# 13. Called Meeting: RE Howie Donahoe

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 23 Nov 2023, 44 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/14014667-13-called-meeting-re-howie-donahoe.mp3

Jared sits down with RE Howie Donahoe to discuss churchmanship, including GA moderating all the way to how to write an overture. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Welcome
- 1:02 Introductions
- 6:01 Churchman
- 10:22 Moderator
- 16:19 Study Committees
- 20:00 Overtures
- 26:07 Being a Young Churchman
- 32:31 Being a Christian Churchman
- 35:00 Hope for the PCA
- 39:19 Lightning Round
- 42:34 Closing

## Transcript

[0:14] SPEAKER_00: Hello and welcome to the first ever Polity Matters called meeting.
[0:18] SPEAKER_00: These called meetings will be periodic shows that allow us to distribute bonus content to you, our dear listeners.
[0:24] SPEAKER_00: Interviews, ramblings, special topics, you'll find it all in this occasional format.
[0:30] SPEAKER_00: These called meetings will also transform you listeners into viewers, as you can plainly see.
[0:35] SPEAKER_00: Our plan is to post these extra episodes on our YouTube channel as well as on our regular podcast feed.
[0:41] SPEAKER_00: So if you're getting this particular show as audio only right now, be sure to check out the show notes where we have a link to our YouTube channel and you can watch us in living color.
[0:49] SPEAKER_00: On this edition of Called Meeting, Jared sits down with ruling elder Howie Donahue to discuss everything from GA moderating to overture writing.
[0:57] SPEAKER_00: Thanks for listening and for watching.
[0:59] SPEAKER_00: Enjoy the show.
[1:02] SPEAKER_01: Well, welcome to uh Polity Matters.
[1:04] SPEAKER_01: This is a uh special episode, a type that we're going to be calling a called meeting, uh, where we um talk to somebody about a particular subject or uh get more insight into uh perhaps just being a good churchman.
[1:16] SPEAKER_01: Um and for our first such episode, um, I'm happy to introduce uh ruling elder uh Howie Donahoe.
[1:24] SPEAKER_01: Uh Howie's been in the PCA for uh over four decades, if I can uh date you that much.
[1:30] SPEAKER_01: Uh you've been a ruling elder for, I think, 37 years, um, served as a clerk in several uh churches, uh, one of which you may not know is only like 15 miles south of me here.
[1:41] SPEAKER_01: Um Presbytery, but uh but nearby.
[1:44] SPEAKER_01: Um but if you are a uh a PCA General Assembly enjoyer, uh you probably know him as uh best as the moderator of the 47th General Assembly.
[1:54] SPEAKER_01: So um welcome, Howie.
[1:56] SPEAKER_01: Thank you.
[1:58] SPEAKER_01: Glad to be here.
[1:59] SPEAKER_01: Well, thanks for being on.
[2:01] SPEAKER_01: Um I wanted to talk to you about a few different things, some of it just getting to know you as a churchman, and then um I wanted to talk to you a little bit about um your role as a moderator, but then also get into a particular subject uh that is um uh of interest to perhaps people around this time, which is uh writing overtures, uh, something that you have a little bit of experience with.
[2:20] SPEAKER_01: But um I introduced you a little bit, uh, but can you tell us a little bit about um your your faith?
[2:26] SPEAKER_01: Did when did you come to faith?
[2:28] SPEAKER_01: Did you grow up in a Christian home?
[2:30] SPEAKER_01: Uh, and when did you get interested in in Presbyterian polity?
[2:34] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I grew up in an Irish Catholic family, six kids born in Pittsburgh, moved to Ohio, then New Jersey, then back to um Mount Lebanon in the southern parts of Allegheny County for high school.
[2:49] SPEAKER_02: Um went to church every Sunday, was pretty serious about um that faith um uh uh church anyway, and um was dating a gal whose mother came to faith through uh John Gueston at Episcopal Church in Swickley.
[3:12] SPEAKER_02: Um and then the daughter, the gal I was dating, came to faith.
[3:16] SPEAKER_02: She got me reading C.S.
[3:18] SPEAKER_02: Lewis and um uh Christmas of my senior year of college, I realized that uh what grace was.
[3:27] SPEAKER_02: Um and so then graduated from uh Academy, went to flight school, met a guy who was raised as a conservative Baptist, so I went to conservative Baptist Church in Gilbert, Arizona for three years.
[3:41] SPEAKER_02: Um came to understand that there were some Protestant churches that were not pro-life and some that were, uh, after seeing Francis Schaefer and C.
[3:51] SPEAKER_02: Everett Coop do a seminar at Arizona State.
[3:55] SPEAKER_02: And so then when I moved to uh in the Air Force transferred to Tacoma, Washington to fly different airplanes, um I kind of had a pretty good idea which denominations were pro-life.
