# Why MIRV Agni-V Marks a Military Milestone and What Future-Ready AMCA Fighter Jet Holds in Store| In Our Defence, S02, Ep 15

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 14 Mar 2024, 1 h 00 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/59044909/14_mar_24_iod_14_mar_128.mp3

From an ambitious fighter jet project to a landmark missile test, the last few days marked important milestones for the nation’s defence. India test-launched the nuclear capable Agni-V missile in a ‘multiple independently targetable reentry vehicle’, or MIRV, avatar. Just days before, the government gave the all-clear for the development of the AMCA, or Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft, a fifth-generation fighter jet that will feature cutting-edge technology. On this episode of In Our Defence, host Dev Goswami and Defence expert Shiv Aroor discuss these two projects and what they mean for the Indian Air force and the country’s nuclear arsenal. The two also briefly discuss the unfortunate crash of the Tejas fighter jet, the first in its service history. Tune&nbsp;in! Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound mix by Sachin Dwivedi

## Transcript

[0:00] This is India Today, podcasts. How many legions of pilots have died in
[0:09] fighter crashes in this country. You know, we've seen movies made about it.
[0:12] We've seen horrible terms like flying coffin. I saw some idiot on social
[0:16] media calling the stages of flying coffin. It's the first crash eight years in
[0:20] service. So sadly we have to exist among the you know, not so
[0:23] literate, and I think that's where podcasts, like in our defense, you
[0:27] know, play a very important role. As soon as he comes out of
[0:29] the cockpit, the wind blast is going to throw him towards the tail of
[0:33] the aircraft and if it hits him, he's finished. He's going to be
[0:36] in pieces, there'll be nothing left of him. So therefore it needs to
[0:39] clear that tail and that's why it needs to be thrown out very very violently.
[0:43] But in two thousand and six, I became the first Indian journalist to
[0:46] be allowed access to the Foxbat base in Bareley. It was called the Trysonic
[0:50] Squadron and just months before the Foxbats were being retired from service, I was
[0:55] allowed to go there and do a double spread for the Indian Express on the
[0:59] thing and I still remember the headline, which was farewell Foxbat's magnificent flying machines.
[1:04] A little pun that shaker gupan Indian Express I've done. Hello and welcome
[1:10] to Another Defense, a weekly podcast on all things well defense, where I
[1:15] They've go Swami, your host, along with senior journalist Shivaru, break down
[1:19] the world of conflicts that range from the subtle to the brutal. We bring
[1:23] you nuances and perspectives that will inform and at times provoke. This is in
[1:32] our Defense. Hello and welcome to the fifteenth episode of A Defense. So
[1:41] it's been a quite the week in the world of defense. Hi Shif,
[1:45] guessing you work very very caught up with all that's been happening. After weeks
[1:48] of nothing happening in defense, I think everything decided to happen in a span
[1:52] of ten days. So this is going to be a very very fun fifteenth
[1:55] episode of Defense. It was in troth for actually on Monday, I was
[1:59] a day's leave and I just saw all the breaking news coming in. Yeah,
[2:01] and something happened even yesterday. We record like a base one of men's
[2:06] day. So lots to talk about this week. Let's start off with the
[2:10] breaking news that happened yesterday and unfortunate one the crash of the LCA AS being
[2:16] operated by the Indian Air Force somewhere over Jesselware. While the Air Force has
[2:20] not formally said it, but I think it's became pretty much sure. You
[2:23] take it for a guarantee that it happened because the aircraft was going to take
[2:27] part or had taken part in Barrachukti, which was going on in pok Run
[2:31] nearby. I think a two day, three daysercition of live firing grills,
[2:35] et cetera. Lots of buzz about the crash on social media, some of
[2:38] which I personally did not really like. I won't say there was glee over
[2:43] it, but you know, just once again those negative commentary about you know,
[2:46] one more air Force jet has crashed. What does this say about the
[2:50] THEAS line of fighter jets. The Air Force has currently around forty or they
[2:57] in service and they placed an order for eighty. It is pretty more redmore,
[3:00] yeah, exactly, and they plan to have around two hundred yeah,
[3:04] of some of the versions of tages. So right of the bat, your
[3:07] thoughts on the crash, obviously it's too soon for you to tell us what
[3:10] may have happened because it's just been literally one day. The quote of inquiry
[3:15] of the Air Force is just about I think began their their investigations, so
[3:19] we don't quite know exactly what happened. The good part was the pilot or
[3:22] pilots. I'm not sure if it's a two single pilot yea, the pilots
[3:24] survived having ejected. So your thoughts on the crash and your thoughts on the
[3:30] commentary about surrounding it. So so there, Yeah, I know about the
[3:35] social media buzz that you're talking about. It usually happens with every crash,
[3:38] but this particular one attracted a special amount of attention because it's the first ever
[3:44] crash of a Tager's fighter, So it's a it's an important it's an important
[3:47] event for sure because the Tages. Let's you know, let's put down the
[3:52] facts right off the bat that this is a fighter that first flew twenty three
[3:57] years ago, which means that it has had nearly a quarter century of accident
[4:01] free flight, which is a huge feat, not just in India but across
[4:04] the world, because there are very few, if I'm not mistaken or perhaps
[4:09] no, you know, fighter aircraft projects that have you know, gone from
[4:14] design to prototyping to flight test to operational service, you know, without a
[4:17] single crash. So that's a that's a feather in the tagus's gap without any
[4:21] doubt. Point number two, it's been eight years since it entered operational squadron
[4:26] service. So unlike your developmental flight testing phase, operational service is your you
[4:30] know, proper rugged eye of the aircraft in a squadron. So it's not
[4:35] like the aircraft was being treated with kid clubs. It was in a squadron,
[4:39] you know, breathing the same fumes, you know, operating at a
[4:42] high tempo with like any other fighter in service. So this is a fighter
[4:46] that is cutting its teeth in squadron service. So you know, like I
[4:50] always say about crashes, two things that I always say a military aviation is
[4:57] an inherently risky business, no matter how much you try and prevent accidents.
[5:01] Uh, you know, these are these are operations that take place at the
[5:05] extremes of physics and engineering, and accidents will happen. They will happen.
[5:10] It's a it's a it's a tragic thing to say, but they will happen.
[5:13] But like you said, they've the pilot ejected from this fighter safely.
[5:17] He's totally safe, he's unharmed, you know, which is as my as
[5:21] as a colleague and friend of mine angers saying, who I had on my
[5:25] TV show today said it's the best possible outcome. Accidents will happen, but
[5:30] if the pilot is safe and there's no damage on the ground, it's the
[5:32] best possible outcome, you know, within the larger, unfortunate sort of shadow
[5:36] of a of an accident. Point number two, there's no room for sentiment
[5:41] in such things. You know, military aviation is a you know, is
[5:45] a is an enterprise that where the luxury of emotion and sentiment doesn't exist.
[5:49] All that sentiment only happens on social media by people who don't have to strap
[5:53] into those cockpits and take those risks. All that uh, you know,
[5:57] oh my god, another fighter has gone down, or you know, comparisons
[6:00] between Indian and Pakistani fighters or Indian and Chinese fighters. That usually is the
[6:04] preserve of those who don't have to get into those fighters and actually do the
[6:09] job of flying them. So my initial, my initial assessment of this is
[6:15] I completely agree with you. It's wrong to you know, conjecture or speculate
[6:18] as to what happened. This aircraft was clearly at a very low altitude and
[6:25] whatever emergency it was that forced the pilot to eject, and Indian Air Force
[6:30] pilots are very very well trained, let me tell you. So for him
[6:31] to eject means that obviously it was some kind of an emergency. He couldn't
[6:35] have recovered the aircraft from. We don't know what that is, and I
[6:39] don't want to speculate that'll come out from the crash investigation. But my last
[6:44] point, just to close that thought, is on a day like this,
[6:46] this could have been any fighter. It could have been a Sooth thirty.
