# SPECIAL EDITION: MONEY MENTOR X WILSON'S WEEKLY

An episode of [Money Mentor Podcast™](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1632604767), 6 Mar 2025, 57 min.

Audio: https://episode.flightcast.com/dujnhmwkp6sp7v9s1jg9y7g2.mp3

On this special edition of The Money Mentor Podcast we are joined by the one and only Doctor Andrew Wilson for a Q & A session. Doc was sick during our last Real Estate Mastery so we skipped the Question and Answer section to pack him off home to bed. Now he's back and ready to get to those burning client questions - including whether or not a rates cut will kickstart the Melbourne housing market.

## Transcript

[0:00] Welcome back to the Money Mentor ladies and gentlemen with Graeme Holm and also for another very interesting very exciting Wilson Weekly.
[0:07] G'day Doc.
[0:08] Hello Graeme, how are you?
[0:10] Well we're here in the flesh today.
[0:11] It's very good.
[0:12] It is mano a mano.
[0:13] It's a bit romantic isn't it?
[0:15] Well don't go that far.
[0:17] It's certainly good to have a you know.
[0:19] Yeah it's good to get together every now and then.
[0:21] You feeling a bit better?
[0:22] Yeah a little bit, 75% I think.
[0:24] Just a tickly you know.
[0:26] You look better.
[0:27] Thanks very much.
[0:28] It's my air conditioning.
[0:31] We're going to compliment each other.
[0:33] We better stop.
[0:35] All right.
[0:35] Well, let's get into it today.
[0:37] Yep.
[0:38] And let's get into, we've got a bit of a detailed Q&A for everyone for this podcast.
[0:42] Yes, yes, yes.
[0:42] It's been coming through on social media.
[0:44] So what we'll do is we'll jump straight into it, rip in, get as many as possible for everyone tuning in from home.
[0:49] Sure.
[0:49] Okay.
[0:50] First question.
[0:51] Has there been stability in construction costs for new homes across Australia?
[0:56] Well, obviously we've gone through this period of volatility.
[1:01] Previous government had the home builder agenda or policy, brought forward a lot of demand, not enough supply, not enough building materials, not enough labour, and building costs, house building costs went through the roof.
[1:13] So, in fact, we saw unprecedented rises in house building costs.
[1:16] We've just started to see that ease again, but we're just starting to see maybe that picking up, that it hasn't continued to get down to the levels we had prior to that big burst a couple of years ago.
[1:27] And it's interesting that it's also happening where we're seeing a downturn in home building or house building approvals.
[1:34] Approvals.
[1:34] Which has been the bright light for dwelling construction has been house building approvals.
[1:39] Apartments are still pretty flat.
[1:41] And they've started to actually wane.
[1:43] So maybe there's a reason that we're seeing higher prices because there's not enough energy in the market for builders.
[1:52] But it'll pan out.
[1:53] But, yeah, we're just starting to see growth again in house building costs.
[1:58] We thought it would stabilize, but it's starting to creep in.
[2:00] Yeah, it's not heading back to those levels prior to COVID, which was 2% or 3% a year, which is what?
[2:07] Because we have a very competitive house building industry.
[2:10] Very competitive, given the amount of builders that have gone kaput.
[2:13] But that's sort of the nature of the beast as well.
[2:16] Builders come in and come out depending on the cycle.
[2:19] And that's what keeps the margins low because there's a lot of competition.
[2:25] But we were sort of expecting it.
[2:27] Okay, we went from those ridiculous increases annually in house building costs to getting back to 3%, 4% increases.
[2:34] And now it's picking up again to 5% on our latest data.
[2:36] Okay.
[2:37] Now, it may stabilise again, but this is a sort of a trend that's emerging.
[2:43] And the RBA hasn't picked it up yet.
[2:45] The ABS hasn't picked it up yet.
[2:47] But I'm sure it'll come through because our data is very, very accurate and very forward-looking as well.
[2:52] And what do you think around trades and the specific issues we're facing with lack of skilled workers, trades, apprentices even coming through at the moment?
[3:02] Do you think that's going to play any effect into construction costs in the years to come?
[3:05] But this has always been the problem with Australia.
[3:07] I mean, when you have that cyclical home building environment built, you know, sort of boom and bust and peaks and troughs, you know, you always have too many trades or not enough trades.
[3:20] Never stable.
[3:21] And it's, well, you just can't add water and, hey, here's another thousand, you know, sparky sort of thing.
[3:25] Then you need to plan for more tradespeople as the market recovers.
[3:30] And it's difficult to do that.
[3:31] for builders to take on apprentices, tradesmen to take on apprentices in a period where there's not a lot of work.
[3:37] And of course that takes government guidance to sort of do that.
[3:42] And things have changed a lot.
[3:43] But it is that cyclical effect that we have.
[3:45] And that was exacerbated by, you know, with all good...
[3:49] The good intentions of the previous government was to, through COVID, create more demand, create more building, but they created too much demand and there wasn't enough supply.
[3:57] And then that got back to the point we didn't have enough tradesmen.
[4:00] And yet now, once that demand was satisfied, you're sort of like, well, we've got lots of tradesmen now, but we haven't got enough work because it's that pattern of volatility, which is the nature of the building.
[4:11] And that's why the margin, and I think another reason why perhaps building costs have started to rise again is an expectation.
[4:18] It's like if you're a builder or tradesman and all of a sudden you're seeing your prices increase by 10 or 15% a year, do you really want to go back to 2% a year increase?
[4:28] It's like, well, I like- Pretty happy with this 10 or 15 or 12.
[4:31] You can't keep that up, of course, because the buyers aren't going to be paying.
[4:35] Well, even if it wasn't going up, it's probably still going up or it's stable.
[4:38] That's right.
[4:38] So it's a journey that's come through, you know, extremely unusual circumstances, COVID.
[4:46] And we're still sort of feeling our way through it.
[4:49] But, you know, the bad news is it's just going to, again, constrain house building.
[4:53] And we need more houses in this country.
[4:56] And nothing's really changing there.
[4:57] Okay.
[4:57] Next question.
[4:59] Will the US tariffs affect the Australian economy as a whole?
[5:05] Well, you know, if I had this answer, of course, I'd be CNN.
[5:08] Hey, they're still the clients, right?
[5:10] I've just been passing it on.
[5:12] Don't shoot the messenger.
[5:13] Well, what's a tariff?
[5:14] A tariff is a tax.
[5:15] It's a tax on imports, right?
[5:17] And it's interesting if you look at the history of tariffs just quickly.
[5:20] In the US, the US government, federal government, didn't have the – originally, and we're talking hundreds of years ago –
[5:26] didn't have the capacity to raise taxes.
[5:28] So the way it used to raise taxes, because it needs income, their federal government, was to tax imports.
[5:33] So it would get that.
[5:34] And that sort of worked really well for the American economy.
[5:38] But, you know, as things changed...
[5:41] They then got their own tax base, you know, blah, blah, blah.
[5:45] So the essential point is it's a tax on imports, right?
[5:49] So it can only mean higher prices because that's what it's all about.
[5:53] So if you're importing something and the government's put a tariff on it,
[5:58] Well, you've got to pay it.
[6:00] So you either pass on that extra cost to your customer.
[6:03] I think I really want to raise my prices or it's because you've got a lot of back stock so you can absorb it.
[6:09] Your margins are high anyway.
[6:11] But the point is, as it sifts through the system.
[6:13] It only means higher prices.
[6:15] Now, Australia has a good relationship in terms of trade with the US.
[6:20] We buy more than we sell, and the US likes that.
[6:23] Okay, we like you Aussie guys because you're buying more of our stuff than we're buying of your stuff.
[6:28] But it's different in Canada and Mexico because they actually sell more to the US than they buy.
[6:37] Yeah.
[6:37] So there's a deficit.
[6:38] Yeah.
[6:39] So, you know.
[6:40] We're in good stead.
