# How Drones Are Changing Warfare And Why India Needs To Catch Up Fast | In Our Defence, Ep 09

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 1 Feb 2024, 1 h 03 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/58533710/01_feb_24_iod_s2_ep_9_mix_feb_1_128.mp3

We live in an age where drones are everywhere. In this episode, host Dev Goswami and defence expert Shiv Aroor delve into the world of UAVs or UAS, commonly known as drones. These unmanned air systems have played pivotal roles in global events, from the U.S. war on terror to conflicts in Ukraine, Israel-Hamas, and Azerbaijan-Armenia. Despite their ubiquitous presence, popular culture and mainstream defense writing lag in portraying the significance of these non-human aircraft. Why? While India boasts a list of domestically manufactured drones, none are currently in service. The discussion delves into the reasons behind India's delayed adoption and the increasing involvement of private companies in the drone ecosystem. The duo also contemplates the potential takeover of drones by AI, about the elimination of the human loop and the future of drone warfare. What game-changing effects drones can have in military operations? What are the challenges faced by the military in drone usage, including concerns about proliferation and security threats from terrorists and non-state actors. The ultimate question remains: Is drone warfare here to stay, and how will it shape the landscape of future conflicts? Tune in to listen! Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound Mix by Kapil Dev Singh

## Transcript

[0:00] This is India Today podcasts decision making to drones. The reliance on drones for
[0:08] sort of effect based operations will become overwhelming in future wars because it's just going
[0:13] to be impossible to risk human life anymore. We've missed the bus several several
[0:18] times. The reasons for it, I can wager it because I was not
[0:21] a journalist then. But from what my understanding of it is that India simply
[0:26] did not recognize the importance of drone warfare. Once drones came into play in
[0:33] military operations, they overnight changed the game, which is why the Indian government,
[0:38] in order to not miss the bus, they suddenly realize we've not been
[0:41] developing anything by ourselves. We don't even have drone tech. But until then
[0:44] we're completely dependent on important drones, which is a sad, sad thing.
[0:48] Two hundred dollars drone rigged with a grenade the isis losing five guys is no
[0:53] big deal, but that grenade killing two US soldiers is a huge deal.
[0:57] Right. That's what I mean by how these grew can use them as game
[1:00] changers. Hello, and welcome to Another Defense, a weekly podcast on all
[1:04] things well defense, where I they've Goswami, your host, along with senior
[1:11] journalist Shivaru, break down the world of conflicts that range from the subtle to
[1:15] the brute. We bring you nuances and perspectives that will inform and at times
[1:19] provoke. This is in Our Defense. Hello, and welcome to ninth episode
[1:29] of Another Defense this season two. Welcome shift, How are you. How's
[1:32] your week? It's been a very very political weekend. That's all It's going
[1:34] to be until May. The same thing the next few of you months,
[1:38] you know, talking to my dad yesterday about my day, and it's it's
[1:41] just like, you know, as hectic as it can be. And I
[1:42] think it's not going to like, you know, don't soon. I don't
[1:46] think you can describe what it's like really to be an election season until you're
[1:49] in a media, yeah, an organization like ours, especially where it's just
[1:53] completely NonStop. So yeah, absolutely, there's nothing else. I think it's
[1:57] a it's a bit of a bit of a magical process that even this podcast
[2:01] is happening on something apart from politics, So we all should be really thankful
[2:06] for that. Yeah, right, uh, you know, let's dive into
[2:09] our topic of discussion. We've been wanting to talk about this such a long
[2:14] couple of two three episodes now, but something like the other game kept coming
[2:17] up and we kept pushing it. But we'll get to it. Uh.
[2:21] And I think it will be a lot of a lot of interest to people
[2:23] who already watch or listen to our podcast because of the comments that I've I've
[2:28] read over the last couple of episodes that we've done. Last several episodes actually
[2:31] have been to do with this topic, and which is drones. Yea very
[2:36] fascinating piece of technology. Uh and carried a lot of promise when it was
[2:42] when it started slowly getting sort of unveiled general public. But you know I
[2:46] have when I was doing my research, I have like lots of questions about
[2:50] this because I don't fully understand it yet. The industry, what where we
[2:53] are at, where we will be going, where, how did we reach
[2:57] it? Et cetera, et cetera. But before we go into all those
[3:00] aspects, I want to start with a very uh uh funny question. Uh.
[3:05] You know when drones became all the age, they became really popular in
[3:08] popular culture, in social media, et cetera. Uh, there was this
[3:12] meme that started doing the rounds a meme or what you want to call it
[3:15] of people posting whatever and saying that, you know, remember those days when
[3:19] parents used to question their gamer teenage kids, is how will you know gaming
[3:23] help you in the rest of your life? Is going to be anything to
[3:27] do with your career, et cetera. And this is the answer, prone
[3:30] operator, because only doing is sitting over there operating some joystick and using flying
[3:34] something game pad, game pads and you know, flying something thousands of my
[3:37] kilumbus away. So I wanted to ask you a modern day drone operator in
[3:40] whatever air force, whether it's the US Air Posting Air Force or whatever arm
[3:44] you also have drones in the military and the Navy. Is it just like
[3:47] that or can you also compare it to you know, that scene from Casino
[3:52] Royal when James Bond played by Daniel Craig meets the new Quartermaster Q as he's
[3:58] called, and Q says that I can do a lot of damage sitting in
[4:00] my pajamas using just a laptop, and then James Bond asks, then why
[4:04] do you need me? So C response saying sometimes you know, we need
[4:08] to pull a trigger, and James Bond repliesing, or not pull one?
[4:11] For that you need me, yeah, or is it something like that you
[4:15] still need the pilots. I know, so a very overarching question. But
[4:17] first let's tackle that. Yeah. So look, you know, first of
[4:20] all, the even the word drones is slightly problematic because it denotes anything that
[4:28] is an unmanned aircraft, right from your piddly little quad copter drones which you
[4:31] can buy from Amazon or carn market for like three thousand rupees and fly around
[4:36] in your colony without a care in the world, all the way up to
[4:41] you know, predator type drones and predator type drones are like as large as
[4:44] aircraft. Obviously, they're not the same thing. So to call both those
[4:47] things drones is a little ridiculous. But we journalists are guilty of that,
[4:53] and I can tell you that in the in defense journalism especially, anything that
[4:57] flies without a pilot is called a drone. So first all, I'd like
[5:00] to clarify very plainly that these are these are highly highly complicated systems. There
[5:06] is no similarity whatsoever between a small, little, you know, recreational quad
[5:12] copter drone and something like a predator apart from the fact that they're remote controlled.
[5:16] Uh, and even there sometimes that remote control is a little complicated because
[5:20] many of these drones are pre programmable for autonomous flight. Right, So that's
[5:26] one thing. You know, you mentioned game pads and you know, joysticks
[5:29] and things. You'd be surprised they've that many you know, many control stations
[5:33] for even the most advanced drones actually have off the shelf commercial you know,
[5:40] input equipment like PlayStation joysticks. You remember seeing it during that uh, that
[5:46] tragic incident last year with that submersible that went down to the Titanic. The
[5:49] control was Xbox joystick and many people are wondering, oh my god, how
[5:54] horrible is this? But that's actually really really common. Instead of you know,
[5:58] reinventing an input device, simply buy something that's proven and effective and tested
[6:02] off the shelf commercially, and a PlayStation joystick, you'd be surprised, is
[6:06] extremely common in drone. You know, input devices and control systems including I
[6:12] dare say, some of the most advanced drones in the world. So that's
[6:15] one thing. Point number two is that you know, we live in an
[6:18] age where drones are literally everywhere, you know, in all manner of speaking,
[6:24] you know, the drones are used for all kinds of photography, they
[6:27] used in you know, in political rallies, they used extensively in journalism.
