# 85. BCO 37: The Removal of Censure

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 27 May 2025, 1 h 01 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/17229376-85-bco-37-the-removal-of-censure.mp3

Mel Duncan joins the show to help us think through the removal of censures in BCO 27. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Transcript

[0:07] SPEAKER_02: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:09] SPEAKER_02: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined as always by Scott Edberg and Jared Nelson.
[0:14] SPEAKER_02: I almost mixed y'all's names up entirely just then.
[0:17] SPEAKER_02: I don't know what's going on.
[0:18] SPEAKER_02: Well, regardless of what's going on with me and my ability to remember my co-hosts, I do remember our guest that has joined us is ruling Elder Mel Duncan.
[0:26] SPEAKER_02: We are glad to have him with us.
[0:28] SPEAKER_02: And I know he's been on before, but I'm going to ask him to introduce himself for anybody that may be unaware of who he is, and I know he wants to tell us some other things about uh an organization that he loves and is near to his heart.
[0:40] SPEAKER_00: Ben, Scott, Jared, what a delight to be with my favorite BCO polity uh experts today.
[0:46] SPEAKER_00: Thanks for having me.
[0:47] SPEAKER_00: I'm Mel Duncan.
[0:48] SPEAKER_00: Uh, I'm a ruling elder at a church in PCA Church in Greenville, South Carolina.
[0:52] SPEAKER_00: I clerk Calvary Presbytery, which is uh a family of PCA churches in upcountry, South Carolina.
[1:00] SPEAKER_00: And for the last uh few years, I've also been the administrator uh for the Gospel Reformation Network.
[1:06] SPEAKER_00: And we're delighted uh just today we announced our event at General Assembly.
[1:11] SPEAKER_00: If you're coming to Chattanooga this summer, we'd love to see you.
[1:14] SPEAKER_00: Just go to gospelreformation.net and follow the links.
[1:18] SPEAKER_00: Uh we're we are uh so pleased to have my older brother Liggan as our speaker uh this year, and we would love to connect with you in Chattanooga this summer.
[1:30] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I just I just signed up for that uh this morning.
[1:33] SPEAKER_02: I think I saw it posted on social media, and then there was an email that came through.
[1:36] SPEAKER_02: I do know Jared hasn't signed up yet, unless you've done it in the last 30 seconds.
[1:39] SPEAKER_02: But uh get you gotta get on top of it, man.
[1:42] SPEAKER_02: Uh what's the deal?
[1:44] SPEAKER_02: Um Scott obviously has departed to sign up somewhere.
[1:48] SPEAKER_01: Um, and then people can check and see how far um in the past this episode was by Yeah.
[1:54] SPEAKER_02: By the yeah, well uh yeah, we do a lot of time traveling here at Polity Matters, let's just say that.
[2:01] SPEAKER_02: Um we we have been working our way through the rules of discipline as listeners well know, and have arrived at BCO chapter 37.
[2:10] SPEAKER_02: Last time we looked at what uh I think Dr.
[2:12] SPEAKER_02: Waters reflected towards the end uh was a rather grim chapter on the infliction of church censures, but this week we get to to kind of move to the other side of the matter, the restoration of a repentant sinner.
[2:23] SPEAKER_02: Uh Mel, would you what can you help us understand?
[2:26] SPEAKER_02: What's on your mind as we begin this chapter that would that's helpful just to kind of frame everything up?
[2:31] SPEAKER_00: Thank you, Ben.
[2:32] SPEAKER_00: That's a helpful setting.
[2:34] SPEAKER_00: Uh, this is a glorious chapter in the Book of Church Order.
[2:37] SPEAKER_00: This really is, in many ways, the the result and the fruit of a lot of work.
[2:44] SPEAKER_00: Uh every minister, every elder, every involved church member knows what it's like to work with someone who doesn't want to be loved or cared for by the church, who has a spirit of contumaciousness, a spirit of hostility uh towards the church, uh has, in their own way of thinking, been wronged by the church.
[3:06] SPEAKER_00: And the last thing in the world they want to do is to be restored to the kingdom of God.
[3:12] SPEAKER_00: You think about uh folks who've been excommunicated, um oftentimes carry around a sense of shame and hostility for the rest of their life.
[3:23] SPEAKER_00: And any good Christian minister or elder wants to help people be restored.
[3:30] SPEAKER_00: And in classic PCA Book of Church Order Fashion, chapter 27, which has old, old roots in the Presbyterian and Reformed tradition, is a uh a guidebook to how a church can lift that oppressive grave censure off of somebody and what those steps look like.
[3:51] SPEAKER_00: Uh, I was listening to one of your episodes a few weeks ago uh with Brother Fred Greco, and he was talking about how uh the BCO, you think it's a rule book, but it's actually a book of principles.
[4:07] SPEAKER_00: And the trick to understanding the BCO is how to weave those principles in the right order.
[4:13] SPEAKER_00: And this is a classic chapter on how do you help restore somebody, not just to the church, but to the kingdom of God.
[4:20] SPEAKER_00: And uh I I love chapter 27.
[4:23] SPEAKER_00: Um, a couple of throwaways as we get started on this.
[4:27] SPEAKER_00: Um I uh think Jared and I both have a connection to Paul Settle, a PCA founding father.
[4:35] SPEAKER_00: Uh Paul Settle used to say, he pastored uh the church that I serve in now when I was a boy, that contumaciousness is the only thing the PCA can agree on as a sin.
[4:47] SPEAKER_00: And uh oftentimes it's the thing that we end up excommunicating people over.
[4:52] SPEAKER_00: Um I think that's a dramatic way of putting it, but uh there is a spirit of contumaciousness that when you see it, you never forget it and you understand it.
[5:02] SPEAKER_00: And chapter 27, when we read it, we shouldn't read it like we're the prodigal brother.
[5:09] SPEAKER_00: We should really read it like we're the prodigal, because there's a sense in which Christ has reached down in time and space and restored us to the kingdom, uh, certainly for the first time, but oftentimes through repentance, uh, he does that throughout our life.
[5:25] SPEAKER_00: So we should have some humility as we look at chapter 27, as we have the privilege of doing this for other people, we need to remember that Christ did this for us.
[5:38] SPEAKER_02: Thank you.
[5:39] SPEAKER_02: That's a good word as we as we jump in here.
[5:42] SPEAKER_02: Listeners, make sure you have it pulled up.
[5:45] SPEAKER_02: Um it will it will come across maybe a little bit out of order.
[5:49] SPEAKER_02: The way that we've dealt with censures um and then infliction of them.
[5:54] SPEAKER_02: 37 kind of deals with them uh first with suspension from office and then sacraments for a couple sections, excommunication, uh, then deposition, and then some some things said about uh unique situations, perhaps, ruling elders, deacons, uh, if they're at a distance, and then some matters about ministers toward the end.
[6:13] SPEAKER_02: Uh buckle up and we're gonna start working through 37 uh section one.
[6:18] SPEAKER_02: There's a lot of pronouncements that are prescribed here, so we'll just read through these uh as best we can to get a sense of them.
[6:25] SPEAKER_02: And then, guys, I'll I'll kind of kick to y'all to walk us through the significant portions of these of these paragraphs.
[6:31] SPEAKER_02: So thirty-seven one begins saying, A person who has been definitely suspended from office shall be restored by the court at the end of the term of his suspension by declaring words of the following import to him.