[6:41] Yeah, in that term.
[6:42] But it doesn't mean that they're not going to say, oh, we're just going to put a tariff on everything, right, on everyone.
[6:45] So it is inflationary.
[6:47] Essentially, it's inflationary because it's putting up prices.
[6:50] It's fabricated inflationary.
[6:51] Yeah, and you've got to cover it.
[6:53] The importer has to either cover it by absorbing in the profits or passing it on.
[6:58] And really the end owner or purchaser is copying it because it's going to be passed along somewhere.
[7:02] That's right, and it grows.
[7:04] There you go.
[7:05] It's like if they put an import on steel...
[7:07] well, okay, okay, you know, raw steel, whatever.
[7:09] But then it sort of works its way into all those finished goods that rely on steel.
[7:16] Aluminium's the same, cans, those sort of end products.
[7:20] It all eventually will get passed on.
[7:23] So it's like the rising tide of tariffs, everything rises.
[7:27] And so it's essentially inflationary.
[7:30] And I would have thought the Reserve Bank would have paid a bit more attention to the prospect of that.
[7:36] with their interest rate decision because it does mean that the potential there is for higher prices internationally, notwithstanding the trading relationship between countries.
[7:47] Because it just means that businesses are thinking, well, I've got to cover these extra costs, so I want to keep my prices.
[7:53] So it just becomes then everybody's chasing higher profits to cover all these higher prices.
[7:59] costs that are happening through the food chain.
[8:01] You know what I mean?
[8:02] And Trump, he said, I think we've had a pause for a few weeks in terms of what he was going to do to Canada and Mexico.
[8:10] I thought he was just buying everyone's countries.
[8:13] Greenland and Australia.
[8:18] But no, he's saying now he's going to resume that in another week or two.
[8:21] So it's something that's a reality and it can only have...
[8:24] upward pressure on prices.
[8:27] And of course, that potentially means inflation, which puts downward or upward pressure on interest rates.
[8:33] Next one, double question.
[8:34] So two, one, should I buy unit, apartment or house in Melbourne?
[8:41] And are there any signs of Melbourne's market showing any sign of growth or recovery at the moment?
[8:46] So what is this interesting when they always ask you, what should I buy doc?
[8:50] Well, what's your circumstances, right?
[8:51] But should I look at house or unit in Melbourne and are there signs of a Melbourne recovery yet at all?
[8:57] Well, firstly, traditionally, an investor will look at the highest yielding.
[9:02] So the best returns you get.
[9:04] And traditionally, of course, they are units.
[9:06] Because when you compare a unit's price to a house price and a unit's rent to a house rent, you have a higher yield.
[9:15] So a return on investment.
[9:16] So I guess if you're looking for a return on investment, which you are, you look for a unit to get that higher yield, which traditionally you get regardless of the capital city, you get a higher return on a yield.
[9:26] Cheaper price point, similar rent.
[9:28] But then again, you start thinking about, okay, well, I'm not just about yield, return on income.
[9:35] I want some capital growth.
[9:36] And that's where houses have the advantage typically.
[9:40] over units is with capital growth.
[9:43] So we're generalising.
[9:44] Yeah, of course.
[9:44] But then you have to do your homework and start looking at individual suburbs.
[9:47] Wait, I've got the answer.
[9:49] It depends.
[9:50] Yeah, that's right.
[9:52] Yeah, so you've got to take that.
[9:54] It's not just, there's not a one-size-fits-all.
[9:55] What's the strategy?
[9:57] But, you know, you can generalise.
[10:00] But for a house, you look for an outer suburban, lower priced house, which will give you a higher yield and potentially give you a higher capital growth profile.
[10:09] But it depends on the cycle, depends on which suburb it is.
[10:11] Is it a bridesmaid suburb?
[10:12] You know, is it already overtaxed in terms of demand?
[10:16] But you can look for the same things in terms of units, you know, but then you tend to have to pay probably a higher price for a unit which has higher capital growth potential.
[10:25] So you get a lower yield, right?
[10:27] But yields have been a great forward indicator, which we've used for a number of years to identify those suburbs.
[10:34] which have potential for capital growth.
[10:37] Because if you look at the yield on a suburb by suburb basis, even a capital city by capital city basis, and it just looks a bit too high.
[10:44] It's like, hey, how come this capital city's yields are so high?
[10:48] We saw Canberra, we saw Brisbane, and yet, fine, they can be high because there's a high vacancy rate, there's less demand for
[10:58] you know, rental properties, whatever.
[11:00] But if it's a strong rental market, so you're getting, you know, that sustained income source and you're still getting a high yield, it means that the property value is too low compared to what the sort of norm is.
[11:13] So that's sort of taking a scientific approach.
[11:16] We talked about this in South East Queensland many years ago in the first few podcasts.
[11:19] Even before the surge out of the migration crisis.
[11:22] And then we've seen Melbourne follow a similar suit with the prices versus the yields there, which South East Queensland has just experienced.
[11:29] We've seen Adelaide do it.
[11:30] Yeah.
[11:30] We've seen Canberra.
[11:32] So it's interesting.
[11:33] And what happens, of course, to explain that, is that when the yields are high, an investor will say, hey, this is a really good return.
[11:40] It's better that I can get here, here, and here.
[11:42] And I'm not going to have a problem getting a tenant because it's still got a strong rental market.
[11:47] Rents are rising.
[11:49] So that's maintaining my return.
[11:52] So it creates demand, right?
[11:54] And that demand, of course, pushes up prices and the yields come down.
[11:58] Then they start looking like every other yield.
[12:01] But those that have got onto it while the yields were high have taken the advantage of the capital growth.
[12:05] That's what we saw in Queensland.
[12:07] And that's potentially what we're looking at Melbourne.
[12:10] And you asked me about the signs in Melbourne.
[12:12] Yeah, second part of the question was, is Melbourne showing any signs of growth or recovery yet?
[12:17] Well, Melbourne hasn't...
[12:19] It's a big question because Melbourne's just Melbourne.
[12:21] That's right.
[12:22] There's a lot of subs there, right?
[12:23] A lot of mini-Melbourne, right?
[12:25] But Melbourne hasn't fallen.
[12:28] It's continued to make sort of flattish headway, if I can say that.
[12:35] But it just hasn't performed like the other capitalists.
[12:36] There's no wake.
[12:37] It's in a four-knot zone.
[12:38] Yeah, that's right.
[12:39] Yeah, that's right.
[12:40] Yeah, it's just sort of, you know, trundling along.
[12:44] Whereas the others, you know, Perth, oh my God, you know, Brisbane, Adelaide, very strong, Sydney robust.
[12:51] But Melbourne sort of dragged the chain a bit, which is unusual because there's no reason you can point to, this is the point with Melbourne, as to why it hasn't performed as strongly as the other capital cities.
[13:03] Because the macro scenarios are the same, interest rates are nationally set.
[13:07] Its economy is doing OK.
[13:09] In fact, Melbourne creates more jobs per year as a percentage than any of the other capital cities.
[13:15] So its economy is doing OK. Everybody points to the new taxes from the local government through the COVID period, particularly the land tax, right?
[13:24] When I do meetings in Melbourne, events in Melbourne.
[13:28] Do you see the dark cloud hanging over?
[13:31] I'm dreading Q&A because they're all, what about the land tax?
[13:35] What are they going to do with the land tax?
[13:36] And it's all investors asking that same question.
[13:38] That's the reason why.
[13:40] But it's not because – why is it not just investor-type suburbs with high yields that are underperforming?
[13:47] In fact, in Melbourne, it's the higher-priced suburbs.
[13:49] High end of the market.
[13:49] Which aren't investor-friendly suburbs, typically, right?
[13:52] It's outer suburbs and units that where investors head towards because they have – they are lower entry points and have higher yields.
[14:00] But it's the higher-priced suburbs in Melbourne that are really just doing nothing.
[14:03] In fact, they're going backwards.
[14:04] Yeah.
