# Israel-Hamas to India-China: What Future Holds In Store For These Conflicts | In Our Defence S2, Ep 01

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 7 Dec 2023, 59 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/57939876/07_dec_23_iod_s2_ep_1_dec_7_mix_128.mp3

In Our Defence team is back and how! With a different avatar! In Season 2, India Today TV Output’s Senior Executive Editor, Shiv Aroor, joins host Dev Goswami, where they will talk of more guns and battles, wars and coups, interspersed with tales of glory from the battlefields! This episode delves into major global events—Russia's war in Ukraine, the India-China conflict, and the Israel-Hamas conflict. Shiv provides on-the-ground insights from Tel Aviv, analysing&nbsp;whether Israel, in combating terrorists, might inadvertently adopt tactics resembling those they oppose. He recounts a former IDF chief telling him, that “Israel will spend the next 25 years recovering its reputation”. Why does the Israel-Hamas issue persist cyclically? What unfolds in the Russia-Ukraine war, and how concerned should India be? “I see a lot of blood between Russia and Ukraine next summer but the silver lining is that they will be in some way forced to a resolution,” Shiv says. And what developments are on the horizon for the India-China front?&nbsp; Listen in! Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound Mix by Kapil Dev Singh

## Transcript

[0:00] This is in Hour Today podcasts. The world of defense blows hot and cold.
[0:09] Whether it's boundary disputes or outright wars, whether it's happening between diplomats or
[0:15] militaries. Conflicts invite discussions that range from the subtle to the brutal and increasingly
[0:24] polarized. I they've go Swami, your host, along with defense expert and
[0:28] senior journalist Hivarur break down this world for you if we bring you nuances and
[0:33] perspectives that will inform and at times provoke. This is in our Defense.
[0:47] Hello, and welcome or should I say welcome back? In our Defense is
[0:51] back after a break of a few weeks that we took over the valley and
[0:55] we are back in a very new of the If you had followed our last
[0:59] episode, you would know that Abala, who was with me on this podcast
[1:03] for around eighty episodes, has left the podcast and he's moved on to some
[1:08] like we discussed last Selena pastures someone with the same level of experience in defense
[1:12] and say the same level of interest I would say in defense as a bishak
[1:15] and I also and that person is Shivaro. Hello. Shift this podcast and
[1:21] the replacement and I've been watching your podcast as Good to Be Shiv has an
[1:27] experience of around twenty years, I think covering defense, covering defense, Yeah,
[1:32] covering defense. You started off in print, if I'm not wrong,
[1:34] yeah, and then moved to television, attended a group. You've been here
[1:38] for how long? Well some would say too long, but about sixteen and
[1:42] a half years. Now. Wow, that's that's quite a lot. That's
[1:45] quite a lot. So before we begin and before we discuss matters of defense,
[1:49] tell us a bit, what made you cover defense or was it just
[1:53] like you know, as it happened in the older days, that editor decided
[1:56] to me, again, that's just how it bigan. Was it your personal
[1:57] interest in this? Yeah? So you know when I started covering defense,
[2:01] was it was not because I wanted it. I was actually like most people
[2:06] who get into journalism, at least in that generation, I wanted to do
[2:09] politics because you know, for new journalists in India it's like, you know,
[2:15] at that time, at least, it was if you're not covering politics,
[2:16] what are you covering? Right? But as it happened, I was
[2:20] given a job with the Indian Express, the National Bureau, and I think
[2:23] I was the youngest person in the National Bureau Indian expresses like an institution,
[2:27] right and over there, I was twenty I was twenty two years old.
[2:31] And usually you spend a good ten twelve years of your career doing other stuff
[2:38] before you get inducted in the National Bureau. And here I was just like
[2:40] inducted into the National Bureau and it was it was a really big deal.
[2:45] And Shiker Gupta, who was my boss at that time, he said,
[2:50] we don't have any vacancies in politics right now, so you covered defense,
[2:53] which was the scariest day of my life because it's like, I don't know
[2:55] anything about defense. I mean, I like aircraft and stuff, but I
[2:59] don't know about defense. But he said, no, you've got to do
[3:02] it. So so that was my entry into defense. And like I said,
[3:06] it's been That was two thousand and four. So next year'll be twenty
[3:08] years since I took that decision. Wow, And we hope to get whatever
[3:12] you learned to over those twenty years onto this podcast because the idea of this
[3:15] podcast is to you know, kind of break through the noise and bring you
[3:19] the nuances because ye, matters of defense are not black and white. You
[3:23] know that you have subtleties, you have nuances that need to be really explained,
[3:27] and that is what we aim to do. That is what we've been
[3:29] doing for the past eight years, I hope. So actually listen, no,
[3:31] I'm glad you said that, because there's very little about defense that's black
[3:36] and white, especially in the world we live in right now where you've got
[3:39] you've got three major conflicts in different parts of the world, so there's very
[3:45] little good and bad, black and white, you know, us versus them.
[3:50] It's a very very mixed bag. So it's I think it's a good
[3:53] thing that you're doing with this podcast to try and simplify things ad perspective,
[3:57] So happy to add that plat to have you. So let's start off,
[4:00] and since you mentioned conflicts going on different parts of the world, I think
[4:03] this episode will just kind of get a brief overview of what's happening in the
[4:08] in the world of conflict. And let's jump in with the one that's reading
[4:11] right now is rel Haamas. We record this on I think seventh that is
[4:15] today, So it's almost nearly two months since Hamas launched has attack into Israel
[4:19] and Israel has responded ferociously there was a truce broker, but that kind of
[4:25] fell through last week last Friday, and Israel has once again pushed into into
[4:30] Gaza. You've been there, which is one of the reasons I actually wanted
[4:33] to start this episode by talking about Digil lamas you were therefore, I think
[4:38] a good week and a half or two weeks, almost three weeks most weeks.
[4:41] All right, So you've been there, You've seen things that you know,
[4:44] we haven't seen. We've seen mostly stuff on social media, a lot
[4:47] of which is propaganda, a lot of which not to beilate to fake news.
[4:50] First, tell us what do you think where the war is at right
[4:55] now? And we'll obviously get into the whole see wars and if matters of
[4:59] defense don't really can't really go handed hand with models, but we'll obviously get
[5:02] into that because the situation that's happening in Gaza right not really speaks for also
[5:08] that. But firs, still, what do you think is the situation?
