# Encounter Stories: Behind The Headlines | In Our Defence Ep 55

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 20 Apr 2023, 53 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/53594479/20_apr_23_iod_ep_55_mix_april_20_128.mp3

Def-Savvy Abhishek Bhalla and Dev Goswami discuss the controversial nature of "encounter killings" and "shoot-outs, exploring the history of the term, including its glorification by the press during the 2008 Mumbai terror attacks. Abhishek also shares his own experiences covering the 2008 Batla House encounter. The conversation highlights the need for greater transparency and accountability in law enforcement agencies' use of force. Listen in!

## Transcript

[0:01] This is in the Today podcasts. There are boundary disputes and then there are
[0:07] outright wars, hot and cold, diplomatic and military. In this podcast,
[0:13] we will dissect all that's brutal and subtle about the defense of our nations.
[0:18] I am Dave Goswami, your host, and I will be joined by a
[0:22] Bishikbala who's been on the front lines of wars and conflicts and has seen the
[0:26] Indian military up close. Hello, and welcome to the fifty fifth episode of
[0:35] In Our Defense. How are you doing very well? I'm very fine.
[0:40] And what's kept you busy? Newsman? Lots of news? I had to,
[0:45] you know, rush to office at eleven pm on a weekend, son,
[0:49] Saray knight. Uh, we'll come to that. I think you have
[0:54] to ask me why? Uh yeah, So that was no. I'm asking
[0:59] generally because our listeners viewers might we will not know I especially because you know
[1:03] most of them might be listening to this some like a few days after we
[1:07] release the episode, which happens every Thursday. Well, so what happened was
[1:12] mafia h Dawn at camera was killed, not in an encounter by sensation,
[1:21] not in an encounter, which is that I've ever seen yea on television.
[1:25] Yeah, which is what people who expecting to be killing an encounter, which,
[1:29] by the way, was my first reaction because I remember was at home
[1:33] at speaking to my parents and I just caught the phone and I saw the
[1:37] inputs coming in Killing Cotton camera life. I just I just in fact,
[1:41] our camera yeah sama, and the camera person with the leader. Yeah,
[1:47] amazing work they've done. I'm yeah, just to put it on record once
[1:51] again for our viewers listeners that all those visuals that they've seen they were shot
[1:56] by our cameras on the ground. Yeah. Uh. First line input was
[2:00] that he and his brother had been killed. And my initial message to my
[2:07] colleagues who are working in office was key, you know, the headline is
[2:09] wrong. You should say an encounter, because, like I'm saying, that's
[2:13] what as you work, Yeah, count because he was under arrest, right,
[2:17] he was was in jail and he was brought to you. You thought
[2:22] that he's trying to run away or something, and something has happened. That's
[2:24] what normally happens in such cases. But then I was told, you know,
[2:29] that's not the that's not it. That's not what we know. What
[2:30] we know is that you know, he's just been This was the initial couple
[2:35] of you know moments, and then of course it turned out that yeah,
[2:37] fewer sales. Three of them, um kind of you know, barged into
[2:40] the media sopose a journalist year and shot the two dead while they were being
[2:46] transferred by the police for a medical chaabah. So that happened. So that
[2:51] was my weekend. What was your life? Mine was similar. It was
[2:54] a Saturday evening and when I got to know of this, yeah, that
[2:59] was of course a lot of phone calls back and forth. How do we
[3:04] plan this coverage? Do we need to send people on the ground. We
[3:07] already had many on the ground, luckily, and that's the reason why we
[3:12] were ahead with the story. But yeah, there was a lot of discussion
[3:15] even the next day how to go about things. So, yeah, this
[3:19] has taken up most of the editorial brainstorming time, if we can say so.
[3:25] Yeah, of course, Karnataka ellections is another thing which is which is
[3:30] big on agenda eating up now. Yeah, and just before this skilling,
[3:36] there had been a quote unquote in counter council of his son of Steak's son.
[3:42] So yes, a lot of bloodshed's raining in the last week, which
[3:46] has taken up the new space. Yeah. Yeah, so, I mean
[3:50] that's what's kept me busy, and I'm guessing that's what kept our you know,
[3:55] listeners, viewers, readers, everyone busy as well, because that's mostly
[4:00] what's been talked about in the last few days, and that's something we'll talk
[4:02] about in this episode. But like you know, I thought, like I
[4:05] think we discussed this that I think we should kind of shift focus from the
[4:08] hardcore military defense that we do normally every day, every week, and perhaps
[4:12] as we've i think put out many a time, we put this out upfront.
[4:17] Anything to do with the security of the nation, yes, we'll find
[4:20] mention on this podcast. Yeah so, I mean killings, encounters, mafias
[4:27] is in a way related to the security of the nation, and you can't
[4:30] ignore of course these things. Yeah, and you know, just before we
[4:32] are well into the topic, just a message for our viewers and listeners to
[4:36] let us know what you think of this podcast. Drop a message to us
[4:39] at eight five eight nine double six, double nine six, or an email
[4:42] to us at pots at the rate interred dot com. That's pods at the
[4:45] rate interred dot com. We'd really like to know what you think of the
[4:47] our discussions that Bish and I have every week, and whether there's something that
[4:51] you'd like us to talk about or any feedback that you have, any input
[4:55] will be really appreciated to let us now, right, so let's get into
[4:59] it. I don't really know, and I'm dreading are producer and as message
[5:03] tomorrow when she'll ask me for a headline for these episodes. I don't really
[5:06] know what to call the topic of a discussion today because I think it's going
[5:12] to be very far reaching. Because when you use the word encounter, there's
[5:17] not really a particular definition of the term. There are there are those alleged
[5:24] not alleged purse. There are some fake encounters where basically you know, police
[5:28] or anyone in part uh kind of takes criminals kills them, and the extra
[5:34] judicial extra killings. Yeah, then there are ones where there are actually are
[5:40] cases of you know, criminals, you know, trying to escape a customed
[5:42] shooting shot and their operations done by security forces. You know, you'll see
[5:46] them happening in German Cushmidia, and you'll see them happening in Axel invested areas
[5:50] and in cases like twenti eleven, Notast, not the supers, not East
[5:55] as well specially as well back then in a teas when you had desigence series
[6:00] in Punjab police those who are basically done by the police, by the police.
