# Gaza War: What Will It Take For Israel To Completely Destroy Hamas? | In Our Defence, Ep 80

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 26 Oct 2023, 41 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/57396381/26_oct_23_iod_26_mix_128.mp3

Why do Indians seem to be more interested in the Israel-Hamas conflict compared to the Russia-Ukraine war, which has greater geopolitical impact and trade-business implications for India, considering the significant defense partnership with Russia? Many Indians draw a simplistic parallel between Israel and themselves as victims of terror. Why is this belief prevalent, and why do our host, Dev Goswami, and "Def Savvy" Abhishek Bhalla hold differing views on this? What are the key differences and similarities between the situations of India and Israel? Also, Israel has recently conducted a series of airstrikes on the Gaza Strip and issued an ultimatum for the evacuation of 1.2 million civilians in northern Gaza. However, this ultimatum has expired without action yet. Given the evolving dynamics, will Israel consider a ground invasion due to growing threats from Hezbollah in the northern part and warnings from Iran about preemptive actions? Will this invasion happen? And will Israel be able to decimate Hamas amid such sort of pressure building against it?&nbsp;If yes, what happens to Gaza then? Listen in! Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound Mix by Nitin Rawat

## Transcript

[0:01] This is India Today podcasts. There are boundary disputes and then there are outright
[0:08] wars, hot and cold, diplomatic and military. In this podcast, we
[0:14] will dissect all that's brutal and subtle about the defense of our nations. I
[0:19] am They've Goswami your host, and I will be joined by Abishik Bala,
[0:22] who's been on the frontlines of wars and conflicts and has seen the Indian military
[0:28] up close. Hello, and welcome to the eightieth episode of Another Defense.
[0:35] It's been around twenty days since Hamas launched a terror tack on Israel and that
[0:41] sparked a war about which there's a lot of talk in India. Actually,
[0:48] that's you know, something that's surprised me because for me, so for the
[0:53] two of us, we've covered two wars on this podcast. One was the
[0:57] Russia Ukraine, which began I think when we started off, and you also
[1:00] had to rush to Russia, and we got a few episodes over zoom because
[1:06] you were in you were in Ukraine. But after the initial few days,
[1:11] I think the interest sort of peter down in India. However, it is
[1:15] still Hamas conflict. It's just ongoing and ongoing not the conflict. The interest
[1:21] in India. Is that a bit surprising for you because it is for me
[1:23] because I would think if there was to be any interest, it would be
[1:26] in the Russia Ukraine conflict, considering Russia has been this long standing ally of
[1:30] India's when it comes to defense supplies, and you know we did speak about
[1:34] a lot of that on various episodes. Of the much more impact on geopolitics.
[1:38] Yes, yes, that war has yes, exactly, it affects a
[1:41] lot of trade business. Also because Russia was an important defense partner in terms
[1:48] of that, there should have been much more interest because there was more at
[1:53] stake. India was a bigger stakeholder in what was happening there. But human
[1:57] emotions sometimes don't see these nuancewers, and that's a classic example. I think
[2:05] it's the The interest is because a lot of Indians feel that they are in
[2:10] the same position as Israel. I don't know why, but that's what they
[2:15] feel, a victim of terror, Islamic terror per se. So I think
[2:21] that's what has generated interest. And for years, if you see, you
[2:23] know, there is this long standing belief that we should respond like Israel whenever
[2:31] there is a terror attack. I mean, I've've covered several terror attacks over
[2:35] the last almost two decades. Now. The list is quite long. The
[2:39] deadliest, of course, was twenty six eleven. But really I don't want
[2:43] to, you know, like, I hate putting this categorization when it comes
[2:49] to terror attacks because it's it's rather unfair, because a terror attack is a
[2:55] terror attack. People are going to lose lives, there is going to be
[2:58] a him around it. But yeah, twenty six eleven for the sheer audacity
[3:02] of it, and there was a breach of the borders and the Mourdorsuperandai again,
[3:07] that's what made it so much more different. But then there were the
[3:09] train attacks. There have been a series of attacks in Delhi. I've covered
[3:16] those two thousand and five, two thousand and eight, then two thousand and
[3:20] eight Mdabad. I couldn't go to Amabad because for some reasons. But yeah,
[3:24] I mean I've seen that. So I think a lot of Indians find
[3:30] a very simplistic parallel between Israel and India being victims of terror, and they
[3:38] see Palestinian cause a little similar to what Pakistan has been doing. The Kashmir
[3:47] impact. So I think it's a bit of a cocktail of all these things
[3:53] that makes a lot of Indians believe that Israel is a very similar kind of
[4:00] a story to India, which I personally though think isn't. It's it's a
[4:03] little more different and a little more complicated than this. Yeah, there will
[4:10] be some parallels at some point of time. I mean, you can say
[4:14] Kashmi could be the closest parallel, that there is a movement, separatist movement
[4:19] in Kashmi and how they want a separate land for themselves based on religion,
[4:26] Pakistan backing them. But still I think while there are similarities, there are
[4:31] also stark differences of course that I mean, I don't think even the Kashmi
[4:35] thing, that example that you gave is just like too far faster. It's
[4:40] like forcing it if somebody wants to see the similarity exactly. Yeah, because
[4:45] I don't think India Indians ever have to contend with the question on the right
[4:50] to stay where you stay, because the Israel Palestine conflict is all about that.
