# Wagner Uprising: Putin Losing Grip Over Russia’s Ukraine War? | In Our Defence, Ep 65

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 29 Jun 2023, 55 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/55499574/29_jun_23_iod_ep_65_mix_29_june_128.mp3

Amidst the ongoing Russia-Ukraine war, a surprising internal strife has erupted between the Russian military and the Wagner mercenary group, led by Yevgeny Prigozhin, a close ally of Russian President Vladimir Putin. Did Putin foresee the possibility of creating a powerful private military company that could challenge the Kremlin's forces? With Wagner turning against Putin, does this development alleviate the threat to Ukraine and Europe? Why did the uprising fizzle out quickly and require Belarusian intervention? What are the implications of Gorkhas joining the Wagner group? Find out more in this intriguing discussion with host Dev Goswami and "Def Savvy," Abhishek Bhalla.

## Transcript

[0:01] This is in the Today podcasts. There are boundary disputes and then there are
[0:07] outright wars, hot and cold, diplomatic and military. In this podcast,
[0:13] we will dissect all that's brutal and subtle about the defense of our nations.
[0:18] I am Dave Goswami, your host, and I will be joined by a
[0:22] Bishikbala who's been on the front lines of wars and conflicts and has seen the
[0:26] Indian military up close. Hello, and welcome to the sixty fifth episode of
[0:35] In Our Defense. Yeah, what's up? How are you? They?
[0:38] All? Well? All well, busy day, busy weeks, busy weekend,
[0:42] actually a weekend. I was over the weekend. Just before the weekend.
[0:48] I was in office all night. Oh yeah, when the US visit
[0:52] was all right, Oh yes, yes, that was going on. I
[0:55] was in office the concluding layoff for two days. I was fad night for
[1:00] US was I think the last Yeah. So it was a Thursday night and
[1:03] Friday morning and Friday night and Thursday Saturday morning. Yeah, Saturday morning is
[1:08] when Pmod's visit to the US wrapped down. Interesting visit. Some couple of
[1:14] we we've discussed. We've discussed the drones and the Fighter Jet Engines HLD.
[1:19] Yeah, but what we'll discussed on this episode is actually what happened I think
[1:26] just around the same time. I think probably when you were wrapping up your
[1:29] night thurday, however you want to call it, and I was just kind
[1:34] of waking up and something happened in Russia, something that hooked to the entire
[1:38] world for I'm guessing the whole weekend, and then it just mysteriously fizzled out.
[1:44] We're talking about the attempt at coup by the Wagner Group, the mysterious
[1:49] Wagner Group. Not sure if it was an attempted I mean that's I mean,
[1:53] some people call it in coups, something set uprising, some said rebellion,
[1:56] some said, I mean, that's why there's so many conspiracis exactly because
[1:59] no one he knows, there's no clarity what that action was. Yeah,
[2:02] supposed to do, Yeah, exactly. So that's what happened over the weekend,
[2:07] and that's something we'll discuss on this episode. And I'm pretty sure are
[2:10] you know, viewers and listeners will have some interest in this because I'm drinking.
[2:15] Yeah, I've been reading up as much as I can about this group
[2:20] and this group has been you know, in the headlines since the UKN war
[2:23] began, it's been pretty much and out of headlines. I remember us on
[2:28] the online side of the website doing several stories on the group. But what
[2:31] happened this weekend really really put the focus on the group and its leader.
[2:36] You have Guinny Provosion, once known as Putin Chef, noted che So that's
[2:43] uh, I'm trying to you know, oh you find out so exactly is
[2:47] the reason for him to be called his chef? So it's not got nothing
[2:52] to do with that. He made meals for Laddim the pure probably he could
[2:54] get things fixed. No, not even that actually apparently so he operated a
[3:00] catering company in Russia and he his company was awarded contracts for the Russian military
[3:07] uh to cater for their you know, supplies and events sets as from the
[3:10] Russian Ministry of Defense, and some of the money that he earned from those
[3:15] deals, that money was apparently skimmed and then diverted to form this this mysterious
[3:21] magnet. Since he provided food thence vision chef has a very gangster ring to
[3:27] it. Now, Chef Chef right before we do, before we go on
[3:31] on this topic because it's going to be an interesting forty fifteen minute chat I
[3:36] think before we do. But you know, as always a quick word to
[3:38] our listeners and have viewers, you know, do let us know what you
[3:40] think of this podcast whatever chats that A bus and I have on various episodes
[3:44] in various topics. You can drop a you know, mail to us at
[3:46] pots at the retai data dot com that's pods at the date interro dat dot
[3:50] com, or even text us at eight five double nine, double six,
[3:53] double nine six, And if you want, you can also leave a comment
[3:55] wherever you're listening to. You know, it could be YouTube where you're watching
[3:59] us, or it could be able podcast, Google podcast spotified. Steve was
[4:01] a rating to let us know what you think. So let's talk about the
[4:04] Wagner group and before we go to what happened this weekend. You were in
[4:10] Ukraine last year when the war broke out, I think a couple of a
[4:14] few days. I think after the war broke out, you you flew to
[4:15] Ukraine, which is also when we started in our defense. The first few
[4:19] episodes. Our first episode was from was from when I was getting into Ukraine.
