# 76. Story Time with Steve (BCO 31 part one)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 18 Mar 2025, 1 h 04 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/16809468-76-story-time-with-steve-bco-31-part-one.mp3

Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Tipton to dive into BCO 31, which outlines the key players and procedures involved in formal judicial processes within the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA). They start off with a bit of fun—Jared presents a quiz on judicial cases that have shaped the PCA. Then, the discussion turns serious as they unpack the nuances of BCO 31, addressing questions of jurisdiction, the role of the courts, and the necessity of due process in church discipline. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Starting with a Game
- 8:18 Intro to BCO 31
- 9:04 BCO 31-1
- 16:01 BCO 31-2 paragraph 1
- 35:25 BCO 31-2 paragraph 2
- 48:11 BCO 31-3
- 59:36 BCO 31-4
- 1:03:10 Conclusion

## Transcript

[0:05] SPEAKER_01: Hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:07] SPEAKER_01: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined as always by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg, and today we have our friend with us, Steve Tipton.
[0:14] SPEAKER_01: We're gonna get into BCO 31 here in just a minute, but we we were talking earlier and we realized it's been a long time since we played a game and had some really awkward audio content for y'all to listen to, and so we thought that we would try that today.
[0:25] SPEAKER_01: And I I I called on Jared late last night, and he's already put something together.
[0:29] SPEAKER_01: So when when ministry fails and you're not able to continue as a pastor, you could go into game show uh you know writing or something like that, I suppose.
[0:37] SPEAKER_03: Alright.
[0:38] SPEAKER_03: Well, uh my game here for the the three of you is going to be about judicial cases that influence the PCA, some of them outside of the PCA, some of them in the PCA.
[0:50] SPEAKER_03: So um you guys ready?
[0:52] SPEAKER_03: Um I think if you if you want to answer the question, you can just raise your hand since that will transfer very well into audio.
[1:01] SPEAKER_03: Well call on you then.
[1:03] SPEAKER_03: All right.
[1:04] SPEAKER_03: All right, these are famous cases uh that influenced the PCA or uh that you should know about that happened in the PCA.
[1:12] SPEAKER_03: Um so my uh first question is this Jay Gresham Machin was famously put on trial and convicted in the Northern Presbyterian Church.
[1:21] SPEAKER_03: What offense was he convicted of?
[1:24] SPEAKER_03: Does anybody want to buzz on?
[1:25] unknown: Jaywalking.
[1:26] SPEAKER_03: Jaywalking.
[1:27] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:28] SPEAKER_00: Nobody has this?
[1:30] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I don't know what the actual offense was.
[1:32] SPEAKER_00: I mean, I he he created like a separate board of missions, but I guess schism maybe, or schism.
[1:40] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, it was for supporting an independent missionary board and not supporting the denominational missionary board.
[1:46] SPEAKER_03: So yes.
[1:48] SPEAKER_03: I I don't think we're good at OPC ministers since that wasn't at the tip of our tongue.
[1:53] SPEAKER_03: But um another one that is known to Northern Presbyterians here.
[1:58] SPEAKER_03: Uh the Kenyon and Caseman cases were famous for many Northern Presbyterian churches to cause them to leave the main line and eventually enter the PCA.
[2:08] SPEAKER_03: What was the main issue at stake in those cases?
[2:12] SPEAKER_03: Oh, is that Scott over there?
[2:14] SPEAKER_03: Ordination of women.
[2:16] SPEAKER_01: I was gonna say, yeah.
[2:17] SPEAKER_03: Ordination of women.
[2:18] SPEAKER_03: Sorry, you don't get to answer that.
[2:19] SPEAKER_03: Yes, and whether they could say that they were against it.
[2:24] SPEAKER_03: Very good.
[2:25] SPEAKER_01: I was taught by uh Wynn Kenyon in undergrad of that case.
[2:29] SPEAKER_01: Very nice.
[2:29] SPEAKER_01: Oh, okay.
[2:31] SPEAKER_03: All right.
[2:32] SPEAKER_03: My third question.
[2:33] SPEAKER_03: Uh it's a little bit more out there.
[2:35] SPEAKER_03: You may not know this unless you've looked it up.
[2:38] SPEAKER_03: Um of course the PCA was founded in 1973.
[2:42] SPEAKER_03: But what was the first there's two answers to this.
[2:46] SPEAKER_03: What is the first case that was decided?
[2:49] SPEAKER_03: Um what year was the first case decided that was not just a dismissal, but actually on the merits of the case, and which one and which year was a case actually rendered that had a judgment uh from the GA?
[3:04] SPEAKER_03: This is just guess a year.
[3:05] SPEAKER_03: 1976.
[3:07] SPEAKER_03: All right, Scott's guess to 76.
[3:09] SPEAKER_03: 83.
[3:09] SPEAKER_03: 1952.
[3:10] SPEAKER_03: Tipton 52 before the PCA was founded.
[3:14] SPEAKER_00: 1952.
[3:15] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[3:16] SPEAKER_00: 83.
[3:20] SPEAKER_03: Um okay, now tipped it going tipton going for the uh uh price's right strategy there uh did not pay out for me.
[3:26] SPEAKER_03: Um 77, they actually ruled as to the substance.
[3:31] SPEAKER_03: 78 was the first time they actually had a judgment, which is interesting.
[3:34] SPEAKER_03: It took like five years for them to actually write a judicial judgment from the GA.
[3:38] SPEAKER_03: So if you have a case that's going through Presbytery, don't worry.
[3:42] SPEAKER_03: Uh it could be worse.
[3:43] SPEAKER_03: Um, number four actually happened in the PCA.
[3:49] SPEAKER_03: There was a pastor in uh the PCA at a church in Tennessee that invited a female preacher to preach on Sunday morning in their church, leading to a famous case, which is perhaps the only invocation of 31-2 uh before a few years ago uh for the GA to reconsider a case.
[4:10] SPEAKER_03: Can you name either the pastor that was at the center of that, whose name is in the case file, or if barring that, the presbytery that brought the 31-2?
[4:20] SPEAKER_00: Well, I don't think you mean 31-2, right?
[4:22] SPEAKER_00: It's the the jurisdiction one, is that what you're talking about?
[4:27] SPEAKER_00: Where's the original jurisdiction?
[4:30] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[4:31] SPEAKER_00: Okay.
[4:31] SPEAKER_03: You know what I mean.
[4:32] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[4:32] SPEAKER_03: I wrote this at 11 30 last night before bed.
[4:36] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I don't remember.
[4:37] SPEAKER_02: Missouri Presbytery.
[4:38] SPEAKER_03: Missouri Presbytery did not bring that.
[4:41] SPEAKER_01: That's Metro New York Presbytery?
[4:44] SPEAKER_03: It was against a church in Tennessee, Tennessee Valley.
[4:48] SPEAKER_03: A different Presbytery brought it, or the name of the pastor.
[4:52] SPEAKER_03: Three.
[4:53] SPEAKER_03: This is too hard for us.
[4:54] SPEAKER_03: It was uh John Wood.
[4:56] SPEAKER_03: And the reason I was asking about the Presbytery was it was Ascension Presbytery that brought that overture.
[5:02] SPEAKER_03: And they were told not to do that again.
[5:03] SPEAKER_03: They didn't like that.
[5:04] SPEAKER_03: Alright.
[5:05] SPEAKER_03: This is this is a speed round.
[5:07] SPEAKER_03: Um, I'm gonna give you a case, and at the end of it, you have to say were they actually tried and were they found guilty or not guilty?
[5:16] SPEAKER_03: All right.
[5:18] SPEAKER_03: This is in the history of the PCA, this is a little bit more controversial.
[5:20] SPEAKER_03: Hope we're not digging up.
[5:22] SPEAKER_03: Were they tried and if they were, what was a verdict?
[5:26] SPEAKER_03: Um, signer of the federal vision joint statement in Pacific Northwest, Peter Lighthart, for his views on baptism and justification.
[5:37] SPEAKER_03: Was he tried, and if so, what was the verdict?
[5:39] SPEAKER_03: Not tried.
[5:41] SPEAKER_02: Tried, not guilty.
[5:43] SPEAKER_03: Steve has a guess?
