# Predator Drones Coming to India: Why It's A Big Deal | In Our Defence, Ep 66

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 6 Jul 2023, 44 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/56013916/06_jul_23_in_our_deence_6_july_ep_66_128.mp3

During the state visit of Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the US from June 21 to 24, India successfully finalized a significant government-to-government deal with the United States. The agreement involves the procurement of 31 Predator drones, amounting to a value exceeding USD 4 billion. In this episode, host Dev Goswami and "Def Savvy” Abhishek Bhalla, discuss why this is a big deal and what are its implications for the respective countries involved. Abhishek Bhalla emphasizes the magnitude of this acquisition by comparing it to the procurement of a fighter jet deal. The purchase of advanced drones carries immense strategic importance for both nations. The conversation delves into the underlying strategic interests associated with the deal. Abhishek emphasized that these agreements extend beyond the current leadership of Presidents Biden and Modi; they lay the groundwork for future political administrations as well. Similar precedent was established through a template set with Russia in previous years. The duo expands on the potential of such a deal, discussing how the enhanced surveillance capabilities offered by the drones could revolutionize warfare. Abhishek offers the intriguing possibility of conducting surgical strikes without risking the lives of soldiers, thanks to the extended reach of surveillance these drones provide. The discussion also explores the curiosity surrounding the greater insistence of the United States on finalizing this deal, despite India's expressed interest. It is intriguing to ponder why the US attaches more urgency to the agreement. Listen in! Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound mix by Kapil Dev Singh Do check our website here!

## Transcript

[0:01] This is in the Today podcasts. There are boundary disputes and then there are
[0:07] outright wars, hot and cold, diplomatic and military. In this podcast,
[0:13] we will dissect all that's brutal and subtle about the defense of our nations.
[0:18] I am Dave Goswami, your host, and I will be joined by Abishakala,
[0:22] who's been on the front lines of wars and conflicts and has seen the
[0:26] Indian military up close. Hello, and welcome to the sixty sixth episode of
[0:35] An Our Defense. How are you well? How are you doing all?
[0:39] Well? You look a bit harried. It's it's been a tough day and
[0:42] that's the reason why we are recording later the day as well. Yeah,
[0:46] it's almost seven pm. We try to usually do it earlier in the day.
[0:50] Yeah, I think five has been has been the standard yeast day at
[0:54] five. Yeah, in the day later, But so so much of drama
[0:58] happening in marastratical developments. So just really caught up with so many things.
[1:03] I'm sure you've been caught up as with them. Fully, fully, that's
[1:06] what I mean. We were discussing on our group as well, is body,
[1:07] what do we talk about? Because I think you know what, I
[1:11] was pretty sure that we have to talk about this, but it's just that
[1:15] I couldn't get time to respond. I mean it might sound that not getting
[1:19] time to respond because there are so many WhatsApp groups that you're part of.
[1:22] Yeah, so I the ones that you're fixed with something. I knew that
[1:26] I'm gonna do this, so I said, t K, we can sort
[1:27] of procrastinate answering what you could you're going to do. Let's fix things that
[1:33] are still not done learn exactly. Yeah, So both of us caught up
[1:36] with the political developments and Manster, it's part of our you know, daily
[1:38] day job, so I can't really help that part. Yeah. So this
[1:42] week we'll talk about something that we refer to last episode, and we talked
[1:47] briefly the episode before that. Um, it's to do with PM these visits
[1:53] to the US, after which one of the announcements of the many announcements made
[1:57] was that India will be going ahead with what was speculated before a deal to
[2:02] buy the US predator rone. Actually I think it's called the Reaper, the
[2:07] one, the one that India, but I think that's a moral A reaper
[2:12] is another version. This is the MQ nine B. So the big differences
[2:16] this has the capability to be armed. India doesn't have a weaponized drone webstill
[2:23] now, so that's where this will be a huge, huge boost in India's
[2:29] military capabilities to have drones beca are still now. Indian military establishment, security
[2:35] establishment uses rons only for service picking up data, picking up information reckis.
[2:44] But if rons can do a dual job duo RECKI and at the same time
[2:47] strike, that's that's breaches another level of modern day warfing. We've seen a
[2:54] current wars beat Ukraine or so many operations done by the US forces in Afghanistan,
[3:02] and that's what has made made a big difference. And we all talk
[3:06] about AI artificial intelligence in our lives, isn't it Just before before we started
[3:12] recording, there was a mention by Anna about chat GPT, So that's our
[3:15] small little drone. Isn't it our weaponized drones? How we use it is
[3:22] I don't know and that that will decide, be chat GPT or these kind
[3:25] of drones. So yes, because we don't have the experience of using them.