[4:09] SPEAKER_02: And uh, in those days we used the yellow pages, so I was going through the yellow pages and visiting different churches, and uh one day I ended up at Faith Tacoma and uh been in the PCA ever since 1982, I guess.
[4:25] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, and then you've been in PCA churches in Pittsburgh area, and then now you're in the Pacific Northwest.
[4:31] SPEAKER_01: So what was it that actually took you uh different places in your vocation?
[4:35] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, well, um when I got out of the Air Force, got married, um, wanted to work actually pro-life full-time, but there was a retired Navy ruling elder.
[4:49] SPEAKER_02: He said, Well, the airlines are hiring, can't you do both at the same time?
[4:52] SPEAKER_02: And I took his advice, went to work for U.S.
[4:55] SPEAKER_02: Airways, got based in DC, um, PCA church there.
[5:01] SPEAKER_02: Uh, and we couldn't buy a house, couldn't afford a house in DC, so we moved to Pittsburgh and U.S.
[5:07] SPEAKER_02: Airways had a big crew base in Pittsburgh.
[5:10] SPEAKER_02: So that's when we were at Providence for 12 years.
[5:13] SPEAKER_02: And then we had homeschooled the kids and uh didn't really feel like we could do it very well in high school.
[5:19] SPEAKER_02: So we were looking for a PCA church and a U.S.
[5:22] SPEAKER_02: Airways crew base and a good Christian school.
[5:26] SPEAKER_02: And uh we were living in the South Hills in Bridgeville, so there was one in Penn Hills, but we didn't want to commute to that.
[5:33] SPEAKER_02: So uh we moved to Charlotte, uh, went to Christ Covenant and uh Covenant Day School, and uh then we were there for about 10 years, and Deb's folks were getting older, uh Seattle and Queerlaine, Idaho.
[5:49] SPEAKER_02: So we moved out to Seattle, and I finished uh my career out there 10 years there.
[5:54] SPEAKER_02: I was commuting from Seattle to Philly or Charlotte or LA to fly my trips from Seattle.
[6:02] SPEAKER_01: And still within that, you were ordained as a ruling elder and then started to serve within the church.
[6:09] SPEAKER_01: And um sometimes we use this term uh being a good churchman.
[6:13] SPEAKER_01: Um, how would you define being a churchman or what made you think I need to be more than just serving in the local church, but serving at Presbytery, serving at General Assembly, and being a good churchman?
[6:23] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, well, I was ordained when I was 31, which was at least 10 years too early.
[6:29] SPEAKER_02: I can get into that later, uh at Christchurch, Arlington.
[6:34] SPEAKER_02: And um, at the time I didn't even know what presbytery was or presbytery meetings were because our pastor at the time didn't really tell us.
[6:42] SPEAKER_02: I mean, I didn't, I should have known, but I didn't.
[6:44] SPEAKER_02: So I didn't go to any presbytery meetings till I moved to um Pittsburgh, Providence Pres.
[6:51] SPEAKER_02: And uh Art Broadwick was a pastor, and he was serious about polity and presbytery.
[6:56] SPEAKER_02: So I started getting involved up there and um it really was something I was just personally interested in.
[7:05] SPEAKER_02: I like doing it, yeah.
[7:06] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, so I guess that's when it started, and then went to general.
[7:11] SPEAKER_02: I mean, I think I've been to 29 of 29 or 30 general assemblies, and um first couple, you know, I didn't know what was going on, and uh, but eventually you figure it out.
[7:24] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, there's a learning curve, especially at PCAGA.
[7:26] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, and I had a career that allowed me flexibility that others don't have.
[7:30] SPEAKER_02: I mean, um, you know, we've got an elder in our session, he's uh he's a doctor with little kids, and he just doesn't have nearly the flexibility that I had flying.
[7:42] SPEAKER_02: I could arrange the schedule to make press street meetings and things like that.
[7:45] SPEAKER_02: So um I was blessed that way.
[7:49] SPEAKER_01: So yeah.
[7:51] SPEAKER_01: Um within church polity, polity suggests politics.
[7:57] SPEAKER_01: Um, sometimes you get different groups that that form uh, in fact, PCA came from certain groups that were concerned within the PC USA.
[8:05] SPEAKER_01: Um, I think it's uh kind of funny as I've paid attention uh as a since I've been ordained, uh uh not quite as long ago, almost 15 years ago, but um there's there's groups like that will um advocate one way, like uh um GRN Gospel Reformation Network and uh other groups that have been known, such as uh national partnership.