[6:42] SPEAKER_02: Whereas you have been debarred from the office of teaching elder or ruling elder or deacon, but have now fulfilled the time of your censure, we of the church session or presbytery do hereby in the name of uh and by the authority of the Lord Jesus Christ absolve you from the sentence of suspension and do restore you to the exercise of your said office and all the functions thereof.
[7:06] SPEAKER_02: I guess the first question is is it debarred or debarred?
[7:10] SPEAKER_02: That might be the first decision we have to make.
[7:12] SPEAKER_02: Um that that came out a little strange.
[7:14] SPEAKER_02: Uh so so just uh to cue it up for you guys, somebody has been definitely suspended, which we remember is is there they were suspended for a certain amount of time, and at the end of that amount of time, they're to be restored.
[7:28] SPEAKER_02: Is there what what more do we need to add here?
[7:32] SPEAKER_01: This might feel a little out of place uh for this this type of accenture, but it's because this didn't exist in the PCUS directory before.
[7:41] SPEAKER_01: Uh most of the rest of this is all old language, but this is something that the PCA inserted, and it was uh it seemed to be with a a view towards there should be something said at the end of the suspension so that people in the congregation know, and there there wasn't something that was prescribed.
[7:56] SPEAKER_01: So this is uh it feels a little out of order, but this is uh starting a pattern of if you're going to have a censure and it's publicly announced, when you remove it, you're gonna need to announce it too.
[8:08] SPEAKER_01: And it's gonna have to feel different rather than the sorrow.
[8:11] SPEAKER_01: You know, uh almost all of these, uh at least the next ones that we go through, are gonna have some sort of like, now have prayer and thanksgiving afterwards.
[8:17] SPEAKER_01: So um showing you a bit of the different in tone that's there.
[8:22] SPEAKER_04: And 37-1 is kind of like a best case scenario because you're dealing with someone who's already repentant of their sin.
[8:28] SPEAKER_04: And so there is a consequence for the sin itself, and so you're given a definite time that you'll be uh under the censure, but then it will be removed.
[8:38] SPEAKER_04: And so 37-1 upstarts um perhaps in the most positive light, uh, the most common for those who are already repentant of their sin.
[8:47] SPEAKER_04: And what does that look like as they, I guess, do their time?
[8:52] SPEAKER_04: Their sentence is complete.
[8:54] SPEAKER_04: Um, and so it it's perhaps the best case that you hope for um in in censures and sins.
[9:02] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it's the only one that that doesn't prescribe a searching for repentance because it was a definite matter.
[9:08] SPEAKER_02: Um, good.
[9:11] SPEAKER_02: Well, let's I think that's that's pretty straightforward.
[9:15] SPEAKER_02: Everybody agree we're on board.
[9:16] SPEAKER_02: Okay, 37.2.
[9:17] SPEAKER_02: And Mel, I'm gonna read this and then ask you to comment in some particular ways here.
[9:20] SPEAKER_02: I think this is a a very important section, of course.
[9:24] SPEAKER_02: 37.2, after any person has been indefinitely suspended from the sacraments, it is proper that the rulers of the church should frequently converse with him as well as pray with him and for him, that it would please God to give him repentance.
[9:38] SPEAKER_02: Uh, Mel, my question is, you what does this look like?
[9:41] SPEAKER_02: I I think a lot of guys, I c I can speak for myself, um, if I were ever to have somebody that was had submitted to the process and had become uh arrived at this situation of indefinite suspension from the sacraments.
[9:55] SPEAKER_02: It is uh it can be challenging, I think, to think through how you interact with that person and and what you do as a minister or an elder to seek after their repentance.
[10:03] SPEAKER_02: May can you help us think through this?
[10:09] SPEAKER_06: Oh no, Mel, I lost you.
[10:12] SPEAKER_06: We don't have the audio, Mel.
[10:22] SPEAKER_06: People are gonna wonder if we actually had Mel on or if we just had some like Mel are you there?
[10:29] SPEAKER_04: There's the title.
[10:35] SPEAKER_02: I think it must have jumped into your other microphone somehow.
[10:40] SPEAKER_06: I'm still not getting you.
[10:46] SPEAKER_06: Note to future Ben, edit this part out.
[10:49] SPEAKER_02: Oh yeah, this is easy.
[10:50] SPEAKER_02: This is one of the things I actually will take out.
[10:53] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, a little quieter, but I we can hear you.
[10:55] SPEAKER_00: Okay.
[10:56] SPEAKER_00: Um, I'm gonna suspense for you here.
[11:02] SPEAKER_00: So this section in the BCO reminds me of Mark Dever's practice at Capitol Hill Baptist Church in Washington, DC.
[11:12] SPEAKER_00: When they serve communion, they announce anyone who has been placed under church discipline.
[11:21] SPEAKER_00: And if a person has been excommunicated, Mark will frequently say uh we will no longer consider this man a brother or this woman a sister, but we should think of them as a friend.
[11:37] SPEAKER_00: And I've often thought that that's a pastoral, a grave way, but also a pastoral way to approach how you think about people, because excommunication is the church's uh responsibility to declare someone outside of Christ.
[11:54] SPEAKER_00: And it's a it's it's a terrible thing to have to do.
[11:58] SPEAKER_00: And yet it's it's something that when you do you're planting the seeds of God's restorative justice, but also the consequences of failing to uh to heed his warnings.
[12:12] SPEAKER_00: And so I think this section reminds us that the work of the church is always ongoing, that it's it's always got to be in front of us.
[12:22] SPEAKER_00: And just as we have an attitude of cultivate, my pastor likes to say, always have in mind someone you're trying to evangelize.
[12:31] SPEAKER_00: You probably should always have someone in mind who you're trying to help restore to the life of the church.
[12:38] SPEAKER_00: Um we'll we'll get into some of the the censures here that deal with officers, but uh in my own life, I've only seen in my own church life as an elder one case of someone who was excommunicated being restored to the church.
[12:56] SPEAKER_00: And maybe if it's okay, Ben, I'll just tell that story now.
[13:00] SPEAKER_00: Um there was a young person in our church, newly married, who had engaged in a scandalous uh public uh uh sin, and it was it was known to all.
[13:13] SPEAKER_00: And the church did its uh duty and confronted that person in their sin, and that person did what most people do in that situation.
[13:24] SPEAKER_00: Uh I'm thinking of Tom Cruise in the movie Minority Report, they always run, you know, when you try to when you try to catch them.
[13:32] SPEAKER_00: And they ran as far away as they could from our church, from our city, and uh so much so that we couldn't even find this person on the grid.
[13:42] SPEAKER_00: And so we did the the dutiful process of of of appealing, of of communicating, of documenting our communication, trying to meet with them, and then eventually they were excommunicated.
[13:55] SPEAKER_00: Years go by and we often wondered, wonder what happened to that dear soul that we placed under the awful uh pronouncements of excommunication.
[14:06] SPEAKER_00: And we were contacted by that person's spouse.
[14:11] SPEAKER_00: They were about to be or are soon to be their their fiance.
[14:15] SPEAKER_00: They were about to be remarried, and the person who the former member of our church was going to marry had a godly and in many ways enlightened view of the church and church discipline.
[14:29] SPEAKER_00: And that person knew that in order for them to be married that their fiance needed to make it right with God.
[14:37] SPEAKER_00: And so that person drove the former member of our church back to Grainville, met with our pastor, uh, always had the meeting before the meeting would be my my encouragement uh to your listeners.
[14:50] SPEAKER_00: The pastor discerned true repentance, prayerfully met and rejoiced with the person, and then we called a session meeting.
