# Wilson Weekly 69 - House Price Cycle

An episode of [Money Mentor Podcast™](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1632604767), 15 Feb 2024, 43 min.

Audio: https://episode.flightcast.com/wjd7xlle0e0oel0wqe63fgf8.mp3

Money Mentor Podcast Weekly Property Market Update with Australia's leading Independent Chief Economist Dr Andrew Wilson of My Housing Market and your Money Mentor, Graeme Holm. TIME STAMPS: 00:00 Intro 15:34 Home Loan Data 19:35 House Building Costs 23:25 House Price Cycle 30:53 Weekend Auction Market 37:14 How Much Is My Home Currently Worth? 38:31 What's On Next Week 42:24 Outro Money Mentor Youtube Channel: https://bit.ly/3S11sAv Link to Dr Andrew Wilsons LinkedIN: https://www.linkedin.com/in/dr-andrew-wilson-79b70058/ If you enjoyed our Podcast, make sure you hit the FOLLOW button to stay up to date with the latest episodes. We really appreciate you supporting our podcast. See you next week :)

## Transcript

[0:13] Alright, good morning ladies and gentlemen.
[0:15] Welcome back to the Wilson Weekly with myself, Graeme Holm, as boringly usual, and the amazing Dr. Andrew Wilson from my housing market.
[0:23] And this is the Wilson Weekly 69.
[0:27] How are you, Doc?
[0:28] Well, there you go.
[0:29] Well, we're rocking along there.
[0:30] Numbers up.
[0:31] We have to have a big 100 show, won't we?
[0:33] So...
[0:33] We will.
[0:34] Maybe some giveaways or something, some special tips perhaps.
[0:37] And I heard you mention that you're boring.
[0:40] I think you're the last person on earth to be called boring, Graham.
[0:45] Stop it.
[0:46] Stop it.
[0:47] It's nice to be modest.
[0:49] Yes, and here we are again, second week of February, rocking along.
[0:53] Housing markets are back in town and we'll look at the latest auction results.
[0:58] And, you know, we were waiting to see if that strong start to the year would be consolidated.
[1:03] And quick tip, yes, it has been.
[1:05] It's really been a strong start, Graham, perhaps taken most by surprise, given that we're tracking well above where we were at the end of last year.
[1:14] So we'll have a look at that in some depth.
[1:17] and also at the latest data that's come through.
[1:20] We're also going to have a look at the house price cycle, Graeme.
[1:25] Everybody talks about the cycle.
[1:27] Everybody talks about the cycle, but nobody does anything about it.
[1:30] But we're going to actually give you a model in regard to that cycle.
[1:34] Oh, that would be good.
[1:35] Because you hear everyone say a house price cycle, every seven years they double.
[1:39] And I'm like, no, if they grow 7% per annum for 10 years, they double.
[1:43] Oh, no, no, they double every 10.
[1:44] No, no, no, there's an 18-year cycle.
[1:46] I'm like...
[1:47] well, this is going to be fun.
[1:49] This is good, everyone.
[1:50] Pay attention so we can have some form of model, I guess you're saying, Doc, you're suggesting that.
[1:55] Well, yes, it is a model, a model that goes well back in time.
[1:59] I did it actually in my university days, my study days.
[2:03] It was part of my research, and it sort of stood in good stead.
[2:08] It's an interesting sort of concept.
[2:10] But there are other models of the housing market that are sort of out there, and I don't understand them.
[2:14] There's the clock.
[2:15] If you've seen the clock,
[2:17] I think Heron Todd White do a clock.
[2:20] It's like downturn, upswing.
[2:23] I'm like, okay.
[2:24] I don't get that.
[2:25] It just goes around in circles.
[2:26] It never actually, yeah.
[2:30] I don't understand, but ours is a lot better, and we'll have a look at that today.
[2:36] Latest home loan data, and we'll also look at the latest building costs, house building costs data, which is some better news, but we've had hot off the press from the US today, and we have been having a little bit of a go at the experts, which we do.
[2:53] if we can call them experts in regard particularly to the prospect of what's going to happen in the economy, particularly interest rates and inflation.
[3:00] There's a bit of a shock for those experts that have all looked a bit silly this year also in the US because they've been predicting a cut in interest rates and a lot of the Australian media have sort of picked up on that, no surprise.
[3:12] Unfortunately, the Australian media is not known for its originality.
[3:15] It just sort of does a cut and paste of whatever's happening in the US.
[3:19] It's a little bit embarrassing, but nonetheless, the experts that were last year, and we've mentioned this a number of times, Graeme, predicting a 100% chance that interest rates would be cut in February, sorry, in March, at the March meeting of the Federal Reserve.
[3:35] The experts all predicted, in fact, all of them put together was 100% chance, MarketWatch said, that interest rates would be cut in the March meeting.
[3:45] Well, that's turned into just about zero now.
[3:47] I'm not sure how you go to 100% chance and then all of a sudden it's not happening.