[6:05] Yes, And the recent one, the most recent one I can think
[6:10] of his twenty seven obviously the Mombitter attack, when you had ten people storming
[6:15] the city and you had to have the energ kind of take them down.
[6:17] Nine of them Marcos Marcos were involved as well. So yeah, that's what
[6:23] I'm saying. So I'm kind of dreading when Anna things be tomorrow. He's
[6:25] guy, had led career, so he come to that when we come to
[6:28] that. But let's talk about encounters then. So let's talk about encounters.
[6:31] And I've grown up in Bombay, by the way, so I high and
[6:36] I've grown up during the period when encounters were like under Yeah, the world
[6:42] you'd come across in newspapers almost every week or so. You know, you'll
[6:45] have some of the other gangster being encountered by the special squad of police officers
[6:50] you had back then then, counter specialists. The names are you know,
[6:54] very very well. Films have been films have been made about them lots.
[6:57] They've written books as well, roths has been done. You know, there's
[6:59] lots of about about them. I first of all grew up obviously reading those
[7:04] reports. I then grew up to read some of the books authored by some
[7:09] journalists, by some of the officers themselves. Uh. You know, a
[7:14] common theme I found was, without coming out right and saying it, there
[7:20] was always an underlying mention, even in the books authored by the police officers
[7:25] themselves, that yeah, things did not really add up. They won't come
[7:29] out and say yam many fake and counter kia for example. Okay, they
[7:31] won't say kay hamna, we picked that criminal up from so and so place
[7:34] and shot him dead and you know, passed it off as a as an
[7:36] as an encounter. They won't tried that. But if you read the if
[7:41] they read the stories, you'll you'll get the sense that they that busy didn't
[7:44] tell Yuki. I know it's not exactly what it was made up to be.
[7:46] In in the courts, for example, have you gotten the sense that
[7:49] sense when you've spoken to police officers, when you've spoken to people in the
[7:54] establishment, see begin with we're not sitting in judgment. Of course, all
[8:00] these quote unquote encounters. But I'd like to just mention a small thing.
[8:05] What is an encounter? The term encounter in itself is quite intriguing, you
[8:09] know, for me, purely from a linguist point of view, an encounter
[8:15] as a verb, isn't it? Yeah, it's it's an action verb.
[8:18] It's it's shoe. But it's been turned into and down. Now there was
[8:24] an encounter encounter Ugia. So this is uh something very interesting that the usage
[8:31] of the term encounter has has become as if it's an entity, we're talking
[8:37] about a legitimate entity, whereas an encounter to me is a shootout, yes,
[8:43] where you know, bullets are fired, have been fired from both ends,
[8:48] but in a lot of films, in a lot of books, as
[8:50] you said, and also at one point of time a section of the press
[8:54] all sort of glorified more so in Mumbai because I don't know this, this
[9:01] is a deliversis Mumbi argument. But for us journalists in Delhi, whenever an
[9:07] encounter happened, it meant as a reporter to find loop holes in what has
[9:13] happened. That was always a story for me, irrespective of whether the right
[9:18] guy has been killed or not. But if an encounter has happened and somebody's
[9:24] died. You'd always when the story to look cool would be punching holes in
[9:30] the police's theory. Not sure that exists so much today, even though heads
[9:35] off to Shams Tai Khan, who in this current encounters encounter actually went down
[9:43] to the ground and did some reporting, just old school crime reporting, you
[9:48] know, punching holes in the police's theory. I love that story of his
[9:52] way. He's a he's a veteran of crime. He's been a guru to
[9:56] me as well. So great story, just basic common sense. He looked
[10:01] at the bike, not a scratch. Then he showed that the number plate
[10:05] was painted white, right, there was no key. Just raising questions.
[10:09] You know, this is what a primary job of journalists is, raising uncomfortable
[10:16] questions. The police obviously have enough platforms to give out their version, and
[10:22] it's only their version that actually gets amplified. And it's only a bit of
[10:28] a few punches that are thrown in by some reporters that raises these questions.
[10:33] It's important and in the earlier days I think that was the norm. It
[10:37] still happens. I wouldn't say it doesn't happen but yeah, as chums By
[10:41] I was referring to, he showed it and the story was carried. So
[10:46] nobody can say that such stories don't have space and people get scared by the
[10:50] state. Today the story was carried on all our platforms in a big way.
