# 72. Chapter 27 is Chiastic (BCO 27)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 18 Feb 2025, 1 h 06 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/16645711-72-chapter-27-is-chiastic-bco-27.mp3

Steve Dowling joins Ben, Jared, and Scott to discuss BCO 27 on the nature, subjects, and ends of church discipline. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Transcript

[0:01] SPEAKER_04: Hey there, Polity Nerds.
[0:02] SPEAKER_04: Just a quick note about this episode.
[0:04] SPEAKER_04: I want to personally apologize for the audio quality at certain points.
[0:08] SPEAKER_04: We had a snafu during our recording session, and I was neither able to repair the damage nor re-record this valuable content.
[0:15] SPEAKER_04: Please bear with us just this time.
[0:18] SPEAKER_04: I think the content will more than make up for it in full.
[0:22] SPEAKER_04: Thanks.
[0:28] SPEAKER_04: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:30] SPEAKER_04: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg.
[0:34] SPEAKER_04: And we've been off for a little while as we record.
[0:36] SPEAKER_04: We've been taking some time to take care of many other things.
[0:39] SPEAKER_04: It hasn't been restful so much as it has been just not doing Polity Matters.
[0:43] SPEAKER_04: But we're glad to be back into it and we're getting into the rules for uh of discipline.
[0:48] SPEAKER_04: But first, I wanted to touch in with you two gentlemen.
[0:52] SPEAKER_04: As of our recording, GA registration has opened this morning, and I want to know, did you get the hotel that you wanted?
[0:58] SPEAKER_04: That's what everybody's curious about.
[0:59] SPEAKER_04: It doesn't matter about what's actually happening at General Assembly.
[1:04] SPEAKER_02: Well, I'm actually in the motel across the street.
[1:07] SPEAKER_02: There's no internal, you just enter from the outside.
[1:10] SPEAKER_02: And so we are like Jesus riding into Jerusalem on the donkey.
[1:14] SPEAKER_02: I will be sitting at the two-star hotel across the street.
[1:21] SPEAKER_04: Did you just mix up the great the triumphal entry and and Bethlehem and the stable?
[1:26] SPEAKER_02: I mean that was I preached at it last Sunday.
[1:31] SPEAKER_02: It's on the top of my mind.
[1:32] SPEAKER_04: Oh, yes, yes.
[1:34] SPEAKER_04: Jared, do you have a special suite that everybody reserves for you since you chaired the nominations committee last year?
[1:40] SPEAKER_00: No, I'm not even officially in a hotel.
[1:43] SPEAKER_00: I'm probably going to be sleeping in my car the whole time.
[1:45] SPEAKER_00: So we'll see if my wait list uh pans out.
[1:48] SPEAKER_00: We'll we'll get it.
[1:49] SPEAKER_04: Depending on your roommate, sleeping in your car is not always a bad idea.
[1:54] SPEAKER_04: We are really excited to welcome to the show.
[1:57] SPEAKER_04: The I asked him if I should properly say this.
[1:59] SPEAKER_04: He said it's true that he is the current moderator of the PCA General Assembly.
[2:03] SPEAKER_04: Ruling Elder Steve Dowling is with us.
[2:05] SPEAKER_04: You may remember him from episode 37 when he walked us through all how Overtures works at General Assembly.
[2:11] SPEAKER_04: Steve, welcome back.
[2:13] SPEAKER_04: Thank you for being with us.
[2:14] SPEAKER_01: Thanks, brothers.
[2:16] SPEAKER_04: We are turning our attention finally to the terrifying part of the BCO and starting in chapter 27 with the discipline, its nature, subjects, and ends.
[2:28] SPEAKER_04: Morton Smith said in his commentary that discipline is so important for the church that a whole section of the Book of Church Order is devoted to it.
[2:36] SPEAKER_04: Discipline often conjures images of correction or judicial process, but in the church, it encompasses much more than that.
[2:43] SPEAKER_04: It reflects the authority of Christ to instruct and guide and care for his people.
[2:47] SPEAKER_04: It promotes purity of the church and the welfare of the members.
[2:51] SPEAKER_04: And in this episode, we're going to explore how discipline is not just about maintaining order, which it is, but also about fostering godliness and glorifying God and nurturing the growth of the whole body as we get into this sort of big picture chapter as we get into the process of judicial matters.
[3:09] SPEAKER_04: And so with that, I want to ask my friends here before we even start the chapter, what's on your minds as you as we embark into the matter of discipline?
[3:20] SPEAKER_04: Is there anything to say before we start reading chapter 27?
[3:23] SPEAKER_00: It brings to mind for me Hebrews 12, which has a lengthy section on the good of discipline and the fact that we were disciplined as seemed best to our earthly parents, and it was for our good.
[3:35] SPEAKER_00: So discipline is a good, even though it is unpleasant at the time.
[3:39] SPEAKER_00: Even the writer of Hebrews says that.
[3:41] SPEAKER_00: I think it's unpleasant for those that are under formal discipline, as we'll get into some of the distinctions there of discipline more broadly and more narrowly.
[3:49] SPEAKER_00: But it's it's unpleasant sometimes for the people that are under, it's not it's often unpleasant for the people that have to do it.
[3:54] SPEAKER_00: Um, and yet it is a good.
[3:56] SPEAKER_00: It is something that is um much like the discipline of the body, uh, it is for our good, and there's a good result at the end of it, but at the time is not always pleasant feeling.
[4:06] SPEAKER_00: And so I I think it's good to focus on the fact that this isn't um a topic that people choose because it's fun, but because it's necessary, but it also is very good.
[4:17] SPEAKER_00: Good for the person, good for the church, and good for those involved in the end.
[4:22] SPEAKER_02: And we all vow to submit to to this as we become members of the church.
[4:27] SPEAKER_02: And so we might not open this section of the BCO until there's a problem, but whether we know it or not, we are making vows before the Lord in the presence of his people that we will submit to the discipline of the church.
[4:40] SPEAKER_02: And that's preventative in many cases, but it can lead to times of correction.
[4:46] SPEAKER_02: And that's where this passage or this section, I should say, comes in.
[4:49] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[4:51] SPEAKER_04: I like Jared's idea.
[4:52] SPEAKER_04: It's not not always fun.
[4:55] SPEAKER_04: It makes me think of disciplining my daughters, right?
[4:58] SPEAKER_04: They they certainly don't like it when they have to get a spanking for disobedience.
[5:02] SPEAKER_04: And and contrary to what they may believe, I also don't like it, you know.
[5:08] SPEAKER_00: I wonder with Steve, since Steve has served on the standing judicial commission, what was it that actually led you to accept doing that since it isn't something that's necessarily fun?
[5:18] SPEAKER_01: Well, that might actually be the motive, Jared.
[5:21] SPEAKER_01: You know, I had a lot of experience in the Marine Corps with the administration of discipline, and uh the kind of discipline that you render apart from a court martial in the military is really kind of bent the same way church discipline is.
[5:32] SPEAKER_01: The amount of punishment you can level is limited, and usually it's for building up, you know, making sure on the one hand that you've got an individual that's being properly developed, that he has the discipline or she has the discipline to grow and become the right kind of marine.
[5:45] SPEAKER_01: And in the other, you're trying to make sure that nothing bad happens to what we call the good order and discipline of the command.
[5:51] SPEAKER_01: So you see a great similarity there between the BCO and and then uh and the uh uniform cone of military justice as as it applies to the development of individuals and then what it means about the organization as a whole.
[6:02] SPEAKER_01: That said, I think that my experience with discipline has led me to a very high degree of respect for it.
[6:09] SPEAKER_01: And I think that your the point you made is one hundred percent correct.
[6:13] SPEAKER_01: The failure in most churches that that leads to so much ongoing acrimony and and rises to such an acute level in so many cases is a direct result of the fact that discipline is hard whether you're getting it or whether you're administering it.
[6:27] SPEAKER_01: And I think that's the beauty of the of the BCO is that it lines that out.
[6:31] SPEAKER_01: But before you delve too or we delve too heavily into this uh subject, I would mention, and I hope you'll do a section on it, but appendix I of the BCO ought to be consulted as soon as you smell a problem.
[6:43] SPEAKER_01: Because it's a beautiful piece of work on biblical conflict resolution for the most part.
[6:48] SPEAKER_01: Um there are a couple things in there that I personally don't like, like signing agreements that you'll submit to arbitration and mediation.
[6:55] SPEAKER_01: You know, I think that really does something foundational to the form of government of the church as it's administered through elders.
[7:02] SPEAKER_01: But that notwithstanding, that's a beautiful piece of work, and uh we would all be well advised to inform the way that we approach discipline by probably looking at that appendix when we first see that something may be tending that way.
[7:14] SPEAKER_01: And by that way I mean in the judicial sense of discipline.
[7:19] SPEAKER_04: Well, let's uh let's get into it.
[7:22] SPEAKER_04: So 27 has six uh five sections, excuse me.
[7:27] SPEAKER_04: And uh as long as I copied them all right, Scott.
[7:29] SPEAKER_04: Did I did I get all of them?
[7:30] SPEAKER_04: Five?
[7:31] SPEAKER_04: He's nodding for the for the okay.
[7:33] SPEAKER_04: This is an audio podcast, Scott.
[7:36] SPEAKER_04: All right, and so we'll jump in at 27.1 that gets into the definition and the scope.
[7:40] SPEAKER_04: Uh uh it reads discipline is the exercise of authority given the church by the Lord Jesus Christ to instruct and guide its members and to promote its purity and welfare.
[7:50] SPEAKER_04: The term has two senses.
[7:52] SPEAKER_04: A, the one referring to the whole government, inspection, training, guardianship, and control which the church maintains over its members, its officers, and its courts.
[8:02] SPEAKER_04: And B, the other a restricted and technical sense signifying judicial process.
[8:08] SPEAKER_04: So there's a few things we need to tease out here.
[8:12] SPEAKER_04: First, discipline is an exercise of authority, and then there's two senses of it.