[6:30] I have to say that India today, in India at least, we pioneered
[6:33] the use of drones in you know, in camera work. We did that
[6:36] during the twenty fourteen campaign, I remember. And so those are those are
[6:42] drones, right, those are drones. But the kind of drones that I
[6:45] that I think we're going to be focusing on today are ironically not even drones.
[6:49] They actually called you know, either UAVs or UAS. UAS is the
[6:55] is the more accepted abbreviation for such equipment. It basically stands for unmanned air
[7:00] systems. And that is a much more accurate description of what these are,
[7:05] because these are systems. They're not just uh, you know, flying machines
[7:10] that are remote controls. They these are highly highly sophisticated systems. They're highly
[7:16] programmable. Uh. They are capable of incredibly long distance and long endurance flight.
[7:21] Uh. Like you just said, you're taking the example of the Iranian
[7:26] General sole money. They're capable of you know, attack, They're capable of
[7:30] dropping bombs and missiles. So these are in every way not just the future.
[7:33] They're very much. Here. The great thing about uh, you know,
[7:38] and I'm going to use the word drone because we use it generically and
[7:41] it's easier to say than unmanned air systems. So but when I say drones,
[7:44] I'm gonna I'm going to be talking about the military type drones. Uh.
[7:46] They they these are these are basically just aircraft with intelligent brains, non
[7:53] human brains. Uh where you know, somewhere in that control loop, a
[7:57] human can plug himself for herself in as a controller. But let me tell
[8:01] you that the kind of drone technology that's coming into play right now. These
[8:05] are drones that are highly intelligent. They've got artificial intelligence algorithms that gives them
[8:13] a sense of where they need to fly and survey. We've got drones that
[8:16] are coming into India that are now capable of thirty six hours of NonStop flight,
[8:20] which basically means that the operator can program a flight path, go to
[8:24] sleep, and come back the next day and it'll still be circling over the
[8:26] Indian Ocean somewhere, and you know, harvesting huge amounts of map data.
[8:31] So that it may sound futuristic, but that is already there now. And
[8:39] we've may. It may sound weird, but the advanced drone eras actually started
[8:46] a good twenty years ago when predator drones actually came into play and started firing
[8:50] missiles in Afghanistan. So we've a whole generation has passed in the world,
[8:56] you know, under the age of drones. So the next the next step
[9:00] in ron warfare is going to be even more interesting. Right then, explain
[9:03] me something. Why is it that when I was doing my research, I
[9:07] still don't find like you say that rones are almost everywhere. Rones are very
[9:11] much the reality, you know, the revolution started twenty years ago, et
[9:15] cetera. Yeah, but I still sort of see them to be invisible when
[9:18] it comes to the popular culture. When it comes to you know, mainstream
[9:22] defense writing. I know you defense journalists love to talk about rones. You
[9:26] know, in season one we had Abishake on the show. He used to
[9:30] love talking about prones. I've heard several Air Force chiefs or talk about prones.
[9:33] But when I was doing my research, I just found that there's not
[9:37] a lot of information easily available about just the breakup of what kinds of drones
[9:41] are there, who has what? And you know, even if you talk
[9:45] about popular culture in terms of films and cinema. I was a bit surprised
[9:48] when I tried to think of a science fiction movie that depicted rones before the
[9:52] times. You know, you've had them show some of the weird at some
[9:56] of the most futuristic equipment, but some of this one thing was never predict
[10:00] so to speak, by all these science fiction movies. Can you get me
[10:03] a sense of why that's that? Because I just could not wrap my head
[10:05] around that. So so, actually, the Star Wars, the Star Wars
[10:09] films have had you know, uh systems that are analogous to drones for a
[10:13] very long time. Basically, you know, aircraft X wings without pilots.
[10:16] Those are basically unmanned you know, drones. So so I wouldn't agree that
[10:22] they've nobody actually thought of them, They were envisaged. But I'm guessing that
[10:26] what you what you're saying is right in so far as that nobody ever thought
[10:30] of them as a as a separate kind of warfare you know, instrument.
[10:35] So that is definitely true as far as as far as you know, who
[10:39] has what you know that has changed now now now there is a great deal
[10:43] of uh curiosity like yours and mine about you know, who's uh you know,
[10:48] who owns what kind of drones? All countries worth their assault, including
[10:52] India, are involved in developing their own drones. And we'll come to how
[10:56] India is actually very very late on that bus in just a moment. But
[11:01] as all you know, and in and in a very it's very sad because
[11:05] it's a very critical area where India shouldn't have missed the bus, but we
[11:07] did unfortunately, and now we're trying to run to catch up. But I
[11:11] think, like I said, since for the last for the last two decades
[11:15] or so, Uh, the military planners, uh, you know, aerospace
[11:20] engineers, uh, you know, national security specialists are they don't need any
[11:26] more convincing that drones are no longer a luxury item in any war. They're
[11:31] absolutely indispensable. Uh. And when I say indispensable, I mean that,
[11:35] you know, good luck fighting a war if you don't have some kind of
[11:39] drone support somewhere. Now, let's just quickly break down what drones are used
[11:43] for, you know, in a in a typical military operation. And we've
[11:48] got we've got live examples right in front of us. We've got Ukraine,
[11:52] we've got Israel, we've got Armenia versus Azerbaijan. We've got the tension between
[11:58] China and Taiwan as well, So let's look at that. The overwhelming,
[12:03] overwhelming duties taken on by drones at all levels if of military battle, whether
[12:09] it is at the soldier level or whether it is at the battlefield level,
[12:13] is surveillance. It is basically surveillance, surveillance, reconnaissance, intelligence gathering,
[12:18] mapping, keeping an eye. You know. That's the reason why drones are
[12:22] called eyes in the sky, I in the sky. It's basically it gives
[12:24] you a kind of game changing, you know, view of the battlefield or
[12:28] the place where you're fighting, or at the infantry level, if you've got
[12:31] a small little drone which our guys also have now, which you launch to
[12:35] give you a quick video snippet of what's happening on the other side of the
[12:39] hill. That gives you usable real time intelligence about what that threat is.
[12:43] Are you going to go over that hill and run into an enemy or is
[12:46] it going to be safe for you? So it so reconnaissance, intelligence,
[12:50] surveillance is the main overwhelming ninety nine point nine nine percent of all drone operations
[12:56] in the military sphere are about intelligence gathering, surveillance, uh, you know,
[13:01] operations and reconnaissance just to to to give you a give you a fix,
[13:05] a visual fix on what there are there are. There are, of
[13:09] course, many sophisticated drones that are capable of uh, you know, giving
[13:13] you synthetic aperture, radar pictures and stuff. But that's beyond the scope of
[13:16] this discussion. Let's just keep it as visual intelligence of the of your area
[13:20] of battle. Uh. There are of course drones that are capable of maritime
[13:24] surveillance long you know, very very long missions over ocean to keep a tab
[13:30] on, you know, ships and suspicious movements at sea. Uh. That
[13:33] kind of thing can also happen. The very very tiny, minuscule uh percentage
[13:39] of drone operations in military warfare, which you actually saw quite frequently in the
[13:43] Ukraine Russia war is is attacked drones. Now even under attack drones. They've
[13:50] There are two kinds. There's one thing called a suicide drone or a kamakazi
[13:54] drone, which is basically it's basically a small little aircraft which which you can
[14:00] control remotely, fly it to your target and then smash it into that target.
[14:05] So it's basically like a loitering little aircraft which contains a warhead in it.
[14:09] So it's called a suicide drone because the entire drone smashes into its target
[14:15] in order to try and destroy it. The other is called a hunter killer
[14:18] drone, which is what the Predator family of drones is basically. Now,
[14:22] the Predator is a drone which is basically like a large aircraft. Now,
[14:26] you know, in pictures, people like to imagine the Predator is this small
[14:28] little thing because that looks small, it looks compact. It's a big,
[14:33] big aircraft. It's a big aircraft sized machine. Right if you look it
[14:37] up on Google, look at look at pictures off predators at their bases and
[14:43] you can see that there, you know, controllers and maintenance engineers standing next
[14:46] to them. You get a sense of how big they did it are.