[5:44] SPEAKER_03: I think it was not tried.
[5:46] SPEAKER_03: Scott is actually right.
[5:47] SPEAKER_03: He was tried.
[5:47] SPEAKER_03: Not tried.
[5:49] SPEAKER_03: He was tried, but found not guilty.
[5:52] SPEAKER_03: So all right.
[5:54] SPEAKER_03: So, Scott, you got the points on that one.
[5:57] SPEAKER_03: All right, another one.
[5:58] SPEAKER_03: Yes, good, good.
[5:59] SPEAKER_03: One that Scott might know about, but I don't know if anybody else does.
[6:03] SPEAKER_03: Burke Shade.
[6:05] SPEAKER_03: He was among those who were uh known as the first to defend doctrines that eventually became the federal vision theology in regards to baptism in the PCA.
[6:15] SPEAKER_03: Was he tried, and if so, what was the verdict?
[6:18] SPEAKER_03: Not tried.
[6:19] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I'm gonna say not tried.
[6:20] SPEAKER_03: I don't I don't know the name.
[6:21] SPEAKER_03: Not tried.
[6:22] SPEAKER_03: He was tried, and he was found guilty by Ileana.
[6:26] SPEAKER_03: So there you go.
[6:29] SPEAKER_02: Oh man.
[6:30] SPEAKER_02: Shame.
[6:31] SPEAKER_02: I should be reading my my histories.
[6:33] SPEAKER_02: I own all the records, but I don't read on the records.
[6:35] SPEAKER_03: All right, go back and do your homework.
[6:37] SPEAKER_03: All right.
[6:37] SPEAKER_03: Um begun in 1930.
[6:39] SPEAKER_00: You don't suffer from that much insomnia.
[6:42] SPEAKER_03: Begun in 1989 and concluded in 1991.
[6:47] SPEAKER_03: Um, what case, and this I guess you say, yes, it was um tried, but uh of a ruling elder known as Adler in New River was teaching theistic evolution and uh was tried uh for that being outside the bounds and that he was not allowed to teach that.
[7:05] SPEAKER_03: Uh was he found guilty or not guilty?
[7:07] SPEAKER_03: Tried guilty.
[7:09] SPEAKER_02: He's guilty.
[7:10] SPEAKER_02: Confident, 100%.
[7:14] SPEAKER_02: Not tried.
[7:15] SPEAKER_02: That's terrible.
[7:16] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, that was a bad option, man.
[7:17] SPEAKER_02: That it was it's clear.
[7:19] SPEAKER_03: He was tried and he was You still can't teach the Istic evolution.
[7:22] SPEAKER_03: He was tried and he was found guilty, yes.
[7:24] SPEAKER_03: All right.
[7:25] SPEAKER_03: Um, probably one that you guys all know.
[7:28] SPEAKER_03: Greg Johnson.
[7:30] SPEAKER_03: Subject to much controversy in the PCA.
[7:32] SPEAKER_03: Was he personally ever tried for this?
[7:34] SPEAKER_03: And if so, what was the verdict?
[7:36] SPEAKER_03: No.
[7:36] SPEAKER_03: Not tried.
[7:37] SPEAKER_03: Not tried.
[7:40] SPEAKER_03: Never tried.
[7:41] SPEAKER_03: So there you go.
[7:42] SPEAKER_03: I I have Scott down as for the most and Steve for the next.
[7:46] SPEAKER_03: Sometimes Steve just didn't answer, so he might have known the right answer, but there you go.
[7:50] SPEAKER_01: Did I do you say are you saying I lost?
[7:53] SPEAKER_01: That's the only thing that I know.
[7:55] SPEAKER_03: Isn't what he lost?
[7:56] SPEAKER_03: Loser.
[7:58] SPEAKER_01: Is Jared laggy for anybody else?
[8:01] SPEAKER_01: I thought it was me.
[8:02] SPEAKER_01: But fix your and uh Jared.
[8:05] SPEAKER_01: Maybe it's Jared.
[8:06] SPEAKER_01: I'll fix it in post.
[8:07] SPEAKER_01: It'll be alright.
[8:08] SPEAKER_01: All right.
[8:08] SPEAKER_01: Jared, as finish as soon as I finish this next sentence, say a word.
[8:14] SPEAKER_03: A word.
[8:14] SPEAKER_01: Oh, yeah, that was way too long.
[8:16] SPEAKER_01: Man, okay.
[8:18] SPEAKER_01: We'll figure it out.
[8:20] SPEAKER_01: Listeners, today we're talking about BCO 31, the parties in cases of process.
[8:26] SPEAKER_01: We've talked about church courts before.
[8:27] SPEAKER_01: We've talked talked about jurisdictions, how discipline functions in the PCA, but this section is going to begin to answer important questions like who are the key players when a formal judicial process takes place.
[8:38] SPEAKER_01: This is an area where there can be a lot of confusion.
[8:41] SPEAKER_01: Uh, you know, what happens when accusations are made, who actually brings the charges, uh, what safeguards are in place to ensure uh fairness in trials, and ultimately how does church discipline serve the peace and the purity of Christ's church?
[8:54] SPEAKER_01: And so we're going to get into BCO 311, which begins to discuss jurisdiction over cases.
[9:00] SPEAKER_01: And we're just diving straight in.
[9:02] SPEAKER_01: So pull out your BCOs and let's go.
[9:04] SPEAKER_01: 311 reads original jurisdiction, the right first or initially to hear and determine, in relation to ministers of the gospel shall be in the presbytery of which the minister is a member, except in cases as provided in BCO thirty-four-one.
[9:18] SPEAKER_01: Such original jurisdiction in relation to church members shall be in the session of the church of which he or she is a member, except in cases as provided in BCO thirty-three one.
[9:29] SPEAKER_01: So original jurisdiction in cases of process lies with the presbytery for ministers and the session for members, except where there are exceptions, of course.
[9:37] SPEAKER_01: Um what's the practical impact, I suppose, of this uh paragraph?
[9:42] SPEAKER_01: And that that's a very open-ended question that allows you all to go kind of wherever you want to to start with.
[9:47] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so um I mean, I I think first of all, the the name of the chapter is really important um in the in the sense that the whole chapter is setting up the parties in the case.
[10:00] SPEAKER_00: Um so even before you get into process and how that is instituted in the next chapter and then sub subsequent chapters between a session or or before a presbytery, that this one establishes who those two different parties are.
[10:15] SPEAKER_00: And uh and it seems to begin in an odd place, right?
[10:20] SPEAKER_00: Because it's talking about parties, but then it immediately talks about jurisdiction.
[10:24] SPEAKER_00: But the you might say the source of those parties is going to be different depending upon whether we're talking about a minister who has his membership with a presbytery or a regular member who has their membership with a session, so that the jurisdiction, the place where those parties are first heard, um is part of the process.
[10:48] SPEAKER_00: So later chapters, yes, but it also is important because it establishes um in a in a sense like where those parties would go and under whose authority those parties are going to be debating and and arguing in their cases.
[11:04] SPEAKER_00: So really it just sets up uh you know sets up jurisdiction.
[11:09] SPEAKER_00: I mean, it's not much more difficult than that.
[11:12] SPEAKER_00: Um with the two provisions 34-1 and 33-1 uh regarding how original jurisdiction can be assumed, um there's lots of debate and discussion over those phrases, but um but you know, the the the the right to to hear and then to determine that case uh resides ultimately where the individual's membership is.
[11:40] SPEAKER_02: And it's good to remind um our listeners, but just generally in the PCA, that that membership for the pastor is in the presbytery, and it's not the role or work of the session to bring discipline to the pastor, that appeal is to be to the presbytery.
[11:57] SPEAKER_02: And so it's not the session's role to shepherd the minister in the midst of a failure.
[12:02] SPEAKER_02: Uh it's something that's actually better ground in the presbytery.
[12:06] SPEAKER_02: And I know that sometimes sessions try to deal with things, but when it comes to ministers, it's not that's outside of their jurisdiction.
[12:13] SPEAKER_02: They they have to go to the presbytery to have intervention.
[12:17] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I remember an issue happening in a church in a previous uh presbytery that I was a part of in uh Texas, where there was an issue that happened, it became known to the session, and they started trying to debate what it was that they were going to do.
