# 27. Animated By Our Apathy (Witherow's Practical Lessons)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 27 Feb 2024, 33 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/14581196-27-animated-by-our-apathy-witherow-s-practical-lessons.mp3

The one in which we conclude our time with Thomas Witherow's The Apostolic Church. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Welcome & Introduction
- 2:37 The Pulpit Dumb
- 19:57 Truth Must Be Planted
- 31:00 Call No Man Master
- 32:02 Coclusion

## Transcript

[0:08] SPEAKER_02: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:11] SPEAKER_02: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg, and this is episode nine in our series before the book.
[0:19] SPEAKER_02: We are excited, uh, but a little sad to be leaving Thomas Witherow.
[0:23] SPEAKER_02: We've enjoyed spending time with him and with our other friends as we've worked our way through his book, The Apostolic Church.
[0:31] SPEAKER_02: Um, you recall that he was posing uh the one singular question of the three forms of church government that are prevalent throughout the world, which is it the duty of a Christian to select and to support?
[0:42] SPEAKER_02: And he walked through uh the scriptures mostly a lot in Acts, but we we tagged on some extra stuff along the way, and we found six principles of the Apostolic Church in the pages of scripture, principles for us to lay out and apply uh in our governing of Christ's people.
[0:59] SPEAKER_02: And we've determined that Presbyterianism uh most suits the apostolic principles of church government.
[1:05] SPEAKER_02: And the final chapter we're in today, chapter four, is simply titled Practical Lessons.
[1:11] SPEAKER_02: Um, where we've already joked before starting recording, he says a lot of the same things over and over again, but he just drives the point home so freshly and in so many good uh turns of phrase that we uh think it's worth spending time uh discussing and asking questions and applying these things.
[1:27] SPEAKER_02: So um I don't really know where to start.
[1:30] SPEAKER_02: Honestly, guys, I I feel uh at a loss today.
[1:32] SPEAKER_02: This is not quite as orderly as his previous chapters have been, and so it um makes my brain kind of turn in circles.
[1:39] SPEAKER_02: But um, I can start off by pointing out what he says at the beginning.
[1:43] SPEAKER_02: He's he says uh right on the first page, Presbyterianism has done what the rival system has failed to do, preserved the principles of apostolic government, and for this reason possesses an amount of scriptural warrant, not to speak of unity, coherence, and vigor.
[1:56] SPEAKER_02: And he goes on um to draw two conclusions that one, if we discover that the peculiarities of the system are either not truth or truths just of minor consequence, we should take speedy steps to heal the schism that exists.
[2:09] SPEAKER_02: So he would say if if we if we're not convinced that Presbyterianism is right according to Scripture, we should get rid of it.
[2:15] SPEAKER_02: But he says, if on the other hand, our distinctive principles are very important as well as true, then duty to God and the church demands that we avow, illustrate, and defend them.
[2:24] SPEAKER_02: And that's what he spends the rest of the chapter doing.
[2:27] SPEAKER_02: Uh, he works through three uh major sections uh discussing what it looks like for us to uh avow, illustrate, and defend the principles of Presbyterian church governments.
[2:37] SPEAKER_02: And so I might turn it over to one of y'all to get us started on his first section, which you gotta love the title, The Pulpit Dumb on the Subject.
[2:45] SPEAKER_02: Uh, assuming he means mute and silent, not stupid or foolish, but maybe either one would apply.
[2:51] SPEAKER_02: We'll figure that out, I suppose.
[2:53] SPEAKER_02: Uh, what stood out to you guys here?
[2:55] SPEAKER_02: Talk to us about the argument he's making.
[2:57] SPEAKER_01: He he's basically making the argument that um Presbyterians are perhaps the least zealous about their polity um when compared to perhaps other traditions.
[3:08] SPEAKER_01: Um, I don't know a Baptist that is not proud of being a Baptist, um, or perhaps even a Catholic who's not proud of their Pope.
[3:16] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so there's this idea that in Presbyterianism, we are often very quiet upon the foundations for why we believe what we believe concerning church government.
[3:29] SPEAKER_01: And he goes through perhaps a few of the reasons um that for the few of the reasons why we are quiet.
[3:37] SPEAKER_01: Um, he says one is that uh perhaps we are quiet because we think it's plain in scripture.
[3:44] SPEAKER_01: We don't need to defend it, and so we need not talk about it.
[3:48] SPEAKER_01: Um he he he says it's it's somewhat funny in how he talks about that.
[3:53] SPEAKER_01: He says, uh, this, I am persuaded, is a clerical delusion, gross and gigantic.
[3:59] SPEAKER_01: Presbyterian principles are indeed clearly embodied in the Bible, but we are not to forget that what is very clear uh to one man can be very dark to another.