[8:16] SPEAKER_04: So maybe maybe first to spend some time thinking about how discipline is an exercise of authority.
[8:21] SPEAKER_04: This gets it back into even to the preliminary principles that Jesus has given officers not to run the church however they see fit, but to run the church underneath his authority and guiding through his word.
[8:32] SPEAKER_04: And so there's an authoritative aspect to their rule, and discipline is an exercise of that authority.
[8:37] SPEAKER_04: So I mean, y'all, y'all help me out.
[8:38] SPEAKER_04: Y'all know how it goes.
[8:40] SPEAKER_00: This reminds me of one of my favorite uh questions that I got from a mutual friend of Steve and I, Jay Nightkirk, when I was coming into the presbytery, he asked me the question, have you ever been under church discipline?
[8:51] SPEAKER_00: And my uh answer was no.
[8:52] SPEAKER_00: And he said, Well, I hope you have, because broadly speaking, church discipline is from the pulpit throughout the entire church.
[8:58] SPEAKER_00: I mean, if you're a member of the church, you're subject to church discipline.
[9:01] SPEAKER_00: And I think that broader sense of the term, I think it's helpful if we used it more broadly that way of you discipline your body, you discipline your mind, you study a discipline.
[9:09] SPEAKER_00: Discipline doesn't have to have a negative connotation of punishment, but is for some good.
[9:14] SPEAKER_00: And so I I like the fact that it kind of leaves that out there of like we can mean discipline in a broader sense or a more narrow sense, and to realize that the broader sense is a good thing for us to be under, even if we never are in judicial process.
[9:25] SPEAKER_04: It points out that this authority of discipline, the exercise of discipline, is to instruct and guide its members and to promote its purity and welfare.
[9:35] SPEAKER_04: So it's interesting to me at least that this first statement about discipline has to do with the members.
[9:41] SPEAKER_04: Usually you hear church discipline, you think, oh, that's things that teaching elders and ruling elders are concerned about up at Presbyterio and those guys on the Standing Judicial Commission.
[9:49] SPEAKER_04: But church discipline is for the good of the people in both cases, the the the positive and the negative, if you will.
[9:54] SPEAKER_04: But it's all to promote purity and welfare.
[9:56] SPEAKER_04: And so maybe a couple of y'all would would walk through this point A under here, the first sense of discipline.
[10:03] SPEAKER_04: Maybe we call it a broad sense of discipline.
[10:06] SPEAKER_04: Yes, sir.
[10:07] SPEAKER_01: We pay to just take a closer look at the beauty of that first piece because it speaks of the exercise of authority, as we've rightly said, but but it's authority given by the Lord Jesus Christ, which is where everything that comes after this triangulates.
[10:21] SPEAKER_01: And so you have both the doctrinal and the moral sense that's rooted in Christ.
[10:25] SPEAKER_01: And so there's a very tight parallel, in my view, between what uh the kind of discipline that's administered through the training and the teaching and all of that, that's the special gift of teaching elders and then the province of all elders, and then the judicial sense.
[10:40] SPEAKER_01: And so finding their rooting in both of those, I think, is a point that's that's worth at least saying before we move to the two senses of it.
[10:48] SPEAKER_01: Because I don't find it to be the two sides of even the same coin.
[10:52] SPEAKER_01: I mean, it's kind of the same side of one coin, in the sense that it all sits so firmly on Christ.
[10:57] SPEAKER_01: All the authority comes from Christ, the exercise of that authority comes from Christ.
[11:01] SPEAKER_01: The ends of all of it are the same, but they're they're rooted in the glory of God.
[11:05] SPEAKER_01: So I just wanted to throw that at you.
[11:07] SPEAKER_04: This is where I'm gonna remind listeners, this is why we're having guests on for the whole rules of discipline section of of the BCO, is because we we need this.
[11:15] SPEAKER_04: We need guys that have thought about this.
[11:16] SPEAKER_04: So Steve, I'll just say thank you again uh for being here.
[11:19] SPEAKER_04: It's very important.
[11:22] SPEAKER_04: No, no, I I'm always uh allowed to be interrupted.
[11:25] SPEAKER_04: That's a rule.
[11:28] SPEAKER_04: Well, Scott, would it be appropriate for us to move along to that first A?
[11:33] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[11:33] SPEAKER_02: Uh A in my mind is dealing with the entire ministry of the Church of the Lord Jesus Christ.
[11:38] SPEAKER_02: Perhaps that's the broader sense.
[11:40] SPEAKER_02: It's that broad.
[11:41] SPEAKER_02: It is perhaps the things you don't even think about.
[11:43] SPEAKER_02: Interviewing people for membership or having coffee with someone, maybe it's Bible studies, the preaching of the word, Sunday school, all of these fall under Section A.
[11:53] SPEAKER_02: It's interviewing men for office.
[11:55] SPEAKER_02: And then them coming forward before the congregation, perhaps giving testimony.
[12:00] SPEAKER_02: It's as broad as can be, and it includes the entire ministry of the church.
[12:04] SPEAKER_02: And so this is where I think it's positive.
[12:07] SPEAKER_02: We are disciplining people so that they might be disciplined.
[12:10] SPEAKER_02: Like I might be disciplined with reading my Bible every year or their lack of.
[12:14] SPEAKER_02: If I have a disciplined heart, I'm going to do it.
[12:16] SPEAKER_02: And that's what we are gearing our people towards as we participate in the ministry of the word and the work of the church.
[12:23] SPEAKER_02: Um, it's that kind of discipline.
[12:25] SPEAKER_02: And so even when we make those vows, we're vowing to that part of discipline as well, the positive part, the part that seeks to prevent us from getting into the technical part, perhaps, so that we may not ever enter the technical part.
[12:37] SPEAKER_04: That's the hope of every pastor, I think.
[12:39] SPEAKER_04: This is the this is the side that I always try to emphasize with our church members.
[12:42] SPEAKER_04: You know, if discipline comes up, I always kind of want to pause, and it may be, I mean, maybe it's sort of cliche at this point to say, listen, before we talk about the the bad part of discipline that you're always thinking about when you hear the word.
[12:53] SPEAKER_04: This part of it is so significant.
[12:55] SPEAKER_04: And it's probably, I mean, to Jared's point earlier about what Jay asked you, this is the side that everybody sees most regularly.
[13:01] SPEAKER_04: And and Lord willing is the only part of of of discipline, rather, that anybody will ever experience.
[13:08] SPEAKER_04: Not to say they won't have corrective discipline, because all of this serves as corrective discipline as well, but it's not the formal judicial process sense.
[13:14] SPEAKER_04: Just I try to remind folks this is this is what you're familiar with in terms of discipline.
[13:19] SPEAKER_04: You experience this regularly.
[13:23] SPEAKER_01: You make a very good point.
[13:25] SPEAKER_01: I mean, if you think about it, the better rooted you are in scripture, the better equipped you are to deal with conflict.
[13:30] SPEAKER_01: And uh there's a trick question that I like to do in officer training.
[13:33] SPEAKER_01: You guys probably can't be tricked, but I'd still like to try it.
[13:36] SPEAKER_01: But but you know, you look at church discipline, and uh when someone creates an offense, what what's the very first thing that you can do that you the Bible that the Bible requires of you?
[13:47] SPEAKER_01: Well, you have to be overlooking the offense, okay?
[13:49] SPEAKER_01: That's the answer.
[13:51] SPEAKER_01: And and and you know, because it's the glory of a man to overlook an offense.
[13:54] SPEAKER_01: And so there's a a way in which, in my conception, anyway, this rooting in the word, you know, this feeding on the word of God, and maybe even praying scripture and getting into a dialogue instead of a monologue and all those things that really are very pietistic, but that influence you so profoundly in the way that you engage emotionally with others, to me seems to drive you to the lowest kind of solution.
[14:16] SPEAKER_01: You don't have to take offense.
[14:18] SPEAKER_01: But when someone offends you, then Matthew 18.
[14:22] SPEAKER_01: And uh so I've always I think that that the point you made is really well taken because I do think you're right.
[14:27] SPEAKER_01: Uh the better job we do with the non-judicial aspect of discipline, the less likely we are to see judicial discipline, and probably we'll be better equipped in doing judicial discipline if we're that well rooted in the word.
[14:41] SPEAKER_01: So I like you went there.
[14:43] SPEAKER_01: I like that you went there first.
[14:45] SPEAKER_01: Was a good trick question though, wasn't it?
[14:47] SPEAKER_01: It's a great trick question.
[14:49] SPEAKER_01: Love covers a multitude of sentences.
[14:51] SPEAKER_01: Okay, now I'm gonna steal that too.
[14:55] SPEAKER_03: That's from the Bible, don't it's not from Scott.
[14:57] SPEAKER_03: That's right?
[14:59] SPEAKER_04: Anyway.
[15:00] SPEAKER_04: That's a problem, I think.
[15:02] SPEAKER_04: Sounds I think.
[15:04] SPEAKER_04: We think, yeah.
[15:05] SPEAKER_04: People come here for polity, not for the Bible.
[15:10] SPEAKER_04: Well, that's I mean, we're obviously gonna spend a lot of time on this next point in future episodes and and the rest of this one, but the second sense, a restricted and technical sense signifying judicial process is there, um that's what this whole new section of the BCO is devoted to.
[15:25] SPEAKER_04: The rules by which judicial process is carried out.
[15:29] SPEAKER_04: That's a the restricted technical sense.
[15:31] SPEAKER_04: Morton Smith points out, and I love this, and uh Jared, I know you and I have talked about some of this, um, and Steve, having served on the SJC, I wonder what you would think.
[15:39] SPEAKER_04: Morton says that that the rules are set out to protect the rights of all parties involved.
[15:45] SPEAKER_04: And I think we we all agree with that, but it can often look and feel like you know, only the guys that know it are really being protected because it it's it's only useful to people that know it.