[3:52] I think you should have left yourself a little bit of wriggle room there or some of the experts, but just shows you.
[3:57] that they're like lemmings jumping off the cliff.
[3:59] One's wrong.
[3:59] They're all wrong.
[4:00] So I guess we could say that.
[4:02] We try not to be wrong here.
[4:03] But the point is today we've had some data, fresh data, come out of the US.
[4:08] It's the January inflation data, and it's gone the wrong way, Graham.
[4:13] It's...
[4:14] not looking good.
[4:15] The trends have been significantly improving for inflation in the US, but the trend actually, certainly the forecasts were well off in terms of where they thought it would go.
[4:26] The trend is now moving, and it's only one month, but moved the other way, and that's created now a completely nil prospect
[4:36] in terms of the experts of an interest rate cut in March.
[4:39] They're now talking May or June, you know, still hanging on to, for grim death it seems, to the prospect of an interest rate cut, but the data's not supporting it now.
[4:49] The underlying inflation is now well above the 2% target
[4:55] that the Federal Reserve has.
[4:56] It's above 3%.
[4:58] And as I said, sort of heading in the wrong direction.
[5:01] So it's proving a very big challenge for the market.
[5:05] I find it really intriguing.
[5:07] Like 100%, if you're going to say 100%, you might as well say 1,000%.
[5:10] Like you were saying unequivocally, there is no other opposing outcome.
[5:15] It is 100% going to occur.
[5:19] Like I find that a little bit intriguing, like to have absolute, not 99, not 95, like absolute certainty, and they were absolutely wrong.
[5:28] So, I mean, it's the point is that I guess if you've got X amount of experts and they're all saying that, well, it's 100% chance.
[5:35] But even if you say, okay, well, it's not saying per se that it is absolutely going to happen.
[5:39] It's just the number of experts that have predicted this.
[5:42] But really, doesn't it show the confluence of ineptitude,
[5:48] If everybody is saying the wrong thing and, you know, what worries me, and it's a bit the same in Australia, is there's a lot of agendas out there, Graham.
[5:58] A lot of the commentary is based on a particular, I guess, you know, prospect or a particular agenda for, you know, wanting to have the stock market higher because lower interest rates will push the stock market up or, you know, having some sort of a movement
[6:16] in interest rates or bonds, so people can bet in favour of that.
[6:21] And, of course, those that operate in those markets, they make money on the margins, you know, not necessarily what's happening, but the fact is that it's about change.
[6:31] And a lot of these economists that are, you know, part of the commentariat are...
[6:39] in the media are associated with these particular businesses whose job it is, you know, to make money.
[6:45] And they're obviously wanting to sort of create a positive energy around what their agenda is, you know.
[6:50] Yeah.
[6:51] And as we keep saying here, okay, it's a bit of fun.
[6:53] Yeah, you can laugh at them because they're wrong.
[6:55] But as long as you're not making business decisions based on these predictions.
[7:00] So it was interesting, Graeme.
[7:02] And just to finish off on that before we get started into the data, yeah.
[7:07] they said it's quite noticeable that all the goods issues with inflation have basically been put to bed.
[7:14] In other words, all those supply constraints that were created through COVID where we had all that demand because of stimulus packages, and you remember we couldn't buy a used car, we couldn't buy a couch, we couldn't buy anything because we just didn't have the supply coming through to cope with this, you know, avalanche of demand.
[7:34] Well, that's sort of settled down now.
[7:36] And, of course, we've got lower fuel prices as well, and that's all part of the supply catching up with demand.
[7:42] So all that good stuff has settled down, but the drive for higher prices is coming from services, and that's a product of, you know, higher prices driving higher wages and employees going to the boss saying, hey, I need some more money here, Mr. Boss or Mrs. Boss or Miss Boss Man, woman.
[8:05] to cover all these extra prices.
[8:07] And this is where the real issue is that it's not about productivity gains.
[8:12] It's about just saying, hey, I want to cover all these extra prices, so you've got to pay me more.
[8:17] So it's the services costs which are clearly on the rise now in the US.
[8:24] And, you know, as we say,
[8:28] we should look to the US to some degree in regard to what would happen here in Australia.
[8:34] And our inflation rate is still well above the US's inflation rate, underlying inflation rate.
[8:40] We're at four, they're at three, and our interest rates are below where the US interest rates are.
[8:48] So, you know, there's still some work to do going forward, but I just thought that was interesting to mention.
[8:54] So let's have a look at the latest data, Graeme.
[8:57] While you bring your slides up, Doc, I'm going to share some very sad news with you while you bring those slides up.
[9:04] Okay.
[9:06] ConBank CBA, Mr. Matt Common, has just come out and pledged support of customers during the ongoing cost of the living crisis, and he's optimistic about the economy, but he's a little bit upset, Doc.
[9:20] Do you know why he's upset?
[9:21] Why is he upset?
[9:22] Why is he upset?
[9:23] They've just announced their half-year profit, which is down 3% on the same period 12 months ago.