[14:04] So it doesn't make sense to say it's because of the land tax.
[14:07] And what we've been saying consistently is it's up here.
[14:11] It's like, oh, things are bad.
[14:14] And if you say things are bad long enough, loud enough, they are bad.
[14:18] Because guess what?
[14:19] I'm not buying a house.
[14:20] I'm not selling a house because things are bad.
[14:21] But then it becomes like the boy who cried wolf.
[14:23] That's right.
[14:23] Eventually you stop looking and he gets eaten by the bloody wolf.
[14:26] But all of a sudden the market turns overnight.
[14:29] And you're eaten.
[14:29] Oh, Melvin's great.
[14:30] Yeah, that's right.
[14:31] Oh, gee, if only I had known.
[14:32] If I, yeah.
[14:33] Yeah, you know, but you did, right?
[14:36] But that's the scientific approach, right?
[14:37] So that's telling you that what is keeping Melbourne flat, what is the reason?
[14:43] Now, if it was, you know, an economic factor that you could look at, hey, unemployment's rising, it's high, you know, whatever, migration is people leaving Melbourne, you know, whatever.
[14:54] But there's nothing you can really point to there.
[14:56] It's underperforming more as confidence.
[14:58] And as I said, those are the factors.
[14:59] You look at the strata of the market.
[15:01] higher priced properties that are underperforming.
[15:03] So what's happening in the Melbourne market now?
[15:05] And as we do, firstly let's talk about yields.
[15:08] And we have a little app, right, that we promote, Infinity My Housing Market app.
[15:12] If they're a client, they get the password.
[15:14] Yeah.
[15:15] Sorry, not sorry everyone else.
[15:16] Ray's quite happy to answer your phone calls.
[15:18] Yeah.
[15:20] But not really.
[15:23] But it's a great little app because it gives you real-time insights into suburb data.
[15:27] So it identifies down that granular level rather than talking about regions or capital cities.
[15:34] So we've recently introduced for investors a new part of that app, which gives you the top 10 yielding suburbs with various filters you can use for each of the capital cities.
[15:46] So it's capital cities.
[15:47] There's two regions for each state.
[15:49] There's the capital city region and the outside capital city region.
[15:52] So it's interesting when you look at Melbourne, so you filter Melbourne region and, for example, you say one bedroom units, which are typically the highest yielding because they're the cheapest entry point.
[16:06] And when you look at it, if you look at the top, because it brings you out the top 10, they're all seven or eight.
[16:12] They're all 7% or 8% gross yields.
[16:16] But this is Queensland a few years ago.
[16:18] But if you go to Sydney and then you go even to Brisbane, they're 5% and 6%.
[16:22] Well, Sydney, some of them get down into threes.
[16:24] But this is the top 10.
[16:26] So we've already filtered it for people.
[16:28] So you can get a feel for what the top performances are.
[16:31] And where they are.
[16:32] Yeah, and then we've also got where you can click on where they are.
[16:35] But Melbourne shows, you can clearly see when you compare them,
[16:39] that Melbourne's got all these 7% and 8%, or certainly a lot of 7% in their top 10.
[16:44] That tells us a key... Well, that's showing it.
[16:46] Well, if you're just looking on that basis, you'd be saying, gee, this is where I'm going to get my best return on investment.
[16:52] I was going to say, best yield right now... Is there.
[16:54] But if I buy there right now, I expect that value to increase at some point.
[16:58] For the same reasoning that we're saying.
[17:00] That yield to diminish and stabilise.
[17:02] Because a lot of inner city...
[17:04] It's interesting because if we look specifically at suburbs, a lot of inner city Melbourne apartments, and we're talking...
[17:09] city apartments, so that's the CBD, Docklands, and Southbank, right, which were part of a massive redevelopment government-led scenario for 30 years, right?
[17:21] They're actually very popular suburbs with investors, because they get great yields.
[17:26] They always get higher yields than anywhere else.
[17:28] And if we ever get to the point of like Canary Wharves, London, Hudson Yards, or eventually what's old become, hopefully bloody becomes cool one day, and then you think, shit, right?
[17:36] And that's right.
[17:37] But the interesting thing about, to sort of explain this, is those yields have always been high.
[17:42] And people say, well, such a great investor place, stock lands, you know.
[17:46] So investors would buy there because there's a lot of student interest in there because it's close to unis and that sort of thing, close to the city.
[17:52] So you always get high demand for rentals, particularly from overseas students, right?
[17:57] Or even locals, you know, because it has that great connection to established infrastructure.
[18:02] But people don't want to buy them to live in.
[18:05] You understand?
[18:06] They want to buy them to invest.
[18:07] High yield investment, convenient.
[18:09] Right?
[18:09] But they don't want to live.
[18:10] Because they think, oh, Docklands?
[18:11] Where's the Docklands?
[18:12] What do you do in the Docklands?
[18:13] Because Melbourne are very suburb savvy.
[18:17] You know, they're very, oh.
[18:18] So is Sydney.
[18:19] I think every city, it's like, oh.
[18:21] It's like, I mean, you look years ago, Frankston.
[18:24] That's right.
[18:24] Franger.
[18:25] Yeah, the Franger.
[18:26] And if you look at the median values in Franger now,
[18:29] It's wild.
[18:30] Yeah, yeah.
[18:31] So it's Surrey Hills in Sydney.
[18:33] That's right.
[18:34] That's right.
[18:35] Yeah, Redfern.
[18:36] Redfern.
[18:36] The hills in Western Sydney.
[18:38] Yeah.
[18:38] I mean, look at Bella Vista in Kellyville now.
[18:40] Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[18:41] So it's interesting, these dock lands.
[18:43] That's that bridesmaid effect where you get priced out, so you move into the next region.
[18:48] Yeah.
[18:49] The CBD apartment model in Melbourne is still that example of where people don't want to live, they want to invest because they get good returns.
[18:57] If there was a shift for people saying, hey, I really like this place to live in, then you'd start getting that capital growth coming in.
[19:05] But the fact is that you still get growth in those markets because of those higher yields.
[19:11] It sort of validates that sort of concept.
[19:17] Now, signs, what are we seeing?
[19:19] So as we always do with our podcasts and our insights into the housing market, we look at the auction markets.
[19:25] Yep.
[19:26] We look at the auction markets every week.
[19:28] So we do a weekly auction market summary.
[19:30] Why?
[19:31] Because they're a great forward indicator as to what's happening underneath in the market.
[19:35] And all you have to do is model clearance rates versus house prices.
[19:39] in all the capital cities, and you'll see they follow each other.
[19:41] Higher clearance rate, higher price.
[19:43] It makes sense.
[19:44] So it's a great opportunity to get on a week-to-week basis to understand what's happening.
[19:49] So we're two weeks in or two months into the housing market, right?
[19:53] So we've had enough data to sort of get a feel for what's happening this year in the housing market.
[19:59] How much doom and gloom have we got here?
[20:00] Well, none really for Melbourne and Sydney.
[20:02] This has been a really good start for Melbourne and Sydney in the auction market.
[20:06] In fact, Sydney's clearance rates have been tracking above 75% for most of February.
[20:10] Oh, careful.
[20:11] If you hit that 80 number, we're going to... Well, that's right.
[20:13] Be the boom.
[20:14] Be the boom.
[20:15] That's right.
[20:16] I'm not saying we're going there.
[20:17] And that's certainly higher than where it was...
[20:22] at the end of the year, because it just started to flatten out the end of the year last year in Sydney.
[20:26] And around about where it was at the beginning of the year last year in Sydney, same period.
[20:31] And that was a very strong period because all the sellers were coming back into the market.
[20:37] Now, for Melbourne, it's a similar story.
[20:39] Melbourne's been tracking around about 70%, not as high as Sydney, for February so far.
[20:45] Now, that's significantly higher than where it finished the year, and it's also higher than where it started the year, or roundabout where it started the year last year.
[20:53] So there's some really good positive signs for Melbourne.
