# 62. Good Faith Subscription with David Strain

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 26 Nov 2024, 1 h 05 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/16148864-62-good-faith-subscription-with-david-strain.mp3

Jared, Scott, and Ben are joined by David Strain to discuss good faith subscription in the PCA. David Strain Good Faith Subscription? (Part 1) Confessional Integrity in the PCA Good Faith Subscription? (Part 2) Confessional Integrity in the PCA Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Transcript

[0:08] SPEAKER_02: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:11] SPEAKER_02: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined as always by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg.
[0:16] SPEAKER_02: We are glad today to welcome David Strain to our show.
[0:21] SPEAKER_02: David, before I explain what you're doing here to everyone, why don't you introduce yourself first?
[0:26] SPEAKER_02: Um tell us about you, your family, your ministry experience, what your current work is, just so folks can get a sense of who you are and what you're up to.
[0:35] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, thanks.
[0:36] SPEAKER_03: Um great to be with you guys and uh glad for the opportunity to spend some time talking about things that matter like this.
[0:44] SPEAKER_03: Uh I am currently the senior minister at uh the First Presbyterian Church of Jackson, Mississippi.
[0:52] SPEAKER_03: And uh before that I served in Columbus, Mississippi, in a smaller congregation, Main Street Presbyterian Church.
[1:00] SPEAKER_03: And before that, I was the pastor of London City Presbyterian Church in the center of downtown London, England, which is a congregation of the Free Church of Scotland.
[1:11] SPEAKER_03: Um, the denomination in which I was ordained.
[1:14] SPEAKER_03: My wife is Sheena, and we have two grown boys, um, one in college, one uh working gainfully employed, um, but still to some extent on the payroll uh uh here in Jackson.
[1:30] SPEAKER_03: And um, yeah, we're very grateful for the Lord's mercy and have a wonderful, kind, very patient congregation who put up with an awful lot in me and are very supportive and prayerful.
[1:41] SPEAKER_03: So I'm thankful.
[1:44] SPEAKER_02: Well, the last couple of months we've been working through the BCO in matters related to the orders of the church, so that the the the whole matter concerning how the Lord calls men to ministry um to office in the church.
[1:57] SPEAKER_02: Most recently we concluded our discussion of BCO chapter 21 on ordination and installation.
[2:02] SPEAKER_02: And before that, uh listeners, you'll remember we we looked at BCO 19 on licensure and internship.
[2:07] SPEAKER_02: And in both licensing and ordaining a man, our book requires presbyteries to, and this is from BCO 19, to determine if the applicant is out of accord with any of the fundamentals of our doctrinal standards, and as a consequence, may not be able in good faith sincerely to receive and adopt the confession of faith and catechisms of this church as containing the system of doctrine taught in the Holy Scriptures.
[2:30] SPEAKER_02: And there's language in there in making this determination that instructs presbyteries to require the candidate to state specific instances in which he may differ with our doctrinal standards.
[2:41] SPEAKER_02: And then the court is instructed to grant, uh, well, the court is told they may grant an exception if the applicant um doesn't have a view that is an exception that is hostile to our system or or strikes at the vitals of religion.
[2:54] SPEAKER_02: And so you've probably heard in all of that language, especially from BCO 19 and 21, that this is all in an effort to have men receive and adopt our standards in good faith.
[3:06] SPEAKER_02: Um and that there's been debate over the years since this has come into our book as to the meaning and the intention of this idea.
[3:13] SPEAKER_02: And so, since since we've just dealt with these relevant chapters, uh, we thought it would be helpful to have a fuller discussion of this particular matter.
[3:20] SPEAKER_02: David, you've put significant time and effort into considering this idea.
[3:24] SPEAKER_02: I know you've written at least two things on GRN.
[3:26] SPEAKER_02: I've heard you speak about it publicly before.
[3:28] SPEAKER_02: Um thank you for helping us out because we need all the help we can get.
[3:32] SPEAKER_02: Maybe it would be helpful to start by explaining what the purpose and use of doctrinal standards or confession of faith is or are for a denomination.
[3:43] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, uh, well, I hope I'll be some help.
[3:46] SPEAKER_03: Um, and you all will need to guide me as we go here.
[3:50] SPEAKER_03: Um, but yeah, the purpose and use of a confession.
[3:54] SPEAKER_03: Um it's common, isn't it, in in broader evangelical circles to hear the no creed but Christ, you know, no doctrinal standard except the Bible only.
[4:05] SPEAKER_03: But inevitably, uh we all have a confession of faith.
[4:11] SPEAKER_03: Every preacher has a body of doctrine to which they adhere that rules certain things in and certain things out.
[4:18] SPEAKER_03: The question is not do you have a confession, but is your confession any good?
[4:23] SPEAKER_03: Um, and I would much rather that the confession was one that was published and scrutinized and weighed and evaluated, not just by the church uh for a week or two or a year or two, but over centuries, that has been used and its utility has been proven than something that I've written on the back of a napkin or invented for myself, uh, or is even undisclosed and is it just only exists in my head.
[4:54] SPEAKER_03: Everyone has a confession.
[4:56] SPEAKER_03: The question is, is your confession any good?
[4:58] SPEAKER_03: Is it transparent and clear?
[5:00] SPEAKER_03: So, in one sense, the the question before the question was the use of a confession is uh really about the inevitability of a confession.
[5:10] SPEAKER_03: Uh, you cannot be a Christian and not adhere to a body of doctrine.
[5:16] SPEAKER_03: Um so that said, uh, I think there's you can summarize the the use of a confession or confessional standards in three ways.
[5:26] SPEAKER_03: They are for unity, they are for clarity, and they are for purity.
[5:33] SPEAKER_03: So so a confession, confessional standards, in our case, the Westminster standards, the confession in larger and shorter catechisms, allows the church to say we have agreed together on a body of doctrine that we affirm to be the teaching of holy scripture.
[5:58] SPEAKER_03: And we agree to align our teaching with the teaching of this summary exposition of the doctrine of holy scripture, so that we are all saying the same thing.
[6:13] SPEAKER_03: That doesn't mean that we're all preaching the identical message or we're all working through the same text on every any given Sunday, but it does mean, at least in theory, that uh if you move from one congregation to the next, you're going to hear uh biblical teaching that is consistent with itself and with each other.
[6:36] SPEAKER_03: There's unity around the truth.
[6:38] SPEAKER_03: There can be no other basis of unity.
[6:41] SPEAKER_03: The only other option for ecclesiastical unity is governmental.
[6:48] SPEAKER_03: Um, and that's usually the route that liberal churches take when they jettison a shared commitment to common truths.
[7:00] SPEAKER_03: They uh they enforce and maintain the their ecclesiastical cohesion through the courts of the church, and that is a shortcut to tyranny.
[7:12] SPEAKER_03: Um and so having confession as the ground of our unity actually ensures our liberty.
[7:22] SPEAKER_03: It means that we're we're united around truth rather than united around some sort of ecclesiastical structure that controls and directs us.
[7:32] SPEAKER_03: Unity, clarity.
[7:34] SPEAKER_03: Um we have a summary standard treatment of the truth that is open.
