# 20. Trying to Claim Apostolic Authority (Witherow's 1st Principle)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 9 Jan 2024, 50 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/14275619-20-trying-to-claim-apostolic-authority-witherow-s-1st-principle.mp3

The polity bros are joined by kindred spirit Jacob Gerber to discuss Witherow’s first principle of the apostolic church: the Office-Bearers are Chosen by the People. Jacob Gerber, pastor of Harvest PCA @jacobgerber Jacob's book! (get a copy) Polity Matters 13: BCO 8.1-8.4 (The Elder) Polity Matters 14: BCO 8.5-8.10 (The Elder) Polity Matters 15: BCO 9 (The Deacon) Called to the Ministry by Ed Clowney Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Welcome, Jacob!
- 2:41 Introduction
- 3:31 Temporary Church Offices
- 11:46 Perpetual Church Offices
- 15:49 Apostolic Principle #1
- 29:28 Are you convinced?
- 31:59 What is the significance?
- 47:07 Concluding Thoughts

## Transcript

[0:15] SPEAKER_00: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:17] SPEAKER_00: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined as always by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg.
[0:21] SPEAKER_00: This is episode two in Polity Matters before the book, and we're excited to continue our study of Thomas Witherow's The Apostolic Church, which is it.
[0:31] SPEAKER_00: We're basically have formed a little book club where we gather together every once in a while to discuss this material that we've read from Witherow that has significant bearing on our church government.
[0:41] SPEAKER_00: And to that end of sort of sharing in the discussion, we've invited several uh friends on to discuss with us over the next several weeks.
[0:49] SPEAKER_00: And today we are happy to welcome our friend Jacob Gerber uh to discuss the first principle of the Apostolic Church with us.
[0:56] SPEAKER_00: Jacob, welcome.
[0:57] SPEAKER_00: Uh tell us a little bit about yourself and uh maybe maybe touch a little bit on what interests you when it comes to church polity.
[1:04] SPEAKER_00: Uh and maybe don't talk too long on that one since I know we could do a whole episode alone on that material.
[1:09] SPEAKER_04: Well, thanks for having me.
[1:10] SPEAKER_04: Um my name is Jacob Gerber.
[1:12] SPEAKER_04: I'm the senior pastor at Harvest Community Church.
[1:14] SPEAKER_04: That's a PCA church in Omaha, Nebraska.
[1:17] SPEAKER_04: Um, I've been here um actually tomorrow was is my eighth anniversary of installation here.
[1:24] SPEAKER_04: Um so I've been here right at eight years.
[1:25] SPEAKER_04: Um I've been in the PCA, it was ordained in 2011.
[1:29] SPEAKER_04: Um I'm married, I have five children.
[1:31] SPEAKER_04: Um, and also tomorrow is special because we're gonna formally adopt um one of our kiddos that we've had for as in foster care for quite a while.
[1:39] SPEAKER_04: So pretty excited about that.
[1:41] SPEAKER_04: Um, in terms of polity, um I really like parliamentary procedure.
[1:45] SPEAKER_04: I've been involved in parliamentary procedure for quite a while.
[1:49] SPEAKER_04: Um, used to serve as a professional parliamentarian in a former life.
[1:52] SPEAKER_04: Um, recently wrote a little booklet about it for the PCA.
[1:55] SPEAKER_04: Um and uh I currently serve on RPR.
[1:58] SPEAKER_04: I'm the secretary for review of presbytery records.
[2:01] SPEAKER_04: Um so I I like I like reviewing minutes and things like that.
[2:05] SPEAKER_04: I think those are just special magical Presbyterian um worlds.
[2:10] SPEAKER_04: So really enjoying that and um um just really enjoy pastoral ministry, so the whole gamut.
[2:16] SPEAKER_00: Well, we're very glad to have you.
[2:18] SPEAKER_00: Uh we we were joking before we started recording that um all of us know right where our copy of Gerber is.
[2:24] SPEAKER_00: Uh either either it's tucked in our BCO or you've got it in your bag.
[2:27] SPEAKER_00: Uh, we really appreciate that resource you've provided for us.
[2:30] SPEAKER_00: And um, for listeners, we'll have links to that in in the show notes.
[2:33] SPEAKER_00: So if you need to get a copy, you know, if you weren't one of the thousand people that Scott already sent a copy to, uh, they're they're out there for you to acquire somewhere.
[2:41] SPEAKER_00: Well, as you recall from our last episode, we're reading through Thomas Witherow's The Apostolic Church.
[2:46] SPEAKER_00: And in the first chapter, the question was posed: which of the three forms of church government prevalent throughout the world is it the duty of a Christian to select and to support?
[2:55] SPEAKER_00: Uh, there's different types of government out there when it comes to the church.
[2:59] SPEAKER_00: Uh, where should we go?
[3:00] SPEAKER_00: What should we look for?
[3:01] SPEAKER_00: And in order to answer this, Witherow observes the Apostolic Church in the pages of Scripture.
[3:07] SPEAKER_00: Just as the moral law of God is laid out in principles, so also the polity of the church is given not in these detailed instructions, but in principles that are to be applied in our exercise of governing.
[3:20] SPEAKER_00: And so today we're going to be discussing the first of his six principles.
[3:23] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but just before he gets into that, he writes on the church offices in general, which is where our discussion begins today.
[3:31] SPEAKER_00: So he he distinguishes for us there's four different kinds of office bears in the apostolic church.
[3:36] SPEAKER_00: Two are temporary and two are perpetual.
[3:39] SPEAKER_00: Uh the apostles and the evangelists on the one side, and the bishops and the deacons on the other.
[3:44] SPEAKER_00: Uh let's work through these, just sort of, you know, teasing out, reminding everybody what these are.
[3:48] SPEAKER_00: Some of this has come up in our previous episodes on the Book of Church Order, but uh we want to talk through what Witherow has to say.
[3:56] SPEAKER_00: What do you think, guys?
[3:57] SPEAKER_00: What's important for us to note here about how he distinguishes the temporary offices of apostle and evangelists?
[4:03] SPEAKER_02: Well, when you think of at least the the idea of apostle, these were eyewitnesses of the resurrection of the Lord Jesus Christ.
[4:10] SPEAKER_02: These are men called and selected by Christ uh in the early church in regards to establishing the foundation of the church.
[4:18] SPEAKER_02: So these men, as you recall in Luke 5 and particularly 6, where they are called and sent out, Jesus teaches them and sends them out in the way of the ministry.
[4:29] SPEAKER_02: The only perhaps different one would be Paul out of the apostolic tradition, who met Christ in a different resurrected uh scenario where he's on the way to Damascus.
[4:40] SPEAKER_02: But all the other apostles who were just his disciples, um, those 12 plus one after Judas were called eyewitnesses of the Lord Jesus Christ.
[4:52] SPEAKER_02: Jesus probably had many uh, you know, hundreds of followers.
[4:55] SPEAKER_02: Um, these twelve apostles were ones that were selected from them, not necessarily by giftedness.
[5:02] SPEAKER_02: Um, like Jesus didn't go around and choose the 12 most abled men, but those whom magnified the grace of God um in establishing that early church.