[4:55] I mean, both sides say this is our homeland and you are illegally
[4:58] occupying our homeland. That's not a question when it comes to me, at
[5:02] least, there is a defined line. Yes, there are no differences within
[5:08] that same land, so you don't have different pockets being controlled by one party.
[5:13] That that's what happens in the Israel Palestinian conflicts, especially in the West
[5:17] Bank area, where there are different pockets summer Israeli controlled, it's not,
[5:24] it's really controlled at least dominated by Jews and a lot of Muslim dominated.
[5:30] And that's what creates a lot of confusions. Right, But what about the
[5:35] Indian government and more particularly the defense establishment. You know, we spoke about
[5:41] this back then as well, and obviously, for obvious reasons, the defense
[5:46] set up was keeping a very close eye on the Russia Ukraine War because,
[5:48] like we discussed, around sixty seventy percent of our supplies come from Russia.
[5:54] So the immediate pressing question was the need to diversify because we remember we are
[5:58] also in a long standing standoff with China, and you need constant supplies arms,
[6:03] ammunition to replace what you're you're finishing on the line over there. So
[6:09] the setup was obviously keeping a very close eye on Russia Ukraine. Like you
[6:12] said, what about in the case of Israel, Amas, is that also
[6:15] something see doesn't It's not something that directly impacts the Indian interests, unlike the
[6:20] Russia Ukraine war. But yeah, I mean, all militaries would want to
[6:25] keep an eye on any kind of conflict that's happening. And one big takeaway
[6:30] I feel is that Israel. You know, I visited Israel recently and we've
[6:33] touched upon that. I was there in March this year and it was to
[6:39] attend us a conference related to cybersecurity. So of course there was a lot
[6:43] of talk about high tech cyber warfare that Israel is preparing for and it is
[6:49] really good at and just generally you know, there the approach to modern day
[6:55] militarism is advanced, modern tech, and they were chally that nobody would say
[7:00] that they have not achieved that. Now they are suddenly caught in a situation
[7:04] that it's it's a different battle that high tech, advanced modern stuff could not
[7:11] really stop this kind of an audacious strike on Israeli land. Even even the
[7:17] fence that they have on the on the Gaza Strip, which they spent millions
[7:23] and millions on that has been breached. So traces those questions and also the
[7:27] kind of tactics that Hamas has used is to sort of go past this,
[7:31] uh, this kind of technology, you know, that's that's the whole idea.
[7:36] So I think that the Indian military, or for that matter, any
[7:41] military in the world, will be keeping an eye on how to sort of
[7:45] mitigate these kind of risks and how to strike that right balance. Where of
[7:49] course you need modern technology. I mean, nobody can deny that. But
[7:55] can you just be a slave to modern technology and overlook such an archaic guerrilla
[8:03] warfare kind of tactics which Hamas has used. My answer is no. I
[8:07] mean even in the Israelis would be saying that, no, we were prepared
[8:11] for it. It's not that we were ignoring because we've been watching Amas for
[8:15] so long and this is exactly the kind of warfare we expect from them.
[8:20] But somewhere they were caught napping. And to be very frank and candid,
[8:26] So I think the big interest would be this how to strike that balance to
[8:31] fight battles like this. See, you will not expect a conventional army to
[8:37] use these kind of tactics, But who says that your enemy or adversary is
[8:43] going to be a professional, traditional army. Yes, And that's the big
[8:48] takeaway. And I think in terms of that, there's a lot of interest.
[8:50] You'll see a lot of writeups by Indian military veterans. You'll see a
[8:56] lot of talk around this. There already is, and I think that's that's
[9:01] that's something that's going to be the focus as far as in India's concerned.