[5:11] Yeah? So I spent you know, between two and three weeks over then,
[5:14] and I got a chance to travel to all parts of Israel and spent
[5:17] a large part of my time on the Gaza border, you know, with
[5:21] the forces with the people. Unfortunately couldn't get into Gaza for various reasons,
[5:26] but I was able to travel extensively in the West Bank, the Palestinian territories
[5:30] in the West Bank and did a lot of stories from there. I think
[5:33] the thing that most people forget about the Israel Palestine conflict, and I mean
[5:38] this relative to other conflicts, is this is a conflict that's been happening in
[5:42] cycles for since World War Two. Right. It's not like Russia Ukraine where
[5:46] they're fighting now, or India and China, who've you know who fought once
[5:50] in sixty two and now they've got a confrontation. The Israel Palestine conflict is
[5:56] a geographical, cultural, historical conflict that's been on for since literally the creation
[6:01] of Israel, right, and it's it's gone in cycles. Every there's there's
[6:08] almost like a sort of proverb on the ground there that something has to happen
[6:12] every seven or eight years, and it usually has the first in the father,
[6:15] the second ante father. You know, the invasion of Gaza in two
[6:18] twenty nine, twenty fourteen. Now you've almost got a semi invasion of Gaza
[6:23] as well. So this is going to continue the way things are at is
[6:28] this time unlike every other time that that you know violence has taken place between
[6:32] the two sides. Is that Israel has never lost fourteen hundred people in one
[6:39] go before. Okay, you're right when you say they that this is a
[6:43] conflict that is drenched in propaganda. There is perhaps no better example of the
[6:48] use of psychological operations, false claims, fake allegations, exaggerated you know,
[6:57] death tolls like Israel Palestine. You saw it in the opening days of the
[7:00] conflict, you know, with that Allah be a hospital in Gaza, and
[7:03] you know the beheaded babies, et cetera. And I was there at those
[7:06] kibbutzes. And once you're there in the ground, you know, these things
[7:11] start to make sense because because emotions are so so deep running when it comes
[7:16] to Israel and Palestine, in many ways, both sides have lost the capacity
[7:21] for, you know, a sober conversation. Very difficult for Israelis and Palestine
[7:27] Paratinonians to have a sober conversation and for an outsider like me to understand.
[7:30] And the thing is, for me, I had a bit of a vested
[7:33] interest in covering this because it was actually my subject matter in my thesis Inheming
[7:39] back in two thousand and two, way way way long ago. And so
[7:43] in the course of my research, I'd met lots of Israelis and Palestinians,
[7:45] but to be there on the ground and to experience what what almost kind of
[7:49] survival nationalism feels like is difficult to understand because we live in a huge country
[7:55] right where India is geographically vast. There's no there's no real territorial threat to
[8:01] India. You know, China might come in, Pakistan came to Kargil,
[8:05] but you know, there's no danger of losing territory as such. When it
[8:11] comes to Palestinians and Israelis on both sides, if you look at it is
[8:13] they're like, you know, if something big happens, our homeland has gone
[8:18] gone. You know, from Tel Aviv, I could drive to every part
[8:20] of Israel in four hours the Father's tip from Tel Aviv with six hours,
[8:26] So a tiny little place you can go anywhere in a day. It's a
[8:28] day trip, right, So over there, geographical survival is like a day
[8:33] trip, Okay, it's not a flight away. And so I think the
[8:39] optimist in me says that this is a war that will you know, sort
[8:43] of digest itself out. Certain objectives that Israel has listed out will need to
[8:48] be met, most obviously the hostages. Thankfully there's some movement on that front.
[8:54] But beyond that, I don't think it's going to be one of those
[8:56] conflicts that stretches for too long because Israel, for all its ability is its
[9:01] strength that the aid it receives from abroad, is not a country that has
[9:05] the appetite for extended conflict. It has always preferred short, sharp, aggressive,
[9:13] you know, punitive, punitive conflicts where it teaches the other side a
[9:16] lesson creates a situation where those things may not happen again. But I think
[9:22] the gorilla in the room for Israel is not so much how do we end
[9:28] this war that has happened now? But how the hell did we get here?
[9:31] How the hell did October the seventh happen? So, you know,
[9:33] it's a terrifying proposition for who's in power right now Israel, because they know
[9:39] once the fighting stops and already angry public is going to want heads to rule.
[9:43] So that's that's where the real trick, and they already have been called
[9:46] for Natan how to resign, I mean for not right now, obviously,
[9:48] because there is a war going on and the immediate focus area is kind of
[9:52] eliminating Hamas and just destroying all its abilities. But no, you made a
[9:58] very good point, and like that when you say it key when it comes
[10:01] to in Hamas, there is no room for basically emotions or having logical talks,
[10:05] because that's also a sense I've been getting, and that's something that answers
[10:09] the question that you know, how can Israel be so brutal because unlike let's
[10:13] say and India China, you it is a land dispute at the end of
[10:18] the day, so you have that ability to come to the negotiating table even
[10:22] if it goes nowhere, which it has been for the way, and we'll
[10:24] come to that for twenty Core Commander talks has been going nowhere. But even
[10:28] if it goes nowhere, at least you sit down and you say ye,
[10:30] so you know, you go there, I go here. We will do
[10:31] this. But there is no given take when it comes to Hamas because it's
[10:35] basically either you survive or I survive. But in what's been happening in the
[10:41] last few weeks, so in the last two days, for example, Israel's
[10:45] pushed south towards what is known as Khanyu, which is one of the other
[10:48] big cities of Gaza south of the Kaza City, and has been telling Gazans
[10:54] to move south. Egypt, which is the country that the shares the southern
[11:00] border, has refused to accept a Gazan refugees, and Israel just keeps moving
[11:05] there down. It's like almost sandwiching them between the border and where the forces
[11:09] are. One humanitarian chrisis of a large, large level. Do you think
[11:15] based on your interactions with the forces? Their forces obviously will not care much
[11:18] about this, but basically interactions with the public over there, is there any
[11:22] sense of what Israel is doing in Gaza? Because I'll give an example.
[11:26] One of our colleagues spoke to an Israeli woman whose brother is in the idea
[11:31] of this great defense forces, and she gave this one quote which I really
[11:35] like that she said that there's a slight fear in some people that while fighting
[11:39] terrorists, Israel might end up looking like a terrorist. Did you get that
[11:43] sentiment over that at all? It's a great question. Look, there are
[11:46] three answers to that question. A for most part, For most part,
[11:50] Israel believes that its reputation as far as Hamas is concerned, that ship has
[11:54] already sailed. The world already sees them as aggressors. The you know,
[12:00] large parts of the global intelligentsia, the woke part of the world as it
[12:05] were, already sees Israel as a terrorist state that's been killing babies and going
[12:09] after children and old people and stuff. So the narrative war is a separate
[12:13] and parallel war, and the one that it takes very seriously. Like,
[12:16] for instance, when I was in Israel, and i'll answer the second part
[12:20] of your question as well. When I was in Israel, they held screenings
[12:22] where they were showing bodycam footage of what was captured from the Hammas terrorists,
[12:26] going completely against what Israel's principles usually are. They never usually show that kind
[12:31] of stuff because they take all that stuff into their security domain for analysis and
[12:35] stuff. They were showing this to journalists and diplomats and stuff. The reason
[12:39] for that is they believe they were losing the narrative war. The thought process
[12:45] in every IDF person's mind or military planner's mind was what the hell we lost
[12:50] fourteen hundred people in one single day to barbaric terrorists. Over one hundred and
[12:56] twenty hostages, including babies, are sitting in Hamma's captivity, and the world
[13:01] is telling us we are terrorists. That's the default Israeli emotion right now,
[13:07] or at least at that time there even now, So they believe, boss,
[13:13] if we're good, we are terrorists. If you're bad, we're terrorists.
[13:16] If you're reacting to our baby, skilled, we are terrorists. If
[13:18] we try and hold back and you know, not conduct an invasion, we
[13:20] are terrorists. So it's like it's for them, it's like it's a battle
[13:24] lost. They believe there's no recovering that reputation. Also, remember that,
[13:30] like I said, since this war has happened in cycles, war crimes,
[13:33] you know, humanitarian torture, abuse, collateral damage. Yes, all this
[13:39] is already there on Israel's back. They can't wash it off. You know,
[13:43] what is true and what is not true is a different matter altogether.