[6:48] It could have been a it could have been a you know, a Mike
[6:51] twenty nine. It could have it could have been a Mirage. It could
[6:54] have been any fighter. It happened to be a tageous at that point of
[6:58] time. If there is any silver like in a crash, it's this.
[7:00] It is that the tags and you know, a friend of mine on Twitter
[7:05] had something to say which I found very interesting. He said, I'm happy
[7:09] that the first crash has happened. Now you may agree or disagree with this,
[7:13] but you know what he said. He said, I'm happy thata so
[7:16] that so that, you know, crash free syndrome, that fear of that
[7:21] first crash, that's gone now and you know, now you can breathe easy
[7:26] a little bit because through through service when you know, I think the sentiment
[7:30] he's trying to express is there must have been this kind of uh, you
[7:33] know, fear among pilots. I hope I'm not that guy who crashes the
[7:38] first stages. And I know this is no snark on the pilot who was
[7:42] in the stages. Okay, this was something that was completely out of his
[7:46] hands, as we will see in the crash report whenever it comes out.
[7:47] So I'm just saying that this is military aviation. This is a risky business.
[7:53] You know how many legions of pilots have died in fighters in fighter crashes
[7:58] in this country. You know, we've seen movies made about it. We've
[8:01] seen horrible terms like flying coffin. I saw some idiot on social media calling
[8:05] the stages of flying coff And it's the first crash eight years in service.
[8:09] So sadly we have to exist among the you know, not so literate,
[8:15] and I think that's where podcasts like in our defense. Yes, you know,
[8:18] play a very important role where we illuminate these topics on which people tend
[8:22] to jump to conclusions about. Since we're talking about the crash and the fact
[8:26] that the pilot managed to eject, I just want to slightly briefly focus and
[8:31] just go through the tangent of an ejection, because I remember eating lots about
[8:33] it during the aftermath of the Balacote strike when then wing Comata Martaman had to
[8:41] eject from his Make twenty one and fell into Pakistani tiltory. So I remember
[8:46] eating about just the sheer amount of force that is put on a pilot's body
[8:50] at that moment when they pull that lever, and then you know that this
[8:56] synchronized so small rockets sort of fire throwing the can of pav and the away
[9:00] from the from the debris of the not the Debrit Persia, but the following
[9:03] jet at that moment. Yeah. Uh. And what I remember reading about
[9:07] also is that recovery after such an injection is usually impossible, in the sense
[9:13] that most pilots who reject at times don't even make it back to flying a
[9:16] fighter jet because they're physically not in that state. Ataman was able to recover
[9:22] from it and make a full recovery and back to flying duty. So,
[9:24] in your conversations with fighter pilots who've had to eject, how do they describe
[9:28] that moment and how difficult is a medical recovery after? So, you know,
[9:33] an ejection is u is basically, you know, a bomb exploding in
[9:37] the cockpit. It's an it's it's there are four, four or five explosives
[9:41] that actually detonate inside the cockpit to throw you out of the aircraft. Now,
[9:46] obviously I'm making it sound a little simplistic. It's a it's a it's
[9:48] a symphony of explosions that take place and moving parts that have to move in
[9:56] order for that entire sequence of actions to throw you out of the aircraft.
[10:00] But basically, when you pull that ejection handle, you know which is under
[10:03] your seat, Uh, it triggers, uh. You know, a sequence
[10:07] of events that starts first with the canopy shattering, either the glass shattering or
[10:11] the entire canopy blowing away, depending on what happens. In the case of
[10:15] the Tages, it's only the glass that shatters, not the entire canopy,
[10:18] which is why when you can see in that crash video with somebody to put
[10:22] a mobile phone, you can see the canopy that's still there. Uh.
[10:24] And after that, there are there are four explosions that take place, you
[10:30] know, on the ejection seat of the of the aircraft, basically mini rocket
[10:33] rocket motor explosions, after which the pilot with the with the seat that he's
[10:39] sitting in, the ejection seat that he's sitting in, is thrown very very
[10:43] violently and vertically out of the uh, you know, out of the cockpit.
[10:48] Now, the reason why the pilot needs to be thrown in a jerk
[10:50] and so violently and fast is because he can't he shouldn't be hit by the
[10:54] tail fin of the aircraft, the you know, the the vertical stabilizer,
[10:58] the the fin of the the tail of the aircraft shouldn't go slicing into the
[11:03] pilot. That's why when the plane is like that, he needs to be
[11:05] thrown out very violently. So because the plane is moving. Remember, so
[11:09] as soon as he comes out of the cockpit, the wind blast is going
[11:11] to throw him towards the tail of the aircraft. And if it hits him,
[11:16] he's finished. He's going to be in pieces, there'll be nothing left
[11:18] of him. So therefore it needs to clear that tail, and that's why
[11:20] he needs to be thrown out, you know, very very violently. Now
[11:24] during that during that ejection phase, when you when you you know, the
[11:28] thrown out of the cockpit, A multiplicity of injuries can happen, from the
[11:33] most basic, which is concussion, to the possibility of your hands of feet.
[11:37] This is rare, but your hands or feet could hit some part of
[11:39] the aircraft. You can have a shoulder dislocation, you can have a you
[11:43] can have fractures on your hands. The most serious kind of injuries can be
[11:46] what is called a compression fracture, which is of your spine because you're sitting
[11:50] back in an ejection seat and you're suddenly thrown upwards, so your entire spine
[11:54] there's a there's an enormous amount of force sort of compressing your spine almost like
[11:58] in aodian so it can it can actually fuse your vertebrae together. So compression
[12:03] fractures actually very very common in ejection cases. H And you're right, you
[12:07] know, there have been hundreds of ejection cases where pilots are medically downgraded and
[12:13] they're not able to return to flying. Because you need you need the robustness
[12:18] of your spine to sustain g forces, you know, when you're in fighter
[12:22] aviation and God forbid another ejection if which is always going to be possible.
[12:28] So so yeah, it's a. It's a. It's a life saving piece
[12:31] of engineering. You know, thousands of lives over many years have been saved
[12:35] thanks to ejection seats. But yeah, it's a. It's a. It's
[12:39] a. It's a difficult call for any pilot. I can tell you that
[12:43] pilots will exhaust all their training, every possible protocol to save the aircraft or
[12:50] to bring the aircraft down safely before pulling that ejection because they know what ejection
[12:56] means, because it means a they you will save your life for show,
[13:00] but there's going to be some kind of harm to your body, either permanent
[13:03] or temporary. But an aircraft loss is going to be on your record.
[13:07] Now, that's not going to be held against you if it was a problem
[13:11] with the aircraft. But pilots are a sentimental lot, and for them it's
[13:16] a very very difficult thing to have a crash on your record. But I
[13:18] can tell you that you know that shouldn't dissuade anyone, you know, from
[13:22] combat aviation there have been chiefs who rejected from aircraft. You know, Air
[13:26] Chief Marshal Danad ejected from a Kiran, if I'm not mistaken, while he
[13:31] was a cadet during one particular emergency. The current Air Chief, a Chief
[13:35] Marshall ve Akram Chaudhry, had an incredible experience when he was the squadron commander
[13:41] of a mid twenty nine unit in Pune where the entire canopy shattered in mid
[13:46] air because of some kind of locking mechanism malfunction. And he's an example of
[13:52] someone who didn't eject. He's used his training, stayed in the aircraft completely
[13:58] cool mind, real killer in tinked saying I'm not going to let this aircraft
[14:01] you know, crash and then be on my record. And he was a
[14:03] squad and leader then a wing com under them and he landed the plane safely.
