# Retaking Pakistan-occupied Kashmir a pipe dream or very much a possibility? | In Our Defence, S02, Ep 24

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 16 May 2024, 47 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/60059691/16_may_24_iod_16_may_128.mp3

The election season in India is heating up, and the rhetoric around Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir (PoK) is becoming increasingly prominent among politicians. No surprises there! Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma recently addressed opposition allegations of constitutional changes by emphasising the government's focus on integrating PoK into India. Echoing this sentiment, Union Home Minister Amit Shah affirmed that PoK is "part of India", highlighting that people across the border in PoK are calling for freedom. Since May 10, PoK has been experiencing significant unrest, with traders protesting against high electricity and food prices. Similar protests occurred in August 2023 over high electricity bills. External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar commented on the ongoing unrest, contrasting the situation in PoK with the relative stability in Jammu and Kashmir. In this episode, host Dev Goswami and defence expert Shiv Aroor delve into the history and politics surrounding PoK. They discuss whether the topic of Pakistan still resonates with Indian voters and examine the feasibility of politicians' claims about reclaiming PoK. Are these assertions even possible? The duo explores the practicality of India potentially reclaiming PoK and managing the aftermath. How realistic is it? What hypothetical actions or operations might India undertake, and what strategic or other purposes would these serve? Tune in! Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound mix by Sachin Dwivedi

## Transcript

[0:00] This is India Today podcasts. Let's put all the disclaimers to bed and say,
[0:08] if an order comes in politically saying go out and bring back, don't
[0:11] come back until you've got Poka. Now, obviously this is not going to
[0:15] be a you know, an army specific operation because we live in a in
[0:19] a world that where all warfare is is hybrid. But I still hold that
[0:25] what Rajanath saying has echoed, you know, from from many previous ministers and
[0:30] prime ministers have said in the past as well that the impulse of Pok coming
[0:34] back to India will involve the military as a catalyst. The real fight will
[0:38] be happening in Pok itself. When it comes to Pakistan, manaishankarayers problem has
[0:44] never been you know, speaking the reality or speaking you know, facts and
[0:48] things like that. His problem is timing. His problem is saying it right
[0:51] before an election. But Manashankara all is in completely in love with himself and
[0:56] he thinks he's an intellectual giant. You know. If he doesn't way in
[1:00] on India and Pakistan, the world will be incomplete. Hello and welcome to
[1:04] Another Defense, a weekly podcast on all things well defense, where I they've
[1:11] go Swami, your host, along with senior journalist Shivarur, break down the
[1:15] world of conflicts that range from the subtle to the brutal. We bring you
[1:19] nuances and perspectives that will inform and at times provoke. This is In Our
[1:26] Defense. Hello, and welcome the twenty fourth episode of In Our Defense.
[1:36] We are right bang in the middle of the Grand In election, a topic
[1:40] I thought actually won't come up purduing our chats shift in the lead up in
[1:44] the runner because I was actually hoping for In Our Defense to be this one
[1:47] hour of you know, peace for us, the two of us, away
[1:49] from the routine, daily routine of newsroom coverage, covering politics, covering speeches,
[1:53] covering rallies, et cetera. But today's going to come up, actually
[1:57] because the topic of a discussion has come a lot in the run up to
[2:00] the elections. We are recording this on a Wednesday. Four phases have been
[2:05] done, done and dusted, three more to go. They're right there.
[2:07] But before that, welcome, Hi, How is your week? Seventy percent
[2:13] of the election done, and like I said, the end is finally in
[2:15] sight. So that's the only thing on my mind right now, right,
[2:19] So we'll talk about Pakistan occupied Kashmir, a topic that's come up a lot
[2:23] in the election, come up during the election campaign, actually playing campaign exactly.
[2:27] And also there have been a protest going on. The protesting now have
[2:30] been kind of called called off. I like I said, we record on
[2:31] a Wenesday and I think on Tuesday the protests were called off after some sort
[2:36] of agreement between the protesters and the government. The protestan mostly do with high
[2:40] prices, food prices, electricity prices, et cetera, et cetera. Won't
[2:44] get into that. We'll talk about Parkistan occupied Kashmir. So in what context
[2:47] does it come up? Several ministers of the more the government, a Homemage
[2:52] Rami, Defense ministras Thing, Foreign Minister Ja Shankar, and I think today
[2:55] it was also some Chiefness him and the biscers Rama have said that Pakistan occupied
[3:00] kashmeas are and we will take it back. Nothing wrong with that statement that's
[3:05] been you know, Actually it's a bit funny when people tend to be surprised
[3:08] with the statements, you know, because just like you know, our previous
[3:14] episode is real Palestine, just like India's position on Palestine, Indians possion on
[3:17] POK has been consistent throughout all right throughout across governments, no matter head by
[3:23] b JP of Congress. We have always said in Parliament, outside Parliament that
[3:28] Pakistan occupied kashmeas Ares and you know we have we have an obligation to take
[3:32] it back, right, But what I want to actually talk about is the
[3:36] practicality, uh and whether it's even realistic to you know, take Pok back.