[13:46] And we'll get to the United Nations in a bit, because in no part
[13:50] of the world has United Nations proven to be more useless, incompetent, wasteful,
[13:56] counterproductive than it is in Israel and Palestine. But that's a separate story,
[14:01] so fear about their reputation is definitely there. You can see it in
[14:05] many official actions taken by Israel, releasing audio tapes of terrorists while they were
[14:13] killing Jews in those kibootzes, folding their families and boasting about it. All
[14:16] these things never usually happen, but in this day and age of very quick
[14:20] social media, very quick being able to edit videos put them out, Israel
[14:24] feels like they're almost on an even battlefield as far as Hamas is concerned.
[14:30] If you look at it like this, there's no comparison between Hamas and Israel
[14:33] when it comes to military capabilities, right, there's no comparison. Israel has
[14:37] tanks, aircraft, radars, etc. And yet they were hit in the
[14:41] manner they were on October seventh. So Hammas perceptionally has equalized that capability gap
[14:48] between the two, saying that look, here's a country there is occupied our
[14:50] territory. This is Hammas speaking, not me. Here's a country that occupies
[14:54] my land. Here's a country that has killed my family. Here's a country
[14:58] that has the best military equipment in the world. Here's a country that has
[15:01] the Mozad. Here's a country that's reputated reputed globally for being hyper aware of
[15:09] everything that's happening around it. Here's a country that is, you know,
[15:13] hyper alert and stays awake, does not sleep because it's guarding its borders twenty
[15:18] four hours and nothing can move. Fou the NIEVO and all that stuff.
[15:20] You know, that reputation in visual essay. And yet you saw what happened
[15:24] on October seven by a bunch of guys with kalashnikovs and parag and bloody you
[15:30] know, Toyota trucks. Okay, let's be very frank. They used off
[15:33] the shelf equipment drones with grenades to do what they did. Okay, it
[15:39] was a terror attack, Let's make no mistake. But what happened was a
[15:43] colossal, historic, you know, historically humiliating intelligence failure and in just those
[15:48] few hours. And this is something that an idea of a former idea of
[15:52] chief said to me. He said, is varreable to have to spend the
[15:54] next twenty five years recovering the pieces of its reputation. In many cases,
[15:58] they say that in many cases, Arab states or Israel's enemies would not attack
[16:04] Israel because its reputation was a Deterrentay, nobody want to mess with Nobody's want
[16:10] to mess with israelis Man, Israeli is a dangerous guys. You know,
[16:12] wherever you go in the world is very special forces. Nobody messes with them.
[16:17] So that reputation was a deterrent. Now, if you don't have that
[16:19] reputation, then everybody's going to mess with you, which is why you're seeing
[16:22] the Yemenies and the Syrians and the Jordanians and everyone sort of piling on to
[16:27] Israel at this point of time. So while Israel navigates what that sort of
[16:33] elusive end game is going to be. In Gaza, they've they've been burnt
[16:37] twice becausand nine. They invaded Gaza, didn't know what to do after they
[16:41] invaded it. Twenty fourteen, they invaded Gaza. Ilaka is under us.
[16:45] Now what do we do? You know? Now? What? Okay?
[16:47] Fine, We've brought our tanks and we've invaded everything. We occupied the whole
[16:49] territory. Everything's under control. Now what you know? So that now?
[16:52] What is They still haven't defined what that now? What is is it about
[16:56] killing all of Hammas? Technically impossible because you've got a lot of Hamas leaders
[17:02] sitting abroad in Kata and Turkey and what have you. Is it about not
[17:06] causing you a manitarent crisis that's already happened. You've already got the world being
[17:10] fair blood. So what is that end game? You know, where where
[17:15] do they draw a line and say, Okay, we've achieved what we wanted
[17:18] to do, and now we're going to pull out and go back. Everyone
[17:19] goes back to work. We don't know what that is, but you're going
[17:22] to just pull out, by the way, just like that, because once
[17:25] after you've done what you've done, someone has to come in and you know,
[17:27] kind of do something absolutely. And there's also why they were theory.
[17:30] I don't know if you believe in it, but there's a theory that Hamas
[17:33] was that plan. By the way, post twenty fourteen, Hama Hamas was
[17:37] kind of propped up by Israel through Qatar to keep the PA separate by the
[17:41] position authority separated and like just control Gaza like to you know, day to
[17:45] day some hollow and we'll just keep the border crossings with you. But they
[17:48] were not expecting Amas to do what Amas did. So to answer that question
[17:52] again, I'll quote what an idea of person told me. So, you
[17:55] know, first of all, I'm sure you've said this in your podcast before,
[17:59] but the Hamas is a political party. They like projecting themselves as this
[18:03] movement and revolutionaries, and you'll hear a lot of that stuff when you go
[18:07] down there. But Hamas is the political party. Like like you have the
[18:11] Congress and the BJP distinctent examples Congress and the BJP, you have the Fada
[18:15] and you have the Hamas. There are two rival political parties under the Palestinian
[18:19] umbrella, the Fatha organization which is which is the political party that was founded
[18:25] by Yasara Rafat. They control the West Bank, which is your the areas
[18:30] around Jerusalem which I traveled to as well. Ramala as the capital there.
[18:33] Gaza is completely different. It's controlled completely by Hamas. One of the reasons
[18:38] for what happened in October the seventh, according to senior senior intelligence officials and
[18:44] commanders I spoke to, was Israel doesn't Israel doesn't want the new sense of
[18:48] having to govern Garda. They don't want that. You know. It's like,
[18:53] boss, We've got our stuff to do. We are happy. We're
[18:56] a happy, rich, progressive country with billions of dollars in aid flowing in.
[19:02] We don't want to we don't want the you know, nuisance of having
[19:04] to go and govern these rat holes. Okay, I'm using harsh language,
[19:08] but I'm just trying to reflect the sensibility there. Now. For two reasons,
[19:12] Israel was cool about what's happening in Gaza, even though they consider Hamas
[19:15] to be a terrorist organization according to their intelligence. What was happening in Gaza
[19:22] was you know, now you're hearing a lot of propaganda. Open air prison,
[19:25] world's biggest open air prison. If you actually look at images of Gaza,
[19:27] it looks like any other beat down. It's like a beatown. It's
[19:30] like an Indian beat down. You know, little little gullies, you know,
[19:34] cheek by jowl, slum's, crowded city places, beautiful you know,
[19:41] Marina, the coastal areas where of course all the Hammas people live. Lovely,
[19:45] lovely marine drive and stuff. One of the some of the best beaches
[19:48] in the world apparently are in Gaza. So there was prosperity. There was
[19:51] internet, those there were jobs. When I say prosperity, obviously mean it
[19:56] relatively. Yes, of course, there were lots of schools, quite quite
[20:00] a lot of NGOs operating, the huge amounts of global aid pouring in,
[20:03] so there was there was no there was no you know, there was no
[20:07] destitution and poverty in Gaza in that sense. So Israel, we're saying,
[20:11] so we've incentivized them. You know, peace is an incentive. Profit is
[20:15] an incentive. There are businesses working in Gaza, so you know, nothing
[20:19] brings peace like profit. So you know people are making money. Restaurants are
[20:22] running, schools are running, there are cinemas all that stuff, so you
[20:26] know, there's a there's a sort of equilibrium in Gaza, and therefore Hamas
[20:30] has no incentive to attack. So a you've got peace and prosperity and all
[20:36] that stuff happening in Gaza. Like you said, the border crossings are there,
[20:40] so aid and you know, trade and all that stuff is going on.
