# Iconic Sea Harrier to upcoming Rafale: Deep dive into Indian Navy's fighter jets | In Our Defence, S02, Ep 39

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 12 Sep 2024, 1 h 03 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/61388253/12_sep_24_iod_12_sept_128.mp3

The Indian Navy is set to finalise the procurement of 26 Rafale-Marine fighter jets by the end of this financial year. Indian Navy plans to equip the indigenous aircraft carrier INS Vikrant with these planes and develop a vital capability for the force on the maritime front. Host Dev Goswami and defence expert Shiv Aroor explore the evolution of naval fighter jets in the Indian Navy—a subject that might seem niche but is crucial to India’s defence. The hosts walk through the history of India's naval aviation, starting with the acquisition of the British aircraft carrier HMS Hercules, later INS Vikrant, and the arrival of Seahawk fighter jets in 1960. Why did India switch from British to Russian aircraft, with the MiG-29K replacing the Harriers? As they discuss India’s push for self-reliance, they explore the challenges of transitioning the Light Combat Aircraft to a naval variant and why the Navy prefers twin-engine fighters. They highlight future projects like the Twin Engine Deck-Based Fighter, noting its promise and challenges. How will India balance its ambitions for indigenous fighters with its current defence needs? The episode also touches on the increasing role of drones in naval operations, hinting at a future where combat drones could fly from aircraft carriers. What does the future hold for India's naval aviation? Listen in! Produced by Anna Priydarshini Sound mix by Sachin Dwivedi

## Transcript

[0:00] Speaker 1: This is India Today podcasts.
[0:03] Speaker 2: In nineteen sixty, India was thirteen years old, a teenager
[0:07] Speaker 2: of an independent country had its first aircraft carrier with
[0:11] Speaker 2: onboard fighters.
[0:12] Speaker 1: An amazing thing.
[0:14] Speaker 2: The sea harrier is in many ways similar to any
[0:16] Speaker 2: other fighter aircraft, except that, unlike normal fighters, which basically
[0:20] Speaker 2: have a nozzle at the back end which is blowing
[0:23] Speaker 2: out all that jet exhaust and propelling the fighter forward,
[0:26] Speaker 2: the engine in a sea harrier has a module strapped
[0:29] Speaker 2: onto it with nozzles that can turn either backward or downwards.
[0:34] Speaker 2: So they are basically able to vector the jet exhaust
[0:38] Speaker 2: and thrust either backwards for forward movement, or they can
[0:41] Speaker 2: swivel downwards for your up down helicopter like movement. It's
[0:45] Speaker 2: a technology called direct lift. After the harrier, the British
[0:49] Speaker 2: haven't developed a naval aircraft. They haven't developed an aircraft
[0:53] Speaker 2: specifically purpose built for naval operations.
[0:55] Speaker 1: After the sea harrier.
[0:56] Speaker 3: Did no one in the system at any point think that,
[0:59] Speaker 3: you know, hey, a kelsea program beach old rahamaak, why
[1:03] Speaker 3: not also start let's see if we can get somewhere
[1:05] Speaker 3: with it.
[1:06] Speaker 2: In our defense podcast, you've developed this habit of putting
[1:09] Speaker 2: your finger once again straight in the pain point. So
[1:13] Speaker 2: a naval fighter is not going to be purchased in
[1:15] Speaker 2: as many numbers as an air force fighter. An air
[1:18] Speaker 2: force fighter, like the Theages, you're going to buy two
[1:20] Speaker 2: hundred and twenty three hundred four undreed, the Amka you're
[1:22] Speaker 2: gonna buy like three hundred four wanted aircraft. A naval
[1:25] Speaker 2: fighter you require thirty to forty. The Raphael deal that
[1:28] Speaker 2: is going to be signed this financially as twenty seven aircraft.
[1:33] Speaker 3: Hello and welcome to Another Defense, a weekly podcast on
[1:36] Speaker 3: all things well defense, where I They've go Swami, your host,
[1:41] Speaker 3: along with senior journalist Svarur, break down the world of
[1:44] Speaker 3: conflicts that range from the subtle to the brutal. We
[1:47] Speaker 3: bring you nuances and perspectives that will inform and at
[1:50] Speaker 3: times provoke.
[1:54] Speaker 4: This is in Our Defense.
[1:57] Speaker 1: Hello and welcome.
[1:58] Speaker 3: This is a thirty nine episode for Our Defense, and
[2:01] Speaker 3: it's a very warm welcome to all our listeners and yours. Hello, Shift, Hi,
[2:04] Speaker 3: how are you and good?
[2:05] Speaker 4: How are you all? Well?
[2:07] Speaker 3: All well, I'm actually very excited about the topic of
[2:10] Speaker 3: our day. I mean, for some it might be a bit,
[2:13] Speaker 3: you know, sort of academic boring, but I'm excited because
[2:17] Speaker 3: we go back to a topic which I think was
[2:20] Speaker 3: has been so far when it comes to viral moments
[2:23] Speaker 3: of a defense season.
[2:24] Speaker 4: To the star of this of.
[2:25] Speaker 3: This podcast, your take on which who among the who
[2:31] Speaker 3: among the two sets of fighter jet pilots that most
[2:33] Speaker 3: militaries have, naval fighter pilots and FOS fighter pilots is
[2:36] Speaker 3: cooler and better? If you remember that clip?
[2:39] Speaker 4: Ship, do you?
[2:40] Speaker 3: Or do you hate me for keep bringing from bringing
[2:42] Speaker 3: it up again again once episode?
[2:44] Speaker 2: No, because nobody ever reminds me about that clip on
[2:47] Speaker 2: all my social media, So hopefully on this episode we'll
[2:51] Speaker 2: get a chance to redeem ourselves.
[2:53] Speaker 1: Yes, and I will explain that a little better.
[2:55] Speaker 4: Also.
[2:55] Speaker 3: Yes, yes, actually yes, that's exactly why I'm happy with
[2:58] Speaker 3: discussing this because that will kind of actually apart from
[3:01] Speaker 3: the fun aspect of that vital clip where you know,
[3:04] Speaker 3: for our listeners and youwers who haven't chanced upon that clip,
[3:06] Speaker 3: it's basically where I asked Shift if compared comparing between
[3:09] Speaker 3: Air Force fighter jet fighter pilots and naval fighter pilots,
[3:13] Speaker 3: our naval fighter pilots cooler and better?
[3:15] Speaker 4: And she had said yes.
[3:16] Speaker 3: They are, which got quite the reaction from within the community.
[3:21] Speaker 5: Especially they haven't forgiven me yes, but this this this
[3:24] Speaker 5: episode will actually let us give us that give us
[3:28] Speaker 5: that space to kind of get in the serious business
[3:30] Speaker 5: of fighter jets or naval fighter jets especially and talk
[3:33] Speaker 5: about exactly why you said what you said, what we're
[3:36] Speaker 5: going to do.
[3:36] Speaker 3: Are we going to talk about the evolution, the history
[3:39] Speaker 3: and the status of India's naval fighter jet. I wouldn't
[3:43] Speaker 3: say program as starts, because we've never really had a
[3:45] Speaker 3: program for naval fighter jets. Why we didn't is actually
[3:49] Speaker 3: a question that I'm going to bring up on this episode.
[3:53] Speaker 3: But before we do that, let's briefly, maybe for the
[3:56] Speaker 3: first half of the first quarter of this episode, talk
[3:58] Speaker 3: about the history of naval fight naval aviation in India,
[4:01] Speaker 3: because that's sort something we really talk much about, especially
[4:05] Speaker 3: when it comes to the planes on the decks of
[4:06] Speaker 3: those fighter carriage that we have. Everyone knows the old
[4:10] Speaker 3: Iron squick Ruant. Everyone knows the Iron swareat which sadly
[4:13] Speaker 3: was you know, broken up and staf you know, being
[4:15] Speaker 3: converted into our museum ship. But that's a pre controversy.
[4:18] Speaker 3: Everyone knows about the iron which we have in service.
[4:21] Speaker 3: And everyone knows about the new Irons Pick Granth on
[4:23] Speaker 3: which we had a full episode a few months ago
[4:26] Speaker 3: when it was commissioned into the Indian Navy. But we're
[4:28] Speaker 3: want to talk about the jets on these fighter fighter carriers,
[4:32] Speaker 3: and we'll start with the first one ever, the Irons
[4:34] Speaker 3: Pick Rand, which was the HMS Hercules.
[4:37] Speaker 2: Uh.
[4:38] Speaker 3: If I'm not wrong, this ship was being built in
[4:41] Speaker 3: the UK during World War Two.
[4:43] Speaker 4: It didn't reach.
[4:45] Speaker 3: Completion and then the World War ended and I think
[4:47] Speaker 3: the UK navies didn't really see much point in completing
[4:50] Speaker 3: the project, and then India kind of bought it and
[4:53] Speaker 3: made Irons pack Grant. Then along with Irons Pack ranth
[4:55] Speaker 3: came the Seahawks which flew on on the ship. So
[4:59] Speaker 3: as start tell me about the that that time, because
[5:02] Speaker 3: you know, on this episode we talk about how procurements work,
[5:06] Speaker 3: how there's a need, there are negotiations, there's a there's
[5:09] Speaker 3: a there's some sort of you know document that's floated
[5:11] Speaker 3: out their competitions, et et cetera. But this is back
[5:14] Speaker 3: in the sixties. India had freshly become independent. You had
[5:16] Speaker 3: you know, young leaders within the military kind of you know,
[5:19] Speaker 3: going up the ranks, replacing the British officers. When was
[5:24] Speaker 3: a need for a fighter carrier and fighter naval fighter
[5:27] Speaker 3: jets felt in India back then? And how how much
[5:31] Speaker 3: do you can you tell us about what happened for
[5:33] Speaker 3: us to get the innsback Grant and the Seahawks.
[5:36] Speaker 2: So the it's a very interesting tale because you know,
[5:40] Speaker 2: the nineteen fifties, young, newly independent India, you know, shortly
[5:45] Speaker 2: after the World Wars, you know, was sort of finding
[5:48] Speaker 2: its feet as it were, as a as a as
[5:51] Speaker 2: a new country and all the all the different challenges
[5:54] Speaker 2: that came after partition with you know, new neighbors and
[5:57] Speaker 2: the rest of it. This is nineteen seventy one, so
[6:01] Speaker 2: there was a completely separate dynamic. This was also pre
[6:04] Speaker 2: nineteen sixty two, which brought its own, you know, dynamics
[6:08] Speaker 2: as far as the war which China was concerned. The
[6:10] Speaker 2: nineteen fifties for India was an interesting time because this
[6:15] Speaker 2: was in many ways sort of the peak or the
[6:19] Speaker 2: sort of the genesis of India's quote unquote non aligned movement.