[3:30] So first part would be to gain that knowledge, which obviously will come
[3:35] when the acquisition happens. But yeah, for me. This is a big,
[3:38] big acquisition, as big as getting fighter jets, probably because because it's
[3:44] an acquisition that you don't have till now, you don't have that kind of
[3:49] a product till now. And everyone talks about about when it comes to drones,
[3:53] that famous al Zawaii killing. Yes, the hell Fire missile. So
[3:58] I mean, I'm not sure if they're going to be quick with the hell
[4:00] Fires missiles, but yeah, I mean those when you think those kind of
[4:04] images al Zawari standing in a balcony and some bird comes and just kills him.
[4:12] Yeah, and no collateral damage, nothing else is you know, even
[4:15] damaged, no lives lost, just the target sounds too cool. Yeah,
[4:20] and even the top getting mistaken, if I'm not wrong, Iranian or Iraqi.
[4:26] Yeah, yeah, the general he was also killed by US military prone
[4:31] strike, and I think the Reaper was involved. I'm not wrong. I
[4:33] think. See, they don't they don't, they don't give out they don't
[4:35] give out details whether they use that or not. But yeah, there are
[4:39] a lot of things that the Predator has been used in these kind of assaults
[4:46] that the US Force Left carried out. And to talk about the dual purpose,
[4:48] so I think even with the tracking of Osama. Obviously was was taken
[4:54] out by a US Navy. It was it was an operation out yea of
[5:00] actual people. But I think the Breda rone was involved in tracking the courier
[5:04] that you used to visit that home in about a bar and you know,
[5:08] make so again, surveillance will help you. But we are now we are
[5:11] talking surveillance leading to an assault assault. Yes, so that's that's definitely a
[5:17] big boost. I would say, yeah, it won't happen overnight, of
[5:23] course, but when it happens, yeah, it will happen. So you
[5:27] you mentioned that for you this is as big as you know, a deed,
[5:30] four fighter jets, And that's kind of the impression I've been getting from
[5:32] many defense you own lists and people who follow the world of defense, and
[5:36] also ironically the opposition because they've launched a similar attack on the on the government
[5:42] over the pricing of the drone deal like they did with their affail. But
[5:46] before we come to that, I also want to briefly do a small tangent
[5:51] to what you just said right now of that it won't happen overnight. So
[5:55] I was reading up about the process of how this will go about how India
[5:58] will go about buying this tone. It's quite laborous. So before PM's visit,
[6:03] the Defense Acquisition Council apparently had to clear what's known as a letter sorry,
[6:09] something known as acceptance of necessity. So you know, if my listeners
[6:15] and viewers will forgive me for this very crude example. This is like,
[6:18] you know, if I want to buy a car my parents and let's say
[6:24] my c as sort of have a council and then they first of all have
[6:28] to clear k TK we accept that you need a car, and then they
[6:31] know set up sort of. Then they give a letter to the dealer,
[6:34] OK, we want to buy a car. The leader the dealer then comes
[6:39] back with some price quote, and then you have a panel going to the
[6:42] dealer and you know, having a negotiation done, and then it comes back
[6:45] to the council and it's cleared by them. It's quite laborious. Honestly,
[6:49] when I was reading up about this, I felt this would be made simpler.
[6:54] Do you agree in this case it will be made simpler? Okay,
[6:57] it's not going to the long drawn kind of a deal. It's similar to
[7:01] how a false are brought the right sort of government to government so there's no
[7:05] bidding. So if there's no bidding, there's no competition, there's no there's
[7:11] that's the reason why opposition is uh, you know, making similar allegations like
[7:15] they did, even though I feel it's it's a bit of a self goal
[7:19] at this point of time, frankly, I mean Raphael was as well.
[7:23] If you saw the results of the elections. See, it's very difficult to
[7:29] bring out any wrongdoing establish a wrongdoing. You can bring out, you can
[7:34] highlight it, but how do you establish it because they are no middlemen supposedly
[7:42] the way m government to government deal that two governments are deciding to get this
[7:46] deal done. So the only allegation that you can make is that about overpricing,
[7:53] which again they've done. Now the government has come out with a huge
[7:59] response. It was all off the record, but it was a pretty big
[8:03] docket to shared, and they've dealt with the pricing issue that you know,
[8:07] it's it's cheaper than what they have sold to the other countries, and they've
[8:09] said that it's still at a price final price yet anyway, this is just
[8:13] what they use the kind offer price has been negotiate. It's what we will
[8:18] negotiate and it all depends on what price they give us what. So,
[8:24] yeah, it would be speculative to sort of pinpoint and say that what we're
[8:28] going to buy, it's going to be overpriced. What what if it comes
[8:31] with some weapons exactly? What if it comes with some other new age technology
[8:37] awesome India specic modifications that no one has sure there will be something because that's
[8:41] what your needs are. So yeah, I mean at this point of time,
[8:46] it sounds a little premature to make those kind of allegations from a from
[8:52] an opposition point of view, one can argue that why should we wait for
[8:58] overpriced stuff to be bought? But that's a political take on it. And
[9:03] it's fine that the opposition is within their rights to raise whatever objections they have,
[9:09] and because those are political objections, that would I would say, And
[9:15] then if it backfires politically, they take the problems that come with it.