[14:58] SPEAKER_00: And that person did the best statement of repentance that I'd ever heard in my entire life.
[15:05] SPEAKER_00: Uh we're we're a room full of older men, and we were weeping because we knew that the Lord had gotten a hold of this person and that they were now right with the Lord.
[15:18] SPEAKER_00: And so it was really a joy to use some of the languages language that we find in chapter twenty thir thirty-seven to remove the the the sanction from this person.
[15:30] SPEAKER_00: We admitted them back into membership in our church and then we immediately uh sent a letter releasing them to a church in another state in another town.
[15:41] SPEAKER_00: Uh but but yet we we did our our duty.
[15:44] SPEAKER_00: Now you don't often get that.
[15:46] SPEAKER_00: You you don't often get success stories, but the point of it is that just like when you present the gospel, when you're doing church discipline, your job is to faithfully do what the book tells you to do.
[16:00] SPEAKER_00: Um my father was a Marine and fought in World War II, and he was he had many famous leadership maxims.
[16:09] SPEAKER_00: But one of them was when you have to say something hard to someone, you don't have to enjoy doing that.
[16:16] SPEAKER_00: And part of doing BCO thirty seven is you have to say hard things to people who don't want to hear it.
[16:23] SPEAKER_00: And you have to remind yourself, just like when you men get in the pulpit and preach God's word, that your job is to be faithful to the word entrusted to you to preach and teach.
[16:34] SPEAKER_00: And so it is as we work through these ancient maxims of biblical church principles of discipline.
[16:43] SPEAKER_00: Our job is to l is to remind unrepentant people of their sin and let the Holy Spirit do the convincing of that.
[16:54] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, and that's uh um when the process has gotten to 37.4 where you're removing excommunication, uh, that seems so very rare.
[17:03] SPEAKER_01: Um in my time at my church, we've had it once um uh as well.
[17:08] SPEAKER_01: But um I I think what's great about 37.2 and 37.3 is hopefully this happens more often that um it doesn't get to excommunication and there's a removal that happens there.
[17:20] SPEAKER_01: Uh I almost wish 37.2 was the first section here.
[17:24] SPEAKER_01: If I could rearrange uh 37, I would take 37.1 and move it later and put 37.2 first because this is this is saying, hey, there's an opportunity and discipline to not have it get to excommunication yet, and that's if they're indefinitely suspended, that's not uh, you know, you're washing your hands of something because it's not excommunication yet.
[17:43] SPEAKER_01: This is the 99 and the one.
[17:45] SPEAKER_01: You're supposed to go after them and you need to try to get them back because uh the further, the longer they're away, the the harder it is to get them back.
[17:53] SPEAKER_01: I mean, what Mel is talking about uh doesn't happen as often as you know, if there is a suspension from the sacraments, you know, this says you are to pray with them, you pray for them, you frequently converse with them, like you're going after them.
[18:04] SPEAKER_01: So when this starts, uh there should be diligent effort and should take a lot more of your time.
[18:09] SPEAKER_01: It's not a brushing of your hands, it's uh putting on your shoes.
[18:15] SPEAKER_02: It reminds me of the way we treat our children, you know, ideally, right?
[18:18] SPEAKER_02: We'd we pray with them, we'd we talk to them, we'd we plead with them um to return to us.
[18:28] SPEAKER_02: Jared, I'm on board with rearranging this chapter, but only if we maintain the numbers that are already present.
[18:33] SPEAKER_02: So thirty-seven two would just come before thirty-seven one so that we wouldn't have to renumber anywhere else.
[18:38] SPEAKER_02: That that would be the call.
[18:40] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[18:44] SPEAKER_02: 373 When the court shall be satisfied as to the reality of the repentance of an indefinitely suspended offender, he shall be admitted to profess his repentance, either in the presence of the court alone or publicly.
[18:56] SPEAKER_02: At this time the offender shall be restored to the sacraments of the church and or to his office, if such shall be the judgment of the court.
[19:04] SPEAKER_02: The restoration shall be declared to the penitent in the words of the following import, whereas you have been debarred from the sacraments of the church andor from the office of teaching elder or ruling elder or deacon, but have now manifested such repentance as satisfies the church, we, the Presbyterian session, do hereby in the name and by the authority of the Lord Jesus Christ absolve you from the said sentence of suspension from the sacraments or your office, and do restore you to the full communion of the church and or the exercise of your said office and all the functions thereof, after which there shall be prayer and thanksgiving.
[19:39] SPEAKER_02: I'm on board, Jared, to prayer and a party, or or prayer thanksgiving, uh done so in a party.
[19:45] SPEAKER_02: I think that is the coolest thing.
[19:47] SPEAKER_02: Um so you arrive at this this uh opportunity to restore the offending party uh to their office or to the table.
[19:56] SPEAKER_02: And I mean, I don't know why you wouldn't do this publicly.
[20:01] SPEAKER_02: I mean, I suppose that that maybe that's a question.
[20:05] SPEAKER_02: What what would determine whether you do this alone by the in front of the court or publicly?
[20:09] SPEAKER_02: It seems to me that we do things one or the other uh depending on the nature of the sin and the offense.
[20:16] SPEAKER_02: But when you get to this point, why why not make it as public as possible?
[20:20] SPEAKER_02: And maybe that's a dumb question, but there it is.
[20:24] SPEAKER_00: I think it on one level, Ben, i i you know, is it most helpful to do it publicly?
[20:32] SPEAKER_00: And I think the answer is yes.
[20:34] SPEAKER_00: Um I I've I mentioned to you the the instance in my own church where we had someone come before our session.
[20:42] SPEAKER_00: I've seen this happen once at Presbytery.
[20:46] SPEAKER_00: And there was a great deal of thought to how we would apply uh the language of this uh to the repentant former pastor.
[20:56] SPEAKER_00: And we we had a some godly older men who pursued this former PCA minister for many years and really had a heart, uh a burden would be a better way to put it, uh for restoring him.
[21:10] SPEAKER_00: And we we actually ended up inviting his family to come.
[21:17] SPEAKER_00: And um you know, you you've got to be careful about when you do these things publicly because there is a statical aspect to it.
[21:26] SPEAKER_00: But we we talked with the man before we did this and he actually really wanted this to be public.
[21:34] SPEAKER_00: And I people's repentance look differently, but on on the one hand there has to be a mark of genuineness.
[21:43] SPEAKER_00: Um Morton Smith in this section talks about the court needing to be satisfied of the genuineness of repentance.
[21:50] SPEAKER_00: Oftentimes things like that need to be public in order to really show the mark of that.
[21:56] SPEAKER_00: Um I think if you apply this consistently, I mean I I think a church having a practice or a court having a practice of how you do this and then doing it consistently is the most important aspect of this.
[22:10] SPEAKER_00: Um I I'm just so I I I love like Scott, I imagine, reading some of the statistical things that the PCA produces.
[22:19] SPEAKER_00: I'm I'm always just amazed at how few churches meaningfully are doing discipline of any kind.
[22:26] SPEAKER_00: Um I'm I'm a a clerk and and Scott knows on Monday morning that that means a small town PCA pastor is gonna call him and say, Hell, I don't know what to to do.
[22:38] SPEAKER_00: And so um you know, church discipline i and I think I've shared this with this podcast before.
[22:46] SPEAKER_00: Um my own church, though it's a hundred and thirty years old, didn't really start doing church discipline until the last uh forty years or so.