[12:31] SPEAKER_03: And eventually one of the teaching elders said, Stop.
[12:34] SPEAKER_03: This is this is not our discipline matter.
[12:36] SPEAKER_03: We're not starting process here.
[12:38] SPEAKER_03: We're we're getting all of this together and forwarding it to the presbytery.
[12:41] SPEAKER_03: So it's it's good to know if you have an issue that comes up with a deacon or a ruling elder or a member session, you need to take care of that.
[12:48] SPEAKER_03: But if it's a teaching elder, uh, at least at an area in which you need to start process, that's supposed to be the presbytery level.
[12:56] SPEAKER_01: It may be worth saying here too that the church members are accountable to the session and not a higher court uh in a similar sense.
[13:03] SPEAKER_01: I've seen situations where a presbytery uh might try to get involved.
[13:08] SPEAKER_01: You know, they get involved through an issue with a teaching elder and they try to start doing things in the local congregation.
[13:13] SPEAKER_01: That's not allowed.
[13:14] SPEAKER_01: Um members are not accountable to the presbytery, uh, they are held accountable to their local session.
[13:20] SPEAKER_00: Well, and and part of it, you know, especially when you think about church members, that obviously, you know, the the the the the process matter is more for the for later chapters.
[13:31] SPEAKER_00: But but there's a huge issue in process where you know those individuals who are you know sort of closest to that person, know them best, interact with them most, um they have a better capacity, at least potential capacity, right, to uh be able to know, again, I mean know character, uh know whether someone holds a grudge against somebody else, uh establish testimony and all the rest.
[13:59] SPEAKER_00: And if that is usurped by a presbytery who theoretically knows the pastor better than they know the members, then there there could be, I mean, not necessarily, but there could be uh a skewing in the favor of a pastor.
[14:13] SPEAKER_00: Um but also, and this is a more of an issue, I think, with with teaching elders when the General Assembly assumes original jurisdiction, that anytime original jurisdiction is assumed, one level of appeal has automatically been removed.
[14:30] SPEAKER_00: Uh, if you're a member of a set or a church and the session uh or the jurisdiction of the session is usurped by the presbyter, or not usurped, but just taken up by the presbytery, you obviously cannot appeal to the presbytery anymore.
[14:43] SPEAKER_00: The presbytery is now dealing with that.
[14:46] SPEAKER_00: And similarly, with a teaching elder, if a presbytery refused to act, whatever that means, um, then the General Assembly can assume that jurisdiction, but there's no appeal at that point.
[14:59] SPEAKER_00: It's whatever whatever decision is made.
[15:02] SPEAKER_00: Um, and you know the benefits of an appeal, you know, somebody who is not frustrated by 80 hours of testimony, you know, and just says, just throws the book at the guy at the end because he's tired of listening or whatever.
[15:16] SPEAKER_00: That they can theoretically, as an appeal, sort of dispassionately look at everything and and try to see whether it was done correctly.
[15:23] SPEAKER_00: But uh but I guess you guys will take those up in 33 and 34 later.
[15:28] SPEAKER_03: And this is why Scott is for a 33 and a 34.
[15:31] SPEAKER_03: Well, I think this is why Scott is for uh synods, right?
[15:34] SPEAKER_03: So you'd have another level of appeal, Scott.
[15:36] SPEAKER_02: I hate synods.
[15:37] SPEAKER_02: No, synods, no.
[15:39] SPEAKER_02: We don't need more bureaucracy.
[15:40] SPEAKER_02: We need less bureaucracy.
[15:42] SPEAKER_02: Don't do this to us.
[15:43] SPEAKER_00: Well that we could have less.
[15:44] SPEAKER_00: I mean, if you're like he's adding a layer.
[15:47] SPEAKER_00: Is there a layer we can get rid of?
[15:48] SPEAKER_00: Is that what you're saying?
[15:49] SPEAKER_02: No, you get out of here.
[15:51] SPEAKER_02: No.
[15:52] SPEAKER_02: Let's let's let's gut the bureaucracy, yes.
[15:56] SPEAKER_02: We're gonna doge the PCA.
[15:58] SPEAKER_02: That's the that's the goal.
[16:00] SPEAKER_01: Okay, I think that's my cue to move on to the next section.
[16:04] SPEAKER_01: Uh I we're gonna probably try to deal with 32, 31.2 in you know, one paragraph at a time, but I'm gonna read both of them altogether just in case we start to bleed over.
[16:14] SPEAKER_01: I don't want people to be out of context.
[16:16] SPEAKER_01: So 312 reads It is the duty of all church sessions and presbyteries to exercise care over those subject to their authority.
[16:24] SPEAKER_01: They shall with due diligence and great discretion demand from such persons satisfactory explanations concerning reports affecting their Christian character.
[16:33] SPEAKER_01: This duty is more imperative when those who deem themselves aggrieved by injurious reports shall ask an investigation.
[16:40] SPEAKER_01: If such investigation, however originating, should result in raising a strong presumption of the guilt of the party involved, the court shall institute process and shall appoint a prosecutor to prepare the indictment and to conduct the case.
[16:52] SPEAKER_01: This prosecutor shall be a member of the court, except that in a case before the session he may be any communing member of the same congregation with the accused.
[17:01] SPEAKER_01: Okay.
[17:03] SPEAKER_01: The first paragraph is probably the easiest to deal with of these two, or maybe it's the lighter of the two, I suppose.
[17:10] SPEAKER_01: Um, that sessions and presbyteries need to exercise care over those subject to their authority.
[17:15] SPEAKER_01: Um what's the significance of this?
[17:19] SPEAKER_01: I mean, let's let's talk about this and emphasize this to our listeners, right?
[17:22] SPEAKER_01: This is a big deal, uh, this instruction here.
[17:27] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean, in one sense, the first sentence isn't really saying anything that you can't find elsewhere in the BCO or that isn't implied uh by you know that the duties and powers belonging jointly and severally to sessions and presbyteries.
[17:43] SPEAKER_00: Um but I think it is reiterated here so that the second sentence, and really the rest of it, but certainly the second sentence, is is attaching itself to something that no small part of the duty that is being, you know, the broad duty that's being referred to in the first sentence is um how they handle reports concerning or reports affecting the Christian character of a member, you know, someone who's subject to the authority, the jurisdiction of that particular court.
[18:18] SPEAKER_00: Um and so they cannot, uh, you know, just as they should not ignore uh, say, you know, sinful activities in the members that they themselves are witnesses to, um so also they should take seriously reports from someone that says uh, you know, Mr.
[18:40] SPEAKER_00: Smith is sinning in whatever manner, right?
[18:44] SPEAKER_00: I mean, they need to take those seriously, and um they uh it it provides then a particular way in which the session can investigate those reports.
[18:58] SPEAKER_00: Um and and so it uses the phrase, right, uh you know, they shall, with due diligence and great discretion, demand um from such persons satisfactory explanations.
[19:12] SPEAKER_00: So if they get a report about Mr.
[19:14] SPEAKER_00: Smith, they need to um first of all discern, in one sense, the nature of that accusation.
[19:25] SPEAKER_00: Um and then there they have discretion.
[19:29] SPEAKER_00: I mean, I think that's something that that Ramsey in particular points out that the the court receiving this report, the court receiving the report has discretion in whether it it wants to investigate it at all, um and and indeed it they have great discretion, uh, but at the same time that that requirement uh to at least do their due diligence, whatever, you know, however we want to describe that, uh, so that they can pursue those reports and and come to a satisfactory explanation of whatever event is being alleged.
[20:08] SPEAKER_02: So uh what event would likely lead to no investigation from the court?
[20:14] SPEAKER_00: Well, I mean I could I could think of two.
[20:17] SPEAKER_00: One where someone brings a report regarding an event or an action that isn't sinned.
[20:27] SPEAKER_00: Um so if you receive a report that um I mean I can't even think of an example, but you know, Mr.
[20:33] SPEAKER_00: Smith um walks his dog on the opposite side of the street, then I think he should.
[20:38] SPEAKER_00: Well, okay, that's whatever.