[20:56] And again, it's the Melbourne suburbs, which are the meat and potato suburbs in a way, mid-price budget-price suburbs that are sort of doing well.
[21:04] It's the higher-price suburbs now.
[21:06] that are continuing to drag the chain a bit.
[21:10] So that's as good an early sign as we can get in terms of the prospects for the Melbourne market.
[21:15] Certainly it's a start off as well as you'd have.
[21:17] I'd like to say it's the last Melbourne question, but I'm going to scroll through.
[21:20] I've got the questions up here coming through on socials and Instagram.
[21:23] Another Melbourne question, off the back of that, you mentioned auction clearance rates.
[21:26] Yeah.
[21:27] If I'm selling my house in Melbourne, home, this is, I'm assuming, because it says home, would you be under auction or private treaty?
[21:34] Auction.
[21:34] It depends where you are.
[21:35] Again, it's where.
[21:36] But Melbourne is the Australia centre for auction.
[21:39] Whereas Brisbane, private treaty.
[21:40] Absolutely.
[21:41] They're not really an auction.
[21:41] Well, they call it an auction, but it's like, really?
[21:43] Is that an auction?
[21:44] auction because they say, yeah, let's go to auction.
[21:46] Yeah, passed in.
[21:47] What do I care?
[21:47] It's a private sale.
[21:48] And so they get lower clearance rates.
[21:50] But Melbourne are a legitimate.
[21:52] Melbourne auctions around about 35% of all its properties go to auction.
[21:58] Sydney about 25%.
[21:59] Brisbane about 8%, right?
[22:00] Yep.
[22:02] So that's the difference.
[22:03] It's a very strong auction culture in Melbourne.
[22:06] And that's because people are tuned in to understanding the value of auction.
[22:12] The essence of it is to get a competitive environment.
[22:16] You've got three or four people.
[22:17] They don't know what prices.
[22:18] Well, they're given an indication, which is how the government's changed auctions.
[22:22] over the past decade.
[22:23] But anyway, they certainly don't know what the end price is, right?
[22:26] It's not like a private treaty where the price is there and you've got to negotiate downwards.
[22:31] Um, where here you don't know what the price is and you've got to push up till you find that price.
[22:36] So that's the, you know, and people understand that that's what they've got to do.
[22:39] They've got to compete with other buyers, uh, and the seller knows I'm just going to sit here and you fight about it in the dirt in front of me.
[22:45] Right.
[22:46] And the winner takes all.
[22:48] And it works, you know, and agents support it.
[22:52] And, of course, it's because there is such strong competition for property in the middle and in the suburbs of Melbourne.
[22:58] As you start getting further out and there's less competition out of suburbs, you start thinking, well, private treaty's better because I can pitch my price up here.
[23:06] I haven't got as many people competing, so I can negotiate more on a one-on-one basis to try to get as close to what I would like, you know,
[23:14] What I'd like to get, sort of plus 10%, you know, and then that 10% is the regular room.
[23:19] But Melbourne typically is a city which is much more tuned in for auctions.
[23:26] Auctions, yep.
[23:27] But it does depend on what part of the, you know.
[23:29] How far in or out you are.
[23:31] In or out you are, absolutely.
[23:32] Two-part question.
[23:35] Firstly, will the RBA drop rates again this year?
[23:38] And secondly, where do you see the Australian property market heading in the next six months?
[23:43] Okay.
[23:44] Gee whiz.
[23:45] I do a- Gee whiz, you got the crystal ball?
[23:47] No, no, no.
[23:52] To inform you, finder.com.
[23:55] I do a monthly, and I've done for years, part of their survey.
[23:58] They survey people, what's going on in the Reserve Bank.
[24:00] And one of the questions was interesting, as usual, I said, what do you think the Reserve Bank is going to do?
[24:04] And I knew they were going to cut.
[24:06] But they also asked, what do you think they should do?
[24:09] And I said, they shouldn't cut.
[24:11] So this is the point.
[24:13] What the Reserve Bank is doing, we can't really rationalise it.
[24:18] Because it's such an extraordinary...
[24:20] The economy is pumping along.
[24:21] Booming along.
[24:21] Unemployment's... Yeah, I know.
[24:23] Is there unemployment?
[24:25] No.
[24:25] Well, this is the issue.
[24:26] You've got to understand that what the Reserve Bank is, it drives the economy.
[24:32] So the Reserve Bank is driving the economy, right?
[24:35] I think there's an... What's that thing happening this year?
[24:40] Elections?
[24:40] Oh, that's right.
[24:41] We'll talk about that in a second.
[24:43] I could get into trouble, so I don't want to say too much.
[24:45] But we'll sort of do or join the dots.
[24:48] Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[24:49] But no, no, no.
[24:50] So the RBA, its job is to drive the economy.
[24:55] So what happens?
[24:56] You drive along and it's got like, this is the ideal speed, right, for the economy.
[25:00] So they're driving the economy, okay?
[25:03] and hey, it's getting really fast here.
[25:06] Whoa, I can smell something burning, right?
[25:08] This is not gonna be good.
[25:10] So they up the brakes, right?
[25:12] And that means they put up interest rates.
[25:14] Just to steady things down a bit to make the car run efficiently.
[25:18] And then all of a sudden it starts, what's going on here, you know, up a hill, you know, we got it, we got it.
[25:24] So they pumped the accelerator and that's dropping interest rates.
[25:28] So dropping interest rates stimulates the economy, raising interest rates retards the economy to try to keep it running, you know, in the ideal sweet spot.
[25:38] This is the first time we've cut interest rates in an economy this strong.
[25:43] So look back to the last few times we've cut interest rates.
[25:45] 2008, the global financial crisis.
[25:48] We slashed interest rates because it was an international economic downturn.
[25:54] Then we cut interest rates in 2012 because that was the end of the mining boom.
[25:59] We started to see unemployment rising and the rest of the world were going through big recessionary periods.
[26:06] And then we cut rates again during COVID.
[26:09] Of course, that was like, and they cut them down a 0.1% percent.
[26:12] So every time we've cut rates, started that rate cutting cycle, it's been because we've needed to put our foot on the accelerator.
[26:21] We have absolutely no, in fact, all the signs except for GDP, and we should probably ignore GDP because it's a little bit questionable, but I won't go into that too deep.
[26:32] But we've got the strongest labour market in our history.
[26:35] We have.
[26:36] So where's the influence for a rate cut?
[26:40] Well, it's got to make, firstly, everybody's like patting you on the back.
[26:44] Because you cut rates, it's not a decision which doesn't go down well.
[26:49] Because it was like, wow, this is great.
[26:50] Well, not today.
[26:51] Well, that's what I'm saying.
[26:52] Today.
[26:53] Of course, when you cut them, it's like, yeah, you cut rates.
[26:55] I get to make, I've got more money because I'm paying less on my mortgage.
[26:59] It's also good if you're a depositor and you're relying on a fixed income because all of a sudden your term deposit's going down, right?
[27:05] Well, it's a term deposit, but when you go to renew it, Yeah.
[27:08] you're going to be paying less.
[27:09] But the banks have been paying ducks and drakes with that for the last six months, putting down their term deposit rates in anticipation.
[27:15] In lieu of the rate cut.
[27:16] What did they know, right?
[27:17] Yeah, I know.
[27:17] In lieu of the rate cut.
[27:20] But this is unquestionably the strongest labour market we've had in our history.
[27:26] And to be cutting rates, that will only refuel, well, it will only impact the labour market because, you know, employers will lower rates for their borrowing, will have more to invest.
[27:40] And we've got a smaller pool of workers.
[27:42] You know, we can't find enough workers.
[27:45] And that's only going to be exacerbated if we create more work through lower interest rates.
[27:52] The Reserve Bank will say, well, it's 0.25%, whatever.
[27:56] And they've said that.
[27:58] And that's the point that the Reserve Bank governor was obviously horrified by the amount of questions she got about, oh, when's the next rate cut going to come?
