# Ayo Gorkhali! The Fierce Fighters, Their Nepal Legacy And A China Angle | In Our Defence, Ep 60

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 25 May 2023, 55 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/53996658/25_may_23_iod_may_25_128.mp3

Join "Def-Savvy" Abhishek Bhalla and host Dev Goswami as they delve into the reports suggesting Beijing's interest in recruiting Nepal's renowned Gorkhas into the Peoples Liberation Army (PLA). The Indian Army's routine intake of the Gorkhas came to a halt after the Agnipath scheme was introduced. So, what factors contribute to the desirability of Gorkhas in the military forces of various nations, including China, India, and Pakistan, during times of conflict? How does the demographic composition of the Gorkha regiment, with a majority of soldiers from Nepal and a significant portion from India, influence the dynamics and demand for Gorkhas in different military alliances? Considering China's growing influence in Nepal, what potential consequences could arise if China successfully attracts Gorkhas away from their traditional military alliances, particularly with India, and how? Listen in!

## Transcript

[0:01] This is in the Today podcasts. There are boundary disputes and then there are
[0:07] outright wars, hot and cold, diplomatic and military. In this podcast,
[0:13] we will dissect all that's brutal and subtle about the defense of our nations.
[0:18] I am Dave Goswami, your host, and I will be joined by a
[0:22] Bishek Bala who's been on the front lines of wars and conflicts and has seen
[0:26] the Indian military up close. Hello, and welcome to the sixtieth episode of
[0:35] A Defense Hi. How are you doing all well? I hope very well.
[0:40] How's it going. How's life any summer vacation plans? Yeah? In
[0:44] fact time as we record. That's why we're recording a little bit earlier.
[0:48] Actually. Yeah, So if there are references which seem a little dated,
[0:53] dated a week old or something when you listen to this a little later,
[0:57] forgive us for that. To our listeners. You know, we've missed a
[1:00] big news event, yeah, the defense world. Yeah. I mean,
[1:03] if something really really big happens, then we might be doing that wherever I
[1:07] am. That's you know, we have done that in the part done when
[1:11] I've been out or on leave. We have I think last day I was
[1:18] on vacation in Thailand and something happened. Oh, yes, I remembered we
[1:22] did, Oh I remember. Yeah, you were sitting in the thing that
[1:26] the sea facing or something. Yeah, and I was in the studio where
[1:29] that's right, like complete us of you, vus of you. But I
[1:33] mean people should realize that there's no vacation for a journalists, true, isn't
[1:37] it. Before going on and moving on a vacation, you just keeping your
[1:42] fingers crossed that it can be an uneventful one. People go for eventful vacations.
[1:47] We pray for it. Eventful vacation. People want to do things and
[1:52] we want our vacations nothing to happen, basically, and the force to say
[1:57] a silent yes. Uh. You know. This week I want to talk
[2:01] to you about something I think you will be very interested in because I think
[2:06] several episodes now you mentioned that you love history and it was one of your
[2:09] topics I think while graduating. Yeah, yeah, owners in history in his
[2:15] universe, and it's also something that you know. We've gotten the feedback.
[2:19] One one of our listeners, I think a couple of weeks ago, had
[2:23] messaged saying that you know, we should talk a bit more about the history
[2:28] of the army and its various regiments, because you know, almost elimilitary in
[2:31] the world has a rich history, especially in the Indians, especially the army
[2:36] especially. I mean, yeah, yeah, maybe as well. Indian Air
[2:39] Force is a relatively newer but that's that's true for almost any air force in
[2:44] the world because air force itself is technically quiet now also because the British Air
[2:47] Force wasn't operating in India. Yeah, so our air force is completely indigenous.
[2:54] No, no colonial baggage there. I was waiting for that more to
[2:58] come up at the colonial And actually if you go for air force events and
[3:02] even their messes things like that, they feel very different from the Navy.
[3:08] And I haven't been so they do feel. They do feel Indians a type
[3:13] feeling. What do I have to do, by the way, to get
[3:15] invited to an air force or are any military mess event. Sometimes there are
[3:19] press conferences and a thing like that, or if you're traveling for some special
[3:24] story, you might go there for a meal if somebody invites you, and
[3:30] that's the place where you are sort of entertained. I mean, if if
[3:36] they decide to play host, which they do. Women the Indian defense forces.
[3:42] I must have pretty hospitable. Another British legacy. I think that's an
[3:46] Indian thing, indiant thing, Yeah, I think the Indian thing. Yeah.
[3:49] Well, I actually came across us while I was in Ukraine. I
[3:53] came across a situation and this was in the middle of battle. Was selling
[3:58] happening, and I was that of frontline area near the don Bas region and
[4:03] the Ukrainian forces, the Ukrainian im it didn't allow us to leave without a
[4:09] meal, simple food of course when you're at war. But they said so.
[4:13] I actually I tweeted that picture meeting in a small bunker and being also
[4:19] being served. So I said that very feels at home, even though I'm
[4:24] in Ukraine covering the war. When it comes to this, you know,
[4:27] our military is also very similar. Yeah, they will not let you.
[4:30] I think it's a military culture that you don't go to war empty stom,
[4:34] empty stomach. So I think it comes from there. If somebody's come,
[4:39] you make sure that they get something to eat. Yeah right, yeah,
[4:42] So I know, let's talk a bit history and you know, two our
[4:46] other listeners and viewers. If you also want to pitch in an idea,
[4:50] if there's anything that you want us to talk about, do letters know,
[4:53] you know, drop a text to us at eight five double at nine double
[4:55] six million six, or an email to us at pods at the rate Interda
[4:59] dot com. That's pod at the rate in your day dot com. So
[5:00] I'll talk to you this week about the good h reagement and uh, just
[5:06] like always, China's going to be a part of this as well, and
[5:11] also the the Agnewal scheme that we have so many things, so many things
[5:15] together and also in Nepal by the way that one country is always sandwiched between
[5:20] the ligies two big power powers of Indian China, and historically I think they've
[5:25] they've complained many times that you know, when your fights and your ego tassels,
[5:29] we seem to be the ones always getting the short of the stake.