[9:22] Yeah, and that's the escaping it. Considering this is an election here,
[9:24] I mean, that's per se, but it's the start of an election here,
[9:26] I mean it is. Yeah, we are definitely an election mode and
[9:30] we will see much more of all this exact slinging. But since we don't
[9:35] discuss politics here. I mean, I let's not go on and on.
[9:37] Yes, it will just get diverted, but you know, I'll still take
[9:43] up the point of what the opposition said and you know, kind of segue.
[9:46] And I think this will give you an opportunity to exactly tell us,
[9:50] tell our listeners and viewers what and why exactly this tone is a special is
[9:54] something that you mentioned just at the beginning of your answer, that you said
[9:58] there is no bidding involved over here. But in the case of Raphael fighter
[10:01] jets, that makes sense because you have several at least two three countries and
[10:05] their companies having high tech fifth generation aircraft Fighter five five fighter jets. In
[10:11] the case of armed drones, is there a competition for the predator? Is
[10:15] there any other see, there could be a competition, but again there are
[10:20] very few. But there there there are Turkish drones, which of course we
[10:24] don't want to buy for several reasons. So these these kind of uh,
[10:28] you know, tactical operational things come in. We're not in the best relations
[10:35] with Turkey, especially military relations. Why would you want to buy Turkish drones?
[10:43] Something? So that this is what nuances? What are the options,
[10:48] what are the choices that you have exactly my point. So where there might
[10:50] be technically there might be options, but are there really really an option?
[10:54] An option? And the other is, you know there's a lot of geopolitics
[10:58] involved in it, strategic interests. Suddenly, you know, US is all
[11:03] out to prove to you that this is a security strategic partnership. The term
[11:07] strategic partnership was used several times by both the presidents when Prime Minister Movie was
[11:13] there. So what is a strategic partnership? Strategic partnership is something that goes
[11:18] beyond buyer seller export import kind of relationship. It's saying much more than the
[11:26] fact that we're just selling and buying. So that's why the term strategic partnership,
[11:31] and it might not be restricted just to military hardware could it could go
[11:35] on to other sphares as well, for example, space collaboration, space program
[11:43] collaborations which has been announced that is a immense strategic importance. So when the
[11:50] two countries have sort of come on this platform and decided that this is a
[11:56] strategic partnership, then you will have these kind of deal. Otherwise, how
[12:00] how do you establish that this strategic partnership? And also, you know,
[12:05] back to politics, as we don't want to discuss politics, but you can't
[12:09] completely ignore it. After these are political leaders who had met. These are
[12:13] not whatever was being discussed in this deal or in this visit. Whatever.
[12:18] Are the key takeaways. It's not about Biden and arnd movie. You set
[12:24] a template for future political leaderships as well by doing what you're doing today.
[12:31] There was a template set with Russia many years back, and it had a
[12:35] vision. That's why it continued for so many years. In fact, it's
[12:37] still continuing. You've you've sort of you can't completely put it out of the
[12:41] picture. So and we are at a very crucial juncture where because of the
[12:46] Russia Ukraine War, there definitely is a pressure that you know, if this
[12:52] continues, what happens to US pare parts several military. It might have not
[12:58] made a big impact by now, but you need to audit and those that
[13:01] that auditing is happening, so you need to think of other options, alternatives.
[13:07] And this is not a spare part anyway. This is this is a
[13:11] huge acquisition, as we've discussed, so lots of lots of planning being done
[13:16] around it already. So this is going this is going to be a price
[13:20] service asset, so that in itself shows that you are the kind of tweakings
[13:28] that you're doing to your existing military structure. Your acquisitions are also being done
[13:35] and keeping that in mind. So yeah, I mean, this is how
[13:39] reforms begin. It cannot be restricted just to formations. There has to be
[13:43] a reform in your head as well, isn't it. But only if you
[13:48] think of reforms first, you put them on paper, but then you have
[13:50] to decide how it will be done practically on the ground. So thirty one
[13:54] drones, sixteen for the Navy, fifteen for the Navy, eight each air
[14:00] Force and the Yeah, so now let's get into this drone itself. Over
[14:05] the years, you know, when I've always read about high tech drones,
[14:09] the name Predator has always come up, Like, you know, I'll be
[14:11] honest, I have I don't really know about the capabilities of his drone very
[14:15] much, but you say predator and I just instantly know what you're talking about.
[14:18] So this name has been there. It's so you know, on the
[14:22] Internet and in media report it comes up quite often, and you just have
[14:26] this just vivid imagery of this. You know, you can imagine I can
[14:30] see the I can imagine the drone right now, I know how it looks,
[14:31] and you know it's flying high in the air and you see anybody who's
[14:33] interested in knowing exact capabilities, it's all there in public domain. It's that's
[14:39] that's if we don't even need to sort of discuss that, because that's something
[14:43] that our viewers are listeners, would would be able to find out very easily.
