# Are Hate Crimes Terror Attacks? | In Our Defence, Ep 70

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 3 Aug 2023, 43 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/56356672/03_aug_23_in_our_deence_ep_70_3_aug_128.mp3

Earlier this week, communal violence erupted in Haryana, spreading to Gurugram and other areas with reports of vandalism. The clashes in Nuh during a religious procession resulted in six deaths. The violence allegedly stemmed from rumors that a cow vigilante, Monu Manesar, involved in previous killings in Bhiwani, would attend the procession. However, as reported, Manesar did not show up at the event and claimed that he has nothing to do with the violence or the killings. Another distressing incident involved an RPF constable who shot and killed four people, including his senior officer and three Muslim passengers,&nbsp;on the Mumbai-bound Jaipur-Mumbai Superfast Express near Palghar railway station. The constable, Chetan Kumar, was later arrested by the Government Railway Police, GRP. These incidents raise concerns about India's internal security mechanism. The lack of police presence during the Haryana clash raises questions about the administration's preparedness and response. Why was the police not present during the Haryana clash?&nbsp;Is it unrealistic to even expect unbiased policing during such violent times? Why did the administration fail to prevent the planned violence from unfolding? Dev Goswami and "Def Savvy," Abhishek Bhalla, delve into the role of the police in internal security and why it often comes under scrutiny. &nbsp;Also, the RPF incident prompts questions about provisions to handle 'mentally challenged'&nbsp;officers and why such an officer was allowed on duty, if that's the case. And do such hate crimes qualify as terror attacks? Listen in! Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound mix by Sachin Dwivedi

## Transcript

[0:01] This is in the Today podcasts. There are boundary disputes and then there are
[0:07] outright wars, hot and cold, diplomatic and military. In this podcast,
[0:13] we will dissect all that's brutal and subtle about the defense of our nations.
[0:18] I am Dave Goswami, your host, and I will be joined by Abishek
[0:22] Bala, who's been on the front lines of wars and conflicts and has seen
[0:26] the Indian military up close and Welcome seventieth episode of Another Offense. Were you
[0:38] doing a valuable sentieth seven zero one of duringenty? What is it called?
[0:49] This is not a blastomy? I mean what jubilee? Is this platinum?
[0:56] Latinum? I don't know, No, Jubli. Jubili is seventy five fifties
[1:00] gold right right? Seventy five is platinum one hundred days of course, essentially
[1:06] that's platinum. I think, are we right? I don't know. Uh
[1:12] Nearing Chat seventy five, it came to our mind because you're also going to
[1:18] be celebrating the seventy fifth day next week a second, so ten days from
[1:23] now. But you know, one of our listeners, actually viewers, actually
[1:29] came up to mean office. He is in our company and said that he
[1:34] enjoys the podcast, but he said that he doesn't know where to get the
[1:38] rest of the episodes on. So I just thought, like, you know,
[1:40] for our listeners and us, we'll just let them know that, you
[1:42] know, we are there on Apple podcasts, where on Google podcasts with the
[1:46] sports Spotify and all our videos at since we began doing videos, which has
[1:51] been what I think around maybe twelve more than that fifteen episodes lost count.
[1:55] So all our videos twenty six twenty six of them are available on our YouTube
[1:59] channel. The handle is India Today. You can go there and there's a
[2:01] tap called podcast where you can find in our Defense Cup playlist which has all
[2:05] the episodes that we've done on video. You know, we'd also love some
[2:08] some feedback from you. You can ropple comment to us on the YouTube channel
[2:13] if you want, or you know, a text to us at eight five
[2:15] double eight nine, double six, double nine six. You can also email
[2:16] us at pots at the rate indi day dot com. Let's be od is
[2:20] at the rate indire day dot com. So let's talk about some of the
[2:24] most headline ramming happenings that happened this week. Then a series of yeah,
[2:35] rarely being headlined. You know, I was actually a bit conflicted whether I
[2:38] wanted to discuss this with you this week, especially on our on our podcast.
[2:43] I mean, I'd let talk about it in general with you separately.
[2:46] But and the reason for that is, Uh, First, our podcast is
[2:51] called in our Defense, So the immediate image that comes to mind, there's
[2:54] you know, war, military, big guns, tanks, stiles sets.