[5:32] And this topic especially has Godson to do with that. So too for our
[5:39] listeners and viewers. If you don't know, and this is something not I
[5:44] think like we even obs ever talking before people who don't really closely follow defense.
[5:47] This is one aspect of the recent developments with respect to the Indian military
[5:53] that may have been missed. Uh. Is so the Indian Army has around
[5:58] if my reas is correct, around seven God couragements went on. Seven seven
[6:02] God couragements with the Indian Army, four with the British Army. The obviously
[6:05] she goes back to the British and In Army when they recruited coredcasts from the
[6:10] from from Nepal into the British and In Army. After after independence, seventh
[6:14] stayed backed with in Army and four went to the British at the time of
[6:16] independence, sixth state back with the Indian Army. Okay one was independent was
[6:20] raised later. Right eleven is the one that has been raised post independent.
[6:27] Right, So what's happened apparently there have been some reports about this. What's
[6:30] happened apparently is after the Indian government introduced the Naval scheme, which is like
[6:34] a four year short duty sort of a scheme for soldiers non officers, there
[6:43] has not been much recruitment happening from Nepal in the regiment much. It would
[6:47] be uh inaccurate. There has been no no recruitment happening. The genesis of
[6:53] that, apparently is an agreement between the Britain, India and Nepal, and
[7:00] Nepal says that the terms of Abia. I wouldn't go in the technicalities of
[7:02] it, but basically what Nepal is saying is key. We were supposed to
[7:06] be sending also just to your armies, and they were supposed to be coming
[7:10] after retirement with their pensions in hand. So that's because because all of that
[7:14] because of Ignibal, might not be possible. And if a soldier now goes
[7:16] and needs to come come back after four years, then Nepal will have to
[7:20] figure out employment for a man as a country. For them, it's not
[7:24] for them. It's not a military matter, yeah, but a much bigger
[7:29] issue because the Indian Army is a big employer, has been a big employer
[7:34] for young brave men from Nepal and also looks after their families because pensions are
[7:42] being paid yes to those families. Yes. And again, just like in
[7:46] any other regiments, it becomes a tradition for young boys to you know,
[7:51] follow the footsteps of their forefathers. So similar is the case there. And
[7:56] so they feeling that this is not the most opportune thing to have happened,
[8:01] and and they're not not very happy about it. And somehow China's involved.
[8:07] So China comes to the picture with this idea, and I think this has
[8:11] been This is something that China's wanted for a while. They've also wanted to
[8:13] Recruiturkhas post sixty two. Actually it's not something which is a new thing.
[8:18] They've been fascinated by the idea of Gurkhas being part of the army, not
[8:24] just China. In nineteen forty seven, even Pakistan claimed that some part of
[8:30] the Gurkhas should be with them with their army. Although that I don't think
[8:33] they really pressed their case because at that point of time, I think their
[8:37] priorities were different. But yes there was a thought I have read about it.
[8:43] But Nepal was very clear that they will not want to join the Pakistan
[8:46] Army, so they were not too keen either way. So maybe that was
[8:50] the reason that the Pakistanis didn't press their case. Didn't want to be embarrassed
[8:56] and red faced being told that sorry, but no, thank you, we
[9:01] are happy here. Yeah. Right. So China has been eyeing the good
[9:03] cause of Nepal for a while and now a new theory has developed. I'm
[9:07] not sure how much of it has actually happened on the diplomatic level between China
[9:13] and Nepal. And and et cetera. But there's a new theory doing the
[9:15] rounds thatt with with the good cause not going to the new Army because of
[9:20] the embargo China might kind of, you know, become an alternative for the
[9:26] good cause of Nepal. We'll come to that a bit later. Let's let's
[9:31] just you know, lighten up the first. I shouldn't be answering this question
[9:37] because I know people from all regiments, so I will not answer which is
[9:41] my favorite Indian Army regiment? But you should give it a show. Would
[9:45] haven't come on? I was literally just going to go through that question,
[9:48] and he shot me, you should give a shot, and you should list
[9:50] your top three, if not five, and if you can just explain why,
[9:56] what's the fascination to three would be a bit much? I'll just I
[10:00] just bu see. I'll tell Uki, I've always been fashioned with the gold
[10:01] couragement, always since since the time I started reading up about in military in
[10:07] an army, since when I was in my by trying to join this over
[10:11] two hundred years old, by the way, being fifteen is when the it
[10:13] was raised. Yeah, so fascinated by it. But there are older regiments
[10:18] than this also I think, if I'm not wrong, this Sagas started in
[10:24] seventeen fifties, seventeen thirties, forties fifties, So there are older regiments than
[10:30] the Gold Cars. If you thought that the gods are really old, they
[10:33] are very old. I mean two hundred plus years is yeah, But there
[10:37] are regiments that were raised before. All right, But you know too,
[10:41] I to answer your question point line, I would just like it would be
[10:43] good cause because I don't know. Just think. The moment you ask a
[10:46] question like that, the image of the Gold Regiment just pops up in my
[10:50] head. So are you you do you think of like really fierce guys,
[10:56] really brave? I want you to answer them, because what's the image that
[11:00] you have? Then I'll I'll tell you what I've what I've seen and what
[11:03] I've felt. Well, the walker I comes to mind, by the way,
[11:07] ay Godkhali, which means come, that comes to mind. And the
[11:13] image of a very fierce fighter comes to mind, who's not perhaps who didn't
[11:18] look like a fierce fighter, but fights very fiercely when he has to fight.
[11:22] That's sort of them. I think you're on the right track. Sometimes
[11:26] I feel, how can these guys be soldiers. They look so specific.
[11:33] Is that is the word they are in peace and you would say that fighting
[11:37] in fierce warriors and then extremely polite. I think in the in the army.
[11:43] I could be wrong. This is just sort of my experience of seeing
[11:48] different regiments, hearing of story, hearing stories from officers people. I think
[11:56] they they should be given the term of a sensitive warrior, which nobody talks
[12:00] about. They are the most sensitive guys or gurkhas may galili An officer if
[12:07] he uses a swear word or something, the soldiers will not rebel, but
[12:13] they take it too heart. Wow, So you are supposed to be very
[12:18] well mannered there is unlike in some other regiments where it's a norm. Nobody
[12:24] takes it too heart. It's fine, it's just but sensitive guys, okay.