[22:56] SPEAKER_00: And so the first few times we did it, we did it incorrectly and it was a mess.
[23:03] SPEAKER_00: But once we started the pattern and people realize, wow, this church really believes in this stuff and and they're going to challenge us with it, it began to change the congregation for the better.
[23:17] SPEAKER_00: And it's almost like a guardrail that the Lord gives to us that we need to be reminded that that that there are places which we may not take the car where there won't be an accident.
[23:30] SPEAKER_00: And um yeah, I I think these things the more I I talk here, the more I'm convincing myself.
[23:35] SPEAKER_00: I think these things should be public, though it has to be dealt with very carefully.
[23:41] SPEAKER_00: Um I I think the the restoration of a minister or an officer in the church who's been fallen absolutely needs to be a public.
[23:59] SPEAKER_02: I've Mel, something you said made me think about I've I've talked to Fred before about um how I I wish that there was a way um to to just read the book enough times to become familiar with how to do these things, but there's a very real sense in which you can't learn how to do these things until you do them.
[24:19] SPEAKER_02: It's like preaching.
[24:20] SPEAKER_02: You can't really learn how to preach unless you start preaching.
[24:23] SPEAKER_02: You know, you can study and read a lot, but it's it's really not gonna come.
[24:27] SPEAKER_02: And so you saying that y'all kind of stumbled a little bit as you started 40 years ago but have s settled into it, that um that should be an encouragement to anyone out there.
[24:36] SPEAKER_02: Any of you elders out there that are listening, um, if if you struggle to do this, uh, you know, look to 37 with some hope that doing this may lead to these kinds of of events where you get to restore people um instead of just see them disappear or whatever it may be because you failed to to to do what you needed to do.
[24:55] SPEAKER_00: You know, the church is the most meaningful organization that we'll ever be a part of in our lives.
[25:03] SPEAKER_00: And if you communicate that it has gravity to it, you don't want it always to be, you know, grave.
[25:10] SPEAKER_00: Everything doesn't need to be grave.
[25:13] SPEAKER_00: But just like family is sacred, so many of our churches have a flippancy about them and a casualness about them and a just a here today, gone tomorrow thing about it.
[25:26] SPEAKER_00: Um the the BC Moses didn't bring the BCO down from the mountain.
[25:32] SPEAKER_00: But the Presbyterians have been using some form of this for the better part of a half millennium to try to guide the the practice and life of the church.
[25:42] SPEAKER_00: It's actually kind of uh exciting to know when you are trying to do church discipline that Presbyterians who believe exactly like you do have been trying to perfect this book for a half millennium.
[25:58] SPEAKER_00: And you know, you get to be part of the story next.
[26:01] SPEAKER_00: Now I don't know about rearranging chapter 34 or chapter 37, Ben, but but if you can get Scott to go along with it and Jared, I'm I'll I'll consider it.
[26:10] SPEAKER_02: Well it was Jared's idea.
[26:11] SPEAKER_02: I don't don't don't don't put that on me.
[26:15] SPEAKER_02: I heard you say that Moses didn't bring the BCO down from the mountain.
[26:18] SPEAKER_02: Does that mean he left it up on the mountain?
[26:19] SPEAKER_02: It's still it's it's up there somewhere.
[26:21] SPEAKER_00: It means that Jethro was probably working on it, uh, you know, waiting for Moses to come down with the law so he could hand him the blue book at that point.
[26:30] SPEAKER_04: That's solid.
[26:31] SPEAKER_04: The unconstitutional parts are still up there somewhere.
[26:34] SPEAKER_00: That's right.
[26:35] SPEAKER_00: Ed Ed Berg is still trying to get uh Jethro down with the directory for worship.
[26:40] SPEAKER_00: Um he's got those errant Midianite ideas that he can't let go of.
[26:47] SPEAKER_04: I just hope against hope, you know.
[26:49] SPEAKER_00: Yep.
[26:50] SPEAKER_00: We got to.
[26:51] SPEAKER_00: We got to.
[26:52] SPEAKER_00: One day, Scott.
[26:53] SPEAKER_00: One day.
[26:55] SPEAKER_02: Okay, so we've we've uh we've dealt with suspension from office and sacraments, and now 374 gets us into uh dealing with an excommunication.
[27:06] SPEAKER_02: Uh 374.
[27:08] SPEAKER_00: And I was thinking, you know, it's almost like the membership vows, if you look at it.
[27:14] SPEAKER_00: You you acknowledge that you're a sinner, you acknowledge you need a savior.
[27:18] SPEAKER_00: Uh it it's almost like a kind of a a redo or in a sense of the membership vows.
[27:24] SPEAKER_00: I thought that was kind of interesting.
[27:25] SPEAKER_02: Okay.
[27:26] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[27:27] SPEAKER_02: Alright, so y'all track with that.
[27:28] SPEAKER_02: That's a good that's a good precursor to this.
[27:31] SPEAKER_02: When an excommunicated person shall be so affected with his state as to be brought to repentance and to desire to be readmitted to the communion of the church, the session having obtained sufficient evidence of his sincere penitence shall proceed to restore him.
[27:45] SPEAKER_02: This may be done in the presence of the court or of the congregation as seems best to the session.
[27:50] SPEAKER_02: On the day appointed for his restoration, the minister shall call upon the excommunicated person and propose to him in the presence of the court or the congregation the following questions Do you, from a deep sense of your great wickedness, freely confess your sins in thus rebelling against God and in refusing to hear his church?
[28:08] SPEAKER_02: And do you acknowledge that you have been in justice and mercy cut off from the communion of the church?
[28:13] SPEAKER_02: Do you now voluntarily profess your sincere repentance and contrition for your sin and obstinacy, and do you humbly ask the forgiveness of God and his church?
[28:23] SPEAKER_02: Do you sincerely promise, through divine grace, to live in all humbleness of mind and circumspection, and to endeavor to adorn by a holy life the doctrine of God our Savior?
[28:34] SPEAKER_02: Here the minister shall give the penitent a suitable exhortation, encouraging and comforting him.
[28:39] SPEAKER_02: Then he shall pronounce the sentence of restoration in the following words Whereas you have been shut off from the communion of the Church, and now have manifested such repentance as satisfies the Church, in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by his authority we the session of this church do declare you absolved from the sentence of excommunication formerly pronounced against you, and we do restore you to the communion of the church that you may be partaker of all the benefits of the Lord Jesus to your eternal salvation.
[29:05] SPEAKER_02: The whole shall be concluded with prayer and thanksgiving.
[29:15] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, the we have in chapter thirty-seven uh bolded scripts, and we were thinking before about you know the installation of elders and deacons and how those are things that we don't see very often.
[29:27] SPEAKER_01: This these may be scripts that we see the least in church.
[29:30] SPEAKER_01: Um in fact, um I had it as a part of a service once ten years ago, and so I was able to look up my old script, and my uh introduction to it was uh this today in the service, you will see an element that you will likely have never seen before and you may not see again for a while, if ever again.
[29:47] SPEAKER_01: And that's unfortunate because today we are doing something that should be more common and as a reason for celebration.
[29:53] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so yeah, just going through and doing the vows, these are things that they haven't heard before.
[29:59] SPEAKER_01: And to see it publicly, uh, a picture of repentance of somebody coming in, of wanting to have that public acknowledgement of the removal of excommunication, and then uh just the whole tone of it at the very end, you know, prayer and thanksgiving.
[30:12] SPEAKER_01: Uh at the end, we actually added a welcome by the elders.
