# Army’s Uniform Uniforms for Senior Officers: What’s Behind The Move? | In Our Defence, Ep 59

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 18 May 2023, 45 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/53918478/18_may_23_iod_may_18_128.mp3

The Indian Army has made a significant decision to introduce a standardized uniform for Brigadier and above rank officers, regardless of their parent cadre or appointment. This change comes after extensive deliberations during the Army Commanders' Conference. Different uniforms and accoutrements in the Indian Army have traditionally represented specific arms, regiments, and services, fostering a sense of identity and camaraderie. But, what change will this decision bring? Is this move towards a common uniform aims to promote unity and uniformity as officers progress beyond their regimental roles, eliminating visible affiliations. The decision's implications, timing, and the desire to shed colonial influences are discussed in the "Def-Savvy" podcast featuring Abhishek Bhalla and host Dev Goswami. Tune in for the full conversation.

## Transcript

[0:01] This is in the Today podcasts. There are boundary disputes and then there are
[0:07] outright wars, hot and cold, diplomatic and military. In this podcast,
[0:13] we will dissect all that's brutal and subtle about the defense of our nations.
[0:18] I am Dave Goswami, your host, and I will be joined by a
[0:22] Bishik Baala who's been on the front lines of wars and conflicts and has seen
[0:26] the Indian military up close. Hello, and welcome to episode of Our Defense.
[0:38] How are you doing all well? Very busy week for you, one,
[0:42] extremely tied up, a lot of drama even after a clear election for
[0:46] the Congress in Karnataka. But the internal theatrics have taken over taken. Let's
[0:52] see how how long it lasts. It's a busy weekend for the two of
[0:56] us. The results came out on Saturday and since then it's been quite busy.
[1:00] You're working on Saturday, Yeah, I was working on me too.
[1:03] Sunday was also sort of a busy day. Yeah, not as much small
[1:07] break between between, but still yeah, quite busy otherwise. Um, so
[1:12] have you been otherwise? I mean, why have you been? Try?
[1:14] Because I mean I think this is just consumed that I think my entire day.
[1:18] So it's yeah, most of your thinking and planning has just been around
[1:22] this. Yeah, so if we do a bad job on in our defense
[1:25] this time, we should be excused. We should be excused. Yeah,
[1:29] but you can, you know, let us know regardless, you can do
[1:32] our listeners, because both of us have other responsibilities. So I am not
[1:37] in the mind frame, uh to think defense right now. That's the problem.
[1:42] Yeah, I can understand. I can totally understand because I think I'm
[1:45] in the same space so much happening. It's kind of tough to suddenly talk
[1:51] and think about something that's just like that seems very not happening this week,
[1:55] because I think even used by it's been quite trying. Is happening, have
[1:57] militaries there, But we did, We did Pakistan, and I think now
[2:01] it's just like, you know, more of our daily develop and like some
[2:05] code development here, and there's nothing much happening, nothing fast pace. Basically,
[2:07] I think the timing was a Pakistan, yeah timing the last episode.
[2:12] Yeah, speaking of which, the last episode, you know, I got
[2:14] a comment from one of our of our I think listeners who said that sometimes
[2:17] they find it a bit difficult to find findal latest episodes, so you know
[2:23] to to everyone if that's the case. There's a specific place on our YouTube
[2:28] channel where we have our episodes listed. You can go to the end of
[2:30] the Day's YouTube channel and click on the podcast tap where you'll find in our
[2:36] defensive episodes whenever they're out, which is all the video all the videos.
[2:40] Yeah yeah, on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Google podcast there, so videos
[2:45] would be fewer because because we began ten no, I've not drone, not
[2:51] ten more than ten. Yeah, and you know other platforms. If you
[2:54] listening to another platforms, Apple podcast Spotify, Google podcasts, just drop whatever
[2:59] eating you think is. Whatever you think of us basically, and if you'd
[3:01] like to know, reach out to us and let us know in writing what
[3:05] you think of our episodes. To let us not at pods at the retaen
[3:08] day dot com, let's bods at the day dot com. Right, So,
[3:13] ibs. This week, we'll discuss something that we talked about last time.
[3:16] Actually before we discussed Pakistan. We didn't speak about it on air,
[3:21] but we spoke about it personally when we were just trying to figure out what
[3:23] to talk about. It's a piece of development that I don't think it got
[3:29] much traction in mainstream news. I mean, they were both about it,
[3:32] but it was mostly followed up and followed by people who really follow defense,
[3:37] which I'm guessing is a large chunk of our viewership and listenership and a subsection
[3:44] of people who are really passionate about this one aspect of the military, which
[3:47] is uniforms. I don't know if you've done this, but if you go
[3:51] online, you'll actually find forums online where you have people discussing just everything to
[3:58] do with military uniforms, whether it's Indian or any other military in the world.
[4:01] They'll sit in dissect and you know, have histories about it. Because
[4:05] I'm guessing this is a very integral part. I'm not saying not integral in
[4:10] the sense in the military sense, but integral in terms of tradition to almost
[4:14] any military in the world. What's your favorite uniform with service service? I
[4:20] go with the armored one. Actually, if I'm not wrong, they're the
[4:24] ones who wear black, right, yeah, Yeah, that's the Berey Yeah.