[10:56] So yeah, I mean to start this discussion to shade it. Let's
[11:01] take it from here. Yeah, yeah, I get your point about what
[11:05] when you said keep uh, maybe that's not really what happened in Delhi when
[11:09] it comes to the Bombay encounters, because I if I look back, I
[11:13] was like, you know, growing up, so it was a young phase
[11:15] of my life, have very vague memories. But if I can recall,
[11:18] then yeah, the glorification did happen. I mean you had I think you
[11:24] had newspapers, reporters kind of you know, having a score of different of
[11:28] some of those officers, some of them are very names, have entered households,
[11:33] uh, you know, kept keeping score key. So and so officer
[11:35] has killed exom of gangsters, and so and so has killed exam and you
[11:39] know, with one more encounter, he's you know, kind of surpassed the
[11:41] other one, which is also I think, very very mombiting, very bombiting,
[11:46] and I'm guessing you can kind of tied up to the reign of terror
[11:50] that was present because of the under world, the grass kind world kind of
[11:54] had And if you think of about that then kind of enters ary a philosophical
[12:01] debate. Then you know the whole point of encounters and where kind of the
[12:05] law takes a while for justice to be served. So this is ten seen
[12:07] as a quick install justice. I've also heard stories that the police themselves would
[12:13] plant information to either of the gangs so that there's a gang war and one
[12:20] gets members of one gang sort of get killed. Yes, I've heard these
[12:24] stories and it's been represented in films as well. So it was a dirty
[12:28] game. There was, there's no doubt about it. So it's various categories
[12:33] of these encounters that we have seen. One bay under world kinds. The
[12:37] other is most of the times terror, suspects, mafia. Of course,
[12:43] in up, there's not the first time these these these kind of encounters have
[12:46] happened, in fact, in in the Yogi regime. I think it's one
[12:50] eighty three is the number, if I'm not number, but I was mentioned
[12:54] in the press conference that day that one eighty three is the number. So
[12:56] that's that's a pretty big number in about how many years now, five six
[13:01] years more than that twenty seventeen was seventeen yeah, yeah, and this is
[13:05] the second term of second so yeah, since twenty seventeen, nine years,
[13:09] so I think is a big enough number number. Now you can have a
[13:15] debate here. On one side, people are saying that the up government has
[13:20] cracked down upon mafia law and orders in place and things like that, law
[13:24] in order situation is much better now just for the sake of debate an argument
[13:30] and get a bit of nuance in it. See if these encounters are genuine
[13:33] pull shootouts where where mafia, criminals, gangsters, whatever you want to call
[13:39] them, have fired at the police twenty three times, it's not a very
[13:43] good reflection of the lawder I must say, from where are they getting weapons,
[13:52] the the alacrity, the brazenness with which they're doing this. It shows
[13:56] that there's there's no fear of law and of the police. And that's where
[14:01] the controversial part comes at. If these are staged fake encounters, then what
[14:07] it's two sides of an argument, not as I said, not setting an
[14:11] argument, not setting in judgment, but just giving a nuanced picture. So
[14:16] this is the other aspect of the encounters that we are going to talk about.
[14:20] One was, as you mentioned, Bombay kind of encounters. Another is
[14:26] which is stopped now, which used to be a very daily thing, which
[14:28] is ahead of Republic Day, ahead of Independence day, you would have some
[14:35] encounters somewhere in Many of those actually guys were not killed, sometimes they were.
[14:41] I remember covering one ahead of twenty six January, many many years back,
[14:45] somewhere in the farms of Noida, and Noida wasn't as developed as it
[14:50] is today. I remember reaching early morning on the spot and two guys who
[14:54] come down. It was an operation done by up police. Again, there
[14:58] were there were a lot of questions unanswered. I remember then seeing the kind
[15:05] of story that the Upi police had given twenties when you're talking about Republic Day,
[15:11] they were planning something in the literally in the vast farmlands of western Upe.
[15:18] Didn't add up, and it was just it was a fresh quote unquote
[15:22] encounter. When I reached and no police personnel were in Hawai chapels with their
[15:28] weapon. Things didn't look good. It wasn't good optics either. It's one
[15:33] of my stories personal stories. The other are, of course, the kind
[15:35] of encounters operations that you hear in insurgency areas my West Kushmi Northeast. Many
[15:43] of them can come under scanner and scrutiny. So many times sometimes they passed
[15:50] the test of all the scrutinies, sometimes they don't. There have been so
[15:54] many quote marshals things like that have happened where if armies involved. So there's
[16:00] no pattern the patterns, but my my personal experience. And I asked this
[16:07] question on Twitter when the Wecast Dubay encounter happened twenty twenty, I think it
[16:11] was. Yes, he was on the run, and again it was a
[16:12] up police encounter. So I put out a tweet asking all crime reporters,
[16:18] security affairs reporters who have covered on these cases, which is the encounter that
[16:26] you think was completely genuine? This was my tweet and form most beginning answers.
[16:33] Yeah, many many answered And I didn't ask which one is fake because
[16:38] the list could be very, very very long. Yeah, so that's why
[16:41] I asked which one is genuine? And to my generation of reporters, the
[16:48] answer was the Butler House encounter. That's something that even I have covered and
[16:53] I totally agreed that that was even I I think that it was completely genuine
[17:00] encounter, even though there was a lot of scrutiny back then on the Butler
[17:06] House encounter I remember, I mean the Battler House was in two thousand and
[17:08] eight thousand was I think the last stages of miss schooling or maybe early call
[17:14] I think last tieares of miss schooling. Yeah, and it took a very
[17:17] political turn as well. You know, there was you know, lots of
[17:19] I think the Congress government was in power in the center, there was a
[17:23] government upa government and I forgot who the Home Minister was, but yeah,
[17:29] there was lots of questions. The Home minister was even a high thing.