[8:26] SPEAKER_01: And uh something that I've always kind of found uh a little funny is um you have friends that are uh people like Fred Greco, and um I think you've been to at least one of the GRN conferences, and then you tried to get um some guys that were in GRN and national partnership uh together, which I think uh made some people label you one way or another.
[8:46] SPEAKER_01: Um, but um I guess what I'm asking is is is being a churchman what role do groups and sides have?
[8:53] SPEAKER_01: And um what's what's maybe some of the disadvantages or advantages of that?
[8:57] SPEAKER_01: And how have you seen your role as a churchman in the midst of that?
[9:02] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I mean, it's not hard for me to be friends with people that I disagree with.
[9:10] SPEAKER_02: I mean um there are guys on the SJC that I vote differently from often, but I uh they're actually the guys I hang out with the most probably.
[9:24] SPEAKER_02: Um I'm I I'm I guess I'm ambivalent about political groups, but I'm not ambivalent about people being able to energetically advocate for a position or recruit others for a position.
[9:40] SPEAKER_02: So um I don't have that big a big a heartburn about that.
[9:44] SPEAKER_02: Um I do think it's good for people to vote knowledgeably, not just because somebody tells them to vote a certain way, but at the same time, if I'm at least early on in General Assembly and Presbytery attendance, um if I wasn't that familiar with uh an issue that was coming up for vote, if I knew that somebody who I think like most often was voting a certain way, I didn't feel bad about voting that way.
[10:19] SPEAKER_02: So it's kind of a mixed bag, I guess.
[10:23] SPEAKER_01: All right.
[10:24] SPEAKER_01: Well, then let me ask you about a particular way in which um you've been involved as um a churchman, which has been your moderator.
[10:32] SPEAKER_01: Um little trivia fact.
[10:34] SPEAKER_01: I think you were the longest serving uh moderator of the PCA since we canceled 2020, is that right?
[10:39] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I canceled 2020 just for that reason.
[10:42] SPEAKER_01: Yes, just just to be a trivia answer.
[10:44] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[10:45] SPEAKER_01: Um uh just a few questions about that.
[10:48] SPEAKER_01: What was the most interesting or unexpected part about being moderator?
[10:53] SPEAKER_01: I mean, we can read about what the moderator does in BCO and RAO, and it's not a long description, and so maybe you don't know all what to expect.
[11:03] SPEAKER_02: Well, yeah, you gotta you've gotta prepare for it.
[11:07] SPEAKER_02: I knew I was gonna be nominated, so John Bison and I prepared together.
[11:11] SPEAKER_02: And um, you know, you you get pretty familiar with the docket, you get pretty familiar with you know where minority reports might be.
[11:19] SPEAKER_02: Um, you gotta watch the clock because you gotta try to guide the ship through the canal in time.
[11:27] SPEAKER_02: Um but I mean, having been to a lot of presbytery meetings and GAs, I was familiar enough with Roberts, and there's also parliamentarians, so um nothing really surprised me that much.
[11:45] SPEAKER_02: But I will say there was um I'll make fun of myself here.
[11:50] SPEAKER_02: There was a point towards the end of the Thursday night, it was almost midnight, and I was tired.
[11:56] SPEAKER_02: I knew we were gonna adjourn that night, and somebody was delivering a minority report that I was confident didn't have a chance of passing, but they have a right to do that.
[12:07] SPEAKER_02: So I went back and sat down and wasn't really paying attention.
[12:13] SPEAKER_02: And someone went to a mic and yelled, point of order, point of order.
[12:16] SPEAKER_02: And I thought, Oh my gosh, I don't know what that guy was saying, and I'm in trouble now.
[12:20] SPEAKER_02: So I went to the mic and the guy said his point of order, and I mumbled something like, Well, just keep it germane and continue or whatever.
[12:28] SPEAKER_01: So yeah, uh yeah.
[12:30] SPEAKER_01: So try to try to have caffeine up there is what you're saying.
[12:32] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I have to have caffeine up there, at least towards the end.
[12:35] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[12:36] SPEAKER_01: So you had said there, um, at the 47th General Assembly, actually, both you and Bice uh were nominated.
[12:44] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[12:44] SPEAKER_01: So in essence, running against each other, but although it wasn't really necessarily uh framed that way.
[12:49] SPEAKER_01: Um you won and then you nominated Bice at the 49th General Assembly.
[12:54] SPEAKER_01: So do you want to talk a little bit about what was going on there and that relationship a little bit?
[13:01] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, John and I have been friends pretty much since coming on the SJC.
[13:07] SPEAKER_02: Um neither one of us thought it was a problem in Dallas.
[13:14] SPEAKER_02: People could pick who they wanted as the moderator, but I was pretty confident he would be the next rolling elder moderator, but um I knew there would be another uh competitive election, I guess.
[13:28] SPEAKER_02: But um yeah, nothing.