[14:50] So it's not just about the capabilities, it's about how Indian security establishment
[14:56] is looking to sort of bring in many change is just with this acquisition.
[15:01] And I think that's that's the big takeaway as well of this acquisition that happens.
[15:07] Yeah, so that's what I want to talk about. So tell us,
[15:09] now, what gets you so excited about this about this deal? Because
[15:11] you know I've been sensing it since for three episodes now, I think the
[15:16] week before PMOD went to the US, you talk to me about of the
[15:20] off the camera of the mics. You know, keep this is something that's
[15:22] going to huge happen. You know we should talk about it, and like
[15:26] you said this week itself, even though we were so caught up, you
[15:28] had it in mind. Don't discuss Yeah, yeah, So what is it
[15:31] about this deal. What is it about this roone that gets you so so
[15:33] excited? Yeah, they're just let's just take think of the kind of operations
[15:39] combat operations that our military security establishment does, and you will start getting a
[15:46] clear picture. You will get answers. Our maximum casualties happen because the terrain
[15:52] is staff dense jungles. Either counter terror operations LC has been silent for the
[16:00] last two and a half years. We've discussed that as well, but there's
[16:03] no guarantee. Yes, the rig will remain silent. They used to be
[16:07] huge infiltrations terror camps. What if you could carry out a surgical strike with
[16:14] all your soldiers actually going And it's a simple explanation. It's very simple explanation.
[16:18] Your reach of surveillance enhances big time if if it's a if all three
[16:25] services are using it. Currently, the Indian Navy has two of these predators
[16:30] on lease which are being used only for surveillance. There they aren't armed,
[16:36] they aren't own. So from the deep oceans to Arunachal and Ladak, just
[16:42] these two drones have given you a lot of advantage, a lot of information.
[16:49] Two there we are talking thirty one which are armed. So the armed
[16:55] part brings a deterrent, not that the adversary doesn't have capability to probably bring
[17:02] down these drones. They could have capabilities, but they are capabilities to bring
[17:07] down fighter jets as well. Yes, their capabilities to uh yeah, I
[17:12] mean everything. So that's not the point. The point is what you have
[17:18] and why why we are so excited because we didn't have this. No,
[17:21] we had fighter jets. A fall is good, fine, but we have
[17:25] never had this. So that's the reason that everybody is excited about it,
[17:29] and to to get to know that this is our colleague, very good report
[17:34] on it. That how the try service command aspect is something that that is
[17:40] an eye opener. Again if it's a try service asset and it has to
[17:44] be under a try service command, so it will be interesting how that will
[17:48] be done. So it's it's not, you know, working in isolation,
[17:51] and that's the that's the kind of vision that the military leadership has right now
[17:56] and all of us all of that is pretty exciting. So well, when
[18:00] you say it will be under a try service command, but then you also
[18:03] said that fifteen for the Navy, eight each for the Army and the Air
[18:07] Force, So how does that kind of no, so they come with different
[18:11] configurations. YEA, the sea Guardians are only for right mat for maritime operations
[18:18] and the other one is for the sky Guardians for the army or the air
[18:22] force to use. But the maritime version, which is called the Sea Guardian
[18:27] has to be obviously quite different. But the sea Guardian is doubling up for
[18:33] other purposes also right now the two on least that you want to lease here
[18:37] in the same side note over here that fifteen the sea Guardians. And I
[18:41] think this kind of harks back to one of our previous episodes, I think
[18:45] six seven episodes ago when we talked about navies slowly emerging is importance in opositions.
[18:52] Don't don't forget that. You you you have two cours. So if
[18:56] you if you want these to be your eyes and striking capabilities or whatever the
[19:04] term you want to use, it to be deployed on both the both the
[19:11] course and of course the numbers need to be higher. Interesting, very interesting.
[19:15] We'll come back to this after a quick treak. Hello, I'm Raj's
[19:25] Chambapa from India Today Podcasts and your host for Nothing but the Truth. Every
[19:32] week we will deal with key issues of concern and bring your perspectives and clarity
[19:37] as to why this should matter to you and what is the clear truth that
[19:41] emerges. Welcome back, A Bush and I are talking about India's upcoming deal
[19:56] with the US for the predator roles. I say upcoming because even though there's
[20:00] like I'm guessing a hand check agreement right now sort of between the two leaders
[20:04] of it. You mean the deal deal deal? Yeah? Yeah, exactly,
[20:07] how at what price? And then what configuration? Does it come armed
[20:11] with deadlines? Yeah? Does it come down with missiles from the manufacturer or
[20:15] it doesn't have to buy them separately? Or there there is a stalk of
[20:19] indigenous weapons being used? Yeah, I don't know. I mean, do
[20:25] we have since we don't have armed rooms, then we would have Yeah,
[20:30] there is talk of right right. So before we talk a bit more about
[20:33] the deal itself, just one quick though. I've been wondering since day one,
[20:37] why thirty one? Why not thirty or thirty five or thirty two,
[20:41] or like why not round it off? So if you look at the division,
[20:45] it's sort of rounded off fifteen six eight eight, fifteen eight, So
[20:51] if you look at the division, that's why it comes to thirty one.