[15:56] SPEAKER_04: But it is intended, all of these rules that we're about to start proceeding through are meant to protect the rights of the offense the offending party and those offended or the church, I guess, in every sense.
[16:10] SPEAKER_04: Jared, I mean what do you have more thoughts on that?
[16:13] SPEAKER_04: I mean, I suppose as we go, they'll develop.
[16:15] SPEAKER_04: But Steve, how has that how has that worked out with the SJC as you've watched it?
[16:19] SPEAKER_04: You know, the the idea that that it's there to protect people, but it probably doesn't always feel like it's there to protect people.
[16:24] SPEAKER_01: I I do think that there's a lot of appropriation of principles that are designed to protect the innocent, but you know, there's a sense in which a professing Christian is held to a little bit of a higher standard because it isn't their own pride, integrity, glory that's at stake.
[16:40] SPEAKER_01: It's it's the integrity and the glory of Jesus Christ that's at stake.
[16:45] SPEAKER_01: And so when you start getting into the details of our process, sometimes it can take on a more secular uh character than maybe it ought to, which is why I like to constantly repeat what we'll go over in a few minutes, which is what's the first purpose of discipline, what's the glory of God?
[17:03] SPEAKER_01: And when you become so embedded in process that you that you you'll you'll stumble over whether you know you're giving somebody the benefit of the doubt, or or you'll you'll essentially uh treat discipline as if unless it can be proven beyond any reasonable doubt, you can't find someone guilty, then the process is failing because it can't possibly glorify God if you if you're merely finding a mechanism for getting out from under discipline.
[17:31] SPEAKER_01: You may want to excise this, but I had a really interesting thing happen recently at the session level.
[17:37] SPEAKER_01: International church plant.
[17:39] SPEAKER_01: And um the the the minister there uh had a daughter who uh at one of these churches had a daughter who uh ran off the rails.
[17:48] SPEAKER_01: And he asked for help uh from the from the uh Presbytery.
[17:52] SPEAKER_01: Presbytery constituted a a session level court to deal with it.
[17:55] SPEAKER_01: Charged her with offenses that I won't get into here.
[17:58] SPEAKER_01: Uh and uh she responded to the citation to appear at a at a plea hearing and said, Um, you know, I'm about to go into boot camp and I'll go to A school after that.
[18:07] SPEAKER_01: I will appear and and plea.
[18:09] SPEAKER_01: So we extended the date to early January.
[18:12] SPEAKER_01: In the meantime, I looked at the papers and it appeared as though she went she had attempted to withdraw from the church when she was not under discipline.
[18:19] SPEAKER_01: And that meant that I had to inform her that she actually did not have to show up for this plea hearing, and that the reality was is that when she said she was withdrawing, she was withdrawing.
[18:29] SPEAKER_01: And the Holy Spirit worked on her and she said, You know, am I still a member?
[18:33] SPEAKER_01: And I said, Well, you know, I I would be delighted if you declared yourself a member and submitted to discipline.
[18:38] SPEAKER_01: And she said, I want to be a member because I want to be held accountable.
[18:42] SPEAKER_01: And she came in a completely repentant and pled guilty to the charges.
[18:46] SPEAKER_01: And the reality is that she could have gotten out from under it.
[18:49] SPEAKER_01: Her rights would have been completely validated by her just saying, I don't have to do it, I'm not gonna do it.
[18:55] SPEAKER_01: But instead, she actually craved the the nurture and administer of the Lord.
[18:59] SPEAKER_01: She wanted to be accountable, she wanted to appear before the authorities that Christ had delegated to do this kind of function and to clear her conscience there, and to tell us what she was gonna do to turn it around.
[19:09] SPEAKER_01: You know, she'd been in chapel, she's looking for a church, still uh in the same relationship was ship she was in, but chased, moved out, you know, all that kind of thing.
[19:17] SPEAKER_01: Just a really truly remarkable example of the distinction between wanting to glorify God and the administration of judicial discipline and wanting to stick to rules of fairness.
[19:27] SPEAKER_01: Although I've spoken too long, but I'll say this last thing.
[19:30] SPEAKER_01: The other thing that happens when you start to uh think that you can operate in in too detailed a manner around the rules of discipline is that you have differences of opinion about how to interpret them.
[19:40] SPEAKER_01: And every year in overtures, and a number of you that are on this podcast have been in overtures multiple times, and you know that we start to argue about what the meaning of is is.
[19:50] SPEAKER_01: And so if we bear in mind constantly in the administration of judicial discipline that our primary purpose is the very first thing is the glory of God, I think that we've got a foundation upon which to understand those rules that ought to make us want to preserve the rights of the accused and make sure that everyone is treated fairly in the way that uh Morton Smith elucidated it.
[20:12] SPEAKER_01: But at the same time keeps us triangulated in a way that doesn't put us into the kind of morass that you see in the secular courts.
[20:20] SPEAKER_04: That's a good word.
[20:23] SPEAKER_04: Let's look at uh 27-2.
[20:26] SPEAKER_04: It spells out for us who the recipients of discipline are, those the subjects, um those those who are under it.
[20:32] SPEAKER_04: All baptized persons being members of the church are subjects to its discipline and entitled to the benefits thereof.
[20:41] SPEAKER_04: Now I have an issue with this that I can wait to bring up if one of one of my co-hosts would like to just sort of you know explain what this means and then I can protest a little bit.
[20:50] SPEAKER_02: But yeah, so this section in the BCO is actually arguing that both the non-communing and communing members are the subject of discipline within the church.
[21:00] SPEAKER_02: And this means that there are there's a group of non-professing members that receive obviously preventative discipline.
[21:07] SPEAKER_02: The hope is that they would come to faith in the Lord Jesus Christ and profess faith.
[21:11] SPEAKER_02: That's part of the discipline, but also corrective discipline in the technical sense.
[21:15] SPEAKER_02: And Morton Smith outlines it being used uh to that very end.
[21:20] SPEAKER_02: And so this is basically just saying, and it's pretty, it's it's unique to our constitution when comparing to perhaps other traditions, the main line before us, but even some that are even present-day confessional groups.
[21:32] SPEAKER_02: This is a unique standard that we have within the PCA, that non-members or baptized non-professing members are also the subject of church discipline.
[21:44] SPEAKER_04: Okay, so my issue.
[21:47] SPEAKER_04: Sorry, did is it am I too fast or that way?
[21:52] SPEAKER_04: My issue is the presumption that baptism makes you a member.
[21:57] SPEAKER_04: Now, I get it with new, older professionals.
[22:00] SPEAKER_04: Professing believers, right, like you know, convert coming into your church.
[22:03] SPEAKER_04: But BCO six one says that the children of believers are non-commuting members of the church.
[22:09] SPEAKER_04: And by and by virtue of of that, by right of birth, then they are entitled to baptism and discipline.
[22:18] SPEAKER_04: So while they seem 272 seems to say that baptism is the requirement to be subject to discipline, six one seems to indicate that it's your your birth right to have access to both baptism and discipline.
[22:32] SPEAKER_04: Now, is this just where our BCO is a little quirky and not in full agreement with each other?
[22:37] SPEAKER_04: But it seems significant to me.
[22:38] SPEAKER_04: So come on.
[22:41] SPEAKER_00: I think it's assuming that the Venn diagram is basically a circle, that if you are a member, you are baptized, and so that's another way to refer to it is baptism is it's cooked.
[22:50] SPEAKER_04: So if my daughter waits, if we wait six weeks to baptize her after she's born, is she not she's not a non-communing member until that that week six when she's baptized?
[22:59] SPEAKER_04: Because six one says she's a she's a member when she's born.
[23:04] SPEAKER_00: How many times do you think this has come up?
[23:06] SPEAKER_00: I I guess it would come up if you have a couple that has children that um they they don't ever bring for baptism, and are they considered a member of the church?
[23:14] SPEAKER_00: Are they considered for discipline?
[23:16] SPEAKER_00: I guess it would come up in in a case like that, and that would be a place where that Venn diagram has some unoverlapping parts that you'd have to figure out.
[23:24] SPEAKER_04: I'm not saying it comes up.
[23:25] SPEAKER_04: I'm just if we're not gonna argue about it, if if we're gonna argue about it, why not here?
[23:29] SPEAKER_04: That's that's basically my point, but anyway.
[23:32] SPEAKER_00: I'm actually more struck by the end of that sentence, uh, which I love, which it says that they are subject to its discipline and entitled to the benefits thereof.
[23:40] SPEAKER_00: Just the way that right away the BCO is speaking of discipline as a benefit or the benefits coming from discipline.
[23:47] SPEAKER_00: Uh again, reminds me of Hebrews 12, right?
[23:50] SPEAKER_00: The Lord disciplines the one he loves and chastises every son whom he receives.
[23:55] SPEAKER_00: Uh makes the point if you are left without discipline in which all have participated, then you are illegitimate children and not sons.
[24:01] SPEAKER_00: Sometimes I have to be reminded of this, especially when we're looking into things of why are we, you know, dragging our feet on certain discipline issues?
[24:09] SPEAKER_00: Do we not love them?
[24:09] SPEAKER_00: Do we not want to give them the benefit of this?
[24:11] SPEAKER_00: So it it just frames it in an entirely different way.
[24:13] SPEAKER_00: I just love that one word there, the benefits thereof.
[24:15] SPEAKER_04: There's some fun trivia from the history of this one, too, that Morton Smith points it out in his commentary.
[24:23] SPEAKER_04: By the way, I'm gonna be talking a lot about Morton Smith from now on because Pear Almquist doesn't have any material yet published on this section of the BCO.
[24:33] SPEAKER_04: Come on, Pear.
[24:34] SPEAKER_04: Gotta gotta get on that, man.
[24:36] SPEAKER_04: One of the anomalies in the PC US Constitution was that it non-commuting members were not included as subjects of discipline.
[24:42] SPEAKER_04: Um and their view, as far as Morton explained it, was that uh you you if they weren't at the table, you didn't have anything you could take away from them, basically.