[7:41] SPEAKER_03: Anyone can pick it up.
[7:42] SPEAKER_03: You can find it everywhere online, it's published, it's in print, it has been examined and scrutinized and tested and tried and used over and over and over.
[7:52] SPEAKER_03: Any member of the church, uh as well as any officer in the church, can make use of it and access it and compare it against the text of Holy Scripture, and can see that it is uh marvelously uh clear.
[8:10] SPEAKER_03: It has worked uh so hard, the the framers of our standards have worked so hard to articulate the teaching of scripture with crystal clarity.
[8:21] SPEAKER_03: That's why it's stood the test of time, of course.
[8:24] SPEAKER_03: But it also makes sure that um uh the the church's message to the world, our witness, is not ambiguous.
[8:36] SPEAKER_03: This this is what we say.
[8:38] SPEAKER_03: These things are our message for the world.
[8:43] SPEAKER_03: The answer to the question, what does the Presbyterian Church in America believe, is found in these three documents.
[8:52] SPEAKER_03: The PCA believes the Westminster Confession of Faith and larger and shorter catechisms.
[8:58] SPEAKER_03: That provides enormous clarity and and evangelistically and myssiologically, it provides great reassurance to people who wander into our churches to be able to tell them you these are public documents.
[9:14] SPEAKER_03: Uh you can you can evaluate the standard of our message, you can scrutinize it in the light of scripture for yourself.
[9:23] SPEAKER_03: There's nothing we're not hiding anything, there's no hidden agenda, there's no secret message.
[9:29] SPEAKER_03: Um, so unity, clarity, and purity.
[9:33] SPEAKER_03: Um these are our doctrinal boundaries, and uh the PCA does a pretty good job actually of policing those boundaries, um and and of saying, look, you may be our brother in Christ, you may believe the gospel, but there's there's more here than the gospel only, and there may be a better place for you to serve if you want to be a preacher than the Presbyterian Church in America if you don't affirm these additional things that we believe are also perhaps not of first importance, but of secondary importance, that have huge structural implications for the way the church orders its life, its worship, and its discipleship ministry.
[10:22] SPEAKER_03: And so unity, clarity, and purity.
[10:25] SPEAKER_03: And unity and purity sort of go, it's like the horseshoe.
[10:28] SPEAKER_03: They almost meet again at the other end, don't they?
[10:30] SPEAKER_03: The reason our standards promote our unity is because they allow us to enforce doctrinal purity.
[10:38] SPEAKER_03: If we can't enforce purity, there can be no possibility of unity because we don't have a common message to proclaim.
[10:47] SPEAKER_01: So the the Westminster Confession, this is Jared.
[10:50] SPEAKER_01: Um, thanks for joining us, David.
[10:52] SPEAKER_01: Um the Westminster Confession is a little bit more detailed than some other confessions, uh, even than um perhaps our Dutch um Reform brothers.
[11:02] SPEAKER_01: And so uh as you're going along, uh, we wouldn't say that the Westminster Confession is on the same level of scripture in terms of being infallible.
[11:10] SPEAKER_01: Although uh if you take Sproul's definition, some would say it is an errant if they agree with all of it.
[11:14] SPEAKER_01: But um in reading through it, it it is detailed and you know, your first experience reading through the entire thing, you may come to something that you say, um, oh, that's not what I've been taught before, or that's not my understanding of something.
[11:27] SPEAKER_01: And you're you're an impasse there.
[11:30] SPEAKER_01: Uh either the confession is wrong or I'm wrong.
[11:33] SPEAKER_01: Um, how do we approach the confession?
[11:35] SPEAKER_01: And um, is there one side of the uh the horse to fall on in terms of that that question of you come to someplace in the confession, you disagree with it.
[11:43] SPEAKER_01: What should our attitude be in exploring that?
[11:46] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, so you're right, and the confession itself acknowledges that synods and councils have and do and will er, including the Westminster divines themselves, and that uh the only infallible, inerrant, inspired document given to us is found in the Holy Scripture, the the Bible, the 66 books of Holy Scripture.
[12:08] SPEAKER_03: Um, having said that, um, the Westminster Confession and Catechisms is the doctrinal standard of an entire communion of the Presbyterian Church in America, and not just of the PCA, but of the family of Presbyterian churches globally.
[12:26] SPEAKER_03: It is centuries old, it is appropriately venerable, um, and should be held in honor.
[12:36] SPEAKER_03: Um, and it should be embraced, affirmed, and believed insofar as it teaches what the scriptures teach.
[12:45] SPEAKER_03: I would say because it teaches what the scriptures teach, it teaches what the Bible teaches.
[12:52] SPEAKER_03: Um and uh so our default stance ought to be because we want to honor our fathers and our mothers, right?
[13:02] SPEAKER_03: And that doesn't just mean mom and dad, that means those who are over us in the Lord and those who've gone ahead of us in the faith.
[13:09] SPEAKER_03: Um there's a there's a respect and an honor uh that we owe uh to our standards, where we approach them with a degree of reverence and we want to say, well, if if my fathers in the faith have affirmed this, I must have um compelling reason from the word of God and from the wide consensus of the Christian church that this is wrong if I'm going to reject it.
[13:42] SPEAKER_03: Because actually, what you have in the Westminster Standards is it is self the consensus of wide sections of the church for centuries.
[13:52] SPEAKER_03: Um, the the early church, the the the credal affirmations of the church Catholic, as well as the consensus of all the reformed churches, uh summed up beautifully in our standards.
[14:04] SPEAKER_03: If I'm going to depart from that, it must be because um I am compelled to do so, not by my private opinion, but but by Holy Scripture.
[14:16] SPEAKER_03: The issue here is um who will be the the the interpretator, the interpreter?
[14:24] SPEAKER_03: What whose grid will I use?
[14:26] SPEAKER_03: My own, my individualistic private interpretive grid?
[14:32] SPEAKER_03: Or will I use the interpretive grid that many millions of Christians use today and have used over the centuries and found to reflect the teaching of scripture itself?
[14:44] SPEAKER_03: I think when put in those terms, you you have to say, no, I I should default to the latter over against my private opinion.
[14:55] SPEAKER_03: Not that I'm going to completely ignore my private opinion.
[14:59] SPEAKER_03: Um, you have liberty of conscience and your your view, you you may not sacrifice your own convictions to someone else.
[15:10] SPEAKER_03: You must hold your own convictions, you must own them for yourself.
[15:14] SPEAKER_03: But I I must scrutinize my convictions and test them and modify them where necessary.
[15:21] SPEAKER_03: Um, and and so I think I think there's a a starting assumption that the confession of the church carries an implicitly higher weight of authority than my private judgment.
[15:36] SPEAKER_03: And so if I don't agree with it, my starting position should be I wonder where I got this wrong along the way.
[15:45] SPEAKER_03: Which step in my process, where did I, where did I where did I land that was off?
[15:53] SPEAKER_03: It may be actually several moves further back.
