# Dead or Alive, Why Dawood Ibrahim Weighs Heavy On India's Psyche | In Our Defence S2, Ep 03

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 21 Dec 2023, 51 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/58084717/21_dec_23_defence_21_dec_128.mp3

Dawood Ibrahim, the notorious figure behind the 1993 Mumbai blasts, is once again in the spotlight amid claims of being poisoned. Designated a global terrorist in 2003 by both India and the United States, Ibrahim carries a staggering $25 million bounty on his head due to his alleged orchestration of the 1993 Bombay bombings and involvement in various crimes such as extortion, murder, and smuggling. Although rumours abound regarding his alleged poisoning and subsequent hospitalisation, reliable intelligence sources have discredited these claims. But why does news about Dawood remain palatable to India? And how much of a threat is he actually to India? It's been over four decades since he went into hiding, morphing into a shadowy figure. Does his ability to evade authorities raise questions about the failure of India's security apparatus and the potential mesh of corruption behind his rise? And what are the practical difficulties in actually ‘poisoning’ Dawood? India Today TV Output’s Senior Executive Editor Shiv Aroor and host Dev Goswami discuss. Listen in! Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound Mix by Sachin Dwivedi

## Transcript

[0:00] This is India Today podcasts, and there is reason to believe that about forty
[0:07] percent of Ibrahim's income, the Crime Empire's income actually comes from India or India
[0:14] related activities, which is huge. Right, He's become symbolic of just what
[0:20] a diseased system we have here in India because ever since he left. First
[0:24] of all, how is he allowed to leave here? Secondly have there been
[0:27] attempts on his life after he left? The practical difficulties a of guarding against
[0:33] thou Wood's effects on India are difficult and they will never end their ongoing Hi,
[0:40] they've go Swami, your host along with defense expert and senior journal Shivadur
[0:44] break down this world for you. If we bring you nuances and perspectives that
[0:48] will inform and at times provoke. This is in our defense. Hello and
[1:02] welcome, and UH start by giving up big thanks to all our listeners and
[1:07] viewers. Koshev. We've ranked number one on Apple Podcasts chart for government category
[1:14] in India and even on YouTube. This has been Indian a podcast is best
[1:19] performing episode so far. So this is the episode on unknown Government. Yeah,
[1:23] why am I not surprised? All? There is? The topic was
[1:26] all on social media, which is where we chose to talk about that because
[1:30] again, like we discussed topic that you know, can easily be printed,
[1:34] put in print or on TV because there you have to be as factual as
[1:38] possible. But we wanted to use your years of two decades of experience in
[1:44] covering defense to kind of you know, give us your gut feeling of what
[1:48] you've There's nothing there's nothing better than to you know, be on the top
[1:52] of the charge. Yeah, you know that, because what else does one
[1:55] really work for other than to get that kind of affirmation from an audience.
[1:57] So absolutely they w and I thank all of our viewers. That's fantastic.
[2:01] It means that people see value in what we're talking about. And I hope
[2:05] that we can share more information and maybe even keep this conversation open, you
[2:08] know, get more feedback from our listeners about what they'd like to hear us
[2:12] talk about. Yeah, yeah, yeah, and you know, just like
[2:15] thanks everyone, and you know, do leave us comments. A lot of
[2:19] people did leave comments by the film the previous episode talking about how they enjoyed
[2:23] the conversation. So do leave us comments. Your feedback is very, very
[2:27] valuable. So she if you know it might be repetitive, but because our
[2:30] our previous episode did so well, and also because we recorded before something big
[2:36] broke this week, which is linked to our previous discussion, I think we're
[2:38] going to continue on that. On that tangent, we talk about not unknown
[2:43] government per se, but the mysterious deaths reported deaths of India's enemies abroad.
[2:49] The story I'm talking about that broke this week is the reported death of the
[2:53] Braham. Don't need to obviously introduce the guy. Everyone knows his name,
[2:58] especially if people like me who from Bombay and just grew up around all this
[3:00] folklore around the underworld and now the d gang, et cetera. Sources have
[3:07] confirmed Trinada TV that that has not happened. There was some reports that said
[3:10] he's been hospitalized after being poisoned, some said he has you know, died,
[3:15] some said he's just been hospitalized. But sources have confirmed, top level
[3:19] sources are going to come from Trinida TV that that has not happened. Regardless.
[3:23] Once again, a juicy topic for social media to just rumor monger,
[3:27] just like you know, like you said very nicely last episode, naj Najwing
[3:30] wink at India as a play again mystery or voice are out there on the
[3:36] field, you know, just getting some getting the bad guys out of the
[3:39] way for India. Uh. Before I come to what you think about the
[3:45] Taou the episode, I'll just like, you know, briefly talk about why
[3:49] I think even if India had to get Thau with in Pakistan, it would
[3:53] not be in a way like this and not pay because unlike with some of
[3:58] the characters we discussed last time, level people, not all of them,
[4:00] some were obviously commanders in some of the terrorist organizations. Uh, some like
[4:04] the Khalistani terrorists, are very visible. But unlike those people. Now that
[4:10] I think is somebody India would want to and seem to be worn to getting
[4:15] legitimately as far as possible, you know, either through an extradition that will
[4:19] never happen because past Pakistan refused to even acknowledge that he's on the soil,
[4:24] just like India is lying and he's not in in Karachi where he stays.
[4:29] So if not through that, then something like let's say the US Rada,
[4:33] but India can formally go on record and say, you know why we did
[4:38] this because he was I think the most wanted terrorists officially proscript terrorists, not
[4:44] just by India, by also by the US, and we got him because
[4:46] he was our enemy. He was behind the mombig Last that kilm over two
[4:50] hundred people, and he has been funding organizations like the last Mohamad Last,
[4:57] like we know what was involved in the firty six eleven attacks. That's what
[5:00] I think, which is why I feel every time you come across a report
[5:02] or a rumor or a speculative theory that you know he's dying, is dead
[5:06] or something like the poisoning angler. So you know he's by the way,
[5:09] died many times. In twenty twenty was a report that he had COVID and
[5:12] he's died. In twenty seventeen, there was a report that he had a
[5:15] brain tumor and he's dying. In twenty sixteen here, or there's a report
[5:19] that he had gangerine and he's dying. Those were he was also famously abducted
[5:24] one. Yes, yes, those were natural causes if they were to be
[5:30] taken as the truth. Yeah, in this case poisoning, so again o
[5:32] poisoning. Yeah, your thoughts on this, well, you know, first
[5:36] of all, Doo de Brahim left India and you know, moved to Pakistan
[5:42] in the in the mid eighties. Yes, so it's been it's been nearly
[5:46] four decades since he has ceased to be on Indian soil. We don't know
[5:51] if he's ever come back. I doubt he would have dared to do that.