[24:50] SPEAKER_04: But he said that that you could wind up in a situation where you have someone who's on the rolls as a non-commuting member who is living in flagrant sin and is not able to be disciplined for that sin they're committing.
[25:00] SPEAKER_04: And then he says, you know, we have we have other things besides the table that you can censure someone with, you can admonish someone, and you can even excommunicate someone.
[25:09] SPEAKER_04: You know, you don't only have to be able to take the table away.
[25:13] SPEAKER_02: Have you ever seen charges brought against a non-commuting member?
[25:17] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it's funny, it just happened uh about two weeks ago.
[25:20] SPEAKER_01: I got a call from a friend, the teach guilder, and he said, We got a non-commuting member who's grown up and they're off the rails.
[25:26] SPEAKER_01: You know, what can we do?
[25:27] SPEAKER_01: Unfortunately, you can't you can't charge them and drag them in and subject them to the judicial conditions of of uh the rules of discipline.
[25:36] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, you can do the other things, you can admonish them and so on, and in the end, I think there's even a legitimate discussion about how you excommunicate somebody who isn't uh you know, isn't an actual uh community member.
[25:50] SPEAKER_01: Obviously, could be exercised, but that seems to be bound by a number of conditions.
[25:55] SPEAKER_01: You know, it was kind of an interesting conversation, but uh up until two weeks ago I'd had to tell you no.
[26:00] SPEAKER_01: I hadn't seen it and hadn't even thought of it.
[26:03] SPEAKER_01: But there you go.
[26:05] SPEAKER_04: There's a few kids in our church that make me think about it a lot, anyway.
[26:11] SPEAKER_01: But they're not baptized yet because they're only six weeks old.
[26:14] SPEAKER_04: That's right, yeah.
[26:15] SPEAKER_04: Well, let's keep going.
[26:16] SPEAKER_04: 273 gets into the the importance and the necessity of discipline, uh, speaks to the the goal and the purpose, some of which Steve has already highlighted for us.
[26:27] SPEAKER_01: I'm sorry I got out of sequence.
[26:29] SPEAKER_04: It doesn't bother me in the least.
[26:31] SPEAKER_04: No, this is all I I think I think we can't talk enough about the the first See, your brothers are all teaching elders, so I'm just gonna give you the secret.
[26:39] SPEAKER_01: You know, chapter 27 is chiastic.
[26:43] SPEAKER_01: You may not have picked up on that, but when you're exegeting 27, there you go, right at the middle of the chiasm there, 27-3, baby.
[26:52] SPEAKER_01: I like it.
[26:53] SPEAKER_04: There's gotta be a title in there somewhere.
[26:55] SPEAKER_04: I'm gonna pull that out.
[26:56] SPEAKER_04: Right in the middle of the chiasm in 27-3, the exercise of discipline is highly important and necessary.
[27:02] SPEAKER_04: In its proper usage, discipline maintains a the glory of God, B, the purity of his church, C, the keeping and reclaiming of disobedient sinners.
[27:12] SPEAKER_04: Discipline is for the purpose of godliness, therefore it demands a self-examination under Scripture.
[27:18] SPEAKER_04: Its ends, so far as it involves judicial action, are the rebuke of offenses, the removal of scandal, the vindication of the honor of Christ, the promotion of the purity and general edification of the church, and the spiritual good of offenders themselves.
[27:35] SPEAKER_04: I think I'm gonna ask one of my yeah, where should we start?
[27:38] SPEAKER_04: Jared, you're you're leaning in.
[27:40] SPEAKER_00: I love this section partly for these three purposes, these three aims of discipline, uh, for what it says and what it doesn't say.
[27:47] SPEAKER_00: I I love the fact that we have here, okay, why do we do discipline?
[27:51] SPEAKER_00: Well, you can answer for the glory of God, for the purity of the church, for the keeping and reclaiming of disobedient sinners.
[27:56] SPEAKER_00: And yet one of those purposes is not to get rid of a problem member, to punish somebody who always is asking the wrong questions, you know, of the pastor after the sermon.
[28:06] SPEAKER_00: Like there are ways in which I think uh discipline has attempted to be used in churches that are not at these aims.
[28:12] SPEAKER_00: And that's this is a question to ask.
[28:14] SPEAKER_00: Like, is discipline coming in here for this purpose?
[28:16] SPEAKER_00: And especially and thinking of the way we're cheap, that last one, the keeping and reclaiming of disobedient sinners, is this meant to bring them back, to show them the seriousness of this?
[28:27] SPEAKER_00: I'm struck by uh Christ's instructions that when you get to the end of discipline, you treat them as if they were a publican, uh, if they were a sinner.
[28:36] SPEAKER_00: And what did Jesus do with them?
[28:38] SPEAKER_00: He evangelized them, right?
[28:39] SPEAKER_00: It's as if to say, now you need to treat them as if they're not one of us and you want to bring them into us because we're basically recognizing it seems like you don't understand Christ as Lord or Christ as Savior, and we're declaring that and saying, now we're inviting you to come in because you're really not in.
[28:55] SPEAKER_00: You thought you were, but you're not, but by the way that this is going.
[28:58] SPEAKER_00: I I just I love to have these as the purpose to anytime you start discipline, you have to say, does this fall under A, B, or C?
[29:05] SPEAKER_00: Because we can't just invent new reasons to have discipline just for our own purposes.
[29:09] SPEAKER_02: It's probably helpful to remember these when we've been discussing, we've been discussing the rules of discipline for the last few years at the assembly and what its hopes and aims are.
[29:19] SPEAKER_02: And there has been in some sections of our church the temptation to perhaps pursue a more civil route to church discipline and making it somewhat more like a civil court.
[29:30] SPEAKER_02: But perhaps we it'd be good for us to remind ourselves of 27-3 and what we seek to do.
[29:36] SPEAKER_02: It's not to bring a civil justice, it's to bring honor and glory to God.
[29:40] SPEAKER_02: And so perhaps it's a helpful reminder of what we seek to do in our church courts.
[29:46] SPEAKER_02: Because it seems that in many cases over the last few years, there's been a conflating of the church court versing that it's not.
[29:53] SPEAKER_02: Um it's like I failed in the civil realm, so now I'm gonna go to the ecclesiastical realm, and maybe I'll find civil justice there, but that's not the aim or purpose of the civil or the the ecclesiastical court, I should say.
[30:05] SPEAKER_01: Well, I like I'm like Jared.
[30:06] SPEAKER_01: I I think that this is uh by the way, I completely agree with that, Scott.
[30:10] SPEAKER_01: Uh, but but I think that this thing is a beautifully constructed.
[30:14] SPEAKER_01: Uh, you know, if you look at it, it goes from the general to the specific.
[30:17] SPEAKER_01: You know, like so no matter how confusing everything gets, you can always ask yourself the question is what we're doing, does it glorify God?
[30:25] SPEAKER_01: You know, are are we are we pointing to the glory of God, are we preserving the glory of God, and so on.
[30:29] SPEAKER_01: Um the second thing becomes a little bit more specific, but it's also collective and not individual.
[30:35] SPEAKER_01: It's it's about the purity of the church.
[30:37] SPEAKER_01: Now you could say, well, you know, that's a synecdoche or something where, you know, that could mean every member of the church, each and every member, and so on.
[30:43] SPEAKER_01: But I'd submit to you that that's not what's in view here.
[30:46] SPEAKER_01: I mean, what's in view here is the church, the bride of Christ, as the bride of Christ.
[30:50] SPEAKER_01: And then you get to the individual members of the church, which we've already established are community members, right?
[30:56] SPEAKER_01: And then when you look at the ends, you know, like what happens as a result of the administration of judicial discipline, you rebuke offenses.
[31:03] SPEAKER_01: In other words, you call out sin.
[31:05] SPEAKER_01: Why do you do that?
[31:06] SPEAKER_01: Because you're removing scandal.
[31:08] SPEAKER_01: And what is scandal?
[31:09] SPEAKER_01: I mean, scandal is when something becomes notorious and it impends reflects on the the integrity of the church.
[31:16] SPEAKER_01: So you have scandals that are related to, you know, abuse of children or or things like that.
[31:21] SPEAKER_01: I mean, uh, those things must be removed because they do triangulate to the glory of God, and and it's something that affects the entire church.
[31:29] SPEAKER_01: Dealing with the individual who actually sinned there is in a sense a tertiary issue.
[31:34] SPEAKER_01: While it may be the most important thing to that individual in the administration of justice, that's not the most important thing.
[31:40] SPEAKER_01: The most important thing are these other things, and so you have then again the vindication of the honor of Christ, and then the promotion and purity of the church, which echoes uh number uh both A and B, and then you finally get to C, uh, which is the spiritual good of the offenders themselves.
[31:54] SPEAKER_01: And I just think that that thing is constructed in a way that deserves contemplation because it makes the administration of discipline more coherent for those who are participating in it, either because they have to administer it or they have to receive it.
[32:07] SPEAKER_01: Um it's humbling.
[32:08] SPEAKER_01: If I've done something wrong and I'm being called to account for it, to realize that there's a little bit of a bigger picture here to whether I've repented from it and I think it should be over with now, over and against the damage that I may have done to the church.
[32:20] SPEAKER_04: Y'all f y'all anything else on 27-3?
[32:22] SPEAKER_04: I don't want to move too quick, but we hit everything.
[32:27] SPEAKER_04: Alright, we're coming coming back down the bend of of the chiasm in 27-4.
[32:34] SPEAKER_04: Gonna start returning.
[32:35] SPEAKER_04: So by discipline, the church authoritatively separates between the holy and the profane.
[32:42] SPEAKER_04: In this it acts the part of a tender mother, correcting her children for their good, that every one of them may be presented faultless in the day of the Lord Jesus.
[32:51] SPEAKER_04: Discipline is systematic, training under the authority of God's Scripture.
[32:56] SPEAKER_04: No communing or non-communing member of the church should be allowed to stray from the scriptures' discipline.