[3:00] Uh. What's happened in the last couple of days that we are going to
[3:05] discuss and this will tell our lessons and viewers before we go into it is
[3:08] one of the violence in Haryana that began in new when clashes broke out in
[3:14] a religious procession that wasn't being taken out that spread to several districts, reached
[3:19] gorda Um one of the cities of fancy are high Alert and Delhi, Faridabad,
[3:25] Noida regions about bordering on near by Gourga. And while this was happening,
[3:31] Railway Constable Protection Railway Protection Force Constable murdered four people in cold blood,
[3:40] including one of his seniors, on a running train and three passengers. The
[3:45] reason I was a bit conflicted because the thing is a topics Gona. There
[3:50] is no way you can avoid the politics around it because both of them that
[3:53] it's the firing that took place near Mumbai, not near Mumba, actually just
[3:58] out on the outcots of Mumbai when the train was just about to basically,
[4:01] and the violence that happened in Hariana. There is already politics happening over it.
[4:05] Do you have everyone all spectrums reacting to it. You cannot avoid that,
[4:13] which then made me think Yogurham School is episode of bath cutting and then
[4:16] we have a medical now a jack. But then I also thought there's also
[4:20] a big security angle to it, because this again goes back to the days
[4:25] when you were covering the local polices of Bombay and Delhi. First, let's
[4:30] just just just sorry to cut you short. The politics bit that you mentioned.
[4:36] There is no subject in the world which from which you can completely isolate
[4:43] polit politics. So even when we discuss defense, heavy heavy defense stuff,
[4:49] there are political linkages to sulations. When we when we discuss a war,
[4:54] war is a political instruments in India, especially because the civilian government no even
[5:01] Russia Ukraine's politics geo politics, so you can't leave politics out of anything.
[5:10] So if we have to touch upon politics, so exactly, that's why.
[5:14] Yeah, So I just like want to start for I was in two minds
[5:17] giving a sort of a rejoinder. Yeah, it was in two minds about
[5:19] that about you do just like know before we start discussing this, first things
[5:24] First, how is it like? What is a riot? Like? I
[5:30] mean, no, and I want you to to describe this for us,
[5:32] because actually you have described something like this to us off camera of the mics,
[5:38] not that you are hiding something to just keep naturally you've mentioned a couple
[5:43] of incidents where you've seen it up close, not being at the receiving end,
[5:46] but you've seen stuff like, for example, stone belting. Just like,
[5:49] take us through what is it like to be in a situation where there
[5:53] is just pure violence happening? Let's forget you know. So see there are
[5:57] there are different categories, if I can say so, of unrest. One,
[6:01] of course, we've discussed money pour, which I feel is a civil
[6:04] war. This is a classic example of a riot. Yeah, what's happened
[6:11] in the two communities clash and the genesis of the clash is religion. It's
[6:17] a classic example of a riot. We often talk about nineteen eighty four,
[6:20] and there's this big debate whether it was a right or just you know,
[6:25] one sided bloodshed against a community. Because there were no clashes, pity was
[6:31] sort of target. That's another category. Another is where there's unrest, but
[6:38] it's certainly nowhere close to a riot. It might be, it might be
[6:43] it might turn violent, say nearby a protests. So you have to understand
[6:47] the intent of the people who are indulging in that unrest and violence. So
[6:53] those guys who are not rioters, those were common citizens. And that's the
[6:57] reason why somewhere the state, the police allowed them to do it all right
[7:03] now, because they could understand the sentiments of what's happening here. What has
[7:10] happened is I think both sides were completely ready to take each other. Yeah,
[7:15] that's what you men to take each other on. They were so begs
[7:21] the question that what what did the local administration do prior to this event,
[7:28] to this march religious march that was planned. And in fact, one of
[7:32] our young reporters who did a fabulous job that day in Mulbali, he was
[7:38] I think he was the only reporter to be present in the middle of that
[7:42] stone pelting at that point of time, and in his ground report, he
[7:46] kept his calm and he just showed what's happening. The camera was showing everything
[7:53] and he were just speaking. And you know what struck me was when he
[7:57] said, can a police So you have been saying, the organizers were saying
[8:05] that this is an annual event taking place for the last three If it's an
[8:11] annual event taking place for the last three years in an extremely volatile, charged
[8:15] up environment, and you also have to understand the demography agency again to say
[8:22] that it's one community, a lot of gangs actually function out of that place.
[8:26] Yes, there's no hiding it's it's something on record. And perhaps that's
[8:31] the reason why one of the police stations, a cyber police station, was
[8:35] conduct cletely burned down. So somewhere somebody took advantage, probably those gangsters who
[8:43] run those uh jump. Actually, we were discussing this in the newsroom that
[8:48] MEWA actually is emerging as the a cyber police station was targeted. Somebody must
[8:56] have thought that, you know, in the middle of all this the right
[8:58] time to sort of target infrastructure something something of that sort. But to just
[9:09] simply explain to our viewers listeners why we are discussing. This is very much
[9:13] an internal security problem, definitely, there's absolutely no shying away from it.