[9:05] But as far as India being a stakeholder, uh, nowhere in comparison to
[9:11] what we are as far as Russia and Ukraine is concerned. But despite not
[9:16] having that that great at stake, Uh, the interest is amongst the people
[9:22] of the country much much, much more true. And we've touched upon that,
[9:26] and we can go on and on on that issue. No, you're
[9:30] right, I mean if and what you say is reflecting the government's statements,
[9:33] it's been very to the point. Yeah, there was initial statement from the
[9:37] Prime Minister's office saying that people stand with the is really people and you know,
[9:41] we condemned attack. And then they came out of the statement saying that
[9:45] our position on this issue has been long standing. There's no change in that
[9:48] and that's it, and so no real change in status school. Yeah,
[9:52] and also I think then Prime Minister of the Palestinian leader as well. Yes,
[9:56] yes, that's again great balance. A couple of data called and and
[10:01] I think it was after the after the strike on that hospital. Yes,
[10:03] yes, yes, yeah, it's turned out. It's turned out very controversial
[10:07] by the way it is controversial, but raising my hand up and saying I
[10:11] don't know what the truth is, yeah, no one does. And no,
[10:15] but the kind the way people have just written judgments on it, it's
[10:22] it's amazing how it can be done. Yeah. Yeah, I thinion.
[10:24] That's been one of my takeaways from the from this conflict, not so much
[10:31] with the Russia Ukraine because like you said, there was not a lot of
[10:33] emotion and war. It was more of a strategic war between two countries for
[10:37] their own aims. I mean, there's not a lot of there could be
[10:41] emotion as far as Russians of course, of course, yeah they're but I
[10:43] mean globally speaking, but with an emotional conflict like this, when you have
[10:48] people who are seeing elsewhere, not just there, people who are polarized on
[10:52] the code issue, and you bring in social media, and you bring in
[10:56] a social media that, under the new owner of what used to be called
[11:01] Twitter has kind of you know, has kind of you know, gone a
[11:05] bit bonkers. It's just crazy the level of misinformation. I mean, if
[11:11] you just go on any social media platform right now, you will be bombarded
[11:15] with visuals you don't even know where they're from, but they come with such
[11:18] commanding authority. This is not this is it was happening during the Russia Ukraine
[11:22] War as well. There was a lot of information warfare on social media where
[11:28] just like so many other things, you expected to take a clear stand either
[11:35] you are with this or with this. From an Indian context, again,
[11:37] I'm saying one wouldn't see so much of involvement, involvement or emotion and this
[11:45] this is what is surprising that actually it's not as I said, that that
[11:48] comes from it comes from a sense of being victim of terror. And see,
[11:56] I mean you have to understand what this is Palestinian conflict is all about.
[12:03] It's of course it's religion, but it was a political movement when it
[12:07] started, the Zionist movement of resettling Jews in Israel, which was supposed supposedly
[12:13] supposed to be their natural homeland in which they had left centuries ago, many
[12:18] many years ago, and after after all those years, so there was that
[12:24] that that bid was political sprinkle the religion and the beliefs in it. It
[12:30] makes for a deadly combination. And in the era that this was happening and
[12:35] the events that happened later, so I would I would categorize it as religious,
[12:41] religious as well as political. There was a lot of geopolitics at at
[12:46] stake at that point of time, and you have that combination of religion and
[12:50] beliefs. That's what made it more deadly. I think a lot of Indian
[12:54] sea don't want to see that religious angle with it. That you know,
[12:58] Pakistan Islamic terror, India victim of terror. Yeah, but I I mean,
[13:03] if you get into the details there is, then then you'll you'll realize
[13:07] that it's not that simple. It's not that simple. This conflict is not
[13:13] that simple. You've spoken see India being a victim of Islamic terror. Again,
[13:18] it's it's a bit of a controversial thing. See India is a definitely
[13:22] a victim of Pakistani terror. Yes, that Pakistani terra happens to be Islamic.
[13:26] You can say India per se is not a victim of Islamic terror.
[13:30] That's a good point. Actually, that's a very good distinction you made.
[13:33] I agree with you. So when this there is absolutely no two ways.
[13:37] We've not been attacked, forget attack, We've not been cornered condemned by any
[13:43] other Islamic country on the issue of Kashmir, which is which is supposedly a
[13:48] religious issue as far as Pakistan is concerned, no other Islamic country has sort
[13:54] of for that matter, know, the terrorist group, whether it's Al Kaeda
[13:58] or I. Yes, at the crisis has to something global global level.
[14:01] You have had offshoots of ices within operating from within India that have you not
[14:05] tried to destabilize, create some create some terror movements in India, but I'm
[14:11] saying at the global level, you haven't had the actual IZIS organization targeting.