[6:25] Speaker 2: There were many pulls and pressures with the Cold War
[6:28] Speaker 2: sort of eating up over which side a country the
[6:30] Speaker 2: size of India would actually turn to and it was
[6:36] Speaker 2: no surprise whatsoever. And the India Russia relationship militarily speaking
[6:41] Speaker 2: was still too you know fully mature into the kind
[6:45] Speaker 2: of amazing relationship it would later become.
[6:48] Speaker 1: So in the.
[6:48] Speaker 2: Fifties, the only real, or really the closest relationship that
[6:56] Speaker 2: India had internationally speaking, was with its you know, it's
[7:00] Speaker 2: its colonial ruler until a few years before that, which
[7:04] Speaker 2: was Britain, and.
[7:06] Speaker 1: Post post independence, the.
[7:09] Speaker 2: United Kingdom, Great Britain did you know, did create a
[7:14] Speaker 2: platform for military support to India in terms of trade,
[7:17] Speaker 2: in terms of you know, various things, which is why
[7:22] Speaker 2: practically all of Indian aircraft in the military off that
[7:27] Speaker 2: time basically of British origin. Some are Anglo French, but
[7:31] Speaker 2: largely of British origin. In the fifties, with India realizing
[7:37] Speaker 2: that such a large country needing to have, you know,
[7:41] Speaker 2: a credible military presence, not just on land, you know,
[7:46] Speaker 2: owing to and remember this was before the nineteen sixty
[7:49] Speaker 2: five war. So even though the nineteen forty seven post
[7:52] Speaker 2: partition operations had taken place and we had fought a
[7:56] Speaker 2: military operation against Pakistan, a full scale war had not
[7:59] Speaker 2: yet happen. That would happen only in nineteen sixty five,
[8:03] Speaker 2: So this was a time of relative peace. It was
[8:05] Speaker 2: a time of relative uncertainty. I sometimes think about that time.
[8:08] Speaker 2: What must it have been like before the you know,
[8:12] Speaker 2: the era of war for India actually began with the
[8:16] Speaker 2: nineteen sixty two, sixty five and seventy one Wars. It
[8:19] Speaker 2: was an interesting time because India was not only establishing
[8:23] Speaker 2: its identity but also crafting its military might, and all
[8:28] Speaker 2: the moves that it made at this time were very,
[8:30] Speaker 2: very important. And I think the fact that India at
[8:34] Speaker 2: that time felt the need for an aircraft carrier is amazing.
[8:39] Speaker 2: You're talking about the Narrow era, right and the HMS Hercules,
[8:45] Speaker 2: which would later become the ions Wikrant, like you rightly
[8:48] Speaker 2: pointed out, was an aircraft carrier that had been built
[8:53] Speaker 2: during the war. It had been used by the Royal Navy,
[8:57] Speaker 2: and discussions took place between India and and the United
[9:01] Speaker 2: Kingdom and it was decided that this ship would be
[9:04] Speaker 2: transferred to India with a complement of fighters on its deck.
[9:08] Speaker 2: Like you said, the Hawker Seahawks. So nineteen sixty, if
[9:13] Speaker 2: I'm not mistaken, is the year in which the Hawker
[9:16] Speaker 2: Seahawk officially became India's first ever deck based fighter. Amazingly
[9:22] Speaker 2: landmark occasion because so in nineteen sixty India was thirteen
[9:28] Speaker 2: years old. Thirteen years old, a teenager of an independent
[9:32] Speaker 2: country had its first aircraft carrier with onboard fighters.
[9:37] Speaker 1: An amazing thing.
[9:37] Speaker 2: I mean, there's yes, of course, you know it was
[9:40] Speaker 2: our military was under the British for the longest time,
[9:42] Speaker 2: so it's not like, you know, India was spring chickens.
[9:45] Speaker 1: I'm not saying that. But for an independent country to have.
[9:49] Speaker 2: The maturity and the wherewithal to be able to absorb
[9:53] Speaker 2: something as complicated as a carrier in the fifties and sixties,
[9:58] Speaker 2: hats off to the powers that base. So the Indian
[10:01] Speaker 2: Navy got its first taste of of deck based naval
[10:04] Speaker 2: aviation through the Hawker Hunter, which which served for a
[10:09] Speaker 2: for a couple of decades at least, if I'm not mistaken,
[10:13] Speaker 2: shortly thereafter, I think, I think it was in the
[10:15] Speaker 2: seventies when when the when a French aircraft called the
[10:19] Speaker 2: Alise came into service, now the Hawker, the Seahawk that
[10:24] Speaker 2: that came into service with the with the Indian Navy
[10:28] Speaker 2: was a version of a very successful air force fighter
[10:31] Speaker 2: that the British had had already built. It was in
[10:35] Speaker 2: service with many miilitaries around the world with the Alise
[10:39] Speaker 2: that came a few years later, also based on the Vicgrant. Remember,
[10:42] Speaker 2: by this time the Vikrant had also been joined by
[10:44] Speaker 2: the by the Virat. Virat had come in, you know,
[10:48] Speaker 2: a couple of decades later. But at a time when
[10:51] Speaker 2: India had basically two aircraft carriers, an aircraft called the
[10:55] Speaker 2: Alise arrived on the scene. The Alise was a French
[10:59] Speaker 2: It was a French aircraft. It was a deck based fighter,
[11:04] Speaker 2: very very iconic in naval lore because it was that
[11:06] Speaker 2: first aircraft in Indian service which had those beautiful folded wings,
[11:11] Speaker 2: wings that could fold on the deck to you know,
[11:13] Speaker 2: to give to give aviators more space on the carrier deck.
[11:17] Speaker 1: Uh and uh.
[11:18] Speaker 2: So this was this was the These two aircraft, the
[11:22] Speaker 2: Seahawk and the Alise, comprised the first to the kind
[11:26] Speaker 2: of vintage phase of the Indian.
[11:29] Speaker 1: Navy's twist with deck based aviation.
[11:31] Speaker 2: And now, obviously viewer listeners and viewers of in our
[11:35] Speaker 2: defense know that naval aircraft are of many different kinds.
[11:39] Speaker 4: Uh.
[11:40] Speaker 2: Not all aircraft are operated from an aircraft carrier deck
[11:43] Speaker 2: navies operate carriers aircraft from shore as well, but this
[11:47] Speaker 2: episode we're talking only about deck based fighter aircraft. Therefore,
[11:51] Speaker 2: I'm not mentioning many of the other aircraft that the
[11:53] Speaker 2: Indian Navy also operated at this time. So the so
[11:56] Speaker 2: the the Seahawk was the first. Then came the Alise,
[12:00] Speaker 2: and then came one of my favorite aircraft and most
[12:02] Speaker 2: people's favorite aircraft of all time, which was the which
[12:05] Speaker 2: was the Harrier. The Sea Harrier, which is a variant
[12:08] Speaker 2: of the Harrier. Again, British came into service at that time,
[12:13] Speaker 2: which which was a which was a it's difficult to
[12:17] Speaker 2: put into words what a legacy leap that was because
[12:19] Speaker 2: the because the Sea the Sea Harriers had basically proven
[12:24] Speaker 2: during the early eighties during the Falklands War. Ye that
[12:27] Speaker 2: the that the British had the capacity to execute a
[12:32] Speaker 2: military operation all the way across the Atlantic, you know
[12:37] Speaker 2: down in in in South America, UH in Argent you
[12:41] Speaker 2: know against Argent, against the Argentinian military uh.
[12:45] Speaker 1: And the Sea Harrier this this this sort of.
[12:48] Speaker 2: Very compact little fighter that could do UH, that could
[12:52] Speaker 2: do a trick that no other aircraft could, which was
[12:55] Speaker 2: a vertical takeoff and landing. Uh meant that the the
[13:00] Speaker 2: that the Royal military was able to actually send a
[13:05] Speaker 2: kind of very compact carrier force to a great distance
[13:10] Speaker 2: and be able to you know, get Argentina to bend.
[13:15] Speaker 2: So the Sea Harrier, for all its diminutive size, etc.
[13:18] Speaker 2: It was an amazing machine. And it came into service
[13:21] Speaker 2: with the Indian Navy. So the Sea Harrier sort of
[13:24] Speaker 2: started the modern era. I would say the vintage was gone.
[13:29] Speaker 2: Then the modern era of Indian naval aviation actually started
[13:34] Speaker 2: and it's we're still in that era because the Sea
[13:37] Speaker 2: Harriers would retire only a few years ago. They were upgraded,
[13:40] Speaker 2: many nice things were done to them. They were given
[13:42] Speaker 2: Israeli weapons. But every machine has its life and unfortunately
[13:49] Speaker 2: they had to be bid farewell. And the aircraft that
[13:52] Speaker 2: replaced the Sea Harriers are the aircraft that we currently
[13:55] Speaker 2: have in service right now, which other Russian make twenty nineties.
[13:59] Speaker 3: Yeah, and before we get to them, I just wanted
[14:01] Speaker 3: to go on a a tangent when it came to
[14:03] Speaker 3: see harriers, because then you'd bring this up, and I
[14:06] Speaker 3: have a feeling even you know, I'd bring this up.
[14:08] Speaker 3: Their ability to take off vertically and land vertically now
[14:12] Speaker 3: like a dumb moment for me, that seems the most
[14:14] Speaker 3: obvious kind of technology to have for every single naval
[14:18] Speaker 3: fighter jet across the world.
[14:19] Speaker 4: Right, that's like, you know, you.
[14:21] Speaker 3: Don't need then a longest run where you don't need
[14:23] Speaker 3: to worry about size and stuff like that, not don't
[14:25] Speaker 3: need to worry about you know, the plane not hitting
[14:27] Speaker 3: the hitting the deck on landing or feeling to you know,
[14:30] Speaker 3: have sufficient movest while taking off, great for safety as well.
[14:34] Speaker 3: So then why is it that this technology has not evolved,
[14:38] Speaker 3: you know, to a stage that you have every single
[14:41] Speaker 3: naval fighter jet in the world using this technology.
[14:44] Speaker 1: Because it's so terribly complicated. That's the simple answer.
[14:47] Speaker 2: And I'll tell you I'm glad you asked this question
[14:49] Speaker 2: because and I'm telling you that Harryer pilots love being
[14:52] Speaker 2: asked this question as well. First, I'll tell you what
[14:55] Speaker 2: it is that allows a sea harrier to execute that
[14:58] Speaker 2: amazing trick of being able to land and take off vertically,
[15:02] Speaker 2: you know, unlike a conventional.
[15:04] Speaker 1: Fixed wing fighter.
[15:05] Speaker 2: Uh, the sea harrier is a in many ways similar
[15:08] Speaker 2: to any other fighter aircraft, except that unlike normal fighters,
[15:12] Speaker 2: which basically have a nozzle at the back end which
[15:15] Speaker 2: is blowing out all that jet exhaust and propelling the
[15:18] Speaker 2: fighter forward. The engine in a sea harrier has a
[15:21] Speaker 2: module strapped onto it with nozzles that can turn either
[15:26] Speaker 2: backward or downwards.
