.
[13:28] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that's right.
[13:28] SPEAKER_01: Or or or pick a color or a a tree and combine them, and you probably find a church, you know, like blue spruce.
[13:35] SPEAKER_01: It's probably a church out there that's probably gonna be congregational.
[13:39] SPEAKER_01: Um, and I don't know what you guys think.
[13:41] SPEAKER_01: I would I would probably throw non-denominational in that independent uh bucket.
[13:45] SPEAKER_01: I think that's that's probably what we're gonna see there.
[13:47] SPEAKER_01: They're that they're gonna have maybe less structure on the outside, but it's got to be in there somewhere.
[13:51] SPEAKER_01: And then Presbytery, of course, is you're gonna see the Presbyterian churches of uh well to to spoil him and to give attention to him of the Presbyterian churches of Ireland, where Witherow's from Scotland, England, the Americas.
[14:03] SPEAKER_01: And these all vary widely in characteristic, um, and they actually are against each other in some places.
[14:10] SPEAKER_01: And Witherow makes the point.
[14:11] SPEAKER_01: He says, these cannot all be right.
[14:15] SPEAKER_01: Uh they they are different enough that they can't all be uh correct.
[14:20] SPEAKER_01: And and he says in light of that, neither can God's word support all of them, because God's word can't support in his phrase or sanction contradictory systems.
[14:32] SPEAKER_01: So he says one of them must be more biblical than the other.
[14:36] SPEAKER_01: And that that's really where he's headed um in his question.
[14:41] SPEAKER_01: You know, which of these three forms of church government is uh he says it is is it the duty of a Christian to select and support?
[14:50] SPEAKER_01: And back to Scott's point earlier about how it's not just a preference issue, it really is the duty of every Christian to look at the scriptures and to see what God has uh prescribed and to find a church that suits what he has prescribed.
[15:04] SPEAKER_01: Um most people don't think about this question.
[15:06] SPEAKER_01: I I want to ask y'all uh sort of a follow-up to this thought because he makes he he actually draws a point here and says that some of the reason that people don't think about it is because the pulpits are quiet on this issue.
[15:19] SPEAKER_01: Where do you all think this question about about church government and the proper proper church government comes into play in our in our ministries uh before our people?
[15:29] SPEAKER_01: Should we talk about it with them?
[15:30] SPEAKER_01: Should we make a point to tell them what we think is is right and scriptural on this point, or just because they're in our churches, we don't need to worry about it because they're here and not somewhere else.
[15:39] SPEAKER_00: Well, I make a point to talk about this in new members' class, especially, um, just to talk about the different forms of government, why we're Presbyterian, uh, why we think that is good for our congregation and for the longevity of our church.
[15:52] SPEAKER_00: Um, and when you come to it in scripture.
[15:55] SPEAKER_00: And sometimes you need to think about, you know, I we have three pastoral epistles that are um have a lot of ecclesiology in them.
[16:03] SPEAKER_00: And it's good for our people to hear from them every now and then.
[16:06] SPEAKER_00: So to pick first or second Timothy or Titus and start talking about um uh church officers as well as uh church government would be um something that would be healthy for them in the normal diet of the church.
[16:18] SPEAKER_00: You probably shouldn't only talk about polity, but you should not ever not talk about polity if that works.
[16:25] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I can get carried away during the um actual the part of a worship service when you do have new members being received and they're making vows.
[16:35] SPEAKER_02: I have a tendency to want to get carried away with exhorting the people on why people are making vows and what kind of government they're making vows within.
[16:46] SPEAKER_02: And so it's a good opportunity when you have new members coming forward uh to take some time um out of the service to discuss the nature of our church government and the non-accidental nature of it.
[17:00] SPEAKER_02: Um because even within our, I think within our system, the many pastors uh can forget the importance of ecclesiology and as how we see it.
[17:11] SPEAKER_02: Um and so yeah, I I I've not had a church polity sermon series, uh, you know, topical thematics.
[17:18] SPEAKER_02: Um, but I I think those parts of the service, when you get to baptism, um, when you when you're doing the Lord's Supper, those are times when you can put little nuggets uh of your polity um within the worship service.
