# 74. Just Give Me Another Hour (BCO 29)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 4 Mar 2025, 35 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/16727797-74-just-give-me-another-hour-bco-29.mp3

In this episode of Polity Matters, hosts Ben Ratliff, Jared Nelson, and Scott Edberg welcome Ruling Elder John Bise to discuss Chapter 29 of the PCA Book of Church Order: Offenses. The conversation tackles the distinctions between personal and general offenses, as well as private and public offenses, and how church courts should approach discipline in a biblical and pastoral manner. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Introductions
- 3:43 BCO 29-1
- 19:22 BCO 29-2
- 23:31 BCO 29-3
- 28:10 BCO 29-4
- 34:18 Conclusion

## Transcript

[0:06] SPEAKER_02: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:08] SPEAKER_02: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined, as always, by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg.
[0:14] SPEAKER_02: Hello, fellas.
[0:15] SPEAKER_02: Welcome.
[0:15] SPEAKER_02: Welcome back from the last time we were together.
[0:18] SPEAKER_02: Scott, your studies are going well in preparation for the show.
[0:22] SPEAKER_02: Will you be ready in the in the next little while?
[0:23] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, we can just give me another hour and just give it.
[0:28] SPEAKER_02: Okay.
[0:29] SPEAKER_02: Okay.
[0:29] SPEAKER_02: Well, then we'll just record some banter with me and Jared and our guests for a while while you get prepared.
[0:35] SPEAKER_02: Jared, everything everything hanging on?
[0:37] SPEAKER_01: I'm hanging in there.
[0:39] SPEAKER_01: Yep.
[0:40] SPEAKER_01: I'm all ready for Valentine's Day if we want to date this show.
[0:47] SPEAKER_02: And there we go again, losing the timelessness of Polity Matters.
[0:51] SPEAKER_02: Well, we are uh glad to have a friend of ours joining us today, ruling elder John Bice.
[0:57] SPEAKER_02: Uh John, for those who don't know you, can you just introduce yourself, let us know who you are and where you're from.
[1:02] SPEAKER_02: Welcome, welcome to the show for the first time.
[1:04] SPEAKER_02: We hope it's not the last time, but you know, you never know what happens.
[1:08] SPEAKER_00: Sure.
[1:09] SPEAKER_00: Well, thanks.
[1:10] SPEAKER_00: I appreciate being here and I appreciate uh the work that you guys are doing with Polity Matters.
[1:16] SPEAKER_00: It's uh it's always uh in our best interest for um our officers as well as our people to understand the way our process works, and so I commend you for this work and the uh benefit that it brings to the broader church.
[1:31] SPEAKER_00: Uh I am in Huntsville, Alabama, where I serve as a ruling elder at Cornerstone Presbyterian Church.
[1:37] SPEAKER_00: Uh I've been at Cornerstone uh since its inception.
[1:42] SPEAKER_00: The church is roughly 14 years old or thereabouts.
[1:46] SPEAKER_00: Um prior to coming here to Huntsville.
[1:49] SPEAKER_00: Uh I lived in Jackson, Mississippi, uh, where I uh was reared and uh have been active um in the church uh locally and at the presbytery level as well as the assembly level.
[2:03] SPEAKER_00: Um actually served with Scott in uh Providence Presbytery where we had some good times together and uh I've served at the assembly.
[2:13] SPEAKER_00: Um I've been active at in the assembly for 20 odd years now.
[2:19] SPEAKER_00: Um I serve presently and have served since uh, I believe 2013 on the uh Standing Judicial Commission, and prior to that I served on the Committee on Constitutional Business.
[2:34] SPEAKER_00: So good to be here with you, and I thank you for having me.
[2:39] SPEAKER_02: Well, we are we're I I'll just speak for myself.
[2:44] SPEAKER_02: We're still terrified of the rules of discipline.
[2:46] SPEAKER_02: I mean, I I feel like moving into this is just the the worst idea we've ever had.
