# 78. The People I Lied to Are Dead (BCO 32 Part One)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 1 Apr 2025, 49 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/16872712-78-the-people-i-lied-to-are-dead-bco-32-part-one.mp3

Ben, Jared, Scott, and Fred deal with the first six sections of BCO 32. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Introductions
- 5:39 BCO 32-1
- 11:30 BCO 32-2
- 18:04 BCO 32-3
- 31:38 BCO 32-4
- 34:14 BCO 32-5
- 37:42 BCO 32-6
- 48:58 Intermission

## Transcript

[0:05] SPEAKER_04: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:07] SPEAKER_04: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined as always by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg.
[0:12] SPEAKER_04: And we are here to discuss PCO 32.
[0:15] SPEAKER_04: But since all of us only have the credentials that each of us has, we decided to bring another guy in to help us out.
[0:21] SPEAKER_04: I hear he may be the author of some of this chapter, maybe not, but Fred Greco's with us today, and we're grateful.
[0:26] SPEAKER_04: Fred, how you doing, man?
[0:28] SPEAKER_04: What's going on?
[0:29] SPEAKER_03: Doing very well, Ben.
[0:30] SPEAKER_03: Glad to be with y'all.
[0:33] SPEAKER_04: We thought about just having Fred read the whole chapter and comment as he goes, but we're going to keep more to our traditional style for the whole episode.
[0:42] SPEAKER_04: BCO 32 is titled General Provisions Applicable to All Cases of Process.
[0:48] SPEAKER_04: So, in a in a big picture sense, it provides the foundational framework for handling all judicial cases in the church.
[0:55] SPEAKER_04: And it sets up a lot of principles that we're going to get into here in just a minute.
[1:00] SPEAKER_04: It outlines the process and the procedures for initiating process and notifying the accused for gathering evidence, conducting trials, maintaining the impartiality of courts of the church, and lots of other big words like that.
[1:13] SPEAKER_04: So I should ask the three of y'all, maybe Fred in particular, before we get into 32-1, is there any big picture we need to have in mind as we work our way through this content?
[1:25] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I think there is been, and I often give this advice to uh members of sessions and members of Presbytery.
[1:32] SPEAKER_03: And that is that this chapter, although you've said that it's long, is really not.
[1:39] SPEAKER_03: So being a repenting lawyer, I took entire classes, entire semester-long classes on civil procedure and criminal procedure, with gigantic big textbooks that cover rules, like for example, the federal rules of civil procedure are in the hundreds of pages.
[1:59] SPEAKER_03: We don't have that in our process.
[2:02] SPEAKER_03: And so it's more about principles in terms of how a court conducts itself.
[2:07] SPEAKER_03: We can delve into this in some of the details.
[2:10] SPEAKER_03: I'll just give you one for instance that surprises people.
[2:14] SPEAKER_03: There is absolutely no rule concerning hearsay statements in our Book of Church Order.
[2:21] SPEAKER_03: Now, hearsay is you probably if you ever watch Law and Order or you know you're an old school and you watch Perry Mason or Matlock, that's when someone says, you know, Bob told me this, and someone jumps up and yells, objection, hearsay.
[2:37] SPEAKER_03: You can't testify to what someone else told you.
[2:40] SPEAKER_03: They have to say it themselves.
[2:43] SPEAKER_03: In our court, you can do that.
[2:45] SPEAKER_03: Now the court can judge it as being not really very credible because it doesn't come from a direct source.
[2:52] SPEAKER_03: But this is the sort of thing that our courts are different than the civil magistrate courts.
[2:58] SPEAKER_03: And so while this may seem like a big chapter with a lot of detail, it really isn't.
[3:05] SPEAKER_03: And so courts have to keep in mind that the main thing that they need to have in view is the glory of God and justice.
[3:15] SPEAKER_03: I think on an earlier episode, Steve Dowling talked about this with respect to discipline, and he's 100% correct.
[3:22] SPEAKER_03: And so we need to understand this chapter and these details within that context.
[3:27] SPEAKER_03: This chapter is not going to answer every question we might have about process or a trial or anything like that.
[3:34] SPEAKER_04: There's proof now in recorded uh material, as long as I publish this on time, that Fred Greco listens to Polity Matters.
[3:42] SPEAKER_04: So just I'm sorry, I'm trying to I'm trying to collect myself after that realization.
[3:47] SPEAKER_03: Uh an avid subscriber, Ben.
[3:50] SPEAKER_01: Avid subscriber.
[3:51] SPEAKER_01: Have you supported us on Patreon yet?
[3:55] SPEAKER_01: Um, you know what?
[3:57] SPEAKER_01: Because we don't have one.
[3:58] SPEAKER_03: I have I have a free PCA ice cream button already, so I don't need to support you.
[4:04] SPEAKER_03: You've already given me the game.
[4:08] SPEAKER_04: Don't worry, the perks are not that good.
[4:10] SPEAKER_04: Uh there's about well, there's a handful of guys that can testify to that.
[4:15] SPEAKER_00: Well, uh I I would just want to piggyback on uh what Fred said, uh, other than feeling a little bit attacked since I did watch uh Matt Lock growing up, so I guess I'm old.
[4:24] SPEAKER_00: Um but uh one thing I was struck by with Ramsey's introduction to this is uh the importance of this chapter, that it may feel like it's a lot of technical things and it's maybe boring for some people, but if you're in the midst of process and you're the accused and you want to know your rights, um he points out that at least in the PCUS version that he was uh dealing with in this section, that the first ten look at the protection of the accused.
[4:51] SPEAKER_00: So in in some ways, this is a a bill of rights uh for the accused, uh, at least in some of these provisions, to know um what your rights are within process if you're fighting something and you're you're taking issue with the the church charging you in discipline and you want to know what your rights are.
[5:06] SPEAKER_00: Chapter 32 needs to be high in your list of things to read.
[5:10] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, when thinking about this, it it seems thorough at first glance and until as Jared said, you go through process and then you wish there were more.
[5:19] SPEAKER_01: You you just wish you had more rules to follow rather than having to chart your own path or best practices kind of thing.
[5:26] SPEAKER_01: And so, yeah, it it's it's a long one for the BCO standard, but you will want more as you engage in process because there's a lot of questions not answered as well.
[5:38] SPEAKER_04: All right.
[5:39] SPEAKER_04: Well, I think we're we're ready to do this.
[5:41] SPEAKER_04: Let's get into thirty-two, starting in section one.