[5:14] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, you can go to Acts chapter one, where they're trying to replace Judas, and they draw um well, they they rather determine on Matthias and that uh there in Acts 1 in the 20s.
[5:24] SPEAKER_00: So one of the men uh who's accompanied us during all the time the Lord Jesus went in and out among us, beginning from the baptism of John until the day when he was taken up from us.
[5:32] SPEAKER_00: Uh one of these men must become with us a witness to his resurrection.
[5:36] SPEAKER_01: It is interesting that he designates evangelist as an office, yeah.
[5:40] SPEAKER_01: Whereas we may think of it as either a type of um uh elder or or teaching elder.
[5:47] SPEAKER_01: That's how we have it in uh the the PCA's BCO, um, or maybe just something that you do, something that's an evangelist but has no particular office.
[5:56] SPEAKER_01: Um, so it might be interesting to think about um, is this an office that has gone away?
[6:02] SPEAKER_01: Was this ever an office at all, or was this the type of um something that was in the office of an um overseer?
[6:10] SPEAKER_04: I think um that's I I I find that question about the evangelist really interesting.
[6:14] SPEAKER_04: I it's really interesting in the in the list of offices, you know, Paul talks about some as apostles, some as prophets, some as evangelists, uh, some pastor teachers.
[6:24] SPEAKER_04: Um so I would take that as an office.
[6:26] SPEAKER_04: I think a lot of historic Presbyterianism takes that as a as an office, um an itinerant kind of a thing.
[6:33] SPEAKER_04: Um, it's not, you know, the the traveling conference speaker like like Billy Graham, that kind of a thing.
[6:40] SPEAKER_04: Um but the way I describe it in um different classes is if you think about, you know, uh they were connected to the office of the um of the apostles.
[6:51] SPEAKER_04: So if you think about like Paul, this holy hurricane coming through different areas and leaving churches, you know, fledgling churches in his wake, then he's always sending um Timothy or Titus, um uh different places, you know, you read in Philippians or 2 Timothy 4, but you go here, you go there, um, trying to get some of these evangelists to go behind him to set up things, you know.
[7:16] SPEAKER_04: Titus, this is for this reason I left you um uh in Crete um to put what remained in order, to uh appoint elders in all the churches.
[7:25] SPEAKER_04: So it it you can see that that was very much tied to the office of apostle.
[7:31] SPEAKER_04: But yeah, it is different than the way that we have it as um one of the classes or one of the order, uh not order, but one of the classes of of being a teaching elder.
[7:40] SPEAKER_04: Uh so we're it's kind of patterned after that uh biblical evangelist office, but it's not it's not a separate office.
[7:45] SPEAKER_04: And it and I I don't think it should be that that's passed away with the apostles.
[7:49] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think it wasn't it like Dabney that would put it under like a family.
[7:53] SPEAKER_02: So like there's your your elders, your deacons, your the order um would be ruling elder, teaching elder, and then the family.
[8:00] SPEAKER_02: You could be a pastor, a teacher, or an evangelist.
[8:03] SPEAKER_02: And so it's like subclassing each of those, um, getting perhaps more detailed for the work.
[8:10] SPEAKER_00: This is a question that I don't have written down, and I'm I'm not sure he speaks to it very specifically at all.
[8:14] SPEAKER_00: But what what makes these temporary uh offices?
[8:18] SPEAKER_00: You know, there's no successors to these two, at least in the way that Witherow presents them as the temporary offices.
[8:24] SPEAKER_00: What makes them such?
[8:25] SPEAKER_00: It's like a pop quiz.
[8:27] SPEAKER_02: Well, the I think the apostles, it makes sense.
[8:30] SPEAKER_02: We just kind of already outlined it.
[8:31] SPEAKER_02: These were eyewitnesses of the resurrection of the Lord Jesus Christ selected by Christ themselves.
[8:36] SPEAKER_02: There might be many men in our own age that claim to be apostles, whether they be bishops or in the low church setting, uh in the Pentecostal system, where these men believe that they've been particularly called.
[8:50] SPEAKER_02: But uh there's a unique nature, and that unique nature is ones who traveled with Christ almost two millennia ago.
[8:59] SPEAKER_02: And so that's the that that's the the limitation of such an office.
[9:04] SPEAKER_02: Um I've not seen the resurrected Christ.
[9:09] SPEAKER_02: I hope to, uh, sooner rather than later, perhaps, but uh I have not, and he has not called me to that office.
[9:16] SPEAKER_02: And so I don't think he's called any of us here to that.
[9:19] SPEAKER_01: I I would think of it in terms of uh authority in revelation.
[9:23] SPEAKER_01: Um, the authority that was given to, especially the apostles, was one that you do not see replicated.
[9:29] SPEAKER_01: Um and so that would be an objection that you'd have to something like the office of a uh of the pope if they're trying to claim apostolic authority.
[9:36] SPEAKER_01: Um and also in Revelation, there's not new revelation that's coming.
[9:39] SPEAKER_01: You're just expounding the revelation that's already there.
[9:42] SPEAKER_01: And so that's why these two are perpetual, whereas the other ones that had special authority and special revelation attached to them uh are no longer among us.
[9:49] SPEAKER_02: And you think of the apostolic connections, right?
[9:52] SPEAKER_02: Like in the early church, the Roman church wanted to connect it like uh Peter passed the keys on to this person who passed the keys on to that person.
[10:00] SPEAKER_02: Whereas we would say the apostolic tradition continues and perpetuates in the teaching of the apostles.
[10:06] SPEAKER_02: And so we are all a part of the apostolic tradition as we study the apostolic principles of the church, not by keys being handed off individually to new apostles, but by the teachings being handed off from church to church.
[10:20] SPEAKER_04: Even just procedurally, um, there's no procedures established for appointing um successors.
[10:27] SPEAKER_04: Um, there's, you know, you see um um elders being appointed in every church's, you see, you know, Acts chapter six, the the deacons appointed, and you see the ongoing uh work of the deacons, um, for example, acknowledged in Philippians chapter one.
[10:41] SPEAKER_04: Um, but you don't see any ongoing way of by the way, here's how you appoint new evangelists, or here's how you appoint new new apostles.
[10:49] SPEAKER_04: Um, so so even just how would that happen, there's no way spelled out in scripture for that to happen.
[10:55] SPEAKER_04: It's I was recently preaching in in uh Matthew 16 of the confession of Peter, and um it is interesting, whatever you make of exactly what Peter's or what Jesus is saying to Peter, you or Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, uh the play on words Petros and Petra for for Peter and Rock.
[11:13] SPEAKER_04: Um even if you even if you and and I would take this as really talking about Peter, but but even so you could you could have a really high view of what that what Jesus is saying to Peter and with him the rest of the apostles.
[11:27] SPEAKER_04: Um but that doesn't in any way relate to the current um bishop, and we'll talk about bishop slater of Rome, uh, because there's no clear um um ongoing role for for establishing that apostolic seat.
[11:42] SPEAKER_04: That's not in at all in view of what Jesus says there.
[11:45] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so you know, Witherow says that what we do have still, not these temporary offices, but the perpetual offices of bishop and deacon.