[4:08] SPEAKER_01: And so he goes through these various ideas for why we are quiet and the insufficiency of our quietness um within um within our worship services.
[4:20] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, he he notes that often these things aren't talked about unless they're attacked.
[4:25] SPEAKER_00: Um, he just has this great description of um we never talk about it except when some champion of another sect, animated by their apathy, is brave enough to attack our system.
[4:36] SPEAKER_00: And then he says, uh, some Presbyterian war warrior clad in the uh um panoply of battle descends into the field of controversy.
[4:47] SPEAKER_00: But before he strikes a blow, he takes care to apologize for his intrusion upon the public by alleging that he appears in self-defense, which is much the same as saying that he would not have troubled the world by telling it the truth had he not been provoked by the occasion.
[5:02] SPEAKER_00: That's just great.
[5:02] SPEAKER_00: It's and it's true though, it's uh it's not something that's really talked about um a lot.
[5:07] SPEAKER_00: And I haven't seen it talked about a lot in Presbyterian circles, unless in a new member's class somebody asks a question or somebody comes up to the pastor and says, you know, what's what's the deal with uh deacons and elders and how you guys do these things?
[5:18] SPEAKER_00: Um I think he's he's on to something there that we're we're just reticent to say anything unless uh somebody else brings it up.
[5:26] SPEAKER_02: You know, I suppose in this conversation we can weave in and out of of where we see these things in our modern day.
[5:32] SPEAKER_02: But he he spoke just before what you read, Jared, about how um he says even at ordinations, the explanation of our principles is beginning to be felt as a periodical encumbrance.
[5:42] SPEAKER_02: Um, you know, and and you can think about it if you guys have been to services recently, you know, some sometimes, and maybe especially if you're installing local officers like ruling elders and deacons, we sort of apologize.
[5:53] SPEAKER_02: Listen, we're sorry, we've got to have this service.
[5:55] SPEAKER_02: You know, we know that you guys don't really understand what's going on, but we have to do this.
[5:58] SPEAKER_02: This is the way our book tells us to do it.
[6:00] SPEAKER_02: Um that is on the one hand, this also made me think about you know, men that I see come before our credentials committee for ordination or licensure.
[6:08] SPEAKER_02: The BCO and church government is usually their the the place where they are most efficient, um, and and may even be the place that they seem not to care very much um about whether they know it or not.
[6:20] SPEAKER_02: You know, I can't tell you how many guys we've had come through lately that don't know a single preliminary principle.
[6:25] SPEAKER_02: Now that that that hurts me because we've spent so much time together with our preliminary principles on the show.
[6:31] SPEAKER_02: But um yeah, there's something something about our polity.
[6:34] SPEAKER_02: We we don't seem to to press in towards it.
[6:37] SPEAKER_02: Um well, what else?
[6:39] SPEAKER_02: I mean, there's still several more pages underneath this heading.
[6:42] SPEAKER_00: Well, there seems to be a couple reasons for it though.
[6:45] SPEAKER_00: Um why are we so shy about it?
[6:47] SPEAKER_00: And I think there's basically two that he puts his fingers on, I maybe more.
[6:53] SPEAKER_00: Uh one is uh it almost seems like it's it's bigoted or it's uh closed-minded.
[7:00] SPEAKER_00: Um and you think about that, uh it's kind of understandable.
[7:04] SPEAKER_00: You know, if you um early in the book, he talks about essentials and non-essentials.
[7:09] SPEAKER_00: And if you think about it, if you're talking about the essentials, often your opponent on the other end is not a Christian.
[7:15] SPEAKER_00: But if you're talking about non-essentials, you know, things that are not about um uh the gospel, on the other end of the table, if you have a Baptist, you have an episcopal uh person, that there's another Christian on the other end of that.
[7:28] SPEAKER_00: And so if it feels a little awkward to, it's almost like fighting in your family.
[7:31] SPEAKER_00: You just have certain things you don't talk about.
[7:33] SPEAKER_00: And so um he addresses that of saying we perhaps feel um bigoted uh for talking about, especially if the the world is watching.
[7:43] SPEAKER_00: Um uh but he basically says, look, you know, um we're telling the truth here, and so don't be afraid of just having somebody call you a bigot because you defend what you believe.
[7:54] SPEAKER_00: Um, but I also think he says uh he says something along the lines of do it as mildly as you want to, just do it.
[8:00] SPEAKER_00: You know, um this and I think he's kind of saying, yeah, you know our word today would be winsome rather than mild, but you don't, you're not a jerk about it, but you can talk about these things in public.
[8:10] SPEAKER_01: I think mixing both those ideas together gets at our issue, the the ignorance, perhaps in our own day, um, with the optionality of polity.
