# 84. BCO 36 The Infliction of Church Censures

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 13 May 2025, 1 h 02 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/17148248-84-bco-36-the-infliction-of-church-censures.mp3

Dr. Waters joins the guys to discuss the infliction of censures. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Introductions
- 6:41 BCO 36-1
- 13:01 BCO 36-2
- 23:38 BCO 36-3
- 31:53 BCO 36-4
- 37:03 BCO 36-5
- 44:00 BCO 36-6
- 55:07 BCO 36-7
- 59:20 Conclusions

## Transcript

[0:05] SPEAKER_04: Hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:07] SPEAKER_04: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined by your friends and mine, Scott Edberg and Jared Nelson, and we are glad to have another of our friends back with us today, Dr.
[0:16] SPEAKER_04: Guy Waters, as we jump into BCO 36, The Infliction of Church Centures.
[0:22] SPEAKER_04: Dr.
[0:22] SPEAKER_04: Waters, I didn't ask you this before we started recording, but I think that you have traveled to foreign lands since the last time we saw you.
[0:28] SPEAKER_04: Is there anything of interest to report?
[0:32] SPEAKER_00: There is, and this is not the subject of the podcast, but I was in Kenya and Uganda.
[0:38] SPEAKER_00: I serve on the board of Rafiki Foundation, and one of the encouraging things that I was able to do that week is meet with church partners, uh, Anglican, Lutheran, and Presbyterian.
[0:51] SPEAKER_00: The Church of Jesus Christ is alive and well, not without its problems and challenges, of course, as we, but the church is doing well.
[1:00] SPEAKER_00: And then I spent a week in São Paulo, Brazil.
[1:03] SPEAKER_00: We have a partnership here at RTS with the Sister Institution, Mackenzie University, the Jumper Center for Postgraduate Study, and spent a delightful week with 44 pastors and seminary professors of the Presbyterian Church in Brazil.
[1:20] SPEAKER_00: Your listeners may not know it, but the Presbyterian Church of Brazil has been around since 1859 when Ashbell Green Simontons stepped off the boat from the U.S.
[1:30] SPEAKER_00: and Rio de Janeiro.
[1:32] SPEAKER_00: And they are a million strong, uh thriving, not again, not without its problems and challenges, but uh good work going on down in Brazil.
[1:42] SPEAKER_00: So glad to be home in my own time zone and back with you, gents.
[1:47] SPEAKER_00: Yes, sir.
[1:48] SPEAKER_04: Interesting, maybe maybe well known, but not commonly thought of.
[1:52] SPEAKER_04: The Brazilian Presbyterians sound a lot cooler than us.
[1:56] SPEAKER_00: I'm I'm afraid you're right, Dan.
[1:58] SPEAKER_00: As as with most points of comparison, Brazil shows up the U.S.
[2:03] SPEAKER_00: on many metrics.
[2:04] SPEAKER_00: Music, food, you run down the line.
[2:07] unknown: Oh man.
[2:08] SPEAKER_04: Well, thank you for traveling back to be with us today.
[2:12] SPEAKER_04: Um we're in 36, guys.
[2:14] SPEAKER_04: Uh you know, we talk about a lot of these things, but we we remind our listeners that church discipline is one of the distinguishing marks of a true church.
[2:23] SPEAKER_04: And there's often things misunderstood about this.
[2:25] SPEAKER_04: Uh maybe some things feared about church discipline.
[2:29] SPEAKER_04: And um and maybe n nothing tops that list higher than the actual infliction of church censures.
[2:36] SPEAKER_04: Uh BCO 36 brings us the form and encourages the solemnity to this stage of the discipline process, and it's it was helpful for me in thinking through it that this chapter is not about when to discipline, but about how it should be administered when the time comes.
[2:52] SPEAKER_04: So my first question, uh I think, is for us to try to consider why why is it important that the church have a formal and orderly process for inflicting censures?
[3:06] SPEAKER_00: Well, uh it's a great question.
[3:09] SPEAKER_00: I think the infliction of a censure is at one level the conclusion of the process of discipline.
[3:19] SPEAKER_00: And it's an act of the church, uh, and so when a censure is inflicted, that is the church acting and speaking.
[3:30] SPEAKER_00: And in some cases, we we may talk about this, it becomes uh important, advisable, even necessary to communicate this to the church for its own edification and and for the good of the person receiving the infliction.
[3:48] SPEAKER_00: So I think wisely our Presbyterian fathers didn't leave this to our imagination or devices to work out.
[3:56] SPEAKER_00: I think a lot of harm could have been done.
[3:59] SPEAKER_00: Uh having an orderly pattern uh helps to prevent uh a lot of the problems that can come with the sensitivities that surface in matters of church discipline and bringing that to a godly conclusion.
[4:17] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, it's it's significant that the language that's used here is a spirit of meekness.
[4:22] SPEAKER_03: Um and I I think that gives you more of the tone of uh laying out one of these censures is uh we may have some anger, uh anger at the fact that there's been something that's been done, um something along those lines, but there's also a sense of sadness, whether it's even just for the victims uh of uh whatever had been done.
[4:43] SPEAKER_03: Uh, but there's uh there's also just a sense of uh the solemnity of it that um the way this is done is to realize, but for the grace of God, um this can happen to any um sinner.
[4:55] SPEAKER_03: And so uh I think it's it's just significant that the how is is just this sense of this is not um this is not an angry time, this is this is a solemn time.
[5:05] SPEAKER_03: Uh there's some there's some sadness that's attached to this.
[5:08] SPEAKER_00: That's right.
[5:08] SPEAKER_00: And that that's a great point, Jared.
[5:10] SPEAKER_00: You know, that that's a critical difference between justice in the state and justice in the church.
[5:18] SPEAKER_00: Justice in the state's retributive.
[5:20] SPEAKER_00: And we've all seen sentencing hearings on TV, perhaps we've been present at some, and uh the the anger, the vituperation, uh sometimes coming from the bench, is palpable.
[5:32] SPEAKER_00: And that's never to characterize discipline in the church at any stage.
[5:37] SPEAKER_00: Uh discipline is always done, as you say, with with a sense of sorrow and solemnity.
[5:43] SPEAKER_00: This is not something we're we're relishing or delighting in.
[5:47] SPEAKER_00: And as the provision reminds us, that but for God's grace, we would be in precisely where this person is who's receiving the censure.
[5:57] SPEAKER_00: I mean, I there this opening paragraph, 36.1, it's using language that echoes 32.1, where Galatians 6.1 is to be cited at the commencement of trial.
[6:14] SPEAKER_00: And so I think it's appropriate that we end the process as we begin the process with a reminder that all of this needs to be done with uh a temper of gentleness and a self-awareness that I'm as subject to temptation as anyone else.
[6:33] SPEAKER_00: And that, as much as anything, is going to distinguish this proceeding from anything else outside the church.
[6:42] SPEAKER_04: Let me let me get us into 36.1.
[6:45] SPEAKER_04: Um it's it's these first two sections that that do a lot of what we've already described.
[6:50] SPEAKER_04: They set the tone for these inflictions, and then three through seven kind of prescribe the the particular uh formulas, if you will.
[6:59] SPEAKER_04: So into thirty-six one says, When any member or officer of the church shall be found guilty of an offense, the court shall proceed with all tenderness and shall deal with its offending brother in the spirit of meekness, the members considering themselves lest they also be tempted.
[7:16] SPEAKER_04: And just because it is there's a clear reference here, and and Dr.
