# 6. No One Wanted To Be On My Team (BCO 2)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 10 Oct 2023, 39 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/13568637-6-no-one-wanted-to-be-on-my-team-bco-2.mp3

Jared forces Ben and Scott to play a guessing game about theology quotes, and then the three discuss the visible church from BCO chapter two. Scott Swain on Twitter Tim Keller on Twitter Burk Parsons on Twitter Polity Matters episode #5 Covenant Theology resources: RTS App on Apple App Store RTS App on Google Play Ligon Duncan Covenant Theology course Jonty Rhodes' Covenants Made Simple O. Palmer Robertson's Christ of the Covenants Dr. Randy Thompson’s sermon at 50th PCA GA Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Welcome
- 0:35 Puritan Quote or PCA Pastor
- 7:44 Introduction to BCO 2
- 8:25 BCO 2-1
- 16:53 BCO 2-2
- 28:00 BCO 2-3
- 30:18 Visible-Invisible Distinction
- 36:13 Departing Thoughts

## Transcript

[0:15] SPEAKER_02: Hello, and welcome to Polity Matters episode six.
[0:18] SPEAKER_02: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I am joined as always by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg.
[0:24] SPEAKER_02: We are excited to get into the second chapter of the Book of Church Order with you today.
[0:29] SPEAKER_02: And um I have a note here actually that Jared needs to jump in for just a second before we get started.
[0:35] SPEAKER_00: Well, a few weeks ago, you gave Scott and I a game, and um, in terms of uh embarrassing us with our knowledge of the BCO and other um trivia, and so I thought uh Ben, it would be good to have you on the hot seat as well to uh play a game that I invented.
[0:52] SPEAKER_00: Uh let me explain it to you, and then I can tell you how the the scoring will work here.
[0:57] SPEAKER_00: This is called Puritan Quote or PCA tweet or X or whatever it's called now.
[1:02] SPEAKER_00: Um basically, what I'm going to do is to read to you something that is either a quote from a Puritan or is a tweet from a PCA pastor.
[1:13] SPEAKER_00: And what I notice is that often uh the Puritans will be very relevant to today, and often uh PCA pastors will try to sound like Puritans or um maybe they're just being uh timeless.
[1:23] SPEAKER_00: Um, so I will I will read something to you, and then uh you have to say, I can I think that's a Puritan quote or it's a PCA tweet.
[1:32] SPEAKER_00: And then at the end of that, I'll give you a chance for a bonus to come in, if especially if you guys have the same answer, raise your hand, and then whoever's first can see if you can name either the Puritan or um or the pastor, uh uh whatever it may be.
[1:46] SPEAKER_00: And uh there's no rhyme or reason to this, they could all be the same, they could all be um uh Puritan quotes, they could all be PCA tweets, uh, they could be four and one, three, whatever.
[1:55] SPEAKER_00: Um, so uh I'll just read one.
[1:57] SPEAKER_00: Here's here's an example that would hopefully be a little bit easier.
[2:01] SPEAKER_00: Uh, for instance, if I were to read this to you, in classical philosophy, justice refers both to the meta virtue that rightly orders all virtues and also to the specific virtue that gives particular things their due.
[2:13] SPEAKER_00: Example, recognizing the sheer goodness of mayo.
[2:17] SPEAKER_00: Would that be a PCA tweet or would that be a Puritan quote?
[2:21] SPEAKER_00: Quote.
[2:22] SPEAKER_00: That's too long to be a tweet.
[2:24] SPEAKER_00: Tweet.
[2:26] SPEAKER_00: That's a tweet.
[2:27] SPEAKER_00: It's talking about mayo.
[2:28] SPEAKER_00: And bonus points if you can if you can uh name the person who said that.
[2:32] SPEAKER_00: Oh, you said mayo.
[2:34] SPEAKER_00: Mayo.
[2:35] SPEAKER_01: I thought you said mayo.
[2:38] SPEAKER_01: I don't know who said that.
[2:42] SPEAKER_02: I'm afraid to name who Scott Swain.
[2:47] SPEAKER_00: Of course, the other kid.
[2:48] SPEAKER_00: One of the great tweeters of all time.
[2:50] SPEAKER_00: So if you're not following Scott Swain, you are not using Twitter rightly, or X or whatever it's called.
[2:54] SPEAKER_00: Anyway, that was ridiculous.
[2:56] SPEAKER_00: Um, I will start off with some that are a little bit harder.
[2:58] SPEAKER_00: Uh, I have five of these, and just tell me what if you think that this is a Puritan quote or a PCA tweet, and then uh at the end, then I'll have you raise your hand to see if you can have a bonus of seeing who it is.
[3:10] SPEAKER_00: So uh here's the first one uh between Ben and Scott.
[3:13] SPEAKER_00: Let's see how you're doing this.
[3:14] SPEAKER_00: Though we may complain to God, we must not complain of God.
[3:21] SPEAKER_00: Is that a quote or is that a PCA tweet?
[3:25] SPEAKER_00: Quote.
[3:26] SPEAKER_00: Uh uh tweet.
[3:28] SPEAKER_00: Uh it is a quote from a Puritan.
[3:31] SPEAKER_00: Ben, you can have a bonus uh point if you can name name the Puritan that it is a quote of.
[3:37] SPEAKER_00: Sibs.
[3:39] SPEAKER_00: No, it is Watson, but you do get a point, and and Scott, you're gonna have to catch up on this.
[3:43] SPEAKER_00: Um, do well.
[3:45] SPEAKER_00: I'll tell you that right now.