[14:07] So so ejection is a is a difficult decision to make for any pile,
[14:11] right And I think what makes it even more difficult and more scary is
[14:15] the fact that you can't train for it. And so something and practically trained
[14:18] for you can abviously read about it, you can be hold in classes that
[14:20] this is what you need to do and this is what you will feel like,
[14:22] but the actual moment is going to happen only once in your life,
[14:26] perhaps a right. H Two other things happened this week, one of which
[14:31] was breaking news completely caught most of us off guard. I like I said,
[14:37] I was. It was in I think it was just around your show,
[14:41] your daily five o'clock show, when the information first came out that p
[14:43] and you will be addressing the nation, and as always it was like,
[14:48] oh my god, yoga. Initial thought obviously that de monetization lockdown. But
[14:56] then it wasn't an announcement, as Saget, was just a tweet, a
[15:00] very short piece of post on what's now known as X where he announced I
[15:05] forgot the name of the mission. Mission, which is the launch test launch
[15:09] of five that had been remodeled in an n r V setup, which is
[15:15] short for multiple independently Targetable reusable Vehicles. We'll come to that. We'll come
[15:20] to that in the second half of this episode, because I want to stay
[15:22] on the topic of fighter jets since we're talking tages and something that I'm guessing
[15:28] is going to be built on the platform of the stages, if not the
[15:31] entire jet of the stages is the AMCA, which got cabinet approval I think
[15:35] over the weekend or on Friday last week last week. Yes, AMCA is
[15:39] short for Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft. We've briefly referred to the to this during
[15:45] our episode on theses itself. Actually I don't, by the way, how
[15:48] several other things that happened this week we've already spoken about. Yeah, uh,
[15:50] you know, defense is prophetic. Yeah, let's chin piece with that.
[15:54] Navy will come to the Navy, you know, in in a while,
[15:58] Navy research vehicles and nuclear weapons, which, like I said, we'll
[16:02] come to it exactly. Yeah. So, yeah, you know, defense
[16:04] is prophetic, I think, and I should note that down for our promotions.
[16:07] We should just like you know, have it or maybe someone in the
[16:10] Ministry of Defense is listening to us. Yeah, correct, but they definitely
[16:14] listen to us, by the way. Right, So coming back to AMCAR,
[16:18] I think in the TAS episode, Shave had given us sort of a
[16:21] very brief sort of an overview of an AMCA. Looks like AMCA basically your
[16:25] fifth generation aircraft. There are already several fifth generation aircraft in operation. I
[16:30] think the US has two of them. The F two Raptor and the F
[16:33] thirty five if I'm not wrong, I forgot one more in the in Europe
[16:37] and Russia has the SOU fifty seven if I'm not wrong. Yes, yeah,
[16:41] that's what the fifth generation aircraft. In case you don't want to go
[16:42] back to our you know, episode ontages, I think shive, you can
[16:47] just like one second, just revise what a fifth generation fighter basically is.
[16:49] So the reason the reason that Dave and I are speaking now about the AMCA
[16:55] is because, after you know, many years of delay, the AMCA project
[16:59] is actually is the government has sanctioned it, which means it has been accorded
[17:06] formal sanctioned by the Cabinet Committee on Security. Fifteen thousand crores have been granted
[17:11] to this project for the design phase and to bring it up to an actual
[17:15] prototype. Now what does this actually mean. First of all, they've the
[17:18] the AMCA draws many lessons from the Tagus, but it is not based on
[17:22] the theagas at all. It's it's a completely from the scratch, from scratch
[17:27] kind of project because it's a it's a dramatically different kind of aircraft. You
[17:33] know, the Tagus is a is a conventional fourth generation fighter. And I'll
[17:38] explain why the AMCA is a fifth generation fighter. Basically, it's a it's
[17:41] a stealth fighter. If you google AMCA, you see the shape. It's
[17:45] very familiar. You know, all fifth generation fighters largely have similar geometry.
[17:49] You know, they've got you know, they've they've got the kind of shape
[17:52] that you know, evades radar or deflects radar instead of sending it back to
[17:57] the you know, the radar operator. You know, they have a certain
[18:02] look if you look at the F thirty five, the F twenty two,
[18:04] a certain futuristics correctly, so you know, they don't have any uh,
[18:10] you know, any sharp edges, et cetera. They're all very smooth and
[18:12] kind of radar unfriendly. Now, the AMCA is India's attempt at building a
[18:18] fifth generation fighter. Now, stealth isn't the only characteristic of a fifth generation
[18:22] fighter. It's much more complicated than that. Obviously, low observability and stealth
[18:26] as they call it is is one of the key characteristics. But beyond that,
[18:32] the real heart of a fifth generation fighter is more about its systems,
[18:36] its network centric operations, smart cockpits, the ability of the pilot in a
[18:41] fifth generation fighter, you know, to control other objects like a UAV you
[18:47] know, or or other aircraft or you know, anything on the ground.
[18:49] The ability for you know, the war fighter in the cockpit to use amazing
[18:55] amounts of data to actually execute missions. Uh, you know, smart weapons,
[19:00] things like that, things that go beyond just stealth, that are system
[19:03] related and network related rather than how an aircraft actually looks now. Like you
[19:08] rightly said, India is a little late to this game. The United States
[19:12] already has two, Russia has the ZUKHOIU fifty seven, China has the J
[19:19] twenty, even though there's a very vibrant debate out there over whether it's really
[19:23] a fifth generation fighter because nobody really knows very much about it. But that's
[19:27] not the point. China at least has it out then they've built like hundreds
[19:30] already. In fact, they're building a second fifth generation fighter called the FC
[19:36] thirty one. In Europe, there are two concept fifth generation fighters, you
[19:41] know, like what happened in the eighties and nineties with the Raphaele and the
[19:44] Typhoon. Now you know of France centric and UK centric rivalry has broken out
[19:49] with two separate fifth generation fighters happening there. One is called the Tempest,
[19:53] which is in Britain. One is called the FCAS or Future Combat Air System,
[19:56] which is you know, France centric whole. Hopefully they'll merge at some
[20:00] point of time. But the amazing thing is even even Turkey. Turkey has
[20:06] just conducted the first flight, you know, of the Khan, which is
[20:08] its own fifth generation so called fifth generation fighter, which had its first flight
[20:12] just weeks ago at the Singapore issue. So India is woefully late to this
[20:18] thing. We you know, a completely separate episode can be dedicated to the
[20:22] to the to the follies of planning as a result of which India's air power
[20:26] has come up short in terms of what we need, what our pilots and
[20:30] our war fighters and military planners need now for the kind of missions we need
[20:33] now. And one of the reasons why, you know, we were fighting
[20:37] the post ballacote you know skirmish with Mike twenty ones, which is which is
[20:42] a separate issue. Not that the Make twenty ones did badly, but I'm
[20:45] just saying the AMCA comes late. It has had a it has had a
[20:49] troubled planning journey so far. It's extremely you know, it's extreme it's still
[20:55] extremely nascent. The first flight of the AMCA is likely to take place sometime
[21:00] towards the end of this decade, maybe around twenty twenty eight, twenty nine
[21:04] to thirty, could be as early as twenty seven, but I have my
[21:07] doubts about that. The official aim is to get a first flight by twenty
[21:11] seven. I doubt that's going to happen. I think it's going to be
[21:15] more realistically around twenty thirty. But the point, a piece of reassurance that
[21:22] people in the program and people in the air Force give me is even though
[21:25] the aircraft is late, obsolescence is not going to be a problem because the
[21:29] Indian Air Force says, we're on board right now. It's been sanctioned right
[21:32] now. So everything that happens as far as developing this aircraft is concerned,
[21:36] is going to constantly have a cycle of updates, so it will constantly have
[21:41] new technologies and when it finally enters service, it will be cutting edge.