[7:19] SPEAKER_04: Waters has already uh mentioned it, Galatians 6 1 reads, Brothers, if anyone is caught in any transgression, you who are spiritual should restore him in a spirit of gentleness.
[7:29] SPEAKER_04: Keep watch on yourself lest you too be tempted.
[7:32] SPEAKER_04: Um maybe beyond what we've already discussed, let's tease out a little bit.
[7:37] SPEAKER_04: What does it mean for for a court to proceed with tenderness?
[7:43] SPEAKER_04: Uh, what is it to for a court to behave with meekness toward an offending brother?
[7:51] SPEAKER_00: Well, I think you know, d gentleness stands in opposition to to harshness, uh severity, uh a retributive spirit.
[8:03] SPEAKER_00: And we we could think of it this way that discipline is calculated to do many things in the church.
[8:10] SPEAKER_00: We're we're glorifying God, we're preserving, uh humanly speaking, the holiness of the church, but we're also seeking, especially, the restoration of the offender.
[8:23] SPEAKER_00: And and just as in your own family, if uh a family member has offended you, if you go at them barrels of blazing, that's not calculated to win them.
[8:35] SPEAKER_00: Uh it's when you approach them in humility and gentleness and meekness that you're you're best able to have a profitable conversation.
[8:46] SPEAKER_00: So I think what this provision is reminding us is that look, what are we about here?
[8:52] SPEAKER_00: We're not about letting loose on this fellow.
[8:55] SPEAKER_00: Uh we're we're not about pending all this pent-up frustration pouring it out on him on this occasion.
[9:03] SPEAKER_00: We're doing this in the hopes that in in God's hands it'll be the means of his restoration.
[9:09] SPEAKER_00: And we're we're taking God at his word that if we carry ourselves with this disposition, that he may well bless that for this person's good.
[9:20] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it's almost it's very difficult to see a man restored when there's act of combativeness against the man with any committee that's erected to oversee a shepherding.
[9:32] SPEAKER_02: And so if there is a hostile relationship between the Presbytery and the man who's been inflicted of the censure, that the man who is under censure feels under the microscope of every correspondence, he's gonna be very measured in how he honestly appeals and works with that committee.
[9:49] SPEAKER_02: It's gonna be difficult.
[9:50] SPEAKER_02: Um, and so if there's a hostile combativeness between the presbytery and the one who's been found guilty, it's it is very hard, like you said, Dr.
[9:58] SPEAKER_02: Waters, to see any sort of fruitful endeavor from that relationship.
[10:03] unknown: Right.
[10:04] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and I I think that's part of the uh whoever's conducting the trial, that's part of the reason why they need to take extra measures to ensure that they're carrying themselves impartially in all their proceedings.
[10:21] SPEAKER_00: Because as you say, if there's a sense in which if if uh a person who's found guilty believes that the deck was stacked against them and they were never going to need a fair hearing anyway, uh they they may not be persuaded out of that.
[10:36] SPEAKER_00: But I think the the court and whoever's conducting the trial needs to bend over backwards to ensure that everything is not just done uh fairly, impartially, gently, but it's done in such a way as to be perceived by an impartial public as such.
[10:54] SPEAKER_00: And I think that's that's why Galatians six is to be read not only at the beginning of the process, but it's brought into view at the very end of the process.
[11:06] SPEAKER_00: It is to cover the whole of the proceeding.
[11:11] SPEAKER_04: I would I would guess that this particular section s would surprise a lot of people in the language that we use in the infliction of censures, just because I think I mean we've talked Scott kind of referenced it there, that the the discipline process can sound really bad to to people that don't know very well.
[11:31] SPEAKER_04: Um but but you know, this this would be one of the parag one of the paragraphs, Jared, that we would use in our BCO devotional that we're gonna write one day.
[11:39] SPEAKER_04: Um you know, that we that tenderness and meekness and brotherly, you know, counsel and and shepherding and and all these things that are built into this.
[11:47] SPEAKER_04: Um it it is it's a very spiritual matter, and um I think folks would be encouraged here at the end of the day.
[11:55] SPEAKER_00: And and and just speaking from experience, I mean, unfortunately our Presbyteries had on a number of occasions to to inflict censures.
[12:05] SPEAKER_00: And I'm I've been struck not just with the solemnity of the proceeding, but the the quantity of tears that were shed within the court.
[12:16] SPEAKER_00: I mean, it's it's clear this is done out of great sorrow, out of a longing to see this brother restored.
[12:23] SPEAKER_00: And I mean there these aren't manufactured tears, they're sincere.
[12:28] SPEAKER_00: And, you know, I think however a a body of elders carries itself, that that ought to be evident to anyone watching.
[12:37] SPEAKER_00: This is not something the court uh has been ginning up to do.
[12:41] SPEAKER_00: It's being done with with great sorrow and care and love for this fellow, e even though it's a hard thing.
[12:47] SPEAKER_00: I mean, to give or to receive, church discipline is a hard thing.
[12:51] SPEAKER_00: But the spirit of it uh needs needs to be Christian through and through, just as discipline itself is uh to be Christian through and through.
[13:01] SPEAKER_04: 362 continues uh uh uh giving us instruction and and how to conduct these things.
[13:08] SPEAKER_04: Church censures and the modes of administering them should be suited to the nature of the offenses.
[13:14] SPEAKER_04: For private offenses, censure should be administered in the presence of the court alone, or in private by one or more members of the court.
[13:21] SPEAKER_04: In the case of public offenses, the degree of censure and mode of administering it shall be within the discretion of the court, acting in accordance with paragraphs below which deal with particular censures.
[13:33] SPEAKER_04: So just just so that we're clear, for those who may be listening, but it it would be good to go read this paragraph to see how things line up.
[13:41] SPEAKER_04: You're you're trying to match the mode of administration to the nature of the offense.
[13:46] SPEAKER_04: Um so so how do you inflict it?
[13:49] SPEAKER_04: What's what's the the who's gonna be present?
[13:52] SPEAKER_04: What's the context of the infliction?
[13:54] SPEAKER_04: Is it in line with the nature of the offense?
[13:57] SPEAKER_04: And and y'all, some, you know, Dr.
[13:58] SPEAKER_04: Waters, you may want to tease that out for us a little bit more here in a minute, but what what what biblical principles undergird this will be a little review, the distinction between private and public?
[14:10] SPEAKER_04: Because it may be helpful to to distinguish the nature of of an offense as private or public as we try to understand how to how to administer the censure.
[14:19] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, Ben, I think uh the the distinction is um defined at 29-4.
[14:27] SPEAKER_00: Uh private offenses are those which are known only to a few persons, public offenses are those which are notorious, uh, and and notoriety meaning that they they're matters of of common fame knowledge.
[14:42] SPEAKER_00: Um I think you see that distinction reflected in Scripture, Matthew 18.
[14:48] SPEAKER_00: If your brother sins against you, so there's a personal offense that in context is private, you're to go and rebuke him.
[14:56] SPEAKER_00: And then if his impenitence continues, then you're to widen the circle until the church is involved.
[15:06] SPEAKER_00: So uh private offense is dealt with privately.
[15:10] SPEAKER_00: And then uh public offenses, you we could think of teaching heresy, and you think of the way that Paul calls out people in the pastoral epistles by name for, say, denying the resurrection.
[15:24] SPEAKER_00: Uh we don't know, but I wouldn't say that Paul would have been obligated to go and confront these people in private.
[15:32] SPEAKER_00: I mean, they've committed a public offense, and so Paul is dealing with that offense within the same sphere that that sin was committed.