[17:34] So yeah, even I have a big memory. Yeah, So yeah,
[17:37] a lot of key you know, this was. And so the premise was
[17:41] that this was a group of UH Indiana Indian sorry seem mophed into Maadin who
[17:48] had come from Gujarad, I'm not wrong, and planned to have sort of
[17:51] a terror attack in Delhi. And uh, they didn't plan to have an
[17:56] attack in Delhi. There was already an attack in Delhi on thirteen September two
[18:00] thousand and eight, which was a Saturday, evening and I was planning to
[18:04] sort of wind up work early at Saturday. Let's wind up and let's move
[18:10] on. Our office used to be in Gender one and that time, which
[18:14] is not the same price. It was the same organization I was working in
[18:18] my earliest stint as a young TV reporter, then just moved out of print
[18:23] and was I was just cutting my teeth with the TV reporting. So there
[18:29] was there were no smartphones, so you would check with colleagues, with corps
[18:33] what's happening. You had to call. So suddenly there was there was a
[18:37] word that there has been a blast in korul Bag. The DCP denied in
[18:44] saying that you know, I've checked and there's not a blast. There's not
[18:47] ter blast, it's not a bomb blast, no turangle, it's a gas
[18:49] cylinder. And I'm just ascertaining the kind of damage, destruction, casualties,
[18:52] etc. So not that a gas cylinder, if it turns into huge casualties,
[18:59] is not big. But at least you are relieved in the sense that
[19:03] it doesn't have the ramifications of attack. But I think within minutes it was
[19:08] pretty clear that it's not a gas cylinder blast and it indeed is a terror
[19:14] attack. And that's when I rushed to the spot and I was very quick
[19:19] to reach the spot because our office was closed by and suddenly there was news
[19:23] flashing all over that there are serial blasts in Delhi. This was on thirteen
[19:27] September two thousand and eight. The blast took place in karol Bag, in
[19:32] Connaught Place and in GK. In g K there were no casualties, but
[19:37] in karol Bag and in CP there were some casualties, most in karol Bag
[19:41] if I remember correctly. And you know, this was after the two thousand
[19:47] and five pre Devali blasts, which were deadly blasts, many people and died.
[19:52] This was the next big terror attack that has happened in Delhi. And
[19:56] the two thousand and five attacks were really really bad because it was on the
[20:02] eve of the Valley and it was also either if I remember correctly, so
[20:06] lots of people out on the streets and places like Sugini Nagar, a packed
[20:11] bus, pahada guns. You can just imagine the footfall during festivities. Anyway,
[20:17] these places are you know, always always high on numbers, but just
[20:23] just visualize on either and on the Vali. So the casualties were really high.
[20:30] So that's why, you know, everybody recalled what's happened a few years
[20:33] back in Delhi, so we were all hoping that that kind of casualties are
[20:37] not there. The Butler House encounter happened exactly a week later. It was
[20:42] nineteen September when there was information of a shootout in Delhi's Butler House. This
[20:51] is a locality in chahine Ba, which is quote unquote Muslim ghetto, and
[20:56] a lot of rumor mongering happened that the poor entered a mosque and carried out
[21:02] a shootout, etc. But nothing of that sort had happened because when we
[21:04] reached there we realized that it was the shootout was restricted to a flat in
[21:10] battle House, and moments later it was known that Inspectumu Charma, who was
[21:18] very high profile police officer of the Special Cell, has also sustained bullet injuries.
[21:23] I don't know if you remember those pictures of Inspectrum Hunch and Charma actually,
[21:29] you know, hit in the stomach in the abdomen area and literally walking
[21:33] with the help of two people. It's it's a it's a picture which is
[21:37] very clear in my memory. And Inspectrum Chara was somebody who was also accessible
[21:44] to a lot of reporters. He was that old school kind of policeman who
[21:49] thought that, you know, it's okay to give out information. And the
[21:53] Special Cell in those days in Deli had a different aura. If I can
[21:57] say, so, how the encounter happened can be a matter of debate,
[22:03] A matter of little controversy. Oh, I wouldn't say controversial, a matter
[22:07] of debate. It see, it was the Gujarat police. This is this
[22:11] is a this is an old story folklore if you want to say that it
[22:15] was the Gujarat police that was already in Delhi and they had information about these
[22:18] Indian Mujadian guys who were part of planning of the Delhi blast that I just
[22:23] spoke about. And then the same year there had been blasts in July and
[22:29] earlier even in Jaipour quote blasts in Varanasi. Luck now, so there had
[22:36] been a series of this and Mdabad was really deadly, and then Delhi happened.
[22:41] Mdabad was in July. I remember all this very clearly, and I
[22:45] think it was also appeated in one other city. You had some pressure bombs
[22:48] recovered, but that didn't go off person. But this was the modus operandi
[22:52] of ye just drawing the whole change basically there or some modubject of Indian and
[23:00] I uh, the July blasts is in him bad. I couldn't go to
[23:07] Kawa that because I just got married, so I wasn't leave. And in
[23:11] September, after Delhi, this encounter happened on eighteen nineteen September, huge controversy
[23:18] and finally I was talking about Munch and Sherma. He assustained bullet injuries.
[23:22] He by Later that evening there was news confirmation that Munch and Sherma succume to
[23:29] his injuries. Big, big loss for Delhi Police, for Special Cell,
[23:33] and I think there was also a lot of emotional side to a lot of
[23:38] police officers that I saw who were closed to Munch and Sherma, including then
[23:42] Joint CP of Special Cell, the officer heading the Special Cell, gentleman called
[23:48] mister Colonel Singh in a press conference after the Butlerhouse encounter. I remember him.
[23:56] He's a very soft spoken kind of a guy. So a question was
[24:00] asked to him that how can Delli police be so unprofessional? They were going
[24:06] for such an operation, why didn't they were bulletproof jackets? So he said
[24:12] that Manchon Sherma and my team are no novices, and he said it in
[24:18] Hindie. Also, you look Nosiki and there are no novices. And as
[24:22] you said, they've carried out such operations like this, And he actually gave
[24:27] a reasoning which I thought was good enough. One see, this is not
[24:32] an operation happening in a conflict zone. It's happening in the middle of a
[24:37] residential area. If you have police roaming around in bulletproof jackets, it's a
[24:44] giveaway. And they were there for a raid. They were not. They
[24:47] were not there to carry a carry out a spectacular shootout. They were there
[24:53] for a raid, isn't it, And nab the guys. There are secret
[24:57] operations, you have guys, and this guy is standing here and there.