[12:28] And that's just stands out about them that we keep on hearing. They'll
[12:33] take out their cookery and you know, do all sorts of things. But
[12:37] they speak I less have They only speak when spoken to, don't don't ask
[12:43] many questions. And again I mean, you'd be surprised. Why am I
[12:48] stressing on the word sensitive. They are? So that's that's for me that
[12:52] stands out for that's why they are something get into that fascinating sort of brackett
[13:01] for me, because they're completely opposite to what the world thinks they would be.
[13:05] Perhaps, yeah, that perhaps that's probably why this this regiment is so
[13:07] so talked about. I mean, the enigma of this regiment and even the
[13:11] officers you know, they uh, they think of themselves as as the cream,
[13:18] you know, the real officers and the officer of commanded, the officers
[13:22] of yea of the regiment. Yeah, so they're also different and they feel
[13:28] that there's a term og olive green comes from the uniform. So it said
[13:33] that Gurkh officers are most og most olive greens, and they are most particular
[13:37] about about their mess rules, about their protocols, etc. They're they're as
[13:46] army as an army and kid basically just like you know, the disciplines trigged.
[13:50] So that's that's the things they are different. Yeah. Yeah, So
[13:54] this regiment has a has a storied history which you know we'll talk about.
[13:58] And just that you because you mentioned officers Manic Show. Yeah, Salm Manic
[14:01] Show one of the in one of India's only two field marshals and also chief
[14:05] during nineteen seventy one and the first Chief of Defense Staff of the in the
[14:09] military was also the current CDs. Oh general he's also, oh, I
[14:16] did not do that. So and the famous quote of Field Marshal salm Manick
[14:24] show that if somebody says they're they're not scared, they're either lying or there
[14:31] or he's a gore car Oh nice salm Manic show. I had a thing
[14:37] about giving these great quotable quotes. So he happened when I happened to be
[14:41] from his school. He doesn't happen to be from my school. So in
[14:46] the school old school magazines, yeah, I'm sure they're still there. I
[14:52] came across one of his schoots when he had come as a chief guest when
[14:54] he was the army chief. I think it was nineteen sixty nine and nineteen
[14:58] seventies. So I had this. Since I like history, I also used
[15:03] to, you know, go to this room and look at old books magazines
[15:07] of my school because my school also had a really really old history, if
[15:13] I can say so, over one hundred and fifty years old. When I
[15:16] was in school, it was over one hundred and twenty five years old then.
[15:20] So I came across this court when his speech to the students that I
[15:24] learned how to hate my enemy right here in Sherwood thanks to Saint Joseph's next
[15:30] door. So that was the neighborhood school in the neighborhood, you know that
[15:33] the enemy school that rival read. So, yeah, the guy had a
[15:37] you know, he was he had away with coming up with these schootable courts.
[15:41] Nice we know, speak of General Field Marsh Sorry it's Sam Manick.
[15:46] Just like some thoughts struck me. And this harks back to our previous episode.
[15:50] Last episode we talked about uniforms and we did mention how the good Car
[15:54] officers have a hat and not a big cap like most officers. General Rabat
[16:00] and General that will Bill, there will be Sauha also again, so when
[16:06] I think of them, I can remember their photos wearing the tilted hats.
[16:11] But I can't remember a Sam Mani show picture where he's wearing a hat.
[16:14] I always remember of him wearing a the normal cap. Can you yeah,
[16:19] is it? Can you think? Why just thought of it? Because you
[16:22] know, because uniforms last last week, last week, so just suddenly get
[16:26] to mind. Maybe perhaps was at the time when the Indinet we had a
[16:30] common uniform for senior officers. Maybe, I don't know. I don't think
[16:33] so. I don't think so. The hat has been around for a while.
[16:37] Well, if any one from the army or the that's a good one.
[16:40] Industry of defenses in the department some military history geek. Yeah, maybe
[16:47] if you can find out a photo, because I can't think of a single
[16:48] If I google Sam Manager, I'm pretty sure I won't find a photo of
[16:52] him in a tilted hat. So let's see if something someone comes with something,
[16:56] right, So bang on first question and that I want to ask you
[17:00] about Gourkas. And I thought I'll always ask this to you whenever we talked
[17:03] to this topic. What's the thing about them? Because what you just kind
[17:08] of said, India accepted them, the British Army also wanted them. Pakistan
[17:14] was kind of fine in China as you knowing them for a while. So
[17:18] what is it about these Gurkhas that make them these fears? And to say
[17:22] that they are good fighters and all that would be a cliche. I will
[17:26] want to get into all of that, because of course there is if one
[17:30] sees the history even but again, you know, it would be unfair to
[17:33] other regiments they've been gallantry awards yes with other regiments, yeah, but generally
[17:40] very discipline a lot extremely I think discipline comes to them naturally. Okay,
[17:44] that way they stand out. Again maybe in other regiments it's instilled trained,
[17:49] yeah, but for them it's a way, natural way of doing things.
[17:55] And again the terrain that they come from, natural sons of the soil,
[18:00] mountainous today in jungles for us. Again, natural fighters for those kind of
[18:07] places. So that's what I think makes them extremely wanted. And the British
[18:11] actually was if you again get into the history, how did the Gurkhas get
[18:17] into the British army es So it was during the Anglo Nepal War where it
[18:23] was some there was there was some some of the defectors who first from the
[18:27] Nepalese side got into the British forces. That wasn't a very formalized kind of
[18:33] a setup. They were more like a militia who started fighting for the British.