[14:48] They're huge machines, okay. And those are hunter killer or you know,
[14:52] unmanned combat aerial vehicles because they don't crash into the target. They drop bombs
[14:56] of fire missiles into the target. So they're basically like strike aircraft without a
[15:00] pilot. So those are the two kinds of things that I used in offensive
[15:03] operations where drones are concerned the future of drone operations in the military sphere.
[15:09] They've will be of two kinds. There's something called swarm drones, where many
[15:15] different drones can come together with a similar kind of objective sharing information in a
[15:20] kind of in a kind of neural network of drones, which is very very
[15:24] exciting for military planners because it allows them to use many low cost drones to
[15:30] you know, to affect something much larger. The second is something called unmanned
[15:33] teaming. Unmanned teaming is an even more interesting that's something that excites me even
[15:39] more. And this actually, you know, came up in a movie called
[15:43] Stealth. I don't know if you've seen it. It was a movie that
[15:45] was widely panned because the acting was so bad, but it happens to be
[15:50] one of my favorite films because it's like one of those so bad, it's
[15:52] good films that was made in the United States. Absolutely fabulous because it was
[15:56] a movie about an unmanned aircraft that kind of turns rogue against its makers,
[16:02] like a Frankenstein drone, right, But in that the beautiful part about that
[16:07] is it it kind of foresaw a technology that has become very real now,
[16:11] and it's called manned unmanned teeming, which is that if I'm flying a fighter,
[16:15] I'm flying a fighter aircraft, I can launch a drone either from the
[16:19] ground or from my aircraft, which is which is like an advanced drone that
[16:23] may even look like my fighter. So I'm flying a fighter as a human
[16:27] and there's a drone flying alongside me, and I am not only controlling that
[16:32] fighter, but I'm getting that drone to also do some side missions for me.
[16:36] If I see a threat a few kilometers argue, I can get the
[16:40] drone instead of risking me and my aircraft, I'll get the drone to go
[16:42] and check it out to see whether they have actually, you know, anything
[16:45] credible in terms of surface to air missiles or radiar cover, whatever it is.
[16:49] So get that drone to do some of the more dangerous sort of dirty
[16:53] work, and you know, and you use that to fine tune my targeting
[16:59] and my operation. So it's absolutely amazing. And you can program that drone
[17:03] to do something on its own. Say, you know, give me a
[17:06] six radio six kilometer radius protection. Anything you see moving in six kilometer radios
[17:11] using a radar alert me. So you know, you can get it to
[17:14] do that because you don't have the As a human, you can't do it.
[17:17] But as a machine, it has the ability to look three sixty degrees
[17:19] all the time. So these are fabulous, uh you know, capabilities that
[17:25] drones are going to have in the future. They're kind of scary, you
[17:26] know, people who people who buy into the whole sky in it and terminator
[17:30] kind of psychology like and if you're like me, you know you think the
[17:34] world is definitely heading in that direction that you know, technology is going to
[17:38] turn on us at some point of time. Uh, you know, these
[17:41] are these are these are kind of troubling things with ethical concerns also. But
[17:45] but I can tell you that millions and billions of dollars are being spent into
[17:49] making unmanned air systems more intelligent, more capable, longer endurance, more lethal,
[17:56] uh you know, more evasive, more stealthy, more invisible to radar.
[18:00] So that's the way it's headed. Yeah, you know before lovely insight
[18:03] and you know, thanks for letting us know that you are the believer of
[18:07] you know, he is going to take over the world's kind of is gonna
[18:10] go live and then joke, I am not Frank, But I think we
[18:15] can do a several episode on that sometimes else. Uh, no shift before
[18:18] we come to where we're at in terms of what does India have, And
[18:22] like you said, we'll obviously talk about the delay in India hopping on the
[18:25] bandwagon of developing and making its own rooms, etcetera, systems, et cetera.
[18:29] Uh, this is a quick segue to the counterparts in the in the
[18:33] navy and on the land. So obviously land drones don't really go together if
[18:38] you think of drones as only UAVs. But like Shi mentioned, if we
[18:42] think of drones as sort of automated sort of equipment that can be operated by
[18:48] a soldier or an officer at a base or somewhere far away, what's the
[18:52] picture like in the ocean there, I know we definitely have a lot of
[18:56] you know, unmanned underwater vehicles. There are several submarines. The one tightened
[19:00] that to describe the propulsion has done from someplace else. Similarly, I think
[19:04] on the land we have some at least equipment used by bomb disposal squads where
[19:08] they send sort of a robot to check on an object instead of sending a
[19:12] human being to see if it's kind of okay for a human being to then
[19:15] approach and finally verify what's what's going on. Similarly, I think there was,
[19:19] if I'm not wrong, some sort of similar robotic thing for an infantry
[19:23] division to send into a into a house right to see what's there, and
[19:27] then you know, relay that information back and then these guys go in.
[19:32] Similarly, I think some of the dog squads where some sort of AUTOMATEDID systems
[19:36] to relay again pictures and images back to the base again to help decision making.
[19:40] Can you give us a picture of what's the situation? Like? So,
[19:42] see drones specifically denotes air systems, so we can't use the word drones
[19:48] for you know, land and undersea equipment. But like you're absolutely right that
[19:52] the funda is basically the same. It's a remote controlled or autonomous piece of
[19:56] equipment that you know, that does its job as it's told. Now,
[20:00] it's a very interesting question because it's also extremely crucial the mini unmanned submarines that
[20:06] are used for surveillance and you know, detecting mines and basically harbor reconnaissance,
[20:12] et cetera. Those are called autonomous underwater vehicles AUVs. Now, India does
[20:18] have these. India builds them in the private sector as well as the DRDO
[20:22] makes them themselves. In fact, just a couple of years ago they began
[20:26] induction into the Indian Navy. And the Indian Navy needs hundreds of these because
[20:30] we've got such a vast coastline. Uh. You know, if you're if
[20:33] you're able to have a kind of a network of autonomous underwater vehicles that are
[20:38] just constantly on surveillance duty along our coastline, in our harbors and our ports.
[20:44] Uh, it it takes the pressure of manned surveillance by the Coast Guard
[20:48] and others to a large extent. So those those things are happening, much
[20:52] more needs to be done. Uh. In terms of the Indian Navy has
[20:56] been in the market for unmanned boats as well. Israel is one of the
[21:03] pioneers in the in the in the manufacturer and development of these mini unmanned boats.
[21:10] They look very much like fast patrol craft that are used by by the
[21:12] coast Guard for interception and stuff interceptor you know, motor boats, but they're
[21:17] completely unmanned and they'll have a machine gun on them, so they completely so
[21:21] these can be controlled from a mother ship, like a mothership, which is
[21:23] like a warship, like a coast gard ship or a naval ship. They
[21:26] can deploy these unmanned boats to go. They'll have you know, go pro
[21:30] cameras on them, they've got a machine gun on them, with a with
[21:33] an auto targeter, you know, all the equipment, and there will be
[21:36] a guy sitting on a warship with a with a console with the camera feed,
[21:40] with the remote control, probably a PlayStation GamePad as well, and actually
[21:44] doing that work. So these kinds of things can become very useful if you're
[21:48] approaching a suspicious ship, if there's a piracy incident and you don't want to
[21:52] risk your and we've seen the Indian Navy conducting manned operations on you know,
[21:56] pirate vessels a lot in the last few days. But these unmanned ships,
[22:00] unmanned boats are something that Israel had developed in a large part because they saw
[22:04] that threat coming in from the sea, the possibility of seaborn terror, you
[22:07] know, attacks and stuff, and that's why they developed those on land.