[8:19] SPEAKER_01: Like it's just a you just do whatever you want, uh, believe whatever is most convenient um to you, but also um what Jared was talking about, because it's optional, there's a a sense, at least in the own modern idea, that well, why would you fight about something that's really not that important?
[8:38] SPEAKER_01: Um, and obviously we would push back on that, and Witherrow does so here.
[8:44] SPEAKER_01: Um, and but there's a a causality that that leads to um when we as pastors or elders in the church think that it's optional or do not talk about it, which basically de facto makes it optional.
[8:58] SPEAKER_01: People are just born into Presbyterianism and they don't, and they very seldom have any conviction for Presbyterianism.
[9:06] SPEAKER_01: And and so when you when you have that sort of culture, it becomes something, well, why do I have to stay at the Presbyterian this Presbyterian church?
[9:13] SPEAKER_01: Why can't I go down the road?
[9:14] SPEAKER_01: There's a better preacher down the road.
[9:15] SPEAKER_01: It almost changes the ministry of polity is optional to whatever, whoever's the best shop in town, that's where we go to worship because he's the best preacher.
[9:25] SPEAKER_01: You know, that's I'm a Methodist or an Anglican.
[9:28] SPEAKER_01: And so if your conviction is Presbyterianism, that changes where you worship um as a people.
[9:35] SPEAKER_01: And so it's helpful in just that alone when thinking through it.
[9:40] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that that relates to what I would say is the second um reason I think he puts his finger on one is it seems bigoted.
[9:46] SPEAKER_00: The second is it seems unnecessary.
[9:48] SPEAKER_00: But as you're saying, um, it actually is more necessary than we think.
[9:51] SPEAKER_00: It's not everybody in our churches is not like, well, they already know Presbyterianism, so I don't need to talk about it.
[9:57] SPEAKER_00: Um many of them just happen to be there and they don't really understand um these six principles or uh what it means to be a Presbyterian.
[10:04] SPEAKER_00: It just happens to be this is where my family grew up, this is where I was baptized, this is where I'm going.
[10:09] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but if there's another option, yeah, that they might be somewhere else.
[10:13] SPEAKER_00: So it's maybe more necessary than we un than we think that it is.
[10:16] SPEAKER_01: And can provide church unity um when you think about it.
[10:20] SPEAKER_01: Um, I mean, I've been in circumstances where there are various groups within congregations, and the if that there's a different culture between those who are uh convicted Presbyterian by conviction and those who are merely born in it.
[10:36] SPEAKER_01: And what could unify those groups together, those who are born without conviction and those who have conviction, is to study polity.
[10:43] SPEAKER_01: There's a greater understanding of polity, it will unify us um uh in our churches.
[10:48] SPEAKER_01: And so there's a sense of we see both of these camps, perhaps within our congregation and at some level where, yeah, they're Baptists, but they they like our congregation, or they were born here, or they came here because this is the Presbyterian church and they must be here.
[11:04] SPEAKER_01: Uh, what can unify us is our polity.
[11:07] SPEAKER_01: And so it it's more than just mere debating on the outside, but there's a unifying aspect on the inside if we think that our polity is a principle that can have benefit not only for the church, but for the people as they gather.
[11:22] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and I think it's not just a unity within the church.
[11:25] SPEAKER_00: Um, good fences make good neighbors.
[11:27] SPEAKER_00: Um, I like when somebody knows why they believe what they believe.
[11:31] SPEAKER_00: It makes our conversations better, less anxious.
[11:34] SPEAKER_00: I mean, uh, although he's gotten in trouble for speaking uh forcefully, one of my favorite Baptists is Mark Dever because he actually knows his polity.
[11:42] SPEAKER_00: And so I love whenever I hear him in conversation with somebody that I'm gonna hear the best argument on that side, and he wants to hear the best argument on the other side, and and it makes you less anxious about having those conversations when you when you know what you believe and why you believe it uh on matters of polity.
[11:57] SPEAKER_02: You know, you guys were talking about the the the positive aspect of of putting something like this into place, but there's a negative side too that over time, right?
[12:05] SPEAKER_02: So if you've got folks that are born into Presbyterianism and not and they're not in Presbyterianism by conviction, they're they're born into it, but that doesn't mean they're gonna stay there.
[12:15] SPEAKER_02: You know, we see a lot of a lot of folks leaving the Presbyterian church over time.
[12:19] SPEAKER_02: I mean, I you know, I ministered in mid mid-south Mississippi for a while.
[12:23] SPEAKER_02: Plenty of small town churches full of old people, but not very many old people, because old people are heading in a particular direction, and all the young people went in a whole different direction, right?
