# 93. BCO Amendments Are Coming!

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 22 Jul 2025, 52 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/17541953-93-bco-amendments-are-coming.mp3

Scott leads us through the BCO amendments sent down from this years General Assembly. https://pcapolity.com/2025/07/22/thirteen-proposed-amendments-in-2025/ Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Transcript

[0:00] SPEAKER_00: Do we want to talk about um overture nine and twelve at all?
[0:04] SPEAKER_02: Are they in your document?
[0:06] SPEAKER_02: No.
[0:07] SPEAKER_02: The no?
[0:08] SPEAKER_00: Well, those are the failed amendments.
[0:11] SPEAKER_00: There's some they were the ones with minorities.
[0:14] SPEAKER_01: These are the ones you won't be voting on.
[0:16] SPEAKER_00: These are the ones you won't be voting on.
[0:18] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, let's just keep it to this.
[0:20] SPEAKER_00: Alright.
[0:21] SPEAKER_02: Here I hit record, so I should probably.
[0:29] SPEAKER_02: Hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:31] SPEAKER_02: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg.
[0:35] SPEAKER_02: And we are eager to get into our content today.
[0:38] SPEAKER_02: But first we have a little bit of housekeeping to take care of.
[0:41] SPEAKER_02: You know, we're still kind of riding the coattails of General Assembly.
[0:44] SPEAKER_02: We can see it off in the distance as it runs away, but we're still talking about it a little.
[0:49] SPEAKER_02: We are still very excited about the new BCO commentary that Peralmquist has published.
[0:55] SPEAKER_02: Uh and we have a signed copy that we want to give away to one of you dear listeners.
[1:00] SPEAKER_02: So please make sure that if you'd like to uh enter to win a copy uh of this commentary, reach out through email or text message and let us know particularly how Polity Matters has benefited you over the years since you've been listening.
[1:16] SPEAKER_02: Uh we'll choose from the entries that send in uh that content, and we'll select a winner in the early parts of August, assuming that we get some entries, because we've we've said this once publicly and have gotten one entry.
[1:27] SPEAKER_02: Uh so let us know.
[1:29] SPEAKER_02: You can send us emails at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[1:33] SPEAKER_02: If you know us, most of you guys know us somehow.
[1:35] SPEAKER_02: You can send us a personal text message or email or get in touch with us somehow and uh give us that information and we will put you in the running for this copy of Pear's new commentary.
[1:47] SPEAKER_02: Uh we are talking about BCO amendments that are headed to the Presbyteries this year.
[1:53] SPEAKER_02: Uh there are 13 of them that were approved by uh the General Assembly just a month ago, and we're going to talk about them.
[2:02] SPEAKER_02: And Scott is really going to kind of be the one to head this up because he served on overtures this year.
[2:06] SPEAKER_02: So he was there for some of the more detailed conversations and can offer some insight that uh Jared and I were not privy to, or at least not 100% of it.
[2:14] SPEAKER_02: I know we were in there for a little while.
[2:16] SPEAKER_02: So um, I mean, Scott, do you have anything you want to say before we kind of work through these individually?
[2:23] SPEAKER_00: Uh yeah, there's perhaps two helps as we begin to work through them.
[2:27] SPEAKER_00: I'm hoping that by the time that uh we publish this episode, there will be a Presbyterian polity article that outlines each of these amendments, and we'll try to include those in the show notes so that you can have the language before you, because I think that's probably more important than just us talking about it is seeing what the amendments actually are.
[2:47] SPEAKER_00: Um it's kind of difficult as you exit the assembly to figure out actually what you just passed.
[2:54] SPEAKER_00: Uh, because some things that you pass, they just go into effect immediately, and other things don't go into effect immediately.
[3:00] SPEAKER_00: There's a larger process, and that process of ratifying amendments takes about two years, uh, or the better part of a whole entire year, uh, where one assembly approves it, then the presbyteries offer their advice and consent, and that has to be done on a two-thirds of our presbytery's basis, and then for its final ratification at the next assembly.
[3:21] SPEAKER_00: And so there are 13 amendments that passed this assembly, and now they all go to the 87 Presbyteries for advice.
[3:31] SPEAKER_00: And if they receive two-thirds support from the Presbyteries, they'll then come back at our next assembly for final ratification.
[3:39] SPEAKER_00: And so today's episode is to perhaps introduce that the amendments, what they hope to achieve, and perhaps help uh commissioners as they prepare to deliberate on them uh in the presbytery in the presbyteries as the months ahead come.
[3:55] SPEAKER_00: And so this is meant to be a preparatory uh episode for those who want to know what we're trying to do in our book.
[4:04] SPEAKER_02: Great.
[4:05] SPEAKER_02: Well, this is good.
[4:06] SPEAKER_02: Um let's uh let's just jump into it.
[4:09] SPEAKER_02: We're gonna hopefully if if the article's out, we're working through in the same order unless you change anything that the article's written, but I think it's just all numerical.
[4:17] SPEAKER_02: Um so first was uh overture six, and I suppose these will be re-renumbered by items, right, as we work our way through the year, won't they, when they come back?
[4:27] SPEAKER_02: So these are not the numbers that we'll see uh eventually, but for now, overture six having to do the BCO 18 uh and candidates coming under care.
[4:34] SPEAKER_02: Uh, I'm just gonna introduce them, Scott, and kick it to you, and then we'll see what we can do.
[4:38] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so overture six and the overtures committee deals with uh uh when a presbytery uh receives uh application from a candidate to come under care.
[4:51] SPEAKER_00: Uh in our book, we had uh previously had it that an applicant must uh file his application one month in advance.
[4:59] SPEAKER_00: We talked about this in our our overtures um perhaps discussion a few months ago.
[5:06] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but the proposal is basically to strike out that one-month meeting and allow Presbyteries to have their own set of rules and discretions for how quick or how slow they accept applications.
[5:20] SPEAKER_00: And so the general idea in the Overtures Committee, as we talked about it, is it necessary for our Constitution to outline in that particular detail the application of candidates, or can we just leave that to standing rules?
[5:35] SPEAKER_00: And I think the Overtures Committee and the Assembly thought at the end of the day, it's something better that is left to the discretion of the Presbytery.
[5:42] SPEAKER_00: It's uh somewhat arbitrary to set a one-month limit uh on candidates for how they can come under care.
[5:49] SPEAKER_00: And so it was a really small amendment.
[5:51] SPEAKER_00: Um, I thought at the time when we were talking about it on the Overtures episode that it's kind of unnecessary.
[5:57] SPEAKER_00: How big how much of a big deal is it to have your paperwork done a month in advance?
[6:02] SPEAKER_00: But I was wrong, apparently, at least when you compare me to the assembly uh itself.
[6:07] SPEAKER_00: Uh I think I've ended up voting for it at the end of the day.
[6:10] SPEAKER_00: It shows that even Presbyterians can change their mind from time to time.
[6:14] SPEAKER_00: Um but it's a pretty modest revision, and it passed with almost uh unanimous uh fervor.
[6:21] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, this was in the in gross or omnibus um package.
[6:26] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[6:28] SPEAKER_01: The big beautiful omnibus.