[5:44] SPEAKER_04: It is incumbent on every member of a court of Jesus Christ engaged in a trial of offenders to bear in mind the inspired injunction.
[5:53] SPEAKER_04: Brethren, if a man is overtaken in any trespass, you who are spiritual, restore such a one in the spirit of gentleness, considering yourself lest you also be tempted.
[6:03] SPEAKER_04: Galatians six one.
[6:05] SPEAKER_04: I guess the question right at the start is why do they bring this inspired injunction?
[6:10] SPEAKER_04: I mean, obviously we know what that means.
[6:12] SPEAKER_04: This is a quotation from Scripture.
[6:14] SPEAKER_04: Why start with Galatians 6 1?
[6:18] SPEAKER_03: I think, Ben, it's it gets back to we we saw earlier in chapter 27 about the purposes of discipline.
[6:25] SPEAKER_03: And the purpose of discipline is not really to fix problems.
[6:31] SPEAKER_03: That we can often, as we get in the weeds, we're either trying to fix problems that are causing challenges in the church, or we're trying to fix a person's problems.
[6:43] SPEAKER_03: And, you know, there a result of discipline might be to fix those problems, but that's not the primary aim.
[6:51] SPEAKER_03: You know, the primary aim is that this is a spiritual matter, and we need to remember this spirit of gentleness, um, and remember that you know we're not standing as the guiltless, as those who've never sinned, as those who've never made fault.
[7:09] SPEAKER_03: And and the scripture makes it you know really clear that when you're coming alongside someone, you need to realize that you know you yourself are a sinner.
[7:20] SPEAKER_03: That's the great if there anything is the great blind spot of the Pharisees in the gospels.
[7:26] SPEAKER_03: That's what it is.
[7:28] SPEAKER_03: It's not that they were too strict, it's that they felt like they never had any problems.
[7:36] SPEAKER_03: And so therefore, they could speak into other people's lives and they were somehow above it.
[7:41] SPEAKER_03: And I think this this biblical injunction here warns us against that.
[7:45] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, two words stick out to me in citing Galatians 6 1.
[7:50] SPEAKER_00: Uh one of them is gentleness, as as Fred pointed out.
[7:54] SPEAKER_00: Um I think of 1 Timothy 6 points out the man of God is gentle, so that's uh not only fruit of the Spirit, but it's it's a manly fruit.
[8:01] SPEAKER_00: Um and so to be remembering that, but also restore, you know, there's a there's a goal of winning back the person.
[8:07] SPEAKER_00: And so the whole way that you do this um will either communicate to them that you want them gone or or you want them to repent and you want them restored.
[8:16] SPEAKER_00: Uh, and so it's it's just great that it this begins pastorally uh before getting into the weeds.
[8:21] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, but you gotta check yourself before you wreck yourself, and uh you gotta consider your own heart in the matter.
[8:28] SPEAKER_04: Fred, you mentioned Steve a second ago.
[8:30] SPEAKER_04: I think it was off the air when we had Dowling on not long ago, but he he referred to this to some degree that that there um we do have to be careful not to move far away from the pastoral element of discipline.
[8:43] SPEAKER_04: We can't become too um litigious uh about it.
[8:47] SPEAKER_04: We we have to remember the the pastoral nature of of the office that we hold, um, but also of of this seeking to restore people.
[8:56] SPEAKER_04: Um and so I I love that it starts this way.
[9:00] SPEAKER_03: I don't I mean I'm a sap, but uh now Ben, I will give you one other overarching comment that I think is important.
[9:07] SPEAKER_03: I agree with what you've just said and I agree with my good friend Steve.
[9:12] SPEAKER_03: But I think one of the things that we have to do is there's a difference between having a pastoral heart and seeking to address things pastorally.
[9:22] unknown: Yeah.
[9:23] SPEAKER_03: What do I mean by that?
[9:24] SPEAKER_03: I mean once you have entered a judicial process, you have to follow the rules.
[9:31] SPEAKER_03: You can't say to an accused, well, I know you've got this right, but pastorally, we don't think it's good for you to have this right, and so we're gonna ignore it.
[9:39] SPEAKER_03: I think we have to understand that.
[9:42] SPEAKER_03: That um there's a difference.
[9:43] SPEAKER_03: And I think even especially presbyteries would be wise if they're dealing with matters of discipline.
[9:49] SPEAKER_03: There's often a committee of presbytery that deals with, I call it the church trouble committee.
[9:56] SPEAKER_03: You know, it's a different name in other in different presbyteries, but it's always church trouble.
[10:02] SPEAKER_03: They come alongside churches, sessions, and pastors.
[10:08] SPEAKER_03: It's often a good and wise thing to have that committee be different than the people, the men who are commissioned to handle judicial matters.
[10:21] SPEAKER_03: It doesn't always have to be the case, but especially in a long-running issue, so there's a kind of a clear division.
[10:28] SPEAKER_03: Because, you know, when we come to something that's judicial, we have to understand that people have rights and there's a process to be followed, and we can't shortcut that, and our good intentions are not appropriate to violate express provisions of the book.
[10:46] SPEAKER_04: I I I can't tell y'all where it was, but it's been resolved.
[10:49] SPEAKER_04: I can say that much.
[10:51] SPEAKER_04: But there was a situation I heard about, and it started at a presbytery level, and there was a suggestion that they instead of instead of handling something um, you know, so tightly and narrowly and and coldly with with process, they they've sort of figured out a new way to handle a very serious issue.
[11:11] SPEAKER_04: And they called it pastoral.
[11:13] SPEAKER_04: And I remember just shrinking when I heard this, I thought, no, you you don't understand that our our process is pastoral.
[11:20] SPEAKER_04: It is it is the way we've set up to shepherd people is the right way to do it.
[11:23] SPEAKER_04: And you're actually doing a disservice if you think that you're gonna be better at being a pastor shepherd without following our rules.
[11:30] SPEAKER_04: 322.
[11:32] SPEAKER_04: Process against an offender shall not be commenced unless some person or persons undertake to make out the charge, or unless the court finds it necessary for the honor of religion itself to take the step provided for in BCO 312.
[11:46] SPEAKER_04: Uh sorry, my my cadence was off a little bit, but if you go read 32.2, you'll see it properly.
[11:52] SPEAKER_04: Um so we've we've already talked about in 31 about investigations and charges, but this this is now coming with a sort of a principle that we should we should dissect and maybe compare even to what we had in 31.
[12:07] SPEAKER_04: So y'all tell me where we're at.