[14:16] That's also India's diplomacy has been such that, you know, we've made sure
[14:20] that this remains an issue between between Islankistan. We've not allowed it to be
[14:26] internationalized. And having said that, also because of your diplomatic relations with the
[14:31] Arab world and Muslim countries, you've made sure that there's no Islamic Muslim global
[14:39] cause like there is with Palestine, the Muslim Brotherhood. You might hear some
[14:43] people again off shoots here and they talk about it, but it's not something
[14:46] which is backed by states. Iran openly sides with the Palestinian not just the
[14:54] cause, but it's it's being top that Iran is helping hamas Lebanon is hea
[15:00] ping Ahmas through his bullah. That's not the case with Lashkaiwa. Yes,
[15:03] true. So I mean that's that's why I say that Indians should look through
[15:07] these This This is a very good it's a very good point because you know,
[15:11] I'll even take it a step forward and say that India is actually just
[15:15] a target or a victim of a proxy war fought by Pakistan through groups that
[15:22] they've set up and have indocrinated using Islam. Right. I mean, I
[15:26] don't think there is, like you said, a cause global jihad against India.
[15:31] These groups also sprung up when the Pakistani army was Islamized, Yes,
[15:37] the mullaization of the Pakistani army. As they say, these groups were also
[15:43] an offshoot of that. Prior to that, the Pakistani army turning away Islamic.
[15:48] Prior to that, these groups did not exist. So there is a
[15:50] clear connection. So if somebody cannot see through this, then I mean,
[15:54] this is the basic, most basic thing that we can tell our listeners and
[16:00] viewers also coming to India again being the even the indigenous Islamic terror that India
[16:07] has faced for a while, groups like Indian Mujahid the some elements of SIMI.
[16:14] There's again a lot of controversy whether SIMI was really a terror group or
[16:18] not, although it is classified as one. But a lot of our quotals
[16:22] have happened in the last few years. We can probably talk about that separately
[16:26] as as somebody who covered a lot of terror cases. I just as I
[16:30] mentioned, and went through a lot of chart sheets, court judgments. Islamic
[16:36] radicalization in India, if you leave aside Kashmir is a post nineteen ninety three
[16:41] phenomenon, post demolition. That's what investigations have shown. That's what the accused,
[16:49] the suspects, their interrogations revealed. And these were part this is part
[16:55] of chart sheet. I'm not saying that this is not my opinion, this
[16:57] is not my analysis. This part of chart sheets, part of court judgments
[17:03] that in that era of two thousands or late nineties, people who were caught
[17:11] to be associated with these kind of groups, all of them said that the
[17:15] trigger for us was ninety three and ninety three led to the Bombay blast.
[17:21] Bombay blast again had a Pakistani angle. A lot of RDX and things like
[17:23] that came from Pakistan. So Pakistan definitely the proxy that you said used some
[17:30] kind of internal fault lines that had sprung up at that point of time,
[17:36] and it's still happening. I'm not saying that there's no Islamic terror in India.
[17:40] Of course there is. There are people who are fascinated with the idea
[17:45] of violence, and a lot of radicalization happens, let's not get into I'm
[17:52] sure somebody who will be watching or listening later will say that there is Hindu
[17:56] terror as well and things like that, So that could be and we're not
[18:00] denying that. I mean, radicalization has happened across religions, but we're just
[18:04] trying to bring out the differences between Israel, Palestine, India, Pakistan,
[18:12] Muslim world, Islam, et cetera. It's everything is not it's not the
[18:18] same as what's happening there. Yeah, I think that was a very good
[18:22] point, and frankly, in a discussion that we won't even prepared for,
[18:26] honestly, because what happens when you just go with the flour containing things naturally.
