# Rafale Boost For the Indian Navy? | In Our Defence, Ep 67

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 13 Jul 2023, 40 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/56090098/13_jul_23_iod_ep_67_mix_13_july_128.mp3

The Indian Defense Ministry has recently approved plans to procure 26 Rafale fighter aircraft and three Scorpene class conventional submarines for the Indian Navy from France. In this episode, host Dev Goswami and "Def Savvy" Abhishek Bhalla delve into the significance of this deal and its implications for the concerned countries. “India's defense acquisitions are entering an exciting phase, particularly after the recent predator drones deal with the US. Now, India is eagerly looking forward to finalizing a deal with France,” Abhishek says. Of particular interest is the inclusion of 3-4 Rafale jets in the Bastille Day parade. These Indian Rafale jets have arrived in France, where they will participate in the Bastille Day flypast over the iconic Champs Elysees in Paris. Prime Minister Narendra Modi is expected to be the guest of honor at this event. The hosts also explore the concept of a government-to-government deal and highlight its distinctive features compared to conventional deals. They shed light on the pressing need for new fighter jets for the Indian Air Force, emphasizing the current shortage in the fleet. They also touch upon the reasons behind the urgency for acquiring new fighter jets for the Indian Navy. The hosts examine the challenges involved in developing fighter jets for naval purposes, considering their unique requirements. Listen in! Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound mix by Kapil Dev Singh

## Transcript

[0:01] This is India Today podcasts. There are boundary disputes and then there are outright
[0:08] wars, hot and cold, diplomatic and military. In this podcast, we
[0:14] will dissect all that's brutal and subtle about the defense of our nations. I
[0:19] am Dave Goswami, your host, and I will be joined by a Bishikbala,
[0:22] who's been on the front lines of wars and conflicts and has seen the
[0:26] Indian military up close. Hello, and welcome to the sixty seventh episode of
[0:36] In Our Defense. You are doing well. How's your workpeek been like mix?
[0:43] Actually, certain days are very disease. Others are like okash nothing no,
[0:49] no, no, no, no. News story that's really been keeping
[0:51] us very very caught up. But monsoon actually in North India, large parts
[0:57] of North India wrecking havoc. That's one thing that's a heavy rate. Yes,
[1:03] very it isn't the scary visuals coming in several parts of Yeah, yeah,
[1:08] yeah, So that's that. That's pretty my date tech team. What
[1:11] about you, I'm saying, yeah, I'm just going through the grind.
[1:15] Cool. Uh. This week we'll talk about one of my favorite aspects of
[1:19] military naval aviation. I think we've We've said this before. I've at least
[1:25] said this before about my fascination with naval aviation, and I think part of
[1:30] it, honestly has to do with the tom Cruise top gun is immensely popular.
[1:34] I think even with your generation as with mine, that's one of the
[1:40] reasons. But apart from that, like i've you know, previously said,
[1:42] we've always seen aircraft carriers as these behemith. The term that's often used in
[1:47] media is city in the sea, floating city everything. Yeah, just sure
[1:52] size. And you've been on a couple of them. I'm missing at least
[1:56] one Indians I've been missing. You've been on all the one that we have
[2:00] right now. I've not been on Kan's okay. And I've been on a
[2:04] French aircraft carrier, yes, very decently, very recently. Yeah, And
[2:08] we had spoken about this what we are about to discuss today as well back
[2:14] then when you were on the French aircraft carrier, and it had some to
[2:17] do with what we want to discuss. Another landmark defense deal that's about to
[2:23] be signed. First, first re joinder, Yes, there's nothing official there
[2:30] that an announcement is likely to be made. We made about finally, India
[2:36] going in for naval variant of Fighter Jet Aviation's fighter jets, despite all the
[2:45] controversy regarding the earlier procurement for the Indian Air Force where thirty six were bought
[2:52] and there was a bit of a political hangmayeh over. It also a very
[2:57] strong messaging by the government business and it's it's the the format is going to
[3:00] be similar if it happens, it's a government to government deal. But yeah,
[3:05] so we've given the disiny joinder first that we are expecting this to be
[3:10] announced because a lot of people have already started asking me questions even in the
[3:15] newsroom. So what is the cost price going to be and things like that
[3:20] comparison with the previous purchase that we did for the air force. So first
[3:27] things first, you know the deal hasn't happened. Yes, you will only
[3:30] know the cost when there's a contract. Even if it's announced. It's not
[3:36] necessary that the deal will take place immediately, so that's when the negotiations will
[3:42] start, etc. Something very similar to the Predator drone deal that we discussed
[3:47] I think last week or before, so a similar kind of a situation.