[15:43] SPEAKER_00: So that that seems to be the principle that in in whatever sphere the sin was committed, uh, as much as possible you you keep the disciplinary process within that sphere.
[15:53] SPEAKER_00: At times that that sphere will have to be expanded.
[15:56] SPEAKER_00: And what I I think is going on in 36-2 is that that principle carries all the way through the disciplinary process.
[16:05] SPEAKER_00: So it's not as though you can you can be private and discreet to a point, and then you just broadcast it to the world at the end.
[16:13] SPEAKER_00: Um you you have to carry the same principles that were driving you uh through the disciplinary process out to the conclusion of the disciplinary process.
[16:26] SPEAKER_02: So in private offenses, uh it's kind of gets mucky with pastors because there are real-world implications if a pastor is suspended from the ministry and he's no longer in his pulpit.
[16:38] SPEAKER_02: Um, and if it's a private offense that's only administered in the context of the court, often churches feel left out.
[16:45] SPEAKER_02: They don't know what's going on.
[16:47] SPEAKER_02: Um, and so how can how can a church court, the presbytery, better help navigate a congregation who has a their pastor censured?
[16:57] SPEAKER_02: They don't really know the reason why he's censured or what's going on, but they know that they don't have a pastor anymore.
[17:03] SPEAKER_02: Sometimes it seems that it's like smoke-filled rooms that they're not allowed to be in.
[17:07] SPEAKER_02: And so how can a presbytery help navigate a church when a pastor falls under a private uh sin that he's censured for?
[17:15] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[17:17] SPEAKER_00: Well, I think that that's a it's a fair concern, a pastoral concern.
[17:22] SPEAKER_00: And it, you know, I think you're right in saying to begin, look, the congregation doesn't play a role in the disciplinary process.
[17:32] SPEAKER_00: That's that's a critical point of distinction between a lot of forms of congregational polity where they do, and Presbyterian polity where it's the officers of the church jointly engaging in the discipline of uh a member or an officer of the church.
[17:53] SPEAKER_00: So certainly there has to be some way, and we we can talk about this further, perhaps, of communicating appropriately within appropriate sphere the action of the presbytery to the church.
[18:08] SPEAKER_00: I I don't think they should uh wake up and find out about it on the internet or on the local news, hey, the presbytery has censured this person.
[18:19] SPEAKER_00: And if, and and there usually are, if if the church has a session uh in place uh for that church, then the that particular session can be an important intermediary between the presbytery and the congregation.
[18:36] SPEAKER_00: Presumably members of session have participated at some level in the disciplinary proceedings, perhaps even as commissioners to the presbytery, and they ought to take initiative, or presbytery ought to take initiative to work with the session to ensure that these matters get communicated timely and sensitively to the congregation.
[19:00] SPEAKER_03: Well, I think this would be um really relevant, especially with admonition, wouldn't it?
[19:05] SPEAKER_03: Um if there's some something where, say, an officer in your church, you know, he he gets into an argument with somebody else in the church, curses them out, and um, you know, that person comes to the station tells them about it, and you know, there's there's other circumstances around it.
[19:21] SPEAKER_03: They had just lost a family member, they had just you know gone through these things, he's really repented about it, and those are the only two people that know.
[19:28] SPEAKER_03: Um that might be an instance in which you think about the Ninth Commandment covering over infirmities.
[19:34] SPEAKER_03: The other guy says, Yeah, I just like to keep this between us, but I think he does need to be admonished about um dealing with these things in different ways.
[19:42] SPEAKER_03: And so that might be something where there's an admonishment, it's kept private, and we'd see that it's appropriate of covering over an infirmity that is not a characteristic.
[19:52] SPEAKER_00: So that's right.
[19:53] SPEAKER_00: And and that's where discretion comes in on the part of the session.
[19:57] SPEAKER_00: And you know, we remember what Paul says, let all things be done for edification.
[20:02] SPEAKER_00: And so that's uh a sine qua non that w we can only communicate this in any way if insofar as it serves to edify.
[20:13] SPEAKER_00: And if if we're just dumping fuel on the fire of of gossip and slander and an innuendo, then no, we we can't communicate this.
[20:22] SPEAKER_00: So there's an element of discretion, and and our book, I think, allows courts, affords courts, that kind of discretion under each censure.
[20:37] SPEAKER_04: Let me see if I can phrase this properly.
[20:39] SPEAKER_04: It seems that we have instructions and guidelines here for for keeping something uh maybe we would say as close as possible or as close as necessary.
[20:48] SPEAKER_04: We want to be careful not to let it out too far.
[20:52] SPEAKER_04: W are are there also in this uh is does this also serve as a guideline on the on the other side that um some things ought to be brought out?
[21:03] SPEAKER_04: Uh and maybe we get into that more when we talk about the excommunication and deposition uh uh formalities down further, but there are some things that should be made public.
[21:13] SPEAKER_04: Um I think uh for maybe it was Ramsey that talked about that.
[21:16] SPEAKER_04: I think he said earlier than our section comes up that excommunication and deposition should be administered before um the church or even announced to it.
[21:27] SPEAKER_04: Does that track at all or is that does that fit in here?
[21:29] SPEAKER_04: I I'm just trying to process out loud maybe what some listeners are thinking through.
[21:32] SPEAKER_00: So yeah.
[21:33] SPEAKER_00: I I and I'm glad you raised that, Ben, because in c couple of examples.
[21:38] SPEAKER_00: One one would be if you're looking at the the discipline of a church officer compared to a church member who's not an officer, then I think there are considerations that factor into the how how widely are we we gonna make any kind of announcement about the discipline of this officer.
[22:00] SPEAKER_00: Because he is put before the church as an example in character, in doctrine, in life.
[22:07] SPEAKER_00: And so any kind of failing or transgression on his part in that respect has a there's a magnitude to it that would not be true of a of a non-officer.
[22:19] SPEAKER_00: I think also whether you're dealing with a a church officer or or not, if something is attained uh notoriety, you know, if it's being reported on the news, and particularly if you're in a you're in a smaller community and it's it's widely known, if the church says nothing at all, or is thought to say nothing at all, I mean that that can add a measure of scandal to the matter.
[22:49] SPEAKER_00: Look at what this person did, and the church, they're just closing ranks.
[22:54] SPEAKER_00: They're not doing anything, they're just sitting on their hands and pretending like it didn't even happen.
[22:59] SPEAKER_00: You know, isn't that something of the church to do?
[23:01] SPEAKER_00: And we we we would never want that to be communicated.
[23:05] SPEAKER_00: Um, we're we're not gonna we're not gonna deal unjustly or um carelessly with somebody who's been convicted and is being censured uh just to protect ourselves.
[23:24] SPEAKER_00: That's not what we're saying.
[23:25] SPEAKER_00: But there are times when when some kind of public statement or disclosure uh ha has to be made.
[23:33] SPEAKER_00: And again, that that's going to be left to the discretion of the session.
[23:38] SPEAKER_04: 363.
[23:40] SPEAKER_04: The censure of admonition should be administered in private by one or more members of the court if the offense is known only to a few and is not aggravated in character.
[23:49] SPEAKER_04: If the offense is public, the admonition should be administered by the moderator in presence of the court and may also be announced in public should the court deem it expedient.
[23:59] SPEAKER_04: Just to remind everyone, this is uh talking about the infliction of what's defined in BCO thirty, section two.
[24:07] SPEAKER_04: Admonition is formal reproof of an offender by a church court, warning him of his guilt and danger, and exhorting him to be more circumspect and watchful in the future.