[3:42] But we'll get to that a bit later. First, I want to
[3:45] know, deviate from defense altogether and talk politics. You know, we have
[3:47] many better experts in this building and outside, but since we both cover news
[3:53] on a daily basis, I think we are allowed to have our opinion as
[3:55] well. First tell me, do you really think Pakistan the pick of Pakistan
[4:00] sells to the Indian water or in today's day? And is because I've always
[4:03] thought it's very interesting that PMOD in a recent interview said that you know,
[4:06] I I've dealt with Pakistan, ohyam, but love, you know, we
[4:10] don't have to worry about Pakistan because they can't even manage to get two plates
[4:13] of food on there on the table, So I don't have to worry about
[4:15] it yet you have his ministers, you know, bring up Pakistan, bring
[4:18] up Pakistan Qubu kush Median rallies and speeches and interviews. Do you think,
[4:23] you know, talking politics, that the issue of Pakistan is still alive or
[4:27] is it just like you know one last you know, he tous. You
[4:30] know, I come from a school of thought that believes that Pakistan will always
[4:33] be an issue for Indians. Okay, you'd probably have to go forward another
[4:39] two or three generations for Pakistan to ceaze to you know, be in a
[4:42] sort of mind space. You know, you and I probably belonged to that
[4:45] last generation where it's where it's it's actually an emotive issue. You know,
[4:49] when I talk to my daughter, for instance, who's now old enough to
[4:51] understand these things, Uh, there's not even a flicker of uh, this
[4:58] the same kind of sentiment or emotion that un fields, you know when one
[5:00] talks about Pakistan. But Pakistan is a potent political jews as far as Indian
[5:06] elections are concerned. I don't think it has lost that potency. When the
[5:10] Prime Minister says, you know Jo Karnatha gurm Whu's Kemara, all that stuff
[5:15] has happened. But you know, I want to there are two things I
[5:20] want to clarify before I answer your question. They won. There is this
[5:25] fallacy, okay about the twenty nineteen election where Balakote happened. And we've spoken
[5:30] extensively about what happened in Balakot. There are many political pundits who suggest that
[5:35] twenty nineteen was a Balacote election. That because India attacked after Pulwama, India
[5:42] attacked Balacote and suddenly the narrative Badhal Yadha, it went from being a normal
[5:47] issue election to a Musbooth Nathan nationalism, patriotism, Sabak Sikhya, Pakistan Coote
[5:54] type election. I'm very, very skeptical about that because I actually think that
[6:00] that is a bit of a cowardly cop out for what I believe were was
[6:06] a pretty standard election being fought on various issues, most definitely on leadership and
[6:14] you know the image of Modi versus Rahul Gandhi ra Al Ghandi at all but
[6:16] projected himself as the Prime minister at that time. But I think the several
[6:23] failures of the opposition to really consolidate into a real challenge to Modi were explained
[6:29] away by political pundits as the Balakote effect. You know, since the Balakot
[6:33] thing happened, therefore, therefore the opposition didn't stand a chance, as if
[6:36] to suggest that without Ballakot the opposition stud a chance, which is in my
[6:41] view ridiculous. So that that's one question which kind of partially answers your question
[6:46] about the effect that Pakistan has in terms of the Indian psyche. My second
[6:50] answer is that Pakistan matters to voters in some parts of the country there's Punjab.
[6:58] In places like Punja, for instance, the Punjab factor matters enormously because
[7:02] there it is you know there. It's not only because you know, there's
[7:06] a shared border, et cetera. But there are historical reasons why Pakistan continues
[7:12] to be a motive issue. So obviously politically and otherwise sociologically, Pakistan is
[7:16] very relevant issue as far as India is concerned. Finally, my final point
[7:20] is there's a difference between talking about Pakistan and a difference beeen talking about pok
[7:26] Totally different things, two totally different things. Pakistan is the other the enemy.
[7:30] You know, we've shown them a lesson. They have tried to bleed
[7:33] us, and we've taught them a lesson using the Oi surgical strikes and balakot.
[7:38] That's for political effect. Pok is about what is rightfully India's it's about.
[7:44] It's about, you know, articulating a sentiment that has literally been there
[7:49] from the time of independence October nineteen forty seven is when the you know,
[7:54] the line of control was formed after you know, when when Pok was occupied
[7:59] by Pakistan. That point of time, that sentiment is literally as old as
[8:01] this country. For Pok and therefore expressing the expressing the will to bring Pok
[8:09] back, you know, rejoin Pok with the rest of Kashmir and the rest
[8:13] of India is hardly new. We hear it every now and there in every
[8:18] election. This time it's become a little more it's become a little more voluble,
[8:22] yes, because you've got big ministers sort of saying it almost in a
[8:26] kind of organized fashion. You know, doctor Ja Shankar Rajanat saying Ahmed Shah
[8:31] Himanta like you said, They're all saying it. So it seems like,
[8:35] you know, people people who hear it will wonder is there something afoot or
[8:39] is there some plan. I just want to remind everyone we have an election
[8:41] going on. Okay, we will get into the into the into the practicality
[8:48] of these of these claims and these assertions. And remember the not a single
[8:52] thing that any of these ministers have said is wrong exactly, they are completely
[8:56] one hundred percent the India's officials stand as far as POK is concerned. And
[9:00] that is the reality of it. So let's let's differentiate those two things.
[9:03] But the practicality of executing it or letting it happen is a different question,
[9:09] That's all I'm saying. And we will get that question. In fact,
[9:13] I'm going to get Shift to do what he did a few episodes ago when
[9:16] you're talking about China, and he did this sort of war gaming the invasion
[9:20] of tibetan of Tibet. Yeah, so I'm going to get you to do
[9:22] that same thing for Pakistan occupied Kashmir. But before that, before that,
[9:28] sure, so I get the reason why I prefer to begin with the politics
[9:31] of it, because the two are interling. So sure, I get the
[9:33] politics of it. I get you know, it's an a motive issue for
[9:37] a certain section of people, especially certain areas of northern India. But is
[9:43] the idea or does occupying or reoccupying Pakistan occupied Kashmir make any strategic sense.
[9:48] Let's again keep the practicality aside from now we'll get to that the reality of
[9:54] it. But strategically in terms of when you look at the map of Jumpoint
[9:56] cush Me, when you look at the locations of on on the northern side,
[10:01] you have what is what Pakistan called the Azad Jamukashmir on the left hand
[10:05] side, western side, does that area hold any value any value to us
[10:11] because of important bit that we need to remember is that this part that we're
[10:16] talking about, the Pakistan Kaba Kashmia technically speaking physically was never with independent India.