[4:25] Yes, yes, yes, yes, and the first few episodes we
[4:29] did talk about your experiences. Then, did you come across any Russian soldiers
[4:32] during your visit? Russian soldiers know, because there was there was that last
[4:38] line which one could which you got. Obviously as a journalist you could not
[4:42] Russian soldiers know. But yeah, I did come across a lot of other
[4:46] foreign soldiers, if we can call so. Well. There certainly weren't boots
[4:51] on the ground, not fighting, but yeah, there were there were people
[4:54] from other nationalities who were part of either intelligence gathering, passing on obtaining training
[5:01] Russian soldiers certainly was part of the mandate given to some of the people that
[5:06] I came across. The Ukrainian soldiers, Yes, Ukrainian soldiers that were given
[5:11] that. People from countries like humans, UK and other European countries were there
[5:15] and they were Yeah, they're openly were saying that we are here to train
[5:19] them. Yeah. The reason I asked you that was that if you had
[5:23] I wanted to know if you had come across soldiers without any arm patches or
[5:29] insignias, because I was watching this documentary about the Wagnon Group. We'll get
[5:34] to what the Wagner Group is in a bit for viewers and listeners who aren't
[5:38] really following this, but before we do so. One of the first times
[5:42] this group made an appearance was also in Ukraine in twenty fourteen, when Russia
[5:47] next Crimea and there were reports of a group of soldiers without any arm patches,
[5:54] without so no way to identify them who they belong to, just bearing
[5:58] the battle fatigues, you know, the that you normally have militaries wearing and
[6:02] obviously moving around with guns. So back then Putin had said, these are
[6:06] you know, locals, there's a natural uprising, there are parallels to yeah,
[6:13] but uh, but later it turned out that this actually was a group
[6:18] of mercenaries, which now we know as the Wagner groups. So that's why
[6:23] I asked to Actually that's why something simil happen in Kurgil. Yeah, yeah,
[6:27] the Pakistani these are local non state actors gotten I know, with the
[6:31] military, but they were basically proper officers and the ones who are not were
[6:38] mercenaries who are backed by them, backed by them, yeah, probably fully
[6:41] trained in professional warfare. Yeah, so it's something similar, is right.
[6:45] Yeah, So what is the Wagner group is actually a very difficult question to
[6:49] answer, but what we've gathered, what I've gathered in the reading that I've
[6:55] been doing, is that it's a private military company, but it's more of
[6:59] an extended arm of the Russian state. It's a state like someone. I
[7:02] think one of the journalists who wrote about this almost call it a non state
[7:08] paramilitary force. What does that mean? I have no idea as an observer
[7:14] of Indian military, which I think qualifies as a professional military. Yes,
[7:18] this is this is a puzzle exactly. I mean, even Indian military officials
[7:24] would wouldn't know what exactly do? What's up? What's up? Non state
[7:29] paramilitary have zero? Only the Russians can explain this. And that's why I
[7:33] have certain really so certain questions that come to mind that make you feel that
[7:42] this this, this whole thing about Russia being a big superpower and a military
[7:48] power. I think all that narrative gets questioned in the last one and a
[7:53] half years. Yes, yes, especially what happened over the weekend. I
[7:55] mean, if you think of it, I mean, I for a second,
[7:59] for a couple of moments, they're actually laughing. Mercenaries. What is
[8:01] going on in this country? Why would you need musteries? I have no
[8:05] answer to that, I can only say that professional military should not depend on
[8:09] mercenaries because they can turn into Frankenstein monsters at any moment. And I don't
[8:16] know whether they turned into a Frankenstein monster right now or not. There's only
[8:18] these theories to go in the round that it was probably a fixed match between
[8:24] the two, so nobody will know the reality. Reality in such cases was
[8:28] always an illusion. In fact, the illusion is the only reality, I
[8:33] think, because nobody will tell you what what was the purpose behind it.
[8:37] But just on the face of it, the idea of a private company being
[8:43] a mercenary army in a country which boasts of a very professional military is mind
[8:50] boggling. Yeah it is, it is. And no, mercenaries do have
[8:56] a history. I mean if you go back, they do have a of
[8:58] course, of course, so high modern professionals advanced militaries. See I can
[9:07] another example, which is actually opposite to what has happened, where where India
[9:15] used sort of mercenaries in a way. It was probably the m yes,
[9:20] but there was a line when you need to sort of now you know,
[9:24] move away from them. It was more of a covert operation operation to go
[9:31] and do a reki so that your army gets a sense of what's happening before
[9:37] they move in create some trouble there. But once the war started, so
[9:43] the local knowledge helped army. But after the war ended, we did not
[9:50] continue with a muti unita seems more of a strategic You carry out operations that
[10:00] you said, you know, you don't know the local lay of land,
[10:01] so you probably exactly rather have the locals or the kind of co there and
[10:05] you know, blend in. And the other is the s strategic front of
[10:09] force that we've spoken so much about. No way you pick up young boys
[10:13] from Ladak, can get them into the army, which is again a sort
[10:18] of a covert. It's not covert anymore. Everybody knows about it, but
[10:22] it's not. It's not a militia. Yeah, it's professional trained. They're
[10:26] trained. They're professional. They're part of a part of a system which is
[10:30] official. It might be secret, yeah, but it's official. And that
[10:33] kind of makes them accountable. I mean, not in maybe perhaps in public
[10:37] like because they're secret, but at least because they're in the system, they're
[10:39] accountable precisely. And there's no scope of them doing a coup. Yeah,
[10:46] absolutely, no scope. I mean I hope. So, but this is
[10:50] this, this was this. Why it's more intriguing is again not because what
[10:54] happened, but the fact that you have empowered a mercenary group so much is
[11:01] what raises questions. Yeah, that they could think they could they could just
[11:03] let you know, walk into Moscow and take over your mind retreat. They
[11:05] were two hundred kilometers close to Moscow. They entered the town of I don't
[11:09] know how to pronounce it, Rostov Rostov wolves far away. Yeah, that's
[11:13] that's about twelve hundred kilometers from Moscow. That's close to the border. You
[11:16] can order. That's where they were operating from. But they moved in about
[11:20] two hundred kilometers from Moscow, so they did travel, managed to travel aboue
[11:24] thousand kilometers, which is which is again very weird. And where was the
[11:28] Russian military four thousand kilometers? That's why the conspiracy theories doing the rounds that
[11:35] this was fixed match. But why is it a fixed match? We can
[11:37] discuss that. Yeah. So yeah, so just again, like us,
[11:41] a little brief about the Magnet group for you know, our listeners and viewers
[11:46] in case they haven't really followed this mysterious group. So, like I said.
[11:50] The first appearance in the world media kind of came during the next section
[11:54] of annexation of Crimea in twenty fourteen, again part of Ukraine. Back then,
[11:58] uh, like I said, there were reports of you know, these
[12:03] untagged Russian looking soldiers taking part in the offensive. Back then Putin has said,
[12:09] key, this is not the Russian military, that these are like locals,
[12:11] natural uprising there to lend models support to them because we believe Crimeyer to
[12:16] be part of Russia, etcetera. But over the years that has been debunked.