[3:52] So I think we should just hold on to you know, to get more
[3:57] information, and the information will only come when there is a deal. Right
[4:01] now, what we're expecting is, for all you know, this is announced
[4:06] by the time we put up we publish our podcast, for all you know,
[4:12] the judgment is made. So yeah, at the most an announcement will
[4:16] be made. We still might not know the nitty grities of cost and India
[4:20] specific enhancements things like that. But yeah, interesting that this was long awaited
[4:28] super hornet or a fall m enough indications now that the government is going with
[4:34] the saw and not just this. There are some other deals that are likely
[4:41] to go through one another. One is three more scorpion class summary with the
[4:47] MDL Musgow doclment. So six have already been manufactured, so it'd be interesting
[4:55] that if India goes for three more and in this partnership with France and MDL
[5:01] gets gets the contract for that as well. And of course another another big
[5:06] deal which is being talked about again no announcements yet is the Suffran engine.
[5:11] So you've had a joint venture already discussed as far as g engine is concerned
[5:17] from the US from the US and now the Saffran Let's see whether whether it's
[5:21] a joint venture tot transfer of technology. Yeah, I mean exciting days ahead
[5:27] when it comes to defense acquisitions. Yeah, exactly. And this I mean
[5:31] this is expected. All of these deals expected to be signed or some sort
[5:36] of an understanding to be reached during Primes in the road these visits to France
[5:41] later this month. So I think right now, like if we were locked
[5:45] up, the timeline this episode is as at the juncture of where we were
[5:47] before PM's visit to the US, where we had there was enough talk about
[5:53] the patrolled Engel signed, but we didn't really have to know about the specifics,
[5:57] and even after the visit, we don't know the exact you know,
[6:00] parameters of what works going just no key. How this is like a sort
[6:02] of an understanding. This is the will purchase a chase these bones for how
[6:06] much, within what capabilities. That's not something that will that will be in
[6:12] public domain once the contract is done. Yeah, so I think something similar
[6:15] probably might happen with the yes, yes, I recommend yea. But even
[6:19] that's something we don't know saying because there's no formal announcement yet. But we'll
[6:27] still talk about it because it's other than the acquisitions, uh, something that's
[6:31] got my attention, as there are three or four of us that are going
[6:36] to be part of the bastil day, Yes, yes, four, I
[6:40] think four. Yeah, there's a there's a try service contingent, yes,
[6:44] of the Indian forces. Lovely visuals of them carrying out rehearsals in Paris to
[6:51] the tune of Sara really interesting. Yeah, so yeah, I mean military
[6:57] soft power you want to call it or whatever. So yeah, I I
[7:00] really like those visuals when we saw and you know, there's a try service
[7:04] contingent there. So I think that's going to be a big highlight as well.
[7:08] Yeah, that is fALS flying over the skies of Paris. If the
[7:14] new fALS naval falles have to come try service contingent, good military diplomacy at
[7:20] display. Probably, So let's get into it with almost every defense deal,
[7:28] but that happens of late. You have like you know, words like landmark,
[7:32] major, big boost, etc. So every day deal, obviously can
[7:39] every acquisition cannot obviously be at the same level of a big boost. How
[7:45] would you rate if this deal goes through for the naval raffles? How important
[7:49] do you rate it in the current scheme of things? For you see the
[7:55] remarkable, big boost, landmark. These are just adjectives just to amplify the
[8:01] story, I think, without getting into the meritage of the usage. I
[8:05] think context is important. You you need new fight aircraft for the Navy.
[8:11] That's given the mid twenty nine case that you have our aging. You want
[8:16] to replace your fleet. With so many defense deals, things were stuck.
[8:22] You finally managed to sort of zero in on two and which is the Superhortinet
[8:28] and RAFAL, And then it seems that you have made up your mind and
[8:33] you're going ahead with the RAFAL. Whereas you know, the original demand of
[8:39] the Navy was to get almost sixty seven fifty eight fighters for the aircraft carriers,
[8:46] so that has come down to twenty six. It's come down to twenty
[8:48] six because of cost constraints. So that's why I said context is important.
[8:52] And it's quite similar to what happened with the Air Force. Your requirement was
[8:58] for hundred or one hundred plus and under and fourteen you settled for thirty six
[9:03] because something is better than nothing, and you change status school and went in
[9:09] for a government to government deal, which it seems is becoming the norm slowly.