[28:07] Because I think they realise that if you looked at the sort of percentage risks one way or the other, they've sort of headed towards maybe doing it a bit early, given what the data was saying.
[28:18] We went up too late.
[28:19] That's right.
[28:20] Well, we didn't go up high enough.
[28:22] Yeah, and then we're going down.
[28:23] And then they had to go up again.
[28:24] And now we've gone down too early.
[28:25] And now we've maybe gone down too early.
[28:27] Now, people are going to be more happy about going down too early.
[28:30] Of course.
[28:31] Right?
[28:31] Because it sort of helps.
[28:32] It's a good news story.
[28:33] Well, it is a good news story unless we have to go up again.
[28:36] And they can sort of keep them where it is and say, okay, we'll wait and see.
[28:40] But again, it questions, you know, what's the sort of mindset of the Reserve Bank?
[28:45] I mean, they're supposed to have these economists.
[28:47] They're supposed to have analysts that are looking at these things.
[28:49] I mean, if we can look at these things and quite objectively and say this, what about this, what are you doing?
[28:56] In the US, they cut rates last year by 1.5%.
[28:59] Holy moly, that's a big cut.
[29:02] And now they're saying, ooh, you know, because inflation's rising again in the US, their economies on eight cylinders are really very strong again.
[29:12] So all the question marks that were around the economy and inflation last year that encouraged that interest rate cut have gone.
[29:19] And now the Fed Reserve in the US is saying, ooh, no more rate cuts.
[29:24] And yet they've been saying that for a while now.
[29:26] So the RBA, our reserve bank, has known this, that there's a different circumstance there.
[29:33] It's almost as though this was a sort of preordained decision was going to happen.
[29:37] It's been a little bit externally influenced.
[29:38] I don't know, but it is an election year, Graeme.
[29:42] And I'll tell you who's really happy about it, cutting interest rates.
[29:45] then that's the government.
[29:46] Because it looks, I don't know, I don't follow Australian politics.
[29:49] No, no, no, no, do I.
[29:51] Moving right along.
[29:51] But I'm just saying that they'll be welcoming in what looks to be a tight election environment, a cut in interest rates.
[29:57] Of course, it's going to make them more popular.
[30:01] But as I said, all we're doing is looking at the evidence and suggesting, well, you know, this is an extraordinary rate cut given these circumstances.
[30:09] And even with the inflation environment, because that's what's supposed to be, we're trying to get back to,
[30:14] our target range inflation, we actually haven't got there.
[30:17] So it's gone from being we're not going to cut rates till we get to the target range, right, to the midpoint of the target range.
[30:24] And then it's gone to, well, we're going to cut rates when we're moving sustainably towards the midpoint.
[30:30] So it's not getting there, it's moving there.
[30:33] And we have been moving there because the trend's going.
[30:35] But the interesting thing,
[30:36] word there is sustainably.
[30:38] So how can it be sustainable?
[30:40] Because the two factors that have got us near the inflation target range, particularly have been electricity.
[30:48] And we all got the big handout last year from the government, 300 bucks off the electricity bill, and that's pushed electricity prices through the floor.
[30:58] And that's been a considerable factor in the fall in inflation.
[31:02] So how can that be sustainable?
[31:04] Government's going to give us $300.
[31:05] Maybe they're going to pay more electricity this year too.
[31:07] Forever.
[31:07] Yeah.
[31:08] Forever.
[31:08] It's sustainable.
[31:09] They're going to pay your electricity for every year.
[31:11] Maybe they've got a secret solar plant we don't know about.
[31:13] That's right.
[31:13] Or, yes, a magic Aladdin's lamp that produces electricity.
[31:17] So, Doc, just jumping on, because we've got some live questions coming through on socials here on Insta and that, and getting into this Aladdin's lamp of your brain.
[31:25] Yes.
[31:25] So there's a lot, I'm going to skip some of this, a lot of Melbourne stuff going on here.
[31:29] And I just was thinking, a couple of months, maybe, hopefully a couple of months later this year we'll be sitting here and all of a sudden people go, have I missed the market in Melbourne?
[31:37] Have I missed the boat when it turns?
[31:38] Well, hopefully it's this year, but it's going to be interest turnaround.
[31:41] But here's a couple more.
[31:42] Could these interest rate cuts happen?
[31:45] kickstart the Melbourne market and how soon?
[31:48] Melbourne, Melbourne, Melbourne.
[31:49] Well look, what we've sort of discussed with Melbourne is, is there any rational reason why Melbourne has underperformed?
[31:56] Well we can say, look it's certainly problematic, you know, to find something other than confidence.
[32:02] And if you've got the ability to pay more now in a market that already has a high yield, surely that's going to help your confidence going forward.
[32:13] All of a sudden, you'll see the sold stickers go up.
[32:16] And people go, ooh.
[32:17] Do you see that place?
[32:18] That was for sale for it.
[32:18] And look, it's got a salt sticker on, right?
[32:21] And then it becomes another salt sticker.
[32:23] And then it's like, as we've discussed other markets, it becomes fear of missing out.
[32:28] You go from FOMO and FOB, right?
[32:30] Fear of being involved and fear of missing out.
[32:32] And, of course, that's what's happened in Perth.
[32:35] It's fear of, you know, the fear of missing out has pushed that market.
[32:38] And Brisbane and Adelaide to a certain degree.
[32:41] And Sydney, of course.
[32:41] But I do think that...
[32:44] logic tells us and I mean we're talking about more interest rate cuts I can't I just can't see it okay well I can't see it on the there's a few in here I'm going to ignore then asking about how many more interest rate cuts this year and the data at the moment probably doesn't really substantiate it
[33:00] If we get more interest rate cuts, it's sort of a good news, bad news story.
[33:05] We're going to blow the economy out.
[33:06] Yeah, but they won't do that because you'll see inflation running again.
[33:11] We'll get a whole new Reserve Bank board, right?
[33:13] They'll change the whole structure again.
[33:15] Back to square one.
[33:15] And we're back again.
[33:16] We've changed the Reserve Bank because, you know...
[33:19] This question's a good one, Doc, because this one from Clayton, I think it says, do you think this interest rate cut may have been a little premature?
[33:28] Could another quarter at least have hurt for them to wait before they acted?
[33:32] No, that's the point, that there's no essential justification for this.
[33:39] Our inflation is still too high.
[33:41] The measure they have as their benchmark,
[33:44] which is 2.5%, we're at basically 3.5%.
[33:47] So we're still too high, right, on their preferred measure, which is the underlying inflation on the quarterly model, right?
[33:54] It's still too high.
[33:56] But they're saying, yeah, but when you look at the trend, yeah, it's moving downwards, it's moving down the line.
[34:01] And that's what we're happy, we're confident that we're heading towards that midpoint, we're happy, so therefore we're going to give some relief to people, blah, blah, blah, with an interest rate cut because we are moving towards it.
[34:15] But it's the sustainability that worries me, because that's the real question that should be asked of the Reserve Bank.
[34:21] is how is this sustainable?
[34:24] You're basically saying this is sustainable, so it's going to continue to happen.
[34:27] How can it, you know, when most of the inflation reductions have come from the government's electricity handout, right, and a big drop in the price of oil?
[34:37] So it's a fabricated reduction.
[34:39] Well, it hasn't come as... Look, there are two essential items to inflation, right, which are measured.
[34:46] That's goods inflation and services inflation.
[34:49] Now, goods inflation is about zero at the moment because that's electricity and fuel, right?
[34:53] Goods inflation.
[34:55] Services inflation is, you know, what most of us do, is services.
[34:59] It's tracking at 4.5% at the moment, which is way above the target range.
[35:04] And that's because the strong labour market, people are able to go to the boss and say, I want another 10 grand or else I'm walking.
[35:12] There's job hopping.
[35:13] Yeah.
[35:14] I don't know a single business owner that has not said to me, I cannot get staff at all.
