# Manipur Going Down Path of a Civil War? | In Our Defence, Ep 69

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 27 Jul 2023, 56 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/56248088/27_jul_23_iod_ep_69_mix_27_july_128.mp3

For close to three months now Manipur has been burning. Unfortunately, it was a viral video that sparked&nbsp;outrage across India. The video depicted several men parading and assaulting two Kuki women, sparking widespread condemnation. But what specific factors led to both state and centre administration's failure to contain the conflict between the Meiteis and the Kukis? Why did it require a viral video to trigger outrage and media attention to the crisis? And how do internet shutdowns in Manipur and India contribute to concealing the extent of crimes and brutalities? Is the situation in Manipur so severe that it can only be classified as a civil war now? Dev Goswami and "Def Savvy," Abhishek Bhalla discuss! Listen in! Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound mix by Sachin Dwivedi Listen to our Manipur coverage here:&nbsp;https://bit.ly/44KkpOE

## Transcript

[0:01] This is in the Today podcasts. There are boundary disputes and then there are
[0:07] outright wars, hot and cold, diplomatic and military. In this podcast,
[0:13] we will dissect all that's brutal and subtle about the defense of our nations.
[0:18] I am Dave Goswami, your host, and I will be joined by a
[0:22] Bishikbala who's been on the front lines of wars and conflicts and has seen the
[0:26] Indian military up close. Welcome to another offense and Hi to abishaik Hi.
[0:37] How are you doing all well? How are you very well? Busy week?
[0:41] Lots happening in the news, you know, Yeah, I mean with
[0:43] the Parliament on lots of political developments are taking place. In fact, we're
[0:50] going to be discussing money poor and yourself has made a lot of you know,
[0:55] political headlines. It's literally rocked the part lament and the politics of the
[1:02] country is for a change being dictated by what's happening in a state which otherwise
[1:07] is not spoken about. It's very sad that this is what it takes for
[1:14] mainstream politicians to look look at one of the states of the country. Yeah,
[1:22] that it usually happens with states in the Northeast. Something has to be
[1:26] drastically wrong day for them to make headlines and for politicians to speak about it,
[1:30] and for it to literally literally you know, make an impact even when
[1:37] the parliament is on uh and yeah, you know since it blew up a
[1:42] few days ago. I mean see money pool who has been learning for the
[1:44] last two and a half months that now violence was began early early May,
[1:49] first peak of May. If I'm not wrong, and I think we've spoken
[1:53] about it in one episode, there have been media. Media has generally been
[1:57] covering it more or less, but perhaps a too extent of the horrors of
[2:02] the violence didn't really make it through mainstream up until Friday evening, if I'm
[2:07] not wrong, when this video went viral of two women being predat naked and
[2:14] being grew up by a mob of In the video it was easily thirty forty
[2:17] men. Many something even in the newsroom called it the Vietnam moment for money
[2:24] Pools violence, comparing it too if you remember the viral video of a small
[2:29] kid who was running naked because I think napalm bomb had just been just been
[2:35] explored by the US. We'll come back to We'll circle back to this part.
[2:38] You know, my first question to you, my first thing that I
[2:42] want to discussed with you. Actually, there's a quote I came across over
[2:46] this weekend. I haven't had the time to fact check it, but I
[2:49] get the essense of it. I want to talk about the essence of the
[2:52] quote per se. The uote apparently is by a former DGP of the up
[2:54] Police, we boota Ran Ryan, and he apparently while talking to these a
[3:00] little the activist, had said that no riot can last for more than twenty
[3:04] four hours without the consent of the state. Like I said, I haven't
[3:07] fact checked the quote. I'm not sure if he actually said it, but
[3:09] the essence of it is that the state, if it wants, can bring
[3:15] any riot under control. Now you've you've in your career as a journalist,
[3:19] you've seen the police upclose. I like I told you previously, I'm the
[3:23] son of a journalist. My father was from print journalism and he also got
[3:30] a chance and from Bombay so underworld police. So he also saw and this
[3:37] is something. The essence of what this quote says is something he's told me
[3:39] previously that if a state wants, with the level of violence, the state
[3:44] can inflict they can bring any right under control. First, before we get
[3:47] to what I'm getting to. First, do you get do you agree with
[3:50] this completely, completely agree with it. What I don't agree with it is
[3:54] this being classified as a riot. Okay, money pool, so civil Let's
[4:00] let's be very very straightforward. It was right at some point, right exactly,
[4:03] That's what I'm getting at. It is civil war, and the telltale
[4:09] signs of this being civil strife very much visible from the first day. It's
[4:15] when the state lives in denial and thinks that this is a law and order
[4:19] problem. This is a riot like situation. That's when it escalates to a
[4:25] full blown war where two communities actually have borders. It's like India Pakistan.