[9:18] And if it's an internal security problem in our defense, we'll talk about it
[9:22] definitely. And you know, you mentioned the Cybersecurity Police station, cyber police
[9:26] station, and it's ironically just a thought struck me that they were probably the
[9:31] ones who should have been monitoring for intelligence. So iron incision because in this
[9:37] day and age, all this planning happens online, does not happen, and
[9:39] there are telltale signs also social media. Yes, and again we've done a
[9:43] report today on this. The journalists who heads an awesome team has again done
[9:52] this report. This team has done this report saying that they were telltale signs
[9:56] on social media of how this was, you know, waiting to happen.
[10:01] It was brewing from both the sides, so very simple. Nobody's watching them.
[10:05] What was happening. That person I'm forgetting his name, that was his
[10:15] robot presence was the one that also triggered is available on phone to us.
[10:20] Imagine he's available on phone to us, but he's not available to the police
[10:24] they wanted, I think. So again, we're not saying whether it's the
[10:31] Rajasthan police or the Haryana police. There's no blame game here. I'm just
[10:35] talking about the way police has dealt with Muna, even if Haryana is saying
[10:43] problem. So yes, I mean, I'm sure Rajasthan police should do some
[10:50] answering. But at the same time, when Haryana police knew that his name
[10:56] is being used to trigger all this, they are within their rights to go
[11:01] and pick him up or do whatever with them of course, of course.
[11:03] Yeah, come back to that with just like what you said right now,
[11:07] just a tangential thought struck me, struck me and you, I think the
[11:11] other perfect person to answer this. Journalists have a history of talking to criminals,
[11:18] people who and especially criminals who are running away from the corps, whether
[11:22] it's Thou Brahim or like you said, mun who's wanted Rastan but is available
[11:28] to us on phone. How does it work? I mean, you've been
[11:31] a crime reporter, so how is it? What's first? Of like,
[11:33] have you in your career ever had to speak to cops about for example,
[11:37] corps who are on the hunt. They call you up like by no see
[11:43] in this day and it is really easy. Even phone numbers are available social
[11:48] media handles are there and you can get in touch with somebody and they respond.
[11:52] Earlier, of course it wasn't so easy, but for the last twenty
[11:56] years, I guess, since mobile phones have come, tracking a person is
[12:01] not that big a deal. So if any cops says that we were unable
[12:05] to track the gentleman, uh, it's it's you don't sort of digest how
[12:13] can you give that excuse? Numbers are available. WhatsApp is that these guys
[12:18] are running websites in the name of being go lu shucks, vigilant, vigilantism
[12:26] and things like that. So I don't know, it's it sounds odd.
[12:31] Back in the day when mobile phones k remember cops saying that you should should
[12:37] not write how we track them down because it was the mobile phone that we
[12:43] was the bile phone dump that was used to track down criminals. So don't
[12:46] write that. They'll know this. Uh, they already knew it. Maybe
[12:50] at some the early stages they did not know, and then later they got
[12:54] to know, and then this wasn't a story that how criminals were picked up
[13:00] and they were traced tracking their mobile phone locations. Now it's a given and
[13:05] gangsters, criminals, terrorists, they use different means and to doing the authorities,
[13:13] but they still use phones. Its phone has become such an integral part.
[13:16] If I don't think somebody can really give up or her phone and if
[13:20] you are and I remember in those days, uh, cops also telling me
[13:24] that if somebody has a phone, this was this was the context was also
[13:30] privacy. Then just forgot about a privacy. It's compromised and you can be
[13:35] tracked. So being your privacy or being a criminal. If you have a
[13:39] phone, you can easily be tracked by us. So it's difficult to understand
[13:46] how some of these guys were wanted and are planning and making provocative videos.
[13:50] Videos are being made and you know, flashed all over social media and rarely
[13:56] hideous videos which were meant to book. And that's what happened. And again
[14:01] that's what I'm saying. I don't I don't mean to sort of de mean
[14:05] any community, but Maywath is known for criminals. Yes, yeah, this
[14:11] is what you expected from them. Yeah, I get your point about you
[14:16] know, police, what you've said about being able to attack anyone know,
[14:20] very easily and you know from a personal experience, completely nothing to do with
[14:22] my profession. But just a random chat with senior inspector at a police station
[14:28] at gont for some personal matter. He basically is the same what you said.