[12:20] It's now particularly that the Wagner Group was the one involved and the people
[12:22] seen those non tagged but fatigue wearying soldiers were actually Wagner mercenaries people, uh,
[12:30] you know, soldiers for higher basing. Over the years, then I
[12:33] think the Wagner group spredits reached to Africa, several countries of Africa where it's
[12:37] set up where it basically got in return for security services, that got some
[12:43] business contracts oil mostly and it's a cycle. Basically Kremlin funds Wagner through various
[12:50] shell companies and then they these shell companies go in and you know, invest
[12:54] in African countries for mostly for oil energy. They found that money back to
[12:58] Kremlin. More to it than just being on being a must, yeah,
[13:01] for sure. So what's happened is over the years the Wagner group, especially
[13:07] the CEO, CEO, the head, if you want to be the chief,
[13:11] you want to call it, it's fine to see if it's a company,
[13:13] companies have yeah, the head precosion. It has been seen to be
[13:20] very very close to put in. Yeah, and for decades, this guy,
[13:22] if it's it's it's not a new relationship, it's for decades. I
[13:26] think I put in once any dirty work done, that's the group he'll go
[13:28] to. Because of things that we just discussed. Because this group has no
[13:31] accountability, I can always say not our guys. You know, I don't
[13:35] know who they are. Humilities on involve Ukraine. The current war is bad,
[13:39] things get interesting. That's that's what is the most significant aspect I think
[13:46] of the developments that have happened in the last few days. So earlier,
[13:48] when I said that you know this group has been making some headlines during the
[13:52] war, that's because this group suddenly was seen at the battlefront fighting a war.
[13:58] You don't so, you know, when you said the mercenaries in the
[14:01] modern world don't normally fight war. So you have an example of this company
[14:05] called the black Water US similar private military company, but I don't I haven't
[14:11] seen them fight a war in Iraq or Afghanistan. They were there as like,
[14:13] you know, more or less logistical back support. Yes, there were
[14:16] allegations of torture. Yes, it was like this was like an army unity
[14:20] army regiment. Yes, actually fighting literally at the front lines. Yeah.
[14:24] Yeah, so and they got a lot of success in the place. That's
[14:28] actually one of the one of the points that came doing my research is that
[14:31] these guys apparently were even more effective than the actual Russian military. The reasons
[14:37] I'm not sure, but one could be that deep. Because they'd already been
[14:39] there in eastern Ukraine, yes, for the last for five six years.
[14:46] Yeah, so it was through them that the Russian side was fighting what they
[14:52] called an insurgency. Yeah. So again it's knowing the lay of the line.
[14:56] So they were there, they knew what it takes in the at part
[15:00] of the country to sustain probably in battle, and that's why they got success.
[15:05] Yeah. And also the fact that you know, the Wagner fighters are
[15:09] known to be very ferocious, immoral at times, not at times. I
[15:13] mean, there have been several videos of them torturing people. Many of them
[15:18] are convicts. Many of them are convicts came from prison. Yeah, there's
[15:22] a video of Prevosion I think, standing in front of a Russian jail and
[15:26] basically telling the convicts that I am your get out of jail free card.
[15:30] Yes, you so with me for six months. You know. There is
[15:31] another very interesting theory doing the round. It's not not theory, it's actually
[15:37] factually correct that one of the reasons why Wagner was sort of propped up is
[15:43] because Russia was not getting enough young people to join the military. So interesting,
[15:50] Yeah, that's why it's it's that's why it's might be a mercenary group,
[15:54] but the way of functioning is exactly what a military regiment would be doing.
[16:00] Yeah, so, and that's why people who picked up from prisons and
[16:03] things like that. So the group made headlines. Over the last one year,
[16:07] things seemed fine. So what was covered in the media and what even
[16:11] we read away Okay at TM mercenary group seems shady, seems mysterious, but
[16:15] Russia is Russia. In the last few weeks something went off. We're not
[16:19] sure we don't don't attribute to what's going on in Russia. Shake his back
[16:23] here for a year now, so he's not there to get some ground information.
[16:27] But I'm tracking, tracking stuff as you. The good thing is that
[16:32] when when you go and spend time, even outside of your country, you
[16:34] make friends there. Yeah, you have people easier to attack, so I'm
[16:37] still in touch with them. Yeah, and you get a sense of what's
[16:41] happening after reading news reports. You can sort of cross check with people and
[16:48] ask what does this mean? So how are things on the ground. So
[16:49] I do get a sense, but of course it's not quite the same as
[16:52] being there physically. Yeah. So what happened in the last few weeks,
[16:56] I mean this is if people who've been tracking the Russian war Russia in war,
[17:00] they wouldn't have been supplied to what happened to a weekend because in the
[17:03] last few weeks, Prevosition made some statements, some videos provider yeah against the
[17:08] Russian Minister of Defense Sergei Shoigu and the Russian military chief General Valrie Gerasimov,
[17:17] basically accusing them of not lending enough support to the front line troops. That's
[17:22] where the conspiracy theory is coming. You know, because of your the fixed
[17:26] match between Yeah, yeah, I'm going to come to that and I can
[17:30] see cont wait to get to that. So almost done. So he made
[17:36] some vidy he put them so there's some videos that went viral where he basically
[17:42] accused these two that because of your lack of logistical support, my guys are
[17:48] dying on the front lines. Again, you would not see a mercenary chief
[17:53] countries, Minister of Defense and the army chief that because of your lack of
[17:56] you know, support, my guys are dying, like any chief is saying
[18:00] that. But anyway, so for people who've been watching this war very closely,
[18:03] they saw what was happened though, they saw what was coming, and
[18:06] it kind of happened over the weekend. This guy then said, okay,
[18:10] that's it done for unless these these two go, I'm going to go to
[18:14] Moscow take over the Ministry of Defense. Set things right. Apart from I
[18:18] think one statement he didn't directly challenge putin. He didn't. He didn't,
[18:22] which is where again fixed match things comes in. Right. In fact,
[18:25] he said that this is not not against Russia, patriot to topple the government,
[18:30] not to the government. This is just about these two corrupt guys.
[18:33] It's you know, I'm a failures, yeah, etc. So that's the
[18:40] background of what happened over the weekend. Then, of course, you know,
[18:42] he launched a march, went to Rostov, you know, to cover
[18:47] the Southern Command of the Russian military, I think over there the headquarters of
[18:49] them. There there were videos on social media of the Wagner soldiers walking et
[18:53] cetera, mysterious to play four US later they're walking back. Yeah, there's
[18:59] a proposion, note are walking back. Putin had I think, without using
[19:03] those words, almost sad and thread to kill him, basically saying people who
[19:07] backstabbed us will not be spared. But now he is apparently an examined Belarus.
