# 73. The Jared Nelson Memorial Episode (BCO 28)

An episode of [Polity Matters](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1697383708), 25 Feb 2025, 53 min.

Audio: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2215222/episodes/16687787-73-the-jared-nelson-memorial-episode-bco-28.mp3

Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Tipton --the fourth polity bro-- to discuss BCO 28: Disciplining of Non-communing Members. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

## Chapters

- 0:00 Introduction
- 2:11 BCO 28-1
- 6:25 BCO 28-2
- 12:48 BCO 28-3
- 23:19 BCO 28-4
- 32:15 BCO 28-5
- 38:14 Excursus
- 51:08 Conclusion

## Transcript

[0:07] SPEAKER_02: Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters.
[0:09] SPEAKER_02: My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined today by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg.
[0:13] SPEAKER_02: And you know what?
[0:14] SPEAKER_02: We're not even gonna take time to introduce him anymore.
[0:16] SPEAKER_02: I'm just gonna call him one of our fourth co-hosts, Steve Tipton.
[0:19] SPEAKER_02: Guys, it's good to see you all today.
[0:21] SPEAKER_02: We're gonna be talking about BCO 28, all about the dis disciplining of non-commuting members.
[0:28] SPEAKER_02: I almost read that discipling, which is very close, but not not quite the same thing.
[0:33] SPEAKER_02: I guess it more or less is the same thing.
[0:35] SPEAKER_02: What's going on, fellas?
[0:37] SPEAKER_02: I feel like I haven't seen you in a while, but I think it's only because we postponed recording a day.
[0:44] SPEAKER_02: Scott and Jerry Scott, you've been working on projects at home?
[0:46] SPEAKER_02: You keep seeing his pictures?
[0:47] SPEAKER_02: I'm always insulating things and working on things.
[0:50] SPEAKER_02: You have a cordless hammer drill that looks pretty pretty intense.
[1:07] SPEAKER_03: But I did get a nice cordless one that I thought, hey, why not?
[1:11] SPEAKER_03: I don't drill that much hole that many holes in concrete.
[1:14] SPEAKER_03: Might as well get something that's a little more flexible.
[1:16] SPEAKER_02: I would say if you're gonna drill a hole in concrete, make sure that it's a really well drilled hole.
[1:24] SPEAKER_02: I've done some concrete drilling, but you want a hammer drill for that.
[1:28] SPEAKER_01: You do.
[1:29] SPEAKER_02: You don't want to just drill your normal drill.
[1:31] SPEAKER_02: Scott, the cheap corded one from Harbor Freight worked pretty good for me.
[1:35] SPEAKER_02: So maybe in thirty in thirty years when you have to do another hole in your cordless DeWalt.
[1:42] SPEAKER_03: There's a few months back I was trying to knock out a step with a hammer drill, like a whole concrete step that was like a hundred years old, and concrete gets harder as it ages, and I there's a lot of sanctification happening with that with that step.
[1:56] SPEAKER_03: It it beat me like four or five times before I finally finished it.
[1:59] SPEAKER_02: There's gotta be a sermon illustration in there somewhere.
[2:02] SPEAKER_03: I probably already that's all my sermon illustrations, me just working out my house.
[2:06] SPEAKER_01: Like the hungry heart of an unbeliever, it just gets harder over time.
[2:12] SPEAKER_02: Let's get into 28-1, the role of parents in spiritual discipline.
[2:16] SPEAKER_02: Without learning, there is no growth, and without growth, there is no discipline, and without discipline, there is no there is sin and iniquity, with a reference to First Timothy four seven.
[2:26] SPEAKER_02: So I mean somebody somebody, you know, has thoughts on this.
[2:30] SPEAKER_02: Let's let's jump in.
[2:30] SPEAKER_02: Scott, you've been quiet.
[2:32] SPEAKER_02: Mostly Steve and I have just been arguing, so maybe one of you other guys.
[2:38] SPEAKER_01: Well, we agreed though, I thought.
[2:39] SPEAKER_02: And we do, yeah, we do, we do.
[2:41] SPEAKER_00: I would just say that I I think this section gives you the avenue through which some of the church's role is in this, and that is through the parents.
[2:49] SPEAKER_00: So yeah, the session doesn't have the power of the paddle, but the the parents do.
[2:53] SPEAKER_00: And if the parents are not bringing their children to worship, if the parents are completely neglecting their duties as the primary disciplers of their children, the children may not be subject to as as much recourse for judicial action, but the parents are.
[3:08] SPEAKER_00: So if you have somebody that's like, yeah, my eight-year-old is just deciding for himself whether or not he's going to come to church, that that parent needs to be instructed.
[3:15] SPEAKER_00: That parent needs to be subject to some talking twos by the uh the session.
[3:19] SPEAKER_00: You can overdo this.
[3:20] SPEAKER_00: You can have a session that is involved to the point of saying you have to do this sort of schooling, private schooling or homeschooling or something like that.
[3:28] SPEAKER_00: But they do have this power that should be executed if they're just not bringing them at all to worship or just saying they're, you know, they're off for soccer and they do that half the year.
[3:36] SPEAKER_00: And so I think this locates it with the parents, and the session should be encouraging the parents to use their powers, their powers of the paddle.
[3:43] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[3:44] SPEAKER_01: Well, and too, like I I you see this less, I think, in PCA churches, or at least the churches that I've been a part of.
[3:51] SPEAKER_01: I mean, I don't want to speak for all of them, but in other churches that I belong to, you know, prior to coming into the PCA, usually what I saw was the opposite, which was the parents abdicating the spiritual nurture of their children to the church.
[4:04] SPEAKER_01: Right.
[4:05] SPEAKER_01: So I'd you know, I drop my kid off at youth group, and it's your responsibility to teach them who Jesus is and how to live.
[4:11] SPEAKER_01: I'm not going to do that.
[4:13] SPEAKER_01: I'm not gonna, you know, I I don't I don't teach them spiritual things, that's your job.
[4:17] SPEAKER_01: And you know, certainly that this is a complete uh you know repudiation of any kind of notion that it's the the church's job primarily, right, uh first and foremost, to be engaged in those.
[4:32] SPEAKER_01: Now, obviously it does, right?
[4:34] SPEAKER_01: The the full ministry of the church, all the means of grace are going not just to parents, they're going to children.
[4:39] SPEAKER_01: Um, and you know, certainly something could be said even just about the way in which we preach to ensure that we are communicating truth, not just to adult minds, but to children's minds, you know, all of that kind of stuff.
[4:52] SPEAKER_01: But there is this mutual responsibility.
[4:54] SPEAKER_01: The parents are responsible for their children, and as Jared said, there is a responsibility of the parents to the church for how they do that or or don't do it.
[5:03] SPEAKER_01: So I also think it's interesting the last two sentences, 28-1, were added by the second GA.
[5:09] SPEAKER_01: That those are found in no other that I was able to find precursor BCO.
[5:14] SPEAKER_01: And I also think it's interesting that the first of those two sentences has the word discipleship in it.
[5:20] SPEAKER_01: Everywhere else in this chapter talks about discipline, but here, you know, we added just sort of underlining the that idea that that really what this is talking about is the discipleship of our children and how that how that's carried out.
[5:33] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it uses it almost as a synonym.
[5:35] SPEAKER_02: I mean, there's really no reference to it, it just speaks of it like you've already been talking about it.
[5:38] SPEAKER_02: It's crazy it's good.
[5:39] SPEAKER_02: I didn't realize it was added after.
[5:42] SPEAKER_02: That's a good line, that last one.
[5:43] SPEAKER_02: Without learning, there's no growth.