[22:11] You're absolutely right, whether it is a bomb disposal, whether it is you
[22:15] know, reconnaissance inside a built up area to make sure there's no terrorists inside.
[22:19] The DRDO has, you know, unlike many of its other laboratories,
[22:22] has a very successful robotics laboratory that has built these modular robots. There's one
[22:29] called the Ducks, which is a bomb disposal robot. There's another infantry robot
[22:33] which is actually armed with machine guns and a rocket launcher. Those are already
[22:37] in service. Happy to tell you that there's something called a stair climbing robot.
[22:42] They specifically created this thing called a stair climbing robot, which is capable
[22:47] of you know, navigating steep stairs and it's also got cameras and stuff.
[22:52] And this was particularly because there was a high degree of casualties of soldiers when
[22:56] they were conducting house searches in parts of Kashmir. So that's why they had
[23:02] told the d ADO, we need a robot that can climb stairs, because
[23:04] the robots we have right now, we can send them into a house,
[23:07] but they can't go upstairs. It's and and going upstairs is where the greatest
[23:11] vulnerability lies because you're going up and the person standing on the top has all
[23:15] the advantage. They see you coming up, and they and they kill you,
[23:17] So, like an untold number of casualties used to happen in the army
[23:21] and the CRP of et cetera during house searches because the terrorists would be hiding
[23:25] on the top floor of a house that they'd taken over in some village.
[23:26] So so those those robots have also already come online. Apart from them unmanned
[23:33] you know, unmanned mini tanks, there's one called the Muntra which the which
[23:37] the DRDO has developed, which is basically a remote controlled, remote controlled infantry
[23:42] vehicle, a very small infantry vehicle which which could be used in a kind
[23:48] of nuclear biological scenario if there is a meltdown or a you know, a
[23:52] germ warfare or biological warfare. Uh. These are remote controlled vehicles, armored
[23:57] vehicles that could go into the battle, rescue people, or conduct any kind
[24:02] of surveillance. So so you know the possibilities of remote control equipment are endless.
[24:07] But the complexity is in the actual systems there because you know, you
[24:12] know, one might think that building a drone, you know, how how
[24:15] complicated can can it actually be. It's a simple piece of equipment if you
[24:19] can buy, if you can build a fighter aircraft, you can most certainly
[24:22] build a drone, but the whole challenge is there is no human in that
[24:26] loop. You know, in the active loop, there is no human.
[24:30] The human is sitting far away, you know, controlling controlling the drone.
[24:33] There are systems onboard drones which need to be perfected, the satellite link.
[24:38] Remember that these are not line of sight systems. You know, if you
[24:44] had a system that was line of sight, which means that you know,
[24:45] from where I'm sitting, I can see the drone and therefore control it by
[24:48] a you know, a ray of light using my controller. Most drones are
[24:52] not line of sight. They're going to be traveling tens of hundreds of possibly
[24:56] thousands of kilometers away from where you're controlling them, which means your satellite link,
[25:00] your you know, communication linkages and devices need to be absolutely perfect because
[25:06] you need to control that damn thing in real time. They can't be a
[25:08] huge delay in what you're doing. Secondly, if you if you want your
[25:12] drones to be autonomous, you know how much autonomy are going to give your
[25:17] drones? Are you going to give your drones the ability to detect and strike
[25:22] That has never happened so far, autonomy for strike has never been provided to
[25:26] drones. There's always human override. A person launching a missile is never a
[25:30] drone. It's always a human right. But going into the future, like
[25:33] for example, right now, the Indian Navy has two leased m Q nine
[25:38] Sea Guardian drones which have been leased from the United States, which operate out
[25:42] of an air base called Araconum which is on the coast of Tamal Ladu.
[25:47] Now, these are predator type drones that are capable of you know, twenty
[25:51] four to forty eight hours flight, NonStop flight over ocean. These can be
[25:55] programmed and I've seen those control stations, I've seen those algorithms. They can
[25:59] be they can be programmed to with such precision. There they can you can
[26:04] say, I can I can send one of those drones out and say I
[26:07] want you to go and fly around the Anderman Islands for the next fifteen hours,
[26:15] and I only want you to send me a notification if you see anything
[26:18] suspicious a minimum of six kilometers off the coast of the islands, and whatever
[26:23] you spot needs to be at least ten meters long. So by giving that
[26:30] stipulation, it won't bother about fishing boats and stuff, but anything bigger than
[26:33] that, it'll it'll alert me saying okay, here's this and that. That's
[26:38] what those cameras are programmable for. You can you can literally tell it.
[26:42] So if you see anything white, let me know. If you see anything
[26:48] you know that's that you can feed in pictures of certain ships, saying,
[26:52] head out here, here's a reference image of what I'm looking for. Let
[26:56] me know if you see anything like this. So you you know there's a
[27:00] suspicious Chinese vessel somewhere and you've got this grainy Google image of it, feed
[27:04] that picture into the data set. Tell the drone okay, take off,
[27:07] please and report back to me if you see anything like this in this designated
[27:11] zone that I'm asking you to fly in, and it will do that.
[27:15] And there are algorithms and there are software updates that are coming where drones are
[27:19] capable of doing that. And that basically means you're adding more and more layers
[27:23] of decision making to drones. You're giving them, you know, you're giving
[27:27] them mission objectives, and these things will become more and more and more and
[27:32] more narrow, you know, the reliance on drones for you know, sort
[27:36] of effect based operations, as it's called, will become will will become overwhelming
[27:41] in future wars because it's just going to be impossible to risk human life anymore.
[27:48] In a small conflict, you know, forget about in Ukraine and versus
[27:52] Russia, you saw the use of a lot of Kamakazi drones, the suicide
[27:56] rones that I was talking about, huge numbers, hundreds were used to destroy
[28:00] tanks and stuff like that. Even in a tiny little conflict like the Azerbaijan
[28:03] Armenia conflict, you saw drones being used to devastating effect. You know,
[28:10] the the the the Azerbaijan army was using uh you know, targeted Kamakazi drones
[28:15] to destroy Armenian Armenian uh you know, radar trucks and sensor trucks and things
[28:22] like that. So imagine like just imagine the the the the huge game changing
[28:29] effect that a tiny little drone can have. Imagine having like this huge,
[28:33] multi million dollar surface to air missile system deployed somewhere in in in Pakistani Punjab.
[28:41] Okay, they've got this massive They've spent millions of dollars acquiring this Chinese
[28:47] state of the art, you know, air defense system and they're like bragging
[28:52] about it on social media and everywhere, saying that you know, now you
[28:55] can't do you guys can't touch us, and you know you guys can't do
[28:56] shit. And it's you know now with you know, our airspace is impregnable.
[29:02] Blah blah blah. Now all India would need to do. And now,
[29:06] of course I'm oversimplifying it, but I'm just saying that millions of dollars
[29:08] worth of equipment, a twenty five thousand dollars drone Kamakazi drone like the Harrop
[29:15] which we have in operation here in India, which we bought from Israel,
[29:18] with the right amount of intelligence, with the right amount of coordinates and data
[29:22] and targeting information, a twenty five thousand dollars drone can go and destroy millions
[29:27] of dollars worth of sensor equipment and completely switch off an air defense shield that
[29:33] a country may claim to have. I'm just saying India and Pakistan because it's
[29:37] emotive and we love Pakistan so much. But I'm just saying that the reason
[29:41] why the drones become these massive game changers is because they are inherently cheap.
[29:47] I'm talking about this, I'm talking about the suicide drones, which actually do
[29:51] the dirty work of attacking and you know, destroying equipment. They are cheap
[29:55] to operate, they are cheap to develop, they're cheap to maintain, they're
[29:57] cheap to store. They are small. You cannot detect them using satellites.