[30:16] SPEAKER_01: The elders all went up and basically shook hands uh with the person that was coming in to show no, they're really coming in, we're really accepting them in.
[30:24] SPEAKER_01: So um it may not be something that happens often, if ever, in your church, but if you're able to use 374, it's uh it's it's a neat thing for the congregation to experience.
[30:39] SPEAKER_02: Let me ask y'all a question about this, the the top part of this.
[30:43] SPEAKER_02: Um this maybe doubling up a little bit on things we've mentioned in the past, but how would we judge sufficient evidence of sincere penitence?
[30:52] SPEAKER_02: Maybe just categorically.
[30:54] SPEAKER_02: Like what what are what's a what's a session need to be paying attention to and looking for?
[30:58] SPEAKER_02: Um obviously having submitted to the process so far, that's a big deal, right?
[31:03] SPEAKER_02: Because it you you're not contumacious, you've been well, I suppose you could have been contumacious.
[31:07] SPEAKER_02: Um that may be the more common thing, actually.
[31:09] SPEAKER_02: Um okay, I think I just I just messed myself up in my brain.
[31:13] SPEAKER_02: What are some categories we can use to think through this?
[31:22] SPEAKER_01: Well, it's almost as if on the on 37-2 and 37-3 the church is going after the person, it's the 99 and the one.
[31:30] SPEAKER_01: This almost feels more like the prodigal son coming home.
[31:33] SPEAKER_01: Like there's some initiation on their part that they're they're wanting this, they're asking the church session about that.
[31:38] SPEAKER_01: It sounds like that's what was the case in Mel's church and in our church, they were coming to us.
[31:42] SPEAKER_01: They was like, you know, I want to meet with you, I want to go through whatever process.
[31:47] SPEAKER_01: And in fact, at that point, you you can't really be talking a whole lot about, you know, the the faults of uh whatever process in the past they were going through.
[31:55] SPEAKER_01: It's like that's off the table.
[31:57] SPEAKER_01: We're just talking about you.
[31:58] SPEAKER_01: What was your role in it?
[31:59] SPEAKER_01: And so if if there's some sort of initiation on their part, I think it's a big part.
[32:04] SPEAKER_01: If they're not talking about the faults of others, but they're saying this, here's what I did, this is what I did, and here's my fault in it, and this is why I shouldn't, you know, here's why it was wrong, and here's what I've been doing for repentance.
[32:16] SPEAKER_01: And it can take some time to to measure that to some degree.
[32:20] SPEAKER_01: But I think if those elements are there, that's a good indication that there's repentance there.
[32:26] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, this section we should think of not like a cheap repentance, which is often just like an I'm sorry, my bad, uh, but what are the what does true repentance look like?
[32:36] SPEAKER_04: And I think the shorter catechism gives us a good answer of that, that's apprehension of your own sin towards the mercy of God, that you have hatred and grief for your sin, and that you seek to endeavor after new obedience.
[32:49] SPEAKER_04: And so those are the three uh perhaps ideas that a session should be looking for when interviewing and discipling and caring for someone who you are trying to find out if they have the true evidence, evidences for repentance.
[33:03] SPEAKER_04: And so it's more than just of I'm sorry.
[33:05] SPEAKER_04: Um, there has to be a hatred for that sin and of a uh a workful part of the heart where there's a seeking of making things right, whether that be between you and God or others that you've wronged.
[33:20] SPEAKER_04: And so it's more than just an I'm sorry.
[33:23] SPEAKER_04: Um sometimes that's what we think all repentance is, I'm sorry.
[33:26] SPEAKER_04: Uh, but there's more to it than that.
[33:29] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, and the the standards have one of my favorite words in the the section on repentance for how your sin is viewed.
[33:35] SPEAKER_01: It says uh from the odiousness of it.
[33:38] SPEAKER_01: You know, there's there's almost a visceral reaction of this is what I did.
[33:42] SPEAKER_01: Ugh.
[33:43] SPEAKER_06: Yeah.
[33:45] SPEAKER_06: Shame isn't always bad.
[33:47] SPEAKER_00: Jared, I know you're a connoisseur of uh great American folk music and and musicians.
[33:55] SPEAKER_00: I I don't know if you have this sense, but it in the in the popular music of today, I oftentimes feel like as entertaining as it is and as flashy as it is, there's just no depth to to the to the expressions either of love or sorrow.
[34:14] SPEAKER_00: And it it's like that with me with biblical language.
[34:18] SPEAKER_00: Um I I think when people are really repenting of their sins, they sound like something in the Bible or someone in the Bible.
[34:27] SPEAKER_00: And it's a sign that God has gotten a hold of them and they're thinking differently, and their words are even a little different.
[34:34] SPEAKER_00: Um obviously um restoration is putting off but also putting on and you you have to see and hear both of those things in the life of the person.
[34:52] SPEAKER_06: Let's go let's keep going.
[34:54] SPEAKER_02: Thirty-seven five The restoration of a deposed officer after public confession has been made in a manner similar to that prescribed in the case of the removal of censure from an excommunicated person shall be announced to him by the moderator in the following form, namely Whereas you, formerly a teaching elder of this presbytery, or ruling elder or deacon of this church, have been deposed from your office, but have now manifested such repentance as satisfies the church, in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by his authority, we the Presbyterian session, do declare you absolved from the said sentence of deposition formerly pronounced against you, and we do furthermore restore you to your said office and to exercise all of the functions thereof whenever you may be orderly called thereto.
[35:41] SPEAKER_02: After this there shall be prayer and thanksgiving, and the members of the court shall extend to him the right hand of fellowship.
[35:49] SPEAKER_02: Well, we're certainly gonna get into thirty-seven six uh in in some of this.
[35:54] SPEAKER_02: We need to move quickly, probably, to that in just a minute.
[35:57] SPEAKER_02: Anything here that stands out to you guys, it's it's a similar form, done in a similar fashion as to the the matter of excommunication.
[36:04] SPEAKER_00: It's interesting, Ben, Dr.
[36:06] SPEAKER_00: Morton Smith in his commentary says that an officer who's been suspended from both should be restored to the table first.
[36:15] SPEAKER_00: And I I think there's some just good first principles there that are a useful teaching tool, not only for the restored officer, but for the congregation.
[36:26] SPEAKER_02: And presumably he would have had to have been restored to the table before he could be restored to office.
[36:30] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[36:31] SPEAKER_01: Here's your excommunicated officer.
[36:33] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that doesn't really work.
[36:34] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[36:36] SPEAKER_01: Well, and there's some the logic to order here.
[36:38] SPEAKER_01: I mean, two and three are indefinite suspension from sacraments, um, four is excommunication, uh, five and six are deposition.
[36:48] SPEAKER_01: This is why 37-1 should be after six.
[36:51] SPEAKER_01: You know, that would be the logical ordering of this.
[36:53] SPEAKER_01: So this is depending on the section that you're dealing with here.
[36:56] SPEAKER_00: But remember, Jared, the Book of Church Order is a grand choose your own polity adventure.
[37:03] SPEAKER_00: And you'd you take away the fun if you put everything in the right order.
[37:10] SPEAKER_06: True, true.
[37:14] SPEAKER_04: Well, here I appreciate that.
[37:16] SPEAKER_04: Before we move on to the next, I do appreciate that none of this is left up to chance on what the minister moderator is to say, that there's something already prepared, it creates the solemn nature of the occasion where it's it's not left to a flippant comment.