[11:53] SPEAKER_00: And we're gonna use those words.
[11:54] SPEAKER_00: I mean, we can shift up here in a second.
[11:56] SPEAKER_00: Uh but these regular offices that we still see in the church today, bishop and deacon.
[12:00] SPEAKER_00: Bishops, uh, you know, just for everybody's clarification, we mean elder here.
[12:05] SPEAKER_00: And that's a whole point in Witherow when we get a little further on into this chapter, not something we're dealing with today, is that one of his what his whole second principle is that that bishop and elder are identical um in their Greek usage in the New Testament.
[12:17] SPEAKER_00: And so um that's something for another day, but is still uh worth discussing here.
[12:22] SPEAKER_00: Jacob, you had some notes here I thought were interesting about about bishop uh and the the identical interchangeable use of presbyter and bishop um and elder, you know, kind of not just in the New Testament, but also a little bit later on.
[12:34] SPEAKER_00: Do you want to talk about any of that?
[12:36] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, well, I think I think a lot of Presbyterians are aware that those terms are used interchangeably in scripture.
[12:42] SPEAKER_04: Um, and that's that's certainly where we would draw the most that that is what is authoritative.
[12:48] SPEAKER_04: But it's really interesting.
[12:49] SPEAKER_04: If if you want to learn, just um take a little bit of time and learn a lot about early church uh polity, um, read the writings of Clement, Clement of Rome and Ignatius of Antioch.
[13:03] SPEAKER_04: Um, these are two of the authors who really the very first authors post um apostolic age that we have.
[13:11] SPEAKER_04: Um they knew the apostles, they, you know, they they learned from the apostles.
[13:15] SPEAKER_04: And in the letters that we have, and there's just a few of them, it wouldn't take you long to read through these, it's really interesting.
[13:20] SPEAKER_04: Clement of Rome, he is regularly talking about submission to the presbyters, the presbyters, the presbyters, the elders, elders, elders.
[13:28] SPEAKER_04: Um, and then um, in then in the Ignatius, the works of Ignatius, it's very interesting because then he talks about uh a distinction, the the the bishop and the presbyters.
[13:40] SPEAKER_04: Um as a presbyterian, I would I would think he's talking about the pastor there, you know.
[13:45] SPEAKER_04: He's drawing a distinction between the teaching elder and and ruling elders, uh, presbyters who are ruling elders.
[13:50] SPEAKER_04: Uh, but it's it's interesting that in those two terms, there's there's no hierarchical um bishop that's like one man over a diocese of churches in the way that that hierarchical office came to be in the Roman Catholic and then the Anglican church.
[14:07] SPEAKER_04: Um, but but you see those used as just the ordinary officers in churches.
[14:11] SPEAKER_04: And so I think those terms map very easily onto the way that we are still doing this today in terms of distinguishing.
[14:19] SPEAKER_04: There's one group of presbyters, you get that from one author, but then you also have a distinction between teaching elders and ruling elders, is kind of how I would see that distinction, at least as a presbyterian.
[14:29] SPEAKER_00: Jared Scott, any thoughts on bishop?
[14:31] SPEAKER_02: Uh Jacob is the chief bishop of Platte Valley, I believe, if I am recalling, right?
[14:36] SPEAKER_04: You're the Oh no, I'm the clerk.
[14:38] SPEAKER_04: I'm I'm just I'm I'm just a servant.
[14:40] SPEAKER_04: I'm just uh under I just try or I just write the minutes, that's all.
[14:45] SPEAKER_02: Oh, that's all that clerks do?
[14:47] SPEAKER_02: I thought they were bishops.
[14:49] SPEAKER_00: Glorified secretaries.
[14:51] SPEAKER_02: Wow.
[14:52] SPEAKER_00: Speaking of servants, uh the you know, the other perpetual office in the church is is the deacons, which uh Witherow says deal with the more temporal concerns than the the instruction and government of the church as he assigns to um to bishops.
[15:05] SPEAKER_00: You know, I'd think I would just refer everyone back to uh our fairly recent episodes at this point on elder and deacon from the PCA Book of Church Order, both of those episodes um or several of them, I forget exactly how many we had.
[15:17] SPEAKER_00: Uh, we're gonna are gonna detail Elder and Deacon uh quite a bit for you and probably work through uh a lot of the distinctions that Witherow would agree with.
[15:25] SPEAKER_00: Um he doesn't work through a whole lot that we're talking really about one paragraph at the moment.
[15:29] SPEAKER_00: Uh he does say towards the end of that that the church can never cease to have need of these two offices of bishop and deacon, so long as its members have spiritual and temporal wants to be supplied.
[15:41] SPEAKER_00: Uh it's just a good reminder that this is the way that Christ has provided for the care of his people in these perpetual offices of elder and deacon.
[15:47] SPEAKER_00: And um this whole discussion of offices sets up for us the discussion of his first uh principle that he observes in the apostolic church.
[15:58] SPEAKER_00: Uh just a reminder that this is uh Witherow's way of figuring out what what did the Apostolic Church do?
[16:06] SPEAKER_00: What were the principles at play in their church government that we're going to apply uh to our church still today?
[16:12] SPEAKER_00: And the first principle is this that the office bearers are chosen by the people.
[16:18] SPEAKER_00: He starts off by saying that all offices originate in the Lord Jesus.
[16:21] SPEAKER_00: And I I love this because I always like to go back to the first part of the preface of the BCO because I just think it's a uh widely overlooked uh part of our book.
[16:30] SPEAKER_00: Um, you know, it may seem strange to at first to say that all the offices in the church originate in the Lord Jesus, but it's just what our book says that Jesus, the mediator, the sole priest, prophet, king, savior, and head of the church, contains in himself by way of eminency all the offices of his church and has many of their names attributed to him in the scriptures.
[16:48] SPEAKER_00: He is apostle, teacher, pastor, minister, bishop, and the only lawgiver in Zion.
[16:54] SPEAKER_00: And so he he he establishes this uh in order to sort of tease out the fact that that the Lord Jesus is the one who has authored these offices.
[17:04] SPEAKER_00: And there's there's a connecting point to the apostles.
[17:07] SPEAKER_00: Um, you know, how did Jesus choose the apostles?
[17:10] SPEAKER_00: Maybe we need to circle back again, but but what's the significance of the personal call of Jesus on the apostles?
[17:16] SPEAKER_00: So it wasn't just that, um, you know, what did we say already?
[17:19] SPEAKER_00: You know, that they they were with him, but they were called by him.
[17:22] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, Scott, jump in.
[17:23] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I just preached on this, so maybe I have some some knowledge of it in Luke chapter six.
[17:28] SPEAKER_02: Um, there's an interesting nature that Jesus doesn't just randomly choose um who will be his twelve, and he doesn't even order them.
[17:38] SPEAKER_02: You know, he doesn't have 500 guys stand in front of him and order them, the most competent to the least competent, and choose the 12 most competent.
[17:47] SPEAKER_02: Instead, he goes away, he would draws, and he spends all night in prayer.
[17:52] SPEAKER_02: Uh that's what the Bible says, all night in prayer.
[17:55] SPEAKER_02: Uh it's almost like this decision was so weighty to the humanity of Christ that it kept him up all night.