[13:30] SPEAKER_02: I mean, we talked about who who would be good on the sexuality committee because that was a hot topic at the time, and uh he gave me some names that I hadn't thought of, and um yeah, so that was we just helped each other prepare for the GA.
[13:45] SPEAKER_01: So yeah, so you always knew that he was he was uh prepared, even though he didn't get it at the uh 47.
[13:52] SPEAKER_02: Oh yeah, I'm sure he was the if you're not, then I mean it's gonna be tough.
[14:00] SPEAKER_02: Um, I mean, I had this big notebook with all my little tabs on it and stuff, and so yeah, you need to be, but and I think the EPC has uh they have a moderator and a moderator in waiting or something, like a moderator elect.
[14:20] SPEAKER_02: Um and he's normally elected the next year as the moderator, but doesn't have to be.
[14:27] SPEAKER_02: It's it's still an election the following year.
[14:30] SPEAKER_02: But the wisdom of that is at least it gets a guy ready to prepped.
[14:37] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think Fred, I think yeah, I think Fred knew he was probably gonna run out of post.
[14:43] SPEAKER_02: So um, you know, if you were there, you realize he was very unprepared.
[14:50] SPEAKER_01: Well, the uh uh actually in our presbytery, we do that.
[14:54] SPEAKER_01: I don't know if yours does.
[14:54] SPEAKER_01: We're we have a moderator and we have a vice moderator.
[14:58] SPEAKER_01: Oh, nice.
[14:58] SPEAKER_01: They step in if they can't make it, and then they're usually voted in next time.
[15:02] SPEAKER_01: So yeah.
[15:04] SPEAKER_02: Fred didn't have to prepare.
[15:05] SPEAKER_01: I know he did, but uh he knows that stuff pretty well.
[15:09] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[15:10] SPEAKER_01: Um a lot of the things that you do as moderator are at the assembly.
[15:14] SPEAKER_01: Um to something that is um outlasts that in terms of um something that's going on after that um would be the study committee um uh selections and for those to do their work.
[15:29] SPEAKER_01: Uh first, is there anything else that a moderator does after like outside of General Assembly, or after that, is it just kind of largely over?
[15:38] SPEAKER_01: It's largely over.
[15:39] SPEAKER_02: Um there's a cooperative ministries committee, which is the heads of the committees and agencies and the chief operating officers of each, and the last six moderators that meets for a one-day meeting in January in Atlanta, but that's and the moderator of the last general assembly moderates that meeting, but um it's it's essentially done.
[16:02] SPEAKER_02: It's not like the moderator or presbytery who appoints commissions, who might be initiating investigations, stuff like that.
[16:10] SPEAKER_02: Um, because you know, we have a stated clerk and and uh staff, so it's pretty much the General Assembly.
[16:17] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[16:18] SPEAKER_01: Well, two you actually had uh the distinction, I don't know if this has happened often of appointing two study committees, uh one of which was the sexuality uh one that was dealing with um issues of um desires in light of especially LGBTQ um thinking and um reactions to that.
[16:38] SPEAKER_01: And then the other one was DASA, the domestic abuse.
[16:41] SPEAKER_01: Um, it it seems like um uh today there's a lot of feeling that the the sexuality uh debate is somewhat winding down.
[16:50] SPEAKER_01: There's kind of a last amendment that's going through, but that seems to be winding down.
[16:55] SPEAKER_01: I wonder if that was your take on that.
[16:57] SPEAKER_01: While on the other side, um domestic abuse, it seems like there's still some uh talk about some changes that need to be made or uh things that need to be implemented.
[17:06] SPEAKER_01: So, where do you see those two things now?
[17:08] SPEAKER_01: You you helped appoint the people that were on those committees.
[17:11] SPEAKER_01: Where do you see the work of the church still after that?
[17:14] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think your assessment's probably correct on what the level of attention is and things.
[17:19] SPEAKER_02: And I know that um um some people are working on maybe uh I think DASA report was 220 pages or something like that.
[17:31] SPEAKER_02: So trying to whittle it down to a pamphlet that sessions can use.
[17:36] SPEAKER_02: Um, for example, every session should probably know where the women's shelter is, who the contact for that is, and child protective services, stuff like that.
[17:46] SPEAKER_02: Um best practices in uh uh nursery policies and stuff.
[17:53] SPEAKER_02: Um so yeah, I I expect um that's gonna get more attention um as people implement things and realize that maybe maybe there's a um a BCO provision that might help.
[18:11] SPEAKER_02: But the DASA thing probably isn't um as constitutional an issue, meaning we need to know best practices, but we don't necessarily need to codify them in the in the BCO, I think.
