# 97. Inept to Do This Alone (BCO 40)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 19 Aug 2025, 58 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/17672123-97-inept-to-do-this-alone-bco-40.mp3

A Ben and Fred duo episode--all about Review and Control. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Intro
- 5:16 BCO 40-1
- 14:15 BCO 40-2
- 31:11 BCO 40-3
- 34:53 BCO 40-4
- 38:33 BCO 40-5
- 49:30 BCO 40-6
- 57:18 Closing

## Transcript

[0:05] SPEAKER_01: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:07] SPEAKER_01: My name is Ben Ratliff, and today I am not joined by either of my normal co-hosts.
[0:12] SPEAKER_01: I'm joined instead by uh our friend Fred Greco.
[0:14] SPEAKER_01: And we're getting into BCO 40 on general review and control.
[0:19] SPEAKER_01: Uh Fred, thank you for joining me.
[0:21] SPEAKER_01: I I I I was feeling kind of inept to do this alone, but you more than make up for my two co-hosts, I think.
[0:28] SPEAKER_01: Glad to always be on, Ben.
[0:29] SPEAKER_01: Yes, sir.
[0:30] SPEAKER_01: Uh students of the BCO will remember that when uh when the jurisdiction of the church courts is discussed in BCO Chapter 11, we're told that although each court exercises exclusive original jurisdiction over all matters, especially belonging to it, the lower courts are subject to the review and control of the higher courts in regular gradation.
[0:51] SPEAKER_01: And that review and control reference there is what chapter 40 begins to address today.
[0:57] SPEAKER_01: Fred, before we get into the details, I want to ask you this question.
[1:00] SPEAKER_01: So a chapter ago, which you handled with us last time, BCO 391 lists the modes by which the acts and decisions of a lower court are brought under the supervision of a higher court.
[1:12] SPEAKER_01: And they give us four things review and control, reference, appeal, and complaint.
[1:17] SPEAKER_01: Now, I often hear uh about the other ones, you know, just in common parlance, right?
[1:22] SPEAKER_01: Reference, appeal, complaint.
[1:23] SPEAKER_01: People kind of know what those are.
[1:24] SPEAKER_01: I usually hear about review and control more as like a category, as if it's like the umbrella term to cover the other three things.
[1:31] SPEAKER_01: But 39-1 and the chapter we're in today, 40, seem to present review and control as an action in and of itself.
[1:38] SPEAKER_01: And I know we're going to get into the details, but I was wondering if you could help parse that out for us a little bit, you know, in the in the bigger scheme of things.
[1:44] SPEAKER_03: So I think, Ben, that this is a little bit of both and.
[1:47] SPEAKER_03: So um, review and control really is Presbyterianism.
[1:54] SPEAKER_03: And by that I mean you have entire courts acting uh with each other.
[2:01] SPEAKER_03: This is not, you know, a complaint brought by an individual.
[2:05] SPEAKER_03: This is not an appeal in a discrete judicial case.
[2:08] SPEAKER_03: It's not even a reference where one court asks another court to take up a one particular matter.
[2:15] SPEAKER_03: This review and control is really our book of church order uh giving us the nuts and the bolts of how we're Presbyterian.
[2:22] SPEAKER_03: So if I could put it this way, some people talk about um Acts 15 as the first General Assembly, and I think that's true.
[2:30] SPEAKER_03: It's probably also the first case of review and control, uh, in which, you know, a local uh church uh sends up a matter for review by uh a higher court.
[2:41] SPEAKER_03: Now, when higher courts uh do this review and control, there are different ways in which it's gone about.
[2:49] SPEAKER_03: And that is different both when a presbytery reviews uh the session and when the General Assembly reviews a uh a presbytery.
[2:59] SPEAKER_03: And I, along with uh Scott, hope that a synod never reviews anyone ever because there's never any synods.
[3:06] SPEAKER_03: So um, you know, but this this is so there are different mechanisms, and I'm we're gonna get into the details, I'm sure, but they all come under that general umbrella that a higher court actually has a duty to review the lower courts.
[3:22] SPEAKER_03: And and I want to put it this way in the in the umbrella that's broad.
[3:26] SPEAKER_03: It's not just to find mistakes and to poke at a lower court.
[3:32] SPEAKER_03: You know, when a higher court reviews records and declares that everything's good and it is in order, that should be an encouragement not only to the lower court, but to all of the members.
[3:44] SPEAKER_03: So when a presbytery reviews the records of a session, the members of that church should feel good about their session and their government.
[3:53] SPEAKER_03: Because if there was anything grossly unconstitutional, to use a phrase, the presbytery would step in.
[3:59] SPEAKER_03: And so if the members of a church don't hear anything about review and control, they should be happy.
[4:05] SPEAKER_03: They should know that their elders are doing the right thing and doing things in order.
[4:09] SPEAKER_03: Well, to use our life verse, decently and in order.
[4:12] SPEAKER_03: And so, you know, this is an important principle, not just for finding errors, but for showing that we are a connected church.
[4:24] SPEAKER_03: So my PCA church, for example, in Katy, Texas, is connected organically to your PCA church in Cleveland, Mississippi.
[4:33] SPEAKER_03: Now we don't have this uh a direct review and control relationship, but we are all operating under the same rules, under the principles of the scriptures in government, as we've agreed to.
[4:47] SPEAKER_03: That's what the PCO is.
[4:48] SPEAKER_03: It's our agreement as to what the scriptures teach concerning church government.
[4:54] SPEAKER_03: And review and control is one of the things that ties us together.
[5:02] SPEAKER_01: That's good.
[5:02] SPEAKER_01: I appreciate the the thought there that we should we should maintain that positive spin as well.
[5:08] SPEAKER_01: The the approach to it.
[5:09] SPEAKER_01: We hear a lot of negative stuff, but there's a there's a positive thing going on as well, which which we get into here, I think, as we as we start off the chapter in uh section one.
[5:19] SPEAKER_01: It is the right and duty of every court above the session to review at least once a year the records of the court next below.
[5:27] SPEAKER_01: And if any lower court fails to present its records for this purpose, the higher court may require them to be produced immediately or at any time fixed by this higher court.
[5:37] SPEAKER_01: Uh back to BCO eleven as we as we think through this one, just kind of establishing the principle that's at play here.
[5:43] SPEAKER_01: BCO eleven four says these courts are not separate and independent tribunals, but they have a mutual relation, and every act of jurisdiction is the act of the whole church performed by it through the appropriate organ.
[5:55] SPEAKER_01: Uh and so be because we are all one, um, it it is the obligation of each court higher to review the records of the court immediately below it.
[6:03] SPEAKER_01: So presbyteries need to take care to examine the records of the sessions, and General Assembly needs to take care to examine the records of the Presbyteries.
[6:12] SPEAKER_01: Um let's talk about how this well, unless maybe you've got thoughts on the principle itself, and then we can talk about how this happens.
[6:18] SPEAKER_03: This goes back again to our integrated relationship.
[6:23] SPEAKER_03: It's the reason why one of the things I say in my church polity classes is that we are the Presbyterian church in America.
[6:33] SPEAKER_03: And then I will often ask what is the Southern Baptist group called?
[6:40] SPEAKER_03: It's the Southern Baptist Convention.
[6:45] SPEAKER_03: Now I know when you go to General Assembly, it can look a little bit like a convention, not as much.
[6:49] SPEAKER_03: There's there's no ice cream social, so maybe that keeps us from being a convention.
[6:53] SPEAKER_01: And we're not there yet.
[6:54] SPEAKER_03: But there's an important difference there that we're, you know, we're related.
