# Indian Navy Rafale jet deal in sight | In Our Defence, S02, Ep 29

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 4 Jul 2024, 48 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/60601028/04_jul_24_iod_4_july_mix_128.mp3

India and France are negotiating a Rs 50,000-crore deal for 26 Rafale Marine (Rafale M) fighter jets. If finalised, these aircraft will be deployed on the Indian Navy's aircraft carriers, INS Vikrant and INS Vikramaditya. Why the Rafale M? The French Rafale M emerged as the frontrunner against its competitor, the American Boeing F/A-18 Super Hornet. Why does the Navy need a new fighter jet? The Indian Navy’s current fleet, primarily composed of ageing Sukhoi jets, is becoming obsolete. This decline in capability is driving the urgent need for new, modern fighters. But how does the Rafale M differ from the IAF’s Rafale? Interestingly, the Rafale M predates the Air Force version. Despite this, France completed the delivery of all 36 Rafale jets to the Indian Air Force in December 2022, following a Rs 59,000-crore deal signed in September 2016. Why didn't the Navy and Air Force consolidate their orders together? A joint deal could have potentially reduced post-purchase costs. And why the repeated trials? If the government had already determined that the Rafale M was the best choice, why did they conduct another contest only to choose the same fighter jet again? We tackle these tough questions and more. Tune in and share your thoughts at pods@indiatoday.com or text us at 8588966996! Produced by Anna Priydarshini Sound mix by Kapil Dev Singh

## Transcript

[0:00] This is India Today podcasts. Fun fact the Rafael M came before the Raphael
[0:09] Air Force version. Wow. The hard truth of the MAKE twenty nine K
[0:13] is that it is simply not the optimal frontline fighter for a navy of the
[0:18] kind that the Indian Navy has become in the last ten years. The fact
[0:22] that the Raffa has been chosen for the Navy as well, despite all the
[0:26] politics that was played over the Raffale in the twenty nineteen election campaign, shows
[0:30] that the government has taken a very strategic hard stance not to bow to politics
[0:35] when it comes to defense deals, which is in my view, a very
[0:38] good thing because politics only benefits the companies, it never benefits the country.
[0:42] The simple reason is the Air Force would not ever deign to share negotiating space
[0:48] with the Navy. Okay, Wow, I will take what shit comes my
[0:52] way for having said this, and anyone who wants to argue back with me,
[0:55] I will eat it. If you have a museum of fighters. The
[0:58] entire point of trying to economize and you know, make in India and create
[1:02] capacity here in India is about commonality and saving costs and bang for your buck
[1:07] and all those wonderful things, then why is there even a context? Yes?
[1:11] Exactly. Hello and welcome to Another Defense, a weekly podcast on all
[1:17] things well defense, where I they've Goswami, your host, along with senior
[1:22] journalist Shivarur, break down the world of conflicts that range from the subtle to
[1:26] the brute. We bring you nuances and perspectives that will inform and at times
[1:30] provoke. This is in our Defense. Hello and welcome to the twenty ninth
[1:41] episode of Another Defense. Hi, Schev, how are you all good?
[1:44] Twenty nine episodes already, Yeah, difficult to believe. Yes, and I'm
[1:48] pretty sure we'll reach hundred very very soon. All right, So what do
[1:52] we want to talk about this week? Let's talk about the Raffel jet if
[1:56] you can see it in the frame. I was in Chanderguard, i think
[1:59] last week, and there's a museum that was opened. I think a year
[2:01] ago. Air Force had as musing God from there. But that's of the
[2:06] reason we're talking about, and that's not the reason I got it. Actually,
[2:08] we'll talk about the naval refel uh and and the Navys fighter jet,
[2:14] not let's not say program, but the fleet, et cetera, et cetera,
[2:16] because that's something that no people not generally talk about when you say fighter
[2:20] jets just associated with air Force and the legacy problems we faced. We've spent
[2:23] I think two three episodes talking about the air forces issues with its fighter jet
[2:28] fleets. They just the rafel that the Air Force has, and I think
[2:32] this episode, let's talk about the Navy before we get into the what Navy
[2:38] wants from a fighter jet and what's happening with the fl deal for the Navy.
[2:42] Can you explain briefly the difference between an air Force fighter jet and naval
[2:46] fighter jet because on the looks of it, they kind of look similar.
[2:50] But how different are they because obviously they operate from different decks and one,
[2:53] you operate from land, you have a longer runway, you have space to
[2:57] do much more, while the Navy naval jet obviously operate from a very very
[3:01] thin strip. So when it comes to the ionix of the of the fighter
[3:05] jet, when it comes to the structure of the fighter jet, how different
[3:07] is a naval fighter jet from an airflight So so you know this this is
[3:12] one of my favorite topics, and if you remember, they've this is a
[3:14] topic on which we've both gotten into trouble in the past. One notorious episode
[3:19] where we were both talking about, you know, naval pilots versus Air force
[3:23] pilots. And I can tell you that even now my social media will always
[3:27] have a few mentions every single day on Instagram and on Twitter on that one
[3:32] episode. I can't remember which one it is, but we we link it
[3:35] in the description where we we had it out over who do we prefer naval
[3:39] pilots or air force pilots. If you guys have missed that, go and
[3:43] check that out. It's a detailed discussion on what that is. But the
[3:46] reason why THEVE and I have come back to it today is because of the
[3:50] Indian Navy's deal that's being negotiated right now. They've for twenty six Raphal maritime
[3:57] fighter jets for its aircraft carriers. Now, as our viewers already know,
[4:00] the Indian Air Force currently operates two squadrons of Raffales, the Air Force version
[4:05] of the Raphile, which operates from conventional runways use are. These are thirty
[4:12] six in all, which are currently deployed in two squadrons. One is based
[4:16] in Umbala in Ariana. That takes care of your northern sectors and one based
[4:23] in Hashimara in West Bengal, which takes care of your uh you know,
[4:27] the Eastern sector China, et cetera. So two squadrons of raffles already in
[4:31] operation, in service, active flying every day, you know, conducting weapons,
[4:38] you know, weapons testing, all of that for the last few years.