[20:42] And secondly, you've got Israeli intelligence and Israel's border sensors and all that
[20:48] tracking it. So in case someone has a bad idea of trying to disturb
[20:52] this equilibrium, well we'll catch them doing it. Both these things didn't happen.
[20:56] The Hamas guys were waring, aiming their entire attack right in front of
[21:02] cameras. But the Israel were asleep because they thought niney why would they Notaza?
[21:08] Everyone is chill, everyone's on the beach, everyone's you know, going
[21:11] for a swim. People from Gaza going abroad for holidays, you know,
[21:17] fishing beach are We have allowed so many lovely things and Gaza. Why will
[21:19] they attack us completely? Uh? You know, not figuring that this goes
[21:26] beyond Gaza. There's the Arab world, there's you know, there are other
[21:29] unsettled issues. The fact that the you know, the alleged occupation of this
[21:33] territory is an is an unresolved issue as far as Hamas is concerned. Why
[21:38] would they just be happy with Gaza in the West Bank? Uh so so
[21:42] yeah, soo those things are going to take for a very very long time
[21:45] to come. The cynic in me believes I don't think it's going to be
[21:48] resolved. It's going to be another cycle of violence. Yeah, and even
[21:52] you know, I agree with you. I don't think it's going to be
[21:52] resolved in my life. Yeah. So, but the current crisis the endgame,
[21:57] like she said, not sure. And in this new version of in
[22:02] our defense, we'll keep cracking it because I think that's going to be one
[22:04] of the hot topics quickly moving a bit north of Israel to Russia Ukraine.
[22:11] Most of our listeners and viewers will think you kah foract. But that the
[22:15] thing is, you know, very weirdly, even though the most the most
[22:18] amount of conversation India was about Israel Lama's war, when it comes to conflicts,
[22:22] the one conflict where we actually have some steak as a country is Russia
[22:26] Ukraine and not ISRAELAMAS. Which is also why by the Government of India has
[22:30] not really bothered much with statements boiler played statements. We are sending it,
[22:34] we are against terrorism. What happened to ISRAELO is bad, but we can
[22:37] fever solutions. Why Russia Ukraine because as of my last research, I think
[22:45] around sixty to seventy percent of our defense imports are Russia dependent. I don't
[22:49] know the current figure because it's a big push by the current government towards making
[22:53] India and also to by the ways relevant and America. But the worry that
[22:57] you know, we discuss this on the previous episode or sorry, previous season
[23:02] as well with Abishi. The big warry is that a lot of our current
[23:04] equipment, spare parts depend on Russia. The MiGs, for example, some
[23:10] of our tanks for example, we've just bought a battery of the I don't
[23:14] know what's it called, the S four hundred, what's it called? The
[23:18] system and systems? Yeah, from Russia, especially after the China stand up,
[23:22] which will come to in a bit. Two quick questions on this part.
[23:26] Your thoughts on one, where is the Russia Ukraine war going? If
[23:30] it's going anywhere, is it just going to be a slog match with them,
[23:32] just like you know, Ukraine taking some diltary, Russia taking some over
[23:36] there and then back and forth. And how big of a wari is it
[23:38] for the establishment? Right? Well, the thing is, it's to answer
[23:41] your first question, it's it seems like a grind right, you know,
[23:45] the the very aggressive you know, missiles flying at each other kind of phase
[23:51] of the war has ended right now. You know, now you're seeing that
[23:53] happen periodically, still happening, but it's happening less frequently. There are still
[23:57] you know, the like you said, being taken on both sides. Uh,
[24:02] huge part of the Eastern flank is completely occupied now by Russia, which
[24:06] claims the Donbas region as Russian territory anyway. So again, this is this
[24:11] is going to stretch out because this is uh and to remind everyone listening that
[24:17] this is this has not for a moment has this been a Russia Ukraine war.
[24:22] This has been a Russia against the NATO and the world. That's what
[24:26] this is. This is this is Russia plus China against literally the rest of
[24:30] the world. Of course, there are important countries like India that have taken
[24:33] an independent view and vindicated for that view as far as Russia is concerned.
[24:38] But this is in effect a kind of a kind of Cold World War,
[24:44] right, That's what That's what, that's what This basically is that there are
[24:45] two countries doing the fighting, but everyone else is in the game as is
[24:49] involved. Now. The reason why there might be some kind of a horizon
[24:55] line as far as Russia Ukraine is concerned is a where's the money? The
[24:59] U has an election coming up and they've just said that they're gonna run out
[25:03] of money for Biden. Biden. Biden is is practically on his knees burying
[25:07] Congress saying please clear this money. Otherwise this this war is going to you
[25:11] know, turn on his head and we can't afford that it's still going to
[25:14] happen on our watch. Uh, the United States has an electric that is
[25:18] already pissed off with Biden for everything that is done. As far as Ukraine
[25:22] is concerned. You've got a Ukraine which is you know, which is conducting
[25:29] special forces strikes, some missile strikes. But what Russia has proved, even
[25:33] though Russia's war didn't go at all the way it wanted to. It wanted
[25:37] to it to be like a lightning quick kind of pincer movement on Ukraine and
[25:41] completely suppress the country and you know, do what it wanted. That didn't
[25:45] happen, obviously because of NATO support. But now with money intended for Ukraine
[25:52] being diverted towards Israel, the resources that that Ukraine needs to extend this.
[25:57] It's winter now, okay, So in win everything comes to a standstill because
[26:00] it's it's health freezes over in Ukraine. It's so cold that you can't think,
[26:06] right, So the war sort of grinds to a halt, thankfully in
[26:08] winter. But as soon as winter breaks, as spring arrives, the fighting
[26:11] will begin again. It'll be the it will be the third year of the
[26:14] fighting right, and and this time it comes at a time when Russia will
[26:19] be aware of Ukraine's weaknesses. They will know that the world's attention is diverted
[26:23] towards Israel and Palestine. They know that NATO will be slightly less capable of
[26:30] providing readily the equipment, missiles, money, whatever it is to Ukraine because
[26:36] of what's happening in Israel h And therefore they'll they'll you know, probably be
[26:41] even more aggressive. So I see, I see a lot of blood next
[26:45] summer in between Ukraine and Russia. But I also on the the the silver
[26:51] lining to that blood is that I believe that with with resources drained from this
[26:56] war, I think both sides will have to also sort of, you know,
[27:00] be forced into some kind of a resolution. You've seen putin very rare.
[27:04] He's gone out of Russia. Remember he didn't even come to India for
[27:07] the G twenty. He didn't come for anything else. He doesn't travel out
[27:11] of Russia since this war began. He's currently sitting in Ua traveling to Saudi
[27:15] Arabia. You know, Opek can all those things he's discussing because he also
[27:18] realizes that Boss I can't sit in I can't sit in Moscow and fight an
[27:22] endless war. I have to interact with the world. I have to be
[27:26] a world leader. Okay. So it's gone beyond putin looking for some kind
[27:33] of a face saving exit from this, because no matter which side you believe,
[27:37] Russia has achieved a great deal in this. They've occupied enormous, enormous
[27:41] square kilometer numbers of territory in the eastern flank of Ukraine. There's fighting still
[27:47] happening in the Crimea Peninsula between Ukraine and Russia as well. So as far
[27:51] as military objectives are concerned, Russia has demonstrated that has an almost infinite appetite
[27:56] for loss, for damage for him human human death toll. It's a monster
[28:03] Russia. It's called a bear for a reason. You can fling like kilograms
[28:08] and kilograms of lead at it and it will just keep coming it. They'll
[28:11] just keep coming at you. Because it's such an enormous country with enormous resources.