[18:30] But yeah, it was a very good, very good thought that you've
[18:33] raised. But let's move back to Israel and Bahamas and Gaza. But we'll
[18:40] come back to a break. Hello. I'm graj Chengepa from India Today Podcasts
[18:51] and your host for Nothing but the Truth. Every week we will deal with
[18:56] key issues of concern and bring you perspectives and clarity as to why this should
[19:02] matter to you and what is the clear truth that emerges. Welcome back a
[19:15] Michigan. I are discussing. We're discussing actually the level of interest that the
[19:19] Israel Hamas War, which is now and it's twentieth day as we record on
[19:23] a Thursday, has generator in India. There's a good discussion that we had,
[19:30] but let's move on to and move back to the actual conflict that's happening
[19:33] there. For the last seven days since we last spoke on this issue in
[19:37] the pre in our previous episode, you've had some of the other is ready
[19:41] official top official, whether it's the chief of the military or the Prime Minister
[19:45] himself in Nyaho say that yes, ground vision was hon yesterday. The military
[19:51] said that we are ready just waiting for the go ahead. That go ahead
[19:55] is not yet come slowly. You're seeing a lot of pressure building on Israel
[20:00] from its own allies the West, where they are now adding certain you can
[20:06] see conditions apply to their support for Israel and we back you. You have
[20:10] the right to decible defense. But and that butt is usually followed by something
[20:12] on the lines of you should follow international law or that but you should wait
[20:17] let some aid go into Gaza, because it's been so many days since you've
[20:19] put a blockade over there. Turkey, an ally of the US it's part
[20:23] of the NATO, has openly said that Hamas it does not see Hamas is
[20:27] a Terrist outfit. It sees Hamas is a set of liberators. Strong statements
[20:32] coming from at least really coming against Israel. In this scenario, do you
[20:38] think Israel is going to be able to morally and god even strategically go ahead
[20:45] of this objective. It's objectives made very clear. I think two days aw
[20:48] I saw a radio put out by the IDF there is great defense process of
[20:52] their chief of General Staff where he said their objectives dismantle HAMAS and its entire
[20:59] network that operates out of Gaza. How do you go about doing that?
[21:03] When you have such sort of pressure building on you, is it even possible
[21:07] anymore? It's not. It's not an easy task for sure. And just
[21:12] taking forward what we were discussing the Indian emotion behind this conflict recently, in
[21:21] one of these conversations with family friends, I heard toking up. That's the
[21:30] question, because you don't want casualties. You definitely want hoko, but you
[21:36] don't want casualties. When happened, and for that matter, when Balakote happened,
[21:42] you heard Indian uh top officials military off She'll say that one of our
[21:47] concerns was to make sure that we have minimum casualties. Of course, in
[21:52] war, you you you don't go into war, or you don't go go
[21:55] into battle. Saying that our objective is not to have casualties, they might
[21:59] as well not go. You can't be scoring runs being at the non strikers
[22:03] sign. You have to face the ball, you have to face the bullet.
[22:07] But mitigating those risks is part of your tactical approach towards any kind of
[22:12] conflict. And one of the big achievements of Uri war was that they all
[22:18] came back safe. There was no casualty, so which is like the cherry
[22:22] on the cake. You feel good that we achieved our military goal, military
[22:26] objective, and at the same time we made sure that all the guys who
[22:30] went in there are back safe. So, of course not the right example
[22:36] to give with with Hamas, but I'm just trying to draw parallels as far
[22:41] as basic human emotion is concerned. The kind of war that we fought inside
[22:52] Gaza is not what conventional warfare is all about. We've talked about that before
[22:57] as well, and Israel knows that very well, and that's the reason you're
[23:02] seeing this this delay. I also heard someone say key tanks so, and
[23:07] that's the reason, because they can't enter there. So if if tanks enter,
[23:11] not only will people die, not only that military personal die, but
[23:17] all those tanks will get destroyed. I saw that happening in Ukraine as well,
[23:22] so I know what kind of WARFA, especially armor WARFA in an urban
[23:26] setting means. Now, this is quite confusing because it's not that tanks have
[23:32] not been used in urban settings. They have been used. But the most
[23:37] recent example of the Russia Ukraine war, we saw that how those tanks became
[23:42] sitting ducks if we want to use that cliche. So and forget tanks.
[23:48] Even if you make ground invasion, I don't know. I mean if you
[23:52] have your RT supported by air strikes, if you need to move in there
[23:56] with your troops on the ground, it's it's a huge task. Narrow bi
[24:02] Laines, cramped up area, you don't know from where the fire is coming.
[24:08] By the time you figure that out, you will have a lot of
[24:11] losses. You're blinded going in there. And again the gorilla tactics that Hamas
[24:18] uses, so it'll have to be a lot of planning, tactical tweaking of
[24:23] what you've been doing till now and what you can do. We all expected
[24:29] a response like this from Israel, where they used air power and missiles and
[24:36] a lot of buildings have been blown up. Casualties on the Palestinian side far
[24:41] more than what happened on the Israeli side. I think it's five times more.
[24:45] Yes, and this has happened, hoping that you know you're flushing out
[24:48] Hamas terrorists. And also nobody says it officially, but this feeling that every
[24:56] house has Hammas operatives, so none of them are clean. That's that's the
[25:02] mental thinking that the Israeli forces are operating with that's the point actually I want
[25:07] to come to. So when you talk about dismantling Hamas, when you talk
[25:11] about decimating Hamas, what do you think Israel sees as the final objective?