[10:20] It was always part of the Jamukashmir princely state. When Pakistan invaded,
[10:24] the king of the time Harisi signed the instrumental sessions based on which India sent
[10:30] in troops and then there was a war. Then there was a un Manadachis
[10:31] fare which resulted in what we now know as the Line of Control, which
[10:35] was more or less formalized in the seventy one Shiml Agreement after the seventy one
[10:39] war. So India has never physically occupied Pakistan Kubat custrit. It's always Pakistan
[10:45] be in there, so I would also see that that place would have become
[10:48] very intertwined with Pakistan's establishment, with Pakistan's you know, internal structures, whatever
[10:54] governance you have in terms of human culture, or to an extent, because
[10:58] terms of demographic demograph exactly exactly, so does this place hold any strategic value
[11:03] to us? Apart from the emotivate, the harsh reality of Pakistan occupied Kashmir
[11:09] is that since nineteen forty seven, the population percentage of kashmiri is there has
[11:16] shrunk to a single digit. It's between eight and nine percent, possibly less.
[11:20] A large part of the demographic in POK are other ethnicities from Pakistan,
[11:24] including Pakistani, Punjab and elsewhere. If you ask about let's keep aside the
[11:31] obvious answer, which is that the reason why Pok should be part of India
[11:35] is because because that's the right thing, and that's the way it should be,
[11:37] and it's part of Kashmir, and therefore Kashmir is part of India,
[11:41] and there's no question this way or that way. But let's talk strictly about
[11:43] the strategic value, Like you said, enormous strategic value. Enormous strategic value,
[11:50] for instance, with a whole KASHMIRI, which includes Pok, India has
[11:56] a border with Afghanistan. India completely negates China's advantage in the northern areas which
[12:05] it currently has access to. The Karakorum Range north of Siachen, et cetera,
[12:09] are places where India has been slightly at a disadvantage owing to owing to
[12:15] China's occupation of Tibet, the Chinese access access routes into into Pakistan occupied Kushmi,
[12:22] the northern areas Gilget Baltistan area, and the rest of Pakistan via Pakistan
[12:28] occupied Kashmir and the Gilgate Baltistan areas would be completely negated. And these are
[12:31] very important routes for the Chinese. Uh So, therefore you would it would
[12:37] be a strategic counter to things that China has been setting in stone for decades
[12:41] together, So it would be a huge blow to them. If let's theoretically
[12:45] assume that suddenly, overnight Pok has re merged with India, so the strategic
[12:50] values enormously there. The line of control ceases to exist. Your entire frontier
[12:54] becomes one big international border, which brings its own implications as far as international
[13:01] diplomacy are concerned. The United nations are concerned, et cetera. Kashmir becomes
[13:05] whole as a as a state. Uh it it it gives India an enormously
[13:13] higher standing uh in terms of talking for the people of Kashmir who are Indians,
[13:20] because the state is whole. India has taken actions regarding that state right
[13:24] from the beginning, and it has fought that fight right right from the beginning.
[13:28] And the images that we see now in po K are you know,
[13:31] if you if you, if you do a contrast of what's happening in Pok
[13:35] and what's happening in in Jammu and Kashmi right now, it's an incredible study
[13:39] in contrast, isn't it. Just look at what's happening in pok terrible terrible
[13:43] parameters in terms of poverty, in terms of education, in terms of opportunity,
[13:48] in terms of virtually every you know, growth in disease or any other
[13:52] kind of index. POK fairs poorly compared to compared to anywhere, but especially
[13:58] to Jummu and Krishmi UH and German Kashmia, especially post the abrogation of Article
[14:03] three seventy, when commerce and opportunity has been on a visible upswing in that
[14:09] particular place. So I think I think in terms of strategic value, it's
[14:15] it's it's it's a it's a closed argument. This is something that India must
[14:20] have right right, So let's get to the practicality of it. And then
[14:24] again, like I said, we'll do the whole war gaming bit. Great
[14:28] strategic value, yes, immotive value yes, care is it really even possible?
[14:31] Practically speaking? You have China. The way I see it, if
[14:35] India were to invade Pakistan occupied Kashmir, definitely that the theory that the army
[14:41] has been talking about for a long time to front what that will definite turn
[14:45] into reality. You will definitely have China reacting to it because like you just
[14:48] described, China has huge investments in the area. The CPEG, China's flagship
[14:52] bi I project, China Pakistan Economic Corridor passes through a Pakistan oquiped cosmeter or
[14:58] something that India has huge issues but can't really do much because that area is
[15:01] not really in our in our control. Uh And also a slight interesting nugget,
[15:05] by the way, within the Pakistan occupied Custan, there is also a
[15:09] dispute between China and Pakistan because of Pakistan had seeded land Okay, that is
[15:16] Indian land to China the Shakshan Valley. I'm not wrong anyway, So you
[15:20] have the China threat. You also have the fact that the world would not
[15:24] look at India too kindly even if they were not to intervene, because you
[15:26] have then India being sort of a not a responsible player, you know,
[15:31] not following agreements that has signed because of nineteen seventy one or seventy two.
[15:35] If I'm not wrong, Shimla accord is pretty solid, rock solid, and
[15:37] we're not China that you know, we signed something and then we just go
[15:39] back and there, like Maranita. So practically speaking, militarily and literally,
[15:46] I think pretty sure we can do it. And you know, it's funny
[15:48] whenever army chiefs are asked this question, they're like, ah, we are
[15:52] already and willing to do it, and people sort of, you know,
[15:56] go gang oot, and it's not like they'd be like NINIANI sorry, So
[16:00] obviously I like yeah. But anyway, so militarily I'm pretty sure we can
[16:04] do it. But practically speaking, if we were to do it, would
[16:08] India be able to survive the mess that would happened after So so obviously this,
[16:12] you know, and we're talking in we're talking in very harsh simplicities.