[25:02] So he said that you might think that this question is extremely intelligent, but
[25:07] it isn't because in a secret operation where you're going for a rate, you
[25:11] can't give it away. So anyway, they were sure that these guys are
[25:17] inside here. They're ordered for pizzas from Domino's. These guys, the five
[25:22] guys staying in that LA team blast any LA team flat and the police team
[25:30] was there, so they let the pizza guy go and sort of get a
[25:34] confirmation from him what was happening inside. So unfortunately, when he came down,
[25:40] he could not give a lot of information because obviously you don't let a
[25:44] guy come inside, and there was no real activity or anything that could be
[25:48] caught. So he just came down and he said they took and I couldn't
[25:53] get much information. So anyway, then that place, the police raided that
[25:59] place and then there was a shootout. Two guys got killed in Spectrum on
[26:03] Cherma was killed. I think one was arrested, and two got away.
[26:10] Another story after a story linked to this, one of the guys who got
[26:14] caught away. Obviously we didn't know the identities. Then it was only later
[26:17] that these identities was revealed. We at arch Stuck and then Headlines Today Inda
[26:22] Today channel was called Headlines Today. One of us, one of our reporters,
[26:26] managed to get in touch with this guy without knowing his antecedents or anything.
[26:32] One of the two who got away. Yeah, yeah, So he
[26:33] he came to us saying that you know, I'm a witness. That's so
[26:37] we thought it's a scoop. You have a witness of the of the of
[26:42] the encounter and so let's see what he has to say. Obviously, phones
[26:47] and all were on surveillance, so this guy was tracked for a lot of
[26:49] times, phone was not working. But then he got in touch with Actually
[26:53] it was a call that he made to our reporter. That's where he got
[26:59] tracked again. And our office used to be in not in Noida. So
[27:06] police got to know of it. They got in touch with editors et cetera.
[27:10] That no, this is this is what it is. He's one of
[27:12] those guys and it's it. It will not be right for him to be
[27:17] near studios, et cetera, whatever you're planning, because we are coming to
[27:19] arrest him. So it's it would only get more embarrassing. Yeah, of
[27:25] course. So anyway, police came arrested him from there. His official arrest
[27:32] was shown from there. So this is my story that I have seen,
[27:37] uh, you know, completely pan out from being at the spot in Chahinebag
[27:41] outside Battler House when all of this happened. Of course, not the encounter.
[27:45] You reached a little late, but there was a lot of action because
[27:48] when there is an encounter in in such a place which is thickly populated obviously
[27:55] there's there's going to be a lot of tamasha following that, and as I
[27:59] said, Muslim ghetto, so things got really sensitive. Police, Muslim boys,
[28:04] guill these are extremely sensitive things. It wasn't easy reporting from there because
[28:10] again people start questioning you as well, sometimes that you know you are only
[28:15] putting out the police propaganda. But the fact was that it was difficult to
[28:21] know the other side of the story, and there was enough evidence of a
[28:25] shootout. A high profile officer, decorated officer gets killed, that means something
[28:33] has really really happened there. So anyway, this was the nine eighteen,
[28:40] nineteen September on about ten days later, there was another encounter. Enderly,
[28:44] this was in Green Park, so everybody was surprised, what's happening encounter after
[28:48] encounter, But that encounter had no tarangle. It was a gangster or something.
[28:52] I remember that year. In September onwards, there was something or the
[28:59] other just kept on happening, and it ended with twenty six eleven and the
[29:03] mother of all encounters you would call it. And I was there twenty six
[29:07] eleven as well. Again, as I said, these were early days of
[29:11] TV reporting. Literally living on the pavement of a Mumbai till these operations got
[29:19] over. So a bit of my personal experience I thought was important to tell
[29:26] the stories around encounters as a young reporter. I mentioned that Naida story where
[29:32] yeah there was always again thirty first December New Year's Eve was the time where
[29:37] some bigger rest could happen. So as a young reporter, you know you
[29:41] would have to forego partying on these days because you would invariably be the late
[29:47] evening reporter, would stay out in case something happens, and you you,
[29:51] I was covering crime, so in case something happened, you have to be
[29:55] ready on your tours. Yeah, so I when just some storytelling I thought
[30:00] about encounters since we added yeah, no, of course, I mean that's
[30:03] a great story and it obviously helps to get to get some sort of background,
[30:08] sort of a view of what's just been reported in headlines and in on
[30:15] TV and that Sorry sorry coming back to the buttlouse encounter, missed out on
[30:18] one thing I mentioned, but then I think we digressed to something else.
[30:22] The point where you could argue that it was slightly unprofessional or something was the
[30:26] hurry that the Delhi Police show showed to reach there probably without getting all the
[30:32] information the details, and that hurry was because they had an eye inkling that
[30:37] pic is also here. So this is part of a lot of reportage.
[30:41] So you had these, uh, this kind of a competition between state polices
[30:48] and that was one of the reasons why the National Investigation is Inc was a
[30:52] familated that was thought by then Home Minister mister Chidambar there needs to be a
[30:59] fed drill anti terror agency to investigate, investigate, at least forget operations,
[31:04] but at least investigations should should come at one platform. So, yeah,
[31:08] there are a lot of stories about these encounters going horribly wrong because of these
[31:14] internal rivalries competition between some police officers. Also that you know, of course
[31:21] you'll get it first and things like that. So that bit of the Butlerhouse
[31:26] encounter can be debated for the sake of debate. But coming to the question
[31:30] that which of the encounters you think was not fake, the majority of journalists
[31:36] who have covered these kinds of things, yeah, always mentioned and you know,
[31:41] if you ask the other question that which of the encounters you most definitely
[31:45] know was fake, you know, I'd stick my neck out and say that
[31:51] the answer probably would have been very decent one would have been the twenty nineteen
[31:56] encounter of four alleged ary pists in telling Ana. It was a it was
[32:00] a very distressing case of gang rape. The media picked it up, but
[32:07] it was highlighted. It was called I hate that term, by the way,
[32:09] but for the sake of it, it was called na the nipe.