[5:55] But you know, the Brahim, I like to start by saying that
[5:59] thou so the Brahim is less of a terrorist now and more of a kind
[6:02] of mythology. He's become a kind of mythology as far as India is concerned.
[6:06] The bad news, of course, is they've that he's still alive.
[6:12] You know, I would love nothing better than for us to have an episode
[6:15] in the future where we're reporting the death of Daoudebrahim. Let me be brutally
[6:18] honest about that, because you know, as the years pass, it only
[6:23] becomes more and more clear that this is one of India's most wanted terrorists,
[6:27] responsible for one of the worst terror attacks on our soil, who's been plainly
[6:32] out of reach, and even though he doesn't live very far away from India,
[6:36] right, that's point number one. Point number two is that Daoudbrahim is
[6:41] definitely alive. We don't know if he's well, he's not very old.
[6:45] He's about sixty seven years old, which is not that old. He's had
[6:47] some health complications which have been known to exist. But beyond that, like
[6:54] you said, he's you know, he's he's been killed more times than abubak
[6:58] al Baghdadi of the Ice, who we know was killed approximately three times a
[7:02] year in the American press. Uh, and then we all know, you
[7:05] know, when the end finally came. So yeah, he's he I'm sure
[7:10] wherever he's sitting, he's he's been watching these exaggerated stories of his death.
[7:14] But but you know, let's be very clear, he's there are there are
[7:17] many, there are many different Like in our previous episode when we're talking about
[7:20] the levels of protection that terrorists enjoy in Pakistan, Ibrahim is gold class.
[7:29] He enjoys the gold class of protection, which is that he is not he's
[7:33] not your stereotypical ragtag, you know, cleric style terrorist. He's an Indian.
[7:40] He's from Mahrashtra. You know, he's a suited booted guy. Clearly
[7:44] someone who likes the big life. You know, the the glamorous life has
[7:48] has successfully run you know, a very very big crime empire that involves terror
[7:56] financing, film financing, extortion, gun running, drug traffic, and the
[8:00] rest of it. And there is no reason to believe that his business as
[8:03] in any way stopped because he's still functioning. Shotasha Kiel still operates Tiger Memon
[8:09] as India today. We just got a new photograph of him. So all
[8:13] of these guys are still active, right, So so the d Company still
[8:16] exists. I mean, we can argue endlessly about, you know, whether
[8:20] it has been brought to its knees, whether it's smaller than before. But
[8:24] the simple fact of the matter is India's most wanted terrorists lives in Karachi.
[8:28] That's beyond debate. He you know, whether he lives in the Clifton area,
[8:31] which is which is basically like the like the Latians Delhi of Karachi or
[8:37] not, we don't know for sure, but there's reason to believe that he
[8:39] operates basically between Pakistan and the United Arab Emirates. Husseinsei is written extensively about
[8:45] this in those you know, in those wonderful books as well, but you
[8:48] know, they one of the things I think I want to say right at
[8:50] the start for our listeners, and I think this is important as we consume
[8:54] this story about the about daoudi Brahim is that he's become symbol of just what
[9:01] a diseased system we have here in India because ever since he left, First
[9:07] of all, how is he allowed to leave? Secondly, have there been
[9:11] attempts on his life after he left? Third? How is it that you
[9:15] know, a man sitting in Pakistan, you know, has been so completely
[9:18] out of reach of India for nearly forty years, for four decades, A
[9:22] person who killed two hundred and fifty of your citizens on your soil, in
[9:26] your biggest financial city. How is it possible? So you know, this
[9:31] has been extensively documented, but I think very broadly speaking, what Ibrahim in
[9:35] my mind represents is that it is a reminder of how much corruption there has
[9:41] been in the Indian you know, criminal justice system, law and orders system,
[9:46] you know, how compromised certain sections and I don't mean all of our
[9:50] forces, but you know, sections of the Mumbai Police, sections of the
[9:54] Intelligence Bureau, sections of our external intelligence, sections of our other security apparators.
[10:00] Uh. You know, this is a terrorist who has managed to you
[10:03] know, have assets in all of these places who've been useful to him,
[10:07] who've you know who've you know, tipped him off, kept him briefed about
[10:09] India's intentions as far as he's concerned. I remember, you know, Union
[10:13] minister are casing it famously talked about how the Wajpai government had a covert operation
[10:18] to to kill uh to kill Daubrahim, and at the last minute it was
[10:22] compromised because of some rogue police officers in the in the you know, it's
[10:28] been dramatized, it's been put into movies and stuff as well. But you
[10:31] know, that's just one small example of the kind of guy he is.
[10:35] And remember that Daoud Abrahim, whose existence is denied by Pakistan. You know,
[10:41] even though he lives a life of great protection, he's elusive. There
[10:43] are no real photographs of the guy et cetera, et cetera. But it's
[10:46] not like he's been living in some hole. You know. His daughter married
[10:50] Javid Miyanda son, another daughter married a big businessman in the UK. A
[10:56] third married some guy, you know, some big shot in the United States.
[11:00] So this is a man who has managed to stay elusive, you know,
[11:05] from a country that as powerful as India, country that is, you
[11:09] know, in no tinpot nation, and yet lived the high life. He's
[11:11] maintained that lifestyle and everyone's mind. That picture of Tao is him in that
[11:16] striped T shirt, which, by the way, is an India Today photograph,
[11:18] an India Today video by a guy called Baban Singh. Yes in charger
[11:24] and uh, you know, after that, he just becomes like a you
[11:28] know, a wisp in the air. Nobody sees him again. You only
[11:31] hear the see the effects of his actions. He's understood to have financed the
[11:35] last but during the twenty six to eleven attacks as well. So yeah,
[11:39] that's the which is all of these are reasons why they've to close this thought.
