# 96. Nothing of Substance (RPR w/Thomas Rickard)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 12 Aug 2025, 58 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/17654896-96-nothing-of-substance-rpr-w-thomas-rickard.mp3

Scott and Jared are joined by Thomas Rickard to have (another) discussion about Review of Presbytery Records. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Transcript

[0:05] SPEAKER_03: You can you can say what you want.
[0:07] SPEAKER_03: This episode hasn't started yet.
[0:09] SPEAKER_03: No, this will be the episode, I guarantee you.
[0:14] SPEAKER_01: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:17] SPEAKER_01: Uh my name is uh Scott Edberg.
[0:19] SPEAKER_01: I am joined here with my co-host Jared Nelson.
[0:22] SPEAKER_01: Ben Ratliff is not with us uh this uh morning or afternoon.
[0:27] SPEAKER_01: I don't know where he is, but he has tasked this Polity Matters episode to me.
[0:32] SPEAKER_01: And so, you know, it's it is what it is.
[0:34] SPEAKER_01: Uh, we do have one additional guest with us, though.
[0:37] SPEAKER_01: Thomas Ricard uh is with us, and I'm going to let you introduce yourself and perhaps uh introduce our topic after you're done with that.
[0:46] SPEAKER_01: Can you do that, Thomas?
[0:48] SPEAKER_00: Sure.
[0:48] SPEAKER_00: Just uh throw me into the host seat just because you don't want to do it, I guess.
[0:51] SPEAKER_00: But uh yeah, I'm Thomas.
[0:53] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I'm Thomas uh Ricard.
[0:56] SPEAKER_00: I uh am husband of one wife, uh Sarah, and we have uh four beautiful children, Stella, Calvin, Nora, and Elizabeth.
[1:04] SPEAKER_00: And I serve as pastor of Seven Springs Presbyterian Church, an old rural uh PCUS church that came into the PCA in the 19 uh seventies.
[1:14] SPEAKER_00: And so that's where I currently serve, but also outside of my uh pastoral duties as a churchman, I serve as clerk of Westminster Presbytery, and then I also serve as the secretary of everyone's favorite committee of the General Assembly, uh Review of Presbytery Records.
[1:32] SPEAKER_00: And uh we're known uh for many things upsetting people, uh, but uh majority for taking up a large part of time at General Assembly, but also our super long report, uh normally about 200 pages, and so I serve there of RPR, and so that's what we'll be talking about today, and uh see how many people are committed to real Presbyterian polity.
[1:56] SPEAKER_01: And uh uh can you perhaps uh what is the scope of the work of the review of Presbytery Records?
[2:03] SPEAKER_01: Could we maybe start there?
[2:05] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so RPR is uh really found in BCO chapter 40, and I think you've had another uh podcast uh dealing with that.
[2:15] SPEAKER_00: Um but uh BCO 40 really deals with review and control.
[2:19] SPEAKER_00: So a part of Presbyterian polity is not merely that you're ruled by elders, but there's also checks and balances, and checks and balances come in the form of appeals and complaints going up to higher courts, but also through review, that uh minutes of presbytery, minutes of session are sent to the next higher court where they're reviewed.
[2:38] SPEAKER_00: And so there's a sense of accountability, not just with what uh complaints and appeals that are sent up, but also by other elders reviewing minutes to be able to check that they're in conformity with scripture and also our BCO.
[2:53] SPEAKER_00: So uh RPR, the Committee of Review of Presbytery Records, is the Committee of General Assembly, and they review all the Presbytery's minutes of 87 Presbyteries.
[3:05] SPEAKER_00: And so this year we reviewed over 400 sets of minutes that are sent in to General Assembly, and then we uh meet together.
[3:14] SPEAKER_00: Uh they're prepared by read teams, and then we meet together and go through and prepare that report where we deal with um exceptions of uh form and substance with the minutes.
[3:25] SPEAKER_00: Um that's kind of what we carry out in that review and control, and we're looking for those requirements that are set in BCO chapter 40, which is whether the proceedings have been recorded correctly, whether they've been in accordance with the Constitution, even if they're wise, equitable, and suited for the to promote the welfare of the church, and any lawful injunctions are uh followed by the higher courts.
[3:52] SPEAKER_00: So we review all of those minutes for that.
[3:54] SPEAKER_00: We prepare a report, and what goes to General Assembly is a report dealing mainly with the minutes that are approved, the minutes that are approved with exceptions of form, and the minutes that are approved with exceptions of substance.
[4:07] SPEAKER_00: And so the difference between form and substance varies.
[4:10] SPEAKER_00: Uh we're given a list in RO 16.6 and chapter 16 deals with review of Presbytery Records, and 16.6 explains uh what an exception of substance is, that it's an apparent violation of either Constitution or Scripture and other things that are uh dealt with by the General Assembly.
[4:32] SPEAKER_00: Exceptions of form uh generally deal with violations of how we're to keep uh minutes, um, and so they vary depending on the committee.
[4:43] SPEAKER_00: Um but you know, one might be that uh it's constitutionally required that a meeting is opened and closed in prayer, and so that might not be recorded.
[4:53] SPEAKER_00: And so that would be an exception of form.
[4:55] SPEAKER_00: Uh that the meeting meeting was not opened and closed in prayer.
[4:59] SPEAKER_00: Uh but there's more significant things that we need to be able to deal with in their exceptions of substance, and they're sent uh to the Presbytery by General Assembly, who then um uh uh cite them and there to the Presbyteries to give uh a response to that uh exception of substance.
[5:21] SPEAKER_00: So uh they they can come in multiple forms, but uh one common one is um exceptions of substance dealing with the list of examinations and uh for any type of uh candidates for ministry, licensure, ordination transfers.
[5:39] SPEAKER_00: We're required to be able to do certain things in our BCO, examine them in certain areas, ask about their stated differences, rule on those stated differences.
[5:47] SPEAKER_00: And if a presbytery doesn't record those in their minutes, then they need to be able to say uh why they didn't.
[5:54] SPEAKER_00: Uh often it's just they didn't record it.
[5:56] SPEAKER_00: They did it, they just didn't record it.
[5:58] SPEAKER_01: Um but yeah, so the the timeline for RPR's work it basically starts, what is it, March every year, where um uh the presbyteries have to give and submit their minutes from the prior year, and then for the next couple of months or so, you have read teams reading through those minutes and making recommendations to the whole committee, and then those after adopted by the committee go before the whole assembly, and the assembly usually has a nice go of it by trying to amend the year work on the floor without any context.
[6:34] SPEAKER_01: Uh, and then whatever's approved or is still standing gets sent back to the presbyteries for further review, uh, particularly the issues of substance to give response when they submit their minutes again for the next year.
[6:47] SPEAKER_03: Um I now I just want to note that um since I can try to have a contribution of substance, um there is a contribution of substance.
[6:55] SPEAKER_03: There is a possibility that the presbytery has no issues, such as maybe like the Presbytery of the Ascension last year, um, and have nothing to correct.
[7:03] SPEAKER_03: Is that is that correct?
[7:06] SPEAKER_00: Yes.
[7:07] SPEAKER_00: Yes.
[7:07] SPEAKER_00: So it is a bit clearer on that.
[7:10] SPEAKER_00: It's a hard timeline to follow because you know, we kind of deal our presbytery meets three times a year, others meet four or five, maybe uh, you know, just generally about the the time, some only meet twice.
[7:23] SPEAKER_00: Um but you can meet in January, February of 2025.