[18:02] SPEAKER_02: And he dwelled upon who would be the 12 that would serve as apostles.
[18:07] SPEAKER_02: I have all of these disciples in my midst.
[18:09] SPEAKER_02: Who, oh Lord, are you choosing to come alongside me?
[18:14] SPEAKER_02: Uh there's an intentionality, and it's not on competency necessarily, which is probably good for us that you know Jesus doesn't choose the the most, the best of the cream of the crop for to serve him, uh, but he chooses those who the father reveals to him.
[18:32] SPEAKER_02: And it's not a simple process.
[18:34] SPEAKER_02: You know, you think that Jesus would go and pray to the Father and say, Father, who are the 12?
[18:38] SPEAKER_02: The father would just send him a grocery list of here are the 12 names and you can move on.
[18:43] SPEAKER_02: Um, but he's up all night discerning and talking with the father in order to make this really important decision in the life of the church.
[18:52] SPEAKER_02: And so it's not on the whim, it's not unintentional, it's very intentionally chosen.
[18:57] SPEAKER_02: Um, we obviously don't know all of that went into that.
[19:01] SPEAKER_02: Um, but it is a choice by Christ in conjunction as he is talking with his father through prayer all night.
[19:09] SPEAKER_02: Um, and so there's an intentional choice made by the Father with the Son.
[19:15] SPEAKER_00: Apostles were called particularly by Jesus.
[19:17] SPEAKER_00: Um, this is not to say, and I just noticed a little faux pas in my notes.
[19:21] SPEAKER_00: Uh, my notes actually say this is not to say bishops and demons aren't called by Jesus.
[19:26] SPEAKER_00: That's not what I mean.
[19:26] SPEAKER_00: Bishops, uh, this is not to say that bishops and deacons aren't called by Jesus, they're just not called in person in the in the particularly the same way we see the apostles called.
[19:35] SPEAKER_00: What's the shift?
[19:36] SPEAKER_00: And and let's let's you know move to this and we'll use uh Witherow's outline, but I just want us to work through some of these texts.
[19:42] SPEAKER_00: But what what's the new principle of calling to office in the New Testament church, in the apostolic church?
[19:48] SPEAKER_00: What's where how do we see the principle of of calling to office developed in the course of the New Testament?
[19:54] SPEAKER_00: And we I'm just gonna point us to Acts chapter one and hand it over to a couple of you guys to kind of work through this for us.
[20:00] SPEAKER_01: Well, you have you have some human um in Acts one, you basically have the disciples there, and that's the full number of the church in a sense.
[20:09] SPEAKER_01: Um this is before Pentecost, before you have thousands more that will join.
[20:13] SPEAKER_01: And um there when there's some sort of an office that they're they're looking at filling, uh, what happens?
[20:19] SPEAKER_01: Uh there is some sort of a human choice that's involved.
[20:22] SPEAKER_01: It's not direct, um, you know, uh uh just having Jesus choose because he's just ascended, uh, but they're having an election uh that's there.
[20:32] SPEAKER_01: Um and so that's that's something that seems to have changed.
[20:36] SPEAKER_01: Uh obviously the the apostles and the the office of apostle um was the only one that had that directness uh from Witherow.
[20:44] SPEAKER_01: Uh but now something has changed.
[20:45] SPEAKER_01: There's some sort of choice of the assembly together on who is occupying this office.
[20:51] SPEAKER_02: I have a question, perhaps building off of that.
[20:54] SPEAKER_02: Um in those early chapters and and acts, there's a lot of casting of lots.
[20:59] SPEAKER_02: Uh how would that compare then to our own practice?
[21:03] SPEAKER_02: Would casting lots violate our own constitution as it relates to calling officers?
[21:08] SPEAKER_04: You know, it it was really interesting because I I don't know that I've thought about this.
[21:12] SPEAKER_04: I'm gonna have to give it more thought, but the way that Witherow dealt with it was he treated the casting of lots very different than like the Urim and the Fumim of the Old Testament.
[21:22] SPEAKER_04: Yes, that that would um certainly violate um the principle of long ago.
[21:30] SPEAKER_04: God spoke to uh to our fathers in many ways, many times, uh, but in these last days he's spoken to us by his son.
[21:36] SPEAKER_04: So sort of the cessationism that we would have.
[21:39] SPEAKER_04: Um but he but Witherow seems to take this as a straight up like nomination and election process.
[21:46] SPEAKER_04: So like uh Acts 1, verse 23 ESV has, and they put forward two Joseph called Barsabbas, who was also called um Eustace and Matthias.
[21:59] SPEAKER_04: Um He has they they nominated, they nominated two men.
[22:03] SPEAKER_04: Um King James has a has appointed somehow some the NIV has nominated for that one, which is kind of interesting to look it up.
[22:10] SPEAKER_04: It's clearly a sense of a nomination.
[22:12] SPEAKER_04: It's it's the the verb to to stand, um histamine, so to to cause to stand, to stand for an election kind of a thing.
[22:20] SPEAKER_04: Um and so with, while Peter explained the necessary qualifications and the peculiar duties of the office, the appointment of the person did not rest with Peter, but with the men and brothers to whom the address of Peter was directed.
[22:34] SPEAKER_04: So he really takes this as the casting of lots as a straight-up election to choose those officers.
[22:40] SPEAKER_04: And that's a very interesting.
[22:42] SPEAKER_04: I'm not sure.
[22:43] SPEAKER_04: I'm not familiar, I haven't preached through this part of acts, so I don't I don't I don't know if that's a widely held view or not, but it was a really interesting one.
[22:51] SPEAKER_02: I I was elected as a deacon in the mainline church through the casting of lots in the Old Testament sense.
[22:57] SPEAKER_02: And we had there's a bunch of little pieces of paper, and they were folded up and put in a hat.
[23:03] SPEAKER_02: And when you took the paper out, it either said deacon or not deacon.
[23:08] SPEAKER_02: And so when I when I pulled it out, it said deacon.
[23:11] SPEAKER_02: And I was like, oh, I I've been chosen, I've been selected by God.
[23:14] SPEAKER_02: And then the congregation would then vote on that slate of whoever was chosen through that randomized process.
[23:22] SPEAKER_02: And I can tell you, I was not the most qualified man that was standing, but it was like almost left up to I it was just left up to whoever drew what.
[23:31] SPEAKER_00: I can't tell if you're making this up.
[23:33] SPEAKER_00: I'm not making it up.
[23:35] SPEAKER_02: I'm not making it up.
[23:36] SPEAKER_02: I've I pulled up my ordination out of a hat.
[23:40] SPEAKER_02: Was it a sword?
[23:42] SPEAKER_02: Uh no, I don't remember what hat.
[23:44] SPEAKER_02: It may have been just a bag.
[23:47] SPEAKER_02: You know, you give me my my story some flair, okay?
[23:50] SPEAKER_02: Let me let it be a top hat.
[23:52] SPEAKER_01: Well, I have known of um there being ties before in church courts in terms of uh an election and them flipping a coin um to see who would get the um position.
[24:03] SPEAKER_01: So PCA church courts?