[12:12] SPEAKER_03: Well, this provision is probably in my top ten of where I get questions on.
[12:18] SPEAKER_03: And so um I think this provision is pretty clear.
[12:22] SPEAKER_03: Um there is a debate within our denomination and within our courts as to exactly when uh process needs to begin with someone files charges.
[12:34] SPEAKER_03: Um I have a very firm opinion that has been ratified by the Standing Judicial Commission in several cases.
[12:40] SPEAKER_03: Um I'm on the uh prevailing side.
[12:42] SPEAKER_03: I have friends on the non-prevailing side.
[12:45] SPEAKER_03: Um, but I believe that, for example, when you go with a case of process where there are charges, an indictment, a prosecutor, a trial, etc., that there are two parallel ways to get there.
[13:00] SPEAKER_03: They're not the same and they're not consecutive.
[13:04] SPEAKER_03: Under BCO 312, a court can undergo a formal investigation by receiving a report.
[13:14] SPEAKER_03: That could be from a person, that could be from a periodical, that could be from a social media post, that could be from a rumor floating around town.
[13:22] SPEAKER_03: And they can do a formal investigation to find whether there's a strong presumption of guilt.
[13:27] SPEAKER_03: And if there is, then 31-2 says they must proceed to process.
[13:32] SPEAKER_03: Now, one of the things about that, though, is 31-2, at least in theory, is the mechanism for a man to acquit himself.
[13:40] SPEAKER_03: In other words, if I feel like my reputation is on the line and people are saying things about me, I can go to my court and say, please investigate me.
[13:49] SPEAKER_03: This is about as close to a you are innocent verdict as you can get.
[13:53] SPEAKER_03: Okay?
[13:54] SPEAKER_03: But if there is a strong presumption of guilt, you must go forward.
[13:58] SPEAKER_03: Under 32-2, if someone brings a charge, if someone says, you know, you have violated the ninth commandment because on February 22nd you wrote this in a public forum about me and it is untrue, that's a charge with a specification.
[14:18] SPEAKER_03: And I believe if someone makes out a charge that the court must proceed to process.
[14:25] SPEAKER_03: There are some in our denomination that say, no, the Presbytery can go back and it can determine whether there's a strong presumption of guilt.
[14:33] SPEAKER_03: I don't believe that is the case.
[14:35] SPEAKER_03: I don't think that is appropriate.
[14:37] SPEAKER_03: Now, I will say that there is an initial judgment that the court can make.
[14:44] SPEAKER_03: Under BCO 31.
[15:02] SPEAKER_03: We're done.
[15:03] SPEAKER_03: Right?
[15:04] SPEAKER_03: But you must adjudicate otherwise.
[15:07] SPEAKER_03: Now, the counter effect that I get back is, well, what do you do if Johnny comes, 15-year-old Johnny comes and files charges against 13-year-old Bobby for you know stealing his Star Wars toy?
[15:21] SPEAKER_03: My answer is if you do that, then you adjudicate it.
[15:25] SPEAKER_03: It doesn't mean you need to have a three-day trial.
[15:28] SPEAKER_03: It doesn't need to mean you need to be overly formal.
[15:31] SPEAKER_03: You may be able to handle that in 10 minutes.
[15:34] SPEAKER_03: But I think you do need to adjudicate it.
[15:36] SPEAKER_03: Um and if it's a frivolous charge, you can say so and deal with it that way.
[15:42] SPEAKER_03: But I think this is important because it gives accountability.
[15:46] SPEAKER_03: You know, especially at the presbytery level, we're all aware of kind of what's in the air and in the water about, you know, pastors are above um accountability, and there's nothing that laid people can do to hold their pastors accountable and know where they can go, and presbytery's an old boys' club, and etc.
[16:06] SPEAKER_03: No.
[16:07] SPEAKER_03: Someone files charges, then they need to be adjudicated.
[16:12] SPEAKER_01: You don't take it to an investigation.
[16:14] SPEAKER_01: So would you say that like like who has the who has the right to file charges in this sense?
[16:22] SPEAKER_01: Is it anyone?
[16:23] SPEAKER_01: Anyone can file charges?
[16:24] SPEAKER_01: Or like what's the limiter?
[16:27] SPEAKER_03: I personally think anyone can.
[16:30] SPEAKER_03: Um I think that, you know, again, the veracity of those charges could depend.
[16:35] SPEAKER_03: Is it a Christian, is it a non-Christian, is it someone familiar to them or not, etc.
[16:40] SPEAKER_03: Again, this is one of those instances we talked about at the beginning.
[16:43] SPEAKER_03: The book here isn't really clear.
[16:45] SPEAKER_03: It doesn't say you need to be a member of that court.
[16:47] SPEAKER_03: It doesn't say you need to be a member of the PCA.
[16:50] SPEAKER_03: You know, it doesn't say you have to be a Christian.
[16:53] SPEAKER_03: It's that's really up to the court's discretion and judgment.
[16:57] SPEAKER_03: Um, and if someone feels like the court has erred, that's where we have appeals and we have complaints.
[17:03] SPEAKER_03: But my personal opinion is that anyone can bring charges.
[17:08] SPEAKER_04: Scott, can you context your question a little bit?
[17:11] SPEAKER_04: So, like what why did you ask what you asked?
[17:14] SPEAKER_04: Can anybody?
[17:16] SPEAKER_01: Uh well, I'm just wondering, you know, at more at the Presbytery level, I was wondering if it had to be with someone who is a member of the court or outside the court.
[17:25] SPEAKER_01: And I think we I don't know, was it Dr.
[17:27] SPEAKER_01: Waters or Steve Tipton that we had on?
[17:29] SPEAKER_01: We were talking about something similar um a few weeks ago where 31, maybe it was a 31-2, uh, dealing with like where does that originate from and all of that?
[17:43] SPEAKER_01: Jared, do you got anything on this one?
[17:45] SPEAKER_04: Alright, yeah, me neither.
[17:46] SPEAKER_04: Cool.
[17:47] SPEAKER_01: Jared, it looks like you might be disagreeing with Fred and your facial expressions.
[17:51] SPEAKER_01: Can you please outline that?
[17:54] SPEAKER_00: I I wouldn't dare.
[17:58] SPEAKER_04: He called you old earlier, you sure?
[18:00] SPEAKER_04: You don't want to disagree later?
[18:02] SPEAKER_04: No?
[18:02] SPEAKER_04: Okay.
[18:03] SPEAKER_04: Alright.