[12:32] SPEAKER_02: They left.
[12:33] SPEAKER_02: And so smaller churches in the Presbyterian church when when that starts to happen, but also uh, you know, I've seen it and and see it to some degree in you know, in our current context, you get folks that come into the Presbyterian church from other denominations.
[12:48] SPEAKER_02: You know, we've seen quite a few folks move into our church uh because of issues in other denominations at the moment, think about the Methodists, you know, we've had some trouble, there there's been some shakeups at some other churches in our area.
[13:01] SPEAKER_02: And I and at this point, I'm not speaking about particular people in our congregation that have come.
[13:05] SPEAKER_02: But when that happens, if you're not clear about your polity and you're not preaching it and teaching it, you wind up with other views growing up into the church that have come from other traditions, and it starts to mix, and it makes me uh well, it reminded me at least of what he says in on page 145.
[13:23] SPEAKER_02: The prevalent indifference to Presbyterianism that our defective instruction has produced has left us open to the incursions of every sect that chooses to give us opposition.
[13:33] SPEAKER_02: And so if we don't maintain a clarity and a direct instruction of our people in our polity, we'll start to see things come in from every possible direction.
[13:42] SPEAKER_02: Um, you know, and we might even say this on see this on a bigger scale.
[13:47] SPEAKER_02: Sometimes our presbyteries can act in a very sort of congregational way.
[13:51] SPEAKER_02: I mean, how often have you heard of a of a presbytery saying no to a church calling a particular man?
[13:57] SPEAKER_02: Um I don't think I've ever heard of that happening before, uh, and at least not for theological issues, you know.
[14:04] SPEAKER_02: Jared just turned his microphone on, so I'm hoping he has something good to say.
[14:08] SPEAKER_00: Our presbytery's been known to say no every now and then.
[14:11] SPEAKER_01: Oh, good.
[14:12] SPEAKER_01: I also have two examples or or so of no as well, but I I'll I digress.
[14:17] SPEAKER_01: You're just a happy go-lucky presbytery, you know.
[14:19] SPEAKER_01: You just everyone come in in, you just say, Yeah, come on in.
[14:23] SPEAKER_01: I should probably clarify what I mean.
[14:28] SPEAKER_02: You know, oftentimes in the PCA, it, you know, if somebody has a call from a church, and especially if they're already ordained in the denomination, uh, you know, there's there's there's almost a presumption, maybe that's the better way to say it, it's there's almost a presumption that they're just gonna come in and be the pastor of that church and that the presbytery matters are sort of a rubber stamp, but that's not Presbyterian, right?
[14:49] SPEAKER_02: That that's more of a Baptist-y way to do it.
[14:51] SPEAKER_02: Um, did you know that our book actually says that if you want to call a man from the church he's at in the same denomination, that you're supposed to send a note to the presbytery and ask if if his call can be moved?
[15:05] SPEAKER_02: It there's so many things that we're supposed to do that we don't do, um, and we're not very Presbyterian for not doing them.
[15:12] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it's kind of um there's like a presumption in that regard.
[15:16] SPEAKER_01: I I think it I think Fred Greco gave me the personal advice to never move on the field too early.
[15:22] SPEAKER_01: Do we have a cowbell?
[15:23] SPEAKER_02: You're supposed to ring the bell when we say cowbell.
[15:27] SPEAKER_01: He doesn't get a horn, he gets a bell, cowbell.
[15:29] SPEAKER_01: Um, but there's this idea that you don't want like just because a congregation says yes doesn't mean that the presbytery will receive you.
[15:38] SPEAKER_01: And it's not, it might not even be like um you have some heterodox view, but like say they just got over that congregation, just had a a blow-up over, I don't know, Pedal Communion or something, and I held that view but did not practice it, the presbytery might say, Oh, sell your brakes here.
[15:56] SPEAKER_01: Like, we don't think this is a good fit for the church given its most recent schism.
[16:02] SPEAKER_01: And so there sometimes guys can be too hasty in that regard.
[16:06] SPEAKER_01: And perhaps that's why the polity of all this is important when you're thinking through the importance of it.
[16:12] SPEAKER_01: Um, is yeah, we can act congregational at times, but the tried and true slowness of Presbyterianism is about you.
[16:21] SPEAKER_02: I'm sure Jared wants to stop and and be explained to why payo-communion is so bad, but we don't have time for that today, brother.
[16:27] SPEAKER_02: We'll have to come back another time.
[16:28] SPEAKER_01: Yes.
[16:29] SPEAKER_01: Um the only other thing I see in this section that I I've there's just so many quotes you could pull and put on Twitter or something.
[16:37] SPEAKER_01: Uh I think uh Jared has a 25 uh tweet thread coming tomorrow, but uh what he says this.