[24:17] SPEAKER_04: Umbe the first thing here is just for us to refresh a little bit.
[24:22] SPEAKER_04: What distinguishes formal admonition in this sense from you know informal pastoral counsel or what some people would call admonition?
[24:33] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I I think and and I we've even got the the text here to help us, there's there's capital A admonition, which is what we're looking at here in section three, and there's small A admonition.
[24:46] SPEAKER_00: You know, admonition small A is uh of different levels or grades.
[24:52] SPEAKER_00: It it happens spontaneously when Christians are talking to each other, but but can even extend as far as an elder meeting with a church member and having a pretty sober conversation with them about something in their life.
[25:11] SPEAKER_00: But that's different than what we're talking about here.
[25:14] SPEAKER_00: This is a censure, it's administered by a court in conclusion or upon conclusion of judicial process.
[25:24] SPEAKER_00: Um in this case, the person has come forward, they've made confession, or they've been found guilty at trial.
[25:33] SPEAKER_00: This is often confused, I think partly because the scripture uses the lowercase a admonish in in a variety of senses, but I think in ways that admit of what we're looking at here in in paragraph three.
[25:49] SPEAKER_00: So I think keeping these categories straight in our own thinking will help us from blurring categories and making mistakes.
[25:59] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think it's good to remember admonition is the end of a process as well, where there's no nothing to correct, there's nothing to do outside of sin no more.
[26:11] SPEAKER_02: Um and so the court exhorts you to refrain from falling back into that sin, but you remember in good standing after the censure is delivered.
[26:20] SPEAKER_02: Um it's the lightest censure in that regard, where uh you can take the Lord's Supper the following Sunday.
[26:27] SPEAKER_02: There's nothing prohibiting you from doing so.
[26:29] SPEAKER_02: Um, there's nothing that needs to be done.
[26:31] SPEAKER_02: I was talking with a friend a few weeks ago that said they were going to go to forward to censoring a man with admonition, and then they're like, Well, what do we do to remove that?
[26:41] SPEAKER_02: And I'm like, there's there's nothing you need to do to remove that.
[26:44] SPEAKER_02: They don't need to meet with you anymore or do anything else.
[26:47] SPEAKER_02: You might want them to, you can request them to, but there's no conditions to remove that censure.
[26:52] SPEAKER_02: It's been administered, you've admonished, and now you're done.
[26:56] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[26:57] SPEAKER_00: That's a great point.
[27:01] SPEAKER_04: Just uh, you know, we may feel like we're repeating ourselves some, but in in the instance that somebody has pulled up this episode and has jumped immediately to this section to talk about 36-3.
[27:12] SPEAKER_04: Maybe uh help us think through Dr.
[27:15] SPEAKER_04: Waters a a situation where it might be wise to announce an admonition to the congregation.
[27:21] SPEAKER_04: I wonder if it could be easy for somebody thinking through admonition as sort of a lesser censure, which it certainly is, but you don't need to announce that to everybody.
[27:29] SPEAKER_04: That's just something for that person individually.
[27:32] SPEAKER_04: Where might a public admonition come into play?
[27:35] SPEAKER_00: Well, I I can't remember if I shared this last time or not, but let me let me give an example of, I mean, this happened years ago in in one of our churches.
[27:44] SPEAKER_00: So a young woman, member of uh uh PCA church, becomes pregnant out of wedlock.
[27:50] SPEAKER_00: And of course, you're pregnant, that's that's something at some point you you just can't hide.
[27:55] SPEAKER_00: So she she came before the session and she she confessed her sin.
[28:00] SPEAKER_00: The session then proceeded to inflict the censure of admonition, and as Scott said, that that concluded the process.
[28:09] SPEAKER_00: But then what the session did, they I thought this was brilliant.
[28:13] SPEAKER_00: They went to the congregation and they said, uh Ms.
[28:17] SPEAKER_00: So-and-so's come before us.
[28:19] SPEAKER_00: She has been formally admonished, she is no longer under discipline.
[28:24] SPEAKER_00: Uh you you are to treat her with um the way you would treat any other church member.
[28:29] SPEAKER_00: We are going to rally around her, care for her, love her, provide for her.
[28:34] SPEAKER_00: And at the sessions leading, the congregation rallied.
[28:37] SPEAKER_00: So I think that's a marvelous example of how discipline is supposed to work.
[28:42] SPEAKER_00: There's a case where public announcement of admonition really ticks all the boxes of church discipline, and in this case, worked out for this person's good.
[28:54] SPEAKER_02: I've seen that exact thing in a church.
[28:56] SPEAKER_02: And uh in that pastoral letter to the congregation, the the session also exhorted the congregation to not gossip.
[29:04] SPEAKER_02: That they have been they have everything has been resolved.
[29:07] SPEAKER_02: We have confessed these sins, and when this child is is born, they are joining the covenant community like any other child.
[29:15] SPEAKER_02: And so that exact thing happened.
[29:17] SPEAKER_02: It's always you don't get those beautiful situations often, but when they do happen, um it's a blessing to the church.
[29:25] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[29:26] SPEAKER_03: It becomes important, I think, to show to the congregation that you don't approve of what they did.
[29:31] SPEAKER_03: And so that both says to the congregation, we're aware this is this was not good, but then it also has a don't follow that example.
[29:39] SPEAKER_03: We are saying this is not what you're supposed to do.
[29:42] SPEAKER_03: Um so in a sense, you're taking the 36-1 and applying it to the entire congregation, right?
[29:47] SPEAKER_03: Uh don't be tempted in this way.
[29:49] SPEAKER_03: This this isn't this isn't good, uh, and then allows you to move on from there.
[29:53] SPEAKER_00: That's right.
[29:55] SPEAKER_00: Let me just say something at this point.
[29:57] SPEAKER_00: Um uh just about announcements generally.
[30:01] SPEAKER_00: I'm I'm not an attorney.
[30:02] SPEAKER_00: This is not legal advice, but we do live in a litigious culture, and I I just think it would would be folly not to be aware that making public declarations of um uh of offenses uh uh of this sort uh can, if not done carefully and according to law, expose one to litigation.
[30:32] SPEAKER_00: So that's something I think sessions and presbyteries want to think through pretty carefully.
[30:38] SPEAKER_00: Um and one way to make an announcement is to write a letter or to have a congregational meeting, make a verbal announcement, but ensure that non-members are sent out from the room.
[30:52] SPEAKER_00: Um there are lots of ways to go about doing this.
[30:55] SPEAKER_00: I I don't think that the only response to the uh prospect of litigation is just to clam up and say nothing at all.
[31:05] SPEAKER_00: But I don't think we should just blaze ahead uh as as though this weren't a concern.
[31:10] SPEAKER_00: You know, it is a concern, and and there's some legitimate reasons for that.
[31:14] SPEAKER_00: But that's just something that sessions and presbyteries need to keep before them.
[31:18] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and and don't live stream it.
[31:22] SPEAKER_00: Turn it off.
[31:23] SPEAKER_00: Yes.
[31:25] SPEAKER_00: Oh man.
[31:27] SPEAKER_00: And and happily um lawyers abound in sessions and presbyteries in the PCA, so you probably won't have to hunt far to find someone with some legal background and expertise.
[31:41] SPEAKER_00: Did you say happily?
[31:42] SPEAKER_00: Huh.
[31:42] SPEAKER_00: That's interesting.
[31:48] SPEAKER_04: Okay.
[31:49] SPEAKER_04: So add admonition there in section three, and then we move along.
[31:53] SPEAKER_04: Um four and five are going to deal with with suspension, uh, definite and indefinite respectively.