[6:58] SPEAKER_03: And so if you just think of one, you know, sort of obvious example.
[7:03] SPEAKER_03: If a church was ordaining someone who was ineligible to office, ordaining someone um to be an elder, whether it was um uh not a man and instead a woman or a man who could not subscribe to our standards, that would affect the higher courts because that person would be an elder eligible to serve in a presbytery and serve on a general assembly.
[7:29] SPEAKER_03: And so be we're you can't parse these things out.
[7:33] SPEAKER_03: You can't say, well, we're only going to be together for these purposes and we're gonna be separate for all these other purposes.
[7:41] SPEAKER_03: You just can't.
[7:42] SPEAKER_03: And so this review and control is is important to uh to keep that connectionalism.
[7:52] SPEAKER_01: So there's this instruction for us that it has to uh review the records at least once a year.
[7:58] SPEAKER_01: Uh so there's regular oversight occurring uh by these higher courts.
[8:02] SPEAKER_01: When a court, when a lower court fails to present its records, the higher court has to request.
[8:07] SPEAKER_01: Um, in fact, I think the link let me go back, the higher court may require them.
[8:11] SPEAKER_01: So they may, but then the requirement word is there too.
[8:14] SPEAKER_01: So it's it's if they do, it's a strong thing.
[8:16] SPEAKER_01: They they need to bring those immediately.
[8:18] SPEAKER_01: What happens when a court fails to respond to that request from a higher court?
[8:22] SPEAKER_01: I mean, you know, you got a session that just isn't bringing their minutes.
[8:25] SPEAKER_01: What's a presbytery to do?
[8:26] SPEAKER_03: Well, it's interesting because what you see here in in 40-1 is really most of what a session has instructions to be obligated to do.
[8:37] SPEAKER_03: Presbyteries have much more instructions under our rules of assembly operation because of our General Assembly committee has its own rules.
[8:48] SPEAKER_03: And so I often advise presbyteries and sessions to act analogously to the rules for the review of presbytery uh records.
[8:59] SPEAKER_03: Usually the committee at a presbytery level is called the review of session records, uh, in doing that.
[9:05] SPEAKER_03: But um it can get uh a little bit uh difficult to get these things accomplished.
[9:10] SPEAKER_03: So when I first became a teaching elder almost 20 years ago, um I traded in my R for a T to become a teaching elder.
[9:18] SPEAKER_03: Um even though I'd been an elder for about a decade, and even though I'd served on General Assembly committees, I was new to the Presbytery.
[9:26] SPEAKER_03: And so I got placed on the review of session records committee, which is about as close to Presbyterian purgatory as you can get.
[9:35] SPEAKER_03: And um uh because I had a background as a ruling elder and a lawyer, I was made the chairman of that committee.
[9:41] SPEAKER_03: And one of the things I immediately did was to come up with some rules as to what you do, not if, but when sessions don't submit things on time, because they just don't.
[9:52] SPEAKER_03: Um, it could be because they forget, it could be because they're not used to, it could be because they don't know.
[9:58] SPEAKER_03: And so I think presbyteries should all have rules in their bylaws, standing rules, rules of operation, whatever you would call, to basically follow along with the basic principles that we have for rule uh review of presbytery records.
[10:14] SPEAKER_03: So, like if you don't submit your records, we're gonna send you a notice.
[10:19] SPEAKER_03: And if you don't respond to the notice, uh we're gonna take some action.
[10:23] SPEAKER_03: And I think presbyteries could um deny seeding delegates from a church if they don't uh submit their records.
[10:33] SPEAKER_03: Um and so, you know, I've dealt with this several times uh on the General Assembly level.
[10:40] SPEAKER_03: Um Review of Presbytery Records has probably more often than any other type of review and control case sent to the SJC um exceptions of substance from presbyteries for not submitting their minutes.
[10:58] SPEAKER_03: And then, you know, we've had to take action.
[11:02] SPEAKER_03: And usually our action is to try to come alongside a presbytery, encourage them in how to do it right, and et cetera, and whatever.
[11:09] SPEAKER_03: But ultimately, as we can get into the details a little bit later, um the General Assembly could A, fail to seat their delegates at the General Assembly, and B, they could kick the Presbytery out of the PCA.
[11:23] SPEAKER_03: Now that sounds like kind of a nuclear option, but if you can't get a Presbytery to even respond, then you're really left with no other option.
[11:32] SPEAKER_03: But usually in this case, it's just a matter of, you know, trying to encourage, poke, say, come on, you really need to do this.
[11:41] SPEAKER_03: Um, it's it's usually not uh a matter of willful neglect or of rebellion.
[11:47] SPEAKER_03: It's just we got a new clerk and he didn't know what he needed to do and we're behind or something like that.
[11:53] SPEAKER_03: And and we have done this on several occasions.
[11:56] SPEAKER_03: We've sent members of the SJC to meet with presbyteries to help them respond properly.
[12:02] SPEAKER_03: Because we want to do this in a brotherly fashion, not in an adversarial fashion if we can.
[12:09] SPEAKER_01: So, yeah, listeners, that's that's a helpful thought on how it works at the the two higher courts.
[12:15] SPEAKER_01: At Presbytery, what you'll probably see is um I've served in a couple different presbyteries that have done this in different ways.
[12:22] SPEAKER_01: One presbytery had certain um churches turning in their chur certain sessions turning in minutes at certain meetings every year.
[12:29] SPEAKER_01: So every first meeting, a third of the sessions would turn in their minutes, and they would just call up a standing committee.
[12:36] SPEAKER_01: They'd ask for volunteers basically to meet over lunch and and review the minutes submitted for that meeting.
[12:43] SPEAKER_01: Um then uh the Presbytery I'm currently serving in in Covenant, we have a church care committee, and the review of session minutes is given to that committee as a part of their regular work, and so they usually do it on an annual basis, so all minutes are due by mid-December, and they report at our February meeting.
[13:00] SPEAKER_01: Um and so that that's how you'll usually see it worked out.
[13:04] SPEAKER_01: Fred, I can't think of any other ways that Presbyteries have done review.
[13:08] SPEAKER_01: Those are the two main ways, I think.
[13:10] SPEAKER_03: Oh, they are, and my Presbytery, Houston Metro, does it the latter way that you've described.
[13:15] SPEAKER_03: You know, they have to submit their records, all churches by a certain date, and then the the review of records committee will look at them and and respond to the sessions if there's any items of concern, and then you know, continue down that path.
[13:30] SPEAKER_03: But those are really the only you know two ways to do that, I think.
[13:35] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I would if if there are any uh any men listening that have any influence in these areas, whatever you can do to turn that into an electronic uh process for your churches and presbyteries, please do that.
[13:47] SPEAKER_01: Ours, we still have to mail physical copies into our our committee every December.
[13:52] SPEAKER_01: Uh I I I love the brother that's been chairing that committee.
[13:55] SPEAKER_01: I think he just inherited that uh tradition, but still uh work hard to turn electronic things on.
[14:01] SPEAKER_03: Well, you can do that because again, there's no particulars in the Book of Church Order.
[14:06] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[14:06] SPEAKER_03: And so that's just a matter for standing rules, and we have in our standing rules that they'll be submitted electronically.
[14:13] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it's a handy way to do it.
[14:15] SPEAKER_01: Okay, so that now now we really get into some details.
[14:19] SPEAKER_01: So the you know, they've got to review the records.
[14:21] SPEAKER_01: Okay, what are they looking for?
[14:22] SPEAKER_01: That's 40-2.