[2:51] SPEAKER_02: But we started the BCO and we just have to continue on.
[2:54] SPEAKER_02: Fortunately for us today, uh we are in a chapter uh that is fairly simple and straightforward, chapter 29 of the book on offenses.
[3:04] SPEAKER_02: It's four sections, relatively short.
[3:06] SPEAKER_02: The first one's the longest, and we're just gonna work through these.
[3:10] SPEAKER_02: Listeners, so turn over to your BCO and keep an eye out.
[3:14] SPEAKER_02: Uh BCO 29 gives us the definition of offenses, uh, and and the first section is the main substance of the chapter, with the specifications related to personal or general, private or public in the following sections.
[3:28] SPEAKER_02: And uh Morton Smith is the one who notes that the technical usage of discipline as it relates to judicial process begins in this chapter.
[3:37] SPEAKER_02: So this is really where the rubber starts to meet the road of the process and how it works out.
[3:42] SPEAKER_02: And uh so we're just gonna get straight into it.
[3:44] SPEAKER_02: So BCO 291, an offense, the proper object of judicial process is anything in the doctrines or practice of a church member professing faith in Christ which is contrary to the Word of God.
[3:58] SPEAKER_02: The confession of faith and the larger and shorter catechisms of the Westminster Assembly, together with the formularies of government, discipline, and worship, are accepted by the Presbyterian Church in America as standard expositions of the teachings of Scripture in relation to both faith and practice.
[4:15] SPEAKER_02: Nothing therefore ought to be considered by any court as an offense or admitted as a matter of accusation, which cannot be proved to be such from Scripture.
[4:27] SPEAKER_02: So this gives us a definition and several qualifications for them.
[4:31] SPEAKER_02: I'm going to kick to one of you guys uh just to kind of get the discussion going on the basics of an offense and how the book here starts to make the definition for us.
[4:44] SPEAKER_01: Well, we're Scott's lurping on we we see here doctrines and practice, and so this may have something to do with either what we are teaching in the church or how it is that we are acting uh in the church, and exactly what it looks like will be different uh for those two things, but those are both subject to um having some sort of uh an offense that's happened, some sort of articulable um crime in a sense, if you were to put it in the uh the civil realm of something that's happened, and then here gives us our standard for what we can say is or is not an offense, and it's something that's in the scripture as uh we have it stated uh in the subordinate standard of the confession and catechism and alluded to here, the BCO, so that those things would be subject for citation, but ultimately because they're deriving what they're teaching from uh the Word of God.
[5:48] SPEAKER_02: So just so that we're clear, that your your you said it, I just want to make sure we un see it, that the formularies of government discipline and worship that's a direct reference to the the three sections of the Book of Church Order, um, most of them being constitutional.
[6:00] SPEAKER_02: Uh and so that they they fit in there with our our uh standard of what rises to an offense.
[6:08] SPEAKER_02: Um what's let's let's talk about the the difference there between the doctrine or practice of a church member.
[6:15] SPEAKER_02: So I think normally when you think about church discipline and offenses, you think about practice, uh especially at church member level.
[6:22] SPEAKER_02: So if you're a session thinking about your congregation, the practices of someone's life is what may come up as an offense.
[6:30] SPEAKER_02: Doctrines or heresy, I guess maybe the category we would put there, would would be more at the level of church officer teaching elder a little you know up further.
[6:38] SPEAKER_02: Um is there any way for us to parse that out at each level?
[6:42] SPEAKER_02: You know, where is there a church member, just not an officer, that could be liable for an offense in the area of doctrine instead of practice?
[6:52] SPEAKER_00: You know, Ben, we can certainly have church members who hold doctrinal views that are uh are not completely aligned.
[7:01] SPEAKER_00: Um as as we all know, our standard for uh admission to membership into the table is not total adherence to all of our doctrinal beliefs, but it's a credible profession of faith.
[7:15] SPEAKER_00: So I think that with regard to individual members, the holding of a doctrine uh as long as it's not taught, um, is is not a problem.