[20:40] SPEAKER_00: Um so that's one where and I know that was a silly example, but my point is like, you know, there's an allegation where there is no there's no sin attached to it.
[20:50] SPEAKER_00: Um I think the other would in the same way that you can refuse to take up a charge against someone if the person bringing that charge is known to be um you know litigious or have something against that individual, uh, I think you could you could make a decision not to go forward with it.
[21:14] SPEAKER_00: So you I mean think about like a uh a situation that that I was in once where not me personally, I was in the presbytery where an individual was bringing up sort of 31-2 request after 31-2 request after 31-2 request.
[21:31] SPEAKER_00: Um and at a certain point the presbytery just said, We're not gonna take this, we're not, you know, we're not gonna keep listening to you come back to us again and again and again and again.
[21:43] SPEAKER_00: Um I mean, in in particular, it was sort of like you have every capacity to file charges against this man, but you want us to do all the heavy lifting of an investigation, etc.
[21:54] SPEAKER_00: etcetera.
[21:55] SPEAKER_00: So I think that there are sorry, I think there are circumstances where.
[22:00] SPEAKER_00: The court would be within its discretion to decide not to investigate.
[22:05] SPEAKER_00: But I th but I want to be very clear though, especially to our listeners, uh, if you're an elder involved in any of these courts, I think that should be the extreme exception rather than the rule.
[22:19] SPEAKER_00: Um that in the vast majority of the cases that we that that come up where a report can some concerning someone's Christian character is brought to a court, that the court ought to uh ought to do what this section requires.
[22:35] SPEAKER_00: Um and and if I can I go on for two more seconds here.
[22:40] SPEAKER_00: I'm sorry.
[22:41] SPEAKER_00: Um I think there are a couple of things too that are very important that need to be addressed here as well.
[22:48] SPEAKER_00: That first of all, um the the reports can take a whole variety of uh of forms.
[22:59] SPEAKER_00: Um and so it isn't necessary, I don't think, for a court to try to or sorry, it's not not it's not necessary.
[23:09] SPEAKER_00: I think it would be counterproductive for a court to nitpick what constitutes a report or not, or in what format it comes, or potentially even who it comes from.
[23:21] SPEAKER_00: They should look at those things not so much on the basis of does it dot all I's and cross all T's or whatever, but rather look at the substance of it and investigate it from that perspective.
[23:34] SPEAKER_00: Um so that's one.
[23:37] SPEAKER_00: But the other, which I've also seen at times that this is not handled very well, is that 31-2 requires that if the presbytery or the court rather, if the court is going to conduct this investigation, that the person from whom they are to demand these answers are the person who is accused.
[23:58] SPEAKER_00: Right?
[23:59] SPEAKER_00: So a 31-2 investigation that never speaks to the person who was accused of doing something wrong isn't a 31-2 investigation.
[24:11] SPEAKER_00: Um that doesn't mean they can't interview other people, especially if the report was vague or confusing or whatever else.
[24:20] SPEAKER_00: I mean, get all the details, but you have to take those to the individual, the the person who's being accused, and and demand satisfactory explanations from them concerning those reports about their Christian character.
[24:35] SPEAKER_00: Um, and again, you know, story time with Steve, but I have been on a 31-2 investigation before, and I sat through hours and hours and hours of reports from um the individuals who were making the accusations, and all of the members of that committee, as we were talking about it before we spoke to the individual about whom those reports had been given, we were like, wow, this guy's you know horrible.
[25:00] SPEAKER_00: And but but then when we heard his side of the story, right?
[25:04] SPEAKER_00: You know, that uh I think there's a proverb about this, right?
[25:06] SPEAKER_00: The the the first person who speaks seems right until you hear the second person.
[25:10] SPEAKER_00: You know, and and and so if we hadn't done what 31.2 requires, which is to talk to the person about whom the accusations have been made, uh, we might have been willing to find a strong presumption of guilt.
[25:24] SPEAKER_00: But once we heard both sides, and once we specifically heard his answers uh concerning those reports, uh it was far clearer to us that uh that he was not, that there was no strong presumption of guilt.
[25:38] SPEAKER_00: Um so anyway, so yeah, I think that that sentence is uh very important, very pregnant with lots of meaning, and there's a lot of lot packed in there.
[25:48] SPEAKER_02: I I wonder, though the 31.2 does dem it it says make it makes a demand for satisfactory explanation.
[25:57] SPEAKER_02: Uh for those who are accused, do they have liberty to not participate in that said investigation?
[26:05] SPEAKER_02: Uh what is the rights perhaps for the person accused in this sense?
[26:09] SPEAKER_02: Because this is before trial.
[26:11] SPEAKER_02: And so they're not being indicted, they're not yeah, nothing is under scrutiny in that sense.
[26:17] SPEAKER_02: This is like pretrial stuff.
[26:18] SPEAKER_02: Uh, what what should can the accused not participate?
[26:22] SPEAKER_02: When is it wise for that if it is possible?
[26:26] SPEAKER_01: It strikes me as a very pastoral comment that that you know so many things come to us on our session or I mean and and and previous to this session too.
[26:36] SPEAKER_01: We hear about something going on with an individual in our church, and and a pastor or an elder will approach them and hey, what's going on?
[26:43] SPEAKER_01: We heard about this thing.
[26:45] SPEAKER_01: That's probably not a good thing if it's true, but we didn't want to assume anything because we heard about it, and so we want to ask you what's going on.
[26:52] SPEAKER_01: That's the way that I well, I mean, uh somebody could correct me if I'm wrong.
[26:55] SPEAKER_01: You you two other guys, maybe we do need to read this technically, but they will, with due diligence and great discretion, demand from such person satisfactory explanations concerning reports affecting their Christian character.
[27:07] SPEAKER_01: That's like that feels to me the way I approach my children when I hear that they've sinned against their sibling.
[27:13] SPEAKER_01: I go, hey, I need you to tell me what's going on because I'm I'm responsible for you.
[27:17] SPEAKER_01: Uh I don't know if there's a lot demanded of them in as much as it is an imploring on our part of them to to come into the the dialogue.
[27:29] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I I mean I I think I would take it a little bit more than that.
[27:33] SPEAKER_00: Um, you know, kind of answer Scott's question that if uh because the 31-2 investigation, in my opinion, is not something that um is part of the the broad sense of discipline.
[27:51] SPEAKER_00: Uh I think for a court to do something like this, they have to do it as a court.
[27:56] SPEAKER_00: Right?
[27:57] SPEAKER_00: So this is not a several power, this is a joint power.
[28:00] SPEAKER_00: And and whether they do that as a whole or whether they you know give that to a commission or a committee or whatever, that that body is is acting in that sense on behalf of the court, and and therefore they do have a right to to make a demand of the person who's so accused.
[28:18] SPEAKER_00: Um now obviously, maybe not so obviously, right?
[28:22] SPEAKER_00: I mean, they can't pull out their torture devices until you give answers.
[28:26] SPEAKER_00: Um and and even then, right, I mean, you can't demand from somebody satisfactory explanations if there are no satisfactory explanations, right?
[28:37] SPEAKER_00: If there's no satisfactory explanation, then probably you're gonna find a strong presumption of guilt.
[28:44] SPEAKER_00: Well, yeah, yeah, go ahead.
[28:45] SPEAKER_01: Well, I was just gonna say, so do you see a distinction between the second sentence of the first paragraph and the third sentence of the first paragraph?
[28:52] SPEAKER_01: Because I was thinking more that the second sentence is that uh individual, pastoral, and then it it moves to an investigation in the third sentence.
[29:04] SPEAKER_01: Do you or do you see both of those as being a part of investigation altogether?
[29:09] SPEAKER_00: Well, I I think the second and the third sentence make reference to the two sources of a 31-2 investigation.
[29:17] SPEAKER_00: So that the third sentence is saying if I go to my presbytery and say, you know, one of my ruling elders is spreading lies about me in the congregation, and I need you to defend my good name or something along those lines.
[29:32] SPEAKER_00: I mean, I suppose the question would be, why don't you bring him up on charges of slander or something?
[29:36] SPEAKER_00: But um, but but still, uh, or maybe, you know, somebody outside the presbytery is accusing me of something, and I want the presbytery to investigate, because as we said earlier, right?