[18:38] And that's when the British realized that these gays are got gifted natural and
[18:45] that's when the Gurkha regiment was raised in eighteen fifteen. Slowly the number of
[18:51] regiments kept on increasing. You had several battles in pre independent India, just
[18:59] about all the Anglo Maratta wars, you name it, they were, they
[19:04] were part of action. And in the First World War they were part of
[19:07] action. Second World War they were part of action, and then post independent
[19:11] India once again they've been. They've been. They're in almost all major conflicts
[19:18] that we have seen. So just to put their history in brief, that's
[19:23] how it started. And yeah, I mean extremely proud lot. As I
[19:30] said, officers also take a lot of pride in them. And are they
[19:34] what is you know, generally referred to other warrior class in the typical definition
[19:40] of that term, which basically would mean like they just have a history of
[19:44] fighting for armies. I mean, it's difficult to say when I don't know,
[19:48] I mean, our gourkhas a warrior class. I don't know. I
[19:49] don't know if to answer, whether we can say yes or no. But
[19:55] yeah, they're natural naturally sort of built. When they're not huge, they're
[20:02] swift, okay, very unlike you know, tall broad culsar troop, so
[20:08] they have other you know, capabilities. They might be short, but they'll
[20:14] be strong because of the terrains that they come from. They're good. They're
[20:18] good at running naturally physically athletic kind of and very very agile and swift.
[20:26] So when yeah, those are natural capabilities that a soldiers should have, and
[20:32] I think yes, they do tick those boxes. So when you when you
[20:36] say that they're they're fierce fighters, is it just physical prowess or is it
[20:41] also that they have their strategic bent of mind which makes them a depth See,
[20:45] I know nobody has a strategic bent of mind. I would say all
[20:49] that comes with training, and obviously that's what professional militaries do. They train
[20:55] you to be professionals and not to be fighters. There's a difference, isn't
[21:00] it. There will be so many street fighters, but that's the difference.
[21:03] So, yes, they are natural athletes, which is a big plus for
[21:07] any army, and extremely disciplined. As I said that, that's something that
[21:14] stands out and again I'm hopping on it. Their sensitivity is I think that's
[21:19] that's a potent weapon. Turns out to be a potent weapon for them because
[21:22] that sensitivity is somewhere linked to their discipline. That is, you know then
[21:34] that that triggers sort of the urge to get back at you and not in
[21:41] a revengeful manner, but sort of justice. So I think they think that
[21:45] way. I'm not a gorkh Off, sir, I'm not the right guy
[21:48] to be speaking on their behalf. But you must definitely the kind of wives
[21:52] that I've got in the stories that I've heard. Yeah, So have you
[21:56] been to Nepal? I have? So have you been able to relate what
[22:00] we were just discussing right now with the kind of the society over there and
[22:03] explain? Because you know you say that you know you well since you love
[22:07] history and you love the military, so you obviously when you had gone there,
[22:11] you must have been thinking about what is it about this place that you
[22:14] know? I actually have a lot of friends in Nepal, again, going
[22:15] back to my school day, a lot of guys who came from Nepal Okay
[22:19] and they had a history and there were two three families for them, it
[22:22] was a tradition to send their kids to the school. So I've been to
[22:27] Nepal several times and see what you talk of Nepal as a nation and the
[22:34] army the gurkhas serving in the Indian Army. It's not like that if you
[22:38] speak to a normal Nepalese, they can be critical of India. So you
[22:47] don't think that everybody in Nepal is saying all Indians have this when several politicians
[22:52] have been quite critical of India. Yeah, and all of those politicians,
[22:56] many of those politicians have studied there and the thing, yes, and their
[23:00] Nepalese so their interests come first. So the point that I'm trying to say
[23:04] is it will not happen even if there is a say, a neighborhood where
[23:11] only Hura soldiers live. So this uh divided loyalty and allegiance is something that
[23:21] comes naturally to them because not every not every nepales is joining the DNA army.
[23:26] The ones who are again have their allegiance, as I've said before,
[23:30] first to their pultan and then then to India. Yes, so their allegiance.
[23:34] Yes, they are extremely respectful of India, thankful of India. Obviously
[23:38] that at the end of their India as their employer. They're salaried because of
[23:44] the government of India. They're getting pensions because of the government of India.
[23:47] So of course that gratitude and respect is there. But it's not that all
[23:52] of Nepal, you know, sings praises of India, is right? And
[23:56] what about your interactions with these means, the good couragements, what's like,
[24:02] what's like the one or two memory that you still hold and the moment I
[24:06] say it, that's the thing you recorded colla I had gone there and this
[24:08] had happened, anything like that. See, they're very extremely simple guys.
[24:14] And as I said that, if something is not clear, they will not
[24:19] see a clarification. I'll give you an example. My uncle was a go
[24:27] as well. So this is as a child. So he was commanding a
[24:32] brigade in Kasali. So we were going somewhere. So somebody asked a person
[24:36] who's driving gurkha soldier? Just a query. An officer asked that how far
[24:41] is this place from here? You didn't answer. After some time this officer
[24:48] realized there's a story that where are we going? Said you asked how far
[24:51] is that place? So he was going in that direction to the simple question
[24:57] how far is this place going there? So they're they're very very simple guys,
[25:03] lovely guys, lovely and they don't look like soldiers, so they're not
[25:08] wearing a uniform. You will say this guy cannot be a soldier. But
[25:14] yeah, nothing. Don't take don't go go buy this deception. They can
[25:19] be quite deadly. So if somebody thinks that they can sort of get have
[25:22] their way with a it's not going to happen. In the film Eloc there
[25:27] is there is a scene where p posthumous. Of course he's he was a
[25:36] Gourka officer again. So he comes with his Pulton and he briefs. He
[25:41] gives a brief to the people. He who's who who, His pelton is
[25:45] relieving tension. So yeah, those kinds of things are there with them.
[25:53] Is the is this regiment has storied within the army as well, because you
[25:59] know you briefly mentioned all of them. All of them are if you if
[26:02] you if you tell Rajare for a sick or a sickly or a Maratha,
[26:08] any regiment that your history is less cool. No, they won't get offended.
[26:15] They will counter it, okay, saying that how is it less right?
[26:21] So that is I think that's more a civilian thing. That's why coming
[26:25] to like Yeah, but as I said that the gas are more og,
[26:27] more olive, green, more try to be most spick and span, most
[26:33] organized, most suave in the in their demeanor, which other regiments sometimes,
[26:41] you know, don't pay attention to those kind of things. Maybe maybe that's
[26:47] a British thing. Maybe, but again you know the other regiments actually yeah
[26:52] British I mean, so maybe maybe it's again just thinking on their behalf.