[16:44] SPEAKER_01: We are picking on you.
[16:45] SPEAKER_02: I'm so sorry.
[16:46] SPEAKER_01: I I always pick on Jared.
[16:47] SPEAKER_01: I'm always asking him thought-provoking questions that he doesn't want to answer.
[16:50] SPEAKER_01: Um, 145 uh Witherow says, I have often remarked at how a cat a Roman Catholic, a Methodist, and a Baptist each thinks that their own church, the purest and best in the world, while the Presbyterian is usually a man who regards any other Protestant church as being at the very least as good as his own.
[17:10] SPEAKER_01: And so it's building on that idea of confidence and pride within your own ecclesiastical system, where there's a sense of perhaps shame in in some regards for our own polity.
[17:23] SPEAKER_01: And oh yeah, you know, oh, you're a Baptist, that's great, that's a great denomination.
[17:27] SPEAKER_01: Whereas uh when you talk to some of these other traditions, they believe truly well.
[17:31] SPEAKER_01: Um, they're prideful uh in their understanding of polity, but also the church and Jesus Christ Himself.
[17:38] SPEAKER_01: And we very rarely see that in, I think even in the PCA, uh, that sort of uh ecclesiastical pride for our polity.
[17:47] SPEAKER_01: Uh and perhaps it's something we can learn from other traditions.
[17:51] SPEAKER_02: I promise you, I thought he was telling a joke when he started that sentence earlier.
[17:55] SPEAKER_02: I have often remarked how a Roman Catholic, a Methodist, and a Baptist each center.
[17:59] SPEAKER_02: Center a bar.
[18:01] SPEAKER_00: Well, uh, I think on that point, you can fall off the horse on two different sides.
[18:07] SPEAKER_00: And uh in his own context, he's talking about uh a context in which they're not a part of the establishment.
[18:14] SPEAKER_00: There's a lot of different um churches that are around, and they had swung into this uh with the pendulum, into this not talking about it time.
[18:22] SPEAKER_00: Whereas 200 years earlier, everybody was debating this, whether you're a congregationalist, uh Presbyterian, or um Episcopalian.
[18:30] SPEAKER_00: And uh some of that depends on what's your what's your context.
[18:33] SPEAKER_00: And I think in some ways, um Witherow, I think, speaks to us in the PCA because we're a little bit more um broad in our associations than say some of the uh some other denominations that are smaller might be um fine being small and and um talking about this a lot more.
[18:50] SPEAKER_00: So this perhaps actually talks to us a little bit more in our uh PCA context uh about uh a good uh subtle dose of uh Presbyterian exceptionalism.
[19:01] SPEAKER_02: He kind of ends that section by by saying, and it sort of transitions to the other section that's coming.
[19:07] SPEAKER_02: Um he says the most likely expedient for communicating a new and better tone to the Presbyterian mind is the minister um and and the the pulpit in particular.
[19:17] SPEAKER_02: Uh I I I I wonder, and uh he says something else later on, and I'll ask you guys when I get there, but he starts to sound a little post-millennial to me, uh, especially when he says things like we have it in our power to mold the opinions of our own community and to make deak, deep impression on society beyond.
[19:32] SPEAKER_02: And I'm not saying it's bad that he sounds that way.
[19:34] SPEAKER_02: I like it.
[19:35] SPEAKER_02: I I try to be a little more optimistic with my eschatology.
[19:37] SPEAKER_02: And so I like, I like that he's saying, Hey, we have a place where we can uh establish some change and move in a good direction.
[19:44] SPEAKER_02: Um he says that last that last sentence of this section, there is as much mind in the Presbyterian ministry at this moment as if wisely directed could revolutionize the religious sentiment of the nation.
[19:56] SPEAKER_02: Uh and with that he moves into his section that he titled Truth Must Be Planted.
[20:00] SPEAKER_02: Uh he says that we need to um well we need to take action to some degree.
[20:06] SPEAKER_02: Uh what what stood out to you guys here?
[20:08] SPEAKER_01: Uh well what stands out in the second section, I think, is perhaps he he does uh a few attaboys uh before he gets into the critique.
[20:17] SPEAKER_01: Um he basically argues uh hey uh Presbyterians, you're doing great in all these various fields, uh preaching according to the scriptures, maintaining soundness of faith, building godly character, pastorally caring for your congregation, visitation of the sick, you're doing really good work in all of these areas.
[20:35] SPEAKER_01: Uh, but then he builds upon his previous point by saying, now do more, uh, do more as it relates um to teaching Presbyterian principles.
[20:46] SPEAKER_01: I think most exclusively, I think the main point of this section is from the pulpit.