[15:58] SPEAKER_03: Um uh, you know, if you're I had a pilot friend who was in the in the air force who used to talk about uh briefings and you're you're you're plotting your course, and if if uh your destination is a thousand miles away and you're one degree off, you know, ten miles into your journey, that one degree doesn't make a lot of difference.
[16:22] SPEAKER_03: But 900 miles into your journey, that one degree difference means you're way, way, way off.
[16:28] SPEAKER_03: And so so that's my question.
[16:30] SPEAKER_03: Is where am I?
[16:32] SPEAKER_03: It may even be quite subtle, but where am I off?
[16:36] SPEAKER_03: And uh I want to invite other people, especially the officers and leaders of the church that Christ has ordained to shepherd me into the answer to that question.
[16:49] SPEAKER_02: So this is this is where I have often had trouble.
[16:53] SPEAKER_02: And I confess I, you know, became an elder after good faith subscription had come into the PCA.
[16:58] SPEAKER_02: I wonder actually if any of us were members of the PCA before good faith subscription.
[17:02] SPEAKER_02: I don't think so.
[17:03] SPEAKER_02: Um and so so the idea of good faith that comes from that, I think the only place it comes from, as far as I can tell, is that section in 19 and 21, where we require men to receive and adopt the confession of faith and catechisms um sincerely in good faith.
[17:21] SPEAKER_02: Um the the question would basically is what is good faith subscription in relationship to our standards?
[17:29] SPEAKER_02: Um and and what how should we understand that phrase in in our Book of Church Order?
[17:35] SPEAKER_02: Which I I wonder if if uh if we should tell our listeners, we don't believe the BCO is as venerable um as our our doctrinal standards.
[17:43] SPEAKER_03: Uh and neither wish we could we change it every year.
[17:49] SPEAKER_03: That's right.
[17:50] SPEAKER_03: Um for better or worse.
[17:52] SPEAKER_03: That's right.
[17:53] SPEAKER_03: Um uh so yeah, what is good faith subscription?
[17:56] SPEAKER_03: That's a great it's a great question, and I think actually since it that became our our standard, our pattern, that question is constantly um uh wrestled with.
[18:09] SPEAKER_03: The the phrase good faith subscription is actually nowhere to be found um in any of our constitutional documents.
[18:19] SPEAKER_03: Um but uh we ask candidates uh uh officers to subscribe to the standards sincerely in good faith.
[18:32] SPEAKER_03: I think those two are synonymous, they're synonyms.
[18:36] SPEAKER_03: Uh in good faith explains what we mean when we say you're being sincere.
[18:42] SPEAKER_03: That is, you're acting in good faith.
[18:44] SPEAKER_03: You you your fingers are not crossed behind your back when you make your promises.
[18:49] SPEAKER_03: You you're not saying one thing but meaning another.
[18:51] SPEAKER_03: You're not trying to be deceptive or devious or disingenuous, there's no ambiguity, you're being straightforward with the courts of the church.
[19:00] SPEAKER_03: Uh, your conscience is clear before God.
[19:03] SPEAKER_03: Uh you're not being, there are no circumlocutions, there's no avoidance, there's no attempts to dodge and weave.
[19:11] SPEAKER_03: Uh, you want to be direct and plain.
[19:14] SPEAKER_03: This is what I believe, court of the church.
[19:18] SPEAKER_03: You determine if it accords with our standards.
[19:22] SPEAKER_03: Um, I believe this is what the standards teach, and I affirm it.
[19:26] SPEAKER_03: And if you don't think that I've got that right, then I will submit to your judgment and and your your conclusions.
[19:34] SPEAKER_03: That's what it means.
[19:34] SPEAKER_03: We're we're acting in full sincerity with honesty and integrity and transparency.
[19:44] SPEAKER_02: Why is that an well, I was gonna ask, why is that an issue?
[19:48] SPEAKER_02: Not not even to get into like I expect Jared's gonna ask about strict subscription or something here in a minute, something historical, I'm sure.
[19:54] SPEAKER_02: Um, but just for like pretending that somebody has no idea, because what you just described is is helpful for good faith.
[20:00] SPEAKER_02: What why is that something to be discussed and and to be talked about ever since it came to be?
[20:06] SPEAKER_03: The answer to that really is bound up with whatever question you assumed Jared was about to ask about um the different types and models of subscription that are out there, because the PCA didn't use that phrase good faith subscription before, and now it does.
[20:25] SPEAKER_03: Um and and I think the way that the PCA in practice understands good faith subscription is that candidates are to declare any difference to the standards.
[20:41] SPEAKER_03: Any officer must declare any difference they have with the standards to any of its language, vocabulary, statements, teaching.
[20:50] SPEAKER_03: Um they are not to be the determiners of whether or not their convictions are in accord with our standards.
[20:57] SPEAKER_03: Um, but the the presbytery is, the courts of the church are.
[21:02] SPEAKER_03: They make their declaration that I, so far as I know my own heart before God, in the plain reading of the text, having studied it, I have no differences.
[21:11] SPEAKER_03: Or here are my two or three differences, three or four differences.
[21:15] SPEAKER_03: And I've stated them in writing.
[21:18] SPEAKER_03: And but it but those accepting, you can you can take it on good faith, Presbyteri, that I agree with everything else that's there.
[21:29] SPEAKER_03: Not just that I'm I'm comfortable with it, that's not adequate.
[21:33] SPEAKER_03: It's not that I'm I can I can go along with that, that's that's not adequate.
[21:38] SPEAKER_03: No, no, this is the confession of my faith.
[21:42] SPEAKER_03: I believe everything in the confession, with perhaps any differences that I may with that that I may declare accepted.
[21:52] SPEAKER_03: And and then the presbytery must determine whether or not those differences strike at the vitals or are hostile to.
[22:00] SPEAKER_03: The system, whether they are semantic or more than semantic, and take appropriate action in the light of that.
[22:07] SPEAKER_03: And I imagine we'll get to that.
[22:08] SPEAKER_03: And where the controversy comes in is that really there are there were two parties before, and there are still two parties now.
[22:19] SPEAKER_03: There were those who thought of themselves as strict or stricter.
[22:26] SPEAKER_03: I'm not sure that there's ever really been in the PCA uh total subscriptionism.
[22:34] SPEAKER_03: And so sometimes in this debate, total or absolute subscription is conflated with strict subscription.
[22:44] SPEAKER_03: But there are those who are who are more strict and want to say that really we ought not to depart at all from the standards, um, except perhaps minor scruples on matters of semantics.
[22:59] SPEAKER_03: And then there are those who would say, really, we are affirming only the system of doctrine contained in the which is constitutional language, the system of doctrine contained in the confession of faith and catechisms.
[23:14] SPEAKER_03: They understand that phrase to mean that there is a subset of truths inside the confession and catechisms somewhere, undefined by anyone, to which you are bound uh and and and you're required to affirm those, but all the rest is is sort of negotiable and up for grabs.
[23:39] SPEAKER_03: And those two parties have always have always been there in varying degrees uh of intensity, uh and that's been the debate, and and good faith subscription um it is the language that we use, and so that that's become the battleground, but really this is what we're fighting about.
[23:59] SPEAKER_03: How should those who subscribe to the standards make their vows?