[9:13] So these government to government deals might not be for a big, big
[9:18] acquisition in terms of numbers, So you might not have a government of government
[9:22] deal for fifty six aircraft, but for twenty six. Similarly, not one
[9:26] hundred but thirty six. So maybe you're trying to ensure that you get something
[9:31] before you change that status school, before you go on. Just like you
[9:33] know, for our listeners and viewers, just break it down, what's a
[9:37] government to government deal and how is it different from a conventional deal, like
[9:41] what's so there's no bidding to let's let's okay, break it down simply right,
[9:45] So the government is that kid, this is what you want, and
[9:46] so full governments get together and they negotiate, right, So and that those
[9:52] other questions that I asked probing questions that how come this was done? Who's
[9:58] benefiting out of this? Is there's that? But in a government to government
[10:03] who It's very difficult to sort of establish if there is a middle player at
[10:07] all unless you really catch somebody redheaded handed, isn't it. So the paperwork
[10:13] I think is difficult to establish because you're saying these are specifications, you're speaking
[10:20] to the government, and the government is facilitating the deal with the respective company.
[10:26] So that's that's the big difference. So I mean, that's that's a
[10:30] big change after the Air Force bot refuse because there was a need felt that
[10:35] you know, becoming slaves to procedure is sort of really really really creating bottlenecks.
[10:43] And even now the Air Force needs more fight aircraft. So you can
[10:48] still that by the way, that that original requirement still stands. The Air
[10:54] Force is not saying that it's been taken care of. Now there's a request
[11:00] for water for conformation issued very recently. No, No, it's it's an
[11:05] old one. It's an old one. That is that that is still pending,
[11:09] and that is in addition to what you're doing with your PAGES sets,
[11:11] all those things. Right, So air Force is very clear ahoard that you
[11:16] know their demand despite what is happening with the PAGES program, all the AMCA
[11:20] program still stands. That's that's that's the underlying factor as far as Navy is
[11:26] consider of course you don't need so many. The numbers are much less and
[11:31] they're settling down for twenty six as against the requirement of fifty six. The
[11:35] reason again there is that you are looking for an indigenous deck based for the
[11:41] Navy and the leadership is quite confident by twenty six twenty seven you will have
[11:50] the first prototype ready and things like that, and things are on the right
[11:54] track. So if you get twenty six right now, again the they will
[11:58] not come together together. The entire delivery might take say three years. So
[12:05] I think that's the calculation. That's that that's been done. So if you
[12:09] sign the deal now, delivery start by twenty six, that's when you're indigenous
[12:15] deck based fighter sort of comes into the picture. Is the trial start prototype
[12:20] is ready over the next four or five years, you have them ready.
[12:24] So that's the blueprint. But if you have two aircraft carriers, you would
[12:31] want your fighter jets to be new as well. MICK twenty nine is good.
[12:37] It's fine because unfortunately LCN Navy is out of question as far as operation
[12:43] keeps making landings and takeoffs. Yes, yeah, so it's it's just to
[12:48] showcase probably that. Yeah, it's something that we have. That's a bit
[12:54] of a contradiction. I don't know. Yeah, I've always felt weird about
[12:58] that because like the initial few weeks after Vikrant was out in the what are
[13:03] you testing? Are you testing? Why? Maybe? Are you are you
[13:07] testing Krant? Maybe? They were testing. I think, yeah, I
[13:11] think those were part of sea trials. Yeah, maybe perhaps, And you
[13:13] know, just to help our listeners and viewers with some more context, when
[13:18] we think of a fighter jet shortfalls, no one ever thinks of Indian daedia,
[13:22] at least no one who's not like you and me who closely follows the
[13:26] world of defense, because you look at it very simply from a normal layman's
[13:31] perspective. You first keeps saying, Kammara official sanctions strength is forty two squadrons,
[13:37] and we are at about thirty right now. And this is after the
[13:41] affair came a fair came in. Before that, it was twenty eightive.
[13:43] This is when he's doing major headlines. KIF is major down office. A
[13:48] majority of them are old meg Russian Russian MiGs. Many of them, unfortunately,
[13:54] face accidents crashes that have seen pie Let's lose their lives, which has
[14:01] led to media coining phases that you personally do not like, you know,
[14:05] flying coffins and stuff like that. But we don't want to go there.