[20:53] Earlier it was thirty rose ten each. Okay, so there was again some
[21:00] change in thought that the navy needs more. So that's why the number has
[21:04] come to thirty one. But you know, just for me, it's it's
[21:07] one of those you know, really interesting side notes about defense deals and different
[21:12] just like you know, like you said, like ten ten, ten,
[21:15] and then nay needs more to make that fifteen, so over out it comes
[21:17] to ty one. So that is the It was a peculiar question, but
[21:21] that's the only other thought in mind. I mean, yeah, are you
[21:23] convinced with the reasoning logic? I mean, Tay, navy needs needed more.
[21:29] So round of quirk fifteen try two would even too expensive, I guess,
[21:33] because these are, by the way, quite expensive. I check them.
[21:34] Even though you don't know what the Indian price would be, I think
[21:38] if you go by general figures, I think one hundred million for one drone
[21:45] is yes, yes, because I think even the government response into the opposition
[21:48] was in Saudi Arabia brought it four hundred million. If I'm not the government
[21:52] response was what in Indian rupees was how much I don't remember right now,
[21:56] eight hundred crows? Yeah, poor something something, Yeah, yeah something that
[22:02] Yeah, so quite expensive. So yeah, so tell me, you know,
[22:07] even though you've explained it quite well, but if you were to talk
[22:10] about some of the recent missions or some of the recent operations that the Indian
[22:15] military has carried out, which one do you would you see in hindsight benefiting
[22:19] the most from a road like this? Oh, listen, all of them
[22:23] be long, It could be really really lengthy. Let's go back in time
[22:29] as well, let's say six seven years back when a lot of these operations
[22:33] were happening. Yeah, all, I mean, surgical strike is one that
[22:38] such certainly comes to mind. The surgical strike in mind, mark is another
[22:45] one that comes to mind. And every time these shallow rags take place on
[22:52] the Luci and so many time terr hideouts that you know are there, but
[22:56] it's just you know, going across, which is the biggest challenge. See,
[23:03] even if you carry out a drone strike just disrupt your target, that
[23:10] in itself could be you know, really really beneficial. Once they move around,
[23:14] then you amplify with soldiers on the ground. So there's obviously a whole
[23:19] lot of difference that these will make. And again, one would coming back
[23:23] to why navy needs more and things like that, and we're openly talking China
[23:29] now, Yes, definitely, which we've touched upon so many times in our
[23:34] podcast. That China word, which was sort of brushed under under the carpet
[23:41] earlier, has suddenly become part of normal discourse. Even the government is talking,
[23:47] the miracle leadership is talking. So there is a huge impact that China
[23:52] is making in the waters in the seas South China Sea, they come towards
[23:56] the Indian Ocean region, they send their surveillance vessels as they want. When
[24:03] we have some sort of a missile test, so surveillance vessels against spying missions,
[24:07] things like that. The submarines also have been spotted. Yeah, so
[24:11] when you have this kind of capabilities, so you're letting the addsary know that
[24:17] we are prepared, we're watching you as well. So that that's that's that's
[24:22] that's what comes to mind straight away. And so many, so many operations
[24:27] in dense forests of of northeast East. So this will of course be a
[24:36] big thing when it comes to those operations, because you're talking waters. Just
[24:40] the thought came to a mind. Can it also strike submarines? That does
[24:44] a missile it carry have not that easy, yeah, and wouldn't be that
[24:51] easy because anti submarine warfare different is different. You have different weapons for it,
[24:56] so and and not too sure if a drone can see that. You
[25:02] have helicopters that come with anti submarine so and there might there might not be
[25:07] any particularly, it's just the payload that it can take. If it has
[25:11] the configuration the design to take that kind of a missile, then yeah,
[25:18] so we'll have to wait and watch what kind of configuration. Again, it
[25:23] goes back to that, right. Let's remind a little to our earlier to
[25:30] the chat that we had before the break, where you talked about the word
[25:33] strategic partnership that was used very often by President Biden and PM. What I've
[25:41] read about the whole background to India's So, India has been eyeing the predator
[25:45] for a while now, yeah, this was this was in the pipeline for
[25:48] a while. Yeah, for a while. Yeah, you also said that,
[25:52] you two told me that. But the US always has had a history
[25:56] of not wanting to sell its most technological advance. I've always had reservations.
[26:00] So even with the fighter jet, for example, the one being offered is
[26:03] the F twenty two and not their twenty five, which is the most advanced.
[26:07] So they have a history that you know, they'll develop any one and
[26:08] then they'll sell the older model, which is not the case with the Preator.