[6:30] SPEAKER_02: Now what this would, if it passed in the long run, would it would does it require a Presbytery to add something to their rules, or it would just mean that a candidate could submit it at any point and it would have to be received.
[6:45] SPEAKER_02: So the day before or the day of uh a meeting.
[6:48] SPEAKER_00: That'd be up to the it would be up to the complete discretion of the court.
[6:51] SPEAKER_00: I would think if you didn't have a standing rule in place for it, which probably most don't because of this provision.
[6:58] SPEAKER_02: We've had it, yeah.
[6:59] SPEAKER_00: Uh, is that it would just be up to the discretion of the court on that day whether to receive an application at that time.
[7:08] SPEAKER_00: Um applications aren't really heavy typically.
[7:10] SPEAKER_00: I mean, usually you just get a character exam and things of that nature.
[7:14] SPEAKER_00: It's really low maintenance on the burden of the Presbytery.
[7:18] SPEAKER_00: And that's perhaps why it's not that big of a deal to strike this sentence from it.
[7:25] SPEAKER_00: I I tend to think people should just be prepared um and have their file paperwork filed.
[7:31] SPEAKER_00: But I do admit that it is arbitrary, that it must be one month.
[7:34] SPEAKER_00: Why not two weeks?
[7:35] SPEAKER_00: Why not three weeks?
[7:36] SPEAKER_00: You know, it's just an arbitrary timeline.
[7:39] SPEAKER_02: Most of this kind of stuff is going to be coming through a committee of sorts, which is going to have a deadline on their material as it is, and so they'd uh it it'll have something attached to it still.
[7:49] SPEAKER_02: Cool.
[7:50] SPEAKER_02: Uh overture number eight.
[7:53] SPEAKER_02: I've got questions about this after you talk about it a second, uh, with this uh confessional differences for elders and deacons.
[8:01] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so overture eight is an amendment to BCO 241.
[8:06] SPEAKER_00: Uh the first thing it does, which was confusing to the Overtures Committee, is that it restructures the entire section.
[8:13] SPEAKER_00: Um, and it was somewhat difficult to figure out where we were amending when we were amending uh in the committee.
[8:20] SPEAKER_00: Uh but what it seeks to allow or it seeks to enforce is that in addition to teaching elders being examined and having their differences stated, that also ruling elders and deacons would have to have their differences stated and then judged by their court, which would be the session.
[8:41] SPEAKER_00: And so the teaching elder has their differences currently evaluated by the presbytery.
[8:46] SPEAKER_00: Uh, this provision would then apply something similar to that effect to the local church as it relates to the ordination of ruling elders and deacons.
[8:57] SPEAKER_00: And it adds two substantial paragraphs to 24 uh that seeks to outline that and it essentially mirrors what is already done in the uh other parts of the book for the teaching elder.
[9:10] SPEAKER_00: It just now applies it to the other officers.
[9:16] SPEAKER_00: What's your question?
[9:18] SPEAKER_02: What happens to already ordained uh ruling elders and deacons in regards to their confessional differences?
[9:24] SPEAKER_02: If they've let's say you've got some guys that never had to that never stated their differences.
[9:30] SPEAKER_02: Um is it only on the I don't think so new stuff.
[9:37] SPEAKER_00: If you look at the amendments, Ben, if you open your OHOS, they uh it says examining nominees for ordination.
[9:46] SPEAKER_00: And so I would assume that this is not retroactive, it's forward-looking.
[9:53] SPEAKER_00: Um we have a modified rotational system at Providence, and we will probably re-examine these as people get re-nominated and come back on for active duty.
[10:05] SPEAKER_00: But I would think if you're on a perhaps uh permanent session, I don't think this applies because this is examining nominees for ordination, not people that are already in office.
[10:17] SPEAKER_00: That's my read of it.
[10:18] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[10:19] SPEAKER_02: Well, I'm glad to know that Snarky Edberg showed up today.
[10:21] SPEAKER_02: So it's good to know.
[10:22] SPEAKER_02: Uh you just gotta read the language, Ben.
[10:25] SPEAKER_02: Don't ask any questions, man.
[10:27] SPEAKER_02: All right.
[10:28] SPEAKER_02: Jared, would you like to uh in fear and trepidation ask Scott a question about this one, or are you good to go?
[10:35] SPEAKER_02: No.
[10:36] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[10:37] SPEAKER_00: The the Overtures Committee really they uh they spent a decent amount of time on this um this amendment, and I think that the it was uh it was received by a strong vote, but it was not uniform.
[10:56] SPEAKER_00: And I think on the actual floor of the um assembly we saw some of that.
[11:02] SPEAKER_00: I think it was a three to one vote or something similar of that nature.
[11:06] SPEAKER_00: I need the numbers in front of me, I don't have them.
[11:08] SPEAKER_01: Um 74% to 26%?
[11:12] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so there was a decent minority, though there was no minority report.
[11:15] SPEAKER_00: And so I think this would be one to watch because that is a substantial minority.
[11:20] SPEAKER_00: In past years, uh an amendment with that large of a minority would fail the Presbyteries.
[11:26] SPEAKER_00: That's not to say this one will, but just his in my data collection over the past couple of years it's been that way.
[11:37] SPEAKER_02: Very good overture 15.
[11:42] SPEAKER_02: Um having to do with some BCO36.
[11:45] SPEAKER_02: I don't know if you want to take 15 and 16 together.
[11:49] SPEAKER_02: Pretty straightforward.
[11:49] SPEAKER_00: Do you want to take 15 and 16?
[11:52] SPEAKER_02: No, you should make a decision on your own.
[11:55] SPEAKER_00: Alright, 15 and 16.
[11:57] SPEAKER_00: Uh, they're somewhat similar.
[11:58] SPEAKER_00: They're both from, I believe, Mississippi Valley Presbytery originally, um, but they essentially seek to um add language for what the moderator would say with a definite uh uh suspension.
[12:13] SPEAKER_00: We had to distinguish, and I think we have in our episodes prior that a definite of suspension is for a definite period of time.
[12:21] SPEAKER_00: It's typically given to someone who's been found guilty and has like plead pled guilty.
[12:26] SPEAKER_00: And so that it's like you've you are already repentant, but there should be repercussion for your sin.
[12:32] SPEAKER_00: And so you might be given six months suspension for it.
[12:35] SPEAKER_00: Uh indefinite suspension is uh it is indefinite in nature, and it can go on for as long as it needs until the court is satisfied with repentance.
[12:45] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but there is no distinguishing language between definite and indefinite suspension in our book.
[12:50] SPEAKER_00: And so what Overture 15 seeks to do in BCO 36-4 is to now add language for a definite suspension that is unique from indefinite suspension that also includes the dates for that definite suspension.
[13:05] SPEAKER_00: Um so it that that's the main gist of 36.4.
[13:09] SPEAKER_00: And then overture 16 is similar, uh, is uh trying to seek conformity between other sections as it relates to suspension.
[13:18] SPEAKER_00: And overture 16 amends might be the smallest amendment ever made in our book.
[13:23] SPEAKER_00: Uh it adds the word or uh and then deletes a parenthetical and moves it to one other location.