[14:24] SPEAKER_01: In reviewing records of a lower court, the higher court is to examine four things whether the proceedings have been correctly recorded, whether they have been regular and in accordance with the Constitution, whether they have been wise, equitable, and suited to promote the welfare of the church, and whether the lawful injunctions of the higher court have been obeyed.
[14:43] SPEAKER_01: Um Pear Almquist, by the way, I'll I'm gonna reference Pear a couple times, I think, today.
[14:48] SPEAKER_01: Uh it is so nice to have that new commentary, if if not for anything else, to have another name uh that we can we can reference and another another way of saying pretty much the same thing.
[14:58] SPEAKER_01: That's not a slight on his commentary at all, but there's only so many things you can say about a book of church order.
[15:03] SPEAKER_01: Uh but he says almost as if ex as if expecting the suggestion, the examination of records is not a pendantic exercise in petty details.
[15:13] SPEAKER_01: So lest you think that may be what it is, listener, it is certainly not.
[15:17] SPEAKER_01: Um he points us to Morton Smith, who writes, It is not constitutional uh it is not constitutional regularity, it is not mechanical perfection that makes the church efficient for its end.
[15:28] SPEAKER_01: It is the Spirit of Christ using the church as his agent.
[15:32] SPEAKER_01: And I think Fred that hits on sort of the positive light you were trying to shine at the beginning, which is review and control is confirmation that churches are doing what they've been called to do, uh what that presbyteries are being faithful in what they've been given to do.
[15:46] SPEAKER_01: And so there's four areas that higher courts have to look for.
[15:48] SPEAKER_01: First is just court recording, or excuse me, correct recording.
[15:52] SPEAKER_01: Um let me uh let me pitch this to you.
[15:56] SPEAKER_01: Why is it important for courts to have proper recording of their actions?
[16:02] SPEAKER_03: Well, I think there's there are several reasons, Ben, and and some of them aren't really controversial, but they're very important.
[16:10] SPEAKER_03: So you want to have a record of what you've done for two reasons.
[16:15] SPEAKER_03: For the history of the church, and so that the court can know what they've done.
[16:20] SPEAKER_03: Now, this may sound commonsensical, but the number of times that I've been in a meeting, either of my church or another church, and the question has come up, you know, what did we do about that?
[16:34] SPEAKER_03: We had that matter come up like 15 years ago.
[16:39] SPEAKER_03: What did we do?
[16:41] SPEAKER_03: Well, if you haven't recorded it well in your minutes, you don't know.
[16:45] SPEAKER_03: You know, have we always approved every individual member of a mission team?
[16:50] SPEAKER_03: Or do we just approve the leader and then let the leader pick?
[16:54] SPEAKER_03: And so this way a court knows what it's done and can follow a consistent practice.
[17:01] SPEAKER_03: Um the other thing is there are important details for the history of the church.
[17:05] SPEAKER_03: So, for example, a session should be recording baptisms.
[17:10] SPEAKER_03: Now, that may seem you know mundane the week after a baptism to put it in your minutes, but that could be very important to that family.
[17:23] SPEAKER_03: Um, there are instances even in the present day where records of baptism are used for personal identification for people.
[17:34] SPEAKER_03: Um not maybe as much anymore as a hundred years ago.
[17:38] SPEAKER_03: But these are these are important matters to observe when you observe the Lord's Supper, that's recorded in your minutes.
[17:46] SPEAKER_03: Um and how you have handled certain matters, and so if you if you don't take a record of those things, you have no way of knowing or proving it's happened.
[18:02] SPEAKER_03: You can't count on people to just remember things.
[18:07] SPEAKER_03: And and that's not a knock on on people's memories, but people die, people move, um, and you know see the faithfulness of the Lord in a church.
[18:19] SPEAKER_03: My church just celebrated our 25th anniversary last fall.
[18:24] SPEAKER_03: And one of the things that we used uh as a record of God's faithfulness to us were our records, our minutes.
[18:33] SPEAKER_03: Um, seeing members joining the church and when they joined and who our first members were, and you know, what our first Sunday school class was, and you know, all of these things, if you don't have them recorded, you don't have a history of your church.
[18:47] SPEAKER_03: So it's not just to make sure everybody does things right, and a higher court can make sure all the I's are dotted and the T's are crossed.
[18:56] SPEAKER_03: This is a part of the history of the church, which is a record of God's faithfulness to the church.
[19:03] SPEAKER_03: I think that's very important.
[19:05] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[19:06] SPEAKER_01: And a record, even going so far back into scripture, genealogies themselves in in the scriptures are an example of this, uh, the history of God's faithfulness to his people.
[19:15] SPEAKER_01: Uh what about this this idea of let me scroll back up and find these these words.
[19:21] SPEAKER_01: Whether the second point here, whether they have been regular and in accordance with the Constitution.
[19:25] SPEAKER_01: So you correct me if I'm wrong.
[19:27] SPEAKER_01: Let me let me throw something out there.
[19:28] SPEAKER_01: The regularity has to do with um maybe you you have an action that is proper, but it was taken improperly with regard to its process or its procedure.
[19:42] SPEAKER_01: And so you want to you want to make sure that courts are are behaving regularly, doing things the way they're supposed to be done, and not doing the right things in the wrong way.
[19:50] SPEAKER_01: Is that is that would that be a fair way to think about that?
[19:52] SPEAKER_03: Yes, it would.
[19:53] SPEAKER_03: I'll give you an example that I'm aware of that when I first found out about it just blew me away.
[19:59] SPEAKER_03: So we I became aware of a church that when admitting new members did what every church in the PCA does, which is the session interviewed the person for membership, whether it was an initial profession of faith or or a transfer or a reaffirmation of faith.
[20:19] SPEAKER_03: And then after that interview was concluded, rather than asking the constitutional questions for admitting people people to ceiling ordinances, the new member was asked the evangelism explosion questions.
[20:37] SPEAKER_03: And and and here's the thing that really so you're you're laughing.
[20:42] SPEAKER_03: They recorded that in their minutes.
[20:45] SPEAKER_03: So it's not just that they forgot to do something.
[20:50] SPEAKER_03: They actually recorded doing it wrong in their minutes.
[20:53] SPEAKER_03: Now, I say that, you know, we're we're kind of chuckling a little bit.
[20:57] SPEAKER_03: I have nothing against the evangelism explosion questions.
[21:00] SPEAKER_03: I don't even have anything against a session or a session commission asking those questions of people making a profession of faith.
[21:08] SPEAKER_03: They're good questions, but they're not our constitutional questions.
[21:13] SPEAKER_03: And so that's something that needed to be corrected.
[21:17] SPEAKER_03: Now, why would that need to be corrected?
[21:20] SPEAKER_03: We could say, well, they had a profession of faith, they believe in Jesus, that's all that's important.
[21:25] SPEAKER_03: Well, if you don't ask someone the constitutional questions, if ten years later a matter of discipline comes up and someone is charged with violating one of the vows to support the mission and vision of the church, how can you charge them with that when they've never taken that vow?
[21:46] SPEAKER_03: Right?
[21:46] SPEAKER_03: And so this is not just again, to use Harris's term, it's not just pedantic.
[21:52] SPEAKER_03: It's not just window dressing.
[21:54] SPEAKER_03: It's something that you know, oftentimes when I talk to people about the BCO, they think.
[22:00] SPEAKER_03: The BCO is not important and the provisions aren't important because they're mundane, they're detailed.
[22:05] SPEAKER_03: The reason we have the provisions we have is to prevent problems and to undo problems we've seen in the past.
[22:13] SPEAKER_03: That's what they're there for.
[22:15] SPEAKER_03: They're not there for just because, well, we've got you know some time on our hands and let's do this.