[30:03] They can be fired from a truck. They can be fired from a field,
[30:06] they can be fired from a house terrace. They can be used,
[30:08] fired and operated from literally anywhere. And that's why it's become such a huge
[30:12] menace also, these suicide drones. So so yeah, so drone warfare is
[30:17] here to stay. It's going to become more much more precise. I see
[30:22] more, you know, I see more intelligence being given to drones to take
[30:27] their own decisions. But but you know, I'm one of those people who
[30:33] who always believes in erring on the side of caution as far as technology is
[30:37] concerned, because these are these are machines that are being bestowed with life and
[30:44] death powers. And you know, going forward, that's exactly the appetite for
[30:48] human loss will come down. The appetite for human loss is something that governments
[30:53] will find hard to sell to their people and to their domestic audiences. After
[30:59] after Operation Enduring Freedom, the post nine to eleven phase, after COVID and
[31:03] all these things and on these wars, especially governments I believe, will find
[31:07] it very difficult to justify sending people into war in the future. And that's
[31:11] the reason why all these machines that you've just mentioned, they've will come into
[31:15] play. Fascinating, I think, just fascinating and just very cool look into
[31:21] the kind of equipment that already exists. Not forget the futuristic part that she
[31:26] was talking about. So yeah, let's move our focus a bit back to
[31:30] the air and to the current status of what we have. A lot of
[31:34] it that's an operation is real has given us, not given us, sorry,
[31:38] we bought from it. Actually all of it. All of it,
[31:41] Yeah, apart if you unless you want to count the deal for the most
[31:45] advanced version of the data that's I think under negotiation is still in progress,
[31:48] so we have to go one. Yeah, but I more or less it
[31:52] mostly should happen if nothing goes wrong, correct. But I was also looking
[31:56] at what we are doing internally, and I have a long list, by
[32:00] the way, a lot of it being done by the dr do in in
[32:04] in partnership with several private companies long list, but all under development. So
[32:09] there are multiple strands over which I'd like to you to tell us more about.
[32:15] One is, like you mentioned at the beginning of this episode, why
[32:17] did it take us so long to start, uh looking at building our own
[32:22] drone systems? Uh. Second, I have gotten this sense that the private
[32:27] sector is hugely involved in drone manufacturing, unlike let's say the other equipment that
[32:31] we operate, whether it's fighter jet, missiles, etcetera, and not just
[32:36] a private sector. A lot of young startups, small companies. You've not
[32:38] even heard of the list I have, for example, that the dr DO
[32:42] has partnered with. I don't even know those companies. Uh, you know
[32:44] most some Bangalore based, some Mumbai based, and am based. In fact,
[32:47] if you remember last year, there was during the day before this,
[32:51] there was a nice, very lovely drone show swarm drones display, beautiful to
[32:57] watch. Uh. This was I think the beating themony a few days of
[33:00] the public day, very beautiful images and that was by a young startup from
[33:05] I think, if I'm not wrong, Benuel. Yeah, So these two
[33:07] strands, one what took us so long? And second, how is it?
[33:10] And is it a good thing that you have all these young startups all
[33:14] over the place, you know, coming in in this industry. So so
[33:16] the bad I'll start with the bad news first because I like to get that
[33:20] out of the way. Uh. And it and the truth needs to be
[33:22] told. We've missed the bus several several times on as far as drone technology
[33:28] is concerned. The reasons for it, I can I can wager it because
[33:31] I was not a journalist then. But from what my understanding of it is,
[33:36] they've that that India simply did not recognize. And when I say India,
[33:40] I mean the system, I mean the Ministry of Defense, I mean
[33:43] the Air Force, I mean the military at large didn't recognize the importance of
[33:49] drone warfare. It was it was viewed as a possibly a luxury item,
[33:53] you know, something you can do with, do without if push comes to
[33:57] shove. Uh. But it totally missed the simple fact that once once drones
[34:05] came into play in military operations, they overnight, overnight changed the game.
[34:12] And once they changed the game, the developments of drones, their advancements and
[34:17] their sort of pervasive nature in warfare was so rapid that it was like it
[34:22] was like a blaze and by which time India had kind of missed that bus.
[34:27] Now we're talking about a Postcargill kind of era, because Postcargill is when
[34:32] India kind of kind of woke up from a semi slumber as far as military
[34:37] equipment was concerned, and decided it needed to do all these things that need
[34:42] to restructure, it needed to do self reliance. The Cargill Review Committee,
[34:45] and you know, it's almost like before the Cargill War, we had no
[34:50] idea what was going on, and Postcargill, finally we woke up and decided,
[34:52] okay, we've not been doing these things. Now, drones became a
[34:57] kind of reality in the early tow thousands, uh, which is why the
[35:02] Indian government, in order to not miss the bus, they suddenly realized,
[35:07] we've not been developing anything by ourselves. You know, we we don't even
[35:09] know we don't even have drone tech. We India had just started flight testing
[35:15] the Tagus manned fighter aircraft. So drones were a far cry from anything that
[35:20] was in the you know, on the drawing board for our scientists. So
[35:23] I'm not their fault. This is a like I said, nobody is to
[35:28] know, no individualists to blame. This was like a system failure for not
[35:31] recognizing the importance that drones were going to uh, you know, embrace in
[35:35] the in just a matter of a few years. They were going to be
[35:37] the dominant technology. UH. So UH, India always does what UH it
[35:45] the the only thing it can do in such a situation, which is to
[35:46] buy from abroad. UH. And at that point of time, thankfully,
[35:51] UH, Israel UH had been a very good friend of India through the Cargile
[35:55] War. Israel had provided us with you know, precision weapons that were used
[36:00] in the Tiger Hill bombings, et cetera. And so that relationship between India
[36:04] and Israel on the military front was extremely strong, and that's why India was
[36:08] able to quickly procure some drones from Israel. These were pretty rudimentary drones.
[36:14] There were the Heron and the Searcher Mark two drones still very much in operation,
[36:17] by the way, all these years later, they're still being operated.
[36:21] Very trusty, good workhouse drones, but fairly basic. Parallel to this,
[36:25] India decided, yes, we need a drone program of our own, so
[36:29] let's start developing our own drones. So they had one drone program the initial
[36:34] drone program called the Nishanth. Now, the Nishanth was a drone very much
[36:37] like the Searcher, small, not very big, not very capable, but
[36:42] a kind of easy drone to operate the problem with the Nishanth drone was that
[36:46] it was it was a rail launched drone, so you needed a rail launcher
[36:51] for it instead of a runway like the other drones. And therefore it had
[36:55] a very short short stint in the Army. The arm he just kind of,
[37:00] you know, despite some advantages it may have had, which is to
[37:05] be launched and recovered from wherever it is, the Army said, this is
[37:07] not what we want. We want a takeoff and landing type drone system.
[37:12] So the Nishanth was shelved. Then the DRDO began. The Air Force,
[37:16] Navy and the Army basically came together and told the drd you, look,
[37:19] we want, you know, if you're going to be developing a drone's let's
[37:23] aim for the Moon. Develop something big and capable for us that's capable of,
[37:29] you know, twenty four hours of NonStop flight, long distance surveillance,
[37:34] long endurance, medium altitude, high altitude flight. You know that we can
[37:38] do instead of these, you know, piddly little drones that you want to
[37:40] make for us. So they started developing something called the Tappas. It was
[37:45] called the ROOSTERM, initially named after a famous scientist in the DRDO, but
[37:50] they renamed it Tappas for whatever reason. The Tapas development went on for many
[37:55] years. Some of them crashed during development, but it seemed to be a
[38:00] very promising platform. It was a it was a it was a pretty basic
[38:05] twin engined unmanned aircraft capable of a long distance flight, et cetera. But
[38:09] for some reason, and this was just recently, just a couple of months
[38:13] ago, the know in a in a in a move that kind of surprised
[38:16] me but also didn't surprise me, the Indian military said, we don't want
[38:21] it, Okay, we don't want this done because UH. And the inside
[38:24] story of that is that the DRDO apparently UH rejected or ignored many design changes,
[38:35] weight related issue concerns and other concerns that the military had been constantly in
[38:39] putting on the program right through its development phase. To cut a long story
[38:45] short, the Tapas is now no longer a you know, a mission mode
[38:49] program, a mission mode program means something that's been developed in a timely manner
[38:52] with a stated objective and mission. Right, So so the military has shut
[38:57] its doors on the Tapas, so crows of piece down the drain in terms
[39:00] of nothing is a waste in military development in my view, but in so
[39:05] far as something that should have been delivered by now that that money is evaporated.