[3:47] SPEAKER_00: Here's the second one.
[3:48] SPEAKER_00: This is either a tweet or a quote.
[3:50] SPEAKER_00: See what you think it is.
[3:52] SPEAKER_00: In temptations, it is safest to behold nothing but Christ, the true brazen serpent, the true lamb of God that takes away the sins of the world.
[4:03] SPEAKER_00: Quote Wait.
[4:06] SPEAKER_00: Uh it is a quote.
[4:08] SPEAKER_00: Now, uh bonus points to Scott, if you can name what it is a who said that.
[4:16] SPEAKER_00: Uh Edwards.
[4:18] SPEAKER_00: No, that was Richard Sibbs.
[4:20] SPEAKER_00: Who did you think it was, uh Ben?
[4:23] SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
[4:24] SPEAKER_00: You don't know.
[4:25] SPEAKER_00: Okay.
[4:28] SPEAKER_02: I don't know on Twitter as much as some people, so I don't know.
[4:31] SPEAKER_00: I'm just guessing.
[4:33] SPEAKER_00: All right.
[4:34] SPEAKER_00: Uh let's see if you can get this, whether this is a tweet or whether this is a quote.
[4:39] SPEAKER_00: Um an ounce of sin can harm us more than a ton of suffering.
[4:44] SPEAKER_00: Sin can harden our hearts so we lose everything.
[4:47] SPEAKER_00: But suffering, if handled rightly, can make us wiser, happier, and deeper.
[4:52] SPEAKER_00: Tweet.
[4:54] SPEAKER_00: Quote Owen.
[4:56] SPEAKER_00: Uh this is a tweet.
[4:58] SPEAKER_00: That is good, Ben.
[4:59] SPEAKER_00: Who do you think tweeted that?
[5:01] SPEAKER_02: I don't know, but they were summarizing Owen.
[5:04] SPEAKER_00: Uh that is actually Tim Keller.
[5:07] SPEAKER_00: So that is a tweet.
[5:09] SPEAKER_00: Um, all right.
[5:10] SPEAKER_00: The next one is the fourth one.
[5:13] SPEAKER_00: Let's see what we're doing.
[5:14] SPEAKER_00: Scott, you have one, Ben, you have two.
[5:15] SPEAKER_00: I have one.
[5:16] SPEAKER_00: Uh you have one, yeah.
[5:19] SPEAKER_00: Um, the fourth one is because God is holy, he requires propitiation for his wrath against us for our sin against him.
[5:28] SPEAKER_00: Because God is love, he propitiated his wrath against us in Jesus Christ, who took our sin and nailed it to the cross.
[5:35] SPEAKER_00: Is that a Puritan quote or is that a PCA tweet?
[5:40] SPEAKER_00: Well, uh, so Scott, you're going with a uh quote and then uh Ben you're going with a tweet.
[5:49] SPEAKER_00: It is a tweet.
[5:50] SPEAKER_00: Um, you can have a book.
[5:52] SPEAKER_02: It doesn't have that timeless character to it.
[5:54] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it didn't.
[5:55] SPEAKER_00: So can can you name the person who tweeted this for a bonus point?
[5:58] SPEAKER_00: No.
[5:59] SPEAKER_00: No.
[6:00] SPEAKER_00: Oh, that was that was Burke Parsons.
[6:01] SPEAKER_00: Uh the great Burke Parsons.
[6:03] SPEAKER_00: All right.
[6:04] SPEAKER_00: Um, all right, coming down to the last one.
[6:06] SPEAKER_00: Uh, so it is with my little book.
[6:08] SPEAKER_00: It may not include pretty pictures to make it attractive, but it does hold the treasure worth looking for.
[6:14] SPEAKER_00: Was that a PCA tweet or was that a Puritan quote?
[6:17] SPEAKER_02: Just so that we're clear, Scott would have to get this right and the bonus in order to tie with me, right?
[6:22] SPEAKER_02: Is that where we're correct?
[6:24] SPEAKER_02: Okay, yeah.
[6:25] SPEAKER_02: Sorry, I just want to rub it in a little bit.
[6:28] SPEAKER_00: Can you read it again?
[6:30] SPEAKER_00: So it is with my little book.
[6:32] SPEAKER_00: It may not include pretty pictures to make it attractive, but it does hold a treasure worth looking for.
[6:39] SPEAKER_02: Puritan quote.
[6:41] SPEAKER_00: Can I agree?
[6:42] SPEAKER_00: You can, yes.
[6:44] SPEAKER_00: All right, quote.
[6:45] SPEAKER_00: Uh, it is a quote.
[6:46] SPEAKER_00: Um, bonus if you can say who said it.
[6:49] SPEAKER_00: Watson.
[6:50] SPEAKER_00: Bunyan.
[6:52] SPEAKER_00: Ben is right.
[6:53] SPEAKER_00: It was Watson talking about his book.
[6:55] SPEAKER_00: The Pilgrim.
[6:56] SPEAKER_00: The Pilgrim's Progressive.
[6:57] SPEAKER_00: You said Watson.
[6:58] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, no, uh, sorry, no, it was Bunyan.
[7:00] SPEAKER_00: Bunyan talking about his book, uh, The Pilgrim's Progress, which warms some hearts and leaves others cold.
[7:07] SPEAKER_00: But um, so at the end of that creepy to others, yeah, yeah.
[7:10] SPEAKER_00: At the end of that, uh, Ben, uh, you are uh the winner there.
[7:15] SPEAKER_00: So uh congratulations on that.
[7:17] SPEAKER_01: I'm gonna boycott game shows because I am terrible at recalling things on the fly.