[4:27] But even the uniform which which the I mean amongst the services. So
[4:30] that brings the question that you know what uniform because there's so many uniforms actually
[4:34] the basic everyday uniform or the camouflage. Let's if I were to go with
[4:40] the everyday uniform, I go with maybe. I think so sweite stands out,
[4:46] Yeah, smartest king, I think, Yeah, the cameo I like
[4:48] the new Indian Army camouflage. Yeah, I forgot what it called the digital
[4:53] print. Yeah, how is it decided? By the way? Is it
[4:56] based on the various terrains then the Army operates and the logest the camera large
[5:00] is common across the three services. I mean every service has their own,
[5:08] but yeah, I mean it's it's the name suggests that you know, camouflage
[5:11] is supposed to be a camouflage. So the new Indian Army uniform, which
[5:15] is a cameo camp which is the digital that you mentioned, is a little
[5:19] different from the one that has been worn up till now. And not everybody's
[5:26] got it. You still see it's some people wearing the older ones. Senior
[5:31] officers have got it, but it's not been done all through. So I
[5:34] think in sometimes you'll have the common uniform cameo flage or the fatigues as they're
[5:41] called, being worn by the way the army wears them. Every Friday,
[5:45] so that's there. Yeah, I've heard about this, yea, even when
[5:46] they're you know, at their headquarters. Yes, yes, yes, yes,
[5:49] Friday is the deadly headquarters, by the way you'd find them. So
[5:55] the Senior conclave when Army Chief came for contlay was a guest. He was
[6:00] one of the speakers, gentleman. Which one day, So it was a
[6:03] Friday, if I'm not mistake, yea Friday. Yes, yes, that's
[6:08] right. So it was a Friday. So he was wearing a camera because
[6:11] it was a Friday, and some people asked him that we usually associate this
[6:16] uniform with Batley. Are you going to Friday. He also told that you
[6:21] know, this is a Friday reform, that we were even at the headquarters,
[6:27] not just him, others who are who accompanying him also wearing Yeah,
[6:30] I remember the photos the photo actually from the from the event. Yes,
[6:34] when uniforms have a lot of you know, tidbits associated with them. I
[6:38] remember why when I was you know, when I wanted to join the NBA
[6:41] and I was preparing for my SSB, so I kind of just was researching
[6:46] just basically for a personal knowledge. So even within the NBA, which is
[6:49] the National Defense Academy for people fresh out of schools, which is college for
[6:55] essentially military training. Even there you have various uniform Oh yeah, the morning
[7:00] pete uniform and then you are breakfast uniform. And the voting school that I
[7:04] went to had different uniforms for different times of the day, different events.
[7:12] There was a ceremonial kind of uniform that that you wore for special events,
[7:16] and one was the everyday uniform. So yeah, I think the training did
[7:20] start from these kind of schools that have sent a lot of people to the
[7:25] armed forces. Yeah, right, so you don't talk about just uniforms,
[7:29] by the way, generally. But you know, now that you ask me
[7:30] that question, this question, I you know, also ask it to our
[7:33] listeners and us, you know, do let us know, Yeah, they
[7:35] should let us what your favorite inniforms are between the services, mine is and
[7:43] the ceremonial ones are even more fascinating. Yes, actually, and again,
[7:46] the Navy has most The number of uniforms that the Navy has is crazy.
[7:50] Okay, they have the most number of uniforms for every different thing, and
[7:57] yeah, and I think they're the most interesting. Yeah, So yeah,
[8:00] do let us know what your favorite uniforms are from the services. You can
[8:03] drop a text to us at eight five double nine double six double nine six,
[8:07] or an email to us at parts at the rat in da dot com.
[8:09] Let's pod has at the Radi dot com. Right. So, what
[8:13] I wanted to talk to you about was something that was last week in all
[8:16] the websites and all the publications is that officers in the in An Army who
[8:20] are brigadiers and above will now be wearing a common uniform. When we say
[8:26] common, what we mean is they will not be having and you can explain
[8:31] more, but what the what I understood is that they won't be having any
[8:33] visible uh let's say, patches or signs on the uniforms that signify that they
[8:39] are from this particular regiment. I think the most like to given example,
[8:43] I think the image that I can think of is the late General Bipin Rabba
[8:46] and I remember him having Siem scouts written on his on his on his shoulder
[8:50] patch because he was from that regiment. Now he was actually a Gurkha sorry
[8:54] okay, officer and Sikkim scouts. He was also the colonel maybe that's why.