[39:09] So the Tapas program story is over at least four now, though my
[39:15] sources tell me it's still being developed using internal money of the DRDO and hopefully
[39:19] they'll meet those criteria a little later on. Now things switch to something called
[39:23] the Archer. There's an Archer drone which the Indian labs are now developing,
[39:30] which is a kind of It looks very much like the Heron. So now
[39:34] there's a kind of debate going on online especially, but we've come this far
[39:37] just to copy the Heron. We should have done this in the first place,
[39:42] because it was a tried and testine design, et cetera, et cetera.
[39:44] There's one section that claims this has nothing to do with the Heron.
[39:46] You know, it's a completely indigenous Indian design made in India, blah blah
[39:51] blah. But there are those who say, come on, man, just
[39:52] look at these two things together. They look exactly like it's the same kind
[39:55] of aerodynamics, et cetera, et cetera. And if you use your comments,
[40:00] it does look like there. And so it's quite likely that's at least
[40:02] inspired by that. But that's a low risk option. At least you're going
[40:05] with a design that is already tried and tested. So now the military is
[40:10] kind of depending on this thing called the Archer NGI New Generation, which is
[40:15] a drone that will come online. But we still don't have any strike drones.
[40:20] We don't have any offensive drones. Now. That is where the US
[40:23] deal comes into play. So thirty one Sea Guardian and Sky Guardian drones,
[40:28] which are basically highly advanced, souped up versions of the Predator, capable of
[40:32] maritime surveillance, capable of carrying missiles and weapons. You know, whenever that
[40:37] happens, that will happen. We love to see when that happens. But
[40:40] very interestingly, something that happened just a few days ago again is that the
[40:45] Adani group has just handed over the first of four Hermes nine hundred long long
[40:53] distance surveillance drones to the Indian Navy. There's going to be two for the
[40:57] Navy and two for the army. These are, once again ironic Israeli drones
[41:01] assembled by the Adani Group in Telangana. So these are going to be called
[41:05] made in India drones. But these are not Indian drones by any stretch.
[41:07] The tech, the materials, it's all you know from Israel, and they've
[41:12] got to be handed over and up to one hundred more of these drones could
[41:15] also potentially be ordered right now. Perhaps it's a little politically sensitive to order
[41:21] one hundred rones from the Adani Group, So maybe this small, little limited
[41:23] order is just to test the waters, et cetera. Election neeer blah blah
[41:27] blah. So so those drones are also coming online. But then again those
[41:30] are not Indian drones. They're only assembled in India. I'm not belittling that
[41:35] even assembly means hundreds of jobs, but it's not an Indian Indian drone.
[41:39] So so so look at it. So look at the the drone fleet overview
[41:45] they've it. This is what it looks like. It looks like this.
[41:47] You've got an old fleet of Heron and searcher marked two drones. You've got
[41:52] two leased NQ nine Sea Guardian rones that are operated by the Navy that will
[41:58] go back once the new ones arriving. You you've got the Hermes nine hundred
[42:02] Israeli drones that are joining up. Now you've got the MQ nine thirty one
[42:07] of which which will come from the United States. So you have an you
[42:10] have a one hundred percent imported you know, non Indian drone fleet at the
[42:19] advanced level. Okay, at the advanced level, all your drones are basically
[42:22] of a foreign make until the archer that I was just speaking about, when
[42:25] that is ready, when it gets manufactured. But until then we're completely dependent
[42:30] on imported drones, which is a sad, sad thing. And if you
[42:34] look at our neighborhood, Iran has its own drones, Turkey has its own
[42:37] drones. Pakistan claims to have its own drones, though they're all Chinese.
[42:40] China has built a vast fleet of drones of their own. Some of them
[42:45] are very credible, including drones that are capable of firing weapons. I saw
[42:49] some of those at the Paris Air Show and they're very impressive machines. We
[42:52] can we can talk till the cows come home about the quality of Chinese equipment,
[42:57] and that is a real argument to make. But the fact is they've
[43:00] made equipment that they're able to export to other countries, which India has not
[43:02] as far as drones is concerned. Now, you know, you mentioned something
[43:07] very very important and I want to touch upon that Day've you talked about how
[43:10] there was that spectacular swarm drone show at a beating retreat ceremony. Now,
[43:15] the private sector startups and companies that are making these small tactical drones that are
[43:22] for very very you know, very targeted specific missions. There are plenty of
[43:28] those that startup. Ecosystem is actually flourishing right now. It's blossomed and it's
[43:32] flourishing right now. They are not only doing great work, they are being
[43:38] given contracts by the Army. The reason also is because it's easier to buy
[43:44] small tactical drones because the value of those deals is small. The financial powers
[43:47] that the Army has, especially in light of the military standard with China,
[43:52] to make quick emergency orders of small, small value deals of equipment are easy
[43:58] to do. That's why between twenty twenty and now, a whole plethora of
[44:00] deals have been signed by the Army and Air force with the startup companies to
[44:06] provide them with the you know, a few crowsworth of these drones. So
[44:08] whether it is hand launched drones you know, like the Swift that I used
[44:13] in Ladakh. You know, they're literally just hand launched drones, you know,
[44:16] for surveillance, to these heavy duty quad cropter drones which are capable of
[44:22] carrying fifty kilograms of cargo, you know, for high altitude areas. They're
[44:28] actually being used to carry hot meals to soldiers in high altitudes. So no
[44:32] longer no more risky helicopter flights to ferry equipment, medicines, food. They're
[44:37] using these drones as the workhouse. It's happening in a brilliant way. Already
[44:40] in Ladakh you've got drones that are conducting surveillance from ships. The navies bought
[44:46] these India and these are all private sector manufactured and developed drones made in India.
[44:51] Equipment completely made over here. Now when it comes to swarm drones,
[44:55] the game changes a little bit. There's a company called news Space, which
[45:00] is run by a former Air Force officer. I think that's the company you
[45:02] were talking about from Bengaluru. They their tech they've is not just the drones.
[45:07] It's the technology and the software that goes into the drones that because building
[45:13] an actual drone is is very very rudimentary technology. That's the reason why you
[45:17] can pick up a drone for three thousand rupees in car market. Because the
[45:21] tech itself. Any any kid in college or an iet can build a drone.
[45:24] It's no big deal. But it's what you put into the drones brain
[45:28] that matters. It's the software, it's the censors, it's the communication links,
[45:32] it's the algorithms that you're putting into the drones that allows them to speak
[45:37] to each other, you know, become part of a drone neural network,
[45:40] take joint decisions, you know, conduct you know, conduct coordinated operations.
[45:46] You know, be able to be able to distribute objectives between like fifteen drones
[45:52] that you send out for one objective, you know, maybe some drones will
[45:57] fall back, letting the other drones go ahead. That's what what swarm operations
[46:00] is. The swarm operations is basically saying, look, I don't have one
[46:04] big advance drone to do this, but if I have fifteen to sixteen smaller
[46:07] drones that are going to pool their resources, pool their computing power, their
[46:13] pool, their the strength of their cameras and their visual equipment and sensors.