[4:30] There's a line of control. That's how it's become. They're guarding their homes
[4:33] against each other. And if this is not a civil war, what is?
[4:38] And when this started? When I don't want to I don't want this
[4:43] to be I told you so a moment. But you can go into a
[4:46] newsroom and ask people what was my assessment in the early days of the violence
[4:49] there. I was maintaining that this is heading towards civil war. When there
[4:55] is ethnic violence of such level it. This is this is what civil wars
[5:00] are and to treat it like a riot is the biggest mistake I think that
[5:05] probably the state has made. And there are various several, uh you know,
[5:12] layers to what has happened. We can discuss those in detail. But
[5:15] to begin with, I would like to put this question to our listeners.
[5:19] Viewers. Have they heard of civil wars in India? If they have,
[5:25] they can tell us which wor the other civil wars a civil strife that they
[5:28] know of, and whether this one classifies as one or not. See other
[5:32] conflicts where you have a militant group versus the state is still not a civil
[5:39] war. Yes, it's still a militancy, insurgency, militancy, terrorism,
[5:45] whatever whatever you want to call. But when you have man versus man,
[5:48] community versus community, not rioting but literally fighting for the existence, that's a
[5:57] war. Yeah, I mean what you're getting at it, it's just a
[5:59] war where they're not being a military led by under some countries flag. Basically,
[6:03] if you if you have we've heard, I mean you have, you
[6:06] see it's it's not under a professional military. These are people who have arms,
[6:12] they have some rudimentary training, perhaps and there are bunkers things like that.
[6:16] Haven't we seen visuals and pictures. We've seen ground reports of our reporters
[6:19] who are the fabulous stuff our reporters have done India to day and arch.
[6:25] The reporters who are on the ground, and you know, they've they've been
[6:30] to some of the places that are extremely difficult to access. It's very difficult
[6:34] to be balanced because you're obviously going with one community. Yeah, of course,
[6:39] so you can understand the you know, dichotomy of a reporter at that
[6:43] time. I've been in such situations. That's that's why I can tell you
[6:46] what you go through. So it's why I call this a warlike situation because
[6:50] reporters literally have to be embedded like you would be embedded with a military,
[6:55] and that's exactly what is happening. Uh yeah, wow, So yeah,
[7:00] okay, So I get your distinction. Like I said, that's a good
[7:02] distinction. But at some point this was wioless, this was right, And
[7:05] the reason I wanted to begin with this quote and this sense of it essentially
[7:10] was that I still cannot understand why can can't the state bring the violence into
[7:15] control. This is something we discussed in the last episode, and even then
[7:19] I had this question, uh, and you did not have an answer,
[7:23] And I'm guessing like even you don't have right now because we can't have clear
[7:27] cut answers. But you know, it's interesting. That's why I mentioned the
[7:31] political narrative, the political discourse around what's happening. It's interesting that the opposition
[7:35] has come up with a no confidence motion, yes, based on what's happening
[7:40] in money Boo, which is mostly going to lose most of you have you
[7:45] have other than in Jodrey on record saying to again to Arch that Saray no
[7:51] confidence motion set of numbers killing in I'm very much Bury. What else do
[7:57] we do? We want, we want to discuss. We want to put
[8:00] the government in the dock. We want them to answer what's happening, what's
[8:03] not happened, And that's why they brought this the no confidence motion. It's
[8:09] the nomenclature no confidence. Yes. They're trying to suggest that the nation has
[8:13] lost confidence in the government. Right or wrong. I'm not in the right
[8:18] place to judge that technically. Of course, as you said that, they're
[8:22] they're not the numbers to go through. Everybody knows that. But but for
[8:26] the for the opposition to on record say this that we are doing this for
[8:31] some political messaging tells another story as well. Yeah, she knew where I
[8:35] came across that court. By the way, I actually came across it in
[8:37] the condience of money poot And it was when people start commenting that. So
[8:43] the first reaction on that day itself, I think on Friday itself, when
[8:46] the video went viral, was that, hold on, it's an old video.