[11:45] Why why the news of the death of now the brehme is so palatable
[11:50] and so welcome here, which is why that let him die year after year.
[11:52] It doesn't matter. Let him be a media story. It will be
[11:54] a media story every time he dies. Yeah, you know, a quick
[11:56] point to add to what you said. And it's a distinct I think that
[12:01] we should make for our listeners and viewers. And the fact that you know,
[12:03] I think Abraham became became a person not to be seen with, not
[12:09] to be seen in close proximity. But I think only post the movee blast
[12:13] because when you said, you know, how was it, how was he
[12:16] allowed to leave? And yeah, he left Tendia like you said, mid
[12:18] eighties, and this was a time when the underworld was seen to be basically
[12:24] businessmen who were criminals, you know, who did not target innocent uh if
[12:28] they had a gang where it was mostly amongst the between themselves and if a
[12:31] civilian died or innocent died, it was usually collateral. It wasn't their intention.
[12:37] And I think this this was a time back in the day when the
[12:39] movement underball itself looked very look did not like involving civilians or or an aisance.
[12:46] They had this policy of you know, if it's between the two of
[12:48] us and the two of us that's not involved innocence and get bad heat from
[12:52] police. So that's why I think you had the police involved, you had
[12:54] politicians involved. By the way, it was this whole mesh of corruption like
[12:58] you said that I think probably played a role in his rise till nineteen ninety
[13:03] two when the bomb blasts happened, and that's when suddenly the people who were
[13:07] associated they did not is like, oh my god, this is what we
[13:09] who were we with? And you know what happened to happen, but tell
[13:13] me something how because I see the story of Tao Debrahim as kind of similar
[13:20] to The Godfather, the Mario Pooso book that was then made into a three
[13:24] part so he wrote three books and those were also put on film. To
[13:28] an extent, I'll qualif im a statement to an extent because terrorism obviously was
[13:31] not part of that of that series. But I see him as a person
[13:37] who began his life in crime and then started to deviate or divert his businesses
[13:41] to businesses to some sort of legitimacy like realistic for example, film financing for
[13:46] example, even though the core funding in that may may have been gotten through
[13:52] illegal means, but this aspect of terrorism came involved, came into the picture,
[13:58] and I think it has been it's been widely reported that Pakistan's I s
[14:01] I was the one that kind of pushed him that on that side. On
[14:05] that side, my question to you, based on your charts with people in
[14:09] the establishment, is how serious of a threat is to india snatal security as
[14:13] of today? Okay, so he's definitely a threat. The straight black and
[14:18] white answer is that the reason why he is a threat is because he's a
[14:22] terror financier, right, he doesn't. He doesn't have a he doesn't have
[14:28] a terror outfit of his own. But the D Company we know very well,
[14:33] not just from Indian evidence but also from American evidence, that the D
[14:37] Company has a lucrative enough business empire where much of their funding goes into terror
[14:43] financing. And you know it, it was the United States that shared information
[14:48] about the D Companies financing of the lash Caretaiba for the for the twenty six
[14:54] to eleven attacks. This was reported at that time. I remember also by
[14:56] India today now in so far as him being a threat to India is that,
[15:01] you know, in Pakistan, where money is in short supply right now,
[15:07] anyone with a lucrative business operation that's in the business of crime and gun
[15:11] running and you know, drug trafficking is very, very valuable. I imagine
[15:18] that the D Company's value amidst this current economic crisis in Pakistan has probably gone
[15:24] up many many levels. Because let's remember that Daoud Ibrahim and the D Company
[15:30] function in a space which is effectively recession proof, right, drugs are never
[15:37] going to go out of style. Drug running between Afghanistan and the rest of
[15:39] the world is never going to go out of fashion. Gun running in this
[15:43] atmosphere and this world is never going to be hit by recession extortion obviously.
[15:50] You know, nobody's ever going to say, oh I don't have enough money,
[15:52] let's stop extortion. You know, film financing will continue. Real estate
[15:56] is largely recession proof. And there is reason to believe that about forty percent
[16:03] of Ibrahim's income, the crime Empire's income actually comes from India or India related
[16:11] activity, which is huge. Right, So so his value to Pakistan is
[16:15] massive, and his danger to India is definitely there. I'm not going to
[16:19] play it down and say, oh, he's a nobody. Now we're too
[16:22] strong. There's no such thing in the gray areas of you know, terror
[16:26] finance saying and the kind of thing, the kind of space where the ISI
[16:30] operates. You know, the enemy is usually invisible. So if you have
[16:33] practically endless source of funds, you know, bankrolling these terror outfits, which
[16:37] actually struggling at this point of time because of the economic crisis in Pakistan,
[16:42] that's a real threat to India. But I also wanted to talk about how
[16:48] Tao Ibrahim may be valuable to Pakistan, and you you know, you made
[16:52] a reference to The Godfather. I you know, I whether it is cinema,
[16:56] whether it is books, there has always been an attempt to kind of
[17:00] humanize gangsters, you know, you know, add a layer of emotion and
[17:06] motive and humanity to gangsters. And nobody did that better than Maru Puzo in
[17:11] The Godfather, right. I mean, these were these were ruthless, absolutely
[17:15] ruthless, soulless people in large part, but you know, you end up
[17:19] loving those characters. There may have been some part of the Audi Brahim's life
[17:25] where the Godfather may have been applicable to him. This would have been in
[17:27] the seventies when the d Company began, maybe in the early eighties, you
[17:32] know, the whole Karim Lala Haji Mustan phase where like you said, these
[17:36] were businessmen who operated in a you know, inter gang world where where the
[17:41] blood spillage was usually restricted to rival gangs. You know, people who were
[17:47] in the game as it were, and you never really saw innocence being killed.