[33:02] SPEAKER_04: Therefore, teaching elders must a instruct the officers in discipline, b, instruct the congregation in discipline, and c jointly practice it in the context of the congregation and church courts.
[33:16] SPEAKER_04: Again, several things we need to start dividing here.
[33:19] SPEAKER_04: First, the the power that Christ has given is described in a couple of different ways, firstly being for building up, not for destruction.
[33:27] SPEAKER_04: Administer under mercy, not wrath.
[33:31] SPEAKER_04: Certainly, this is describing the attitude we should approach it with.
[33:37] SPEAKER_04: What what are what are y'all's thoughts on this?
[33:40] SPEAKER_04: I mean, the question I want to ask is how do we do this?
[33:42] SPEAKER_04: You know, it can be very hard to have the right attitude sometimes in these matters.
[33:47] SPEAKER_00: I think some of it is the attitude that it's presented to the congregation or presented to the person that is possibly subject to judicial process.
[33:55] SPEAKER_00: This is the section where if we ever did commission different daily devotionals from the BCO, I think this would be one of them.
[34:01] SPEAKER_00: You know, the the idea of why did our parents discipline us?
[34:04] SPEAKER_00: And sometimes we saw anger in their faces, but they really did it because they loved us.
[34:08] SPEAKER_00: You know, they were angry that we wanted to run into the street, but uh it wasn't just anger, they didn't want us to be hurt.
[34:14] SPEAKER_00: And so I think a big thing for this section for us is to whenever we instruct on discipline, we do it with kind of that pleading sense of the this this is for your like please do this, like please, like you you don't realize that this is for your good, this is out of love, and to always have that in mind, not just to be, again, if you're thinking of the purposes of it, it's it's not just strict punishment or because we're mad, it's uh for the reclaiming.
[34:38] SPEAKER_00: It's there's a there's a pleading sense in the tone that we have in discipline.
[34:42] SPEAKER_04: And that I mean, I just my mind is going to the the contrary side, right?
[34:46] SPEAKER_04: Like I think as a parent, uh Lord willing, you know, most of us are disciplining our children and we have that pleading sense attached to it.
[34:54] SPEAKER_04: But so often it can it can get lost, I think, in the more judicial side of things in the church.
[35:01] SPEAKER_04: Because you you know, I can I can get frustrated.
[35:04] SPEAKER_04: I just wish people would act right.
[35:05] SPEAKER_04: Why can't people just act like Christians, you know?
[35:07] SPEAKER_04: And it I mean, I'll confess, you know, that that's a really difficult thing for me to do because my first instinct is why can't they just do what they're supposed to do?
[35:16] SPEAKER_04: But then this this paragraph, right, is meant to draw us back and and say, hey, listen, Christ Christ has given us this power not to destroy people and not to not to meet out wrath on on our congregations, but to build them up and to show them mercy.
[35:34] SPEAKER_04: And then they he compares it.
[35:35] SPEAKER_04: He, I say he.
[35:36] SPEAKER_04: Like you know, Paul, who wrote the BCO.
[35:38] SPEAKER_04: I don't know what I'm talking about.
[35:39] SPEAKER_04: Um That was Peter.
[35:41] SPEAKER_04: As oh, sorry.
[35:42] SPEAKER_04: So there's this comparison.
[35:44] SPEAKER_04: As in the preaching of the word, the wicked are doctrinally separated from the good.
[35:47] SPEAKER_04: So also by discipline, the church authoritatively separates between the holy and the profane.
[35:54] SPEAKER_04: So while while we deal with them mercifully, while while elders should deal mercifully with those that they are disciplining and they're building them up, it is still necessary for discipline to separate the profane from the holy.
[36:07] SPEAKER_04: We are still we're still doing something of a separation as as the wicked and good are separated in the preaching of the word.
[36:13] SPEAKER_04: So those who demonstrate their true nature to be profane must be separated from the holy, as we say.
[36:18] SPEAKER_04: I mean, y'all y'all jump in and elaborate.
[36:21] SPEAKER_04: I don't know.
[36:21] SPEAKER_04: I don't know if there's much more to say.
[36:22] SPEAKER_04: I'm not trying to say it all.
[36:24] SPEAKER_01: Could I make a comment?
[36:25] SPEAKER_01: Of course.
[36:40] SPEAKER_01: One of the things that happens, especially at the appellate level in the PCA, is guys act like enemies.
[36:46] SPEAKER_01: They act mad at one another and they like to score points off one another.
[36:50] SPEAKER_01: I'm not in a trivia motive.
[36:51] SPEAKER_01: I don't think they they uh, you know, like uh make up a scorecard and go, aha, I got you, right?
[36:56] SPEAKER_01: But I mean you're trying to win a case, and so if you can make someone look foolish, then you know you're proving their guilt, right?
[37:03] SPEAKER_01: They say they can't give a satisfactory answer.
[37:06] SPEAKER_01: And I I would say that that what that's done is instead of in in Jared's example of how parents administer discipline, it's like two brothers and they're twins trying to administer discipline, and so they engage with it as peers.
[37:18] SPEAKER_01: And we are, in fact, all peers.
[37:20] SPEAKER_01: All of us are members, we have the same standing before Jesus Christ.
[37:23] SPEAKER_01: Um, you know, God is not a respecter of persons, and we all are standing only on our faith, right?
[37:28] SPEAKER_01: When but when we appear for discipline in this judicial sense, there is a power asymmetry.
[37:34] SPEAKER_01: And the way that we engage with that, you know, has two responsibilities.
[37:37] SPEAKER_01: You know, one of the things that happens to an accused is if they frustrate the court, they can be charged with contumacy and the court can just administer discipline.
[37:46] SPEAKER_01: Um you know, on and and as a result of having that power, I think that the court ought to really, really be careful not to collectively or individually get its feelings hurt so that they want to engage in a you know in a in what really amounts to a an argument instead of uh an an absolute generous kind of hearing, getting all the facts and then reaching a a reason determination and and encouraging and exhorting that brother to understand that they're in the wrong place.
[38:16] SPEAKER_01: But when you create that dynamic where you don't have a a clear parental or child relationship where you where you act like that's been ameliorated or diluted in some way, I think it leads to that combative nature and makes it impossible to administer in a dispensation of mercy.
[38:32] SPEAKER_01: Instead, it just gets angry sounding, and I find that to be a complete abnegation of principle number one that we've covered on at least three times already, which is the glory of God.
[38:44] SPEAKER_01: We are not glorying God when we get into a courtroom setting and we fight with one another.
[38:49] SPEAKER_01: If you're the accused, you need to be submissive and be and and and uh to be careful that you're heard properly.
[38:56] SPEAKER_01: And if you're the ones wielding the authority, you need to be aware that you're you're holding you're handling that authority, not so that you can get your way because this person made you angry, but because you're administering a discipline in the name of the name of Jesus Christ to someone that he loves.
[39:11] SPEAKER_01: And and even someone you're gonna excommunicate who may have done a horrible thing.
[39:15] SPEAKER_01: It's certainly not our judgment to decide whether in the end they're elect.
[39:19] SPEAKER_01: So, anyway, I'm sorry about rebooting on that, but you know, normally you don't have a bunch of guys sitting around going through the BCL line by line, and it made me think about it in a little bit of a different way.
[39:28] SPEAKER_04: Very helpful.
[39:31] SPEAKER_04: I've only sat in on one SJC hearing.
[39:34] SPEAKER_04: I was connected to a case and was allowed to sit in and and observe.
[39:38] SPEAKER_04: And it does there is an error about it.
[39:40] SPEAKER_04: I can see how easily there could be an error about it between the two parties of contention and and aggressive disagreement.
[39:49] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, you're totally right.
[39:50] SPEAKER_01: Even with the session level court though, it can be very, very angry because uh and and if you read the transcripts that come in these records of cases, which I'm not sure that they're all distributed, but the records themselves, I I don't know what the rules are about distributing those.
[40:05] SPEAKER_01: But if you go read them, in so many cases it's obvious that you've got some people who are angry.
[40:09] SPEAKER_01: And you know, and that kind of just completely blows this stuff out of the water.
[40:13] SPEAKER_01: So hovering on it the way that you're doing here, I think really has benefit for the church.
[40:18] SPEAKER_01: If you're gonna be involved in this, know what role you're playing.
[40:21] SPEAKER_01: Are you the accuser or the accused?
[40:22] SPEAKER_01: And deport yourself accordingly, because in the end you're both there and you have one obligation, and that's the glory of God.
[40:29] SPEAKER_01: Peace and purity of the church, and getting this sin called out and rebuked or proven not to be not to you know to not have merit.
[40:36] SPEAKER_04: This is uh what every elder wants to be called, a tender mother.
[40:40] SPEAKER_04: Because it was ref it's a reference of the church properly, we should be clear.
[40:43] SPEAKER_04: So in this exercise of power that Christ has given, the church acts as a tender mother correcting her children for their good, that every one of them may be presented faultless in the day of the Lord Jesus, which I again just goes back for me to what Jared's been reiterating is Hebrews 12.
[41:01] SPEAKER_04: That discipline is for our good, even though for the moment it seems painful rather than pleasant.
[41:05] SPEAKER_04: It later yields the peaceful fruit of righteousness.
[41:08] SPEAKER_04: We we're able to be presented faultless in the day of the Lord Jesus.
[41:10] SPEAKER_04: It's systematic training under the authority of God's scripture.
[41:13] SPEAKER_04: I'd love for somebody to explain to me what that sentence means.
[41:16] SPEAKER_04: Discipline is systematic training under the authority of God's scripture.
[41:19] SPEAKER_04: No takers.
[41:20] SPEAKER_01: Oh, I know the answer, but I've talked too much, so I'm leaving it to Scott.
[41:25] SPEAKER_01: He called you Scott.
[41:27] SPEAKER_01: You can't prove it.
[41:28] SPEAKER_02: I want to answer this.
[41:29] SPEAKER_02: I don't have a an answer that's gonna be coherent.