[4:41] So that's that's part A of the answer. Part me is the Indian
[4:45] Navy now needs new fighter jets to operate off its aircraft carriers. Uh it
[4:49] currently, as you know, as many people know, the Indian Navy currently
[4:54] has two aircraft carriers on which they operate, uh you know, the mid
[4:58] twenty nine K fighter jets, which are your operational sort of you know,
[5:02] your standard fighter jet for the navy is the mid twenty nine K. But
[5:06] the Indian Navy has been for a long time looking for a new generation,
[5:11] more capable fighter jet, and they've been casting their eyes on the West,
[5:15] which is also quite well known. They want to move away from Russian Russian
[5:19] stuff and go towards slightly higher quality, you know, better you know,
[5:25] better quality Western equipment. So that's where the Raphal comes into the picture now.
[5:30] So so that's we'll talk about those negotiations in a bit. But to
[5:32] answer your question, an air force fighter and a naval fighter, you know,
[5:36] on the you know, on the surface, they don't look very different.
[5:41] Obviously, they look very similar. They conduct for for for most part,
[5:46] pretty similar operations. You know, there's a there's a quite a bit
[5:48] of overlap in terms of what each of the fighters can do. But obviously
[5:53] there are very very big and fundamental differences between the two, the most obvious
[5:57] being that an air force fighter is built to operate from uh, you know,
[6:00] the kind of runway you see in any airport. Uh. And a
[6:03] naval fighter, which can do the same thing, it can it can operate
[6:06] from any runway, of course, but it's its specialized task is to operate
[6:12] off an aircraft carrier deck, which is a ship deck, which, like
[6:15] you rightly pointed out, is a tiny, little, uh you know,
[6:18] runway on a pitching and rolling ocean. So it's a very very difficult,
[6:23] uh and confined space on which to actually land and operate an aircraft. Uh.
[6:29] And because because of this fundamental difference, the aircraft are engineered quite differently,
[6:34] uh, you know, the the landing, the landing dynamics, the
[6:38] takeoff dynamics, they're all, you know, vastly different. Uh. You
[6:44] know, even though the even though the aero dynamics and the the the general
[6:47] way in which these aircraft fly are exactly the same. Uh. The engine
[6:50] is exactly the same. Uh, the undercarriage is vastly different because these aircraft
[6:56] have to land on tiny surfaces, you know of a roller and pitching runway,
[7:00] which is literally not staying in one place. So so so there are
[7:05] many features on these aircraft that make them different. You know. They are
[7:10] specifically designed from scratch in order to land in a much harder way and not
[7:16] have the kind of smooth, gentle landing that you have on a on a
[7:20] you know, on a on a runway, on a normal land runway.
[7:24] They are you know, they are launched through a catapult launch. They don't
[7:28] have a takeoff role. They're literally thrown into the air using you know,
[7:31] steam energy on nuclear energy in the case of the American aircraft carriers, and
[7:35] they land using a trapping mechanism where they have a tailhook which basically traps on
[7:41] you know, one of three or four while arresting cables that are there on
[7:46] the ships. So apart from the landing and takeoff mechanism. Obviously, because
[7:50] of where these aircraft operate, the mission profiles are slightly different, you know,
[7:56] even though these aircraft can be armed identically in a very similar way.
[8:00] Uh. These these aircraft that operate on ships typically are used for fleet defense,
[8:05] for fleet air defense, you know, to defend the entire fleet.
[8:09] They can conduct anti ship operations, they can conduct uh, you know,
[8:13] they can conduct intelligence gathering operations out at sea. Uh. There are there
[8:16] are obviously also some engineering differences they've in terms of navalized aircraft. So navalizing
[8:22] an aircraft basically also means using materials that you know, give the aircraft the
[8:28] capacity to operate in extremely saline weather uh, and saline conditions. Salt is
[8:35] a corrosive. You know, salt is something we eat every day, but
[8:37] it's also an extreme corrosive, you know, Salty sea air, which is
[8:43] rich in you know, salt drenched humidity, has a very corrosive effect on
[8:48] metals and materials. And therefore, naval aircraft have to be built with materials
[8:52] that are capable of withstanding that kind of thing and not you know, quickly
[8:56] being eroded or rusting away. So all of these differences make naval eg craft
[9:00] different from aircraft. So these are also basically therefore the differences between the Air
[9:05] Force rafle which we operate and the naval raffle which we are negotiating to operate.
[9:11] A right, So tell us about what's the scene with the Indian Navy's
[9:13] a fighter fleet. So because like I mentioned at the beginning of this episode
[9:18] that historically we know the media is always focused on the air Force's depleting fleet,
[9:24] but if you look at navies or fighting numbers, even those aren't that
[9:26] great. I mean, there's no official full number out there, but I
[9:30] think they have around forty make twenty nine case that operate from both and both
[9:35] the ships, by the way, have a full capacity of around I think
[9:37] seventy two aircraft, which this also includes space for some helicopters, so I
[9:41] would guess maybe the two together would have space for let's say sixty sixty two
[9:46] maybe fighter jets. So the Navy is under the fleet and the naval fighter
[9:52] fleet is not up to the mark they would require. Remember, the Navy
[9:56] also is looking for a third aircraft carrier, another version of Finess Big runs
[9:58] justmmissioned a couple of years ago. Why have we never talked about Indian Navy's
[10:03] depleting fighter squadron strength? And what's the scene that the Navy has right now?
[10:09] Is the Navy just like you know, done with it? Are they
[10:13] really really old? And is that the reason that we are looking for a
[10:15] new modern, modern acra. So you know, your question is going to
[10:18] actually gladden the hearts of the Navy and naval aviators, which is because it's
[10:22] a question that they have asked in a small voice from the sidelines amidst the
[10:28] blaring narrative of squeak squadron depletions of the air Force and the Navy, which
[10:33] feels, you know, sidelined on the best of days, is like,
[10:37] you know, what about our fighter numbers? You know, you know,
[10:41] we don't exactly have healthy fighter numbers or you know, quality or quantity.