[17:52] All of that changed in the eighties when he had to leave because because
[17:56] he obviously aspired for greater crimes, bigger crimes, crimes that came to the
[18:00] notice of the government crimes that started making making the administration look bad. Suddenly
[18:07] there was so much crime that the administration said, you know, or at
[18:11] least parts of the administration I say, said, you know, we can't
[18:12] let you continue like this because you're making us look bad and we lose the
[18:15] next election because law and order is going to become an issue. That's when
[18:18] he had to leave India, go abroad to Pakistan and Dubai, et cetera.
[18:22] But the fact of the matter is things completely change. You know,
[18:26] the nineteen ninety three bomb blasts in Mumbai and I know we'll explore this in
[18:30] detail there, but you know, a narrative, there has been a narrative
[18:34] that you know, he was pushed down that path because of the Barbari muster
[18:38] demolition and you know, being a Muslim himself, he was affected by it.
[18:42] And you know this was his reaction to it. You know, this
[18:47] has been given a kind of emotional you know, there was anger the crow
[18:52] that's this guy was a terrorist. Okay, this guy was a bloodless terrorist
[18:56] who was you know, being funded back bylled and protected by the I S
[19:00] I. The I S I saw you know, a very willing, influential
[19:07] resourceful, powerful Indian criminal. Uh, you know, willing to do anything
[19:11] for them in order to be protected in exchange for their protection. Uh.
[19:15] And the Bombay bomblast is what they wanted. So you know, let's let's
[19:19] first of all, dispense with this theory that has been you know, that
[19:23] has been projected in book after book, film after film, article arter article
[19:29] that you know Daudbrahim uh, you know it. This was this was a
[19:33] reaction and a manifestation of his anger over communal violence in India. You know,
[19:40] these are people who don't operate in a in a space of morality.
[19:42] There are you know, I'm not making a value judgment, but I mean
[19:45] these are These are guys who are there for the money. They're there to
[19:49] you know, create empires. Uh. They don't care about life and limb
[19:55] many Muslims were killed in the Bombay bomb blast. So let no one lecture
[19:59] U, you know, any community about what Dau Abrahim stood for. He
[20:03] didn't stand for any religion. He certainly didn't stand for Muslims. He certainly
[20:07] did not stand for what was right and wrong. He was given orders by
[20:11] an is I that saw him as an as an extremely useful, capable I
[20:18] should say capable, because he was capable, you know, you know,
[20:22] crime lord who was able to further what the is I wanted to do in
[20:26] India. So so that's that's really where he is. The distinction between a
[20:32] gangster a godfather like figure, and you know how that completely evaporated to give
[20:37] way to a person who was basically a kind of master terrorist or a financier.
[20:41] You know, happened in the eighties. I don't think there was any
[20:42] looking back after that. I think you've been a very good point about why
[20:47] and how and meshed Braham is to Pakistan's economy and its largest structure, because
[20:52] you know, a thought coming to my mind after our last episode was that,
[20:57] you know, and after the story broke earlier this week, was that,
[21:00] you know, it should be so so easy for Pakistan to, you
[21:04] know, the fatfaction that's happening against it, for example, to just like,
[21:07] you know, give him over to Indian let's see, we're the good
[21:10] guys, you know. But then I thought of what he said exactly,
[21:12] But no, wait, this guy's also helping them with the funds that they
[21:17] crucially need through his vast empire that he's running. So let's go to talking
[21:25] about the practical difficulties of, to put it bluntly, poisoning the ouse in
[21:30] Pakistan if we wanted to, Because you've explained how big of the thirty is
[21:34] remains. He played a role in financing the twenty six eleven attacks, and
[21:38] there's nothing And I mean, we can be defensive, but at some point
[21:41] you have to be offensive as well. Right, you don't want to risk
[21:47] or you don't want to be defending every attempt for a bunch of ten guys
[21:51] to you know, saale towards your financial capital and you know, bomb the
[21:55] place and just shoot people left, friend and center. You'd want to ensure
[21:59] that that sort of planning never even takes shape by hitting at the resources.
[22:03] Let's talk about the practical challenges UH faced by Indian agencies, whether they are
[22:08] the intelligencies or IB or whether it's CBI. For all that matter, CBA
[22:12] is is the is the police arm that represents India at the global level.
[22:18] Obviously bubble police cannot do much is for things happening in Dubai or in Pakistan.
[22:22] For UH, for example, what are the practical difficulties of ensuring that
[22:27] thous empire poses as less of a risk to India as possible, and the
[22:33] practical difficulties of actually doing something about the man himself, whether it's poisoning him
[22:38] or whether it's extradition like we said it's out of the picture because pakistanrifrage to
[22:41] admit, or whether it's something else like the about that Tokado someone will.
[22:47] So the practical difficulties a of guarding against thous you know effects on India are
[22:53] difficult and they will never end their ongoing because the damage that Daoud can do
[22:59] to India are at many different levels. A through through directly financing terror,
[23:07] which we've seen in twenty sixty eleven. B through Hawala. We forgot to
[23:11] talk about Hawala, and he controls Havala, which is a massive money laundering
[23:15] you know operation which has economic effects on India. C is he can have
[23:21] direct economic effects on India in terms of counterfeit currency and we do know that
[23:25] counterfeit fake note currency terror is something that Pakistan has deployed to devastating effect in
[23:30] parts of the country in the past. We've got a handle of it on
[23:33] it now, but thou there's been behind some of that as well. So
[23:37] so guarding or you know, sorting out and protecting India against Thou's actions is
[23:45] is not a sprint, It's a marathon. It will continue, you know,
[23:49] and this is a crime empire. Remember he's one man, but he
[23:52] has a second run. There's Shota Shakil and I imagine we don't know,
[23:56] but you know, those in the business of tracking this, we'll probably know
[24:00] who's going to be next in line. These are these these are not things
[24:03] that are left to chance in crime empires where you're you know, dealing with
[24:07] millions of dollars on a daily basis. Uh So, so guarding against the
[24:11] threat of DAOO is going to be a permanent sort of crime prerogative as far
[24:17] as India is concerned. Now, the complexities and the logistical challenges in well,
[24:22] say, Killingbrahim are you know, are exponentially high. They've you know,
[24:27] we were talking in our previous episode, uh you know, which has
[24:30] done so well about about unknown gunmen bumping off you know, random terrorists.