[7:25] SPEAKER_02: Well, I think you just need to make the next game we play.
[7:28] SPEAKER_01: There you go.
[7:29] SPEAKER_01: My family always made me play Trivial Pursuit, and no one wanted to be on my team.
[7:36] SPEAKER_01: That's for sure.
[7:38] SPEAKER_00: So so Ben, I think you get you win being the host this week.
[7:41] SPEAKER_02: Awesome.
[7:42] SPEAKER_02: Sounds good.
[7:43] SPEAKER_02: Let's get to it.
[7:44] SPEAKER_02: We're into chapter two of the PCA Book of Church Order.
[7:49] SPEAKER_02: Chapter one introduced us to these five heads under which Presbyterian church government is comprehended.
[7:56] SPEAKER_02: And beginning in chapter two, we take a deeper dive into each one of these heads.
[8:01] SPEAKER_02: And so we'll we're gonna look at the church for a few chapters, the members for a chapter, the officers for a few chapters, the courts, and then the orders.
[8:10] SPEAKER_02: And so you can kind of track that through the first um couple dozen chapters of the book, and we begin um today with chapter two.
[8:20] SPEAKER_02: Uh, there's only three paragraphs here.
[8:22] SPEAKER_02: Uh here's the first one: the visible church before the law, under the law, and now under the gospel is one and the same and consists of all those who make profession of their faith in the Lord Jesus Christ together with their children.
[8:39] SPEAKER_02: Chapter two is setting up right on the outset a distinction between the visible church and what we'll come to know as the invisible church.
[8:47] SPEAKER_02: And we're going to take some time towards the end of our episode to discuss that distinction more in depth.
[8:53] SPEAKER_02: But for now, it's worth quoting the confession of faith that talks about the visible church in Confession of Faith 25.2, the visible church, which is also Catholic or universal under the gospel, consists of all those throughout the world that profess the true religion and of their children, and is the kingdom of the Lord Jesus Christ, the house and family of God.
[9:14] SPEAKER_02: Guys, what what comes to mind?
[9:16] SPEAKER_02: What stands out to you in this chapter as we talk about the visible church?
[9:19] SPEAKER_02: That is, those those people who have professed faith and have joined the the it's not physical, it's it's uh you know, it's the church you can see, I guess we would say what what stands out here in this paragraph?
[9:32] SPEAKER_01: Uh that it can it the visible church includes both those who profess faith and their children, that it is not merely a visible church that has professed believers, but also the children of those professed believers.
[9:49] SPEAKER_01: And so sometimes there might be a confusion that, well, the visible church are those who have joined the church.
[9:55] SPEAKER_01: And sometimes we talk about joining the church when we make profession of faith.
[9:59] SPEAKER_01: But if your parents were believers within the church, you were also a member of the visible church.
[10:06] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and that goes back to scriptural uh basis, uh, Genesis 17.
[10:12] SPEAKER_00: Uh, the sign of the covenant was to be given not only to Abraham but to his son at eight days old.
[10:17] SPEAKER_00: Um, and then in Acts 2, you have almost the same language that's being used that the promise is for you and for your children.
[10:25] SPEAKER_00: And so uh a traditional Presbyterian understanding is uh the membership uh in the Old Testament included children, uh, or at least the male children, but in the new testament it does include uh their children as well.
[10:38] SPEAKER_00: Not that the promise is possessed by all of them, but it is for them, it is extended to them, uh, it is over them.
[10:44] SPEAKER_00: And so um that that's something to note is that it also includes uh children that are in the visible church, but actually may not be part of the invisible church yet.
[10:54] SPEAKER_02: That's a good point to make, too.
[10:56] SPEAKER_02: You you refer there, or you're at least pointing towards covenant theology, which is described in the first part of the sentence, right?
[11:03] SPEAKER_02: The visible church before the law, under the law, and now under the gospel.
[11:07] SPEAKER_02: So that the visible church has existed in in all of scripture and all of God's redemptive history, not just now um under the gospel in the New Testament, not just in the Old Testament, but um across the spectrum of history.
[11:22] SPEAKER_02: Um, is covenant theology necessary to the perfection of church government?
[11:29] SPEAKER_00: It certainly is helpful, um, especially since if you think of some will make the distinction, I think, especially among the Dutch, between the internal and external covenant.
[11:40] SPEAKER_00: And uh that follows pretty closely to what we mean by visible and invisible church.
[11:45] SPEAKER_00: And so you have to have this idea of what is the covenant?
[11:48] SPEAKER_00: Is there a sense in which you can be in the covenant at least externally um and not internally have had the benefits of the covenant?
[11:56] SPEAKER_00: Can you be a covenant breaker?
[11:58] SPEAKER_00: And there are some that will say no, that you can't be.
[12:01] SPEAKER_00: Um, the covenant is only invisible or internal.
[12:04] SPEAKER_00: Um, going back and trying to look for some that have a different view of uh church membership.
[12:10] SPEAKER_00: Um, the some Baptist churches as far back as the uh Somerset confession uh will say that they have a regenerate church membership, and that's the only membership that they recognize is regenerate church membership.
[12:21] SPEAKER_00: Um, that of course has some difficulties in how how can you tell, other than a profession of faith.
[12:27] SPEAKER_00: Uh, but there there seems to be this idea that the invisible and the visible are exactly the same or they or they should be, um, versus the idea that you may have some people that are not yet regenerate that are in um that have been born into uh the covenant community that are being taught the faith but haven't yet come to faith.