[9:05] So yeah, he had sims, but he was a Gorka rifles of
[9:07] an infantry regiment. Right, so yeah again, but the example is the
[9:11] right one because I think the most striking difference is that hat hat which Gorka's
[9:18] where also the K regiment, I think even the ard all has a similar
[9:24] hat. So yeah, the Gorka rifles is always associated with that kind of
[9:30] hat, which is yeah, because even as the chief, it shoot out
[9:33] exactly. That's what That's why his name comes to mind because in my recent
[9:37] memory of all the army chiefs I've seen, he's the one that standard because
[9:39] of the hat. Everyone else it's a minor differences, like the shoulder patch
[9:43] made. The writing might be different because the lanyards. The lanyards is another
[9:46] thing. Yeah, but these are not very I don't know if people who
[9:50] don't follow military no what lanyards would be. And of course they can go
[9:54] and check them, sort of like groups that are thread gord around the shoulder
[9:58] golden usually if I'm not not different colors, that's I mean, every regiment
[10:03] has a different color. Oh okay, so yeah, but the hat is
[10:05] the most striking part. So that's the reason I remember when we talk about
[10:09] this aspect of what was deported last week. So for example, the sick
[10:15] or the sick light has a sick light infantry or the sick regiment as a
[10:18] saffron kind of kind of a lanyard that stands out again, Okay, olive
[10:24] wearing saff so it just stands out here. So first explain what's happened.
[10:30] Yeah, so as you right least said brigadier and above common uniforms, I
[10:35] think a big change. The reason is that once you've moved out of your
[10:43] regimental rule and you've become a brigadier, there should be no visible affiliations to
[10:50] your regiment because then you are in different rules, different staff rules, basically
[10:56] leadership rules outside your regiment as well. So ideas that have more uniformity towards
[11:03] a common army rather than see a lot of infantry regiments have this thing about
[11:07] Paulton. Yes, which is very important at the Paulton level, But there
[11:11] has to be a time where senior officers, maybe it's easier said than done
[11:18] for somebody who's not been there. Yeah, but rightful thinking, if I
[11:24] can take the sort of leeway to use the term rightful, would be not
[11:31] to get tangled in regional affiliations because that sometimes creates hurdles, and that's been
[11:39] one of the most debated aspects of the Indian Army. And this is mostly
[11:45] for infantry regiments because they are the ones who some have a cast component,
[11:50] some have a religious component which stands out, so their culture is different.
[11:56] So while you can maintain, you can go go for your regiment mental events,
[12:01] dinners, etc. But in your every day functioning, it shouldn't be
[12:07] visible. You should be just the Indian Army. And they're very interesting things
[12:11] that stand out, as you said, the hat, the berets that they
[12:16] were. Of course the black one by the one by the armored core again
[12:20] stands out because it's black as opposed to what the uniform is. The maroon
[12:24] beret is obviously is the funkiest thing that comes across, you know, the
[12:31] special and the Para regiments, special forces of the Parta regiments. So they'll
[12:35] have to do a way with it. If you become a brigadier, leave
[12:39] it for the colonels. And I was reading in fact this, I didn't
[12:43] know this thing until a few days back when I was just reading about the
[12:46] subject. That back in the eighties until the late eighties, a similar pattern
[12:52] was followed, but somewhere in the mid eighties, these things you know,
[12:56] continued. They went back to this practice of senior officers all wearing the same
[13:01] uniforms. See right now, the regimental service of an officer actually ends when
[13:09] he's when he or she is a colonel, and as a colonel you command.
[13:15] So actually, come to think of it, after you've commanded, after
[13:18] you've been a CEO of your pulton, you move out of regimental service.
[13:26] The next posting would be outside of your regiment could be also of regiment.
[13:31] So if you ask me, it should have been for colonels till the time
[13:33] they are CEO's in the same regiment. Once they've moved out of being a
[13:37] CEO, then they should actually shed their regimental affiliations. But anyway, I
[13:46] think it's a good thing that's been done. And I'll tell you something that
[13:48] you might not know. In fact, many defense correspondents didn't know. I
[13:52] was somehow aware because I noticed these things a lot. You do you know
[13:54] that even shoes can differ. No, I did not. It's very so
[14:00] I didn't realize that something as basic as shoes also will have to change.
[14:05] So some of the armored units armored Core units actually wear brown shoes, okay,
[14:11] not black. So I knew this. I knew this, but I
[14:15] did not fathom think that even the shoes aspect will change. So it was
[14:22] brought to my notice that even the shoes will have to change, So no
[14:24] more brown. Those who wear brown armored guys are a little weird. Yeah,
[14:28] I mean, they're a little different. So this brown shoes, I
[14:31] think is about being different. Also, they are allowed to keep long hair
[14:37] in some of the regiments. They allowed to keep not a pony tail.
[14:41] Now we're not saying that they'll go head banging with their long hair or something,
[14:45] but slightly, which is different from the norm. Okay, so they
[14:50] are they consider themselves slightly. I didn't I know the armored being a bit
[14:54] you know, the armored Core being a bit different, because I remember seeing
[14:58] some I forgot which I just I think when the Army chief was visiting some
[15:03] base somewhere and I saw some officer in black, and that was like what
[15:07] And then I, you know, researched a bit and a part of the
[15:09] logic goes that because they work with tanks and all, they have you know,
[15:11] oil all around them. So that's that's the basically, like you know,
[15:15] keep the uniform like those for the packages, not to show. Basically,
[15:18] that's the sort of the logics. So that's all. That's all I
[15:20] knew. I didn't know the shoes of a difference, but not all of
[15:22] them, not all armored regiments, some of them, Okay, okay.
