# 71. Procedural Checklist (w/T. David Gordon)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 11 Feb 2025, 57 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/16598511-71-procedural-checklist-w-t-david-gordon.mp3

Procedural Checklist for PCA BCO Rules of Discipline Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Transcript

[0:08] SPEAKER_03: Hello and welcome to Penny Manners.
[0:10] SPEAKER_03: My name is Jared Nelson.
[0:11] SPEAKER_03: I'm joined by Nice Gun Edinburgh.
[0:13] SPEAKER_03: Ben is absent, I think taking a tour of uh Blue Bunny ice cream or something.
[0:18] SPEAKER_03: Um today we have a special guest, a uh fellow member of my Presbytery, a uh former professor at Grove City, and I believe uh Gordon uh college before that, uh Dr.
[0:30] SPEAKER_03: T.
[0:30] SPEAKER_03: David Gordon.
[0:31] SPEAKER_03: Welcome.
[0:34] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, thanks.
[0:34] SPEAKER_01: Good be here.
[0:35] SPEAKER_01: It was Gordon Campbell, by the way, uh not Gordon College.
[0:39] SPEAKER_01: Okay.
[0:39] SPEAKER_01: So I was I was at the semin I was at the seminary for about 14 years before coming to Grove City.
[0:45] SPEAKER_03: Well, you have uh some other things that are on your resume too.
[0:48] SPEAKER_03: Uh you've authored uh some books.
[0:51] SPEAKER_03: I think I first encountered you about 15 years ago.
[0:54] SPEAKER_03: I was uh at uh another seminary that was not uh reformed at Dallas Theological Seminary, but there was a group of us that were reading through uh why Johnny Can't Preach, which really helped influence uh my approach uh to preaching, uh actually got me to read some poetry.
[1:11] SPEAKER_03: So that was a that was a first for me.
[1:13] SPEAKER_03: Um but you've uh you've written some other uh things.
[1:16] SPEAKER_03: Do you want to tell us a little bit about uh some of your other books?
[1:19] SPEAKER_03: And you have a new one that you just authored?
[1:23] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, um uh I also wrote Why Johnny Can't Sing Hymns, How Pop Culture rewrote the hymnal.
[1:32] SPEAKER_01: And both of the Johnny books were, of course, influenced by the original Why Johnny Can't Read uh and then Why Johnny Can't Write.
[1:40] SPEAKER_01: And then the subtitle for each reflected 18 years of teaching media ecology and probably 40 years of reading and studying media ecology.
[1:48] SPEAKER_01: So you'll note the uh casual reference to Marshall McLuhan in the subtitle to the first, The Media Have Shaped the Messengers.
[1:56] SPEAKER_01: Uh and then in the second one, how pop culture rewrote the hymnal.
[1:59] SPEAKER_01: Students of musicology um have argued that the period from 1890 to 1930 was a revolution uh in music.
[2:10] SPEAKER_01: Um so, in fact, in uh uh Dr.
[2:13] SPEAKER_01: Swiesman's book, he's at the University of uh Delaware in Wilmington.
[2:18] SPEAKER_01: Um it's called Selling Sounds: The Commercial Revolution in Music.
[2:24] SPEAKER_01: And a very similar book came out around 2010 by Mark Katz, who was then at UNC and is now at the Peabody Institute at Johns Hopkins uh Music Institute.
[2:35] SPEAKER_01: Um, he wrote, interestingly, Capturing Sound.
[2:38] SPEAKER_01: And in the same year, Capturing Sound and Selling Sounds came out.
[2:42] SPEAKER_01: And what both argued and many others is music was not a commercial commodity until that period, 1890 to 1930.
[2:49] SPEAKER_01: And then the uh player piano appeared, the gramophone appeared, and later long play records and so forth.
[2:55] SPEAKER_01: But prior to 1890, all music had a human attached.
[2:59] SPEAKER_01: There was no way to mass produce it.
[3:01] SPEAKER_01: And so uh it was not a commercial product, it was a very serious thing.
[3:06] SPEAKER_01: So now everywhere you go, you're you are forced to listen to um uh music that you didn't solicit.
[3:13] SPEAKER_01: Uh and it shapes our musical sensibilities, you see.
[3:15] SPEAKER_01: So when I say how pop culture rewrote the Himmel, what I mean is that um we learn music in many ways the way we learn English.
[3:23] SPEAKER_01: A young 10-year-old boy, you know, in France today is speaking French, and a 10-year-old boy in Pittsburgh is speaking something approximating English.
[3:31] SPEAKER_01: Um, and the reason is because they grew up in a culture where they heard the sounds respectively of French and English.
[3:38] SPEAKER_01: So also, if people fill up their car with gas at sheets and they hear, you know, 60s or 70s or 80s pop music, and then they go inside of sheets, you know, to purchase a Coca-Cola and they hear it there, and they go to the men's room and cheats and they hear it there.
[3:53] SPEAKER_01: Well, it's hard to take music seriously as a serious thing in a culture where when you're pooping or filling the gas in your car, whatever you're doing, you're surrounded by this what I call crappy music because they play it in the restaurant, right?
[4:07] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so it's hard to believe that music once was defined by the Greek adjective musicae, derivative of the muses.
[4:14] SPEAKER_01: They thought it was so sublime that it must have come down to us from the six daughters or seven daughters of Athena.
[4:21] SPEAKER_01: And so to say something was musical is to say it was of above ordinary social consequence, and now nothing is less consequential than music.
[4:28] SPEAKER_01: And so it's really altered the whole sociological role and function.
[4:33] SPEAKER_01: So those books were both, you know, sort of media ecologically informed books.
[4:37] SPEAKER_01: Um, you know, uh my theological education is like anybody else, is an M-A R and a THM, and maybe a PhD in biblical studies on top of that.
[4:44] SPEAKER_01: But um, I don't think I have any real theological insights, but I did have some, I think, media ecological insights.
[4:51] SPEAKER_01: And then in 2019, um uh promised law of faith, uh covenant historical reasoning in Galatians appeared, uh, in which I argued that Paul's reasoning throughout the letter is covenant historical, not merely redemptive historical, but covenant historical.
[5:09] SPEAKER_01: Um, so he understands the new covenant and its relationship temporally to the Abrahamic covenant and the Sinai covenant.
[5:16] SPEAKER_01: And then I just sent the manuscript of the sequel about a year about a month ago to Hendrickson, and it will come out and it'll be the covenant historical reasoning in Romans.
[5:25] SPEAKER_01: And so those will be the bookends.
[5:27] SPEAKER_01: I did my dissertation under Paul Ochtemeyer on Paul's understanding of the law.
[5:31] SPEAKER_01: So it's the only thing that I've studied seriously as an academic for 40 years, is that the question.
[5:37] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so that'll be that.
[5:38] SPEAKER_01: But yeah, this April uh uh my little book uh came out from uh P and R, must be upstairs somewhere, uh, called um uh uh Choose Better, uh, five Biblical models for making ethical decisions, um, in which I define ethics as uh not something that's narrow, but something that grows out of anthropology.
[6:00] SPEAKER_01: The human's a decision-making creature.
[6:02] SPEAKER_01: Um, we're a choice-making creature, we're the only form of animate life that really makes consequential choices, and we make hundreds of them daily.
[6:10] SPEAKER_01: And so uh to embrace that as part of the image of God, and then to think well about how we go out making decisions uh is the purpose of the book.
[6:18] SPEAKER_01: And so I in the course of you know 30 or 40 years of studies, I found what I call five models of ethics um uh a law model, an imitation model, a wisdom model, a warfare model, and a communion model, five different ways of finding uh wisdom to live well uh before God.
[6:37] SPEAKER_01: So, yeah, I've done some of those kinds of things and done the occasional article and journals, both academic and non-academic.