[14:07] The point being widowmakers. Widowmakers, yeah, is the worst one in today's
[14:13] context, because there are women fighter pilots. Isn't exactly. Yeah, the
[14:16] point being that the air force lacks the required number of fighter jets that needs
[14:20] to fight whatever it thinks eating to fight in a situation where you have Parkistan
[14:24] on the western China on these is pretty clear Nia, because you know,
[14:31] first of all, i've yeah, even even if you think about it,
[14:33] Navy fighter jets hauntily involved in that being accidents, I haven't. I can't
[14:37] recall one for example in recent memory. I mean the deck based ones,
[14:41] the offshore ones which take off from you know, the shore areas. They
[14:46] have obviously seen some accidents. In the helicopterslicopters. Yeah, the aircraft carriers
[14:50] for Heaven, you have two aircraft carriers. One was launched recently with much
[14:54] fanfare. Their strength is around thirty six capacity ch strength capacity. You support
[15:00] around twenty five six aircraft on on the decks. So that's including helicopters,
[15:05] and you have I think around forty or forty plus. Uh make trainland case
[15:11] without the Navy. Uh, they I think they were there. How how
[15:15] are the o these aircraft so? Uh? I think India the first induction
[15:20] was in twenty and ten, but they are easily four decades old in terms
[15:24] of anyone wah Russian. I think it was in late teas that they were
[15:28] sort of designed came into service. Fun So India has also brought them pretty
[15:35] late, pretty late. Yeah, So I don't know why. Maybe it
[15:37] was again no cost factors back then. Perhaps we don't know, We don't
[15:41] country callum. But the point being, uh explained to our listeners and viewers
[15:46] the pressing need for the Navy for new fighter jets, because, like I
[15:50] said, if you just put these facts and figures to a normal person and
[15:54] be like HOWK put on our old but tcraft was pressing case. Let me
[16:02] see if if you look at it, that forty is a decent number for
[16:06] two rea, isn't it. You have some in repairs, some in some
[16:11] kind of maintenance. Still you have still you have for either of the aircraft
[16:17] carriers, you will have a decent number at least a dozen or ready for
[16:22] operations. But the fact is that, I mean, the fact that they
[16:27] are old and the aircraft carrier is new, I think is the simplest,
[16:33] most simplest explanation one can give. And also, what is the vision that
[16:37] you have for your maritime security? That's again I think big context. We've
[16:44] mentioned before that there has been a big thrust on Navy's budget in the last
[16:51] two three years. If you just go through the budget papers of the Ministry
[16:55] of Defense, one will actually realize that a huge amount is being allocated for
[17:00] capital procurement. Capital procurement, for me, that's what the budget raially is.
[17:08] The other heads like revenue go for salaries, etc. And those kinds
[17:14] of things. Capital is what is meant for modernization. So if you're allocating
[17:19] a big chunk on capital procure for capital procurement, there certainly is a clear
[17:26] indication that there is a big need to overhaul and spike up your maritime power.
[17:34] So if those allocations have been have been made, that means there is
[17:40] a clear blueprint in mind of your leadership on where to go with your navy.
[17:45] And the big debate whether we need the third aircraft carrier, as far
[17:51] as the Navy is concerned, they still maintain that we need a third aircraft
[17:55] carrier. So if you if you need another aircraft carrier, you will need
[18:00] fighters as well. So I think there's no way that the Navy is going
[18:03] to hold back their demands. And of course you can demand the moon exactly
[18:08] different thing but yeah, there has to be some practicalities, realistic targets that
[18:15] one has in mind. Also with the squadron strength that we always hear about,
[18:19] I don't remember the last time the Indian Air Force had forty two squads,
[18:25] so I think some introspection needs to be done there. That isn't just
[18:29] a number written somewhere in papers. Actually it's a fantastic point, because yeah,
[18:33] it's probably just a number written papers. He sanctions strength this, so
[18:38] maybe maybe you need to tweak that as well, keeping your current capabilities.
[18:45] The sanction strength was forty two probably at a time when fighter aircraft was you're
[18:53] only and only source of air power. I think this was quite done before
[18:59] the age of drones. I'm definitely sure about that, much before the age
[19:02] of things. I'm not even sure what was the level of your other surface
[19:07] to air missile sizes which can take down five aircraft your air defense guns.