[29:46] SPEAKER_00: I mean, they're the only ones who can do that kind of investigation of me.
[29:50] SPEAKER_00: And so I I I want you to uh I've been I've been aggrieved by injurious reports and I want an investigation.
[29:57] SPEAKER_00: Uh but I do think the second sentence is much more the court receives those reports, those those accusations against someone, and that they need to go to that person and and to to get a satisfactory or you know, at least to seek a satisfactory answer.
[30:14] SPEAKER_00: I mean, again, I think you know demanding a satisfactory exam explanation almost presumes there is one.
[30:20] SPEAKER_01: Well, but if there is an investigation, is what you're saying.
[30:23] SPEAKER_01: It's the same as a good idea.
[30:23] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, absolutely.
[30:25] SPEAKER_00: That is the Jared.
[30:28] SPEAKER_03: I I think directly to Scott's question though, I don't think you have a right to remain silent.
[30:33] SPEAKER_03: Um if you're a teaching elder, you need to have an answer for all of your conduct and all of your doctrine.
[30:38] SPEAKER_03: Um so I don't think you can say I'm not gonna cooperate with investigation and say that they're not gonna draw some sort of level of guilt from that.
[30:46] SPEAKER_00: Um, but it also I think at that point you're violating a vow to be subject to your brothers and the Lord, too.
[30:53] SPEAKER_00: Um I mean, particularly if this is before a presbytery.
[30:56] SPEAKER_00: I mean, maybe you could say a committee, um, but like a commission or a presbytery, absolutely, if they ask you, they have every right to ask you.
[31:06] SPEAKER_00: Um if they don't have a right to ask you, then nobody has a right to ask you.
[31:10] SPEAKER_00: And you know, that's not Presbyterian, that's not Christian.
[31:14] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, nobody wants to live in that world.
[31:16] SPEAKER_00: So uh, well, I shouldn't say that.
[31:18] SPEAKER_00: I don't want to live in that world.
[31:20] SPEAKER_03: Well, and implied there too is that you may want to clear your name.
[31:24] SPEAKER_03: I mean, here in 31.2, it's implied, and think in 31.5, it's a little more explicit.
[31:29] SPEAKER_03: The person may say, hey, look, there's not a strong presumption of guilt here.
[31:33] SPEAKER_03: I want you to investigate this so that when this comes up, I can point back and say, they looked into it.
[31:38] SPEAKER_03: Here's the report that's been answered.
[31:40] SPEAKER_03: Um so there's much more of a willingness there to submit to your brethren in that process.
[31:45] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[31:46] SPEAKER_01: I think investigation is is such a technical term that it I would love to see it inside that second sentence of the first paragraph.
[31:55] SPEAKER_01: Just even just for the clarity that we've the the um the lack of clarity that has been present here, mostly on my part.
[32:02] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, but it yeah, I think it needs to say something like with due diligence and great discretion, conduct an investigation in which they demand, or something like that.
[32:11] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[32:12] SPEAKER_00: Um and there was an attempt a few years ago uh to radically change this section um from at least one member of the SJC, if not a couple.
[32:24] SPEAKER_00: Uh it didn't go anywhere because I think it was too radical.
[32:26] SPEAKER_00: We don't like big, big changes to the rules of discipline.
[32:31] SPEAKER_00: Like we didn't like that one last summer.
[32:33] SPEAKER_00: Um, so I I think there is a lot of help that could could could go here.
[32:39] SPEAKER_00: Um because that that is one of the difficulties, right?
[32:42] SPEAKER_00: I mean, I know this kind of goes far afield, but uh a lot of presbyteries or a lot of presbyters, I'll say, believe that you cannot institute process without doing a 31-2 investigation, and that's completely wrong.
[32:57] SPEAKER_00: Um this is you don't have to do a 31-2 investigation.
[33:02] SPEAKER_00: What is required to do process is somebody needs to make out a charge.
[33:06] SPEAKER_00: And in fact, the very reason why the 31-2 investigation section is in chapter 31 is because it lays out one way in which a party in a case of process uh can come forth, right?
[33:21] SPEAKER_00: The the presbytery conducts an investigation, finds a strong presumption of guilt, and then proceeds to process that that that is one way through which uh a party in the case can arise.
[33:33] SPEAKER_00: I mean, the other party is obviously the accused, he's a right, he's arisen because there's accusations against him, but the but a party can arise within the court through a 31-2 investigation, but all that is required for a case is for someone to make out a charge.
[33:49] SPEAKER_00: You don't have to go through 31-2.
[33:52] SPEAKER_00: But even apart from that confusion, I I do think a lot of presbyteries, and I've seen several, whether it's through RPR or through just helping Presbyteries with various you know judicial things, uh their 31-2 investigations are um sort of one of two far kind of pendulum swings.
[34:16] SPEAKER_00: Either they sent you know Jared to go sit down over coffee with somebody and say, hey man, can you tell me what happened?
[34:23] SPEAKER_00: Or they basically conduct a trial under the auspice of a 31-2, invest, you know, they they cross you know, witnesses out the you know, whatever.
[34:33] SPEAKER_00: Um so anyway, I I do think 31-2 is is a section that could definitely benefit from more specificity, even what you were saying, Ben, but but even in sense of like some helpful guidance in how to conduct a 31-2 investigation, um as it stands, you have this enormous duty placed upon a uh a group of uh presbyters, either a session or a presbytery, and yet you're really not s saying how to do that.
[35:05] SPEAKER_00: How is that done?
[35:06] SPEAKER_00: What is the standard?
[35:07] SPEAKER_00: I know strong presumption of guilt, which is I'm sure we'll get there in a minute, but um but but even that standard is confusing to most people.
[35:16] SPEAKER_00: I don't I don't think it's confusing, but I think most people come to that and they find it very confusing.
[35:20] SPEAKER_00: So anyway, I I think it it could be helped with some uh additional things.
[35:26] SPEAKER_01: Well, at at the risk of well, there's no risk.
[35:29] SPEAKER_01: We are running long, and this is gonna be a long chapter, and we probably won't finish it today, so just heads up to you guys who are here with me, and we'll figure it out.
[35:37] SPEAKER_01: Um because we need to spend some time in here.
[35:39] SPEAKER_01: So let's go into that second paragraph of 312.
[35:42] SPEAKER_01: Steve just referenced it.
[35:44] SPEAKER_01: If such investigation, however originating, should result in raising a strong presumption of the guilt of the party involved, the court shall institute process, which involves appointing a prosecutor uh to prepare the indictment and to conduct the case.
[35:56] SPEAKER_01: So the investigation, however it goes, right, from one of those two sentences in the first paragraph, you come at the end of it and there's a strong presumption of guilt that uh of the party who's been accused, uh, and the court shall institute process.
[36:13] SPEAKER_01: So the big question is gonna be what amounts to a strong presumption of guilt?
[36:19] SPEAKER_01: And I think the answer is gonna be, like Guy Waters was telling us the last time, or when we recorded with him last time, it's always up to the discretion of the court.
[36:26] SPEAKER_01: But let's talk about what uh categories we're gonna use to think through that.
[36:30] SPEAKER_01: Jared just unmuted, so I'm gonna kick to him.
[36:33] SPEAKER_03: Ramsey has a good quote on this where he says, a strong presumption means a belief by the members of the court that the evidence as then known to them would indicate that guilt probably exists, unless evidence to the contrary can be produced not then known to them.
[36:49] SPEAKER_03: So we at least have a definition, and then now you just have to apply it.
[36:54] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and I mean two things it doesn't mean, right?
[36:59] SPEAKER_00: It it doesn't mean that the person is presumed guilty in the sense of sort of American jurisprudence, where a lot of people, uh either even, you know, even elders who should know better would object to that language being used because I thought I was innocent until proven guilty, or I thought, you know, Ben was innocent until proven guilty, and it's like, well, he is.
[37:25] SPEAKER_00: But on the other hand, if we did an investigation, why would we why would we want to go to charges if there was a strong presumption he was innocent?
[37:37] SPEAKER_00: Like, why would we do that if we didn't think he there there was enough evidence before us as a committee or as a presbytery, right, to say, based like you know, like Jared was saying, based on what we know now, without a defense having been given by the accused, based on what we know now, uh, I mean, again, maybe to use the language from the court systems, right?