[26:59] Maybe it's the fact that this is the only regiment that's there with the Indian
[27:03] Army and the British Army. I think that that could be one of the
[27:07] X factors school factors associated with them. So talking about that, how how
[27:12] like so in terms of the practicality of the situation, how is it decided?
[27:17] I mean not decided. Perhaps is the wrong work, but how does
[27:19] it work both the British and the Indian Army and by the just the Naples
[27:23] Army as well. Recruiting works they take this from this particular region, the
[27:29] people go to the Indian Army and then so again I should clarify this,
[27:33] not at least the Indian Army. It's not as if each and every Gourkha
[27:40] regiment has one hundred percent recruits the police recruits. There about sixty to seventeen
[27:45] apoligic recruits. The rest come from in fact, when the regiment was raised
[27:55] back in eighteen fifteen. That was the idea to have soldiers from the Hills,
[28:00] which included present day and Nepal. So it was to have guys from
[28:07] the hills. That's that was the concert. Now let's you know, we
[28:11] moved to the reason I actually want to talk about this topic this week,
[28:15] but we do that after a quick break. Also, I have been born
[28:25] and brought up in a metro city, so this one time my first really
[28:29] really really horrible break up which like almost ended my life. So that person
[28:33] was from a tier three sort of town, not even a city or a
[28:37] sort of like town. And because he had studied in metro cities, lived
[28:40] in metro cities, worked in metro city as I thought that, you know,
[28:42] I obviously one when one is educated, you tend to think that they
[28:47] overcome wherever they come from or whatever. So we were really happy. You're
[28:51] planning on getting married, spending the rest of our lives together, parents met
[28:53] and everything. So it was very very serious and long term as well,
[28:56] and it didn't end well. It was horrendous and within three months of that
[29:00] he ended up getting married to someone his parents want for him. Okay,
[29:02] and the biggest issues his parents had with him with me was what I was
[29:07] wearing, the way I spoke, wow, things like that because of where
[29:10] they came from. It was very like But honestly, I mean, you
[29:14] escaped it, Yeah, you got really rescued. Yeah, but so scarred
[29:18] from that that I'm probably like scarred for life. Also, I've noticed it's
[29:22] not just like a small town thing. I've faced the same thing here as
[29:26] well. Yeah, I've heard utter English ungraz Bolk accentive. But back then,
[29:33] being in a place like Bangalore, I could not understand that mentality.
[29:36] But that hurt me so much that I vowed to never ever date someone who
[29:41] was from like a not a metrocity. For more insights into the A to
[29:45] Z of the dating world, tune into The Rights Wife every Friday. Catch
[29:48] us on Spotify, Apple podcasts, Google podcasts, and other audio streaming platforms.
[30:04] Welcome back, Abih and are talking about the Army's regiment, and now
[30:11] we'll move on to how we've We've spent the first half of this episode discussing
[30:17] the history of this regiment, fascinating history, just like every other regiment of
[30:22] the An Army, and I think you should do this more often by the
[30:23] every few episodes, maybe maybe we can get an officer from yeah regiments and
[30:30] just talk about their history and everything. But the gurkhas as something we wanted
[30:34] to talk about this week is because they led very closely to one significant development
[30:40] with respect to the military policy vicision that was taken recently and the ongoing China
[30:45] crisis at the border that we've spent several episodes talking about the policy decision being
[30:51] agnew. So before the break we spoke about how because of the scheme under
[30:56] which Indian Army will be in in all three M four will be recruiting none
[31:02] off soldiers for a four year sort of a period, twenty five percent of
[31:06] whom would be retained. The others would be like you know, gradually backed
[31:08] in civilian life without any pensions. This is the part which Nepal has an
[31:15] issue with because for Napal, it would been accepting uh, youngsters essentially who've
[31:19] spent four years in the military without any pension to ka for future. Yeah.
[31:25] Yeah, I mean, it's a it's a serious issue, serious issue.
[31:26] It makes sense actually, you know, to be fair without you know,
[31:30] I mean, I don't want to take sites, but we fair.
[31:32] It's a serious issue and uh, so was this aspect ever considered during the
[31:37] planning See Frankly, I don't think anybody ever thought that Nepal will have a
[31:41] problem hard because I think this is what happened. It was for granted kind
[31:45] of a situation, and I don't know if anything is happening to find a
[31:51] middle path and now resolution even now. In fact, a little while earlier,
[31:56] the Army chief had said that if if they if they're not going to
[32:00] join, then they will have to divert the weakendcies to other regiments. So
[32:05] does that mean if this doesn't stop, will the good hornagement see the end
[32:09] of the day or will you have people from various other regions joiningagement. So
[32:21] for that to happen, the numbers might drastically come down, because as I
[32:24] said earlier before the break that it's not that one hundred percent un please,
[32:29] it's about sixty sixty sixty five percent. So thirty thirty five percent are still
[32:34] coming from within India. So the situation might not be as bad as it
[32:38] seems as far as recruitment to these regiments is concerned. And of course there's
[32:43] a big Gurkha population in place. Leg Sitem and West Bengal. Yes,
[32:49] so you can always have I'm sure they come from there as well. Yes.
[32:52] The bigger problem is I think this is turning into a bit of a
[32:58] diplomatic Yeah. And as you mentioned that, you know, China is looking
[33:04] at this as an opportunity to play some games. In fact, I'll have
[33:08] you a very interesting story much before the agniv scheme, I did a report
[33:14] in twenty twenty that the Chinese actually conducting study to find out what attracts Nepalese
[33:23] join the Indian army okay, just to study to you know, completely scrutinize,
[33:30] get into their mind and motivations. And see, there's no doubt that
[33:32] China has been influencing Nepal as Yes, and all this started when there was
[33:37] this border dispute that came to the forefront again around twenty twenty. Calash Manser
[33:46] made that road very close to the borders China object again there were murmurs that
[33:54] you know, somebody's pushing them to do it. The current dispensation in Nepah,
[34:00] once again, the Prime Minister of Nepal has made utterances saying that we'll
[34:05] get back the territory that has gone to India, get it back. So
[34:10] there is a simmering and there is a feeling that you know, it's at
[34:15] the behest of China here and there. It's felt that the current prime minister
[34:19] who is close to Nepal, China, China and China Nepal does have a
[34:25] very strong communist background. So that yes, it does, it doesn't when
[34:31] whenever, whenever a communist sort of government, you will have these kinds of
[34:36] things. And there has been a lot of Chinese influence. Again, about
[34:40] a decade back, I remember doing a story report on how Chinese are starting
[34:46] community radio stations in Nepal, how they are distributing literature in Nepal linked to
[34:54] a communism maoism. So China, China has been keeping an on Nepal.