[13:31] SPEAKER_00: It's it's so minuscule, overture 16.
[13:34] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but overture 15 uh was not really debated in our overtures committee.
[13:40] SPEAKER_00: Uh it seemed prudent, uh, and it basically just tries to clear up uh the duration of a uh definite suspension.
[13:48] SPEAKER_00: When does it start?
[13:49] SPEAKER_00: When does it end?
[13:50] SPEAKER_00: It seeks to make that clearer for the for our churches.
[13:54] SPEAKER_01: And this seems rare in overtures committee.
[13:57] SPEAKER_01: It was 100% was a vote for Yay, and then was included in the omnibus.
[14:03] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, it is rare to have a unanimous vote, and uh it was like 119 to zero, which was essentially the entire committee, if you look at the other votes from the from the guys.
[14:16] SPEAKER_00: Same with 16, but uh there's something 16 will pass the Presbyterians by by blink of an eye because of how minuscule it is.
[14:23] SPEAKER_00: Um in this work.
[14:27] SPEAKER_02: How much debate happened about the that moving of a parenthetical and adding of two letters?
[14:34] SPEAKER_00: Uh well, in overture, uh, or was already in the amendment.
[14:39] SPEAKER_00: Uh it was not debated at all.
[14:41] SPEAKER_00: The the debate, oddly enough, it wasn't even a debate.
[14:44] SPEAKER_00: The discussion was should we move the parenthetical from the or to the P, to the Presbytery?
[14:51] SPEAKER_00: Why?
[14:52] SPEAKER_00: Because we just did it in the last amendment.
[14:55] SPEAKER_00: And so shouldn't we have it be there?
[14:57] SPEAKER_00: Shouldn't there be parody?
[14:59] SPEAKER_00: I mean, that's literally the discussion on the Overtures Committee on these amendments was mostly on like, shouldn't the parenthetical be here instead of there?
[15:07] SPEAKER_00: And no one cared enough to actually move like either way.
[15:11] SPEAKER_00: They're just like, whatever, if that guy over there wants the parenthetical moved, we'll move the parenthetical.
[15:17] SPEAKER_02: So good.
[15:17] SPEAKER_02: Man, that's so good.
[15:18] SPEAKER_02: That's true Presbyterianism at work, gentlemen.
[15:23] SPEAKER_02: Um, well, good.
[15:24] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, those those are those will be good to have.
[15:27] SPEAKER_02: Hopefully they'll sail on through.
[15:30] SPEAKER_02: Keep us going.
[15:31] SPEAKER_02: 23.
[15:32] SPEAKER_02: Uh this this one this one I'm curious about, especially the debate in the Overtures Committee given how close the vote from overtures was.
[15:41] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, the overture uh 23 deals with supplemental judges for a sessional trial.
[15:47] SPEAKER_00: Uh, it seeks to amend BCO 413 uh by allowing a session to uh ask the presbytery for uh additional judges uh in the case in a case locally.
[16:02] SPEAKER_00: The the issue that churches sometimes deal with is that they don't have enough people to prosecute a case.
[16:08] SPEAKER_00: Uh we uh at here at Providence, we have four ruling elders and then me.
[16:13] SPEAKER_00: And if some of those ruling elders, one has to be the prosecutor, so he can't testify uh or be a judge, and then you might have some other guys who are witnesses that you don't want to judge, and you can whittle down that to where you don't have uh a court of judges.
[16:30] SPEAKER_00: Um and so Overture 23 seeks to remedy that by allowing a local session to appeal almost like a reference in some regards to the Presbytery uh to ask for additional judges.
[16:44] SPEAKER_00: Uh I don't I I can't really there wasn't a lot of debate or amending to the language here.
[16:50] SPEAKER_00: Um I threw I we may not have amended it at all.
[16:54] SPEAKER_00: I think the issue was an issue of polity.
[16:56] SPEAKER_00: Uh the vote was 64 to 49.
[17:00] SPEAKER_00: I think it may have been one of our closest votes.
[17:02] SPEAKER_00: It was early an early vote uh that we took, and it was probably the closest vote that we had.
[17:07] SPEAKER_00: Uh, and I think it was close because it seemed to perhaps like what do you do with guys that okay, you've you just got all these supplemental judges at the local session, and now the issue gets appealed to the Presbytery that that just supplied the judges for that case?
[17:25] SPEAKER_00: Isn't there like a conflict?
[17:27] SPEAKER_00: Are they allowed to vote?
[17:28] SPEAKER_00: Uh, the amendment didn't really clarify if they were allowed to vote at the regional one now because of their involvement at the sessional one.
[17:35] SPEAKER_00: And I think it's also just an issue of sovereignty as it relates to each of our courts.
[17:43] SPEAKER_00: Uh, does a higher court have jurisdiction to judge in a matter of a lower court without a traditional approach, which would be through like complaint or appeal or through reference?
[17:56] SPEAKER_00: Uh that's how you would or review, those are how you would take these matters on as a higher court.
[18:02] SPEAKER_00: But here it seems that it would the people that would be judging in a local church court would be outside of their jurisdiction in doing so.
[18:12] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so that's why I think this was it was a more of a principled issue uh for the 40.
[18:17] SPEAKER_00: I think I may have been in the minority.
[18:19] SPEAKER_00: It's hard to remember all those votes we took.
[18:21] SPEAKER_00: You know, you're in the overtures committee.
[18:24] SPEAKER_00: I think I've been in the minority.
[18:25] SPEAKER_00: I think one of the interesting things, though, at the assembly is that this was not debated at all.
[18:32] SPEAKER_00: I went back to listen to the um to the debate on it, and there wasn't even a clicker vote.
[18:39] SPEAKER_00: It was just a voice vote, and it was a strong voice vote with no opposition.
[18:44] SPEAKER_00: And so that was curious to me because how close the vote was on the overtures committee, and it was no one even spoke to it on the floor.
[18:51] SPEAKER_00: Uh Kevin DeYoung said, Is there anyone to speak to this?
[18:53] SPEAKER_00: And no one spoke to it.
[18:54] SPEAKER_00: And so we passed it um without any debate, even though it was such a contentious issue uh in the overtures committee.
[19:02] SPEAKER_00: And maybe that's an oversight just because we had so much uh to debate already.
[19:07] SPEAKER_00: Uh but it passed without any opposition.
[19:10] SPEAKER_00: It'll still be something to watch in the presbyteries, I think, given the closed vote on overtures.
[19:16] SPEAKER_01: I think some of the debate was over preliminary principles and do you have people judging that have not been elected at that level?
[19:22] SPEAKER_01: But then I think other people's pointed out uh people pointed out that if you appeal or there's a complaint, the same thing's gonna happen at the presbytery level.
[19:29] SPEAKER_01: So it just kind of brings that uh in earlier.
[19:34] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[19:38] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[19:39] SPEAKER_02: You want qualified people to be involved in those things.
[19:43] SPEAKER_00: It it's interesting over the last couple of years because we're talking about we just passed an amendment that allows sessions to also have representation from the Presbytery.