[10:46] So they have they have a major problem. Now. The truth of the
[10:50] matter is the Navy has struggled because of a variety of reasons. Its current
[10:56] fleet is entirely dominated by one type of fighter aircraft, which is the mid
[11:01] twenty nine K, which operates off the Vikrama, the aircraft carrier, and
[11:05] it's already it's also conducted some landings on the I V Rant and will be
[11:11] soon fully operational. I'm told now, the mid twenty nine K. Let's
[11:15] make no mistake. Mdwenty nine K is a is a terrific, terrific piece
[11:18] of aircraft. It's a it's a it's it's a fighter that pilots love.
[11:22] It's a it's a fighter aircraft that you know, that you know. The
[11:24] Navy has appreciated. It chose the MIKE twenty nine K for most part,
[11:28] even though there's a backstory. I'll tell you about that also in a little
[11:31] while, But the fact is, at one level, the Navy is kind
[11:35] of saddled with the MC twenty nine K because it's not a new generation aircraft.
[11:41] It has it has been sort of restricted by what can only be described
[11:50] as major serviceability and maintenance issues. Like you rightly pointed out, forty five,
[11:56] what was the number that we purchased. Five been lost in accidents and
[12:01] been written off in various instances. That's not abnormal, that's that's that happens
[12:05] in military operations. So there are forty roughly two squadrons of Make twenty nine
[12:11] k's that are currently operational. The truth, the hard truth of the make
[12:16] twenty nine K is that it is simply not the optimal frontline fighter for a
[12:22] navy of the kind that the Indian Navy has become in the last ten years,
[12:26] the kind of navy that has responsibilities that go way beyond its own waters,
[12:31] that has responsibilities that now are part of Quad and Malabar Rising, you
[12:37] know, China, the South China Sea where you where you now have allies
[12:41] you know in the South China Sea, countries, et cetera. And therefore
[12:46] you need, you know, you need assets and weapons and aircraft which are
[12:52] which are many degrees more capable than your kind of bread and butter fighters.
[12:56] The great thing about so fighters and the mid twenty nine K is a Soviet
[13:01] origin fighter, is that they do the job. They will do the job.
[13:05] But the point is the Indian Navy and the Indian military in general need
[13:11] military hardware and aircraft especially that do much more than the job. Because air
[13:16] power in the Indian context, especially in the last ten years, has gone
[13:20] from being tactical, which is, you know, causing effects in your immediate
[13:24] neighborhood, to causing much more strategic effects sending out you know, power projection
[13:31] to areas way beyond the horizon line to be able to tell the region that
[13:37] you are the you are the you know, the number one force in the
[13:41] region, and that a country like China, which is unpredictable, you know,
[13:46] that has been you know, had this runaway kind of capacity accretion in
[13:50] its navy cannot be trusted to you know, govern these waters in a fair
[13:56] manner. And therefore India is that counter balancing force. Now, obviously,
[14:00] a strong navy is more than just aircraft carriers and aircraft. That is just
[14:05] one out of a million things that need to happen for the Navy to sort
[14:09] of step up into that big role that the world expects of it. But
[14:13] aircraft carriers and aircraft do, pray play a very significant part, maybe one
[14:16] in a million, but it's still a very very important and indispensable part.
[14:20] And therefore the mid twenty nine K simply don't cut it. The good news
[14:26] is that the Indian Navy had realized this quite quite early on. You know,
[14:30] I'm sure we'll do us an entirely separate offshoot episode on the ionis Viklamara,
[14:35] which was earlier called the Admiral Goshkov, And like many things in the
[14:39] Indian military. It was something that the Indian Navy sort of didn't really have
[14:43] a choice with. The Admiral Goshkov came with mid twenty nine K fighters,
[14:46] so they didn't really have a choice in terms of I mean a bit of
[14:52] a you know, a bit of a play was made in terms of whether
[14:54] they could choose fighters, but ultimately it came down to us share saying,
[14:56] look, with this aircraft, this is the fighter that works. So these
[15:01] are the fighters you'll have to take. So they were actually, you know,
[15:05] practically the aircraft were even developed and navalized using Indian money. So it's
[15:11] another one of those kind of you know, fifty shades of gray kind of
[15:13] tails. And we'll get into that on another occasion. But the simple fact
[15:18] of the matter is now the Indian Navy is clear that it needs to move
[15:22] beyond the mid twenty nine K and that's where there are futcmes in. I
[15:26] love that nugget about how the fighters came with the carrier because when I was
[15:30] researching for this episode, I realized that that Russia does not even use mcrane
[15:33] in case they have I think recently placed in order because I think they use
[15:37] the thing the suit thirty three if I'm not wrong, but that those are
[15:41] retiring. So now they say mcgrant produce. But to imagine a country developing
[15:46] a fighter jet for a navy and then not even placing orders for them,
[15:50] and they're giving it like they don't use the Bramos. Yes, right,
[15:54] So I think that's a good idea. We should do a separate episode on
[15:56] that. I think a on Russia, actually Russia and that lay episodes are
[16:00] coming up for sure in this season, no doubt about it. Right,
[16:03] So let's talk about the Rafael that the navy's negotiating for. I think the
[16:07] best way to describe it would be in your previous answer what you said,
[16:11] and I think previously in one of the episodes you spoke about how the Raffael
[16:14] is basically a weapon that is meant not to be used because if India has
[16:18] to use a rafl that means, you know, war is war is coming.
[16:21] So it's kind of a deet rend force, which is exactly what it
[16:22] said the Navy is looking for, which is what the mcquin and kid does
[16:25] not give the Navy, right right, So tell us about the Rafael M
[16:27] the naval variant for which negotiations are going going on right now. We'll talk
[16:30] about the bureaucracy of that after the break perhaps, But about the jet,
[16:36] what the Navy wants from the jet? Are we also looking for, like
[16:38] we did with the air Force deal, some modifications to kind of suit our
[16:41] needs the domain that we operate in. The aircraft that we have, for
[16:48] example, I think we have the ramp takeoff and not the steam one that
[16:51] you kind of described earlier in this episode. So what are we looking for?