[12:44] SPEAKER_01: We've discussed this a little bit with the preliminary principles of um when you think of uh this idea of is Presbyterian church government um beneficial, or uh what does the preliminary principle say?
[13:00] SPEAKER_01: Uh it is to the perfection of the church that you would uphold this form of government, but it is not essential to make a church a church.
[13:09] SPEAKER_01: And I think it's the same way with covenant theology.
[13:12] SPEAKER_01: The CT is not essential to make a church a church, but it is helpful as it relates to the government of the church and who's within the church.
[13:21] SPEAKER_01: Well, you could also think of this with dispensationalism.
[13:25] SPEAKER_01: Um this section actually pushes against dispensationalism, and Presbyterianism hasn't been um immune to the influences of dispensationalism.
[13:37] SPEAKER_01: And so I think it's helpful to think through the visible church as being one throughout all the ages.
[13:43] SPEAKER_01: Uh, it's not multiple different peoples of God, but one unified people of God.
[13:48] SPEAKER_01: Um, whether that be from the garden all the way to the eschaton, uh, there is one people of God, and that is the church.
[13:55] SPEAKER_01: I was kind of a black sheep at Moody Bible Institute for this point, um, where they would often say you believe in replacement theology, multiple peoples of God, um, multiple views of how people are saved, even, um, at least in its founding.
[14:09] SPEAKER_01: And this unifies that.
[14:11] SPEAKER_01: No, God has one redemptive people, God, there's one story within all of creation, and uh that is bound with the visible church throughout various epochs.
[14:22] SPEAKER_00: And that would be a distinction there, too, because with covenant theology and dispensational theology, how much is um uh continuous and how much is uh discontinuous between the old and the new covenant?
[14:33] SPEAKER_00: Um, that's partly what we're talking about.
[14:35] SPEAKER_00: There is uh most would recognize uh Abraham had uh Isaac, yes, but he also had Ishmael, but Isaac was the covenant keeper.
[14:43] SPEAKER_00: Um, we also know Isaac had Jacob and Esau, and um Jacob was uh in a in some sense a covenant keeper in terms of uh seeking the birthright and the blessing, whereas Esau was not, he never found a place of repentance according to uh Hebrews.
[14:57] SPEAKER_00: And so we understand there the covenant sign being given to people who were not ultimately uh ones that the covenant was for there.
[15:05] SPEAKER_00: Um, whereas when you get to the New Testament, the question is, are children still included or not?
[15:10] SPEAKER_00: And covenant theology helps us with our understanding of the fact that it's those who make profession and their children, it's there's a continuity uh with the way that it functioned in the Old Testament, that there still is the covenant of grace uh is the same uh in many respects, at least to the parties, uh, from Abraham uh onto the new covenant.
[15:29] SPEAKER_02: Guys, uh, in the interest of our listeners who either may have their interest peaked towards covenant theology after our discussion of this paragraph, or may be utterly confused after our discussion of this paragraph.
[15:40] SPEAKER_02: What resources are out there that may serve as a good introduction to covenant theology that you could recommend?
[15:46] SPEAKER_01: I would download the Reform Theological Seminary app and just listen to uh Ligan Duncan's Covenant Theology course.
[15:52] SPEAKER_01: That's pretty much all anyone needs uh as a primer.
[15:55] SPEAKER_01: Another good one is uh John T.
[15:57] SPEAKER_01: Rhodes book uh on covenants.
[15:59] SPEAKER_01: Does anybody remember that title?
[16:03] SPEAKER_01: Uh he has a good one.
[16:04] SPEAKER_01: Covenants made simple by John T.
[16:06] SPEAKER_01: Rhodes.
[16:06] SPEAKER_01: That's a good primer.
[16:08] SPEAKER_01: Um, if you don't want to listen to 20 hours of Ligan.
[16:12] SPEAKER_02: But listening may be easier than reading sometimes.
[16:16] SPEAKER_02: Also love that you uh you said that Ligan was all you needed, and then you gave him them a second choice, too.
[16:22] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[16:23] SPEAKER_02: Jared, anything out there that you think of?
[16:26] SPEAKER_00: Uh that's that's the classic.
[16:28] SPEAKER_00: I think that's the one that you go to now is uh Ligan Duncan's course.
[16:31] SPEAKER_00: Um, there's some older ones, um, O Palmer Robertson's, although sometimes it's a little bit difficult for some people.
[16:37] SPEAKER_00: Um, and he and Horton are kind of going back and forth, they have different um shades of covenant theology, but I think once you get to Lig and Duncan, you get kind of the main um uh the mainstream of covenant theology in the PCA today is in Lig and Duncan's course.
[16:53] SPEAKER_02: Well, here let's let's go ahead and move on to paragraph two.
[16:57] SPEAKER_02: This visible unity of the body of Christ, though obscured, is not destroyed by its division into different denominations of professing Christians.
[17:06] SPEAKER_02: But all of these which maintain the word and sacraments and their fundamental integrity are to be recognized as true branches of the Church of Jesus Christ.
[17:15] SPEAKER_02: Scott, why don't you kick us off here?
[17:18] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I can do that.
[17:20] SPEAKER_01: And when you're thinking about the the visible church, uh something that is associated with it quite intimately is the unity of the church.
[17:28] SPEAKER_01: And so when thinking about paragraph two, you might say, well, the the church doesn't seem really united.
[17:35] SPEAKER_01: It seems pretty obscured, uh, especially after the reformation.
[17:39] SPEAKER_01: Uh one thing that Rome was right about is that if you part ways with the one true church, as they would say, uh, you will have fragmentation.