[16:18] But there are two or three things to keep in mind when we even approach
[16:22] the subject of can we recover Poka? Number One, India, Pakistan and
[16:26] China are all three nuclear armed countries. Okay, let's just keep that as
[16:30] the elephant in the room for a moment when we're talking about a large scale
[16:36] territory recovery operation of the kind that we are discussing in our defense today.
[16:41] B under no circumstances and in nobody's imagination, can the recovery of Pok be
[16:48] a purely military enterprise or a smash and grab enterprise where you know, just
[16:55] brute strength and overwhelming odds in favor of India militarily or otherwise result in the
[17:02] territorial recovery of Pok. It's not going to happen. Can the Army mount
[17:07] an operation or the military mount and operation to recover Pok? One hundred percent,
[17:11] like you said, not just because they have to say it, but
[17:14] because I'm sure they're capable of it. From nineteen forty seven, the military
[17:18] has been in part training for precisely a kind of large scale operation to recover
[17:25] Pok. So let's make no mistake about that. It's not some pipe dream.
[17:29] It's it's very very relevant to how the military acts, and should the
[17:33] opportunity present itself, perhaps there will be a large military element to this recovery.
[17:38] But something that the Rajanat Saying, the Defense Minister said just a couple
[17:42] of days ago, I think in luck now strikes me as being the very
[17:47] heart of it, he said. And Rajanat sing is one of the more
[17:52] measured and thoughtful, you know, political voices over the last many days,
[17:56] many years whove occupied the Defense ministry. And he said, he says,
[18:00] we may not even need the military to recover Poka. You know, the
[18:04] implication of what he said is that the recovery may not be a military process
[18:08] at all. It may be a completely organic internal mass rebellion that you know,
[18:17] of the kind that took place in Bangladesh. The words left unsaid are,
[18:22] of course, you know, rebellions that are you know, have an
[18:26] Indian hand or except. The important thing to remember here is there's a huge
[18:33] there's a stark difference between Bangladesh and Pok. Pok is Indian territory. So
[18:37] when we say Indian hand. Remember that India treats the people of Pok's Indian
[18:41] citizens. They're Indian citizens. They theoretically have Indian rights, right, So,
[18:48] so when you talk theoretically about an Indian hand in the protests over there,
[18:52] there are people what you been Indian hand. We are their government.
[18:56] That's what that's the Indian government stand And therefore, whether it is the Jamun
[19:00] Kashmir a Army Action Committee, or the three or four other organizations that function
[19:07] in pok Uh, the Pakistan Pakistan government standards that these are raw you know,
[19:14] raw funded organizations or Indian government sponsored organizations. My retort to that is,
[19:18] yeah, so, uh, this is Indian territory. So you know,
[19:22] Indian agencies and Indian organizations will you know, provide sucker and muscle and
[19:27] support to these organizations. India does not arm any of these organizations, there's
[19:32] no there's no arming of any of these organizations. But are some of them
[19:34] sustained by India? For God's sake, It's Indian territory. It's not Bangladesh,
[19:38] it's not it's not Baluchistan. It's p Okay. It's Pakistan occupied Kashmir.
[19:44] It's formally Indian territory as far as India is concerned, uh and as
[19:48] far as many other countries concerned as well. So so the military aspect of
[19:52] recovery, in my view is is theoretical at best at this point of time,
[19:57] but never completely off the table, becau because for two reasons one,
[20:02] Pakistan in the last seven years seven eight years has deteriorated spectacularly on all fronts,
[20:10] militarily, socially, commercially, and most importantly economically. Nothing makes it's
[20:15] not the military that makes a country strong, it's your economist. There's only
[20:19] so much the military can achieve. The economy can take you to the moon.
[20:23] Right. So, Pakistan is a country that is completely crushed now having
[20:29] to you know, literally quell food protests in different parts of its provinces,
[20:34] has run away inflation of the kind that pakistanis have never seen for generations.
[20:40] Is a country that's on edge in the literal sense. It's really a country
[20:44] on edge where things are not going their way at all. And Pakistan occupied
[20:48] Kashmir has never been a governance priority for them. They always hope that you
[20:52] have some a few puppet organizations there and you know, things would run themselves.
[20:56] If things were running successfully in Pok from the beginning, how could the
[21:00] Kashmiri demographic drop to a ridiculous single digit figure of the population is anybody's guests.
[21:07] But like I said, a kind of theoretical hybrid practicality of this would
[21:15] have to be that Pok implodes. It would have to politically, socially,
[21:18] commercially economically implode, and that's the only way that in that event, the
[21:23] military can move in and take power something like that. But all of the
[21:27] caveats that I've mentioned in the start are applicable. You're talking about nuclear countries,
[21:32] You're talking about countries that have huge investments and interests in these areas,
[21:37] specifically Pakistan and China. So it's not going to be a smash and grab
[21:41] affair, is what I'm going to say. Yeah, which is why I
[21:42] think it makes it very close to impractical to actually do that, because China
[21:48] has invested, I think, at a level right now from which it's not
[21:52] going to walk back. So I think what you were trying to mention earlier
[21:55] is that wouldn't just be a military opperation. It's like diplomatically, have to
[21:57] low logic and offensive to convince to let you do this, but Channa's never
[22:00] ever got to let you do it because these just have far, far too
[22:03] much At stake Writer, we'll talk more about parks, Tush media and an
[22:10] area closely linked to it. Part After a quick break, Eat eggs,
[22:18] no eat fiber, sleep, no take short naps, don't listen to others,
[22:22] no serve others. Do you ever feel like you're drowning in a pool
[22:26] of advice? This is Sonali a Charge, a health journalist for the last
[22:33] ten years who is equally fed up of lines like ten ways to stay fit.