[17:31] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, let us not have quiet pulpits on this matter.
[17:33] SPEAKER_01: Um, you know, let us not be the object of Witherow's um criticism here.
[17:38] SPEAKER_01: We we want our people to know uh what we believe scripture teaches to his original point, even on these matters, right?
[17:46] SPEAKER_01: Um Well, the the question's been posed um which which of these three forms of church government is it the duty of a Christian to select and support?
[17:57] SPEAKER_01: And he sets up the way that we're going to answer.
[18:00] SPEAKER_01: And he he's he simply says at one point that the most obvious method of arriving at the truth is to compare our modern systems of ecclesiastical government with the model presented in the holy scriptures.
[18:11] SPEAKER_01: And essentially says, How are we going to answer this?
[18:13] SPEAKER_01: We're gonna go to the word of God.
[18:16] SPEAKER_01: So he starts by studying the word church in scripture and points out the variety of uses that it has.
[18:25] SPEAKER_01: I wonder, uh well, guys, what what of these stood out to you as he worked his way through?
[18:31] SPEAKER_01: You know, he he gave one definition to the word church, either an assembly of the people of God or a society of Christians, and then he went through and and proved it out.
[18:40] SPEAKER_01: Uh, did is it you guys find this compelling, the argument he has that uh that a church is an assembly of the people of God, even though we see different words used for all these different things.
[18:50] SPEAKER_02: I like his definition.
[18:52] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, he says it's an assembly of the people God, and then I think particularly it is a society of Christians.
[19:00] SPEAKER_02: Um the society of Christians, I think, is a helpful qualifier from when we're talking about the church.
[19:06] SPEAKER_02: That again, it's not a mere building.
[19:09] SPEAKER_02: You we heard that probably throughout, I heard that regularly throughout my evangelical uh upbringing.
[19:16] SPEAKER_02: The church is not the building, it's the people.
[19:17] SPEAKER_02: Um, but I think it it's a better way to frame it as it's not merely a person, but it's a society.
[19:25] SPEAKER_02: Uh that it I can't say that the church is the church is me on Sunday in my bed.
[19:33] SPEAKER_02: Like I the church is here because Scott is laying in the bed.
[19:37] SPEAKER_02: I think it's better framed in this idea of society.
[19:39] SPEAKER_02: It's a society of gathered people.
[19:42] SPEAKER_02: Uh it's a town coming together um to worship, a religious town uh coming together to worship their God.
[19:49] SPEAKER_02: I think it gives perhaps better clarity for what we're trying to communicate with what the church is.
[19:54] SPEAKER_02: Because if we say that, if we mindlessly at least say that the church is just the people, we might mistake and undervalue or undermine our ecclesiology by arguing that, well, I'm the church, me, myself, and I.
[20:12] SPEAKER_02: Um, when the church is more than just Scott Hedberg, it's much larger than that as a society.
[20:19] SPEAKER_00: So Scott isn't like the emperor in Star Wars.
[20:22] SPEAKER_00: I am the Senate.
[20:24] SPEAKER_02: Sometimes, you know, maybe that's my temptation.
[20:27] SPEAKER_02: But then I would be episcopal.
[20:30] SPEAKER_00: Well, I I do think he he points out and says we don't need to get too pedantic on the fact that sometimes we'll say, I'm gonna go down to the church and we mean the building, or that the news will report such and such a church made this action.
[20:44] SPEAKER_00: And what they really mean is this court of the church made such and such an action.
[20:48] SPEAKER_00: Um, but on the whole, this is what it means, especially scripturally.
[20:52] SPEAKER_00: Um, the the one reservation I had was uh it also might mean the church acting.
[20:58] SPEAKER_00: Um, Matthew 16, I think about that of go tell the church.
[21:01] SPEAKER_00: Um, I think that actually can be the leadership of the church, but it's not one person.
[21:06] SPEAKER_00: Um, I think his point there is clear.
[21:08] SPEAKER_01: For those of you who are listening, you you may want to go pick up and read.
[21:11] SPEAKER_01: He goes through several different proof texts and sort of explains the different ways uh the the particular society of Christians is being used uh when the church is uh well then the word church is employed in the scriptures.