[35:20] But you've got to pay more to get the staff.
[35:22] If I can get them, they cost a fortune, but I can't get them.
[35:25] Yeah, and that's where the services inflation comes from.
[35:29] It's because we have this very strong labour market, strong competition for available jobs, for jobs, for workers, from employers, and that continues to put upward pressure.
[35:39] And I mean, that's, you know, you say, well, hey, you're cutting interest rates.
[35:42] We'll only make it...
[35:44] tougher, in a sense, to fine those workers.
[35:49] Yep.
[35:50] I don't think we'll have any more rate cuts.
[35:52] This year.
[35:52] I think, well, who knows what's going to come out of left field.
[35:55] Based on the data we see at the moment.
[35:57] Yeah, and the trends as well.
[35:58] And that's the point, that the trends don't look, they're sort of moving down, but you've got to look at the essential data that's driving the trends.
[36:06] Well, this one goes in line with this, off the back of it.
[36:09] Should I fix my interest rate, and what if rates go back up?
[36:13] Yeah, well, you know, we're starting to see some signs, and this is the other thing when we talk about sustainability, is you can't model oil prices.
[36:24] They're up, they're down, they're up, you know what I mean?
[36:26] And you've got this tariff thing happening.
[36:30] You know, the Ukraine thing looks like it's finished, but then we've just heard that the US are putting big restrictions on exports from Iran of oil.
[36:42] And these things fluctuate the oil price, which is just driven by a lot of, you know, smarty pants who are trying to, you know, make short-term profits and they don't care if the price of oil goes back up to $80 or $90 a barrel.
[36:54] But, so again, we're in the land of who knows what's happening, but we're in an economy where we don't have enough workers, right, which is always going to put upward pressure on wages, which will mean employers have to pay more, put upward pressure on pay more for their...
[37:12] put their prices up to cover the wage rise.
[37:15] It's interesting we talk about wage rises.
[37:17] We had the wage index released last week, right?
[37:20] And it was a funny number.
[37:22] It was just 3.3% increase over the year in wages, 3.3%.
[37:28] Now, that's come down in the low fours.
[37:31] And the low fours is sort of what you'd expect in such a strong economy, as we've discussed, particularly the labour market.
[37:37] And yet we had a low result over the September quarter
[37:41] And it was put down to the national wage case, right?
[37:45] And the ABS said, oh, this was because there was a low national wage case, blah, blah, blah.
[37:49] And I thought, okay, well, there'll be an adjustment upwards.
[37:51] It didn't occur.
[37:53] And it's like, well, why aren't we seeing big wages growth with such a strong labour market?
[37:58] So there's another data points that we can use for wages, and that's weekly incomes, right?
[38:07] So average weekly incomes were released just a couple of days ago, right?
[38:11] And they've increased by 4.5%.
[38:15] So we've got one and then the other, and they're so different.
[38:18] You understand?
[38:19] And that's what we'd expect to see that 4.5%, which is a big number.
[38:25] And we've got to go back to...
[38:27] the the boom days of you know the early or the noughties that that mining boom to see wages growth and unemployment rates wages growth at that high level and unemployment rates at that low level so there's just it's like you're scratching the head your head is saying you know this doesn't look right sort of thing um some of the data supports it and some doesn't so as i said that's why i'm
[38:50] In that finder.com survey, I said, I believe the Reserve Bank would fall.
[38:57] I thought the vibe was just irresistible that they were going to cut rates.
[39:00] But then they said, do you think they should cut rates?
[39:03] And I said, no, I don't think they should cut rates.
[39:06] But I don't think we'll see a rate increase.
[39:10] Unless things really got out of control, because that would be an indictment for the Reserve Bank to have to increase rates.
[39:16] But I do think they're going to be very, very circumspect about cutting rates again going forward.
[39:23] What industry innovations do you think could most effectively try to reduce construction costs in Australia?
[39:30] I don't think we need innovations, construction innovations.
[39:35] I think Australia are good builders.
[39:36] They work in that highly competitive environment, you know, through the cycles.
[39:42] I mean, we've just got to change the way we, you know, we approve, you know, we use land.
[39:52] You know, it's the red tape, the green tape, and the planning restrictions.
[39:56] They're the biggest impediments.
[39:57] It's not so much, we build good homes, we're good at what we do.
[40:01] It's more so the supply demand, getting them approved, getting them in demand.
[40:05] I mean, we talked a lot over the last couple of years, Doc, about building approvals versus commencements.
[40:11] That's right.
[40:11] That's right.
[40:12] So there's an approval issue, but then there's also a commencement issue.
[40:15] Yeah, and that's widening now.
[40:16] I mean, we're still pathetic in terms of our building approval numbers.
[40:20] We had some very aspirational targets.
[40:22] And that's right.
[40:23] I mean, it was going to be when we put it together on an annual basis, the government said that we were going to build $220,000 a year.
[40:30] Build, not approve.
[40:32] And that was their – because they don't build it.
[40:33] They're just saying, well, that's what we're hoping for, and the HIA said the same thing.
[40:37] Well, currently we're on around about $180,000.
[40:41] So 180,000 versus 220,000.
[40:43] And that 180,000 are approvals.
[40:48] So we're going to be lucky to get 90% of those 180,000 turning into actual places where people can live.
[40:56] 150, 160, maybe at the ground.
[40:58] That's right.
[40:59] Which is a terrible undershoot, isn't it?
[41:01] In terms of what they're hoping for.
[41:03] Yeah.
[41:05] And...
[41:05] You know, the apartment is starting to pick up slightly.
[41:08] Its trend is improving apartment approvals.
[41:11] But they're so low, they're like 60% fewer apartments being approved now on an annual basis than back in the peak in 2016.
[41:19] And houses, that's the real worry because houses were a bright spot last year.
[41:23] We were approving, that trend had certainly picked up house approvals, and now that's heading south.
[41:29] It's going the other way.
[41:31] So, and houses are something that are much more here and now in terms of providing shelter for people because you can approve and build a house in nine months, right?
[41:41] Whereas an apartment, we're talking three years.
[41:43] A couple of years, yeah.
[41:43] That's right.
[41:44] And so now we've sort of moved from the shorter term solution with houses is now becoming a problem.
[41:50] And we're seeing house prices in the latest, our latest data, or house building costs starting to rise.
[41:58] Which was one of the first questions around construction costs.
[42:01] Now, Doc, hang on.
[42:04] It's a bit weird, this one.
[42:07] Where do you... Where do you...
[42:11] I think the basic question is, where do you see the housing market in Australia in 12 months' time?
[42:16] Okay, so...
[42:17] I guess, you know, would we say decline, stabilise, increase.
[42:21] We're going to have some hot off the press stuff.
[42:23] Yep.
[42:23] Exclusive here.
[42:25] We're going to be releasing our February house price data on Friday.
[42:28] We do it the day before... Well, the last day of the month, we release our data.
[42:32] So we're the first in the market with the data and the commentary analysis.
[42:37] We are going to see house prices falling.
[42:40] National house prices will be down for the second month in a row, which is the first time in over a year that we've seen consecutive months of falling house prices.
[42:50] Who's leading the charge?
[42:51] Sydney are down.
[42:52] Sydney is the worst performer.
[42:54] It's one of our bigger markets.
[42:55] Well, that's our biggest market, right, Sydney.
[42:59] Then Sydney just started to taper off a little bit anyway last year.
[43:04] Now, we've got to understand that this is data that's three months old going to February.
[43:09] Now, we've already spoke about latest data, which is the February auction results, which are much more positive for Sydney.
[43:14] And the thing we've got to understand about the data, which isn't going to stop the headlines, because when this comes out, all the headlines will be, oh, house prices falling.
[43:22] And of course, the reaction of people... We've got to see some predictions of 10%, 20% crashes again.
[43:26] Again!
[43:26] They'll just, you know, be AI.
[43:28] They'll just revisit the old stories, right?