[19:11] So there is a deal that people who want to go to Belarus can
[19:15] go to Belarus along with precausion. Those who want to stay back can stay
[19:19] back and sign an agreement within the military of Defense, basically to take part
[19:25] in the military. Yeah. So somebody who's picked up arms against the country
[19:30] is being happily welcomed in your own military. Unheard of. So that's what
[19:36] happened over the weekend. Reason is, and backstabbing is the biggest crime and
[19:41] sin that can that one can commit being in a military military exactly. So
[19:45] here technically they were not part of the military. But even after the action
[19:52] that they did, which was completely against the military, which I in my
[19:56] this thing vocabulary, it would be treasoned, they're being welcomed with open arms.
[20:02] Yeah. This is almost like you know, India saying the GM chief
[20:04] can stay in examined Pakistan forever, yes, we won't do anything, or
[20:08] the lity chief can just like yeah whatever. You can draw parallels of any
[20:12] insurgent group or whatever who's picked up arms saying that fine, you can go
[20:18] and stay in some other country, we won't say anything, and those who
[20:21] want to stay backs and join our forces. Right. So that's what happened
[20:27] over the weekend. Sobi, now, first thoughts, you've been cracking this
[20:32] closely. You follow defense, you follow wars. What do you make of
[20:34] what two scenarios? One of course, that this is all on the face
[20:40] of it, what we are seeing is correct. This is what whatever has
[20:44] happened. There's no conspiracy theory. This is what actually happened. And Russia
[20:48] and the leadership in Russia believe that this is the best way to ensure that
[20:55] there's no civil war. This is what Putin said. But you know,
[20:57] if this was not stopped the war, so in, if this scenario is
[21:03] the correct one, it shows the political leadership in extremely polite. And Putin
[21:10] is supposed to be a strong leader. That's the that's my take on strong
[21:14] leaders. You know, I think it's a it's a term which doesn't mean
[21:18] much. You don't define what strong leaders are supposed to do, and very
[21:22] often without getting into details and examples, when when strong leaders take some weird
[21:30] steps, these kind of things happen. So that's number one. So if
[21:36] this is true, whatever happen, it shows the leadership in very polite.
[21:41] If this is not true and it's a it's a conspiracy, it still shows
[21:45] the leadership in very polite because in the second scenario especially, there is a
[21:51] big acknowledgment of your failures in Ukraine, because that's exactly what Preclusion said.
[21:57] The premise of is you know, doing this act was to punish those who
[22:06] are responsible for failures. Now it's very convenient to say that those responsible for
[22:14] failures in Ukraine are just the Defense Minister and the military chiefs. The decision
[22:18] to go to war was certainly wasn't there. So that's where I think that
[22:23] whatever has happened, I think it's frustration is creeping in in Russia big time
[22:30] on where this war is headed. And now my theory not a conspiracy theory
[22:36] that you've probably seen or read anywhere else, because I was in Ukraine for
[22:41] a long time, more than a month. I sort of have the map
[22:45] of Ukraine now completely he it just there is a there is a switch whenever
[22:49] we talk of Ukraine, that switch automatically is put on. So where is
[22:55] Belarus north of Ukraine? That's where the first assault came from. It came
[23:02] from north of Ukraine. Idea was to capture Kievs, armored columns, tanks
[23:07] rolling in. It was aborted because the Russians faced heavy casualty. I have
[23:14] been to all those places which i'm north of Kief and there was a blood
[23:18] bath when I saw tanks queued up that were charred Russian tanks. There were
[23:26] places a place that I visited closer to the border thrust the Enets, that's
[23:30] where the Russians were actually in occupation for forty fifty days there to go back.
[23:37] So now my theory is that with Russia and not getting the kind of
[23:41] success that they want, and the war being restricted only to the eastern part
[23:47] of Ukraine. That border, you could have Belarus pregusion coalition attempting another assault
[23:56] from the north. Because the DA is to capture Kiev. Kiv falls,
[24:03] obviously the war is over. Yeah, that's something that was planned by Russia,
[24:07] war gamed by Russia, but not always do you get all your war
[24:11] games right. And that's exactly what happened. There were several locations north of
[24:18] Kiev, one of them being Boucha, which is just about fifty sixty kilometers
[24:22] outside of Kiev, where there was a big, big battle. Cherney Hive
[24:27] is another place close where from where the assault had come again from the north.
[24:33] The town was completely destroyed, but for some reason the Russians had to
[24:37] retreat. So my theory is that why is he going to Belaroos? Yeah,
[24:44] that's the same question. Why is he going to Belaroos? Why are
[24:47] they setting up sort of a camp or whatever you want to say in Belarus
[24:52] has to be some reasoning for it. It's not. It's not simply an
[24:55] exile, because they remember that it's not just him. The option also is
[25:00] for many of his soldiers to go with it exactly. And so why why
[25:03] Belarus is an option is why can't all of them stay in Russia? Why
[25:08] Belarus? Yeah, because I mean there is a direct connection. Yeah.
[25:12] Excuse wondering this, because one of the questions that I had over the weekend
[25:17] was that why was it that Belarus had to interfere in the first place.
[25:21] If this guy, you know, Belarus is a state which is in which
[25:25] is which is a puppet, it's in the it's in Russian hands. And
[25:29] that's why that's why I said the first assault came from belous. In fact,
[25:33] before the attack happened, there were military drill drills happening and all of
[25:40] them were armored drills, So that probably gave enough indication that it's going to
[25:44] be an armored assault. And that's why I think the Ukrainians were prepared with
[25:49] the anti tank missiles, anti tank weaponry, because they had them in huge
[25:56] numbers. Every everywhere that I saw Ukrainian especially in the early stages, every
[26:03] small formation had these you know, shoulder fired anti tank weapons with them because
[26:11] that they were prepared for it. The same drills I think the US had
[26:15] flagged before the war. Yeah, it was in public, to mean,
[26:18] everybody knew that this is happening. You can't stop this. In this day
[26:22] and ages, everything is visible to so many eyes in the sky, So
[26:26] everybody knew that it's going to be an armored assault that they're likely to carry,
[26:32] and that's why Ukraine was prepared. So I have a feeling that whatever
[26:37] is happening in Belarus now with the Wagner company and obviously some assistance from Russia
[26:44] somewhere very speculative. Again, but this this is my hypothesis why they uprising
[26:51] in the first place, or was that just not that. Either either the
[26:56] uprising is completely genuine where there is anger again the military, or it's a
[27:00] fixed match. In both scenarios, as I say, there is a sense
[27:07] of some kind of failure on the Russian side for an outsider to observe in
[27:12] both scenarios, especially in the second one, because I mean when you say
[27:15] that you know this is like a deal, I mean your theory that this
[27:18] is a deal struck to ensure that Wagner and his group of soldiers remain in
[27:22] Belarus close to the Ukraine and border from where a fresh salt can be planned.