[35:00] Yes, it does feel if they can widen their influence in Nepal, it
[35:06] will help them in a big way. But having said that, it's not
[35:09] so easy because even though there might be some disputes here in there between India
[35:15] and Nepal, I think the history of the two countries, the culture,
[35:22] the religion that overpowers several other political developments that happened. Yeah, I mean,
[35:30] I mean, I for one can't can't see like a gorka soldier in
[35:34] the Chinese Army for the simple reason that it would be a culture shock for
[35:37] them. Yes, because they are culturally much more closer to India compared to
[35:40] China, and China having no history of having them in the first place.
[35:45] I mean, Indian Army at least has a history. So even if there
[35:46] was a cultural difference over the years, I'm guessing that must have must have
[35:51] been enbridged. But with China it would just be a culture So what would
[35:53] the Chinese. I can't even do apart from just working India, by the
[35:55] way, which would be I'm because you said this several times on episode that
[36:00] China just loves to do this, like you know, it loves to like
[36:02] play mine. Yeah, so this is this could be one of the mind
[36:05] games. And I just said that it's since sixty two that they have been
[36:08] eyeing gurkhas to be part of the PLA and it's never happened. I'm talking
[36:14] about culture. You know, all regiments have a very strong cultural affiliation.
[36:19] The gurkhas. The Sarah is a big thing in Nepal. It's bigger than
[36:23] the Valia. So when the Shara is celebrated and the run up to the
[36:29] Sara is actually Navara three where most North Indian in those turn vegetarian, but
[36:37] there are parts of India like Bengal where totally the opposite. That happens similarly
[36:43] with Nepalese, they would rather consume more on vegetarian it's festivity and things like
[36:47] that. So a story actually that I can share right now. It is
[36:52] a very good one. I don't know if I've done that before on the
[36:54] podcast. So this about the Gurkha regiment because of the influx of the Indian
[37:01] indianization of the Gurkhas. There was an officer who who was commanding once he
[37:09] narrated the story to me when he was commanding his unit, Gurka unit.
[37:13] So this thing came up that during the Navara three time, let's go vegetarian.
[37:20] So the officer was fixed that you know this, how can this happen?
[37:23] Because if you allow the it's it's playing with tinkering with the culture.
[37:30] And then again there are Gurkha recruits, there are Indian recruits unnecessarily you know,
[37:38] creating a riff. There is that. So he asked the Jesus,
[37:43] do not deal with the situation that find out what's happening. So Jesus was
[37:47] a Nipolis. So he said, yeah, this is an issue. So
[37:52] well, so he said, let's how to deal with it. So he
[37:55] said, I'll manage. He got back to him. He said, it's
[38:00] been managed, but there is still some simmerings are still there is the pundit
[38:07] of the unit. So he said that and that's the North Indian Hindu thing.
[38:15] There was confusion. So he found a solution. He said, okay,
[38:19] if they want to go vegetarian, then also no alcohol. Is this
[38:25] a good good solution to it? Yeah, Syria. So this proposal was
[38:32] made and it was back to normal, and Guessing rejected you. He was
[38:37] back to normal. They said, it's okay. So these are the Yeah,
[38:42] these are the these are the storytelling. Yea, Now I can't imagine
[38:45] this happening. Yeah, yeah, this can't happen, of course. Yeah,
[38:50] but and and how how I just imagine the gas celebrating the share with
[38:54] the Chinese. Yeah exactly. They sacrifice a buff by the way, I
[39:00] think you mentioned this previously once. Yeah, yeah, so they sacrifice a
[39:05] buffalo on the Shara day that's supposed to be the big thing, the big
[39:08] treat. So just imagine with the Chinese, and they'll lose that identity.
[39:15] Also, I'm sure, I'm sure the Gorkas won't want bec with with an
[39:21] army folklore again, but I think folklore become they become the truth when there
[39:28] is no rejecting the fact. Okay, So they wouldn't want to be associated
[39:31] with an army which actually left their positions in a un mission, deserted their
[39:39] locations, and in fact, the Indian army fought where the Chinese were supposed
[39:45] to supposed also also rescued them. Yeah, especially the kind of legacy that
[39:51] the Gorkhas have seen as soldiers. They wouldn't they wouldn't want to be associated
[39:55] in any manner with an army that has this uh sort of blemish. Yes.
[40:04] Also also because you are and this is I think we keep forgetting,
[40:07] not forgetting, but this keeps going missed when we talk about the location of
[40:12] China, is that that population actually isn't the far East. The majority of
[40:16] the of the of the country that borders India is actually just you know,
[40:21] it's just that's empty land, miniscule part. So there has historically, i'm
[40:25] guessing, not been much intermingling off the two populations, so there cannot be
[40:31] like a common culture that leveloped, unlike with India, where the border is
[40:34] almost like you know, you can literally appeen. It's as Indians with an
[40:37] Indian passport, you can just like one. That's sort of sometimes it's a
[40:40] porous border'd free board open borders. It's not porous. Porus is where there
[40:47] are restrictions, but movement is happening illegally as it's not illegal movement. Yeah.
[40:53] In fact, I think, if I'm not wrong, Nepal is not
[40:55] the few countries where you can drive a car, your own car without a
[40:59] without driving license. And also I think employment employment exactly either way, there
[41:04] isn't any We don't need special permits either of the citizens to be employed by
[41:10] at least a private company. I don't know what the rules in the government
[41:15] jobs are, those I think might be might be different, but at least
[41:21] private jobs, schools, colleges, admissions, every other side. I've studied
[41:24] with a lot of Nepanies. Yeah, but of course, again you cannot
[41:29] distrigard the strategic importance of the country, and someone like you who appreciates maps
[41:35] as we all know, would know that really well. And this is something
[41:38] that you know has come up quite frequently of late. And this is again
[41:43] in line with the whole idea that I read about since I was in my
[41:47] late early twenties. I think China's designs sort of circle India the ring of
[41:52] fire, so called ring of fire, Nepal comes, Nepal, Bangladesh,
[41:57] Myanmar, she Lanka downs south and you know, the kind of build these
[42:00] relationships with these countries to kind of so clear Agne presents China with a good
[42:06] opportunity actually that this at least the opportunity to play some kind of a disrupt
[42:12] Yeah, because disruption has happened. Yeah, they can say that, you
[42:15] know when India bt that to you, we were there kind of you know,
[42:17] so that disruption has happened. I don't know how it's being dealt with.