[9:30] Guess what he announced as their half-year profit?
[9:33] What is it?
[9:35] $5 billion.
[9:36] Well, that's nice if you can get it, mate.
[9:40] You know what I'm saying?
[9:41] We're definitely going to support families with out-of-cycle rate rises and buffers.
[9:49] We're here to support you, but we're very upset that we only made $5 billion this half year.
[9:56] Yeah, well, no wonder they're talking up the prospect of changing interest rates, because that gives them the opportunity to fiddle with their margins, which they've been doing, as we know, for the best part of a decade.
[10:13] Well, the interesting...
[10:15] The interesting one, Doc, is if you remember when APRA got involved with macroprudential regulation and they increased in interest-only investment loans 1% per annum, right?
[10:25] Now, that was predominantly what?
[10:27] Because of the hot Sydney housing market through 18, 19, do you think?
[10:31] Well, they were predicting interest rates were going to rise, right?
[10:33] That was the bottom line.
[10:35] The Reserve Bank said the next move in rates would be up.
[10:39] So the APRA and the banks all said, okay, well, we're worried that if there's an increase in interest rates, it's going to expose all these investors that have been flooding the market, particularly in Sydney.
[10:50] Mm-hmm.
[10:51] and that will cause some issues in terms of defaults, and we don't want that.
[10:55] So we want to dissuade investors from being part of the market.
[10:59] Well, firstly, of course, they were so wrong about interest rates, it's laughable because not only did interest rates not rise, Graeme, they actually fell, and they fell by a dramatic amount in the back half of 2019, and that was the first big negative for the ex-governor of the Reserve Bank.
[11:19] Those predictions were just really...
[11:21] To pull that apart more, but pulling that apart more, we still have a 1% per annum higher rate roughly for invest.
[11:28] They never reduced that margin.
[11:31] Yeah.
[11:31] So as rates went down, they've continued to maintain this half a percent, 1% increase on investors.
[11:38] But what are they calling now?
[11:39] I don't understand.
[11:41] That's a bit cheeky, Doc.
[11:42] Yeah.
[11:43] Absolutely.
[11:44] And this is why we keep saying, Graham, that it's great that we've got such a strong banking sector and it is part of what makes our housing market so successful because it is very risk averse.
[11:55] So we don't get the chance really to take risks.
[11:58] because banks are not operating in a highly competitive market environment.
[12:03] Now, that's fine and we want that, but at the same time, they've got an obligation because of all that market power, at least to be considering the consumers and I think the government
[12:14] really needs to find the courage to have a better control over what the banks are doing in relation to protecting the rights of consumers.
[12:26] And looking at the changes in margins, we've seen mortgage rates back in 2012 were actually lower than where they are now, even though official interest rates were higher.
[12:40] than where they are now.
[12:42] So even though we've seen a reduction in interest rates compared to where they were 10 years ago, official rates, we've now seen mortgage rates are higher.
[12:53] So it means that margin creep has continued.
[12:56] And that's what happens.
[12:57] You know, banks creep through the margin.
[12:59] And part of what that is, what you said, Graham, about the
[13:02] not passing on the restrictions that were made to those investors once it became clear that the economic predictions were completely fanciful that the banks were basing this on.
[13:16] And the banks have a terrible record
[13:19] in terms of their economic insights.
[13:23] And yet they have these massive economic departments, but they keep getting it wrong.
[13:27] Just look at their predictions for the housing market over the past three, four, five years.
[13:32] They've been so wrong, it's almost ludicrous.
[13:36] And yet, of course, they do guide a lot of what people's mindset is because they're expected to have a high level of competency
[13:44] banks, but their record just doesn't reflect that.
[13:47] And it's just part of, you think that the economic department seems to be just another arm of the marketing department, you know what I mean?
[13:56] Just trying to control risk outcomes.
[14:01] But
[14:01] Yeah, okay, so bad luck, boo-hoo, only $5 billion profit, and maybe that's a little bit of a smokescreen to cover the fact that they're still really rocking along in what are certainly high inflation environments.
[14:18] and a higher interest rate environment, clearly.
[14:20] So that's just the banks for you.
[14:22] And I guess we'll shed a tear, maybe not for the poor result from the Commonwealth Bank, you know, going forward.
[14:30] But what worries me is they might start to think, well, we've got to recover that loss in profits.
[14:37] It's not a loss.
[14:38] It's just it's not as big as it was.
[14:40] It was humongous, and now it's just enormous, right?
[14:44] Yeah.
[14:44] Yeah, it says $5 billion, but it should have been $5 billion plus 3%.
[14:49] Oh, tsk, tsk.
[14:50] Yeah, that's right.
[14:51] But as I said, the concern is that that might activate some other activities in terms of margins to try to recover that going forward.
[15:02] And as I said, I think we need a government with the –
[15:05] The fortitude at least to be able to hold banks accountable, given how much market power that they do have, and I'm not criticising the market power, I'm just saying there should be some balance in all of this.
[15:17] Yeah.