[21:45] It will be top of the line and state of the art, or as
[21:47] much as is you know, reasonably possible for our aviation scientists to do.
[21:52] So it's good news, you know, a project sanction coming this late in
[21:55] the day is definitely good news. It's a country which has limited rest sources,
[22:00] so we can't be throwing money at every single project. You know,
[22:03] that's one of the excuses that the spreadsheets in the mod will give you that.
[22:07] You know, I wish we had the luxury of sanctioning all projects at
[22:10] one go. In you you're always, you know, finding problems with what
[22:12] we do. But it's true. You know, you just had an aviation
[22:17] skirmish with your nearest neighbor, China. You've got, you know, a
[22:22] current active operational scenario with China, you know your nuclear neighbor. Uh,
[22:26] and you're not emphasizing the importance of air power. That's a real problem as
[22:33] far as India's planning is concerned. So within all of this, I think
[22:36] they've the sanction for the AMCA is a good one. The reason why I
[22:40] am a little confident about the AMCA and not, you know, I'm not
[22:44] hesitant about it is because it's being developed by teams that have had you know,
[22:49] lifelong lessons from the tages. They know what pitfalls to avoid, they
[22:55] know all the cracks in the system. Now, uh, they have inherited
[22:59] an air force which is no longer suspicious about getting they see stuff. They
[23:03] just is a beloved aircraft of the Indian Air Force right now. Uh,
[23:07] and the Air Force knows that the era of importing stuff is over. That's
[23:12] behind us. You know, many people will criticize this Mbarat thing as a
[23:18] as a kind of pr campaign, but the intentions of it are extremely noble
[23:23] and not just noble, they're very crucial. We cannot depend on outside arms
[23:27] indefinitely. We can't be importing fighter aircraft from the outside. We have to
[23:32] build our own. And that's why the AMCA, which is India's first futuristic
[23:36] combat aircraft enterprise, being cleared is a very big deal. I'm glad you
[23:40] cleared the whole thing about it being it's going to be cutting edge when it
[23:44] comes into service, because that actually was going to be a follow up point
[23:47] I was going to raise us that that's what wyre you being when I was
[23:49] doing my research, is that one you already so late to developing a fifth
[23:52] generation to even thinking of developing a fifth generation fighter jet. By the way
[23:57] you get around to producing it for your customer, maybe fifteen to twenty years
[24:02] down the line, you might already have a situation where countries are actively experimenting
[24:07] with six generation fighter. By the way, yeah, I think I've what
[24:11] tired about was concepts like, you know, a sort of a virtual cockpit
[24:15] where the pilot doesn't physically see outside the cockpit, everything is just stream to
[24:18] him. And also optionally manned aircraft that doesn't need to have a human in
[24:22] the cockpit. Yeah, but you mentioned that, you know, there is
[24:25] the whole idea is to incrementally update every system that you're kind of developing right
[24:29] now, so that when you inducted in the service, you have what's probably
[24:32] the latest tech existing in the world at that moment. So then I'll skip
[24:36] to my second warry, which is what we discussed at length during the stage's
[24:40] episode, and the problems with its development and the problems with therefore taking so
[24:45] long to come on board and to accept the fighter jet, the problems with
[24:49] HL not being able to deliver what the Air Force wanted. Before I complete
[24:53] my complete by thought on that point, just like a brief acide. You
[24:56] know, during the Navy the discussion on on Indian Indian Navy, you had
[25:00] mentioned how Indian Navy is blessed to have all these naval shipbuilding yards that are
[25:07] not all of them as be manned completely by former Navy of officers, but
[25:11] most of them have or head by them. And you said how that was
[25:15] in stark contrast with the Indian Air Force. Just the opposite, just the
[25:18] opposite. So now going back to my earlier thought, is that going to
[25:22] be the same with amcar Because my question in right now is if the AHL
[25:27] even manages to produce a fighter jet and a fifth generation fighter jet, what
[25:32] if after ten years the Air Force comes up and says, yeah, yeah,
[25:37] So that's that's a very important question, a very good question. Now,
[25:38] look, see, the Air Force doesn't have the luxury of saying,
[25:44] you know, when a project is sanctioned by the government, that's basically air
[25:48] force budget, that's budget from the Air Force. So the Air Force is
[25:51] not going to walk away from something that it has it has asked for.
[25:55] Point number one. Point number two, The Air Force doesn't have the luxury
[25:59] of walking away from something after ten years because that would mean that the Air
[26:03] Force was not involved from day one, and that's and that would be pegged
[26:07] on the Air Force, not on HL. Now, when a weapon development
[26:11] project takes place, it is it is imperative and obligatory on the customer service,
[26:17] in this case the Air Force, to embed itself in that project and
[26:22] monitor it on literally a weekly basis up to the chiefs level. Because this
[26:27] is not these are not these are not small little things. This is national
[26:30] taxpayer public money being spent on stuff that's going to defend your country. So
[26:36] it is your obligation as the customer intended operator of that equipment to monitor the
[26:41] project and make sure that it stays on track and is delivered according to your
[26:45] requirements. Of course there will always be but you've not met this requirement.
[26:49] But you've not met that requirement, as we're seeing with the Theages. The
[26:52] theages that's in service right now is a theages that didn't meet all the requirements,
[26:56] which is why you've got something called the Theages Mark one A which has
[27:00] additional improvements which are going to start arriving in service very shortly. I understand
[27:04] eighteenth of March is going to be when the first flight takes place in Bengaluru.
[27:08] But beyond that you've got the the Just Mark two, which is actually
[27:11] the original it's the first they Just Mark two, which will come much later,
[27:15] is actually what will meet the original requirements of the Air Force in terms
[27:18] of performance. So this, this goalpost shifting is not a new thing,
[27:23] you know, as a normal thing in the Air Force, but they can't
[27:27] walk away from it. Is the only point I'm making as far as the
[27:30] AMCAS concerned. There's been a cultural shift, you know, like we've discussed
[27:34] in one of our earlier episodes. The Air Force HL relationship is a way
[27:38] unique one. The Air Force is the only is the biggest, overwhelmingly biggest
[27:42] customer of HL. The Air Force is completely dependent on HL. HL has
[27:47] a monopolistic kind of supply relationship with the Air Force, but they have totally
[27:53] no trust for each other. Okay. There is a lot of hostility and
[27:57] people will people will send me messages because I'm saying this, But there is
[28:02] a great deal of trust deficit between HL and the Indian Air Force. They
[28:07] you know, to put it very simplistically, they don't really like each other
[28:10] very much, okay, And that relationship has changed even now. The HL
[28:14] has not been able to ramp up its you know, production rate of the
[28:18] theages to meet the Air Force's requirements. They bloody well better do it now
[28:22] with these big orders that have been landed on them, So that relationship is
[28:26] now one of you know that that's gone from you know, this Lala Sarkari
[28:30] relationship or kahase lega to you know that that kind of relationship to now saying
[28:34] boss, look now there's competition. Okay, you don't do it. I
[28:37] will go to the Tatas, or I'll go to LNT, or I'll go
[28:40] to whoever it is. The Tata's are already building aircraft in Baduda right now,
[28:44] so therefore the Air Force understands that HL understands that, and so that
[28:48] relationship has become much more professional now. So I don't think anybody is going
[28:52] to mess around. HL has seen the writing on the wall. They know
[28:56] that if they screw this up, if they screw up AMCA, you know,
[28:59] like some labs, some entities screwed up the stages, and the Air
[29:03] Force can't shirk its share of the blame because they've also been ones who've jumped
[29:07] the gun, said no to this, said no to that, changed requirements
[29:11] midstream, etc. But I'm just saying that now there is a mutual kind
[29:14] of equilibrium and understanding, saying we are on the same team. We have
[29:18] to have a common focus and a common goal to get this aircraft right so
[29:22] that we can deliver it and get into service. Because we live in an
[29:26] age unlike the eighties and nineties. We live in age now of massive scrutiny,
[29:30] social media, accountability or sent our own media, which is much more
[29:36] ruthless. So they can't get away with some slap dash amcar. They better
[29:40] deliver it. The bloody well deliver it. And they're not doing anyone a
[29:42] favor by doing that. It's their job, so what they're paid to do.