[27:27] This looks like if you just like take a look back for this mighty
[27:33] Russian for this mighty Russian military to such lens had to want to such lens
[27:41] to attack a so called tiny country, just tells you that this superpower,
[27:47] like the biggest the episode, like you said, is just not a no.
[27:51] That's that's why I say that the idea of the whole idea of being
[27:53] a superpower is needs to be kelly spelled out. What does it entail?
[28:00] I mean, according to me, any country which is a nuclear military nuclear
[28:03] power is a superspowerer. But I mean, what's India's standards used as a
[28:10] deterrent, no first use and things like that. So modern day warfare has
[28:15] probably changed so much that just having the resources is not enough. There's more
[28:23] to tactics as well as operations and strategy when you plan something like this.
[28:33] Even China, whatever has happened in Ladak, Yeah, we've discussed that.
[28:37] Yes, there are we faced sort of reverses somewhere. The Chinese are sitting
[28:42] right, they're not going back, But at the same time, it's not
[28:45] spanned out exactly the way Chinese wanted. Yes, it's not a kke walk.
[28:51] The fact that they have to player, wait and watch game, cat
[28:55] and mouse game. That's that's not what you want when you want to take
[28:57] hold of land anyway. So I think this whole concept of a superpower sometimes
[29:04] turns out to be a hyperbole because when when things have to be translated on
[29:10] ground, they might not be what the superpower tag talks about. It can
[29:17] sort of humble you in real time scenarios. So there's no doubt that I'm
[29:22] not saying that Russia is a useless military. They don't have the resources like
[29:26] that. But it's not a cake walk. One and a half years have
[29:30] gone by, probably another half year will probably be two years, two and
[29:34] a half. It's getting a country to surrender in the modern day is not
[29:41] easy, clearly. I mean this, it's not easy. And you might
[29:45] give whatever reasons that the West is supporting them, but that's geopolitics. You're
[29:49] supposed to do those calculations. That's what makes you superpower. That's what strategic
[29:55] vision is. If you can get enough countries to back you during a war,
[29:57] and why should why should you you expect that some country will fight alone?
[30:02] Exactly if that's the assumption, And that's not a very professional way of
[30:04] strategizing. I think anybody who feels that they are a superpower needs to do
[30:10] this kind of introspection. Taiwan and China. Again, China has not had
[30:14] their way. They can also cry foul that America is supporting them. Yeah
[30:18] they are so, so be it right? What do you think this does
[30:23] now to Putin's image, whether it's domestic or internationally, because, like we
[30:30] mentioned crucial point that throughout the happenings of the weekend progusion never directly mentioned he
[30:41] attacked the Minister of Defense, he attacked the Army Chief, the military chief,
[30:45] also giving rise to speculation maybe this was just like a sharad so that
[30:48] Putin could then take action against those two and like put the entire blame of
[30:52] the failed war so far on those two and kind of clear his hands of
[30:56] the mess against lots of speculation, lots of conspiracy theories because we just don't
[31:00] know exactly what's going on. What's what's going on. But regardless, like
[31:04] you said that, even if this was a sharad, even if this was
[31:08] like a fixed game for something like this to happen in the first place under
[31:12] a strongman leader, that itself is it's embarrassing. It's embarrassing. And again
[31:18] again I go back to what we understand best and what we relate to more.
[31:23] I just don't get the logic of having a mercenary group. I mean,
[31:29] if somebody can explain to me how that is important. I think the
[31:33] only strategic importance one can draw out of it is how they've sent them to
[31:37] Africa and things like that, and they virtually work as a company giving assistance.
[31:44] But at what expense? Again, you can send UN troops and things
[31:48] like that to other countries, but a mercenary group when they come back.
[31:53] Yeah, And the only parallel that we can draw not a parallel, but
[31:59] just they were concerns raised about AGNEV Also isn't yes yes in India, Yeah,
[32:04] not saying that they are they're going to be mercenaries. Actually, some
[32:06] people did go to the extent of saying that they'll end up being mrscenaries people.
[32:10] I don't agree with that, as will not end up being. But
[32:15] the question remains, what will they do the guys who don't make it for
[32:20] the entire service, what do they do after they leave? We've discussed that
[32:22] as well in detail. So if we raised questions on agne what will people
[32:30] do after four years of military service? Then this is I mean, this
[32:35] is blasphemous if you are to compare and Agne is like really an very innocent
[32:42] kind of idea, and isn't it. But you know, coming back to
[32:45] Lassia and to answer you, not answer you a question, but just to
[32:49] expand on the thought, I think, why what was a mercenary group doing
[32:52] in the first place in a war? I think the answer not just in
[32:54] a war, what space does it have in a country? In a country?
[32:59] So I mean, like you said, one Africa, a country which
[33:01] is one can argue that putin b is like a dictator and things like that,
[33:06] but it's not quote and quote a dictatorship. Yeah, yeah, so
[33:08] you can you can have mercenary groups where where there is a dictator and he
[33:13] says, okay, this group will function there. This group will function there.
[33:16] So technically, theoretically, RuSHA is not a country that functions like this.
[33:22] So why did they need I can't make sense of that. In One
[33:27] reasoning given for such groups, especially in the case of Wagner's, is that
[33:30] that allows us share to keep its official Yes, yes, so that's maybe
[33:35] foreign foreign operation. Like twenty fourteen when the war started, and the numbers
[33:40] have risen from five thousand, they've gone up to fifty sixty thousand. But
[33:45] that's also hollow because after a point people will see through it. I mean,
[33:47] like, what's happening right now everyone knows I mean Wagner, no Wagner
[33:50] military, no military. I mean, these are Russians. At the end
[33:52] of the day, it's part of Putin's larger plan, and he's suffering losses.