[26:12] Again, China, India, whatever. So what do you make of
[26:15] this work, because I think one of the things that happened before pmovies visit
[26:21] some reporting by foreign agencies. I think it was writers, I'm not wrong,
[26:25] was that the US is now actually pushing India to come and make sure
[26:29] this deal is done. Even for a while he was initially reluctant, but
[26:33] now suddenly in the last few months, after the Russia, Ukraine more China's
[26:37] sort of you know, needling South China, se in Taiwan, and India's
[26:41] issues with China, etc. The US certainly wants to be there and tell
[26:45] India, oh, bro, we have I'm glad that we are discussing this,
[26:48] because sometimes in this cheering the big deal, we sort of tend to
[26:56] forget the larger pictures. So yeah, I'm glad that we've touched upon this.
[27:02] Let nobody feel that there's some favor that's been told out to India.
[27:06] Yeah, exactly, isn't it. And it's not that. And at the
[27:11] same time, it's not that they've found this new newfound love and respect for
[27:15] you, isn't it Exactly? There are strategic reasons and forget about these deals.
[27:21] Just notice US's official discourse visa India and China. The kind the kind
[27:30] of language that has used, the kind of information that they're putting in their
[27:37] official reports, official Department of Defense reports, Pentagon reports on not just China,
[27:42] but China at LAC is unprecedented. So this clearly shows that this is
[27:48] a big focus area for them. Every time you have a US diplomat or
[27:55] some big dignitary visiting India, they make sure they talk about China and not
[28:00] China and South China. See Taiwan China at LAS. So what does that
[28:07] show that One they want to sort of cash in on what's happening in LAC
[28:15] at the LAC and what China's activities in other places is because it's quite similar
[28:21] to what they're doing at LAS. And the other is the Russia Ukraine War.
[28:26] So they definitely see an opportunity there of India sort of shifting from our
[28:33] dependence on Russian military hardware two American military hardware, and also the fact that
[28:40] we bought rafals, although we've we've bought French aircraft before before as well.
[28:47] But they think they would have thought that, you know, this is the
[28:49] right moment to sort of woo you and talk of the strategic partnership. Strategic
[28:56] partnerships cannot be one way, So now it would be interesting to see that
[29:02] how do we leverage this strategic partnership. We need to make them feel us
[29:07] can also be dependent on us on something. And I think that's the challenge
[29:11] for the Indian leadership, which not might not be military, could be so
[29:15] many other things. We are certainly not. We could observers of other aspects
[29:22] of trade or business and things like that. But I think that's the challenge
[29:26] that if a strategic partnership, it cannot be one person dictating terms and letting
[29:32] you feel that we're helping you. It's a partnership has to be both ways
[29:36] and the strategic advantages need to be shared. Right, So, just carrying
[29:41] forward on the thought, do you think it's just like, you know,
[29:45] just a nice coincidence for us that just when the Russia you can war happened
[29:49] and suddenly we have this big question of a few years down the line.
[29:52] Certainly might your your spare parts for a lot of the Russian military hardware that
[29:56] you have might fall short. There. You have certainly kind of what you
[30:00] said, but you have certainly US willing to, you know, give you
[30:03] a lending hand. So do you think it's just a coincidence or do you
[30:07] think it has been done? Come keeping exactly that in mind, and which
[30:10] is why you say, see again, it's not just this. India US
[30:15] military cooperation started to see a churn back in two thousand and eight. Okay,
[30:21] so it's not something that's happened overnight. And this is the only reason
[30:26] so and two thousand and eight wide happened was it was an immediate result of
[30:33] the nuclear deal, the civil nuclear deal that India and USC and I think
[30:37] that marked the change in the relationship per se. There was more trust from
[30:44] the Americans towards US towards India, and also the manner in which the deal
[30:49] was done undancing government could have could have collapsed. Left Withdrew, there was
[30:56] a lot of drama. I don't know, I remember the yea so it
[31:00] was yeah. So and when Mons was adamant and using the term adamant and
[31:08] as a young journalist. I felt that he is this actually going to work
[31:12] in India. Governments can actually fall. And it was a government of alliance
[31:18] of so many parties. The government managed both left withdrew support. The deal
[31:25] happened the government and not fall. It's important to talk about that when we
[31:27] were talking about the big Indo US relations today. So the big change began
[31:33] to happen since two thousand and eight, and there have been some big ticket
[31:38] acquisitions. The Empriple seven knotlery guns, Chinook helicopters, Apache Armed helicopters,
[31:47] Chinook. We've we already have seen how crucial they were just recently again during
[31:53] the Laddark crisis, carrying loads of material to high peaks, several sorties in
[32:00] a day. Chatrying the m Triple seven. I mean, what else,
[32:06] what what better endorsement of the kind of corporation. So it's not that Indo
[32:10] US corporation hinges on this deal. I think that change had already begun.
[32:16] The six or rifles there's another one, and maybe even the Boeing transport jets.
[32:21] I think was that also after because I think they're the cause of this
[32:28] master. So it has happened, and I don't have the correct figures.