[7:27] SPEAKER_00: But if if a member holds a view contrary to our doctrinal views and begins to press that issue in a way that disturbs the peace and purity of the church, then I think that member is subject, though at that point it has um crossed the line from doctrinal and gotten into practice because it's a disturbance of the peace and purity of the church.
[7:53] SPEAKER_00: But for the most part, I would say that for an individual member, unless they are actively teaching and in some way um propounding and putting forth a false doctrine, they're generally not going to be subject to that uh aspect with regard to the holding of a doctrinal view.
[8:13] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I've had a Sunday school teacher reach reach out to me once asking if he could teach something, and uh and it was a typical Second Commandment violation issue and whether he could use props in Sunday school.
[8:26] SPEAKER_03: And I I shared with him, well, it's okay perhaps in the context as a member to hold that view, but it's not okay to teach against the view of the church itself.
[8:37] SPEAKER_03: And so while we give you the liberty to hold that view, we do not give you the liberty to teach that view.
[8:43] SPEAKER_03: And so I merely asked him to restrain himself in the teaching of the Second Commandment violation.
[8:50] SPEAKER_03: Why?
[8:50] SPEAKER_03: Because it's the doctrine of the church itself.
[8:53] SPEAKER_03: And I tried to encourage the member that this is the same thing I submit myself to.
[8:57] SPEAKER_03: So I'm not putting something, I'm not laying something at your feet that I'm not willing myself to also submit to.
[9:04] SPEAKER_03: And so I think that's a helpful perhaps paradigm when dealing with this issue in the local context.
[9:11] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that is interesting that we naturally do this with members, and that question also comes up with pastors and teaching.
[9:19] SPEAKER_01: Can they be limited in what they can teach?
[9:21] SPEAKER_01: And that there seems to be corollary there.
[9:23] SPEAKER_01: Uh, but there's also a difference because I think as we pointed out, you know, some people may hold things that if they're not actively teaching it as a member would be fine.
[9:33] SPEAKER_01: I think some of us have have in our congregations uh those that don't hold to paedo baptism and we don't go after them with discipline.
[9:43] SPEAKER_01: Uh whereas if there was a teaching elder that held to that, they they wouldn't be allowed, or if they confessed that, it would say, okay, you you may be a Christian, but we don't want you uh to be in the the office of teaching elder, and that would uh if you had something as an offense that came through um in the church courts for teaching elder, you'd say that makes sense.
[10:01] SPEAKER_01: But if it was just for a member of the congregation, you'd say, uh that's that's not really rising to that level.
[10:07] SPEAKER_01: So I think it's helpful to make a distinction on that.
[10:14] SPEAKER_02: So all of that I think is sticks squarely in that idea of doctrine there and still in the very first sentence.
[10:19] SPEAKER_02: Um but uh this has risen up in my mind as I've been studying this.
[10:24] SPEAKER_02: We in practice members are um able to be charged with offenses against our standards.
[10:34] SPEAKER_02: Now, of course, ever an offense is anything contrary to the word of God, our understanding of the word of God is given to us, or we we've we've subscribed to the standards.
[10:43] SPEAKER_02: So how how is it let me let me rephrase the question.
[10:46] SPEAKER_02: Why can a church member be held accountable um for offenses against our standards when they have not subscribed to those standards in the same way the officers have?
[10:58] SPEAKER_02: Is that a fair question?
[11:00] SPEAKER_00: It's a fair question, it's a challenging question.
[11:04] SPEAKER_00: Um I I think that this uh the question itself actually brings up an aspect of this, which is that um not all offenses warrant uh the pursuit of process.
[11:18] SPEAKER_00: Um and I think that you know this would be an example of one of those.
[11:24] SPEAKER_00: We may believe that um an individual member, such as the example you gave a moment ago, ones who who don't hold to uh paedo baptism, um, we may believe that they're in error, but as long as they're not teaching it and it doesn't disturb the peace and purity of the church, then I think that that's an instance in which um we uh we would certainly not pursue them from the standpoint of a pro of process.