[15:28] Speaker 1: So they are basic basically.
[15:29] Speaker 2: Able to vector the jet exhaust and thrust either backwards
[15:34] Speaker 2: for forward movement or they can swivel downwards for your
[15:38] Speaker 2: up down helicopter like movement. It's a it's a technology
[15:41] Speaker 2: called direct lift. Now, direct lift was a technology pioneered
[15:45] Speaker 2: by the by the British. One has to acknowledge that
[15:49] Speaker 2: post war British aviation technology is unparalleled in the world.
[15:55] Speaker 2: No country has been able to match that kind of
[15:57] Speaker 2: technology in that era technology, and I'll tell you why.
[16:02] Speaker 2: Nobody has been able to replicate it ever since. There
[16:04] Speaker 2: are complicated reasons for it. So you basically take an engine,
[16:08] Speaker 2: you strap on this kind of direct lift module onto it,
[16:11] Speaker 2: and you build a fighter around it. And so a
[16:14] Speaker 2: harrier pilot in his or her cockpit is able to basically,
[16:19] Speaker 2: in a very complicated symphony of maneuvers, tell the engine
[16:23] Speaker 2: which way to point the jet exhaust. So when those
[16:27] Speaker 2: nozzles are swiveled down the pilot has the ability to turn,
[16:31] Speaker 2: make the aircraft go rise up or down in a
[16:34] Speaker 2: vertical way, and then when the nozzles turn backwards.
[16:37] Speaker 1: Then you've got forward movement.
[16:39] Speaker 2: This amazing flexibility obviously means that the for a harrier
[16:44] Speaker 2: a runway becomes redundant because a harrier can can quite
[16:48] Speaker 2: literally land on any reasonably flat surface, including a carrier deck,
[16:52] Speaker 2: Which is why in terms of flexibility, in terms of
[16:56] Speaker 2: the sheer possibilities of a harrier, no aircraft has come
[17:00] Speaker 2: close to it. But the very same technology that gives
[17:04] Speaker 2: it this flexibility also introduces many drawbacks. A. The amount
[17:11] Speaker 2: of fuel consumption taken in a direct lift configuration is
[17:16] Speaker 2: significantly more than a normal normal jet engine. A, So
[17:21] Speaker 2: in a tiny little fighter with with very limited fuel space,
[17:26] Speaker 2: fuel consumption is everything, which means there's a compromise on
[17:29] Speaker 2: how many weapons you can carry.
[17:31] Speaker 1: Point number two. The Harrier was subsnic, and this was
[17:34] Speaker 1: a hugely.
[17:35] Speaker 2: Important issue for militaries because this is a fighter by
[17:39] Speaker 2: virtue of its engine configuration and choosing direct lift rather
[17:43] Speaker 2: than conventional trust. It meant that this aircraft couldn't go supersonic.
[17:48] Speaker 2: It couldn't break the sound barrier, and for various different reasons,
[17:51] Speaker 2: being able to break the sound barrier is a huge
[17:54] Speaker 2: compulsion for military aviation. Your aircraft has to be able
[17:58] Speaker 2: to go supersonic for various different things. So as a
[18:03] Speaker 2: result of this, the Sea Harrier, for all its beautiful flexibility,
[18:07] Speaker 2: was seen as a compromise kind of aircraft. Now we
[18:11] Speaker 2: have to remember that the Sea Harrier is still in service. Rather,
[18:13] Speaker 2: the Harrier is still in service. The US Marine still
[18:17] Speaker 2: use Harriers because literally no other aircraft has been able
[18:21] Speaker 2: to do the kind of stunt that the Harrier can
[18:26] Speaker 2: actually do. The F thirty five, the Lockheed Martin F
[18:30] Speaker 2: thirty five lightning to aircraft, which became the US Air Forces,
[18:36] Speaker 2: the US military's biggest ever fighter program, is only the
[18:40] Speaker 2: next aircraft that came along that could do the same
[18:44] Speaker 2: thing that the Harrier could. The F thirty five B,
[18:46] Speaker 2: which is what the Marine Corps needed, is basically an
[18:51] Speaker 2: aircraft that was built specifically to replace the Harrier, because
[18:55] Speaker 2: the Marine said, we want a jump jet. We need
[18:59] Speaker 2: a jump jet. We we're not going to compromise on that.
[19:02] Speaker 2: We need a jet that can take off and land vertically.
[19:06] Speaker 2: And obviously the technology that goes into the F thirty
[19:09] Speaker 2: five B is significantly different from the Harrier. They execute
[19:14] Speaker 2: the same trick of being able to land vertically and
[19:17] Speaker 2: take off like a Harrier, but they don't use direct lift.
[19:19] Speaker 2: They use something called a lift fan, which is a
[19:22] Speaker 2: separate technology. We can discuss that in another episode maybe,
[19:24] Speaker 2: but the fruits of the Harrier, you know what the
[19:28] Speaker 2: Harrier brought to the fight. It's interesting to see that
[19:31] Speaker 2: all the years after most of them have retired, people
[19:34] Speaker 2: still want that technology because there is value in being
[19:37] Speaker 2: able to land an aircraft vertically.
[19:39] Speaker 3: And you know, that is why I think this whole
[19:41] Speaker 3: this whole topic is pretty cool. Like you said at
[19:43] Speaker 3: the beginning of this episode that you know, it's within
[19:45] Speaker 3: like fifteen years of your independence you had an aircraft carrier,
[19:48] Speaker 3: and within like you know, like a half a dacre
[19:51] Speaker 3: to be a decade after that, you also had this
[19:53] Speaker 3: very cool piece of equipment that you know, for that
[19:56] Speaker 3: time was far far technology advance, and even now, like
[19:59] Speaker 3: you've just described, that was on a side on the
[20:01] Speaker 3: on the head and the tech that's used on that
[20:02] Speaker 3: on that fighter jet. Let's move back to our discussion
[20:06] Speaker 3: the mcwent and case, which are what we operate right now,
[20:09] Speaker 3: and then we'll get to obviously the Indian program so
[20:12] Speaker 3: to speak, if there even is one, but before that,
[20:16] Speaker 3: in fact, because we're talking about that, so Mota mota.
[20:18] Speaker 3: You know, while I was jotting down stuff, what I've
[20:21] Speaker 3: realized is with the Indian Navies fighter jet slash aircraft
[20:25] Speaker 3: carrier program of projects, there is roughly sort of a
[20:28] Speaker 3: two decade twenty year cycle where you have one carrier
[20:32] Speaker 3: coming in uh and then maybe twenty years later you
[20:35] Speaker 3: are either thinking of a new one or you're kind
[20:37] Speaker 3: of about to get a new one. So you had
[20:39] Speaker 3: the the Wikaran, the original Wikaran in the sixties, you
[20:43] Speaker 3: had the Wirrat in the eighties late eighties, you had
[20:46] Speaker 3: the in the two thousands. And also what I noticed
[20:50] Speaker 3: was these these these are almost like packaged deals, so
[20:53] Speaker 3: to speak. So you had the Vikaran, the original one,
[20:55] Speaker 3: coming with the Seahawks. There's a overlap between the harriers,
[20:59] Speaker 3: but you know, you kind of had the harriers coming
[21:01] Speaker 3: with the Verrat, which was a Chamis Hermes also also
[21:04] Speaker 3: a UK Navy ship, and you had the mcwent nine
[21:07] Speaker 3: case coming with the which is a Russian aircraft carrier
[21:12] Speaker 3: originally called Admiral Gorshkov. Now I want to know why
[21:16] Speaker 3: and when did we when to be known it was
[21:19] Speaker 3: in the two thousands. Why did India choose to make
[21:22] Speaker 3: the shift from British aircraft carriers to a Russian one?
[21:26] Speaker 3: Was it, like you said at the start of this episode,
[21:28] Speaker 3: that perhaps that military friendship that India had developed with
[21:32] Speaker 3: Russia had finally come to fruition. And were the mccrientine
[21:36] Speaker 3: case part of sort of this package deal that you
[21:38] Speaker 3: take this carrier and you get these planes or were
[21:41] Speaker 3: these two separate, you know, discussions that you know, we
[21:43] Speaker 3: also need planes, we also need a carrier. Hey, it
[21:47] Speaker 3: looks like you have both and both seem great for us,
[21:49] Speaker 3: so better give us both.
[21:51] Speaker 4: Was it? How did it go about?
[21:52] Speaker 2: So the brief answer to that is after the Harrier,
[21:56] Speaker 2: the British haven't developed a naval aircraft. They haven't developed
[22:00] Speaker 2: an aircraft specifically purpose built for naval operations after the Harrier,
[22:05] Speaker 2: after the Sea Harrier. So remember that after the Sea Harrier,
[22:11] Speaker 2: the British and Europe in general had had basically figured
[22:15] Speaker 2: that you know, each country building its own fighter is
[22:18] Speaker 2: a is an uneconomical, uneconomical, expensive hell of a proposition,
[22:24] Speaker 2: and that's why countries started coming together.
[22:27] Speaker 1: To build build fighters.
[22:30] Speaker 2: It was decided in the eighties that you know, a
[22:33] Speaker 2: group of European countries would come together and build an
[22:38] Speaker 2: aircraft together. They would all pitch in, they would all
[22:42] Speaker 2: add their own components and their own workshare and their
[22:45] Speaker 2: own expertise and build one fighter and each of their
[22:47] Speaker 2: militaries would buy them. It would make sense, it would
[22:50] Speaker 2: cost less money, and you know, it would create jobs
[22:53] Speaker 2: in all these countries and cooperatively, let's build a fighter.
[22:56] Speaker 1: The result of that cooperation was the Eurofighter.
[22:58] Speaker 2: Typhoon, which which is a fighter that is now in
[23:02] Speaker 2: service with the UK, with the with Spain, Italy.
[23:06] Speaker 1: All these all these countries.
[23:08] Speaker 2: The problem was Franz said, nay, we don't want to
[23:14] Speaker 2: We don't want this stuff. You know, we have a
[23:16] Speaker 2: we have an amazing aviation legacy. I mean it was
[23:18] Speaker 2: more complicated than that. They they thought it was an
[23:21] Speaker 2: unfair equation and uh and stuff, and they there were
[23:25] Speaker 2: complicated reasons why they didn't want to be part of
[23:28] Speaker 2: the Typhoon program. But France said, screw you guys, we're
[23:32] Speaker 2: doing We're going to go our own way. And the
[23:34] Speaker 2: result of that going our own way was the Raffal. Now,
[23:38] Speaker 2: the Rafael and the Typhoon are very similar aircraft in
[23:41] Speaker 2: many ways. Even when you look at them in terms
[23:43] Speaker 2: of pictures, if you're not an aviation expert, they look
[23:46] Speaker 2: kind of similar. They're similar in size, you know, they
[23:49] Speaker 2: they both don't have you know, they both have those
[23:52] Speaker 2: cannard for fourplanes in the front. They're both twin engine fighters.