[14:31] You know, in this day and age, if we really want to
[14:33] find somebody, it's like in a child's paved play for us, if we
[14:37] just need the resources in terms of manpower and the will. So comes the
[14:41] question that we since you mentioned this early days of my reporting, I remember
[14:48] asking some senior corp for something where I wanted some information or and I was
[14:58] giving some clue or some information to the person that this lad. He said,
[15:03] Okay, okay, I'll speak to the speak to him and he'll let
[15:07] you know. So in my innocence, I asked, should I speak to
[15:11] the n should I give these details to him? So he said no,
[15:16] no, he'll know. So I said, how will you know? Said
[15:20] sexual, Yeah, oh can he not exactly. So that's how it is
[15:26] that how can you not know that this is what's going to happen? Is
[15:30] my question when you know very small little details of what happens in your jurisdiction.
[15:37] Yeah, So that was gonna lead up to the next thing I'll discussed
[15:41] with you. We briefly discussed that during the last last week's episode, Money
[15:45] Poor Violence, where I began by talking about the police can bring any riot
[15:50] under control if it has the full freedom to and if it really wants to,
[15:56] but obviously because of money pool. We then discussed more about the situation
[15:58] there and how it's, like you said, a civil war and not just
[16:02] a riot anymore. On this podcast we've discussed the military, and uh,
[16:07] you know we have that we have that safe space in military matters where it's
[16:11] taken for granted. Key first of all, their professionals altogether, like completely
[16:17] comes through and through and when it comes to situations like a riot, when
[16:22] sometimes our nie is called in for control, Uh, you don't expect them
[16:26] to be uh politically biased or have any political leanings. That's not so much
[16:30] the case with the police as pleas in perception and honestly we can be honest.
[16:37] Is that you know, the political masters get their way. Yea.
[16:41] In your in your career, you've seen both these forces and you've seen them
[16:47] in right now we're talking about internal violence. We're not talking about external conflicts.
[16:52] You've seen them in situations where they've had to control violence. Just like
[16:56] as a observer, how would you describe the roaches that two forces taken is
[17:02] one of a topic where I can talk for hours and I'm extremely passionate,
[17:07] extremely passionate about it, and unlike a lot of people, I sometimes empathize
[17:15] with the police police for the individual more than the institution. They don't work
[17:21] because of the system. Certainly they work despite the system. I'm very certain
[17:26] about that. The army or the armed forces are extremely efficient. The police
[17:33] might not seem to be efficient, but as I said, despite the system,
[17:38] against all odds, there's a different kind of a respect that I have
[17:45] a cops. Actually, you know, not that I condone the wrongdoings that
[17:49] happen in the police. And I've told this two cops on their faces,
[17:55] you know, speaking to them very being very candid. That just go to
[18:00] a thana in civil clothes, looking a little vulnerable and try and explain to
[18:07] the person in the thana that you're a victim of some crime. You will
[18:11] feel like they accused the problem here mindset, the cop sitting there will start
[18:17] questioning you. Just go there and say I've lost my wallet, Medici pickpocket
[18:27] layer. Let's assume this is the mindset of the police. The other side
[18:36] is why this mindset is there, and we are not None of us are
[18:41] experts. Its psychology, just sort of experience. They get so used to
[18:47] lies around themselves every time somebody or the else who they are dealing with is
[18:52] briatantly lying to them, so they just don't know what the truth is and
[18:57] what what's what's a lie? So by nature they become proving without realizing that
[19:03] this guy could actually be a victim. He's come here for a complaint.
[19:08] So that problem is there. But then there are so many examples of the
[19:12] police doing a great job. Some blind cases have been solved. I mean,
[19:19] the list is long. We can we can have a series of great
[19:22] cases cracked. The armed forces, on the other hand, is extremely efficient
[19:29] because they get the platform to be efficient. They're given everything. Yes,
[19:33] that's very much. Resources are there, and the training, by the way,
[19:37] I think it plays a big role, a big rule, big role.
[19:40] So yeah, I mean there is there is a huge, huge scope
[19:44] of police reforms. And it sounds like a cliche. Now I don't like
[19:47] using that term anymore. It's it's not police reform. You need a modern
[19:52] day police. Our police system is what the colonial rule gave us, and
[20:00] that's why it's always suspecting of the guy who's coming to complain, because that
[20:03] is exactly that's a colonial legacy that plans to be shared as well. Yeah,
[20:08] that's why it's always suspecting of a complaint. On the other hand,
[20:12] there is obviously a huge colonial legacy in the armed forces. We've done our
[20:18] episodes and that. But again it's scucooned. They have their own life.
[20:22] That's why they're more efficient, that's why. That's why the world doesn't get
[20:26] to know about them, about them. But here cop is under scrutiny every
[20:32] day and rightly so I'm not saying that they shouldn't be in just this is
[20:34] the basic difference. And again coming to police reforms, it's hugely discussed percash
[20:42] saying versus Union of India case. Yes, yes, yes, where you
[20:49] know the court has actually laid down how police should be divided law in order.