[29:47] Right, Since you mentioned tatas and then manufacturing a fighter jet outside Baroda,
[29:52] just a very small point from you. Do you ever foresee because when
[29:56] you said we spoke about how this is money coming out of the air forces
[30:00] budget or to develop fighter jet, do you ever force a situation in India
[30:03] like the one in the US where you have private companies taking charge of development,
[30:08] investing money, showing it to their respective air force or to air forces
[30:12] across the world and recouping the investment through that. Instead of the government funding
[30:18] a project for a fighter jet, that funding comes from your air force's own
[30:21] budget and your air force then, like you said, right now has to
[30:23] be closely involved in the project to ensure that it meets its requirements. So
[30:27] do you see such a situation happening in India. I'm very glad you asked
[30:30] that question, because they've believe it or not. The AMCA, India's fifth
[30:34] generation fighter project. Five years ago, HL and the government had decided that
[30:41] this project AMCA would be India's first public private partnership project a PPP project where
[30:48] they invited interests from large private sector companies to come and join HL as a
[30:55] joint venture. It would be an HL private sector joint venture to build this
[30:59] aircraft, to design, to take it up, complete the design prototyping phase
[31:03] and develop it. And that private sector would company would be basically a half
[31:07] half partner in it. And like you said, they would have the freedom
[31:10] to market it. Uh, you know, with with protocols and permissions and
[31:12] licenses in place, they would be able to export that aircraft, et cetera.
[31:15] And you know, bring all that vibrant energy that the private sector has.
[31:18] Unlike the you know, lackadaisical Sarkari PSU culture, not a single company
[31:23] came forward. These are companies that have been struggling for years saying ah,
[31:29] there's no level playing field opportunity L and T Lassen and two BRO, which
[31:34] is which is in many ways bigger than the government. It's a huge company,
[31:37] huge private sector company which does so much. You know, they build
[31:41] nuclear submarines, they build ships, they build frigates, they build tanks,
[31:45] they build uh you know how it's the guns they built, all manner of
[31:48] defense equipment. But they didn't step up to this. They were expected to
[31:52] be the company that would step up and say yes, HL and Lent will
[31:56] will will form a joint venture and execute the AMKA. They did And the
[32:00] reason I don't know the official reason why they didn't, but probably one of
[32:02] the reasons Whyolenty and any of the other statas and my Indras and all the
[32:06] others didn't step forward is because they saw risk in it. Ultimately, these
[32:09] companies are not sarkari companies. They have boards, they have shareholders. You
[32:14] know, they've got deadlines as far as their you know, profits and balance
[32:16] sheets are concerned. So they saw it as a as a risk that could
[32:21] be avoided. So they basically, I think, said, you know,
[32:23] we would like to be involved as suppliers and partners in terms of subsystems etset,
[32:28] but not at this top corporate sort of level. So that was a
[32:32] bit of a body blow because I was frankly quite excited about the prospect of
[32:36] a public private partnership executing this, because that would have professionalized and corporatized this
[32:40] what you're talking about, you know, which, because when you bring the
[32:44] private sector in, then there's it brings in an entirely new culture of accountability.
[32:50] Then deadlines are not negotiable, Then requirements are not like one one you
[32:53] know for cyclosisle sheet lying around somewhere. It's not that there's a there's a
[32:58] brutality about the private sector because you are answerable to your shareholders and your board
[33:02] and your your your deliverables and your money and your balance sheet depends on whether
[33:08] you execute a project on time. If d Ido and HL don't execute a
[33:13] project on time, there are no consequences for that cost over and time over
[33:16] and noga. You know, these are the risks of development process, et
[33:21] cetera. Which is fine, but I'm saying there is a desperate requirement for
[33:23] this private sector energy and culture of accountability in the public sector space, which
[33:30] is not there. And this was an opportunity for that to happen. Sadly
[33:32] it hasn't. Let's see how it goes going forward. Yeah, one last
[33:37] point on the topic of fighter jets and the Indiane Air Force and the development
[33:39] procurement, et cetera. When we discuss stages in the previous episode, and
[33:44] we'll have a link to the episode in our show notes, you had actually
[33:47] mentioned something that you've got to talk about in the episode, and someone on
[33:51] the comments section actually pointed it out and he was like, you know,
[33:53] I was waiting for the answer. It never happened. You had said that
[33:58] not ensuring that Mirage two thousands were made and were put together in India like
[34:04] you have with the Superos. Yeah, yeah, the Suquiz, not with
[34:06] fl because you bought them off the shelf and you know that deal fell to
[34:08] So you had said that if mirages had been put together in India like you
[34:13] the deal with Sukhois, the need for a TAGS would not have been there.
[34:16] A lot of the problems being faced by the Air Force would not have
[34:20] been there. And I'm guessing in my in like you know and at my
[34:22] level, then perhaps perhaps you would have thought of developing Amka a bit sooner
[34:27] because you wouldn't be so caught up worrying about your depleting squad and strength.
[34:30] So just like, yeah, I just recall that question, so if you
[34:34] can, no, absolutely, Yeah. So look, the Tagus was a
[34:38] project that was going to happen anyway independent of whether Miragers were built here or
[34:43] not, because the Tagos was initially envissaged as a you know, as a
[34:47] sort of very very advanced top level replacement for the mid twenty one. You're
[34:52] an aircraft that could be built easily, cheaply, and therefore you're able to
[34:55] buy it in large numbers and populate a number of squadrons like originally had with
[35:00] the Make twenty one. Basically a cheap to buy, easy to maintain,
[35:05] you know, reasonably capable frontline fighter like the Make twenty one. That's what
[35:07] the they just was. The Mirage two thousand is a few leagues above that
[35:12] now building the Mirage two thousand in India, which was an opportunity that presented
[35:16] itself before multiple governments Vajpai government, Man Mown government, I think before that
[35:22] also, there were a couple of governments that had the opportunity to basically take
[35:25] the Mirage production line from France, lock Stock and Battle and shifted to India.
[35:30] Was not entertained for various reasons. I don't want to get into the
[35:36] blame game of why it didn't happen, But to this day they've The Air
[35:39] Force and many aviation analysts believe that if you had a Mirage two thousand production
[35:45] line, the Mirage two thousand is a very high quality fighter. It has
[35:51] a low accident rate, it's very very capable. You use You've used your
[35:53] Mirages right from Cargill to bomb Tiger Hill. You use them to bomb Balacote
[35:58] also just a few years ago. So these are aircraft with a remarkable longevity
[36:05] the way they were built. When they were built in the seventies, you
[36:08] know, have they've stood the test of time, They've been upgradeable. They're
[36:12] incredibly smart aircraft right now, they've got smart cockpits. So they're very,
[36:15] very cutting edge fighters, even though they're of a certain vintage. And therefore,
[36:20] if you were we've got about I think fifty or sixty of those fighters
[36:22] right now. I'm saying that if you had them in large numbers, where
[36:25] you had a fleet of about maybe two hundred or two hundred and fifteen mirages,
[36:30] the requirement of this stop gap of Rafael MMRCA, considering the F sixteen
[36:37] F eighteen Eurofighter Grippin you know, mid thirty five, all this thing wouldn't
[36:42] have happened. All that, Junget that the Air Force had to spend so
[36:45] much energy on for over a decade to look for a fighter from abroad which
[36:47] finally became the Raphaele deal, you know, would not have happened. You
[36:52] wouldn't. That pressure on the system to bring aircraft in would not have been
[36:57] there because you would have had a local production line giving you a fighter that
[37:00] you love, that you know very well, that you're anyway upgrading, that
[37:05] your that your war fighters you know, depend on and trust very implicitly.