[16:55] I think we're looking for a deal of around fifty thousand for like you
[16:59] said, twenty twenty six, twenty six of which four would be for your
[17:03] two seater trainers and twenty two would be single seaters. So what are we
[17:06] looking for? Where is the deal right now? And how assumed you expect
[17:11] it to get close? Because you've been talking about this deal, by the
[17:12] way, for a couple of years now. So the Indian Navy's you know,
[17:15] quest for new generation deck based fighters has been on for you know,
[17:22] the better half of a decade now, better part of a decade in fact,
[17:25] in fact more than that, So it has gone through many different avatars.
[17:30] The original number was it was looking for fifty seven aircraft. You know,
[17:33] when it was realized that you know, this is an unmanageably large number
[17:37] when you don't even have the aircraft carrier to justify that number. You know
[17:41] that it was whittled down to just twenty six aircraft. Not twenty six is
[17:45] by no means a small number. It's still a big numbers. It's basically
[17:49] about two small squadrons. But the Navy is happy with that because the Navy
[17:55] actually sees the Rapha as something of a stop gap. Now we'll come back
[17:59] to the problems with this whole stop gap concept that we have in the Indian
[18:03] military, which has been the root cause of many different problems. But that
[18:07] that maybe also for another episode, but I'll touch upon that now. The
[18:11] rafael M is obviously you know, it's a it's it's a naval fighter.
[18:17] Fun fact, the rafael M came before the Raphael air force version. Wow.
[18:22] So when the Raffaele was built, Uh, the Raffle was actually built
[18:26] as a naval fighter and then it spawned an air force version, which is
[18:30] actually the easier way to do things because when you build a build a naval
[18:33] fighter and you need to spin off an air force land version, you're actually
[18:38] simplifying the jet. But if you do it in reverse, which many other
[18:42] people have, you're actually complicating the jet because you have to re engineer many
[18:47] parts of it. So the raffaele M came before, before the Vanilla Rafaele
[18:51] that the Air Force uses. Uh. That's that's one small not important,
[18:55] but it's important in terms of how we are looking at the rafile now.
[18:59] So the raffa M has only one customer right now, and that's the French
[19:02] Navy. They operated off one aircraft carrier, that's the Charles Degaul. But
[19:07] that one aircraft carrier, that one group. And I've visited I've visited the
[19:11] you know, the the home of the Raphael in north northwestern France in a
[19:18] place called on the Visio many years ago. Uh and uh. These are
[19:21] these are highly capable aircraft that were purpose built for naval operations and for power
[19:26] projection. So these are extremely agile aircraft. They're capable of carrying a lot
[19:32] of weaponry. The French Navy was the was the prime you know, the
[19:36] prime customer for the Raphael, so they called all the shots. It's something
[19:40] that's almost unthinkable in the Indian context, right the Navy calling the shots in
[19:44] terms of what some a piece of aircraft is going to look like. That
[19:47] may happen with the twin engine deck based fighter, but if that actually comes
[19:51] to a reality, I have my own doubts about that. Uh So,
[19:53] the raphaele m is A is one of perhaps two current through blue purpose built
[20:02] naval fighters. The other is the F eighteen Hornet or the Super Hornet,
[20:07] which is also currently in operations and which actually competed against the Rafael for this
[20:11] Indian Navy contract. So the Raphael is A is a fighter that operates off
[20:17] one aircraft carrier. The Air Force version of the Rafahle, which is built
[20:19] by Dasso as well, has many customers. India was the first foreign customer.
[20:25] There have been other customers since then, you know, Kata and Egypt
[20:29] and many other countries have ordered the Raphael. But the Indian Navy, when
[20:33] it places this order, when it completes negotiations and places its order, will
[20:37] be the first export customer of the naval Raffle, the raffaele M, as
[20:41] you rightly said. Uh and that's a big deal, you know, for
[20:44] India to be just the second operator of that aircraft. You know, makes
[20:48] it a huge validation and an affirmation of that aircraft. But it's also not
[20:52] surprising because remember that India operates the RAPHAAL already h and commonality is a huge,
[21:00] huge thing when it comes to defense procurement. You know, if you
[21:03] have the infrastructure to support, maintain and operate a type of aircraft, why
[21:07] wouldn't you want to operate more of the same type, you know, which
[21:11] would lead to the question, how similar is the raffaele M to the Air
[21:15] Force raffle You know, there are various things that do the around. There's
[21:18] sixty percent similar, seventy percent similar, eighty percent similar. The spare parts
[21:22] are all the same, you know. The line replaceable units are all the
[21:25] same. The you know, the other the aggregates, the lubricants, the
[21:30] maintenance procedures and protocols, they're all the same. Those are all major major
[21:34] elements of economy. And you know, cost saving because you have one type
[21:38] and you don't need to completely, you know, create infrastructure for a different
[21:45] type of aircraft. And I think that was one of the one, not
[21:48] all, but one of the reasons why the Indian Navy chose the rafael But
[21:52] it is very important to note that that is not the only reason the Indian
[21:56] Navy still went through the motions of UH you know, conducting field evaluation tests
[22:02] of aircraft. It invited bids from countries across the world that made aircraft.
[22:07] Even countries that don't have naval aircraft submitted bids, which is which is why
[22:12] the Indian Navy's quest for these deck based fighters was actually a fascinating kind of
[22:19] almost like a beauty contest. It was incredible. You had Sweden, which
[22:26] makes the Grippin Air Force fighter, propose a product called the Sea Grippin doesn't
[22:32] exist only on paper. But for the Indian deal Sea Grippin, you had
[22:36] a Eurofighter, which is the air Bus, and the European company which makes
[22:38] the Typhoon UH propose something called the maritime Typhoon for the Indian Navy doesn't exist.
[22:45] It just exists. It only existed as a brochure aircraft. And because
[22:51] the Indian Navy is a force that cannot be ignored, it's a big customer.