[22:37] So join me in the podcast Health Wealth as we learn about health from
[22:41] a completely new perspective where investing in yourself is not a task but simple,
[22:48] satisfying and joyful. Full episodes are available on Apple, Google, Spotify,
[22:53] and the India Today podcast website. Tune in now, Welcome back shiven I
[23:04] discussing Pakistan Occupied Kashmir. That's come up a lot in the election season India,
[23:10] as it does almost before ever ever any any election in India, and
[23:15] huge statement being made by some of the top more the ministers, Aja sing
[23:18] Doctor Jesshankar, all three of them, by the way. Part of the
[23:21] Cabinet Committee and Security so which which is what makes us even a bit bigger
[23:26] where they've basically said what has been Indian scussion all along that p ok is
[23:29] RS and you know we will we will take it back. We've talked about
[23:33] why it's an immotive issue for India. We've talked about strategic the strategic value
[23:37] of that land and how practically it's not that easy because you have vested interests
[23:41] in the form of China involved. Usually over there, I slightly want to
[23:47] go from a slight different tangent to an area that's very close by, to
[23:49] an area which would actually get kind of sort of resolved if you had India
[23:55] occupying the whole of Pakistan okuped Kashmir Sachan very often in Internet, especially people
[24:00] who don't understand strategy, which is why I wanted to talk about this.
[24:03] Uh, be more on that, you know India Ahasta. So the numbers
[24:07] are around top six corore daily for the upkeep of the troops over there that
[24:12] surrounded think two thousand core. Yeah, that's a huge amount. Uh and
[24:17] even versus around twenty to thirty that's annually of soldiers because very very inhospitable avalanches.
[24:22] We I think every couple of months you have news of an avalanche and
[24:26] soldiers being trapped, etcetera. I've seen documentaries. Uh you know the famous
[24:30] videos of you know, eggs being rock solid. You know they're having to
[24:33] use a hammer and something to break apart fruit. Uh So, yeah,
[24:38] people keep saying ce queue or Cupi Kara, so very very iconic operation.
[24:45] You know, both Pakistan and India. But I think racing towards the top
[24:47] of sach In because India had gotten intelled that Pakistan would be trying to trying
[24:51] to occupy Sachin. Uh And I think there were fist fights at the top
[24:55] and then India banaged to control. India has been controlling since then. Uh
[24:59] So, if Pakistan Kashmi were to be in India's position, I'm pretty sure
[25:02] Siachin would cease to matter because I think that a trijunction. You have China
[25:06] on the north, Pakistan pok on the on the west, and India down
[25:08] south. So for those people who keep wondering in get the Passaku Karasta have
[25:12] we could build trains and better vises with this. Can you tell us in
[25:17] the current context, again, looking at the map of the point, why
[25:19] does Sachin hold so much value to us? So right off the bat,
[25:23] you know, for people who are wondering about money being spent over there,
[25:26] et cetera, let me just say that, you know, the domination of
[25:30] Siachin was not and is not a pissing match between India and Pakistan. There
[25:34] are very real reasons why India did what it needed to do because remember that
[25:40] in Siachin, unlike in many other places, India dominates. And when you
[25:44] say dominate in the context of Mountain Warfa, it means you're at a higher
[25:48] level and you're able to look down upon your adversary or your enemy. And
[25:53] unlike in many other parts of uh you know, Poki or elsewhere, in
[25:59] Siachin, there is the Indian positions on the Saltoru ridgion, the Siachen Glacier
[26:06] completely dominate all, you know, Pakistani points over there to an extent that
[26:12] Pakistan is practically pinned down there. They cannot even move there. There's no
[26:18] hope of any kind of gain this way or that way in that area.
[26:21] Now remember that the Siachen Glacier, the line of control when it was delineated,
[26:26] when it was created, all the way back in nineteen forty seven,
[26:30] it was not. It did not completely delineate the separation between India and Pakistan
[26:36] occupied Kashmir, including the northern areas, which meant that there was confusion and
[26:41] there was a lack of clarity of where the line of control went beyond point
[26:47] nj nine four eight two, if I'm not mistaken, and that basically could
[26:52] have either gone According to Pakistan, that line should have gone northeastward, which
[26:59] would base give Pakistan occupied Krishmi the Siach and Glacier, and India said,
[27:03] no, it goes due north towards the Carara Korum Pass and K two et
[27:07] cetera Carricorum Pass, and therefore the seach in Glacier is on our side.
[27:12] Now, most people, you know, perhaps don't know the fascinating story of
[27:17] how India finally, you know, occupied, you know, took position on
[27:22] the seatch in Glacier, which I'm sure we'll do a separate episode on,
[27:25] especially since we are now in the fortieth year of Operation migdo So. Nineteen
[27:30] eighty four, April fourth, if I'm not mistaken, was the date on
[27:34] which Indian Army soldiers and officers dropped from the helicopters onto the Kumar Post what
[27:41] became known as the Komar Post, and began India's presence on the siatch in
[27:48] glacier. So you're right, you know, recovery of Pok would end all
[27:52] these things about about Siachen, but they would not end India's presence in those
[28:00] India's presence in those areas would have to continue. Now, let's assume that
[28:03] Pok is back. Okay, we're taking big leaps here, you know,
[28:07] with all the disclaimers and clarifications about whether you know something like this is even
[28:11] possible and realistic, et cetera, and all the applicable caveats. Let's assume
[28:17] in an ideal scenario that the world is stable, no nukes have been launched,
[28:21] and Pok is back with India. That would not mean for a moment
[28:25] that in the Indian Army gets to climb down from its heights. It would
[28:29] still very much, you know, be present at those heights, perhaps not
[28:33] in the same kind of strength in the Siachan area itself, but in other
[28:37] heights. Those heights would move forward, you'd be nearer to the Karakorum Pass,
[28:41] you'd be in Gilgit Baltistan, you'd be in those areas which have you
[28:45] know, borders with the China occupied Tibet, or with Afghanistan or indeed with
[28:48] Pakistan. So those positions would change. The geography would obviously change, but
[28:56] the nature of the warfare, the nature of the missions, those would not
[29:00] change at all. Yeah, another thing on things that would change, And
[29:04] I think we've briefly talked about this in a previous episode of Forget which one,
[29:08] But the fact that the army is deployed along the LOC is because there
[29:12] is an l OC. If there was no l C, there was just
[29:15] an international border, then you'd had the BSF deployed along the border. And
[29:19] I think we've discussed this, how how even you feel that the army being
[29:22] at the LOC is just a base because the army should not technically guarding borders
[29:26] to be sort of a bit in land training for war and et cetera.