[19:15] So there there are other areas where capabilities come in as well, So that
[19:21] if you keep that in mind, and if you leverage that, then perhaps
[19:25] forty two is a number that can be tweaked. Yeah, that's actually a
[19:29] good point as well. Not like what I'm saying but I'm saying, is
[19:32] it just a number because it's there, or is it is it something rarely
[19:37] sacosymed? Yeah, I think actually that's something we should talk about. And
[19:41] you know, a side note to a producer, and I'll ask her to
[19:45] keep a note because this will make for a good headline of our podcast at
[19:48] least does the if surely need forty two squadrons? And but you know the
[19:52] letter of viewers and you know we'll be discussing navy today's Yeah, yeah,
[19:57] so we won't be, won't We won't spend time this, So we'll let
[20:00] our viewers and listeners come on this loud. Let us know if you think
[20:03] we should discuss this, you know, in the comments below, just say
[20:06] what you think of this idea we should should do you want to talk about
[20:10] this or you know, if you're not on YouTube, you can drop a
[20:11] text to us at eight five double eight nine, double six, double nine
[20:15] six, or just email us spots at the rate interator dot com. That's
[20:18] p ods at the rate interator dot com. Let us know what you think
[20:22] if you wanted to discuss based on that, we'll think of that and also
[20:25] we'll just you back after a quick break. Hello, I'm Ranch Champa from
[20:36] India Today Podcasts and your host for Nothing but the Truth. Every week we
[20:41] will deal with key issues of concern and bring you perspectives and clarity as to
[20:47] why this should matter to you and what is the clear truth that emerges.
[21:03] Welcome back. Discussing this time, I won't say I use the word upcoming
[21:07] because it's still we don't know the specifics yet. It's just there's a strong
[21:12] speculation and strong buzz that India's indications go ahead and buy another set of a
[21:21] fel it's time for the Indian Navy and not for the Air Force. Off
[21:23] the shelf again, you don't know, but probably of the shelf, all
[21:26] all of them. Yes, even if it happens, it will be twenty
[21:30] six is to less number for the to be transfer technology. I guess.
[21:34] So, yeah, so I'll shake. Before the break, you were explaining
[21:38] if you manage to sort of bargain and get some transfer of technology in this,
[21:44] it could be a cool I think. Yeah. I was actually just
[21:47] gonna come to that because because the reason why you went for a government to
[21:52] government deal with with the SAW aviation with France earlier for air Force, because
[21:59] there was sticking points when it came to transfer technology. Yes, it was
[22:02] just taking too long for them. Yeah, that's the So if you managed
[22:06] to do that now, yeah, you would have struck a hard bargain,
[22:10] really hard bargain. And I was just gonna come to that. I mean,
[22:12] so just before the break you're talking about, not just before, but
[22:18] towards the beginning of this episode, you're talking about how all of this health
[22:22] has to be seen in the context of India's own h project to develop a
[22:27] fighter jet for its aircraft carriers. The first one that was developed, the
[22:32] prototype You've said, it's just out. There's no way the navy wants that
[22:36] because unfortunately having they showcase it. Yeah, they keep doing that. I
[22:41] mean it's good, it's good to be seen. But sorry, Yeah,
[22:44] so the Navy, because I think they want a twin engine version and not
[22:48] the one that's there, which is a single engine version. Anyways, so
[22:49] that's under development. You said by twenty twenty six, twenty seven, cast
[22:53] Pass might have the first protoype et. So this is what I said,
[22:57] what I meant. So, if they're some transfer of technology, do you
[23:02] or that the just literally just put it this way, how difficult is it
[23:06] to develop a fighter jet for naval purposes compared to something for land And where
[23:14] do you practically see India's project at based on what you've read, what you've
[23:18] heard, what you've talked about in the whole setup of the military. Again,
[23:22] the India's indigenous fighter programmers again easily four decades old, so it's certainly
[23:30] not been a smooth ride. The fact that you had they just only now
[23:34] a few few years back. I mean, it's still we're still looking for
[23:40] the numbers that we are. But yeah, it's been decided that they just
[23:45] will form, if not the backbone, it will at least hold some significance
[23:52] in India in the Indian Air Force's scheme of things that has been decided.
[23:59] The program of India's own fifth generation aircraft AMCA again is something that the defense
[24:07] planners are really excited about and the feel that things are on the right path.