[32:12] I hate the terminal the nipe, I mean. But yeah, that was
[32:15] and the four people who had been detained or arrested for that gang rape were
[32:20] you know, shot dead with the police. Even the commission that probe the
[32:23] probe the encounter said it was the police acted with an intend to kill and
[32:28] then recommended action. And I think the Supreme Court can have gotten involved,
[32:30] et cetera. So that I think would have been the answer if you had
[32:35] asked the other question. But but then, like like you said, many
[32:39] see it would be unfair for us to just give out our judgment that this
[32:45] one is this one. Yeah, you've not carried out an investigation, of
[32:47] course, but yes, there are more encounters that that actually raised a lot
[32:53] of questions than the ones that do. They don't true. So as as
[32:58] a journalist, i'le put way that the list of those that look dodgy,
[33:04] where questions left are left unanswered. The list is much longer than That's why
[33:09] I pose the questions to fellow reporters, which one of them do you think
[33:14] is truly genuine and not fake? And Butler House top of the list,
[33:19] even though so many people think otherwise. There was a lot of today's day
[33:23] by the eaven There are people even today who still still still believe that it
[33:27] was not you know, a completely leged that there were things. And then
[33:30] of course there has been a series of controversial encounters in Gujarat that have a
[33:36] great, great significance in the politics are contemporary politics because Ishira Jahan and we
[33:46] all know the background happened. We are not going to get into that,
[33:50] but yes, all those things that happened played an extremely important role in how
[33:55] the politics is shaped up. But you know, coming to when you say,
[34:00] like why the list of encounters that are dodgy or the list of encounters
[34:05] that raise questions is definitely much much longer than those that don't. I'd like
[34:08] to talk to you more about on that, but we do that utter a
[34:12] quick break. Hello, I'm Raj Chambaba from India Today Podcasts and your host
[34:23] for Nothing but the Truth. Every week we will deal with key issues of
[34:30] concern and bring you perspectives and clarity as to why they should matter to you
[34:35] and what is the clear truth that emerges. Welcome back, Abi and I
[34:50] are discussing encounters or shootouts or whatever term you want to you want to call
[34:53] them. You know, before the break we were discussing, you said you
[34:58] mentioned how if you were to not dissect us, if you were to list
[35:01] some of the top not top top again is the wrong word. Encounters those
[35:07] made that the ones that made headline, yeah, triggered controvers triggered controversies,
[35:10] yeah, and kind of put them into boxes. The box off encounters that
[35:15] raised questions. The box of encounters that seemed something was awful year would be
[35:21] much bigger or larger than the box that seemed okay, perfectly find, perfectly
[35:24] legged. I'd like to talk to you more on that topic. In your
[35:29] career, you've covered almost like you keep mentioning every time, you know,
[35:32] you've covered almost every division of India security, whether it's the local police or
[35:38] the federal beer agencies. In your interactions with the officers. With police officers,
[35:45] have you ever come across. Is there an so sop for an encounter?
[35:49] Because I'll tell you that the questions that remain unanswered, the reasons some
[35:52] of the encounter seems to dodgies because no one really knows what's alleged encounter,
[35:58] right you? I I mean as a as a as a lay person,
[36:01] I know that I have the right of self defense, like if somebody's going
[36:06] to try to kill me, I can you know, do something to protect
[36:08] myself and later and argue that whatever happened in that moment was because I was
[36:12] scared for my life. I was defending my own life and that that right
[36:15] extends to police and to other people in the security establishment as well. But
[36:22] apart from that, is there really an speak you know? For example,
[36:25] Uh, this is something some of my colleagues believe when I'm not. I
[36:30] don't know if I to believe it or not. But is there an undertone
[36:32] rule that if you are shooting, the first shot should be below the way
[36:37] waste? Because I think this is a legend perpetuated by movies mostly MR to
[36:42] that you can cast them alive. But is that something that you've come play's
[36:45] advocate if if you have been fired at why will you then you need to
[36:51] bring down the guy. Yeah, to save yourself. Yeah. So for
[36:53] me, that's the basic protocol. If you've been fired at, life is
[36:57] in danger, so you need to neutralize. That's the term that is used
[37:01] in security forces. Neutralize the threat, and the threat at that point of
[37:06] time is somebody who's firing at you. For me, that's a legit encounter.
[37:09] That's exactly what a shootout is. What is not is where it's not
[37:15] clear whether you were shot at. If it's not clear that you were shot
[37:20] at, and then there is a sort of corroborative I wouldn't say evidence too
[37:24] loaded a term, but something that hints at the entire thing being staged,
[37:30] then questions will be raised. Kaliman, nobody around. It's just written all
[37:36] over that you followed some kind of a script. So it gives it gives
[37:39] away. And even though it's very difficult to prove it that it's false,
[37:45] but it happens. There have been people who've got convicted and things like that.
[37:52] Beat in the army on the police and again one of the classic encounters,
[37:59] fake encounters or encounters gone wrong is an old story back back goes back
[38:05] to nineteen eighty seven. I have not covered it. I was back in
[38:07] school, but I remember reading about it, and then as a young journalist,
[38:13] I have interacted with those journalists who had covered that CP shootout. CP
[38:17] killings of two businessmen in a carp by therefore not place in a place in
[38:23] New Day. It's a very popular place. So that was a case of
[38:30] mistaken identity. But why does it qualify as a fake encounters because the intent
[38:37] to kill was very very clear, So the intent was not to nab them.
[38:45] The intent was to kill. And when it turned out to be fake,
[38:49] because it turned out too because it turned out to be a fake identity.