[5:45] SPEAKER_02: Without growth, there's no discipline.
[5:46] SPEAKER_02: Without discipline, there is sin and iniquity.
[5:48] SPEAKER_02: It's a good approval.
[5:50] SPEAKER_03: The founding fathers of the PCA, Jedi Council.
[5:55] SPEAKER_02: I've been reading through uh David Hall's you know, the book on the fifty years lately.
[5:59] SPEAKER_02: I just got through the fourth or fifth General Assembly.
[6:02] SPEAKER_02: I don't know if he referenced the edition there, but it's uh there was a lot that was added in the second GA.
[6:09] SPEAKER_02: Like there was a ton of things related to it.
[6:12] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it was like we got a year into it and we're like, oh, we we are a denomination now.
[6:16] SPEAKER_02: Man.
[6:19] SPEAKER_02: Well, I'm I've got some questions for the end that will hit back on this stuff.
[6:22] SPEAKER_02: Anything else there in the first paragraph that y'all need to highlight?
[6:26] SPEAKER_02: So on to twenty eight two.
[6:28] SPEAKER_02: The home and the church should also make special provision for instructing the children in the Bible and in the church catechisms.
[6:36] SPEAKER_02: To this end, sessions should establish and conduct under their authority Sunday schools and Bible classes, and adopt such other methods as may be found helpful.
[6:44] SPEAKER_02: The session shall encourage the parents of the church to guide their children and the catechizing and disciplining of them in their Christian religion.
[6:51] SPEAKER_02: So this has some references, maybe not direct, but some analogy at least back to BCO twelve and the responsibilities the session has, and with special attention to the children.
[7:01] SPEAKER_02: Um and this uh especially focuses on the teaching of the children through various means.
[7:08] SPEAKER_02: Uh we might say it's a joint responsibility between the home and the church.
[7:14] SPEAKER_02: How does I mean maybe this is a good place to talk practicality?
[7:17] SPEAKER_02: How have you guys seen this worked out uh most effectively?
[7:21] SPEAKER_02: You know, Sunday schools are pretty common, Bible classes, Bible studies, these are things we see all over the place.
[7:26] SPEAKER_02: But what's good to do in the sense Jared's got kids running around, I love it.
[7:30] SPEAKER_02: It's fantastic.
[7:30] SPEAKER_02: Usually they're not home when we record, but I do think it's interesting.
[7:34] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[7:35] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I mean, both of the churches that I've served Jared's.
[7:39] SPEAKER_00: One thing I will note, which is just my fascination, is that in the original PCUS, it wasn't Sunday school, it was Sabbath school.
[7:46] SPEAKER_00: So I wonder when that terminology dropped out.
[7:48] SPEAKER_00: Maybe goes along with our view of the Lord's Day.
[7:51] SPEAKER_00: I do think what you see here too is a focus of the catechisms.
[7:54] SPEAKER_00: And it's a good reminder to have catechism incorporated into our Sunday schools.
[7:58] SPEAKER_00: We had a separate when I was at a different church before my current one, uh, I helped start a catechism ministry on Wednesday nights that uh they basically came, they would memorize uh questions, they'd get candy for it if they got the right answers, and then would learn a little bit more about the doctrine that they've been memorizing.
[8:13] SPEAKER_00: So it doesn't have to just be on Sunday, it could be involved in other places.
[8:16] SPEAKER_00: And I don't think it just has to be the catechism.
[8:19] SPEAKER_00: You know, you're doing something else, but the catechism should be a part of it that you're they're using somewhere in that vicinity.
[8:24] SPEAKER_00: In our church, we do a a midweek, a ministry, and part of that is them memorizing catechism questions and getting lessons based on that.
[8:31] SPEAKER_03: We have discontinued Jared's catechism hour at Providence.
[8:34] SPEAKER_03: Since this is church, you gotta explain the background.
[8:38] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, there you go.
[8:39] SPEAKER_03: Jared served as an assistant at Providence.
[8:42] SPEAKER_03: We hope to actually restart some of that.
[8:43] SPEAKER_03: We actually do the catechism still, but because of the location we're in, it's also just included on Sunday rather than its own time on Wednesday.
[8:51] SPEAKER_03: So we still do your catechism, Jared, just not on Wednesdays because it's candy anymore.
[8:57] SPEAKER_02: Jared's Catechism?
[8:58] SPEAKER_02: The Brother Nelson Memorial Catechism class.
[9:01] SPEAKER_02: I think that has a good ring to it.
[9:03] SPEAKER_03: You know, we're fundraising, Jared, and so if you want to name a classroom.
[9:07] SPEAKER_01: Although I got in trouble with that, naming something the mem somebody memorial, and they're like, I'm not dead yet.
[9:12] SPEAKER_01: I'm like, oh, you're right.
[9:13] SPEAKER_01: You're right.
[9:14] SPEAKER_01: We're just preparing.
[9:15] SPEAKER_01: We're just preparing.
[9:16] SPEAKER_02: What's the alternative to memorial?
[9:18] SPEAKER_02: Uh honor in honor of, but that I mean, I don't think this is honor rary.
[9:23] SPEAKER_01: Well, back to the question at hand.
[9:25] SPEAKER_01: I also think it's interesting the first sentence.
[9:28] SPEAKER_01: I mean, it it's not just the catechism, right?
[9:30] SPEAKER_01: It's the catechisms.
[9:32] SPEAKER_01: Right.
[9:32] SPEAKER_01: So there is this uh, you know, the the larger catechism is envisioned in this.
[9:36] SPEAKER_01: I think I think it's maybe Ramsey that underlines that or points it out or something, you know, that there is this uh we have more than one catechism.
[9:42] SPEAKER_01: Obviously, we're not asking children to memorize the larger catechism, but there's an awful lot of really good information there.
[9:48] SPEAKER_01: And I think, you know, Wednesday night programs, midweek programs, whatever that that that looks like, are a great way to provide additional instruction before children, provide some tools for parents.
[10:00] SPEAKER_01: You know, one of the things we do in our worship, and we have a our confession of faith, is just we just we just go through the shorter catechism, and when we get to the end, we start over again.
[10:09] SPEAKER_01: And in fact, we uh I think the last iteration or the iteration before that, our uh children's ministry coordinator requested that we use the same version that the kids are memorizing.
[10:20] SPEAKER_01: And it's the newer one, I don't remember the name of it uh off the top of my head.
[10:25] SPEAKER_01: But it's all new things on Polity Matters.
[10:28] SPEAKER_01: So but it's a modern English version of it.
[10:30] SPEAKER_01: It may have been.
[10:31] SPEAKER_01: I don't I I'd I I'd have to look and see.
[10:33] SPEAKER_01: Maybe not, Jared.
[10:34] SPEAKER_01: You just shook your head no.
[10:35] SPEAKER_01: But the point is that because we were been asking them to memorize that rather than you know, when we came to that time, especially the kids who had already memorized those those parts, right?
[10:45] SPEAKER_01: I mean, yeah, they're reading it, but you can see there's a connection in their head.
[10:49] SPEAKER_01: It's not just some other different distant thing.
[10:52] SPEAKER_01: And I think it's you know it's been really good for getting the kids even more kind of involved even in our regular worship.
[10:57] SPEAKER_01: This is this is something that uh you know that there's an echo of that with what they've been previously doing.
[11:03] SPEAKER_01: So but also you know, without getting too much into the details, which are part of our non-confessional directory for worship, you know, part of this is you know that idea of home worship, that there is something that the parents, you know, that that obviously gives direction to the session, or maybe, you know, pious advice in this portion to the session about what they should do, but the home and the church should make special provision for instructing children.
[11:30] SPEAKER_01: Um and the church should not be your special provision for instructing your kids.