[24:14] I don't think the problem lies with capability so much. It's about meeting
[24:18] deadlines. I would like to believe that we have the capability to do all
[24:23] of this. And even though that you know, we say that LCA is
[24:29] just a sort of a showstopper on an aircraft carrier, but it was still
[24:33] one step taken. If that were not done, you would not probably move
[24:38] on to the next stage of saying, okay, we'll have deck based,
[24:44] full fledged fighter as the one that you are thinking of. So yeah,
[24:48] it's it's been long. It's not been an easy journey as far as India's
[24:53] fighter program is concerned. But yeah, there are a few options because I
[25:00] think cost is something that comes in the way far too many times, so
[25:07] there is there has to be a blend. You need to have your own
[25:10] stuff and at the same time, probably that's what we'll put pressure on your
[25:15] local industry, indigenous industry as well, because if you completely say we're not
[25:19] going to buy stuff from outside, only on it and where's the pressure,
[25:22] where's the competition. So I think we are in a stage where the indigenous
[25:29] industry it's sort of feeling that, okay, we can compete. Earlier that
[25:34] was not happening. And forget about fighter jets. That's that's those are big
[25:37] platforms. There's so many other things. Drones, for example, there's a
[25:41] big indigenous drone bush program that is that is already taking place. So yeah,
[25:48] I mean it's it's a big churn that we've discussed before as well,
[25:52] and this is something that I think we'll keep making reference to because when you
[25:56] discuss defense in India, whether you like it or not, self reliance,
[26:02] they have become buzzwords. Not not to say that these things were not happening
[26:07] before, but yeah, something that Prime Minister who he has done, that
[26:12] he's made people conscious about, extremely conscious, and not just people in sitting
[26:17] in South Block, even civilians. And I feel there's nothing wrong with that
[26:22] in a sense that if civilians are aware that this is a big priority for
[26:30] the government, then obviously they would want to read more about it, and
[26:33] I would want to hear more about it. That also sort of adds not
[26:37] I wouldn't want to use the word pressure expectations from the indigenous industry, you
[26:44] know, because you mentioned this, something just came to my mind and I've
[26:47] been meaning to ask you about this. I a few months ago, I
[26:51] was reading an article by I forgot whom it was retired, definitely retired a
[26:55] officer of a top ranking officer. I forgot. I forget which branch are
[26:59] either the army or the navy. But he was writing on the topic of
[27:03] accutions and how the military historically has seen Indian maid products for the military,
[27:10] and he used some users sentence on the lines of that the military has always
[27:14] seen foreign equipment as like a Ferrari and Indian equipment as the Kamui. Yeah
[27:19] that was the mindset, as would you agree there was a mindset like that?
[27:22] Probably is. And if you're saying that, you've the piece that you
[27:26] read was by a veteran, Yeah, so yeah, I mean he was
[27:29] speaking for himself. Yeah, so yeah, that that that mindset was there,
[27:33] and you needed somebody to sort of drill into your heads and change that
[27:37] mindset. And I'm being very candid about so that's not asking has that changed,
[27:41] Maybe not completely, but yeah that it's been forced into you. Not
[27:45] to say that you compromise on quality quality, but you can't have a prejudice
[27:52] as well, isn't it. And uh, see it again, as a
[27:56] civilian, let's let's figure about military. We might be military observers, but
[27:59] we are at the end of the day civilians being on board the krant.
[28:03] As a citizen of this country, I feel good. It was a big
[28:07] deal and I think it's natural any civilian who would you know, go go
[28:12] there and get a chance to be on the grant and be told that you
[28:15] know, this is what we've made on our own. And there only four
[28:18] five countries in the world who have the capability to make aircraft carriers. That's
[28:22] what that's what you look up to. Your country is doing well. These
[28:27] are these are indications that we've done something right. I don't need to be
[28:32] I mean, I'm not being nationalistic overtly nationalistic. I think this is just
[28:36] a basic sense of sort of security and a sense of achievement that I'm a
[28:42] taxpayer, my country is capable of doing this. If I see tomorrow any
[28:49] military platform being exported, not just is it a matter of pride statting to
[28:56] your economy. I mean it'll be a big thing. So it's only in
[28:59] our wrist for the indigenous. Why this defense industatement. Isn't that the mantra
[29:06] for all business that you make sure that you your exports go up? So
[29:08] why not in defense? That's that's the big question. Yeah. A couple
[29:14] of last points on this topic. One about Raphael, the naval variant and
[29:19] it's competitive super hornted F eighteen eighteen. Sorry, So in the you said
[29:26] at the beginning there was with a government government purchase, there's no bidding involved,
[29:29] so there's no competition per se. But obviously we know, because we've
[29:32] been tracking this for a while that the Navy was considering both testing, had
[29:36] been not testing per se, hadn't done, but the trials would done,
[29:37] trials would done. You know, we had visual yeah, which is Navy
[29:41] Offshore Planning Facility, which which just represents a sort of a replica of aircraft
[29:48] DECT. Yeah, exactly, k deck exactly, And if I'm not wrong,
[29:51] the FA eighteen has was designed keeping American aircraft Karen in mind, which
[29:56] more or less are catapult where basically something shoots the aircraft of the deck.