[18:27] SPEAKER_02: I know that the overture the first overture this year is on uh witness testimony, and you know that's probably an important one, and that'll that'll get discussed, I think, at length.
[18:38] SPEAKER_02: But um I'm not sure how much BCO change will come out of on that topic, I guess.
[18:49] SPEAKER_02: I'm not sure.
[18:50] SPEAKER_02: I mean, we've sent one up last year, Pacific Northwest, on um if there's uh someone who's personally offended in a 38-1 case uh without process, that they need to be involved more.
[19:08] SPEAKER_02: We needed to codify that they're they they needed to be um approached and get their opinion of the confession itself and things like that.
[19:19] SPEAKER_01: So that uh if somebody had sinned against somebody else that it wasn't just a sorry you were offended and they accept that, but actually making sure that the repentance was um fits what the what happened to the person, right?
[19:30] SPEAKER_02: Well, yeah, and at least at least before the court decides it's a full statement of the facts, yeah.
[19:35] SPEAKER_02: Uh find out from somebody that was involved in it whether they view it as that way.
[19:42] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[19:44] SPEAKER_01: So it sounds like it's um even with DASA, there there may be a few more things that need to change, but some of it is just actually implementing what's in our book and and using it properly.
[19:55] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think so.
[19:57] SPEAKER_01: Um yeah.
[20:00] SPEAKER_01: But one of the major ways uh you mentioned it that you've um been involved in Minut Churchman is um writing overtures.
[20:07] SPEAKER_01: I remember one year uh opening up the overtures page, and I think I saw four from Pacific Northwest, and I said out loud, I guess how he's been busy this year.
[20:16] SPEAKER_01: Uh maybe you had a lot of flights that you were you're odd that you were writing.
[20:19] SPEAKER_01: So um you're somebody that's that's written um quite a few overtures, and if um this is kind of overture season that some people are thinking about them or uh perhaps proposing them in um uh in their presbyteries.
[20:34] SPEAKER_01: And so, as somebody who perhaps beyond the founders, maybe you have more language in the BCO than anybody else uh uh currently active at the courts.
[20:41] SPEAKER_01: I thought maybe I could ask you a little bit about that.
[20:44] SPEAKER_01: Um, first, um uh can you just tell us first what overtures are and when when do we consider an overture at General Assembly?
[20:54] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, overture is basically just a law.
[20:56] SPEAKER_02: You're writing a law because the BCO is the law book, you know.
[21:01] SPEAKER_02: Um, I'm sympathetic to Dr.
[21:06] SPEAKER_02: Taylor's position.
[21:07] SPEAKER_02: He doesn't he he doesn't like the book changing so frequently.
[21:11] SPEAKER_02: Um uh so he wasn't real fond of all my writers, he isn't real fond of, but I would I've been in a position on the SJC that I get to see problems in a different way, maybe than than some others.
[21:25] SPEAKER_02: And you know, if it if you can fix that for other presbyteries in the future with a couple sentences, then you give it a try.
[21:34] SPEAKER_02: Um I think you try to write an overture that you're confident is necessary, but also confident they can get passed.
[21:45] SPEAKER_02: Um two thirds of the presbyteries is kind of hard to hard to get.
[21:51] SPEAKER_02: There's some presbyteries that uh rarely even vote, and those are no votes.
[21:57] SPEAKER_02: So you really have to.
[22:00] SPEAKER_02: get close to 70-75% of the the voters voting presbyteries to approve.
[22:11] SPEAKER_02: So you know to me it's no point to send an overture up that you're not pretty confident it's going to pass because that's just a waste of people's time, I think.
[22:22] SPEAKER_02: But yeah, and um I've realized that the more words that are in an overture the less likely it's going to pass.
[22:38] SPEAKER_02: I um I was a rebel in that I I didn't like the format that we were using whereas, whereas, whereas, whereas and then therefore because we don't do that with motions.
[22:51] SPEAKER_02: So I uh started writing them where we just said this is what we want to do and here's why and I think that's easier to understand.
[23:02] SPEAKER_02: I think it's good to get feedback on them before you send them up.
[23:07] SPEAKER_02: And even after you send them up if your Presbytery has um has time you can revise them and refile them.
[23:16] SPEAKER_02: What we do kind of routinely in Pacific Northwest is we uh if a session sends an overture we consider it and if there's general approval of it we assign it to a commission and give the commission power to amend it and file it before the deadline because we meet in early February and the deadline I think is mid-March or mid-April anyway for uh CCB review if it's a BCO overture.
[23:47] SPEAKER_02: And that way the commission our commission has time to perfect the thing before we file it.
[23:55] SPEAKER_02: So um so yeah identify a clear problem and uh propose the best solution to it.