[43:31] And that'll be it.
[43:32] Copy, paste.
[43:33] That's right, copy, paste.
[43:35] But yeah, and of course, what will that do?
[43:37] People go, ooh, I'm not buying a house.
[43:39] Oh, this is bad news.
[43:40] Which, of course, is the greatest.
[43:42] It means it's an opportunity knocking quite loudly because of that misinformation.
[43:47] Those new clearance rates.
[43:49] That's right, are showing us now.
[43:50] Historical data.
[43:51] That's right.
[43:52] Yeah, and we've got to understand that house price is falling in Sydney.
[43:55] And when we look at the data, and I've looked at the regional data, and it is a three-monthly period, right?
[44:01] So it's three months to February versus three months to January.
[44:04] It is monthly, but it's taking three months snapshot at a time.
[44:08] Now, that period includes the two strongest holiday periods of the year, which is January and December.
[44:17] Yep.
[44:18] All right?
[44:19] And that period, we see a significant drop in the number of properties being transacted.
[44:23] Yep.
[44:24] on holidays, what are we doing?
[44:25] And we also see a significant falling away of the higher priced market because the higher priced market, they're all in holidays in Europe, right?
[44:34] So you always see a seasonal effect at this time of the year, which puts, and even though our data is modelled to adjust for that,
[44:42] you can't completely adjust for it, right?
[44:44] Because you've got fewer properties and you've got a lower proportion of higher-priced properties.
[44:48] So that always means it's a little lower, right?
[44:50] So you've got to take that into consideration because that's the part of the market that has been softer in Sydney.
[44:55] Lower North Shore, eastern suburbs, northern beaches and the inner west are the sort of underperformers.
[45:01] But some of the others are a little bit soft as well in Sydney, right?
[45:04] So it's not just a seasonal effect here.
[45:07] We've got to understand this is what we talk about all the time, Graeme, and that's the model of the Australian housing market.
[45:12] And that's why it is so robust and resilient, is because it's fenced in by those lending restrictions by the banks.
[45:19] So we've gone up and up and up for two years.
[45:21] And you get to the point where you can't keep going up anymore, not because there's not people out there wanting to buy or sell houses, because the bank's going to say, sorry, you know, you're not earning anymore.
[45:33] We're not cutting our interest rates yet, so we can't give you more money, right?
[45:37] So what effect that is, so they go to the auction or they go to the sale, and they say, well, this is all I can afford, this is all the bank's going to give me.
[45:42] So that has a stabilising effect on prices.
[45:45] It's exactly what happened at the last peak of our cycle in 2017.
[45:49] If we look at Melbourne,
[45:51] Melbourne, Melbourne, Melbourne, in your head, you're dead.
[45:53] Yeah, that's right.
[45:53] Lo is me.
[45:54] Misery loves company.
[45:55] Storm cloud everywhere.
[45:56] Yeah.
[45:56] We've now got some historical data that Sydney settled down.
[45:59] That's right.
[46:00] But yet everyone thinks Sydney's the most amazing market on the planet and the country.
[46:04] Sydney, Sydney, Sydney.
[46:05] You don't hear anyone.
[46:06] I mean, the media will grab headlines about the overall market, Sydney being the largest and affecting it, right?
[46:11] Yeah.
[46:11] But you don't hear the same negative tones or undertone that you do about Melbourne.
[46:16] No, it's...
[46:17] Look, what will happen here, and this is what we say, that the biggest problem with Australian housing markets...
[46:24] is the disinformation and misinformation.
[46:26] Except for those who take advantage of it and understand that the markets are essentially robust and resilient, which history tells us, right?
[46:32] I've never really known a house to get any cheaper.
[46:34] No, that's not certainly over time, we can see that's ridiculous.
[46:37] Over time, that's right.
[46:39] But so really, in a way, this is the time the savvy buyer, and I'm not promoting any particular thing here, but it is, history tells us, this is when the savvy buyer realises, understanding how strong our capital city markets are, essentially,
[46:52] When we do get to the peak of the cycle, right, they understand that this is the time when people are like, ooh, we're staying out of this.
[47:00] And it then gives you the opportunity you're not in as much competition to take advantage.
[47:05] And then it's exacerbated.
[47:07] So it's like a double whammy because you're getting a rate cut as well.
[47:11] So it's like, ooh, you know, I can finally get into that suburb now and not have to keep paying up and up and up as I have been in Sydney for the last two years.
[47:20] And it's all part of that adjustment process.
[47:23] The same thing happened back in 2017.
[47:25] You mentioned those 10% price falls, 20% price falls.
[47:29] In 2017, we peaked.
[47:32] Our cycle peaked.
[47:34] And then we had the most outrageous scare campaign in the media in 2017.
[47:39] Bricks and Slaughter, remember that?
[47:40] 40% price falls.
[47:42] 40%.
[47:42] 40%.
[47:42] Except it went the other way.
[47:44] They were wrong massively in the whole fucking direction.
[47:46] Yeah, that's right.
[47:46] And, you know, the market shit itself, literally.
[47:48] Yeah.
[47:48] You know, buyers and sellers just, oh, this is terrible.
[47:50] Look at these predictions right across the board.
[47:53] All the banks got it wrong.
[47:54] All the media got it wrong.
[47:55] And in fact, you know, we had a strong year in 2018.
[47:59] But it's the same energy that started that negativity that we'll likely get when the headlines come up next week that house prices are falling again.
[48:08] You know, people don't understand the context.
[48:10] There's no, the analysts, the analytics are appalling.
[48:14] People who make the statements just say, the prices are falling, the prices are falling.
[48:17] Yeah, why?
[48:18] Well, because they're falling, you know, and it's really bad and it's really bad, right?
[48:23] And that's the sort of the end of the story.
[48:25] And then they reverse themselves and it's like, well, prices are rising again and.
[48:28] Yeah, we didn't.
[48:29] Don't worry what we said last week.
[48:30] That's right, what we said last week.
[48:32] But that's the latest data.
[48:33] It's showing us that the cycle isn't just Sydney.
[48:36] It's also Brisbane, Perth and Adelaide are also showing signs of hitting the peak.
[48:44] Brisbane has grown 40% in two years.
[48:47] Perth has grown nearly 50% in two years.
[48:50] You can't keep sustaining this when you have rigid controls over your lending in Australia, which makes Australia one of the most robust and resilient and stable housing markets in the world, right, because of that strong financial power that banks have.
[49:05] Put a bow on it, Doc, because I know you've got a flight.
[49:07] So to put a bow on it, take a breath.
[49:10] Remain calm.
[49:12] Do your homework.
[49:13] Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[49:13] And just make a smart, mathematical, intellectual, educated decision.
[49:18] Take advantage of what's to come in terms of what will be another set, perhaps, of hysterical headlines.
[49:25] Yeah.
[49:26] Bit of fear into people.
[49:28] Soften them up.
[49:31] It might even influence the Reserve Bank.
[49:32] Yeah.
[49:33] They might be thinking.
[49:34] They might even buy into the doom and gloom.
[49:35] I mean, God knows what to do.
[49:38] But I would suggest that wouldn't.
[49:40] But I'm saying at the end of the day, we have the strongest labour market in our history.
[49:44] If you haven't got a job out there, with all due respect, and if you're not making 100 grand a year, well, get in and ask for 100 grand, right?
[49:53] Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
[49:54] No.
[49:54] No.
[49:57] Anyway, you know what I'm saying?
[49:58] It's a very strong economy.
[50:00] So there's nothing like, oh, we're selling our house because I haven't got a job.
[50:03] Right?
[50:03] And that's, you know, what an essential would underscore an issue with the housing market.
[50:10] House prices falling.
[50:11] It's a cyclical peak.
[50:13] We've had very strong growth for a while.
[50:17] It's the early part of the year, which is particularly Melbourne and Sydney, which have strong prestige markets.
[50:22] We always see that seasonal effect because there's not as many higher-priced properties being sold or for sale.