[11:54] SPEAKER_00: On the other hand, um when we speak of um discipline, we're also thinking about the broader process, not only of judicial process, but that process of learning.
[12:11] SPEAKER_00: And so I think that that's where we're called upon in our roles in the church uh to instruct uh in a way that is uh compassionate and understanding, uh, but is also responsible with regard to our doctrinal views.
[12:26] SPEAKER_03: And perhaps helpful in this discussion is thinking about the vows that they do take.
[12:31] SPEAKER_03: And there is an intersection between our doctrinal standards and the confession with those vows.
[12:37] SPEAKER_03: Uh, and so there are doctrinal standards that our members must uphold.
[12:41] SPEAKER_03: They must uphold the divinity of the Lord Jesus Christ as the Son of God.
[12:45] SPEAKER_03: That's a vow that they've made before God in the presence of the people, and if they violate that in doctrine and or practice, they are liable to church discipline.
[12:53] SPEAKER_03: And so, even as John was just talking about the peace and purity of the church, that is part of the vows that our congregants make, and that has an intersection with our doctrinal views as well, depending how you hold those and how you practice those in the midst of the body.
[13:11] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think it limits also what may be seen as an offense.
[13:16] SPEAKER_01: It lets people know uh exactly how the church interprets things, because the reason that we hold to the standards is we believe that they're a faithful exposition of what the scripture teaches.
[13:28] SPEAKER_01: And so having this in there that if you're going to charge somebody with an offense, you better be able to have a scripture citation and have something from our standards, probably larger catechism if it's a matter of practice or some sort of a sin under the Ten Commandments.
[13:43] SPEAKER_01: And this actually helps to limit what it is that somebody might be liable to.
[13:48] SPEAKER_01: Um, Hodge has this great discussion uh about what might be an offense and um says that the reason that we use our standards is uh we might have a difference of opinion on something or think something might be expedient.
[14:01] SPEAKER_01: He gives the um example of drinking wine.
[14:04] SPEAKER_01: That was a big problem in the late 1800s.
[14:07] SPEAKER_01: There was this debate that was leading up to the temperance movement, and he said, unless you can prove it from scripture, we might not think it's expedient, but it's a matter of opinion.
[14:15] SPEAKER_01: This isn't a matter of offense.
[14:17] SPEAKER_01: And so he says, you know, matters of dress, modes of living, uh, meats and drinks, uh, fast and fet uh festivals, thousand other things which God has left us free from are not subject to uh church discipline.
[14:30] SPEAKER_01: And so it helps us to know there's there is some sort of a guidance of if we have a difference of uh of opinion on something, if our standards are clear on it, that's where the church is going to fall.
[14:40] SPEAKER_01: And if it's silent to it, it's something that's left to our liberty.
[14:47] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[14:48] SPEAKER_02: That's good, and that seems to be the the you know the trajectory of this paragraph.
[14:52] SPEAKER_02: So the first whole is it one sentence, man, uh that that goes all the way through defining offense, and then that second sentence, nothing ought to be considered by any court as an offense which cannot be proved to be such from Scripture.
[15:04] SPEAKER_02: So there's there's a definition of offense and then a limitation on the court as they seek to um consider these things.
[15:12] SPEAKER_02: Uh lining up with what you just read from Hodge, Jared Ramsey has great stuff on this too.
[15:16] SPEAKER_02: He says, what is contrary to a custom of the church or to some deliverance of a church court, or even to a symbol of doctrine or government, is not an offense unless it is contrary to the word of God.
[15:28] SPEAKER_02: So we it can't just be whatever we think, even if even if we have great material.
[15:34] SPEAKER_02: It can't it has to be contrary to the word of God, and uh we ought not admit anything other than that.
[15:41] SPEAKER_03: It's perhaps also good to remember, well, where in the Word of God should we often look?