[19:54] SPEAKER_00: And so there seems to be a movement in the PCA where there's a blurring between the local church and the regional church as it relates to judicial responsibilities.
[20:06] SPEAKER_00: Um I don't know if that's good or bad.
[20:08] SPEAKER_00: Um, I probably my gut would maybe say that's not good.
[20:12] SPEAKER_00: Um but that happened last year.
[20:14] SPEAKER_00: We just so passed an amendment that allows for a congregant to get better representation at the presbytery.
[20:20] SPEAKER_00: Now we're allowing the church basically to get better representation from the presbytery in the judging of your trial as well.
[20:26] SPEAKER_00: You know what I mean?
[20:27] SPEAKER_02: So there's blurry scott.
[20:29] SPEAKER_02: You know what it is, right?
[20:30] SPEAKER_02: You know what would help this.
[20:32] SPEAKER_02: What?
[20:32] SPEAKER_02: Synods would just would just help that whole issue.
[20:36] SPEAKER_02: Just add another layer.
[20:38] SPEAKER_00: And then the presbytery would blur at the bottom once you just blur them all together.
[20:45] SPEAKER_00: Next thing you know, we'll have prosecutors from the Presbytery coming to prosecute cases at local churches.
[20:51] SPEAKER_00: That's that's the next I'm gonna make that amendment.
[20:54] SPEAKER_00: Might as well just complete the circle here.
[20:58] SPEAKER_02: Uh that okay, so so uh what what were we just on?
[21:02] SPEAKER_02: 20 23 was a little contentious at Overtures.
[21:05] SPEAKER_02: 24 seems to be pretty I mean it uh not contentious, but just uh pretty there's a big disparity on 24 at the assembly level.
[21:14] SPEAKER_02: Uh-huh.
[21:15] SPEAKER_02: So it was the overtures kind of sent it with a strong vote of affirmative, and it didn't receive quite that much on the floor.
[21:22] SPEAKER_02: You want to tell us about 24?
[21:24] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, 24 uh is an amendment to 24-1 on the role of uh sessions um examining already ordained officers in character.
[21:37] SPEAKER_00: It's a really simple and modest provision in the length of it.
[21:41] SPEAKER_00: It's just adding like five or six words that basically say that a man should have his uh Christian experience examined at any point, whether he's already ordained or not.
[21:52] SPEAKER_00: I think the purpose of this overture is dealing with, I think, in view of men who either go to a new church or a rotate.
[22:00] SPEAKER_00: Session is probably more in view where you have a man coming back on the session.
[22:04] SPEAKER_00: He's been renominated, and you do some sort of views exam typically when you are in that system.
[22:10] SPEAKER_00: And this is perhaps adding a clarification of the court having the permission to uh evaluate the Christian of experience of an already ordained man that's going back into active service.
[22:23] SPEAKER_00: Uh at the overtures committee, this really wasn't debated at all.
[22:26] SPEAKER_00: And you can kind of see the majority.
[22:28] SPEAKER_00: Uh, I mean, it was like an 85, 90% approval from uh the overtures committee.
[22:35] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but then on the floor of the assembly, uh it was a 935 to 678 vote, and so uh a three to two vote on the issue, which is surprising.
[22:46] SPEAKER_00: And I went back to listen to why there was such a turnaround.
[22:50] SPEAKER_00: At first, I thought there was a confusion between overture 23 and 24, uh, because the the percentages actually match up perfectly, and so I was like, maybe the assembly just didn't realize what it was voting on, and accidentally, you know, there's a minority on it.
[23:05] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but then I went back and listened, and I think the reason for it was actually not that, uh, but David Coffin was the sole person to speak on overture 24, and he said something to the uh akin to this is a trial and judgment without process.
[23:23] SPEAKER_00: It sidesteps and skirts the authority of the uh um of the individual, and therefore you should voted down.
[23:33] SPEAKER_00: He said it's unpresbyterian uh and that it's uh it's basically someone being judged without proper process.
[23:41] SPEAKER_00: And I think that's where the six hundred and seventy-eight people they said, okay, well, if Coffin is that strong against these seven words, then it must be uh troublesome enough to say no to.
[23:53] SPEAKER_00: Still passed.
[23:54] SPEAKER_00: But I think that I mean he's the only person that spoke on Overture 24, and some were convinced by it.
[24:00] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think we need to have a clarification of the difference between what affects your ordination and what affects for this particular spot coming in.
[24:08] SPEAKER_01: This wouldn't unordain a person, it would just say you're not going to serve in this spot because of uh questions of Christian character.
[24:16] SPEAKER_01: So um I think he's saying broadly in principle it almost seems like a trial, but technically it's not.
[24:21] SPEAKER_01: It's just um is your Christian character in a line with this particular position?
[24:28] SPEAKER_02: It it seems to me to be parallel to what you do when um a TE transfers to a new presbytery.
[24:33] SPEAKER_02: Uh I mean, we examine transfers in areas of Christian experience as well as views in uh what theology, sacraments, and uh book of church order.
[24:42] SPEAKER_02: So I mean, unless that is a whole you know re-examination trial, whatever, that this is this is no more than that.
[24:50] SPEAKER_00: Um and a presbytery can say no, we don't want you.
[24:53] SPEAKER_00: And it's not uh Right.
[24:55] SPEAKER_00: It's not like you're not ordained, you know, you're still ordained, you're just you've not been transferred to this presbytery for this reason or that.
[25:02] SPEAKER_03: Yep.
[25:03] SPEAKER_00: We had a we had a deacon at a an inactive deacon at one of my last ministries who and when he was inactive, he just stopped attending churches often.
[25:13] SPEAKER_00: He wasn't there as often.
[25:15] SPEAKER_00: Uh he had some life issues that also came into play, and the broader church didn't know anything of it.
[25:21] SPEAKER_00: Um then he was renominated by you know a good intentioned person within the church, and the session said, I don't think this is a good time for you.
[25:29] SPEAKER_00: And it was according to Christian character.
[25:32] SPEAKER_00: They were they had already been ordained in that church, they've served multiple terms or tours, whatever you want to call them.
[25:38] SPEAKER_00: Um but at that time he just wasn't up to the task because of some things in his life.
[25:43] SPEAKER_00: And so this uh is kind of I think that churches already do this.
[25:48] SPEAKER_00: This would if you have a if you have a rotational session, most certainly you already do this.
[25:53] SPEAKER_00: Um permanent sessions probably don't know what we're talking about.
[25:59] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[26:00] SPEAKER_02: Well, it's funny, I've I've only I've served the two churches I've served most recently had permanent sessions, and so my initial thought on this one is for a guy moving to a new church uh who was a deacon or ruling elder previously and was going which of course is a possible uh scenario here, but well good.
[26:17] SPEAKER_02: Uh let's go into 29.
[26:19] SPEAKER_02: I 29 I don't know why, but just kind of makes me laugh, just because it hasn't been changed yet.
[26:25] SPEAKER_02: You know, like that it still exists, that that that uh BCO fifteen still exists in the way it it is right now is hilarious to me.
[26:35] SPEAKER_02: Uh so why don't you walk us through and and show us why 29 uh hopefully should be kind of an easy pass, I would think.