[25:15] Because put it this way, not put it this way. This is a
[25:18] fact and this is something I think. This is the point that our viewers
[25:21] and listens would also understand that Hammas, unlike Let's Saya, is not just
[25:26] an outfit, it also controls Gaza. It controls Gaza, it controls daily
[25:32] operations. So for example, the hospital a political outfit is yes, exactly,
[25:37] the hospitals over there are operated by Hamas. So doctors over there are
[25:41] technically employees of Hamas. So does Israel see them also asterirists? Does Israel
[25:47] see the municipal workers over there as terrorists? So what is the how do
[25:51] you That's that's what I want to understand when when Israel's they might not officially,
[25:56] but that's the mindset they function with that if you going into Gaza,
[26:00] then morality is out. So then you're saying that two million people, all
[26:06] of them are children, which includes children. I mean, there is a
[26:11] belief that these are the future Hammas fighters. But that's what I'm saying that
[26:15] I refuse to believe that in this day and age, the world is going
[26:19] to let that happen. It's already happening. Bombing is happening. Yeah,
[26:23] I'm saying ground in. I mean even in the bombing, I fear.
[26:27] I feel that in a strikes you actually end up losing more people because you
[26:34] don't know who you are striking unless you have a specific, pinpointed information that
[26:40] this is a hideout, this is a place that we want to bring down.
[26:42] If that happens, fine, But the kind of strikes that we are
[26:48] amount of the kind of strikes we have seen discriminate. It is. It
[26:53] is even though you know the is really point of view would be that now
[26:56] we have struck at where these Of course, of course they will say that
[27:00] we had intelligence, we knew that this is a building. Impossible for us
[27:03] to know what the truth is. But there's a picture of three kids that
[27:07] I saw last evening standing in the middle of rubble, smoked faces literally with
[27:18] a smile on the face. Three Palestinian kids and Ramas in Gaza a three
[27:23] little kids. I think that's the picture of this conflict. Don't you think
[27:29] that day by day, making it difficult for itself. Like I said,
[27:33] we've already seen in the last few days how I wanted. The global sentiment
[27:37] has turned against Israel, but there have been certain nuances added to the support
[27:42] that was to happen. You know, the exactly the point. The more
[27:47] you keep pounding, the more those pictures come out, the more. So
[27:51] that's my whole point, that Israel is not going to be not going to
[27:55] be able to achieve its ultimate object of dismantling or decimating Hamas. It's just
[28:00] impossible unless you tell me that. You know, the world will keep saying
[28:03] whatever it wants to say, but is there will ensure that every person living
[28:07] in that strip is just dead. Yeah, and then what happens That sounds
[28:10] very bad. Does that mean that Israel wants to sort of take control of
[28:15] Gaza? I don't know. So that's what I'm saying, that we haven't
[28:18] heard what their objectives are in terms of the long long vision, long term
[28:25] vision, that's my pack. Yeah, if they want to take over Gaza,
[28:27] and yeah, about you're saying, could be the only way out.
[28:32] But to say that we'll dismantle only Hamas let the rest of the people be
[28:38] then that's a bit of a contrarian sort of view on the issue. If
[28:44] if you want to let the rest of the population be, then how are
[28:48] you making sure that you make the distinction exactly? Which is what something I
[28:52] can't wrap my head around, because you know, it has officially stated objectives.
[28:56] They say they have a three point plan. One is to mental estimate
[29:00] Hamas. Second, for that, they said there will be some limited or
[29:03] whatever encouragion into into Gaza. Second is to draw from Gaza, and the
[29:08] third is to give the people of Gaza a new political setup. I don't
[29:12] know what that means. Third one is definitely some kind of a political ploy,
[29:18] but that can only happen when the first two objectives are achieved. Yeah,
[29:22] and I still can't figure out how they will achieve the first objective.
[29:25] Now, the first two objectives are that you clean up the place and you
[29:27] have some kind of a proxy, probably convinced the Parisian authority from the messe.
[29:32] Yeah, yeah, exactly, some kind of a proxy who you think
[29:36] is pliable, who you can work with way through see and that there is
[29:41] a lot been written about this that why the Israeli is got it wrong or
[29:48] couldn't over cottnapping because one of the reasons was that they can that they're they're
[29:53] talking it out with Hamas and they have found a manageable solution with AMASU.