[38:52] Obviously, there was no firing from their end, Yeah, so they
[38:57] were not the gangsters that the police was trailing. I think ten people were
[39:01] convicted, and I've heard a lot of stories about that from senior journalists what
[39:07] happened, and one of them, one of the officers in fact in jail,
[39:12] completed his PhD. And when the conviction happened. I remember covering the
[39:15] conviction, so I was a little sympathetic towards the driver of the vehicle who
[39:23] was also convicted the same punishment life imprisonment like others. So it was the
[39:30] police officer who said that, yeah, he's unlucky. In purely legal terms,
[39:37] he was part of the planning, He was part of the conspiracy or
[39:40] the way he had he acknowledged that this world is going to happen, and
[39:44] that's the reason why the court has put him in the same bracket. So,
[39:47] I mean, these are some casualties of encounters call so so Yeah,
[39:53] that cannot place. Shootout is my first memory. And of course the famous
[39:58] film say I don't know if you've seen that, you must you must watch
[40:04] that film because it's a very well made film. Again it's Yupi And that
[40:10] was we were talking about different categories of encounters. That that one was again
[40:15] a completely different category. Here was a guy, young criminal in Up who
[40:23] had just reached the pinnacle of the world of crime and mafia at a very
[40:30] young age, and so much so that he had decided to kill the chief
[40:37] Minister of Up if he gets the right price for it, which he Supari
[40:45] so Up got intelligence, Yupi police and everybody, that is what he's planning
[40:50] to do. So now you can well imagine what category of encounter that that
[40:53] would be fall in. I think rare rare, extremely except exceptional kind of
[40:59] a situation and a film was made on it and the new method of surveillance
[41:06] using your phone. It started with that case. And the officer that has
[41:10] been showcased in that film is room Kumara, fine officer. He served with
[41:16] the CBI as well. So there are different kind of kinds of encounter stories.
[41:22] So Sleeprakash class story again, I think it goes back to nineties.
[41:25] I think the chase, it was chase happened somewhere in Gaza, the Delhi
[41:30] m I have faded memory of it, but it definitely happened in up.
[41:37] So another another encounter story that people should revisit if they want to know about
[41:42] and hear about this. All right, let's move to a little bit towards
[41:47] the military. Now, a topic that we talk about every every every week
[41:52] on this topic as well, the military has had some you know, controversies
[41:55] when it comes to encounters. There have been allegations of the army carrying out
[42:01] fake encounters in in the Northeast. There have been allegations, uh this is
[42:08] not the military but the Central lum police forces carrying out encounters in the Nuxell
[42:14] regions or an excellent invested regions of the country. But moving to the part
[42:17] of the army, can you first of all give us an overview of how
[42:22] does the army look at the world encounter Let's make it simple like that.
[42:28] Well, they call it operation. I have very seldom heard that there was
[42:34] they were. They actually used the term encounter in the right sense, in
[42:36] the right sense and the little sense of the word we encountered. Yeah,
[42:39] it was encounter. There was an exchange of fire. So actually they get
[42:44] the usage right, and to give it to them. See the army's role
[42:46] in j n K for that matter, in uh Northeast. A lot of
[42:52] people are not aware. A lot of Special Forces operations have been carried out
[42:57] in the Northeast. There are SAM Rifles and there is a lot of Special
[43:02] Forces that I've carried out several secret operations. So just to sort of explain
[43:08] the mindset of the army in these places. Every time they move out of
[43:15] their camp, the camps are extremely high highly fortified kind of zones. This
[43:22] is like, these are heavily terror insurgency infested areas. Every time they move
[43:29] out of their camp, they're not going out for a stool. They're either
[43:32] going out for a search and cordon operation, or they are going out for
[43:37] an operation which will require using their weapons. That thought process is extremely clear,
[43:44] and in fact rust their rifles their camps. I've noticed in almost all
[43:51] when you open the door or the gate, like when you're leaving the camp,
[43:55] in bold letters somewhere on the gate or the end it says arch contact
[44:01] hoga. So the point that I'm trying to explain what is contact contact is
[44:07] exchange of fire. When an exchange of fire happens, that's when you have
[44:10] established contact with the enemy, with the adversary. Once the contact is established,
[44:16] you knew there is something here whereas the fire come from. So that
[44:22] message arch contact hoga is to drill it into their heads. Every time you
[44:28] move out, expect bullet to be fired at you, keeping them a lord
[44:32] basically, so only if a bullet is fired at you will you know who
[44:37] to fire art, isn't it? So that's that's those are those are operations
[44:42] where of course you would believe that not fake. But there have been stories,
[44:47] several stories. If anybody wants to know of army encounters that are on
[44:52] the question, a Google search will give you many many sort of options to
[44:59] read upon. And again good Hindi film which was actually a completely complete copy
[45:06] lift of an English movie, but still I like it. A movie called
[45:09] Sharia. I've watched the both. I've watched both by the and the English
[45:13] version is A Few Good Men starting a few A few good Men has that
[45:17] racist angle, yes, and this of course has a Muslim angle, a
[45:22] Muslim angle where a Muslim officer serving in Kashmir is accused of fake killings,
[45:30] and he's accused because the film shows that he's actually raising questions on a senior
[45:37] officer's actions. So a representation of how things go wrong. Of course this
[45:42] is fiction, but both films are very good that bring out certain prejudices that
[45:47] people can have. Both films very well made, and yeah, I mean
[45:53] those things happen. So you know, if you want to take this at
[45:58] a slightly intellectual level, do you think this entanglement, if I can use
[46:02] that word of the army in Encounters is primarily because and I think this is
[46:08] something we've discussed previously. Stranded because they are operating in a domain that they're
[46:13] not meant to. Then a train time and now they're trained because so many
[46:16] years of insurgency. But that's what technically what armies are meant to be doing,
[46:21] right, They're not to be meant to be fighting a war within your
[46:24] country's own borders, because if you look at what we discussed in the first
[46:29] half of this episode, this is a very civil sort of encounters, a
[46:32] very civil sort of development where you have the police force for whatever reason,
[46:37] because we discuss several it's the civilian encounters that actually trigger more contract more and
[46:44] more controversy. So do you think this entanglement of the army is also because
[46:46] it's operating in this the civilian zone where this is not training that they've been
[46:52] given. No, it is, but I sort of don't agree that they're
[46:58] not trained for it now because now is for a very long time. Yeah,
[47:01] so somewhere there is training for these kinds of situations. But yes,
[47:07] in the classic sense, an army is not supposed to do that. Yeah,
[47:09] but there is. The army has been there since nine decades, early
[47:15] nineties in Kashmir. The Sam Rifles has been there since long, long long
[47:20] time. Special forces have been there for a long long time. But but
[47:23] yeah, special forces have a different minded. I think it's the Assam rifles
[47:29] and Rashtra rifles that need a lot of civilian interface, and that's why you
[47:35] are seeing that they have carried out a huge change in their way of functioning.