[21:24] SPEAKER_01: And he he he sees that clearly in the in the word, and then he he goes on to show that the government of such a church must exist, and so it must also have a form.
[21:32] SPEAKER_01: Uh Jared, you had some notes on this.
[21:34] SPEAKER_01: I wanted to see if you wanted to address it.
[21:38] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, some people will think, well, maybe I don't have to pick a form of government, but there are certain commands within scripture about submitting to leadership, and that means there's a government, and that means that there are uh some people that are submitting and some people who are being submitted to.
[21:55] SPEAKER_00: Um, although everybody within the church has to submit to somebody at some point.
[22:00] SPEAKER_00: Within um within the government.
[22:02] SPEAKER_00: Um so as he's saying this though, he's he's saying what we have to figure out is not if we're gonna have a church government, but what sort of church government, and are we just gonna let our ancestors choose it for us, or are we gonna think about this biblically of um is it actually the most biblical form?
[22:19] SPEAKER_01: And he gets to a point in that section there where and this is where I I like to uh see him pressing a little bit, and I'm encouraged by it because I think that we need to press this more.
[22:29] SPEAKER_01: He says, Look, if we're going, if we're going to look at the scripture and answer this question, whatever we find is not just an opinion, it's not just sort of a tradition, but actually what he says is the government presented in scripture must carry lawfulness and authority that no human system can claim.
[22:48] SPEAKER_01: And so maybe this is uh you know, though the warning that we give to you listeners on on working your way through Witherow that if you see in scripture what he's about to present and you're convinced by it, if you're not Presbyterian, you you may need to become Presbyterian.
[23:03] SPEAKER_01: Because if if you if we find these things in Scripture, it is incumbent upon us as God's people to apply them in our own practice as much as we're able to.
[23:12] SPEAKER_01: And so this is not a light thing at all, um, to his point.
[23:16] SPEAKER_01: It may be non-essential to our salvation, but it is certainly an important matter for God's people to take up.
[23:22] SPEAKER_01: And so then he moves into talking about the difficulties that we're going to experience as we seek to answer this question.
[23:30] SPEAKER_01: Uh, you know, he's got a couple listed.
[23:32] SPEAKER_01: Maybe you guys can talk about these.
[23:34] SPEAKER_01: Maybe there's some on your own minds.
[23:36] SPEAKER_01: What are the difficulties with with finding and understanding the system of government that's set up in scripture?
[23:42] SPEAKER_00: One would be finding it all in one place.
[23:44] SPEAKER_00: It's it's not systematically laid out like our uh Westminster Confession likes to lay out topics.
[23:50] SPEAKER_00: And so you're going to find a little bit of it in practice here and a little bit of it in practice there, and you have to put those things together.
[23:57] SPEAKER_00: And so there's a there's a challenge there also in that it doesn't give you every detail of what's supposed to happen.
[24:04] SPEAKER_00: Instead, there's these principles, which is why he's going to have the rest of his book unfold under principles rather than just getting down to exact detail of what a quorum is or something like that.
[24:15] SPEAKER_00: Um, we see that vary between churches, and um it doesn't uh concern us too much.
[24:21] SPEAKER_00: Um, in fact, if you try to look at early church uh government, um you'll find different documents like the Dida Key or uh the Apostolic Constitutions or the Apostolic Tradition.
[24:32] SPEAKER_00: These are like three different, almost like book of church orders in the early church, and they're all a little bit different because they're from different regions.
[24:39] SPEAKER_00: So everyone seemed to have a different way in which they were applying it, but they have the same offices.
[24:44] SPEAKER_00: They have, you're going to be baptized, we're gonna come to the Lord's Supper.
[24:47] SPEAKER_00: Um, so they had uh principles that were the same in all of them.
[24:51] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, and I think that gets at the the other difficulty as it relates to it not being uh explicit.
[24:59] SPEAKER_02: Uh the the scriptures don't say uh thou shalt be congregational, uh episcopal, or uh Presbyterian.
[25:08] SPEAKER_02: And so there must be synthesis and uh systematic development, as we see in many of our doctrines, right?