[26:45] SPEAKER_00: Uh yeah, there was actually a lot of debate and wordsmithing on the Overtures Committee with this one.
[26:50] SPEAKER_00: We we spent some time on it, though the vote doesn't tell you we did, uh, because it was just so almost unanimously passed.
[26:56] SPEAKER_00: But uh this overture does two things.
[26:58] SPEAKER_00: It amends uh 15-5C and the SJC uh for SJC reporting minority decisions.
[27:05] SPEAKER_00: Uh the first thing it does, which is the no-brainer you're talking about, is that prior, if you were in the minority and wanted to file a minority report on the SJC, the State of Clerk's office would have to print out all of the paperwork related to the case and then send it to every single church in the PCA.
[27:26] SPEAKER_00: Uh and and so that is uh it's very expensive.
[27:31] SPEAKER_00: And so what the uh first thing it does is it makes that more digitized, and so that every church should receive a digital copy, kind of like what we do with our commissioner handbooks already.
[27:43] SPEAKER_00: Um, that would be a better way to do it, uh, rather than distributing hard mail.
[27:49] SPEAKER_00: Um, and that's actually there was a case this year that was a split vote, like right down the middle.
[27:54] SPEAKER_00: And there was a desire, I think, by some to file a minority report.
[27:59] SPEAKER_00: But when they saw the costs of what it would cost the assembly to file that minority report, they said, okay, maybe we shouldn't.
[28:06] SPEAKER_00: This will cost us several thousand dollars, you know, tens of thousands of dollars.
[28:10] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so they said, Well, okay, we screwed up this time in that regard.
[28:15] SPEAKER_00: Let's fix the book.
[28:16] SPEAKER_00: Uh, the second thing it does is in the context of what if the assembly rejects both the majority and the minority decision?
[28:25] SPEAKER_00: Uh, what shall it do?
[28:26] SPEAKER_00: Uh, and so it establishes a principle of the moderator electing uh six TEs and six REs uh from the assembly to basically redo the case uh and to for it to be the final uh resolve.
[28:41] SPEAKER_00: It was kind of funny.
[28:43] SPEAKER_00: Uh we had some amendments in the Overtures Committee that got really, really complicated on that last point.
[28:48] SPEAKER_00: And it was like it should be like six TEs, six REs, but we want the SJC to have veto power for up to eight nominees, and I mean it got so randomly complicated, uh, and it just got ultimately thrown out, and we just resolved with this uh amendment here.
[29:08] SPEAKER_00: But at the end of the day, I think everyone was satisfied on the Overtures Committee, and obviously the assembly too.
[29:14] SPEAKER_00: Uh it passed with flying colors, and so it's a good it's a good uh amendment with little controversy.
[29:26] SPEAKER_00: This is the Scott Edberg show here.
[29:29] SPEAKER_02: I'm loving it.
[29:31] SPEAKER_02: I mean, I think the last one that we recorded was only me and Jared at all, so this is like recommended.
[29:40] SPEAKER_02: Some of our listeners may say that we're mad at them, and that's why we're doing this.
[29:43] SPEAKER_02: But you know, I I don't think anybody would mind too much.
[29:48] SPEAKER_02: Okay, uh Overture 30 is long.
[29:51] SPEAKER_02: I mean, I think what is it?
[29:52] SPEAKER_02: I mean, even just in this document that I printed out is five or six pages uh of material.
[29:57] SPEAKER_02: But it's basic it's a lot of duplication, but for a particular purpose.
[30:01] SPEAKER_02: Uh Overture 30 is dealing with several chapters out of the BCO, but it's it's um it's taking up the matter of how do you ordain a guy to a work that's not a local congregation, basically.
[30:13] SPEAKER_02: Uh, we have provisions for that in the book, but it's not consistent across the board, and this is trying to to remedy that.
[30:19] SPEAKER_02: Uh so help us help us understand, Scott, and and uh let us know what overtures thought.
[30:26] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, we um we spent a lot of time on this overture just because of the length um of it.
[30:31] SPEAKER_00: It's hard to uh amend something that I mean it amends play like one, two, three, four, five different parts of our book.
[30:39] SPEAKER_00: Um, and it seeks to a lot of it's minor there, but there is some substantial.
[30:44] SPEAKER_00: Uh, as Ben said, um, the main issue here is what I think the main issue is what do you do with men that are ordained to RUF, they're missionaries, they're chaplains, they're agency coordinators, they're state clerks of denominations.
[31:00] SPEAKER_00: Uh, what does their ordination or installation look like uh in the context of the church?
[31:05] SPEAKER_00: And what are their vows that are they supposed to take?
[31:08] SPEAKER_00: Um, if you look at our current set of vows, I think that's where probably most of this focus is on, is on the vows.
[31:15] SPEAKER_00: Uh, at a local church, the the vows are created to are they're tailor-made for the local church.
[31:23] SPEAKER_00: And so when you take a call outside of the local church, some of the vows just make absolutely no sense.
[31:30] SPEAKER_00: Um when you're talking about preaching um to a particular congregation, maintaining the peace and purity of a particular congregation, um, your responsibilities to individuals in the local congregation, those kind of vows that you take in installation services make no sense for stated clerks of denominations.
[31:51] SPEAKER_00: And so this amendment seeks to perhaps um create vows for those external circumstances that are more tailored to those special sorts of calls.
[32:06] SPEAKER_00: Uh, there was not a lot of pushback on the concept on from the overtures committee at all.
[32:11] SPEAKER_00: It was again just trying to refine the work um to making it uh just basically refining it.
[32:19] SPEAKER_00: And so it took a long time to refine it, though I think everyone kind of mostly agreed that it was a good idea.
[32:25] SPEAKER_00: It was just getting it all on paper.
[32:28] SPEAKER_00: Um Fred Greco is the author of this overture, and he begged the committee not to refer it back to the presbytery because he said there is no other there's nothing else to be added.
[32:42] SPEAKER_00: That everyone is exhausted.
[32:44] SPEAKER_00: There's nothing more to consider here.
[32:46] SPEAKER_00: Um and I'm glad we didn't.
[32:47] SPEAKER_00: Uh this is a good but lengthy um amendment.
[32:53] SPEAKER_00: Though it's large, it does just restate a lot of what's already in the book to apply now to more diverse sets of people.
[33:06] SPEAKER_02: This would be a pretty big uh change packet if we pass this thing.
[33:10] SPEAKER_02: Several pages added to our book.
[33:13] SPEAKER_02: Yes.
[33:14] SPEAKER_02: That ex that excites some people.
[33:16] SPEAKER_02: I don't know, but alright.
[33:18] unknown: Good.
[33:18] SPEAKER_02: I mean, Jared, you got any questions on that one?
[33:20] SPEAKER_02: I feel like pretty straightforward.
[33:25] SPEAKER_02: Seems good to me.
[33:26] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, okay.
[33:27] SPEAKER_02: I've just given you a chance to talk.
[33:28] SPEAKER_02: That's that's all.
[33:29] SPEAKER_02: Thanks.
[33:33] SPEAKER_02: Uh 31 jumps in and uh requires a vote of the entire court to suspend an officer's official functions during process.