[28:17] You know, one of the bloodiest histories from the Russian Revolution onwards.
[28:22] So or whether it comes to the Battle of Stalingrad or the Soviet Germany operations,
[28:26] this is a country that is completely desensitized to human life loss. Okay,
[28:33] millions of people can die, and they're like, let's keep fighting like
[28:37] that. So and I'm simplifying it, I mean, of course, but
[28:41] I don't want to. I don't want to make it sound like Russians don't
[28:44] give a toss about human life. But I'm just saying that this is a
[28:45] country that has an appetite for destruction, and therefore, in many ways,
[28:52] I think I see blood next summer. Yeah, the second part, it's
[28:55] definitely a worry. And I think it's a good question, Dave, because,
[28:57] like you said, a huge out of our equipment is still dependent on
[29:02] Russia. There's been an ongoing effort for the last nearly two decades, as
[29:07] a matter of fact, to try and diversify. Even before Russia, Ukraine,
[29:11] India had already realized. You know, we're not the you know,
[29:15] Chota Muta country we thought we were. We were actually a big, capable
[29:18] country with a massive coastline, and you know, everyone wants us to be
[29:22] this bulwark against China. So we are nobody's uh. We are not a
[29:26] satellite country to anyone. So we need to be able to make our defense
[29:30] needs autonomous. We can't be dependent like you said on spares and things like
[29:36] that. Now, Russia is our strategic partner. Okay, they've been a
[29:40] very reliable strategic partner. But you know, people tend to you know,
[29:44] I think people tend to romanticize international relations a lot, saying at the reliable
[29:48] partner. Hey, and you know when we were in need, they came
[29:52] for us. Boss. When when those needs were provided, we had to
[29:55] pay for those needs. Okay. None of this was free. Okay.
[29:57] So if if Israel missiles for cargill or Russia gave you, you know,
[30:03] guidance kits during some other conflict of Balakot or whatever, we paid a lot
[30:08] of money for it. Okay, it was taxpayer money. Yours in my
[30:11] money was paying for it. There was no It's not like what's sweethearts.
[30:15] They gave us weapons when we needed blood and sweat, went for it.
[30:18] So let's let's put that out of the way for a moment. So anyone
[30:22] who thinks that, yeah, pades such sweet friends, that's rubbish. Okay.
[30:26] Everyone pays for what they get and nobody does anything without a reason for
[30:30] it. Everyone sees benefit. In India, those is a very big thing
[30:34] for countries. Let's let's make that very clear. Russia gains enormously from a
[30:38] country like India backing them in the Russia Ukraine War and having an independent policy
[30:45] as far as that is concerned. But dependence on weapons is a serious issue,
[30:52] and the reason for that is going to be a part three of our
[30:53] discussion day, which is that the world's biggest military confrontation right now involves India
[31:00] in Lada. Yes, so we are not a country which is at peace
[31:03] right now. We are at a country where where the war between the two
[31:07] world's largest armies is. I'm told the closest is sixteen meters away. The
[31:15] closest that Indian and Chinese soldiers stand right now in a place called in a
[31:18] place called Konkala is sixteen meters away. Wow, Okay, so it's it's
[31:23] chill, it's peaceful. They're not going to fight. I don't think they're
[31:26] going to fight. We talk about that in greater detail. But we are
[31:30] a country at wares okay, for all practical purposes, India is a country
[31:33] at war, So we can't. We don't have the elbow room to mess
[31:37] around with our supply chains. You know, tomorrow our fleet goes down or
[31:41] our aircraft needs certain things we need. We can't have a DOOS guaranteee,
[31:48] especially if it's a country like Russia that's bogged down in its own conflict.
[31:51] Ukraine forget about it, and we've got transfer. We've got a lot of
[31:55] Ukrainian equipment in India, whether it is our A and three two aircraft,
[32:00] several different engines for our ships, the gas turbine engines that power our ships.
[32:06] I don't know if our listeners know are made in Ukraine. So we
[32:09] are very dependent on Ukraine. Forget about Russia. So it's difficult. It's
[32:15] I was in Russia in twenty nineteen, very interesting. Okay, this is
[32:19] before the war, right, But Russia and Ukraine we're not talking. They
[32:22] would They don't like each other, right, And I'm done, I'm saying
[32:25] before the war. So we were buying these warships frigates from this place called
[32:30] the Yanta Shipyard, which is in a place called Kaliningrad in western Russia.
[32:35] And it's a Russian built ship with the Ukrainian engine. Right, So the
[32:40] engines can't be transported by Ukraine to Russia. So an Indian team goes contracts
[32:47] the engine takes delivery of the engine from there and then personally takes it to
[32:52] Russia, gives it to the Russians and then they fit it and then we
[32:55] bring the ship back. Amazing. So India is India has a lot of
[33:00] experience in dealing with these really really troublesome parts of the world, okay,
[33:04] and as a result of jugaard and stuff, we make use of it really
[33:07] well. This is a perfect example of this is crazy juguard. But except
[33:12] the thing is, you know, for a country like India, and I
[33:14] keep saying, we shouldn't have to do jugar jugat though in a Soviet era
[33:19] you know, cold war times ata, but now we shouldn't. There has
[33:22] to be absolute certainty because war is a not a joke. It's a serious
[33:27] business. You know. If we need weapons and we need absolute assurance in
[33:31] terms of our military hardware supply chains. It can't be dependent on two countries
[33:36] that are at war. It can't. It simply cannot, which is why,
[33:39] starting twenty years ago, this kind of diversification started. Let's get more
[33:44] French stuff, Let's get the raphale. Forget about the more South thirties,
[33:47] Let's get the raffle because it's France. France will will bleed your dry as
[33:52] far as money is concerned. They will believe to death in terms of money,
[33:55] but they'll deliver the goods. And France is not at at least not
[33:59] at any great conflict right now. They've got internal stuff, but that's not
[34:02] a problem. America is another reliable partner. But there there are complexities in
[34:07] terms of can we use it for this? Can use it? Who can
[34:09] use it against? That's well, do a separate episode on that. But
[34:15] but the diversification of our hardware is absolutely necessary. The recent orders that the
[34:21] Indian Ministry of Defense is cleared for pages fighters and attack helicopters, this goes
[34:25] a very long way in pushing that is a huge criticism. I cover the
[34:30] Ministry of Defense, and I can tell you that in the armed forces they're
[34:34] like an is just a slogan. They can do you guys, even do
[34:38] anything on the ground. But now that's actually because because this government, for
[34:45] all its faults as far as defense is many criticisms, has actually put its
[34:49] money where its mouth is as far as making India's concerned, because they believe
[34:52] that if you don't make hardware in India, you cannot control it. I
[34:57] can buy. I can buy rafiles or Sooth thirties or Mirajus or whatever it
[35:00] is till Kingdom come. But at the end of the day, if I
[35:02] want to change some code in it, I still have to go back to
[35:06] answer exactly if I do it here, if HL builds my fighters, you
[35:09] can get an inforces graduate to come in, do it, jimmy my computer
[35:14] and get it working. So there's there's there's that. So there's a very
[35:16] concerted effort. So it's bad news to answer a question after all this is
[35:21] it's bad news that we are still so dependent on So good point, Dan.