[24:05] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, Jacob, is that constitutionally verifiable?
[24:09] SPEAKER_02: Is that good?
[24:10] SPEAKER_02: I don't think I think it's probably the coin an elected elder of the church.
[24:18] SPEAKER_03: This is one of the questions people subscribe to the Polity Matters podcast to get answered.
[24:24] SPEAKER_00: No, no, we have the questions.
[24:25] SPEAKER_00: We need answers.
[24:26] SPEAKER_00: Please help.
[24:27] SPEAKER_00: Send help fast.
[24:31] SPEAKER_04: Um, I did think it was interesting that Witherow went on and pointed to Acts 14, verse 23.
[24:40] SPEAKER_04: And he kind of pursued this idea of elections there as well.
[24:45] SPEAKER_04: Um in Acts 14, verse 23, he says that they were doing the same thing, and he really argues that it's mistranslated in current things because it doesn't say they elected them.
[24:55] SPEAKER_04: Uh the ESV has, and when they had appointed elders for them in every church with prayer and fasting, they committed them to the Lord in whom they had believed.
[25:02] SPEAKER_04: And he's saying this is the congregation doing this.
[25:05] SPEAKER_04: I don't think that's likely.
[25:06] SPEAKER_04: Um, I looked it up in B Dag, and um that's not the view that B Dag takes.
[25:12] SPEAKER_04: It really sees this as the acts of the apostles themselves, uh, Paul and Barnabas to uh appoint them.
[25:18] SPEAKER_04: Well, uh Paul.
[25:20] SPEAKER_04: Uh so that was kind of an interesting, interesting kind of uh wrinkle that he pulled Acts 14 23 in there as well.
[25:27] SPEAKER_01: Uh but isn't ordination and election in some ways the two agreeing?
[25:31] SPEAKER_01: And so it's not whether it's one or the other that's doing this, it's both.
[25:34] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, I I I think you're you're just saying like they the congregation could elect and as well as they were appointed or or installed or whatever.
[25:43] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[25:44] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, I I think that's very true.
[25:46] SPEAKER_04: I just think the text is is pointing more toward the the latter and not toward the a congregational election in the way that we would hold it now.
[25:53] SPEAKER_04: I think I think there are other reasons to do that.
[25:55] SPEAKER_04: I was I'll have to think more about what Witherow has for those sections um in his arguments there.
[26:03] SPEAKER_00: Fight.
[26:04] SPEAKER_00: I really want Jared and Jacob.
[26:05] SPEAKER_00: No.
[26:06] SPEAKER_00: Jared pushed the button on his microphone.
[26:08] SPEAKER_00: I expect him to.
[26:09] SPEAKER_00: Well, that's good.
[26:10] SPEAKER_00: Your microphone's on.
[26:11] SPEAKER_00: I was gonna move along.
[26:12] SPEAKER_00: So so we we so he he wrote some things here in Acts 1 and then he moves us along to Acts chapter six.
[26:17] SPEAKER_00: Jared, you want to kind of set up the the picture for us?
[26:20] SPEAKER_01: Well, I thought this interesting.
[26:21] SPEAKER_01: I hadn't thought of Acts six before as a an argument for election of elders, but I think he makes a really good case here on when they were uh needing deacons.
[26:33] SPEAKER_01: Um, what did they do?
[26:34] SPEAKER_01: They had some number that were eligible from their number, and then you have this language of all and the gathering in terms of the selection of them and uh the appointing of them.
[26:45] SPEAKER_01: Um and so this is um, I think in verse uh five of chapter six, it talks about the whole gathering here.
[26:52] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so these were people that were not elders before or any kind of officers.
[26:57] SPEAKER_01: They were among the people and then they were elevated to uh the level of being uh an officer.
[27:02] SPEAKER_01: And so um I think this is um this was interesting for me, just of a scriptural place where you see some sort of an election in process.
[27:10] SPEAKER_01: And I actually looked it up in um there's a a volume that was published by um Naftali Press, which is a back and forth between Presbyterians and um independents uh on certain questions.
[27:23] SPEAKER_01: And they actually have a section in which um the independents are pointing to this, and then the Presbyterians came back and said, We agree that that that's an election happening there.
[27:32] SPEAKER_01: So that's that's not a point of contention.
[27:34] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, I um I've I've I've read this.
[27:36] SPEAKER_04: I I forget exactly where I encountered someone made the argument.
[27:40] SPEAKER_04: It wasn't a Witherow, it was either in that um might have been in Use the Use Divenum uh book that that um we've talked about, I think, before the recording.
[27:51] SPEAKER_04: Either that or possibly Bannerman.
[27:52] SPEAKER_04: I'm not I'm not sure where I read it, but but the idea of uh how much more important would it be if the lower office, if if if it required congregational approval, how much more important is it for a higher office of elder um to to be by congregational approval?
[28:08] SPEAKER_04: Um and you might pair that if you say, well, why go higher?
[28:13] SPEAKER_04: Well the higher office of evangelist is also chosen by the churches of 2 Corinthians 8, verse 19, um, where Paul writes, and not only that, but he, Titus, had been appointed by the churches to travel with us as we carry out this act of grace that is being ministered by us for the glory of the Lord Himself and to show our goodwill.
[28:32] SPEAKER_04: So there's um at least aspects of the evangelist um office that's being appointed by the churches to perform those.
[28:40] SPEAKER_04: So in both cases, you see that that those are actually appointed by the churches, selected by the churches.
[28:46] SPEAKER_04: Um I I don't know that you see it directly as about elders where where we would really see the importance as Presbyterians, uh, but I think the good and necessary consequence of seeing all of these um ways of doing it again after the apostolic era, uh after Jesus is ascended, um, I think those really make the case that uh those should be the way that we especially conduct elder elections.
[29:10] SPEAKER_00: Well, good.
[29:10] SPEAKER_00: So so again, we're we're seeing this principle that Witherow's pointing to.
[29:15] SPEAKER_00: The office bearers are chosen by the people.
[29:17] SPEAKER_00: Acts one, he he shows us with the elders.
[29:20] SPEAKER_00: Acts six, he's pointing it to it for the deacons, and then by some uh some some connecting points even back to the elders again.
[29:27] SPEAKER_00: And as we as we sort of move into a discussion time uh amongst ourselves about this principle that he's pointed to, uh I do want to ask y'all first, are you convinced uh you know, do you see the principle in scripture that he's pointing to?
[29:42] SPEAKER_00: We're gonna talk in in future episodes about applying this and where we see it in particular churches or if we saw if we don't see it in those uh particular church governments.
[29:52] SPEAKER_00: But are you, are you gentlemen, convinced uh that this is a uh a principle of the apostolic church that is necessary to the government of the church?
[30:01] SPEAKER_01: I I think he makes a good case, especially for Max um and and seeing it in practice, a description of it happening.
[30:08] SPEAKER_01: Um so I I I think he makes a good case.
[30:11] SPEAKER_01: I think it could have gone on longer.
[30:12] SPEAKER_01: I was actually more interested of like, man, I wonder where else this has been uh expounded and uh to find some of this, because I just don't see this talked about a whole lot in um in systematic theologies or in ecclesiology.