[22:55] All these companies know that the Indian Navy will because of it's because of
[22:59] the UH you know, responsibilities that will be put on India in the years
[23:02] ahead. Because of China, the Indian Navy will become a hungrier and hungrier
[23:06] customer will need more aircraft. And therefore all these people literally created these concept
[23:11] aircraft on brochures and proposed them. But ultimately the reality was that there are
[23:17] only two aircraft that can actively participate in field evaluations, and that was the
[23:22] Raphai M and the American F eighteen souper on it. So the tests happened
[23:27] in Goa. Multiple kinds of different kinds of you know, criteria were tested,
[23:34] different kinds of takeoff profiles, different kinds of weapons load profiles. All
[23:40] of these were taken into account in addition to the fact that the Air Force
[23:42] also already operates the Raphai which which remember will also reduce your training costs.
[23:49] If you already have a large fleet of rafaele pilots, you don't need to
[23:53] go abroad the train, right, even though the training is quite different because
[23:57] you're doing carrier based training, but there are savings to be made when you
[24:03] have a similar kind of aircraft across the Indian Navy and the Indian Air Force.
[24:07] And I think that's the reason why the Raphile inmost choose right. Right,
[24:11] we'll talk about the negotiations and like I said, the bureaucracy, the
[24:15] great Indian bureaucracy when it comes to deals like these. But up a quick
[24:18] break. India Likes podcast Today. Welcome to India Today Podcasts, a repository
[24:29] of thoughtful audio discussions for the comfort of those who want to consume information on
[24:34] the go. Catches on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts and other audio
[24:40] platforms. Tune in now Welcome back. Shaven are discussing the Indian Navy's quest
[24:51] to get a new fighter jet. India has finalized the FLM negotiations still going
[24:56] on, so the deal could fall through, but I don't see that happening
[24:59] because of reasons that ship described just before the break of the reasons the Navy
[25:03] has chosen this aircraft, one of which is the fact that you already have
[25:07] the Air Force using the aircraft, which would reduce a lot of your post
[25:11] purchase cost of maintenance, training, ETCA. Tell us what happens in these
[25:15] negotiations. Who's part of it? I'm guessing there would be civilians from the
[25:18] Finance ministry, there would be a people from a defense ministry, and there
[25:22] would also be naval officers involved in the team. I remember there was a
[25:26] team that that a Feil deal which kind of fell through during the upa years.
[25:29] We'll come back to that and the next segment. But what happens in
[25:33] these deals? Because I came across this this this fancyful term known as the
[25:37] DPP the Defense Procurement Procedures. So there's a laid out PDF if anyone's interested,
[25:42] you can google it here. The Ministry of Defense has on their website
[25:45] with chapters which describe of how a negotiating team should go about doing a negotiation
[25:52] for defense deals. And you know, we can make fun of it,
[25:55] but that there's a reason for that because these are huge. This is a
[25:57] big, big, big money money. So there has to be obviously laid
[26:02] on procedures to ensure that the money is being well, is used well,
[26:04] and spent well. What happens during these negotiations is it just about the money
[26:10] bit or is it also a bit more than that? So these are called
[26:11] techno commercial negotiations, which means that there are teams on both sides which sit
[26:18] across literally sit across the table in a conference room, you know, with
[26:22] with computers and spreadsheets and projectors and things like that and actually incrementally hammer out
[26:30] what will finally become you know, the master document that will be used to
[26:37] execute the contract. Now, according to as per my information, these negotiations
[26:41] began sometime at the end of May. That's when the first negotiation team from
[26:48] from France, which was basically comprised of people from DASSO persons from the French
[26:53] MOD had come down. And similarly the price NEGO the Techno Commercial Negotiation Committee
[27:00] UH from here in India is comprised of people from the Ministry of Defense,
[27:04] Department of Finance, you know, various bureaucrats, members of the Indian Navy,
[27:11] like you rightly said, but also interestingly members of the Air Force because
[27:15] because they've they're the datas of the raphile. Now, you know, they've
[27:18] been through the motions, they've they've seen the whole thing through. You know,
[27:22] they know where all the issues are, they know what the negotiating points
[27:26] are. You know, even though they they're not the ones who pull the
[27:29] strings. It's finally the MOD and the government. But you know, they've
[27:33] literally been through this process. So they're there obviously as observers, advisors,
[27:37] uh and that kind of thing. So those negotiations have been happening. The
[27:41] intention, according to the Indian Navy is that they hope to see a government
[27:47] to government contract being signed within this financial year, which is very ambitious.
[27:51] Remember that's very ambitious. But this government has shown that when it comes to
[27:55] government to government deals, it doesn't let the grass grow under its face.
[28:00] It's usually quite quick to do that. We saw that with the twenty sixteen
[28:03] Rafael deal, which the Modi government, the first movie government had signed in
[28:07] twenty sixteen. You know, it happened very very quickly, if you remember.
[28:12] And the fact that the RAFA has been chosen for the Navy as well,
[28:18] despite all the politics that was played over the RAPHA in the twenty nineteen
[28:22] election campaign, shows that the government, you know, has taken a very
[28:26] strategic hard stance not to bow to politics when it comes to defense deals,
[28:32] which is which is in my view, a very good thing because politics only
[28:34] benefits the companies. It never benefits the country. I'm very very clear about
[28:38] that. The only people who would suffer because of you know, politics over
[28:44] scams, alleged scams, et cetera, is the Navy in this case.
[28:48] And so the negotiations will continue in a very very detailed manner. They go
[28:55] into every aspect literally the nutsymbolds of the aircraft. Good news is since since
[29:00] the Indian Air Force did it just a few couple of a few years ago
[29:06] and is well versed in negotiating a deal of this kind, it'll be all
[29:11] It'll be a slightly more straightforward process. Still complicated because a different aircraft,
[29:17] different deal. It's not connected to that deal because it's not a follow on
[29:22] order or an options order. It's a it's an all new by itself order
[29:26] for aircraft, et cetera. It'll be an all new deal. But like
[29:30] I said, India has whatever you may say about the DPP, and you
[29:37] know how many things India has negotiated over the years, Every new negotiation is
[29:41] a new negotiation, believe me. So they can go very very quickly like
[29:45] they did with the RAPHAL, or they can wind for years and years and
[29:48] years. I think the current record is nineteen years for the Hawk trainers.
[29:52] That's how long wow, things went between different countries until India signed a deal.