[35:23] You know, I like the point I made about how that we alway've
[35:28] always paid for the equipment that Russia has given as it's not like they can
[35:30] to us for fee, because that's a point also made with Abishek back in
[35:34] season one, that all this aid that you can just getting generations will pay
[35:38] for it. Yeah, when this war no one way stuff right, let's
[35:44] move come back home to the India China conflict. Very interested to talk to
[35:49] you about it, but let's go after a quick break. Eat eggs,
[35:55] no eat fiber, sleep no take short apps. Don't listen to others,
[36:00] no serve others. Do you ever feel like you're drowning in a pool of
[36:06] advice? This is Sonalia Chargi, a health journalist for the last ten years,
[36:12] who is equally fed up of lines like ten ways to stay fit.
[36:16] So join me in the podcast Health Wealth as we learn about health from a
[36:21] completely new perspective where investing in yourself is not a task but simple, satisfying
[36:28] and joyful. Full episodes are available on Apple, Google, Spotify, and
[36:32] the India Today podcast website. Tune in now, Welcome back. This is
[36:44] the first episode of season two of In Our Defense with defense expert and journalist
[36:49] Shivarur. Shive and I have been since This is the first episode of the
[36:52] new season. Shiven I have been discussing the three major raging global conflicts in
[36:55] the world, and we're now going to move back home to the India China,
[37:00] where I think our listeners in US might be surprised. I'm referring to
[37:04] India chen as a raging conflict BECAA. But I'll tell you something. And
[37:09] for someone like me who follows a lot of defense journalists on social media and
[37:15] has had the privilege to talk to a few of them like you included,
[37:17] because I'm also in journalism, there are things that cannot be printed or reported
[37:22] because what's reported is always what is definitive, what is official, what comes
[37:27] from authoritative sources. But defense journalists, because they've been doing this for a
[37:32] wild shift, for example, twenty years, they do get a sense of
[37:36] what's going on. And what I've gotten from every defense journalist, regardless of
[37:40] their personal biases every defense journalist, is that the India China conflict is a
[37:46] massive one. India China almost came to a war after the Kalwan incident,
[37:52] in which twenty soldiers died, including a commanding officer on the Indian side,
[37:59] and I think a similar number of Chinese said China has never obviously come out
[38:02] and given the actual numbers, and it still remains a huge crisis that people
[38:07] are not talking about because I think August or September the twentieth round of Core
[38:15] Commander talks happened, which I honestly, as someone who follows it pointless,
[38:19] it feels like, because I don't even know what they do, I think,
[38:22] just come sign off, Karedia, No we don't agree, but okay,
[38:28] we'll maintain peace, won't shoot bulls each other, won't you know,
[38:30] get into stones and sticks fight, which they have gotten. That's more or
[38:36] less it because the sense that I'm getting is key. This obviously requires a
[38:39] political solution, not a military solution, because and this is a joke that
[38:45] Abishai I used to keep making on season one, that this is an issue
[38:49] on which both sides can't even agree what the issue is because you have a
[38:52] so called LAC but which is not defined China seas and LAC somewhere else in
[38:57] somewhere else, they can't even decide. Kismaki Cooper. So to begin this
[39:02] new season with Tube and this topic, trust me, is going to keep
[39:06] coming up a lot more because Pakistan is done with ceasefire, is going on
[39:09] holding solid China is the new problem for India. The government, the military
[39:15] has obviously realized for the longest time because when I was a child, I
[39:17] remember these headlines of former retired Army, Navy, Air Force chiefs that you
[39:22] know, politicians need to stop talking about Park because that was this was a
[39:27] time when Pakistan bashing was all the all the game, and you know,
[39:30] politicians just stopped start focusing on China. This is what the military veterans back
[39:34] then used to and this is what I read about the newspapers. So obviously
[39:37] military knew this for a while. Now the government increasingly has also realized that
[39:43] this is a big, big issue, your impression of where we are with
[39:46] China and how are we going to get out of this mess if we are
[39:51] at all. Since you started with the twenty rounds of talks that we've had,
[39:54] I'll just tell you a small little story. So whenever these talks happened,
[39:59] right, journalists will basically harang the army spokesperson, not the spokesperson Syrie
[40:04] in ladakh Or or the Northern Command and says, so takeaway k from this
[40:07] round of talks, and you usually get a you know, in a we
[40:13] discussed this, and we exchange notes and and we've agreed to talk again in
[40:16] the future and blah blah blah. But in the I think I think it
[40:21] was the fourteenth or the fifteenth round of talks where I think I got the
[40:23] best answer from uh, you know, a brigadier who was part of the
[40:28] Indian Brigadierho was part of the talks. So he said, yeah, are
[40:30] you journalists keep asking what are the takeaways? He said, the biggest takeaways
[40:35] that we are talking, right, okay? And I and I really thought
[40:39] about that for a bit bit and then I traveled to Ladak and I met
[40:42] him and over a drink we were talking and I said, so, I've
[40:44] been thinking about what you said for a very long time because Dilli may or
[40:47] baratme the senses Na, you're not doing anything. So so he said,
[40:55] exactly, aren't you happy that nothing is happening? Aren't you happy that we
[40:59] are only talking because it's so easy? And I think we live in a
[41:05] world where war is romanticized, and we live in a world where you know,
[41:09] everyone wants like a definitive end to a situation, not knowing that war
[41:15] is for most part, not only an extension of politics, but can also
[41:20] be interminable. We've seen conflicts going on for centuries in certain parts of the
[41:23] world. Not saying that that's going to be the case here. But first
[41:28] of all, India and China are two vastly different countries but also very similar,
[41:32] also very very similar in some fundamental ways. They both share this part
[41:37] of the world. They both are enormously aspirational, they both have you know,
[41:44] global ambitions. Let's not get into comparing the two countries. Let's zoom
[41:49] in now to what's happening on the ground. Sixteen meters is how far the
[41:57] nearest soldiers of India and China are currently. Like you said after the gal
[42:00] Wan War, that the two sides came very close to actual conflict. The
[42:07] it's it's something of a strategic miracle that the Galvan conflict didn't trigger a larger
[42:12] confrontation between the two sides. Uh. And that goes to not only not
[42:17] only yeah, you know, people might emotionally say, you know, maturity,
[42:21] there was maturity on both sides and all that stuff, but it's also
[42:24] both sides knowing that a war between these two sides are going to be mutually
[42:30] destructive, Yes, okay, mutually like totally destructive as anyone. You know.
[42:37] People saying so takeaway kah and talks say, can they imagine what would
[42:40] be happening if India and China were not talking? Someone might argue back there
[42:45] and say that, I mean, yeah, you guys are talking, but
[42:47] the Chinese are kind of bogging you down into talks and busy building all that
[42:52] infrastructure over there. What you don't here is and this is not propaganda this
[42:55] is. These are facts. I've traveled there. I report on what's happening
[42:59] there. Who says India is not building infrastructure. Who says India is not
[43:01] building roads? Who says India is not building permanent structures? Like you said,
[43:07] both sides don't agree. What the issue is. Where the line is,
[43:08] Where your LAC claim line is, our LAC claim line is fine.
[43:13] Let's keep Baratmataki j aside on this discussion and let's just talk about facts on
[43:15] the ground. We say our line is there, they say our line is
[43:20] here. Okay, they say their line is behind us. So we are
[43:22] on their territory, they are on our territory. It's a mess, a
[43:25] mess of lines. You remember during the Ladak coverage. Yes, how many
[43:29] satellite maps have we've seen, how many lines and graphics we've seen. It's
[43:31] become a mess in people's minds. Okay, So put all that aside.