[29:30] Since you've discussed it practical difficulties of actually taking but Poka, we have to
[29:34] kind of moral less except that the LC is moral is going to be the
[29:37] defacto border. I mean that's what now? Yeah, so then why do
[29:41] we still have the army deployed on the LC if you are going to if
[29:44] you're treating as a de facto border, is it because of infiltration or do
[29:47] you think the BSF cannot manage in filtration? Why just not pull the army
[29:49] back and have the BSF tack over the LC simply because de facto border doesn't
[29:53] mean border. It's as It's really as simple as that. Also, because
[30:00] is Kashmir does not allow you the luxury of quibbling over de facto border head
[30:03] would b BESF Colago. It's not like that. Kashmir is a Jabun.
[30:08] Kashmir is a is a completely unique specimen state with issues, historical problems,
[30:15] threats that are entirely unique to it, the nature of its births, the
[30:22] nature of accession, the fact that Pakistan continues to UH you know, have
[30:26] you know an influence in Jamun Kashmir in many ways through terrorism and infiltration.
[30:33] All of these mean that this is not a This is not a paramilitary UH
[30:37] specific threat. This is an international sovereignty threat, and therefore that's what the
[30:44] army is for. That's the only reason the army is deployed there. Because
[30:47] the threat here is not just drugs coming over the border or a couple of
[30:51] drones bringing in some pistols. This is a war waging machine of a large
[30:57] country completely sort of almost racially committed to your destruction and the takeover of your
[31:06] sovereignty. It's as simple as that. And for that, you don't deploy
[31:08] the BSF. You deploy. And this is not to dis the BSF at
[31:12] all. The BSF does an amazing job in all parts of the country,
[31:15] as brave as any Army soldier. All I'm saying is that the army is
[31:18] trained for a higher degree of defense and combat. That's all I'm saying.
[31:23] Right, So let's get to that war gaming situation scenario. Of course,
[31:29] with lots and lots of disclaimers, I think we should ask kinda producer to
[31:32] have like disclaimers running in red. Otherwise you'll have people like you know,
[31:36] clipping like different parts and making a sensational video out of it, not trying
[31:40] to sensualize. Because you know, the reason we guy host this podcast is
[31:44] because of stuff like this. Because this is a bit academic, perhaps,
[31:47] but this is you know, this is how basically you have military exposed talking
[31:51] strategy. Like you've said earlier, this is definitely something the army has already
[31:55] the military has already wargamed because this is a very real sort of a scenario
[31:59] for the military, because this is a land of yours that has been occupied
[32:04] on which you have complete rights, and so you definitely have was sort of
[32:07] a plan of how to go about doing it if you were to do it,
[32:09] so like we did with the episode on China and the idea of liberating
[32:14] Tibet, if if there was a political message to the military that yes cohad
[32:19] and take Pok, how do you envision that playing out on the ground in
[32:24] Pakistan Ocupad Cushman and also back in Delhi, when, like we said,
[32:28] India will have to also launch a diplomatic offensive to ensure that, you know,
[32:31] other countries do not get interested, you do not get invested in that
[32:35] conflict. So the disclaimer I'd like to make here before answering that is that
[32:39] such a situation is going to be virtually impossible. It's it's impossible that the
[32:45] recovery of Pok is going to be an exclusively military affair, like I said
[32:49] in the past, simply because let's first remember that Pok is geographically huge.
[32:54] It's not a small little it's not a village or a beachhead or a mountain
[32:59] or small patch of land that's being recovered. It's a huge place, as
[33:04] big as a as big as an Indian state. So so if you're talking
[33:07] about a military operation, you're talking about a military operation of vast scale,
[33:12] country sized scale. Uh. That's one of the challenges, b uh,
[33:16] for the for the sake of argument, since you've since you've said, let's
[33:21] let's put all the disclaimers to bed and say if an order comes in politically
[33:24] saying go out and bring back, don't come back until you've got p okay
[33:29] right now. Obviously this is not going to be, uh, you know,
[33:31] an army specific operation, because we live in a in a world that
[33:36] where all warfare is is hybrid. It functions at all you know levels,
[33:42] Like we discussed in detail in one of our first episodes of this season,
[33:45] that the future war is going to have The military is going to be one
[33:50] jigsaw piece in any future war, but there will be many other aspects.
[33:53] There will be a uh, you know, there will be cyber warfare,
[33:57] there will be you know, economic attack, there will be obviously be the
[34:00] diplomatic element to everything. But I still hold that what Rajanath saying has echoed,
[34:07] uh, you know, from from many previous ministers and prime ministers have
[34:10] said in the past as well. The the the impulse of Pok coming back
[34:15] to India will involve the military as a catalyst. The military will not be
[34:20] the prime facilitator of that of that reclamation or that re that rejoining of Pok
[34:24] with India. The real fight will be happening in Pok itself. There will
[34:30] be a large people led India. India helped rebellion, which which in many
[34:38] ways, uh, simply reaches a point where for Pakistan it is it's just
[34:44] no longer feasible. It completely spirals out of their control and they are unable
[34:47] to do anything about it except send in their military. And once the Pakistani
[34:52] military moves in, because it's such a you know, tense situation, then
[34:58] the the Indian the Indian government has a case is belly, which is,
[35:01] you know, a cause for war. You know, you're attacking my people
[35:05] with your military, which they are in a small way, but I mean
[35:07] in terms of a large scale uh, you know, conventional Pakistan military assault
[35:13] in Pok. Because of the situation that's happening, they're very much like in
[35:15] Bangladesh, except that this is Indian territory. Let me remind everyone again.