[8:52] It's from May four, May five, which it was in the middle
[8:54] of the violence, that was taking the violence, and the police managed to
[8:58] catch one of the men in the video, I think the very next day.
[9:01] And then I think someone circular to this courte that this space, he
[9:05] tells you for two month, month and a half, you could not do
[9:07] anything, and suddenly, once the video goes viral, you suddenly have managed
[9:11] to trace that on one one of the people and arrest them, which again
[9:16] then brings me back, how what is this something stopping the state that when
[9:22] I see the state, I mean both the state government and the center,
[9:24] the center central government. Is there something stopping Is this something like we discussed
[9:28] last time, that it's so complex that it's not as easy as just sending
[9:33] a big force with advanced weapons and just bringing things under control. No,
[9:37] that's the thing. I mean, what does a force to hear? Who
[9:41] does it initiate action against a good point against people with just put it simply.
[9:46] Yeah, and in some places probably it's been done. But it's so
[9:50] widespread now and the escalation is at that level that it's it's difficult to fathom,
[10:00] you know, how was it reached these levels? And make no mistake
[10:05] about it that of course it's a complete failure. I mean, it would
[10:07] be an understand if you're discussing whether it's a failure or not, that's a
[10:11] stupid argument. Yeah it is. I mean ye, I mean I think
[10:16] it's definitely it's a complete not just a faith failure. It's a complete blunder
[10:22] of how things should have been managed. What went wrong is something that that
[10:28] needs to be obviously assessed today happens to be. I came across a very
[10:35] very interesting tweet by one of the veterans who speaks his mind, a gentleman
[10:41] called general who I don't think he writes his designation Twitter bio. I hope
[10:46] I'm right here, I hope I think I follow this handle, because I
[10:50] think people often confuse him with the army, so this veteran. I maybe
[10:56] I've got the name wrong. If that's the case, apologies if I've or
[11:00] it right, and fine, okay, But I mean the content was very
[11:05] thought provoking that obviously you will celebrate the sacrifices, the heroism, the bravery,
[11:13] the legends who were part of that battle. But on such days you
[11:18] should also introspect what went wrong. I think that's a very straightforward thing.
[11:22] And if that introspection hasn't already happened, I mean a head should have ruled
[11:26] by now, which is what I don't get ruled by now. They should
[11:31] have been some messaging, some narrative to suggest that you know that you you
[11:39] are dealing with this with the utmost competence, because they have various levels where
[11:46] things have gone wrong, which is that's what I'm saying, which is what
[11:48] I don't get complete part from. I think the chief of Money Police,
[11:52] no senior ranking officier or officer, has been acted against. There are calls
[11:58] We'll get to that later as well, but you know, since be talking
[12:01] about it, there are calls for the resignation of the Chief Minister experiencing.
[12:05] Obviously there's a lot of politics involved there and each man there was I think
[12:09] also a period where it was almost as if he was going to resign.