[33:42] SPEAKER_02: Uh Scott, I know that this is something we have talked about some on the show.
[33:46] SPEAKER_02: You've brought it up several times.
[33:47] SPEAKER_02: It's it's uh significant to you.
[33:49] SPEAKER_02: Um hit us.
[33:51] SPEAKER_00: That's overture 32.
[33:53] SPEAKER_00: You're on the wrong overture.
[33:57] SPEAKER_02: I just thirty one.
[33:59] SPEAKER_02: I read straight from the page, so I don't know.
[34:01] SPEAKER_02: It's 31.
[34:02] SPEAKER_02: Um maybe one of the things.
[34:04] SPEAKER_02: It's 32.
[34:05] SPEAKER_02: Yes, you're right.
[34:06] SPEAKER_02: You're right.
[34:06] SPEAKER_02: Sorry.
[34:07] SPEAKER_02: I apologize.
[34:07] SPEAKER_00: 31 is right on the context you just summarized.
[34:10] SPEAKER_00: I don't care about 31, though.
[34:12] SPEAKER_02: Well, do we want to say anything else about 31?
[34:14] SPEAKER_02: Or we can refer people to our show.
[34:16] SPEAKER_02: Okay.
[34:16] SPEAKER_01: I think it's let me give it a chance to speak now.
[34:19] SPEAKER_01: Um this is going down to the you know, when you're doing process and uh there's the opportunity that you would suspend but somebody from their official functions if it's serious.
[34:32] SPEAKER_01: But if you've given those powers to a commission, to have a commission do that uh seems to be putting a lot of power in the hands of I mean, if this is a commission of three or five people uh out of the uh entire Presbytery, they can suspend a man from his uh work, especially if this is a TE, this is his livelihood.
[34:50] SPEAKER_01: Uh that's a serious thing to do, and it shouldn't be done lightly.
[34:54] SPEAKER_01: Um some complain, well, then you're gonna have to have a called meeting.
[34:57] SPEAKER_01: Well, have a called meeting, because this is a serious and rare thing that you're going to do.
[35:01] SPEAKER_01: Um sorry, I'm I'm arguing for it, but this would be uh the argument for it is that um this is not something that you should just leave to a commission to do, but that uh the entire Presbyterian needs to vote if they're going to administratively suspend somebody from uh their functions um instead of having a commission do it in that.
[35:24] SPEAKER_00: This is one of the rare sections in our book, if we amend that, give a limitation to what commissions can do.
[35:31] SPEAKER_00: Um and that would be that it can't um can't administratively suspend someone.
[35:36] SPEAKER_00: Again, what Jared was saying was perhaps what we developed a lot of the arguments from in the Overtures Committee, which was that it's a subs you're doing when you administratively suspend someone, you're doing more than stopping them from working.
[35:51] SPEAKER_00: In stopping them from working, it there is consequence, financial consequence to the person you are forcing to not work.
[35:59] SPEAKER_00: Uh, the church may no longer pay them because they're not working.
[36:03] SPEAKER_00: Uh, and the churches don't have the money.
[36:05] SPEAKER_00: I mean, if you're honest, like they don't have the money to pay a TE while he's suspended, while also now having someone else come in and do all the preaching work uh as an interim or something of that nature.
[36:15] SPEAKER_00: And so the who you're really hurting uh unintendedly is the church uh that has to deal with the financial offset of a man being suspended.
[36:27] SPEAKER_00: Uh, and so because of the nature of just the gravitas of that, the Overtures Committee thought it wise that it should be done by the whole Presbytery and not just a commission of the Presbytery.
[36:38] SPEAKER_00: Though the Commission of the Presbytery acts on behalf of the Presbytery, uh they thought that there should be a larger pool of men to deliberate in doing such a an action.
[36:49] SPEAKER_00: Because though it is an administrative suspension, there is a quasi-disciplinary effect upon the man, his ministry, and his church, and that is a financial burden uh that is placed upon them.
[37:01] SPEAKER_00: And so uh I thought this was a good amendment.
[37:04] SPEAKER_00: It passed almost unanimously.
[37:06] SPEAKER_00: There was some debate on the floor, I would say more debate on the floor than really the even the overtures committee.
[37:13] SPEAKER_00: Um and that may be just because of current events or something in the church, but I think it's a good provision.
[37:19] SPEAKER_00: It it was there was no clicker vote on this, it was just a voice vote, and it was strong.
[37:27] SPEAKER_02: Obviously, you care a whole lot about that one, but 32, not as significant.
[37:31] SPEAKER_02: Um no, no, okay, alright.
[37:34] SPEAKER_02: Come on.
[37:34] SPEAKER_02: Uh 32.
[37:36] SPEAKER_02: That I got confused.
[37:37] SPEAKER_02: 32 is the one that uh you have brought up with us before and we've talked about.
[37:41] SPEAKER_02: So come on.
[37:42] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, 32 is our gift from Ileana Presbytery to the PCA.
[37:46] SPEAKER_00: It exists because of us.
[37:48] SPEAKER_00: Um, and that is we tried to elevate the suspension of a man to disdeposition and excommunication um without additional process.
[37:58] SPEAKER_00: And so we we saw that there was historical precedent for that to be done um in another SJC case.
[38:05] SPEAKER_00: And so the court, our court, decided to try it.
[38:08] SPEAKER_00: Um it got appealed, and the sus the appeal was sustained.
[38:13] SPEAKER_00: And the result of that was well, if we're gonna, if the SJC has differing opinions at differing time periods, maybe we need clearer provisions in our constitution.
[38:24] SPEAKER_00: Uh, and that's what 36.8, this uh um overture 32 and amending 36.8 does.
[38:29] SPEAKER_00: It uh it uh allows for the process or creates process for how to elevate um a censure in a court of the church.
[38:38] SPEAKER_00: How do you go from being suspended from office to being deposed?
[38:42] SPEAKER_00: Do you have to have a whole entire new trial where you have to have new witnesses, new indictments, etc.?
[38:48] SPEAKER_00: Or can you have an additional hearing um to take in further evidence and then perhaps elevate the cess uh the um censure to deposition or excommunication?
[39:02] SPEAKER_00: It's a more perhaps middle ground approach.
[39:05] SPEAKER_00: Uh there are two ends here.
[39:06] SPEAKER_00: The one end is we try to take, we tried to make deposition and excommunication the escalation to it anyway as a mere administrative act.
[39:15] SPEAKER_00: That's like the that's one end.
[39:17] SPEAKER_00: The other end is to start a whole entire new process.
[39:20] SPEAKER_00: That means you start from you, you know, square one uh and start over.
[39:25] SPEAKER_00: Uh this provision gives a middle ground that says, well, the person's already been found guilty, so they don't deserve complete freedom from that guilt if they haven't repented.
[39:35] SPEAKER_00: But you should probably have more to it than just administratively acting.
[39:39] SPEAKER_00: And so this is uh a middle ground.
[39:42] SPEAKER_00: Uh it passed uh with uh kind of with some of the same vote margins uh as the um other ones we've talked about, and there was a strong voice vote on this one too.