[23:57] Speaker 2: So the the aircraft kind of came from the same
[24:01] Speaker 2: same kind of aviation legacy, but they were very different
[24:04] Speaker 2: and the most basic difference was the Raphle that was
[24:08] Speaker 2: built and developed by the French was built as a
[24:12] Speaker 2: naval fighter from the start, while the Typhoon was built
[24:15] Speaker 2: as an air force fighter from the start.
[24:17] Speaker 1: Difference number two.
[24:18] Speaker 2: The Raphaele as a naval fighter, it was possible to
[24:22] Speaker 2: quickly convert it into an air force fighter, because that
[24:25] Speaker 2: is possible. A naval fighter is a complicated machine, but
[24:28] Speaker 2: converting it into an air force fighter is easy. Here
[24:31] Speaker 2: you're flying it on our deck. We need to fly
[24:33] Speaker 2: it on the shore. Some modifications for Jager. But converting
[24:37] Speaker 2: an air force fighter into a naval fighter is when
[24:40] Speaker 2: hell begins to show its face. And while the Typhoon
[24:45] Speaker 2: had some plans on paper to become a naval fighter,
[24:48] Speaker 2: it just wasn't deemed economical, which is why the Eurofighter
[24:52] Speaker 2: Typhoon is a strictly air force fighter. It's not used
[24:55] Speaker 2: by any other service. So the Brits didn't have a
[24:58] Speaker 2: naval fighter, and that's the reason and why the United
[25:02] Speaker 2: Kingdom had to officially join the Joint Strike Fighter program
[25:05] Speaker 2: in the United States for the first time in their history.
[25:08] Speaker 2: And it was a it was a symptom of globalization,
[25:12] Speaker 2: a symptom of you know, post Cold War consolidation of resources,
[25:18] Speaker 2: a kind of sad farewell to the British aviation legacy
[25:22] Speaker 2: that had you know, been there since the war. But
[25:25] Speaker 2: the British basically stopped developing a naval aircraft and they
[25:29] Speaker 2: didn't have a naval aircraft development in going, which is
[25:32] Speaker 2: why now the Royal Navy uses the F thirty five B.
[25:38] Speaker 2: The F thirty five B, which is the jump check
[25:40] Speaker 2: that I was talking about, which is the carrier the
[25:41] Speaker 2: new area is the aircraft that has come into into
[25:45] Speaker 2: service with the HMS.
[25:46] Speaker 1: Elizabeth and and other carriers like that.
[25:51] Speaker 2: So that's the reason why India didn't have a choice
[25:55] Speaker 2: in this matter.
[25:57] Speaker 1: We have to remember.
[25:58] Speaker 2: They've that the building a deck based fighter is extremely
[26:04] Speaker 2: small and exclusive club. Very few countries do it. So
[26:08] Speaker 2: so when India chose the Admiral Goshkov as a carrier,
[26:11] Speaker 2: which became the Irons Vikrama, it's not like it was
[26:15] Speaker 2: buying a carrier and there was a brochure with there
[26:18] Speaker 2: are these five six fighters up choosed Loki concert fighters up.
[26:21] Speaker 1: It doesn't work.
[26:22] Speaker 2: It's very complicated because a carrier also has a kind
[26:26] Speaker 2: of native fighter. It's built for a particular kind of fighter,
[26:30] Speaker 2: or a fighter is built for that particular carrier, because
[26:33] Speaker 2: you know, the sizes of lifts, the length of a runway,
[26:37] Speaker 2: the size of the hangars where they are stored, the
[26:40] Speaker 2: you know, the the well deck, although the many different
[26:43] Speaker 2: things that go into a carrier. They had tailor made
[26:45] Speaker 2: for a certain kind of fighter. So your your big
[26:49] Speaker 2: Nimitz class carriers, et cetera, which the United States uses,
[26:53] Speaker 2: are built for large you know, F fourteen, F eighteen
[26:57] Speaker 2: kind of fighters. The Goshkov was was built for smaller
[27:01] Speaker 2: fighters like the mid twenty nine K, and so it
[27:03] Speaker 2: didn't make sense for India to actually, you know, look
[27:06] Speaker 2: at any other kind of fighter and force it even
[27:08] Speaker 2: though interestingly, when the Goshkov was under consideration, many fighter
[27:12] Speaker 2: manufacturers conducted simulated studies to see if their fighters were compatible.
[27:18] Speaker 1: With the Goshkov.
[27:19] Speaker 2: Boeing did it with the F eighteen, Dasso did it
[27:22] Speaker 2: with the Rapaal, basically trying to convince India, we don't
[27:25] Speaker 2: buy this Russian bullshit. Our fighters are equally compatible with.
[27:28] Speaker 1: The Goshkov, and you do it. But this was Russia.
[27:30] Speaker 2: I mean, this was Russia saying like, who are you
[27:32] Speaker 2: gonna believe it's our aircraft carrier Humko patayaki kachaz dispec.
[27:37] Speaker 2: So you have to buy the Goshkov and this is
[27:39] Speaker 2: the best fighter for it. And let's let's let's not
[27:43] Speaker 2: mistake ourselves that the mid twenty nine was a was
[27:46] Speaker 2: like a compromise candidate. It's a bloody good fighter. It's
[27:49] Speaker 2: a really good fighter. The mid twenty nine K is
[27:52] Speaker 2: basically the deck based version of a fighter aircraft that
[27:55] Speaker 2: is in service with Indian Air Force in large numbers, upgraded,
[28:00] Speaker 2: very respected and extremely fine fighter aircraft. It's basically the
[28:04] Speaker 2: fighter that Russia built to tackle the F sixteen.
[28:07] Speaker 1: Yes of the United States.
[28:08] Speaker 2: So the mid twenty nine K is a is an
[28:11] Speaker 2: excellent fighter, but now India has needed to move on
[28:14] Speaker 2: from it.
[28:15] Speaker 1: That's the only problem.
[28:16] Speaker 2: So uh, it's it's you know, when when India was
[28:19] Speaker 2: faced with the purchase of these aircraft carriers, uh, there
[28:22] Speaker 2: was there was very little elbow room in terms of
[28:25] Speaker 2: what it could actually get right.
[28:27] Speaker 4: And yeah, so now India has.
[28:29] Speaker 3: The lead to move on and uh, now we'll kind
[28:31] Speaker 3: of get into the crux of this episode of the
[28:35] Speaker 3: lack careerly what I see at least when again I'm
[28:38] Speaker 3: joring Norman notes because I don't know the NATI grits
[28:39] Speaker 3: and I don't I don't have that inside knowledge inside scoops.
[28:42] Speaker 3: But when you just kind of laid down on a
[28:44] Speaker 3: piece of paper, you kind of can see a glaring,
[28:46] Speaker 3: layering lack of a of a naval fighter program altogether.
[28:51] Speaker 4: But after a quick break.
[28:57] Speaker 6: Eat eggs, no eat fiber, sleep, no take short naps,
[29:02] Speaker 6: don't listen to others, no serve others. Do you ever
[29:05] Speaker 6: feel like you're drowning in a pool of advice? This
[29:10] Speaker 6: is Sonalia Charji, a health journalist for the last ten years,
[29:14] Speaker 6: who is equally fed up of lines like ten ways
[29:17] Speaker 6: to Stay fit so join me in the podcast Health
[29:20] Speaker 6: Wealth as we learn about health from a completely new
[29:23] Speaker 6: perspective where investing in yourself is not a task but simple,
[29:28] Speaker 6: satisfying and joyful. Full episodes are available on Apple, Google, Spotify,
[29:34] Speaker 6: and the India Today podcast website. Tune in now, Hello and.
[29:44] Speaker 3: Welcome back, Shaven. I discussing India's naval fighter jets. Up
[29:48] Speaker 3: until now we've talked about the history of Indian navyes
[29:51] Speaker 3: fighter jets. We've had several versions of UK based fighter
[29:57] Speaker 3: jets and then one mean stay that's been there for
[29:59] Speaker 3: the last start twenty twenty five years. I think the
[30:02] Speaker 3: tent nine K that's on I Sukamaya and also I'm
[30:06] Speaker 3: guessing now on Iron Squick Run Rant Iron Quick Run
[30:09] Speaker 3: the new one very interesting over year. So you got
[30:12] Speaker 3: the WMATA around in the in the.
[30:14] Speaker 4: Two thousands, if I'm not wrong, and that.
[30:17] Speaker 3: Thirteen, sorry, you started to think of getting the from
[30:20] Speaker 3: from Russia in the twenty twenty thirteen and back then
[30:24] Speaker 3: you also had started thinking of developing her own aircraft
[30:27] Speaker 3: carrier because I think you had realized now perhaps it's
[30:30] Speaker 3: come time to see if we can do it. So
[30:32] Speaker 3: let's also start, uh, you know, trying to figure out
[30:34] Speaker 3: a way to do that, and ultimately that became insqickgrant,
[30:38] Speaker 3: which was commissioned a few months ago. And what the
[30:40] Speaker 3: sense I got is that you never thought, Okay, we're
[30:44] Speaker 3: gonna be building a new aircraft carrier and perhaps if
[30:47] Speaker 3: we once we get that technology and that know how,
[30:49] Speaker 3: we'll perhaps build more versions of it. The sense I'm
[30:52] Speaker 3: getting is that we never thought of building a fighter
[30:56] Speaker 3: jet for this new aircraft carrier that you were building.
[30:58] Speaker 3: You knew that, you know, a secondhand ship you're importing.
[31:01] Speaker 3: You're getting these Russian fighter jets, but at some point
[31:03] Speaker 3: they're going to get old, and at some point you're
[31:05] Speaker 3: going to need new fighter jets for your future aircraft carriers.
[31:09] Speaker 3: So I don't want to say it was lack of foresight,
[31:11] Speaker 3: even though you know, we love using very very strong
[31:13] Speaker 3: words and terminologies when it comes to India's military equipment
[31:17] Speaker 3: development process. But you kind of getting my drift, what
[31:20] Speaker 3: I'm where I'm coming from, where I'm getting at. But
[31:23] Speaker 3: yet at the same time, around the same time, you
[31:25] Speaker 3: had a fighter jet.
[31:26] Speaker 4: Program going on.
[31:27] Speaker 3: Note the missing navel word in that the LCA program,
[31:31] Speaker 3: which became the THEAGES now on a previous episode, you've
[31:35] Speaker 3: explained really well, and I think it kind of goes
[31:37] Speaker 3: back to the early answer right now, just before the break,
[31:39] Speaker 3: of why the LCA program was not really fit to
[31:43] Speaker 3: be a naval program because of something that you spoke
[31:45] Speaker 3: about and something that you've spoken about in digital that
[31:47] Speaker 3: it's very, very difficult to take a take a air
[31:50] Speaker 3: force fighter jet and turn that into a nail fighter jet.