[15:46] SPEAKER_03: And I think it's helpful for us to go back to the Ten Commandments um as perhaps the foundation for thinking through offenses.
[15:54] SPEAKER_03: Um the Westminster Larger Catechism does give much ammo and ammunition for seeking to define what offenses look like within the life of the church.
[16:05] SPEAKER_03: Um, but there it's a great place to start whenever someone is thinking that they've been offended, or if they're offending someone, uh, well, what have I done?
[16:14] SPEAKER_03: Uh going to the larger catechism gives much context and background for how each of these commandments can be applied to our own lives, either by positive application or doing what we're called to do, or button by not doing what we're supposed to do, or by not doing anything at all.
[16:31] SPEAKER_03: Um going through the larger catechism in cohort with the Ten Commandments gives us a good baseline.
[16:37] SPEAKER_03: Uh a lot of our offenses can be built upon, and I think our BCO talks about this quite well.
[16:43] SPEAKER_03: Um, what what commandment have they violated?
[16:46] SPEAKER_03: And perhaps explain now how they violated that commandment when you're thinking through the specifications.
[16:53] SPEAKER_00: I'll jump in here and say uh responding to your comment about um you know being uncomfortable uh talking about discipline and the application of it, um, you know, Scott's comment is is helpful in that um when when a charge is being laid out um following this pattern but also following in the manner that Scott described, um describing an offense on the basis of it uh being um you know break a breaking of a commandment, and in particular perhaps uh as elaborated you know in the larger catechism or the shorter catechism uh can be a very helpful way to frame it uh with regard to um establishing charges and with regard to the legitimacy of those charges.
[17:46] SPEAKER_00: And so if if you can't uh establish it in that manner, then I think it warrants real scrutiny as to whether in fact it is an offense or whether you're just reacting out of a sense of um uh common practice or expectations as opposed to a scriptural basis.
[18:06] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I wonder also on the other side of that, um, if there are things that you could prove from scripture are sins or offenses, but really shouldn't be in a matter of formal discipline.
[18:19] SPEAKER_01: Um I didn't know if uh maybe you've seen cases like that before, um, John, where it it comes before you and you're like, why why did you do discipline for this?
[18:30] SPEAKER_01: Yes, it was wrong, but maybe this isn't the best use of our discipline process.
[18:35] SPEAKER_00: Yes, we we certainly do see uh situations like that.
[18:39] SPEAKER_00: Um thankfully it's um it's certainly not all the time, but it's it's more often than we'd like to see.
[18:46] SPEAKER_00: And there are times when you think, um, you know, um, why has this gone this far?
[18:54] SPEAKER_00: You know, reasonable brothers in Christ, brothers and sisters, should have been able to resolve this without resorting to uh formal process.
[19:05] SPEAKER_00: And so uh you make a good point.
[19:08] SPEAKER_00: Not every not every transgression um or its process.
[19:14] SPEAKER_02: Well, unless there's something lingering in y'all's mind still, we can move on to the next section.
[19:22] SPEAKER_02: So 29-2, which I don't I don't even know if we'll spend a lot of time in 29-2, since it's explained a little bit more in 29-3 and 29-4.
[19:31] SPEAKER_02: Uh the section reads, Offenses are either personal or general, private or public, but all of them being sins against God are therefore grounds of discipline.
[19:43] SPEAKER_02: So we have these categories of offenses.
[19:46] SPEAKER_02: There's there's two two columns, I guess you may say, personal or general in the one, private or public in the other.
[19:53] SPEAKER_02: And just as we're talking about how to how you decide how you proceed once an offense has been seen, if it if it rises to the level, uh my impression at least is that these categories help give us uh a sense of how to deal with things, um, certainly how they're to be treated once they get into technical process.
[20:13] SPEAKER_02: But even I think before you get there, I know on our session, these categories have been helpful for us.
[20:19] SPEAKER_02: Is this something we can approach personally and deal with?
[20:22] SPEAKER_02: Is it something public that we need to move faster to a public, you know, kind of court issue?