[39:52] SPEAKER_00: Uh there was a little debate on the floor, um, but really there were two options for how we could go forward.
[39:59] SPEAKER_00: Um, one was produced by Southern Um Southeast Alabama Presbytery, and this one was produced by Houston Metro.
[40:07] SPEAKER_00: I think it was SJC Mines Colliding, uh, and Houston Metro's provision prevailed in the Overtures Committee, and therefore the other provisions were answered in reference to this one.
[40:19] SPEAKER_00: Vote yes on this, please.
[40:23] SPEAKER_00: My advocacy for polity matters right there.
[40:27] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, since religious organizations are now allowed to advocate for political positions uh without fear of uh any any uh anyway.
[40:38] SPEAKER_02: Where are we?
[40:39] SPEAKER_02: I was looking at other things.
[40:40] SPEAKER_02: 33! I like these that go in order.
[40:43] SPEAKER_02: Oh, oh, this is Fred's overture.
[40:48] SPEAKER_00: From the Presbytery of Fred Greco.
[40:51] SPEAKER_02: Yep.
[40:51] SPEAKER_02: As Mel said.
[40:52] SPEAKER_02: Oh boy.
[40:53] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, adds a whole showel sentence to the end of 57-2.
[40:58] SPEAKER_02: I really am curious how this happened how this went in overtures, Scott.
[41:02] SPEAKER_02: I'm not I'm not a fan of this one.
[41:03] SPEAKER_02: I'll just leave the cat out of the bag.
[41:04] SPEAKER_02: But what?
[41:05] SPEAKER_02: I know.
[41:07] SPEAKER_00: Uh uh, I yeah, so overture 33 from the Presbytery of Fred Greco was meant to be something that would accompany another overture, I believe overture 22.
[41:19] SPEAKER_00: Jared would would know if I'm right on the number, uh, on voting age restrictions.
[41:25] SPEAKER_00: And so this overture was meant to go with voting age restrictions.
[41:28] SPEAKER_00: The idea was that you'd pass both of them, they would both go to the presbyteries, and then hopefully all both of them would pass.
[41:35] SPEAKER_00: Um, and what this overture seeks to do, overture 33, which amends BCO 572, was to add perhaps a limitation uh in examining young people for um membership in the church.
[41:49] SPEAKER_00: Overture 22 tried to create age restrictions for those who professed.
[41:54] SPEAKER_00: Uh, this one seeks to now look at the person professing and make sure that they're a professor by stipulating a simple sentence.
[42:02] SPEAKER_00: The examination shall include, this is what it says, uh, include an evaluation of the young person's credible profession of faith, the young person's understanding of the meaning of the supper, and the young person's understanding of the questions found in BCO 57-5.
[42:15] SPEAKER_00: Uh the interesting thing in the overtures committee and subsequently the assembly is that we failed overture 22.
[42:22] SPEAKER_00: Um, we dealt with this overture before overture 22, and we passed it by uh 101 to 23 vote, and then we went on to deal with the voting age restrictions overture, and we failed it by a substantial vote.
[42:41] SPEAKER_00: I don't have the numbers in front of me, but it was not close.
[42:44] SPEAKER_00: Um, we have dealt with voting age restrictions in the past as in the PCA, um, and it kind of ran the same way.
[42:51] SPEAKER_00: Um, we we weren't willing to change the book, but this still passed, and there wasn't a motion to reconsider this one, and so it went to the assembly floor, and I think this one hits PADO communion pretty hard, hard enough that it did cause some debate.
[43:05] SPEAKER_00: And the assembly did a two for one, I think, on the vote here.
[43:10] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so there's a substantial minority.
[43:12] SPEAKER_00: Um and so that's kind of the context for the overture.
[43:16] SPEAKER_00: It was meant to be passed with overture 22, but 22 failed, and this one prevailed.
[43:23] SPEAKER_00: What don't you like about it, Ben?
[43:26] SPEAKER_02: Uh for the record, I'm not a fan of Pedo Communion.
[43:28] SPEAKER_02: That's and that's not why I dislike it.
[43:30] SPEAKER_02: Um I thought that's why you disliked it.
[43:32] SPEAKER_02: No, no, of course not.
[43:33] SPEAKER_02: I just am not a fan of the shell.
[43:35] SPEAKER_02: I think that the the first sentence of 57-2 uh is clear that this has to be left to the prudence of the session, and then I think it's a little ironic that then it there's a prescription.
[43:47] SPEAKER_02: So, hey, session, use your prudence, but here's exactly what you have to do.
[43:51] SPEAKER_02: I just don't think they line up.
[43:52] SPEAKER_02: Um I think you're gonna run into situations where these these three are good advice, and you might have a situation where it's not.
[44:00] SPEAKER_02: Possible to do all of these depending on the child's ability, um you know, the individual's ability.
[44:07] SPEAKER_02: Uh but anyway.
[44:08] SPEAKER_01: I I I don't hate it, but I don't like the shell.
[44:12] SPEAKER_01: I um I had a bit of a different reaction in that I was kind of so-so on it.
[44:16] SPEAKER_01: But then in the midst of the debate on the floor, uh you can correct me if I didn't hear this right, but I thought there was a guy that stood up and said, Hey, we don't actually have the children take the vows uh when they become communicate members, and that was his argument against it.
[44:30] SPEAKER_01: To which I thought, no, you really sh you you have to do that.
[44:34] SPEAKER_01: And so I thought, okay, maybe we do need this because some people don't realize that once you become a communicant member, you need to take the vows.
[44:42] SPEAKER_00: So it always pains me substantially when grossly unconstitutional things are said on the floor of the assembly.
[44:49] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, well, that was said, even though it was uh supposed to be an argument against, I said, I am now for it.
[44:56] SPEAKER_00: Wasn't there an issue like that with the titles overture a few years ago?
[44:59] SPEAKER_00: Somebody talked about how like we should have we should have let like women have the title of pastor and deacon or something.
[45:06] SPEAKER_00: And it's like, well, I didn't know if I was for it then, but now I'm certainly for it now.
[45:10] SPEAKER_02: Well, didn't you?
[45:11] SPEAKER_02: I'm pretty sure several several men confessed to uh commissioning or even ordaining uh women deacons in their churches on the floor of the General Assembly in the last five years.
[45:20] SPEAKER_00: Man Yeah, and it makes you for it.
[45:22] SPEAKER_00: And sometimes arguments can do that.
[45:25] SPEAKER_00: It didn't convince Ben, though.
[45:26] SPEAKER_00: Ben still is against examining children thoroughly.
[45:30] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[45:31] SPEAKER_02: Ben totally against it.
[45:34] SPEAKER_02: Uh right.
[45:34] SPEAKER_02: Um thirty-seven is a pretty common sense thing to do.
[45:40] SPEAKER_02: Uh I mean, Scott, you may have comments on here, but basically, if if you don't have a pastor in your church now, if this would pass, a session can elect one of its own members to preside as moderator.
[45:50] SPEAKER_02: Uh and previously they they couldn't have done that.
[45:53] SPEAKER_02: I'm I'm trying to read through this real quick.
[45:55] SPEAKER_02: Uh oh no, in judicial cases, excuse me.