[11:34] SPEAKER_01: You need to be doing something in your home to to remote.
[11:38] SPEAKER_00: There was a book that I read a while ago that was about church discipline in 15 and 1600, and they would discipline fathers who did not do some sort of family worship in the home.
[11:48] SPEAKER_00: So they they were very serious about it early on in the reform tradition.
[11:51] SPEAKER_02: Was it public execution, or I mean, how did they do that?
[11:55] SPEAKER_02: Spankings.
[11:56] SPEAKER_04: Spankings.
[11:57] SPEAKER_01: Well, and one other thing I thought was kind of interesting too, the eighty-seven eighteen eighty-seven draft, um, which apparently this got erased at some point, but it had this phrase in it, uh, the responsibility of the session to cherish non-commuting members as a nursing parent.
[12:15] SPEAKER_01: That there is that uh especially you think of like a nursing parent with the the care and the attention that is given to a nursing child, right?
[12:25] SPEAKER_01: I mean, to to s the the infants, that the session ought to have that kind of relationship with its children.
[12:32] SPEAKER_01: And I think too, I mean, that's a big piece.
[12:34] SPEAKER_01: Well, we'll we'll get into that in the next one.
[12:36] SPEAKER_01: Never mind.
[12:36] SPEAKER_01: I'll I'll hold my fire on that one.
[12:39] SPEAKER_02: Basically, 28.2 says it takes a village.
[12:41] SPEAKER_02: All right, so or a church.
[12:45] SPEAKER_02: Jared's muted, but he's laughing.
[12:46] SPEAKER_02: I want the listeners to know that.
[12:47] SPEAKER_02: Okay.
[12:48] SPEAKER_02: Twenty-eight three, the church should maintain constant and sympathetic relations with the children.
[12:53] SPEAKER_02: It should also encourage them on coming to years of discretion to make confession of the Lord Jesus Christ and to enter upon all privileges of full church membership.
[13:01] SPEAKER_02: If they are wayward, they should be cherished by the church and every means used to reclaim them.
[13:07] SPEAKER_02: There's just I mean, we've we've talked about it a lot already.
[13:10] SPEAKER_02: Twenty-eight, it's got some wonderful language in it.
[13:12] SPEAKER_02: It's a beautiful chapter.
[13:14] SPEAKER_02: So this idea that that the church must encourage covenant children to profess their faith and to come to full church membership, those things which were promised to them in their baptism.
[13:25] SPEAKER_02: So I think we've already been dancing around some of this stuff.
[13:28] SPEAKER_03: So Yeah, it's kind of transitional.
[13:30] SPEAKER_03: 281 focuses on the role of parents, 282 focuses on the home, so the parents and the church.
[13:37] SPEAKER_03: And then 283 kind of shifts then to the church and what the church's responsibilities are to the family and to this child.
[13:44] SPEAKER_03: And so you can kind of see where the responsibilities are cut up in each of these perhaps pastoral sections.
[13:50] SPEAKER_03: And so, what is the responsibility of the session or the church?
[13:53] SPEAKER_03: It is to lead these children to making a profession of faith.
[13:58] SPEAKER_03: They're coming alongside the parents in order to encourage them as they mature to profess the profess our common Lord as uh they come to maturity.
[14:08] SPEAKER_03: And so, and then to perhaps draw them back when they fail and become wayward.
[14:13] SPEAKER_03: And so the parent, the the elders of the church or the church itself might meet with the family and with the child, trying to call them back, beckoning them to make a profession, but also trying to return to the channel.
[14:25] SPEAKER_00: Practically, I think what this looks like is when your session is meeting, you probably have a time in which you're going over pastoral concerns and going through the roles and saying, is there anything with this certain family?
[14:34] SPEAKER_00: And probably you have an elder assigned to them.
[14:37] SPEAKER_00: But to occasionally, if you're having communicants class, say, who's who do we think might be ready for this at this time?
[14:43] SPEAKER_00: Or what sense do you get of that?
[14:44] SPEAKER_00: And so the elders, if they are talking to the adults in those groups, they they probably should know a little bit about what the is going on with the kids.
[14:52] SPEAKER_00: And so this is a good reminder that when the session is going through its roles, it needs to talk about the non-communicant members too.
[14:58] SPEAKER_01: Right.
[14:59] SPEAKER_01: Well, that's one of the things I was holding over from the last one we were talking about is, you know, I would say in the last six months, there's been a real uh sort of, I want to say shift, but in addition in our session meetings where we do uh try to talk about some of those kids that have not yet made profession of faith that are in that, you know, years of discretion.
[15:20] SPEAKER_01: Um and you know, really to encourage the shepherding elder who is over the family, that it's not just the dad that that that they're the shepherding elder of or whatever, it's the whole family, and to to get to know the kids and uh to see elders really take an interest in the children of the church.
[15:39] SPEAKER_01: Not that they didn't before, but I mean, but just to continue that and increase it.
[15:43] SPEAKER_01: One of the things I've known I've seen this, and it was more my previous church because I was just there for 12 years.
[15:48] SPEAKER_01: And, you know, when you think about years of discretion somewhere between nine and twelve, let's say, you know, especially near the end, these were kids that I'd known, I mean, since they were babies.
[15:59] SPEAKER_01: And so um I like kids.
[16:02] SPEAKER_01: I mean, I like to talk to them and you know, hang out with them and and that sort of thing.
[16:06] SPEAKER_01: Uh a lot of those kids would know me, and when I would come to them and say, hey, you know, we want you to come to session, not always, but there would be a couple of them that were like, you know, wide-eyed and terrified about going into that room with the men, you know, who stand in front of them on Sunday in dark suits.
[16:20] SPEAKER_01: And and I'm not trying to suggest that the elders at the other church didn't have a good relationship with children at all.
[16:26] SPEAKER_01: The point I'm trying to make is that we can make that moment where they come into the session easy or hard.
[16:32] SPEAKER_01: And if and if we don't get down on their level and talk to them and teach some of their classes and know them by name and know their interests, then you're gonna have kids that are gonna be terrified of us because they've never had an opportunity really to get to know us.
[16:48] SPEAKER_01: And so I think there is that you know, that that contact, that sympathetic relation right that that is required here is is one that is so so very important.
[17:00] SPEAKER_01: Uh the other thing I thought was interesting too is just that this seems to put the the impetus, I guess, on the session as it comes to encouraging, you know, young'uns as they come to years of discretion.
[17:15] SPEAKER_01: You know, it's not uh wait in your office until someone knocks on the door at age 19 and says, Hey, I think I want to join the church, but to encourage them to make a profession of faith, to encourage them to grow in their knowledge of Christ and in their love for him, and and to make that profession, uh, is something that the the session, I really think it's the session here as the representative of the church, pastors and elders doing that.
[17:41] SPEAKER_01: I think that's a really important piece of being, you know, just the session of a church is again cherishing those children as uh as well.
[17:52] SPEAKER_02: One thing we haven't mentioned yet that's certainly true, I think all of us would be on board, is is the the idea of preaching as discipleship, right?
[18:00] SPEAKER_02: And so as you think through who's in your congregation and you're preaching, hopefully most ministers are considering the fact that there are non-communic.
[18:08] SPEAKER_02: And some of them too young to understand all the everything you're saying, but a lot of them getting up into, you know, years of discretion, especially, can understand, and so it's not uh it's not inappropriate to make pointed application to them and to to take hold of the faith, take hold of the Christ that you're preaching and to to believe on him.
[18:26] SPEAKER_02: So we can if you're not preaching evangelistically, uh you you probably want to take aim at some of those kids and make sure they know that what you're preaching has something to do with them too.