[24:07] SPEAKER_01: And and maybe this is just a um asking your opinion on something, but uh I've sometimes wondered how to think about the PCA's subscription.
[24:15] SPEAKER_01: Um you kind of were talking about the difference between a strict and full subscription in a sense versus a system.
[24:21] SPEAKER_01: Um is what we have something that's different than both of them, or is it like a species of full subscription just with stated exceptions?
[24:30] SPEAKER_01: Uh, do you have an opinion on that?
[24:32] SPEAKER_03: I think the latter of those is actually where we really are.
[24:36] SPEAKER_03: That that we we do actually have a species of a stricter kind of subscription where we we permit the presbytery to judge exceptions, differences.
[24:49] SPEAKER_03: Um, but we expect uh the confessor, the candidate, to affirm the standards.
[25:00] SPEAKER_03: Um I I think it's fascinating that the PCA as a denomination confesses the standards without exception.
[25:11] SPEAKER_03: The Presbyterian Church in America's doctrinal standards are the Westminster Confession and Catechisms.
[25:19] SPEAKER_03: And the denomination has no declared denominational difference with our standards at any point.
[25:28] SPEAKER_03: Um individuals within the PCA differ from our standards and are allowed those differences with certain stipulations according to the will of the presbyteries.
[25:41] SPEAKER_03: Um but the PCA adheres, this is what we teach.
[25:46] SPEAKER_03: Everything in these documents, this is our standard of doctrine.
[25:50] SPEAKER_03: This is our message, this is our understanding of the of the word of God.
[25:55] SPEAKER_03: So we are we are a we're a denomination that adheres to a form of stricter subscription.
[26:02] SPEAKER_03: Um that doesn't mean that there isn't stricter and less strict practices within presbyteries around the country.
[26:13] SPEAKER_03: Um there there no doubt there no doubt is.
[26:16] SPEAKER_03: Um and that's and and that's why we continue to have differences of opinion.
[26:21] SPEAKER_03: But at our best, even with that, I think our practice has allowed us to push one another, uh, to scrutinize each other, to challenge and ask questions about whether or not a given difference is or is not acceptable.
[26:39] SPEAKER_03: Um, and and where do we draw those lines?
[26:42] SPEAKER_03: And and generally speaking, I think we do pretty well with that in upholding and affirming our standards.
[26:52] SPEAKER_00: It's interesting.
[26:53] SPEAKER_00: Some some folks in the PCA will argue the opposite of what you just argued as it relates to good faith subscription.
[27:00] SPEAKER_00: Um, they would say that it's no different than system subscription.
[27:04] SPEAKER_00: So how do we navigate that?
[27:07] SPEAKER_00: I mean, it can't be both.
[27:09] SPEAKER_00: I mean, maybe in a post-um modern world it can be both, but it can't.
[27:13] SPEAKER_00: And so what do we say to brothers who think that the our our subscription model is looser or perhaps no different than system subscription, just a different title?
[27:25] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[27:28] SPEAKER_03: Well, they're wrong.
[27:30] SPEAKER_03: So you can say that.
[27:31] SPEAKER_03: Uh we practice good faith subscription.
[27:34] SPEAKER_03: We do not practice system subscription.
[27:37] SPEAKER_03: You confess the standards in good faith, that is, sincerely as the confession of your own faith.
[27:45] SPEAKER_03: And you may have some differences, but they are they are stated as departures from the standards.
[27:54] SPEAKER_03: Um, and if they are hostile to the system of doctrine contained in the confession of faith and catechisms, they are not allowed.
[28:04] SPEAKER_03: Um, that doesn't mean that you only subscribe to the system.
[28:10] SPEAKER_03: So just on the surface of it, we are not a system subscription denomination.
[28:16] SPEAKER_03: Uh, secondly, the language contained in is lifted from the shorter catechism.
[28:25] SPEAKER_03: The word of God contained in the scriptures of the Old and New Testaments does not mean that the word of God is somewhere to be found as a subset of the Bible to be determined by the reader, perhaps, as they read the Bible.
[28:49] SPEAKER_03: No, it means that the word of God is contained in the scriptures so as to exhaust them.
[29:00] SPEAKER_03: The scriptures are the word of God, the word of God fills the scriptures up with no room for any scripture that isn't the word of God.
[29:11] SPEAKER_03: And that that language, the confession of faith, that this the system of doctrine contained in the confession of faith is directly borrowed from that, our own confessional language and vocabulary.
[29:23] SPEAKER_03: Where do you look for the system of doctrine?
[29:26] SPEAKER_03: It's it you're not flicking pages frantically trying to identify the two or three doctrinal points that constitute the system.
[29:36] SPEAKER_03: No, the system is contained in it so as to exhaust it.
[29:39] SPEAKER_03: That is to say, the standards are the system.
[29:44] SPEAKER_03: Um and we affirm the system.
[29:48] SPEAKER_03: And and so I would argue that substantive differences um that fatally undermine the teaching of an entire chapter of our confession are hot must be hostile to the system.
[30:06] SPEAKER_03: Um and and that that person ought not to be uh an officer in the Presbyterian Church in America.
[30:14] SPEAKER_02: Let's talk about um how this works out in the presbytery level.
[30:19] SPEAKER_02: So as we as men come for licensure ordination, RAO 16 kind of gives the language that presbyteries are to use um when when judging differences, or I suppose when when evaluating exceptions, if they're gonna grant them.
[30:35] SPEAKER_02: So we have language of uh it's it's merely semantic, it's more than semantic, but doesn't strike, and and after that it strikes.
[30:43] SPEAKER_02: And so you've you can have one of two kinds of exceptions in the PCA.
[30:47] SPEAKER_02: Um maybe we need to talk through what the difference is before we talk about how to evaluate them, or maybe maybe that's all part of the same conversation, right?
[30:55] SPEAKER_02: What's the difference between merely semantic or more than semantic, and how do we evaluate if if they're striking at a vital?
[31:04] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[31:05] SPEAKER_03: Um part of the trouble that presbyteries often have is that um at the polls the semantic and the substantive are fairly straightforward and easy to spot.
[31:22] SPEAKER_03: But there is there is where they touch, it gets it gets a little challenging.
[31:28] SPEAKER_03: And sometimes presbyteries land in different places over whether an exception is merely semantic or more than semantic, but not hostile to the system or striking at the vitals.
[31:41] SPEAKER_03: Um, so for example, the confession says that covenant is frequently set forth in scripture as a testament.
[31:51] SPEAKER_03: Well, it's commonly argued, and I've argued myself, and this is a difference that I have, that I'm not sure that frequently is the right word to use, or even ever.
[32:06] SPEAKER_03: Uh, in the one instance I can think of in the book of Hebrews where uh that that Greek word could be translated testament, even there, covenant may be the better word.
[32:17] SPEAKER_03: Um, I agree with the substance of what is being taught.
[32:22] SPEAKER_03: I'm just not sure that the link, the particular linguistic argument that the confession is making there is right.
[32:30] SPEAKER_03: And that was judged by Mississippi Valley Presbytery to be semantic.