[15:24] That also even within that there is a sort of a classification. Then of
[15:30] course something like ranks lanyard. We've already discussed ranks are different color. Of
[15:37] all the rifle regiments in the infantry which have rifles in front of them have
[15:43] black rifles, raja if anything that has rifles, all rifle regiments. Uh,
[15:52] So that that will change, they'll have common ranks again. And an
[15:56] interesting thing is that you know why this has happened has happened. Also,
[16:00] timing is important for these things. You have an engineer officer who's the army
[16:04] chief, so he doesn't have these affiliations. These decisions are easier when somebody
[16:11] right at the top is sort of above these things. So a classic infantry
[16:17] officer, if he were at the helm, would not have I'm not sure
[16:21] if this, if this decision would have been taken. Yeah, I mean
[16:25] they probably have seen the logic behind it, but it probably wouldn't have been
[16:27] taken because it's just the traditions. Because this is my personal reading into it,
[16:34] I'm allowed this this much of this thing, you know, understanding the
[16:38] army a bit so, I think because this is something which has been debated
[16:42] for long, it's not something new. Now the next step the biggest challenges.
[16:47] Will the Indian Army ever have a common uniform? See why did this
[16:51] stop at Colonel's Because somewhere there's a ceiling that you know, yes, when
[16:56] you're with your troops, you should look the same mission at the same uniform.
[16:59] I think that aspect has come in that all the other thing is that
[17:03] you just swear one uniform like some other countries do. I don't think,
[17:10] I mean you can differentiate the US. I think, of course the officer
[17:12] and the ranks that some differences, minor differences would be there. But really
[17:18] even caps and berries, they probably won't laniards. I don't even know if
[17:22] they were lanyards. Maybe in the ceremonial perhaps uniforms they would have, but
[17:26] working uniform I doubt that they have lanyards. So was this long time coming?
[17:32] You said this was discussed for over the said buckles again, belt buckles,
[17:36] another one, belt buckles a different Yeah, so now it'll just have
[17:40] an Indian arm insignia for brigadiers animals. But was this a long time coming?
[17:45] You said this? This hat has been discussed for, it has been
[17:48] discussed. It's it's part of the discourse. In fact, changing the uniform
[17:52] is part of the discourse, okay, completely in common uniform. So I
[17:56] think it's it's a beginning if we have more chief from non infantry kind of
[18:03] affiliations, and who knows that might change as well. Is there a controversial
[18:10] statement, by the way, Why is it controversial? I don't think so.
[18:14] I don't think it's controversial a right, so tell me. And this
[18:18] is something that I even thought of back then when we spoke about the regiment
[18:25] system of the Army in context of the scheme which proposes not proposal, not
[18:30] exactly proposes, but which kind of sets up an all India also is sort
[18:36] of a sort of a class system within the army, and we discuss the
[18:41] aspects that are not very that are not easy to see at first first instance.
[18:45] So something like this, something like changing the uniforms of officers who are
[18:49] brigadiers and above. Is it just a cosmetic change or is it does it
[18:53] actually have something have a different think to it's a precursor to something else.
[19:00] But when I mean coot, cosmetic changing doesn't really also address a problem that
[19:03] is present right now? Or is it just, like you said, a
[19:06] step towards a larger Uh see, now you've asked a very controversial question and
[19:11] you're couching it as something which is not controversial. So if you want to
[19:17] be clear, you I allow you to be clear, or if you want
[19:21] me to bite the bullet, I will do it. So you're trying to
[19:25] say that regimental affiliations come in the way, Yes, let's let's okay,
[19:30] let's do it that way. I was I'm not trying to do that better
[19:33] than trying to couch it. But yeah, I was basically asking that kid,
[19:37] regimental affiliations just because a partuliar officer has been from a particlar regiment,
[19:41] that officer rise up to the through the ranks, and now he controls not
[19:45] he controls and he oversees the functionings of various units and regiments. It can
[19:51] happen, does it? It can happen. Not saying that it's the norm.
[19:56] It could be the exception. It's been prevalent. People from non infantry
[20:03] kind of affiliations have raised this concern. I wouldn't say have complaint, but
[20:07] have raised their concern that you know, at times it comes in the way
[20:11] of some important decision making. What these decision makings could be is difficult to
[20:18] say. One would't want to conjecture on those aspects. But yes, if
[20:23] if this is a precursor to sort of move away from such kind of affiliations
[20:30] that are far too deep rooted, then of course it will have a big
[20:34] implication. And again you know it's in sync with what the Agnevi scheme is.
[20:40] Yes, I can. I actually noticed the I didn't notice person,
[20:44] but I was. I was going to ask you about this, that this
[20:45] is part of the larger thing, right, because the moment you discussed this
[20:51] last week with me, you mentioned I wasn't aware when you told me about
[20:55] this. I think that that is when the news was just kind of coming
[20:56] even into all our systems, so I hadn't seen it. But the moment
[21:00] you said it, my first thing was this is somehow linked to the scheme.