[25:16] SPEAKER_02: Um, a lot of our theology is derived and developed out of those couplings of those scriptures wedded together to create a system of doctrine and thought.
[25:27] SPEAKER_02: And so the the it would have been nice perhaps if if Paul or Peter would have laid out the foundations very systematically for for what the apostolic church government functioned as, but instead we have to develop uh that out of the scriptures themselves where we do find it.
[25:47] SPEAKER_02: And I think Witherow outlines that um somewhat early with some of the scriptures that we do read for the work of the church.
[25:55] SPEAKER_01: He draws the parallel right in the next sections that that it is it's more common for God's word to give us principles more than detailed instructions.
[26:05] SPEAKER_01: Um he he draws out the point that the human legislators descend into details.
[26:12] SPEAKER_01: Um, you know, they they want to micromanage every single part of everything they can.
[26:16] SPEAKER_01: He says a divine law rarely entered into specific details, but lays down general principles, any one of which is quite sufficient to decide a whole multitude of cases.
[26:26] SPEAKER_01: And so you can he he gives the example that you know, instead of instead of laying down every single jot and tittle of what it would be good for you to do towards your neighbor, he simply says the the word simply says, you shall love your neighbor as yourself.
[26:39] SPEAKER_01: And so he draws this connection between the the principles of morality that are given in God's law, and and says it's the same thing for polity.
[26:48] SPEAKER_01: Um we're not given minute details, but we're we're supplied with big, broad, leading principles that we're meant to apply uh in the government of the church.
[26:58] SPEAKER_02: And it might be helpful to define government, right?
[27:01] SPEAKER_02: Um Witherow says that in every society where it is acknowledged the duty of some parties to exercise authority and others to practice submission, there must be what is called a government.
[27:15] SPEAKER_02: And so when we were talking about the idea of government, is that there are some who are ruled uh over, and then there are some who are rulers.
[27:23] SPEAKER_02: And so that's kind of the idea of what we're developing here when we think of the church and then its form of government.
[27:29] SPEAKER_02: Uh, all three of the forms of government we see here, you might be like, uh, I don't like this idea of submission, I don't like the idea of some ruling over others.
[27:37] SPEAKER_02: All three of these forms of government have that.
[27:39] SPEAKER_02: And if you make any form of government, if uh it's gonna have one of these three or combined together some of them.
[27:46] SPEAKER_02: And so government is there are some who rule over and some who submit under.
[27:51] SPEAKER_02: And that is the government not only of the church, but also in broader civil society as well.
[27:57] SPEAKER_02: There are some who rule over and then others who are ruled and they submit under.
[28:03] SPEAKER_02: And so it's the same with the church.
[28:05] SPEAKER_02: There is no church where there is no one who is ruled over and who rules.
[28:09] SPEAKER_02: Um, otherwise, there is no government.
[28:11] SPEAKER_02: Uh, that that's that's chaos.
[28:13] SPEAKER_02: And you might get a trish tradition that's outside of what we've seen in most of evangelicalism um when you deny the idea of government itself.
[28:22] SPEAKER_02: You even um our brothers, our Baptist brothers, non-denominational brothers, they do have government.
[28:28] SPEAKER_02: And there are some who are ruled and others who are rulers, um, but that's that's the frame of government.
[28:34] SPEAKER_02: And so we should probably understand what we mean by government, um, as Witherow understands it.
[28:39] SPEAKER_01: Sorry, all I'm thinking is a great thing to say early on.
[28:42] SPEAKER_01: I wish we'd thought about that.
[28:44] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
[28:45] SPEAKER_02: I I want I wanted to I wanted to jump in in the midst of defining something.
[28:49] SPEAKER_02: I was like, I'll just wait.
[28:51] SPEAKER_02: You could edit it backwards, you could retcon this however you want.
[28:55] SPEAKER_01: Oh man.
[28:57] SPEAKER_01: So so he lastly he sort of stops and says, Okay, so here's the plan.
[29:01] SPEAKER_01: We're going to examine scriptures for the principles, and then we're gonna see which which uh present form of church government embodies these principles.