[32:02] SPEAKER_04: So well, let's let me just read it and we'll get into it.
[32:06] SPEAKER_04: So 364, definite suspension from office should be administered in the presence of the court alone or in open session of the court as may deem best, and public announcement thereof shall be at the court's discretion.
[32:18] SPEAKER_04: So again, just a reminder, back to chapter 30, which Dr.
[32:22] SPEAKER_04: Waters, we thought about earlier, has was sat with us and discussed chapter 30, so go back and see that episode.
[32:27] SPEAKER_04: Um, suspension from office uh is the exclusion of a church officer from his office.
[32:33] SPEAKER_04: Definite suspension is administered on the credit of religion, the honor of Christ, and the good of the delinquent demand it, even though the delinquent has given satisfaction to the court.
[32:42] SPEAKER_04: So we may connect this to admonition that there's repentance present in this individual, though they have been found guilty of an offense, and suspension, uh definite suspension has been deemed appropriate.
[32:55] SPEAKER_04: Uh I really am just going to kind of open this up.
[32:58] SPEAKER_04: Uh w what's important here to point out?
[33:00] SPEAKER_04: We've talked about definite suspension, now we've talked about admonition being administered.
[33:05] SPEAKER_04: What is there for us to tease out here?
[33:13] SPEAKER_04: Jared or Scott, y'all have any any sort of thoughts from from experience?
[33:17] SPEAKER_04: Anything to to ask our esteemed guest?
[33:21] SPEAKER_04: Well uh I I'll ask this, why, maybe to revisit something from chapter thirty, why is it uh appropriate to administer this even after repentance has has been the congregation has to know why this elder or this deacon isn't serving currently.
[33:38] SPEAKER_03: And so um i to to cut off rumors, to cut off gossip, this is it it it's helpful to the congregation to say this is why you're not gonna see this person serving for this period of time.
[33:51] SPEAKER_00: And I think for that person, you know, to have the Church of Jesus Christ pronounce a censure is it's a hard thing to receive, but what a uh powerful means, a check, when temptation to sin arises again.
[34:10] SPEAKER_00: You know, to to remember that moment, that experience, boy, I don't want to do this again.
[34:16] SPEAKER_00: Um so that it's not to humiliate a person, not to grind them in into the dust, but it it's designed to impress on them, brother, you professed repentance, you need to keep on in repentance, you're gonna be facing temptations in this and other areas, and so this is given as a help to you to to press on in bearing fruit for repentance and maintaining a consistent Christian lifestyle.
[34:46] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, it was Morton Smith that wrote sort of summarizing to a degree some offenses are so serious that there must be some sanction imposed despite the repentance of the offender.
[34:56] SPEAKER_00: That's right.
[34:59] SPEAKER_00: Good.
[34:59] SPEAKER_00: And I would just note, um, Ben, that 365 the the paragraph globs together suspension from office and sacraments.
[35:09] SPEAKER_00: I I think we just recognize and and maybe here just cross-reference our discussion in 30 that those are distinguishable censures, they're distinct censures, and uh one may be suspended from office, but not necessarily from the sacraments.
[35:26] SPEAKER_00: Um they sometimes go together, but they they needn't go together in every case.
[35:32] SPEAKER_02: Dr.
[35:33] SPEAKER_02: Waters, uh your Presbytery is sending up a couple overtures concerning these sections.
[35:38] SPEAKER_02: Uh are you the author of these overtures?
[35:40] SPEAKER_02: What's the rationale behind some of the overtures being sent up to amend 36, 4, and 5?
[35:47] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, well, that that arose out of a recent experience in our presbytery, uh really having to do with the infliction of censures.
[35:58] SPEAKER_00: Um I I I played a part more editorial than authorial.
[36:03] SPEAKER_00: I I think the changes are fairly modest as these things go.
[36:07] SPEAKER_00: We're not trying to add a new paragraph or rewrite language, but just give a little more direction and clarity to church courts, especially the poor moderator on whom it falls to inflict the censure, what language to use and not to use in any given censure.
[36:25] SPEAKER_00: So we've submitted this to the wisdom and judgment of the church.
[36:29] SPEAKER_00: If the church thinks it's a good idea, uh great.
[36:32] SPEAKER_00: Uh if not, then I hope someone will come up with acceptable language, because I do think these paragraphs could stand a little more elaboration from the standpoint of implementation at the moment of the infliction.
[36:46] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, and 34 uh 36.4, it would add just a paragraph for the moderator to address the body and then the body's response, which is prayer for the one who's been inflicted this entry.
[36:59] SPEAKER_04: Mm-hmm.
[36:59] SPEAKER_02: That's right.
[37:03] SPEAKER_04: Well, we've we've kind of referred to it already, um, because they're they are connected, these two sections.
[37:09] SPEAKER_04: Let me read 36.5, and this can be a time for listeners to take a nap.
[37:13] SPEAKER_04: Um, but I would hope for my companions here as I'm reading, if anything comes to mind that we need to comment on here, uh, make note and and uh speak up here in just a moment.
[37:22] SPEAKER_04: 36.5, indefinite suspension from office or the sacraments should be administered after the manner prescribed for definite suspension, but with added solemnity.
[37:32] SPEAKER_04: That the indefinite suspension may be the means of impressing the mind of the delinquent with a proper sense of his danger.
[37:38] SPEAKER_04: Indefinite suspension should also be administered under the blessing of God of leading him to repentance.
[37:44] SPEAKER_04: When the court is resolved to pass this sentence, the moderator shall address the offending brother to the following purpose.
[37:50] SPEAKER_04: Whereas you are convicted by sufficient proof, or are guilty by your own confession of the sin of, and you insert it there, we the church or presbytery in the name of the in the name and by the authority of the Lord Jesus Christ do not declare you suspended from the sacraments of the church and from the exercise of your office until you give satisfactory evidence of repentance.
[38:12] SPEAKER_04: To this shall be added such advice or admonition as may be judged necessary, and the whole shall be concluded with prayer to Almighty God that he would follow this act of discipline with his blessing.
[38:24] SPEAKER_04: Maybe we do need to comment here a little bit about the added solemnity uh in in mind with indefinite suspension.
[38:31] SPEAKER_04: What it may be evident uh as we read it, but let's let's just ask the question why uh why is indefinite suspension especially solemn?
[38:41] SPEAKER_00: Yes.
[38:42] SPEAKER_00: Well, I think you know, added solemnity, so yeah, everything is solemn, but this particularly so.
[38:49] SPEAKER_00: Why would that be the case?
[38:51] SPEAKER_00: Well, think of the difference between definite suspension and indefinite suspension.
[38:56] SPEAKER_00: Definite suspension is when there's evidence of repentance, the court's satisfied to the person's repentance indefinite.
[39:04] SPEAKER_00: The court's not saying the person is impenitent, but it's saying we don't see repentance in place such that we could proceed with definite suspension.
[39:14] SPEAKER_00: So you're dealing with someone who is not known to be repentant.
[39:18] SPEAKER_00: And the the court's deep desire is that this person would be brought to repentance, hence the added solemnity, some of the language that's that's being used here.
[39:30] SPEAKER_00: Uh all of this is calculated uh as instruments, as means to awaken this person that that by God's grace he might be brought to repentance.
[39:41] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, it's it's almost the equivalent of announcing somebody's undergoing chemo.
[39:46] SPEAKER_03: Right?
[39:47] SPEAKER_03: There's there's this feeling of there's a couple of different ways that this could go.