[15:18] Let's have a look at the data, Graeme.
[15:20] Let's.
[15:20] Always excited for the data.
[15:22] Yeah, hot off the press from my housing market, and we're always, of course, about the current state and future prospects of housing markets, particularly the current states.
[15:30] We're always up to date with what's happening in the market, and the latest data out of the ABS is for home loans.
[15:36] It was interesting that the home loan data actually tracked back.
[15:40] A little bit over December, Graeme, after being certainly showing an upward trend over the last six months of last year.
[15:48] Of course, that followed what was robust housing market activity.
[15:52] So no surprise, we saw a recovery in home lending over 2023, just as we saw a general recovery in house prices.
[16:01] But that went back a little bit over, and this is seasonal adjusted data, a little bit over December, down by 4.4% over the month.
[16:09] Again, we've got to say this, as we say all the time, with the seasonally adjusted data out of the ABS, you have to take this with just a pinch of salt because there have been problems with the seasonal adjustment modelling.
[16:21] The American statistical products, the UK statistical products and Europe statistical products are all saying that the
[16:30] they've been caught out by the changes to the seasonal adjustment model because of what happened during COVID.
[16:36] And that's when we had months that are typically stronger became weaker, and months that were typically weaker became stronger.
[16:43] And that's how your base seasonal adjustment is on the long-term nature of particular parts of the year in terms of being weaker or stronger, and you adjust for that going forward.
[16:52] So,
[16:53] The underlying trend is still pretty reasonable, but we have to take that into account.
[16:57] But nonetheless, it was a little bit of a surprise, but it is the December data, which should, you know, even being December, which is quite a month typically for home lending, we still should have had perhaps a better outcome later.
[17:13] in terms of accounting for the seasonal adjustment.
[17:16] But what was interesting is when we look at, we break down the lending as we do into owner-occupiers, investors and first-home buyers.
[17:24] We saw that first-home buyers, sorry, the investors and owner-occupiers track down by similar amounts, owner-occupiers more than first-home buyers.
[17:33] investors, but it was still a down month for both of those particular buyer groups.
[17:38] But interestingly, Graham, first-home buyers continue to rise, and we discussed this last month.
[17:43] We're really seeing early days, perhaps, a bounce back in first-home buyer activity above what's happening with the other buyer types.
[17:51] And I think as we've explained that, and when we look at the chart, we can see first home buyer numbers or loan value was up by 1.7%, owner occupiers generally down 6.3%, and investors down just 1.3%.
[18:05] Now, all this data is still well below where it was when we compared the year-on-year results.
[18:12] But I do think that that revival from first home buyers is just reflecting how tough that rental market is, Graeme, that there's plenty of incentives out there.
[18:21] to get into a house from first-home buyers.
[18:23] I think the bank of mum and dad is very active at the moment, realising that it's just such a trap to be in that rental market.
[18:31] We're still seeing rents rise.
[18:32] We're not seeing really any sign that...
[18:36] supply is catching up with demand.
[18:39] And I think, you know, once again, this is a very significant encouragement for those that are renting to get into the housing market.
[18:48] And, of course, you know, there are other constraints, generally high prices with higher inflation making it tougher to save for your deposit.
[18:56] Yeah.
[18:57] And as I said, I think that those constraints are motivating more first-home buyers to come into the market, so we shouldn't be surprised at that.
[19:06] But clearly, two months in a row now, the trend has been up for first-home buyers.
[19:12] whereas the trend has been against that for investors and owner-occupiers.
[19:18] Western Australia was the top state for housing loans over December.
[19:24] All the other states headed backwards, but Western Australia overall was down by just 0.9%, but over the years so far up by 5.5%.
[19:35] We know that Western Australian housing market, well, particularly the Perth housing market, Graham,
[19:41] It has a lot of value in it, high wages in Perth, and yet the median house price is well below eastern seaboard prices.
[19:49] So that's obviously giving that affordability advantage some sort of a kick-along, and perhaps that's why we're seeing more lending occurring in Western Australia compared to particularly the eastern states.
[20:01] So that's home loans, Graeme, which are always good to, I guess, get a deeper look into the housing market, particularly in terms of biotypes.
[20:10] We also have a model for house building costs, Graeme, which we look at every month.
[20:15] And this is important, firstly, of course, for inflation, because the surge in house building costs, which is an important component of overall housing costs,
[20:24] In the CPI data model, the inflation data model from the ABS, that's been part of what drove inflation higher.
[20:32] Steeply higher has been the steep increase in house building costs.
[20:36] However, we've started to see some improvement there.
[20:39] Although costs are continuing to rise, Graham, they're not rising at the same annual rate as they have been previously and the trend is clearly downward.
[20:49] So still rising house building costs when we're looking
[20:54] data there at record levels.
[20:56] And you can see how that just really exploded, given that the home builder package from the previous government, which brought forward a lot of demand.
[21:05] We didn't have the tradespeople.
[21:07] We didn't have the suppliers to keep up with all that demand.