[41:32] SPEAKER_02: So I'm gonna leave it back to Steve.
[41:35] SPEAKER_01: I could say something, but I'd just be rambling.
[41:38] SPEAKER_01: You know, Scott, you know, I I know that we talked about that before and decided that Jared would answer that question.
[41:47] SPEAKER_00: Well, I think it partly relates to what's gonna come next, which is there are steps for discipline and where it begins is in the word.
[41:54] SPEAKER_00: And this is one of the big parts of discipline.
[41:57] SPEAKER_00: Discipline comes in, especially without process, when you have people who have neglected their membership vows to attend to worship.
[42:04] SPEAKER_00: There's specifications for how long that is, up to a year, but when they've been away from it for so long, then discipline is no longer working in their life in a broader sense, and that's where it's going to come in on a more particular sense because you're gonna have to go after them and say, you're you're not here.
[42:19] SPEAKER_00: You're not hearing God's instruction.
[42:20] SPEAKER_00: You're not hearing what it is that we ought to know about who God is and what we ought to believe and how we ought to live.
[42:25] SPEAKER_00: And the the discipline that is systematic instruction has to be heard.
[42:29] SPEAKER_00: And uh that's why it's one of the biggest parts of discipline is getting somebody back under that.
[42:33] SPEAKER_00: And what that's why next we're gonna see that's where everything starts.
[42:37] SPEAKER_00: First, it starts with instruction.
[42:38] SPEAKER_00: Do you know about what it is you ought to be doing?
[42:40] SPEAKER_00: And hopefully, for for the majority of Christians in the majority of cases, once you hear, oh, I think this and scripture thinks this, or I do this and scripture tells me to do something different, I must be wrong.
[42:51] SPEAKER_00: Scripture is right, and therefore I need to sit under that discipline.
[42:55] SPEAKER_00: I need to be trained to do differently.
[42:57] SPEAKER_00: And that is all in the broader sense of discipline and where discipline starts.
[43:01] SPEAKER_00: And it's only when that's not heated that discipline goes to its next steps.
[43:07] SPEAKER_04: Steve, is that an acceptable answer?
[43:10] SPEAKER_01: Yes, but all of Jared's answers are acceptable answers.
[43:14] SPEAKER_04: Don't tell him that.
[43:16] SPEAKER_04: We don't need him.
[43:17] SPEAKER_04: That's like when people tell me my two-year-old is adorable.
[43:19] SPEAKER_04: I'm like, yeah, don't tell her.
[43:20] SPEAKER_04: I don't want people to, she doesn't need to know that.
[43:22] SPEAKER_01: Well, now that you've called me on it, I admit I've said that Jared's adorable more than once.
[43:28] SPEAKER_04: I love the next sentence.
[43:30] SPEAKER_04: No commuting or non-commuting member of the church should be allowed to stray from the scripture's discipline.
[43:35] SPEAKER_04: Um, you know, it is my chief desire for my children, not that I would get to do the discipline, but that they would not stray from the discipline.
[43:43] SPEAKER_04: I I want them to walk the way that scripture is guiding them to go.
[43:47] SPEAKER_04: And and sometimes it's not pleasant.
[43:49] SPEAKER_04: But my chief desire is for them to stick to that.
[43:52] SPEAKER_00: And that's why we don't say for um the kids, for the non commuting members, for our kids, look, you could just figure it out for yourself.
[43:58] SPEAKER_00: You can choose whether or not you're gonna go or not.
[44:00] SPEAKER_00: We don't do that in going to school and learning math.
[44:02] SPEAKER_00: We shouldn't do that for learning God's word and what it has for them because if we care for their their bodies, their their minds for the things of this world, we ought to care for their immortal souls.
[44:12] SPEAKER_00: So it's they're not allowed to just do you want to go to church this morning or do you want to play Nintendo Switch?
[44:18] SPEAKER_00: No, that's not a choice.
[44:20] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it's not a fair thing.
[44:22] SPEAKER_02: When I was a kid, my family asked, Do you want to go to C C D of the Catholic Church anymore?
[44:27] SPEAKER_02: And I was like, no.
[44:29] SPEAKER_02: Why would I want to go to school after school?
[44:31] SPEAKER_02: Why would you ask me that?
[44:33] SPEAKER_02: And so I never went to C C D because it was in my own choice and will.
[44:37] SPEAKER_02: What's a CCD?
[44:39] SPEAKER_02: Uh that's like Catholic catechism class that you take towards confirmation.
[44:44] SPEAKER_04: Sounds kind of like Polity Matters.
[44:47] SPEAKER_02: Confirmation.
[44:48] SPEAKER_02: That's who you are.
[44:49] SPEAKER_04: I want to ask, and and Steve is the only non-teaching elder in the room, so maybe you have a good answer for this.
[44:55] SPEAKER_04: Why are teaching elders addressed, particularly in this last part of 27-4?
[44:59] SPEAKER_04: We actually had a listener write in reading ahead, wants to know why teaching elders here are addressed.
[45:03] SPEAKER_04: And he he had some sense of why on a couple of them, but Teaching Elders have to instruct.
[45:26] SPEAKER_01: Um, you know, so that's always gonna be a good question.
[45:29] SPEAKER_01: But um, you know, as an example, I don't know if you guys picked up on it, but you will as you go through the rules of discipline here.
[45:35] SPEAKER_01: But it's the weirdest thing in the world that a a ruling elder can uh chair hearing against a teaching elder, but he cannot chair a session level court.
[45:46] SPEAKER_01: Why?
[45:46] SPEAKER_01: Well, there is no answer why.
[45:48] SPEAKER_01: I mean, it's just it's just because that's the way it reads right now.
[45:51] SPEAKER_01: And it'll read that way until it's changed.
[45:53] SPEAKER_01: But um, I think that this is not, you know, that because I do think that uh we have the doctrine of vocation described in the BCL and that uh teaching elders are subjected to a much greater re level of rigor with their training in in the scriptures uh than ruling elders are, and I don't care how well you know 'em.
[46:14] SPEAKER_01: You have had that formalized training, the PCA.
[46:17] SPEAKER_01: A lot of people think we're just too doctrinal, you know, because we have we have pretty rigorous requirements.
[46:21] SPEAKER_01: You guys don't just get to come in and say, Well, I graduated from seminary X and so ordained me.
[46:27] SPEAKER_01: But that's not even good enough.
[46:30] SPEAKER_01: And and so the level of scrutiny that goes to a teaching altar I think is uh is important because you're vocationally going to be shepherds of the flock.
[46:40] SPEAKER_01: And you do have a higher level of education.
[46:42] SPEAKER_01: We require it.
[46:44] SPEAKER_01: And so um when I read this thing, I don't find anything odd about it because I do think that there's a particular duty, a particular level at which a teaching elder has to use has to do it.
[46:57] SPEAKER_01: And if he's not doing it, then he's not a pastor to those ruling elders.
[47:01] SPEAKER_01: Right?
[47:02] SPEAKER_01: So, you know, I mean everybody's gotta have a pastor, but unfortunately the pastors of churches you know they gotta they they gotta go they gotta go someplace else.
[47:11] SPEAKER_01: They gotta go to present when you maybe run off the path and get into a cab to finish the race.
[47:18] SPEAKER_01: So that would be the way that I would view it, but I'm kinda you know, that's just my thoughts getting that question cold.
[47:25] SPEAKER_01: It's helpful for me.
[47:28] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it was kind of a humble brag on teaching elders.
[47:31] SPEAKER_01: I hope you guys appreciated that.
[47:33] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, we we like that you said it and we didn't.
[47:36] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I know you wanted to.
[47:37] SPEAKER_01: Your check is in the mail.
[47:38] SPEAKER_01: There's a note up here where Ben said, say this now.
[47:45] SPEAKER_04: So this would be like like you know, progressively working through portions of the BCO with your ruling elders to to teach them what it says about certain aspects of judicial process or even just general church ministry, or having a Sunday school class where you talk about it with your congregation in you know a lighter scent anyway.
[48:03] SPEAKER_04: Scott.
[48:03] SPEAKER_02: And most most churches don't have Steve Dowling as a ruling elder at their church.
[48:07] SPEAKER_02: And so typically, at least what I've seen is that when matters of discipline too come up, there's a deferential looking to the teaching elder as well, what do we do?
[48:17] SPEAKER_02: If you have Steve, you you just ask Steve, what what do we do now?
[48:20] SPEAKER_02: Um but most congregations that I've had experience with, they look to the pastor for guidance and preparation and how to follow the procedures correctly to get them to the end of where they've started.
[48:31] SPEAKER_02: And so they are to be perhaps educated, as Steve was talking about, in these spheres poignantly as they prepare to lead their guys in the process.
[48:42] SPEAKER_02: And so I I wish we all had Steve's or John Bice's, uh, but there those are those seem to be few and far between.
[48:49] SPEAKER_04: Let me ask y'all a question that might help some folks who listen.
[48:53] SPEAKER_04: Maybe uh there's a teaching elder listening who has not uh found a good way to do this, or he's in a church that hasn't been um the most uh forward thinking with in terms of discipline, and it's just not something that's ever come up, and that they they don't, you know, they put things under the rug.
[49:12] SPEAKER_04: How how would you encourage or give advice to a man who's a teaching elder in a congregation and he wants to start trying to instruct the officers or instruct the congregation, but he's he feels like he's up against something in in an attempt to do that?
[49:25] SPEAKER_01: I've got an answer for that one, Ben.
[49:28] SPEAKER_01: Look, man, it starts with your officer training.
[49:30] SPEAKER_01: Churches that require their officers to be trained and to affirm that they're gonna take that the vow they take, they understand what they're vowing to, have much less trouble with being called to a higher level under the instruction of the pastor.
[49:45] SPEAKER_01: You know, uh I was in a church where they meet you, you come in, meet with the session, everybody you've been there a year, everybody likes you, you seem spiritually mature.
[49:55] SPEAKER_01: By the way, you got a good job in your tithing.