[32:35] SPEAKER_03: In other words, I I have no difference with the teaching of the confession with respect to the covenant.
[32:42] SPEAKER_03: Um, but I I have a difference about preferred vocabulary and nomenclature.
[32:49] SPEAKER_03: Um, that's semantics.
[32:50] SPEAKER_03: That's what semantic means, right?
[32:52] SPEAKER_03: You I like this word more than that word.
[32:54] SPEAKER_03: I really wish they hadn't framed it that way, but framed it this way.
[32:57] SPEAKER_03: But I agree with what they're trying to say.
[32:59] SPEAKER_03: Like the point they're making is right.
[33:02] SPEAKER_03: I just I think they're that's a less felicitous way of making the point.
[33:08] SPEAKER_03: That that those are semantic differences.
[33:11] SPEAKER_03: I think I I worry sometimes that that men are not actually declaring their semantic differences.
[33:18] SPEAKER_03: That they are deciding that they have semantic differences and that therefore they're only semantic and are not worth bringing up.
[33:26] SPEAKER_03: I I think that's a dangerous route to take.
[33:29] SPEAKER_03: Let's let the courts of the church determine whether it is semantic or not.
[33:34] SPEAKER_03: Um, you you declare every difference you may have and then let the courts weigh it.
[33:40] SPEAKER_03: Um something that's more than semantic, but that doesn't strike at the vitals.
[33:46] SPEAKER_03: Um the larger catechism says that the casting of lots in its exposition of the larger catechism, uh, the exposition of the Ten Commandments is one of the ways by which God makes Himself known to us.
[34:02] SPEAKER_03: Um well I I I think that's one of the ways he did, but I I don't think that's one of the ways he still does.
[34:10] SPEAKER_03: Um that might be judged more than semantic, that's a real difference.
[34:17] SPEAKER_03: But really, there's there's there's nothing resting on that doctrinally.
[34:33] SPEAKER_03: That ripples down through the rest of the body of doctrine.
[34:38] SPEAKER_03: Um, and and so that really isn't uh a matter of of concern.
[34:43] SPEAKER_03: It's not uncommon though in our presbyteries.
[34:46] SPEAKER_03: There are the two most common differences that are granted in our presbyteries, and it's not at all uncommon to hear these.
[34:54] SPEAKER_03: The first uh is a difference over um uh images of Christ, and the second is over the recreations clause in the various statements with respect to the fourth commandment um and the Sabbath day.
[35:14] SPEAKER_03: And um depending on how the person, because they're required to say it in their own words now, but depending on how those differences are stated, they're often considered to be more than semantic.
[35:30] SPEAKER_03: They're real differences of opinion, uh, but they're they're not you you affirm that Sunday is the Sabbath, and you you affirm that we ought not to make images of any person of the Godhead, you just think that you can't avoid making a mental image of Jesus.
[35:49] SPEAKER_03: I I don't agree with that, by the way, but that's a common way of saying this.
[35:53] SPEAKER_03: And presbyteries often grant those differences as real differences, but not uh not causing system-wide um failure, as it were.
[36:08] SPEAKER_03: Um, it doesn't crash the program.
[36:12] SPEAKER_03: Um a difference that is hostile to the system would be saying um I don't believe the fourth commandment obtains today at all.
[36:24] SPEAKER_03: I I don't believe that Sunday is the Sabbath.
[36:27] SPEAKER_03: Or I don't believe um uh that um it's wrong to make images of the Godhead.
[36:38] SPEAKER_03: I think it's okay to make images of the Godhead.
[36:42] SPEAKER_03: That's those are hostile to our system.
[36:46] SPEAKER_03: Um because there are a number of consequences from that, about various other other doctrines that are that are entailed in the way that we express that.
[36:56] SPEAKER_03: And and so you're still talking about the fourth commandment and the second commandment, but how you frame that, the language that you use, the the devil's in the details, uh maybe quite literally, the the devil's in the details.
[37:12] SPEAKER_03: And and so it really matters how you say it, and that you say it in your own words, and that you allow the presbytery the opportunity carefully to evaluate and weigh.
[37:19] SPEAKER_03: And good presbyteries will often come back to a candidate when they see the committee, the the candidates or credentials committee will come to them and say, You've said this.
[37:29] SPEAKER_03: Do you really mean this?
[37:31] SPEAKER_03: Or you got or do you stand by how you've said it here?
[37:33] SPEAKER_03: Because if you if you stand by how you've said it here, we have a problem.
[37:37] SPEAKER_03: But but maybe you were trying to say something different, and we want to give you the opportunity to clarify and refine and perfect your your language rather than simply sort of dropping the hammer.
[37:48] SPEAKER_03: But um that those are our those are our differences.
[37:53] SPEAKER_03: Those are the distinctions between those three categories of of difference.
[37:57] SPEAKER_01: There's maybe a little bit of, I don't know if it's subjectivity or just variance in how Presbyteries might um classify striking at the vitals.
[38:06] SPEAKER_01: I think of just reading through history.
[38:08] SPEAKER_01: You know, striking at the vitals doesn't always mean, you know, you can't be a Christian and hold this even.
[38:14] SPEAKER_01: Um there's uh at least an older case of ruling elder who was Credo Baptist, and they said no, that strikes at the vitals, uh, even though we would say we're gonna see Spurgeon in heaven, right?
[38:25] SPEAKER_01: Um so sometimes it can be a little bit difficult to know what the vital doctrines are, exactly how that is.
[38:31] SPEAKER_01: Uh, I think Hodge is about the only person that I know that had something of a list that he had up, but it didn't even seem to be exhaustive in the list that he was doing up.
[38:41] SPEAKER_01: Do you think that would be a good idea to know or draw up what are the vitals, or what's the what would be the downside of doing something like that?
[38:48] SPEAKER_03: I think that yeah, that's a great question.
[38:50] SPEAKER_03: The pitfall uh to what are the vitals is a bit like the pitfall if you said the system is contained in the the confession and catechisms, and you understood that to mean it's in there somewhere, but it's not coterminous with it.
[39:06] SPEAKER_03: And then you were to draw up a list of those doctrines that that uh comprise the system, now you have our another confession.
[39:16] SPEAKER_03: That's the real confession, and the rest of it becomes redundant.
[39:20] SPEAKER_03: And so there are there are some dangers with drawing up lists of vitals, you know, that that these are the essentials.
[39:27] SPEAKER_03: Um for me, I think maybe uh at least a starting place is to ask uh what is the what is the systemic effect of this difference?
[39:45] SPEAKER_03: What are the knock-on consequences for other doctrines and for the way that they all would need to now be adjusted?
[39:55] SPEAKER_03: Um so for example, the the the Credo Baptist point, that affects our doctrine of the covenant, it affects um the doctrine of the church, um, it affects the the nature of church membership, it affects uh how officers practice pastoral oversight and um many other many other things besides the doctrine of the sacraments, um and and on and on.
[40:31] SPEAKER_03: And and so there's there's a system-wide trickle-down effect from that difference.
[40:39] SPEAKER_03: It's not a first order truth, right?