[7:27] SPEAKER_00: Those minutes are then compiled and sent through the AC uh the following year, 2026 and March 15th.
[7:34] SPEAKER_00: That's the deadline that they should be the AC office.
[7:37] SPEAKER_00: Then from March 15th until we meet uh at the end of May, uh they're sent to read teams.
[7:44] SPEAKER_00: So three members of Review of Presbytery Records look over that and they prepare a draft report, kind of like a mini RPR report.
[7:51] SPEAKER_00: And then so they do that and then we meet together over a period of two and a half days.
[7:57] SPEAKER_00: Our meeting is, you know, we spend about 25 hours in the meeting discussing the whole report, going through it line by line basically, and then preparing that for the General Assembly.
[8:07] SPEAKER_00: It then goes to General Assembly in June.
[8:10] SPEAKER_00: Uh so the minutes of this year will go in June 2026.
[8:13] SPEAKER_00: They're cited for exceptions of substance.
[8:15] SPEAKER_00: They're sent to Presbyteries to respond through the AC, and ACs there to respond.
[8:22] SPEAKER_00: And so your minutes from 2025, if you have an exception of substance, might not be dealt with until the General Assembly of 2027.
[8:30] SPEAKER_00: But you can also have another cycle where uh a response is unsatisfactory and it gets sent back and forth.
[8:37] SPEAKER_00: So the the hard thing is that we're we're dealing with multiple levels of this timeline, and so it really can be a lengthy process keeping up with all of those exceptions.
[8:49] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, uh we're still dealing with an Ileana an issue from 2023.
[8:54] SPEAKER_01: Uh and I I'm kicking myself uh because I used the word received instead of approved.
[9:02] SPEAKER_01: And if I would have just used the word approved, it would have probably no one would have batted an eye and it would have been satisfactory.
[9:08] SPEAKER_01: But you need to do more than receive, RPR says.
[9:12] SPEAKER_01: And so maybe this year, maybe this year we'll get that issue resolved.
[9:16] SPEAKER_01: Who knows?
[9:19] SPEAKER_01: Um, when when thinking about did you have something, Thomas?
[9:23] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I just think moving forward, you know, dealing with what we're doing now is kind of after GA.
[9:28] SPEAKER_00: So GA has approved it.
[9:30] SPEAKER_00: People people say, well, RPR cited us for this.
[9:32] SPEAKER_00: Well, RPR didn't cite you for that.
[9:34] SPEAKER_00: GA did.
[9:35] SPEAKER_00: Uh it's a committee of review of presbyterian records, not a commission.
[9:39] SPEAKER_00: And so the the General Assembly cited a Presbytery for an exception of substance.
[9:46] SPEAKER_00: And what's helpful to be able to understand about that is it's an apparent violation.
[9:50] SPEAKER_00: What we see here, even in RPR's process, are clear principles of Presbyterian polity in that you're innocent until proven guilty.
[10:01] SPEAKER_00: And so uh Presbytery is innocent and they're cited, there's an apparent violation.
[10:06] SPEAKER_00: We see something, and so uh it's not a judicial action where you have failed um in your minutes, in a sense, the General Assembly is saying that you're guilty of that.
[10:18] SPEAKER_00: It's an apparent violation.
[10:19] SPEAKER_00: So now we begin the process, you might say, of kind of Matthew 18, where uh General Assembly goes to Presbytery and says, we see this apparent violation.
[10:31] SPEAKER_00: And Presbytery gets a chance to respond.
[10:33] SPEAKER_00: They can say, Yes, we we didn't do that, we're guilty of that.
[10:37] SPEAKER_00: Um or Presbytery has the chance to be able to uh respond and say, no, we disagree.
[10:44] SPEAKER_00: And so that can create a bit of back and forth.
[10:46] SPEAKER_00: But it's helpful for us to be able to understand that as RPR uh uh General Assembly kind of gives these exceptions of substance, that it's not judicial in the in the sense it's only through the SJC that anything judicial can happen.
[11:01] SPEAKER_00: So RPR can go back and forth, and generally we've got a limit of about three years.
[11:05] SPEAKER_00: After three years, then we can send it to SJC.
[11:09] SPEAKER_00: Sometimes it's a little bit less if there's a credible report of an important delinquency or something that's grossly unconstitutional, uh then that can be submitted to the SJC directly uh per 40-5.
[11:21] SPEAKER_00: And so uh we need to be able to understand that.
[11:24] SPEAKER_00: And the other thing that's helpful is to be able to understand that uh what the committee repairs prepares and the um general assembly approves, there's no precedent.
[11:34] SPEAKER_00: So just because General Assembly cites a Presbytery one year doesn't mean that there's a precedent for that to happen in the future.
[11:41] SPEAKER_00: And so that can be a helpful thing for us to be able to understand as well.
[11:45] SPEAKER_00: That we we talk at uh expect exceptions of substance up where it's it's some form of egregious sin where it's merely just a that first step of that dialogue of you know, in your minutes when we reviewed them, we didn't see this.
[12:02] SPEAKER_00: Um and Presbytery gets a chance to respond.
[12:05] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it's this year, it's kind of interesting, like the RPR debate.
[12:10] SPEAKER_01: I I don't I'm not an RPR, but it kind of seems every General Assembly that uh RPR debates something, and then the people that were dissatisfied or lost in RPR then go to the floor of the assembly and try try again, kind of thing.
[12:26] SPEAKER_01: Where it's like some of the same debates I'm guessing that you have in the committee then bear themselves out on the floor um of the assembly.
[12:33] SPEAKER_01: Like Ileana was pulled out of the omnibus this year, and I was thinking to myself, please don't pull us out.
[12:38] SPEAKER_01: Like we'll we'll take our licks, we'll we'll do this through normal process.
[12:42] SPEAKER_01: Like, please don't embarrass us.
[12:44] SPEAKER_01: We will we'll do we'll do we'll do what we're supposed to do.
[12:48] SPEAKER_01: Um, but sometimes it's like, well, we need to skip the dialogue and just undo what RPR did rather than even having a conversation.
[12:57] SPEAKER_01: And it seems to be that like the assembly has different guts on different years.
[13:02] SPEAKER_01: Like two years ago, you you might recall that we had an images issue where the report got amended like five or six different places on exceptions of substance related to images of Christ, and then this year on Pedo Communion, it was slapped down like five times where it's like, no, we're gonna uphold the committee.
[13:21] SPEAKER_01: And so it's just interesting seeing how all of that works on the Presbytery or on the GA floor.
[13:28] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and I mean that's that's anytime you put the same vote up to the same group of people, you might get a different outcome.
[13:34] SPEAKER_00: You you put it up with a different group of people, you might get a different outcome.
[13:37] SPEAKER_00: And so RPR is um always inconsistent because it depends on who serves on the committee.
[13:43] SPEAKER_00: And then General Assembly is always inconsistent as well.
[13:46] SPEAKER_00: Um as they approve the report or things get pro approved or disapproved, and so that's where no precedent w we should be careful to be able to say, well, when the RPR report came up, uh this year we didn't do it, but this year we did, because you know, it's kind of like church history.
[14:03] SPEAKER_00: You can go through church history and find any example you want from any era from any person of how things have been practiced.
[14:12] SPEAKER_00: Um and you can find the plethora.
[14:14] SPEAKER_00: You know, that's the Baptist argument, that's the Presbyterian argument in the early church.
[14:17] SPEAKER_00: How did they do it?
[14:18] SPEAKER_00: Well, I've got that argument.