[21:10] So costs went through the roof, and that was part of why we had the highest inflation for decades.
[21:16] But when we look at the year-on-year comparisons, and that, of course, is what we talk about when we talk about the inflation rate, we're seeing the trend continuing to fall, which is good news, Graeme.
[21:27] So we're down now to just 7% increase over the year, which is way too high.
[21:31] Let's not gild this.
[21:33] But 7% increase, sorry, it's a 6.7% increase.
[21:39] I'm referring to the November data there.
[21:42] But it's now only 6.7% increase over the year to December for that quarterly house building cost index.
[21:50] So clearly running down.
[21:52] I mean, we were at...
[21:54] nearly 25% at the peak and now we're at 6.7%.
[21:57] But that's still too high, Graeme.
[21:59] When you look at the pre-COVID levels at 1%, 2%, you know, which was typical house building costs would rise in a very competitive industry, we're still too high, but we're clearly moving in the right direction and it's part of what's helping the building overall inflation rate
[22:18] to improve.
[22:19] So some good news there, some better news.
[22:21] Still too high, Graeme.
[22:22] And the point to all this is not just about inflation and interest rates.
[22:26] It's also about trying to get more buildings and more homes into the Australian housing market, which clearly need it.
[22:32] And this is just another constraint, you know, attached to, you know, planning restrictions, green tape, red tape.
[22:39] We now have high house building costs, which make it difficult, obviously, for profitability.
[22:45] for house builders, even if they can get that building approval up, they've got to think about, hey, can we make a profit out of this?
[22:52] So, you know, hopefully it will continue to fall and hopefully it will decrease the constraints on profitability for home builders because, Graham, as you know, we need all the new homes we can get to offset the clear imbalance we have, record imbalance between supply and demand in the housing market.
[23:11] And then some, Doc.
[23:12] We need all the homes we can get and then some.
[23:15] Absolutely.
[23:16] But we've got to start somewhere, and at least that's a better statistic going forward.
[23:20] But we've still got a long way to go in terms of really getting the home building industry going gangbusters.
[23:27] Now, as we sort of mentioned earlier, Graeme, we speak about, you know, the housing market cycle and there's a lot of theories around the cycle.
[23:36] Well, we have a model here that we use to explain the house price cycle and it actually helps us locate where capital city housing markets are on the cycle.
[23:48] So what are we talking about with the cycle?
[23:49] Well, this is the real data here, Graeme.
[23:51] So this is the real data going back to –
[23:55] the early 2000s.
[23:56] And you can see that sort of wave effect happening.
[24:00] You can see that shape of how prices move.
[24:03] Now, various factors influence the highs and the lows, which creates the cycle.
[24:09] Of course, higher interest rates, factors such as the GFC and COVID.
[24:17] We had those APRA policies,
[24:24] Things improve.
[24:24] We then get a spurt surge in demand, and that gives us that sort of cycle.
[24:29] You can clearly see the cycle, can't you, Graham, sort of rising and falling there.
[24:33] So that's the cycle of the five major capital cities.
[24:36] If we look quite closely at that, and we're going to illustrate this quickly in a second.
[24:41] You can see the top two cycles there are gold and black.
[24:44] They're Sydney and Melbourne.
[24:45] If you look very closely at where we are over the December quarter and you look backwards to the previous cycle, that's the peak of the previous upswing, you can see that Sydney and Melbourne are still below where they were at their previous peak, right?
[25:01] So even though they've grown strongly, as you can see from last year's performance, they're still below where they were at the peak of the previous cycle.
[25:10] All right?
[25:10] Is that as clear as mud?
[25:12] But when you look at these other three,
[25:14] When you look at the other three cycles there, which is Brisbane, Adelaide and Perth, they're actually tracking higher than their previous peaks of the cycle.
[25:27] So let's see that real data and that's the real model of the data and let's create a model around that to explain exactly where we all are in terms of the cycle.
[25:41] So I mentioned that Sydney and Melbourne were below where they were in their previous cycle.
[25:45] We've actually measured that.
[25:47] So the previous peak of the cycle for Melbourne was April 2022.
[25:52] They're 4.1% below that.
[25:54] Sydney's 2% odd below where they were in March 2022.
[26:00] but Brisbane is actually 7.8% higher than where they were in May 22.
[26:07] It's all similar to the peak of the cycle then, and that, of course, was the end of the COVID surge.
[26:13] Adelaide, 8.2% higher, and Perth is actually 17.6% higher, Graham, than where it was at the peak of its previous cycle.
[26:21] So as you say, this was all about...
[26:23] the same time in 2022, March to June, where those cycles peak.
[26:30] And, of course, they go at different rates because there are different factors in each of those capital city markets.
[26:36] So let's create a model based on what we know in regard to that.
[26:40] So there's our model.
[26:42] And you can see that model has the typical shape that we saw with the real data, and it's defined that shape by trough and peak points.
[26:51] Now, it has an upward bias because we can see when we look at the model, not the model, but the real data, that it actually has an upward trend over time.