[20:50] SPEAKER_01: Um, the whole previous section was dealing with the absence of Presbyterianism from the pulpit.
[20:56] SPEAKER_01: And so here he basically makes the argument that we should be intensely Presbyterian, if I could say that in conviction and declaration.
[21:04] SPEAKER_01: We what we believe on the inside comes out uh of our mouths as we teach and preach God's word.
[21:11] SPEAKER_01: Um, he seeks, uh, in one point he says a lukewarm and odious indifference to Presbyterian principles and goes on to argue that it hurts our churches and ministry.
[21:22] SPEAKER_01: And so the the remedy for a lukewarm, lukewarm and odious indifference to Presbyterianism is by teaching the principles that we've outlined here.
[21:32] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I like this quote where he says we should instruct them periodically as to what Presbyterianism is.
[21:38] SPEAKER_00: Let each minister do this as mildly as he pleases, but let it be done faithfully and firmly.
[21:44] SPEAKER_00: I I think really his application is simply talk about this.
[21:47] SPEAKER_00: When it comes up in the text, talk about this.
[21:50] SPEAKER_00: Point out the S, right?
[21:52] SPEAKER_00: The plural, the uh the fact that these principles are there and they're assumed uh when you're going through the Bible and uh just don't be afraid of them.
[22:00] SPEAKER_00: Um, I don't think he's necessarily saying you have to do a six sermon series uh on this, although perhaps you'd want to do that if you're a topical preacher.
[22:08] SPEAKER_00: But it's more of, you know, did you notice these things as we went through it?
[22:12] SPEAKER_00: Well, notice those things with your congregation.
[22:16] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I don't get the impression that he's he's suggesting that you just have a uh a new member's class, you know, once a year and you talk about Presbyterian polity one time and just drop it.
[22:26] SPEAKER_02: Um I hadn't really thought about that point, Jared, that he certainly would advocate for just addressing it when it comes up, uh making the point to draw it out when we find it.
[22:38] SPEAKER_01: He he has bold ambitions um in this section.
[22:41] SPEAKER_01: Uh he says if we wish to have Presbyterianism the religion of the church universal, yeah, uh, we must let the world know that we cherish a warm and devoted attachment to its principles.
[22:53] SPEAKER_01: And so there's this idea that instead of being in the last point, uh like shamed uh being an ashamed Presbyterian, we we are we should cherish um a warm and devoted attachment to it.
[23:09] SPEAKER_01: Um that is how you teach on it, and that's how you talk about it.
[23:13] SPEAKER_01: Uh and I thought that was very helpful.
[23:15] SPEAKER_01: It also was interesting to me that I see um when I was reading Wither O, he he talks about the lukewarmness and the odiousness of Presbyterian principles, as I said a moment ago, and he labels these Presbyterians as Presbyterians in name only, or in yeah, in name only.
[23:32] SPEAKER_01: And I thought that was interesting because I've heard that phrase thrown out from here and there, even in our own denomination, and I wondered its origin.
[23:40] SPEAKER_01: And I don't know if anyone really knew that.
[23:42] SPEAKER_01: And this might not be even the origin, I don't know, but this is certainly the earliest I've seen someone talk about uh peanos or Presbyterian in name only votes.
[23:51] SPEAKER_01: Let's give it to him.
[23:52] SPEAKER_01: I mean, he can have it.
[23:54] SPEAKER_01: The he he coined the Pinot.
[23:55] SPEAKER_02: There you go.
[23:57] SPEAKER_02: I like his illustration uh when he gets here, right?
[24:00] SPEAKER_02: He he talks how, you know, in terms of practicality, he he talks about how weeds and flowers require different skill and care, right?
[24:06] SPEAKER_02: Weeds just kind of grow, uh, they're they grow on their own, they're just gonna rise up, but the flower requires all the skill and care that a gardener can give it.
[24:14] SPEAKER_02: And so he's making the point, right?
[24:15] SPEAKER_02: If if if these things are not our natural inclination, if if we're not inclined uh always to be teaching our polity, if we want to develop it, we need to make a point to do so, or else other things will grow up, other ideas, errant views.
[24:30] SPEAKER_02: Um, and you know, I I can imagine certain folks reading Witherow and thinking, well, and certainly because he he can be rather firm at points, uh maybe every point, that that he's a little uh hard, right?
[24:44] SPEAKER_02: That this is this is a little heavy, uh, but he is he's very clear to say, you know, that there's a right way to do this.
[24:50] SPEAKER_02: I loved what he wrote on 149.
[24:53] SPEAKER_02: It is certain that a man who at the proper time and place states and illustrates his principles and satisfies others that he believes and prizes them himself is sure sooner or later to make converts to his views.