[31:53] Speaker 3: So the sense I'm getting again is that the LCA
[31:55] Speaker 3: program was never envisioned to have to ever be, you know,
[32:00] Speaker 3: in in a place where it would also supply the Navy.
[32:02] Speaker 3: My question then is why, like you know, you were
[32:05] Speaker 3: developing an aircraft carrier carrier on your own. Did no one
[32:08] Speaker 3: in the system at any point think that, you know, hey,
[32:11] Speaker 3: a KELS program beach old, why not also start Let's
[32:16] Speaker 3: see if we can get somewhere with it. Like you said,
[32:18] Speaker 3: it's difficult. Very few countries in the world even choose
[32:20] Speaker 3: to develop that or make their own fighter jets naval
[32:23] Speaker 3: fighter jets. It could have been difficult, but did no
[32:25] Speaker 3: one ever think of doing that? Because if they had
[32:27] Speaker 3: back then, perhaps we wouldn't be talking about this this topic.
[32:31] Speaker 1: Today.
[32:32] Speaker 2: Uh, you know, they've in in our defense podcast, You've
[32:36] Speaker 2: you've you've developed this habit of putting your finger once
[32:39] Speaker 2: again straight in the pain point. So let's let's take
[32:43] Speaker 2: this up. This is the this is the maza of
[32:46] Speaker 2: this episode. And you know how I love going into
[32:49] Speaker 2: where it really hurts. So let's let's look at all
[32:52] Speaker 2: the different questions you've asked me and I'll answer them
[32:54] Speaker 2: one by one. First off, I will start by saying
[32:57] Speaker 2: that when it comes to foresight, the one serve is
[33:00] Speaker 2: that usually can't be blamed is the Indian Navy. Yes,
[33:04] Speaker 2: and the reason I've blamed in one of our previous episodes,
[33:06] Speaker 2: which we'll share in the show notes, also is that
[33:08] Speaker 2: the Indian Navy doesn't have the luxury of changing decisions
[33:11] Speaker 2: at the last minute because it takes so long, it
[33:14] Speaker 2: takes years or decades for equipment to be built and arrive,
[33:20] Speaker 2: that the Indian Navy has no choice but to pre planned,
[33:23] Speaker 2: pre meditate, you know, pre order.
[33:26] Speaker 1: Years and years and years in advance.
[33:28] Speaker 2: So organized foresight and pre planning is now a part
[33:34] Speaker 2: of the culture and DNA of the Navy. And it's
[33:38] Speaker 2: a very very good thing that many, not just the.
[33:41] Speaker 1: Army and air force.
[33:42] Speaker 2: But in general organizations should be able to learn from
[33:46] Speaker 2: that kind of pre planning. It's an amazing cultural lesson.
[33:50] Speaker 2: Having said that, now, the LCA program started in the
[33:54] Speaker 2: nineteen eighties as a program to basically deliver a you know,
[33:59] Speaker 2: a fighter aircraft for the Indian Air Force, not a
[34:03] Speaker 2: very complicated term of reference. It was supposed to be
[34:06] Speaker 2: an aircraft that would over over its development cycle and
[34:09] Speaker 2: delivery period replace you know, some of India's aging aircraft,
[34:15] Speaker 2: including the mid twenty one you know, and some of
[34:18] Speaker 2: the other fighters that are there in Indian service. Now,
[34:21] Speaker 2: I'm sure at the time that things started off with
[34:25] Speaker 2: the LCA, there must have been there must have been
[34:28] Speaker 2: some noises within the system saying that, you know, why
[34:31] Speaker 2: don't we also consider making this enable fighter. But there
[34:36] Speaker 2: are good reasons why it didn't happen, and there are.
[34:38] Speaker 2: But the question you ask is a fair one. A
[34:41] Speaker 2: because India was entering a very difficult program of developing
[34:46] Speaker 2: its own fighter aircraft. It had taken upon it, it
[34:50] Speaker 2: had taken on a mission to develop its own fighter aircraft,
[34:54] Speaker 2: which was going to be an onerous, extremely difficult task
[34:57] Speaker 2: where it knew that it would have to depend on
[35:00] Speaker 2: or an agencies for certain technologies. And let's not go
[35:03] Speaker 2: back to the engine story because I'm tired of that topic.
[35:05] Speaker 2: Maybe we'll revisited after the fiftieth episode. But at that time,
[35:10] Speaker 2: if there were any if there were any suggestions from
[35:13] Speaker 2: within the system that, you know, maybe we should think
[35:15] Speaker 2: about a naval fighter as well, Uh, they would have
[35:19] Speaker 2: been very quickly silenced because at that time the system
[35:21] Speaker 2: was focused on Yeah, they co already Coffey complicated it.
[35:26] Speaker 2: Let's let's not let's not be too ambitious. Let's get
[35:30] Speaker 2: this done first. Let's get the LCA done first, which
[35:34] Speaker 2: is which which has its own merits. The idea was
[35:37] Speaker 2: to be as laser focused and you know, consistent and
[35:41] Speaker 2: you know and committed to the LCA program without getting
[35:44] Speaker 2: distracted by trying to do too many things. Because it's
[35:47] Speaker 2: a fair argument, you know, if you try and aim
[35:49] Speaker 2: for too many things air first fighter by now, a
[35:51] Speaker 2: naval fighter b BA, now, you might end up with neither.
[35:54] Speaker 2: So so the decision was taken, and I don't I
[35:57] Speaker 2: don't even think it was a decision. I don't think
[35:59] Speaker 2: the naval fighter suggestion ever became something that required a decision.
[36:04] Speaker 1: It simply wasn't there, which.
[36:06] Speaker 2: Is why by two thousand and one when the when
[36:09] Speaker 2: they just first flew, even even at that time, there
[36:12] Speaker 2: was no there was no suggestion within the system that,
[36:15] Speaker 2: you know, why don't we look at it as a
[36:17] Speaker 2: naval fighter as well. The actual naval LCA program started
[36:21] Speaker 2: some time later. And the point that you mentioned, and
[36:25] Speaker 2: which we've spoken about variously before, is that is that
[36:29] Speaker 2: converting a purpose built air force fighter, a fighter that
[36:34] Speaker 2: is built for conventional you know, takeoff and landing from
[36:39] Speaker 2: a normal runway, converting that into a naval fighter that
[36:44] Speaker 2: is capable of taking off and landing from an aircraft
[36:47] Speaker 2: carrier deck is an engineering nightmare.
[36:51] Speaker 1: It is a very very difficult thing to do.
[36:53] Speaker 2: It's not impossible, as the Naval LCAA has proven, because
[36:57] Speaker 2: because India has damn good development scientist and engineers, and
[37:00] Speaker 2: there's no doubt about that, and the Naval LCA team
[37:03] Speaker 2: is actually one of the one of the one of
[37:05] Speaker 2: the bravest and most capable teams that India has when
[37:08] Speaker 2: it comes to aviation. But the fact is that the
[37:11] Speaker 2: Naval LCA in many ways was sort of doomed from
[37:15] Speaker 2: the start. The reason for that is that the Indian
[37:18] Speaker 2: Navy right off the bat had said, look, we will
[37:21] Speaker 2: support this program. We will support this program. But and
[37:25] Speaker 2: sort of unofficially and officially, the Navy basically made it
[37:29] Speaker 2: known that, you know, while the program has our support
[37:31] Speaker 2: in terms of money, in terms of you know, we
[37:33] Speaker 2: will cheer it on because we believe in making India
[37:36] Speaker 2: et cetera, we don't think it's going to meet our
[37:38] Speaker 2: requirements because by the time and aircraft of this kind
[37:41] Speaker 2: comes online, our requirements are going to be significantly more.
[37:46] Speaker 2: At the very surface level, we are going to want
[37:48] Speaker 2: a twin engine fighter because when you're talking about naval aviation,
[37:52] Speaker 2: things have changed now. But when you're talking about naval aviation,
[37:54] Speaker 2: the conventional wisdom is a twin engine fighters required for
[37:58] Speaker 2: safety reasons. In case one engine lams out, you've still
[38:01] Speaker 2: got one engine to make it back safely, et cetera.
[38:03] Speaker 2: So the conventional wisdom dictated that a single engine fighter
[38:07] Speaker 2: simply will not do. Of course, in the modern age,
[38:09] Speaker 2: you've got you know, very very highly reliable engines, which
[38:13] Speaker 2: is why the F thirty five C is a naval
[38:15] Speaker 2: fighter with a single engine. But that's a separate issue.
[38:18] Speaker 2: But so the the Indian Navy sort of held the
[38:22] Speaker 2: hand of the lca AS Navy LCAA Navy right through
[38:26] Speaker 2: its development.
[38:27] Speaker 1: It was very very supportive. It was not it.
[38:31] Speaker 2: It kind of decided to draw the line and say
[38:34] Speaker 2: we can't use the LCAA Navy as a frontline combat platform,
[38:38] Speaker 2: with a great deal of sadness and reluctance, because the
[38:41] Speaker 2: Indian Navy genuinely loves made in India stuff.
[38:45] Speaker 1: They genuinely like it.
[38:46] Speaker 2: But yeah, they had to, with a degree of agony,
[38:49] Speaker 2: say boss yer amarel, you know, we can't use this fighter.
[38:54] Speaker 2: But that didn't stop the lca Navy from, you know,
[38:57] Speaker 2: consistently trying to prove itself more and more and more.
[39:01] Speaker 1: It has.
[39:02] Speaker 2: It has emerged as a very capable light fighter and
[39:06] Speaker 2: even at this stage they've The amazing thing about the
[39:09] Speaker 2: LCAA Navy is that, even at this stage, even after
[39:11] Speaker 2: all that engineering, even after all that uh you know,
[39:15] Speaker 2: development work, uh and very very hard committed testing work
[39:20] Speaker 2: that was done by a brave team of testers, Uh,
[39:23] Speaker 2: the LCA A Navy is not down and out. It's
[39:26] Speaker 2: not flown into the sunset, it's not sitting somewhere on
[39:28] Speaker 2: some airfield. It is still landing on India's newest aircraft
[39:33] Speaker 2: carrier that made in India, Awakrant. It's still conducting tests.
[39:36] Speaker 2: It's still uh, it's still the team still feels optimistic
[39:41] Speaker 2: that maybe one squadron of the lca A Navy may
[39:43] Speaker 2: be bought as a kind of you know, as a
[39:45] Speaker 2: kind of test or training platform for pilots. You know,
[39:48] Speaker 2: why not have your own uh naval fighter, even if
[39:52] Speaker 2: it's the LCAA Navy, in order to train your pilots
[39:55] Speaker 2: in deck based, deck based aviation that's landings and takeoff,
[39:59] Speaker 2: arrested landings and you know, short takeoffs. So that kind
[40:03] Speaker 2: of door is actually still open. But like you said,
[40:06] Speaker 2: the India made many missteps.