[14:20] SPEAKER_00: I've got these uh citations and these proofs, and so uh, you know, we're inconsistent.
[14:26] SPEAKER_00: Um and so yeah, we're we're I think we acknowledge that as RPR.
[14:30] SPEAKER_00: And even in our report, if you were to go through our report in detail, you'd probably notice sometimes we cite something as an exception of substance and sometimes an exception of form.
[14:39] SPEAKER_00: Now, sometimes that's very deliberate that the minutes aren't the same, but other times it's not deliberate at all.
[14:45] SPEAKER_00: It's just that we're human and we we err uh when we prepare it.
[14:50] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[14:51] SPEAKER_01: In in thinking through, uh so let's get to as I I believe all the stated clerks in the PCA have received their schlacking from the assembly, and so now clerks probably are preparing responses um to issues of substance with issues of form from the assembly.
[15:09] SPEAKER_01: It's just a note that the clerk will do better next time personally.
[15:13] SPEAKER_01: Um, but how what are some of the ways that a presbytery should consider in how to respond to RPR?
[15:22] SPEAKER_00: Well yeah, so just a comment on form.
[15:25] SPEAKER_00: I encourage clerks and and clerks should send that to their whole presbytery.
[15:30] SPEAKER_00: I think that uh we as clerks, they're not our minutes, we're merely the recorders of them, but presbytery approves them.
[15:37] SPEAKER_00: So uh encourage them to send them to the whole presbytery.
[15:40] SPEAKER_00: But exceptions of form, it doesn't mean that you don't need to do anything with them.
[15:45] SPEAKER_00: General Assembly doesn't need to hear any response from it.
[15:48] SPEAKER_00: Um I think that Review of Presbytery Records would probably feel better if uh exceptions of form they knew something was happening with them rather than them just getting sent to their a folder somewhere in the clerks that you go through and review what you didn't do and maybe amend your minutes if you failed to record something or correct your record.
[16:09] SPEAKER_00: But yeah, exceptions of form require a response.
[16:12] SPEAKER_00: And so uh as many people would say, there's an app for that, there's a section for that in our REO, REO chapter 16.
[16:21] SPEAKER_00: Um we it tells you that you should approve your minute, uh approve your responses within that same calendar year.
[16:29] SPEAKER_00: So when we're talking about uh 2025 minute in February, you get a citation uh in 2026, it's helpful for Presbytery to deal with that exception of substance in the 2026 year.
[16:43] SPEAKER_00: Uh that's just good for record keeping and helpful uh for that movement.
[16:48] SPEAKER_00: Often I think that we postpone it and push it to, oh, it needs to be due by due by March, so let's do it early on uh later.
[16:56] SPEAKER_00: And uh, but if we can approve that response early, um but they submit that response, it needs to be in by March 15th.
[17:04] SPEAKER_00: Uh it's the same every single year, and every single year people come up and say, Oh, we haven't, we didn't know the date, or you know, sometimes they're new clerks, but March 15th is the date every single year.
[17:17] SPEAKER_00: Your minutes need to be in, um, and same with your responses.
[17:21] SPEAKER_00: We actually changed our standing rules in our presbytery because we meet the second Saturday in March.
[17:26] SPEAKER_00: So, and we approve our November stated meeting at that March meeting.
[17:31] SPEAKER_00: And so for the clerk to be able to have the minutes approved, prepared, and sent off to General Assembly, it was often, you know, it could be 14th of March and they're due on the 15th.
[17:41] SPEAKER_00: So we changed our standing rules so a commission, a committee can form themselves as a commission to be able to approve minutes if necessary.
[17:48] SPEAKER_00: Um But when writing a response, um, maybe some helpful steps might be that you sit down and read and understand that response first.
[17:57] SPEAKER_00: Um what are the citations that they've given in those words?
[18:03] SPEAKER_00: Uh where in the BCO, what does the BCO actually require?
[18:08] SPEAKER_00: Um uh so uh one example is that we used to uh give a citation, exception of substance, that the congregation didn't concur with the dissolution of a relationship between a pastor.
[18:21] SPEAKER_00: And that was kind of the verbiage we used.
[18:23] SPEAKER_00: Um but it's it was poorly worded by RPR as we sent them out.
[18:29] SPEAKER_00: Um but we've changed that since that time.
[18:32] SPEAKER_00: But it's not that a presbyterian uh congregation needs to concur with the dissolution.
[18:37] SPEAKER_00: What needs to happen at that state of meaning is the congregation needs to be able to have their voice heard by the presbytery.
[18:44] SPEAKER_00: That there's three parties that are called to be able to call a pastor, the congregation, the pastor, and the presbytery to approve.
[18:51] SPEAKER_00: And so when you're dissolving that relationship, those three parties should have a say as well.
[18:56] SPEAKER_00: Uh the pastor and the congregation, and then the presbytery uh approving that dissolution.
[19:01] SPEAKER_00: And so that's what we're looking for in that situation.
[19:04] SPEAKER_00: So understanding what that exception of substance is and trying to fathom, looking back at your minutes, was it what's not there?
[19:15] SPEAKER_00: Um we we get we have a chance.
[19:19] SPEAKER_00: I think we we as particularly as clerks get very defensive when someone points something out in our minutes.
[19:24] SPEAKER_00: It's uh you want to offend a clerk, you go tell them they've got poor minutes, and you know they will probably weep.
[19:30] SPEAKER_00: Um but we take it very personally.
[19:33] SPEAKER_00: But I tell my uh Presbytery all the time uh several things.
[19:37] SPEAKER_00: I'm not a bishop, uh I'm a secretary, I'm I'm your clerk.
[19:41] SPEAKER_00: And the second thing I tell them all the time is that these are your minutes.
[19:46] SPEAKER_00: I just record and keep them.
[19:48] SPEAKER_00: Um so you are approving these minutes.
[19:51] SPEAKER_00: If there's an issue with these minutes, it's your issue.
[19:53] SPEAKER_00: Um I will do all I can to make them.
[19:56] SPEAKER_00: And so I'm very grateful we have about six men in our presbytery.
[20:00] SPEAKER_00: Once I send out our minutes, they will send me a long list of corrections.
[20:04] SPEAKER_00: And I I delight in that.
[20:06] SPEAKER_00: Um and so uh when we get these exceptions of substance, uh, clerk, uh, you know, don't take it personally.
[20:14] SPEAKER_00: Um and also presbyters, other elders in your presbytery, don't just say, well, the clerk made a mistake.
[20:20] SPEAKER_00: Like it's it's everyone's duty to read the minutes, to approve the minutes.
[20:24] SPEAKER_00: And so I think that can be helpful.
[20:26] SPEAKER_00: And so when you get an exception of substance to be able to look and say what is this exception of substance is, because if you start on the wrong footing and you write a response to the wrong exception, it's not going to be satisfactory.
[20:38] SPEAKER_01: Um where can you get perhaps advice on that?
[20:42] SPEAKER_01: Uh, because typically the report that the Presbytery receives is basically just a one-sentence kind of thing.
[20:49] SPEAKER_01: You don't get like a rationale typically.
[20:51] SPEAKER_01: It's uh it says one sentence with a citation, and on these this day of minutes, and you don't know the exact line or the exact location, you kind of have to do some sleuthing.
[21:04] SPEAKER_01: Uh, what are some aids in helping you with that?
[21:07] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so right at the very start, you you find the location of the date of the minutes, and we try and write clerks' notes to clerks, uh, which is in the clerk's report.
[21:16] SPEAKER_00: So that's where all the exceptions are formed, and we try and be helpful in there trying to point out where the location is.