[17:49] SPEAKER_01: And they were right about that.
[17:50] SPEAKER_01: There was much fragmentation in the Reformation, whether that be Lutheran, the Reformed, or other sects, there was fragmentation.
[17:57] SPEAKER_01: And so you might think that the unity of the body of Christ is destroyed.
[18:02] SPEAKER_01: Uh, and this um part of our constitution is saying, no, it is not destroyed.
[18:07] SPEAKER_01: It might be obscured, uh, it might be fragmented or fractured, uh, but not destroyed.
[18:12] SPEAKER_01: When we talk about the visible church, we're not just talking about the PCA, but we're talking about the true church, any church that professes what we would say is a foundational doctrine for Christian faith.
[18:26] SPEAKER_01: You think of the various early creeds, the apostles' creed, but uh many others.
[18:31] SPEAKER_01: That that's uh that is defined and gives parameters what for what the true uh visible church is and how we are united.
[18:39] SPEAKER_01: Though we that might manifest itself in various traditions, it remains united because Christ is one and his church is one, even though there are many denominations.
[18:50] SPEAKER_02: Let's talk about that that fundamental issue here in just a second, but first let's hone in on um this unity.
[18:57] SPEAKER_02: And Almaquist in his commentary says the essential unity of the church is not an outward organization nor allegiance to any particular body or form, but in union with Christ.
[19:07] SPEAKER_02: He's making the point, right, that that uh visible separation into different local churches or denominations can't sever the invisible unity that we have in Christ.
[19:19] SPEAKER_02: Uh you can go to places like John 17 where Jesus prays that we would be one, right?
[19:24] SPEAKER_02: That we would be connected.
[19:25] SPEAKER_02: He isn't necessarily praying there against separate local churches.
[19:30] SPEAKER_02: Um, he is praying that we'd be one as we're one in him.
[19:34] SPEAKER_02: Um Jared, you have some good thoughts on this.
[19:38] SPEAKER_00: Well, one, I would share the um the quote from Ramsey, which I think is interesting on this, even if you don't agree that it was true at the time in the PCUS, I think we agree with the principle, uh, which is the the Presbyterian Church in the United States, he says, uh then continues its separate existence as a denomination only upon the ground that its members would not be allowed to obey all the laws of Christ in any other organization.
[20:01] SPEAKER_00: And it stands pledged to organizational union upon any basis permitting full obedience to all the teachings of Christ, um, which means that uh it recognizes that there are other uh true churches that are out there, but um that there may not be a full uh accounting of uh of the truth and an ability to obey uh the truth in those uh other places.
[20:25] SPEAKER_00: And so it continues its existence because of that and seeks union with others that are like-minded.
[20:31] SPEAKER_00: Um, I those that had listened to um uh the opening sermon at the 50th General Assembly, um, it was noted by the speaker that the PCA began and lament that they had to exist.
[20:43] SPEAKER_00: And uh basically since that point, if you get you start talking to the PCA, pretty soon they're gonna ask you to join them.
[20:49] SPEAKER_00: Um a lot of the people in Napark have were um had overtures from the PCA to come together in union, happened with the RPCES, uh, didn't quite happen with the OPC.
[21:00] SPEAKER_00: Um, but if they agree with them and they um there can be a union that's there, there's a desire for union, but not at the expense of truth.
[21:07] SPEAKER_00: Uh, there has to be enough essential unity in order for them to be uh to come together on that.
[21:12] SPEAKER_00: Um one of the areas in which you're looking at that though is uh do they have all of the marks of the church and do they have them in in some sort of purity?
[21:21] SPEAKER_00: Um, this section I think is interesting because it seems like it has two marks of the church that it's talking about here, uh the word and sacraments.
[21:30] SPEAKER_00: And I think um that's not necessarily because it doesn't believe in the three marks of the church.
[21:35] SPEAKER_00: Um, it's interesting at various times people may talk about one mark of the church, two marks of the church, or three marks of the church in terms of word, uh sacraments, and discipline.
[21:45] SPEAKER_00: And uh Turitan noted that basically they're all in some sense trying to get to the same thing, right?
[21:52] SPEAKER_00: There is a unity in what the gospel and what the word is, and the other two marks of the church actually serve that end.
[21:59] SPEAKER_00: So So the sacraments, uh, he actually says, uh Turitan says, uh, these two flow from the word of God and are appendages of it in terms of discipline and sacraments.
[22:08] SPEAKER_00: And so um, these other marks of the church serve them.
[22:12] SPEAKER_00: Sometimes they might be absent uh because a church might not have a minister for a while, and so maybe the sacraments can't be practiced there or discipline might have failed.
[22:20] SPEAKER_00: Um, but um they they return and the the churches and immediately done away with, and they should serve that uh basis of unity in the truth.
[22:29] SPEAKER_00: That's that's as you said before, uh Christ's high priestly prayer that they might be united in the truth, uh, which is his word.
[22:37] SPEAKER_00: And um that's what that's what is being sought here.
[22:40] SPEAKER_00: Um there may be different denominations, uh, but that doesn't mean that there aren't uh true manifestations of the church there, but we need to have a basis of union uh that has the highest basis in truth.
[22:51] SPEAKER_02: Something occurring to me just in the moment.
[22:53] SPEAKER_02: So this might turn into material we cut out entirely.
[22:56] SPEAKER_02: The end of chapter one uh in paragraph seven says this scriptural doctrine of presbytery is necessary to the perfection of the order of the visible church, but is not essential to exist its existence.
[23:10] SPEAKER_02: Being Presbyterian is not required in order to be a true church.