[27:00] So it means we can have an upward trend in our model because that's how it works in real terms.
[27:07] But what we want to do is divide that model into particular phases, all right?
[27:13] So we can figure out where...
[27:15] our housing markets are in terms of the model, in terms of where they are in the phases.
[27:20] So the first phase is a correction phase, and that's when prices start to fall below a defined peak point.
[27:27] If we fall below the previous trough point, we then move into a contraction phase, and that's the notorious bubble you keep hearing about.
[27:38] Where's this bubble dock?
[27:42] Well, see, it doesn't happen because it's a bit of a myth because typically, and that's what gives us our upward bias in the cycle, typically we move into a recovery phase where the trough point is higher than the previous trough point.
[27:57] So we find our trough point.
[27:58] which is typically higher than the previous trough point, and then we move into a recovery phase with prices rising.
[28:06] And then when we move above the previous peak of the cycle, of the previous cycle, we then move into an expansion phase.
[28:13] And on the cycle goes.
[28:14] So that's a pretty simple sort of model to explain where we are.
[28:18] We can relate it to the real data that we saw on the first slide.
[28:22] It's the same shape.
[28:23] but now we're dividing it into particular areas that determine where we are and where we're going.
[28:29] So let's put this all together.
[28:31] There we are.
[28:32] There's our model.
[28:33] It's colour-coded to define the shapes.
[28:38] But what we can see there is that...
[28:41] As we saw with the original actual data, we can see there that Perth, Adelaide and Brisbane are all in the expansion phase of the cycle.
[28:52] So they're moving forward.
[28:53] They're at the highest level compared to the previous cycle.
[28:57] You can see they're actually growing up the cycle because you can see with the latest data, growth data, that Brisbane is rising by 1%.
[29:11] and Perth is rising by 1.9%.
[29:13] So they're all moving up that expansion phase, Graeme, which shows that they are obviously in an upswing in terms of the market.
[29:22] However, when we look at Melbourne and Sydney, they're still in that recovery phase, right?
[29:29] So they're still in the recovery phase.
[29:32] Sydney's flat in the recovery phase with the latest data, so it's sort of steady there.
[29:37] hasn't moved to an expansion phase yet, and Melbourne is actually shifting backwards.
[29:42] It's the underperformer there.
[29:44] It's still in the recovery phase, but it's actually moving backwards.
[29:47] So I think what that shows, obviously, is how markets are performing in terms of the cycle.
[29:53] But I also think that that tells us
[29:55] you know, when we look at the underlying supply and demand factors, the potential for these markets to grow, particularly markets that haven't moved into the expansion phase, which is Melbourne and Sydney.
[30:07] So Melbourne and Sydney prices are still below, Graham, where they were at the beginning of 2022.
[30:13] That's going on to two years.
[30:17] So I think that's why we're seeing strong results, which we'll look at next.
[30:21] in terms of the auction market this year is because that value perception, it's not a perception, it's a reality, that prices are still lower in Sydney and Melbourne than where they were two years ago.
[30:33] And I think that's a force given how strong the economies are, given migration, given undersupply, given the rental markets, that's a force that's continuing to attract buyers in the marketplace.
[30:44] It is.
[30:44] So I think that's a worthwhile model to explain in another way, not just with prices, how our markets are tracking in terms of the cycle.
[30:54] So we mentioned weekend auction markets.
[30:56] It was the second major weekend of the year, Graham.
[31:00] We had a very good start to the year.
[31:01] The big question was going to be, will this hold up or was it just a one-off?
[31:07] in terms of the beginning to the year.
[31:08] Well, it wasn't a one-off.
[31:10] And we know that auction clearance rates, we always say this, look at those weekend auction clearance rate results.
[31:15] They are a really good forward indicator of what's happening in the market, the underlying energy in the market.
[31:21] You can see there how Sydney house prices track clearance rates, almost exactly same with Melbourne, higher clearance rates, higher house prices, lower clearance rates, lower house prices.
[31:31] So a very
[31:32] Very good, you know, real-time Saturday insight into the housing market, which has proven to be remarkably predictive over the journey.
[31:44] So let's have a look at last weekend's results.
[31:45] Another big result, Brian.
[31:48] Really big result.
[31:49] Wow.
[31:51] I've been a little surprised at how strong these markets have started the year.
[31:57] Yes, we're only two weeks in.
[31:58] It is only the second week of February, but gee, we're so far so good, particularly for a seller.
[32:03] If Sydney market, 600, and it's not just the clearance rate.
[32:07] Sydney had a 77.2% clearance rate.
[32:10] But it's the volume, Doc.
[32:12] It's the volume and the clearance rate.
[32:15] That's right.
[32:15] So the clearance rates are strong.
[32:18] If you were to adjust that based on volume, like, wow, that's phenomenal.
[32:23] 688 last Saturday, this time last year 541.
[32:27] Yeah, yeah.
[32:28] I mean, that's a huge jump.