[21:22] SPEAKER_00: So the date of the minutes, the page is normally a reference.
[21:26] SPEAKER_00: Not everyone uses the same numbering system.
[21:28] SPEAKER_00: Um but the the best thing to do is read the BCO reference.
[21:32] SPEAKER_00: What does the BCO then require you to do?
[21:34] SPEAKER_00: Um and so once you read that BCO reference, then look at your minutes and say, if I was an outsider, I wasn't at the meeting, I wasn't there at all, I have no idea of the context, I don't know what the common practice is of your presbytery, uh, does the minutes show that we did what we're supposed to do?
[21:52] SPEAKER_00: Um and if the answer is yes, then maybe then read the response and and kind of, you know, maybe they made a mistake.
[21:58] SPEAKER_00: Again, we we sometimes Find it that we'll cite an exception of substance.
[22:06] SPEAKER_00: Say, for example, we have a uh you know you have a candidate coming forward, uh licensure and then ordination, and that's separated by a calendar year ending.
[22:17] SPEAKER_00: So you have a licensure exam in uh 2025 in November, and then you have an ordination exam in 2026 in uh March, your meeting, uh, we don't get your previous minutes.
[22:31] SPEAKER_00: We're only looking at 2026 when we're reviewing those minutes.
[22:35] SPEAKER_00: And so you might just our presbytery has the same examination for licensure as it does for ordination.
[22:42] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so we just uh just add the additional examinations.
[22:47] SPEAKER_00: We've already asked them their state of difference, we ask them if they've changed their opinion, uh, but we've already done that in a November meeting.
[22:54] SPEAKER_00: But if you're just coming to your uh March meeting, uh we don't get to see that information when we're reviewing just one year.
[23:02] SPEAKER_00: Um so it might be that that information is recorded, but it's not recorded in that specific location.
[23:08] SPEAKER_00: Um another example is licensure, you need to hear the person preach.
[23:12] SPEAKER_00: Um well that happens, and you have them preach in the in the morning of your uh exam, but the exam is not until after lunch.
[23:22] SPEAKER_00: And so uh did Presbytery approve that sermon?
[23:26] SPEAKER_00: You know, it needs to be recorded in the minutes, but there there might be some things, but yeah, and then I think just familiarity, if you do find something that you're unsure about, um you can reach out to anyone on RPR, and most of them they're common exceptions.
[23:40] SPEAKER_00: Most of them, about you know, I would say 95% of them are very regular, ordinary exceptions.
[23:47] SPEAKER_00: Um so if you give a citation, most RPR guys would be able to say, um, this is what we normally mean.
[23:54] SPEAKER_00: Is that what's in your minutes?
[23:55] SPEAKER_00: But doing that little bit of research, because if you start again that year cycle, if you start with your response and don't understand it, and it might be that it's unclear, we're trying to get better at making it very clear of what we're uh stating.
[24:10] SPEAKER_00: Uh but if it's um if if you don't understand it, you're gonna answer the wrong question.
[24:18] SPEAKER_00: Um and so, you know, that that you know, reading comprehension and trying to fathom what that exception actually is can be quite helpful in preparing your response.
[24:30] SPEAKER_01: And so how how can you respond?
[24:32] SPEAKER_01: What what are some ways you can respond to RPR?
[24:35] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so um the once you've understood what that response is, the second step is to go and read RAO 16-10 uh section B.
[24:46] SPEAKER_00: And in there it spells out how a presbytery is to be able to respond to General Assembly and their exceptions.
[24:54] SPEAKER_00: Um and so really there's two options.
[24:58] SPEAKER_00: You can either agree with the exception or disagree.
[25:01] SPEAKER_00: This is kind of the guilty innocent.
[25:04] SPEAKER_00: Are you pleading your innocence or are you pleading you're agreeing with with um the citation given?
[25:09] SPEAKER_00: So if you agree, um again, sit down and read the response, understand it, and then choose which path you're on.
[25:17] SPEAKER_00: Uh sometimes we talk talk about it with our kids all the time.
[25:21] SPEAKER_00: Um they'll say, I'm sorry, but you know, they did something else.
[25:26] SPEAKER_00: And so sometimes you'll hear, we agree, but and then they're actually disagreeing.
[25:31] SPEAKER_00: So choose which lane you're gonna go in and agree and disagree with the citation, the exception of substance.
[25:36] SPEAKER_00: And so when you agree, there's three major portions to it.
[25:40] SPEAKER_00: The first one is you agree with the exception.
[25:42] SPEAKER_00: The second one is you correct your record or the action if possible.
[25:47] SPEAKER_00: We'll come back to that.
[25:48] SPEAKER_00: And the third one is that you promise uh to be more careful in the future.
[25:52] SPEAKER_00: And so this is kind of um, again, a famous uh Rickard catechism question that gets quoted all the time.
[25:58] SPEAKER_00: What must you do with your sin?
[26:00] SPEAKER_00: You must be sorry for your sin, but you also must hate and forsake it.
[26:04] SPEAKER_00: Um and so that's what we must do as well.
[26:06] SPEAKER_00: It's not merely just saying sorry, you're not gonna do it, but you're not gonna do it again.
[26:10] SPEAKER_00: But the key the RPR and General Assembly is looking for is that middle section to be able to correct your record if possible and correct your action if possible.
[26:21] SPEAKER_00: So if your citation says no record of six-month membership of a candidate coming under care, then you need to record that there was a six-month membership.
[26:32] SPEAKER_00: You need to record somewhere that you reviewed the session endorsement, not just saying, sorry, uh, we won't do it again.
[26:39] SPEAKER_00: There needs to be some form of record in your minutes of that that you've recorded what how they were.
[26:46] SPEAKER_00: Were they a member of a PCA for six months?
[26:48] SPEAKER_00: Maybe they weren't, and then you can use the extraordinary clause.
[26:51] SPEAKER_00: Um or if there's an action, if you did something that was unconstitutional, uh, and if it is possible, then you should try and amend and correct that action.
[27:01] SPEAKER_00: Um and so when we come back to unsatisfactory responses, about 53% of unsatisfactory responses is that first one that they don't correct their record.
[27:13] SPEAKER_00: So they don't uh tell us in their response and correct their minutes what they actually didn't do in the first place or they didn't record in the first place.
[27:24] SPEAKER_00: About 13% is they don't correct their action.
[27:27] SPEAKER_00: About 6% of those unsatisfactory responses is that they don't submit something that should have been submitted, like minutes of commission uh minutes or um you know uh other attachments that should be there.
[27:44] SPEAKER_00: And so that's how you agree with so those three steps.
[27:48] SPEAKER_00: You agree um that you have corrected your record, corrected your actions.
[27:52] SPEAKER_00: Uh Jacob Gerber has a great article on Presbyterian polity of how you're to correct your record.
[27:59] SPEAKER_00: Um you can do it the difficult way through Roberts' rules and uh adopt something, amend something previously adopted, and that's you're allowed to do that.
[28:08] SPEAKER_00: And if you give notice of those type of things, the majority vote decreases, but if you don't, then you've got to have a certain number.
[28:14] SPEAKER_00: It can be complicated, but it's not that difficult.
[28:17] SPEAKER_00: Um or you can uh follow Jacob's recommendation and kind of uh record it in your minutes later in your your meeting and then make a notation in your original minutes.
[28:29] SPEAKER_00: We dealt with this again, or we corrected this at this further meeting.