[40:41] SPEAKER_03: You spurgeon will be in heaven, like you said.
[40:47] SPEAKER_03: Um it's not even a second order truth, necessarily.
[40:52] SPEAKER_03: Maybe um maybe it's second order in that it's very difficult to run a church when you don't know and can't agree on who its members are.
[41:02] SPEAKER_03: Are they the children of believers or not?
[41:05] SPEAKER_03: So maybe that would be a second order.
[41:06] SPEAKER_03: And then there are tertiary, third order things where perhaps you don't have to break fellowship over it.
[41:11] SPEAKER_03: Uh differences over eschatology are is the classic, uh, the classic one.
[41:16] SPEAKER_03: And within the PCA, we have historic premillennialists, post-millennialists, and then we have the correct position.
[41:25] SPEAKER_03: Um we have a millennialists, and there may there may be variations on a theme within each of those positions.
[41:35] SPEAKER_03: Um and we've historically not broken fellowship over that, though again, how that's articulated before a presbytery and before a candidates and credentials committee would really matter.
[41:48] SPEAKER_03: So I agree there's wisdom.
[41:50] SPEAKER_03: Um, it's a it's about judging, but isn't that actually, after all, what elders are supposed to do?
[41:58] SPEAKER_03: That they're meant to take our subordinate standards uh with a conscience captive to the word of God, listen carefully to what is being said, what these differences are, and then judge.
[42:13] SPEAKER_03: And and we I think there's a real danger in taking away the responsibility of officers to do that difficult weighing, deliberating, judging work.
[42:27] SPEAKER_03: And that there may be differences within the court as as the debate proceeds.
[42:32] SPEAKER_03: And that's the way it's supposed to be, right?
[42:35] SPEAKER_03: We're meant we're meant to argue back and forth and persuade each other and come to conclusions because there's wisdom uh as as we do that in in many counselors.
[42:45] SPEAKER_03: So I I would be very reluctant to move away from uh courts of the church that are empowered to do that evaluative judging work to providing them a checklist of of uh vitals that so long as this brother affirms these things, then he's good to go.
[43:09] SPEAKER_03: That I think the the better rubric is what are the systemic consequences of this difference?
[43:17] SPEAKER_02: Uh and that's what we have to wrestle through how um we have ruling elders that listen to the show, and we have men who are candidates for ministry that are thinking ahead.
[43:30] SPEAKER_02: What advice might you give to them, especially as they sit on a presbytery floor?
[43:35] SPEAKER_02: They haven't been involved in the committee process, they're hearing some of them probably hearing it for the first time if they didn't get the white book ahead of time.
[43:42] SPEAKER_02: What what advice would you give them in their engagement of those matters on the floor of presbytery?
[43:48] SPEAKER_02: Should they just be quiet because they haven't thought about it until now?
[43:51] SPEAKER_02: Something seems off, but they're it's their first meeting, and so they should probably shouldn't stand up and speak because some Dumbo told them they shouldn't stand up and speak, you know.
[44:00] SPEAKER_02: Their very first meeting, if they hear something.
[44:01] SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
[44:02] SPEAKER_02: I say that to guys on the Dumbo.
[44:04] SPEAKER_02: Um well, how would you counsel these types of men?
[44:07] SPEAKER_02: What what principles can they take into their meetings?
[44:10] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, well, look, if if you've walked into a presbytery, whether you're a ruling elder or not, and you haven't read the materials, and this is the first time you've thought about it, you probably should shut up.
[44:20] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, that's true.
[44:21] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[44:21] SPEAKER_03: Um, yeah.
[44:22] SPEAKER_03: But if you're hearing something and uh nobody else is saying, ah, yellow, there's a yellow flag at least here.
[44:32] SPEAKER_03: I have some concerns.
[44:34] SPEAKER_03: Um, then you actually have a duty to raise the raise the question.
[44:40] SPEAKER_03: I I would say again, we ought to cultivate trust in our committees.
[44:48] SPEAKER_03: You you want a credentials committee that does diligent work.
[44:53] SPEAKER_03: And when the exam is conducted on the floor, it's conducted in such a way as to convey to the presbytery what happened in committee and allow the candidate to come under appropriate scrutiny and show what they do know.
[45:12] SPEAKER_03: Um and uh, you know, if there's a yellow flag or a red flag and nobody else is bringing it up, you should bring it up.
[45:22] SPEAKER_03: Um, I do think sometimes that just there are some men who live for that moment.
[45:31] SPEAKER_03: You know, they're they don't really care about anything else at the presbytery, but they're there for the candidate's exam.
[45:37] SPEAKER_03: And they're they're like sharks trying to smell blood in the water.
[45:43] SPEAKER_03: If the if the poor man flobs a question, they're all over it, and they just and they're up on their feet over and over and over and over.
[45:50] SPEAKER_03: That's really not helpful.
[45:54] SPEAKER_03: Um, so so ask yourself, uh, who am I serving by asking this question?
[46:04] SPEAKER_03: You can ask questions that actually help the brother.
[46:07] SPEAKER_03: If you sense that he said the wrong thing, but you know him enough, and you know that's that's not how he would frame this, were he not so terrified?
[46:16] SPEAKER_03: It's scary, it's a scary moment, right?
[46:18] SPEAKER_03: And so you can stand up and say, Um, you said this, and I'm I'm just wondering, can you elaborate?
[46:27] SPEAKER_03: Because we've talked about it, and that's not how I've heard you phrase it before.
[46:30] SPEAKER_03: And help be kind.
[46:32] SPEAKER_03: Who am I serving?
[46:33] SPEAKER_03: Serve the man who's being asked questions, and and am I serving the brothers and the fathers and brothers in the presbytery around me by by asking a leading question, by getting at the truth, by by trying to drill down on an important topic?
[46:50] SPEAKER_03: Or am I sort of really asking questions to show how much I know and how much this poor sucker doesn't know?
[46:59] SPEAKER_03: Um, am I am I the guy that's always looking for a gotcha question?
[47:05] SPEAKER_03: Um there's a certain kind of vicious delight in stymieing the seminary student.
[47:14] SPEAKER_03: Um and and that's just that's actually ungodly.
[47:20] SPEAKER_03: It's ungodly.
[47:22] SPEAKER_03: So so come prepared.
[47:25] SPEAKER_03: Uh and that means not just reading the candidates and credentials committee report.
[47:32] SPEAKER_03: Um it might mean um if you've got a question in advance, call up the the chairman of the committee and say, hey, just talk me through this.
[47:43] SPEAKER_03: Um help me understand this.
[47:46] SPEAKER_03: Maybe this is something you would want to forewarn the candidate about and work with him to articulate it.
[47:52] SPEAKER_03: If you think that he's actually sound here, but he's he's really framed it badly.
[47:58] SPEAKER_03: Um that would be a good and churchly way to approach it.
[48:03] SPEAKER_03: It means knowing your standards yourself and loving them and being um sincere in your own adherence to them so that you're equipped properly to notice.
[48:16] SPEAKER_03: You know, so often things get said and they're crickets chirp, and you're looking around the room thinking, is nobody gonna flag this?