[20:55] Duty should be different, right, duty should be different. Cyber investigates
[21:00] now of courses and other aspects, several other investigations. You need to have
[21:03] specialists. But today you are in the traffic police. Certainly you're in the
[21:07] thanna. Then you are in the cyber thanna. And of course the favorite
[21:11] word of past that time. So you're you're an all around ye. So
[21:18] how do you expect them to be specialists and professionals? Yes, I still
[21:22] feel their professionals professionals in the sense that whatever is expected out of them,
[21:26] they're doing. They're trying to do the best of their ability here. But
[21:30] they're not specialists, fortunate specialists. There's an infantry, there's an armored core,
[21:36] there's an artillery. You're not expected to do everything. There are fighter
[21:40] pilots, there are guys on the ground, there are submariners. So why
[21:45] is it efficient because it has specialists, The training is specialized here, Joakake
[21:52] Penny, you expected to do everything everything? Yeah, So I don't know
[21:56] when this UH policing system will change in in our setup, and until it's
[22:03] changed, we'll keep on seeing these kinds of things. And actually, the
[22:07] three incidents that have got my eye this week, yeah related to police saying,
[22:14] internal strife, internal security, and all are linked somewhere. There's a
[22:18] hate crime religion. One is, of course, what's happened in Ariana.
[22:23] The other you mentioned the RPF constable. He was looking for Muslim passengers after
[22:30] killing his scene senior and then another one I think you've missed out is in
[22:37] Bareley where the cowardias changed there. Yes, yes, yes, coming from
[22:44] a mosque, can do some hangama there and when the police try to disperse
[22:49] them and all attempts failed, the SSP hard to use force and charge.
[22:56] Now the SSP has been transferred, yes, sent to luck now for some
[23:00] BSc punishment, posting Yeah, how do you look at it? The SSP
[23:07] to me, there's absolutely no no way of you know, calling what I'm
[23:14] going to say now is political or anything. Here was a guy who was
[23:18] ensuring that a communal right did not happen, exactly, that's it, that's
[23:22] it, It's objectives simple. So fairly that's a very good contrast. I
[23:29] mean, here was a guy, like you said, trying to ensure did
[23:30] not take place. And yeah, I'm not sure who the top cop me
[23:33] what was but right did take place? Six people and there was there was
[23:37] prior information, so much as prior, including two home guards. So the
[23:41] thing is that, if you want to that's why I said that police functions
[23:47] despite the system, despite the system. The SSP in barely worked, despite
[23:52] the system knowing fully well that no matter what the political ideology is the rule
[24:00] of law gives him the authority to take action on the ground. He cannot
[24:07] be suspended, he cannot be dismisstring service. He can only be sunered.
[24:11] He probably knew that. And he has a history of his history of sixteen
[24:15] I think sixteen or eighteen times he's been transferred. And but yeah, he
[24:21] also has a history, like you said, of being quite uptight. And
[24:25] you know, law not law of hiding. That would be the wrong word
[24:26] to use for him, but trying to ensure law the land is at least
[24:32] in this case, in this case ye see laty charge of course doesn't sound
[24:37] like a very good There would be elements which which one can say is against
[24:42] human rights and thing which is which it is when you debate it. But
[24:45] whether we like it or not, it's not an illegal act, of course.
[24:48] Yeah, yeah, it's not all within his rights. Yes, Now
[24:53] it becomes illegal or it gets under scrutiny when the power is misused, missu.
[25:00] You think that the power is misused, hold him accountable? Why transwer
[25:03] I know in this case, I mean we've seen that. I think that
[25:07] that that take action, take action against him, suspend him, they should
[25:10] be whatever. Why answer, there's nothing basically not even saying that he had
[25:17] pourteen it was wrong. Do you still you know punishment and legally, technically
[25:22] a transfer of an officer is not considered punitive action the illegally legally, Yeah,
[25:30] true, which is why you know this. This actually is a question
[25:33] that keeps coming to me by a lot of friends who are not in the
[25:36] media. Yeah, this guy is such a controversial career, so many transfers,
[25:40] So how did he end up becoming a Because there are several top corps
[25:42] of you know, states or the Commission of Cities who've had such a career,
[25:47] many transfers in their lives and then suddenly one day they become at a
[25:51] very good post, come at a very good post. The answers said right
[25:53] now that because legally whatever happened in the career as it's also so the political
[26:00] leadership of the day, of course, that's discretion, definitely discretion. We
[26:07] want this guy a big part of the police reforms argument. So this is
[26:12] so there are beneficiaries of the political discretion, and there will be guy who
[26:18] guys who are on the other side of this. Yeah, So there could
[26:22] be a strong political leader, fair political leader who appoints somebody thinking that this
[26:30] person is the right person for the job. And despite what has happened in
[26:34] the past, I overlook all of this, and I'm still a point.