[22:20] SPEAKER_03: So wanting things to be regular and in accordance with the Constitution, that carries in all of the things that, you know, your listeners should be well aware of.
[22:28] SPEAKER_03: As we talked about discipline and the purposes of discipline and, you know, the rights of membership and right, and you know, when you get to complaints and appeals and, you know, all of these things, rights of a congregation, you know, they're all bound up together.
[22:43] SPEAKER_03: And if a church isn't acting constitutionally, then um biblical principles are being violated.
[22:55] SPEAKER_01: Perry draws out this point kind of next to what you're saying, that failure to act constitutionally breaks the unity of the church as well.
[23:04] SPEAKER_01: So it it certainly may be that they're acting improperly and unscripturally, but that our constitution is what binds us together.
[23:11] SPEAKER_01: And so and and the the the questions are really good, too, like as an example.
[23:15] SPEAKER_01: You know, if if one person over here got asked the EE questions and somebody over here got asked the five membership questions, well, they're not they're not united together in their common profession.
[23:23] SPEAKER_01: And that may seem technical to some people, but it's true that they have not professed the same thing in a public way as they joined the physical church, and and we want them to be together.
[23:32] SPEAKER_01: To your point earlier as well, we're not a convention of churches, we're a church.
[23:36] SPEAKER_01: And so, regardless of where your membership is, we share the same constitution and connection.
[23:40] SPEAKER_03: That came up even this year, so we had yet another attempt.
[23:43] SPEAKER_03: Now, I've been doing this a long time, Ben.
[23:45] SPEAKER_03: I've been an elder almost 30 years, and this was like the fifth or sixth time somebody made an effort to amend our membership vows.
[23:53] unknown: Oh, yeah.
[23:54] SPEAKER_03: And I felt really bad for the poor brother from Eastern Carolina because you had a better chance of an ice cream social spontaneously happening at General Assembly than he had of getting two votes for that.
[24:08] SPEAKER_03: It was just not going to happen.
[24:09] SPEAKER_03: And one of the strong arguments against it, I've seen this fail over and over and over again, is well, if we change the vows, which we've had for 150 years, do current members have to retake the vows?
[24:21] SPEAKER_03: Um, you know, does that change membership?
[24:23] SPEAKER_03: And what and I don't know what the exact polity answer is because we've never changed the vows, and I don't think we will.
[24:29] SPEAKER_03: Um, but you know, that gets to your point.
[24:32] SPEAKER_03: Um, you know, about every five, eight, ten years, somebody tries to change the vows and they go down in flames.
[24:39] SPEAKER_03: Um, and so, and that's one of the strong arguments against it, is that, you know, unity that we have together.
[24:49] SPEAKER_01: The the third point here in 48-2 is that we review records of lower courts as to whether they've been wise, equitable, and suited to promote the welfare of the church.
[25:00] SPEAKER_01: Uh some some actions may be recorded properly, and they may be constitutional to cover our first two points, but they might just be dumb or unwise or unpastoral.
[25:14] SPEAKER_01: Uh I I want to ask you for an example.
[25:16] SPEAKER_01: I didn't tell you I was going to ask you for that.
[25:17] SPEAKER_03: If if you have any examples or thoughts on that, Pear's got one too that we can pull in if we need to, but well, this is uh this is a kind of a grab bag.
[25:27] SPEAKER_03: And, you know, I think it it could be, for example, you don't have to give detailed advice to someone who could be coming under process.
[25:43] SPEAKER_03: But it would be very wise and it would be equitable to give them advice as to they could get an assistant, um, they can they can call witnesses, these are the provisions in the book.
[25:55] SPEAKER_03: You know, all that you have to do is just tell them the book covers it.
[25:58] SPEAKER_03: You don't have to give them any advice or anything.
[26:01] SPEAKER_03: But I think it's wise.
[26:02] SPEAKER_03: One of my general principles of polity, whenever anyone asks for advice, is do everything you can to avoid a potential complaint or appeal.
[26:14] SPEAKER_03: Try to work together, try to advise, try to give you know opportunities, try to get agreement on matters that are disputable.
[26:23] SPEAKER_03: And I think um courts would be well suited to do that.
[26:29] SPEAKER_03: Um just because something's constitutional doesn't mean it will come to a good end.
[26:37] SPEAKER_03: And having sat on an appellate court now for 16 or 17 years, I can tell you that we've had occasions where we may sustain a complaint or sustain an appeal on this provision, because even though maybe the court has acted strictly according to the Constitution, um, they didn't do it in such a way as to be um wise and equitable.
[27:03] SPEAKER_01: Now could can a higher court force a lower court to to redo something, or is this just a matter of pointing out that such an action was unwise or unequitable?
[27:16] SPEAKER_03: No, I think clearly um a higher court can um can send something back.
[27:22] SPEAKER_03: Obviously they can on a complaint, but uh you know, we can skip ahead a little bit to 40-5.
[27:28] SPEAKER_03: One of the remedies is to send it back and to say do it right.
[27:33] SPEAKER_03: And usually the higher court will say, by the way, this would be the right way to do it.
[27:38] SPEAKER_03: You might want to do this.
[27:39] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[27:40] SPEAKER_03: You know, I call that the paint by the numbers provision.
[27:43] SPEAKER_03: Um, you know, you want to because you don't want you don't want it ping-ponging.
[27:47] SPEAKER_03: You don't want to send it back down and then they give it a go and then they don't they don't do it again, they send it back up.
[27:52] SPEAKER_03: You know, you don't want it going back and forth, back and forth.
[27:54] SPEAKER_03: So, you know, because again, I think in my experience in ecclesiastical litigation, it is far more likely for a court to have erred by not knowing or misunderstanding than by some sort of willful rebellion or unwillingness to act properly.
[28:19] SPEAKER_03: I mean, the ratio there is like 98 to 2.
[28:22] SPEAKER_03: I mean, it's not even close.
[28:24] SPEAKER_03: And so the higher court would, I think, always do well to let the lower court know what the problem was and how they could fix the problem.
[28:33] SPEAKER_01: That's good.
[28:35] SPEAKER_01: Well, uh, the last one here in 40-2, uh, they need to uh review whether the lawful injunctions of the higher court have been obeyed.
[28:43] SPEAKER_01: And it this seems to me to be sort of a summary statement here at the end.
[28:46] SPEAKER_01: Like, of course, everything that everything that we do is is based on our Book of Church Order and our constitution our doctrinal standards, and so uh in that the highest court has the right to amend those uh with with agreement, like everything that we have to do is in obedience to the injunctions of the highest court.
[29:05] SPEAKER_01: That's right.
[29:05] SPEAKER_01: So we're talking here BCO amendments, we need to make sure we're following things properly, that we've adjusted to shifts that have happened in the book.
[29:12] SPEAKER_01: Is there anything else we need to keep in mind with this one?
[29:14] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[29:15] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[29:15] SPEAKER_03: So so we became aware on the SJC a few years ago of us not having a formal mechanism to make sure that a lower court, whether it's a presbytery or it could be a session, because the case could come all the way from a session, is actually doing what we said they had to do.
[29:36] SPEAKER_03: And so um, I mean, we just assumed they did.
[29:40] SPEAKER_03: But so we started, we've started now in every one of our decisions, and I just wrote one this past week, we add something called recording in the minutes now, according to our in addition to our summary of the facts and our statement of the issue and our judgment.
[29:56] SPEAKER_03: We have we instruct the lower court to record our decision in their minutes.
[30:02] SPEAKER_03: So we know everyone in that court knows what we've done.