[33:57] Whether it's the Wagner groups guys who are dying, or whether it's an
[33:59] actual rush. Anybody who was on the front line, anybody was on the
[34:02] front line is fighting Russia's war. Putin's balls, Putin's ball is getting a
[34:08] face aside said so yeah, I mean I don't really a part maybe otherwise,
[34:15] you know, the discussion that we had on the Ukraine War, one
[34:19] reason could be, especially in the current context, could be that because the
[34:22] Russian military was perhaps unprepared, not unprepared, was taken by surprise with Ukraine
[34:28] resistance and they did not know what to do. They just turned to the
[34:31] only available force that they had, like, oh, we have a Wagner
[34:35] group, or they're armed, or they not to fight, Oh they weren't
[34:37] cragny before. Let's just send them to the front line. Okay, just
[34:39] just to just to play devil's advocate. I mean, we've we've sort of
[34:45] slammed Russian strategy till now, not that I mean war experts any Yeah,
[34:51] I mean exactly, so just to give another kind of scenario that we missed.
[34:57] So yeah, I mean, it's it's very not that in war things
[35:00] don't pan out the way you plan and war game which has happened. Let's
[35:06] assume that that has happened, and that's why I strategy is a long term
[35:09] game vision and not something that you decide overnight and get results within a week
[35:15] or a month or two months. So Russia has at least been successful in
[35:21] ensuring that now the Ukrainian forces are only focusing on the east. And when
[35:30] they attacked from the north, the idea was to sort of create confusion within
[35:37] the Russian forces where do they fight? Do they go south? Because there
[35:40] was a threat of Russia coming from Crimea as well, so do they go
[35:45] south, do they go north? Do they go east? Subsequently, in
[35:50] the last one and a half years, the war is now restricted to the
[35:54] east. Entire Ukrainian force is fighting and fighting hard in the east. So
[36:01] the scenario that we were discussing, why this could be a fixed match and
[36:07] why the Wagner group, along with support from Belarus and some Russian units can
[36:15] move in from the north. Once again, that's where the Russians, that's
[36:20] where the Ukrainians not that strong right now, So the element of surprise.
[36:24] But again, if I and you can talk about it, I'm sure Ukrainian
[36:27] military must have tea, isn't it. I'm not that great a chane care
[36:35] of military off. So if I can discuss this, I'm sure they have
[36:38] because I mean, honestly, I didn't think of this, but now that
[36:42] you mentioned it, Yeah, it does seems a pretty plausible that you know
[36:45] this could be because I'm pretty sure no one in Ukraine is resting you.
[36:49] These guys, have you know, its band aid. Oh, they're watching
[36:52] I'm sure they're watching them. They know that this war is a long one
[36:54] to fight. Yeah, I'm sure they'll do their calculations as well. Yeah,
[36:59] and one thing that you were war in Ukraine has shown as a Ukraine
[37:04] has has proven to be quite smart. Yes, of course, but the
[37:07] way it's gone about even next it's a game of chess sort of thing.
[37:13] You you you do some things, you concealed some things. Element of surprise
[37:17] is what wins wars. Russia has not got right that element of surprise.
[37:23] Probably whatever they thought will surprise did not quite turn out that way. And
[37:31] Cargill was the element of surprise by Pakistan that sort of pushed us back,
[37:37] initially shocked us, but we had the resilience to fight back the Indian hours.
[37:43] So I think that that seventy one it was the element of surprise that
[37:49] you know, Pakistan was suddenly taken aback opening the Eastern Front. When the
[37:53] Eastern Front was opened, you suddenly, you know, did this big blockade
[37:59] in Karachi yacht, so you know, while you're fighting a land war in
[38:04] the Eastern Front, Sudaly Mayby is blocking your port. So that it was
[38:07] the element of surprise, solid planning, I'm sure, as you have planned.
[38:12] But that element of surprise could not reach that levels where the adversary was
[38:17] completely pinned down. There was some vacuum somewhere where you allowed the enemy to
[38:24] stand up again again. The enemy again, Ukraine, It's it's happening again.
[38:30] They stand up again. They're put down again the stand up. So
[38:31] it's going on. At some point of time, maybe that that one move
[38:37] will come which nobody would have predicted from Russia. You mean, could be
[38:42] from cold could be see Ukraine is fighting a defensive Yeah, yeah, the
[38:45] aggressor. Obviously Ukraine is fighting a war to defend. And I don't think
[38:51] Ukraine will carry out an operation and say we've taken a bill rush. Of
[38:53] course, so you're saying, don't take it for granted that Russia has done
[38:58] for yes, yes, of course we'll talk more on this, but after
[39:01] a quick break. Hello, I'm Raj Chamgapa from India Today Podcasts and your
[39:13] host for Nothing but the Truth. Every week we will deal with key issues
[39:19] of concern and bring your perspectives and clarity as to why this should matter to
[39:24] you and what is the clear truth that emerges. Welcome back, Abishag and
[39:38] I are talking about the Rashiukrain War and what happened over the weekend when the
[39:44] Mercenary Group Wagner, led by a Navy precosition launched an armed uprising is what
[39:49] Prussia calls it against the Ministry of Defense. That's what they say. The
[39:54] precos group that it wasn't an uprising against the government per se against Putin was
[40:00] mostly true with how the Ministry of Defense Russian Ministry of Defense. I find
[40:04] this distinction also quite very I was just going to come to that, like
[40:07] but by president, Ministry of Defense corrupt, guy, my military of corrupt.