[18:05] SPEAKER_04: Oh.
[18:07] SPEAKER_04: I'm just gonna read all 32.3.
[18:09] SPEAKER_04: So, Fred, here's here's your nap time if you're looking for it.
[18:12] SPEAKER_04: It is appropriate that with each citation the moderator or clerk call the attention of the parties to the rules of discipline, and assist the parties to obtain access to them.
[18:21] SPEAKER_04: When a charge is laid before the session or presbytery, it shall be reduced to writing, and nothing shall be done at the first meeting of court, unless by consent of parties, except one, to appoint a prosecutor, two, to order the indictment drawn and a copy along with the names of witnesses then known to support it, served on the accused, and three, to cite the accused to appear and be heard at another meeting which shall not be sooner than ten days after such citation.
[18:45] SPEAKER_04: At the second meeting of the court, the charges shall be read to the accused, if present, and he shall be called upon to say whether he be guilty or not.
[18:53] SPEAKER_04: If the accused confesses, the court may deal with him according to its discretion.
[18:57] SPEAKER_04: If he plead and take issue, the trial shall be scheduled and all parties and their witnesses cited to appear.
[19:02] SPEAKER_04: The trial shall not be sooner than fourteen days after such citation.
[19:05] SPEAKER_04: Accused parties may plead in writing when they cannot be personally present.
[19:09] SPEAKER_04: Parties necessarily absent should have counsel assigned to them.
[19:13] SPEAKER_04: Just right off the bat, uh, I'm just going to remind our listeners real quick that um to go back and listen to T.
[19:18] SPEAKER_04: David Gordon talk about the checklist that he made.
[19:20] SPEAKER_04: The checklist is helpful, all this stuff is in there, and it'll it'll kind of put it in a grid format for you to track through, and you can see the ifs-thens and you know where you go after each subsequent action.
[19:31] SPEAKER_04: So if if you need to put this in your mind in an easier way than writing, that's a good place to go.
[19:36] SPEAKER_04: 32-3.
[19:37] SPEAKER_04: Uh there's a lot here.
[19:41] SPEAKER_04: I keep saying that.
[19:42] SPEAKER_04: I realize compared to civil law, maybe there's not, but um we need to encourage people to look at the rules of discipline and we need to assist them.
[19:53] SPEAKER_04: Let's start there.
[19:55] SPEAKER_04: Not everything, yeah.
[19:57] SPEAKER_01: Not everything happens on the same day at the same time.
[20:00] SPEAKER_01: The timetables are spread out, and I think that perhaps helps courts and even the people being accused better prepare.
[20:08] SPEAKER_01: And so you're not um at the same meeting indicting someone, appointing a prosecutor, having them render their own um guilty plea or non-guilty plea, and then taking them to trial.
[20:20] SPEAKER_01: No, you have you have a timeline, a timeline that is set according to the discretion of the court, but has to be at least around 14 days apart for each meeting as you cite people.
[20:31] SPEAKER_01: And so the preparation as we think through this passage or this passage of the BCO is that uh things are spread out across at least three meetings, and maybe even more if the court wants to take time to render their verdict and take time to consider their verdict, they might even send that out by mail.
[20:50] SPEAKER_01: And so there's there's a timeline that is perhaps longer than shorter.
[20:58] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I find it interesting that it says it gives particular direction to either the moderator or the clerk to assist the parties.
[21:07] SPEAKER_00: I mean, they need to know what the BCO is, what their rights are, and so this can't be an ambush on somebody.
[21:14] SPEAKER_00: This has to be something where they know their rights, they know the process, and they're led through it.
[21:18] SPEAKER_00: So many people have no idea that churches even do trials.
[21:23] SPEAKER_00: So there's there may be a lot of explanation that has to go into it.
[21:26] SPEAKER_00: And so this this is part of the gentleness in explaining how what the process is like to people, and so that's uh I think it's a really important provision.
[21:33] SPEAKER_00: Uh you can't have somebody come in and be blindsided.
[21:38] SPEAKER_03: I think it's appropriate here, you know, there is a level of detail, but where where it's not exhaustive detail, another high level thing for courts to remember is that is as much as possible, I advise courts to get agreement of the parties on any of the particulars.
[21:57] SPEAKER_03: Because what that means is you close off.
[22:00] SPEAKER_03: Avenues of disagreement and potential appeal.
[22:02] SPEAKER_03: I'll just give you one example from the text here.
[22:05] SPEAKER_03: It says that the indictment is to be drawn up and quote served on the accused.
[22:11] SPEAKER_03: What does that mean?
[22:12] SPEAKER_03: Does that mean personally?
[22:14] SPEAKER_03: Does that mean email?
[22:16] SPEAKER_03: Does that mean certified mail?
[22:17] SPEAKER_03: Does that mean FedEx?
[22:19] SPEAKER_03: What does it mean?
[22:21] SPEAKER_03: What I would advise a court to do is to deliver it in such a way that they have evidence of receipt.
[22:27] SPEAKER_03: That could be email with a return, email, I got it.
[22:30] SPEAKER_03: That could be one of the members of the court handing it to the man and being able to, you know, say we gave it to him.
[22:37] SPEAKER_03: That, you know, could be any number of things.
[22:39] SPEAKER_03: But you want to make an agreement where there's potential differing interpretation.
[22:45] SPEAKER_03: You want that both parties to be able to say, yes, this is what we mean by this, and this is what we get.
[22:53] SPEAKER_03: And so I think you know that is that that's very important.
[22:57] SPEAKER_03: Now, the other thing that's in here that can sometimes be um confusing is appointing a prosecutor.
[23:05] SPEAKER_03: Who's the prosecutor?
[23:06] SPEAKER_03: You remember that I said if someone brings charges under 32.2, that the court should adjudicate it.
[23:13] SPEAKER_03: And one of my other principles is if someone brings charges, they should be coming forward as a voluntary prosecutor.
[23:22] SPEAKER_03: Now, the court could still appoint someone else, but if someone wants those charges brought, they are in a sense volunteering to prosecute by saying, We think, I think this person is guilty.
[23:37] SPEAKER_03: And so that should be the first place.
[23:39] SPEAKER_03: Uh and that's especially true because if you have smaller sessions, you might not have enough judges to sit in the case.
[23:48] SPEAKER_03: If you have a session of three or four, and one of the elders needs to be a prosecutor, and maybe one of the elders is a witness, you know, you start running out of guys to sit as judges.