[25:05] SPEAKER_02: But a man who is known to profess opinions and is always silent on them, raises doubts as to his own sincerity and never makes one.
[25:13] SPEAKER_02: Um, he's actually saying if if we want to see this more, it's it's better for us not to be quiet and just let people be born into Presbyterianism.
[25:20] SPEAKER_02: But we actually should did somebody already say the word winsome.
[25:24] SPEAKER_02: I think we did.
[25:24] SPEAKER_02: Uh shame on us.
[25:26] SPEAKER_02: Um but we should.
[25:27] SPEAKER_02: We should winsomely teach these things, let people know that that they're they're clear and plain, let them know that we believe them and prize them, and and eventually people will come around to embracing them themselves.
[25:36] SPEAKER_01: You know, we are all uh all of us here are RTS grads, and so RTS grads love the word winsome, and so we just have to talk about it.
[25:47] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, RTS Dallas.
[25:51] SPEAKER_00: Uh well, if you think about um the subject though, of church government, ecclesiology, these principles, it did make me think, are there books out there that are actually about this?
[26:03] SPEAKER_00: I mean, we're reading one that's 200 years old that was a pamphlet, mostly I think because it but it's a fun book to read.
[26:10] SPEAKER_00: But I mean, what has been written?
[26:11] SPEAKER_00: There's Bannerman's book, right?
[26:13] SPEAKER_00: Which is thick that nobody reads.
[26:14] SPEAKER_00: He actually said that um later on, right?
[26:17] SPEAKER_00: Uh large books are often written but seldom read.
[26:20] SPEAKER_02: Um he later on wrote the large book on polity, right?
[26:24] SPEAKER_00: That nobody's read.
[26:25] SPEAKER_02: That nobody's read, yeah.
[26:26] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[26:26] SPEAKER_00: But I mean, other than what, Waters and then Clowney wrote one like 40 years ago.
[26:31] SPEAKER_00: Um, there's just not a lot of books on church polity.
[26:34] SPEAKER_00: That's it is something we're fairly silent on, even in the book world.
[26:38] SPEAKER_02: There's a lot of small ones in particular um denominations.
[26:43] SPEAKER_02: Like I've got a whole stack up here.
[26:45] SPEAKER_02: You know, what Presbytopia, uh well, I guess the well-ordered church's waters.
[26:50] SPEAKER_02: Um, Welcome to the Reformed Church.
[26:52] SPEAKER_02: I think Daniel Hyde has one, right?
[26:54] SPEAKER_02: So there's there's little ones that kind of suit different uh flavors.
[26:58] SPEAKER_02: But yeah, there's not anything that's just out there big time.
[27:03] SPEAKER_01: Next year, when we go on over Bannerman, when we do our next year book study on Bannerman, it's gonna be multi-year, multi-season study on Bannerman.
[27:12] SPEAKER_01: We can have Guy Waters on and convict him to produce a thousand-page tome on biblical ecclesiology.
[27:21] SPEAKER_01: I think it'd be helpful to have something like that, given that there's nothing I mean, Bannerman's Bannerman in the Scottish tradition, and it'd be helpful to have an American give a stab at the Church of Christ.
[27:33] SPEAKER_02: Not to talk about ourselves, you know, we try not to very often, but it's this sort of is some of the impetus for why we started our podcast, right?
[27:40] SPEAKER_02: I mean, there just is not a lot out there, um, especially not out there in the medium we're trying to to provide.
[27:46] SPEAKER_02: Uh but we trust the Lord will we'll work through this.
[27:52] SPEAKER_02: And I man, I I think I pray just about every day for Bannerman Volume 2 from Guy Waters.
[27:58] SPEAKER_01: Until then, you have Polity Matters, which is a replacement for Bannerman.
[28:04] SPEAKER_02: Supplement, you pronounced it wrong.
[28:06] SPEAKER_02: Supplement.
[28:07] SPEAKER_02: Oh, sorry, sorry.
[28:08] SPEAKER_00: So at least a question: if we have teaching elders, ruling elders that are listening to this, um, how do you address this within your own church to talk about these things?
[28:17] SPEAKER_00: Um, you guys have any thoughts of um ways to combat the the dumbness, the silence uh about things that are ecclesial in our in our churches?
[28:28] SPEAKER_01: Um obviously we it's not enough.
[28:31] SPEAKER_01: And you're new members, of course.
[28:32] SPEAKER_01: You want to make sure that the people that are becoming members understand your why you're a Presbyterian.
[28:39] SPEAKER_01: Um, but I I think um I'm hoping, and we were talking about this before the show of a Sunday school, like a six-week part Sunday school on this, maybe nine weeks, however many we've been doing this podcast, we could probably break it down in the same way.