[12:13] He had offered to resign, but then I think the central leadership said no,
[12:16] take it back, etc. Which makes me, you know, I
[12:20] think, like, is it is anyone even taking this seriously? Like,
[12:22] you know, I'm it sounds like a very condos statement to me. But
[12:26] just just takes us back to one of the podcasts that we did with the
[12:30] major Summer Too, who's now retired, who served in South Sudana on a
[12:33] UN assignment where the Indian Army was there, and he narrated some of his
[12:39] stories of the civil war that he had witnessed himself and he was part of
[12:45] the forces. Some of the stories that we were seeing now under similar.
[12:50] Yeah. Actually, especially the thing about women being paraded, isn't it similar?
[12:56] Yeah? And one of the biggest takeaways of civil strife always is the
[13:03] way women are treated treated always happens big evidence. So if this is civil
[13:09] strife, is this is civil war? The writ of the state has diminished,
[13:15] completely diminished. What answers does the state have? What are the solutions
[13:20] because see this is this is not just a law and order problem. You
[13:24] can't say your money, poor state are subject. It's a law. It's
[13:28] something that you need a big time intervention from the center. Of course,
[13:33] the Home Minister is monitoring the situation and things like that. There are central
[13:37] forces on the ground. A SAM Rifles is anywhere there which is a paramilitary
[13:41] force, and in fact a SAM Rifles is you know, playing a very
[13:50] crucial role, and they are under the dock by one community communities sort of
[14:00] that they are being there. They are they are being really helpful and it's
[14:05] see, it's not for us to judge who's right and who's wrong. I
[14:09] was actually what it's But it's okay for the guys on the ground to judge
[14:13] who's right, isn't it. Yeah, Oh definitely of course that they are
[14:16] there and if they are judging it and in their assessments, if they feel
[14:20] that there is an aggressor and there is a victim, but in all means
[14:24] they should act in accordance to that. At the same time, not our
[14:28] prejudice against a particular family or a group just because they feel they belong to
[14:33] the aggressor community. Of course, you apply your mind on the ground,
[14:37] and that's what security forces and police forces are and you can't you can't look
[14:43] at everyone with the same prism. You can't paint everyone in the same picture.
[14:46] So I mean that's that's the assessments that you have to make. Yeah,
[14:50] you know, actually are both gonna talk about our some rifles in this
[14:52] episode because what you kind of hinted at, but I think I was not
[14:56] do it later. But since you've mentioned, that's just it right now.
[15:00] So what's happened over the weekend. One of the things that happened that Court
[15:03] of Attention was the Chief Secretary wrote a letter h too, I think corner
[15:07] of the local commanders of our s rifles. I'm not trowne basically, I
[15:11] think less was it too, I'm not sure, I think uh, in
[15:18] which they said that in the last two days, I think that it was
[15:20] twenty fifth and they were talking about twenty third and twenty fourth or twenty second,
[15:24] twenty third. I'm not very short on the dates. Uh. The
[15:26] last two days, around seven hundred plus refugees from Yanmar have crossed over into
[15:33] money Pour in different districts. The letter gave out the number of men,
[15:37] women, and which districts they had crossed into UH and they said a sum
[15:41] rifles should push them back. Now, obviously it's a letter official sum back.
[15:48] There's also I don't know if it's it's part of that letter or not.
[15:52] I'm not sure of that, but there's certainly a narrative by the state
[15:56] government suggesting that it's the refugees who have triggered the violence. Yes, yes,
[16:03] all right, yeah, And I think even Bing has said that on
[16:06] My Goody. I think he spoke to Koshika Are, editor of the Northeast
[16:10] website yesterday in which he said he it's mostly I think he said immigrants have
[16:15] not wrong. I'll have to go back and cross check, but he did
[16:18] see something on those lines who are mainly responsible for the violence that's happened in
[16:23] so anyway in the letter, I mean, obviously it's an official letters,
[16:27] you can't be so very strong in it, But there was an inherent accusation
[16:30] that the asu rafles that basically led these refugees enter without proper verification at a
[16:36] time in this violence. So basically I think with the letter was there's already
[16:37] violence going on and at this crucial time, somehow you've let seven hundred plus
[16:41] people from Myanmar enter moneypur like you said, the word being that what was
[16:47] left hand sideski These people probably might you know, go on to create most
[16:51] life in the state. First things first, what is a sum raffles?