[24:00] SPEAKER_03: And you don't want to have that problem.
[24:02] SPEAKER_03: Not every you know, court has a choice of 20 elders to pick from.
[24:07] SPEAKER_03: So I think that's important as we think through who the prosecutor is.
[24:14] SPEAKER_03: And as Scott said, there are multiple meetings here in view.
[24:19] SPEAKER_03: Uh one is just to do the basics, appoint a prosecutor, draw up the indictment, and you know, cite the accused.
[24:27] SPEAKER_03: Um, and the the accused doesn't even have to plead, guilty or not guilty.
[24:32] SPEAKER_03: Now, here's another thing as a word of warning.
[24:36] SPEAKER_03: Courts tend to try to speed things up, contrary to the book.
[24:42] SPEAKER_03: So they'll have that first meeting, and a man will show up at the meeting and say, this is ridiculous, this is a travesty, I don't even know why you guys are giving me this indictment.
[24:53] SPEAKER_03: And someone on the court will make a motion.
[24:55] SPEAKER_03: I think that's a plea of not guilty.
[24:57] SPEAKER_03: Let's just speed right ahead.
[25:00] SPEAKER_03: Well, whenever you do that, elders, you need to have something in the back of your mind.
[25:07] SPEAKER_03: It's a clock.
[25:09] SPEAKER_03: I've just given myself three to six months extra worth of work.
[25:14] SPEAKER_03: Anytime you try to move quickly beyond what the book allows you to, you open up the possibility of complete uh complaint or appeal, and that necessarily requires much more time than even actual formal discipline process has.
[25:32] SPEAKER_03: So follow the book, follow it to the letter.
[25:36] SPEAKER_03: If you're not sure what the letter says, get help, get assistance, call the state clerk's office, call someone in your presbytery or a friend that knows the book, and get them to advise you because not following the book closely in an instance like this really sets you up for a mess and a big delay.
[25:59] SPEAKER_04: Fred, I've asked you this off the air before for a matter we had in our church.
[26:04] SPEAKER_04: Uh a session has decided to move ahead with process and they need a prosecutor, and somebody on the session, you know, the moderator says, anybody willing to prosecute, a ruling elder raises his hand, I'll prosecute.
[26:17] SPEAKER_04: How is that not a voluntary prosecutor?
[26:20] SPEAKER_03: So that's that's not voluntary in the sense that it's someone coming to the court to prosecute.
[26:28] SPEAKER_03: Um that's the court actually voting and appointing one of their own to do that.
[26:34] SPEAKER_04: So that wouldn't fall under the 31-9 issue of voluntary prosecutors being liable if they fail.
[26:40] SPEAKER_03: That's exactly right.
[26:41] SPEAKER_03: Because they're they're just fulfilling that role because someone needs to do it.
[26:49] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, in that sense, the um the court is handing off the tr the what has been given to them to one of their own to oversee.
[26:59] SPEAKER_01: And so the indictment actually does not belong to the court.
[27:02] SPEAKER_01: They are handing that over to the person that will prosecute, and they themselves draft it for then the judges to receive.
[27:10] SPEAKER_01: So the judges aren't the ones actually writing the indictment.
[27:13] SPEAKER_01: Um, it's the one among them that they have set aside to do that.
[27:18] SPEAKER_03: That is correct.
[27:19] SPEAKER_03: And the prosecutor would also give the names of the witnesses, which you see here, which is just names.
[27:24] SPEAKER_03: You don't need to give a paragraph about their background and their bio and what they're going to say and whatever.
[27:30] SPEAKER_03: The reason that's listed, I believe, is that the accused can also call his witnesses.
[27:36] SPEAKER_03: And he needs to know if I want to call Bob Smith, is the prosecution going to call them?
[27:44] SPEAKER_03: Because if he's not on their list, then I have to call him.
[27:46] SPEAKER_03: And that means I need to have the court send out a citation and to do this so that I make sure that Bob Smith is present and able to do that.
[27:56] SPEAKER_03: Now, let me say one other thing here.
[27:57] SPEAKER_03: This applies to 32-2 and 32-3.
[28:01] SPEAKER_03: This is the way that a court needs to handle matters of formal discipline.
[28:08] SPEAKER_03: I have had multiple occasions where I've had a conversation with someone that goes something like this.
[28:17] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, we have a member of our church, and you know, it's come to us that they're guilty of this sin.
[28:25] SPEAKER_03: Um we found out that they're living with uh he's living with a woman whom he's not married to.
[28:31] SPEAKER_03: And so, you know, we sent him a letter telling him he was barred from the Lord's table.
[28:38] SPEAKER_03: And that causes me to just have a conniption.
[28:40] SPEAKER_03: And I'm like, well, wait a minute, wait a minute, wait, wait a minute here.
[28:43] SPEAKER_03: Has he come forward as his own accuser?
[28:45] SPEAKER_03: No.
[28:46] SPEAKER_03: Has there been a report that you have set an investigation on?
[28:50] SPEAKER_03: No.
[28:51] SPEAKER_03: Have you had a trial and a conviction?
[28:53] SPEAKER_03: No.
[28:54] SPEAKER_03: Well, then you can't censure him.
[28:56] SPEAKER_03: You need to go through the process.
[28:58] SPEAKER_03: It may very well be an open and shut case.
[29:01] SPEAKER_03: The trial may be quick.
[29:02] SPEAKER_03: It may be, you know, easy to prove, but you can't just jump the process.
[29:08] SPEAKER_03: You know, and this is important because, again, sometimes we're trying to do things quickly and for the honor of religion and etc.
[29:15] SPEAKER_03: But part of the honor of religion is respecting the rights of other Christians, professing Christians.
[29:23] SPEAKER_03: And so we need to keep that in mind.
[29:27] SPEAKER_04: Does a court have to vote to approve the uh indictment?
[29:33] SPEAKER_04: So the the I just that's simple, I think.
[29:36] SPEAKER_03: I don't believe so.
[29:37] SPEAKER_03: I believe the indictment is the purview of the prosecutor.
[29:41] SPEAKER_03: And I was actually a party, uh I was a judge in the SJC's only uh disciplinary trial ever.
[29:51] SPEAKER_03: Uh, and it was a very lengthy trial, it was very formal.
[29:54] SPEAKER_03: And in that instance, the prosecutor actually edited the indictment during the trial based on witnesses' unavailability at certain times and et cetera.
[30:07] SPEAKER_03: So I think it's it's really up to the prosecutor, because the prosecutor's the one who's got to prove this.