[30:06] SPEAKER_03: It's not just the clerk, it's not just the moderator, everyone has access to that.
[30:12] SPEAKER_03: And to also record any concurring or dissenting opinions, and then to show that they have taken actions that are in accordance with that decision.
[30:29] SPEAKER_03: So again, in theory, a session's minutes would be reviewed by a presbytery, and a presbytery's minutes would be reviewed by the General Assembly's Committee on Review of Presbytery Records.
[30:41] SPEAKER_03: So if we said, for example, to a presbytery, you need to reinstate this minister, and they didn't, we would know.
[30:54] SPEAKER_03: And then we could take action upon that.
[30:57] SPEAKER_03: Um and so I think that's that's the classic example of a lawful injunction.
[31:03] SPEAKER_01: Super helpful.
[31:05] SPEAKER_01: Okay, so let's uh let's cruise into 40-3.
[31:12] SPEAKER_01: And the people said that me and Fred couldn't fill the time that four of us normally fill.
[31:18] SPEAKER_01: Come on, guys.
[31:19] SPEAKER_01: 40-3.
[31:21] SPEAKER_01: It is ordinarily sufficient for the higher court merely to record in its own minutes and in the records reviewed, whether it approves, disapproves, or corrects the records in any particular.
[31:30] SPEAKER_01: But should any serious irregularity be discovered, the higher court may require its review and correction by the lower.
[31:35] SPEAKER_01: Proceedings in judicial cases, however, shall not be dealt with under review and control when notice of appeal or complaint has been given the lower court.
[31:43] SPEAKER_01: And no judgment of the lower court in a judicial case shall be reversed except by appeal or complaint.
[31:49] SPEAKER_01: Uh so essentially it starts out by saying the higher court has to record its review of the lower minutes in its own minutes, um, but it it gives us some stipulation to that there's a little more required in cases of serious irregularity.
[32:04] SPEAKER_01: Uh there needs to be correction.
[32:05] SPEAKER_01: We've alluded to that a little bit just now in the previous section, and you may want to comment on these a little bit.
[32:11] SPEAKER_01: So if there's a if there's a complaint or an appeal going on, judicial cases uh aren't to be dealt with until they're complete.
[32:19] SPEAKER_01: And also you can't reverse uh uh a judicial decision except by appeal or complaint.
[32:25] SPEAKER_01: Is that the way we read that?
[32:26] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[32:27] SPEAKER_03: So review and control don't cover those judicial cases because if we could put it this way, there are more particular rules for review and control with respect to complaints and appeals.
[32:40] SPEAKER_02: Sure.
[32:41] SPEAKER_03: Because review and control is really a grab bag, right?
[32:44] SPEAKER_03: And and there's, as you notice in here, there's no time limitations, there's no filing limitations, there's there's not even any standing limitations.
[32:55] SPEAKER_03: So a court could become aware of a problem from a secular newspaper or from a blog or from social media that no one needs to have standing.
[33:06] SPEAKER_03: But in judicial type cases, that is, cases of complaint or appeal, there are very particular rules.
[33:13] SPEAKER_03: You have to file within a certain amount of days, you have to do a certain type of filing, you have to file with certain courts, you have that, you know, those rules need to be adhered to.
[33:23] SPEAKER_03: Um, and you can't use chapter 40 to trump them.
[33:27] SPEAKER_03: Now, there's another aspect to this.
[33:30] SPEAKER_03: It's not just preventing people from doing things.
[33:33] SPEAKER_03: If I am uh charged and convicted by my presbytery, I want to control my appeal and present my evidence in my case.
[33:45] SPEAKER_03: I don't want somebody else elbowing me out of the way under a review and control.
[33:49] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[33:50] SPEAKER_03: Same thing with a complaint.
[33:52] SPEAKER_03: If I file a complaint, I'm the one that's taking the initiative.
[33:56] SPEAKER_03: And I don't want someone, you know, taking precedence over me because I've made the effort uh to do that.
[34:04] SPEAKER_03: And and I think we also need to understand that review and control is not a substitute for an appeal.
[34:12] SPEAKER_03: So you can't uh overturn a conviction, you can't, you know, deal with these things.
[34:17] SPEAKER_03: And and oftentimes people will try this.
[34:21] SPEAKER_03: Uh they'll they'll try and to be blunt, they'll look at the filing deadline, realize they've missed the filing deadline, and try chapter 40.
[34:34] SPEAKER_03: Because they know they can't do it under 43 or under 42, complaints or appeals.
[34:40] SPEAKER_03: Um and this is again the general species of review and control.
[34:45] SPEAKER_03: And it's not that we don't have that particular, we just have particular rules for the particulars.
[34:51] SPEAKER_01: Okay.
[34:53] SPEAKER_01: I'm I'm especially curious about these last few sections.
[34:57] SPEAKER_01: Um well, I suppose I said that too early, especially about five and six, but let's look at uh four to start with.
[35:05] SPEAKER_01: Forty dash four.
[35:06] SPEAKER_01: Courts may sometimes entirely neglect to perform their duty, by which neglect heretical opinions or corrupt practices may be allowed to gain ground, or offenders of a very gross character may be suffered to escape, or some circumstances in their proceedings of very great irregularity may not be distinctly recorded by them.
[35:25] SPEAKER_01: In any of these cases, their records will by no means exhibit to the higher court a full view of their proceedings.
[35:31] SPEAKER_01: If, therefore, the next higher court be well advised that any such neglect or irregularity has occurred on the part of the lower court, it is incumbent on it to take cognizance of the same and to examine deliberate uh excuse me, to examine, deliberate, and judge in the whole matter as completely as if it had been recorded and thus brought up by review of its records.
[35:51] SPEAKER_01: You you sort of just referred to this a second ago.
[35:53] SPEAKER_01: I think we talked about a newspaper.
[35:55] SPEAKER_01: Um maybe I'm maybe I'm reading that wrong.
[35:58] SPEAKER_01: Sometimes things are gonna happen in a session or a presbytery that shouldn't happen, and probably they're not gonna record those things.
[36:06] SPEAKER_01: It's almost a kind of it's laughable almost that our book says this.
[36:09] SPEAKER_01: In any of these cases, their records will by no means exhibit to the higher court a full view of these proceedings.
[36:13] SPEAKER_01: But if the higher court becomes aware of in some form or fashion and they can acquire that information, they can deal with it as if it was in the record.
[36:22] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I mean, this is a very simple provision, but it's very important.
[36:27] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, okay.
[36:28] SPEAKER_03: It's basically courts can't hide actions by not putting them in their minutes.
[36:35] SPEAKER_03: And what this says is if a court is taking an action, but it's not in the minutes, and a higher court becomes aware, a member of the lower court could make the higher court aware of it.
[36:48] SPEAKER_03: Um uh a member of a church could make a higher court aware of it.
[36:52] SPEAKER_03: It could be something common fame that's out, you know, in the public.
[36:59] SPEAKER_03: And uh the higher court then can act as if it were recorded.
[37:04] SPEAKER_03: Now, let me be clear here.
[37:07] SPEAKER_03: That doesn't mean that we hear a rumor that a court has done something and therefore they're convicted and censured.
[37:15] SPEAKER_03: That means the higher court says to the lower court, there was this Facebook post that said y'all did this.
[37:25] SPEAKER_03: Can you tell us what happened and why it wasn't recorded if it happened?
[37:32] SPEAKER_03: And probably the vast majority of the time, the lower court would say something like, I don't know why that Facebook post was made.
[37:39] SPEAKER_03: We never did that.
[37:40] SPEAKER_03: Here's what we did.