[18:38] SPEAKER_04: Can I ask a controversial question?
[18:41] SPEAKER_04: Please.
[18:42] SPEAKER_04: So w what what do we think years of discretion means?
[18:47] SPEAKER_04: It's definitely an age of accountability.
[18:51] SPEAKER_01: Well it's not an age of accountability.
[18:52] SPEAKER_01: It doesn't use that word, I don't think it's a good idea.
[18:54] SPEAKER_02: It's got I mean it's it it's gotta be a reference to 1 Corinthians 11 and discerning the body.
[18:59] SPEAKER_04: Discretion.
[19:02] SPEAKER_04: Is that too strong?
[19:04] SPEAKER_04: No, no, no, I mean I I don't it has to be.
[19:06] SPEAKER_01: That would that hardly should be a little strong.
[19:09] SPEAKER_01: So Yeah, I did I mean it's an archaic use of the word, but most of the words in our BCO have archaic uses.
[19:17] SPEAKER_01: Uh but there was a definition ability to make wise choices or decisions uh which uh you know, I guess in one sense, right, the capacity to understand the gospel and the you know, the natural ability.
[19:32] SPEAKER_01: I don't mean to say we're Arminians all of a sudden, but I mean, you know, the mental capacity to make a decision.
[19:39] SPEAKER_01: Obviously, in this case it has to be the work of the Holy Spirit, but they're at a certain age where they can understand the gospel and respond to it.
[19:50] SPEAKER_01: So I mean there is no particular age.
[19:52] SPEAKER_01: I've seen uh you know, uh fairly young children make amazing professions of faith, and I've seen older children uh you know stumble with uh understanding what you know what sin is or something along those lines.
[20:07] SPEAKER_02: The plural on years is helpful, I think.
[20:09] SPEAKER_02: If this is this might be too nitpicky, but I mean they're not saying a specific two numbers.
[20:16] SPEAKER_02: It's not saying there's a specific time that you have to think about but years of discretion giving it sort of sort of hey, it's it there might be a season where you start to see this kid come into this time and you're gonna work through it.
[20:27] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's different for everybody too.
[20:29] SPEAKER_00: I I remember reading in Bob Ink, he talks about, you know, it's this isn't even the the time of adolescence, like everybody has to go through some sort of a conversion experience when they're in their teen years and dealing with being an adolescent.
[20:41] SPEAKER_00: But the reason that we don't have a number here is because it's different for every kid.
[20:44] SPEAKER_00: You have to have some discernment on the part of the session too on who meets those qualifications.
[20:51] SPEAKER_00: I would think it would be a bad idea to put any kind of years within bylaws or within the BCO to say this is 18 years, 15 years, 12, whatever it may be.
[21:02] SPEAKER_00: Of course, there is too young that you're like, okay, is this a five-year-old?
[21:05] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, probably not.
[21:06] SPEAKER_00: But it's just I'm really reticent to put a number to it.
[21:09] SPEAKER_03: But didn't Jesus go to the temple at the age of the age?
[21:12] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, that's what that's what I've heard before.
[21:15] SPEAKER_03: Common argument on like actually making it an age.
[21:19] SPEAKER_03: I don't agree with it, by the way.
[21:20] SPEAKER_03: Just I thought it was always interesting.
[21:24] SPEAKER_01: Well, and and certainly I mean different sessions, they have the responsibility to make those decisions, and if a session, you know, makes if a session wants to say 13, I mean, other than complaint that comes up through it, I mean it, you know, that's that's that's their responsibility to make that decision.
[21:41] SPEAKER_01: I I you know it's obvious, well not obvious, but I mean clearly in 283, they did not put a number there.
[21:49] SPEAKER_01: And I I can't imagine us getting a number passed at this point.
[21:52] SPEAKER_01: There's just too many differences of opinions.
[21:55] SPEAKER_01: I do and I've seen this too.
[21:56] SPEAKER_01: I mean, not not so much in my own churches, but some others that I've I've known.
[22:00] SPEAKER_01: Where when that age is put too high artificially, that sometimes you can miss that.
[22:10] SPEAKER_01: I don't want to say, I mean, again, we're Calvinists, but I mean that there's like a moment of opportunity with a particular child where they really, you know, they have a strong desire to come to the table, to be part of the church, to do these things.
[22:22] SPEAKER_01: And if you push that off, if you exasperate them, then that that that opportunity, not that it's passed forever, but you do get that that moment like later teen years where, you know, I don't want to get too far into the parable of the soil, but you know, kind of cares of this world start to choke out some of that initial enthusiasm, some of that initial desire.
[22:44] SPEAKER_01: And that doesn't mean, you know, the minute some five-year-old says I want to take communion, you know, you make him a member right away.
[22:50] SPEAKER_01: But I think the care of the children in our church is an enormous responsibility.
[22:54] SPEAKER_01: It deserves five chapters in the BCO in one sense, but it really is such a important part.
[23:01] SPEAKER_01: And I think again, what we're bumping up against part of that struggle is that there is no there's no one answer to any of those things.
[23:08] SPEAKER_01: Different churches do things different ways and different emphases and so forth.
[23:12] SPEAKER_01: But I think it's just a reminder that we need to take it seriously and we need to value children and children's ministries in our churches.
[23:19] SPEAKER_02: Twenty-eight four.
[23:20] SPEAKER_02: Adult noncommuting members who receive with meekness and appreciation the oversight and instruction of the church are entitled to special attention.
[23:28] SPEAKER_02: Their rights and privileges under the covenant should be frequently and fully explained, and they should be warned of the sin and danger of neglecting their covenant obligations.
[23:38] SPEAKER_02: So let's just, you know, paint the picture.
[23:40] SPEAKER_02: You have a a young a young man or young woman who's grown up in the church, has been baptized, has been there their whole life, and they continue attending church, they have yet to make a profession of faith, they have yet to come to the table, but they still come, and they sit in the Sunday service, and they listen to the preaching, and they interact with the members and with the pastor, and they're generally receptive to being a part of that community, but there's still no profession of faith.
[24:11] SPEAKER_02: This is explaining how you how you deal with that.
[24:13] SPEAKER_02: Y'all might have more particular insight into this.
[24:15] SPEAKER_02: I haven't experienced someone like this as of yet, but we should continue to do basically what we've been doing with non-communicants the whole time.
[24:23] SPEAKER_02: Putting before them uh an explanation of their rights and privileges and calling them to faith in Christ.
[24:32] SPEAKER_01: Well, and I think it's it's a really interesting section to just kind of think about a little bit as we're doing right now.
[24:37] SPEAKER_01: But you know, you think about it's almost the opposite of I think what uh tends to happen in our churches.
[24:44] SPEAKER_01: Where once they become adults, we tend to give them less attention.
[24:49] SPEAKER_01: And it says they're entitled to special attention.
[24:53] SPEAKER_01: And then the next sentence, they should be frequently the rights and privileges should be frequently and fully explained.
[25:00] SPEAKER_01: That this is these are those that we need to go after and make a special effort to try and impress upon them the importance of that.
[25:08] SPEAKER_01: And I mean, one of the benefits of that, if you actually did that, I think, would be not only obviously the benefits to that individual son or daughter of the church, but hopefully the session would be like, maybe we ought to do this when they're young.
[25:22] SPEAKER_01: You know, maybe we ought to focus a little bit more effort and attention on them when they're, you know, not adults, so that we don't have to, you know, do all these things.
[25:30] SPEAKER_01: And again, providence is what it is, and there are plenty of circumstances where these things happen.
[25:35] SPEAKER_01: But I you know, I I do think it's it's an interesting statement, you know, rights and privileges, they should be warned of the sin and danger of neglecting their covenant obligations.