[35:20] And therefore, then the Indian government has a has a platform to declare war
[35:25] and push the military in. Then you've got Then you've got what you said
[35:30] in your first question, that the military is fully prepared for this kind of
[35:34] thing. Then it goes out there and actually executes that. Now, if
[35:37] we want to get into the nuts and bolts of how it will execute that,
[35:39] you know, I obviously am not a military commander, but very very
[35:43] broad strokes to use, very very broad strokes. There would necessarily have to
[35:47] be a large air power element. There would be you know, waves and
[35:52] waves of air power usage to you know, to soften targets, UH,
[35:55] to take out takeout defenses, you know, in side Pakistan and inside Pakistan
[36:00] occupied Kashmir. This is of course, assuming no great resistance from their side.
[36:05] And that's for a moment. Assume that China doesn't get involved, because
[36:07] India has for some reason diplomatically conveyed to China that you know, set this
[36:14] one out and you know this is going to happen whether you like it or
[36:16] not. Okay, you know, many leaps of faith in Poka believe me,
[36:21] and I've done this for many years. And then you've got most definitely
[36:25] the navy playing a part, because in all conflict between India and Pakistan,
[36:30] the navy does play a part because because of Mumbai, because of Kolkata,
[36:35] because of Karachi, India's economic India and Pakistan's economic hubs are all their coastal
[36:39] cities, and therefore that aspect would be there. And finally, the actual,
[36:45] the actual reclamation, the actual what what Pakistan will call an occupation,
[36:49] which we will be calling, you know, the recovery of Pok, would
[36:53] be a ground assault, you know, a tremendous like, sort of overwhelming,
[36:58] eye watering kind of grounds which strategically recovers all nodal points of Pok and
[37:05] completely cuts off Pakistan uh and UH and UH sort of stops any future possibility
[37:10] of them gaining strength and UH and remember, a ground occupation means that India
[37:16] is basically institutionalizing that as part of Kashmir once again, which means that the
[37:22] army goes in, it probably doesn't come back out ever again, yes,
[37:24] or at least for the foreseable future. It becomes a force that's holding Pok.
[37:30] In that case, because you're to be realistic about It's not like,
[37:31] oh okay, fine, we've got it now shell we're going now now,
[37:35] now this is the border, please respect it. You know, it's not
[37:37] like that. Obviously, it's not like that. Nothing works like that.
[37:38] So the real work would then start. And like I said, uh,
[37:44] the it's almost comical to make so many leaps of faith, yes, and
[37:47] suppositions about how Pakistan would react, how China would react, how even the
[37:53] United States would react, how Afghanistan would react, how Russia would react.
[37:57] You know, we're assuming that none of these big tech shifts would happen.
[38:00] They would happen. All of these countries have interests in this region. Russia
[38:05] has interests. We're talking only about China. What about the US? US
[38:07] is a great friend of Pakistan. So are we assuming that just because we've
[38:12] got an alliance going with the United States, they'll sit pretty. In nineteen
[38:15] seventy one, they didn't. They didn't sit pretty. They were right,
[38:19] there is spook us in the Bay of Thing all So, so India's in
[38:23] something like Poka, India would be all alone, you know, unless it
[38:28] really miraculously managed to build a kind of almost unreal international coalition that provided the
[38:35] kind of cartvalanche to go in and get this done. That's quite the fantastic
[38:37] scenario. I mean literally speaking fantastic, because I think it is just fantastically
[38:42] Yeah, will never ever happen, but yeah, that's that. And also,
[38:46] like you know, like you mentioned a couple of times on this episode
[38:50] that you cannot forget the nuclear question. And I think one of the Congress
[38:53] leaders, Manishankarai, have got trolled recently because of an old video of his
[38:58] or where he had set on something so miller. To be fair to him,
[39:00] I think if you look at his argument in the larger context, it
[39:04] did make sense that you have to keep in mind they have an atom nuclear
[39:08] bomb scared of Themanka, you know. Apart from his famous chaiwala comment and
[39:14] a few other indiscrete uh and you know, sneering, arrogant comments, I
[39:20] think when it comes to Pakistan, Manashankaraya's problem has never been you know,
[39:25] speaking the reality or speaking you know, facts and things like that. His
[39:30] problem is timing. Yes, his problem is saying it right before an election.
[39:34] His problem is saying it, you know, when when it's already a
[39:37] hot topic or an issue. His problem is, you know, Manishankarall is
[39:42] completely in love with himself and he thinks he's an intellectual, you know,
[39:47] like giant, and that you know, if he doesn't wane on India and
[39:52] Pakistan, the world will be incomplete. And therefore, if the smallest some
[39:57] boom boom broadcast has you know, approached him with the greatest respect to all
[40:02] podcasts and comes in and says, let's let's talk to everyone and give them
[40:07] all again about Pakistan. So I'm just saying, you know, his views
[40:10] are welcome. I'm just saying that he doesn't help his party. That's all
[40:13] that is true. That is true. But yeah, for anyway, so
[40:15] that the nuclear question obviously has to be kept in especially like with China also
[40:20] involved. One last point as we end this episode, and this is to
[40:22] just talk about the pok issue. So you know, like we said,
[40:27] man he comes from a generation of you know, diplomats and from a time
[40:30] when there was this resolute effort being made both under the Watchbay government and another
[40:36] Munsing government to sort of sort sort this issue out. Right. You had
[40:39] like vaccinal talks happening, You had some summits planned or one that happened,
[40:44] some were planned, some were called up et cetera. You also had the
[40:46] initial years of the More the government where he made that a famous stopover to
[40:51] meet and greet on Christmas or his birthday, birthday and his birthday, and
[40:55] you had pm more Denis first him inviting the entire neighborhood for his inauguration.