[29:57] So there is no reason and to believe that this deal won't happen this
[30:02] year. I mean it could slip by a year perhaps, but I don't
[30:06] see that happening because it seems like, uh, you know, all the
[30:08] boxes in terms of process have been ticked. So in terms of what will
[30:12] be negotiated will be price, what will be negotiated and confirmed will be configuration.
[30:18] Uh, what the India specific enhancements will be. I read a report
[30:22] recently by by my friend and colleagues naj in the print where he talks about
[30:27] how most of the enhancements that the Indian Navy is looking for are mostly software
[30:33] specific for different kinds of mission profiles, whether weather radar, you know,
[30:38] capabilities, uh, you know, certain specific tweaks to what the French RAFAEL
[30:44] can do, you know for the specific Indian context, which is not unusual
[30:48] at all, which is something that the Indian Air Force has also done.
[30:51] Uh. There is a possibility of some additional weapons which will be which will
[30:55] be obviously contracted because remember the the Indian Air Force RAFAL does and have anti
[31:00] ship missiles, so the Indian Navy missile. It stands to reason that there
[31:03] will be anti ship weaponry and uh, you know, other other kinds of
[31:07] uh over ocean intelligence gathering sensors which might be part of the deal. So
[31:12] all of that will be negotiated. It's a very very painstaking thing. You
[31:17] know, rooms full of papers are gone through and uh you know, a
[31:22] final master document will be created. Right. A slightly tangential point on the
[31:26] topic of negotiations and what to me seems short sightedness. Two things. One,
[31:33] why couldn't we have done the negotiation for a naval Rafael along with the
[31:37] Air Force Rafael, considering that you knew even then that you needed a fighter
[31:41] jets for your navy because you said that navy real is more than a decade
[31:45] ago. That is now, Hello, our MiGs are kind of getting old,
[31:48] be new new fighters. I'm retty sure the government must have been told
[31:51] so when you had flouted that ambitious MMRCA tender which fell through a multi uh
[31:56] sorry media, multi role combat combat air craft under the UPA, you stand
[32:00] to reason that you might as well if I added, like you know,
[32:02] forty odd you know, fighter jets for your navy. It would have been
[32:07] simpler because same company negotiating with so you. If you negotiate one grand deal
[32:10] for two different forces, I'm guessing you'd have some savings. And the second
[32:15] point, on a similar note, is that the MMRCA has now turned into
[32:17] an mr MRF, a multi roll fighter. Why why do you have to
[32:25] repackage that deal when you have already bought Ruffle So there is still this tantalizing
[32:30] possibility that you could end up with a new another because you know, ship
[32:34] has previously described the Air Force as a museum of you know, fighter jets,
[32:37] and there is still a possibility that the Air Force will end up adding
[32:39] one more different version of fighter Genet s kitty. So why do you have
[32:43] this MRFA if you already are happy with thefl and what happened to the navel?
[32:45] You've gone to a wave, You've gone to a very painful place for
[32:51] the Indian Navy. Uh. And you know I'm not going to break tradition
[32:54] and sugarcoat my answer. The simple answer to your question why the Air Force
[33:00] and Navy couldn't have negotiated one common deal and got all these aircraft as part
[33:05] of one deal. The simple reason is the Air Force would not ever deign
[33:10] to share negotiating space with the Navy. Okay, wow, I will take
[33:15] what shit comes my way for having said this, and anyone wants to argue
[33:20] back with me, I will eat it. The truth is we can talk
[33:23] until the cows come home about jointmanship, about operating together, about theaterization,
[33:30] et cetera. But if you can't sit and figure out modernization, capacity creation,
[33:37] weaponization, you know, a capital acquisition in an integrated manner, then
[33:44] you can forget about everything else because what you've said makes absolute sense. And
[33:49] you're right. It's not like the Indian Navy has now come to know that
[33:52] they need these fighters. They've always known, but then they've you know,
[33:55] if if sense, if you know the big picture, and all these luxurious
[34:05] concepts were part of the everyday way of doing things, you know, I
[34:09] think we'd have the military, would have a lot of money for other things
[34:14] right now. The fact is that does isn't how it works. I don't
[34:16] want to oversimplify it and say I'm sure there are other reasons as well.
[34:21] There are budget priorities, there are there are issues of capacity utilization. There's
[34:27] an entire ladder of priorities in terms of what can happen can't happen in a
[34:30] certain year. It's easy. I'm sure some people listening, and I'm sure
[34:34] officers in the Air Force are going to say, ship, it's very easy
[34:37] for you to sit there in that red chair with Dave and talk about you
[34:40] know, why can't Indian Navy and Indian Air Force just sit together and order
[34:44] the same aircraft. I know it's not that simple, but believe me,
[34:46] sometimes it is that simple. Okay. I'm always suspicious of people who start
[34:52] an argument by saying it's not that simple, okay, because oftentimes it is.
[34:59] Okay. And in this particular case, you're right, it could very
[35:02] much have been possible. And let me let me make the bad news even
[35:06] worse, because you've got thirty six rafiles with the Air Force, You've got
[35:10] twenty six rafiles that you're negotiating with the UH for the Navy right now.
[35:15] And you've got the MRFA which you just talked about, in which the raphile
[35:20] is a contender. Now, if you have a museum of fighters, and
[35:23] I'm not advocating for anyone here, I'm just saying, if you have a
[35:27] museum of fighters, uh, uh and uh. The entire point of trying
[35:31] to economize and you know, make in India and create capacity here in India
[35:37] is about commonality and saving costs and you know, a bang for your buck
[35:42] and all those wonderful things. Then why why is there even a contest?
[35:45] Yes, exactly why is there even a contest? Why are you wasting time
[35:49] with a contest? One part of the Air Force would say, you know,
[35:52] stop all this costly you know, contest business, Stop wasting everybody's time.
[35:58] You've spent a hell of a lot of money choosing the Rafale already,
[36:01] You've spent a boatload of money creating infrastructure for the Rafael already. You can
[36:07] fool your grandfather about how this is a stop gap arrangement. But the Raphael
[36:13] is not a piece of aluminium. It's a bloody expensive toy. It is
[36:16] not a stop gap. Anyone calling the Raffhle a stop gap, either for
[36:20] the Air Force or the Navy, is an idiot. It is not a
[36:22] stop gap. It's the most expensive stop gap in history. So if you're
[36:25] going to commit eighteen thousand crore fifty thousand crore into a stop gap, then
[36:30] we are not India, boss. We've stopped being India a long time ago.