[24:37] Now we don't know who these unknown gunmen were. You know, we don't
[24:40] know if they were Indian death squads or you know, some competing interests in
[24:44] Pakistan. But let's just for the sake of argument assume you know, let's
[24:51] put forward this image that Daoud has been poisoned. Okay, he's been poisoned
[24:56] and uh uh it's it's come back to India now okay. Uh. And
[25:00] like you said, if if Thaoud is ever poisoned or killed, India will
[25:04] not want to make it a covert operation. We'll like you know, Tampa
[25:08] chests and announce it to the world saying this guys has been a wanted terrorist
[25:11] since the eighties, and we we did what we had to do. You
[25:15] know, be what may come, what may Uh. Like I said,
[25:19] Uh, Tao de Brahim is not your not your you know, you know,
[25:26] standard issue terrorist. Uh. He is a businessman. The distinction that
[25:30] we need to make once again is there's a huge difference between a half his
[25:34] moment's side and uh or Malana mas Azar and uh uh Braham. The reason
[25:42] is Molana and half a Sithe are not money centers. They're not profit centers.
[25:51] They are offense centers. They are they are your teeth with which you
[25:55] hurt India. Tao de Brahim is where the money from. He's your profit
[26:00] center. You never harm your profit centers. Okay, you might see led
[26:07] guys, dropping like flies or j Mohmed guys being being you know, killed
[26:11] by gunmen. There was an instance where even someone like Malana Masudasa, the
[26:17] founder of the JH Mohmad, one of the most protected terrorists in Pakistan,
[26:21] got away by the skin of his state in Peshawar. I think this is
[26:23] a few years ago. There was some kind of ambush on his life but
[26:26] at the last minute and he was injured very grievously apparently. Now all that
[26:30] shows you is that pakistanis not doing everything to protect them. Protection though here,
[26:34] but it's not like it's not gold class protection of the kind that this
[26:38] guy has, because those are the guys with the guns. Those are the
[26:41] guys with the training. You know, when orders are given, they will
[26:45] go out and execute your you know, whatever your terror dictat is. Now,
[26:49] Debraham is the guy with the money, and this requires to we should
[26:56] be repeating this over and over again because money in the context of Pakistan,
[27:00] you know, it takes on a very different color in a country which is
[27:03] at this point and I'm talking about the context now where where it is it
[27:07] is literally on the threshold of civil war as a result of the economic collapse,
[27:14] where Pakistan sees its uh, you know, the political implosion between the
[27:18] current government and Imran Khan, you know, riots on the streets for basic
[27:22] items like arta and ghi and stuff like that. That is, that is
[27:26] a threat to Pakistan's stability internally, and it completely endangers Pakistan's strategic programs which
[27:33] are basically aimed at harming India Kashmi et cetera, et cetera. So in
[27:37] in that scheme of things, apart from the ISI and the Pakistani deep state,
[27:42] a person like Thau the Brahim, who has this sort of fountain of
[27:47] cash, this unending pipeline of you know, funds, which will never be
[27:52] under threat of drying up, is a man you protect with everything you've got.
[27:57] Everything you've got Clifton, we say, Clifton, that must be That
[28:02] must be just one layer of it. I cannot imagine what kind of protection
[28:06] a person like that the Brahm must have. I haven't gone into those details,
[28:10] but I imagine it. It is. It is beyond military level security
[28:12] because because the death of Thao the Abrahim would mean not just the death of
[28:18] one individual, but the death of an entire chain of command, which has
[28:21] been very meticulously and you know carefully constructed and nurtured over forty years. So
[28:27] Pakistan is not going to let anything happen to him, you know. Thing.
[28:30] But theoretically, since you asked, what, what what would it take
[28:33] to poison someone like a with Ibrahim, Well, for starters at any level,
[28:38] since there will be multiple layers of security, you you'd have to be
[28:44] able to infiltrate or have a mole or have an asset or a double agent
[28:48] in practically every layer leading up to his his bedroom or his you know,
[28:52] someone in his family, you know, the people around Thau the Brahim we
[28:56] understand are his wife and you know, maybe some very very close people.
[29:00] So assuming you've been able to turn people to your side across say five or
[29:10] six different layers, you know, from the outskirts of Karachi all the way
[29:14] till his actual home in Clifton, you'd basically you'd basically need to finally have
[29:21] a family member who's willing to do that for you. Now can you do
[29:25] that? Who knows? We have phone intercepts of him where he's talking about
[29:29] the price of Louis with your bags and shoes and and you know, clearly
[29:34] clearly a man who still you know feeds his desire to live the high life
[29:38] and the luxury life and stuff. But you know, how do you get
[29:42] to him? It would be really difficult. Obviously in theory everything is possible.
[29:48] But these are people who've got who've got layers of security that have redundancies.
[29:52] They change secure they change those layers frequently. They've got a very small
[29:56] inner coterie where you know, like since you mentioned the Godfather, they've these
[30:00] are people whose families would be at risk if they if they if they betrayed
[30:06] their master. You know, so would you betray someone at the pain of
[30:10] losing your family? All these all these very terrible interlinkages that you know,
[30:15] we would find unpalatable in the civilian world but are probably completely power for the
[30:21] course in uh in uh in Inda wods world would be would definitely apply.