[21:04] I think I don't. Yeah, But then the next the problem with
[21:07] this is that if we sort of simplify it, then the counter debate would
[21:12] be if this will link to the scheme, then they will have change uniforms
[21:17] of the entire in uamy Baby steps. Yeah, so it's it's I don't
[21:22] think I think nobody wants to sort of take bigger radical decisions. Of course,
[21:27] or maybe it was what it was. So you don't want a double
[21:30] engine to strike them? An engine everywhere, so you don't know, I
[21:37] want a double engine to strike them. Yeah. So yes, yes,
[21:40] has been big, big change, easily the biggest reform. We're not getting
[21:44] into whether it's right or wrong. We've discussed this before. We'll have the
[21:48] link that those things can be there, but you know, drawing from that,
[21:51] you know, this is something we discussed even then. The army as
[21:53] an institution is so big that it's prone to inertia and it's resistant to change.
[22:00] Perhaps maybe you know what you're saying, Baby Steps was resistant to change,
[22:03] and yeah, and that's why it's taken a while. Because I'm pretty
[22:07] sure that this particular move of doing away with the regimental uniforms for a particular
[22:12] rank and above. There will be a section in the army serving and retired
[22:17] whould not like this. For some reason, I've not really seen people openly
[22:23] criticize it. Okay, interesting for some reason. I mean, there's no
[22:27] such noise on social media. For show on social media. Come across I
[22:32] know on social media, tell you something because actually this news development has gone
[22:37] under the radar. No one no see the veterans. It's been there in
[22:40] the veterans are quite active on social Yes, I haven't come and for them
[22:45] it doesn't matter what else is happening in the world or not. For them,
[22:48] these matters are big enough. So I haven't come across anybody sort of
[22:53] saying that personally. Also, I don't know, and I haven't been too
[23:00] old personally by any body body that you know. This is a problem because
[23:04] it's not as if you will not have your regimental identity. Of course,
[23:08] so that barry remains with you, of course, just that you're not wearing
[23:11] it, that lanyard will remain. Nobody's going to rob you of it,
[23:17] So that identity is there. It's just that it won't be visible in your
[23:21] day to day activities. And then, as I said, they get together
[23:25] as reunions of your regiments. People go there. So I don't think that
[23:30] identity is restricted just to these aspects of the uniform. I think that that
[23:37] maturity has come in probably also, I would like to believe. Yeah,
[23:44] let's take a quick break before we discuss this further. Also, I have
[23:52] been born and brought up in a metrocity, So this one time my first
[23:56] really really really horrible break up. It's like almost stand in my life.
[24:00] So that person was from a tier three sort of town, not even a
[24:04] city or a sort of like town. And because he had studied in metro
[24:07] cities, lived in metro cities, worked in metro cities, I thought that,
[24:11] you know, I obviously one when one is educated, you tend to
[24:15] think that they've overcome wherever they come from or whatever. So we were really
[24:18] happy, were planning on getting married, spending the rest of our lives together,
[24:22] parents met and everything. So it was very very serious and long term
[24:25] as well. And it didn't end well. It was horrendous, and within
[24:27] three months of that he ended up getting married to someone his parents fun for
[24:30] him, okay, And the biggest issues his parents had with him with me
[24:34] was what I was wearing the way I spoke wow, things like that because
[24:38] of where they came from. It was very like but honestly, I mean
[24:42] you escaped you, Yeah, you got really rescued. Yeah, but so
[24:47] scarred from that that I'm probably like scarred for life. Also, I've noticed
[24:52] it's not just like a small town thing. I've faced the same thing here
[24:55] as well. Yeah, I've heard utter English ungrat is BOLDI a car accenter,
[25:00] but back then, being in a place like Bangalore, I could not
[25:03] understand that mentality. But that hurt me so much that I vowed to never
[25:07] ever date someone who was from like a not a metrocity. For more insights
[25:14] into the A to Z of the dating world, tune into The Rights Wife
[25:17] every Friday. Catch us on Spotify, Apple podcasts, Google podcasts, and
[25:21] other audio streaming platforms. Welcome back, discussing a decision that was made public
[25:38] last peak. Officers of the Indian Army who are of the ranks of Brigadier
[25:42] and above will now be wearing a common uniform. Up until now, I
[25:47] think the basics were common. I mean it was most or lesser an olive
[25:51] uniform, but there were some parts of the uniform that you could that differentiated
[25:56] them from the others. The hats, for example, shoulder patches, which
[26:02] were from the regiment they were inducted into the army when they when they were
[26:06] commissioned into the army. Uh, you've we've we've talked about regiments before.
[26:11] We've talked we like we discussed before the break. We'll have links to the
[26:14] those episodes in our show description. We've talked about this at length when the
[26:18] un scheme was introduced, um and we spoke about how regiments are like just
[26:25] like a large family, and which is why that identity is very, very
[26:27] crucial. But then Agni came in. We had a good enough discussion about
[26:33] that when it did, I think we had more than one, more than
[26:36] one more than episode discussed several several aspects of it. And now this and
[26:40] this again is what you you've said before the break kind of link to that,
[26:45] if not exactly, and you've indicated not as though you know, but
[26:48] you made yeah, but you made a guess that more is coming. We
[26:52] don't know that for a fact. It can happen ten ten years down the
[26:55] yeah, of course us, but it does because this aspect of the army
[27:00] wearing a common uniform is there in the discussion. Yes, it's not something
[27:04] which is sprung up of course just after this. Yeah, So how do
[27:10] you see if you if you kind of take a step back and look at
[27:11] the world picture you had just talking about regiments by the right, I'm not
[27:15] talking about what was talked like so AGNI by like you know we discussed back
[27:19] then, had many aspects to it, the whole financial aspect, paying salaries,
[27:22] being a pension. I'm only talking about the regimental aspect of the army,
[27:27] which you've said this previously as well that you know, a lot of
[27:32] people within the army don't get People who are not from the infantry. Infantry
[27:37] is where the regiments, uh mostly are, do not really get this system.