[40:08] Speaker 1: In terms of the naval fighter issue.
[40:10] Speaker 2: But I would be I think it would be a
[40:12] Speaker 2: little unfit to call them missteps because a naval fighter
[40:16] Speaker 2: is a very difficult thing and India doesn't have the
[40:20] Speaker 2: luxury of saying cello, yea be developed kuring A, or
[40:23] Speaker 2: yea be developed curing A. And we have enough money
[40:25] Speaker 2: to do a fighter aircraft, and we have enough money
[40:27] Speaker 2: to do a nuclear submarine and a naval fighter. And
[40:31] Speaker 2: let's most importantly when I close this point is Please
[40:35] Speaker 2: remember that a naval fighter is not going to be
[40:38] Speaker 2: purchased in as many numbers as an air force fighter.
[40:41] Speaker 1: An air force fighter.
[40:42] Speaker 2: Like the theages, you're gonna buy two hundred and twenty
[40:44] Speaker 2: three hundred, four hundred, the amcar you're gonna buy like
[40:47] Speaker 2: three hundred four wanted aircraft. A naval fighter you require
[40:50] Speaker 2: thirty to forty twenty thirty forty the Raphaele deal that
[40:54] Speaker 2: is going to be signed this financially as twenty seven aircraft.
[40:58] Speaker 2: So a naval fighter is also required in very small numbers.
[41:01] Speaker 2: So are you going to develop your own naval fighter
[41:05] Speaker 2: in order to just buy twenty thirty How are you
[41:09] Speaker 2: going to justify the money spent on developing a fighter
[41:13] Speaker 2: if you're only going to buy a few thinking is
[41:16] Speaker 2: going to be exported is a pipereen? Yeah, So why
[41:20] Speaker 2: would you do that? And that's where the twin engine
[41:22] Speaker 2: deck based fighter comes.
[41:24] Speaker 3: Yeah, uh yeah, that's the point I want to discuss that.
[41:29] Speaker 3: So then what's what's next for the navy, Because, like
[41:32] Speaker 3: you said, we're buying twenty six.
[41:33] Speaker 4: RUFL naval fighter jets.
[41:35] Speaker 3: I think the deal is about to be will be
[41:37] Speaker 3: signed sometimes by the end of this year.
[41:39] Speaker 4: Negotiations still going on.
[41:41] Speaker 3: You have a round a complement of around in thing
[41:43] Speaker 3: forty five forty six or the mccrain and case that
[41:47] Speaker 3: are operated on both then speakerund there's talk of getting
[41:51] Speaker 3: one more version of the innsquicker anthem. So obviously the
[41:54] Speaker 3: raphaels are not going to be enough to completely replace
[41:57] Speaker 3: all the megs.
[41:59] Speaker 4: There will be some, you.
[41:59] Speaker 1: Know, there will be.
[42:00] Speaker 3: Basically you will have a combination of the two right
[42:03] Speaker 3: now in service a topic that you love, by the way,
[42:06] Speaker 3: of having two different variants of fighter JITs in the
[42:09] Speaker 3: same service, but that's something we'll just leave us height.
[42:10] Speaker 3: We've talked about that too many times. So where does
[42:14] Speaker 3: that leave the Navy. I'm guessing one reason for also
[42:16] Speaker 3: ordering just twenty six Rafel jets is that you don't really.
[42:19] Speaker 4: Have the money so damn expensive fighters in the first place.
[42:22] Speaker 3: And remember you also have to buy them for your
[42:24] Speaker 3: first by the way, there's one option, like you said,
[42:27] Speaker 3: the twin engine a deck based fighter. But again then
[42:30] Speaker 3: the question is, like you said, is it really worth
[42:32] Speaker 3: investing so many thousands of crows or truopees when you
[42:36] Speaker 3: can end up buying forty fifty sixty Are you going
[42:38] Speaker 3: to be able to reco recover that investment. So then
[42:41] Speaker 3: the question then in front of me, and I'm guessing
[42:43] Speaker 3: also in front of Navy and maybe the planners and
[42:45] Speaker 3: everybody else, is then what what do you do? Is
[42:48] Speaker 3: there a plan in place? I'm talking practically now. I mean,
[42:51] Speaker 3: there's one thing to have sort of a philosophical quandary
[42:53] Speaker 3: about what to do, but is there really a shore
[42:56] Speaker 3: for plan in place? Because right now all we know
[42:58] Speaker 3: is that the Navy is gonna get twenty six yet.
[43:00] Speaker 3: But that's so.
[43:02] Speaker 2: Yes, the happy news is that there is a plan
[43:06] Speaker 2: in place. The sad news is the plan in place
[43:10] Speaker 2: has been forced by a lack of having many plans
[43:13] Speaker 2: in place before. Okay, and uh, that's it.
[43:18] Speaker 1: That's it. That's the bit of truth. I'm not being
[43:21] Speaker 1: facetious about this.
[43:22] Speaker 2: The the truth of the matter is, and we've said
[43:25] Speaker 2: this many times before on our podcast.
[43:28] Speaker 1: They've which uh and let me say it straight.
[43:30] Speaker 2: We definitely do you know, lobbies don't work in military contracting.
[43:34] Speaker 2: And you know, if if something can be made with
[43:37] Speaker 2: equal quality and capability here in India, I'm all for it.
[43:40] Speaker 2: The truth of the matter is, let's let's let's decode
[43:44] Speaker 2: this one piece of a time. One Number one, the
[43:46] Speaker 2: mid twenty nine K is not going anywhere in a hurry.
[43:48] Speaker 2: Let's let's first of all dispel this myth. The mid
[43:52] Speaker 2: twenty nine k's are actually relatively new fighters. They arrived
[43:56] Speaker 2: like about a decade ago. They've got a good couple
[44:00] Speaker 2: of decades left in them going forward. So the mid
[44:04] Speaker 2: twenty nine case are not going anywhere in a hurry. Okay,
[44:07] Speaker 2: that's point number one. We've got about forty five left.
[44:09] Speaker 2: There are problems with them, we've discussed those, but the
[44:12] Speaker 2: mid twenty nine are there.
[44:13] Speaker 1: It's not like Rafa MC twenty nine is out of
[44:15] Speaker 1: the picture. They're not. They're there.
[44:17] Speaker 2: Point number two, your Rafaele fighter jets, the twenty seven
[44:21] Speaker 2: Raffaele fighter jets are being bought as what is described
[44:25] Speaker 2: in reports as.
[44:26] Speaker 1: A stop gap.
[44:27] Speaker 2: Now, there is no word I hate more than stop gap,
[44:30] Speaker 2: because stop gap is basically your way of saying, shit,
[44:34] Speaker 2: I forgot to do these these these things tenure of
[44:37] Speaker 2: fifteen or twenty years ago, and therefore I need to
[44:39] Speaker 2: spend sixty thousand crores of public you know, taxpayers money
[44:45] Speaker 2: as a stop gap. Okay, And I'm being very polite
[44:48] Speaker 2: about this. Believe me, why should anyone need a stop gap?
[44:52] Speaker 2: A stop gap is A stop gap is a cuss
[44:55] Speaker 2: word in my view, because it basically means you've you've
[44:59] Speaker 2: failed to plan, or your programs have failed, or your
[45:03] Speaker 2: foresight has failed, or your procurement culture has let you down,
[45:09] Speaker 2: and you're needing, you know, a stop gap, which goes
[45:13] Speaker 2: very much to the question you asked previously, which is,
[45:15] Speaker 2: you know, what about foresight? You know why didn't we
[45:18] Speaker 2: think of this earlier. Now it's easy for you and
[45:21] Speaker 2: me to sit here and sayer a q and aki
[45:22] Speaker 2: and stuff. It's complicated. There's you know, there's no one
[45:25] Speaker 2: person or one government or one service to blame. These
[45:28] Speaker 2: are these things do happen. These are extremely complicated issues
[45:33] Speaker 2: with a with a million moving parts and lots of
[45:36] Speaker 2: pools and pressures, including diplomatic. But having said that, now
[45:40] Speaker 2: we're faced with a situation where the mid twenty nine
[45:43] Speaker 2: k's are not going anywhere in a hurry. We are
[45:46] Speaker 2: about to sign our second deal with France for a
[45:49] Speaker 2: file fighters. These are naval fighters which will presumably be
[45:54] Speaker 2: deployed on board the ions Wic Runt, the new ions
[45:57] Speaker 2: Wick runth we don't know whether there's going to be
[45:59] Speaker 2: an IONSK Runt two or not. That's a that's a
[46:02] Speaker 2: whole separate pain point which we will come to, which
[46:05] Speaker 2: we will return to at some point.
[46:07] Speaker 1: Uh, and then you've got this twin engine deck based fighter.
[46:10] Speaker 2: Now. The reason the Raphaele is called the raphael program
[46:14] Speaker 2: is being justified as a stop gap is because, uh,
[46:17] Speaker 2: because the larger picture ahead for the Indian Navy is
[46:21] Speaker 2: that we're not going to stop with the ins vikrant.
[46:23] Speaker 2: We are going to need more aircraft carriers in the future,
[46:26] Speaker 2: you know, perhaps with the you know, electromagnetic launch systems
[46:31] Speaker 2: and who knows, maybe even nuclear powered going ogay, et cetera,
[46:34] Speaker 2: et cetera. Which means that if we start planning now,
[46:38] Speaker 2: we'll have our own deck based fighter, which I think
[46:42] Speaker 2: is is excellent news. Okay, let's let let's for a
[46:45] Speaker 2: moment forget about past failures to plan et cetera. The
[46:49] Speaker 2: fact that the twin engine deck based fighter is a credible,
[46:54] Speaker 2: you know, government recognized, sanctioned program right now means that
[46:59] Speaker 2: we are actually thinking thirty twenty thirty years ahead, which
[47:03] Speaker 2: is brilliant in my view, Which is brilliant in my view,
[47:06] Speaker 2: because twenty thirty years ahead, when you're make twenty nine
[47:09] Speaker 2: k's are gone, when your ruffles.
[47:11] Speaker 1: Are at the end of their lives.
[47:13] Speaker 2: A twin engine deck based fighter. And I'm not saying
[47:16] Speaker 2: that's how long it's going to take for it to deliver.
[47:17] Speaker 2: It's going to deliver far before that. But I'm saying
[47:20] Speaker 2: that if you've already planned for a kind of future
[47:23] Speaker 2: made in India, developed in India fighter aircraft, then you're
[47:27] Speaker 2: prepared for what comes next, because we don't know what
[47:30] Speaker 2: supply lines are going to be like as far as
[47:32] Speaker 2: these aircraft are concerned. The RA twenty seven raffles is
[47:36] Speaker 2: a is a solid naval fleet. It's a solid naval
[47:39] Speaker 2: fleet for a you know, for a navy of India's size,
[47:44] Speaker 2: and these will be operating alongside the thirty six raffles
[47:48] Speaker 2: that the Indian Air Force already uses.