[30:25] SPEAKER_01: So I it it made me curious to see are are these the typical uh arguments for it?
[30:30] SPEAKER_01: Um are there other places we can go in scripture to find it?
[30:34] SPEAKER_04: Yes, I was.
[30:35] SPEAKER_04: I think that's important to be to be the VCA, yes.
[30:39] SPEAKER_02: I I I was and get your 31 twos ready for Jacob, he denies I can cut out whatever I want, so we can just find a place where Jacob said no somewhere and insert it right there.
[30:55] SPEAKER_00: And are you convinced?
[30:56] SPEAKER_00: Nope.
[30:57] SPEAKER_00: Not convinced.
[30:58] SPEAKER_00: I'm gracious.
[30:59] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[31:00] SPEAKER_00: Jared, to your point, I I I agree with you.
[31:02] SPEAKER_00: I I do feel like he there there could be a lot more here.
[31:05] SPEAKER_00: And I, you know, it makes me wonder like, was he was he writing with a particular amount of brevity on purpose?
[31:10] SPEAKER_00: Was he trying just to you know go move quickly through it?
[31:13] SPEAKER_00: But you know, having read before in here, I know that his argument the the principles almost build as we go, right?
[31:20] SPEAKER_00: It's they're they're gonna sort of begin to beef each other up, and we're gonna get into many more places in the New Testament where we see all the uh other principles at play.
[31:29] SPEAKER_00: And um so I'm I'm eager for that.
[31:32] SPEAKER_00: And uh but I'm with you.
[31:35] SPEAKER_00: You know, again, uh without getting into application of it to the different uh church governments that exist, I I I wanted to ask y'all about this, and and I'm I really feel bad because it looks like Jacob probably imagines that none of us do our homework, but we just ask our guests to do it for us, which is not the case.
[31:54] SPEAKER_00: I'm assuming that Scott has tones of research sitting in front of him that he couldn't get into the Google Doc.
[31:59] SPEAKER_00: But what's the significance of this principle?
[32:02] SPEAKER_00: Why is it important?
[32:03] SPEAKER_00: Uh yeah.
[32:06] SPEAKER_00: I mean, what what's on your mind when we think about this?
[32:07] SPEAKER_00: What is the significance of this?
[32:09] SPEAKER_00: I'd like to hear Scott's tones.
[32:11] SPEAKER_00: Um I just assume Scott always has large journals with calligraphy written notes in them as he's turning.
[32:20] SPEAKER_02: I mean, you guys think too highly of me.
[32:23] SPEAKER_01: Well, we see this play itself out in Presbyterian history over and over again.
[32:27] SPEAKER_01: I mean, the ARP exists basically because of this principle.
[32:30] SPEAKER_01: They didn't think it was being followed in um the Church of Scotland.
[32:34] SPEAKER_01: And when he had patrons that were basically forcing uh ministers on congregations, and they said the congregation at least has the right of refusal of those that are offered to them, uh, whether by a um a search committee or by um a presbytery or by these patrons that were just choosing these ministers.
[32:52] SPEAKER_01: And so um we've seen this throughout um church history that when you violate this, um, you're gonna have problems within the church.
[33:00] SPEAKER_01: Um, this was the rise of the moderates in uh the Church of Scotland uh that you read about around the same time as the Merrill controversy was going on.
[33:08] SPEAKER_01: Um so it changed the um the character of the church of Scotland when this principle was not being followed.
[33:16] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think of my favorite Episcopalian, um, Charles Simeon, where he was appointed um at, I believe, Trinity Church in Cambridge, I believe.
[33:28] SPEAKER_02: And his congregation hated him.
[33:30] SPEAKER_02: And he had a very long and difficult ministry.
[33:34] SPEAKER_02: And whenever I'm discouraged in the ministry, I try to remember Charles Simeon and all that he went through.
[33:39] SPEAKER_02: Um, but he had constant uphill battles with the congregation that rejected him, and that was because they were almost like a mainline congregation and he was an evangelical pastor.
[33:49] SPEAKER_02: And so it was perhaps good for the church, and it was good for that church, but you can see the rub.
[33:56] SPEAKER_02: Um, if you read some of his biography, you could see the rub and difficulty of what happens when a church doesn't choose its leaders.
[34:05] SPEAKER_02: Um, and I know we don't want to get into the application part of that, um, but you can see it throughout church history.
[34:11] SPEAKER_02: Um, there is often very very difficult circumstance when a minister is thrown upon a congregation.
[34:19] SPEAKER_04: At a pretty high level, um I think this is important for distinguishing between internal call and external call.
[34:27] SPEAKER_04: Um, you know, we do believe that Jesus selects, he chooses his, he continues to choose his officers.
[34:35] SPEAKER_04: It's but Jesus now does this through congregations, through nomination processes, you know, training processes, examination processes, but then finally through congregational votes to call officers.
[34:50] SPEAKER_04: Um uh just that the fact that someone says, hey, I'm called to do this, this or that in the church is not uh proof in itself that that person is indeed called to that task.
[35:00] SPEAKER_04: So that man needs to be uh voted on.
[35:03] SPEAKER_04: You know, you I think it's it's really interesting in Acts 15, the language of it seemed good to us and to the Holy Spirit.
[35:09] SPEAKER_04: Um, and and that's partially as the the Jerusalem Council is thinking through uh what requirements should be put upon these Gentile believers.
[35:18] SPEAKER_04: Uh, but above that, there's a language um of choosing people to go with uh uh Barnabas and Paul, and they don't mention the Holy Spirit, but it seems to be implied in the text in Acts chapter 15, verse 25.
[35:30] SPEAKER_04: It has seemed good to us, having come to one accord, to choose men and send them to you with our beloved uh Barnabas and Paul.
[35:38] SPEAKER_04: So the idea is that the Holy Spirit really does lead his church, and he does so uh through giving godly and um wise and widespread agreement.
[35:47] SPEAKER_04: Um, you know, I think um these processes of election is kind of the the good and necessary consequence of like, like if there, if there are elders and and we believe that Jesus doesn't appear like he did with Paul and just that's the one, that guy over there, um then the good and necessary consequences how are we going to choose them?
[36:07] SPEAKER_04: I I guess you you could you could try to draw lots and and that that would be one way.
[36:12] SPEAKER_04: Uh but the good and necessary consequences seems that there has to be a selection process.
[36:16] SPEAKER_04: And um, I think when you look at the rest of it of you know some of the stuff we've talked about today, uh that that really does need to be by congregational approval.
[36:24] SPEAKER_00: Uh definitely.
[36:24] SPEAKER_00: If I wasn't Presbyterian, I would be, uh I guess maybe I'd still be Presbyterian, but bag with crumpled up pieces of paper in it is definitely the way to go.
[36:33] SPEAKER_00: Um deacon or no deacon.
[36:35] SPEAKER_02: Um deacon or no deacon, maybe.
[36:37] SPEAKER_02: At Moody Bible Institute, they had us write many papers on like this kind of internal, external.
[36:43] SPEAKER_02: And as a as a Presbyterian, I always found the external part difficult.
[36:47] SPEAKER_02: Uh, because I guess in congregationalism, it's just a little different.