[26:38] So there could be a case where you will say this is a good decision.
[26:41] I see the persons, but there could be a political ideological view as
[26:47] well. And in UPS, I'm not talking about the current dispensation. This
[26:52] has been the norm in UP for decades, decades. I don't know so
[26:56] many other states what the situation is, but because I come from UP,
[27:02] I followed UP a little more than the other states. UP has always been
[27:04] like and you will find officers who have become dgps in one regime and in
[27:10] the other regime there was hunted. Yeah, those contradictions are there. Yeah,
[27:14] you know, one more point on the Haryana thing, and I think
[27:18] this is I think the politics that has happened in the last few last one
[27:22] day since the clash broke out, has kind of taken the spotlight away from
[27:26] what I personally think is in this case. It is just pure police ineffectiveness
[27:32] because for a change year, the police is not being accused of being biased
[27:37] towards one community or the other. We have to also keep in mind two
[27:41] of not police per se, but two home guards also lost their lives in
[27:42] the dashes, one of the first ones to be killed, if I'm not
[27:45] wrong, on the first day of the clash itself. They were shot dead.
[27:48] In this case, the police is not being accused of signing for somebody
[27:52] or letting riots happen. It's just key. Like you said too, there
[27:55] was social media chatter, there was definite, there were strong strong science and
[28:02] they were apparently card of card. So do you think it was just pure
[28:06] ineffectiveness or do you also see sort of a political no Like you said,
[28:11] the contrast, keep just like for example, Mark, if I take action,
[28:17] what if I get transferred? That that's why I we was waiting for
[28:19] his higher ups to come down. So I gave that example. All satting.
[28:23] No matter what the political leadership feels, esp the collector have enough power
[28:30] too well to handle these things and take action. Enough power. Police keun
[28:37] in there. And that's the simple thing. Why I wasn't the police there
[28:40] in full strength in such a volatile environment, an area which is known for
[28:48] crime. And it's a question everyone's asking, and we'll talk more about this,
[28:52] but for a quick plack. Hello, I'm Raj's Chambaa from India Today
[29:03] Podcasts and your host for Nothing but the Truth. Every week we will deal
[29:10] with key issues of concern and bring your perspectives and clarity as to why this
[29:15] should matter to you and what is the clear truth that emerges. Welcome back,
[29:30] I'll be shaken. Ay, are discussing a force in the Indian defense,
[29:33] internal defense set up that we don't trade often the police. Let's uh,
[29:40] we spoke about the classes in Haryana. We spoke about what happens when
[29:44] there is a belief of political pressure, etc. Let's move to for a
[29:49] bit to words Bombay. I think if Hariana classes had not happened, this
[29:55] would be the top two. Now that it wasn't, it was the because
[30:00] this is a story that is shocking and scary on every level from the get
[30:06] go. It was a hate crime. Yeah, but I'm saying from every
[30:10] level as in this that was the development that happened. If you hours after
[30:14] we found out, I'm saying even at the first level, you are in
[30:17] a train, the group of five six people who supposed to supposed to patrol
[30:21] every mind, supposed to defend you defend you guess there is, yeah,
[30:26] and legally are allowed to carry weapons. Just one of them picks up that
[30:30] very weapon, chooses three passengers, shoots him dead alongside of his senior Yes,
[30:34] what you said. Four or five hours later, it turned out this
[30:37] was a hate crem because he chose three Muslim men after shooting. And also
[30:44] that video the video place that was tweeted out by one of the dead people.
[30:49] He was standing over over the body. Some kind of first sermon,
[30:53] I A video with the text wasn't very garb. Yeah, so there was
[31:00] some definite hate speech and hate crime. First things first, and this is
[31:07] a thought that you know, and I forgot when was it last? Because
[31:12] those is some ha when I think if you remember the an ORDERSSA minister was
[31:18] killed by his personal security officer a few months back. Minister or if I'm
[31:23] not ring minister, yes, health minister. Yes, Minister was assassinated by
[31:27] personal security officer, not because of any animosity or parently because he was mentally
[31:32] unwell. Be on the newsroom had discussed this back then. Didn't really get
[31:37] answers when this happened. The first immediate reaction was, h you know,
[31:41] he was suffering from depression and wanted leave. What his family has also said
[31:45] he he's been a long time patient of mental issues, et cetera. Tell
[31:49] me something in India's policing set up, if you have men were legally to
[31:56] carry guns, you'd have some sort of protection against mental or not. I
[32:00] mean, this is this is a subject which is never talked about. And
[32:05] that's why am is. This is somewhere that is scary that the even the
[32:08] armed forces are extremely cagy about that. I have many years back as a
[32:15] younger photo I've tried to pursue people that give me data of how many cases
[32:21] are there, how have you dealt with them? It will be a positive
[32:23] story. They bite the bullet, you know, they realize that it will
[32:28] not be a positive story. You know. How the army, how the
[32:30] armed forces are dealing with such cases. Nobody actually talks about it. And
[32:37] that's very scary. It's it's something that and it's isn't it normal for people
[32:42] in these kind of jobs to be mentally stressed? Yeah, I would think
[32:46] that it's extremely common. Yeah, yeah, definitely. But if there is
[32:52] a problem, people system exactly dealing with it. Maybe they're dealing with it.