[28:33] SPEAKER_00: So when you're reading those minutes, um you go back and you can see that.
[28:37] SPEAKER_00: The second um way to be able to write a response is if you disagree.
[28:41] SPEAKER_00: And so uh RPR General Assembly can be wrong.
[28:46] SPEAKER_01: Before we get to the disagreeing, it I think it's helpful to note that when you're correcting something previously adopted, you're not changing the minutes from that prior meeting, but as you said with Jacob, you're just making a notation there and you're making you're recording the action in the present meeting, not changing the minutes of a prior meeting.
[29:07] SPEAKER_01: Is that that's right?
[29:09] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, correct.
[29:10] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[29:10] SPEAKER_00: So you can go through that process.
[29:12] SPEAKER_01: You don't have to fiddle with older minutes where you're like, okay, now I need to go find the Word document from five years ago and change it.
[29:19] SPEAKER_01: No, you don't need to do that.
[29:20] SPEAKER_01: You're you're making the correction in the meeting today.
[29:24] SPEAKER_01: You're recording it in that meeting, not a prior meeting.
[29:28] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[29:28] SPEAKER_00: And so when you do that, again, you got to be careful about going back and tampering with old minutes.
[29:34] SPEAKER_00: And with Word documents, it's very easy to do that.
[29:37] SPEAKER_00: So that's why it's really important to have something like a print set of minutes to be the official set of minutes.
[29:42] SPEAKER_00: And so a handwritten notation in the sidelines of that minutes is is uh more than uh enough to be able to say um, you know, uh go see this other meeting where we uh fix this correct, you know, fix this error, or we added aspects to it.
[30:00] SPEAKER_00: So yeah, it can be it can appear complicated, but I think we normally just uh make it a little bit more complicated than it needs to be.
[30:09] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and so if you disagree.
[30:13] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, when you disagree, um again, it's an apparent violation.
[30:17] SPEAKER_00: So you might have a different interpretation of the BCO, you might have a disagreement uh with how that uh with how it was worded, or it could be that you did actually record it.
[30:27] SPEAKER_00: Sometimes they're the responses.
[30:29] SPEAKER_00: If you look at minutes on page four, line 45, you know, it clearly says that we did record this.
[30:37] SPEAKER_00: Um and so uh, but uh it the again three steps.
[30:41] SPEAKER_00: The first step is that you respectfully disagree.
[30:44] SPEAKER_00: Uh, you know, uh I don't think we've ever ruled someone out of order or unsatisfactory because they didn't do it respectfully.
[30:52] SPEAKER_00: Uh but uh here you're dealing with General Assembly, so doing it with respect is is helpful.
[30:57] SPEAKER_00: So you you state where your position is, agree or disagree, and then you state your grounds.
[31:02] SPEAKER_00: Why is it that you in your minutes were valid?
[31:06] SPEAKER_00: Um we did record it, uh, we have a different interpretation, um, and then it's referred back to the General Assembly to be able to deal with.
[31:15] SPEAKER_00: Um so there's not that correction of record because there was no error, um, but it you get to be able to state your ground, you get to be able to make your case.
[31:23] SPEAKER_00: Um so make that clear again, that starting point of what the exception was.
[31:28] SPEAKER_00: Um and yeah, our hearts often will go, we disagree, you know.
[31:34] SPEAKER_00: I think that's just our our bent, you know, particularly as clerks.
[31:38] SPEAKER_00: If clerks are writing this, um, you know, we take things very personally.
[31:43] SPEAKER_00: And so we disagree that our minutes were uh well and respectable and everyone else is wrong.
[31:50] SPEAKER_00: But uh, you know, it it's everyone's right, and I encourage them to do that, um, to respect you know, respectfully disagree, and and we we frequently will have a response where Presbytery responds and the the next General Assembly says that's satisfactory.
[32:06] SPEAKER_00: They've made their case, they did it very clearly, articulated it well, um, you know, and uh it's always a delight to see Yeah.
[32:15] SPEAKER_01: I have a different approach as a clerk.
[32:17] SPEAKER_01: I just want RPR to leave me alone.
[32:20] SPEAKER_01: And so like I acquiesc.
[32:22] SPEAKER_01: I'm like, okay, I've screwed up.
[32:24] SPEAKER_01: I'll I'll I'll do whatever you want.
[32:26] SPEAKER_01: Please leave me alone.
[32:27] SPEAKER_01: Uh like uh the federalism, stay away from me.
[32:33] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[32:33] SPEAKER_01: So I mean that I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I won't do this again.
[32:37] SPEAKER_01: Please don't call back.
[32:40] SPEAKER_03: Is there any tips to like send chocolates or uh other items when you send your minutes into RPR to make them treat them bigly?
[32:47] SPEAKER_00: I don't know of any.
[32:48] SPEAKER_00: Um uh for a long time uh uh Paul Lee was on there and uh so he he would love uh everyone that knows Paul Lee knows his his love for is it Coke Zero and uh you know his piles of cans and I don't know where those are funded from, uh, you know, but uh it can hurt.
[33:09] SPEAKER_00: Hey, I mean, uh yeah, old reformed books, uh, you know, I don't know of any bribery that's been taking place.
[33:17] SPEAKER_00: Uh but I'll send you a direct one.
[33:19] SPEAKER_00: I'm sure there's there's ways to soften a reformed uh Presbyterian's heart.
[33:31] SPEAKER_01: What are the most common exceptions that you typically see?
[33:35] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so we used to give uh in our first preliminary report, no one reads the whole report, obviously, but we used to give um up to you know 20, 22 examples that we think that clerks should look at.
[33:49] SPEAKER_00: Uh last year we did 10, and this year we're just giving eight.
[33:53] SPEAKER_00: If clerks look at that first portion of that report, uh those common exceptions, those eight things, make up about 80% of our report, uh, 60% of our report.
[34:05] SPEAKER_00: Um so the simple way to be able to get RPR off your back is just record your minutes correctly.
[34:12] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's the that's the simple way.
[34:15] SPEAKER_00: And often they're not major disagreements.
[34:18] SPEAKER_00: Obviously, we see some where uh General Assembly takes an exception of substance of something that's of a significant matter.
[34:27] SPEAKER_00: Um but we often this year we had about 515 uh previous exceptions that needed a response, and uh only about just under under 100 were unsatisfactory, and often they were unsatisfactory, about 75% for those three categories.
[34:44] SPEAKER_00: That they weren't they didn't correct their record, they didn't correct their action, or they didn't submit minutes that needed to be submitted.
[34:50] SPEAKER_00: Um so 75 of those unsatisfactory.
[34:53] SPEAKER_00: So, you know, you're dealing with about 25 exceptions of of substance that are you know uh deal with something of significant value.
[35:02] SPEAKER_00: A lot of the other times it's just we didn't record it, we've corrected it, we've moved on.
[35:06] SPEAKER_00: And so those uh small things, it's hard to be able to get the exact numbers, but eight things uh that clerks should do.
[35:14] SPEAKER_00: They should go to the start of the RPR report, look at those eight things, print them out after finishing their minutes, go through eight of those things.
[35:22] SPEAKER_00: Do we do any of these eight things, and did we fulfill what we needed to do?
[35:27] SPEAKER_00: Elders do the same thing.
[35:28] SPEAKER_00: When the clerk sends out your minutes, um, look over them.
[35:32] SPEAKER_00: Do we would do we call someone as a pastor?
[35:35] SPEAKER_00: Um do we follow all the steps?
[35:37] SPEAKER_00: And and that's 60%, at least 60% of our report.