[6:46] SPEAKER_01: I have a congregant that's reading.
[6:48] SPEAKER_01: And now that I'm kind of working on because it grows out of the Oh good.
[6:54] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I'm I'm I do I I designed it, you know, to be used by uh lay people, and my hope is that Christian colleges might use it in a freshman course on you know Christian life, and especially that Christian um in classical education uh high schools would use it.
[7:09] SPEAKER_01: I certainly hope that it's accessible uh you know to 10th and 11th graders.
[7:14] SPEAKER_01: Um because uh you know they're gonna make a lifetime of choices.
[7:18] SPEAKER_01: And our tradition, you know, is law model dominant, law model heavy.
[7:22] SPEAKER_01: And so our tradition is comfortable saying as you know, God said do this or don't do that, but we're not as comfortable dealing with issues of how we imitate God as his image.
[7:34] SPEAKER_01: We're not as uh comfortable with the wisdom model of making decisions, it seems to me, um, and not as comfortable with uh thinking quorum deo and living as a life of communion with God uh as we are the others.
[7:45] SPEAKER_01: And I don't think we really believe seriously that there's an invisible warfare going on all around us and that everything we do either contributes to our health and that of others or it does does the opposite.
[7:57] SPEAKER_01: Um so if you think about a British football, not American football, uh, on either side of the stadium, you know, you might you might have Leeds and Manchester United playing uh against one another.
[8:08] SPEAKER_01: And uh and they sit on different sides of the field and and they try to drown each other out by singing their songs, you know, right?
[8:14] SPEAKER_01: They all have their kind of their fight song for their team.
[8:17] SPEAKER_01: And and you and you hear 15,000 people singing this song, and then 20,000 people on the other side singing theirs back, trying to drown each other out.
[8:24] SPEAKER_01: It's almost like the prophets of Baal and the prophets of Yahweh having their contest out there, you see.
[8:30] SPEAKER_01: Well, I I think more silently than uh British football, uh, there is such a reality going on all around us.
[8:37] SPEAKER_01: There's a warfare contending for the souls and contending against everything that is lovely and everything that is life-sustaining.
[8:45] SPEAKER_01: Um, and every decision we make ought to at least be cognizant of that reality and adjust to it.
[8:51] SPEAKER_03: Well, along the uh the theme of ethics um is actually a document that maybe people have your books on their shelf, but if you're in the PCA and you are an elder, uh you we uh you probably have your document either in their computer or printed off, um, especially if they've ever had to go on go through uh discipline, and that is um a procedural checklist um for the BCO rules of discipline.
[9:19] SPEAKER_03: And um I I remember somebody sending this to me early on.
[9:23] SPEAKER_03: This is what you need to know, especially when you come for your BCO exam, or if you ever get involved in process and um your name was always on there, and then I I came into the presbytery that you're in at and was like, hey, I know that guy.
[9:33] SPEAKER_03: I read that book, and then I read the checklist.
[9:35] SPEAKER_03: Um so I I wonder, um, we wanted to take you a little bit about that checklist because it'd be of interest to people who follow us.
[9:41] SPEAKER_03: We're about ready to go through the the rules for discipline.
[9:45] SPEAKER_03: Um can you tell us a little bit about where did this checklist uh come from?
[9:50] SPEAKER_03: Uh was it prompted by something for you to put this uh this thing together?
[9:53] SPEAKER_03: And we'll have a link uh for it in our our show notes too.
[9:58] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, thanks for asking that because the uh understanding the genesis of things is a good part of understanding the thing itself.
[10:04] SPEAKER_01: So for the last nine or 10 years that I was at Gordon Conwell, um, I taught the course on denominational standards, and it was called Presbyterian and Reformed Denominational Standards.
[10:15] SPEAKER_01: So it's an it was an interdenominational seminary, and yet one requirement for the MDiv is you took a course on your denomination's peculiar standards.
[10:24] SPEAKER_01: Normally that was a weekend course taught on a Friday night and a Saturday by some local clergyman.
[10:31] SPEAKER_01: The Methodist would send their clergy, uh, mainline presbyterians send their.
[10:35] SPEAKER_01: But I I taught it as a regular full semester 13-week course.
[10:39] SPEAKER_01: Uh, by the way, I still have the bibliography for that.
[10:42] SPEAKER_01: I've added to it some others.
[10:43] SPEAKER_01: The bibliography is probably 25 pages.
[10:45] SPEAKER_01: Uh and uh so uh it was pretty lengthy.
[10:48] SPEAKER_01: And one of my students at the time, uh Chris Robinson, uh, as his project for that course, decided to put the uh the checklist together to translate the BCAO, which is catch us, catch can, mentioning a procedure here and a process there.
[11:07] SPEAKER_01: And uh we I think I was moderating a trial at Presbytery at the time or something.
[11:11] SPEAKER_01: And so Chris decided uh ask if that would work for his thesis for the course, for his project for the course.
[11:18] SPEAKER_01: So it was really Chris Robinson who put most of it together.
[11:21] SPEAKER_01: And, you know, uh I collaborated a little bit and we chatted some, I suppose.
[11:25] SPEAKER_01: Um, and what we were both concerned with is the book of church order uh is not uh designed or written uh in an order that reflects the procedural order.
[11:38] SPEAKER_01: And so what happens is uh when people are trying to do their best uh to do process according to uh the standards of our constitution, they they actually find it uh frustrating.
[11:51] SPEAKER_01: Uh Scott, perhaps you found it frustrating yourself because I think many people do.
[11:56] SPEAKER_01: Uh you're going through there, you're you're sort of taking uh you photocopy the whole book of discipline, as it were, then you go back with you know with a marker of some sort and you mark everything that you know needs attention, and then you go back to those and say, in what order?
[12:10] SPEAKER_01: Which basically means everyone who's ever done discipline in the PCA did what I did.
[12:15] SPEAKER_01: They just didn't publish it, right?
[12:17] SPEAKER_01: That is to say, they all did the same thing Chris and I did.
[12:20] SPEAKER_01: And that's a lot of reinventing of the same wheel.
[12:23] SPEAKER_01: Um, so now we did this back in the uh late 80s, early 90s.
[12:29] SPEAKER_01: And one of the unfortunate realities is there's there has been at least one that I know of, uh, and possibly two changes in judicial process since the checklist was made.
[12:41] SPEAKER_01: So there's at least one lacuna, and there might be two.
[12:45] SPEAKER_01: Um and um and I stopped attending General Assembly uh in the last century.
[12:52] SPEAKER_01: I haven't been in over 25 years.
[12:54] SPEAKER_01: I've I've been priced out of General Assembly, so I don't I wasn't even in my native Richmond this summer.
[12:58] SPEAKER_01: Um, I grew up there.
[13:00] SPEAKER_01: I was an elder at Stumble Point, I was a founding elder at the uh uh All Saints there on Grove Avenue, had lots of friends and relatives and still didn't go.
[13:08] SPEAKER_01: Um so unfortunately, but by not attending over the last 20 years, whenever there's something that happens that might affect the checklist, I'm not there to notice it.
[13:18] SPEAKER_01: And so uh someone needs to go back through at some point um and uh uh find it find some hapless student at a seminary somewhere to find uh what's missing and uh and update the list.
[13:32] SPEAKER_01: Um and of course, if we weren't in the PCA, it have if I had done it once, it would have never needed to be redone.
[13:40] SPEAKER_01: But one of the hapless things about our hapless communion is that our constitution is a moving target that potentially changes every year.
[13:48] SPEAKER_01: And no other communion has ever functioned that way.
[13:50] SPEAKER_01: And arguably we don't either, we don't function well that way.
[13:53] SPEAKER_01: But uh you you just never know when the constitution will change.