[28:54] SPEAKER_01: Um, but having a uh a podcast, a Sunday school uh on this might be a helpful resource for at least the adults, um, but perhaps even the the youth as well.
[29:05] SPEAKER_01: Um, maybe not the most uh exciting content uh in some regards, but it's helpful to know why we're Presbyterian.
[29:12] SPEAKER_01: And I I think youth do wonder why.
[29:15] SPEAKER_01: Like, why are there Methodists, why are there Baptists, Episcopalians, and Presbyterians, what's different between the traditions?
[29:22] SPEAKER_01: And so perhaps talking even at a young age.
[29:25] SPEAKER_01: Um, when I was in seminary, we talked about the various types of things you should teach on in Sunday school, and one of them is church history.
[29:32] SPEAKER_01: And I think within the idea of church history, you can also include polity.
[29:36] SPEAKER_01: And so that's what I hope to do here.
[29:39] SPEAKER_00: But yeah, and I think we've modeled that if you have this book, um, he gives you scriptures to go to to just study two or three passages of scripture, and that's enough time to fill a Sunday school class.
[29:52] SPEAKER_00: It's enough time to um you could use this book as um men's Bible study for an eight-week, nine-week study, uh, six-week study, whatever it is, um, uh to just go through these principles and and talk about them, do a Bible study in in that format too.
[30:08] SPEAKER_02: He closes this section, and I know I keep reading, but he just writes so well.
[30:12] SPEAKER_02: Uh he says, the church that forgets to assert and teach her peculiar principles lives in such a world as this only by sufferance.
[30:20] SPEAKER_02: Her own children are cold to her, and when she sinks to dust, she shall have few to lament her fall.
[30:26] SPEAKER_02: But the church that thunders its opinions in the ears of mankind, and which neither force nor flattery can silence, is a church that will have many bitter enemies, but many warm friends.
[30:36] SPEAKER_02: It will have many to hate, but it will have some to love, and some to die for it.
[30:41] SPEAKER_02: It may be everywhere spoken against, but faithful to the truth of God, it will have saints and martyrs and in due time bring the world to its feet.
[30:49] SPEAKER_02: That's also where I wrote Postmill in the uh the margin.
[30:52] SPEAKER_02: Um I I don't understand how a man can write such such moving statements in a book about church polity, but I love it.
[30:59] SPEAKER_02: Uh he his last section is can no man master or no, call call no man master, excuse me.
[31:05] SPEAKER_02: Call no man master.
[31:07] SPEAKER_02: Um y'all f help finish us up, get us moving.
[31:11] SPEAKER_00: He ends just by talking about his his study on um you know independency, prelacy, and presbyterianism, and that the end of his study says, I am fully convinced a Presbyterian form of church government approaches more closely than any other which existed in the um the Apostolic Church.
[31:30] SPEAKER_00: And um, so that's the entire reason that he did this.
[31:33] SPEAKER_00: He says he started off just for his own benefit to do this, but uh then he uh put it into a small book form to try to help others uh to think through this, and um ends up um saying in the very end, uh that that very quotable uh line that sums up why he's written this.
[31:50] SPEAKER_00: He says, um, there is such a thing as being a Presbyterian without being a Christian, as it is possible to be a Christian without being a Presbyterian, but depend upon it, it is best to be both.
[32:02] SPEAKER_02: As Thomas Witherow would say, this podcast is over.
[32:06] SPEAKER_02: Thank you for joining us.
[32:07] SPEAKER_02: We're not sure where we're headed next, but stay tuned to Twitter and other places where we are, and we will let you know what's coming in the future.
[32:14] SPEAKER_02: If you're interested in learning more about anything that we've mentioned, check out the show notes in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org.
[32:21] SPEAKER_02: If you've enjoyed the show, please consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters and subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[32:28] SPEAKER_02: If you've got questions or comments, reach out to us on social media.
[32:31] SPEAKER_02: Uh, let us know how you've implemented this in your own church or how you've seen your elders implement it uh on your behalf.
[32:37] SPEAKER_02: Uh, we want to know what's going on.
[32:39] SPEAKER_02: We want to know how we can encourage you, and uh we love hearing uh from y'all uh the encouraging words you have about how um polity is significant to you and your people.
[32:49] SPEAKER_02: Uh, if you need us, we're all on Twitter.
[32:51] SPEAKER_02: Links are in the show notes.
[32:52] SPEAKER_02: Thanks again for spending time with us.
[32:54] SPEAKER_02: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[32:56] SPEAKER_01: Bye, gentlemen.
[32:57] SPEAKER_01: It was a pleasure talking to you.
[32:59] SPEAKER_01: Y'all.
[33:00] SPEAKER_01: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