[30:13] SPEAKER_03: So the court can't say, if you bring a ninth commandment violation, the court can't say, well, we really want you to bring a seventh commandment violation too.
[30:20] SPEAKER_03: Prosecutor's like, I don't have witnesses for that.
[30:23] SPEAKER_03: I don't have evidence for that.
[30:24] SPEAKER_03: You may think that, but I can't prove that in court.
[30:27] SPEAKER_03: So I'm not gonna bring that.
[30:29] SPEAKER_04: So once this once this prosecutor's appointed and he's ordered to draw the indictment and serve it, it's it's in motion after that first meeting.
[30:39] SPEAKER_03: That's correct.
[30:40] SPEAKER_03: The only the only guideline I would give to that is if someone is bringing a charge, the prosecutor needs to incorporate that charge into their indictment.
[30:52] SPEAKER_03: So if if someone charges um a fellow uh uh member of the church with theft, I don't think that the prosecutor can say, we're gonna put you on trial for violations of the third commandment and not theft.
[31:12] SPEAKER_04: Anything else here, guys?
[31:13] SPEAKER_04: I don't, I'm I'm trying not to move too fast, but.
[31:16] SPEAKER_01: No, I'm enjoying this.
[31:16] SPEAKER_01: I'm learning.
[31:20] SPEAKER_01: We're almost through the chapter.
[31:23] SPEAKER_04: Jared's actually listening to an episode today.
[31:26] SPEAKER_04: Uh live episode.
[31:28] SPEAKER_04: I I just I believe, I am convinced, I know, that Jared listens to our episodes every week to make sure that Scott and I don't sound like idiots.
[31:37] SPEAKER_04: So okay, let's keep going.
[31:40] SPEAKER_04: We're on another page, 32-4.
[31:43] SPEAKER_04: The citation shall be issued and signed by the moderator or clerk by order and in the name of the court.
[31:47] SPEAKER_04: He shall also issue citations to such witnesses as either party shall nominate to appear on his behalf.
[31:53] SPEAKER_04: Indictments and citations shall be delivered in person or in another manner, providing verification of the date of receipt.
[31:59] SPEAKER_04: Compliance with these requirements shall be deemed to have been fulfilled if a party cannot be located after diligent inquiry or if a party refuses to accept delivery.
[32:06] SPEAKER_04: So some of this Fred's already alluded to.
[32:08] SPEAKER_04: You got to make sure it gets there.
[32:10] SPEAKER_04: You need to have verification of reception.
[32:13] SPEAKER_04: Is there anything else in here we need to stop and discuss?
[32:19] SPEAKER_01: During this whole process, you'll be using certified mail quite a bit.
[32:23] SPEAKER_01: And so you might just want to get a like a little packet of certified mail things and keep them in your office.
[32:30] SPEAKER_01: Because you'll be sending them to witnesses, you'll be sending them to the accused, just keep a whole stack at your office.
[32:36] SPEAKER_03: Now, I Ben, I got to jump in here because I'm I'm severely disappointed.
[32:41] SPEAKER_03: I really expected Scott as a Dutchman to give the frugal option.
[32:47] SPEAKER_03: I really expected to.
[32:49] SPEAKER_03: Because I think you can deliver something where there's verification of delivery, either using, you know, the Postal Service or UPS or FedEx, where you have a verification of delivery.
[33:04] SPEAKER_03: I don't think you need to have a signed certified mail.
[33:08] SPEAKER_03: Now you can.
[33:09] SPEAKER_03: If Scott wants to be, you know, generous and you know spend the big bucks, he can.
[33:15] SPEAKER_03: Um but I I I don't think that's required.
[33:19] SPEAKER_03: And and and there's a reason why I say that.
[33:23] SPEAKER_03: It says verification of the date of receipt.
[33:26] SPEAKER_03: So, you know, you could send something certified mail, and the person could refuse to sign for it.
[33:34] SPEAKER_03: I don't think they have to sign for it to have verification of receipt.
[33:37] SPEAKER_03: It's it's been given there.
[33:39] SPEAKER_03: I think it's the same with you know a FedEx tracking number or um a priority mail tracking number.
[33:45] SPEAKER_03: That's delivery.
[33:47] SPEAKER_03: Um and I would also go further and say, whether it's certified or otherwise, keep copies of all of that in case it's needed for future litigation.
[33:58] SPEAKER_03: Because what you don't want to do is you've got your handy-dandy certified mail and you have the trial and you throw it away, and then there's an appeal, and one of the grounds of the appeal was you never issued me a citation, and you don't have you know the receipt evidence that it was actually done.
[34:14] SPEAKER_04: 325.
[34:16] SPEAKER_04: In drawing the indictment, the times, places, and circumstances should, if possible, be particularly stated that the accused may have an opportunity to make his defense.
[34:28] SPEAKER_04: This is a very important sentence in our Book of Church Order.
[34:32] SPEAKER_04: You you can't indict someone for a violation of a commandment without specifying how they have violated that commandment.
[34:43] SPEAKER_03: Yes.
[34:44] SPEAKER_03: That's what we call charges and specifications.
[34:48] SPEAKER_03: And so usually the charge is something like a violation of one of the ten commandments andor violations of the commandments as interpreted as interpreted through the um catechisms.
[35:04] SPEAKER_03: But then you need specifications.
[35:06] SPEAKER_03: You can't just say he's a liar.
[35:10] SPEAKER_03: You have to say he said this to someone else on that date.
[35:15] SPEAKER_03: He wrote this to these people on that date.
[35:18] SPEAKER_03: Because otherwise, you know, there's no way to defend yourself.
[35:22] SPEAKER_03: You know, you can't prove a negative, right?
[35:25] SPEAKER_03: You can't say, well, I've always told the truth my whole life and I've never lied ever.
[35:29] SPEAKER_03: That's not possible.
[35:31] SPEAKER_03: And so there needs to be specifications so that the defense can be can be brought to bear on those specific instances.
[35:40] SPEAKER_01: And so perhaps can you distinguish between a charge and a specification for a charge?
[35:45] SPEAKER_03: So again, a charge is something more general, like uh, you know, a violation of the eighth commandment um and um you know accompanying catechism interpretations.
[35:58] SPEAKER_03: And then uh the specification would be on this date, the accused did this.
[36:05] SPEAKER_03: And and it's it's it's just what it sounds like.
[36:08] SPEAKER_03: It's a specification, it's an instance that describes that sin.