[36:34] So let's think about this. Sensibly, if you've got the Raffle for
[36:37] the Air Force and you're about to gelt for the Navy, what is this
[36:40] MRFA? And this MRFA is a contest that has multiple fighters competing, including
[36:47] the Raphaele. You've got the Raphael, You've got the F fifteen. Fun
[36:52] fact, my favorite aircraft, but I still don't know what works here.
[36:58] And when I say a favorite aircraft, I'm in favorite acraft technically, not
[37:00] for this contract. I'm just saying, what is the point of all of
[37:05] this? So it circles back to the beginning of your question, which is
[37:07] that why couldn't the Navy and the Air Force sit together and just negotiate this
[37:12] deal together. I'm saying, we've got a huge deal, which is a
[37:15] requirement which is about double the capacity of the number of raffles we're already contracting,
[37:22] and we're still not thinking of shutting that down and saying, Okay,
[37:24] let's save some costs and just negotiate a larger deal and make this all about
[37:29] the air Force. There was a report by Shishi Gupta in The Sun Times
[37:31] a couple of days ago, which I'll bring into in a more detail about
[37:37] how the Dasso the company is now planning to acquire land in Java, very
[37:42] close to where we are doing this podcast in Javor in Uta, Pradesh,
[37:45] to build an m RO facility that's maintenance, repair and overhaul. That's what
[37:50] MRO stands for for the Rafal, which could potentially expand into a manufacturing facility
[37:55] for the raffle, which means the Dasso guys, who are obviously in it
[38:00] to gain something, of course, are already trying to sweeten the whole thing.
[38:06] Sweetened the picture by saying, m Raffal India mkud Banaygi, We'll partner
[38:12] someone, We'll make the raphalier in India. Now, if that is going
[38:15] to be one of the mandatory elements of this MRFA that we're talking about,
[38:20] which is basically a supposed to be a made in India effort, then what
[38:23] is all this, what is all this negotiation happening? We're sitting and negotiating
[38:29] with twenty six fighters and let me let me, let me be even more
[38:34] specific. It doesn't even have to be about the Raffa. It could be
[38:37] any other fighter. It could literally be about any other fighter. But if
[38:39] you've already chosen two governments have chosen the raffel, two governments, the U
[38:43] pay government and then this government, I've chosen the Raffal. So they actually
[38:46] agree on the fighter in these which is amazing in these times they both agreed
[38:51] on the fighter you pay government chose the RAFFL, This government closed the deal,
[38:53] and there's no this thing, there's no disagreement, then you go for
[38:58] it. Then if you choose a different fighter, I should have gone for
[39:00] that. How many different contests are you going to have? So that's the
[39:04] point. Yeah, I'm very glad with your impassioned answer, because I think
[39:07] the problem that the two of us have is with the contest and not with
[39:09] the idea of getting more jets. Because uh, and it's not as the
[39:15] Raffel did not win the contest. There was a contest, the m m
[39:17] R c A full the Air Force chose the RFL, the UP agreed with
[39:21] it, and the deal fell through for other reasons. It was not as
[39:23] though, like you know, you were not happy with the fighter jet or
[39:27] like you know, the Boeing was better, but you know you stop gap
[39:29] Marina, but was emergent requirement. You you you've tested this fighter jet,
[39:34] you aid, this is the best that we want, and you know everyone's
[39:36] happy with it. But for some reason you're going to have this contest all
[39:39] over again, which makes zero, zero, zero sense to me. Uh,
[39:44] And I'm glad you brought up the part about on a serious note,
[39:45] the part about you know, the report and Hindo sometimes about RFL. Sorry,
[39:49] that's all the kind of looking to purchase land. I think that's more
[39:52] of a sort of a push to the verment. Somebody do that all the
[39:55] time. Yeah, yeah, because I think that would then kind of make
[40:00] Rafel the sort of the mainstay of the Air Force, the future mainstead of
[40:04] the Air Force, like the Suquoi has been. And you know, something
[40:06] struck me while I was thinking about Suquois and the mainstays well a bit that
[40:09] how both the air Force's meanstay the Suquoi and the Navy's mainstage the mid twenty
[40:15] nine is what kind of aircraft forced on them? Because you remember previous episode
[40:19] you told us this nice tale about hurt t was kind of forced on the
[40:22] Air Force even though it's a great aircraft, right, cool, as we
[40:27] bring this episode to a closer, sort of give us a so you know,
[40:30] we talked about mission profiles, We talked about that viral movement from an
[40:34] earlier episode where you said naval fighters or enable fighter pilots better and cooler than
[40:38] the Air Force spider pilots. I kind of sense that you know, you
[40:42] kind of did not mention that right now because you're kind of scared of you
[40:45] know, maybe you know, getting this to just say it. That's what
[40:47] she said in that at that clip that went massively massively. Believe you don't
[40:51] have to say it. Everyone knows it's out there. It's permanent on the
[40:52] internet now, right. But yeah, So on a so, I want
[40:57] to know about the mission profile of pilots who were deployed at Ladakh. There
[41:02] was a point, I think a couple of years ago when mc rain and
[41:05] Case from the Navy were deployed along the border with China when the tensions bet
[41:10] China were at an all time high. They still are, but you know,
[41:13] kind of stabilized right now. One, why did we have to deploy
[41:16] fighters from the navy. Was it that there fores it not have enough chats
[41:20] at that moment at that point or was it some other reason? And second,
[41:23] I would guess that naval fighter pilots are not used to flying over mountains
[41:28] because you know, you're operating at sea, so you are not rarely going
[41:31] to encounter mountains, and especially Indian Ocean, which is just a vast,
[41:35] vast piece of ocean. Must this have been a very new sort of fun
[41:39] you're talking about the mid twenty nine pilots or the Raphile pilots, the Miran
[41:43] right, the naval Micran pilots. Yeah, so was would this have been
[41:46] completely new terrain or have they also seen training of the of this kind?