[37:43] SPEAKER_03: Um and what would happen is the the lower court would formally answer that.
[37:49] SPEAKER_03: So it wouldn't just be a guy saying, No, I don't, I don't think that happened.
[37:53] SPEAKER_03: You know, the court would, you know, uh draft a response, approve the response, and then approve their clerk, whether it's a clerk of session or a clerk of presbytery, reporting that up to the higher court.
[38:06] SPEAKER_03: So this is basically you know omissions from minutes, but it follows the same process that if there's something in the minutes that shows a problem, um that that could be a species of 40-5.
[38:23] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[38:24] SPEAKER_03: You deal with it in the same way.
[38:26] SPEAKER_03: This uh section is just saying you don't have to have a specific notation of an error.
[38:36] SPEAKER_01: Let's let's jump into 45 because 40-5, I think people hear that those numbers thrown out occasionally.
[38:42] SPEAKER_01: Um you know, this is what it's about.
[38:45] SPEAKER_01: Uh when any court having appellate jurisdiction shall receive a credible report with respect to the court next below of any important delinquency or grossly unconstitutional proceedings of such court, the first step shall be to cite the court alleged to have offended, to appear before the court having appellate jurisdiction or its commission by representative or in writing at a specified time and place, and to show what the lower court has done or failed to do in the case in question.
[39:11] SPEAKER_01: The court thus issuing the citation may reverse or redress the proceedings of the court below in other than judicial cases, or it may censure the delinquent court, or it may remit the whole matter to the delinquent court with an injunction to take it up and dispose of it in a constitutional manner, or it may stay all further proceedings in the case as circumstances may require.
[39:32] SPEAKER_01: I have so many uh thoughts and questions here.
[39:36] SPEAKER_01: Um let me start with one.
[39:39] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[39:39] SPEAKER_01: Come on, come on.
[39:40] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[39:40] SPEAKER_03: This is a provision that gives me hives.
[39:45] SPEAKER_03: And the same reason the 31-2 does.
[39:48] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[39:48] SPEAKER_01: Uh-huh.
[39:49] SPEAKER_03: People talk about I'm filing a 40-5, and the court needs to respond to my 40-5 in the same way I'm filing a 31-2, and you need to satisfy me because of my filing.
[40:06] SPEAKER_03: No, sir, you do not.
[40:08] SPEAKER_03: This is a court's prerogative.
[40:11] SPEAKER_03: Now, you may bring a report to a court that's covered under this language.
[40:17] SPEAKER_03: You could write a letter to the court and say, um, brothers of the higher court, you need to be aware that this is going on in one of your churches.
[40:28] SPEAKER_03: But that's the end of it.
[40:30] SPEAKER_03: You don't have standing.
[40:32] SPEAKER_03: The court doesn't have to answer to you.
[40:34] SPEAKER_03: You don't get a right to testify.
[40:36] SPEAKER_03: You don't get a right to bring witnesses.
[40:38] SPEAKER_03: You have no rights.
[40:40] SPEAKER_03: You are a reporter.
[40:43] SPEAKER_03: You are Jimmy Olson, not Clark Kent Superman.
[40:47] SPEAKER_03: All you are doing is sending a report, and the court can decide what it wants to do with it according to these provisions.
[40:54] SPEAKER_03: And so, you know, this is general review and control.
[40:57] SPEAKER_03: And so, again, you know, men don't understand this, and they think that courts have to snap to it when they've done something that they think is a filing when it's not.
[41:10] SPEAKER_03: Someone can send a report to a higher court, and a higher court can look at this and go, Well, that's not credible.
[41:18] SPEAKER_03: We're not even gonna look at it.
[41:20] SPEAKER_03: Um the most frequent instance in which this happens is there are serial reporters.
[41:30] SPEAKER_03: That is, persons who have made higher courts aware of about 143 things.
[41:38] SPEAKER_03: And after a while, you're like, no, we're not gonna listen to you.
[41:43] SPEAKER_03: We know you got an axe to grind, and it's you're you're not credible because the previous 142 weren't credible, so you're not credible, right?
[41:52] SPEAKER_03: So the court has to decide whether, first of all, it's credible.
[41:58] SPEAKER_03: Then secondly, you see it has to either be an important delinquency or a grossly unconstitutional proceeding.
[42:06] SPEAKER_03: Now, these are not terms of art.
[42:10] SPEAKER_03: If if I'm trying to figure this out, the first place that I'm going, for an example, is Ramsey.
[42:16] SPEAKER_03: That's the first place I'm going.
[42:18] SPEAKER_03: And so, you know, you may have noticed when your uh your co-host put up a picture of all of his books on polity.
[42:26] SPEAKER_03: Uh, one of them didn't have the author on the binding, and I told him, There's no Ramsey, do you even polity?
[42:31] SPEAKER_03: What are you doing?
[42:32] SPEAKER_03: So Ramsey is, I think, the best place to go.
[42:35] SPEAKER_03: Um, Smith is a good place to go.
[42:38] SPEAKER_03: Uh, and now I'd have to see what Almquist has.
[42:42] SPEAKER_03: But not every delinquency is an important delinquency.
[42:45] SPEAKER_03: And what makes a delinquency important?
[42:48] SPEAKER_03: You know, I don't know.
[42:49] SPEAKER_03: This is, dare I say it, it's like the Supreme Court's uh definition of pornography.
[42:54] SPEAKER_03: I can't define it, but I know it when I see it.
[42:57] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I think it's important.
[42:58] SPEAKER_03: And and differing courts can differ as to what's important and what's not.
[43:02] SPEAKER_03: Same thing.
[43:03] SPEAKER_03: I can tell you that it's not just something unconstitutional.
[43:07] SPEAKER_03: Otherwise, the word grossly wouldn't exist in this provision.
[43:10] SPEAKER_03: Now, what makes something really unconstitutional?
[43:15] SPEAKER_03: No.
[43:16] SPEAKER_03: But it's got to be more than just something, you know, uh a little bit.
[43:22] SPEAKER_03: And it has to meet those two tests.
[43:24] SPEAKER_03: It has to be credible, and it has to either be an important delinquency or grossly unconstitutional proceeding.
[43:31] SPEAKER_03: Now, all of that is just a report that is not a finding.
[43:36] SPEAKER_03: That's the beginning of the process.
[43:40] SPEAKER_03: And then the court drives what it wants to do with the process.
[43:46] SPEAKER_03: It could communicate with the reporter and say, give us more information, answer these questions for us.
[43:51] SPEAKER_03: Is there anyone else that we should talk to about this?
[43:53] SPEAKER_03: Are there any other records we should seek?
[43:56] SPEAKER_03: They could talk to the lower court and say, tell us what you think of this.
[44:00] SPEAKER_03: Us some records.
[44:01] SPEAKER_03: They can do small eye investigatory work to figure out whether you know there's even something here.
[44:11] SPEAKER_03: And you'll notice here it says that it can cite the court to appear, but notice it says by representative or in writing.
[44:21] SPEAKER_03: So for example, we've had several 40-5 reports come to the SJC and 90% of them are handled in writing.
[44:34] SPEAKER_03: These are the questions we want you to answer.
[44:37] SPEAKER_03: And they write them back and we say one, two, four, and five are satisfactory, fix three and come back to us and do it that way.
[44:46] SPEAKER_03: Now we have had some instances where we've actually had appearances and we've had hearings.
[44:53] SPEAKER_03: And again, a presbytery could do that with a session.
[44:57] SPEAKER_03: And that is um that is the um uh the prerogative here, you know, of the court um and and what it wants to do.
[45:13] SPEAKER_03: Um and I actually think um you're getting a little bit more than you asked for here.