[36:12] SPEAKER_01: Okay.
[36:14] SPEAKER_01: I think that might be helpful for people who've never engaged in church uh trials where they're like, I gotta include charges, specifications.
[36:22] SPEAKER_01: I don't even know what a specification is.
[36:25] SPEAKER_01: But I gotta include them.
[36:26] SPEAKER_03: And and remember, this doesn't mean that you need to write, you know, a 40-page indictment.
[36:31] SPEAKER_03: And it doesn't mean that you need to include every possible instance that you could think of it.
[36:38] SPEAKER_03: So again, let's just stay with our example.
[36:40] SPEAKER_03: Let's say that someone is a habitual liar.
[36:43] SPEAKER_03: Okay, you don't need to charge them with a violation of the ninth commandment with 40 specifications.
[36:51] SPEAKER_03: You could come up with four, or however many you think are significant enough to make the case.
[36:59] SPEAKER_03: Um and you don't need to, in that indictment, have the man be found guilty of every specification.
[37:09] SPEAKER_03: Now, that might affect the censure.
[37:12] SPEAKER_03: So again, using our lying, if someone drove drew up an indictment with you know 20 specifications of lying, and the prosecutor was only able to prove one, well, that might lessen the censure that the court would have than if the prosecutor was able to prove 19.
[37:29] SPEAKER_03: But, you know, this is again, these are this are yet another example of it's flexible, it's not laid out, there's no, you know, magic language, magic number, certain specificity you have to have.
[37:43] SPEAKER_04: Okay.
[37:43] SPEAKER_04: Getting into 32.6, remembering that we've sent citations for the accused to appear.
[37:52] SPEAKER_04: 326.
[37:54] SPEAKER_04: When an accused person shall refuse to obey a citation, he shall be cited a second time.
[38:00] SPEAKER_04: This second citation shall be accompanied with a notice that if he does not appear at the time appointed, unless providentially hindered, which fact he must make known to the court, he shall be dealt with for his contumacy.
[38:12] SPEAKER_04: When an accused person shall appear and refuse to plead, or otherwise refuse to cooperate with lawful proceedings, he shall be dealt with for his contumacy.
[38:23] SPEAKER_04: Contumacy, contumacy, do we have is there a preferred uh pronounce among the brothers?
[38:30] SPEAKER_04: Your contumacious or your contumacy, I don't know.
[38:35] SPEAKER_01: Stop making this an Augusta-Augustine thing.
[38:38] SPEAKER_04: Who's that?
[38:41] SPEAKER_01: Uh I I do have a question on contumacy.
[38:44] SPEAKER_01: Uh when is it appropriate and not appropriate to to declare contumacy?
[38:53] SPEAKER_03: Well, I think so.
[38:55] SPEAKER_03: If if the person hasn't um um appeared and the time has run, I think you can do that.
[39:04] SPEAKER_03: Um but there's an interesting provision here in 326B.
[39:09] SPEAKER_03: Um refused to cooperate with lawful proceedings.
[39:13] SPEAKER_03: And I wasn't really even aware of that um until we had a recent case that the SJC uh just decided.
[39:21] SPEAKER_03: Um, you know, this is one of the instances, guys, where uh, you know, I know a lot about the book, you know, not because I'm particularly smart, but because I've had experience with a lot more uh church litigation than the average elder.
[39:35] SPEAKER_03: And so if someone um appears but doesn't plead, you can declare them consumacious.
[39:45] SPEAKER_03: We normally associate consumacy with, you know, ignoring the court, not showing up, not responding, being in the wind.
[39:52] SPEAKER_03: But someone could show up and just say, you know, I'm not gonna plead.
[39:56] SPEAKER_03: He could do like you see sometimes on social media when the policeman pulls someone over in the car and he says, I don't recognize the authority of the United States of America, you can't stop me, you can't give me a ticket.
[40:06] SPEAKER_03: And it's kind of like, yeah, that and three bucks will get you a Starbucks.
[40:10] SPEAKER_03: Um, you know, or someone could plead, but they could be so disruptive to the process that the court could say, You're not cooperating with the lawful proceedings.
[40:23] SPEAKER_03: You know, an example might be the prosecutor's trying to examine a witness and the accused keeps standing up and screaming and yelling, you're a liar, that's not true, shut up, you know.
[40:32] SPEAKER_03: And they the court can't go through its process.
[40:34] SPEAKER_03: The court could warn that accused.
[40:37] SPEAKER_03: Now, again, there's no, it doesn't say in the book, one warning, two warnings, you know, it doesn't give you any details.
[40:44] SPEAKER_03: And so if the court does this, it has to realize that it it could be the subject of a complaint or of an appeal.
[40:53] SPEAKER_03: And so they want to do it, you know, with wisdom and not on a thin read.
[41:00] SPEAKER_03: But that's another way in which, you know, I didn't even realize until recently that if someone is in the process but they just don't cooperate while the process is going on, the court can declare them consumacious.
[41:14] SPEAKER_04: Can we talk for a minute about what contumacy is?
[41:20] SPEAKER_04: Just I think this is the first time we've really come across it in our reading so far, and it'll show up again in 33 and 34.
[41:26] SPEAKER_04: But um Jared, I don't know.
[41:28] SPEAKER_04: You haven't you've been kind of quiet.
[41:29] SPEAKER_04: Is that something I can pitch to you?
[41:30] SPEAKER_04: Are you you good to help us understand that?
[41:34] SPEAKER_00: Well, I think context can give you some of the definition there, just a stubborn refusal, um, a not um participating in in the authority.
[41:43] SPEAKER_00: We we find this with uh those that will refuse our invitations to come back to worship to fulfill their vows as members.
[41:51] SPEAKER_00: Um that's that's a word that's used for uh the person that just will not come back to worship.
[41:56] SPEAKER_00: Um so this is dealing with somebody that is stubbornly refusing to um participate in the process uh to such a degree that they're really they're really bucking it.
[42:05] SPEAKER_04: Yeah.
[42:07] SPEAKER_04: And I Fred, when it says deal with them for their contumacy, what what is it mean?
[42:14] SPEAKER_04: How do you deal with somebody according to that?
[42:16] SPEAKER_04: What does that mean to deal with them that way?
[42:18] SPEAKER_04: You're you're jettisoning dealing with them in one way and picking up this new way.
[42:24] SPEAKER_03: Right.
[42:24] SPEAKER_03: What what what that is is that is engaging in discipline um as a result of their consumacy rather than the um the underlying offense.