[30:26] You know, for example, the I think it was in the Godfather series
[30:29] they had something called the they called they had something called the Bukichio hostages and
[30:34] maybe getting the pronunciation wrong, where if two families were meeting, and person
[30:40] who went to meet one family was you know, taking the risk and going
[30:44] there, someone called the Bookichi family would send a hostage, yes to that
[30:49] other family, and that hostage would be released only after the one family meet
[30:56] finished the meeting and got back safely. And it didn't, then the family
[31:00] would spend its entire life hunting down that family. So yeah, these are
[31:03] these are normal things in the gang world. I mean, you know,
[31:06] I'm sure there's a romanticization of this. That's Sicilian, this is Pakistan,
[31:10] they're different. But but yeah, this kind of very bloodless, soulless,
[31:15] terrible way of conducting business is probably the reality. I think you've very nicely
[31:18] restated what we spoke about last time about just the sheer complexities of conducting and
[31:23] the covert operation abroad, because you know, it's one thing for social media
[31:26] and for people just to like say, but it's not as simple as just
[31:33] you know, going to another countries and a foreign land, foreign conditions and
[31:36] you don't know who's turn against you, and doing something like this even within
[31:40] India will be quite difficult, by the way, So you know, it's
[31:41] a good point. You also he also he operates in from Dubai as well
[31:45] as well, not just Pakistan. Right, we'll talk more about this,
[31:49] but a a quick break eat eggs, no eat fiber, sleep, no
[31:59] take short time apps, don't listen to others, no serve others. Do
[32:02] you ever feel like you're drowning in a pool of advice? This is Sonalia
[32:08] Charji, a health journalist for the last ten years, who is equally fed
[32:14] up of lines like ten ways to Stay Fit. So join me in the
[32:17] podcast Health Wealth as we learn about health from a completely new perspective where investing
[32:22] in yourself is not a task but simple, satisfying and joyful. Full episodes
[32:30] are available on Apple, Google, Spotify, and the India Today podcast website.
[32:35] Tune in now, Welcome back. Shive and I are discussing the reports
[32:45] that came this week of Tao Debrahim being hospitalized after reportedly being poisoned. Reports
[32:51] that at least at the the group people will to edify or un trooped by
[32:54] talking to sources and the intelligence setup of India. Of the break we talked
[33:00] about the practical difficulties of getting to someone like Brahim the person himself in in
[33:06] in Pakistan, where you also talked about how it's just it's not just the
[33:09] guy. The guy is just a poster boy of his empire. It's also
[33:13] the empire itself that's harming you. It's not just him, and getting him
[33:16] probably would be like a like a vindictive victory, like a vindic vindiction for
[33:22] you know, you got the man responses like US did, but that that
[33:27] apparentis of terrorism still exists. So you know, after that, even though
[33:30] it the d Company as as this gang is called, would be in dis
[33:34] for a while, you would have ultimately somebody or the other coming up and
[33:37] still running the empire and you know, continue to pose a ris to India.
[33:42] I also asked you about the feasibility or the practicality of conducting a Botta
[33:45] art style trade in Pakistan with like, for example, the US god Osa.
[33:50] But I think, you know, in hindsight, that's sort of the
[33:52] question because that's I think an impossible thing for India to do. Because it's
[33:55] not not impossible, I meant practically speaking, it's not a sort of good
[34:00] idea. Yeah, we can talk about that. Actually you want me to
[34:01] answer that, can we do an Abatabad style Yeah, because that would be
[34:06] an outreed war if Pakistan I see. So, I mean, look,
[34:09] are there are a lot of differences between what happened in Abatabad and what could
[34:14] possibly you know, be realistic as far as India is concerned. It's it's
[34:17] a good question in the sense that, look, you know, Osama bin
[34:22] Laden and uh Daudebrahim are both terrorists. Both have been responsible for mass casualty
[34:28] attacks in democratic countries. Uh you know, both have been on most wanted
[34:32] lists for a very very long time. Both have been protected by Pakistan.
[34:37] They have a great deal of similarity. Osa in Lan incidentally, was also
[34:40] a businessman. He was also a profit center as a result of which he
[34:45] wasn't just a cleric, even though he dressed like one. So there are
[34:47] huge similarities between the two. Osamam land much larger empire, of course,
[34:51] but the similarities are quite quite quite a lot between Osama and Daoud. Now
[34:58] it might seem they've that, you know, it's a it's a silly comparison
[35:01] to make, because India, of course can't fly into Karachi, of all
[35:06] places and conduct a huge raid. The reasons for it are not just about
[35:10] the logistics. Also, remember that the Abatabad raid. You know, we
[35:15] like to think that Pakistan was caught off guard, but I happened to think
[35:21] that it's a little bit more complicated than that. It couldn't have happened entirely
[35:24] without Pakistan's you know knowledge. There must have been some some section of the
[35:30] Pakistani security establishment that you know, that was aware of it and actually sort
[35:36] of cleared it. Yes, movies like Zero Dark thirty and you know,
[35:39] all of that will make it seem like Pakistan was comes completely in the dark,
[35:44] completely surprised, and it happened. But I think that that level of
[35:49] silence and that level of stealth was in order to trick those sections of the
[35:54] Pakistani deep state that would actually have tipped Osama off. Because remember, you
[36:00] know, for Pakistan to claim that they didn't know somehow there is rubbish.
[36:04] It simply cannot happen in a similar way. As as much as we you
[36:08] know, wish that Pakistan was a you know, was a you know,
[36:12] failed nation, which it is in many ways, its security systems are very
[36:15] very good. H and for you know, for a for a seal team
[36:19] to be able to fly in, you know, conduct this huge raid and
[36:22] escape without you knowing anything about it sounds lovely in Hollywood. It sounds lovely
[36:28] in books. It sounds beautiful in terms of the mythology of the US Navy.
[36:32] Seals were fantastic, but it couldn't have happened. And this is it's
[36:37] it's not it's not my conspiracy theory. This is this is born out by
[36:40] facts many US Navy seal people that said it themselves, which is that Pakistan
[36:45] basically was pushed into a corner by the United States and the CIA saying that
[36:50] if you don't allow us to do this now, uh, you know,
[36:53] there will be consequences. There will be strategy consequences of Pakistan, and it
[36:57] had to happen. So so so so let's be very clear about that that
[37:00] this was this was not a you know, a sort of ambush, penetrative,
[37:06] unauthorized strike inside Pakistan. I'm sure Pakistan was on board at some level
[37:10] or the other. That level of cooperation will never be there for India.
[37:15] Okay, Uh, India and the United States are not the same in terms
[37:19] of their relationship with Pakistan. Certainly not in terms of our capability. You
[37:23] know, we have to be realistic about military affairs. As much as we'd
[37:27] like to think that we can do something as daring as a airborne raaid into
[37:32] Pakistan to kill Daud Abrahim, you know, theoretically nothing is impossible, but
[37:37] in practicality it's virtually impossible. Uh. You know the Karachi is Uh.