[27:41] So if you were to take a step back, look at the navy
[27:45] scheme as much as it relates to the regimental aspect of the Indian Army.
[27:49] Now look at this move to make to have a common uniform for officers who
[27:53] are not on a day to day basis looking at one particular regiment. They're
[27:56] looking at much more than that. How do you see the larger picture of
[28:02] what's the thought process about the regimental system in the army? Right, now
[28:07] see, I think this decision is a progressive step. First of all,
[28:08] this I don't mean, frankly, while while I have written about it,
[28:15] that regimental system is very important to the army. But tweaking it is the
[28:22] month and how you can have the correct tweaks to sort of make sure that
[28:27] you have the right balance shouldn't be overpowering. It should not overpower the larger
[28:33] functioning and the identity of the army. Also because see you have to understand
[28:40] that again we come from the British Army. Yes, infantry was your most
[28:45] important sort of holding onto ground, most important aspect of warfare. It still
[28:52] is. When you need to control territory, you need infantry personnel to be
[28:56] there. Having said that, the other arms play a much more important role,
[29:03] probably than what they did before. And that role now is I'm again
[29:10] I'm not talking about the traditional armored coat, tanks, artlery, guns,
[29:15] UAV's. Army aviation is you know, expanding in a big way. The
[29:21] army wants their own resources for aviation, their own drones, their own helicopters
[29:26] they already have. I mean, then there might be a day when they
[29:30] say we want our own fighter aircraft you never know, So it's expanding in
[29:36] a big way. And no, seriously on that that was just a joke.
[29:38] No, I got your point. Even logistics we saw China China crisis
[29:42] logistics off, you know, transporting so many troops and bronze. I have
[29:45] seen, especially on the closer to the LAC, the kind of aviation assets
[29:52] that are being used for surveillance and how the aviation is expanding. The Army
[29:57] arm has three brigades just of the Army aviation, which is a big thing.
[30:03] By the way, I mean aviation again, were's Gray Bey, So
[30:07] that's another one that stands out. So with the changing nature of warfare,
[30:14] I think there is a neat felt that there should be more in common rather
[30:19] than what's different, so that that understanding is somewhere there there, and that's
[30:25] why these changes are being made. Also, we talk and hear a lot
[30:29] about shedding the colonial legacies, so this is also in a way the colonial
[30:33] legacies in the British Indian Army war different kinds of uniforms probably and that changed
[30:42] with independence. The British Indian soldiers of the Indian Army or of the British
[30:48] Indian Army, the soldiers would wear khaki uniforms post independence changed to all of
[30:55] because the Pakistan is also work maintain the difference between the first change was done
[31:00] there and then probably the British military has moved on from these kind of uniforms.
[31:06] I'm sure they have a lot of ceremonial uniforms which are meant for different
[31:08] occasions, but I think the basic uniform might not be so much regimental oriented.
[31:15] Right, So yeah, I mean this is one colonial legacy which there
[31:19] is no harm in shedding and moving on. But just you know, because
[31:23] you mentioned aviation RB aviation rule that just like randomly the thought came to our
[31:29] mind. And again we'll be on a different tangel to get that. But
[31:32] that's what happens, you know when we discuss this. Whatever happened to the
[31:34] idea of integrated battle groups something i'd be easy. I think that was like
[31:40] a because you said something about you know, integration. That was the idea
[31:44] of, you know, have an integrated unit that would be almost self sufficient,
[31:47] right, you won't be just because if I think we'll be able to
[31:49] still works what I can say, Yeah, there are a couple of formations
[31:56] where the IBG has been sort of put in place. Ibgs are integrated battle
[32:02] groups where you have the ideas to have several arms of the army in one
[32:09] place. See, the thing is, it's not that it's not happening.
[32:14] It still is happening, but in a maybe a fragmented way. That kind
[32:19] of formal organizational structure maybe is missing. But I know of a lot of
[32:24] formations, especially at again at the brigade level and things like that, where
[32:30] especially the sensitive areas where commanders have got sort of resources from various places.
[32:37] But yeah, it needs a formalized, more formalized structure to be called an
[32:42] IBG. You know, sort of controversial question, per se, But this
[32:47] is a theme I've been wanting to explode with you ever since we discussed the
[32:52] Navy scheme. The question might sound about brash, but you know, the
[32:58] impression that one kind of gets when they do like sort of a deep reading
[33:01] into the whole regimental system, that the different arms of the army, the
[33:07] different traditions like you know, having separate uniforms, et cetera, et cetera,
[33:09] having their whatever. It's that it's just like there's such distinct elements it
[33:15] might be difficult to kind of get them together and make them function together.