[35:40] SPEAKER_00: So the eight things are things dealing with call-related exceptions.
[35:44] SPEAKER_00: Um did the congregation approve?
[35:47] SPEAKER_00: Was the congregation um uh done?
[35:51] SPEAKER_00: Did was it a duly called congregational meeting?
[35:54] SPEAKER_00: Um that that's one of the things I think RPR really does really well is that sees their review, they're seeking to protect the rights of those who don't have a voice in those situations.
[36:07] SPEAKER_00: And so um a congregation, one of their most important rights is their right to be able to elect people to have authority over them.
[36:16] SPEAKER_00: Um and so we as RPR are looking to make sure that the congregation did have a congregational meeting.
[36:22] SPEAKER_00: It was duly called.
[36:24] SPEAKER_00: Did they approve uh that person as their pastor or an assistant pastor to the session, approve that?
[36:30] SPEAKER_00: That's what we're looking for.
[36:31] SPEAKER_00: Um dissolutions, again, the congregation is often the one that's overlooked.
[36:36] SPEAKER_00: Um they invited to the presbytery meeting to be able to say yes, we agree with this dissolution.
[36:42] SPEAKER_00: Or did they say no, we disagree?
[36:44] SPEAKER_00: Um again, presbytery needs to be able to make that decision, but call-related exceptions.
[36:49] SPEAKER_00: Um, one of the major ones is incomplete ordination or any type of examination.
[36:54] SPEAKER_00: Um, candidates under care, licensure, ordination transfers.
[36:58] SPEAKER_00: Um the the details are not recorded.
[37:02] SPEAKER_00: Um what it is is they record that they examine them in church history, but they didn't examine them per their record in PCA church history.
[37:13] SPEAKER_00: Um and so that's just a simple mistake, but just trying to uh correct those things.
[37:20] SPEAKER_00: One change that we've we've um started to do and we will be doing this year, is that uh we've changed our BCO to be able to uh underneath personal character um religious experience is someone do they have sins of notorious concern?
[37:38] SPEAKER_00: And so we want to see that in their minutes.
[37:41] SPEAKER_00: They examined underneath experiential religion.
[37:43] SPEAKER_00: Uh, did you examine them on those particular matters?
[37:47] SPEAKER_00: And so they're things, incomplete exam.
[37:49] SPEAKER_00: Missing minutes, um, review of presbytery records gets a review every single set of minutes.
[37:55] SPEAKER_00: Um that includes commission minutes, judicial commission minutes, executive session minutes.
[38:01] SPEAKER_00: Um you uh send out a commission to ordain and install someone, that report is a report, they're the minutes of presbytery, they need to be included in the minutes of presbytery, and so uh they all need to be sent into the in with the minutes as well.
[38:19] SPEAKER_00: Um annual reports, um so interns need to give a report every single stated meeting, um, and then everyone else, interns, candidates, out of down, out of bounds teaching elders need to give a report annually.
[38:33] SPEAKER_00: And so uh we look for those type of things.
[38:36] SPEAKER_00: Uh and that's an exception of substance.
[38:38] SPEAKER_00: And I think a lot of times we go, well, they're just been nitpicky.
[38:42] SPEAKER_00: Um, but things like session endorsements and yearly intern reports, they're very important for understanding uh the growth of a uh the and the the development of someone preparing for ordination.
[38:56] SPEAKER_00: Um you have a session endorse a man as a candidate, that's very important.
[39:02] SPEAKER_00: That's his character.
[39:03] SPEAKER_00: They're speaking to their character that they he shows the giftings and also he he seems called to the ministry.
[39:09] SPEAKER_00: And then as he performs his internship for at least a year, uh three, four meetings, he should be giving a report.
[39:17] SPEAKER_00: What's he doing?
[39:18] SPEAKER_00: Uh Presbytery oversees that internship, not uh a church or session, it's the Presbytery who's um dealing with that.
[39:26] SPEAKER_00: So uh annual reports, session records, um that uh you're not reviewing minutes of session records or you're not following up with those things.
[39:35] SPEAKER_00: Uh voting thresholds, if the BCO requires a two-thirds majority vote, a three-fourth majority vote, that needs to be recorded.
[39:42] SPEAKER_00: Um six months membership, ministerial obligation form, or not judging stated differences in the prescribed categories.
[39:51] SPEAKER_00: So every time we have a candidate come up, they state their differences.
[39:54] SPEAKER_00: Everyone knows they go, what what are the four categories we get again?
[39:58] SPEAKER_00: And I so I turn to Ario again and read out the four categories that he didn't state a difference, that it's merely semantic, it's more than semantic, but not out of accord of our fundamentals of our system or strikes of the vitals.
[40:09] SPEAKER_00: And so that once someone states a different presbytery must record in their minutes which one of those they are.
[40:15] SPEAKER_00: Um and so there, if if you were to go through those four things, uh those eight things, did we do any of those eight things in one Presbytery meeting?
[40:24] SPEAKER_00: Um that could reduce our report by 60, um, 120 pages, um, roughly, you know, um just just based on numbers.
[40:34] SPEAKER_00: Uh so those type of issues are the common ones that come across our our our desk, and often they're um pretty simple to fix.
[40:43] SPEAKER_00: If if you know often it's just a failure that when the clerk was copying and pasting something, he'd forgot to paste that portion.
[40:50] SPEAKER_00: Um, you know, very rarely does the Presbytery say no, we don't think they need to be examined in church history and PCA.
[40:58] SPEAKER_00: Uh very rare very commonly it's just yeah, we didn't record it.
[41:02] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I mean in Ileana we're smaller, and so we do like the same things at the same time almost every year.
[41:11] SPEAKER_01: And so almost having like templates for some of that, if it passed pretty well last year, then don't you know don't innovate where you don't need to.
[41:21] SPEAKER_01: You know, we we do we vote on BCO amendments every October, so why change how we do that?
[41:26] SPEAKER_01: Let's just copy paste and add the numbers that you need to add rather than um changing the system.
[41:33] SPEAKER_01: I I've created a few templates for exams as well to make sure that I don't forget PCA history.
[41:39] SPEAKER_01: Um I did I just have a random template that I copy and paste that okay, we make make sure we hit all of them so that we don't have to deal with any issues.
[41:49] SPEAKER_01: And so once you have templates for some of these, and especially after you fix some of them, you might have better templates that you don't have to do them again in the near future.
[42:00] SPEAKER_01: And so yeah.
[42:01] SPEAKER_00: And so the I like to um I have templates for examination, but I also uh one of the first things I started doing as clerk was I'd print out four copies of each checklist of every person that comes through, candidate for examining examining someone for candidates under care, and I'd I'd give one to the chairman who's running the exam, I'd give one to the moderator, and I'd have one, and then I have a spare one.
[42:26] SPEAKER_00: Um and that is very helpful because it's not merely that you're recording it, you want to be doing it.
[42:32] SPEAKER_00: And so often the moderator, the chairman will be getting on a roll, they'll they'll get familiar and they they jump to something or they forget something, and the moderator will be able to say, Oh, we need to come back and do this.
[42:43] SPEAKER_00: You know, we didn't do Bible content or we didn't finish Bible content.
[42:47] SPEAKER_00: Um, and that's very helpful because then you've got three people in the meeting confirming that.
[42:53] SPEAKER_00: And then at the end, I can go back and confirm we did everything when we record our minutes and make sure that our minutes reflect what we actually did.
[43:01] SPEAKER_00: Um but yeah, those those checklists, uh the clerk download page, there's a list of checklists, and you can just print them out.