[37:08] You wouldn't have had a problem. That gap wouldn't have been there. So
[37:12] I think, uh, I think you you make a very good point,
[37:15] Dave when you say that it's possible that the AMCA could have been speeded up
[37:17] because without that pressure, the TAGES could have taken its time, The mirage
[37:22] would have populated some squadrons. There wouldn't have been so much pressure on the
[37:25] tags to you know, get to squadron service so quickly. It could have,
[37:30] you know, had its issues and the AMCA could have come much much
[37:32] faster. It would have It would have also freed up budget. Remember with
[37:37] the with the raphaile and with other aircraft. We're talking eye watering sums of
[37:40] money, right, huge sums of money that burning up, burning a huge
[37:45] hole in your pocket. And that's money that could have gone into advancing some
[37:49] of these projects. And I think I think that's a good point that you
[37:51] make, right. We'll now come to the ugly five launched test lonk that
[37:57] happened earlier this week. But after a quick break, eat eggs, no
[38:05] eat fiber, sleep, no take short naps, don't listen to others,
[38:08] no serve others. Do you ever feel like you're drowning in a pool of
[38:14] advice? This is Sonalia Charji, a health journalist for the last ten years,
[38:20] who is equally fed up of lines like ten ways to stay fit.
[38:24] So join me in the podcast Health Wealth, as we learn about health from
[38:28] a completely new perspective where investing in yourself is not a task but simple,
[38:35] satisfying and joyful. Full episodes are available on Apple, Google, Spotify,
[38:40] and the India Today podcast website. Tune in now welcome by Kars Shiv and
[38:52] I are discussing various things actually because lots happened this week in the world of
[38:55] defense, and one of them very exciting test of the five missile. Remember
[39:01] the missile is nuclear capable, capable of carrying nuclear water, and I think
[39:06] it was developed with the purpose of carrying nuclear waters. Actually, this particular
[39:08] test launch was to test a system known as the m i r V Multiple
[39:14] independently Targetable reusable Vehicle. It kind of gives away then, yeah, reentry
[39:20] vehicle. The name kind of gives it away. But if you want sort
[39:22] of I think you know an imagery of how it's like. If people have
[39:25] watched Iron Man the first first movie, there's a moment where where Tony Stark
[39:30] is demoing a missile for the US Armed Forces called the Jericho. He basically
[39:35] calls it like he says before firing the weapon, that he prefers to have
[39:39] a weapon that you only have to fire once and that basically one missile it
[39:43] takes off and then it turns into several missiles and it takes away a huge,
[39:46] huge mountain. That kind of is what im m Iri would look like
[39:52] in my view, shift can obviously tell us a bit more about that.
[39:57] The difference in this case is obviously that these separate missiles would all be nuclear,
[40:02] it would all be carrying nuclear nuclear warrants. Before we get to the
[40:06] nuclear part, before we get to why does India even need to have such
[40:09] a missile, and before we get to the fact that India in this case
[40:14] as well, is quite delayed compared to the other nuclear armed countries. First
[40:19] shift that tech itself, because it sounds very cool, just like, explain
[40:22] it to us. What is it all about? So so first some basic
[40:24] facts about the Ugly five. The Ugly five is nuclear capable ballistic missile that's
[40:30] capable of ranges in excess of six thousand kilometers. Obviously the official range is
[40:36] classified, but it's somewhere above six thousand kilometers. Point number two. The
[40:40] Ugly five is already in operational service with our Nuclear Command, as we mentioned
[40:45] in one of our previous episodes, and this was this was a trial test
[40:51] of a new technology on a missile system that's already in service. So the
[40:54] technology that you refer to, which is MERV, which is MIRV, is
[40:59] a also a technology that has been proven before on a earlier Agney called the
[41:04] Agnit three. So the technology also is not new to India. India's demonstrated
[41:09] it before, tested it before, and it's in service with the Agnit three,
[41:15] which is a three thousand, five h kilometer range similar weapons. So
[41:19] this was the reason why this was a milestone test is because this was the
[41:22] first mirv tech test on a much longer range missile, which brings in its
[41:28] own challenges and capabilities. Now, like you rightly said with that Iron Man
[41:34] example, to put it very simply, what happens is the Augne five takes
[41:38] off. Once it leaves the Earth's atmosphere, just before re entry, the
[41:44] warhead, the warhead assembly basically opens up and it splits into In India's case,
[41:51] where I'm hearing there were three, there are three warheads. It's three
[41:52] re entry vehicles, but there are nerv technologies and different parts of the world
[41:57] that have as many as six, and each of these it basically one warhead
[42:00] turns into three different warheads, and these three warheads are basically guidable from the
[42:07] ground to hit different targets, so all of them are not headed towards the
[42:10] same place. So theoretically, if you want to target three different cities in
[42:17] an enemy country. You can do it with one missile. The reason for
[42:22] this, and this is also something we've addressed in one of our previous episodes
[42:25] on our nuclear arsenal. They've is our no first use policy. Our no
[42:30] first use policy says India will never use its weapons nuclear weapons first. It
[42:35] will always be in response to a nuclear provocation in that in that regime,
[42:42] this kind of thing becomes very important because you want to be able to target
[42:45] as many targets as possible using a single missile. Because once nuclear war breaks
[42:51] out, your enemy is going to try and destroy your nuclear arsenal, Your
[42:54] ugly sites will be you know, come under attack as far as valiatory strikes
[43:00] are concerned. And therefore maximum damage with minimum missile is the mantra. It
[43:07] becomes the mantra. Now think of it like this, would you rather And
[43:10] I nobody wants nuclear war, so I'm not I'm not sitting here wishing for
[43:15] nuclear war disclaimer, but I'm just saying, as a as a war fighter,
[43:19] in a nightmare scenario where you've been struck by a nuclear weapon, would
[43:22] you rather have you know, one agonly hitting each different city in your enemy
[43:29] country? Or would you like the flexibility and the incredible sort of you know,
[43:35] options of launching one AGNE and using that Agne to target three different cities.
[43:40] Now, the ugly five warhead, the nuclear warhead weighs about one and
[43:45] a half tons. Now if you have three different warheads, stands to reason,
[43:47] if the architecture is correct, that each each warhead would be about half
[43:52] a ton about five hundred kilograms, which which obviously lowers the damage yield,
[43:55] et cetera. But it basically gives you that flexibility. A nuclear attack is
[44:00] of a different character altogether. It's mass destructive. You know, it means
[44:06] that things have gone beyond conventional you know, military operations, et cetera.