[47:50] Speaker 1: But the problem with imports.
[47:53] Speaker 2: And I say, and this is again something that I
[47:55] Speaker 2: repeat very often, is imports force more imports. When you
[48:00] Speaker 2: import something the amount of money and energy you've spent
[48:05] Speaker 2: on a acquisition and be readying your force to absorb
[48:09] Speaker 2: that technology, train and be able to operate that technology
[48:13] Speaker 2: means you've basically created a platform to buy more of
[48:16] Speaker 2: the same, like the raphal. The Rafha is a great
[48:19] Speaker 2: example of that. When you've bought thirty six rafiles for
[48:22] Speaker 2: the air Force, it stands to reason that the Navy
[48:24] Speaker 2: would buy the same even though the Navy conducted trials, etc.
[48:27] Speaker 2: It stands to reason because there are economies, there are
[48:30] Speaker 2: savings to be had commonality, so many obvious advantages of
[48:35] Speaker 2: operating the same kind of aircraft. Like you said, the
[48:38] Speaker 2: Air Force needs more fighters. Is it going to conduct
[48:41] Speaker 2: this extravagant beauty contest once again, or is it going
[48:45] Speaker 2: to go with the fighter it already has, or is
[48:47] Speaker 2: it going to choose yet another fighter? So all those
[48:50] Speaker 2: arguments are still going to be there. But again, you know,
[48:53] Speaker 2: the thing is, unless you draw a line in the
[48:55] Speaker 2: sand and say stop gap means stop gap, stop gap
[48:59] Speaker 2: means stop means this is the last this is the
[49:01] Speaker 2: last time we will uh you know, order this kind
[49:04] Speaker 2: of aircraft or we will build this aircraft in India
[49:07] Speaker 2: and therefore, if we have this aircraft again, they will
[49:10] Speaker 2: be rolling off an Indian line, which is also perfectly acceptable.
[49:14] Speaker 2: Or are you going to go the way and say
[49:16] Speaker 2: that no that's it. No more foreign stuff. We're going
[49:19] Speaker 2: to build our own fighter.
[49:21] Speaker 1: Uh.
[49:21] Speaker 2: Will it have an Indian engine? Where's that engine going
[49:23] Speaker 2: to come from? Which engine are you going to use?
[49:26] Speaker 2: Are you going to be able to turn it around
[49:27] Speaker 2: in time? What if it comes too soon? Where is
[49:30] Speaker 2: it going to operate? Which other operators will be there?
[49:33] Speaker 2: Do we have enough money to uh to develop a
[49:36] Speaker 2: twin engine deck based fighter to you know, for the
[49:39] Speaker 2: Indian Navy to operate? Which other customers will it have
[49:42] Speaker 2: apart from the Indian Navy? Will this Will this fighter
[49:45] Speaker 2: also be a air force fighter? Since you're building it
[49:48] Speaker 2: as a naval fighter? Turn turn the issue on its head.
[49:52] Speaker 2: It's a twin engine fighter like the raphaile. Will it
[49:55] Speaker 2: be an Indian raphile?
[49:56] Speaker 4: You know?
[49:56] Speaker 2: The twin engine deck based fighter can also be a
[49:58] Speaker 2: twin engine show based fighter for the Indian Air Force?
[50:01] Speaker 2: So then why does the Indian Air Force need any
[50:03] Speaker 2: other aircraft? Then Rafael fifteen? Now we get it, But
[50:07] Speaker 2: then what about the AMCA. You see how complicated these
[50:11] Speaker 2: things are so and a country like India doesn't have
[50:14] Speaker 2: the luxury of saying, let's do all these things and
[50:17] Speaker 2: then we'll decide later.
[50:18] Speaker 1: We can't do that.
[50:19] Speaker 2: So the twin engine deck based fighter is a is
[50:22] Speaker 2: a marvelous idea. It's a very promising, clean sheet design
[50:26] Speaker 2: of a new futuristic fighter, but there are difficult questions
[50:30] Speaker 2: to answer as far as that is concerned. Something else
[50:34] Speaker 2: will have to be sacrificed. There is no there is
[50:38] Speaker 2: no gentle way of putting it. When you want to
[50:41] Speaker 2: do the hard thing, sacrifices will have to be made.
[50:44] Speaker 2: Because we do not have boundless resources in terms of
[50:48] Speaker 2: procurement budget to develop all kinds of aircraft and then
[50:51] Speaker 2: say we'll decide later which ones we want. We can't
[50:54] Speaker 2: do it because this is sunk money. So if we're
[50:57] Speaker 2: going to if we're going to develop a few touristic
[51:01] Speaker 2: twin engine deck based fighter for the Indian Navy as
[51:03] Speaker 2: its future carrier based fighter platform, then the bad news
[51:09] Speaker 2: is something is going to have to be dropped. Whether
[51:12] Speaker 2: it is an air force program, whether it's a program
[51:15] Speaker 2: in some other wing of the military, whether it is
[51:17] Speaker 2: in the Indian Navy itself, something will have to stop
[51:21] Speaker 2: because that era of.
[51:24] Speaker 1: That era is over.
[51:25] Speaker 3: Yeah, I'm really glad you addressed that point because you know,
[51:30] Speaker 3: many times on the show we look at the past
[51:33] Speaker 3: decisions taken or sometimes not taken, and criticize them, and
[51:36] Speaker 3: you ask questions about nik unique. But this reality that
[51:40] Speaker 3: we've just talked about here with respect to a project
[51:42] Speaker 3: that's very much in front of us, that's very much
[51:44] Speaker 3: you know, for the next thirty years. That kind of
[51:48] Speaker 3: gives us that whole complexity. Now I can imagine, like,
[51:50] Speaker 3: you know, two thirty years from now having their own
[51:52] Speaker 3: podcast on defense looking back at this moment in time
[51:55] Speaker 3: of fare and saying, yeah, when that twin engine deck
[51:58] Speaker 3: best fighters that program had, This is the reason you know,
[52:01] Speaker 3: we're in a men there will be and there will
[52:03] Speaker 3: be there will be yeah, right right as we are
[52:06] Speaker 3: in this episode. One like a final note to end
[52:09] Speaker 3: this episode actually is the future of naval fighter jets
[52:14] Speaker 3: with respect to the technology of drones. That's not something
[52:18] Speaker 3: that really gets a lot of traction when it comes
[52:20] Speaker 3: to drones. You know, you've, like we've discussed and I
[52:22] Speaker 3: think one of the previous episodes we've talked about we
[52:25] Speaker 3: see drones mostly as you know, surveillance, as you know,
[52:28] Speaker 3: like you know, a very close combat close combat sort
[52:31] Speaker 3: of you know, helpful piece of equipment, but you have
[52:34] Speaker 3: the peratidrone that in the Indian Air Force is acquiring,
[52:37] Speaker 3: which is technically a fighter drone like like a fighter
[52:40] Speaker 3: without a pilot in it. Uh, after you after that episode,
[52:43] Speaker 3: actually of ours actually went back and looked for actual
[52:46] Speaker 3: photos of a pedat rone at an at an airfield
[52:49] Speaker 3: so that I could compare a size and I was
[52:50] Speaker 3: shocked by the size of it. It actually is almost
[52:53] Speaker 3: the size of a fighter aircraft. So yeah, like you said,
[52:56] Speaker 3: it's an aircraft. So with this technology definitely going to
[53:01] Speaker 3: be even more advanced in the in the coming years.
[53:04] Speaker 3: Is there is there a thinking within the Indian system
[53:08] Speaker 3: keep perhaps maybe a few years down the line, we
[53:11] Speaker 3: won't perhaps need a lot of manned fighter jets for
[53:14] Speaker 3: the navy, for the Indian Navy, because when it comes
[53:16] Speaker 3: to naval aviation, the one thing that you want at
[53:19] Speaker 3: the top of your list is safety for your pilot,
[53:22] Speaker 3: and drones take that concern out of the picture. They
[53:24] Speaker 3: might be damn expensive, but you if you lose a donut,
[53:27] Speaker 3: you don't lose a pilot. The pilot is safe on
[53:29] Speaker 3: your ship somewhere in a in a in a sort
[53:31] Speaker 3: of video game simulator, you know, manument maneuvering the that
[53:34] Speaker 3: that piece. So is there a thinking within the system?
[53:36] Speaker 3: Are we you know, exploring ideas, are we exploring any
[53:40] Speaker 3: uh piece of equipment? And are there even any drones
[53:45] Speaker 3: for naval.
[53:46] Speaker 4: Uh fighter aviation?
[53:48] Speaker 1: So the good news is that the thinking is there, uh.
[53:52] Speaker 2: And not only is there thinking, there's a lot of planning,
[53:54] Speaker 2: there's a lot of there's a lot of genuine uh
[53:58] Speaker 2: you know study work that has already been done and
[54:00] Speaker 2: is being executed in some pretty interesting ways by the
[54:03] Speaker 2: Indian military and specifically the Navy. Also as far as
[54:06] Speaker 2: how drones can get into the you know, get into
[54:10] Speaker 2: the mission as it were, we're talking everything from small drones.
[54:14] Speaker 1: To high performance big drones.
[54:16] Speaker 2: Now, when we're talking about naval drones, remember that the
[54:20] Speaker 2: deal for thirty one drones that is currently being finalized
[54:22] Speaker 2: with the United States that includes most of those drones.
[54:27] Speaker 2: Fifteen of those drones are going to be sea guardians
[54:29] Speaker 2: for the Indian Navy. Now, those don't operate off an
[54:32] Speaker 2: aircraft carrier deck, but they operate off an airfield and
[54:35] Speaker 2: those are very very capable armed.
[54:38] Speaker 1: You know, naval drones. So the Indian Navy.
[54:41] Speaker 2: Has already used a couple of leased versions of those
[54:44] Speaker 2: drones for a few years now from Aracona and Tamaladu.
[54:48] Speaker 2: So the Navy knows what drones bring to the fight.
[54:52] Speaker 1: The Navy doesn't.
[54:54] Speaker 2: Let me just say, the Navy doesn't need convincing that
[54:56] Speaker 2: drones is where it's at. The next this era of battle,
[54:59] Speaker 2: this era of combat is going to be.
[55:01] Speaker 1: Uh.
[55:02] Speaker 2: Drones are going to play a very very indispensable role
[55:05] Speaker 2: in that they're not a luxury.
[55:06] Speaker 1: It's not like hair.
[55:08] Speaker 2: It's not that you have to have drones. The Indian
[55:11] Speaker 2: Navy has already acquired drones. Uh, and I'm very happy
[55:15] Speaker 2: to say from Indian startups and Indian companies for cargo
[55:18] Speaker 2: handling on ships, they've acquired uh, these small, small drones
[55:23] Speaker 2: for their ship.