[36:50] SPEAKER_02: It it was almost like how are your gifts, your internal gifts being used externally, rather than the an external call of God by the endorsement of a session to uh presbytery and licensure and all of that.
[37:04] SPEAKER_02: It was more like the external call is how do you discern yourself to be externally called by your gifting and the usage thereof.
[37:13] SPEAKER_02: And so I always found it there are there are many weird papers I had to write that were like that um in a Bible institute, but that that was always difficult for me.
[37:23] SPEAKER_02: The internal stuff is easy for an individual to to write about, but it's hard for an individual to write about their own external calling when it it's more involved than that.
[37:34] SPEAKER_00: Anybody that's listening that wants to read more on this, I would just commend to you Ed Clowney's call to the ministry.
[37:40] SPEAKER_00: It's the classic that that everybody's given at seminary uh to distinguish between these things.
[37:46] SPEAKER_04: One other principle I think that's important on this is is um it's it's it's in the BCO.
[37:52] SPEAKER_04: Um I I know uh Bannerman talks a lot about this, um, but the idea that uh Christ has vested um his authority in the church as a whole, as a whole body.
[38:06] SPEAKER_04: Um sometimes we Presbyterians almost talk as though like the power belongs to the elders.
[38:11] SPEAKER_04: Um and and and certainly we're in a lot of cases we're we're maybe just speaking too much to try to differentiate ourselves from kind of a congregationalist church government.
[38:21] SPEAKER_04: No, no, the elders do have a rightful place uh to exercise authority within the church, but that doesn't mean that the elders own the authority.
[38:28] SPEAKER_04: Uh we don't possess it.
[38:30] SPEAKER_04: It's um BCO31 says this uh the power which Christ has committed to his church vests in the whole body, the rulers and those ruled, constituting a spiritual commonwealth.
[38:41] SPEAKER_04: This power, as exercised by the people, extends to the choice of those officers whom he has appointed in the church.
[38:47] SPEAKER_04: So the exercise of Christ's authority by the congregation as a whole is particularly in selecting the officers who will then exercise the rule in the church.
[39:02] SPEAKER_04: Um, I know there's a debate about whether Commonwealth or what exactly commonwealth means.
[39:07] SPEAKER_04: Some people don't assign a whole lot of meaning to the word.
[39:09] SPEAKER_04: From that paragraph, I would understand the idea of a commonwealth, a spiritual commonwealth, to to really refer to the idea of a republic, uh, which isn't just a popular democracy.
[39:19] SPEAKER_04: Everyone in the whole society casts a vote and that's the decision, um, but where elected leaders are appointed to rule.
[39:27] SPEAKER_04: Um and if if if church power really were vested in church officers only, we would have a kind of spiritual preeminence.
[39:34] SPEAKER_04: We we don't have elders don't have spiritual preeminence, they exercise spiritual authority, um, but we don't have a preeminence.
[39:41] SPEAKER_04: We're not, you know, uh that's why we don't go around by titles of, you know, your holiness or something like that.
[39:46] SPEAKER_04: We we don't have a preeminence.
[39:49] SPEAKER_04: Um, we're simply servants, um, we're simply um under-shepherds of the chief shepherd.
[39:56] SPEAKER_04: Um, we we do exercise authority, uh, but but without uh personal superiority over other people.
[40:04] SPEAKER_04: And I think that's really, really important.
[40:05] SPEAKER_04: That that that that power, uh, I think Bannerman talks about it as, you know, if if if you think about it as the body, the eyes are like the eyes that have the ability to see, the eyes see on behalf of the whole body.
[40:20] SPEAKER_04: You know, the eyes don't see for themselves, they see to direct where the hands should go and where the feet should go and things like that.
[40:25] SPEAKER_04: But the eyes don't do it for themselves or have the power for themselves.
[40:29] SPEAKER_04: The body is supporting the eyes with nutrients and oxygen and things like that to let them work.
[40:34] SPEAKER_04: So the whole body is involved in in the power, but even if it's alone exercised by the elders.
[40:40] SPEAKER_02: I have perhaps uh it's off the beaten path, but when we're thinking about um the idea of the church choosing its people, its office bearers, uh, how how does that how do we square that with uh rotating sessions within our own denomination?
[40:57] SPEAKER_02: Uh how do we think through perhaps what does it look like for a man to rotate back on session in a rotating church?
[41:08] SPEAKER_00: Uh it depends on the church, I think I'd say.
[41:10] SPEAKER_00: I've served in one church that had rotating elders, and they required the standing rules of that session had that you had to be re-elected uh by the so you you you didn't like take a break and then you were just still on.
[41:26] SPEAKER_00: It was you actually l left the session.
[41:29] SPEAKER_00: And technically, I guess you're still an elder, but in that particular church, you you you really weren't an elder at all, um, though you were still ordained, and you had to be re-elected by the congregation to get back on the session again.
[41:42] SPEAKER_00: Um and so you'd have these services where you would be in you would have, you know, if you were elected every however often, you could have multiple times where you were a part of an installation service because you had to be installed to the session again, so to speak.
[41:56] SPEAKER_02: What would be the mechanism?
[41:58] SPEAKER_02: I I guess I I struggle if they're if someone rotates off of a session, what would be the mechanism to get them back on the session without nomination?
[42:09] SPEAKER_00: In our in that church we were in, there was no mechanism other than nomination.
[42:14] SPEAKER_02: Is there any anomaly to where a man can get back on session in a rotating session without nomination?
[42:22] SPEAKER_02: And would that, if not, if you let a man back on the session in active duty without nomination, would that violate this principle?
[42:32] SPEAKER_01: Well, probably somebody from the session would nominate him.
[42:34] SPEAKER_01: And this is this is somewhat irregular to what the BCO is set up to do.
[42:39] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[42:39] SPEAKER_01: I was reading in um Hodge uh earlier, um, the J.
[42:44] SPEAKER_01: A.
[42:44] SPEAKER_01: Hodge.
[42:44] SPEAKER_00: You really have to be careful.
[42:45] SPEAKER_00: Oh, J.A.
[42:46] SPEAKER_00: Hodge.
[42:46] SPEAKER_00: Never mind.
[42:47] SPEAKER_00: That's okay.
[42:47] SPEAKER_00: That's okay.
[42:48] SPEAKER_00: That's okay.
[42:48] SPEAKER_00: Sorry.
[42:49] SPEAKER_01: But uh he he was trying to detail this of the General Assembly at one point of the Northern Church.
[42:55] SPEAKER_01: It said um, this is irregular, but there are some churches that do this with terms.
[43:00] SPEAKER_01: And so you see where it starts to come into a few churches, and they're like, we're not quite sure what to do with this.
[43:06] SPEAKER_01: And now it's much more common.
[43:07] SPEAKER_01: I'd be I wouldn't be surprised if there was half the churches in the PCA had some sort of term or something like that.
[43:14] SPEAKER_04: I I think one practical mechanism you could kind of use, it's not exactly what you're talking about, but you could put men on sabbatical for it can't go long longer than a year.
[43:25] SPEAKER_04: If it's longer than a year, the the relationship to the session is is automatically dissolved.