[44:09] So this technology with the uglyify gives you an enormous amount of flexibility to target
[44:16] different sites. It also adds a very very valuable Dave layer of unpredictability to
[44:23] what you're attacking. You're sending a missile up and which means that your anti
[44:28] missile systems from your enemy country can only attack that missile during its boost phase
[44:32] when it's being launched. After that, God help you, because once it's
[44:36] in space and those nerv warheads are separating from the body and going their separate
[44:42] ways. Now, instead of having one target to hit with your anti missile
[44:45] or your ballistic missile defense systems, you've got three targets to hit, and
[44:49] everyone knows that's virtually impossible. Your problem becomes three times as difficult. So
[44:53] that's that's basically the mantra and the theory of how morves work. More flex
[45:00] ability, greater destructive power, more unpreaditability for the enemy, uh, and
[45:04] a huge amount of flexibility for the war fight. That's in fact, I
[45:08] think one of the reasons this technology was developed in the first place was what
[45:12] SHIFT said right now, the idea that an anti ballistic missile defense system can
[45:17] easily take take it on one one nuclear missile, which is why the US
[45:22] and Russia during the Cold War went into the technology developed it from where almost
[45:29] I think every country that has nuclear weapons today has the the r V technology
[45:36] with them. And good that you mentioned that Indy already had it, because
[45:37] actually I was going to come to that because during the research I was like,
[45:40] wait, apart from also apparently has is I think able of carrying two
[45:45] warheads if I'm not wrong, on the on the same same missile. So
[45:49] we've had this tag for a while and Uh, what I'm gonna now still
[45:52] come to though, is a slightly philosophical, perhaps academic, perhaps sort of
[45:59] a question. Uh, but don't you think, and I think this was
[46:01] discussed even back then during the during the Cold War, that this just ends
[46:07] up starting another sort of an arms series because you developed this tech. Remember
[46:12] the Chinese spy ship research vehicleized they like to call them in and around the
[46:15] Bay of Bengal when this this missile test was happening. And there's a very
[46:21] uh straight reason for that because as a as a responsible country, India has
[46:24] to issue no time alone before every missile test that it conducts of the Bay
[46:29] of Bengal, so that no commercial airliners around the vicinity mistakenly during such a
[46:32] test and they get they get hit, And that no time has to be
[46:36] public, has to be formally communicated to entire world, which is how China
[46:38] knows to test cavallet their endorship there. It gets it sitting there waiting to
[46:43] see what goes up in the air and for it to do its analysis anyway,
[46:45] Uh, China must have gathered some sort of data from this launch.
[46:50] I don't know what it would be but then you have the prospect of then
[46:53] China trying to develop a piece of tech that can outdo this tech, and
[46:58] then India tries to or something else that out does that take, and then
[47:01] we just end up creating developing tech just for the sake of it, because
[47:06] you know, they just have something that could be tar systems, so we
[47:07] need to bring up build something that can defeat their systems. Your thoughts on
[47:13] thathing. Like I said, it's going to be a bit of a philosophical
[47:14] question, not very practical, but yet something I really want your thoughts on
[47:17] because I'm very conflicted about about this topic. I'm going to start with my
[47:22] favorite quote from Crimson Tide once again that the true you know, in the
[47:28] nuclear world, the true enemy is war itself, right, because you're talking
[47:32] about the most counterintuitive, paradoxical, ridiculous kind of arms race. You know,
[47:39] you're dealing with weapons that are going to destroy you anyway. If two
[47:43] countries get into a nuclear exchange, it is one hundred percent certain that the
[47:47] rest of the world is going to be drawn in. That's the reason why
[47:51] they call it a nuclear holocaust. No part of the world will be unaffected
[47:54] if there is a modern nuclear exchange between two big countries like India and China.
[48:00] US will get involved, Japan will get involved, Other countries will have
[48:02] to get involved, Russia will get involved. So so you know to think
[48:07] of it as, uh, you know, this arms race where oh,
[48:09] they've got the MORV and we need to get more. Oh, India's launching
[48:13] with three warheads, Let's get five warheads, and that will teach them a
[48:15] lesson. You're you're dealing not with conventional weapons, you know, that have
[48:21] measurable damage. You're dealing with weapons of mass destruction that can wipe out entire
[48:27] towns, cities, neighborhoods, and with enough deployment countries. And the entire
[48:32] purpose of these arms is to make sure that the other country doesn't use theirs.
[48:37] Like I said in my in our earlier episode, Davis, the entire
[48:40] purpose of nuclear weapons is for them not to be used. You know,
[48:45] if if a nuclear weapon gets used, it means they've failed. It's it's
[48:47] the it's the it's this heavenly paradox as far as nuclear weapons are concerned.
[48:53] You've got all of these weapons, You've got this crazy arms race as far
[48:58] as weapons is concerned, and no country. You know, some countries have
[49:00] started to realize it, and that's why they started to lessen their weapons,
[49:04] but most countries don't understand that the arms race as far as conventional weapons is
[49:09] puerile and silly as far as nuclear weapons are concerned, because beyond a certain
[49:15] threshold of possible damage based on the weapons that you have, the world ends.
[49:20] So what more are you developing? The arms race here is in terms
[49:23] of tech, Can I, you know, can I launch in such a
[49:27] way that there's no way they can respond? So I nuke their country,
[49:30] but that's it. Then the war ends right there. But that's impossible,
[49:32] you know. Obviously, obviously the focus of countries like China is going to
[49:37] be on being able to, you know, nuke another country and not provoke
[49:43] a response, not provoke, and that's it's it's puerile to even think that
[49:47] that's possible in this modern world with all the kind of interlinkages that we have.
[49:51] As far as Russia, the Russia and the United States are concerned,
[49:54] it's never going to happen. So so please send your research vessels, please
[49:59] send whatever you want into the Indian Ocean. It's a very serious issue.
[50:02] But as far as India is concerned, it will continue to test these weapons
[50:07] because India, and like I explained last time, with our no first use
[50:10] policy, does see these weapons as deterrents. The whole purpose of these weapons
[50:15] theyve is as a deterrent saying don't make me use this weapon. It's up
[50:21] to you to make sure I don't use this weapon. So that's the other
[50:23] beautiful paradox of nuclear weapons, which is that I'm I've got these weapons,
[50:30] so you better not use yours. It's that. In fact, I think
[50:32] there's a lot of bars and speculation on social media, especially among defense journalists,
[50:37] that India was also going to test launch a submarine launched byisting missile of
[50:43] the case series that are supposed to be carried on as Antarian the ones that
[50:49] come after it. That didn't happen. Some I have linked to the Chinese
[50:52] vessel that was in the b of being called otherwise. But you never know
[50:54] that stuff like this of why a test LNG is not does not happen.
[50:59] Uh. One last point on the topic. On the topic of nuclear weapons,
[51:04] it might be a bit silly, but you know, if you think
[51:06] about it, it's actually practically a very sound question is that nuclear tech actually
[51:12] is tech that you can't legally even test anymore. You have international treaties preventing
[51:16] countries from carrying out nuclear explosions, except the one cowboy nation of North Korea,
[51:22] which goes and you know, literally creates earthquakes in the sea when it
[51:25] tests not singular weapons, but it does carry out nuclear bom bombings. I
[51:30] think the last one was around four four and a half five years ago,
[51:32] if I'm not wrong, right anyway, So the silly question, you can't
[51:37] test nuclear tech, actual nuclear tech like the ugly five missile with Miri technology
[51:43] that was tested obviously do not carrying nuclear warhead. It carried conventional water,
[51:45] if carried waters at all, How can a country then be sure that your
[51:51] nuclear weapon is going to work exactly the way you wanted to in an actual,
[51:54] frightful scenario. And here comes the fifth big paradox of nuclear weaponry,
[52:00] which is that as much as it is the most destructive kind of weaponry on
[52:05] Earth, the science of it is incredibly simple. The science of the destructiveness
[52:10] of nuclear power is painfully simple, which is why a nuclear warhead is actually
[52:16] a very very elementary device. You know, a destructive nuclear bomb was developed
[52:22] in a matter of a you know, a couple of years by the United
[52:25] States in nineteen forty four, nineteen forty five, as Oppenheimer has told,
[52:31] a entirely new and clueless generation. Yes, right, so these are not
[52:36] these are not complicated devices. These are not high tech oh my god,
[52:39] supersonic smart guided It's it's a pretty dumb device. You know, very little
[52:46] has to happen for a nuclear bomb to do its terrible work. Okay,
[52:52] it's like there are many different times types of nuclear warheads. But and I'm
[52:57] not sort of underplaying what science has done as far as nuclear are concern,
[53:00] but they are there. They are not complicated devices, and that that's the
[53:04] scary part because they're not complicated. So building a nuclear bomb is not a
[53:07] big deal you're compared to other kinds of weapons. And therefore, once you've
[53:13] tested them, you know, kiaha yahai, take care you have a plutonium
[53:17] device or a unanium device and stuff. Yeah, you can be reasonably sure
[53:22] this is going to happen. And thank god, nuclear testing all these treaties
[53:25] exists apart from the Cowboy nations, more than just North Korea, I imagine.