[45:18] SPEAKER_03: I actually think this provision gives the benefit of the doubt to the lower court.
[45:25] SPEAKER_03: In other words, the lower court gets to decide whether they want to send a representative or whether they want to respond in writing.
[45:32] SPEAKER_03: Now, of course, the lower court could say, we can't be bothered with you, higher court, we're just sending you a writing.
[45:37] SPEAKER_01: Sure.
[45:37] SPEAKER_03: And the higher court could say, well, that's nice, we don't find it satisfactory, right?
[45:41] SPEAKER_03: But but I do think it's at the lower court's at least initial determination of how they want to respond.
[45:50] SPEAKER_03: Um, and then you know the higher court um can deal with it, and that's the rest of a 40-5.
[45:57] SPEAKER_03: It can, you know, reverse what's happened, it could um redress the proceedings, except for in a judicial case.
[46:06] SPEAKER_03: Um, it can censure the lower court.
[46:09] SPEAKER_03: Um now, this is an interesting thing.
[46:12] SPEAKER_00: I haven't talked about that.
[46:14] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, how do you how do you censor it?
[46:15] SPEAKER_00: How do you send it?
[46:16] SPEAKER_03: Then maybe we'll talk about that in a second.
[46:17] SPEAKER_00: Well, no, I mean, yeah, okay.
[46:19] SPEAKER_03: Um, or it can um send it back, remit the matter uh with an injunction to take it up um in a constitutional manner, or it may stay all further proceedings in the case.
[46:32] SPEAKER_03: So you can obviously see differences here.
[46:34] SPEAKER_03: If a lower court is trying to actively do something unconstitutional, then the higher court could just say, stop it.
[46:41] SPEAKER_03: Don't do it.
[46:42] SPEAKER_03: If the lower court has already done something unconstitutional, the higher court can say fix it.
[46:48] SPEAKER_03: Or they can just say, we're fixing it for you.
[46:53] SPEAKER_03: We're doing this.
[46:55] SPEAKER_03: Right?
[46:56] SPEAKER_03: So um, you know, something that wouldn't be a judicial, uh, you know, a judicial case, um, you know, maybe uh a lower court has um dismissed someone from membership unconstitutionally and there's no judicial case on it.
[47:14] SPEAKER_03: Um, maybe what the church has a pattern of if you don't come to church at least once a month after two months, they they take you off the rolls and they don't follow 384.
[47:31] SPEAKER_03: Well, a higher court could say no, that's not constitutional.
[47:35] SPEAKER_03: You haven't followed the constitution.
[47:37] SPEAKER_03: 384 says what you're supposed to do, and you need to do it.
[47:42] SPEAKER_03: Um and that wouldn't necessarily be a judicial case, you know, because for example, if you took someone off the rolls and didn't under 38-4 send them a letter saying that you were taking them off the rolls, and if they didn't want to be taken off the rolls, they would have the right of having a case of process.
[48:00] SPEAKER_03: That would be an instance where someone wouldn't even know they had a right to have process because they'd never gotten notification of it.
[48:07] SPEAKER_03: Well, a higher court could say, you can't do that.
[48:10] SPEAKER_03: And we're gonna restore those people to membership.
[48:13] SPEAKER_03: And again, that shows our connectionalism, then, because your presbytery or my presbytery could restore someone to membership in our churches because our churches have violated the Constitution.
[48:27] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, you can't do that in a congregational baptistic context.
[48:31] unknown: No.
[48:32] SPEAKER_01: No, and and you know, for anybody who's listening, that you take great encouragement at that reality in our Presbyterian system, that there's you know a church can do something wrong and and the members not need not suffer necessarily.
[48:43] SPEAKER_01: Right.
[48:44] SPEAKER_03: And I think what what should really be encouraging to people is not that there are hundreds of examples of this happening in the PCA and it being fixed, but the very fact that there's a mechanism means churches do the right thing.
[48:59] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[48:59] SPEAKER_03: Right?
[49:00] SPEAKER_03: It's like when I was a kid, my parents said to me, You do know if you lie to us, we're gonna know you're lying.
[49:08] SPEAKER_03: Now, now that I'm an adult and a grandparent, I realize that's not exactly true.
[49:12] SPEAKER_03: But it sure kept me from wanting to lie because I didn't want to get caught.
[49:16] SPEAKER_03: And I knew they were gonna catch me.
[49:19] SPEAKER_03: And so it kept me on a straight, it was one of the ways that kept me on a straight and arrow.
[49:23] SPEAKER_03: And I think just the fact that we have these mechanisms helps us to do things in a proper and biblical fashion.
[49:31] SPEAKER_01: Well, my question is about the censoring, but let's do 46, 40-6, because I think I we can I can ask it in the context of this last paragraph.
[49:39] SPEAKER_01: So 40-6 in process against a lower court, the trial shall be conducted according to the rules provided for process against individuals so far as they may be applicable.
[49:49] SPEAKER_01: So uh my my my question in the previous section was going to be how do you censure a lower court?
[49:55] SPEAKER_01: What does that look like?
[49:56] SPEAKER_01: Because we have censures for individuals, obviously.
[49:58] SPEAKER_01: I don't know if I I don't think I know what that looks like for a court to be censured.
[50:03] SPEAKER_01: This 40-6 is essentially laying out what a process would look like against them.
[50:07] SPEAKER_01: Same as individuals.
[50:08] SPEAKER_01: The lower court is the accused.
[50:10] SPEAKER_01: Um they're they they walk through the process.
[50:12] SPEAKER_01: Rules of evidence, witnesses, yeah, yeah.
[50:16] SPEAKER_03: That's what that's referring to.
[50:17] SPEAKER_03: Now, censure, again, there's no they're convicted.
[50:20] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, there's no explicit provision here.
[50:23] SPEAKER_03: And I can't recall off the top of my head what Smith says.
[50:27] SPEAKER_03: I haven't I haven't looked at Almquist on this.
[50:30] SPEAKER_03: I can tell you what I think it means.
[50:32] SPEAKER_03: I think the analogy is this.
[50:35] SPEAKER_03: You could certainly admonish a lower court.
[50:37] SPEAKER_03: That's easy.
[50:38] SPEAKER_03: It's the same as when you admonish an individual.
[50:41] SPEAKER_03: I think suspension from the sacraments is analogous to seating commissioners in the higher court.
[50:53] SPEAKER_00: Okay.
[50:53] SPEAKER_03: You're suspending them from participation.
[50:56] SPEAKER_03: Okay.
[50:57] SPEAKER_03: So just like you could be suspended from the sacraments for a definite period of time or an indefinite, well, not you not from the sacraments, but from office definitely, and from the sacraments indefinitely, you could do that until there's sufficient repentance and et cetera.
[51:12] SPEAKER_03: I think the analogy to excommunication is a higher court has the ability to remove the lower court from participation in the higher court.
[51:27] SPEAKER_03: So being a part of the Presbyterian Church in America is a voluntary association.
[51:34] SPEAKER_03: Right?
[51:35] SPEAKER_03: So chapter 25 makes it very clear that on 30 days' notice, this is chapter 25, section 11, on 30 days' notice, a church can hold a congregational meeting to leave the PCA.
[51:49] SPEAKER_03: And unlike some other denominations, like the OPC and like the EPC, they don't even have to have a reason.
[51:55] SPEAKER_03: There doesn't even have to be any reason given at all or debated.
[52:00] SPEAKER_03: They can just say, we voted and we left.
[52:02] SPEAKER_03: And it's effective immediately.
[52:06] SPEAKER_03: But the voluntarism works both ways.