[33:20] Is that does that really happen? Or is that just reading too much into
[33:24] into into all of it. No, I mean, see the regimental system
[33:30] till the battalion level. Again, as far as the visa visa uniforms doesn't
[33:34] change yea even now. Yeah, so, I mean, if if there's
[33:37] a Commanding Officers CEO who's of the rank of colonel, he will still wear
[33:43] the same uniform. It's only when he becomes a brigadier. And this has
[33:46] also changed over the years. There was a time when lefton colonels were in
[33:52] a commanding role. Yes, I'm not colonels, so probably I think there
[33:57] are some armies by the way that end. I think I think the Parks
[34:00] Monny Army, if I'm not wrong, ends the regimental affiliations in their in
[34:05] the uniforms at the at the rank of a lefon ConL okay, So these
[34:10] these things differ. But yeah, the Indian Army has been following a system
[34:15] now where a full colonel rank officer is in a command rule so that that
[34:21] doesn't change. In fact, even later it doesn't change. It's only at
[34:24] the time of an officer becoming a brigadier when the person will have to sort
[34:30] of let go of these elements in the uniform, right. And you know,
[34:37] one last thought you mentioned that this is also one part of the colonial
[34:40] legacy that's probably been shared. There's another one that also happened very recently.
[34:45] We never got an episode on that was doing away with the Canadas contonments in
[34:51] Look and major cities of India. Again, again, something which has been
[34:54] in the pipeline under for long, for long, not suddenly something that's happened.
[35:00] And I think this is actually something that has been debated in public for
[35:01] a while because civilians are involved in this sense, you know, I think
[35:05] some civilian cities have made this demand that please you know, like have your
[35:09] base if you if you need to, but kind of gave us our space
[35:12] as well. So that was it. So let me ask I'll take that'll
[35:16] take some time because it's a physical logistics, logistics physical to be of course
[35:23] put in one place. Who will take water supply for example, in this
[35:27] feat will take to take especially in the bigger contonments of course, telecontonment when
[35:32] it's not easy too, of course, it's a huge contonment see delicate cants
[35:37] again, it's not as if it's completely cut off from civilian movement. I
[35:42] think the check identity where you're going and let you go. But as there
[35:46] are some I mean some areas of course no go zone, but there are
[35:51] some contonment towns where civilian movement is completely not possible. So that becomes a
[35:58] bit difficult. So they open areas to public and maintain the military station separately.
[36:05] That and then before that, we had the information and he had the
[36:08] news about the ranks in the Indian Navy being changed. That was only for
[36:15] one level officer anyway, not even officer equivalent of what a junior commissioned officer
[36:22] in petty officers and chief petty officers. I just like to clarify, there's
[36:29] the word petty has nothing to do with being petty, with being pet It's
[36:34] it comes from I think a French word, yeah, which means the junior
[36:37] office. Yeah, I mean you can call them junior officers. You don't
[36:42] like the don't think of it. Never thought people to actually take it that
[36:44] way, But now that you mention it, some people wouldn't, you know,
[36:46] So it has nothing to do with being petty. Somebody might say that,
[36:50] you know, just because it's a junior officer. There's so much a
[36:52] class difference. While you're calling them petty officers, it just means the junior
[36:55] officers. Yeah, like in the army, junior commissioned officers, I mean
[36:59] the junior officer. But yeah, if you just want actually it's okay if
[37:01] somebody wants to call a junior officer, so be it. But I think
[37:05] the biggest symbolic change was, of course the flag, Yes, the Navy
[37:10] flag. Yeah. Yeah, But you said you didn't really have a problem
[37:14] with I don't have a problem yeah, yeah. So question for you,
[37:17] now, what's the next piece of colonial baggage in the Indian Armed forces that
[37:23] you think is best done away with? Whatever? I mean, that's you
[37:28] know, you think is not really meant for today's day and age, like,
[37:30] oh yeah, can avoid see, I don't mind history. Part of
[37:35] this thing. I don't look at it is colonially. I think uniforms is
[37:38] one. I'm okay with the common uniform, complete common uniform for all.
[37:44] Yeah, I'm okay with it. So that's that's one pieces of history should
[37:47] be I don't I don't think they should be done away with just for the
[37:53] love of history, and the sake of nobody's saying follow what the British did.