[37:34] SPEAKER_04: That here's here's a statement or or here's a paragraph that you will declare to the person in order to rightly resolve their censure.
[37:44] SPEAKER_04: Um, and it to me that gives gravitas.
[37:48] SPEAKER_04: Whenever the BCO adds sections like this, these bolded sections, it reminds perhaps the gravity of what you're doing and saying, whether that be an indictment that is drafted, where you're having to say in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, or here where you're restoring someone from a grave sin back into right communion, it it couches the seriousness and also the joy in a proper light.
[38:15] SPEAKER_04: And so I appreciate it.
[38:17] SPEAKER_04: I appreciate that I don't have to write my own words, that they're already there and they're easy to fill in those blanks.
[38:23] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, and it it allows you to have the right tone to that, as you said.
[38:26] SPEAKER_01: You know, it's not I we reluctantly, or I guess we have to, you know, it's it's having the tone.
[38:32] SPEAKER_01: This ends with prayer and thanksgiving too.
[38:34] SPEAKER_05: There should be something of a happy tone.
[39:02] SPEAKER_02: Um Scott, these are numbers.
[39:04] SPEAKER_02: I might need you to explain them to me.
[39:06] SPEAKER_02: Uh not it's not a joke, but okay.
[39:11] SPEAKER_02: Um So obviously, let's start with that first part.
[39:15] SPEAKER_02: You guys see it there.
[39:16] SPEAKER_02: Uh a guy can't he can't um be an officer over uh people without being elected to that position.
[39:23] SPEAKER_02: And so if he's been deposed and he's uh been removed from that deposition, he has to be re-elected in order to resume the exercise of his office.
[39:32] SPEAKER_02: What what's the somebody can somebody explain that second sentence with the three-fourths?
[39:41] SPEAKER_04: So the court that inflicts the censure could I I don't know, it seems pretty obvious to me, my my friend, uh, that a court inflicting a censure is the court that also removes the censure, and that court does so by a three-quarters vote, so 75%, or uh by uh three-quarters vote of a majority of the original delegates that had authority.
[40:01] SPEAKER_04: And so you can go back to the original court that instituted the censure.
[40:07] SPEAKER_04: At in my previous Presbyterian, we had that exact thing happen where a deposed minister wanted to have his credentials restored.
[40:16] SPEAKER_04: And we were wondering, well, how what approach do we take?
[40:19] SPEAKER_04: And the the group decided as we were looking through it that we did the latter, the more clearer one, they thought, um, which was going back who was a member of the court at that time.
[40:30] SPEAKER_04: It's easier on sessions, uh, but perhaps a little more difficult when you think of a presbytery where the original delegates may move on, and so the pool might get smaller.
[40:40] SPEAKER_04: But I think why there's a three-fourths of the original delegates there is because they are the ones that know the context behind the censure that was given.
[40:49] SPEAKER_04: They would be the ones that would be best qualified in understanding what the man did and perhaps whether he has truly repented of those sins.
[40:57] SPEAKER_04: And so I think it's perhaps trying to create continuity um in the in the church court for resolving um prior sins.
[41:07] SPEAKER_04: Uh there might be a sin that arises that no one even knows uh because there has been so much turnover.
[41:13] SPEAKER_04: It's hard to uh resolve something if you don't know the person or what they've done.
[41:18] SPEAKER_04: And so I think that's where the latter part's getting to.
[41:21] SPEAKER_01: Well, yeah, and this goes along with the next section of there might be a uh a delegating of this authority to a different court.
[41:28] SPEAKER_01: Um sometimes we're thinking at presbytery level, but this could be a session level too for a deacon or for an elder.
[41:34] SPEAKER_01: And especially trying to figure out if there aren't people around from there or they can't uh figure that out and they've been working with this other session, they just say, We trust you on this.
[41:43] SPEAKER_01: And so they they can uh delegate some of that authority um in that way.
[41:52] SPEAKER_02: Scott, thank you.
[41:53] SPEAKER_02: Uh as uh you may have believed it to be very clear, but I actually think it it's not, and your explanation uh clarified all of that, so thank you.
[42:01] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, it just wants to ensure that the mo the majority of the people knew the situation in context.
[42:07] SPEAKER_02: I I think one thing that that strikes me here is this is fairly unusual for a church court.
[42:12] SPEAKER_02: Um you know, for a presbytery, if if one meeting of a presbytery takes an action, the the next meeting of the presbytery can do something about that action they took without having to, you know, and they don't limit who can vote on the issue.
[42:24] SPEAKER_02: But this, if you take that second route, seems that it's limiting who who's allowed to cast a vote in a particular matter of restoring this man.
[42:33] SPEAKER_02: And so, anyway, I think it's the as far as I know, it's the only place where this occurs in this fashion.
[42:40] SPEAKER_04: It requires men like Mel Duncan to keep really accurate roles of who's at every meeting.
[42:45] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, for real.
[42:47] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[42:49] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I when when I was a deacon growing up at Second President Greenville, I had a recurring dream slash nightmare that I made it to heaven and somebody put their arms around me and said, Mel, we need you to help us move some tables down in the fellowship hall.
[43:06] SPEAKER_00: And now that I'm a clerk, the dream is somebody says, Mel, can you show me the updated role of Calvary Presbytery?
[43:14] SPEAKER_00: Um, because it's uh you you would be amazed at how complicated keeping track of 125 teaching elders and 329 or so, depending on what day of the week it is, ruling elders in Calvary Presbytery.
[43:32] SPEAKER_00: But uh you do have to have somebody keeping those records, and it reminds me of a of a situation in Calvary Presbytery where one church excommunicated a man, and the other church years later wanted to receive him as a member, and the church that inflicted the discipline didn't have an accurate record of the excommunication.
[43:53] SPEAKER_00: And you you just you can't do that.
[43:55] SPEAKER_00: You gotta write these things down and you gotta make sure that you take care of it.
[44:04] SPEAKER_06: Okay.
[44:04] SPEAKER_02: That was six, right?
[44:05] SPEAKER_02: Thirty seven seven.
[44:07] SPEAKER_02: When a person under censure shall reside at such a distance from the court by which he was sentenced as to make the continued exercise of spiritual oversight impractical, it shall be lawful for the court with the acquiescence of the offender and the concurrence of the receiving court to transmit a certified copy of its proceedings to the court where the delinquent resides, which shall assume jurisdiction, take up the case, and proceed with it as though it had originated with itself.
[44:34] SPEAKER_02: Um Who says long sentences are are clunky and don't flow really well?
[44:39] SPEAKER_02: I just don't understand.
[44:41] SPEAKER_02: Uh we've seen things like this before with jurisdiction that uh you know if somebody moves jurisdiction can become sort of uh transferred, as it were.
[44:52] SPEAKER_02: And so what we're assuming here that uh if somebody is suspended from the table, uh their the oversight of that suspension can be moved to the church that's closer to them.
[45:04] SPEAKER_02: Uh you only have other yeah, Jared.
[45:07] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, uh so this is a um transfer or delegation of that to to some other uh court.
[45:14] SPEAKER_01: Um I do think it's a little bit vague though, what if this was an excommunication?
[45:19] SPEAKER_01: Um so in our case, we worked with another church once on this that where that was the case, and even though we didn't have a clear uh mandate, we decided we're gonna go to that other church and talk to them about it and make sure that they're on board with this.
[45:34] SPEAKER_01: They even voted to say that we we're gonna trust you with this.