[45:57] SPEAKER_02: In judicial cases.
[45:58] SPEAKER_02: Thank you.
[45:59] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[46:00] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[46:00] SPEAKER_00: Our old books that only the the teaching elder or pastor can serve as the moderator of a judicial book.
[46:08] SPEAKER_00: Our current book.
[46:10] SPEAKER_00: Uh and now this provision seeks to change that to allow when there's no teaching elder for a ruling elder to assume that role.
[46:18] SPEAKER_00: There was the main debate in the overtures committee on this provision was how much freedom do we want to give the court in electing its own moderator?
[46:28] SPEAKER_00: Um and since uh and whether or not we should just say, well, the the court can elect anyone, or should we give deference to the teaching elder?
[46:38] SPEAKER_00: Uh the overtures committee ended up saying we should give deference to the teaching elder.
[46:44] SPEAKER_00: Um, there was debate on whether uh a ruling elder, like, can we outvote the teaching elder?
[46:49] SPEAKER_00: Would it be wise to do so, uh, to allow him to step aside and things of that nature, but it kind of got murky in that in trying to create more latitude for sessions, we'd probably also create more division if you didn't give deference to one party or another.
[47:08] SPEAKER_00: And so the idea here was to give deference to the teaching elder, but say he's incapacitated or unable, or even just unwilling in a circumstance.
[47:16] SPEAKER_00: I guess, you know, if you have John Bice on your session, you may want to defer, right, um, to the ruling elder.
[47:24] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so this puts the ball in the teaching elder's court, and he may relinquish the moderator position to a ruling elder, or if there is no teaching elder, a ruling elder can assume that position.
[47:36] SPEAKER_00: But it's not like a free-for-all.
[47:38] SPEAKER_00: The debate on the overtures committee was should we make it a free-for-all?
[47:41] SPEAKER_00: That the the teaching elder could be outvoted and removed from position.
[47:45] SPEAKER_00: Uh, the idea was that that would be too divisive and unnecessary.
[47:49] SPEAKER_00: Um, and rather it'd be better just to give the precedent to our already established rule, which is the teaching elder is the moderator most ordinarily.
[47:58] SPEAKER_00: Um I think this is I've always wondered why that uh a ruling elder couldn't moderate a judicial case.
[48:06] SPEAKER_00: Um, and apparently we can now fix that, so we are fixing it.
[48:15] SPEAKER_02: Alright.
[48:16] SPEAKER_00: This last one is a doozy.
[48:18] SPEAKER_02: There's one more.
[48:19] SPEAKER_02: Oh man.
[48:20] SPEAKER_02: This is rough.
[48:21] SPEAKER_02: 13.
[48:23] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[48:24] SPEAKER_02: So overture 40 uh just changes a little bit of 35-9 to uh you're recording not just testimony, but all of the trial uh other than deliberations.
[48:34] SPEAKER_02: Was this a big deal on overtures?
[48:37] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[48:37] SPEAKER_00: Oh, this is one of the first ones we passed.
[48:40] SPEAKER_00: Um almost no debate.
[48:41] SPEAKER_00: It just seemed kind of a no-brainer.
[48:45] SPEAKER_00: Um I d I don't know if you've guys ever been through a judicial case, um, but it just is it makes the most sense to have uh something being recorded at the entire thing.
[48:59] SPEAKER_00: Like because then you can go back and reference it.
[49:01] SPEAKER_00: Prior, our book only required the testimony, so that'd be like the witness testimony.
[49:06] SPEAKER_00: Um, this would now expand to the witness testimony, but also like the opening arguments, the indictment, etc.
[49:12] SPEAKER_00: etc.
[49:13] SPEAKER_00: Anything with judicial cases, you should just record.
[49:17] SPEAKER_00: It's good advice.
[49:18] SPEAKER_00: And it was the advice I received from SJC people when just asking general uh help questions, like, hey, what should I record?
[49:26] SPEAKER_00: They said, record it all.
[49:27] SPEAKER_00: Record the first meeting of the uh of the court, record the second meeting of the court, record it all, uh, because it's better to have too much than too little, and you don't want your trial to be derailed in an appeal because you failed to record it.
[49:42] SPEAKER_00: Um, and so this is uh there was no debate, unanimous support.
[49:46] SPEAKER_00: It was unamended, it was just affirmed by the Overtures Committee and the Assembly.
[49:56] SPEAKER_02: Well, Jared, what do you have to add to all of this?
[50:00] SPEAKER_01: Nothing.
[50:00] SPEAKER_01: He covered it.
[50:01] SPEAKER_01: I had things I was gonna add, but Scott said it, so.
[50:05] SPEAKER_02: Okay.
[50:07] SPEAKER_02: Well, this has uh this is probably gonna be our last uh episode related to the most recent General Assembly.
[50:14] SPEAKER_02: We are gonna move along to continue in the Book of Church Order, and we are gonna have an episode coming up soon with Thomas Rickard talking about um is that how you say his last name, by the way?
[50:24] SPEAKER_02: I'm gonna find out one day, but Rickard, Ricard.
[50:27] SPEAKER_00: I like Ricard.
[50:28] SPEAKER_00: It sounds like y'all just gonna let me sound Ricard.
[50:31] SPEAKER_02: Okay, cool.
[50:33] SPEAKER_02: Anyway, we're gonna we're gonna work through some some RPR stuff, which will probably refer back a little bit to the assembly, but uh, in terms of of proper uh 50-second General Assembly content, this is this is gonna be the end for us.
[50:46] SPEAKER_02: And uh I think that's it.
[50:48] SPEAKER_02: Unless you guys have other housekeeping matters, um make sure that y'all uh send us uh how how the podcast has benefited you.
[50:56] SPEAKER_02: Uh we know that it has, because you tell us all the time, and we appreciate that.
[51:00] SPEAKER_02: Uh but we want to be able to share that a little bit with some with some of our listeners, so let us know, and we'll send you a copy of Per Elmquist's new commentary.
[51:09] SPEAKER_02: So I guess uh well, you know what?
[51:11] SPEAKER_02: He already talks so much.
[51:12] SPEAKER_02: Let's just say that Scott Edberg would say that this podcast is over.
[51:16] SPEAKER_02: Thanks for joining us.
[51:17] SPEAKER_02: Uh, if you're interested in learning more about anything that we have talked about, check out the show notes in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org.
[51:24] SPEAKER_02: If you've enjoyed the show, do consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters, and be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[51:32] SPEAKER_02: If you have questions or comments, if you want to submit your name uh to win the book, uh you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[51:40] SPEAKER_02: There's also a link below to support our work where uh you can there's some added benefit to that that uh if you chose to do so, I would reach out and let you know what those benefits are.
[51:49] SPEAKER_02: Uh we don't really advertise them a whole lot, yeah.
[51:51] SPEAKER_02: Secret stuff.
[51:52] SPEAKER_02: Uh anyway.
[51:53] SPEAKER_02: Listeners, thank you again for spending your valuable time with us.
[51:56] SPEAKER_02: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[51:58] SPEAKER_02: Congratulations.
[51:59] SPEAKER_02: Y'all take care of the

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