[37:44] Let's let's look at some geeky stuff. You know. For instance, Karachi
[37:47] is on the other end of the It's on the coast, which means which
[37:52] means flying over a large amount of territory in Pakistan undetected before you reach Karachi.
[37:58] Or would you do this from the sea, which is even more logistically
[38:00] difficult because there you can be detected even more easily. So you know,
[38:05] all the and the this is just for the fun fun of discussing it,
[38:08] you know, the actual practical difficulties and impossibilities of such an operation are way
[38:14] way way more because uh India's India's appetite for risk. How much risk would
[38:20] you like to take for something like this? Would you even have the adequate
[38:24] intelligence? Remember that all covert operations they've they're not just you know, smashing
[38:29] grab jobs. They are based on very very specific, corroborated intelligence where for
[38:36] instance, like the Osama operation, they knew which floor he was on,
[38:40] they knew which like which part of the house in that Abbadabad complex he was
[38:45] in, where he slept, They knew which room his wives were in,
[38:49] where the children were to avoid all that. That's the level of intelligence they
[38:52] had from the ground, human intelligence on the ground and satellite imagery. Do
[38:57] we have the resources to get something like that? Can India do it without
[39:00] the help of something like the United States? Would the United States ever help
[39:02] us? You know, these are all questions that have I'm sure gone through
[39:07] people's minds in the Indian system, but they are practically difficult, very difficult.
[39:13] Looking at the big picture, it would probably lead to war. Just
[39:16] as a comparison, just as a comparison for the kind of complexities we're talking
[39:21] about. We're talking about an air raid on a residential complex in Karaate where
[39:27] that wood lives. The Uri surgical strikes, the URIs surgical strikes in twenty
[39:32] sixteen were six kilometers into Pok, just six kilometers Karachi is hundreds of kilometers
[39:39] inside. Right, terror launch pads. Six kilometers inside Pok took a level
[39:46] of planning where the Indian Army didn't lose anybody in that operation, right the
[39:52] four Para Special Forces, nobody was lost. But in every covert operation on
[39:57] enemy soil. You know, a very clinical document is made and I've seen
[40:05] this document which basically talks about the minimum, the minimum loss in human life,
[40:12] you are willing to accept, accept the minimum and still declare the mission
[40:17] successful okay, which means that if I send forty people in okay and twenty
[40:24] five comeback, which means I've lost fifteen people. But if those fifteen guys
[40:30] have completed their mission officially in our books, it's still a successful operation.
[40:35] Okay. That's that's in like way colloquial terms, it's like you, it's
[40:39] your death appetite risk. That's what we're willing to accept. Okay, twenty
[40:44] five guys guy that I'm cool with it, as long as they complete the
[40:47] operation. We lost nobody in the operation, but that's because of the level
[40:51] of intelligence that was available in Balacote conducted from the air. Like we discussed
[40:57] in our last episode, the guy who provided that into regions from the ground
[41:00] to the Jeshi Mohmed more that the Indian intelligence guys had turned So yeah,
[41:06] I mean, the short answer after all this stuff is that it's I mean,
[41:09] the chances of it happening. The logistical challenges are you're too big to
[41:14] even speak of. And even by the way, some operation also, the
[41:17] US went in only after they had confirmation from a career they had managed to
[41:22] turn who delivered something at his house? Human intelligence confirmation that yes, he
[41:28] does stay there, because I think before the courier's confirmation, they were nineteen
[41:32] percent show he's there with through all the spice atllites, they were looking through
[41:35] the trash from the house, yes, to see who exactly is staying there.
[41:38] So I think you've answered that question very very very well. And I
[41:44] just asked for the sake of asking it because even I know, no,
[41:46] it crosses people's mind if you go onto YouTube now there are so many universe
[41:51] who make videos yaha Abbaitabad type operation and like with great details and stuff,
[41:57] and but the conclusions are thankfully all the same. Yeah, because yeah,
[42:00] you're right, this question does properbic. If this government is so all powerful,
[42:04] why doesn't just go go to Pakistan? Get thou Not that simple?
[42:07] And you also have to think of what are you willing to put at stake
[42:13] a war with Pakistan and international reactions, what happens if China gets involved.
[42:16] There's a lot more at stake. It's just for this one guy. He
[42:21] might be a big threat to you. His emparment b a big threat to
[42:22] you, but there is definitely a lot at stake. As we close,
[42:25] I want to spring bring you to one aspect of thou than the underworld.
[42:32] What explains the level of let's say, the kind of nexus he managed to
[42:40] have and I'm not sure if he still has, by the way, with
[42:44] some elements of the Indian establishment, whether it's the politicians, whether it's the
[42:46] security establishment, police intelligence, et cetera. I'll give an example what you
[42:52] referred to earlier before the break there was in a So just to be clear,
[42:55] this has never been formally accepted, but also has never been formally denied.
[43:00] By the way, it's a folklore in journalism. There have been reports
[43:02] about it, but no one has come on record to say. But no
[43:07] one also has says uh. There's a story that two of Shutajan's Uh Sutarajan,
[43:13] the underwol down who seemed to be the out rival, were sort of
[43:16] contracted by the intelligend Bureau or the ROW I'm not sure which ones to bump
[43:22] him off when there was some credible information that he was gonna fly from Karachi
[43:28] to Dubai to attend a meeting or some some event. There was information the
[43:32] Intel guys were sure that he'll be there, so they Contactedajan and they got
[43:37] two of his shooters to travel from Bombay to Delhi and they were supposed to
[43:42] take a flight from del Tubai. However, a team of Mumbai police ended
[43:45] up over there and arrested those guys. Watching the operation up again, like
[43:49] I said, widely reported no confirmation, but no denial as well. So
[43:52] you can make of that, whether you can choose to believe it or not.