[39:51] SPEAKER_03: And the intention of undergoing chemo is uh for a good outcome.
[39:55] SPEAKER_03: Um and even Ramsey in his commentary at the end of this chapter calls this a means of grace.
[40:01] SPEAKER_03: And so um if that's what we believe, it there's solemnness that's there, but there's also uh it's mixed with hope.
[40:09] SPEAKER_04: This is uh this censure I'm thinking especially perhaps of of suspension from the sacraments.
[40:17] SPEAKER_04: Should be revisited by the court, right?
[40:19] SPEAKER_04: They seek repentance.
[40:21] SPEAKER_04: They need to come back to this.
[40:23] SPEAKER_04: This is not um like Scott mentioned, admonitions finished at you know, at sort of the moment of infliction.
[40:29] SPEAKER_04: This is returned to.
[40:31] SPEAKER_04: Um is it um I would imagine it to be possible for uh suspension from sacraments in in an improperly administered situation for it to become sort of a de facto excommunication.
[40:46] SPEAKER_04: That uh a court could uh improperly not return back to this.
[40:52] SPEAKER_04: The person may just disappear if if they're not feeling especially uh repentant and it just sort of falls off.
[40:59] SPEAKER_04: Um can is there anything to speak to that?
[41:02] SPEAKER_04: I mean, uh maybe maybe our encouragement is just for courts to to not do that, of course, but um they're different uh censures.
[41:12] SPEAKER_00: Is anything I'm saying making sense?
[41:14] SPEAKER_00: I I think so, and and lest we tread on the next episode, 37-2, I think speaks to your concern.
[41:22] SPEAKER_00: After any person has been indefinitely suspended from the sacraments, it is proper that the rulers of the church should frequently converse with him as well as pray with him and for him that it would please God to give him repentance.
[41:35] SPEAKER_00: So discipline in that sense is not the end, it's just the beginning.
[41:39] SPEAKER_00: It's not the church saying, Phew, we're done with that guy, let's move on.
[41:44] SPEAKER_00: But this triggers a whole train of pastoral intervention that is designed, is ordered to conclude with that person professing repentance and demonstrating fruit in keeping with repentance.
[42:00] SPEAKER_00: And that burden, spiritually, the burden rests on that individual, the offender.
[42:06] SPEAKER_00: He's accountable before Christ.
[42:08] SPEAKER_00: But there's an ecclesiastical burden, and the book says, look, you don't wait for that guy to come to you, you go to that guy.
[42:17] SPEAKER_00: That's your responsibility.
[42:19] SPEAKER_00: And if we don't do that, we're forfeiting our pastoral responsibilities towards this airing sheep.
[42:26] SPEAKER_02: What happens when that airing sheep moves far away?
[42:29] SPEAKER_02: Often, especially with in the context of pastors, when they're suspended from office, they lose their call typically, and they often relocate, and it's often impractical for a presbytery to continue 37-2 as we jump ahead.
[42:47] SPEAKER_02: Um, what what are courts to do in those circumstances?
[42:50] SPEAKER_02: What are their options?
[42:52] SPEAKER_00: Well, um I I think part of it you have to gauge what the the the disposition and will of this person is.
[43:02] SPEAKER_00: I mean, if if if they're part of what's wrapped up in the move is just to flee jurisdiction and they're wanting to leave the PCA altogether, then then you've got some options available in in BCO 38.
[43:19] SPEAKER_00: Um if, however, that they really are sincerely wanting to continue to put themselves under the church's oversight and discipline, then BCO 46 gives some options about working with the appropriate court in in other settings.
[43:38] SPEAKER_00: And again, all of this for for a for a court to know what's the proper course of action, you've got to be at least attempting to make regular contact and to pursue this person.
[43:52] SPEAKER_00: Uh you you can't just cut them loose and uh two years later say, What do we do with this guy?
[44:00] SPEAKER_04: Oh let listeners understand it seems all you have to do is keep reading the BCO and all of your questions will be answered.
[44:08] SPEAKER_04: Just a few sections ahead.
[44:10] SPEAKER_04: Okay.
[44:11] SPEAKER_04: Let's let's move on to section six.
[44:14] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, I'm gonna read this.
[44:15] SPEAKER_04: I think it's good for people to hear these words.
[44:17] SPEAKER_04: Um maybe maybe they won't ever have to hear them in an official sense, but excommunication is to be administered according to one or other of the two modes laid down for indefinite suspension, or to be inflicted in public as the court may decide.
[44:32] SPEAKER_04: In administering this censure, the moderator of the session shall make a statement of the several steps which have been taken with respect to the offending brother, and of the decision to cut him off from the communion of the church.
[44:42] SPEAKER_04: He shall then show from Matthew eighteen and first Corinthians five the authority of the church to cast out unworthy members, and shall explain the nature, use, and consequences of this censure.
[44:52] SPEAKER_04: He shall then administer the censure in the words following, whereas so and so, a member of this church has been by sufficient proof convicted of the sin of insert sin, and after much admonition and prayer, obstinately refuses to hear the church and has manifested no evidence of repentance.
[45:10] SPEAKER_04: Therefore, in the name and by the authority of the Lord Jesus Christ, we, the session of the church, do pronounce him to be excluded from the sacraments and cut off from the fellowship of the church.
[45:21] SPEAKER_04: Prayer shall then be made that by God's blessing this solemn action of the court may issue in the repentance and restoration of the offender and in the establishment of all true believers.
[45:36] SPEAKER_04: I just I'm just going to observe that there's um more prescribed here for the infliction of this censure than the other ones.
[45:47] SPEAKER_04: I would assume, Dr.
[45:48] SPEAKER_04: Waters, that that is is so that there's no confusion on the part of those present listening and hearing, or or on the offender being censured.
[45:56] SPEAKER_04: Um and it is so weighty and solemn uh and and I think to the point at the very end that the prayers are made in part for the establishment of all true believers, so that it's it's functioning in that part of a warning to the other part of the church.
[46:12] SPEAKER_04: Um what's the significance or or what do you think here is of value to point out to folks as we consider this uh the the the amount of prescribed uh detail here?
[46:24] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[46:25] SPEAKER_00: Well, I think that's in part a function of of the solemnity and finality of of this censure.
[46:32] SPEAKER_00: But I think it also reflects so you you you quoted earlier Ramsey, and he's absolutely right, discipline is a means of grace, and not just to the offender, but to the whole church.
[46:43] SPEAKER_00: So if you look at what's the placed upon the moderator, he he needs to to teach, to explain this is how you get to excommunication, this is its biblical warrant, so it's understood that all of this is coming from Scripture.
[47:02] SPEAKER_00: And I think, you know, there are a couple of things that the this paragraph's wisdom speaks into.
[47:10] SPEAKER_00: One is, oh, the church can just cut off anybody because they don't like them.
[47:14] SPEAKER_00: And and that's not true.
[47:16] SPEAKER_00: Um you the church is acting under the scripture, it's not acting in its own authority.
[47:23] SPEAKER_00: And then there's sometimes a perception that, you know, if the church just gets tired of you, you're out.
[47:30] SPEAKER_00: And that does happen in in other settings.
[47:32] SPEAKER_00: And and it just takes a snap of the fingers and and you're gone.
[47:36] SPEAKER_00: Well, you can't do that in Scripture or in the Presbyterian Church in America.
[47:40] SPEAKER_00: Excommunication is the conclusion of a long sequence of steps and interventions and processes.
[47:48] SPEAKER_00: And so part of this is to impress that we have honored the steps that our Lord has has given us in Scripture and that are codified in our book.