[23:14] SPEAKER_02: Could it be that the authors of this left off the idea of discipline from paragraph two, sort of as a signaling that Presbyterianism is the right way to do church discipline, right?
[23:26] SPEAKER_02: That the way that Christ has set it up for us.
[23:28] SPEAKER_02: But if you don't have that, but you have these other two, we're still recognizing them as a true church.
[23:34] SPEAKER_00: I think in terms of getting members from other churches and transfer, you might have a church that really does not practice church discipline in any meaningful way, yet we still recognize that they were truly baptized and they're they were under the word.
[23:47] SPEAKER_00: Um, I think it gets a lot harder when you get down to say uh salvation army that doesn't have the sacraments at all, you're really stretching there.
[23:55] SPEAKER_00: Um, but there's there's a lot of churches today that don't have the mark really, at least in in practice of church discipline.
[24:02] SPEAKER_00: And yet we would recognize people coming from there, they they were under the word.
[24:07] SPEAKER_00: Uh, there was some manifestation of the church there.
[24:09] SPEAKER_00: So I think that's a that's a possibility.
[24:12] SPEAKER_01: And I think it's helpful to remind people regularly that discipline is not only corrective, but it's also preventative and being under the word in the very various ministries of the church is preventative.
[24:25] SPEAKER_01: Um, you see preventative discipline in your Sunday school class when you're being taught not to do something or you're taught about something.
[24:32] SPEAKER_01: And so you you you receive discipline uh often, regularly, our children receive discipline preventatively.
[24:40] SPEAKER_01: In my own home, when I discipline my kids, I'm doing that every day.
[24:43] SPEAKER_01: Um, most of it's preventative, hopefully.
[24:46] SPEAKER_01: And then when they fail that I correct them.
[24:48] SPEAKER_01: And so discipline must always be remembered and couched in that way, that it is both preventative and corrective.
[24:55] SPEAKER_01: We only correct when the preventative fails.
[24:58] SPEAKER_01: And so when your people um hear a sermon on adultery, you're trying to protect them from adultery, trying to teach them against adultery and the truths of purity and chastity.
[25:10] SPEAKER_01: Uh, but when that fails, now we are moving from preventative discipline into corrective discipline.
[25:15] SPEAKER_01: And uh the that that second part is where many, probably most evangelical churches fail.
[25:21] SPEAKER_01: They struggle to transition from preventative to corrective when they need it.
[25:25] SPEAKER_01: And it's sad because it doesn't it doesn't protect the purity of the church, the glory of God, and it fails ultimately to reclaim the sinner.
[25:35] SPEAKER_01: And so we need both.
[25:37] SPEAKER_01: Um, and so that's probably how we would couch, yeah, that church never's disciplined a person in their lives, but they've sat under the discipline, the preventative discipline of the word.
[25:46] SPEAKER_01: We just wish they'd done more.
[25:49] SPEAKER_02: What do y'all think about this language in paragraph two that we can recognize true branches of the Church of Jesus Christ?
[25:56] SPEAKER_02: Um, you know, is it right for us to go around labeling churches as true or or false branches?
[26:02] SPEAKER_02: Um, what may be examples of these?
[26:05] SPEAKER_02: Where do your minds go with this language here?
[26:09] SPEAKER_01: Well, we're clearly the true church.
[26:14] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, we we should think that and believe that, I suppose.
[26:18] SPEAKER_00: Well, you do have to have some of this again for receiving members.
[26:22] SPEAKER_00: Um, if you have somebody that is coming from a oneness Pentecostal church and they're saying, I was baptized and I'd like to, you know, be transferred in here.
[26:30] SPEAKER_00: Well, they don't actually hold to the Trinity.
[26:32] SPEAKER_00: They baptize just in the name of Jesus and not in uh the name of the Trinity.
[26:37] SPEAKER_00: Um they don't have um a right idea of God and the gospel.
[26:41] SPEAKER_00: Therefore, we have to say that was not a true church, and you never really have been baptized.
[26:46] SPEAKER_00: So when you're coming in here, um, we have to recognize what is a true church and what isn't, so that we know have we been obedient to God's command to baptize when you come in?
[26:55] SPEAKER_00: And um, are we transferring you in, or is this a profession of faith and this is the first time that you're coming into the church?
[27:01] SPEAKER_01: And that's all good to have with your session, um, ensuring that you know the guardrails.
[27:07] SPEAKER_01: Um, you think of things, issues like Roman Catholicism, the PCUSA.
[27:12] SPEAKER_01: Um, there's a diversity of thought, even within our own denomination, on whether you receive those baptisms as valid.
[27:20] SPEAKER_01: And so I before you make an example of somebody that comes before you seeking transfer, you might want to have a discussion with your pastor with the session, ensuring that the proper policies in place so that somebody doesn't get put in a a rough situation where they have to be the example by which you implement a new policy.
[27:41] SPEAKER_01: And so those kind of discussions are good to have.
[27:44] SPEAKER_01: Are main line are the main lines valid?
[27:47] SPEAKER_01: Um, should you view them as true churches?
[27:50] SPEAKER_01: Do you receive them into membership?
[27:51] SPEAKER_01: The same with Catholicism.
[27:53] SPEAKER_01: Some of them are easy.
[27:55] SPEAKER_01: Mormons, Jehovah's Witnesses, uh, but some of them are a little more difficult.
[28:00] SPEAKER_02: Paragraph three.
[28:02] SPEAKER_02: It is according to scriptural example that the church should be divided into many individual churches.