[30:02] They'll pay their way out. Again, we've mentioned for the briefly in our
[30:07] previous discussions that also has this angle, you know where where you have yes,
[30:12] yes, yes, people being layered with money or being layered with money
[30:18] and getting settled in western countries in Europe, et cetera. So that kind
[30:22] of thinking was what also led to what has happened, because there was a
[30:29] belief in the top leadership. I mean, I'm not saying this is what
[30:33] is the commentary that I've read that the Israeli authorities, especially the Israeli security
[30:41] authorities, sort of managing the Hamas infect An argument also has been made that
[30:47] is almost during the last few years through Qatar was kind of propping up Hamas
[30:52] because they thought they could control Gaza through Hammas. Yes, they'll take care
[30:56] of the issues over there. We don't have to, you know, we
[30:57] just have to twice was deception. It was again sort of a trap that
[31:00] was probably saying I found this quite interesting, this take on the entire issue.
[31:07] But you know, again going back to the whole whatever the isually objective
[31:11] is and bringing in some emotion. Now, a colleague of mine has been
[31:17] speaking to a few Israeli people through the internet because for stories that we're doing
[31:21] online. So one of the people is a woman whose cousin or brother,
[31:26] if I'm not wrong, is in the IDEF. She said, there's a
[31:29] growing fear among the citizens over there that while fighting terrorists, Israel might end
[31:34] up being seen as a terrorist across the world. Don't you think that also
[31:41] is something that should be playing at some level. You see what you're saying
[31:45] that you know, Israel's going about this in a very close, cold sort
[31:48] of a way without keeping malls aside. But what the argument I'm trying to
[31:52] make is that can't last very long. It can last in the initial days
[31:56] attack. I'll answer this again from a very personal point of view, because
[32:01] I've happened to be in Israel recently, as I mentioned earlier, and interacted
[32:06] with a lot of civilians as well as military officials. And by the way,
[32:12] they have conscription law, so everybody serves the idea after they finished their
[32:16] school. Yes, so every civilian has gone through idea himself is all of
[32:23] them, all of them now they're they're pretty proud about the fact that they've
[32:28] done it. All civilians, no problem. Even even the toe guide that
[32:31] we had with a group of journalists who she was showing us around in Jerusalem
[32:37] and the Old City, even she was proud of the fact that, you
[32:43] know, she's served in the forces. There was no problem. But that
[32:47] doesn't mean they didn't come across as extremely radical people. So they have a
[32:52] system. Every nation, every culture is allowed to have their system. They
[33:00] didn't come across as extremely radical people to me, even on the Palestinian issue.
[33:05] Yes, they were quite clear what their outlook towards this subject is.
[33:12] But I don't think that they came across as somebody who believes that they should
[33:16] be I mean again, it sounds like really hackney that they should be violence.
[33:22] I mean, everybody wants peace. And I didn't see that kind of
[33:25] radicalism in their in their normal views and thoughts. I mean, I didn't
[33:30] hear anybody said hope thing that was not part of the narrative. It was
[33:35] more strategic, more tactically sound. Whatever they spoke about how to take on
[33:40] their threats. And again the threats was not just Hamass. The biggest threat
[33:46] is it done that they feel is where they have to they might have to
[33:52] take on a conventional, strong military force. Now I don't know if that
[33:57] that's that's turned out to be their mistake, because Iran has an attack them
[34:00] and Hamas has and there's nothing that they are doing about Iran, even though
[34:05] there is of raw murmurs that Iran is backing them and doing things like that,
[34:09] and they help them do this, but you don't have evidence of what
[34:13] do you do? So the sense that I got was that it is Iran
[34:15] that is our biggest threat and we need to be prepared for them. Of
[34:21] course, groups like his Bulla and Hamas are tear outfits that we always need
[34:28] to be wary about, but this is what it is. I mean,
[34:30] it's Hamas that has now taken them into layerd them into a big conflict.
[34:38] Yeah, but that's what I'm saying. You say that you know you've met
[34:40] people there and you haven't really seen you don't see them as radicals, So
[34:45] that's what I'm saying. That the pressure will also come from within. How
[34:50] long can you keep bombing and trying to flatten a place, How can you
[34:55] move in with the objective not stated but practically, and especially if you start
[35:00] having losses there, yes, and while suffering losses yourself, because you start
[35:05] suffering that is what is those losses a lot of stopping them from doing that,
[35:08] because if you start facing losses, then there's a big question mark on
[35:15] on your entire strategy, tactics, objective. Why why were you doing this?
[35:20] I mean, just imagine seventy one if India lost, Oh yes,
[35:25] because that's an offensive that you launched, as we launched, so at least
[35:29] in pakistanis now So just imagine that that objective wasn't achieved and a reverse,
[35:35] a reverse would have happened in that ninety thousand Indians would have surrendered. Just
[35:39] imagine that happened. So that's stretching it too far. Let's say you didn't
[35:45] get what you want. Then questions would be raised and what was that will
[35:50] be why do you do it? So it's that kind of a situation.