[25:45] SPEAKER_01: And I mean that was one of those things just sort of preparing for today, just kind of thinking, you know, what are what are those covenant obligations that we are to set before them?
[25:57] SPEAKER_01: What what do you I mean, I'm gonna take your chair, Ben, for a second.
[26:00] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[26:00] SPEAKER_01: What do we guys, what do you think that is?
[26:03] SPEAKER_02: Guys, please talk, please.
[26:05] SPEAKER_02: I'll give you a teach you how to do it, Steve.
[26:07] SPEAKER_02: You gotta beg and plead with your co-hosts.
[26:10] SPEAKER_00: Well, some of it is he was talking about it.
[26:13] SPEAKER_00: If you're seeing that they have spiritual gifts that they should be using in the congregation and they've just never stepped up to it, and they don't want to make a profession of faith because they don't want to do you know the things that are gonna come with that, okay.
[26:23] SPEAKER_00: Now you're gonna actually have to start serving.
[26:25] SPEAKER_00: Um, I think that's part of it of like, look, you've got gifts and they're we are poor as a congregation if you if you're not gonna fully embrace this and and come into the congregation and use your gifts and be blessed by the rest of the congregation through the spiritual gifts that they have for you.
[26:39] SPEAKER_00: Um, I think that's one way to encourage it of we want to see you more involved in the church, more involved in the family.
[26:45] SPEAKER_03: And it also reminds me of Hebrews 6, where you're dealing with people who are receiving the rights and privileges within the context of the of worship and the people of God, they experience the Holy Spirit while perhaps not having the Holy Spirit in a salvific way.
[27:00] SPEAKER_03: And so I think it's an impressing upon them perhaps the greater severity of sitting under the word with not professing the God behind the word.
[27:09] SPEAKER_03: And Hebrews 6 outlines that very, very poignantly on perhaps the warnings of sitting and receiving the blessings of God and the preaching of the word and the context of worship, but not professing that word or the God behind it.
[27:24] SPEAKER_03: And so I think perhaps that's also in view where you're thinking of what they receive by just being present.
[27:30] SPEAKER_03: And that presence has the rights and privileges of the covenant as they're non-communicable, they're in the covenant, uh, but they have yet to actually affirm that covenant that they've been baptized into, and so they're squandering their birthright in some regard.
[27:46] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[27:47] SPEAKER_01: Well, I I mean, uh the the obviously I had a little more time to think about it than I just threw it at you guys, but as I was, you know, kind of contemplating this and looking back through the BCO and other sections talking about you know children in the church, that you know, it it seems that ultimately their covenant obligation is to repent and believe.
[28:07] SPEAKER_01: Right?
[28:07] SPEAKER_01: Their obligation is to make a profession of faith.
[28:10] SPEAKER_01: And, you know, one of the things I've seen, and I think this kind of goes along with what Jared was talking about with some young adult non-communing members that don't want to make a profession of faith, that on the one hand they're they sort of come at it with this idea, well, there's nothing there's you know, I I believe in Jesus and I know that he's my savior, and there's nothing that I'm gonna get by joining the church that I don't think I already have now.
[28:34] SPEAKER_01: Now, you know, with the obvious exception of taking communion, but for whatever reason, the importance and the value of communion, I mean, you know, they've seen in their own eyes and their own experience, they've seen their faith grow without it.
[28:48] SPEAKER_01: So clearly it's not nearly as necessary or whatever else, you know, so you you kind of have this kind of malaise that that that rests down upon them where, you know, well, I do believe and I do know that Jesus is my savior.
[29:00] SPEAKER_01: I've always known that.
[29:01] SPEAKER_01: Why why do I need to make do some special thing, you know, to to get to that next stage?
[29:07] SPEAKER_01: And I think, you know, again, having a a robust, not super over-the-top robust understanding of communion, you know, not a ex opera operata or anything, but but a real reformed understanding of communion and impressing that is helpful.
[29:22] SPEAKER_01: Um, but also just that i it's part of our responsibility is to to make that public profession um you know before before people who know us, right?
[29:33] SPEAKER_01: I mean it's one thing to, you know, your your close friends at school or at college or whatever, you're in a Bible study and you say, Yeah, I'm a believer, but you know, that the people who who know you, who've known you for a long time, who who you've you know grown up around to to see that.
[29:48] SPEAKER_01: And to see the you know, I I know every time we have, you know, kids, young adults, adults come to faith and make professions of faith, it it's such a encouragement to everybody in that room, you know, from the nursery workers to the children's ministry workers to youth group to every you know, yes, this is this is what this is about is preserving the next generations of Christians and training them up.
[30:13] SPEAKER_03: So it also perhaps is hopeful in that it there's no off-ramp.
[30:20] SPEAKER_03: Maybe you might think that when someone turns 18, are no longer uh any relation to the church, they're on their own, but there's no off-ramp.
[30:28] SPEAKER_03: They are adult non-communing members, remain non-commuting members in so far as they allow themselves to be, and that could be for many, many years.
[30:37] SPEAKER_03: And the BCO doesn't give any outright at this time you should remove them.
[30:42] SPEAKER_03: It just gives the positive direction of pursuing after them.
[30:46] SPEAKER_03: Continue your pursuit, continue, continue, continue, rather than if they don't hear you three times, then just walk away from them, dust your shoes, and ignore them.
[30:56] SPEAKER_03: It's a constant pursuit and it's a positive.
[30:59] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[30:59] SPEAKER_01: Well, and and too, like you notice what this the chapter is saying, right?
[31:03] SPEAKER_01: Those who are engaged in the sin of neglecting their covenant obligations are the ones who are receiving with meekness and appreciation the oversight and instruction of those are not two different groups of people.
[31:16] SPEAKER_01: Right?
[31:17] SPEAKER_01: I mean, in one sense, that's more those who are like, I want nothing to do with you, don't ever contact me again, right?
[31:24] SPEAKER_01: That that's a that's a different category.
[31:26] SPEAKER_01: But it you know, it they are they are sinning against those covenant obligations, even as they meekly and appreciatively receive the word Sunday after Sunday, come to adult Sunday school now, or or whatever else.
[31:40] SPEAKER_00: I mean, this almost seems to be Yeah, it's this almost seems to be the elder brother that's closer to home rather than the prodigal one that went away.
[31:47] SPEAKER_00: I mean, it seems obvious if somebody's like, I want nothing to do with this, take me off the rolls, versus somebody that's like, I'm here, but I'm just not ready yet.
[31:54] SPEAKER_00: I'm here, I'm not gonna do that yet.
[31:55] SPEAKER_00: And just to be long-suffering, I guess, with that category.
[31:59] SPEAKER_01: Well, frequently and fully explaining the duties, rights, and responsibility.
[32:03] SPEAKER_01: Well, I think sorry, Ben, I'll let you lead here again.
[32:07] SPEAKER_01: You kidding me?
[32:08] SPEAKER_01: I think the next section has some interesting implications to this too.
[32:12] SPEAKER_02: Good job, Ben.
[32:13] SPEAKER_02: Built-in segues are my favorite thing.
[32:15] SPEAKER_02: 28-5.
[32:16] SPEAKER_02: All non-committing members shall be deemed under the care of the church to which their parents belong, if they live under the parental roof and are minors.
[32:23] SPEAKER_02: Otherwise, under that of the church where they reside or with which they ordinarily worship.
[32:30] SPEAKER_02: Is this I mean it's speaking to jurisdiction to some degree, even though we may not use that term in a technical sense, um where do where do non-community members belong?
[32:42] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I'm curious where where y'all would go here.