[48:03] SPEAKER_00: We've acted according to law.
[48:05] SPEAKER_00: This is not something we're doing out of our own authority, we're we're not doing it out of out of peak, or uh this doesn't reflect a snap judgment.
[48:14] SPEAKER_00: All of that is good not just for the offender to hear and for the church to hear, but it's just good for the court to be reminded, hey, if we get to this point, we're gonna have to announce this to the church.
[48:25] SPEAKER_00: So we better mean it and act like we mean it as we take steps that could lead up to this point.
[48:35] SPEAKER_04: Morton Smith uh wrote that he said this this censure removes the individual from membership, and later he said, which is to say that the church does not view the individual as a recipient of the grace of salvation.
[48:49] SPEAKER_04: My question is, how how should church members act towards a person excommunicated?
[48:54] SPEAKER_04: I th I hear that a lot.
[48:55] SPEAKER_04: I hear people say, Well, what do you do with the guy?
[48:57] SPEAKER_04: Like, is he not allowed to come anymore?
[48:59] SPEAKER_04: Or we're are we allowed to talk to him in the grocery store if we run into him?
[49:03] SPEAKER_04: I think people don't know what to do with this when it after the fact, you know, it's being lived out and the guy's still in the community, perhaps.
[49:11] SPEAKER_04: Um Do you have any advice or counsel there?
[49:15] SPEAKER_00: Well, you know, we're we're we don't practice shunning, so we're not cutting someone off.
[49:21] SPEAKER_00: We're never gonna talk to you again, we're gonna cross the street to avoid you.
[49:26] SPEAKER_00: So all that has changed is an ecclesiastical relation, and and with it a spiritual relation, of course.
[49:34] SPEAKER_00: But if they're a family member, you still have Thanksgiving dinner with them.
[49:38] SPEAKER_00: If you've been in the habit of shopping at their store in town, you keep shopping at their store.
[49:43] SPEAKER_00: If you're behind them in line at the bank, you you talk to them, you greet them.
[49:48] SPEAKER_00: So we we show to them the same courtesy and affection that we would any other human being, any other image bearer.
[49:55] SPEAKER_00: But there is a change, no question, that needs to be reflected in our conduct.
[50:00] SPEAKER_00: That this person is no longer in the fellowship of the church.
[50:04] SPEAKER_00: They've been put out of the church.
[50:06] SPEAKER_00: And so we we can't speak to them, engage them as we did when they were members of the church.
[50:15] SPEAKER_00: And we have to think about what that looks like practically and and concretely.
[50:22] SPEAKER_00: Because, again, we've not cut them off saying never come back.
[50:28] SPEAKER_00: We cut them off saying this this is a last-ditch effort, so to speak, to recover you.
[50:35] SPEAKER_00: And that means we have to pursue them.
[50:38] SPEAKER_00: And that's got to look different, but but there has to be some pursuit in place.
[50:43] SPEAKER_00: And I think as well, we know from 1 Corinthians 14 that unbelievers were in the worship of the church.
[50:50] SPEAKER_00: So unless there's some restraining order, uh, of course they're welcome to come and worship.
[50:56] SPEAKER_00: And they ought to be warmly invited to come and worship, sit in the pew like like any other one person we would want, um, in the hopes that they would be brought to repentance and restoration with the church.
[51:09] SPEAKER_02: This might be jumping ahead.
[51:12] SPEAKER_04: Um We're not allowed to do that.
[51:15] SPEAKER_02: I'm just trying to think through here.
[51:17] SPEAKER_02: They're not they're no longer on the rolls, but there is some jurisdictional oversight still of that person, even if you excommunicate them, i.e., that you're the people that can remove that censure, and no other PCA church could unless you transferred the whole case.
[51:33] SPEAKER_02: Um what do you do as someone who's somewhat, I don't know, belligerent, they they want the censure removed, but they haven't exhibited repentance and they muck up your system.
[51:43] SPEAKER_02: Uh what how how are sessions to deal with ongoing excommunications, if that makes sense?
[51:51] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I think really if a person has been excommunicated ecclesiastically, there's nothing more that the church can do at that point beyond the steps of recovery that are envisioned here and elsewhere in the book.
[52:09] SPEAKER_00: And, you know, if a person makes themselves a nuisance, that's unfortunate.
[52:15] SPEAKER_00: The church should certainly say, you know, brother, we're we're praying and acting for your restoration.
[52:23] SPEAKER_00: We're not seeing that reciprocated in your conduct.
[52:27] SPEAKER_00: Um, and it'd be really good if you just cut this out and and worked with us.
[52:32] SPEAKER_00: Um now, to be clear, if they believe that they were unjustly censured and they file an appeal, that's not being cantankerous.
[52:44] SPEAKER_00: They are exercising their right as any member of the Church of Jesus Christ would have in that situation.
[52:51] SPEAKER_00: And so we we shouldn't deem that to be evidence of non-repentance or any such thing.
[52:57] SPEAKER_00: At least it needn't be.
[52:59] SPEAKER_00: Um So that that we want to take care to distinguish those two.
[53:04] SPEAKER_00: But um I think love and patience is the order of the day in a in a difficult case like that.
[53:13] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, and that's probably important to know too, is the reading out of this sentence, the the public nature of it.
[53:18] SPEAKER_03: You need to make sure that they're not appealing.
[53:20] SPEAKER_03: You don't do that and then have them appeal.
[53:23] SPEAKER_03: Um that's that's one of the things we need to be conscious of.
[53:27] SPEAKER_03: But yeah, I just think the the entirety of that question comes down to Jesus saying that he's to be to you a Gentile and a tax collector.
[53:34] SPEAKER_03: What did Jesus do to them?
[53:36] SPEAKER_03: He called them to repentance and and called them to faith and grace and uh to turn from their sin.
[53:42] SPEAKER_00: That's right.
[53:43] SPEAKER_00: And it's a great point, Jared.
[53:45] SPEAKER_00: Gentile and tax collector, they're not bywords, uh, they're not insults, terms of reproach.
[53:51] SPEAKER_00: They just refer to people who are outside the boundaries of the covenant community.
[53:55] SPEAKER_00: And then the next question is just the one you asked.
[53:58] SPEAKER_00: How did Jesus treat Gentiles and tax collectors?
[54:01] SPEAKER_00: Well, maybe that's the way we ought to be treating those who have been excommunicated.
[54:06] SPEAKER_04: It really is a strong encouragement for us to consider how we treat Gentiles and tax collectors as well.
[54:11] SPEAKER_04: Uh I wonder if the people, you know, the people that ask me, what do we do with this guy?
[54:16] SPEAKER_04: Well, if he's excommunicated, and I say, Well, you know, you should you should seek to, you know, talk to him about the gospel and and have him be a part of your life if the Lord would, in his providence, would put him back in it in some way.
[54:28] SPEAKER_04: And a lot of people don't interact with unbelievers in that way on a regular basis.
[54:32] SPEAKER_04: You know, it's that's a very difficult thing for a lot of Christians.
[54:35] SPEAKER_04: Um and so that's probably where some of the stumbling comes from when it comes to um somebody uh having been censured like this.
[54:43] SPEAKER_04: Well, we we don't know what to do with these kinds of people.
[54:46] SPEAKER_04: Um and s and so and I you know I say all that as as somebody who has struggled with that a lot.
[54:51] SPEAKER_04: I mean it it is it is a hard thing to be a Christian in the world in those, you know, intimate ways.
[54:56] SPEAKER_04: We like to kind of you know put our garage doors down and go into our homes and not talk to our neighbors at all.