[13:58] SPEAKER_01: So even people who try to follow it find it exasperating because every two to three years the Book of Church Order changes.
[14:06] SPEAKER_01: Um the ARP has one of these, you know, just every if the ARP has one of these, then it's uh it's about 200 years old.
[14:14] SPEAKER_03: The their checklist going through there hasn't changed.
[14:17] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[14:17] SPEAKER_01: What you find is an imperfect constitution that everyone's familiar with works better than a more perfect constitution that no one's familiar with.
[14:24] SPEAKER_01: And so in in most communities, you know, maybe every 70 years or so you consider uh modifying your constitution because you have found some problems with it.
[14:34] SPEAKER_01: But the alternative is even those of us who believe in constitutional government, we we believe it's an important check on our sinful tendencies.
[14:43] SPEAKER_01: So to have a constitution external to Gordon uh protects the church from Gordon's impulses and this stupidity and so forth.
[14:49] SPEAKER_01: So it's good to have a constitution, and I tried to follow it.
[14:52] SPEAKER_01: Uh, but the problem is our changes so often it frustrates those of us who try to follow it.
[14:57] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's kind of connected to we have probably the most thorough uh rules of discipline of Napark.
[15:04] SPEAKER_00: And the more details that you add to the rules of discipline, the more subject to scrutiny they are, and the more then they need to theoretically be changed to make them better.
[15:15] SPEAKER_00: Um and so we I was looking at the OPC's rules of discipline, and I'm like, wow, this is so so simple.
[15:21] SPEAKER_00: Um there's so many uh guardrails, and it's still confusing, even with the more guardrails than other traditions.
[15:31] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[15:32] SPEAKER_01: And I don't know if the two of you have observed this or not, but uh remember, constitution is what constitutes us.
[15:39] SPEAKER_01: Isn't that interesting?
[15:39] SPEAKER_01: You know, that's what the word means.
[15:41] SPEAKER_01: And so what happens is our constitution also in some sense disciplines us and shapes us.
[15:47] SPEAKER_01: And unfortunately, in the case of our constitution, um it it makes us think that there's a procedural solution to every problem.
[15:57] SPEAKER_01: And that's not true, right?
[15:59] SPEAKER_01: There's no procedural solution to Adamic sin.
[16:02] SPEAKER_01: If if if so, you know, we would have all followed that solution years ago.
[16:06] SPEAKER_01: But there isn't one, right?
[16:08] SPEAKER_01: It's only the grace of God that deals with it.
[16:10] SPEAKER_01: So I've noticed even in our little presbytery, and we now have uh an entire chapter on this, on the standing rules, you know, the new chapter 7-2, that mentions six different things that can and should be and must be done whenever a discipline matter comes before the stated clerk.
[16:27] SPEAKER_01: And I'm thinking, well, what did he do before that?
[16:31] SPEAKER_01: Well, he just exercised his judgment and probably consulted the chairman of the ARC, and if he thought it was significant, asked the chairman of the ARC to call an ad hoc meeting of the ARC to advise the stated clerk.
[16:45] SPEAKER_01: Now we have a two-page document that we did not follow correctly two weeks ago at our presbytery.
[16:50] SPEAKER_01: And I'm on the subcommittee studying it right now, and I'm arguing to give it right back to the presbytery because it didn't tell us which of the six things we're supposed to do.
[16:58] SPEAKER_01: And since we don't know which of the six things we're supposed to do, I argue that we should give it back to them and let them realize that this new fancy multiple procedure thing is not working very well because the first time we tried it, it didn't, right?
[17:11] SPEAKER_01: So one of the unfortunate things in the PCA is we we keep adding, don't we, Scott?
[17:16] SPEAKER_01: We keep adding amendments to the book, thinking there has to be a procedural solution here.
[17:23] SPEAKER_01: And there's there's there's no substitute for just Christian compassion and and common sense.
[17:31] SPEAKER_03: So imagine um then somebody who is coming in to a PCA church, he's a new teaching elder, maybe in his first couple years, um, and he's looking at this, and this is this is kind of overwhelming to him how much is in uh the rules of discipline, and he he comes across your checklist and he's realizing there's something that's gonna come up in his church um that's that's gonna require process of some sort.
[17:55] SPEAKER_03: How does he use this uh this checklist?
[17:58] SPEAKER_03: How does he uh approach it?
[18:00] SPEAKER_03: Um does he just kind of pick it up and just start going through and then make his way through the 15 pages, or uh how would you what would you suggest he does as he's approaching uh needing to do process?
[18:10] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think that uh he should make a photocopy of it and then um he should treat it the way Mortimer Adler tells us to treat a book, which is to make marginalia.
[18:19] SPEAKER_01: Um and so I think that as he looks at the checklist, the first thing he should do is uh go down the list and say, are all these things already clear to me?
[18:28] SPEAKER_01: Right.
[18:29] SPEAKER_01: And if not, put a question mark in the margin because they'll they will normally have a BCO reference.
[18:35] SPEAKER_01: And then once he's gone through the list and says, you know, let's say there's 12 things, and he says, you know, nine or ten of them I'm pretty sure I'm familiar with, but there's two or three that I'm not at all uh confident they even understand, uh, then he can go back and actually read the pertinent passages there to be sure that he understands um more than the mere skeleton of a checklist, what the substance of each of those uh is.
[18:59] SPEAKER_01: And then if he really has the time and inclination to do it, uh I think he should probably do what I recommend people do with Robert's rules too, and that is to realize that uh for all of the picking you nature of Robert's rules, it's basically just two broad principles to be fair and to be efficient.
[19:17] SPEAKER_01: And you can explain every single passage in Robert's rules is either designed for fairness or for efficiency.
[19:24] SPEAKER_01: And if you go back through the book of church order and the book of discipline and ask why are there so many processes, is this designed to make it fair?
[19:33] SPEAKER_01: Is this designed to make it efficient?
[19:35] SPEAKER_01: You'll find a similar thing works there.
[19:37] SPEAKER_01: And it really helps once you understand the wisdom behind the original framers, because this goes back to the second book of discipline, I'm sure.
[19:44] SPEAKER_01: Much of it goes all the way back to the Scottish second book.
[19:47] SPEAKER_01: Um, you can be sure there are very good reasons for the various things uh that were there, especially the broader ones.
[19:54] SPEAKER_01: Um in fact, many of them uh you could satisfy through natural law.
[19:59] SPEAKER_01: If if you look at the uh the the 10, the Bill of Rights, the original ten amendments to the Constitution, about five or six of them are what you and I would regard as picky matters of judicial process.
[20:09] SPEAKER_01: A right to have an indictment, to confront your accused, to uh offer uh your own uh rebuttal, um uh uh no undue search and seizure, uh and so forth.
[20:21] SPEAKER_01: So even by the light of human nature in the constitution of the human as a human being, um, the founding fathers understood that you know, if in procedural justice, we will not always in this earth attain true justice.
[20:36] SPEAKER_01: We await the return of Christ for true justice, but we can and must insist on procedural justice.
[20:43] SPEAKER_01: A person who has tried, been tried and found guilty may disagree with the finding, but he ought to be able to look the people in the eye and say, you know, you treated me fairly.
[20:51] SPEAKER_01: You you followed your own rules.
[20:53] SPEAKER_01: I was prepared to follow these rules, you did follow them, I was treated fairly.
[20:58] SPEAKER_01: I got procedural justice.
[21:00] SPEAKER_01: In my opinion, I didn't get actual justice, but I did get procedural justice.
[21:03] SPEAKER_01: And so it's not nothing to get procedural justice.
[21:06] SPEAKER_01: David Coffin taught me this years ago.
[21:09] SPEAKER_01: He really helped me to see that procedural justice is a wonderful expression of the law of charity, to do unto others as you have them do unto you.