[24:06] SPEAKER_01: Yeah when so you're you're particularly talking about overtures that are like BCO maybe RAO which is rules of assembly operation um right of course overtures can do other things such as sure direct agencies or make statements or some a few other things but if somebody's thinking I'm thinking about writing an overture um when do you think that that's appropriate?
[24:27] SPEAKER_01: It sounds like if if if it could be something that actually passes two thirds of the presbyteries um but uh when else is it kind of like okay this is the level of an overture versus wasting people's time um well if they've got a lot of experience then they probably know whether it's needed and whether it'll pass.
[24:53] SPEAKER_02: If they're if they don't have a lot of experience you need to talk to some people and say I think you know I saw this happen in my church.
[25:01] SPEAKER_02: I think it needs to be fixed um and the people with experience can help them know whether that's gonna ch gonna happen or not.
[25:13] SPEAKER_01: But from real life experiences especially if you have a problem in your church is that where you think probably a lot of BCO changes or proposals come from well most of the ones that come from Pacific Northwest come out of judicial cases.
[25:28] SPEAKER_01: Yeah so we don't want that to happen again or obviously that book that paragraph or that sentence is unclear or but um and the book's far from perfect so there'll be changes year after year I think um yeah yeah well you you answered one of my nerdier questions which was which format do you prefer the whereas or the uh the solution with the rationale already um yeah so I I didn't know that you were uh one of the originators of that the rationale format that's a little bit different.
[26:05] SPEAKER_01: Um maybe I was I don't know um so in regards to all of that you you have some people that uh maybe newer in the church um maybe newer to the courts of the church maybe they've gone to one um or two uh general assemblies um what's been your experience in terms of um what does it look like to be a good churchman in that people maybe are are thinking about going to their second general assembly and then then they want to talk or something like that.
[26:34] SPEAKER_01: What would you give as encouragement or even a good example of being a good churchman as a young uh elder yeah that's a great question um young elders are often energetic and uh I'll just tell you my story um uh I was an elder in Arlington Virginia and then in in Pittsburgh um and one day I read uh I think it Marshall Shelley I think is called Wellintentioned Dragons and realized that that pretty well described my first 10 years as an elder and so I went to both those guys at a Dallas GA and apologized to him.
[27:20] SPEAKER_02: I said I just read this book and I think that's that was me when I was on your session and they both said yes it was we accept your apology um so uh watch and learn is a is a good thing um you know I I I can't I can't not go to a mic that's one of my besetting sins and um I don't think I made a good speech until the 10th General Assembly I was at so um and do you prepare all remarks before you you speak or do you kind of at bullet points or you just have it off the top of your head it depends I probably it usually off the top of my head somebody says something and I go wait a minute's not right I got a mic um but if it's like if it's an overture that's coming up I'll probably prepare something but um yeah probably mixed but uh for a guy going to General Sunday there is so much stuff and somebody needs to sit down with them and say listen it's not all critical okay uh don't worry about this don't worry about that I remember when I was a flight instructor I was right after flight school came back as an instructor and I didn't know what the Air Force was like you know I was a new guy I was teaching guys how to fly and I would be telling my guys you need to know this you need to know this and there would be a more experienced uh Air Force guy at the other table telling his students uh you don't need to know that you don't need to know that so there's a lot of stuff at GA yeah you don't you don't really need to read that um you know when the uh RPR report comes out and I don't know it's 140 pages or something um just go look at the exceptions of substance you know or the unsatisfactories you know for responses and those are the things that are gonna get debated so or your presbytery if you agree what with what they said yeah yeah I mean yeah and so a guy that's going to GA somebody's got to help him whittle that book down.
[29:31] SPEAKER_01: Yeah so so find somebody in your church or in your presbytery that you can like hang on and say hey can you can you help me through this one?
[29:39] SPEAKER_02: Yeah yeah and you know walk them through the docket and say here's where this is where going to be a lot of debate on this thing here and here it's just gonna be like some presentations and stuff and let them know when he can go to the bathroom you know what part of the docket he can yeah.
[29:57] SPEAKER_01: Well I've um I've been to I think 10 General Assemblies and I've never I I think I had a point of order that was told was not really a point of order and then was uh dismissed.
[30:05] SPEAKER_01: That's the only time I talked on the floor really but uh I have talked in in committee of commissioners it's a smaller group sure um what would you recommend people um that are going maybe it's a first or second general assembly should they get on a committee of commissioners should they get yeah if they can for sure yeah it's uh it's good a good way to learn a couple different things um and there's always vacancies I mean overtures committee usually is the more experienced guys from presbyteries um but there's always a spot for somebody in a presbytery that wants to go on a um committee of commissioners to learn the thing and sometimes it's you know depending on the committee and stuff might not be as um energetic as some other committees or whatever but um it's a good way to do it you got to fly in a little bit early you know if you're on committee of commissioners that meet on Monday you got to fly in on Sunday but um there are half the committee commissioners or more than half meet on Tuesday so yeah you can still fly in on Monday.