[38:00] Of course, you don't need to sing the national anthem. You see
[38:04] it's an Indian version of the British Indian Army. Yes, Jahan is the
[38:09] salutation. There's there's no other English salutation across the forces. Now ye still
[38:15] jehin, So that means you have in denied it. See, there is
[38:19] something which people are very touchy about, and again I'm not sure if that
[38:23] should be completely erased. How do I put see there are there are references
[38:29] in regimental regimental histories about a particular regiment, regiment's action against Indians. Okay,
[38:36] so that is controversial. How do you deal with something like that for
[38:40] historiography's sake? You cannot. You can't do away. But again, nobody
[38:45] sort of I'm not. I'm one hundred percent sure that when a young officer
[38:52] goes through knowing your regiment's history and to enter the mess, they have to
[38:58] sort of give a test, right, not try to test, but orally
[39:01] they ask questions. It's part of dragging. So I don't think they asked
[39:06] questions about these aspects, even if they are. I mean, one's celebrating
[39:10] that nobody's celebrating. It's it's it's who are that's what has happened. What
[39:15] has happened has happened. Ye. So other than that, I mean,
[39:17] you tell me him and what is you would want to I can't. I
[39:22] can't answer this question because I don't know which one is actually from colonial time,
[39:25] so not a lot of them are. But I'll rephrase the question that
[39:30] the culture is colonial? Yeah, of course, So do you want to
[39:32] do over the culture culture in itself? The concept of a mess. I
[39:37] don't see the need for doing the concept of a mess. If you if
[39:40] you go to a mess, it's not it's you do realize it's not just
[39:44] a mess for eating food. Of course, all the paraphernalia that comes with
[39:47] it comes from a very British army kind of for this thing. So yeah,
[39:53] those are colonial legacies. Should you do away with them? I don't
[39:59] think the mess, but you know, I'll rephrase my question I because I
[40:02] wanted to ask to make it a bit more serious, is that are there
[40:06] any traditions? Are there any practices from British times that are still being followed
[40:10] that you think are actually coming in the way of proper functioning of I don't
[40:14] know if you are there hurdles in your exact operational capability, right, I
[40:17] don't think so. I mean we are a professional military. We will not
[40:22] allow us See the biggest colonial legacy I think is the regimental affiliations. Now,
[40:34] how far do you want to go on with them? Keeping in mind
[40:38] a modern armies requirements. I think that should be the big question that should
[40:45] be discussed debated every two years, three years, five years. I have
[40:50] a theory there, I think it, and you'd agree with that. This
[40:53] has been discussed. This is part of a ongoing debate. I think the
[40:58] answer to that actually is this is not something you can do it in one
[41:00] go, yes, because it is so ingrained, like for example, Karl
[41:04] jack Up, the system is done away with. What happens to the years
[41:08] of training that the current soldiers have had. They you want to make them
[41:14] forget that, right, So probably you'll have to if, for example,
[41:17] the thought processes that you want to do away with it, you'll have to
[41:20] gradually induct newer soldiers, not make them undergo the old training and let the
[41:25] older ones sort of you know that training is the same, isn't the the
[41:30] that that mental the psychological training of the regimental system. The thing is that
[41:36] some of the practical reasonings that are given that a lot of recruitment happens from
[41:39] some region, from some regions, and this is not micro level. Even
[41:44] in my village, yes, your even if there's a neighbor, they say,
[41:52] so, it's very common for people to have these bonds within their pultns.
[41:57] So you know that this guy is there, I will also go there.
[42:00] There's there is that affiliation of your of your background or the region that
[42:07] you come from. Like there are three separate regiments that cater to six,
[42:13] all infantry regions and not on about regiments paultons in other arms which have a
[42:19] sick sort of component. Just infantry regiments. There's a sick light infantry.
[42:24] There's a sick regiment and the Punjab three regiments. Just imagine the in flu
[42:30] of course of people from there that they're all full of six. It's not
[42:37] as if the people from Punjab. So that means that people are coming.
[42:40] So that that is the delema. You know, how how do you deal
[42:43] with it? So I think if you want will have to happen again again?
[42:49] Has there come? Yes? And the intake even in other regiments from
[42:55] Utra Khan. You you will come across guys from Utra Khan who are in
[43:00] other regiments against you can imagine the intake just from that one state. So
[43:06] that these are some of the things that that are very difficult to sort of
[43:10] iron out and answer these questions. Yeah, interesting chat, good thing.
[43:15] We talked about this because I kind of knew, but we didn't discuss this,
[43:21] you know, for our listeners and viewers. I had no idea what
[43:23] I want to talk about when he mentioned this topic. Because this week was
[43:28] quite busy, we didn't get a chance to like share our thoughts. So
[43:30] I just did some of my own research thanks to our produce Ana and came.
[43:34] But I had a feeling that somehow we'll end up on this trajectory because,
[43:37] like I said, when I read this the first time, a gut
[43:40] feeling key. This is not just about just uniform g This has got some
[43:45] of you do with the larger happenings on that are that are going. In
[43:49] the beginning, I told you why it's it was possible, it was it
[43:52] was made a little easier. The decision was yes, yes, because person
[43:58] right at the top, it does it does make a difference. They did
[44:00] not think of that at all, by the way, but yeah, that's
[44:02] a good, good insight. Good that you've got got that. I think
[44:07] nice touch it gave to this conversation. So thanks once again for a great
[44:10] conversation. Once again, be good. Thanks to your insights from your years
[44:15] of covering the military. Thanks again for a lovely conversation, and thanks to
[44:20] our listeners and to our viewers to join us next week. Thanks also to
[44:24] a producer and appear Dene and a sound maased a couple of lives. Thanks
[44:29] to somebody who's been helping us, you know, with these pot with this
[44:31] podcast videos know what to call it now? Ever since these we went on
[44:36] camera Shaky Lamar, who've been coordinating our shoots every week. Thank you all.
[44:40] That's it for this week's defense. Does for more Union next week.
[44:44] They'll then stay safe and not cross any boundary passport but by

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