[46:17] Then it actually becomes one big kind of moving machine. And I'm repeating the
[46:23] word neural network because that's exactly what this is. That's what scientists are trying
[46:28] to do to give militaries the flexibility to to have this kind of low cost
[46:34] swarm warfare where they can send out fifteen drones, you know, hunt for
[46:39] very simplistic example, send out fifteen drones talking to each other, sharing information,
[46:45] you know, and adjusting their flight parts according to the information that they
[46:49] have based on their objective, and then figuring out which one of them is
[46:52] going to go and actually you know, conduct the attack. Maybe not all
[46:55] fifteen will go, maybe maybe two or three, and that will be a
[46:59] joint decision by all the drones together. That's what swarm warfare is. That's
[47:02] like one of thousands of possible examples. It could be a it could be
[47:07] a it could be a rescue mission, it could be humanitarian relief. It
[47:12] could be you know, sending uh sending a swarm of drones out to search
[47:15] for lost people at sea. It could be anything, but it's just it's
[47:20] just one way of using intelligent, smaller machines, you know, for a
[47:24] much larger effect. So all of this is going to happen. The the
[47:28] the the bad news front for India is on the advanced drone level. On
[47:34] the advanced drone level, you know, I feel like crying. There's a
[47:37] lot to cry about because having missed that bus, the you know, the
[47:40] the constant effort to catch up is is is uh you know, is a
[47:45] is a road filled with bad news because this technology is moving so fast.
[47:50] This bus is not stopping for you, right and you're spending money and money
[47:53] and money developing something but then it's already obsolete. But these amazing startups in
[48:00] Guru either a bad Delhi elsewhere, that stuff they're doing, that is the
[48:02] cutting edge. That is where it's at. That is at a level that
[48:07] you know, countries around the world are conducting research and and that's the reason
[48:10] why companies like Boeing and Lockheed Martin have huge R and D centers here because
[48:15] they want to plug into that that startup ecosystem because they realize, hey,
[48:21] Indian guys, software, this can't go wrong. They one hundred percent will
[48:24] do something that either we can't do or will do it at like one hundred
[48:29] the cost without sinking millions of dollars into R and D, and they'll know
[48:34] how to execute it, you know, without too much of us. So,
[48:37] so everyone wants a piece of India's you know, drone startup ecosystem,
[48:42] the you know, the functional drones, the swarm drones, the effect based
[48:46] operations, you know, drone architecture, all of that is going to be
[48:51] a very very big thing going for. Yeah, once again fascinated with your
[48:54] answer and what you what you described that, you know, the last party
[48:58] that you said also kind of takes me back to our previous episode of Making
[49:01] India, and it's got to be thinking that if perhaps the system and the
[49:06] military had empowered startups or private companies back then in the sixties, with the
[49:10] advanced weaponry that we spoke about in the previous episode, perhaps that thing would
[49:15] have been a different picture. Because I'm pretty sure this startup because system that
[49:17] we kind of empowering by the Indian force I think has been has been holding
[49:21] a drone competition they do for these guys for to identify the best talent.
[49:25] So if stuff like that was happening back then, perhaps a picture with our
[49:30] legacy systems would perhaps not have been what it was. We moved a bit
[49:34] too now the challenges posed by drones and drone warfare. But after a quick
[49:38] break, eat eggs, no eat fiber, sleep, no take short naps,
[49:49] don't listen to others, no serve others. Do you ever feel like
[49:52] you're drowning in a pool of advice? This is Sonali, a charge our
[49:59] health journal for the last ten years, who is equally fed up of lines
[50:04] like ten ways to stay fit. So join me in the podcast Health Wealth,
[50:07] as we learn about health from a completely new perspective, where investing in
[50:13] yourself is not a task but simple, satisfying and joyful. Full episodes are
[50:19] available on Apple, Google, Spotify, and the India Today podcast website.
[50:23] Tune in now right, welcome back, our producer, and I just told
[50:35] us shift that you know, we spoke too long in the first half,
[50:37] perhaps a testament rolling on and rolling on nice, But perhaps it's because the
[50:43] topic itself is so fascinating, at least for me, and I'm really hoping
[50:46] it will also be for our viewers and listeners. We've spoken for thing about
[50:50] forty five minutes. Now you should be take a breaker out of twenty minutes
[50:52] anyway. So I think we've more or less SHIV has given us a very
[50:57] nice and vivid description of what drones are currently able to do and what he
[51:00] forces they will be able to do in the near future. UH, and
[51:04] also a picture of where India's throne abilities lie and the severe lack of the
[51:10] advanced combat drone. We have a lot of young, promising startups giving us
[51:15] all sorts of drones for the other task. But there's you know, surveillance
[51:20] like you said, transporting, transporting good sense to stuff like that. But
[51:23] the combat drone like the Predator, which can you know, travel and shoot
[51:28] missiles and take down targets, that is missing, and we are still banking
[51:30] on the US to give us one. UH. I want to focus a
[51:35] bit on the challenges being posed by this new age of drones UH. And
[51:39] there are two threads over One is the training challenges UH, because the way
[51:45] I see it, you've always had your equipment being upgraded in incremental amounts.
[51:51] Right your you have one missile, Your next missile is an advanced version of
[51:54] just the missile. The basic technology remains the same, same with cons same
[51:59] with aircraft, same with ships, et cetera. You can get more advanced,
[52:01] but the basic concept of flying it remains the same. The basic concept
[52:06] of just like you know, traveling and attacking somebody with the gun remains the
[52:08] same. Similarly, the basic concept of going into the cether under or over
[52:13] remains the same. This is entirely new tech. Like we spoke at the
[52:16] beginning of this episode, this is tech when it comes to rones at least
[52:20] operated by a game pad like an Xbox controller. This is tech that is
[52:23] operated, you know, thousands of klometers away from a bunker, so to
[52:28] speak, by one guy who's operating a joystick. When it comes to unarmed
[52:30] aeral vehicles, what are the training challenges like for the military, are there
[52:36] already courses and let's see the NDA or the IAM or the Force Academy for
[52:39] stuff like this or is it something that is done so drones are you know,
[52:45] UH, Unmanned aerial vehicle operations is already a separate card in the Air
[52:51] Force and UH and the military at large. So there's no question that,
[52:54] you know. Once India realized that it had kind of missed the bus in
[52:59] terms of recognizing the importance of drone warfare. Uh, at least structurally in
[53:04] terms of technology, it's still running to catch up. But in terms of
[53:07] creating those structures to create a carter of uh, you know, a drone
[53:12] operators and drone specialists that already exists. We've got dedicated drone training infrastructure.
[53:16] We've got we've got drone squadrons, drone flights, et cetera. So so
[53:22] that is not a worry. The training infrastructure is is very much there,
[53:28] you know, like they've liked with training for any any kind of equipment,
[53:31] there is a there is a stipulated regimen, There is a stipulated curriculum that
[53:36] needs to be gone through. Obviously a lot of tech you know, technical
[53:39] stuff, but also uh, simulation training, all of that, you know,
[53:44] the whole works that you can already thinking about in your mind. All
[53:47] of that is there. There's a great deal of simulation, computer based training
[53:51] on drones obviously until they actually get to go out and fly actual drones.
[53:54] So so so that's not going to be really a pro problem. The challenge
[54:00] for India actually is going to be in the technology itself. I don't foresee
[54:06] I don't foresee training being a problem. I foresee technology being not a problem,
[54:12] but a challenge. It's going to be, you know, how do
[54:14] we milk that technology for India's very unique needs. And let's face it,
[54:19] you know, India has has you know, the kind of challenges that you
[54:24] know, you wouldn't wish on your worst enemy. Right, We've got we've
[54:28] got we've got adversaries on two fronts. In the north, we've got uh,
[54:32] you know, uh, an Indian Ocean that's hotting up quite a bit
[54:36] because of China. We've just seen what's happening in the Persian Gulf. We've
[54:40] seen so much piracy. We've seen how the pressure on India to keep those
[54:45] sea lanes of trade and communication open increasing, so so use the usage of
[54:52] drones. And mind you, the least American drones that we've had have been
[54:57] doing a stellar job for the Navy keep being an eye on all these piracy
[55:01] and you know hoo they attack incidents that have been happening in the Red Seat.