[43:35] The fact is that China only speaks in one particular kind of voice. They
[43:40] only speak through muscular power, and they only respect muscular power for the first
[43:45] time, for the first time. And I'm not saying this because I'm India.
[43:49] I'm saying this as a student of military history. I can say this
[43:51] is the first time that China has kind of run into a wall. Okay,
[43:57] And I'm not saying this in a I'm not saying this in a sentimental
[43:59] way. I'm not saying that, man, India is awesome, look they've
[44:00] hit or I'm not saying that. I'm just saying, think about it.
[44:04] Why would China deploy in such huge numbers a couple of divisions strong last checked
[44:13] in an area where they don't want to achieve anything else? What territory,
[44:15] what more territorial ambitions could they possibly have? Which they do? They do
[44:20] have it. But India is not just any other country, right, India's
[44:22] a country with India's a nuclear country like China. India has a highly professional
[44:28] landforce like China, much more experienced in high altitude waters. You will hear,
[44:34] you know, since since In Our Defense is a podcast where we would
[44:37] like to talk about things that are not maybe spoken about elsewhere is you will
[44:43] constantly hear about Ara. Why did India let go of the Keila Strange?
[44:46] Why did India get down from blacktop and helmet top near the Spangor Gap south
[44:52] of the Pegong Lake. To go into specifics, how do people know that
[44:55] we've a vacated all those heights? A. But China is operating and it
[45:01] has occupied certain advantageous positions or north of the Pangang Lake, how do you
[45:06] know India doesn't have similar positions? Maybe India is a kind of country that
[45:08] doesn't talk about them because they want deniability. You know, if you want
[45:13] to prove it, you have to go there and see And if you go
[45:15] there and see it, by then the situation is already botha. So there
[45:20] are there are those who feel that India is playing this from a position of
[45:24] weakness, is not is not flexing its muscle because it doesn't really have anything
[45:30] to show China in this case. And that's bs that's nothing could be further
[45:35] from the truth. India is in as many positions of advantage with China as
[45:40] China is with India. I'm not saying that China doesn't occupy certain places which
[45:45] are of an advantage which gives them direct strike range for Indian strategic acids.
[45:51] But we've got the same, We've got the same as them, And that's
[45:54] one of the that's actually worth keeping the peace. The fact that they are
[45:59] locked in a kind of cold embrace in Ladakh right now where Oh damn,
[46:05] I you know, nobody has neither side has the flexibility to move there.
[46:08] If I move, then he also moved. Yeah. So it's like that,
[46:12] which which brings which brings it back to the original point that you made,
[46:15] which is that both militaries are are chilling out over there. And I
[46:22] mean this respectfully. They're not chilling out, of course they're on duty,
[46:23] but they're chilling out in the in the confidence that nothing can escalate here on
[46:30] unless something drastic happens, because now the military's work is over. Yes,
[46:34] the military's work is over. Joe Jonatha military neckar there. The military is
[46:38] there in huge numbers on both sides, with invisible distance of each other.
[46:43] Soldiers can see each other by now they must be friends. Also always happens,
[46:45] to believe me, another thing that people don't know on borders l A
[46:49] l O C l A C. When soldiers are deployed for a long time,
[46:52] they become friends, which is why China changed the unit that wasn't correct,
[46:57] so they and then they got those guys correct. So so I'm saying,
[47:01] I'm just saying that now the there is a there is a belief on
[47:06] the ground that look, we've held territory, we've held them off. They're
[47:08] also saying the same thing on their side, their guys are dying in large
[47:13] numbers because of high altitude sickness. Chinese soldiers are not used to high attitude
[47:16] operations, so even three years into this conflict, they've not been able to
[47:21] aclimatize, probably, which is why. And the thing is, when I
[47:25] speak to Indian army forces on the ground, I see I sense a changed
[47:30] tone. Also there's that little that that bit of anger and aggression that was
[47:32] there in the first two years that has kind of evaporated because now nothing has
[47:36] happened. Now is like, which are dying so much in such large numbers
[47:39] because of high altitude sickness. This thing should end soon, so you know,
[47:43] people can go back. Those who talk to each other like, yeah,
[47:45] I'm and I'm the only son of my parents, and you know I've
[47:49] been brought to you have been here for eight months. I want to go
[47:51] back. Also, many of them are, you know, because of the
[47:52] single kid policy in China, because the population thing, many of those in
[47:57] Chinese soldiers there are the only children of their families, So there are all
[48:01] these you know, beautiful, sad, tragic human threads in this story.
[48:07] So you know, war is not just about tanks rolling and you know fire
[48:10] and death and destructions also what people just yearning to get the hell out of
[48:15] there. But just to close that point, the thing is, India is
[48:21] in a far better position because it has had years and years of experience in
[48:25] Sia, Chidren and Ladak and stuff, so they know what high aulitated operations
[48:29] are. But the ideal situation is not for India to have a militarized Ladak
[48:32] at all. The reality might be different. It does not suit anyone's purpose
[48:37] to have you know, one hundred thousand troops in just eastern Ladak. That's
[48:40] what nobody wants. That it's expensive, it's unideal because because it takes a
[48:46] toll on your soldier's health. But India has demonstrated that three years into this
[48:51] conflict it will do what it needs to do. Yeah, that's it,
[48:53] right to close this topic because so what you said is completely bang on.
[48:58] I mean, military has done its work. The only thing left for them
[49:00] to do is actually fight over so and if it comes to that, they'll
[49:04] do that. Obviously that's their job. At the end of the day.
[49:07] So the only people who can resolve this are the politicians in Delhi and Beijing
[49:10] and the diplomats in the respective embassis very very well and knowing how diplomacy works,
[49:19] I'm pretty sure there is something going on that we are not aware of
[49:22] that we will sometime whenever it succeeds, if it does, will be made
[49:25] aware of. But I want to ask you because I've been asking this question
[49:30] to every person I meet when it comes to defense or strategic affairs, and
[49:37] I'm pretty sure Anna, our producer who also hosts her own podcast Etha's World
[49:40] with one of Mohan on strategic affairs, has been the same question. And
[49:46] I'm not going to answer why did China do this in the first place,
[49:50] because you have to remember that Galwan value was not the trigger the current conflict.
[49:53] The conflict began a few months before that because the first core commander level
[49:58] media had happened much before the Kalman Pallet clash. It began because China started
[50:02] building up troops along its border, sorry along the Lac India saw that responded
[50:07] with equal number of troops, and that's how the stand up began. We've
[50:12] had also a fight in lad Dark a couple of years ago, the viral
[50:16] video of stone pelting that was happening, and then you had obviously had Kalvan.
[50:22] But why this is a question that I've just because that's how we sizing
[50:27] thing is facing some internal problems. So just like it kind of showed up
[50:30] domestics support, he's done this because you know, and this is something I've
[50:35] said this on the show previously. If you look at China's map, almost
[50:38] ninety percent of the population is in the eastern coast. There's a huge sort
[50:43] of you know, wasteland in between, and then you have the India border.