[28:10] SPEAKER_02: What's the scriptural example that this paragraph is talking about?
[28:16] SPEAKER_02: As I look at our notes, I'm the only one that's written anything in answer to this question.
[28:20] SPEAKER_01: And Jared and I are just drinking our drinks, waiting for you to answer.
[28:25] SPEAKER_02: Well, on the one hand, you could see that Paul wrote to different churches.
[28:31] SPEAKER_02: Um, he he recognized different individual congregations gathered together for worship and fellowship together under Christ.
[28:44] SPEAKER_02: In some sense, it's just sort of logical because not everybody in the world who professes Christ lives in the same place.
[28:52] SPEAKER_01: There's also cultural divides, right?
[28:54] SPEAKER_01: And there were, in many senses, theological divides that differed from church to church.
[28:58] SPEAKER_01: Otherwise, Paul wouldn't have written all those letters admonishing the Galatians for various things and others.
[29:04] SPEAKER_01: And so there's true diversity even within the one church there in the New Testament, theological diversity, much of it having to be corrected, but cultural diversity.
[29:14] SPEAKER_01: Some churches had more Gentiles than Jewish uh believers, and others had more Jewish believers than Gentiles.
[29:21] SPEAKER_01: And so it's pretty it sometimes we think of perhaps the Apostolic Church as being very simple in its theology.
[29:29] SPEAKER_01: Um, but they had Paul was constantly battling and trying to correct um where there were errors and false teaching, and so it may not be as uh simple as we might think.
[29:43] SPEAKER_00: Well, there you have the some diversity that's there.
[29:45] SPEAKER_00: Although I like what Ramsey says too in emphasizing the the unity.
[29:49] SPEAKER_00: He says the division of the church into particular churches does not obscure its unity, provided the courts of the particular churches are not independent of the court of the church.
[29:59] SPEAKER_00: So then you would think of Acts 15, the fact that you did have some of this diversity that got together and they submitted to uh when they had uh their first general assembly there in uh Jerusalem um and submitted to the court of the church.
[30:13] SPEAKER_01: I thought that was Jerusalem Metro Presbytery.
[30:18] SPEAKER_02: Well, we mentioned it earlier on that BCO2 sets up a distinction between the visible church and the invisible church, and I kind of want to cue it up for my friends here to talk through the distinction between the visible and the invisible.
[30:34] SPEAKER_02: Scott, maybe you want to start the discussion for us and explain uh the distinction that exists here.
[30:41] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, so we've already discussed generally from Westminster Confession uh 25, 1 and 2, um, in defining them.
[30:49] SPEAKER_01: Uh but just to reiterate that again, the visible church is comprised of all those who profess Christ and their children.
[30:56] SPEAKER_01: Uh, that means the visible church fluctuates all the time.
[31:00] SPEAKER_01: Uh, it grows uh uh regularly as we have children, as people are baptized.
[31:06] SPEAKER_01: It may go down at certain times if people apostasize and leave, but it fluctuates.
[31:11] SPEAKER_01: Whereas the invisible church is the total number of God's elect.
[31:15] SPEAKER_01: In that sense, it is static.
[31:17] SPEAKER_01: It doesn't change, it includes those whom the Lord has foreordained uh to be his.
[31:23] SPEAKER_01: That means it includes those who have yet to be born.
[31:27] SPEAKER_01: Um, it is one number, it does not change.
[31:30] SPEAKER_01: It's a Lamb's book of life, uh, as it were.
[31:33] SPEAKER_01: Uh it and so it is perfect as well.
[31:36] SPEAKER_01: Uh, since it's static, it is God's chosen people, it is perfect, it doesn't need perfecting, um, as the the visible church might lend itself to.
[31:46] SPEAKER_01: And so when thinking of the invisible church, sometimes people think that it is only those who truly believe within your local church or your local denomination or in the world today.
[31:58] SPEAKER_01: Um, but it's actually larger than that.
[32:00] SPEAKER_01: It is, it transcends that because it goes through all of time.
[32:04] SPEAKER_01: And so sometimes you might narrow the invisible church, but it's actually the total number of God's redeemed people, even before they were born.
[32:13] SPEAKER_01: Uh well, Jared, um, when thinking about the invisible, visible distinction, are there uh in the reformed world at least, uh, what groups would deny uh that distinction?
[32:27] SPEAKER_00: All groups would tend to have some sort of an idea of a visible, invisible church.
[32:32] SPEAKER_00: Some of the problem is is that a different group at all?
[32:35] SPEAKER_00: And some would confuse um the visible and invisible church to the point where there's really no real distinction between them.
[32:42] SPEAKER_00: Um is the visible church just the church?
[32:45] SPEAKER_00: I Roman Catholics would um say that anybody that really is in the visible church is in the invisible church, uh, too, that there's really no distinction between the two.
[32:54] SPEAKER_00: Um, but I think back to something like uh Romans uh 9.6, where the literal translation would be not all Israel is Israel.
[33:03] SPEAKER_00: And if you read that in modern translations, sometimes they try to put an adjective in there, like not all descended from Israel or not all true Israel, whatever.
[33:11] SPEAKER_00: It's the literal is just not all Israel is Israel, which means that we have to supply what the adjectives are, which seems to be uh not all visible Israel, not all the visible church is the invisible church, right?
[33:23] SPEAKER_00: There's um there's some distinction there that there's a Venn diagram, there's a lot of overlap, but there's some that are outside uh on either side.
[33:30] SPEAKER_00: Um other groups that have come along since then that would um really obscure that, I think would be federal vision.