[32:30] Melbourne as well.
[32:32] Yeah, Melbourne as well.
[32:33] And look, Graeme, if we combine this year and this year's first two weeks with last year's first two weeks, it would be even more profound because the first weekend of the year also had a big jump in the number of listings in Sydney and Melbourne and Brisbane, Adelaide and Canberra.
[32:51] Big, big numbers.
[32:52] But this is a very strong result.
[32:54] This is clearly a seller's market when you're getting a clearance rate pushing over 75%.
[32:59] That means there's strong competition amongst buyers for existing property that is clearing at that rate, nearly 80%, Graeme, and we know that's the boom benchmark.
[33:09] We're not calling this a boom, Graeme, but it's very strong.
[33:12] Boom.
[33:14] Boom.
[33:14] But as you mentioned, 688 auctions well ahead of the same weekend last year.
[33:20] Clearance rate also well ahead of the same weekend last year, which was the beginning of a revival in the market.
[33:26] Melbourne also big numbers, 577 compared to 490.
[33:31] Again, the clearance rate was higher than the previous weekend, and I didn't mention that Sydney's clearance rate
[33:35] not only higher than the same weekend last year, but also higher than the previous weekend.
[33:42] So two very good results there.
[33:43] Melbourne tracking ahead of where it was, and this is the other point, this is considerably higher than where we ended the year last year, Graeme.
[33:51] We ended the year in the mid to high 60s, and here we are in the mid to high 70s just two weeks into the new auction year, you know.
[34:00] Brisbane, good result there for Brisbane.
[34:01] Fewer auctions in Brisbane.
[34:04] A lot of the coastal resort places have auctions this time of the year in Brisbane, so that's come down a little bit, but very strong clearance rate.
[34:13] We know that clearance rate in Brisbane tends to be quite volatile for local factors.
[34:19] Adelaide, fewer auctions than the previous weekend, but certainly higher than the same weekend last year.
[34:26] We were used to 80% plus every weekend in Adelaide, what it seemed like last year.
[34:31] It's not catching that 80% result, which is almost hard to sustain anyway, but still a very good result, nearly 80% for Adelaide.
[34:39] And Canberra picked up a little bit compared to the previous weekend, but auction numbers are down.
[34:44] But Canberra's been...
[34:45] I guess the sideways market to a large degree, and I think there's plenty of upside for that Canberra market going forward.
[34:52] But still, when we look particularly at Sydney and Melbourne, these are very strong results, Graham, and it's two weekends in a row.
[34:59] Let's wait for next weekend to see if it continues.
[35:04] A lot of the – because, of course, there was a lot of head shaking with those who got it wrong a year ago when auction clearance rates started to rise.
[35:12] Of course, we predicted that back in 2022.
[35:15] auction clearance rates started to improve.
[35:17] There was a lot of gobbledygooks coming out of those sort of self-appointed experts that it was all about low volumes of auctions, right?
[35:28] But here we are, we've got massively higher volumes of auctions and we've actually got higher clearance rates.
[35:33] So I'm not sure where the theory of supply and demand goes in terms of the auction market in relation to just looking at demand on its own and supply on its own, generating clearance rates.
[35:47] But as I said, a lot of those so-called experts certainly got it wrong big time last year.
[35:53] And they couldn't just bail out on the fact that it was low auction numbers that were pushing up clearance rates because we did see prices rise.
[36:00] as a result, and we're seeing the reverse here, higher auction numbers, and yet we're getting higher clearance rates.
[36:07] So going forward, let me just look quickly at the trends to finish off, Graham.
[36:11] You can see we're trending in Sydney well above, so far, February, well above February last year and well above the end of last year as well.
[36:19] Melbourne similarly tracking above where it was at the same time last year and above the end of the spring season.
[36:27] Brisbane also higher.
[36:28] Yeah.
[36:29] Adelaide a little bit lower, but it had those very high results last year.
[36:33] And Canberra, still a soft-dish market and some work to do, I guess, to catch up particularly with that Sydney market.
[36:41] But Canberra has been moving a little sideways, particularly over the last six months.
[36:45] Unequivocally strong start to the year.
[36:47] Graham, let's see if it continues next weekend, and surely higher prices will follow higher clearance rates.
[36:53] If you want those auctioned prices,
[36:55] auction clearance rate data every Saturday night on my LinkedIn channel.
[37:00] Around about 6.15, you get the headline results for the capital cities.
[37:06] And then on Sundays, typically Sunday morning, you get the full national report, including regional breakdowns for
[37:14] Sydney and Melbourne.
[37:15] So we always finish off with our app.
[37:18] We have an app, the My Housing Market Infinity app, which is a little toolkit to have you understand what's happening in the market in terms of asking prices.
[37:30] and listings on rent.
[37:34] There's a screenshot of what you can do.
[37:36] You can select any suburb in Australia.
[37:38] You can filter it for houses or units.
[37:41] You can filter for the number of bedrooms and it will give you the median house price for asking prices currently, the high and the low, and the number of listings.