[43:09] SPEAKER_00: Um they they follow the BCO, it's very, very helpful.
[43:13] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so clerks, if you can if you can do your work before your meeting, um it it saves you a lot of time.
[43:21] SPEAKER_00: And if you can kind of uh think about RPR while you're writing your minutes, then I think it'll it'll go a long way.
[43:31] SPEAKER_01: I'm always thinking about RPR.
[43:33] SPEAKER_01: That's the boogeyman.
[43:36] SPEAKER_01: The boogeyman under my bed.
[43:41] SPEAKER_01: Uh how about some brief comments on 40-5 issues?
[43:44] SPEAKER_01: So not all things are in the minutes, right?
[43:48] SPEAKER_01: And so what are can you perhaps give us some comments on uh how a presbytery handles that how RPR handles 40 5 issues?
[43:57] SPEAKER_01: And perhaps you can explain what a 40-5 issue is.
[44:00] SPEAKER_01: Is.
[44:00] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so going back to chapter 40, um, uh we often just deal about chapter 40, uh section one and two.
[44:08] SPEAKER_00: Um and then three and four are kind of not as well uh known, but um but 40-5 is the there's something that is not included in the minutes.
[44:19] SPEAKER_00: There's a there's a lack in the minutes, and so the higher court can go back and tell the court to be able to reconstruct um, you know, or correct or or whatever.
[44:29] SPEAKER_00: 40-5 is something that has been a little bit more frequent.
[44:33] SPEAKER_00: Um and so what 40-5 is is the criteria is pretty simple.
[44:38] SPEAKER_00: That there's a credible report of something of an important delinquency or something that is grossly unconstitutional.
[44:47] SPEAKER_00: Um and so that's what a 40-5 report is when we talk about it.
[44:52] SPEAKER_00: It's a credible report of something that is uh an important delinquency or something that's grossly unconstitutional.
[44:58] SPEAKER_00: And so uh a credible report doesn't mean that it's true.
[45:03] SPEAKER_00: What it means is it's believable.
[45:05] SPEAKER_00: And so uh that that is a pretty low bar.
[45:09] SPEAKER_00: Um was you know, is why would this person know this information?
[45:14] SPEAKER_00: Um, you know, that that bar is pretty low.
[45:16] SPEAKER_00: What the bar is that um 40-5 requires is that it's an important delinquency or something that's grossly unconstitutional.
[45:25] SPEAKER_00: Now there are uh descriptive words important and grossly that have no definition in our BCO.
[45:32] SPEAKER_00: And so trying to understand that.
[45:34] SPEAKER_00: So we've received quite a few 40-5s um through RPR, and the practice is that it goes to RPR first and then to the SJC to be able to, the the latter part of 40-5 is the the judicial part steps in.
[45:50] SPEAKER_00: And so what the practice has been is is it's gone to RPR.
[45:54] SPEAKER_00: And so uh some of those have gone to the SJC that they were grossly unconstitutional uh practices, and ultimately it's up to the SJC to be able to decide if it was or not.
[46:07] SPEAKER_00: Um but uh so 40-5's come.
[46:10] SPEAKER_00: The practice again, RPR changes and there's no written rules.
[46:15] SPEAKER_00: What we've got is the BCO chapter 40.
[46:17] SPEAKER_00: Generally, the practice is is there a mechanism through review and complaint, review complaint, or appeal that could handle this matter?
[46:26] SPEAKER_00: And so 40-5 is a is a catch-all, and a good example of that is um a congregation, something happens to a congregation, a presbytery acts and uh something, and and a member of a congregation doesn't have a right to appeal or complain against that action unless it's taken against them.
[46:48] SPEAKER_00: And so complaint, um, you need to be a member of that court.
[46:52] SPEAKER_00: And so uh 40-5 uh isn't an important uh uh grossly unconstitutional, and so that that then gets sent to uh RPR to review.
[47:06] SPEAKER_00: Uh we've we've a lot of our 40-5s, they don't rise to that that standard that's set in 40-5.
[47:13] SPEAKER_00: They're they're handled through review, uh, through an exception of substance, they're handled through um appeals or complaints.
[47:21] SPEAKER_00: And so we've seen a lot more of those.
[47:24] SPEAKER_00: I think it's um in in our in the recent years, but it's not a way to circumvent or go around uh the ordinary process.
[47:34] SPEAKER_00: Um so encourage people to, if you're unsure, you know what what's the direct path that we can do?
[47:41] SPEAKER_00: Can I complain against an action?
[47:42] SPEAKER_00: Can I appeal against this action?
[47:45] SPEAKER_00: Um that that's ordinarily, or is it through that review process that's ordinary that that comes through it?
[47:56] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it seems like the 40-5, how we're reading it now, that seems like a pretty recent innovation.
[48:04] SPEAKER_01: Would you say so?
[48:05] SPEAKER_01: It like within the last three or four years.
[48:08] SPEAKER_01: Um it seems that it it came with the Metro New York issue, but am I wrong on that?
[48:16] SPEAKER_00: I think it's been a it definitely been around before that.
[48:19] SPEAKER_00: I think it's just been more common.
[48:20] SPEAKER_00: More people know about it now, and more people uh move to that process.
[48:26] SPEAKER_00: And I think that that is um maybe we've just clarified that.
[48:31] SPEAKER_00: Um now people go, oh, I'll just send a 40-5.
[48:34] SPEAKER_00: Um and so we you know, RPR every year, if they get a 40-5 RPR, the comment current practice is RPR reviews it, and we review it with what we've got with the critical report with the minutes.
[48:49] SPEAKER_00: Um and so uh yeah, I I believe it's something that has become it's always been there, and the PCA has seen 40-5s before, but it's like more people know about it now.
[49:01] SPEAKER_01: Um but encourage people to the result of uh just the issues we have with like 31.2 and trying to uh assume original jurisdiction.
[49:13] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I'm not sure that I could like speak to why people choose this route compared to others.
[49:19] SPEAKER_00: I think my assumption is that um there are few people in in the PCA that really understand the intricate process of the BCO.
[49:34] SPEAKER_00: Um I think you know it can be complicated, but quite simple, it's it's somewhat simple with principles.
[49:41] SPEAKER_00: Um and so uh I I don't know exactly.
[49:46] SPEAKER_00: I think more people know about it.
[49:48] SPEAKER_00: I think um uh it it's you know it's been spoken about now.
[49:53] SPEAKER_00: I I don't know if you went to a regular teaching elder in you know 25 years ago, 10 years ago, and you said BCO 40-5, you know, what they know what you're talking about.
[50:05] SPEAKER_00: Now we even just refer to it as a 40-5.
[50:08] SPEAKER_00: We don't even need to know the context of where it's located.
[50:10] SPEAKER_00: We know it's got its own terminology.
[50:13] SPEAKER_01: Um and so that's not you you're trying to change the nomenclature, aren't you?
[50:18] SPEAKER_01: You're gonna ruin all of this.
[50:20] SPEAKER_01: What am I doing?
[50:21] SPEAKER_00: I I'm probably ruining something, I'm sure.
[50:23] SPEAKER_01: Don't you have an overture that you want to put up that re like reorders the paragraphs like by different standards?
[50:32] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[50:33] SPEAKER_00: So isn't that you?
[50:34] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, it's like OCD.
[50:36] SPEAKER_00: When you when you look at uh BCO 40 uh 214, and then you go to chapter 14, and they're they're they're probably the longest, you know, subsections, and they're numbered differently.