[40:13] These two are responsible for the entire Ukraine. Were going to sow if
[40:16] the dogs, if there is I mean, you are saying that if there
[40:19] is a coup against the Ministry of Defense and the military, but should not
[40:23] be read as a coup against the political leadership, against brutal doesn't make sense,
[40:29] doesn't make sense. Nothing about this happening that happened over the weekend makes
[40:35] makes any sense. But you know, before we come my maker of sense
[40:37] to Russians, if they're actually if they're up to something. Yeah, there
[40:42] is some there is some plan, strategy, strategy behind this. But before
[40:45] we you know, circle back to the back group. I just want to
[40:47] quickly again go back to the larger Ukraine war. It's what we were discussing
[40:52] just before the break and how you said, you know, he should not
[40:57] pick the for granted that Russia has done for for now and this this war
[41:00] in Ukraine has really shown us many many different facets of a modern, modern
[41:04] day war. When you were talking, I was just reminded during the initial
[41:07] stage of the war, when you know, the West did everything except to
[41:10] actually enter the war. You know, they said, no, we'll give
[41:14] them so many arms, we'll give them so much training. There was a
[41:17] lot of criticism actually in media and social media that the West is just talking
[41:23] not doing much, you know, junk chidy hair and you know, you
[41:27] guys are just like talking because of your that that signed agreement NATO, that
[41:30] you know, if you actually entered the war, then you'll be inviting Rashia
[41:34] to attack you on your homeland as well, that that was a risk because
[41:37] of it. You did not even take Ukraine into NATO, because if you
[41:39] took Ukraine in NATO, then you would have had to actually enter the war
[41:43] as part of NATO agreements. That reminded me what you were talking just before
[41:46] the break of this, and it also reminded me of what you had said
[41:50] in an earlier episode that people don't really know what the West has been doing
[41:54] to actually help Ukraine. So what we've seen over the last year and a
[41:58] half, the fact that just like if you take a Wagner's uprising on the
[42:02] face of it, that there is dissatisfaction in Russia over a failed war.
[42:06] A year and a half later, no one knows where this war is going.
[42:07] Ukraine has done much much better than what people are expected. Do you
[42:12] think it all harks back to what you had said in an episode of previously,
[42:15] that you know, the West has been giving some solid support, which
[42:17] there is obviously support in terms of financial support, in terms of military equipment,
[42:23] in terms of strategy as well advice and things like that and how to
[42:29] go about. I have witnessed in the UK where the UK Army is actually
[42:37] training the Ukrainian Army and it's a matter of record. It's it's not something
[42:40] that they're hiding hiding. So yeah, his support has been given him.
[42:44] What else is support in war? Of course, they can't send their boots
[42:46] on the ground, nobody will do that, but there has been Without the
[42:52] support, Ukraine wouldn't have sustained. I mean, there's absolutely no doubt about
[42:57] it, So that that's very clear. Right, Let's talk about the Wagner
[43:02] group again now and the report recently. I wanted to talk to you about
[43:07] this regardless of what happened this weekend. By the way, because recently we
[43:10] talked about the Nepali gurkash and how China was eyeing them and how the nav
[43:16] schemes after effect. One of the after impacts are one of the impacts of
[43:21] India's naval scheme was that the Nepali Gurkas were a bit confused about you know,
[43:24] what's the future in the start has still not started because I still not
[43:30] resumed of the concerns of what happens to them after the four years in the
[43:34] Indian military. Nepalikas also served in the British army. There's a report by
[43:40] a national publication that some Nepalis apparently have joined the Wagner Group. Did you
[43:45] come across that, Yes, yes, there are reports and in fact I
[43:50] think first report came in Nepali presson yeah, yeah, first and then a
[43:55] couple of days back, Annascent Platform Billing Cat has in fact geolocated places where
[44:04] these guys are actually training in Russia. So these are military Russian military camps
[44:10] with the kind of the pictures that were doing the rounds. The geolocated those
[44:15] and they have actually established that these official Russian military camps and then there are
[44:21] some reports saying that that they could be joining the Wagner Group. So yeah,
[44:27] are in demand for sure, whether it's the Russian military or the Wagner
[44:30] Group China, you know, keeping an eye on them. I think we
[44:35] should find a way out to get them back everything. Yeah. But you
[44:39] know, the point that I want to make is for someone like me,
[44:44] I've never imagined war to be like this that you have. You know,
[44:47] people from different nationalities going to an army, you have a private military company
[44:52] of fighting at the at the front lines, and the oh it shakes our
[44:57] sensibility. Is the kind of system that we follow. For us, the
[45:00] only military is and if we can quote unquote call the Nepalese foreigners, which
[45:07] in military terminology they aren't, because they are such an integral part of India's
[45:15] military history. And we can again go and talk about for hours if we
[45:21] start talking about the contribution of Gurkhas in the Indian army. Yes so,
[45:25] and it also shows that the Gurkhas are true soldiers. I mean, if
[45:31] you don't take us, we'll go somewhere else. We need to be in
[45:36] that fighting mood every time. And as I said earlier, in one of
[45:40] our podcasts that gentle Warriors, gentlemen Warrior, if you want to see skorkas
[45:52] the speakless, very soft spoken, don't shout. They don't even use swear
[45:58] words. And if you use it, they get very emotional, which is
[46:02] very unlike a military which is so much they're very sensitive. Yeah. Right,
[46:10] So final thought on this, Uh, what do you think this the
[46:16] happenings of the weekend, whatever you've seen in the last year and a half.
[46:21] When it comes to the Wagner Group's involvement in the Ukraine world, what
[46:23] does that have to say about this whole concept of private militaries. Because I'll
[46:29] tell you something, something that is very striking is during this war, the
[46:32] Russia Ukraine War, there have been maybe two or three people who've taken the
[46:38] line that a minute comes to grabbing attention in videos or on social media or
[46:43] wherever. One obviously put in because he's the president of Russia, the other
[46:46] being Zelenski because of his you know, the sort of rocks are attitude,
[46:51] the fatigue green olive green t shirt that he has goes around, good optics,
[46:54] good optics, very good optics, and precotion. At least in the
[47:00] last few days, because I haven't seen a Russian military general giving like a
[47:05] pep talk to their soldiers as much as I have seen Pregosi and giving a
[47:08] pep talk to his soldiers. Because all those videos where we talked about in
[47:13] this episode, they at I'm not sure where they were shot, but they
[47:15] seem to be from a war zone, you know. You like when he
[47:17] was accusing the Minister of Defense of Russia and the military chief of you know,
[47:22] not sending in a ammunition, he was next to a pile of bodies,
[47:24] which he said, you know, these are the people you've let kill
[47:27] because of your incompetence. When he was you know, addressing those those those
[47:32] convicts that he was supposed to like, you know, conscript into his army,
[47:37] he was in front of an actual jail and that's what it looked like.