[32:35] But from two thousand and eight, when your military acquisitions was nearly zero,
[32:38] it has gone up, just spiraled up with respecting the US. Yeah,
[32:44] with respect to the US. So, I mean, we've just listed out
[32:46] so many big platforms that we have bought in the last few years. So
[32:50] it's not that this is the only thing and it's only China. It was,
[32:53] it was changing and now you have a geopolitical scenario where the US is
[33:01] feeling, Yeah, that that it's not just a bias aller relationship what I
[33:06] said earlier. Yeah, right. A couple of more points on the drone
[33:10] of the preator drone. Does China have an armed drone of its own?
[33:15] It does? I don't know what they're called hard with Chinese. I mean,
[33:20] you don't know. But so Jetnabe, you've read about it. How
[33:23] does it compare to the US predator? See, I don't know if they
[33:27] have they've not used it. I've not heard of the Chinese using armed drones
[33:30] actually, so it's I've frankly not come across many reports. So the US
[33:37] drones and the Turkish drones. Armed rones are the ones that have been spoken
[33:42] most about. The Turkish, but by they are drones. We've heard about
[33:47] it during the Ukraine War. How Ukraine has used them effectively against against the
[33:52] Russian forces. In fact, the Ukrainians, I don't know. They've used
[33:58] some really sophisticated arm drones like the Buyack they are, and some really elementary,
[34:05] rudimentary kind of drones in this war. So the US is obviously used
[34:13] in um Afghanistan extensively. Yes, several kinds of armed drones. They've used
[34:19] bombers as well. So yeah, when we've seen the use of drones in
[34:27] by by the US and and and these darkish strones most in recent times,
[34:31] I think what about Israel because even they use US drones or do they have
[34:37] their own, they should be having their own. They certainly have Heron,
[34:40] which is which we use as well, which which we use for surveillance.
[34:45] I'm sure they would be having some kind of armed version of drones as well.
[34:52] Right. Let's you know in des By talking about the deal again,
[34:55] which is not the deal. Deal has not happened, So what happens now?
[35:00] Like you said, this is a piece of equipment that we do not
[35:02] have in any form an armed we have drones. Uh So you know,
[35:07] like we've like you kind of give an example, We've always had fighter yet
[35:09] it was just a matter of upgrading to the latest and newest technology. This
[35:14] is a piece of technology that we've never had. Now, even though there's
[35:17] no bidding, there's no competition involved. But now I'm guessing you'll have a
[35:20] sort of a group of you know, military military and you know, civilian
[35:23] officers getting together and negotiating with the US the price and more crucially of exactly
[35:29] what drone will be getting in what configuration, with what our needs exactly and
[35:34] whether we want some modifications with the affair, for example, we need some
[35:37] motifications. So how do you see this whole thing happening considering the fact that
[35:42] we don't have experience even operating such rones. So how do these negotiations go
[35:45] happen? Forget the price part, No more to go into that controversy,
[35:49] that's you know, like you said, learned to government. That's something later.
[35:52] But when it comes to the technical aspects of missile NHA concerts, what
[35:58] are the capabilities that you want at how do we go about negotiating that?
[36:01] How does that happen? No, I mean we need to put across what
[36:06] our requirements are. That's that's the most important and elementary stage of any kind
[36:12] of acquisition. And once you do that, they'll try to meet your requirements
[36:16] and it will the negotiation will completely depend on that. That's what happened with
[36:22] Raphal. It was the India specific enhancements, which which I think government did
[36:28] not even reveal in parliament. Yeah, they did not. Isn't it stating
[36:32] that if you give details of these security Yeah, it's so. And I
[36:37] think this was in context of giving a break up of cost exactly what cost
[36:43] what the plane aircraft and this cost that much? Just called so I think
[36:49] once again a similar kind of a script is being written. So, yeah,
[36:54] it all boils around to your requirements and how you intend to use what
[36:59] when? Yeah, I mean that's that's that's the most important aspect of the
[37:05] negotiations. Right. So with deals like these, how does it normally go?
[37:08] I mean, so, you know, if you have certain requirements based
[37:12] on our location on the map, our terray and the kind of like you
[37:15] said, the kind of missions, the kind of operations that our military carries
[37:20] out, does the manufacturer then also sometimes need to or have to develop something
[37:25] new to meet your requirements or not, maybe not new but maybe tweak it.
[37:30] Tweak it Okay, maybe, I mean I I really don't know as
[37:35] far as technology is concerned. We obviously have a very very superficial idea.
[37:42] But let's let's use the example of the kind of drones, the predator drones
[37:46] that have been used in Afghanistan and the kind of drones that we would need
[37:51] to carry out operations in Northeast. Completely different. That's exactly what I was
[37:55] thinking, because you know you that completely different is the plan and this is
[38:00] in a hillary region. So maybe for Ladak we can use what we're used
[38:04] in Afghanistan. And that's that's where the challenge comes for every Indian military operations.