[47:42] They don't function as just a anti terror body. There is a lot
[47:49] of interface being done, if not by the Raster rifles, at least by
[47:52] some units of the army. They call it sab Bavna. There's that Kashmir.
[47:59] Their school roles that they open goodwill schools. Senior officers go there.
[48:04] Then they're training trainings for several skills for girls to carry out small businesses from
[48:13] home, small kind of things that keep them busy. Sports is another thing.
[48:19] So there is a very conscious feeling that if this is what you need
[48:22] to do and you need to have an interface, you need to have more
[48:27] interactions with the locals, with the civilians. Of course, there will be
[48:31] times where the civilians will question your actions, but yeah, there the things
[48:38] have changed in the way the army treats their role in these places. It's
[48:45] it's a it's not exactly police, but yeah, civilian interface is definitely right.
[48:52] One last thought from you and one maybe question for you for a moment
[48:59] for you to give as a controversial answer if you if you so choose to,
[49:02] Uh, have you ever come across an officer who's admitted to you,
[49:08] maybe off the record, that you know this particular thing was. I won't
[49:13] even say gout to the extensaying stage, but you know, they don't trust
[49:16] me so much, they don't trust you so much. I probably have not
[49:20] won the trust of officers who will tell me that, yeah, we we
[49:24] deliberate killing, yeah, where we could have arrested somebody, somebody, Why
[49:30] will they say that? So yeah, I'm not I've not had the privilege
[49:34] of upfront to that. Yeah. But you must have met people within this
[49:40] system where you suspected KiHa. This one was like, yeah, of course
[49:45] when you have done stories raising questions a recent one of the nagaland one.
[49:51] I did stories you know that. I mean, look extremely shooting civilians.
[49:58] Yeah. So and it was special forces operation again again it was mistaken identity
[50:02] and they mistook a hunting rifle for some kind of a weapon assaulted for So
[50:09] I think that qualifies as big error in your judgment as a professional force.
[50:15] Things go wrong, but even they cannot be a justification for killings. And
[50:22] I think ASPA has helped them there. The Army has not given the Ministry
[50:25] of Deferent Ministry of Defense sanction. The Ministry of Defense has not given prostitution
[50:30] sanction, which again, I mean I've not seen the official document, but
[50:36] my understanding is that they are obviously saying this that it was unintentional, it
[50:43] was mistaken identity, and that is what should be that. I think what
[50:45] they're saying is because it was accidental, that's kind of protected under AFTS.
[50:50] Otherwise, if there's protection, then you know, future makes you might Yeah,
[50:53] so I think that's an actually interesting tangent. We can discuss an other
[50:58] episode. See, I mean, there's so many aspects to this subject you
[51:01] can have a series. Yeah, so, because yeah, you know,
[51:05] that's what I mean. If you just let you know, kind of recap
[51:07] this episode, you'll notice that almost every encounter has a story in tangent altogether.
[51:13] Yeah, if you can classify them into one bunch of what happens.
[51:15] Why when we started off, I said that they are different categories exactly genuine,
[51:20] fake, whatever you want to call them, But there are always different
[51:22] categories mistaken identity. There is that, So there is a story to every
[51:29] every every encounter encounter every such operation and a story that you can spend hours
[51:34] talking about. Yeah, well, yeah, I think that's a good note
[51:37] on which blend this episode. Thanks a b. You know, thank you.
[51:42] They've kind of you know, talking about the lesser explode side of your
[51:45] professional experience on this podcast. I think, I think I think we should
[51:52] talk about my earlier years a bit more more because I they're closer to heart.
[51:57] If you, if you ask me, I can meet you, quint.
[52:00] When you're trying to find a place for yourself, you want to be
[52:05] recognized as a reporter. You want your byline to have some gravitas. So
[52:09] many times I'm telling you it's not the story, it's the byline. Yeah,
[52:13] which is not a very good thing. It's not the best thing to
[52:15] say for a journalist. But yes, I remember, as a younger journalist
[52:19] a story was good because it had a certain byline. Then you write,
[52:22] anybody's story is one, but it's the byline, the byline, So it
[52:28] takes a while. Fortunately, I can thank my stars. I've probably put
[52:32] some level of gravitas to my byline. Maybe yeah, maybe, I'm not
[52:37] sure. It's it's fathers to tell me. But I always like to talk
[52:39] about those days when I was actually striving and working very hard for people to
[52:46] take my byline seals seriously. Yeah right, yeah, so we'll do We'll
[52:51] do that definitely in the upcoming episode. So thanks a lot. Once again,
[52:54] thanks to our listeners and our viewers. Once again, let us know
[52:58] if you have any comment, any feedback that you have for US Rapper,
[53:00] text to us at eight five, double at nine, double six, double
[53:02] nine six, or an email to us at pots at the rate internet dot
[53:06] com. Let's be ods at the rate interet dot com. That's it for
[53:08] the six Defense Doors for more tune in next week. Will then stay safe
[53:12] and not cross any boundaries. We are a passport by

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