[49:58] SPEAKER_01: Sounds like a good candidate for elders.
[50:00] SPEAKER_01: At one point we had in that church, I'll bet you ten dispensationalists as deacons or elders.
[50:08] SPEAKER_01: And uh we realized that we could never agree on anything because we had such a huge doctrinal divide in fundamental things, and it does actually inform practical decision making, as you're all well aware, and so is probably the whole audience.
[50:21] SPEAKER_01: So we all decided, and it was very interesting because it was a one hundred percent vote.
[50:26] SPEAKER_01: It w it was it was like Polish democracy.
[50:31] SPEAKER_01: You know, we weren't gonna do mu anything unless we had an overwhelming vote.
[50:34] SPEAKER_01: We had a hundred percent vote that we were to submit ourselves to nine weeks of training, and we s we appropriated uh Ligan Duncan's how Ligan trains his men from back then, which is pretty exhaustive.
[50:46] SPEAKER_01: For five hundred questions in the end, administered to everybody, and we lost half of our officers.
[50:52] SPEAKER_01: And then we had to do we had discipline uh to administer and we didn't we didn't do anything judicial, but it was the some of the most serious discipline that I've ever been involved with involved going to men who had taken vows that they didn't mean.
[51:08] SPEAKER_01: They didn't believe them.
[51:09] SPEAKER_01: They didn't believe them doctrinally, they they they they had real problems with them, and so what we did with those men was we had them what's the word, not deposition.
[51:18] SPEAKER_01: When you when you voluntarily Yes, and the reason that we administered that, you know, with minutes and everything was because those vows are made to God, they're administered in that way, and I don't think an individual can get out from under a vow, but a court does have a role there, having been given the authority of Christ, and understanding that these men weren't properly educated, and they took that vow hastily.
[51:39] SPEAKER_01: Now I know we can go to scripture and go, Steve, nice try.
[51:42] SPEAKER_01: That easy out doesn't actually exist, but it's the best that we could do.
[51:46] SPEAKER_01: So I feel very strongly, you probably can't tell.
[51:49] SPEAKER_01: I feel very strongly that the answer to that question is train your elders before you decide to put them up in front of the congregation for election.
[51:59] SPEAKER_01: Make sure that when they take that vow, you've done your job.
[52:02] SPEAKER_01: You know what they're vowing that they know what they're vowing to do.
[52:06] SPEAKER_01: And then that thing becomes a lot easier as you as you move down the road of having to deal with other people's problems.
[52:15] SPEAKER_00: I think that's great advice for the officers.
[52:17] SPEAKER_00: I think for the broader church, you can you can do this a lot of different ways, but from the pulpit, I think it's especially important.
[52:24] SPEAKER_00: Now it could be just when you get to those topics as you come to them, or you can particularly think, I'm going to preach through Matthew 18.
[52:30] SPEAKER_00: I'm going to preach through Hebrews 12.
[52:32] SPEAKER_00: Whether it's you take all of Matthew or just Hebrews 12.
[52:35] SPEAKER_00: Uh, it's it's something you should do.
[52:37] SPEAKER_00: And I know in our church has come up, we actually had a discipline matter that was coming in which somebody was being restored, and we just took a week off and we preached through Matthew 18 and said, What's happening?
[52:49] SPEAKER_00: Like, why are we doing this?
[52:50] SPEAKER_00: I preached the entire book of Hebrews, and part of it was I were just really wanting to preach uh Hebrews 12.
[52:55] SPEAKER_00: And so you could do it that way too.
[52:57] SPEAKER_00: So I think if they hear, especially Hebrews 12, if you ever hear Hebrews 12 exposited, then you start to love discipline where you might have feared it or hated it before.
[53:08] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, taking the opportunities as you can when new members are coming in and they're about to make these vows, taking time before the whole congregation to explain them.
[53:17] SPEAKER_02: Um, particularly spending time in the idea of discipline.
[53:21] SPEAKER_02: I kind of break it up to I do a few questions every time and I just cycle through it.
[53:25] SPEAKER_02: And I spend a lot of time when we do get to discipline, what it means, just because it's a scary thing.
[53:30] SPEAKER_02: What are you vowing?
[53:31] SPEAKER_02: Uh but it it's more than that.
[53:32] SPEAKER_02: And so taking the time if you don't have this sermon ready to whenever somebody joins ends up and professes explaining those things.
[53:40] SPEAKER_04: If the admonition is rejected, then the calling of if rejection persists, then the church must act through her court unto admonition, suspension, excommunication, and deposition.
[53:53] SPEAKER_04: Steps A through D must be followed in proper order for the exercise of discipline.
[54:00] SPEAKER_04: Before we even get into the the steps, there's a a whole couple of sentences there that are worth spending probably a whole episode on.
[54:06] SPEAKER_04: Scriptural law is the basis of all discipline because it is the revelation of God's holy will.
[54:11] SPEAKER_04: And these proper disciplinary principles are set forth there and must be followed.
[54:15] SPEAKER_04: There's a must in there.
[54:16] SPEAKER_04: Is that your favorite word in the BCO, Scott?
[54:18] SPEAKER_04: You like no, you like shall.
[54:20] SPEAKER_04: That's right.
[54:20] SPEAKER_02: You like shall I like ordinarily.
[54:23] SPEAKER_02: I like the word ordinarily.
[54:24] SPEAKER_04: That's my favorite word.
[54:26] SPEAKER_04: My bad.
[54:27] SPEAKER_00: I think it's Morton Smith that points out that Matthew 18 has to do with personal offenses.
[54:32] SPEAKER_00: And so there's there's a different sort of process if this is between two people, somebody is sending it somebody else, versus something that's on like a larger level, like public teaching.
[54:42] SPEAKER_00: Some of the the requirements here of going to somebody first and bringing them and trying to convince them, especially, you have to think of on what level have the offenses been made known.
[54:51] SPEAKER_00: And if it's between two people, you don't first go to the whole church and tell them your business before going to them.
[54:56] SPEAKER_00: I mean, this is just good practical instruction here.
[54:58] SPEAKER_00: However, if there's something that's on a level of heretical teaching, it's not necessary that I have to find that book uh author and go to him personally on the side, buy a plane ticket, and talk to him.
[55:09] SPEAKER_00: You know, if it's been put out there publicly, this needs to be handled in a little bit of a different procedure in the church courts because of how it's been made known.
[55:16] SPEAKER_00: So I think we have to realize what this is applying to particularly there.
[55:20] SPEAKER_04: What else?
[55:21] SPEAKER_04: Let's just walk through them then.
[55:22] SPEAKER_04: So there's these principles.
[55:24] SPEAKER_04: Instruction in the word.
[55:26] SPEAKER_04: Is that is that just the general sitting under the ministry of the word from week to week, going to Sunday school, studying the word on your own?
[55:33] SPEAKER_04: Is that is that the the extent of instruction of the word, or is there something more particular happening?
[55:42] SPEAKER_00: We're going to get to charges later.
[55:43] SPEAKER_00: And when you're writing out charges, they have to have some sort of a scriptural basis.
[55:47] SPEAKER_00: It can't just be your own personal opinion or I was offended because my feelings were hurt.
[55:51] SPEAKER_00: There has to be some sort of scriptural basis to the offense.
[55:54] SPEAKER_00: And so some of the instruction is in the word of like, did you know that you've violated this, that you've gone against God's word in this?
[55:59] SPEAKER_00: And again, some people's reaction may be, no, I had no idea, and therefore there's repentance there, which is great.
[56:05] SPEAKER_00: And the reason that you're supposed to go through these uh steps, because many times if you get to the admonition and the public state, then you're defensive.
[56:12] SPEAKER_00: And if you go to somebody privately and you you have this kind of personal instruction, you're more likely to get a hearing than when the defenses have come up.
[56:19] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, and then and then the individual's responsibility to admonish one another.
[56:22] SPEAKER_04: So presumably they've overlooked the offense once at least, right, Steve?
[56:26] SPEAKER_04: And then they're they're going.
[56:28] SPEAKER_04: Um and there's some references there to Matthew 18 in Galatians six.
[56:33] SPEAKER_04: If a brother sins against you, go and tell him it's fault between you and him alone.
[56:36] SPEAKER_04: If he listens to you, you've gained your brother.
[56:38] SPEAKER_04: Or Galatians six, brothers, if anyone's caught in any transgression, you who are spiritual should restore him in a spirit of gentleness.
[56:45] SPEAKER_04: Keep watch on yourself lest you two be tempted.
[56:48] SPEAKER_04: So there's a there's relationships that build up in the church between Christians, and we need to be able to go to each other.
[56:58] SPEAKER_04: And is that I think I would just say, and I'm curious how y'all would approach this, that this can be a rather informal looking thing.
[57:04] SPEAKER_04: You know, maybe this is going on in our churches a lot and we don't ever know about it.
[57:08] SPEAKER_04: You know, hopefully this is going on between husbands and wives, right?
[57:10] SPEAKER_04: You know, if if you've offended your spouse and she comes to you and says, Hey, listen, we need to talk about this, and then you've you've done this.
[57:17] SPEAKER_04: Um not necessarily a formal process aspect, it's just something that should be happening between people as they live together and and get along attracting.
[57:26] SPEAKER_00: And wives should know from husbands that you can't just say, Well, you should know what you did.
[57:30] SPEAKER_00: No, please tell me what I did.
[57:31] SPEAKER_00: There's a destruction there of like, I know I've done something wrong.
[57:34] SPEAKER_00: I can tell, but I need to be instructed on what it was.
[57:37] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[57:39] SPEAKER_02: Dave, I I'm a science guy, like having things boiled down to a science.
[57:43] SPEAKER_02: Uh, what does the science look like in this section or in church discipline in general?
[57:48] SPEAKER_02: I I see what the in other words, I I see what the text tells me I I should do, but what does that look like when you get down to the details of it?
[57:56] SPEAKER_01: The details are always messy, bro.