[42:22] So that's my question of why. I don't think it's the Indian Army's
[42:23] job ready to think about the integrities of you know, this diplomatic tassle between
[42:29] India, China and Nepal, it would be the m So my question to
[42:34] you then, uh is I'm would not have been consulted about I'm guessing first
[42:38] of all, right, h so this problem was never foreseen by anybody within
[42:45] the middle system. I'm sure it wasn't foreseen. That's why we are facing
[42:49] a problem. And I differ with you a bit that it's not the Army's
[42:53] problem. Military diplomacy is a very important aspect of today's zeo politics. And
[43:00] if the Indian Army thought that it's not their job, and I guess there
[43:05] was no fast sighted vision, especially because in a scenario like this where they
[43:08] are the main stakeholder, Amy is not the stakeholder. It's the Indian Army
[43:13] which is the stakeholder. I will I will not hazard a guess here.
[43:17] I am not aware. First of all, I'll put it this way.
[43:21] I am not aware whether the Indian Army had taken it up or not.
[43:23] Okay, I'll leave it with that disclaimer. Right, it's possible that I'm
[43:28] not aware. I haven't heard of it heard of it yet. I'm I
[43:31] can't for sure with all certainties say that Indian Army had raised concerns. This
[43:37] also because because this issue hasn't really snowballed into public us such that there's not
[43:42] really a lot of you know, focus or like looking into what exactly happened.
[43:45] Because my thought is that any officer up the chain of command, who's
[43:52] ever you know, who knows about these things, the red flag would immediately
[43:55] go up there, you know. Introdigenous scheme like this would probably mean Maple
[43:58] would say this, which would probably mean there would be a vacancy, whichould
[44:00] probably mean your name of China. That's what I'm saying. When the agne
[44:04] wheel was being talked, I did hear people say, well, what will
[44:07] happen with good cause? So it's not that it completely you know, it
[44:13] was off the radar, right, So it's not that this isn't it.
[44:15] That's why I said, interesting, I will not as hard a guess by
[44:20] saying that it was. We are not sure because I don't know of it.
[44:22] I mean, as I report, that's my failure. I would say
[44:24] I've not been able to get my hands on it, because if I get
[44:29] my hands on it, I think it will be a big story story.
[44:30] Actually, yeah, isn't Actually, yes, I think this is one of
[44:35] the bigger ten episodes we've done, because this is a missing element in our
[44:38] China discussions that we didn't interest. Yes. Yes, And anybody who thinks
[44:43] that the decision of Nepal not sending or taking such a such a strong stand.
[44:50] Again, I mean no sort of ill will against the decision of Nepal.
[44:57] And I could be accused of what I'm going to say now, I
[45:00] could be accused of saying that Nepal is working under influence of China. But
[45:07] yeah, there is there is a very strong possibility. And in the Indian
[45:09] established movement, it's been felt that China is up to some games with what's
[45:15] happening in Nepal over the last few years, and it has actually coincided with
[45:21] Ladak, So there's too much happening. I would differ with you on that
[45:25] point. But I do have a counter to that is that on the face
[45:32] of it, if he's, first of all, if he's talking about the
[45:35] current situation and hand the episode in question about the good cause, Nepal's position
[45:40] does logically make sense. I mean economically, it's a big you know,
[45:44] what happens to those population once it comes back? How do you ensure the
[45:47] live Forget Nepal. This was a concern with Indian people. Indian people,
[45:52] we discussed that exactly. We discussed that at length, and you know,
[45:53] by the way, just to address that, several state governments announced schemes you
[45:58] know, once they come back from the army unsure their jobs in our departments.
[46:02] I don't know what the police government, yeah, address add but but
[46:07] I mean Indian government should have been role in that somewhere the Indian army move
[46:13] again, at least the Indian army should have mooted the idea which and second
[46:20] to your large to your thing, to your point about China playing some games,
[46:23] China being involved on that time might take REALI I mean the consplicit theories.
[46:30] So we know you also have the particle and again there was a Chinese
[46:34] pie starting that nonsense. There is nonsense but crash. Yeah yeah, but
[46:40] by point being, uh so, if China's doing it, why can Indian
[46:44] do be as aggressive? If if China isn't, then China kind of beating
[46:50] India at the game. If China is able to convince catch twenty two,
[46:54] yeah, INDI should step up. Actually having this big Gurgu recruitment was not
[47:02] just a military sort of requirement and history and legacy that we've it was the
[47:12] biggest example of India's middibility diplomacy, biggest example which country allows other than British
[47:20] and in even in Britain are there, but they are there more for legacy
[47:24] and yeah, the tradition, legacy, etc. Which country will allow another
[47:30] country's huge number of population to be serving in your army, that to a
[47:36] neighboring country, which neighbors one of your I mean right now, the biggest
[47:39] trible I would say, one of you biggest trials. I think it was
[47:43] the greatest example of your military diplomacy. And also the fact that the control
[47:49] I think the fact that the other country's population is willing to you know,
[47:53] because you know, normally you joined the army for your like you said,
[47:57] of course your Fulton. If you anything, you'd know that. But the
[48:01] idea being you joined the an An army to serve your nation. But this
[48:04] is your serving someone some other nations. But you're doing it because there is
[48:07] so much history and tradition that you're doing it voluntarily willingly. There's no you're
[48:15] not being forced there, there are no there are no special you know,
[48:20] attractions for people who join. It's exactly the same regiment gets the same salary
[48:24] as in year exactly, so there is pensions. Of course, it takes
[48:30] care of a lot of employment in Nepal, but that's that all the more
[48:35] reason this thing shouldn't have happened that they say we're we're not going to say
[48:39] so when I say, see, it's not the it's not the choice of
[48:44] Gorkhas. It's not a choice that those who who are wanting to be recruited,
[48:51] I'm saying, by their government stopping this. The question that also needs
[48:55] to be answered is the government of Nepal being a hurdle to their own people?