[31:15] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[31:15] SPEAKER_01: Yeah and even if I'm on um something that doesn't take as long Ridgehaven or something like that then I like to go and watch overtures then I know what's happening before it actually gets there.
[31:24] SPEAKER_01: Yeah that's awesome to do that.
[31:26] SPEAKER_01: Yeah yeah and then that you probably see you uh speak a little bit more there than even on the floor because you're on there about half a time it seems like yeah I think I'm gonna take Coffin's approach though he cut Dave's never on the overtures committee because then he can speak on the floor.
[31:41] SPEAKER_02: So I think I'm gonna let some of the younger guys in my press for get overtures experience.
[31:46] SPEAKER_01: But yeah but I also enjoy being being in there when they're crafting something and realizing okay it's finally gotten to the point where uh I think it's a good product and it's almost like you're presenting it and uh so I I kind of enjoy being in that process but yeah then you can't speak to it when it's on the floor.
[32:01] SPEAKER_02: So there's there's a give and take and yeah that's why I love Jay Nightkirk in Overtures because he kind of sits back and listens and listens listens.
[32:08] SPEAKER_02: Then he comes up with a magic sentence it's wonderful.
[32:11] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[32:11] SPEAKER_01: Yeah he actually uh uh one time I I I made a a motion and then he got up right after me made amendments to fix what was wrong with my motion and then spoke against it and I just I love the fact that he he was like I want this to be good if we're gonna do it but here's why we shouldn't do it.
[32:27] SPEAKER_01: Yeah that's a good churchman there too for he's a great guy yeah so um and kind of like stepping back from that and thinking about that how how do we be good I'm asking this in another way I kind of asked earlier but uh how do we act as churchmen as Christians?
[32:43] SPEAKER_01: I mean you you've said you've learned some lessons there um how do we avoid falling into error in in going in and trying to be a churchman but doing it in a way that's that's unchristian how uh what have you learned what tips would you give to somebody um just to to kind of fill that out how do we be Christian churchmen yeah that's a great phenomenal question um I've had to learn how to listen better and not just watch your lips move and prepare my next comment about it or whatever um think charitably about the other person um meaning don't put the bet the worst spin on it you know he's not doing this for such and such a reason or whatever and try to get to know people spend time with people um and um and communicate like you know I remember on a commission oh it was after the 1977 General Assembly there was an ad hoc commission that was formed and uh I was on I think it was 12 of us I know Nikirk was on it and I was on one side of the issue and and another guy was on the other side of the issue senior to me and um we finally just said well what are you afraid of what do you want and and he said well I don't I don't want us to do this and I said well I don't want us to do that either but I don't want us to do this and he says okay well I can live with that and so it just kind of took a little talking to say finding out really what the other guy what the main concerns he has and stuff.
[34:34] SPEAKER_01: So be willing to change your mind and and try to actually change other people's minds rather than just make a statement yeah and for me it was it was listening asked tell me why you why you're so passionate about something that I'm not very passionate about.
[34:49] SPEAKER_02: You know what are you afraid of what uh yeah and just passion it out.
[34:55] SPEAKER_01: Yeah um and it's kind of wrapping up some of the things we're thinking about what's what is your hope for um seeing certain things in the next few years within the PCA is there something that we've perhaps um either lost and we need to recover something that we need to be doing you came in with some guys like Schaefer and uh those guys as kind of guiding lights is there um are are we still that same denomination or are there things that we've missed that we need to recover things that you want to see happen uh with the PCA in terms of of your hopes yeah that's a great question um I'm thrilled to have chapel as the state of clerk I think Brian's got the right perspective on um on that question um we had a visitor to our church on Sunday and um we're not a big church but uh he was from Florida he and his wife and his daughter was granddaughter was getting baptized and um the mother of the of the child being baptized was their daughter and um we were talking during uh later and I told him I said uh uh I just want to let you know this is a good church we're gonna take care of your daughter and your granddaughter and the guy almost started crying um so that told me we just need churches that are like that that are peaceful places uh that love Jesus that can care for people and um you know that are I forget who the poet was but he used a phrase called factories of peace and I've just always loved that phrase you know factories of peace um there'll be there'll be disruptions in churches but uh the idea that uh you can go and belong and and feel the peace of Christ the shalom uh especially on the Lord's day is just a great thing so you know it breaks my heart and the other guys on the SJC when we have so many cases of things that it's just like what a sad situation that must be for people in the church.
[37:21] SPEAKER_01: So yeah so it sounds like uh you need to be a good churchman but you also need to be a good shepherd in your own church and um be caring about what things in the local church too, right?