[21:17] SPEAKER_01: And then when you see it that way, it's not just an external checklist of some sort that you have to follow, but you understand it's designed uh to treat people who are parties to a case of process the way you would like to be treated, the way you would like your loved ones to be treated if they had a case of process.
[21:36] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[21:36] SPEAKER_03: And not only the um the BCO and the um the Bill of Rights, but Matthew 18 has something of a process that you start with, you know, uh to go to them, to confront them, to bring a witness, and then at some point to tell it to the church.
[21:50] SPEAKER_03: And so I think I'll let um Scott ask some questions of once you get to that, tell it to the church um part of it, uh, some some detailed questions.
[21:58] SPEAKER_03: So I'll hand it over to Scott there.
[22:00] SPEAKER_00: Uh yeah, um perhaps a good place to start when thinking about the checklist and just general process in the PCA, or what are some of the common errors that you've seen in your ministry uh made by courts of the church when pursuing process?
[22:16] SPEAKER_01: I think the most common one um is um uh uh pursuing process prematurely.
[22:28] SPEAKER_01: Um I used to teach courses on uh elder training, uh not only in my own church, but in some churches in New Hampshire and New England, when we new churches were planted in Presbytery, we'd appoint people to educate the initial elders.
[22:42] SPEAKER_01: And of course, we covered the Westminster Standards and we covered the Constitution.
[22:47] SPEAKER_01: But then in my last session with them, I always covered a few practical matters.
[22:52] SPEAKER_01: And the very last thing I said every time was if you or anyone else on the session or the presbytery says, Well, we have to do something, lock him up and don't let him out until he gets over it.
[23:06] SPEAKER_01: Because when people feel frustrated and are unsure, that's exactly when they should not act, right?
[23:14] SPEAKER_01: But there's something in us as humans that when we feel frustrated and unsure, we do act, and that's the worst time to act.
[23:21] SPEAKER_01: And so um I think the most frequent problem I've seen is people resorting to formal process before they've exhausted the informal process.
[23:34] SPEAKER_01: That's the most common failure.
[23:36] SPEAKER_01: So, for instance, if you think about uh Matthew 18, um since Jared just mentioned that, um what's interesting about Matthew 18 is there are certain repetitions as you go through the, you know, and if you go do this and do this and tell it to this, especially the statement and tell it to them and tell it to them and so forth.
[23:54] SPEAKER_01: Um, but notice that the parallelism, parallelism is not complete, and it could be just for the sake of efficiency, but I think it's more than that.
[24:02] SPEAKER_01: Note then in the first phase, when you go to a brother alone, monon, it says, and if he listens, you have gained a brother.
[24:11] SPEAKER_01: But in the second and third phases, it doesn't say if he listens, you've gained a brother, it says if he does not listen.
[24:19] SPEAKER_01: And that's because people who do not have the grace of God to resolve their matters privately are not going to find the matter resolved uh by public process.
[24:29] SPEAKER_01: So your last chance to actually be reconciled to a brother is when you go to him privately.
[24:33] SPEAKER_01: And that means if it means 10 meetings with him privately, you do that for as long as you possibly can.
[24:39] SPEAKER_01: And if you once you jump to formal process, I think the implicit teaching there of Matthew 18 is at that point, we don't even envision that you're gonna win a brother.
[24:48] SPEAKER_01: You're just gonna have justice established, but you're not gonna you're not gonna uh reconcile brothers once you have formal process.
[24:55] SPEAKER_01: And I don't think I've seen formal process unite people more than twice in my entire lifetime.
[25:01] SPEAKER_01: In 40 years of being an elder or a pastor, um I don't think I've seen it more than twice.
[25:07] SPEAKER_01: I do recall that once at Stony Point, woman had been uh excommunicated because she had an adulterous affair.
[25:13] SPEAKER_01: And uh she later moved, I believe, from Richmond to Atlanta, and like eight, and they and the elders prayed for her for eight years, you know.
[25:22] SPEAKER_01: And at some point they got a phone call and she was moving back to Richmond and they said, Have you changed jobs?
[25:28] SPEAKER_01: And she said, No, I need to be reconciled to God and to this church.
[25:31] SPEAKER_01: I need to come back to Stony Point and repent of my sin and ask to be received back into membership of the church, which was a mind blower, right?
[25:39] SPEAKER_01: But it's also a mind blower because it happens so rarely.
[25:43] SPEAKER_01: So um I know that's that's the highest goal of discipline.
[25:47] SPEAKER_01: Uh, right.
[25:48] SPEAKER_01: That's your goal.
[25:49] SPEAKER_01: And so if Matthew 18 is right, of course it's right.
[25:52] SPEAKER_01: Um the thing to do is to exhaust what can be done at the informal stage before we go to the formal stage, because the formal stage so rarely works.
[26:02] SPEAKER_01: Now, when I say rarely works, it rarely works at reconciling the parties.
[26:06] SPEAKER_01: If someone really has wronged someone else, then justice um requires a public accounting of that.
[26:12] SPEAKER_01: And so, yes, justice can be satisfied, but the relationship will not be healed by formal process, almost never.
[26:19] SPEAKER_01: It just doesn't do it.
[26:21] SPEAKER_01: So that's the most frequent one, Scott.
[26:23] SPEAKER_01: The most frequent one I've seen is people wanting to move to judicial process quickly, like the motion at our presbytery last two weeks ago, right?
[26:32] SPEAKER_01: We did not uh answer 34 or 5.
[26:34] SPEAKER_01: I stood and raised it about uh it is it does it strike at the violence of religion and is spread industriously.
[26:42] SPEAKER_01: We didn't ask the person involved or his elder whether this was spread industriously, or was the MR committee the only people he person he'd ever told us to, right?
[26:52] SPEAKER_01: So we didn't satisfy that mental because bang, we had a process before us.
[26:56] SPEAKER_01: We were going right through to the process of uh standing rules 7-2 and ready to go to process.
[27:02] SPEAKER_01: And I'm gonna throw it right back at Presbytery if I have anything to do with it.
[27:04] SPEAKER_01: We'll come right back to the next meeting and say, We're not, no, sir, brothers, you told us to do this and we didn't do it.
[27:09] SPEAKER_01: We're not going to do it.
[27:10] SPEAKER_01: And if you want someone else to do it, get another committee to do it because we are not going to do it, right?
[27:14] SPEAKER_01: Uh, because there are people in our presbytery who think the first thing to do whenever there's a problem is to institute process.
[27:22] SPEAKER_01: And I think it's the last thing you should do.
[27:24] SPEAKER_00: But and so when when does process start?
[27:27] SPEAKER_00: Um, does that start at the moment of a judicial commission with an investigative committee?
[27:32] SPEAKER_00: How would you see the distinctions between those two?
[27:35] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I uh I'm not sure that we should have investigative committees because I don't read 31.2 the way the PCA reads 31.2.
[27:43] SPEAKER_01: Um, so I'd say it by the way, the reason is if you look at the 1933 book, um, the 1933 book uh does not have a paragraph break in there.
[27:55] SPEAKER_01: And it says um that uh that a person might to clear his name request an investigation.
[28:05] SPEAKER_01: And then the next sentence is if such investigation, however proceeding, leads to a strong presumption of guilt.
[28:14] SPEAKER_01: In the original 1933 book, that's all within one paragraph.
[28:18] SPEAKER_01: And the such investigation refers to the previous sentence and the use of the word investigation there.
[28:23] SPEAKER_01: But if you make it a separate paragraph, which the PCA did, I think, just by typographical error, I don't think they were thinking about it.
[28:29] SPEAKER_01: Now the such investigation could refer to the entirety of that first paragraph, including the regular inspection we have over people under our care and so forth.
[28:37] SPEAKER_01: So you routinely run into people saying, We, I think we should have a 31-2 investigation.