[55:04] SPEAKER_04: So let us be aware.
[55:07] SPEAKER_04: Okay, thirty-six seven.
[55:10] SPEAKER_04: Uh and actually I'm gonna read read it before I read thirty-six seven, just a reminder of deposition from thirty-five is the degradation of an officer from his office, and may or may not be accompanied with the infliction of other censure.
[55:23] SPEAKER_04: So thirty-six seven reads, the censure of deposition shall be administered by the moderator in the words following.
[55:30] SPEAKER_04: Whereas you, a teaching elder of this presbytery or ruling elder or deacon of this church, have been proved by sufficient evidence to be guilty of of this sin, we, the Presbyterian Church session, do adjudge him disqualified from the office of the ministry or ruling eldership or deaconship, and therefore we do hereby, in the name of of and by the authority of the Lord Jesus Christ, depose from the office of a teaching elder or ruling elder or deacon, um the said individual, and do prohibit him from exercising any of the functions thereof.
[56:01] SPEAKER_04: If the censure includes suspension or excommunication, the moderator shall proceed to say we do, moreover, by the same authority, suspend the individual from the sacraments of the church until he shall exhibit satisfactory evidence of sincere repentance, or um uh the uh the same for um excommunication, cutting him off from the fellowship of the church.
[56:22] SPEAKER_04: And then uh it concludes by saying the sentence of deposition ought to be inflicted with solemnities similar to those already prescribed in the case of excommunication.
[56:30] SPEAKER_04: So this well, what more is there that is there to say here uh about deposition after all of this talk of the other censures?
[56:40] SPEAKER_02: Well, you think I go ahead, Dr.
[56:42] SPEAKER_02: Waters, yield the floor to you, my friend.
[56:45] SPEAKER_02: No, no, brother.
[56:47] SPEAKER_02: Well, I I was thinking as we've gone through each of the censures and what the moderator shall pronounce, there's a gravity in in those words.
[56:55] SPEAKER_02: Um you're doing this not in the name of your own authority, but in the name of authority of the Lord Jesus Christ.
[57:02] SPEAKER_02: And when I've engaged in um process in the past, locally and the at the church level, as I read those words aloud and hear myself say them, there's there's a gravitas to those words, and there's a seriousness to those words that you don't flippantly uh inflict censures upon people, and you don't flippantly engage in process.
[57:23] SPEAKER_02: It's not about personal vendettas, um, because what you're doing is to the name and authority of Christ.
[57:30] SPEAKER_02: It's for his honor that you're acting, and and so there is a gravity, and perhaps uh that's where part of the solemn nature of what you're engaging in is seen, is that this is not by my authority or any other authority, but by the authority of Christ that we do what we are doing, whether that be deposition, uh excommunication, suspension, it's by Christ's authority.
[57:54] SPEAKER_02: And so we should not do this work frivolously.
[57:57] SPEAKER_02: We should do the best of our ability to do good process for his honor, not our own.
[58:03] SPEAKER_00: That's right.
[58:04] SPEAKER_00: Well, that's a great point.
[58:06] SPEAKER_00: And you know, it it's important to remember the the church admits a man to office by the authority Christ has given it.
[58:15] SPEAKER_00: The church removes a man from office by the authority Christ has given it.
[58:20] SPEAKER_00: And it you compare this language with what you see in BCO 21, each is solemn in a very different way.
[58:28] SPEAKER_00: When a man is admitted to office, and then when a man is removed from office.
[58:34] SPEAKER_00: But that that's something I think that's wholesome for for the church and for the man, for the the core to be reminded of that this is an exercise of the church's authority.
[58:50] SPEAKER_00: It had best be done according to Scripture, uh woe betide.
[58:55] SPEAKER_00: And y deposition is especially solemn because you're not just t t removing a man from the exercise of the functions of his office, you're removing a man from office altogether.
[59:09] SPEAKER_00: And that's obviously a serious engrave step.
[59:14] SPEAKER_00: Uh but it it has to be done.
[59:21] SPEAKER_04: Well, I think that we have covered all of this.
[59:24] SPEAKER_04: Is there anything still lingering in any of your minds, gentlemen, that you would like to mention or circle back to?
[59:33] SPEAKER_03: Maybe just to reiterate um I think something that Dr.
[59:36] SPEAKER_03: Waters said earlier, that the feel of this is in in the vein of discipline, and we know when we discipline our children, often we don't want to, but we know that it's a means of their correction, in a sense, uh a means of grace, as Ramsey calls it at the end.
[59:51] SPEAKER_03: Um so it's it's something that is done not with glee, but with with duty and with the realization that this is for their good, and if we love uh the person being disciplined, that we'll do it.
[1:00:04] SPEAKER_00: And and just as a note of hope on what's been a pretty grim subject matter uh for a time together, uh yeah, we do have a whole chapter on the infliction of censures, but there is a chapter to follow on the removal of censures.
[1:00:20] SPEAKER_00: And that can happen.
[1:00:22] SPEAKER_00: We pray that it would happen, and it does happen.
[1:00:25] SPEAKER_00: So happily BCO36 is not the last word by any measure.
[1:00:30] SPEAKER_00: It it is a word, but it's not the last word.
[1:00:34] SPEAKER_04: Well, with that, I'm gonna tell you listeners that this podcast is over.
[1:00:37] SPEAKER_04: We're glad that you have joined us.
[1:00:39] SPEAKER_04: And with uh with the end of 36 in mind, we would encourage you to come back next time when we discuss the removal of centers in chapter 37 with our friend Mel Duncan.
[1:00:49] SPEAKER_04: If you're interested in learning more about what we have discussed, you can check out the show notes.
[1:00:54] SPEAKER_04: Uh, we would encourage you to go to the the PCAAC.org website.
[1:00:58] SPEAKER_04: You can find a new digital BCO there, and and from there you can kick off to other uh places where um Wayne Sparkman and others have put together uh good resources on the BCO.
[1:01:09] SPEAKER_04: Uh if you've enjoyed the show, do consider following us on Twitter, Facebook, or at Polity Matters, and be sure to be subscribed in your podcast app so that you get new episodes on Tuesdays.
[1:01:19] SPEAKER_04: Uh our great thanks to Guy for joining us today.
[1:01:22] SPEAKER_04: Many thanks to you, brother.
[1:01:23] SPEAKER_04: We appreciate your work in these areas.
[1:01:25] SPEAKER_04: Um it's a it's a huge blessing to us, not just as former students, but also as continuing elders in the church.
[1:01:30] SPEAKER_04: Thank you.
[1:01:31] SPEAKER_04: Thank you, brothers.
[1:01:32] SPEAKER_04: Looking forward to seeing your listeners and perhaps you in Chattanooga.
[1:01:36] SPEAKER_04: That's right.
[1:01:37] SPEAKER_04: Uh, listeners, if you have questions or comments, uh, especially in these matters, reach out to us.
[1:01:42] SPEAKER_04: We we may not be able to help you with some of these more weighty things.
[1:01:45] SPEAKER_04: We'll do the best we can, but we have uh got connections now that we've been doing this for a little while.
[1:01:50] SPEAKER_04: We can we can connect you with different folks who could give you a lot of help and encouragement in these uh difficult areas of church discipline.
[1:01:57] SPEAKER_04: So get in touch with us, uh Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[1:02:02] SPEAKER_04: Uh thanks again for spending time with us.
[1:02:04] SPEAKER_04: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[1:02:07] SPEAKER_04: Goodbye.
[1:02:08] SPEAKER_04: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