[55:05] They've been doing fabulous work. So the Navy knows for certain that we
[55:08] can't go back to a non drone era. Now, there's no there's no
[55:12] going back. These These are these are our eyes. Now we have to
[55:15] fight with drones. So that's the So I see technology as as a challenge,
[55:21] not not so much training because because the because training h you know,
[55:28] perp repurposing officers and men and women in the military for drone operations. That
[55:35] that process started like a good ten to fifteen years ago. So that momentum
[55:38] has been reached, that critical mass has been reached. There are people there.
[55:42] There are an entire new generation of youngsters now entering the military or entering
[55:46] in an age when you know, operating a phone or a joystick or a
[55:51] computer is it's not even second nature. It's first nature, right, it's
[55:54] first nature. They know everything about it. So so that layer of challenges
[55:59] also not there. You know, there's no such thing as is that person
[56:01] tech savvy? Everyone in this just generation and the last generation. In fact,
[56:07] our generation was the first sort of tech savvy generation. So you can
[56:09] imagine how tech savvy everyone else is, right the post Internet generation. So
[56:14] so there's no problem in terms of training, handling, et cetera. It's
[56:17] about it's about tactics, how you use the drones, how you extract the
[56:22] best out of them. You know, are you aware of everything that your
[56:28] drone can do are you using it optimally for the operation hand? Those are
[56:31] the challenges and so it's not there's nothing robotic about drones. Drones may be
[56:36] robotic, but the but how human operators use them is where you know their
[56:42] success actually lies. I want to do I missed one point earlier they've about
[56:46] about the challenges of drones, and this is that, and it actually I
[56:52] can I can align it in this answer to your question, which is that
[56:54] the other big challenge of drone warfare is let's never forget that if regular militaries
[57:01] can use drones, let's never forget that terrorists and you know, non state
[57:07] actors can will and have been using drones to devastating effect. If you look
[57:13] at Syria, ISIS has been using uh, you know, drones that carried
[57:17] grenades. Hamas used them in Israel during the October seventh attack, where they
[57:22] use drones holding small little rocket propel grenades and they just simply drop them on
[57:28] targets, on tanks. They're doing that now in Gaza. Also, so
[57:31] from the smallest level drone threat, a two hundred dollars drone rigged with a
[57:37] grenade, can you know the isis losing five guys is no big deal.
[57:43] But that grenade killing two US soldiers is a huge deal. Right, So
[57:46] that's what I mean by how these terror groups can use them as game changers.
[57:51] Pakistani terrorists are using drones to transport drugs and guns and stuff into Punjab,
[57:58] which is why you find crashed rones in Punjab all the time. So
[58:00] they're using those drones and brones can evade radar, they can fly at ten
[58:04] feet, fly over the border, drop their stuff and go back and even
[58:07] if it gets shot down, big deal. It's like a two hundred dollars
[58:09] drone return of investment to Hooga. So that is a huge challenge for India.
[58:15] That's massive. You know, the sleeper cells of terror groups using drones
[58:21] armed with IDs in an urban setup can easily escape an intelligence net. You
[58:24] know, how many people will you keep an eye on? So those the
[58:29] proliferation of drones, the threat to airports, like we've seen entire airports shutting
[58:34] down because of drones spotted in flight parts and stuff. Those are the challenges
[58:38] as far as India is concerned. As far as everything else, we've got
[58:42] it sorted. It's like you read in my mind that my last question on
[58:45] this episode is actually going to be about the security challenges being posed by trons
[58:49] and the ability for them to proliferate because not your high end combat drones,
[58:54] because those obviously will be controlled heavily, yeah you can. I think think
[58:58] of them as your nuclear weapons will not make it be so easy for them
[59:01] to go into the black market. That the gray market. But the small
[59:05] little loitering drones, the Kamakazi drones, I'm pretty shut it already has there
[59:09] in Syria and Iraq. They sorry to interrupt you, but in Syria and
[59:13] Iraq, these grenade rigged quad copter drones forced countries like the US and France,
[59:21] you know, into completely retreating, yes, and having to restructure how
[59:27] they were going to conduct those operations because they were losing people like flies,
[59:30] and they had to literally go back to their governments and say, we need
[59:35] anti drone systems that can take these on because these guys are sending hundreds of
[59:38] such drones into places that we are. We take over a city, there'lls
[59:43] and hundred drones. We can't do anything, and they all rigged with grenades
[59:45] cost them nothing. Guys sitting in just two kilometers away and operating these drones
[59:51] and they like massacring us, right, So that's that's what I mean.
[59:54] It's having a big military type effect can sometimes cost nothing. That's what drones
[1:00:01] bring to the game, right, So yeah, that's a nice pay to
[1:00:06] I think end this episode. One last and very quick thought, a little
[1:00:08] bit of trivia, since you were mentioning the different kinds of drones that you've
[1:00:12] seen, and one was a sort of you know, hand propelled one.
[1:00:15] I'm pretty sure you've watched the movie Uriah and in that they depict this,
[1:00:22] and that's what I want to know from you. Do I know the answer?
[1:00:23] I think was it a ridiculous idea for a drone to be like that?
[1:00:27] Or is it something in the realm of possibly I think I think I
[1:00:30] think it was a little to filmy. You know, drones, uh,
[1:00:35] you know, they're not designed to be esthetic in that sense. Of course.
[1:00:39] There is an old adage in aviation which is that if it looks right,
[1:00:42] it flies right. But I don't think that applies in this case.
[1:00:45] There's there was something very fantasy about this particular you know, bird type drone.
[1:00:51] But but you know, I'm not going to make a sensible comment about
[1:00:55] a film it was a film, So you know, there are many things
[1:00:58] that they must have taken. Liberty is on. But let's make no mistake
[1:01:02] that drones are very much aviation itself. Aeronautical engineering. Aviation design takes a
[1:01:09] great deal of a great deal of inspiration from flying creatures, whether it is
[1:01:15] birds, whether it is bats. Lockheed Martin had a had a drone that
[1:01:22] was capable of flying, dropping into the water, conducting undersea operations, and
[1:01:25] then going back up. It was called the Cormorant because it was inspired by
[1:01:30] a bird called the cormorant, which flies, dives into the water, fishes,
[1:01:32] and then flies back out. So and they actually engineered its wings to
[1:01:37] be like the cormorants, which kind of fold inwards, allowing it to become
[1:01:40] like a torpedo. So so, yeah, the connection between the living world
[1:01:45] and drone world is definitely there. It's always the inspiration. Yeah, right,
[1:01:50] So theuri birdlike drone that managed to fly and pots itself on the on
[1:01:53] the window ledge of the that probably wasn't reality, but I'm pretty sure drones
[1:01:58] were up in the air when they were. For sure they were, which
[1:02:00] I think you've also written about you in your book. They were there kind
[1:02:04] of keeping an eye and making sure what was happening was being related back.
[1:02:07] Thanks you a fascinating episode, I think, which is why it's it's gone
[1:02:10] on for so long, but I'm pretty sure our viewers and listeners will will
[1:02:14] love it, which is why we'll also you know, want you to let
[1:02:16] us know in the comments if you're watching us on YouTube, if you're you
[1:02:19] know, listening to us on Apple podcast Spotify, please leave us a reading
[1:02:22] on the respective app that you're listening to us. Thanks as always to our
[1:02:25] lovely producer. And that's it for this week's defense. Does for more tune
[1:02:30] in next week. They'll then, stay safe and do not cross any boundaries
[1:02:32] to our passport

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