[28:42] SPEAKER_01: And I say there is no such thing as a 31-2 investigation unless the person who feels aggrieved by things requests such an investigation.
[28:49] SPEAKER_01: And that's what such investigation means in the next sentence.
[28:52] SPEAKER_01: And you can look at it in the 1933 book.
[28:54] SPEAKER_01: There is no break there.
[28:55] SPEAKER_01: It's all one paragraph.
[28:56] SPEAKER_01: PCA inserts a double space and makes a new paragraph so that such refers to the entire paragraph, not to the previous sentence.
[29:03] SPEAKER_01: And so wittingly or unwittingly, it altered what the thing said.
[29:07] SPEAKER_01: So to answer your question, yeah, I don't think process begins until some court of the church appoints some agent or or assumes to itself agency in the matter and orders that an indictment be drawn up and a prosecutor be appointed.
[29:26] SPEAKER_00: I appreciated your checklist when um the church I served had to deal with some of um a case of prominence.
[29:34] SPEAKER_00: Um but when we got to the trial, I remember thinking the the checklist is good, but how does this look in reality, if that makes sense?
[29:44] SPEAKER_00: What does a trial actually look like?
[29:46] SPEAKER_00: Could you perhaps comment on um what a trial, the day of a trial looks like in a church court?
[29:54] SPEAKER_01: Maybe a little bit.
[29:56] SPEAKER_01: I know that for instance, uh using the checklist or using one's own checklist, um one of the problems are there are certain things that have to be done.
[30:06] SPEAKER_01: And in our presbytery, it has been our custom to do those things and nothing else.
[30:12] SPEAKER_01: And I don't think fulfilling the checklist means that's all that you can do.
[30:16] SPEAKER_01: So, for instance, in in our presbytery, the people who are on the floor are not given an opportunity to ask questions, either of the accused andor of the accused counsel or the prosecutor.
[30:29] SPEAKER_01: Um, and and so we've had cases where I abstained because the question that I thought was the obvious question that the prosecutor should have asked, he didn't ask.
[30:39] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so the question that I think sort of solved the matter just like that was never asked, and there was no occasion for anyone to ask it.
[30:47] SPEAKER_01: So I would say that in addition to the checklist, if a person just raises his hand and seeks the floor from the moderator and says, Mr.
[30:54] SPEAKER_01: Moderator, um, may those of us uh who are present also ask questions.
[30:59] SPEAKER_01: Um, not argue.
[31:01] SPEAKER_01: Not, you know, the time of deliberation is later, I understand that.
[31:04] SPEAKER_01: But I think everyone present should be able to ask questions which they need to have answered.
[31:09] SPEAKER_01: Um so we we had a dispute, you know, seven or eight years ago in a case in our presbytery where uh the accused and the accuser disagreed over whether they had met to discuss a certain matter, right?
[31:27] SPEAKER_01: Neither was present when the other was uh questioned.
[31:30] SPEAKER_01: And the accuser was asked, did you meet with so-and-so about this?
[31:35] SPEAKER_01: And he said, I tried to and he refused.
[31:38] SPEAKER_01: And then the accused was never asked, Did you refuse to meet with this guy?
[31:42] SPEAKER_01: Instead, he he said, Oh, we met many times, right?
[31:47] SPEAKER_01: It I would have said when and where.
[31:49] SPEAKER_01: I don't mean the exact date and time, but was it at McDonald's roughly last March?
[31:54] SPEAKER_01: Or was it, you know, at Popeye's last April?
[31:58] SPEAKER_01: And then we go back and ask the author, he says he did meet with you at Popeye's in April or McDonald's in March, right?
[32:05] SPEAKER_01: Um, and and you could get to the heart of the matter.
[32:08] SPEAKER_01: But in this case, we we never understood whether the accuser was right and the accused was wrong because we never had a chance to cross-examine.
[32:17] SPEAKER_01: So I think the checklist is the minimum that we have to do, the constitution requires us to do.
[32:22] SPEAKER_01: But I think any presbytery, in its own judgment, if it thinks it needs to raise more questions or even to re-examine certain witnesses, it should have the right to do so.
[32:32] SPEAKER_01: Otherwise, it comes down to two people being on their A game every time, right?
[32:35] SPEAKER_01: The prosecutor has to be on his A game, and the defense attorney has to be on his A game.
[32:40] SPEAKER_01: And if either one of them isn't, now we decide a thing because one of them wasn't on his A game.
[32:45] SPEAKER_01: And that's not the right way to do it.
[32:49] SPEAKER_01: So you have to follow the rules, yes, but but you shouldn't feel limited to following the rules.
[32:54] SPEAKER_01: You should also do things that contribute to justice.
[32:59] SPEAKER_00: What are some um active met proactive measures that pastors can take to make sure that everyone's rights are um protected?
[33:11] SPEAKER_01: Uh well, you make sure that they have a copy of the pertinent parts of the book of church order, that they understand the constitution, that they don't uh they don't run into it on the first uh for the first time, you know, we're in the they're on the uh accused end of it, as it were.
[33:28] SPEAKER_01: Uh, and you try to help them see uh how those processes are designed to protect them.
[33:34] SPEAKER_01: Um and then you you offer uh to be their counsel and advocate.
[33:39] SPEAKER_01: Uh I've offered to uh be advocate for people that I thought were guilty.
[33:45] SPEAKER_01: Um, and I don't mind doing that.
[33:47] SPEAKER_01: I the point would be you make the best case you can.
[33:50] SPEAKER_01: And I in fact, I've had cases in the presbytery where I volunteer to be either the prosecutor or the defense counsel and and let the committee decide which one.
[33:58] SPEAKER_01: Because to me, it's an administrative matter and it should be done as an administrative matter.
[34:03] SPEAKER_01: It's a clerical matter where you make sure that you put before the court the pertinent things.
[34:07] SPEAKER_01: It's not like you see it on television.
[34:08] SPEAKER_01: In fact, real court is not like what you see on television and the church courts aren't either.
[34:13] SPEAKER_01: It shouldn't be just a perfectly straightforward thing that anyone could do.
[34:16] SPEAKER_01: We should be able to draw names from a hat from Presbytery and say, okay, Nelson, you're going to be the prosecutor.
[34:23] SPEAKER_01: Gordon, you're going to be defense, right?
[34:26] SPEAKER_01: Any of us should be able to do that when called upon to do so.
[34:29] SPEAKER_01: And if everyone was called on to do so that way, we would all get better at it, too.
[34:35] SPEAKER_01: By the way, one of the European nations used to have a similar thing.
[34:39] SPEAKER_01: Um, one of the European nations uh attorneys were were not privately employed by law firms, they were employed by the state.
[34:48] SPEAKER_01: And a judge would appoint a prosecutor and a defense attorney.
[34:53] SPEAKER_01: And you you might spend half of your career defending and half of your career prosecuting.
[34:57] SPEAKER_01: No one could buy a better lawyer.
[34:58] SPEAKER_01: OJ couldn't buy a better lawyer in such a nation because the court was going to appoint the lawyer for them.
[35:05] SPEAKER_01: And the reason some nations did that is to avoid and evade what's obviously the case in the United States, that if you don't have money, you're going to be in jail for 30 days awaiting arraignment or trial.
[35:17] SPEAKER_01: And if you do have money, you're out on bail.
[35:20] SPEAKER_01: And if you have money, you're probably going to have good defense.
[35:23] SPEAKER_01: Uh, and if you don't have money, you're going to have poor uh court ordered defense.
[35:28] SPEAKER_01: And so, yeah, you buy and sell justice in the United States.
[35:33] SPEAKER_00: Dunning back perhaps to thinking about the origin of accusations.
[35:38] SPEAKER_00: Um what how when someone has an offense against another believer, whether it be a pastor or likewise, um, how should that unfold?