[41:50] And what would have been the mission profile? And very crucially why you were
[41:52] the naval fighters there in the first place. So look, you know,
[41:57] in a it's a really good question and one that hasn't been explored, you
[42:00] know, adequately. The answer to it is, when you're in an unpredictable
[42:07] conflict situation of the kind that the Eastern Ladakh situation was post Galvan, there
[42:13] is a kind of concept that military planners have which is put everything at your
[42:17] disposal, if not put everything into the air, at least keep everything ready.
[42:22] Now, when you're up against a country like China, which is both
[42:25] very well armed and I'm talking about in terms of numbers. Let's forget about
[42:29] quality, that's a that's a far away castle, but in terms of sheer
[42:32] numbers, in terms of sheer strength and squadrons, et cetera, and a
[42:38] situation which is volatile, a situation which you, as a military planner,
[42:43] as a country, believe could escalate into an actual exchange. Why would you
[42:50] not, you know, muster all your strength towards that objective and be prepared
[42:55] at least. Now, look, naval fighters are naval fighters, and naval
[43:00] pilots obviously have very specialized rules. But the mid twenty nine k IS is
[43:06] just as capable, like I said in my first answer, of functioning as
[43:10] a land based fighter. In fact, these when these fighters are not on
[43:15] their ships, they're based in Goa. They're operating off you know, a
[43:20] normal darmac in iron as ansa in Goa. So so these fighters are capable
[43:24] of doing that kind of thing. And remember these fighters are similarly armed as
[43:28] well. These fighters have similar radars, they've got similar weapons apart from the
[43:32] you know, the maritime weapons. So this was this one half of the
[43:37] answer to this is that this was India basically saying we're going to put everything
[43:43] into the fight, or at least put everything into a place where they will
[43:46] be ready for the fight. Okay. And this is this is an age
[43:49] old doctrine. It's a the Royal Air Force, the especially after World War
[43:53] Two, there was a doctrine over whether if war is imminent, you put
[43:58] everything you have into the air, including aircraft. They had armed trainer aircraft
[44:02] in order to be part of the fight. Why waste a flying asset if
[44:06] it can also drop a few bombs? Right, So one off half of
[44:09] the answer is that. The other half of the answer, and remember when
[44:13] the Raffles, the new Raffles first came, they were also sent immediately to
[44:15] Ladakh. Is also that a dynamic, real life, non simulated conflict scenario
[44:22] is a highly valuable canvas to gain very very important experience and live training.
[44:31] Okay, this is not Pokenn, This is not your Mahrjan field firing ranges,
[44:36] this is not the Bay of Bengal where you're simulating a live scenario.
[44:40] But you are deploying your people in a live scenario. But there's no actual
[44:45] fighting going on. So the missions that they're flying are practically training with real
[44:52] consequences, training with real effects, training, keeping an eye on the border,
[44:58] learning about the enemy, you know, getting theoretically getting signatures and radar
[45:04] signatures of what they have on the other side. Whether they do or don't,
[45:07] we don't know, But I'm saying that's part of the entire cat and
[45:09] mouse game that takes place in the air, but having a real effect.
[45:14] You're having a deterrent effect. You're bearing your fangs, you're flexing your muscle
[45:17] with everything you have, but your pilot's also gaining a lot of experience.
[45:22] I actually thought it was a fabulous idea to send your refuls to Ladak immediately,
[45:27] brand new spanking fighters coming in from France. Eighteen days Rada pract the
[45:30] center to Ladakh, which is crazy, brand new fighters, Why would you
[45:36] do that? There was one section which was saying the brand new why would
[45:38] you send them there? It was amazing. They were there to flex,
[45:44] they were there to you know, be seen, they were there to be
[45:47] noticed, but they were also there to soak up, soak up the terrain,
[45:52] soak up the enemy's signature, soak up what the enemy aircraft are trying
[45:58] to do over there. And it was an amazing, you know, very
[46:01] very committed, strong message saying that we will use what we have no matter
[46:06] what. So that's what this was really about. It was about, you
[46:09] know, not having to segregate things. And I think the message that India
[46:13] also sent out not for the world, but even for the military itself was
[46:15] that all forces will operate together. Yes, incredible naval pilots in them in
[46:21] twenty nine ks in Ladakh operating at high altitudes. They're built for aircraft carriers
[46:24] at sea level and they're operating at fifteen thousand feet fabulous. And believe me,
[46:30] in those few weeks that the make twenty nine k's operated there, the
[46:32] naval pilots would have learnt an incredible amount about their own aircraft and what they
[46:37] can do. So that's what this was about. It's an opportunity to train
[46:40] in a real conflict scenario. Also, yeah right, I'm really glad we
[46:45] tested upon that because I think and also it once again highlights something that I've
[46:47] realized as I speak to you know you in this season and Abhishek Palin a
[46:52] previous season, is in hindsight, we keep speaking to defenseion this like you,
[46:58] I keep just getting a sense of just how close to war view of
[47:00] it China, something that I think media reports did not manage to highlight enough.
[47:06] But answers that you gave right now, that's that's quite chilling to know
[47:08] that the military was like, bye, we need to send yeah right now.
[47:13] Absolutely, So that was like that's that's literally it. I mean there's
[47:16] war, there's something else after that. And let's remember that the raffles are
[47:20] still there. Yeah, there's a detachment of raffles that went there in twenty
[47:24] twenty which are still there. Yes, And the apaches are still there in
[47:28] Ladakh, So that hasn't changed. That hasn't changed, right. We end
[47:31] this episode on that note. Thanks Shift, fantastic chat with you, and
[47:36] I loved, like I said, the impassioned answer towards the end about the
[47:38] mismanagement of the deal procurements in India. But I think that's going to be
[47:44] a continuing theme in Defense. Thanks thanks also to our producer, and thanks
[47:50] to our viewers and our listeners. That's it for this week's Defense was for
[47:52] more tune in next week. Till then, stay safe and not close any
[47:55] bodies of the passport by

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