[38:01] SPEAKER_00: I mean, there's sufficient probable cause for us to say an offense was committed and you committed it in the ways uh you know that we're gonna end up putting in the indictment.
[38:12] SPEAKER_00: And so it it's not a denial that someone is innocent until they've actually been charged by a uh by judicial process or through judicial process.
[38:25] SPEAKER_00: Um, but it would be a foolish waste of everyone's time for a court to proceed with a trial that that didn't think the person was guilty through an investigation.
[38:40] SPEAKER_00: It's an unfortunate phrase, but I think it makes a very important point that the only way you can go forward is and it's not again, it's not even a slight presumption, it has to be strong presumption.
[38:52] SPEAKER_02: Um can you can you distinguish between slight and strong?
[39:00] SPEAKER_00: So no, I can't.
[39:04] SPEAKER_00: Um but but but but I think what what I would say is is that I mean again, it comes back to based upon everything that we've heard thus far, it seems probable without without having heard a defense, right?
[39:19] SPEAKER_00: I mean, if if we just had to decide this case purely on the basis of the investigation so far, that it seems very probable that this individual is guilty of these offenses.
[39:32] SPEAKER_00: And the only way that we're gonna get to the bottom of this is through a trial.
[39:40] SPEAKER_00: Because I mean, remember that there's a number of things, well, there's a lot of things that differentiate a trial from an investigation, but I think one of the biggest ones is the fact that you get to cross-examine witnesses, right?
[39:51] SPEAKER_00: When you do an investigation like this, you're, I mean, I think if you're doing it correctly, the group, the committee or the presbytery, whatever, is going to interview a whole lot of people, and on the basis of those interviews, is going to make a decision about whether there is a strong presumption of guilt.
[40:07] SPEAKER_00: But the defense is not going to be in a position to cross-examine, to bring their own evidence.
[40:11] SPEAKER_00: I mean, theoretically, the person, as you demand satisfactory explanations from him, is going to try and explain the situation.
[40:19] SPEAKER_00: Um, but that's not the same as being able to cross-examine.
[40:23] SPEAKER_00: That's not the same as having the rules of evidence and all the rest.
[40:26] SPEAKER_00: And the other big thing is that there's no transcript in a 31-2 investigation.
[40:32] SPEAKER_00: And so there really isn't any other way, you know, that you can't appeal it, right?
[40:39] SPEAKER_00: I mean, you know, that there's nothing you can do with it until it goes to trial.
[40:42] SPEAKER_00: Uh so I think in that sense, I know I'm not really answering your question, um, Scott, but I think that there is a um when I say the difference between slight and strong, um I I think it's more than just there are accusations against the individual.
[41:03] SPEAKER_00: Um I think there is, I think it comes down, I mean to me it would come down to is there a question about the explanations that have been received as to whether or not they address, they satisfactorily, satisfactorily say that five times fast, address the the concerns that have been brought up.
[41:23] SPEAKER_00: Um and if they don't, then that you know, again, depending on the the nature of the accusations.
[41:30] SPEAKER_00: I I don't think there's any way to say here is the here's the standard.
[41:37] SPEAKER_00: Um I mean, even if you look at again, I mean, uh on one level, I I don't want to bring too much from American jurisprudence into this because I think that messes us up more often than not.
[41:47] SPEAKER_00: Um, but even then, like preponderance of evidence, okay, you can say, well, that's 51%, but how do you subjectively, I mean, I'm not a judge, so I don't know, but I mean, how would you actually subjectively say I think it's 51%?
[42:03] SPEAKER_00: I mean, it's still a feeling, right?
[42:05] SPEAKER_00: There's no mathematical way to do that.
[42:09] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so it still comes down to judgment.
[42:13] SPEAKER_00: Um on one level, I think you're safer if you lean in the direction of let's have a trial uh for all of those reasons.
[42:27] SPEAKER_00: Cross-examination, we'll have a record, we have rules of evidence, you know, all of those different things that come into it.
[42:33] SPEAKER_00: Um and it's you know, I think it's better in that sense, if if if there's some hesitation, maybe even to say, we'll do the trial, and that will determine more clearly and more effectively guilt or innocence.
[42:49] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I I ask because often, at least what I've seen in my short time when navigating these issues, is that an accusation will be made, uh, you have an investigative committee investigate it.
[43:02] SPEAKER_02: It doesn't seem as crazy as those who accused were making it out to be, but there is still some guilt.
[43:10] SPEAKER_02: There's still some guilt.
[43:11] SPEAKER_02: Uh the the pastor didn't do everything he was supposed to do, and he he made some mistakes, he lashed out, and and so he's like he's guilty in some respect of certain sins, but not perhaps the whole bandwidth of what he's being accused of.
[43:26] SPEAKER_02: And so I guess my curiosity with this strong presumption of guilt is like, well, do you still take him to trial?
[43:32] SPEAKER_02: It's like, okay, well, yeah, he's guilty of like jaywalking, uh, you know, he he has violated it, he has admitted to violating it, uh, he did that, but he really didn't do all these other things, or they're very greatly exaggerated.
[43:44] SPEAKER_02: And so it's like there is some guilt in that sense, but not necessarily like, well, do we take someone to trial for for you know bad a bad inter a single bad interaction or something like that?
[43:58] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[43:58] SPEAKER_00: Well, but but I I think that in that sense, one of the one of the differences is so again, you know, back to the the sort of the two ways that process begins.
[44:11] SPEAKER_00: Either you go through a 31.2 or somebody makes out a charge.
[44:15] SPEAKER_00: Somebody makes that a charge.
[44:17] SPEAKER_00: Even there, there's still a responsibility on the part of the court to say, do these charges rise to actual offenses?
[44:25] SPEAKER_00: Um there's a there's a whole slew of reasons why a court could throw out charges on the basis of some of the things that you're talking about.
[44:35] SPEAKER_00: Um and even here, like let's say the report has you know seven different things that they're alleging that poor Jared did.
[44:44] SPEAKER_00: Jared's mean, Jared's cruel, you know, I don't know, he's got bad breath or something.
[44:49] SPEAKER_00: Sorry, Jared.
[44:50] SPEAKER_00: Um, you know, and and as you go down through all of those things, you find out that, well, only one of them is um does there seem to be a strong presumption of guilt?
[45:00] SPEAKER_00: I I don't think it is you have to take all seven of them and file charges.
[45:04] SPEAKER_00: I mean, that that would be counterproductive.
[45:07] SPEAKER_00: But I think the issue is is that it raises a strong presumption of guilt about something that that person has done.
[45:16] SPEAKER_00: And and then I I do think that we're still back on a previous chapter on offenses, or that there is a difference between I mean it it doesn't simply say sins, I mean it it uses the specific language of offenses.
[45:32] SPEAKER_00: And so the court at that point ultimately you can only charge somebody with an offense, not just per with a you know with a particular sin, if that makes sense, right?
[45:43] SPEAKER_00: I mean, I'm hoping you guys covered that section and all of those distinctions.
[45:48] SPEAKER_00: I I'm pretty sure it it's prior to this one.
[45:50] SPEAKER_00: Um and so I I I think that there is still that discretion, and and the issue here is is that if taking it holistically, if that committee in the course of their investigation determines that an offense has occurred, or at least that there's a strong presumption that an offense has occurred, and there's a strong presumption that that person is guilty of that offense, then then there is no uh discretion at that point about proceeding to charges.
[46:23] SPEAKER_00: Uh they they they must institute process by you know uh appointing a prosecutor, drawing up an indictment, etc.
[46:31] SPEAKER_00: Um but I don't think that binds them so much to the report as they're bound to the outcome of their investigation about the report.
[46:46] SPEAKER_00: Um so uh somebody may have you know all kinds of uh things that someone doesn't like about them, but none of them are offenses, none of them may even be sins.
[46:59] SPEAKER_00: Those do not you you don't have to say, well, you know, Jared really is guilty of whatever small minor thing, so we have to go proceed with an indictment.
[47:08] SPEAKER_00: I don't think you have to do that.