[48:25] SPEAKER_03: This is not good.
[48:27] SPEAKER_03: Um, and it's because we're all tired, it's been a long day, it's you know, it's a lot of information to take in, we're not paying attention.
[48:35] SPEAKER_03: It may be because we don't actually know our standards as well as as we should.
[48:40] SPEAKER_03: Um when when our standards only become a shibboleth, uh uh a test that you have to meet in order to kind of get into the club, they're already a dead letter.
[48:59] SPEAKER_03: They no longer serve that threefold purpose that we began with: unity, purity, clarity.
[49:05] SPEAKER_03: Um they're no longer helpfully serving the church.
[49:10] SPEAKER_03: Um, and and often when that's how they're viewed, the last time a man opened his confession and catechisms was when he was undergoing trials for licensure or ordination.
[49:22] SPEAKER_03: And he really can ignore them safely for the rest of his ministry.
[49:26] SPEAKER_03: And and that's terrible because you said this is the confession of my faith.
[49:30] SPEAKER_03: This is a standard exposition of the teaching of the Bible.
[49:34] SPEAKER_03: Um, and if we get if we get to that place where we're not regularly commending our confession and catechisms to our congregation, using them, uh showing their helpfulness, um, building on them in our own teaching, using them perhaps even in our own piety and devotional life, um, then then we're in trouble.
[49:58] SPEAKER_02: I think you just said some good words related to the safeguards and practices we can put into place to prevent the abuse, uh so-called abuse, I suppose, of good faith.
[50:08] SPEAKER_02: Or just we just kind of let men go through.
[50:10] SPEAKER_02: Do you have any other thoughts on how we can uh guard well in our existing structure?
[50:20] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, it let me just be clear.
[50:22] SPEAKER_03: That's not that's not that's a that's a when these things happen, that's a failure of the presbytery to do its job.
[50:30] SPEAKER_03: The fault doesn't lie with the system.
[50:33] SPEAKER_03: The the fault lies because there's no system that can um avoid every system is just as strong as the the user, and no stronger than the user.
[50:47] SPEAKER_03: And so the flaws of the user um are what we often see.
[50:52] SPEAKER_03: And every presbytery will make a judgment call, and sometimes they're going to get it wrong.
[50:57] SPEAKER_03: And that's the nature of living this side of the eschaton.
[51:02] SPEAKER_03: Um Christ has given a government to his church that that fallible sinners, redeemed and saved by grace, can implement, and and that means that we will do it fallibly, um, including our scrutiny of the doctrine and convictions of officers.
[51:24] SPEAKER_03: I I think one one thing I'd say is that we are generally speaking a pretty heady doctrinal denomination.
[51:42] SPEAKER_03: And our our biggest danger we can never afford to just you know be indifferent to our theology exams, but I don't think that's our I think that's one real danger, and we're actually I think we're pretty alert to it.
[52:00] SPEAKER_03: And we always and often in these sorts of conversations talk about that danger of of waving people through, of saying, oh, he's one of us, so let's just let him in.
[52:10] SPEAKER_03: And that might happen here or there, but for the most part, generally we are we are good at holding one another to account and pushing each other to adhere to our standards and apply them and implement them and doing the hard thing.
[52:24] SPEAKER_03: And Ben, you just mentioned a brother coming to your presbytery and saying, Here are my differences, and they're the presbyteries now working through the consequences of that.
[52:32] SPEAKER_03: That's our presbyteries generally do that.
[52:36] SPEAKER_03: That you know, there there are there are cases before our SJC from time to time where presbyteries haven't done that well, and we have systems and checks and balances.
[52:47] SPEAKER_03: There is an opposite danger, though, that I maybe would would flag, and that is thinking that we've done all our duty when we've become sort of doctrine hawks, and and that that that our only concern in a in an exam of a candidate or an ordinand is to police the theological boundary.
[53:12] SPEAKER_03: And our denomination, I think, over the last few years has given some attention to questions of character, for example.
[53:20] SPEAKER_03: Um, and uh I would push us further back from the exam when it comes to questions of character, um, to to challenge us all as pastors, um, that we work hard at discipleship and training men for godliness, uh, that holiness is the indispensable, is an indispensable uh qualification for gospel ministry.
[53:53] SPEAKER_03: Um and we've seen a string of terrible pastoral failures, some on a national scale, some um I have a uh a dear friend who's uh had a colleague go through a terrible pastoral failure, moral failure.
[54:11] SPEAKER_03: It's not doctrinal, it's not theological, but but it is a question of character.
[54:17] SPEAKER_03: So I I think we are we can always work at it, we can always can we can always improve, and we need to continue to improve at policing the doctrinal boundaries.
[54:28] SPEAKER_03: I think that's right.
[54:32] SPEAKER_03: But I I think that too often our presbyteries only scrutinize um what does a man believe and how does he say it?
[54:43] SPEAKER_03: And we get into a lot of bother uh over that.
[54:48] SPEAKER_03: And we haven't done anything like the kind of work in in assessing a man's life, his temperament, his character.
[54:57] SPEAKER_03: Can he lead people?
[54:59] SPEAKER_03: What does he do when people don't agree with him?
[55:02] SPEAKER_03: Um, is he is he a loose canon?
[55:05] SPEAKER_03: Is there humility?
[55:07] SPEAKER_03: Um those are those are I think just as important, and we could we could do a better job of that for sure.
[55:18] SPEAKER_02: Jared, you want to come in and look some of these future type questions that we had down there?
[55:24] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[55:24] SPEAKER_01: I I think you hit on a lot of what we were gonna ask in terms of um uh differences and and future, even.
[55:32] SPEAKER_01: Um I wonder if what you've said is um a lot to the answer of what you see as the future of subscriptionism um and how it is that we practiced um uh confessional subscription, um, or what you see the future holding in terms of dangers on uh on any side.
[55:50] SPEAKER_01: And if you think it's mostly of that idea of character or thinking that we've checked the box, I just think of, you know, um, I think it's Ian Hamilton that wrote about um the decline of subscription in the Church of Scotland.
[56:03] SPEAKER_01: And uh I wonder if there's uh if that's kind of what you saw uh there, because you had some time uh in the Church of Scotland.
[56:11] SPEAKER_01: Um and if so, how do we guard against um the degradation of our subscriptionism?
[56:17] SPEAKER_01: And is that the only danger, or uh can you fall off the boat on some other side too?
[56:23] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I I when I was in the Church of Scotland, it was already, it had already sort of punted the standards um uh into the in into the shadows, really.
[56:39] SPEAKER_03: Um they affirmed the substance of the Christian faith contained in, and they definitely articulated what contained in meaning uh meant, which was that it's somewhere in there.
[56:50] SPEAKER_03: So I actually asked when I was training for the ministry in the Church of Scotland, I asked my one of my Church of Scotland professors, what does this mean?
[56:57] SPEAKER_03: How do I do this?
[56:58] SPEAKER_03: He said, What it means is you can get your confession of faith out and look down the index, um, look down the table of contents.
[57:07] SPEAKER_03: Those are all the doctrines.
[57:09] SPEAKER_03: You get to decide which ones you think are uh essential.