[50:49] SPEAKER_00: And so I would like just for human uniformity, something decently in an order.
[50:53] SPEAKER_00: Um this wouldn't change this at all, 40-5.
[50:56] SPEAKER_00: 40-5 would remain.
[50:58] SPEAKER_00: Um, all the sections would remain, it's just all the subsections, the A, B, D, D, the, you know, Roman Numore ones.
[51:04] SPEAKER_01: I want to make it really complicated.
[51:05] SPEAKER_01: I want it to be like uh I dots b dot five dot v six or something.
[51:13] SPEAKER_01: So ahead, yeah.
[51:14] SPEAKER_03: Greek and Hebrew letters instead.
[51:16] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[51:16] SPEAKER_01: And just or watching the LF.
[51:19] SPEAKER_01: LFU.
[51:20] SPEAKER_01: I'm gonna LFU.
[51:21] SPEAKER_01: Alify view.
[51:22] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[51:23] SPEAKER_00: Watch out for that gimmel.
[51:24] SPEAKER_00: It'll get you.
[51:25] SPEAKER_01: That gimbal.
[51:26] SPEAKER_00: Um yeah, don't be gimmicked.
[51:28] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, with the numbering and things like that, and then you try and carry on the uh the Westminsterian uh lack of numbers.
[51:35] SPEAKER_00: What is it?
[51:36] SPEAKER_00: Uh J?
[51:37] SPEAKER_00: Like J.
[51:37] SPEAKER_00: You know, they don't have a J and a V.
[51:39] SPEAKER_01: Um, so there is there anything else you could probably add for uh how we can navigate as Presbyteries uh some of these important issues.
[51:53] SPEAKER_00: No, I just think uh just just it above all it's presbytery responding to General Assembly.
[52:00] SPEAKER_00: Um it's not a clerk responding to RPR, it's a Presbytery responding to General Assembly.
[52:06] SPEAKER_00: And so uh RPR is trying to do a better job of um being more efficient.
[52:13] SPEAKER_00: Uh we've moved to a more automated process in the last couple of years, um, and that has helped us ensure that our report is more accurate, we can uh follow up with exceptions better, things don't fall through the cracks, or you know, just human errors when we're inputting data, um, we can catch that and kind of see, did you actually mean the 17th instead of the 19th?
[52:34] SPEAKER_00: Um and so we're we're trying to do better at that.
[52:37] SPEAKER_00: And uh the AC office is is working very hard to be able to um you know try and make it easier for clerks to submit things, and uh they're doing a fantastic job.
[52:48] SPEAKER_00: We're uh Alyssa uh Chow is the RPR assistant, and I work very closely with her as the secretary, and she's doing a fabulous job.
[52:57] SPEAKER_00: She's she's had that role for a little over a year, uh little under a year.
[53:02] SPEAKER_00: And so last time was her first year, and and she did fantastic.
[53:06] SPEAKER_00: Um you just think about all those minutes get sent to one person, and then that one person needs to keep track of them all, and then send them out to other people, keep track of them and follow up with everything.
[53:17] SPEAKER_00: And she did a fabulous job.
[53:19] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so you know, RPR works hard, and uh we hope that uh we're seen as brothers, not enemies, uh, hopefully seen as um you know uh you know friends and uh doing the work uh that important work of review and control.
[53:39] SPEAKER_01: You're the IRS of the PCA, and you can't shake your reputation that easily.
[53:47] SPEAKER_00: Well, yeah, uh I I really I personally take offense to that.
[53:51] SPEAKER_01: That's uh until I'm on RPR, I'm I'm gonna be very adversarial in our relation.
[53:57] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[53:57] SPEAKER_00: I think that's a helpful thing, is as clerks, one of the best things I've done.
[54:03] SPEAKER_00: Um the clerks do a clerk's conference, the AC runs a clerk's conference every year.
[54:08] SPEAKER_00: Um that is very valuable to be able to interact with other clerks.
[54:12] SPEAKER_00: RPR has been the most valuable thing I've ever done as a clerk because it gives me an intricate detail of uh seeing what the minutes uh should be like.
[54:23] SPEAKER_00: My first time as RPR, they sent I got physical minutes and they mailed me a box with four sets of minutes.
[54:31] SPEAKER_00: And they gave me a form and they said, now produce a report.
[54:34] SPEAKER_00: I talked with other people on our team, it helped me a little bit.
[54:37] SPEAKER_00: I started reading through these minutes, and it took me a long time to read through the minutes and to prepare one report for one presbytery.
[54:46] SPEAKER_00: Um things weren't there, you know.
[54:48] SPEAKER_00: I could it took me a long time to find things, even trying to be gracious um and say, okay, it's here but not here, it's not recorded perfectly, but it's there, give them the benefit of the doubt.
[54:58] SPEAKER_00: Um then finally I came to one set of minutes, and I was like, oh, this is what Presbytery minutes need to look like.
[55:08] SPEAKER_00: Like these are exactly there, there was little to no exceptions in those sets of minutes at all.
[55:14] SPEAKER_00: Um and so clerks going to RPR can be a very valuable tool, you know, just to be able to understand uh what m people are looking for when they're reviewing those minutes.
[55:26] SPEAKER_00: Uh but uh yeah.
[55:30] SPEAKER_01: Well Jared, do you have anything to add?
[55:33] SPEAKER_03: Nothing of substance.
[55:35] SPEAKER_01: Nothing of substance.
[55:38] SPEAKER_03: If we can have like an AI program that just clones our clerk, Jay Nykirk, apparently.
[55:42] SPEAKER_03: He's cloning a top ten list.
[55:47] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, he uh he does a fabulous job, and every year it's like you know, we go through and Ascension says no exceptions.
[55:54] SPEAKER_00: And I it was a couple of years Ascension actually got an exception of substance.
[55:58] SPEAKER_00: And I'm guessing Jay wrote the response for that, uh, respectfully disagreeing, stated his grounds in three clear articulate points with you know two pages of uh response, and it was like no, yeah, RPR and General Assembly made a mistake.
[56:14] SPEAKER_00: Jay was right.
[56:15] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so you can't win against dissension, that's what I've just learned.
[56:19] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[56:20] SPEAKER_01: Even when you try.
[56:25] SPEAKER_01: So all right.
[56:27] SPEAKER_01: Well, it was it was a delight having you on, Thomas, and I know that this is helpful for me, and I hope it's helpful for guys as they go into the fall considering their own issues of substance.
[56:38] SPEAKER_01: Um, there's there's more that we can do uh and much better we can do, and I think this sort of content helps towards that.
[56:47] SPEAKER_01: Uh anything else you want to say to us, Thomas?
[56:50] SPEAKER_00: No, I just appreciate the chance to be able to ramble on for an hour.
[56:54] SPEAKER_00: Um, I don't get that liberty in my own house to be able to talk about these things without uh getting booed off the stage, so to say.
[57:01] SPEAKER_00: And so uh appreciate it.
[57:03] SPEAKER_01: We probably have this podcast.
[57:04] SPEAKER_01: None of our wives care about this stuff, and so we we're this is actually a support group.
[57:09] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, well, yeah, a good affinity group for uh polity.
[57:13] SPEAKER_00: So yeah.
[57:14] SPEAKER_01: Well, as our wives would say, this podcast is over.
[57:18] SPEAKER_01: You can find us in the show notes uh where we all are located and what we do.
[57:23] SPEAKER_01: Um, but until then, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[57:27] SPEAKER_03: Goodbye, gentlemen.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