[47:10] SPEAKER_00: Um but you also have to be able to defend those decisions because it's all subject to the review and control of the higher court.
[47:18] SPEAKER_01: Um so well and we may also say because the the PCA in the next section we're gonna get to, I'm trying to segue if we can.
[47:25] SPEAKER_01: Um because the PCA it herself is the accuser, and so the investigation sort of brings them into the position of being the official accuser, and so then they indict and and bring into trial instead of it leaving on the one report wherever it may have arisen from.
[47:42] SPEAKER_01: Uh before we get into it though, do y'all want to say anything about prosecutor?
[47:47] SPEAKER_01: We're there's gonna be more about this in future chapters.
[47:49] SPEAKER_01: Um but prosecutor has to be a member of the court, except before session it can be any commuting member.
[47:55] SPEAKER_01: Jared.
[47:55] SPEAKER_03: Well, that's in 31.5, so we can talk about it there.
[48:00] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, next week or whenever it may be.
[48:05] SPEAKER_01: Uh my goal is to make it my goal is to make it through this page.
[48:08] SPEAKER_01: So that that's that's where I'm at at this point.
[48:11] SPEAKER_01: Um, let's go on to 31.3.
[48:15] SPEAKER_01: Now that we have squeezed every drop out of 31.2, as we expected we would.
[48:19] SPEAKER_03: Well, I could say more.
[48:20] SPEAKER_01: The original and I believe you.
[48:24] SPEAKER_01: Uh the original and only parties in the case of process are the accuser and the accused.
[48:28] SPEAKER_01: The accuser is always the Presbyterian Church in America whose honor and purity are to be maintained.
[48:33] SPEAKER_01: The prosecutor, whether voluntary or appointed, is always the representative of the church and as such has all rights in the case.
[48:41] SPEAKER_01: All its rights in the case.
[48:42] SPEAKER_01: In appellate courts, the parties are known as appellant and appellee.
[48:47] SPEAKER_01: So the PCA is the accuser, not an individual person.
[48:50] SPEAKER_01: Let's just start off by saying this probably would sound weird to somebody that wasn't aware of it.
[48:55] SPEAKER_01: Right?
[48:55] SPEAKER_01: You come to it for the first time.
[48:57] SPEAKER_01: Wait, the PCA is always the one accusing.
[48:59] SPEAKER_01: I thought it was my session or you know, the Presbytery, but the PCA.
[49:03] SPEAKER_01: Why um why is it this way?
[49:07] SPEAKER_01: Nobody?
[49:08] SPEAKER_00: I don't know.
[49:09] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[49:10] SPEAKER_00: Um well, and I think that's where in in one sense, you know, one of the things that I think Ramsey talks about is this idea that um especially the um the accuser as acting on behalf of the church is basically given the powers of the church.
[49:29] SPEAKER_00: And and since the although this is a later section, but um because it is um the church and Christ as the head of the church who's ultimately been offended by those actions, or at least presumably been offended by those actions, um, that they are standing in place of the church.
[49:54] SPEAKER_00: Um that even even in a personal offense between you know two individuals, a private personal offense, that once that issue comes before the church, that it is no longer uh just two individuals hashing it out, but that the church is taking up the accusation uh on behalf of Christ in the name of Christ, and is pursuing that through um you know through its prosecutor.
[50:21] SPEAKER_00: Um and so that they do have um the rights of the church in that case.
[50:29] SPEAKER_00: And I think that goes back to those issues of um you know subpoena power, the limited level that we have that, um that all the courts that that come into that as opposed to you know a Benure or somebody was making this reference to, you know, when my kid comes and they've been fighting with each other and I demand an action, um, you know, one of them does not take on the role of father, you know, in that that case.
[50:57] SPEAKER_00: But this is a very different type of situation.
[51:00] SPEAKER_03: Um how does that work though with uh 319 that if it's a voluntary prosecutor, that they can be held liable at the end of that as an accuser of the brethren if he doesn't prove his case?
[51:13] SPEAKER_00: Well, and I think, yeah, that that's that's one issue.
[51:16] SPEAKER_00: The other issue is in appellate courts, then it's no longer you know the Presbytery of the Ascension versus Jared Nelson.
[51:26] SPEAKER_00: Now it's you know, you have a representative, the appellee, and and you have the uh yeah, the accused, the appellants.
[51:35] SPEAKER_00: I mean it it is it it almost breaks down at that point, too.
[51:38] SPEAKER_00: Um but I I I think that in the case of a voluntary prosecutor, it's not that as a voluntary prosecutor, you're in a separate circumstance, you still are considered the church for the for the sake of pursuing it.
[51:55] SPEAKER_00: But if it is determined at the end of all of this that you didn't prove your case, uh then you're sub yeah, then then you're still subject to that uh jeopardy of being an accuser of the brethren.
[52:07] SPEAKER_00: Uh I know I just sort of restated it rather than explained it, but but I think there's a connection anyway.
[52:14] SPEAKER_00: I don't know.
[52:17] SPEAKER_01: Y'all okay?
[52:18] SPEAKER_01: I don't feel quite square on that one, but I think it'll maybe become clearer as we go.
[52:23] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, one of the things that and this is this is from Hodge, um which in one sense doesn't have the middle sentence in the Book of Order, the revised book of discipline that he's commenting on.
[52:38] SPEAKER_00: But he makes this statement, it's simple it simplifies greatly the whole process of a trial.
[52:45] SPEAKER_00: Um I thought that was an interesting statement because I I wasn't sure why he was saying that because it didn't seem like it does, because we just said there's some confusion there.
[52:55] SPEAKER_00: But I imagine this is one of those areas of Presbyterian jurisprudence that kind of came about at some point for a super good reason, and the reason isn't necessarily maintained down through the books of order, just the outcome of why we need to do it this way versus another way.
[53:16] SPEAKER_00: Um, so it may be one of those things where um there was some major issue that it that arose earlier in the history of Presbyterianism that this sort of provision is aimed at preventing or circumventing, um, and we just don't know what it is.
[53:34] SPEAKER_00: Um but but I do think that the opposite idea where the court sort of just adjudicates between two parties.
[53:47] SPEAKER_00: So, like you know, again, I think the difference between like a small claims court and a criminal case, right, where the state is the one who's bringing the charges in a criminal case, and they have all the rights of the of the state because you it is a state statute, for instance, that you have violated.
[54:08] SPEAKER_00: And and because we are adjudicating offenses in courts, those offenses, however, however much they may affect an individual, ultimately all sin is sin against Jesus Christ, and his representative on the earth is the church.
[54:23] SPEAKER_00: And so there really isn't anyone who can be that accuser of an offense.
[54:30] SPEAKER_00: This isn't small claims, right?
[54:31] SPEAKER_00: This isn't brothers and sisters can't get along.
[54:34] SPEAKER_00: These are offenses, major issues.
[54:38] SPEAKER_00: And so, not only to impress upon everyone the gravity of any offense, that it is ultimately offense against Jesus Christ as the head of the church, and that it is the church that is to adjudicate those things, uh, that the accuser takes on then the role and has the rights of the church because it is the church that is making the accusation.
[55:03] SPEAKER_00: Um it also potentially gets you away from uh I mean you're never getting away from the perception of this, but at least the reality that it is not you know John Smith versus you know um William whatever it isn't that case.
[55:22] SPEAKER_00: It's not okay, it's not Jared versus Scott.
[55:24] SPEAKER_00: One of them is the representative of the church and the other is the accused.
[55:29] SPEAKER_00: And so uh you do have to maintain that difference.
[55:33] SPEAKER_00: Uh but if for whatever reason the accuser isn't able to make his case and it turns out, you know, to be baseless, then there is the the the danger of slander.
[55:44] SPEAKER_00: Does that help any Ben?
[55:46] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[55:47] SPEAKER_01: No, yeah, thank you.
[55:48] SPEAKER_01: And uh I was gonna I've gotten into this for reasons before, but um voluntary prosecutors would be somebody outside of the court, uh is my understanding.
[56:00] SPEAKER_01: So if the court has decided um we're going to indict this individual, we need a prosecutor, then them choosing a prosecutor from among their own number, like a session, picking a ruling elder to be the prosecutor, just because you're willing on the session, or even raise your hand to say that you'll do it, that doesn't make you a voluntary prosecutor subject to the end results of 31.