[49:02] Fair enough? Yeah, fair enough? And you know, I think
[49:06] we leave that question hanging, and we'll leave settle more questions hanging on this
[49:09] topic. I'll wait for people like you and your colleagues like Githa Muhan,
[49:14] who also hosts a podcast on our podcast platform, to find out more about
[49:17] this because, like you said, diplomacies involved, militaries involved, and like
[49:22] you said, you're not really aware if there's anything even happening to end of
[49:25] solve this. So Nepala said this, that this is the issue. This
[49:28] is why a lot of clarity needs to come come the Nepolie side as well
[49:31] as well. Of course, of course, yeah, of course, So
[49:34] you know what, why would you stop employment of your own people? Yeah,
[49:39] it's a very simple question. Yeah, So I hope this gets a
[49:43] bit more attention in the coming days, and we'll wait for that before we
[49:46] go. But one last thought from you about again the goods good couragement.
[49:53] During the break, you were talking about how this is the only regiment that
[49:57] has several regiments in the seven in four hours. Yeah. Yeah, so
[50:00] you have the one God card I feels three, God car I feels four,
[50:04] God feel eleven. These are now you explained during the break, how
[50:08] when you normally say, let's say, let's say three gold car I Fields,
[50:12] Normally that would mean the third battalion of the gold Carrival regiment. In
[50:15] this case, it actually just means a regiment. It means the third regiment.
[50:19] It's for three to five. Yeah, then that would mean the third
[50:22] regiment, fifth battalion. So you you will be usually it is like which
[50:30] unit are you from? Somebody will say four, that's a fourth regiment,
[50:35] fourth battalion. Story, fourth battalion of our regiment. Yeah, but in
[50:38] this it's confusing three to five yeah. So you were saying that. You
[50:45] were telling that to me in the context of explaining how many good soldiers are
[50:51] not just one regiment, are separate regiment Indian Army, which then begin shows
[50:54] that the recruitment is so high, so high, which then begs the question
[50:59] I want to end this with exactly how significant are they to the in an
[51:02] army, not just in terms of tradition obviously traditions where we've discussed appet from
[51:07] that, but also strategically, because you said a few minutes ago that the
[51:12] army chief recently made a comment that you know, in case there are vacancies,
[51:15] will divert them to some other regiments, basically hinting at uh that Yeah,
[51:21] okay, fine, if it doesn't happen recruitment, then perhaps the regiments
[51:24] might end. You can't force the things that you can't force country, Yeah,
[51:28] yeah, the government doesn't allow it. If you can't pose that.
[51:30] Yeah, we as a nation cannot cannot pose someone. Of course you do.
[51:35] You'll figure out for it will be vacancies. You will maybe fill in
[51:40] with again people from the Hill States, which are already there. I think
[51:44] most probably the most obvious solutions probably maybe a lot of a lot of people
[51:51] of Nepalese origin who are Indian and try and sort of them get them right.
[51:57] So, yeah, So the point the question, the point of the
[52:00] question being how big a loss. Then is it just a diplomatic loss then
[52:04] or is it a bit more than that. See, in terms of numbers,
[52:07] they can be filled in. That's what that's Yeah, that's what you're
[52:08] saying exactly. It can happen. The loss is more at the diplomatic level.
[52:15] The relations that you have, the legacy history, all that will take
[52:20] a hit, right, But yeah, the diplomatic one is the one I'm
[52:24] interested in. That will have a huge significant impact. Though, I really
[52:29] in this case, I'll like we discuss it out. This question of key
[52:32] China will open up it's army for I think that probably won't. This is
[52:36] one of the theories doing the round theory is doing the rounds and they want
[52:42] to do it. That that's for sure, since it like you said,
[52:44] yeah, we want to do it. But the fact that hasn't happened certainly
[52:49] suggests that it's not something that I mean, it will be for me,
[52:53] the biggest news on military matters if this happens. It affects three countries and
[53:00] this would be a cool sense of China actually manages to do it because it
[53:06] will change a lot of things in Nepal. So it will be a big
[53:09] thing if if they can do it today. Sound might sound like a conspiracy,
[53:15] but yeah, if it happens for me, it's going to be.
[53:17] We might end up discussing several episodes of in our Defense on that a pothetical
[53:23] thing to say. Yeah right, I think let's end it there. Let's
[53:29] watch this topic a bit, Moore, and let's see if you and your
[53:32] colleagues are able to come up with something more on this, because quite fascinating.
[53:37] Actually, I wasn't expecting such a fast I was expecting a good fun
[53:40] chat, a good interesting conversation because you know, history is especially of military
[53:45] regiments, are obviously very rich. But let's just say that whenever China is
[53:52] in the picture, things just go from a different tangent and it just like
[53:54] take a different spin altogether and just become even more interesting, interesting in the
[53:59] sense of, you know, worth watching. It adds a completely different dimension,
[54:02] the China angle to all these discussions and spices up our conversation every time
[54:08] we have something to do with China. And who would have thought that we
[54:13] would end up discussing a bit of China. Yes, discussing India, yeah,
[54:19] true, through that and you know, for our listeners and viewers again,
[54:23] let us know what he thought of this episode. We have fun when
[54:28] we discussed things like these. I just want to know if you also have
[54:30] fun new let us know. Proper texts to us at eight tin doable six
[54:32] double nine six, or an email to us at pots at the rate in
[54:36] rata dot com. Let's be ods at the rate in ate dot com.
[54:38] You can also drop us a rating for whatever podcast platform you're listening to us
[54:43] on Exapple Podcast, Google Podcast, Spotify, etc. Thanks to our producer
[54:46] and upstening and a sound because a couple they've seen our video coordinator, Checky
[54:52] Lemon. That's it for the Speak Defense Doors for more Union next week.
[54:55] Let's stay safe and not cross any boundaries without a passport.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