[32:44] SPEAKER_00: I've got questions, but you know, maybe Steve Tipton's more familiar with this from a military background, but I imagine this being like the person that joins up for the army, they've never become a community member, but then they're coming to somebody's church, but they've never become a community member.
[32:58] SPEAKER_00: Uh so it's saying, okay, yeah, you you can take special care for them.
[33:01] SPEAKER_00: They're not under their parents' house anymore, but you the church that they're in, because they're on that base, you have an obligation to them.
[33:08] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[33:08] SPEAKER_01: I mean, this is a in one sense, this is a very odd chapter or section, because uh like on the one hand, non-community members that are under the, you know, that are living at home and are minors, like who who that that's a we could set that category aside.
[33:23] SPEAKER_01: Everybody understands that.
[33:24] SPEAKER_01: Jared's children are under the care of his church.
[33:27] SPEAKER_01: No other church takes responsibility for them.
[33:30] SPEAKER_01: But let's say they're not minors, or they're not living at home, which I guess, and they're not living at home, or they are living at home, but they're not minors.
[33:37] SPEAKER_01: But anyway, under that church where they reside or where they ordinarily attend worship, okay.
[33:43] SPEAKER_01: So my daughter is a community member, but let's say she moves away.
[33:46] SPEAKER_01: She is, she's in Atlanta.
[33:47] SPEAKER_01: Let's say she's in Atlanta, but she's a not she's not a commuting member.
[33:50] SPEAKER_01: It almost sounds like number one, let's say she does attend worship regularly at, you know, I'm sure there's a covenant PCA church in Atlanta.
[33:58] SPEAKER_01: There's a covenant PCA church everywhere.
[34:00] SPEAKER_01: Well, this would suggest that she's under the care of Covenant Church in Atlanta.
[34:05] SPEAKER_01: But it says or.
[34:06] SPEAKER_01: So let's say she doesn't go to any church.
[34:09] SPEAKER_01: It actually makes it almost sound like there is some church there where she resides that's supposed to be caring for my adult community.
[34:16] SPEAKER_01: They don't even know she exists.
[34:17] SPEAKER_01: It has that's what I mean, like the chapter's weird or the section's weird because it almost raises more questions than it answers, gives no provision for how to deal with those weird circumstances.
[34:28] SPEAKER_01: And and is there a difference between under the care of and on the roles of?
[34:33] SPEAKER_01: I mean, it it uses different language than what we would normally I would say that especially like if a member of our church, I mean, that I there's actually one I'm thinking of who is in the armed forces, uh, he's in New Orleans now, I think, and then he's going overseas.
[34:47] SPEAKER_01: Well I think he's a non-community member.
[34:51] SPEAKER_01: Maybe no, maybe he's not.
[34:52] SPEAKER_01: I'm sorry.
[34:52] SPEAKER_01: Let's just assume for the argument he's a non-community member.
[34:55] SPEAKER_01: Well, I mean he's still under our care.
[34:58] SPEAKER_01: Like we still care about him.
[34:59] SPEAKER_01: We don't just say, well, he's gone, we don't care about him, so I mean we're gonna continue to reach out to him.
[35:05] SPEAKER_01: When he comes home, we're gonna do the things we need to do, all those types of stuff.
[35:11] SPEAKER_04: So even he's still on your roles.
[35:14] SPEAKER_04: Yeah, he is.
[35:15] SPEAKER_01: Right?
[35:15] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[35:16] SPEAKER_01: Right.
[35:16] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, he is.
[35:17] SPEAKER_01: Well, and I I mistook the one I'm thinking of is a community member, but I say for the sake of argument, sure he's not.
[35:23] SPEAKER_01: He is still gonna be on our roles.
[35:25] SPEAKER_01: He's still gonna be a member of our church, we're still gonna care for him.
[35:28] SPEAKER_01: So and I get that if he starts to go to a piece this this you know non-existent non-community adult member in the armed forces, starts to go to a PCA church or whatever, I would hope that church would take him under its care, like would would not just say, like, you're in this uh you know, this weird category.
[35:46] SPEAKER_01: We don't want you.
[35:47] SPEAKER_01: No, they're gonna love him, they're gonna hopefully do all those things.
[35:49] SPEAKER_00: It's just a They had this in mind in 28-5, but I've had two instances in which I've had a pastor reach out to me to say, We have a a non-communing member that's in your area.
[35:59] SPEAKER_00: Can you reach out to them?
[36:00] SPEAKER_00: Because one was not going to church anywhere, they just wanted me to see if I could go have lunch with them and encourage them to start coming to worship.
[36:06] SPEAKER_00: Another was going to a church where they didn't think there was any kind of gospel preaching.
[36:10] SPEAKER_00: And so my initial reaction was not like, well, none of my business.
[36:13] SPEAKER_00: I think this may encourage us to say, if that happens to you, yeah, that that could be something that is at least under your purview, we're a connected church, and if somebody has a request like that, that's that's not weird.
[36:26] SPEAKER_00: It's part of our connectionalism, and that if somebody's in a different part of the country, you know, try to help out the other under-shepherd to go after a straying sheep.
[36:35] SPEAKER_02: I'm with you guys, those are the shall in the first sentence is confusing when you combine it with the or in the latter part of the whole section.
[36:42] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[36:43] SPEAKER_01: Well, but it's not just the shall, it shall be deemed under the care of.
[36:47] SPEAKER_01: Like Right, yeah, yeah.
[36:49] SPEAKER_01: It's almost suggesting that, I mean, again, right, that that you know, this wayward child who's not a member who d lives in such and such a city shall be deemed to be under the care of the church that just happens to be in that city.
[37:02] SPEAKER_02: But did you not take the class at RTS where they teach you they or wherever you I think you went to RTS where they teach you how to sense when non-communing children are in your vicinity?
[37:12] SPEAKER_02: There's there's that whole like sixth sense being a pastor.
[37:14] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
[37:15] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, you missed that one.
[37:16] SPEAKER_01: No, no, I didn't have that class.
[37:18] SPEAKER_02: The guy that taught you that class probably got defrocked afterwards anyway, so no big deal anyway.
[37:23] SPEAKER_03: Well, maybe the mechanism for that in a serious note is that that's the responsibility of the outgoing session to reach out.
[37:31] SPEAKER_03: I resent.
[37:34] SPEAKER_01: Well, but that's where I think this is this is a this is a section that is right for I mean, of all the sections that need some revision and some help, I think this is one of those that really does.
[37:44] SPEAKER_01: Because as written, it it sh I don't know, just seems confusing and contrary to practice.
[37:51] SPEAKER_04: Sorry, Scott, I I will you write the revision for this GA to be considered?
[37:59] SPEAKER_01: Well, that that's coming up rel relatively quickly.
[38:03] SPEAKER_01: I used to have a few weeks.
[38:06] SPEAKER_01: My Presbytery meets in a few weeks.
[38:08] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, just get it done.
[38:09] SPEAKER_03: I'm I'm looking forward to it.
[38:11] SPEAKER_01: Knuckle under or just just get her done.
[38:13] SPEAKER_01: Just do it.
[38:15] SPEAKER_02: Listeners, this is Future Bend for just a moment.
[38:18] SPEAKER_02: When we recorded this, we began with a discussion of BCO twenty-eight as a whole, and it moved into some observations about how some men, authors that have commented on this content, have understood these sections in some differing ways.
[38:32] SPEAKER_02: We put it here at the end so as not to draw attention away from the substance of the chapter as a whole.
[38:37] SPEAKER_02: Enjoy.
[38:41] SPEAKER_02: Well, we're in BCO twenty-eight, disciplining of non-committing members.
[38:44] SPEAKER_02: There's good material in here.