[50:28] Yeah.
[50:29] And I am still confident that the predictions we made at the beginning of the year will be very close to the mark at the end of this year.
[50:36] And I say we'll get around about a 5% increase in the national house price this year.
[50:42] 7% last year, 8% the year before.
[50:44] 8%, 7%, 5%.
[50:45] Yeah, and I think that's maybe even under the mark to some degree.
[50:50] We're still not building enough houses.
[50:53] Well, look, all I can say is if we get 5% across the board this year, I'm a pretty happy little boy.
[50:58] Yeah, well, I actually think that the risk is to the upside that we'll actually get more.
[51:04] Six, seven.
[51:04] Yeah, six or seven again, particularly with an interest rate to start the year.
[51:09] We can't catch up on this lack of supply.
[51:11] Yeah, I think we'll get 10% again in Perth, maybe 7% or 8% in Brisbane, five or six in Adelaide, maybe a little lower than that.
[51:21] I still think Sydney's about a 4% market this year, and I think Melbourne will get 3% this year.
[51:27] There you go.
[51:28] And the conservative estimates?
[51:30] Oh, they're mid-price.
[51:31] Mid-price.
[51:31] So, you know, I think we're pretty good with our estimates every year.
[51:35] Okay.
[51:36] And we tend to be under the mark rather than over the mark.
[51:38] Yeah, better be safe than sorry.
[51:39] Yeah, so that's why I say they're mid-price estimates.
[51:43] But as I said, I think that, look, the interest rate cut, and this is a way if we can sort of look at it critically in terms of the macroeconomy, right?
[51:53] Should have this, what about this?
[51:55] But in terms of the housing market, it's really good news.
[51:59] It couldn't have come at a better time
[52:02] At the peak of the cycle, which it has been, there's nothing else driving the housing market downwards.
[52:08] Yes, we're going to get some negative headlines, which will scare the crap out of some people in the short term.
[52:14] But then those that are really needing to get the bigger house, the smaller house, move out to the bush or the beach, will be thinking, hey, this is great.
[52:21] I can borrow an extra 50 grand, right?
[52:23] The only negative here is to the poor, bloody first-time buyer.
[52:27] Well, yeah.
[52:29] If we get growth again... Of course.
[52:32] It's getting tougher.
[52:33] But isn't that another hook to demand, is that the first-time buyer now has got an extra... Yeah, win-win.
[52:39] 0.25% to borrow.
[52:41] Yep.
[52:41] You know.
[52:42] And first-time buyers haven't done too badly.
[52:45] And we've got to take our cap off to a lot of the governments that are now providing those... Yeah, stamp-shared equity.
[52:50] Well, the shared equity loans have been the real winners.
[52:53] First-time deposit scheme, OLMI.
[52:55] Yeah, that's right.
[52:56] They've been real business.
[52:57] There's so many opportunities from 2%, 5%, OLMI.
[53:00] I couldn't believe that.
[53:02] I had to save 40% for my first home.
[53:06] 40%.
[53:06] No matter what's going on in life, if you can't get together a couple of points, you're probably not in a position to own a home.
[53:13] Yeah.
[53:13] That's the truth.
[53:14] 40% I had to borrow.
[53:16] You must have worked hard for that.
[53:17] Well, yeah, me and the wife.
[53:21] But no, no, no.
[53:23] Yeah, it's 40%.
[53:24] People forget that.
[53:24] Yeah.
[53:25] You know, way back when.
[53:26] None of this 98% stuff.
[53:28] It was 40-60.
[53:28] It was 40-60.
[53:29] Yeah.
[53:30] And you had to have an... And I got my loans with the Commonwealth where most people did because it was either the Commonwealth Bank, which was a government-owned bank, or a state bank.
[53:38] You know, that's where you got your housing finance from.
[53:42] And you had to be a customer for like four years or five years.
[53:45] They had to know everything.
[53:46] Yeah.
[53:46] And you had to bring in, you know, your mates and your family.
[53:49] They all had to be customers too.
[53:51] Yeah.
[53:51] Get to grovel to the bank manager, geez, you're looking great.
[53:53] You know?
[53:54] Yeah.
[53:55] Okay, I'll give you the loan sort of thing.
[53:56] But 40% deposit, you know, way back when.
[53:59] So it's a lot easier now, even though it's always hard.
[54:01] It's always hard in different spectrums.
[54:04] Yeah.
[54:04] But like you always say, and we always say, just think about, you know, I think it just encapsulates the whole of the Australian housing market.
[54:12] Just think about how you felt when you were finally a homeowner.
[54:16] It doesn't matter what it was.
[54:18] Just think about, this is mine.
[54:21] No landlord.
[54:22] This is mine.
[54:23] Those first barbecues.
[54:25] That's right.
[54:25] That water in the lawn.
[54:26] Yeah, that's right.
[54:27] You've got to have a water tank.
[54:28] I'm going to paint the bedroom.
[54:29] You know what I mean?
[54:30] Blah, blah, blah.
[54:31] But why do you get that feeling?
[54:33] Because it's such an achievement.
[54:35] And all Australians know that.
[54:37] They all know that.
[54:38] And in a way, it's what we build the whole of the housing market on.
[54:42] is that very strong aspiration for home ownership.
[54:45] And if anything's worth having, it's got to be a bit of a struggle.
[54:50] It's not like, here's your home, another one.
[54:53] It's something you've got to work for, strive for, and then it becomes such a big deal when you finally achieve it.
[54:59] And everything's built on it in Australia.
[55:01] We build our individual wealth and we build our investment profiles through...
[55:06] And it's been the case ever thus, you know.
[55:08] And the other thing that's interesting is that we've imported that culture as well.
[55:12] Yeah.
[55:13] We import that because you look at how strong, you know.
[55:17] Europeans, Southeast Asia.
[55:18] Southeast Asians, or, you know, East Asians, Europeans, particularly.
[55:25] in terms of the housing market, how that first thing they do is they've got to get property, own property.
[55:30] And it's because they come from cultures where you just can't do it.
[55:33] It doesn't matter.
[55:34] It's impossible.
[55:35] But here it's doable.
[55:36] And you're not just get one.
[55:37] You can get investment properties and they know it's the road to building wealth.
[55:41] And everybody out there knows what I'm saying.
[55:43] They feel it in their DNA, you know, and it keeps us chugging along.
[55:46] But, of course, then we have all the negativity, which we're going to see again over the coming week or so.
[55:51] And then you think, hello, really, if you look at this rationally, this is opportunity knocking with an interest rate cut, you know, and a strong economy.
[55:59] There you go, opportunity knocking with an interest rate cut.
[56:02] And I shouldn't have said you should be out there asking for $100,000.
[56:05] I should have said $50,000.
[56:06] $150,000.
[56:06] No.
[56:09] Well, pleasure as always, Doc.
[56:10] Thank you.
[56:11] Appreciate your time, mate.
[56:12] Thank you.
[56:12] Yes, thank you very much, yes.
[56:13] Thank you.
[56:15] And onwards and upwards.
[56:16] Onwards and upwards.
[56:17] A rising tide lifts all boats.
[56:18] There you go.
[56:19] That old saying.
[56:19] What's the old saying?
[56:20] When the tide goes out, you see who's wearing no pants.
[56:24] We'll see what happens.
[56:25] But I think it's pretty stable.
[56:26] It's going to be an interesting year.
[56:27] It's going to be an interesting year.
[56:28] But stay tuned.
[56:28] Year of opportunity.
[56:30] Check out the Wilson Weekly each week.
[56:32] And definitely jump onto Doc's LinkedIn so you can check out the data and get access to all of his reports.
[56:37] Yeah, and look for that...
[56:38] Housing Market Report this week.
[56:39] And you'll see a lot in that report that we've discussed here today.
[56:43] Absolutely.
[56:43] So all good.
[56:44] Pleasure as always.
[56:45] Thanks, mate.
[56:45] Yes.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