[43:31] SPEAKER_04: Uh, but if someone is on sabbatical for less than a year, then there could be an automatic re-entrance so long as he comes off sabbatical within that year.
[43:40] SPEAKER_04: But that's I I think that's maybe not quite what you're suggesting.
[43:43] SPEAKER_04: But that that that would be one way to kind of work within the BCO's uh scheme.
[43:48] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I guess I'm thinking like, can a congregation because in those in rotating sessions, typically there's a vote of the congregation, right?
[43:56] SPEAKER_02: In order to have the man come back on the the active Active duty.
[44:01] SPEAKER_02: And could there be a what what mechanism could there be outside of nomination for a congregation to vote on a man that has not been put forward, if that makes sense, by the congregation after he's rolled off?
[44:14] SPEAKER_00: I mean, Jacob, what you're talking about is the is the mechanism we have that if a man fails to perform his duty for a year or more, then he's to be removed right from the office or from the the board, I guess.
[44:26] SPEAKER_00: Is that is that the point you were talking about?
[44:27] SPEAKER_04: Was that yeah, the relation the relation could be dissolved.
[44:30] SPEAKER_04: But if you if you work within that year, he's kind of off and then he's back on without any vote or anything like that because he had never formally left.
[44:39] SPEAKER_04: That'd be one way to work within the BCO system.
[44:41] SPEAKER_04: Um, Scott, to your question, I don't I think you would have to go through the full process if I if I'm understanding uh maybe there's more to it than that, but I it would seem to me that you would have to go nomination training even.
[44:53] SPEAKER_04: And that could look different for different individuals.
[44:57] SPEAKER_04: It doesn't have to be start from scratch, do you know what the BCO is?
[45:00] SPEAKER_04: But but it could be, you know, you you have to do some training, examination, and then uh putting forth before the congregation vote the whole nine yards to get them back onto the session if they if they're off.
[45:13] SPEAKER_04: You wouldn't ordain them again, but you would reinstall them, would be my understanding.
[45:17] SPEAKER_02: In the previous ministry, uh I was asked to develop a report on officer rotation and what a solution was because our deacons were feeling overworked because we had a rotational system that went six years on, one year off, and the deacons were just getting burnt out in not six years by over labor.
[45:36] SPEAKER_02: And so I had to reach out to a bunch of various PCA churches and see what there um like in our like within our similar demographic, at least with mission and things of that nature.
[45:50] SPEAKER_02: And most of them came back as lifetime eldership.
[45:53] SPEAKER_02: And it was kind of funny because the church really was not ready to go that direction.
[45:57] SPEAKER_02: But like I interviewed 12 churches and like six of them were life eldership, and then the other six were some various form that we were just talking about here today, but none of them were automatically come back on.
[46:09] SPEAKER_02: It was all that process we were just talking about where they had to be not re-nominated by the congregation, and many of them had to be, you know, continued education and training, and then they would be voted on.
[46:21] SPEAKER_02: There was no capacity for the congregation just to vote on a man that they themselves did not put forward.
[46:27] SPEAKER_02: And in a rotational system, that kind of makes sense because if you have a session of five, you have to have like 15 or 20 men that are capable in order to make sure that rotation continues.
[46:38] SPEAKER_02: Um, and so you can't just vote on everyone, otherwise, your session would be like who do you choose among those other 15?
[46:46] SPEAKER_02: How do they get put forward?
[46:48] SPEAKER_02: It's just a difficult quandary within our polity, I guess.
[46:53] SPEAKER_02: Sorry for leading us here.
[46:54] SPEAKER_00: If anybody that's listening knows the answers to these questions, please write in at politymattersfeedback at gmail.com and let us know.
[47:03] SPEAKER_00: We'll invite you on the show to correct all of our mistakes.
[47:07] SPEAKER_00: You guys, before we wrap up, does anybody have any final comments on this first principle of the apostolic church that Witherow's given to us?
[47:15] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, how does this relate to term eldership?
[47:18] SPEAKER_00: Oh, good grief.
[47:21] SPEAKER_02: This relates to term eldership, let me tell you, Jared.
[47:24] SPEAKER_02: Because the officers must be chosen by the church.
[47:27] SPEAKER_04: I think one uh practical implication of this that is not um explicitly spelled out in the BCO.
[47:36] SPEAKER_04: Uh, but for example, um, this actually very recently happened in our presbytery where um there's a very small session, um, one teaching elder, one ruling elder, the teaching elder um received a call elsewhere, so he's leaving.
[47:49] SPEAKER_04: That leaves one ruling elder left.
[47:51] SPEAKER_04: Um you have to have a plurality of elders to have a session.
[47:55] SPEAKER_04: So presbyteries often appoint oversight commissions.
[47:58] SPEAKER_04: Those cannot be dictated from above.
[48:02] SPEAKER_04: Uh, those require then a congregational vote um to um to approve or to receive um those as um overseers over them.
[48:12] SPEAKER_04: Um and and there's no again explicit BCO place where where that's included, uh, but that's simply from uh preliminary principle number six that um uh the it belongs to the the power to elect belongs to those who reside in the in the society.
[48:30] SPEAKER_00: Well, as Ignatius would say, this podcast is over.
[48:33] SPEAKER_00: Thank you for joining us.
[48:35] SPEAKER_00: Be sure to come back next time when we look at Apostolic Principle Number Two.
[48:38] SPEAKER_00: The offices of bishop and elder are identical.
[48:41] SPEAKER_00: Little hints of that today in our discussion.
[48:44] SPEAKER_00: If you're interested in learning anything more about what we've discussed, check out the show notes in your podcast player or at politymatters.org.
[48:51] SPEAKER_00: If you enjoyed the show, consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters, and be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[48:58] SPEAKER_00: If you have questions or comments, if you'd like to send a 31-2 to Scott, you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com and I can provide you with his clerks information.
[49:08] SPEAKER_00: It was indeed our sincere pleasure to have Jacob Gerber join us today for our discussion.
[49:12] SPEAKER_00: We look forward with hopeful expectation to the day when he will moderate the PCA General Assembly.
[49:17] SPEAKER_00: If you want to get in touch with him, we'll have links in the show notes of the places that you can find him around the internet.
[49:23] SPEAKER_00: Scott is the Minister of Providence PCA in Troy, Illinois.
[49:26] SPEAKER_00: He's on Twitter at S.
[49:27] SPEAKER_00: Edberg.
[49:28] SPEAKER_00: Jared's at New Life Presbyterian Church in Aliquippa, Pennsylvania.
[49:31] SPEAKER_00: You can find him at Brother Nelson, and I serve as the Associate Minister at Covenant Presbyterian Church in Cleveland, Mississippi, and I'm on Twitter at underscore Ben Ratliff.
[49:39] SPEAKER_00: Thanks again for spending time with us.
[49:41] SPEAKER_00: Uh don't forget to secure you a copy of the Apostolic Church by Thomas Witherow so that you can follow along in this season of Before the Book.
[49:48] SPEAKER_00: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[49:50] SPEAKER_00: Goodbye, gentlemen.
[49:51] SPEAKER_00: Goodbye.
[49:53] SPEAKER_00: Y'all take care of you.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