[37:48] We've got black down there as an example on the screenshot.
[37:51] And also it does the same thing for rents.
[37:53] It gives you the median, the high and the low and the number of listings.
[37:56] So if you're looking at a particular suburb you're interested in,
[38:00] then this is an interesting little toolkit that you can only get through Infinity, get onto the Infinity crew, and they will let you know how to get onto that.
[38:08] We're going to update this app pretty soon, so look out for that, and we'll have a brand-new sparkling shiny app, which will also include sales data as well.
[38:18] So look out for that one.
[38:19] You need all the tools you can get when you're making decisions about property.
[38:23] It is all about taking a scientific approach.
[38:25] And looking at what's happening on the ground in real time is certainly a good starting point on your property journey.
[38:31] Next week, we've got the January labour market data, first of the year for the data sets.
[38:38] So how is the labour market tracking?
[38:41] Just started to trend down a little bit towards the end of last year, which is probably good news for the Reserve Bank shows perhaps their interest rates are working.
[38:49] It also might show perhaps that the surge in migration is starting to push the unemployment rate up, but it's still very, very low.
[38:58] We're also going to have the December wage price data, which is very important, Graham.
[39:02] Have wages kept up with inflation over the December quarter?
[39:06] We're all interested in seeing that.
[39:08] We had a record result over the September quarter, 4% annual increase.
[39:12] Will we follow that up?
[39:13] We'll also have a quick look at the latest regional home prices
[39:17] And, of course, we'll look at the latest weekend auction results.
[39:20] So that's all for this weekend for this week, Graham.
[39:24] And we look forward to another thrill-packed episode of Housing Market Data.
[39:29] It was a bit interesting today because we had some new stuff, particularly in relation to the house price cycle.
[39:36] That was good, Doc.
[39:37] I like the cycle.
[39:39] And the cycle isn't so much of a cycle cycle.
[39:42] People go every X years, it's peak to trough, it's growing, it's settling.
[39:47] It's very interesting that I think people still think of the word cycle like a clock or it's up or it's down.
[39:54] I really like the way you've broken that down.
[39:56] So hopefully everyone paid attention to that.
[39:58] You actually did use that, Doc, when we were first working together, I don't know, four or five years ago.
[40:03] Yes.
[40:03] You used to have that in a lot of your presentations.
[40:05] I really enjoyed it.
[40:06] So it's good to see it back because it's real.
[40:09] It's back and we're going to work on that and maybe make it even more insightful in terms of where we are.
[40:13] We might have included some of those smaller markets, such as Canberra and Hobart as part of that as well.
[40:20] We might even throw the Gold Coast in.
[40:22] Why not?
[40:22] And the Gold Coast, absolutely, Graham.
[40:24] And maybe we'll have a regional cycle because we can have some of those big regional markets that are close to capital cities such as Geelong, the Gold Coast, Wollongong, these types of markets which are big markets and we can understand where the cycle is there.
[40:40] And that gives us more of an insight into where our markets are at the moment and where they're heading.
[40:45] I think that's the important thing.
[40:47] And I think that's, as I said, that diagram does explain why we're still seeing buyer activity in that Sydney market, because it's still a value market and Melbourne as well.
[40:57] And I think that points to the potential of upside.
[41:00] And we predicted that for prices growth in both Melbourne and Sydney this year.
[41:04] And, you know, Sydney has had a big start to the year, Graeme, and it might surprise on the upside.
[41:09] There's no doubt that these smaller capital cities, compared to Melbourne City, and we're
[41:13] Of course, Brisbane, Adelaide and Perth, they're up and running, Graham.
[41:16] They're well into that expansion cycle and they're moving along, particularly that Perth market.
[41:22] But don't underestimate Queensland as well, particularly southeast Queensland.
[41:27] It's really driving forward at the moment.
[41:29] And, of course, Adelaide's always been a bit of a sleeper and it continues to grow as well.
[41:35] So some interesting insights there from the cycle model.
[41:39] There we go.
[41:40] Look forward to next week, Doc, and look forward to see you Friday night at our event.
[41:45] Absolutely, Graeme.
[41:46] It'll be wet and wild, I think, isn't that what they have the big event up on the Gold Coast?
[41:50] So I'll look forward to all of that, Graeme.
[41:54] You can't beat the Gold Coast.
[41:59] There you go.
[42:00] All right.
[42:00] Well, there you go, ladies and gentlemen.
[42:01] Another great week.
[42:02] Make sure you're following Dr. Andrew Wilson on LinkedIn and make sure you're tuning in on YouTube if you're listening to this in the car.
[42:09] Obviously, if you're a new follower, all the slides are up and available on the Money Mentor YouTube channel with the links in the show notes to Doc's LinkedIn and all of the bits and pieces.
[42:20] Thanks, Doc.
[42:20] We'll see you next week.
[42:22] Thanks, Graeme.
[42:22] Thanks a lot.
[42:23] Thank you.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