[33:37] SPEAKER_00: Um, federal vision really want to have an objective covenantalism.
[33:42] SPEAKER_00: And what they mean there is objective is the external is not really distinguished from the internal.
[33:46] SPEAKER_00: If you're baptized, you're regenerated, you're you're justified, you're all the things, you get all of the benefits uh from uh that external work internally uh at the time that that happens.
[33:58] SPEAKER_00: Um there's a problem with this though, if you don't have some sort of a uh a distinction between them and an idea that you might be in one group but not the other, and that is um, what do you do then with apostasy?
[34:10] SPEAKER_00: Is there is there any preservation or perseverance of the saints?
[34:15] SPEAKER_00: Uh what's the certainty of election if it can be given to you and then taken away?
[34:19] SPEAKER_00: Um, what do you do with the warning passages in Hebrews?
[34:22] SPEAKER_00: Is this a real loss of salvation uh that's happening there?
[34:25] SPEAKER_00: There's a lot of problems that you get into even hermeneutically uh if you don't make this kind of a distinction, but also within um church government of what it is that you're doing.
[34:34] SPEAKER_00: Um, there's there's much more that you're you're really legislating.
[34:37] SPEAKER_00: You're legislating their um the their regeneration there instead of declaring it.
[34:42] SPEAKER_00: I think it just doesn't work with our system.
[34:44] SPEAKER_00: That so many things fall apart if this distinction are is uh is obscured because you you you need to have an ex operate operato in the doing of the doing for the sacraments or um uh that that kind of a uh of a view of the invisible and mystical or invisible church.
[35:03] SPEAKER_01: You you have me caught up with the Venn diagram.
[35:05] SPEAKER_01: It's really hard to Venn diagram this doctrine.
[35:08] SPEAKER_01: I know it's used a lot, but it's really hard to to try to figure out how large I mean, the the invisible church is obviously the largest circle, but it's it it sometimes miscommunicates the the work because some there are people who are members of the visible church who yet who are not members of the visible church yet.
[35:29] SPEAKER_01: And so it's hard to Venn diagram all the various groups.
[35:32] SPEAKER_01: Um, so my little like I guess my children will count because they're members of the visible church, but say they they rebel against the Lord and they reject him and they are uh excommunicated, but the Lord truly will regenerate them at some point.
[35:48] SPEAKER_01: They might not be a part of the visible church, but the Lord has already forordained them to be his people.
[35:54] SPEAKER_01: And so there's uh an interesting way, it's hard to picture it.
[35:57] SPEAKER_01: It's kind of like trying to draw out the diagrams for the Trinity or trying to explain the Trinity where you have all these deficient analogies.
[36:06] SPEAKER_01: Uh, it's really hard to Venn diagram or image the invisible visible distinction.
[36:12] SPEAKER_02: Well, we're glad that y'all joined us for our discussion of BCO chapter two.
[36:16] SPEAKER_02: As Thelonious Monk would say, this podcast is over.
[36:20] SPEAKER_02: If you happen to find yourself outside of the visible church in some way and you have um an interest in learning more, you can contact us directly when I give you our contact information here in just a moment.
[36:31] SPEAKER_02: But you can also look on the PCAC.org website and look for a local PCA church that you can uh reach out to, get involved with, ask the pastor some questions.
[36:42] SPEAKER_02: If you're interested in that, we'd love to see you become a part of the Visible Church somewhere.
[36:47] SPEAKER_02: Thanks for joining us again.
[36:48] SPEAKER_02: Be sure to come back next time when we discuss the nature and extent of church power in BCO chapter three.
[36:54] SPEAKER_02: If you're interested in learning more about anything that we spoke about, check out the show notes in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org.
[37:01] SPEAKER_02: If you enjoyed the show, consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters, and be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[37:09] SPEAKER_02: If you have questions or comments, you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[37:15] SPEAKER_02: Scott here is the senior minister of Providence PCA in Troy, Illinois, right?
[37:21] SPEAKER_02: Not Indiana, as I too often say.
[37:24] SPEAKER_02: You can find him on Twitter at SEDberg, and sometimes he'll write from time to time and make a spreadsheet and throw it on the internet.
[37:31] SPEAKER_02: Uh, you can look for those wherever you buy all your spreadsheets.
[37:35] SPEAKER_02: If you're looking for Jared, he's the pastor at New Life Presbyterian Church of Hopewell Township.
[37:39] SPEAKER_02: And I looked this up earlier, Jared, Aliquippa, Pennsylvania.
[37:42] SPEAKER_02: Am I saying that correctly?
[37:44] SPEAKER_00: That is correct.
[37:44] SPEAKER_00: Aliquippa, Pennsylvania.
[37:46] SPEAKER_02: They spell things the way you say them up in the north, is from what I can tell.
[37:49] SPEAKER_02: He's on Twitter at Brother Nelson.
[37:51] SPEAKER_02: He's also an editor over at Presbyterian Polity, and you can find him writing around the internet from time to time.
[37:55] SPEAKER_02: So uh keep on the lookout.
[37:57] SPEAKER_02: I serve as the associate pastor at Covenant Presbyterian Church in Cleveland, Mississippi.
[38:01] SPEAKER_02: You can find me on Twitter at underscore Ben Ratliff, and you can find my preaching over on Sermon Audio under Benjamin Ratliff.
[38:08] SPEAKER_02: Thanks again for spending time with us.
[38:10] SPEAKER_02: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[38:12] SPEAKER_02: Goodbye, gentlemen.
[38:14] SPEAKER_02: Hope to see y'all soon.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