[20:27] SPEAKER_02: Um they can be helpful in different types of ways.
[20:30] SPEAKER_02: And so that's me, rambling enough for y'all to gather your thoughts.
[20:33] SPEAKER_02: And let me just ask, uh, maybe Scott, do you want to jump in?
[20:36] SPEAKER_02: You want to help us with personal versus general?
[20:39] SPEAKER_02: Or do we want to move on to 29.3 and do that?
[20:41] SPEAKER_02: You you tell me how you want to do that.
[20:42] SPEAKER_03: I think when you're thinking of 29.2, that's it.
[20:45] SPEAKER_03: It's helpful to know that these are just the different categories for types of offenses.
[20:50] SPEAKER_03: Uh they will be outlined very with very brief language in the next two sections, but these are just the categories, and the categories that are presented here will help a court in how to address and deal with accusations and those offenses.
[21:07] SPEAKER_03: And so different types of accusations require different demands from the court, um, whether it be public or private, but also whether it be general or personal.
[21:19] SPEAKER_03: And I think that's perhaps outlined in some other parts that we won't get to today, but the court has different responsibilities depending on the nature or the category of the offense.
[21:29] SPEAKER_00: I think we can also go back to Jared's comment earlier about whether or not items warrant the undertaking of judicial process.
[21:39] SPEAKER_00: Um, matters that are personal can sometimes be dealt with personally within a disciplinary context, but not necessarily from a judicial process context.
[21:52] SPEAKER_00: And so thinking through not only whether an offense is personal or general, but also whether it's private or public.
[22:01] SPEAKER_00: You know, that establishes in one sense sort of four quadrants.
[22:05] SPEAKER_00: And if one is both private and personal, then there's at least um some likelihood that it can be dealt with in a more informal way and with uh with less um knowledge on the part of others.
[22:22] SPEAKER_01: I do think the interesting part of this is yes it names those categories, but the second part says they're all sins against God and therefore grounds of discipline.
[22:33] SPEAKER_01: So you may go about them differently, but somebody can't make the case that well this is personal and private and therefore it's none of the church's business that they've been cheating on their wife or something like that.
[22:45] SPEAKER_01: Well no you don't get to classify them in order to say this is not something that Christ Church needs to get involved in.
[22:52] SPEAKER_01: But it does tell you you go about them differently.
[22:54] SPEAKER_01: So I think it it helps to know there's different categories but you might have to do discipline in in all of these different areas probably some more than others.
[23:02] unknown: Right.
[23:03] SPEAKER_02: It really is it has the heart of Psalm 51 especially verse 4 where where David's confessing this particular sin that he's committed with Bathsheba and obviously there's other parties involved in the sin that he's committed but he says against you and you only have I sinned and done what is evil in your sight.
[23:19] SPEAKER_02: It says recognition that regardless of the parties involved personal, general public private all of our sins are against the Lord primarily and so they say rightly are therefore grounds of discipline.
[23:31] SPEAKER_02: So let me let me move us along to 293 and then I can ask Scott the question I asked him earlier.
[23:36] SPEAKER_02: Personal offenses are violations of the divine law considered in the special relation of wrongs or injuries to particular individuals.
[23:45] SPEAKER_02: General offenses are heresies or immoralities having no such relation or considered apart from it.
[23:52] SPEAKER_02: So if Scott is still willing personal and general you got any helpful beginning categories for us?
[24:00] SPEAKER_03: Yeah so how you distinguish these are personal offenses are violations of God's law with wrongs or as our BCO said injuries to particular individuals.
[24:13] SPEAKER_03: And so a personal offense is an offense against a real human being and not a hypothetical human being or a group of human beings, an actual human being whereas a general offense is an offense that is broader, more general dealing with the whole of Christ's church.
[24:32] SPEAKER_03: And this is perhaps one that sometimes gets misapplied we talk about Matthew 18 often in the church and sometimes a court will say well we're not going to receive that complaint or that accusation because you didn't go to that person first.