[57:16] SPEAKER_03: Um that's what it means.
[57:19] SPEAKER_03: And that kind of blew my mind.
[57:20] SPEAKER_03: So so the the Church of Scotland is a whole other whole other story.
[57:28] SPEAKER_03: Um I I think the the dangers of eroding our commitment to the standards arise when we do things like defining what is the system.
[57:41] SPEAKER_03: Here are the 10 or 15 or 5 or 3 truths that you must now adhere to.
[57:47] SPEAKER_03: Well, now that's our true confession, not the confession in catechisms.
[57:52] SPEAKER_03: But it also arises, as I said a moment ago, when our confession and catechisms ceases to function as a living tool of Christian discipleship and is reduced only to a uh uh a hurdle that candidates must jump to get on the team and start drawing a paying wage as an ordained teaching or ruling elder.
[58:14] SPEAKER_03: Um uh if that's all it is, we're already in big trouble.
[58:21] SPEAKER_03: Um it it and so that that that's a challenge to all of us, isn't it?
[58:26] SPEAKER_03: That we we are to use our confessional standards as helpful tools of Christian discipleship.
[58:33] SPEAKER_03: This is the truth I want my people to know.
[58:37] SPEAKER_03: I I want them to know these words and these documents and not just, I don't just want to teach them these truths in my own words, I want to point them to these texts and and uh help them understand it because I believe that they are health-giving and soul-nourishing truths framed with um unsurpassed clarity and beauty and fidelity to the scriptures.
[59:04] SPEAKER_03: Um don't don't ever let the confession and catechisms become an afterthought in your ministry.
[59:13] SPEAKER_03: We're not we're not preaching the confession and catechisms, we're preaching the word of God.
[59:18] SPEAKER_03: But the confession and catechisms answers so many of our questions about the meaning of the word of God and how to articulate that, and how has the church over its entire history framed these truths?
[59:35] SPEAKER_03: Uh, I I dare not depart from that because I think I know better about how to articulate that.
[59:41] SPEAKER_03: If this is how the church has framed it, I want to revere that and respect that, and I want my people to do the same.
[59:47] SPEAKER_03: The church has its own language, and and citizens of the kingdom should learn that language.
[59:55] SPEAKER_03: Um, it doesn't mean that we deliberately become obscure and I'm not into repristination.
[1:00:03] SPEAKER_03: You know, we don't all need to be wearing buckle shoes and Puritan hats and speaking in Elizabethan English.
[1:00:10] SPEAKER_03: Um, but I believe the confession and catechisms continue to be incredibly relevant.
[1:00:17] SPEAKER_03: They continue to show a remarkable utility for our current context and culture.
[1:00:24] SPEAKER_03: Um, I also think, and I want to be a little cautious and and and um qualified when I say this, our denomination has a certain predilection for uh uh additional doctrinal statements and in-thesis statements and uh study committee reports, and they are our study committee reports are all, I think, probably without exception, really helpful and useful.
[1:00:53] SPEAKER_03: Um, and our in-theses statements are, so far as I can recall, uh uh acceptable, helpful, good, wholesome things.
[1:01:03] SPEAKER_03: Um but I do sometimes find myself worried that um it those things can betray a lack of confidence in our standards.
[1:01:20] SPEAKER_03: Um that very often our standards already address these points and do it well.
[1:01:29] SPEAKER_03: Um and before we say something else, um we we ought to ask if our standards are sufficiently clear and robust on that point, um, lest we run the risk of of of uh relativizing the authority of our standards in our own our own denominational communion.
[1:01:53] SPEAKER_02: Well, guys, I'm gonna ask all three of you if uh there's anything else on this that you want to discuss.
[1:01:59] SPEAKER_02: Uh if Jared or Scott have more questions for our guest.
[1:02:04] SPEAKER_02: Uh David, is there anything in this whole discussion that's still lingering in your mind that you'd like to say to the dozens of people that will hopefully listen to this at some point in the future?
[1:02:15] SPEAKER_03: Um I I love the Westminster standards.
[1:02:19] SPEAKER_03: I I have found them to be a constant help to my Christian life, to my prayers, and to my preaching, and actually to my pastoring.
[1:02:29] SPEAKER_03: I the allegation is that the Heidelberg Catechism is pastoral and the Westminster Confession is scholastic and and and cold, and I just haven't found that to be true.
[1:02:39] SPEAKER_03: I found it to be so full of pastoral wisdom.
[1:02:42] SPEAKER_03: Uh, that the last paragraph, or is it the second to last in the chapter on the divine decree and this high mystery of predestinations to be used with special care and prudence?
[1:02:51] SPEAKER_03: Um, there's there's there are regular pastoral refrains that color how the divines articulate their point.
[1:02:59] SPEAKER_03: And uh I found that to be just so helpful in guiding my ministry and guiding my preaching.
[1:03:05] SPEAKER_03: Uh bust off your copy of the standards and and and prize it and love it, and uh uh search the scriptures in light of it.
[1:03:18] SPEAKER_03: Um I you know, I I preached through Shorter Catechism 4 in the past and used that as a teaching series, you know, what is God, a spirit infinite, eternal, and unchangeable in his being, wisdom, power, holiness, justice, goodness, and truth.
[1:03:32] SPEAKER_03: Just a helpful way to do a short series on the doctrine of God, the attributes of God.
[1:03:38] SPEAKER_03: And you're you're reminding people of the value of our standards um while while you're doing it.
[1:03:45] SPEAKER_03: So love love your love your confession of faith.
[1:03:50] SPEAKER_02: Amen.
[1:03:51] SPEAKER_02: Well, as first-time ruling elders uh who haven't read the white book would certainly say this podcast is over.
[1:03:56] SPEAKER_02: Thank you for joining us.
[1:03:57] SPEAKER_02: If you've enjoyed the show, do follow us on Twitter or Facebook at Polity Matters.
[1:04:01] SPEAKER_02: Be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[1:04:04] SPEAKER_02: If you've uh been interested in any of what we've been talking about, uh well, if you've stuck around this long, I'm sure that's true.
[1:04:10] SPEAKER_02: You can check out the show notes.
[1:04:11] SPEAKER_02: We'll have some links to a couple of David's articles uh where he has written about this matter.
[1:04:16] SPEAKER_02: Uh, if you have questions or comments, you can reach out to us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[1:04:21] SPEAKER_02: Don't forget you can support our work by going to buymeacoffee.com slash Politymatters and keep us in production from week to week.
[1:04:28] SPEAKER_02: Uh David, you are always a great encouragement to me, and I am thrilled that we can share this with some of our listeners uh today.
[1:04:36] SPEAKER_02: So thank you again for being with us.
[1:04:37] SPEAKER_02: We're very grateful.
[1:04:39] SPEAKER_02: Thank you.
[1:04:39] SPEAKER_02: Appreciate it.
[1:04:40] SPEAKER_02: Thanks again, listeners, for spending time with us.
[1:04:43] SPEAKER_02: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[1:04:45] SPEAKER_01: Goodbye.
[1:04:46] SPEAKER_02: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