[57:58] SPEAKER_01: That's why, you know, if you're looking at since you're a science guy, you've got a few cells in a petri dish and you're doing a DNA analysis to see what it is, but you scraped them off a fish, then you know, you've lost sight of something there, right?
[58:14] SPEAKER_01: So the fish in this case would be the those those governing principles.
[58:17] SPEAKER_01: And by the way, brothers, I think that that's uh informative as well for the entire BCO.
[58:22] SPEAKER_01: Those preliminary principles are so frequently overlooked because we want to get right down to the how of something.
[58:28] SPEAKER_01: But the reality is that if we stay within those principles, it makes it an awful lot easier to deal with the with the hows that we're that we're generally forced to do.
[58:39] SPEAKER_01: As a side comment adjacent to that, I think you guys made the right distinctions.
[58:43] SPEAKER_01: Now that really is talking about personal offenses.
[58:45] SPEAKER_01: Uh later in this series, you'll cover what happens when it's necessary for the court itself to take up an offense and and note that all charges are made by the court and so on.
[58:55] SPEAKER_01: Uh you know, so I think both of the the distinction that was made there and the one that Jared made are are the ones that are key out of this section.
[59:01] SPEAKER_04: Scott, is that an acceptable answer to your question?
[59:04] SPEAKER_01: Oh yes, I'll I'll be satisfied.
[59:06] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I know there wasn't an acceptable answer, but he just asked me to divide by zero with no notice, and I don't know how to do that.
[59:12] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[59:14] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[59:14] SPEAKER_01: I was glad he asked you.
[59:19] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, and so then C C and D are there.
[59:21] SPEAKER_04: If admission is rejected, you call for one or more witnesses, and if rejection persists, you get the church involved.
[59:27] SPEAKER_04: Here's my question, Scott.
[59:30] SPEAKER_04: I'll put you on the spot.
[59:31] SPEAKER_04: I mean, I'm not putting you on the spot, I don't think.
[59:32] SPEAKER_04: Where where do you where do you where does an elder get involved?
[59:35] SPEAKER_04: Like where where does it, you know, if there's an individual thing going on and and they're just not progressing in the way that they want, there's no reconciliation, there's no repentance on the offending party's part, where does an elder get involved?
[59:47] SPEAKER_04: Is it in C or is it in D?
[59:50] SPEAKER_02: If we're gonna be, I mean, we're gonna talk about it a little technically, so I I think uh well, the elder might be, the pastor might be involved in even before that, depending on the circumstance.
[1:00:02] SPEAKER_02: Most people come to you before they go to others.
[1:00:05] SPEAKER_02: At least that's how I experience it.
[1:00:07] SPEAKER_02: And then I usually tell them, you should probably go, if you're comfortable, you should go talk with them individually and personally.
[1:00:14] SPEAKER_02: If you're uncomfortable, I would be happy to facilitate uh a meeting where I could be a mediatorial before.
[1:00:21] SPEAKER_02: So in other words, the pastor might be involved in B if there's an uncomfortable nature between the relationship of the offended party and the a party that has done the offending.
[1:00:30] SPEAKER_02: And so I don't know, it just depends, I guess.
[1:00:32] SPEAKER_02: It depends in the sense of the relationship between the offended and and the accused.
[1:00:39] SPEAKER_02: And so that that's that's not an answer that tells you you should get involved at exactly at D, but I think you'd probably be informed as early as B and ask for your advice on how to handle it.
[1:00:50] SPEAKER_02: I've gotten calls like that.
[1:00:51] SPEAKER_02: Have you gotten calls like that where there's like I want to make something known to the session, there's this wrong that's happened to me, and you usually say, Well, have you called them?
[1:00:59] SPEAKER_02: No.
[1:00:59] SPEAKER_02: Well, you should call them if you're comfortable in doing that.
[1:01:03] SPEAKER_04: Sometimes things are gonna come to you as an elder that they've they're long past any of it, you know, and the only really the only option at a point is gonna be to bring it before the session.
[1:01:13] SPEAKER_04: They just they're so far gone.
[1:01:15] SPEAKER_04: You kind of try to catch up as best you can.
[1:01:17] SPEAKER_00: But yeah, and we'll get to the details of where the exceptions are.
[1:01:21] SPEAKER_00: I mean, if it's something where it's like, no, you can't face that person again because it was such a great offense.
[1:01:27] SPEAKER_00: There are ways in which there's a need to uh bring people in earlier.
[1:01:31] SPEAKER_00: Perhaps the, you know, if you're going through the Matthew 18, the witness that you bring in maybe is an elder that's trusted between the two of them that kind of mediates that before it gets to the level of tault of the church, and then the elders are definitely involved.
[1:01:42] SPEAKER_00: So a lot of this just deals with wisdom and how to do it.
[1:01:45] SPEAKER_00: And maybe before any of those things, you're consulting a pastor to say, how do I address this?
[1:01:49] SPEAKER_00: Somebody's offended me.
[1:01:50] SPEAKER_00: Okay, is it something where you can address them?
[1:01:53] SPEAKER_00: Is it okay, why don't you do that first and then we'll bring in maybe take this elder with you to mediate?
[1:01:58] SPEAKER_00: Okay, now it's coming to that level.
[1:02:00] SPEAKER_00: So uh all of this has to do with with wisdom and how you apply it.
[1:02:05] SPEAKER_01: A good one for you if you want an example.
[1:02:09] SPEAKER_01: Come on.
[1:02:09] SPEAKER_01: It's a little bit of a Venn diagram, so I don't know if you want it or not.
[1:02:14] SPEAKER_01: Now, contextually, the the form of discipline that revolves around equipping people by being sure that they understand scripture really can bear fruit in the administration as the of discipline as it moves toward formal discipline.
[1:02:28] SPEAKER_01: So we had two men in our church.
[1:02:30] SPEAKER_01: They went into business together, both were successful independently before they did that.
[1:02:34] SPEAKER_01: And they started a business that shoots in that liquid uh insulation into houses and stuff.
[1:02:39] SPEAKER_01: One guy really had a sales background, the other guy really just was a blue-collar guy who worked himself to the bone all the time.
[1:02:46] SPEAKER_01: Very faithful guys.
[1:02:48] SPEAKER_01: But the guy who was the sales guy liked to spend money, and so he was handling the finances for the two of them.
[1:02:54] SPEAKER_01: Long story short, he drove them into poverty, using their lines of credit and so on to buy things for his children and his household because he was used to that income level and wound up with his part of the equipment, because they both had separate rigs, of being repossessed.
[1:03:06] SPEAKER_01: So one man had been defrauded of a ton of money, and uh they didn't want to go to court, and so they asked to talk to me about it, and we spent several sessions going through it all, and there was a lot of confession, you know, some forgiveness of sin.
[1:03:19] SPEAKER_01: Uh not gonna say that they were hugging when they parted.
[1:03:21] SPEAKER_01: But the other man, the productive man, went and started a second business, not doing that, and uh he had that rig, and he had paid for his rig, and the other guy couldn't make a living, and that man gave him that rig so that he could make a living for his family.
[1:03:38] SPEAKER_01: And within uh I would say 18 months or two years, that guy got uh a a terminal form of cancer and he he he's dead now.
[1:03:46] SPEAKER_01: He's been dead about ten years.
[1:03:47] SPEAKER_01: In my mind, it was uh it remains one of the most beautiful expressions of what happens in dealing with conflict resolution within the context of the church with men who may have sinned, uh in this case one guy sinned, but may have sinned against someone else, but who hasn't lost sight of the fact that they've been bought with the price of the blood of Jesus, bought with the price of Jesus' own blood, and uh submit to the authority of the church, admit their sin, and uh wind up in a situation like that.
[1:04:15] SPEAKER_01: And I'll tell you today that other guy would uh if he'd known the way that that was gonna go and known that guy was gonna die, um, he'd have not only given him that rig, he'd have probably paid his rent too.
[1:04:27] SPEAKER_01: Um, because that's just the kind of guy that he is.
[1:04:29] SPEAKER_01: You know, discipline doesn't always just because it starts down that road matriculate into formal discipline.
[1:04:35] SPEAKER_01: You know, if you have godly enough people who have been instructed in the first sense of discipline, sometimes you all just come to the same spot and you realize you've got a very difficult situation to deal with, and uh formal discipline only makes it worse, not better.
[1:04:48] SPEAKER_01: So I don't know if you found that edifying or not, but boy, I'll tell you it's true.
[1:04:51] SPEAKER_01: And it was it was really, really spiritually rewarding as time went by.
[1:04:56] SPEAKER_04: Well, guys, is there anything else to add?
[1:04:58] SPEAKER_04: Anything you want to finish up on or all right.
[1:05:01] SPEAKER_04: Well, as is clear from the chiastic structure of this episode, this podcast is over.
[1:05:05] SPEAKER_04: Thanks for joining us.
[1:05:06] SPEAKER_04: Be sure to come back next time when we discuss the discipline of non-commuting members in BCO twenty-eight.
[1:05:12] SPEAKER_04: If you're interested in learning more about anything that we've mentioned, check out the show notes in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org.
[1:05:18] SPEAKER_04: A huge thank you to Steve Dowling for submitting himself to sitting alongside us for this chapter.
[1:05:23] SPEAKER_04: Uh, he'll be back before we finish the rules of discipline, so uh you'll you'll get to enjoy him again uh with us.
[1:05:29] SPEAKER_04: If you've enjoyed the show, do consider following us on Twitter or Facebook at Polity Matters, and be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[1:05:36] SPEAKER_04: If you have questions or comments, you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[1:05:41] SPEAKER_04: And uh there's also links below to support the show if that's something you're interested in doing.
[1:05:46] SPEAKER_04: We thank you, listeners, for spending your valuable time with us.
[1:05:48] SPEAKER_04: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[1:05:51] SPEAKER_00: Goodbye, gentlemen.
[1:05:52] SPEAKER_04: Diana.
[1:05:53] SPEAKER_04: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