[24:48] SPEAKER_03: Well if it's a general offense it's broader than a mere personal reconciliation.
[24:54] SPEAKER_03: There is an offense that needs to be brought and should be acted upon by the court.
[24:58] SPEAKER_02: Sometimes we elevate in the PCA general offenses as personal offenses when they aren't actually personal offenses John I I don't want to put you on the spot but I wonder could you help us with some examples of things that would fall into personal or general?
[25:15] SPEAKER_02: I don't I don't know if that's please list us your SJC cases John Well no I just I don't even necessarily mean from the from the SJC but just in your experience in the church what what comes to mind I guess as you think through what what serves in those categories?
[25:32] SPEAKER_00: You know I'll give you a very specific one with regard to personal uh this goes back um over 20 years ago we had a situation in a um in the church where um a church member had um recommended another church member to do some um contracting work for a a non-believer with whom he worked.
[25:56] SPEAKER_00: And uh after a period of time his co-worker came back to him and he said that he was disappointed in the fellow church member, the contractor because he had uh accepted money from his customer but was not uh performing the work on a timely basis and was not being responsive.
[26:17] SPEAKER_00: Well you know in you know the church member then went to the contractor and gently confronted him saying you know you you're harming uh this this individual personal offense but also in so doing you're harming the name of Christ and soiling the reputation of the church.
[26:43] SPEAKER_00: So it was it originated as a personal item but the implications with respect to the harm to the reputation of the church might potentially give it broader impact.
[26:55] SPEAKER_00: So um you know I think that's a a reasonable example of a personal offense, but you know you can have uh similarly matters such as um gossiping about someone spreading um information that uh is harmful to the reputation of one um whether accurate or not.
[27:21] SPEAKER_00: You know there there are a number of things that are personal though as as Jared pointed out and as uh as Ramsey also does you know the fact that something is personal doesn't allow someone to stiff arm the church and say this is not not the business of the church.
[27:39] SPEAKER_01: Yeah can I just read Ramsay I think he puts it uh well uh in his exposition of the Book of Church Order he says um one may not plead that his offense was against a particular individual and that for this reason the church may not intermedle with the matter nor that his offense was not a wrong to anyone and that for this reason the court should not intervene.
[28:01] SPEAKER_02: The court uh the church is enforcing divine law not protecting personal rights well we said it was simple and straightforward I think we can keep going twenty nine four private offenses are those which are known only to a few persons public offenses are those which are notorious Jared can you explain it better than that well again I think we've said you may handle something a little bit differently based on which category that's in.
[28:32] SPEAKER_01: I think John was right to point out this might be something where if it's between two people that there's a lot more private and personal interaction before it gets to the level of formal discipline that's going on.
[28:45] SPEAKER_01: So if it's known only to a few people you probably should not be announcing it to the church during announcements by the way we were trying to settle this dispute somebody accused somebody else of calling them a bad name the the court is on it though that don't let more people know about a sin than already know about it.
[29:04] SPEAKER_01: But that it could be something that does arise to a different level like what John was explaining earlier.
[29:10] SPEAKER_01: So um I it helps you in approaching the case and then uh how it is that you uh first address it but it doesn't get you off the the hook for if there's a need for the church to be involved they can't just say well that was private therefore there's no role for us.
[29:27] SPEAKER_03: If they want a mediator they're going to you want to get the church involved you are going to have to somehow intervene but in a discreet way in our own age we are we have this desire for perhaps overt transparency but there is some discretion when dealing with offenses on the nature of the offense.
[29:47] SPEAKER_03: That you don't need to air someone's dirty laundry when it's a private offense and our constitution will give us greater latitude even with public offenses that you not necessarily announce uh public offenses depending it's at the discretion of the court.
[30:02] SPEAKER_03: And so there perhaps this section 294 is largely forgotten.
[30:07] SPEAKER_03: Everybody wants everything public uh but our own constitution likes to and I think rightly divide what is private and what is public.