[30:02] Kato Bar and Stobar both of our aircraft carriers are Stobar. So but I
[30:10] don't think that could be the only reason. If if that was the reason
[30:14] that faighteen is not good enough for Stobar and solely good for Kato Bar,
[30:18] then why would you test it? Yeah, anyway, that was on my
[30:21] point. My point was, so, yeah, the Navy has been testing,
[30:23] and obviously they would have had a say in which checkcraft to go for.
[30:26] But do you also think because this is where it's a bit confusing for
[30:30] a lot of people by then. I realized this when I was talking to
[30:33] somebody on my team itself, that people don't generally understand the difference between fighters
[30:37] yet used by an air force and the one used by a navy. So
[30:41] you know, you've explained this previously of how the designs are a bit different
[30:45] because you need the ability to take off at high speeds from a shorter distance,
[30:49] land and land very hard on the tech and be able to absorb that
[30:55] impact, and you know, just it certainly needs to be more robust.
[30:57] Yeah, that's the least that is exactly, and it's I think a bit
[31:02] smaller as well, because obviously obviously spaces also because as you said, the
[31:04] aircraft the runways much short. Yeah, it's obviously more challenging. But something
[31:12] that Trelley caught my eye when I saw landings on Vikrant. Every landing that
[31:19] took place beat LCA, Navy or MICK twenty nine. Every landing, every
[31:26] pilot. So there are three hooks to catch the place yea and landing.
[31:30] So if you don't get the first one, the second one, then the
[31:33] third one. If you don't get the third one, you probably go into
[31:37] the CS. Every landing that took place the first one. So the precision
[31:44] with which they are working and the amount of skill. And again we are
[31:48] not pilots, we don't understand the technicalities, but as a layman, as
[31:53] a civilian. Again, the precision something that struck me, which is why
[31:57] I said episode that is something. Yeah, every landing, not one went
[32:04] on to the second home. So yeah, I mean these are very small
[32:07] things. I don't know if if it would be if people would observe all
[32:13] this something, but maybe maybe I would have missed it as well. Yeah,
[32:16] because somebody told me that lookout for this, they will get it right
[32:21] first on the first and I noticed that. Oh yeah, but you know
[32:25] we digressed a little. But these are not digressions. These are very much
[32:30] part of our stories. Of course, we're not taking a class exactly.
[32:34] Maybe yeah, we're talking about yeah, so what else getting to wash?
[32:38] But even then, the fact that both the fighter jets, whether it's the
[32:42] Refel naval VARIANTM or the one that the Indian at post has, will basically
[32:46] be of the same base model, would that also have a fair parts the
[32:52] parts exactly, That's what I'm getting getting at. Would that have been a
[32:53] big factor in deciding which aircraft to go for. Again, you know this
[32:59] has been talked about, so I know where you're coming from. I have
[33:02] a little slightly different take on it. Again what I talked when you mentioned
[33:07] Stoebar and kato Bar. If this is the big factor in choosing Rafal,
[33:15] then why going for a trial of an of the superhounded? If this is
[33:21] the only criteria, If amongst ten criterias this is at eight or nine,
[33:27] I would say fine. So yeah, I'm under pressure to actually get a
[33:31] story on why we have chosen Rafal over faighteen. And in fact, on
[33:40] the news meeting we were discussing and I said that, you know, we
[33:44] can get into analysis. I can do, somebody else can do. We
[33:46] can get veterans to write. But the story would be to get an Indian
[33:52] Navy report which says why and why not. So if we get that,
[33:57] either me or somebody else in our network. Man he has his contacts sources,
[34:04] right, I think that would be the story. Yeah, because otherwise
[34:07] it's otherwise. It's the reason I ask is the reason I asked is something
[34:14] that you know we've discussed several times on this on this podcast, is that
[34:17] cost is becaust could be an Obviously, think of it this way. You're
[34:22] going for a repeat purchase of the same company. Obviously you could cost many
[34:27] things in the air. Cost could be a concern. Geopolitics could be a
[34:30] concern. You need to sort of manage both. Yea France, US,
[34:37] so you've just done a big deal with the US. Geopolitics could be one.