[32:57] They don't tell us, but the signs actually gives you another picture.
[33:01] You see with the army, I still things and also the fact that if
[33:07] if somebody is a patient and there is a prescription, what was he doing
[33:09] on duty then exactly that's my point. So you know, you said one
[33:15] thing, hiding it, hiding it, but if it's known then but you
[33:20] know you said the army, so army is still kind of note happens.
[33:23] It happens, But because the army is so far away from civilian life,
[33:28] there's no I personally don't feel it danger because of it. Yeah, like
[33:31] happens, that's I was an issue that army. But police, it's like,
[33:37] this is a guy in front of me, he's allowed to carry a
[33:38] weapon. What if the next cop voice on the street has an issue and
[33:43] then he just aims a gun at me and troots me dead. I mean
[33:45] that's scary precisely, So do you know anything about like is there not a
[33:50] support system? Is there not a way to tackle this, like you said,
[33:52] what you're using unfortunately unfortunately, and it's dangerous. And coming back to
[33:58] the hate crime and why it's a security problem. One see, if if
[34:01] the guy was a patient, he shouldn't have been there. If he's there,
[34:06] I'm assuming, Okay, fine, the problem was there, but somebody
[34:09] thought he's fit enough to carry out. And even if he was a patient,
[34:15] the inherent problem is is the venom that he has for a particular adversity,
[34:21] whether or not he is even if was going to be my second point,
[34:25] even if he's not a mental mentally unstable, a mental patient. The
[34:30] hate a particular person has a particular part section of the community, of the
[34:34] population that itself will disqualify you from the job. Basically a person who's in
[34:37] a public life, that's what I'm saying, should disqualify you from that job
[34:39] of you know, walking down a train every night with a gun in your
[34:44] hand. Yeah, I mean, these are these are questions that need an
[34:46] answer and nobody has. That's that's really unfortunate. What was your first thought
[34:51] when this news slash, Because I like the first thought was we didn't known
[34:53] that hate angles I'm says thought the new slash first thought that he's killed his
[35:00] colleagues looked like a classic case of rice side. Then you got to know
[35:05] that he's killed three other people passengers, and then you got to know that
[35:07] the trigger was religion. There's there's been a big debate oas he said that
[35:13] this is a terror attacks, his mindset is that of a terrorist. The
[35:16] counter argument is that no, no, no, why is he a terrorist?
[35:20] He was a patient and you can't. Did we carry out a mental
[35:25] assessment of any of the terrorists who have gone on shooting spreeze anywhere in the
[35:30] world. We haven't designed We should have done that. I remember cops always
[35:38] stressing on one thing if if some killer these kind of killings happened, and
[35:45] if somebody said that they are psychos, that narrative they said, no,
[35:47] no, why I call them psychos is that if you do this, you
[35:51] know, they lose it as a defense and other no killer will be guilty
[35:57] if they start taking this defense that they're mentally disturbed. In psychos in this
[36:01] case, okay, playing benefit of giving benefit out that he was mentally disturbed
[36:06] or or undergoing treatment, as as prescriptions have shown, as the family saying
[36:12] he shouldn't have been there. So to me, it looks like a lone
[36:16] wolf, which is a term used in terrorism, is unfortunately people who are
[36:22] self radicalized. As so many times we hear these terms, and that's what
[36:27] I was saying, is an internal security problem. Yes, we've discussed this
[36:30] in a couple of episodes, but yeah, this is the internal that if
[36:36] there are people like this who are lone wolf wearing a uniform or not,
[36:42] what strategy do we have. It cannot be a fool proof strategy. Of
[36:45] course it cannot be because you can't track each and every individual doing something like
[36:52] this. But there has to be some way out. And do you think
[36:58] this is being discussed inside inside as in the central levels security establishment will never
[37:04] be discussed at the highest level till the time you actually admit that this is
[37:10] an internal security problem. If you say this is a law or the problem
[37:15] this this was a case of somebody was mentally unstable. So you are not
[37:21] addressing, You're not forgot addressing, you're not admitting that there is a problem.