[37:31] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, for sure.
[37:33] SPEAKER_01: Um and that reminds me of I remember at Providence Presbyterian uh at one point we decided all the elders had to do the same thing and um you know all the elders had to do nursery and all the elders had to do this much shepherding and phone calling and stuff I said wait that doesn't make sense because one of our elders a guy named Don Maurer was a blind guy single lived with his mom wonderful wonderful guy loved to talk to people on the phone I'm an airline pilot with at the time three little kids I was gone half the time um you don't have to do the same thing each guy's got his own gifts and passions and experience some guys would love Presbytery some guys would hate Presbytery meetings I mean um so yeah I'm an advocate of uh I don't know individual gift um usage or something like that might might have some specialties I uh two guys that are not on our session anymore one guy um I would not put in front of a Sunday school class but I'd always grab him to go do a hospital visit and another guy was our clerk and he could teach but yeah I'm gonna ask the other guy I'm not gonna have him come to our hospital visits and yeah I remember on that with that nursery policy of Providence uh Don the blind guy and another and an elder who had no kids one day just happened to be that they were assigned to the nursery and moms were walking up to the nursery door with their babies and just turning around walking away like neither one of these guys ever changed a diaper yeah and uh Don Maurer actually will play the piano for us every now and then so I know Don't guy.
[39:16] SPEAKER_02: I love Don.
[39:17] SPEAKER_02: I love him.
[39:17] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[39:18] SPEAKER_01: Yeah well um kind of to wrap up I I'm gonna try this as something of an experiment um uh if we if we do something of an interview I uh we're gonna try to do a a lightning round and this is just kind of a this or this and you can give me a sentence or two if you want to explain your answer but if you just want to give me an answer you can or uh if you want to avoid the question um then um that that's on you too so uh you ready just this is like seven or or so this or this all right all right hodge or thornwell hodge hodge um no any explanation or just hodge just hodge all right um marvel or DC I had no idea neither wine or grape juice wine uh supra or infralapsarian um hyper cigar cigar um is it pronounced GIF or GIF GIF you're talking about peanut butter right I'm talking about the little files yeah um what about um okay and do you call it call the question or move the previous question um call the question is fine with me it's fine with you if just colloquial uh use of it's good all right well that that's an authoritative answer now we have a that was fun that was easy all right well hey thank you so much uh how we for uh joining us for this um just um good to get some advice to uh people about being a good churchman about when and when not to write an overture and a little bit of insight into what you did and uh just thank you for um being a churchman and for uh joining us here today so any any last things you want to say something i just remembered is that you know you can't ask an SJC guy about a pending case but there's I've got a list of um 10 or 12 guys that have been on the SJC that aren't on right now and when people ask me stuff I just send it to them I said you can contact one of these guys um and that that would help people a lot I think um so are you talking about writing overtures or are you talking about if something happens within the church you got something there's a there's a case pending you're a clerk of a presbytery and there's an appeal and…
[42:00] SPEAKER_01: Well I'll I may need to get that list from you at some point.
[42:02] SPEAKER_01: I think it'd be a good idea idea to at some point have some sort of a guide for uh people that are wondering how does the process work or if something happens in the church and they they want to know what are what are my options and uh to get something like a a short guide or a pamphlet for that.
[42:18] SPEAKER_01: You can't always hand people that that large DASA report it would be good to have something that's a little bit right uh more digestible.
[42:24] SPEAKER_01: So yeah for sure.
[42:25] SPEAKER_00: Yeah well again thanks a lot uh for yeah for joining us today howry my pleasure thanks for doing this all right thank you bye bye bye well thank you for joining us for this first installment of Called Meeting if you're interested in learning more about anything we addressed check out the show notes in your podcast player or at politymatters dot org.
[42:45] SPEAKER_00: If you enjoyed the show consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters and subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[42:53] SPEAKER_00: If you have questions or comments you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail dot com.
[42:58] SPEAKER_00: A special thanks to Howie for joining us on the show today.
[43:01] SPEAKER_00: He serves the PCA in many ways from the local church all the way up to the General Assembly and we are grateful for all of his work.
[43:07] SPEAKER_00: Scott as you remember is the senior minister of Providence PCA in Troy Illinois you can find him on Twitter at SEDberg if you're looking for Jared he's the pastor of New Life Presbyterian Church of Hope Wall Township in Aliquipa Pennsylvania and he's on Twitter at BrotherNelson.
[43:21] SPEAKER_00: I serve as the associate pastor at Covenant Presbyterian Church in Cleveland Mississippi and I'm on Twitter at underscore Ben Ratliff as always thank you for spending time with us y'all take care of it

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