[45:37] SPEAKER_01: And and part of that was us communicating to them when we're working with this per person, this isn't an appeal.
[45:43] SPEAKER_01: This is saying we're not talking about the the the faults of the the church court that did this, we're talking about the faults of the offender, and that's what you're gonna have to um to focus in on.
[45:55] SPEAKER_01: So you're gonna have to have courts working together on this and not second guessing each other and and just move forward from where that other court was as if they had done it.
[46:05] SPEAKER_01: Uh so I think this is talking mostly about deposition and and indefinite suspension, but it's a probably a good idea with excommunication too.
[46:19] SPEAKER_06: Good.
[46:21] SPEAKER_02: Alright, I'm I just My only purpose is to keep moving unless I'm stopped by a by a thought or an individual, so thirty-seven eight.
[46:32] SPEAKER_02: In the restoration of a minister who is under indefinite suspension from the sacraments and or his office or has been deposed, it is the duty of the Presbytery to proceed with great caution.
[46:42] SPEAKER_02: It should first admit him to the sacraments, if he has been debarred from them.
[46:46] SPEAKER_02: Afterwards it should grant him the privilege of preaching on probation for a time, so as to test the sincerity of his repentance and prospect of his usefulness.
[46:54] SPEAKER_02: When satisfied in these respects, the Presbytery shall take steps to restore him to his office, but the case shall always be under judicial consideration until the declaration of restoration has been pronounced.
[47:06] SPEAKER_02: So this is getting a little bit back to Mel, what you mentioned from um Dr.
[47:12] SPEAKER_02: Smith, that that there should be steps taken, and not maybe all at one time, uh, but but slowly brought back in.
[47:20] SPEAKER_02: And there's obviously prudence and wisdom at play here.
[47:24] SPEAKER_02: You guys have any thoughts here?
[47:27] SPEAKER_02: I like that paragraph.
[47:29] SPEAKER_02: It's a good one.
[47:30] SPEAKER_00: Ben, I've seen entire Presbytery meetings turned upside down because a third of the room doesn't understand the difference between a definite and an indefinite suspension.
[47:43] SPEAKER_00: And you know, it's a reminder if if you're listening to this and you're a clerk, or if you're leading a judicial process, um I'm I'm working on the docket for our next press terror meeting, and I'm actually putting in there a guide to expressions in the report that they're going to receive because I know that a third of the room is just not going to appreciate because we don't have everybody listening to Polity Matters, they're not going to appreciate the finer points in that.
[48:16] SPEAKER_00: But um deliberately, deliberately um, you know, there's never a rush to do these things.
[48:23] SPEAKER_00: There should be a carefulness in lifting them as well, I think is the general principle.
[48:31] SPEAKER_01: Ramsey has a few uh comments here that are reproduced in Smith, so it might be worth us considering uh three things that he uh observations that he makes uh in this removal of censure.
[48:43] SPEAKER_01: Uh first, uh he says that the the court that acts in the removal of censure is not a court representing Christ as judge nor as an accuser, but rather as a parent.
[48:53] SPEAKER_01: Hence, all the members of the court not under censure have a voice and vote therein.
[48:58] SPEAKER_01: Uh number two, uh the court cannot remove a censure without repentance on the part of the offender.
[49:04] SPEAKER_01: But if the court should come to believe that she erred in the sentence of that censure, how can she rectify that wrong?
[49:10] SPEAKER_01: By a new trial in the court of the first resort, if new evidence has been discovered, or by reconsideration uh in the court that passed the final sentence.
[49:19] SPEAKER_01: And so I think that's important here too.
[49:20] SPEAKER_01: Like if there's been an error, you don't just restore the person, pretend like you didn't mess up, you have to go back and redo it.
[49:25] SPEAKER_01: And number three, uh, the censure is not removed until the sentence of removal has been pronounced after being ordered by the court.
[49:32] SPEAKER_01: So just three observations from from Ramsey.
[49:35] SPEAKER_01: And if Smith thought they were important, maybe we should uh uh pass them along too on that point.
[49:45] SPEAKER_06: Okay.
[49:46] SPEAKER_06: Jared, can I have to ask you a favor?
[49:48] SPEAKER_06: Can you clear up my mix up on 376?
[49:59] SPEAKER_06: Should I?
[49:59] SPEAKER_06: You can say no.
[50:01] SPEAKER_06: Should you?
[50:02] SPEAKER_02: Can you clear it up?
[50:07] SPEAKER_00: It's a May Shal, it's a May Shal distinction, Dira.
[50:10] SPEAKER_00: Don't fall into the trial.
[50:16] SPEAKER_01: May show distinction.
[50:17] SPEAKER_01: Just demand it, Scott.
[50:19] SPEAKER_01: I was just I was just trying to say.
[50:52] SPEAKER_04: Let's just ask the SJC member here.
[50:54] SPEAKER_06: Um, how do you understand 376?
[51:03] SPEAKER_00: Well, let me say as a former SJC member, I can now comment on a matter that is uh pending or impending before the SJC.
[51:14] SPEAKER_00: I I used to tell my wife that every time she asked me to do something.
[51:17] SPEAKER_00: I'm sorry, honey, I can't do this.
[51:19] SPEAKER_00: It's a matter pending or impending before the SJC.
[51:23] SPEAKER_00: Um, I'd I'd I'd need to think on that, uh, Scott.
[51:28] SPEAKER_00: I mean, I I'm not you've given me something to think about, is what I would say.
[51:34] SPEAKER_01: Well, I I think it's just that sentence is it's a three-fourths vote of the court that originally inflicted it, or it's a three-fourths vote of whatever court that has been delegated that power.
[51:46] SPEAKER_01: So that person is moved on, or they're at a different church, and that church says, You can you can deal with this, uh, with this deacon or elder, or your presbytery can deal with this teaching elder.
[51:57] SPEAKER_01: That's what I think those numbers are about.
[51:59] SPEAKER_02: So you're saying that 377 should come before 377.
[52:03] SPEAKER_04: Oh my goodness.
[52:04] SPEAKER_04: Oh goodness.
[52:06] SPEAKER_04: We've not helped the listener with this chapter at all.
[52:10] SPEAKER_00: I'm actually thinking about the the wise guy who will read this and say it takes three fours to restore a man, but only fifty percent plus one to elect a man uh to be a ruling elder or deacon.
[52:23] SPEAKER_00: And it's an interesting dilemma there.
[52:25] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[52:26] SPEAKER_01: I I just think that you can take off a couple of Scott's sentences when he's talking about that, and then it sounds fine.
[52:33] SPEAKER_02: I think we're just gonna leave all this in there and figure it out for themselves.
[52:38] SPEAKER_02: This is our this this is gonna be troublesome.
[52:40] SPEAKER_02: This whole editing this this whole episode might just be what Mel said at the beginning and then and then the end of the episode.
[52:47] SPEAKER_02: We'll just, yeah.
[52:48] SPEAKER_02: That was enough.
[52:49] SPEAKER_02: It was good.
[52:50] SPEAKER_02: Well, here, let's do 37-9.
[52:52] SPEAKER_00: Let me let me before we beat the horse to death.
[52:55] SPEAKER_00: The the language at the end of 37.6, Scott, is new language.
[53:00] SPEAKER_00: I mean, that's not been in there all that long.
[53:03] SPEAKER_00: Um Jared, do you have the the table of when that got put in?
[53:08] SPEAKER_00: I don't have that open in front of me.
[53:10] SPEAKER_01: It's not even in the uh PCA history thing yet, so it's within the past couple years.