[29:11] SPEAKER_01: Uh and I I told the guys before we started recording, I really appreciate the trajectory that he sets up and the dynamic that he creates, where it is not simply him trying to prove the validity and and scriptural basis of his own form of government, which is the same one that that we share with him, but rather he says, Listen, we're gonna forget about the present forms for a minute.
[29:30] SPEAKER_01: And the the first part of this little book is spent examining the scriptures.
[29:35] SPEAKER_01: And so for the next six episodes after this one, we're going to go through him with him and examine the scriptures to draw out the apostolic principles, and then we'll come back with him in his third, the third chapter and apply the principles to the different uh forms of government that exist and see if we can prove one better than the others, um, or at least uh maybe one or two better than than the third.
[29:58] SPEAKER_01: Any concluding thoughts on this, guys?
[30:00] SPEAKER_01: I mean, I'm I'm really excited to read this with y'all.
[30:03] SPEAKER_01: I I've been Presbyterian for a long time.
[30:05] SPEAKER_01: Uh, I tell people I feel like I was a carnal Presbyterian before I read Thomas Witherow on the matter a few years ago.
[30:11] SPEAKER_01: Uh finally converted all the way, no going back.
[30:15] SPEAKER_02: For the modern churches, uh Witherow concludes in this chapter, uh, the one that embodies the most apostolic principles is nearest to the apostolic church itself.
[30:27] SPEAKER_02: And that's the title for the book for a reason.
[30:29] SPEAKER_02: It's how do we um take the New Testament scriptures and understand the principles of church government and the form found therein, and then implement them within our churches.
[30:41] SPEAKER_02: And when we do, we come nearest to the apostolic tradition.
[30:46] SPEAKER_02: It comes back to that reformational ideal, uh, ideal uh ad fantes, you know, going back to the sources and trying to recover the ancient apostolic churches' teachings and practices.
[30:57] SPEAKER_02: I think that's what Witherow is doing with the form of government, whereas perhaps in his previous generations, they were doing that with Calvin and doctrine itself.
[31:05] SPEAKER_02: Um, here we see perhaps the maturing as we consider it with the form of government that we see in the early church.
[31:12] SPEAKER_00: And I think it's good to understand the reason to study this and to have the right form of church government is not just to be right, but scripture tells us to do certain things for our maturity, for our growth, and for our preservation.
[31:27] SPEAKER_00: Um, so I want the church to be around for my parents, for my uh children and for my grandchildren.
[31:34] SPEAKER_00: And um, so what preserves the church and in what sort of church are they actually going to um grow into maturity?
[31:42] SPEAKER_00: And some of the things that are talked about here that are principles are things that are necessary for the church for us to grow and for the church to be preserved.
[31:50] SPEAKER_01: Well, as I'm sure Thomas Witherow would be eager to say, this podcast is over.
[31:55] SPEAKER_01: Thanks for joining us.
[31:56] SPEAKER_01: Be sure to come back next time when we begin to discuss the first of those six principles of the Apostolic Church.
[32:01] SPEAKER_01: If you're interested in learning more about anything that we've addressed, check out our show notes in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org.
[32:08] SPEAKER_01: If you enjoyed the show, consider following us on Twitter or Facebook at Polity Matters.
[32:13] SPEAKER_01: Be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[32:15] SPEAKER_01: And if you have questions or comments, you can get in touch with us on social media or at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[32:22] SPEAKER_01: Scott is the Minister of Providence PCA in Troy, Illinois.
[32:26] SPEAKER_01: You can find him on Twitter at SEDberg.
[32:29] SPEAKER_01: If you're looking for Jared, he pastors New Life Presbyterian Church in Alico, Pennsylvania.
[32:33] SPEAKER_01: He's on Twitter at Brother Nelson.
[32:35] SPEAKER_01: I serve as the associate pastor at Covenant Presbyterian Church here in Cleveland, Mississippi, and I'm on Twitter at underscore Ben Ratliff.
[32:42] SPEAKER_01: We thank you again for spending time with us.
[32:43] SPEAKER_01: And until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[32:46] SPEAKER_00: Goodbye, gentlemen.
[32:46] SPEAKER_00: Take it easy.
[32:47] SPEAKER_01: Y'all take care of

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