[30:17] SPEAKER_03: And all of these these two categories can be uh mixed with the other categories that we just referenced.
[30:23] SPEAKER_03: It's not that a personal offense and a general offense are that's the only designation.
[30:29] SPEAKER_03: It could be a private personal offense or a public personal offense.
[30:32] SPEAKER_03: You can have an argument and gossip a some uh argument with someone that leads to a private personal offense or you can rob your own church member and now it's a public offense, you know, and so these can be perhaps uh uh combined in various ways but I think it's helpful to have that distinction when dealing with accusations and offenses in the church courts that there are private offenses and often we well as the our BCO says we deal with them privately while others are at the discretion of the court I think there's uh one other component that we could talk about here backing up and looking at this entire chapter and that is practically speaking if somebody is in the very beginning of process they think that there should be discipline that happens perhaps one of their first tasks is to say can you articulate this as an offense?
[31:25] SPEAKER_01: Can you put it in these categories?
[31:27] SPEAKER_01: That may help you to what your first step is is it private?
[31:30] SPEAKER_01: Is it something that's a particular person you're gonna go about it differently than if it's public, it's notorious it's uh a public heresy or something like that.
[31:40] SPEAKER_01: But then also that you're able to write down this violates this commandment here's my citation from scripture here's my citation from the larger catechism or wherever it is that you're citing.
[31:53] SPEAKER_01: I think some people say you know this this should be dealt with or the church needs to address this, but if you can't articulate it in those ways, it may just be a matter of a difference of opinion that is going to be solved in a different way.
[32:07] SPEAKER_01: I I imagine that's come up in discipline before too.
[32:10] SPEAKER_01: I don't know if John, if you've had uh things where really the failure of the case was because they just couldn't articulate the offense in the proper way.
[32:20] SPEAKER_00: Absolutely yeah saying that before I think it also warrants uh mention um I mean as as you began to look at the uh matters of um discipline uh to remember that um even here you know this should be viewed in the context um when I speak with people about discipline um generally you hear the term discipline or you hear judicial and people sort of uh begin to tighten up if you will they uh they have a almost a uh an unprompted recoiling and yet um you know in our BCO discipline is described as the church acting you know the part of a tender mother caring for her children.
[33:11] SPEAKER_00: And so uh in the same way that we care for our children with tenderness and instruction when we see them um doing something that needs to be corrected the same is true for these kinds of sins.
[33:29] SPEAKER_00: You know not every sin is going to be uh something that is uh reacted to as heinous but nonetheless you know every sin does warrant instruction and discipline and that instruction and and uh disciplinary process should be similar to the way that a mother would undertake caring for her child instructing him for his own good and uh for his knowledge so that he understands why he's being disciplined and uh the basis for that as well as the fruit of it.
[34:06] SPEAKER_02: You know the whole concept is to present um the flock uh to the Lord faultless you know and without sin in Christ of course well as BCO44 says this podcast is over.
[34:22] SPEAKER_02: Thanks for joining us be sure to tune in next week when Dr.
[34:26] SPEAKER_02: Guy Waters joins us to discuss church censures.
[34:29] SPEAKER_02: If you're interested in learning more about what we've spoken about you can check out the show notes and your podcast player or at Politymatters.org though I don't imagine we'll have a whole lot of notes today uh just a link to this uh chapter of the book if you've enjoyed the show we encourage you to consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters you can subscribe in your podcast app of choice our great thanks to John Bice for joining us today.
[34:51] SPEAKER_02: I'm not sure we've gotten our money's worth from John so we're gonna we're gonna try to get him back in the future to to get into some deeper deeper things with us in the rules of discipline.
[35:00] SPEAKER_02: Listeners if you have questions or comments you know you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com and there's also a link below where you can support our work from week to week.
[35:09] SPEAKER_02: Thanks again for spending time with us.
[35:11] SPEAKER_00: Until next time say goodbye gentlemen goodbye gentlemen brothers good to be with you thank you for your work y'all take care

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