[47:40] So he also has maybe maybe maybe uptakes an information warfare. But to
[47:45] go back to what you said earlier in this episode, to embolden somebody to
[47:50] an extent that that person, if if we assume what happened over the weekend
[47:54] has actually happened to a point where he feels strong enough to take on the
[48:00] Usian government, don't you think this is just a mess for Russian lessons to
[48:02] learn. I mean we started from there. Both the scenarios on the face
[48:07] of it don't make Russia and Russian leadership look good, whether it's a genuine
[48:15] attempted overthrow of the military or it's fixed in both scenarios. I at least
[48:22] as an outsider, I'm not Russian, I'm not Ukrainian. Just as a
[48:27] citizen of the world, I wouldn't want this image to be seen for my
[48:35] country because it does seem that something has gone horribly wrong, and there is
[48:39] an acknowledgement somewhere, but it has gone wrong. Yes, they can hit
[48:45] back, they can come up with some trump card or whatever, but at
[48:51] least for the time being, it does it doesn't look good. Last question,
[48:55] what do you have friends in the Indian security establishment, the experts,
[49:00] But they as intrigued as us on this because see they're training their way of
[49:07] thinking. They're psyche military, private military companies, and it's not something that
[49:15] they are they're accustomed to, away comfortable with. And luckily we've had so
[49:21] many service army chiefs, service chiefs, top generals off record on record whatever
[49:27] you want to say, clearly said that you know, we are not we
[49:30] are not the kind of a military that's made for coups and create this kind
[49:34] of that's that's just not there in ur DNA. Yeah, so for them,
[49:38] this is a very extremely alien kind of concept. I'd get that because
[49:45] I mean that's the same for me, like whenever I Yes, for somebody
[49:51] like me, probably you or so many of those who follow military, this
[49:55] looks like some kind of a you know, some kind of a story.
[50:00] How can this be true? Exactly? How? Yeah, So it's our
[50:05] sensibilities, isn't it. And the kind of culture that we have seen,
[50:07] even Pakistan for that matter, no matter how much you said, yeah,
[50:12] they'll do a coup against a civilian leadership, but an army with an army
[50:17] doesn't make even they have not ventured with it. Yes, they did send
[50:22] mercenaries and things like that on more than one occasion. They did it in
[50:29] forty seven, they did it in ninety nine. It was first the mismoscenaries
[50:34] that came in. So yeah, that you can call it tactics or something,
[50:37] but I was going to come to that. I mean that was the
[50:39] only tactical Yeah, it was too like escape the international blame that who are
[50:43] the one doing it. But what I'm maybe maybe in twenty fourteen, Uh,
[50:47] this is something similar that the Russians had planned. Yes, but these
[50:53] guys got so much power and so much as you said in Bolden, that
[51:00] probably things changed on the ground. And even if it's that's what I'm saying,
[51:06] even if it's the conspiracy theory that we've discussed that it's a fixed match
[51:08] with Putin, the fact that Putin is allowing them to do this kind of
[51:14] abuse their own military chiefs and things like that, or something it is,
[51:17] It is something. There's definitely something that will never make us believe what's happening
[51:24] is okay, it will shake our sensibility. Yeah, I think unless we
[51:30] year more and read more about this, I'll just go with what you said
[51:32] earlier. Frankenstein's monster probably is that why would you want to create a one?
[51:37] See, such decisions are not Again, I could be speaking too early.
[51:43] Such decisions as definitely not taken to gain overnight advantages. Maybe year down
[51:51] the line, the Wagner groups actions wins the war for Russia. Yeah,
[51:55] but what happens twenty years, twenty five years after that for that victory if
[52:00] they get it, Yeah, because if they're the ones to get it,
[52:02] then what's the Russian military for? So might as well have the Bagnic group
[52:07] the official military of Russia. Maybe you'll have a competition that who's the official
[52:10] militi Russia. So for me, that that is completely breakdown of normal civil
[52:17] life, even though you're talking militaries, but it's a breakdown of life.
[52:22] Yeah. And you know, we can sit here and joke about it,
[52:25] you know, miles miles away from it, but the fact is that the
[52:30] situation then it's actually quite horrific for people in Russia, for people in just
[52:35] to just to put putocross one more point. While the competition between two militaries
[52:39] is obviously a scary thought, in India, we've seen competition between police police
[52:45] force of one state and another, especially in anti terror operations. And when
[52:51] we sort of question that and find a lot of vulnerable vulnerabilities with that kind
[52:59] of a mindset, Yeah, because you end up doing illegal things at times,
[53:07] yes, very unprofessional, definitely encounters extra judicial killings. One of the
[53:12] reasons is this kind of competition. So when we question this competition within police
[53:16] forces of our states, just imagine a situation where there are two armies competing
[53:23] competing against Yeah, it's a scary thought. Yeah, I think we'll ended
[53:30] there, good chat once again as usual, good insights, good talk,
[53:37] And I think we'll have to watch this a bit more. It just happened
[53:38] over the we yes, uh, And to be honest, I think Ask
[53:43] and I both actually are quite confused about what happened. He has a theory,
[53:46] and solid one at that, by the way, But the theory is
[53:50] based on just like in years of following the World of Defense and of course
[53:53] following the Russia between war and the happenings in that war. But what's happened
[54:00] is very quite in reading, so we keep following it hopefully, you know,
[54:05] when we know more the stories not stories out over. I think,
[54:07] yeah, the stories out over definitely, if he's still there in Belarus with
[54:12] contingent of people who are loyal to who are loyal to him and trained in
[54:16] armed warfare. Stories not over, and like you said, just north of
[54:20] Ukraine where the first trick was cried out. So we'll wait and we'll see
[54:24] what happens. So that's it. Thanks thanks to oproducer and up here this
[54:29] knee as as always, and thanks to our listeners and viewers. You know,
[54:31] let us know what he thought of this episode. Paper texts to us
[54:34] at eight at nine double six, double nine six, or an email to
[54:37] us at pots at the rate, interreday dot com, Let's bods at the
[54:39] rate interday dot com. That's it for the Speaks Defense tours for more Union
[54:44] next week. They'll then stay safe and not cross any bounties at a passport. Bye bye

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