[41:01] U s we have saying it for his taking more Indian right. But like
[41:07] you, like I mentioned the beginning of the episode in a recent interview,
[41:08] PMOD has said and which like you also explained that we have you know,
[41:15] after the surgical strikes, sorry, after the code the surgical strikes, we've
[41:22] showed the message that if you cross the l C and come attack us,
[41:24] we're going to hit you right back. Pakistan right now is in such dire
[41:28] rious traits that it cannot even think of doing something. Will first fix its
[41:31] own cell before it can think of launching other sort of pseudo war against India.
[41:36] So does this question then really need to get resolved, because, like
[41:38] we've discussed on this episode, p ok occupying it is not really a practical
[41:43] solution. It's not going to happen. Okay, let's make that very clear.
[41:45] But the issue still remains. Then loc still remains, Like we said,
[41:49] the defacto border still remains, the defect of the army still remains on
[41:51] the l o C still remains every literalized. So do we then need to
[41:55] resolve this issue at all or so? So that's that's I a really really
[42:00] good question. And I think the answer to the question is in the question
[42:04] itself, which is that India just needs to sort of watch Pakistan implode right
[42:08] now. Pakistan is is caving in. You know, for the longest time,
[42:13] for many years, people used to call Pakistan a failed state, and
[42:15] that was not strictly true. In the last one one and a half years,
[42:20] it's become true. You know, people used to call Pakistan as failed
[42:22] state more as a kind of emotional response to Pakistan than the reality Pakistan is
[42:28] a country. Pakistan is a fully functioning, you know, government led or
[42:31] military led country with the rules and CODs and laws, and you know,
[42:37] it's it's it's not some it's not North Korea. It's it's a real country,
[42:40] right and but it has become a failed state. Now where where the
[42:45] possibility of insurrection, the possibility of h you know, wide scale civil unrest
[42:51] and civil war is not a possibility, is a reality. It's happening in
[42:53] different parts of the country. So and and none of this is of very
[42:59] little this is India's doing. This is entirely on Pakistan's decisions. This is
[43:04] entirely on Pakistan's priorities. This is entirely on Pakistan's way of doing things.
[43:08] As far as it's government, it's people, it's economy, it's you know,
[43:12] decision making is concerned, this has nothing to do with India. As
[43:15] much as they'd love to say, rye agent for everything, this is not
[43:16] about India. So as far as skin in the game is concerned, all
[43:21] India really needs to do is like, let's see how much worse it gets
[43:23] there, we'll decide when we need to move in or do something, or
[43:28] when when the time is optimal for us to get sort of directly involved in
[43:31] some kind of big shift in Pakistan. Until now, man, they're killing
[43:35] themselves, you know, they're ruining themselves, they're imploding, They're a pile
[43:38] of crap right now. So there's nothing that India really needs to do.
[43:42] So I think that's what it is right now. When you say, do
[43:44] we really need to do anything. No, you're right, we don't.
[43:46] We just need to wait and watch the the you know, the sad spectacle
[43:52] of Pakistan completely caving in and see and see where the ducks line up,
[43:58] you know, at the end of this cycle of implosion of Pakistan. Let's
[44:01] see where things finally end up. And then India can take a strategic decision
[44:05] on what it needs to do. Yeah. And at the same time,
[44:07] I think kind of watch our backs, beciues. I think I've expressed this
[44:09] Yu once before as well, that with things reaching to state in Pakistan,
[44:14] and you already have many bad elements there, both in and out of the
[44:17] military. By the way, uh, and this is a country with some
[44:21] expensive, expensive weapons, forget the nuclear weapons. Even then all our weapons
[44:23] thanks to their old friend US, they have some very expensive weapons that all
[44:30] we keeps coming to my mind whenever us such reports that you know, what
[44:32] if you know this one some some piece of equipment fault in the wrong hands
[44:37] and something happens, and then you never know what happens, right, And
[44:40] you know, speaking of the protests and p okay, I was waiting for
[44:44] one some outlet somewhere to like do a story, you know, just when
[44:47] the elections were happening in India, India, you know, send some raw
[44:51] agency over there to like sort of will happen. I'm sure they're all saying
[44:54] yeah, and they'll definitely link to the statements between the ministers like you know,
[44:58] see that's the whole conspiracy. That the a pattern that will definitely happen.
[45:01] Right. I think we ended there a shorter episode than a normal chats
[45:05] because I think the topic itself is such I mean, it's if you were
[45:08] to do it in one sent it's just basically, can we retake p okay?
[45:13] Yes? Is it practically possible? No? But yeah, I think
[45:17] she have explained the complete never off the table. Yeah, but you have
[45:21] explained the complexities of it quite well. The operation and uh you know for
[45:24] a change, also made us understand the reason and the importance of p can
[45:29] you know, countering China, which actually would be a good strategy some day.
[45:31] You know, if they are putting to much pressure on us over there,
[45:35] we can sort of like you know, start pressure. Those are very
[45:37] much part of how you know, how the how the game works anyway.
[45:40] Yeah, yeah, right, So thanks shift, great chat, and thanks
[45:45] to our listeners and viewers. As always, and do keep commenting. In
[45:47] fact, we have been flooded by idea requests and I'm running like my list
[45:52] of idea bank has become longer and longer, and I'm just like, you
[45:53] know, to be a long season beyond the elections. Yeah, so we
[45:58] promise to get to each and every one of them. This one actually was
[46:00] not an idea by anyone of our listeners or readers, but if you were
[46:05] based on the headlights, based on the headlines, we thought we will do
[46:07] it, and we thought that you'd be interested in this. So if you
[46:09] were interested in this, two letters in the comments below, and if you're
[46:12] listening to us on Apple, podcast or Spot, if I do leave us
[46:14] a rating on what are our platform you're listening to us on, Thanks us
[46:16] always to our producer. And that's it for this week's defense. Does for
[46:21] more tune in next week. Till then, stay safe and do not cross
[46:22] any boundaries to passport

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