[53:14] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I was going to say, um, which probably means that this originated in a lunch between Greco, Howie, and Dan Carroll at SJC, which is where a lot where a lot of these things come from.
[53:28] SPEAKER_00: Um so let's just email Howie after the program and he'll tell us where this came from.
[53:36] SPEAKER_02: He's gonna be on next week.
[53:37] SPEAKER_02: We'll just ask him and circle back and then edit it back in.
[53:41] SPEAKER_00: He he tends to be the uh the the emanuensis of a lot of these kind of things in the in the BCF.
[53:53] SPEAKER_06: Oh boy.
[53:55] SPEAKER_06: Listeners, we're very sorry.
[53:57] SPEAKER_04: Sorry.
[53:57] SPEAKER_04: We're sorry.
[53:58] SPEAKER_04: Don't send us any emails on this substantial.
[54:01] SPEAKER_01: They won't hear any of this.
[54:02] SPEAKER_01: You're editing this all out.
[54:04] SPEAKER_02: No.
[54:04] SPEAKER_02: It it depends how much of it I remember or forget when the time comes to edit this episode.
[54:09] SPEAKER_02: There's a lot happening between now and now 379.
[54:14] SPEAKER_02: In the case of the removal of censures from or the restoration of a minister, jurisdiction shall be as follows A.
[54:21] SPEAKER_02: If the censure does not include excommunication, the Presbytery inflicting the censure shall retain the authority to remove the censure and at its discretion restore him to office.
[54:31] SPEAKER_02: This authority is retained by the Presbytery even when a divested or deposed minister is assigned under the provisions of BCO forty six eight to a session.
[54:39] SPEAKER_02: If the censure includes excommunication, the penitent may only be restored to the communion of the church through a session.
[54:46] SPEAKER_02: Once the penitent is restored and therefore a member of a local church, the authority to remove any other censures in respect to office concurrently imposed with that of excommunication shall belong to the court originally imposing such censure.
[55:00] SPEAKER_02: Scott, I am not going to ask you to explain this one.
[55:06] SPEAKER_01: There's an element here of um if you have somebody that was an officer and was excommunicated, right, that the the question of the officer, the church that had elected them as an officer has a say in it because they're the one that elected them and as an officer and then imposed this.
[55:22] SPEAKER_01: So you can have a situation in which somebody is restored at another church, but they can't be elected a deacon or an elder until you settle with that other church.
[55:31] SPEAKER_01: What's what's the status of their uh of their office, and that they would have to concur with that.
[55:36] SPEAKER_01: So it's something to be aware of once you have somebody that's restored.
[55:39] SPEAKER_01: Had they been a deacon or elder before?
[55:41] SPEAKER_01: And if they have, you're gonna have to talk to that other church.
[55:44] SPEAKER_00: And Jared, there's also an implication that the other church involved is a PCA church.
[55:49] SPEAKER_00: Um, I I know our set our Presbyterian in wrestling through 379 with restoring a former teaching elder actually went to this man and said, Look, uh, we we appreciate that you're at another church, but used to be a PCA minister and used to take vows to the PCA.
[56:09] SPEAKER_00: And so we actually ask him to join a PCA church to help us gauge whether he's really rejoined a PCA church to help us uh judge his repentance.
[56:21] SPEAKER_00: And um I think the idea is that um for all our faults, and the PCA has many of them, we are trying to do things in an organic union way in which we're all living under the same rules.
[56:37] SPEAKER_00: And um I I think this is a passage that strengthens the connections and the responsibilities for all the different PCA churches in a presbytery to try to do discipline in the same way.
[56:50] SPEAKER_06: At least try to do something in the same way.
[56:58] SPEAKER_02: Well, guys, is there anything that we need to say as we conclude this discussion of BCO 37?
[57:08] SPEAKER_01: It's a section that will probably be referenced very little, but we wish was referenced a whole lot more.
[57:22] SPEAKER_06: And then enjoying the satisfaction of what you've done.
[57:32] SPEAKER_02: Well, listeners, I think with that I'm gonna say that this podcast is over.
[57:36] SPEAKER_02: Thanks for joining us.
[57:37] SPEAKER_02: Be sure to come next time when we uh hang out with Howie Dunahoe and discuss BCO 38 on cases without process.
[57:44] SPEAKER_02: If you're interested in learning more about anything that we've mentioned, check out the show notes.
[57:48] SPEAKER_02: There's probably not much these days.
[57:50] SPEAKER_02: It's not a lot of extra content out there right now.
[57:52] SPEAKER_02: Uh, if you enjoyed the show, do consider following us on Twitter or Facebook at Polity Matters, and be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[57:59] SPEAKER_02: Our great thanks to Mel for joining us again today.
[58:02] SPEAKER_02: We we hope that you'll come back in the future and and do this again.
[58:05] SPEAKER_02: Uh we we plan to spend uh a lot of time in the directory for worship once we arrive there, so we'll we hope you'd maybe spend some time on that.
[58:12] SPEAKER_02: Thanks for having me.
[58:13] SPEAKER_02: Yes, sir.
[58:14] SPEAKER_02: If you have questions or comments this week, listeners, we don't want to hear about it.
[58:17] SPEAKER_02: So uh that's it.
[58:19] SPEAKER_02: Uh there's also a link below to support our work, which is a bold ask after telling you to leave us alone, I suppose.
[58:24] SPEAKER_02: But anyway, thanks again for spending time with us.
[58:27] SPEAKER_02: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[58:29] SPEAKER_02: Goodbye.
[58:30] SPEAKER_02: Y'all take care.
[58:32] SPEAKER_02: Hey there, listeners.
[58:33] SPEAKER_02: Just a week after we uh spent time with Mel on BCO 37, we were jumping into BCO 38 with Howie Donahoe, and he had some comments for us on BCO 376 that we wanted to share with you here.
[58:46] SPEAKER_04: So, Howie, as we start today, um I did have a question for you on BCO uh BCO 376.
[58:55] SPEAKER_04: The last time it was updated was in 2014 by your Presbytery.
[59:00] SPEAKER_04: This kind of sounds like a quiz or something.
[59:03] SPEAKER_04: Um, but we got into confusion last week.
[59:05] SPEAKER_04: I should say I got into confusion on the current meaning of 376, which says when a ruling elder or deacon has been absolved from a censure of deposition, he cannot be allowed to resume the exercise of his office in the church without re-election by the people.
[59:21] SPEAKER_04: The removal of deposition requires a three-fourths vote of the court inflicting the censure or a three-fourths vote of the court to which the majority of the original court delegates delegates that authority.
[59:35] SPEAKER_04: And so can you just uh distinguish the two options for the removal of deposition for us?
[59:42] SPEAKER_03: Um, sure.
[59:44] SPEAKER_03: If my church session deposed me from office as a ruling elder, uh at some point in the future, the only way for me to be restored is for the three-quarters vote of my session to restore me, or if I've moved to Cleveland uh and uh joined a PCA church there that wanted to call me as a ruling elder, uh my church uh Boise Prez could either vote on it themselves or uh by majority vote give authority to the session in Cleveland, Ohio to remove the censure.
[1:00:24] SPEAKER_04: All right, then that means Jared was right.
[1:00:26] SPEAKER_04: He he does get the bonus points for that.
[1:00:28] SPEAKER_04: Uh I I bungled it.
[1:00:30] SPEAKER_04: And so we want to add that to last week's episode, Ben.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