[38:13] That there is a Ladakh, there is an Arunachal, there is the
[38:20] Elosi, which Kashmir, the mountains of kashmirs of Rajasthan the low lying areas
[38:28] of Northeast. Again, dense forests, so this is largely a lay of
[38:34] the land, isn't so there's so many Why why do we have these helicopter
[38:38] crashes is because of this dense forest weather and we would want rooms to withstand
[38:45] all of that. Imagine a drone coming down because of these things. I
[38:50] mean, the cost is huge. So that's that's the challenge I think when
[38:53] it comes to design and configure configurations. Uh final thought, what does this
[39:00] deal the importance that's been given to it by India. Like you said,
[39:05] we've been eyeing this for a while. What we've seen in the Russia Ukraine
[39:07] war, Ukraine's use of thrones, and I think there was also a recent
[39:10] viral video of a Russian jet dumping fuel to US drone. If I'm not
[39:15] wrong, it's during something happened, something had happened, something on those lines.
[39:21] That thing happened a couple of months ago. But anyway, so what
[39:24] do you where do you see the future of warfare? Because this is I
[39:28] think not a recurring topic on our on our podcast, but we've know with
[39:31] Russia Ukraine war, your visit to Israel where you you know, came back
[39:36] with some very pretty cool sup about cybersecurity. And that's also when we discussed
[39:40] a future of warfare. So we've been like you know, I've been reading
[39:44] about about how drones will change the future of warfare. There are swarm drones
[39:46] that India has now this arm rones are outcoming, and where do you see
[39:51] that going ten, fifteen, twenty years down the line, are do you
[39:54] okay, let you know what. Let me just ask a very point lank
[39:58] question. Do you see any type time in the next few decades fighter just
[40:01] becoming completely absolute? See nothing is obsolete in military warfare. People had given
[40:07] a death warrant to tanks after the Russia Ukraine War. But do you think
[40:14] tanks will be completely out of action? I don't think so we end up
[40:17] sending tanks to hills. Yeah, I mean we have tanks alladad Yeah,
[40:22] So I don't and we are. We are planning lightweight tanks and things like
[40:27] that, keeping in mind challenges. So I don't. I don't. I
[40:30] don't think so that the fighter jet will be out of equation, the foot
[40:36] soldier will be nothing. Nothing will be out. You will have new things
[40:39] come, but you will not have the existing machinery and the existing structures who
[40:46] out When you plan for even your future militaries, all these things would you
[40:52] would want them to amplify what what you already have. But I don't think
[40:58] nothing is really going to be These are not horses. Yeah. By the
[41:02] way, Indian Army still has mules not to fight but for logistics things like
[41:07] that. So they've been talking about what some robot robotic mules or something.
[41:15] It's still not seen like yeah, and I mean I think almost every soldier
[41:20] still carries a knife with him, so the most rudimentary form of weapon,
[41:23] but just to have it. So I think I'll agree with you or there.
[41:27] I mean, that's the answer I have when someone asks me, considering
[41:30] that I work in a field which involves a lot of writing, what will
[41:35] chat GPT do you do to your to your profession? So you know,
[41:38] we start off with that chart Deputy kind of end with that as well,
[41:42] because I think drones, automated systems are to the military board amplify are this
[41:52] thing. But yeah, exactly can be able to place us. Yeah,
[41:55] exactly, so interesting chatterish, Thanks you and I could sense your excitement on
[42:00] this topic, and I think you've been, like you know, able to
[42:04] really lay it out exactly why this is such a big deal the upcoming in
[42:07] the US don't deal. So you said let's wait and watch a couple of
[42:13] questions ago, so I think we'll have to now wit and watch the process
[42:15] begins. I think as we speak sometimes this week, I think an official
[42:19] letter will be sent to the US expressing interests the US Congress. I don't
[42:23] know if it's always happened. Has it happened? I'm not sure. Apologies
[42:27] to our listeners and viewers. There has to be some kind of gratificationification from
[42:31] this. But I get a sense that if something like this is announced at
[42:37] a state, state level, then obviously it is it has a done deal,
[42:40] is it. I don't think that the Congress will sort of have any
[42:45] reservations about it shouldn't happen, yeah, right, so I think that it's
[42:49] just what remains is the negotiations. One aspect of hill be price, and
[42:52] the other protecting is capabilities of the torone that India wants. And once we
[42:57] know more on that, you know, we'll obviously once again have a chat
[43:00] on this. So thanks, thanks a b shake and thanks to our listeners
[43:02] and view us. As always, you can let us know what you thought
[43:06] of this episode or what do you think of this podcast in general. A
[43:08] drop us a text at eight five, double eight nine, double six,
[43:10] double nine six, or an email at pots at the rate indi dot com
[43:14] that's pods at the rate in dreday dot com. A special thanks to our
[43:17] produced an appre listening. As always, that's it for this week's defense tours.
[43:21] For more, tune in next week. They'll then stay safe and to
[43:22] not cross any boundaries without a passport by

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