[56:23] SPEAKER_01: You're you're a part of the court that's doing it.
[56:25] SPEAKER_01: Uh, my understanding has been, or I've been informed rather, that it's somebody outside of that group that would volunteer to prosecute would be subject to the 31-9, which we're gonna get into later, but because it mentions voluntary here.
[56:38] SPEAKER_01: Um you don't need to be worried about it, I guess I'm saying if you're on the session and you have raised your hand to say you'll be the prosecutor, you're not you're not in trouble.
[56:45] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I think the difference is a voluntary prosecutor, in my understanding, isn't as much as this sounds weird, isn't somebody who volunteers to be a prosecutor.
[56:55] SPEAKER_00: A voluntary prosecutor is somebody who is bringing charges, right?
[56:59] SPEAKER_00: Who is the you know, who who ultimately is the offended party um and are making the accusations?
[57:07] SPEAKER_00: No, okay.
[57:07] SPEAKER_02: Um, what are the uh this is just creating a lot of questions in my mind.
[57:12] SPEAKER_02: Um so what sort of standing does one need in order to be a voluntary prosecutor?
[57:18] SPEAKER_02: Can it be just random Joe Schmoe on the street?
[57:21] SPEAKER_02: Like, do they have to be a member in good standing of any PCA church, evangelical church?
[57:26] SPEAKER_02: Like, who who is at liberty to be a voluntary prosecutor?
[57:32] SPEAKER_00: Well, the prosecutor has to be at Presbytery, they have to be a member of the court.
[57:38] SPEAKER_00: Um at a session, they only have to be a member of the church.
[57:44] SPEAKER_00: So you can't have you know your neighbor across the street who's a Jehovah's Witness come to session and say, I want to prosecute you know you before the session for an offense.
[57:57] SPEAKER_00: I mean, A, they couldn't do that because I mean, especially in that case, because they uh a Jehovah's Witness could never be the representative of Christ in his church.
[58:06] SPEAKER_00: Um but that's a whole different discussion on Jehovah's Witnesses.
[58:10] SPEAKER_00: Um but it it it it has to be uh I don't remember which section it is, maybe it's one that we'll get to soon, but but there's a statement there about who the prosecutor can be.
[58:22] SPEAKER_00: Um so if if your neighbor brings a report against you, right?
[58:31] SPEAKER_00: I mean, like let's let's, you know, worst case scenario, um someone is sleeping with their neighbor's wife and the neighbor finds out about it and brings that report before the session andor the presbytery, depending, um, they ought to do something about that, but the neighbor cannot be the voluntary prosecutor unless he also happens to be a member of Presbytery or a member of that church.
[58:56] SPEAKER_00: And so somebody's gonna have to prosecute it.
[58:58] SPEAKER_00: In that case, you end up with an appointed prosecutor, even as Ben said, even if someone says, Hey, I'll do it, that's not really voluntary in this sense.
[59:10] SPEAKER_00: That's not um that's not someone who is pursuing it as a um uh whatever you want to call it, you know, as an offended party.
[59:23] SPEAKER_00: Does that make sense?
[59:25] SPEAKER_00: Scott?
[59:28] SPEAKER_01: Scott gave a thumbs up for all those listening.
[59:32] SPEAKER_01: Which is all of you, by the way.
[59:33] SPEAKER_01: Everybody's listening, nobody's watching.
[59:37] SPEAKER_01: 314, every indictment shall begin in the name of the Presbyterian Church in America and shall conclude against the peace, unity, and purity of the church and the honor and majesty of the Lord Jesus Christ as the King and Head thereof.
[59:48] SPEAKER_01: In every case the church is the injured and accusing party against the accused.
[59:53] SPEAKER_01: And maybe to some degree this answers why the PCA is always um the accuser, is because they are um it's it's the Church of Christ.
[1:00:03] SPEAKER_01: Uh the the our our uh confession of faith calls it the kingdom of the Lord Jesus Christ.
[1:00:09] SPEAKER_01: Uh it's it's his honor that's been offended.
[1:00:11] SPEAKER_00: Um Yeah, and I think Ramsey's last sort of statement on this that the indictment must assert that the thing charged is a sin against Christ, that that that ultimately, you know, just comes back to what we were talking about a minute ago, is is really what is at stake here, is that um this is this is not a criminal court, a civil court, or any, you know, none of those things.
[1:00:35] SPEAKER_00: This is a a court that is determining whether a sin against Christ has been committed.
[1:00:40] SPEAKER_00: However much somebody else may be involved, ultimately it is a sin against Christ.
[1:00:44] SPEAKER_00: And so that's uh the the gravity of this is tied even to the indictment itself.
[1:00:51] SPEAKER_02: I've only had to say these words once, and it it's perhaps it reveals a sense of gravitas uh for what you're about to engage with.
[1:01:02] SPEAKER_02: It's not something that's a personal issue, it's something that you're doing in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, which when we judged a case, it made the work perhaps more difficult in its burden.
[1:01:17] SPEAKER_02: It wasn't something we were just doing willy-nilly.
[1:01:20] SPEAKER_02: This is a very serious endeavor, so in serious, so serious that we are ascribing our work to the honor and work of Christ, that it's his majesty we're defending, not our own.
[1:01:31] SPEAKER_02: Uh, and it's the peace and purity and unity of his church, not our own.
[1:01:35] SPEAKER_02: And and so saying these words out loud in the context of an ecclesiastical trial, just reading the indictment, you sense the gravity of what is about to take place, which perhaps gets back to the previous stuff we've been talking about with is jaywalking an indictable offense, something small and minor.
[1:01:53] SPEAKER_02: It's it's like, okay, like these are serious issues that you're bringing before the church.
[1:01:58] SPEAKER_02: They are so serious that you're invoking the name of its king and lord, the Lord Himself.
[1:02:04] SPEAKER_02: And so it sends, it's a there's a serious nature to BCO314 that when you're reading, you don't really sense, but in the midst of trial and process, it it weighs heavy on the heart.
[1:02:17] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[1:02:18] SPEAKER_00: Well, I think it goes both ways too, right?
[1:02:20] SPEAKER_00: So on the one hand, the court needs to take it seriously because they are stating those things, but then the accused also needs to hear those very things coming the other direction, right?
[1:02:32] SPEAKER_00: This is not just some personal dispute between two individuals.
[1:02:37] SPEAKER_00: Uh, that, you know, um it ultimately my sin, if I committed that sin, again, however much it may involve an individual, it is a sin against Christ and his church.
[1:02:51] SPEAKER_00: And that the the gravity needs to rest on everybody in that situation.
[1:02:58] SPEAKER_00: You know, the the the prosecutor needs to feel it, the accused needs to feel it, the court who's gonna stand in judgment needs to feel it, everyone needs to understand what's happening.
[1:03:08] SPEAKER_01: Um so well, listeners, uh, we have just gotten through with BCO 314, and while we were planning to do all of 31 in one episode, we think we're gonna split it in half and come back next time to deal with the remainder of 315 through 311.
[1:03:27] SPEAKER_01: So I think it's appropriate for us to say, as our investigation of BCO 31 has shown thus far, this podcast at least is over.
[1:03:34] SPEAKER_01: Thanks for joining us.
[1:03:35] SPEAKER_01: Uh, thanks again to Steve for being here.
[1:03:37] SPEAKER_01: It's become uh commonplace for you to be around, and we appreciate your engagement with us on these topics.
[1:03:42] SPEAKER_01: Uh, folks, if you've enjoyed the show, you know how we say it.
[1:03:45] SPEAKER_01: Consider following us on Twitter, Facebook at Polity Matters.
[1:03:48] SPEAKER_01: Be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice if you have questions or comments.
[1:03:51] SPEAKER_01: You can contact us on social media or at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com, and there's a link down below where you can go to support our work.
[1:03:59] SPEAKER_01: Thanks again for listening.
[1:04:00] SPEAKER_01: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[1:04:03] SPEAKER_01: Goodbye.
[1:04:03] SPEAKER_01: Goodbye, gentlemen.
[1:04:04] SPEAKER_01: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