[43:55] But my question to you, the controversy that came after that within journalsy
[44:00] circles was that this just once again proves to you that thou still has elements
[44:04] within the system, has people willing to work for him. There is a
[44:07] level level of corruption involved. After the blot of ninety two, the fact
[44:14] that he's associating with twenty six eleven, do you, as as somebody who's
[44:19] covered this field for so long, do you still think that level of interaction
[44:22] of thous elements with the system exists? And if it does, can you
[44:27] fathom why, because I really cannot. I don't know why anybody in the
[44:30] system would want to be associated with something like so the level of the level
[44:34] of penetration of thou within the Indian system definitely still exists. It hasn't been
[44:38] eradicated yet. And like I said that, that is very clear from the
[44:43] fact that up to forty percent of his business actually emanates or is indirectly linked
[44:49] to activities in India, whether real estate or havala. Now, you don't
[44:52] get to maintain that kind of an operation without having people on the inside.
[44:59] Right now, not to be cynical about it, but the way this works
[45:04] is two things they've and they're the two oldest things in the book, fear
[45:07] and money. Right in the seventies and the eighties, the way this was
[45:13] done was fear. You know, you don't act against me and I don't
[45:15] kill you, okay, So that was the price, and that was a
[45:19] great price which Bollywood filmmakers, actors, politicians, other businessmen were happy to
[45:27] pay extortion money in order to just be spared, right, So that transformed
[45:35] into finance, into actually being paid, you know, to be facilitators within
[45:39] the Indian system. So whether it was police officers, and at no point,
[45:44] remember are theyve and I you know, sort of casting as persions on
[45:49] entire services, because let's remember that whether it is the Mumbai Police, the
[45:52] ib the raw uh. These are for most part full of officers, men
[45:57] and women who've spent their entire lives, you know, hunting individuals like Daouds.
[46:01] So you can imagine what it feels like to see news reports of him
[46:06] being poisoned. But yeah, the length of Daoud's arm and the depth of
[46:13] his pockets continue to be, you know, very compelling for a system that,
[46:19] you know, let's face it, this is not a compromise proof system.
[46:22] This is a system that has since independent's been primed for corruption and compromise,
[46:30] you know, whether it is how our police systems are structured, how
[46:34] the reporting system works, how surveillance and accountability exist. I imagine that now
[46:39] it's much more difficult to do that kind of thing. It must be much
[46:43] more difficult, but not impossible. And let's remember that even crime organizations and
[46:47] terror organizations like the d Company, they are also shape shifting. They've they
[46:52] also learning the new ways of doing things. They also know, okay,
[46:55] this surveillance system is now in force or this kind of over uh, you
[47:00] know, oversight exists now in the Mumbai Police or this place or that agency.
[47:04] So they do things differently. So the manner in which they turn people
[47:07] or compromise or by assets has also evolved over time, I imagine. I
[47:13] don't know the specifics of it, but I'm sure it must have evolved because
[47:15] they're also not just sitting around and doing things the old way. You know.
[47:19] The era of digital money, the era of crypto, the era of
[47:22] uh, you know, online currency, and all this stuff must must have
[47:27] brought an entirely new paradigm of being able to recruit people in India, being
[47:32] able to pay them off, you know, without the agencies sitting up and
[47:37] taking notice. All of these offer avenues to organizations like that would So I'm
[47:42] sure it still must be the case, but it's still the same thing.
[47:44] It's the only thing is now, I imagine, because their violent operations are
[47:51] restricted to financing terror activity abroad. So now it must be less about fear
[47:55] and more about money. Yeah. Yeah, good point. And you know,
[47:59] like you said, were not casting us versions on the entire system and
[48:01] every people associated in it, because you made the point that you know,
[48:06] it's the system that is also that has been flowed since independence. So obviously
[48:08] you have these bad apples, but also I would like to add that you
[48:12] know, you. The systems, after all, are filled with human beings,
[48:15] and human beings un corruptible. That's a fact. You cannot be one
[48:21] hundred percent sure of every person within your system. There will be bad apples.
[48:23] There will be people who are enticed by money, and that also happens
[48:27] on the other side. By the way, this is how this game of
[48:29] works, right. You have the good guys turning the bad apples of thousand
[48:34] Empire in their faces, and you have them turning the bad apples from your
[48:37] team, like Shota, a great example of that age and used to be
[48:39] part of the d Company, exactly turned by raw And you know, you
[48:43] said, we can choose to believe it or not. I totally believe it.
[48:46] Even Jan was you know, sort of crafted as this the patriotic you
[48:52] know, perfect and then it became the you know, first it was patriotic
[48:54] down then it was the Hindu don against the Muslim crime lord. You know,
[48:59] all these all these things which are very magazine and media friendly, were
[49:02] created in order to make this a very palatable story. And that's the reason
[49:06] why your you know, your Anura Kashyavs and your ramas you know, have
[49:10] reveled in telling these stories because these are interesting characters, of course, definitely,
[49:15] you know, and all the all the beautiful Masala layers that the gangsters
[49:17] have brought us are very very compelling stories. So shootout for at Lukanwala and
[49:22] your Black Fridays and all these stories. You know, there's so much truth
[49:27] in them. But I don't think any anyone must lose sight of the fact
[49:30] that these were terrorists, their their reasons and their you know, their impulses.
[49:36] What was compelling them was you know, was was money, fear destruction,
[49:40] that kind of thing. Nothing else. Yeah, and this is exactly
[49:44] why we decided to talk about this on this episode, because it is compelling,
[49:49] and like you said at the beginning, that people have been talking about
[49:52] this online just like left and and Stenter for the last two three days,
[49:54] and we just thought that with your expertise, we'll be able to kind of
[49:57] dissect and get some practicality involved in as well. And it's not as simple
[50:01] as it doesn't happen, by the way, Thanks Shiv, Thanks a lot.
[50:07] Third episode in and I think we're already doing a great so thanks also
[50:12] to our listeners and a thank you, thank you, thanks as always to
[50:15] our lovely producer and a pre audition and once again you know do leave us
[50:20] a feedback, leave us a comment on YouTube. If you're watching us on
[50:22] YouTube before listening to us on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, you can drop a
[50:25] WhatsApp to us at eight five double eight nine, double six, double nine
[50:28] six. That's it for this week's defense. Do us for more, tune
[50:30] in next week. Till then, stay safe and're not watching Boundary to the Passport

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