[50:46] So for China this border should not really matter much, but even then
[50:51] they thought to go ahead and do this build up seek Why I'll answer that
[50:54] question in two ways, to give you a very straight answer right off the
[50:59] bat and not dance around it, is that most people are still asked answering
[51:01] that question, including military planners. Okay, by answer to that question would
[51:07] be that there is a certain element of all of the things you've just mentioned
[51:10] internal politics as far as Regenting is concerned, his own need to flex muscle
[51:16] within the Communist Party. But I think, and this is my reading of
[51:22] the situation, which is that two things. A. China is a country
[51:25] that is opportunistic. It's it's it's the world's greatest opportunist. Okay, whether
[51:31] it is whether it is in terms of manufacturing, how it grabbed the manufacturing
[51:37] opportunity in the sixties and seventies and made itself a great economic superpower, or
[51:43] whether it is its territorial ambitions. Now, territory in the in the India's
[51:49] northern areas has always been an issue as far as China is concerned. Now,
[51:52] China had deployed a large contingent of forces in the on the tip Platau
[52:00] Tibetan region as part of a large training exercise. This was happening in late
[52:07] twenty nineteen, pre pre COVID. The Galvan clash happened in June twenty twenty,
[52:14] a few months into the COVID outbreak, and a global lockdown that happened
[52:20] amidst a lockdown, if you remember. Now, My understanding is China believes
[52:25] that the kind of global diversion provided by the COVID pandemic, which of course
[52:32] was their baby, coupled with the China's own strategic reading that this is the
[52:39] time when the world's attention, India's attention, and there is only one layer
[52:46] of what I'm trying to explain, you know, is diverted towards this enormous
[52:52] global crisis that's looming. And remember at that time, people didn't even know
[52:55] how big COVID was going to get it, but maybe China knew about it.
[52:59] Okay, let's try and do some of the things we can't otherwise.
[53:05] Interesting. Okay, let's move in and create some facts on the ground.
[53:08] And if there's one thing that China knows how to do well, it is
[53:12] to move really fast in large numbers. It's like a lot of the rings
[53:15] kind of country. It's like spectacle. Just we've got all these people on
[53:20] training right now in southern Tibet and Shinjang and wherever. Let's just push them
[53:23] closer to the lac now, okay, let's just push them closer and see
[53:28] how far they can go. We just keep saying, training, training,
[53:30] training, training, see how far it can go until we are stopped.
[53:36] And then now the numbers that they pushed were so large that India, India
[53:42] was like, hello, what's going on man? Okay? Because India also
[53:45] thought that. You know, we've got an equilibrium where both nuclear countries are
[53:47] both strong. We've got enough forces to fight each other to death, So
[53:51] why will you do such a thing. But this was in my reading triggered
[53:55] by internal political compulsions for Shijinping, but also a vision seeing that, okay,
[54:00] diversion, this is what we've always wanted. Oxide Chin is ours,
[54:06] northern Ladakarakorum, all these places are ours. Now is the time to do
[54:09] it. Now is the time to do it because right now India's resources,
[54:14] attention, you know, strategic mindset, everything will be split. You know,
[54:19] how do you save one point two billion people from getting COVID or saving
[54:22] a few square kilometers of territory in the northern hellscape of Ladakh. That was
[54:27] a miscalculation by them. That a major miscalculation, because India is India is
[54:31] not Mongolia or whatever else. Right, it's a It's a country that has
[54:36] a huge armed force, it's nuclear armed, and that's where things are right.
[54:39] So I think it's stemmed from internal compulsions but also opportunism. It's like
[54:45] let's move in there, will talk now, and that they've achieved. See,
[54:50] China may have hit a wall, but they've achieved that objective, which
[54:52] is not that they're there. They've built all those helipads and airports in those
[54:55] areas, hotel and in all those places. Because now they've created those on
[55:00] the ground, they're like, we're here now, now we're not going to
[55:01] move, which is why you see permanent accommodations for soldiers coming up near Pangong
[55:07] and stuff. So now they're like, Okay, we're here, and as
[55:10] it's like a it's like a tenant, like we're here now, we're not
[55:13] going to move out of this place. Bossy. You go to court if
[55:15] you want to, but we're not moving out. It's like that. So
[55:17] now once you're here, you know, it's like it's like occupation is nine
[55:22] tenths of the law. Now we're here, Getting us out is going to
[55:24] be difficult. Of course, deal with us that this is the new reality.
[55:28] Get used to. That's that's what it is, which is why,
[55:30] which is why, like you said, and I completely agree with you that
[55:34] on both sides, the military's work is done. There's nothing more to do.
[55:37] Patrolling children. They bump into each other here and there. All that
[55:42] is happening. And one thing I would tell our listeners is take most reports
[55:47] with the pinch of salt as far as oh they've achieved this, Oh they're
[55:51] denying our patrolling. This. You'll always hear this one thing about how in
[55:54] the in the in the planes in the north, the large planes in the
[56:00] north, you know, dollars, big Oldie and that particular area. Oh,
[56:05] India is completely denied territory there, and we can't we can't do our
[56:08] patrolling there literally four kilometers south of there, literally four kilometers south of there.
[56:15] There's an Indian unit sitting on their side, denying them the same kind
[56:17] of patrolling that will never be reported. Okay, So it's it's this is
[56:23] going to be a continuing thing until there is a political solution to it.
[56:28] Now what is going to be the trigger for that political solution, I don't
[56:31] know, because because this is China, I mean, let's make no mistake,
[56:36] this is an inscrutable country, ruthless in many ways, only understand strength
[56:40] is a bully. All these things are true as far as China's concerned,
[56:44] India, China is not saddled by the baggage that India has a democracy.
[56:50] Hair, parliament, Hair. We have to convince our people before we try
[56:52] and achieve something or they don't have that baggage. It's one guy calling the
[56:57] shots over there, so it's not and even war. But even with those
[57:02] discrepancies, India has taught China a very bitter lesson as far as look,
[57:07] you can come till here now, let the politicians stop, but we can
[57:12] hurt you. Yeah, that's what it is. I think that's a good
[57:14] point to end this episode. And I have a feeling that China will come
[57:19] up a lot more on this season and you know, interesting information for you
[57:23] or in season one, this is something I'm wishing. I has to always
[57:25] joke about. Pakistan rarely came up, and that just tells you how things
[57:30] have changed as far as India's national defense is concerned and its priorities are concerned.
[57:36] They've managed to have this reiteration of the ceasefire agreement and since then the
[57:40] LO see the line of control along with Pakistan. As morel has been Miss
[57:45] Mintanda. Nothing much is happening apart from like one of insince here and there.
[57:49] The focus of the establishment, whether it's the military or the political arm
[57:52] is China, and I'm pretty sure it'll come up even more in our discussions
[57:58] as we begin the season two. Thanks Shift, I hope you had a
[58:01] good first episode. You enjoyed it. I'm not sure if this is the
[58:06] first time you doing a podcast right. Definitely the first time, and it's
[58:08] much more fun than I thought. I thought of things to say, but
[58:12] oh no, no, no, no no, trust me, this is
[58:14] a podcast can just sometimes stretch on and one you only even realize, like
[58:16] after this, after we end this episode, this this episode, and you
[58:20] ask the producer how long it is, you will be a bit surprised.
[58:22] Frost. Okay, so hope I listen to the viewers had fun as always.
[58:27] You can, you know, leave us your comments in the YouTube comments
[58:30] section below, or if you want to drop a message, you can whatschapp
[58:32] us at eight five double eight nine, double six, double nine six.
[58:36] That's it for this week's defense. Does for more tune in next week.
[58:37] Will then, stay safe and do not cross any boundaries to the passport.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