[35:53] But then you know, do you also see and we kind of touched upon
[35:57] this in the first step first time we talked about this episode before the last
[36:00] one, that the level of response that you're seeing right now, the level
[36:05] of violence in the response that you're seeing right now is also because the top
[36:09] bosses to the top leaders need a face saver right now, because the Hamas
[36:14] attack happened under the leadership, and like we discussed in the first episode that
[36:17] a lot of questions were asked about Nataniah himself. So you are the reason
[36:22] now they need to draw the line. Okay, twenty days, we've bombarded
[36:28] them. What makes let's think militarily, yes, and not just emotionally political
[36:34] emotion. This is political emotion, not even human, not even military emotion.
[36:39] Even military emotion is peppered with some kind of tactics. Political emotion is
[36:47] deadly political emotion and a military objective. So you expect the initial response to
[36:54] be this talk thing and we'll show you what you are and things like that.
[36:59] But I think twenty days should be enough for that. Yeah, that
[37:05] kind of thinking to take a back seat and think what exactly do you want
[37:07] to do? How are you want to decimate Hamas. Is Hamas just a
[37:13] terror outfit or is it a huge human emotion that is backed by the people
[37:21] who are living there? What impact is it going to have on people in
[37:24] the West Bank? Yes, what impact is it going to have on as
[37:29] you've been mentioning softening of the stand from the world, and what impact is
[37:34] it going to have on your own people? Are your own people ready to
[37:38] be caught up? I mean they already have been caught up in this conflict,
[37:43] but ready to be caught up in a conflict which is escalated, which
[37:47] has the potential of bringing in other stakeholders and the war expanding to the entire
[37:55] region. I think Israel is thinking on those lines, I'm sure, and
[38:00] Wards are not just about those limited military objectives. These are these larger objectives
[38:07] and the big picture, as they say, to be taken into consideration.
[38:12] Yeah, and I think because of what you just described right now, I'm
[38:15] gonna kind of agree with you now, even though I completely disagreed with you.
[38:19] I think you made this point the first time you spoke about it,
[38:22] that you don't really see a large scale, full scale invasion of Kars are
[38:27] happening. Over the last few days, I've also been thinking that that perhaps
[38:30] there will be some limited sort of surgical strikes or like in limited, the
[38:36] entire strike has to be a surgical strike. Yeah, the entire offensive has
[38:38] to be extremely surgical. In nature, extra urgical nature exactly. But I
[38:42] know, I like, I disagree with you. Back then I said no,
[38:45] no, I'm pretty sure it's going to go in full steam and just
[38:47] you know, let's capture gards. But I don't see that happening because I
[38:51] think it's I want to do that. Yes, how do you do?
[38:53] How you can't? Yes? Because what will happen this year? You keep
[38:58] hearing our political leadership saying puk and things like that is the question. I
[39:06] think. It doesn't mean that you don't have the capability to do it?
[39:08] Yes, yes, Yes, crucial difference, crucial difference and the implications of
[39:13] what has happened. What will you do to get it? What will be
[39:15] the choices you will have to make, have to make to achieve something like
[39:20] that. It has nothing to do with capability. All militaries have a lot
[39:23] of capabilities. Russia has capabilities to have completely flattened out Ukraine by now,
[39:29] but they have chosen not to because again, one, they were surprised by
[39:34] the kind of support Ukraine got from the Western world and the kind of tactics
[39:38] they use, the kind of military platforms that they had so much in common.
[39:45] When we discuss all of this, yes, is not nothing to do
[39:47] with capability, clarifying that we have the capability, but it goes beyond capability.
[39:54] And then I just put it this way, what are you willing to
[39:58] become in order to do that? Whether as a human being on as a
[40:00] country. And like that woman told my colleague that, you know, are
[40:05] you willing to be seen as a terrorist yourself after what you do, after
[40:09] what you've done, not to achieve what you want to achieve. So that's
[40:14] something I think they're grappling with and I don't know what's what how will pan
[40:20] out, So we'll just do what we do best on this podcast is we'll
[40:23] wait, we'll watch, and we'll discuss when they're fresh developments. As always,
[40:30] Thanks Abishik, great chat as as always, and thanks to our listeners
[40:32] and viewers. And a reminder once again you can follow us on WhatsApp.
[40:37] Now we have a WhatsApp channel. The number is eight five double eight nine,
[40:39] double six, double nine six. It's easy for you to stay up
[40:43] to date with whatever the latest offerings we have. That's it then, thanks
[40:46] as always to a lovely producer and adding that's it for the speaks Defense does
[40:50] for more tune in next week. Till then, stay safe and not cross
[40:52] any boundaries for passport

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