[55:24] Speaker 1: And I'm not talking about those silly Chinese drones.
[55:27] Speaker 2: These are proper purpose built drones with high definition cameras
[55:31] Speaker 2: for surveillance from ships, basically like little helicopters from ships
[55:34] Speaker 2: to conduct surveillance operations.
[55:37] Speaker 1: Uh.
[55:37] Speaker 2: There are drones for uh, you know, mechanical work on
[55:41] Speaker 2: board ships as well that are being used now. When
[55:45] Speaker 2: it comes to actual combat, UH, the need for a
[55:49] Speaker 2: deck based fighter drone has not yet has has not
[55:53] Speaker 2: yet been felt necessary even by the countries that operate,
[55:58] Speaker 2: you know, drones in a big way. Because drones can
[56:01] Speaker 2: fly from anywhere. The requirement to actually launch a combat
[56:06] Speaker 2: drone from a ship deck has not been felt necessary
[56:10] Speaker 2: at this stage yet. Because because drones are armed drones
[56:16] Speaker 2: of the kind that we're talking about, they operate already
[56:19] Speaker 2: very very far from their home bases. They are capable
[56:21] Speaker 2: of operating for thirty six forty eight hours. So unless
[56:25] Speaker 2: there is some kind of you know, new requirement or
[56:29] Speaker 2: new mission in a battlefield where an aircraft carrier needs
[56:33] Speaker 2: to be able to launch an armed drone, you know
[56:35] Speaker 2: that that's not something that's going to happen anytime soon.
[56:39] Speaker 1: Two reasons for it.
[56:39] Speaker 2: One, the technology already exists. Like, for example, if the
[56:43] Speaker 2: United States wants to suddenly turn out a deck based
[56:47] Speaker 2: combat drone, they can do it because they're already doing
[56:50] Speaker 2: it with their refueling drone. There's a drone called the
[56:52] Speaker 2: drone program called the m Q twenty five Stingray MQ
[56:55] Speaker 2: twenty five, if I'm not mistaken, Stingray, which is a
[56:59] Speaker 2: deck based air to air refueling drone. It's basically a
[57:03] Speaker 2: drone that can be launched off a deck.
[57:05] Speaker 1: Boeing one that contest.
[57:07] Speaker 2: It's a drone that which is the size of an
[57:10] Speaker 2: aircraft by the way, takes off from an aircraft carrier deck,
[57:13] Speaker 2: flies up there, and fighters that are in the air
[57:15] Speaker 2: plug into the drone and get their gas, get their fuel,
[57:18] Speaker 2: and then that drone comes back in lands miraculous technology.
[57:23] Speaker 2: So nothing theoretical stops the United States from saying I'm
[57:26] Speaker 2: going to take that drone platform sling on some weapons
[57:29] Speaker 2: and wail.
[57:30] Speaker 1: It's a it's a combat platform.
[57:32] Speaker 2: Of course, it's more complicated than that, but I'm just
[57:34] Speaker 2: saying that the building blocks for that such a capability
[57:37] Speaker 2: are definitely there. But in terms of using combat drones,
[57:43] Speaker 2: let's put aside the requirement of them having to be
[57:46] Speaker 2: strictly functioning from an aircraft carrier deck. They don't necessarily
[57:50] Speaker 2: need to. The concept of loyal wingman drones, which basically
[57:55] Speaker 2: fly controlled by fighter aircraft or helicopters is is is
[58:00] Speaker 2: there in foreign aviation? The United States does it already?
[58:05] Speaker 2: Hl India's HL is building something called the cats Hunter,
[58:08] Speaker 2: which is supposed to be a you know, a fighter
[58:11] Speaker 2: controlled combat drone. That's that's a concept right now.
[58:15] Speaker 1: But it is being developed.
[58:16] Speaker 2: But it also proves that the companies building military aircraft
[58:20] Speaker 2: in India are thinking on those lines, which is which
[58:22] Speaker 2: in my view is the best possible news. And this
[58:25] Speaker 2: is something a point that I mentioned in one of
[58:27] Speaker 2: our previous episodes is this entire drone revolution for Indian
[58:32] Speaker 2: the Indian military is being almost wholly led by small startups.
[58:37] Speaker 1: It's it's fabulous.
[58:39] Speaker 4: You know.
[58:39] Speaker 2: There are companies that have been started by former former
[58:42] Speaker 2: military personnel together with people from i T and other
[58:46] Speaker 2: institutes who've come together with with small budgets. They've raised
[58:49] Speaker 2: some funding and developed little little core technologies you know,
[58:53] Speaker 2: swarm drones, the other other kinds of uh you know,
[58:57] Speaker 2: autonomous technologies that are very very attuned towards small specific
[59:03] Speaker 2: requirements at the air Force of the Army or the
[59:05] Speaker 2: Navy might actually have. Which is why these logistics drones
[59:08] Speaker 2: that you see deployed in Ladakh are all made in India,
[59:12] Speaker 2: developed in India. The software is made here right here.
[59:15] Speaker 2: None of it comes from abroad. Similarly, I think it's
[59:17] Speaker 2: just a matter of evolution. Now they've for these smaller
[59:22] Speaker 2: drones to become larger, more capable drones, and when you
[59:24] Speaker 2: get when you have companies like the Tatas and Mahindras
[59:27] Speaker 2: and L and T and all getting into this and
[59:31] Speaker 2: or rather being permitted to get into this in a
[59:33] Speaker 2: big sort of combat way. We have all the building
[59:36] Speaker 2: blocks to do that kind.
[59:37] Speaker 1: Of thing ourselves.
[59:38] Speaker 3: Yeah, right, great, I think I will ended their thanks
[59:42] Speaker 3: shift fun chat and you know, we focused the topic
[59:46] Speaker 3: that you know isn't really talked about much when it
[59:49] Speaker 3: comes to matters of defense in India or military equipment,
[59:53] Speaker 3: which is navies fighter fighter jet, Which is why I
[59:56] Speaker 3: want to do you know, just like ask one small
[59:58] Speaker 3: question the end of this episode, how happy do you
[1:00:01] Speaker 3: think the Navy is going to be that you know,
[1:00:03] Speaker 3: the two of us have focused on something that must
[1:00:05] Speaker 3: be a worry for them. Not not a worry person.
[1:00:08] Speaker 3: Like you know, we've kind of talked about how it's
[1:00:10] Speaker 3: like it's it's kind of okay situations not as bad
[1:00:13] Speaker 3: as the Air Force right now where they keep screaming
[1:00:15] Speaker 3: or depleting squads, and but the Navy also has its
[1:00:19] Speaker 3: fair share of problems. It it's fair share of you know,
[1:00:21] Speaker 3: issues they would want highlighted address, they would want the
[1:00:24] Speaker 3: government of the day to focus on. But like you
[1:00:26] Speaker 3: said again, because of this very like you know, small
[1:00:29] Speaker 3: number or just like forty odd fighters, just that it
[1:00:31] Speaker 3: requires co versus like you know, two hundred and three
[1:00:33] Speaker 3: and four hundred. Not much attention is given to this topic.
[1:00:36] Speaker 3: So do you think they'll be happy that the two
[1:00:38] Speaker 3: of us brought this up on the spot.
[1:00:40] Speaker 1: I think they'll be very happy.
[1:00:41] Speaker 2: And I can tell you that one of the consistent
[1:00:43] Speaker 2: pieces of feedback we get for our podcast, and I'm
[1:00:46] Speaker 2: very thankful for this, is is that we are fair.
[1:00:49] Speaker 1: That we are.
[1:00:52] Speaker 2: We are not reluctant to talk about the ship that
[1:00:55] Speaker 2: exists in all of these complicated issues. Uh and uh.
[1:00:59] Speaker 2: And what I like most about the feedback that we get,
[1:01:02] Speaker 2: and I'm sure i'll get this from the Navy, is
[1:01:04] Speaker 2: that we speak with you know, with a sense of
[1:01:08] Speaker 2: national interest. You know, we ask questions and we you know,
[1:01:13] Speaker 2: we go where most people find it uncomfortable because at
[1:01:16] Speaker 2: the end of the day, you know, even in this
[1:01:19] Speaker 2: particular podcast, I think the the ethic with which both
[1:01:22] Speaker 2: of us speak is that we hope the Indian Navy
[1:01:24] Speaker 2: gets what it wants because we acknowledge with each of
[1:01:27] Speaker 2: our episodes that the men and women of our military
[1:01:30] Speaker 2: do a bloody difficult job. You know, both of us
[1:01:33] Speaker 2: are sitting here and talking about it, and I'm giving
[1:01:36] Speaker 2: so much yarn, But it's the people out there, the
[1:01:38] Speaker 2: men and women who are out there having to fly
[1:01:41] Speaker 2: these machines, risk their lives. You know, they've got families
[1:01:45] Speaker 2: at home wondering about their safety while they're out on
[1:01:48] Speaker 2: a deck. They're doing incredible, dangerous, unparalleled things which which
[1:01:55] Speaker 2: most of us can only dream about.
[1:01:56] Speaker 1: So when we ask.
[1:01:58] Speaker 2: Questions about aut safety, about efficacy, about you know, combat strength,
[1:02:04] Speaker 2: about economy, about whether we're getting the best bang for
[1:02:07] Speaker 2: our buck, I like to think that you and me
[1:02:10] Speaker 2: they've speaking for the men and women who are flying
[1:02:13] Speaker 2: those planes out there, and I think that's all we
[1:02:16] Speaker 2: really neat.
[1:02:17] Speaker 3: Yeah, and we'll keep continuing to do that on this
[1:02:19] Speaker 3: on this podcast. So thanks Shift Fun Chat, and thanks
[1:02:22] Speaker 3: to our viewers and listeners as always, and once again,
[1:02:25] Speaker 3: I just I think I should record this and with
[1:02:27] Speaker 3: Treat again because I really really am glad with the
[1:02:29] Speaker 3: comments we get on our YouTube channel and through our
[1:02:31] Speaker 3: messages and email, so keep them coming. A lot of
[1:02:34] Speaker 3: you you also have ideas that you want us to
[1:02:36] Speaker 3: talk about on this on this episode on these episodes
[1:02:38] Speaker 3: that we have, so please send in your comments, Please
[1:02:40] Speaker 3: send in your request, and we'll keep making notes on
[1:02:42] Speaker 3: whenever we get the time. We will definitely talk about
[1:02:44] Speaker 3: what you.
[1:02:44] Speaker 1: Want us to talk about.
[1:02:46] Speaker 4: So that's it.
[1:02:47] Speaker 3: Thanks to our producer and listening as always, that's it
[1:02:49] Speaker 3: for this week's Defense Toes. For more, tune in next week.
[1:02:52] Speaker 3: Till then, stay safe interront of us any boundaries that
[1:02:54] Speaker 3: passport

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