[38:46] SPEAKER_02: We but before we hit record, Scott mentioned it's it's very pastoral in nature, and he's absolutely right.
[38:51] SPEAKER_02: Lots here about parental responsibility and the instruction of the church and the life of the children and the pastoral care of covenant children.
[38:58] SPEAKER_02: I mean, maybe the maybe a good question before we jump into all the details is can any one of y'all speak a little bit to why BCO28 is important in the broader context of PCA church discipline?
[39:08] SPEAKER_02: You usually think of the rules, rules of discipline as this like, you know, litigious is a word that gets tossed around a lot.
[39:15] SPEAKER_02: Seems a little out of place maybe if you're not expecting it.
[39:17] SPEAKER_02: If you don't know it's coming, all of a sudden there's a chapter that talks a lot about kids.
[39:21] SPEAKER_02: What's significant here?
[39:24] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I mean I think it's actually I had the same thing written down, you know, it just feels kind of out of place.
[39:29] SPEAKER_01: It it reads more like the directory of worship in one sense than it does the rest of the rules of discipline.
[39:35] SPEAKER_01: Usually you turn to this section of the BCO and you look for very specific steps, you know, do A, then B, then C, and this just kind of gives general advice.
[39:45] SPEAKER_01: And the other thing I think is important about this, beyond just the kind of pastoral side, which is important, but but it's also to be read in line with the rest of the BCO.
[39:55] SPEAKER_01: I mean, obviously, but particularly like chapters one, two, and six that talk about membership, this this whole chapter really flows from our understanding of the visible church, uh, that the visible church is made up of those who profess faith in Jesus Christ and their children.
[40:12] SPEAKER_01: And so there are communing and non-communing members sort of built into that idea.
[40:16] SPEAKER_01: I mean, this is one of the places where that's mentioned, but you have, you know, those who profess their faith and their children, and they have similar, yet in one sense, sort of distinct rights and privileges and duties and obligations.
[40:31] SPEAKER_01: And so, as this chapter sets it up, I mean, I think in one sense, as you said, you know, the discipline or the discipling of our children is really what this chapter is talking about.
[40:40] SPEAKER_01: And the discipline that is envisioned, if you go back to the previous chapter of 27, it's not envisioning the sort of formal discipline, because there's no there's no provision here for charging a non-commuting member, uh, taking them to trial.
[40:57] SPEAKER_01: There are no censures you can give a non-commuting member.
[41:00] SPEAKER_01: This is the general sort of non-technical sense of how we do um how we do discipline.
[41:09] SPEAKER_01: You know, you think about obviously censures as down the road, but most of the censures outside of officers or let's just say the initial admonition, the the primary lever that the session has is communion, right?
[41:23] SPEAKER_01: It is it is withholding the table or or holding somebody back from the table as a way to impress upon them the gravity of the charges that have been demonstrated to be true in trial or confess to, you know, in a case without process.
[41:38] SPEAKER_01: And in one sense, I mean it's all around the idea that the profession of faith that you've made has become questionable on the basis of your activities, on the basis of what you've done.
[41:50] SPEAKER_01: And particularly if you're refusing to repent or refusing to acknowledge, confess, etc., well, that's a lever you don't have, obviously, with a non-communing member, right?
[42:00] SPEAKER_01: I mean, they're already non-communing, so you can't take away that.
[42:05] SPEAKER_01: And so the rest of it is, and in one sense, I what I really think it's trying to do is to remind sessions, because that's really the focus, I think, of most of the discussion here, although it uses the word church, it's really talking about the church working through its officers, is the importance of impressing upon our children their covenant obligation to make a profession of faith, that they've been baptized and now as um as they grow, you know, they reach the age of discretion, which is a phrase we can talk about later, but that idea that that they need to make that profession of faith.
[42:39] SPEAKER_01: They need to join the church.
[42:41] SPEAKER_01: Um and they're really everything that I think here is focused upon how do we how do we encourage that and move in that direction with our children, which are non-commuting members.
[42:54] SPEAKER_01: I mean, obviously there's a section on adult non-community members and other things, but that's really kind of the main focus is what is our responsibility to children in the church.
[43:04] SPEAKER_02: Jared keeps clicking his microphone on to say something, but when he does, you can hear his children in the background, which I think is hilarious and appropriate.
[43:10] SPEAKER_00: But it gets a little bit into the substance of it, but along the lines of what Steve was saying, I found it kind of funny that Ramsey makes the point judicial prosecution may not be had of non-commuting children.
[43:22] SPEAKER_00: And then Smith comes in with baptism is the first act of discipline for children.
[43:26] SPEAKER_00: And so there's this, you know, the two different definitions that we had last time of discipline in the larger sense of everything that the church is doing and it in the more narrow sense of the judicial process.
[43:38] SPEAKER_00: I hear it's a helpful pastoral chapter to remind us, even if you're not going to put a non-commuting child through official proceedings of discipline, you still have an obligation to them.
[43:49] SPEAKER_00: And that's part of what this chapter is here for, to remind us of that.
[43:52] SPEAKER_02: Y'all may want to come back at this.
[43:53] SPEAKER_02: I feel like in the previous chapter when we were going through 27, on 27 2, all baptized persons are subject to disability.
[44:00] SPEAKER_02: And entitled to the benefits thereof, that Morton Smith on that point argues that the PCUS church didn't have non-commuting members included underneath that umbrella of discipline precisely because they couldn't have the table withheld from them.
[44:15] SPEAKER_02: They couldn't be barred from the table.
[44:17] SPEAKER_02: But Smith made the point that admonition and excommunication are censors that could be applied to non-commuting children.
[44:23] SPEAKER_02: I don't know how that squares up because I've I'm I've heard men I respect say you you can't discipline, you can't censure a non-commuting member.
[44:29] SPEAKER_02: Anyway, I was just curious if that rang any bells with especially either of you two that have already spoken on that issue.
[44:35] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[44:35] SPEAKER_01: Well, I mean, certainly discipline, we always have to go back to the idea that there are two senses of discipline, right?
[44:41] SPEAKER_01: And so everything the church does is discipline.
[44:44] SPEAKER_01: I think the other piece of that, though, kind of does lean into the first section where we're not suggesting that no one is responsible for disciplining these children, right?
[44:56] SPEAKER_01: That that the primary place for that occurs is with their parents.
[44:59] SPEAKER_01: And in fact, their parents are authorized under scripture to do a lot of things that session isn't authorized to do.
[45:05] SPEAKER_01: There's a lot of people I would love to spank and put in a timeout, but sadly, that's not something the BCO, you know, allows me to do.
[45:15] SPEAKER_01: So I think, you know, it's not the notion that they're without any kind of discipline whatsoever, that there is nothing the church, you know, broadly speaking, cannot do, but it is the responsibility of the parents to do the actual disciplining of those children.
[45:30] SPEAKER_01: Um, I mean, it actually, I think in one sense it creates more trouble when it goes the other direction, because if you have a communing member that is misbehaving, then they are subject to the authority of the session.
[45:42] SPEAKER_01: I mean, I'm not saying like, you know, he hit his brother or something, but I mean, if they are committing, you know, especially let's say they're a little older, they're in their high school or whatever, and they are committing offenses, they are subject to the jurisdiction of the church.
[45:54] SPEAKER_01: And and there, there's a proper place and a way in which that that session needs to discipline that's that child because he's a community member.
[46:03] SPEAKER_01: But non-communing members, certainly there is discipline there.
[46:06] SPEAKER_01: I also don't necessarily know that I agree with the idea that you can excommunicate a non-communing member.