[35:47] SPEAKER_00: And I know that you mentioned perhaps your own disagreement in 31.2 and 31.1 um in the BCO with its original um draft.
[35:58] SPEAKER_00: Um, but how when someone has a grievance or issue that they feel like they've exhausted all their options, uh, how should that be submitted to the court?
[36:07] SPEAKER_01: What should it look like?
[36:08] SPEAKER_01: There's one small step in between, and that is that um you look at 1 Corinthians 7 and say, is it a small, comparatively insignificant matter?
[36:20] SPEAKER_01: Paul, I think it's translated trivial or trifling in most translations, right?
[36:25] SPEAKER_01: So um, and Paul says in some cases it's probably better to suffer wrong.
[36:28] SPEAKER_01: So everyone should consider when they've been wrong, uh, whether it's the kind of thing that they uh they should just let go.
[36:35] SPEAKER_01: Um, and then if they say, I don't, for a variety of reasons, I don't think I can let it go.
[36:40] SPEAKER_01: It might touch upon the person's professional higher ability and this kind of a thing.
[36:45] SPEAKER_01: Um, then if a person finds that it's not trifling, but it's very serious, then uh I think probably at a minimum, what what he does at that point is he contacts the other person one more time and says, uh, I'd like you uh to do me a favor, I'd like you to talk me about, talk me out of what I'm about to do.
[37:03] SPEAKER_01: Because what I'm about to do is to institute formal process against you.
[37:08] SPEAKER_01: And so we haven't been able to resolve this before.
[37:11] SPEAKER_01: And so I feel that I'm now obliged to seek formal redress of my grievance, but I'd like to be talked out of it.
[37:19] SPEAKER_01: And I'd like to give you one more chance to be reconciled to me and me to you, so that we don't have to proceed there.
[37:26] SPEAKER_01: To my knowledge, no one has ever done that in the history of the world since Adam.
[37:29] SPEAKER_01: Right.
[37:30] SPEAKER_01: But to me, it makes perfectly imminent sense that everyone ought to do it, right?
[37:35] SPEAKER_01: That we ought to make that final stab at reconciliation before before formal process.
[37:40] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[37:41] SPEAKER_01: And then after that, of course, we we we try to find someone with a little bit more experience than ourselves to make sure that we make our formal process in an appropriate, constitutionally valid way.
[37:51] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[37:52] unknown: Yeah.
[37:53] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[37:54] SPEAKER_00: As a clerk of a presbytery, I sometimes receive 31-2 kind of Christian character reports that are like just like a scatter shot of a shotgun, where it's like every single little grievance that was ever perpetrated is included in their accusation.
[38:11] SPEAKER_00: And it's sometimes difficult for the presbytery to handle such a wide shot.
[38:16] SPEAKER_00: Um, because some of them might actually rise to the occasion of judicial process, while others are um petty, you know, they're not, they're they're very small, you looked at me the wrong way, kind of things.
[38:27] SPEAKER_00: And so sometimes it's hard to separate those as you just get like almost a regurgitation of everything that's ever been wrong.
[38:36] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that's right.
[38:37] SPEAKER_01: And if you give counsel to people and if they ask your counsel at a time like that, you can say, well, if you want to lose your case, leave it in the form that it currently is, then you're guaranteed to lose.
[38:49] SPEAKER_01: Because the notion that a hundred bad arguments is better than one good argument won't won't fly in court.
[38:54] SPEAKER_01: It's just the opposite.
[38:56] SPEAKER_01: Um, the person who alleges that the pastor has wronged them, let's say 20 times because you uh was curt with them one day when they ask a question or whatever it is, you know.
[39:05] SPEAKER_01: Um, what will happen is human nature being human nature, people will say, well, they he they're just throwing stuff at him until something sticks.
[39:12] SPEAKER_01: Um, so it's it's also ill-advised.
[39:14] SPEAKER_01: What you what you should really boil it down to is there one thing or two things um that I feel aggrieved by?
[39:21] SPEAKER_01: And make the grievance as clear as you can.
[39:23] SPEAKER_01: It's also easier on the court to adjudicate that.
[39:27] SPEAKER_01: Yes.
[39:28] SPEAKER_01: But the problem is, you know, the way that the way that the boy in Pittsburgh speaks something approximating English, uh the problem is what most people know about uh judicial process they've learned from television.
[39:42] SPEAKER_01: And so they, you know, what makes good drama drama an interesting television program doesn't make good law or good process.
[39:51] SPEAKER_01: And so people mislearn uh many things about uh the judicial process that they bring with them unwittingly into this arena.
[40:03] SPEAKER_00: You know, that kind of gets me thinking about how the PCA has been internally debating or overhauling our rules of discipline.
[40:11] SPEAKER_00: Um perhaps could you help us distinguish between then like a civil, a civil trial from an ecclesiastical trial with its jurisdictions?
[40:19] SPEAKER_00: Because it seems that some are talking about almost conflating our ecclesiastical court system with the civil almost and merging them in some capacity just by how they're ran.
[40:32] SPEAKER_00: And so could you perhaps talk about the distinction between the two and their roles in society?
[40:37] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, their distinctions probably go back uh to their distinctions of the nature of the powers that God has given to them.
[40:46] SPEAKER_01: So, for instance, um the state um uh when it subpoenas you, they can find you in contempt of court if you do not attend the trial.
[40:57] SPEAKER_01: And uh we really have no provision for that and probably shouldn't.
[41:01] SPEAKER_01: Um but uh we certainly can't find people, right?
[41:05] SPEAKER_01: We can't we can't jail them, right?
[41:07] SPEAKER_01: Uh but they can, especially grand juries.
[41:10] SPEAKER_01: You know, grand juries are completely illegal.
[41:12] SPEAKER_01: I mean, they're utterly illegal.
[41:13] SPEAKER_01: We shouldn't have them, you know, they're contrary to the Constitution from the beginning to the end of almost because they're basically ways of conducting a pretrial without any of the protections that would be required by law in a real trial.
[41:24] SPEAKER_01: And yet they determine what goes to trial.
[41:26] SPEAKER_01: And so they're very influential in our system of government and they're highly irregular.
[41:30] SPEAKER_01: Um, but that's one of the big differences is that um the state has the power uh to subpoena witnesses.
[41:37] SPEAKER_01: We can invite them.
[41:38] SPEAKER_01: We we can say, you know, the Presbytery of the Ascension uh wishes you to be present on this date.
[41:43] SPEAKER_01: But uh I doubt we could do anything if people refuse uh to show up.
[41:47] SPEAKER_01: The other is that the uh the state doesn't make the distinction we make um between believers and unbelievers, which I think came up at a recent General Assembly, didn't it?
[41:56] SPEAKER_01: Um there were those who wanted to say we want pagans to run our church courts, um, and uh which strikes me as not a great great idea.
[42:04] SPEAKER_01: Uh so um that I think the sons of light and the sons of darkness have a few differences uh uh here and there, and and that would be one of them.
[42:12] SPEAKER_01: But yeah, in fact, the book even requires that they have to believe in an eternal state of reward and punishment, right?
[42:19] SPEAKER_01: They have to realize there are real consequences to this.
[42:22] SPEAKER_01: And one of the one of the consequences mentioned of the Book of Church Order that I don't recall occurring, um, but it ought to have occurred many times, um, is that in the section on uh voluntary prosecution, 31.3, 316, 319, in that section, 319 warrants that if a person presents himself as a voluntary prosecutor and does not prove the case, he may himself be censured as an accuser of the brethren, right?
[42:51] SPEAKER_01: And yet I don't know personally of an experience where a person who brought to the trial a matter that failed was ever disciplined for it.