[34:44] But again it's very difficult to say. This is that one reason why
[34:49] they have gone for this, And these are technical things, and the Navy
[34:52] was like, both are fine, both are good enough first, so maybe
[34:55] there's a government intervention, not so much a technical naval intervention, but a
[35:00] government intervention. That's why geopolitics cost comes in diplomacy. So it's it's it's
[35:08] difficulty. We can talk about it and we can sort of speculate. Fine,
[35:13] I mean, those could be the reasons, but I don't know if
[35:16] if if the Navy internal report actually says that these are the ten reasons why
[35:23] far is better than via superinte. Right. One last point on which to
[35:31] end this, and this is a bit technical, but I think very important.
[35:36] So earlier you were talking about capital procurement being set aside for the Navy
[35:40] I remember a previous episode where you had talked about that. How again,
[35:45] correct me if I'm wrong that how the outlay for a current financial year is
[35:49] not always to buy new stuff, but to also cover for purchases that have
[35:53] already been made earlier, as in't the deals were signed liabilities, but perhaps
[35:58] the payment is being made because of how the deal has been structured. So
[36:02] what that tells me is and this is where the larger picture and the importance
[36:06] of the Navy, because we've discussed our several episodes though that we've seen Navy
[36:09] taking a bit of prominence when it comes to deal them. It comes to
[36:13] new seminute subbodines, even if the predator drown. The bifurcation that you have
[36:17] that Navy is getting much higher. Yes, Navy is getting fifteen while a
[36:22] force an army are going to get eight each. So we have Navy taking
[36:24] precedents over there as well. A new set of fighter jets being purchased for
[36:30] the Navy being in which Navy once one has already come debate whether they should
[36:37] be so. Submarines submarines yea three of them. Again, a deal like
[36:42] to be signed during PM's visit to France, So this intent and this support
[36:46] that's you you're seeing in the last two three years, and the obvious the
[36:52] reason for that is China. Do you think that will continue because all of
[36:54] this will take time and you will need to constantly keep paying for it.
[36:59] It's not as at the end you said for it right, Oh, I
[37:02] haven't see as you rightly pointed out that this has been the pattern over the
[37:07] last few years. And it's obviously keeping in mind your your larger security concerns.
[37:17] China angle is definitely a big, big factor because of why you were
[37:22] sort of trying to enhance your naval capabilities. And yes, I don't think
[37:30] it's being it's a half hearted measure. If all this is happening, there
[37:35] has to be some reasoning and thrust behind it. And the good thing is
[37:38] that the Navy is getting their way. And it did require one of the
[37:45] recent Navy chiefs to publicly say that for so many years our budget allocation has
[37:52] been pretty low. It was Admiral Lamba who said that, Yes, and
[37:58] the next budget that came it was a boom. So to make a public
[38:02] statement was a big statement, and he was telling the government that you know,
[38:07] if if you want all this to be done. And this was in
[38:09] a press conference where some questions were asked about these kinds of things where they
[38:14] start, there's that, so he was very candid. So just go back
[38:17] and look at what do you expect. So there has been a big change
[38:22] after the interesting. So interesting, and we'll keep tracking these changes, especially
[38:28] when it comes from we've been doing it for the last few episodes now or
[38:31] not the last few per se but whenever we've talked about maybe this has come
[38:35] up right. One last point to end this on question fun question again based
[38:39] on my interaction with people and my team, Like I said, the difference
[38:43] between an n Force fighters and naval I know for a fact that naval fighters
[38:47] have and can be used in land operations they recently wore during the during the
[38:54] China But can an Air Force jet land on an aircraft carrier? Very very
[39:01] tough, very tough. Can you recall of for an incident where it was
[39:06] tried? And I'm not seeing Also the Force pilot ah that Dad training perhaps
[39:10] is not ye, that's that's a bit of a yeah. Once again,
[39:15] I think the four pilots might not like this. But once again, the
[39:17] reason I'll love name of aviation in the sex Year, I think, Yeah,
[39:22] it has more glamor Yeah, well that's it I think. And top
[39:28] Gun has added to of course of course as always. Well that's it I
[39:31] think. Thanks a bish fun chat as always, and thanks to our listeners
[39:36] of viewers once again. If just let us know again what you thought of
[39:38] this episode, you can drop a text to us at eight favorable nine double
[39:42] six double n six or an email to us at pods at the rate in
[39:45] your rate dot com, let's b o ds at the rate in the to
[39:47] day dot com. And also a special thanks as always to our produce an
[39:51] appreciation. That's it for the Spix Defense Tours for more, tune in next
[39:53] week. They'll then, stay safe and do not cross any boundaries with the
[39:57] passport. Bye bye

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