[53:29] But I'm just saying that you don't need to constantly test it because once
[53:32] you've seen what it can do, there's an element of predictability in terms of
[53:37] what it is, and there's not nothing much you can improve upon as far
[53:40] as the warhead is concerned. The warhead's destructive power, yield, it has
[53:45] a very elemental nature. It's the power of atoms. For God's sake,
[53:49] you can't There's not not much you can improve upon as far as that is
[53:52] concerned, So therefore you don't need to test it. The real challenges delivery
[53:55] systems, evading systems, range, you know, how to avoid anti ballistic
[54:00] missile systems, ballistic missile defense. Those are the things that you need to
[54:05] test. The actual bomb is like nineteen forty but yeah, improve up,
[54:10] yeah, And I guess what helps is that there's nothing you need to control
[54:15] in such an explosion because you want destructions exactly. Toby hop yeah, argue
[54:19] like that's all you exactly that bomb to happen. But it's a good point
[54:22] that Shiv makes about how a nuclear war in today's modern time would can will
[54:28] definitely mean the end of the world because apart from the fact that every nation
[54:31] would get involved, We also have to remember that the modern nuclear warheads are
[54:36] like hundreds of times much more destructive than the two bombs that were used during
[54:42] the World War I on HEROSI and nuclear weapons which have never been used in
[54:45] anger thankfully. Right right as you bring this episode to a close, are
[54:51] tradition of trivia, and it wasically scared. You know, one day we'll
[54:57] just we won't have something trivial to talk about that the listeners in defense,
[55:00] So we always will, we always will, right, So trivia to do
[55:04] with again a fighter jet. This one was with the Indian Air Force for
[55:08] a brief amount of time. I'm not sure how long, but it is
[55:12] not there anymore. The Make twenty five. Yeah, it's known as the
[55:15] Fox Bat if I'm not wrong, it was. It is till this date,
[55:19] one of the fastest fighter jets ever ever produced, and I think it
[55:22] also has the capability to fly very very high up in the air. There's
[55:25] some trivia that or some rumor that was going around on social media. I
[55:30] don't know why, but it was which I thought, I'll talk to you
[55:31] about that. In the seventies, if I'm not wrong, An Indian Air
[55:37] Force Make twenty five actually flew over Islama path created a sonic boom like basically
[55:43] it reached mark speed and then just escape from there and Pakistan was clueless about
[55:49] that. Have you heard the story? So happened? So a little bit
[55:51] of a backstory and then I'll answer that question, not boasting once again.
[55:54] But in two thousand and six, I became the first Indian journalist to be
[55:59] allowed access to the fox Bat base in Bareley, Okay, this is Braley
[56:01] and Upi. It was called the Trisnic Squadron and just months before the fox
[56:07] Bats were being retired from service, I was allowed to go there and do
[56:10] a double spread for the Indian Express on the thing. And I still remember
[56:15] the headline which was farewell fox Bats, magnificent flying machines, a little pun
[56:22] that Shaker Gupta and the Indian Express had done. Fabulous aircraft, incredibly capable,
[56:28] like you rightly said, you know, three times the speed of sound,
[56:30] extremely fast, able to fly at about sixty thousand feet, which means
[56:35] when you're flying at your sealing altitude, you can see the Earth's curvature.
[56:37] So these were aircraft that were used obviously for photography and for spying. They're
[56:42] basically spyplanes. The Islamaba incident has been widely spoken about. Okay, obviously,
[56:50] you know it lies in that realm of the shadows where nobody wants to
[56:53] confirm. And I know fox Bat pilots, so I've spoken to them,
[56:57] I've spoken to the squadron commander chiefs, but nobody one gives me a little
[57:00] smile, but nobody confirms it. Not the seventies. I think it happened
[57:04] sometime in the eighties actually under Indra Gandhi and and apparently there was a situation
[57:10] where these guys had crossed over and needed to take some photographs and they got
[57:15] detected and you know, the sonic boom or whatever. Maybe there was a
[57:19] sonic boom or not. But the sonic boom part I puts me into doubt
[57:22] a little bit, Dave, because these aircraft flew really high, so I'm
[57:25] wondering what kind of sonic boom. And to get to that altitude, they
[57:30] wouldn't be flying low obviously for Islamabad. They'd be flying very, very high.
[57:32] And when they're flying at that height, obviously they'd already be flying fast.
[57:37] So I don't know about that, but I'm sure they've done their done
[57:40] their work, and these were aircraft of amazingly capable aircraft, you know,
[57:45] and all the things you've heard about the fox Bats are true. Like standard
[57:49] operating procedure when there's a missile coming at you from the ground is just to
[57:52] accelerate, nothing else. You don't have to do anything else, just just
[57:54] just go faster than missile and your and your home free. So these are
[57:58] incredible, incredible aircraft. Obviously, the journalist in me wishes the Islamabad story
[58:05] is true, and I think, but I just like the fact that nobody
[58:07] will ever know. Perhaps, Yeah, and that speaks a lot about the
[58:09] professionalism of those pilots. They are just like very happy to just give you
[58:13] a smile and not even tell you something off the record, these two West
[58:16] the pilots. The flight suit of the fox Bat was almost like a space
[58:20] suit, like a cosmonaut suit, where they had to wear that because you
[58:22] were flying at such high altitude, so to make sure that you don't get
[58:27] your blood doesn't bubble up through your veins, you needed to wear a really
[58:30] tight sort of rubber suit under your overall. So it's a totally different kind
[58:35] of league of flying. Yeah, a nice tidbit actually shave help that you
[58:39] will managed to actually talk to Foxbat pilots, so you have that. If
[58:44] our listeners google Shivaru and Foxbat, they'll find that famous two thousand and six.
[58:49] I look like a school boy in these pictures, but they're all there,
[58:52] and I think the bar Structure website has a full reproduction of those photos
[58:55] we took over there, so that's incredible. Yeah, but you know,
[58:58] I think what makes me want believe the Islambert story also is the fact that
[59:04] what that plane must have been doing is not something India isn't doing right now
[59:07] as well. And one of the reasons the fox Bats were retired is that
[59:12] you have more capable satellites right that are able to do that without satellites that
[59:15] made the fox pat so you don't have to risk your human pilots flying over
[59:21] any enemy countries or hostile countries and you know, is their lives. But
[59:23] yeah, fun, fun tidbit. Uh, that's it. Then I think
[59:28] we will ended on that note once again, Shift Great Insights, thanks a
[59:30] lot for making time and giving us a beautiful insight into the amcar program,
[59:36] which we hope to see in the next take it and a half and the
[59:40] m I r V tech that was tested by by the Indian military this this
[59:45] week and as always special thanks to our producer. And that's it for this
[59:50] week's defense doors for more tune in next week. Will then, stay safe
[59:52] and do not cross any boundaries to the passport

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