[52:09] SPEAKER_03: So a presbytery or a congregation can't say to the higher courts, you have to keep us even if we flout your constitution.
[52:21] SPEAKER_03: So a higher court can dismiss a lower court from the body.
[52:28] SPEAKER_03: Now, this almost happened in our history.
[52:31] SPEAKER_03: If you recall, you may be a little young to remember the federal vision controversy in Louisiana.
[52:37] SPEAKER_03: But one of the remedies that was coming down the pike, there was a trial.
[52:41] SPEAKER_03: There were charges made against Louisiana Presbytery under 40-5.
[52:46] SPEAKER_03: It was a 40-5 that came from several presbyteries.
[52:49] SPEAKER_03: Uh, charges were proffered, a prosecutor was appointed.
[52:53] SPEAKER_03: It was my good friend ruling elder Sam Duncan.
[52:56] SPEAKER_03: He had assistant prosecutors appointed, and a trial, you know, date was set.
[53:02] SPEAKER_03: And then the individuals and churches that were at issue voluntarily left the PCA.
[53:10] SPEAKER_03: But if they hadn't, the whole presbytery was going to be on trial because they had allowed this to happen.
[53:16] SPEAKER_03: And if convicted, that whole presbytery would have been kicked out of the PCA.
[53:22] SPEAKER_03: And the idea would have been that the whole presbytery and all of its churches would have been dismissed from the PCA, and the churches that did not have part in the error and wanted to stay in the PCA would have petitioned to come back in.
[53:35] SPEAKER_03: And they would have been assigned to another presbytery.
[53:39] SPEAKER_03: And that's kind of a nuclear option.
[53:42] SPEAKER_03: But that's there are instances in which a higher court really can't do anything other than that.
[53:50] SPEAKER_03: And so um it hasn't happened.
[53:54] SPEAKER_03: I haven't uh I haven't heard, I know there hasn't been a presbytery that has been dismissed from the PCA.
[54:01] SPEAKER_03: I don't think I've heard of a church that's been dismissed from the PCA.
[54:07] SPEAKER_03: I'm sure it's happened.
[54:09] SPEAKER_03: Um but um a presbytery could do that.
[54:14] SPEAKER_03: A presbytery could vote and say to a church under BCO 139, we are dismissing you.
[54:23] SPEAKER_03: Again, that voluntarism goes both ways, right?
[54:25] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[54:26] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[54:28] SPEAKER_01: Super helpful.
[54:29] SPEAKER_01: And I just you may have said this in in a way, I just to help any clarity that listeners may need.
[54:35] SPEAKER_01: So with an individual, uh, censures um remove those things which the church has granted to those members.
[54:44] SPEAKER_01: Seat at the table, you know, table fellowship, uh, membership in the congregation, those things can be removed when they've been convicted of an offense.
[54:53] SPEAKER_01: Right.
[54:53] SPEAKER_01: And so the analogy would carry up further seats at Presbytery for a church, membership in the Presbytery for a church, even further up the presbytery, seats well, you didn't say seats at GA, but membership in the General Assembly as a whole.
[55:06] SPEAKER_01: Those things which the higher court can give to the lower um an analogo analogously uh to back to members.
[55:15] SPEAKER_01: Okay.
[55:16] SPEAKER_01: Just want to make sure I'm thinking about it properly.
[55:17] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[55:18] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I'm not aware of any specific litigation that makes those analogies.
[55:22] SPEAKER_03: And I haven't seen a case.
[55:23] SPEAKER_03: If I had, I'd have written an opinion that said what I just said.
[55:26] SPEAKER_03: But but it does make sense, and I've talked to others about that.
[55:29] SPEAKER_03: And I'm not sure what else there could be.
[55:32] SPEAKER_03: Because remember, this gets back to all of our general principles.
[55:35] SPEAKER_03: It goes together with the book, that our authority is ministerial and declarative.
[55:39] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[55:40] SPEAKER_03: So a presbytery couldn't find a church.
[55:44] SPEAKER_03: Right?
[55:44] SPEAKER_03: Um, a presbytery couldn't make a church, you know, do mandatory service or something like that.
[55:51] SPEAKER_01: They couldn't go lock the church up until they repented and then let the members back in after, right?
[55:55] SPEAKER_03: That's correct.
[55:55] SPEAKER_03: And that's especially true in the PCA.
[55:59] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[55:59] SPEAKER_03: We've guarded against that because those abuses happened in the PCUS.
[56:04] SPEAKER_03: Uh, where literally locks were changed and you know, passwords changed and presbyteries took over buildings.
[56:12] SPEAKER_03: Um, but yet having ministerial and declarative authority doesn't mean we have no authority.
[56:17] SPEAKER_03: We certainly have authority.
[56:18] SPEAKER_03: And while on the one hand, someone might say, well, big deal, you could kick this church out of the PCA.
[56:24] SPEAKER_03: They won't care, they'll just go along on their own business.
[56:27] SPEAKER_03: Well, no, that actually says something.
[56:30] SPEAKER_03: And it says something not just to the PCA, but if a church got kicked out of the PCA, the OPC would take cognizance of that.
[56:38] SPEAKER_03: The ARP would take cognizance of that.
[56:40] SPEAKER_03: I would dare say that even the Southern Baptist Convention would take cognizance of that and say, wait a minute, these folks all of a sudden became Baptists because they had trouble in the PCA and got kicked out.
[56:52] SPEAKER_03: We don't want them.
[56:54] SPEAKER_03: Right?
[56:54] SPEAKER_03: I mean, I think, you know, it's a declaration, which is in any kind of discipline, that's what it's meant to do.
[57:02] SPEAKER_03: And then ultimately, in theory, would be to drive the offender, if I can use that phrase, to repentance and a change in in attitude and in action.
[57:12] SPEAKER_03: And again, that's where the analogy would play out.
[57:14] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that's helpful.
[57:16] SPEAKER_01: Well, as uh as Scott and Jared would say, this podcast is over.
[57:21] SPEAKER_01: Now, I, you know, I didn't reference it at the beginning.
[57:24] SPEAKER_01: Jared is doing something with his with children this week.
[57:27] SPEAKER_01: I think he's helping in like a kids' camp, maybe for the Presbytery.
[57:30] SPEAKER_01: Scott's uh sons have lead poisoning.
[57:34] SPEAKER_01: No, that's not true.
[57:35] SPEAKER_01: I that's that's a terrible clip.
[57:37] SPEAKER_01: I think it was a typo when he texted that to us.
[57:39] SPEAKER_01: I don't think his children have lead poisoning.
[57:41] SPEAKER_01: I think his house has some kind of lead poisoning or something.
[57:44] SPEAKER_01: Anyway, y'all can check in on them if you want to.
[57:47] SPEAKER_01: But we're grateful for Fred for joining us.
[57:49] SPEAKER_01: Listeners, thank you for joining us.
[57:51] SPEAKER_01: If you're interested about anything else that we've mentioned, you can check out the show notes in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org.
[57:58] SPEAKER_01: If you've enjoyed the show, do follow us on Twitter or Facebook at Polity Matters, and be sure that you're subscribed in your podcast app of choice.
[58:04] SPEAKER_01: If you have questions or comments, you know that you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[58:09] SPEAKER_01: And there's also a link below to support our work if you'd care to do so.
[58:13] SPEAKER_01: Thanks again for spending time with us.
[58:14] SPEAKER_01: Uh until next time, Fred say goodbye.
[58:17] SPEAKER_01: Goodbye.
[58:18] SPEAKER_01: Thanks.
[58:18] SPEAKER_01: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