[46:11] SPEAKER_01: That just you'd have to explain that more to me because I mean not you, but whoever is arguing that because in a sense, like, well, they're they've never been communicated, so how do you excommunicate?
[46:22] SPEAKER_01: So, yeah.
[46:24] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I guess the I would like to know a little more about okay, so they're on the roles in some capacity.
[46:31] SPEAKER_03: What's the process then to remove them from the roles if there's no official acts of discipline allowed from the session?
[46:41] SPEAKER_01: Well, I mean, removing somebody from the role though is a pastoral discipline, right?
[46:46] SPEAKER_01: It's not it's not an official, it's not the same thing as a censure.
[46:49] SPEAKER_01: And so I certainly think you can remove a non-commuting member from the role, particularly, you know, you think about uh, you know, 38-4, the idea of somebody saying, you know, I am not going to fulfill my vows in this or any other, you know, branch of the visible church.
[47:07] SPEAKER_01: Well, this wouldn't be I'm not going to fulfill my vow.
[47:10] SPEAKER_01: I'm not going to make a vow.
[47:11] SPEAKER_01: I'm not even going to do that.
[47:13] SPEAKER_01: I'm completely disowning the church.
[47:14] SPEAKER_01: And I think you could remove somebody in that, in that respect.
[47:17] SPEAKER_01: I would be very careful just from my limited, well, not my limited, my many years of uh working alongside Jay Nykirk on sessions, admonish is a word you you need to reserve for very specific, you know, moments.
[47:31] SPEAKER_01: Don't don't put in your minutes, you know, we admonished so-and-so to do, you know, that that's a that's a censure, but but I think, you know, outside of the technical use of the word, chastise, maybe, I don't know, but you know, I I think sessions individually, jointly, and severally can do that sort of thing with commuting or non-commuting members.
[47:48] SPEAKER_01: You know, I do that regularly as they this gaggle of boys run past me at breakneck speed after the end of the work.
[47:54] SPEAKER_01: Slow down, you know.
[47:56] SPEAKER_02: So I don't I'm not trying to have the whole conversation before the episode, and maybe all of this will just go after at the end of the episode.
[48:03] SPEAKER_02: I'll just make it a bonus thing at the end.
[48:04] SPEAKER_02: But so I found the thing from Smith from 27.
[48:08] SPEAKER_02: Did we not read 281 yet?
[48:10] SPEAKER_02: No, not yet.
[48:11] SPEAKER_02: Oh.
[48:12] SPEAKER_02: No, we haven't gotten to that yet.
[48:13] SPEAKER_02: We'll get there.
[48:14] SPEAKER_02: It'll happen.
[48:15] SPEAKER_02: No, it's not like we're on a time crunch or anything in this particular recording session.
[48:19] SPEAKER_02: Okay.
[48:19] SPEAKER_02: He says the PCA has specifically included the non-commuting members here, while the PCUS had excluded non-commuting members from it.
[48:26] SPEAKER_02: He says the argument was since they had never been admitted to the table, they could not have had that privilege taken from them.
[48:32] SPEAKER_02: I'm on board, right?
[48:33] SPEAKER_02: Like I get why they kept them away.
[48:35] SPEAKER_02: This is true, but there are other sanctions that can be invoked on the non-commuting member, says Smith.
[48:40] SPEAKER_02: For example, they can be admonished by the session regarding the way in which they are living.
[48:44] SPEAKER_02: He says this sanction can only be executed under judicial process.
[48:48] SPEAKER_02: It is true that the next step of discipline, namely suspension from the sacrament, cannot be invoked, but the next stage, namely excommunication, can be imposed.
[48:56] SPEAKER_02: So I don't know where I'm sitting on this.
[48:59] SPEAKER_02: I'm just pointing out that Smith seems to say a PCA session under 27-2 can go through process, arrive at a at a guilty verdict, and censure with admonition or excommunication a non-commuting member.
[49:15] SPEAKER_02: I'm no no hey, no, I'm no no I'm just I'm just curious, like like I mean, are we because I have it's all just kind of coming to me.
[49:25] SPEAKER_02: I'm like I'm with you guys, but then I get confused when Smith writes this.
[49:30] SPEAKER_02: So Yeah.
[49:32] SPEAKER_01: Well, and I think, you know, again, part of that is is a process thing, right?
[49:36] SPEAKER_01: So you know, we think about and this is obviously this is a discussion for a later time with censures, but you know, the censures are divided what is even available to you on the basis of whether or not you're satisfied with the repentance demonstrated by the individual.
[49:52] SPEAKER_01: Right?
[49:52] SPEAKER_01: I mean, if if you think somebody is not repentant, you cannot admonish them.
[49:56] SPEAKER_01: And so there's a in in one sense, if you if you're talking about a non-community member, somebody who's not made a profession of faith, uh and again, I don't I don't want to get too far ahead of myself because we're all just kind of thinking about this off the top of my head, our heads, but it's sort of like, well, they haven't made a profession of faith and though though repentance and faith is required of them by the covenant that they're under, I I don't know.
[50:24] SPEAKER_01: I I I just I there's a there's a piece of this that I'm just kind of uncomfortable going down that road.
[50:29] SPEAKER_01: And I don't think RBCO has any provision for that.
[50:34] SPEAKER_01: So I don't know that's probably something for some of the more learned legal scholars as you have them on later.
[50:41] SPEAKER_01: So so when Howie Donohoe's on for a completely different topic, just say, before we get into that, I wanted to ask you this question.
[50:47] SPEAKER_01: Listen.
[50:48] SPEAKER_02: Can you excommunique a non-community member?
[50:51] SPEAKER_02: I'm definitely sending this whole section to the end of the episode.
[50:55] SPEAKER_02: We'll have the episode begin with 18 or with 28-1, but uh this is uh riveting, riveting.
[51:00] SPEAKER_02: Patreon level stuff, I think, guys.
[51:04] SPEAKER_02: You think people go looking for our Patreon sometimes?
[51:06] SPEAKER_02: We talk about it.
[51:08] SPEAKER_02: I don't think anybody would object.
[51:10] SPEAKER_02: As non-commuting members everywhere would say, this podcast is over.
[51:14] SPEAKER_02: Thanks for joining us.
[51:15] SPEAKER_02: Be sure to come back next time when we discuss offenses from BCO29.
[51:19] SPEAKER_02: That's gonna be a whole episode where we try to offend you endlessly, by the way.
[51:22] SPEAKER_02: Not not actually on the chapter of offenses.
[51:25] SPEAKER_02: If you're interested in learning more about what we've talked about, check out the show notes.
[51:28] SPEAKER_02: There may be some things down there.
[51:29] SPEAKER_02: You can find those in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org.
[51:33] SPEAKER_02: Thanks again to Steve for being on.
[51:35] SPEAKER_02: I want to tell the listeners to stick around after the drop.
[51:37] SPEAKER_02: We had a discussion earlier about censors and non-commuting members that we're gonna tack on to the end of the episode so that the beginning of the episode actually gets into the content a little quicker.
[51:46] SPEAKER_02: If you've enjoyed the show, consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters, and be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
[51:52] SPEAKER_02: If you have questions or comments, as always, you can get in touch with us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com.
[51:58] SPEAKER_02: There's a link below to support our work, and if you do so, you'll be uh entitled to enter into our signal chat group, which is uh alive and thriving these days, where you can get direct access to me and my co-hosts.
[52:10] SPEAKER_02: If you have any polity questions you'd like answered incorrectly, we'd be happy to oblige.
[52:15] SPEAKER_02: Thanks again for spending time with us.
[52:16] SPEAKER_02: Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.
[52:21] SPEAKER_02: Goodbye, gentlemen.
[52:22] SPEAKER_02: Y'all take care.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