[42:58] SPEAKER_01: But in the Mosaic law, especially if it was a capital crime, if you bore false witness in a capital crime, they put you to death.
[43:05] SPEAKER_01: I mean, that'll keep you honest, right?
[43:08] SPEAKER_01: So so there's it was basically, you know, if it's 20 years in prison and you bear false witness, you get the 20 years in prison.
[43:15] SPEAKER_01: If it's a capital crime and you bear false witness, you get killed.
[43:19] SPEAKER_01: And so uh whether there's skin in the game or not, you see, is an important part of the way our book looks at it.
[43:26] SPEAKER_01: And so if people don't believe in God or in an eternal state of reward and punishment, what skin do they have in the game?
[43:33] SPEAKER_01: There's really no motivation for them uh to speak the truth, because unlike in the civil courts, they can't be found in contempt of court, they can't be found guilty of perjury and so forth.
[43:43] SPEAKER_01: So there's really no other uh good motive for them uh to speak truthfully uh in our courts other than that they the fear of God, as it were.
[43:53] SPEAKER_01: That if you don't believe in God, how can you fear him?
[43:58] SPEAKER_03: Looking at the Infliction of like what it is that you do if you get to say a guilty uh verdict.
[44:04] SPEAKER_03: Um you have these different church uh censors because we are ministerial and declarative.
[44:10] SPEAKER_03: We don't have the power of the sword, so we can't lock them up.
[44:12] SPEAKER_03: Um I I think within the church that would just be like putting you on nursery committee to duty or something like that, right?
[44:18] SPEAKER_03: Um but um there's these different things that you can do.
[44:22] SPEAKER_03: Admonition, um, there's a suspension from uh the sacraments and there's excommunication.
[44:27] SPEAKER_03: And then if you're an officer, there's deposition or suspension from office.
[44:32] SPEAKER_03: Um I I have noticed the times in which I've uh been involved with something, whether it was a case with process or without, this seems to be the hardest one to figure out what do we what goes into what bucket of, you know, is this an admonition thing?
[44:46] SPEAKER_03: Is this a suspension from the table?
[44:48] SPEAKER_03: How how do we uh navigate when we get to the end of a process, what's what's the appropriate thing to um to find for a church uh censor?
[44:59] SPEAKER_01: Well, there's a little bit of advice, you know, in the book itself, in the chapter on censures, uh, so for instance, um, if a matter is not widely known, it's privately known, let's say a dispute between two or three parties and so forth, and uh and the guilty uh party uh declares his sorrow for what he's done, there's really no need to do anything more than admonition.
[45:22] SPEAKER_01: Uh that's this that's the the church's way, the church court's way of saying a wrongdoing was done, it was admittedly a wrongdoing, and uh and we admonish the person because uh we wanted to encourage his repentance.
[45:36] SPEAKER_01: Uh and if and then I think the book says that if it's if it's generally known, if it's a more public matter and so forth, then the public is in some sense demanding uh the church uh recognize the severity of the issue.
[45:50] SPEAKER_01: And so there are times when even if the accused is found guilty and uh expresses penitence, there's still occasions uh in uh in which the severity of the offense um requires at least a temporary suspension of some sort either from the sacrament uh or from office um uh because it satisfies the proportionality of justice.
[46:14] SPEAKER_01: That there are smaller offenses and greater offenses, and uh the standards even say that, right?
[46:19] SPEAKER_01: That they're not equally heinous.
[46:21] SPEAKER_01: They're things that aggregate aggravate uh offenses and make some more heinous than others.
[46:26] SPEAKER_01: So I think the public expects um that we proceed through degrees of censure and and and and that's why we have them.
[46:36] SPEAKER_01: Um we we don't do it well.
[46:38] SPEAKER_01: Um, I guess it's the good news is we don't do many do judicial cases, and the bad news is we don't do many judicial cases, so we don't learn to do it well.
[46:48] SPEAKER_01: And so um uh we had a you know a case a few years ago where there was an honest difference of opinion as to what the ninth commandment required.
[46:58] SPEAKER_01: Um and and so uh the individual who had presented himself as his own accuser on two grounds, one other ground, and uh the ninth commandment.
[47:07] SPEAKER_01: Um he he later stood in front of the whole presbytery and read through what are the sins and the ninth commandment.
[47:12] SPEAKER_01: He read the whole list out loud and said, I didn't do any of this.
[47:15] SPEAKER_01: Right.
[47:16] SPEAKER_01: And then we moved to a higher degree of censure than the original admonition just because he had an honest difference of opinion with us.
[47:22] SPEAKER_01: Now I thought it was utterly wrong for us to have done that.
[47:25] SPEAKER_01: Uh, we should have just left it.
[47:27] SPEAKER_01: There was no need for us to do anything at that point.
[47:29] SPEAKER_01: We'd already admonished him for two grounds that he had himself acknowledged, and now he was just informing us that had he to do it all over again, he would withdraw that second ground.
[47:39] SPEAKER_01: But that doesn't do the admonition that was already delivered.
[47:43] SPEAKER_01: And so we had already declared ourselves as a court of the church that we thought what he did violated the ninth commandment and we admonished him for it.
[47:52] SPEAKER_01: And now, if he doesn't think so, okay, that's a difference of opinion.
[47:54] SPEAKER_01: But we're we don't have to go any farther.
[47:56] SPEAKER_01: And we ended up driving that good brother out of the PCA entirely, right?
[48:00] SPEAKER_01: He's gone, right?
[48:01] SPEAKER_01: He probably hadn't had lunch with anyone in our presbytery since then.
[48:05] SPEAKER_01: And he was already a retired man at the time.
[48:07] SPEAKER_01: So how did we protect the flock from an abusive pastor when he wasn't even a pastor anymore?
[48:13] SPEAKER_03: Well, I wonder, too, with with the whole process, what does submission to the brethren look like then at the end of that process?
[48:19] SPEAKER_03: Because there's the possibility of appeal or complaint, uh, depending on where you're at in that process and who what party you are.
[48:26] SPEAKER_03: Um, but what does it look like to submit to the brethren in process?
[48:31] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think it's the opposite, isn't it, from uh contumacy?
[48:36] SPEAKER_01: Uh so contumacy is on one side of the seesaw and submission is on the other.
[48:40] SPEAKER_01: Then in both, it is the question of whether you cooperate with the process.
[48:44] SPEAKER_01: Submission does not mean you surrender your conscience.
[48:47] SPEAKER_01: Submission does not mean that you that if you believe X is a sin, that you have to now believe that it isn't a sin and vice versa.
[48:55] SPEAKER_01: So submission to the brothers does not mean that we concur with their judgment.
[48:59] SPEAKER_01: It means we submit to their administration.
[49:01] SPEAKER_01: So we attend the trial, we offer testimony, we answer the questions they ask us to answer and so forth.
[49:07] SPEAKER_01: Um but uh it does not require uh the uh uh violating the doctrine of conscience, which is interesting because the doctrine of conscience appears not only in the chapter on that, on Christian liberty, but it appears implicitly in chapter one on scripture.
[49:22] SPEAKER_01: So the idea that God alone is Lord of the conscience pops up several places in the standards, and it seems to have been a very central doctrine that animated the Reformation, certainly animated Luther, didn't it?
[49:34] SPEAKER_01: Um and so submission to the brothers does not mean that one agrees with them.
[49:39] SPEAKER_01: It means uh one submits to the processes to which one uh submits when he joins the church and submits to the government and discipline of the church.
[49:49] SPEAKER_01: And very similar for office holders, they do a similar thing.
[49:52] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I've learned uh I've had to do a decent amount of study just because of my own Presbyterian sub issues.
[49:58] SPEAKER_00: And what I've learned is that censures are sentencing, and after the trial is done, the censure is the sentence.