[42:40] SPEAKER_03: So I assume uh, you know, in your in your next uh episode uh under 33, you'll see when an accused person is found consumacious, this is what happens.
[42:52] SPEAKER_03: So 33 um deals with consumacy before sessions, and and then 34 deals with consumacy before uh presbyteries, you know, against um ministers.
[43:08] SPEAKER_03: And what that means is this is probably worth saying here, the PCA has no provision for being tried in absentia.
[43:17] SPEAKER_03: So if someone either doesn't show up for a trial or doesn't cooperate with with a trial, you cannot find them guilty of the underlying offense.
[43:29] SPEAKER_03: You can only find them guilty of consumacy.
[43:32] SPEAKER_03: Now you can censure them, and then if they come back and repent of their consumacy, you can remove the censure for consumacy, and then you have to proceed back to the underlying offense and have that dealt with.
[43:49] SPEAKER_03: However, the man could be repentant about that, or you could go back to the indictment, etc.
[43:54] SPEAKER_03: But the idea is you know, this is a United States kind of rule of law.
[44:00] SPEAKER_03: It's not true in Europe.
[44:02] SPEAKER_03: In Europe, if uh the state comes after you with a with an indictment of murder and you flee the jurisdiction in France, for example, they can hold a trial even though you're not there.
[44:13] SPEAKER_03: And they can find you guilty.
[44:16] SPEAKER_03: That doesn't happen in the United States.
[44:18] SPEAKER_03: And it doesn't happen in our ecclesiastical courts either.
[44:21] SPEAKER_03: However, we have a provision in our courts that the civil magistrate doesn't have.
[44:27] SPEAKER_03: We can find you guilty of consumacy because there is an underlying membership vow that says I will submit to the government and discipline of the church.
[44:38] SPEAKER_03: And when I do not submit to discipline in trials, I have broken that vow.
[44:44] SPEAKER_03: And therefore I can be disciplined, censured for that.
[44:49] SPEAKER_04: So to keep using your same illustration of the habitual liar, he's uh let's let's use thirty two six B.
[44:58] SPEAKER_04: So he's he's coming, he's refusing to plead and cooperate.
[45:02] SPEAKER_04: Dealing with him according to his contumacy is not finding him guilty of the charges that he's been brought up on.
[45:08] SPEAKER_04: It's it's shifting to a whole new m uh you're finding him guilty, you're declaring him guilty, really, of willful unrepentance or stubbornness to submit to the courts that he's promised previously to submit to.
[45:20] SPEAKER_04: Yeah.
[45:21] SPEAKER_03: So so, in other words, to give a paint by the numbers to a session, if that's the case, someone in the session should make a motion that John Doe be found consumacious.
[45:30] SPEAKER_03: The session should take a vote on that, it should minute that, and then as a result, someone should make a motion that as a result he should be censured by being suspended from the sacraments.
[45:44] SPEAKER_03: And and then that again would have to pass and be minuted.
[45:47] SPEAKER_03: And so, you know, you need to deal with it, you you actually move away from the process.
[45:53] SPEAKER_03: You put the process on hold, and you go just to dealing with him for not cooperating.
[46:01] SPEAKER_04: We're gonna get Fred already said we'll get into that more when we get into 33, and maybe maybe not as much since we've dealt with it here, but it was just we have to handle those phrases here in order to get a sense.
[46:13] SPEAKER_01: And this is just in the confines of ecclesiastical process.
[46:17] SPEAKER_01: This is not something you do outside of that.
[46:20] SPEAKER_01: This is a response in the midst of process, uh, not something that happens outside of that.
[46:27] SPEAKER_01: Um, so I have a somewhat subtle question on that, uh, and it gets back to a thought that I'm constantly recurring in my mind is when does process end?
[46:38] SPEAKER_01: Does contumacy come into play for those who are under censure in the church as well?
[46:44] SPEAKER_01: Or is it just within the trial itself?
[46:46] SPEAKER_01: Can you be contumacious for not um for not repenting of your sins that you were found guilty of, and so you were suspended from office and sacraments, and so you've failed to repent of that or given satisfactory repentance?
[47:00] SPEAKER_01: Can the court then say, well, you're being contumacious for not repenting according to our rule, or how does that work?
[47:08] SPEAKER_03: Yes, you can, and the court does that in order to what we call elevate a censure.
[47:15] SPEAKER_03: So if a man is suspended from the sacraments, but it's clear he's not repentant, that censure can be elevated to excommunication.
[47:24] SPEAKER_03: Now, again, this is an instance where the book is not clear as to exactly what is required.
[47:30] SPEAKER_03: So here's your spoiler alert.
[47:33] SPEAKER_03: I am in the midst of drafting an overture to amend the book to make that specific and clear.
[47:40] SPEAKER_03: The latest ruling on that is an SJC case that comes out of a certain Spreadberg's presbytery in which I drafted the decision that I was shaking my head.
[47:52] SPEAKER_01: No, don't do that.
[47:55] SPEAKER_03: Um so um uh, you know, it because it's unclear.
[48:00] SPEAKER_03: There was ecclesiastical litigation because it's unclear.
[48:04] SPEAKER_03: And so the SJC made a decision, but I think it needs to be clear.
[48:08] SPEAKER_03: So I'm going to be drafting uh hopefully for this assembly an overture to make clear what happens with that.
[48:15] SPEAKER_03: Now I will say something else that I think Scott pointed out.
[48:18] SPEAKER_03: Consumacy is something within the confines of process.
[48:22] SPEAKER_03: A session can't just say, you know, member, you're emailing people all the time about how bad the pastor is.
[48:31] SPEAKER_03: We find you consumacious, you need to stop it.
[48:35] SPEAKER_03: You can't do that.
[48:37] SPEAKER_03: You have to charge them and cite them and indict them and have a trial and find them guilty.
[48:44] SPEAKER_03: That's what you have to be doing.
[48:46] SPEAKER_03: Um, and so um, you know, you it has to happen within the context of um process.
[48:58] SPEAKER_04: Well, listener, the podcast isn't over, but we do need to take a break until next week when we'll jump into BCO327 and work through the end of the chapter.
[49:06] SPEAKER_04: Be sure to subscribe in your podcast player so that you don't miss an episode.
[49:10] SPEAKER_04: And there's also a link down below where you can support us and help the show keep moving along from week to week.
[49:16] SPEAKER_04: Our huge thanks to Fred Greco for joining us again.
[49:19] SPEAKER_04: Until next time, y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