[37:25] But I really think the not to not to see that the other incidents
[37:32] that have happened, or any other cumminal incident that has happened, whether or
[37:37] not involving the police, is of lesser importance. But don't you think the
[37:40] Mumbai train firing one is should be a wake up call? I mean this
[37:44] is different, So it's it's it's it's it's a blot essentially on the this
[37:50] time the railway production Force which falls into the Indian reliefs. If I'm not
[37:52] wrong, No, I think GRP fall into just a blot. Uh yeah,
[38:00] I mean definitely is, and it's not. It's it's more scary than
[38:05] just being a blot. And as to your question, again, is it
[38:09] being discussed. It's not being discussed because there's no admission of Until you diagnose
[38:15] a problem, you will not find That's what I think. The problem is
[38:20] not shown diagnosed. Ignos is high time it is identified as a problem and
[38:25] a problem an ailment that is going to have big implications on internal security of
[38:32] this country. The more loan wolfs you allow to come up, the bigger
[38:37] the threat. So how do you my humble two cents on how to deal
[38:45] with the idea of controlling loan wolves. You're gonna control the loan wolves,
[38:50] of course, you can create an environment that loan wolves do not exist.
[38:55] I think ultimately the will end up being Frankenstein's one day. So you you
[39:00] allow them to exist because you let a narrative spread around the country, this
[39:07] is okay, you legitimize it. So that's why one fine day somebody gets
[39:12] up and says, it's okay. This is what radicalization. Indoctrination is not
[39:16] getting into which religion does it best. This is what indoctrination is. When
[39:23] you spread a narrative through whatever means, religious sermon, political sermon, messaging
[39:35] that this is legitimized and this is sort of justified you. That's when you
[39:43] have loan wolks. This is what I sis is done. I think,
[39:45] yes, yes, exactly that strategy, not strategy, strategy, but exactly
[39:50] that this is what they've done. I have I have met Isis as princes
[39:54] in India spoke, They shared their experience with me and they said that this
[40:00] is exactly what it was. We were told that doing all this is correct
[40:05] because there has been an injustice. So you first you make sure that you
[40:08] spread the narrative that you're a victim. When you convince somebody that you're a
[40:14] victim, that's when the second step comes in, because you're a victim.
[40:19] You have to fight for your rights because you've been victimized for so many years.
[40:22] The third step is who has victimized you? When you paint pictures,
[40:28] these are the kind of people who victimize me. You're told that again through
[40:31] various narratives, and these days, unfortunately those narratives are in the public space,
[40:37] which are not being dealt with. No just when with the thought they're
[40:43] not being dealt with. But even if, like if we were to deal
[40:45] with them, just like Struck just reminded me of what you said earlier that
[40:50] this what you described just in the last few moments, this would require like
[40:54] specialist police force, because dealing with this you'd need somebody more than this doesn't
[41:00] require a specialist police force. Why does it? Don't we as journalists in
[41:04] the newsrooms follow on social media handles. A constable is in today's date,
[41:08] even if he's just class twelve past, which is the basic eligibility. Understand
[41:13] your smartphone, young boys and girls are on social media who joined the police?
[41:17] This is this is the lowest hanging fruit. Just identify people who are
[41:22] doing all this on social media and sort them out and the lowest hanging fruit.
[41:29] Good point. The specialization of dealing with cyber and all this comes much
[41:34] later. This is this is why is it so difficult? Why is it
[41:38] so difficult? And being dent the intent and the narrative that is being spread
[41:44] I think we'll entered that. Thanks once again, good chat and I hope
[41:47] our listeners us also enjoyed it. Once again, do let us know what
[41:52] you thought, what you think of our discussions, and if there's anything that
[41:54] you'd like us to talk about, whatever topic that you think we haven't discussed
[41:59] or you know you would year bond to year from US alves. This time
[42:01] we'll leave a question, I hate crimes terror attacks? Yeah, let's love
[42:07] to hear from your Yeah, do you think hate crimes should qualify a stterror
[42:10] attacks? Yeah? So let us know. Let us know in the comments
[42:14] if you're watching us on YouTube, in the comments, and that's why it's
[42:15] an internal security problem. Yeah, it is. And if you text us
[42:20] a response, you can do that. Text us at eight five double eight
[42:22] nine, double six, double nine six. That's it for this week's defense.
[42:25] Does for more tune in next week they'll learn stay safe and do not
[42:29] cross any boundaries or of passport. Bye bye

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