[50:05] SPEAKER_00: And the person who is found guilty sits under that censure until they repent, and there's no um escalating the censure because he won't repent of what he has been found guilty of.
[50:18] SPEAKER_00: He just lives in that sentence.
[50:20] SPEAKER_00: And so it's not contumacy because he hasn't said everything that you've wanted to say, and it's not failing to submit just because he disagrees.
[50:30] SPEAKER_00: And so um, there's been a lot of back and forth between my presbytery and the NSJC trying to figure out how to move forward with our current problem.
[50:40] SPEAKER_00: And a part of that is thinking that, well, if he doesn't, he's not submitting to us unless he does X, Y, and Z.
[50:47] SPEAKER_00: But we're already way past that, right?
[50:48] SPEAKER_00: And that's way, that was like three, four years ago.
[50:51] SPEAKER_00: There is no process or trial currently against him.
[50:54] SPEAKER_00: This is looking back and trying to do more, even though if you wanted to do more, you failed when you sentenced him.
[51:00] SPEAKER_00: You may have missentenced him, right?
[51:02] SPEAKER_00: You might have done something more if you'd have known the weight of a sentence, but there's no escalating because he hasn't said what you wanted him to say.
[51:11] SPEAKER_01: Correct.
[51:12] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think that's right.
[51:13] SPEAKER_01: The only exception would be if there's an indefinite suspension, uh, where it's not a definite suspension for a definite period of time, but an indefinite suspension, there might be certain conditions that that would cause the church to then remove the indefinite suspension.
[51:28] SPEAKER_01: And they could make, I think, legitimate requests, you know, that the person church uh attend church every week or that if they're having marital troubles, that they once or twice a month go to marital counseling and this kind of a thing.
[51:40] SPEAKER_01: So um, and then when the person submits both to the censure but into the recommended uh source of relief, um, then they could say at some point, yeah, we we we think that we can lift the censure at this point.
[51:53] unknown: Yeah.
[51:55] SPEAKER_03: So we can't be exhaustive and everything and going through the list, but um, this is kind of meant to be an introduction for people that um as we're we're gonna start going through uh chapter by chapter and and looking at uh some commentaries and exploring that together.
[52:10] SPEAKER_03: But if somebody finds this, they're they're gonna begin process on some sort of a matter, they're they're using the the checklist.
[52:18] SPEAKER_03: Um maybe not just procedurally.
[52:21] SPEAKER_03: You can ask your clerk, of course, you can ask other people around to get some advice on that.
[52:25] SPEAKER_03: But would you have any spiritual advice uh to somebody uh doing that?
[52:29] SPEAKER_03: I I just think of Newton uh writing his famous uh letter to somebody who was about to engage in controversy and said something along the lines of uh this may be important, but it's also dangerous to the soul.
[52:42] SPEAKER_03: Um would you have any kind of advice spiritually or um keeping your uh your sanctification throughout the uh the process uh yourself uh to somebody who's about to begin process?
[52:53] SPEAKER_03: What should they be on guard uh for themselves about?
[52:58] SPEAKER_01: Well, I think that it's it's very wise to do some reflection on Galatians uh 6.1 uh under those kinds of circumstances.
[53:06] SPEAKER_01: Um and it's very interesting uh where uh lest you yourself uh become caught up, and you can get caught up in two ways.
[53:16] SPEAKER_01: If you're too sympathetic to the accused, you might develop sympathy for for what he's been accused of and be more inclined to commit that sin yourself in the future.
[53:26] SPEAKER_01: There's also the possibility, and the commentators mention this as a a second possibility, which is that you become judgmental and you start to think of yourself as better than the accused.
[53:36] SPEAKER_01: Um and so the there you you can become puffed up uh and uh I mean we saw this recently when a reasonably prominent uh preacher in the United States uh uh left the ministry.
[53:49] SPEAKER_01: And uh as you could imagine, within three or four days on the internet, everyone speculated as to what was wrong with this individual that led to this.
[53:57] SPEAKER_01: And uh and I remember thinking, you know what was wrong with him?
[54:00] SPEAKER_01: Is the same thing wrong with me?
[54:01] SPEAKER_01: He has original sin.
[54:02] SPEAKER_01: That's what's wrong with him.
[54:04] SPEAKER_01: And and and and there isn't a pill that we can take.
[54:10] SPEAKER_01: And so whether he followed the gram rule or didn't, whether he did this or didn't, whether, right?
[54:15] SPEAKER_01: Um the the simple fact of the matter is uh uh as sinners, uh we could break all ten commandments tomorrow.
[54:23] SPEAKER_01: Any day of the week we could.
[54:25] SPEAKER_01: And apart from the restraining grace of common grace or the restraining grace of special grace, we could.
[54:31] SPEAKER_01: So I think there's the double temptation to avoid there in Galatians 6.
[54:36] SPEAKER_01: It's warning us on the one hand uh in our sympathy for the accused not to develop sympathy for the behavior that is accused, um, and think of it too lightly, because then we will welcome it into our own soul and we'll start contemplating those kinds of things.
[54:54] SPEAKER_01: The other is I think you know, to become puffed up and to think that we're above all that and this would never happen to us.
[55:00] SPEAKER_01: So I I think a good amount of uh reflecting on that would be wise.
[55:05] SPEAKER_01: I think maybe in the two or three week process of the entire thing, uh it wouldn't hurt for people involved in it to reflect on that passage every morning.
[55:13] SPEAKER_01: Just to say I would add to my normal devotional practice some reflection and meditation on Galatians 6 and just reflect on that again and again and again, and to avoid, on the one hand, oversympathizing with the behavior accused, and then on the other hand being judgmental as though we are above that and this would never happen to me.
[55:35] SPEAKER_01: Um because it's just dangerous for our soul either way.
[55:40] SPEAKER_01: And very clever of Paul to realize it too.
[55:43] SPEAKER_01: In a remarkable short frame of time, you know, he he covered a lot of ground.
[55:48] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[55:49] SPEAKER_03: Well, do either of you have any final uh thoughts as we uh seek to wrap this up?
[55:56] SPEAKER_03: All right.
[55:57] SPEAKER_03: Well, I'll let uh Ben put a little ending onto this episode.
[56:00] SPEAKER_03: But uh, Dr.
[56:01] SPEAKER_03: Gordon, thank you so much for uh your time uh and attention on this.
[56:05] SPEAKER_03: Uh, this has been a really helpful uh document, I know, to a lot of people, and hopefully some people find it uh uh helpful to think through it on uh on a podcast, too.
[56:14] SPEAKER_03: So thank you so much for your time.
[56:15] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, it was my pleasure.
[56:17] SPEAKER_01: It's good to be with you guys.
[56:20] SPEAKER_02: As the tour guide at the Blue Bunny plant said surprisingly, several times, this podcast is over.
[56:25] SPEAKER_02: Thank you for joining us.
[56:26] SPEAKER_02: Uh, if you're interested in learning anything more about what we have talked about, check out the show notes in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org.
[56:34] SPEAKER_02: If you enjoyed the show, consider following us on Twitter or Facebook at Polity Matters, and be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[56:42] SPEAKER_02: Share episodes with friends, let people know that we're about to start working our way through the BCO rules of discipline.
[56:49] SPEAKER_02: Big thanks to Dr.
[56:50] SPEAKER_02: T.
[56:50] SPEAKER_02: David Gordon for joining the guys for this interview on that very valuable resource.
[56:56] SPEAKER_02: If you have questions or comments, listeners, you know you can reach out to us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[57:01] SPEAKER_02: There's also a link below to support our work that gets you not just uh supporting the production of the show, but there's some added value in there as well.
[57:10] SPEAKER_02: Be sure to check that out and consider helping us out.
[57:14] SPEAKER_02: Until next, come, we thank you for spending time with us.
[57:17] SPEAKER_02: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