[16:55] Because up a previous episode, may you've you've sometimes mentioned of how people get
[17:00] a bit confused that are some rifles? Is the army? It's not technically
[17:03] the army because our some rifles falls under the m the Ministry of Home Affairs.
[17:07] It's a paramilitary force, but it's the central arm It's the only paramilitary
[17:11] force. The others, the other which are referred to as paramilitary forces actually
[17:17] central armed police. So I'll explain this is officered by the Indian Army.
[17:22] Okay, entire Assam Rifles is the officers are from the Indian Army, right,
[17:27] so the training, the culture, the way of functioning is a lot
[17:33] like the army because the leadership is the Indian Army right, whereas the other
[17:40] central armed police forces the leadership is either the carter of the force or IPS.
[17:48] So that's the secretaryship is what separates the two. But it's the it's
[17:53] the oldest paramilitary force force India. In India. But the officers of our
[17:59] some rifles, when the are in our SAM Rifles, they don't report to
[18:02] the army hierarchy right now. They report to the civilian at civilians in them
[18:06] Minish of Home Affairs. So SAM Rifles they have their loyalties. You will
[18:11] not you will not have a DG. Sam Rifles not being loyal to the
[18:15] army chief. We are asking a little too much from it. And they
[18:21] have to work in close coordination because one it is an insurgency area, it
[18:26] is a border area. There is a lot of infiltration and the infiltration is
[18:32] linked to a lot of external threats and there are camps of these insurgent groups
[18:40] within Myanmar. The army has carried out several operations, so as SAM Rifles
[18:45] that versus the army if there is a big, big operation that needs to
[18:48] be carried out, because they are the guys on the ground. Twenty four
[18:52] seven. A lot of Special forces operations take place in the northeast. There
[18:57] has been a cross border operation recently as well. I mean not recently,
[19:03] it's been for five years now, but it was an operation of a high
[19:06] magnitude when the Indian Army struck at these camps across Mayan in Mayanmar after this
[19:15] incident where eighteen army personnel were killed by a militant group called c K.
[19:23] Kaplang Yes, which is the head lead led by the Kaplang were led by
[19:27] Kaplang who's one of the top leaders, and they are a very deadly Naga
[19:33] insurgency group, probably the deadliest in today's date when it comes to the northeast.
[19:37] So Sam Rifles plays a very pivotal rule in uh In sort of you
[19:42] can say external threats as well, taking them on and being part of operations
[19:49] along along with the army. Right, So this unit is there because northeast
[19:55] is an incidency prone area. You have the borders with China are from where
[20:00] refugees have come in have come in previously. This is the reason the force
[20:03] is there. You had said this in the previous episode as well. They
[20:07] are not there for the current strife. They they're deployed there. What role
[20:12] does play in crisis like these now? See one of the mandates is to
[20:18] be prepared for situations like these because it is a very extremely volatile situation in
[20:25] the Northeast and like what's happened there. See all these militant slash insurgency groups
[20:30] that you have. The genesis is there is the tribe is their local affiliations.
[20:40] That is what the genesis of these groups is. Hence these kind of
[20:44] this kind of civil strife is happening, Cookie versus Mighty. Now both Cookies
[20:48] and Mighties have their own insurgent groups. In money Pour you have other than
[20:52] Cookies and Mathis, you have Nagasa as well. So it's it's it's a
[20:57] little complicated. I don't think we can discuss Northeast insurgency in one episode.
[21:03] Probably need ours and ours endless podcasts to discuss the history and what has panned
[21:10] out and what is the situation today. But just to put it crisply in
[21:14] a brief way, see the Naga insurgency, as I said, is the
[21:17] most active one, and their demand for greater Nagaland Nagalem as they say,
[21:25] which is not just the state of Nagaland, but parts of parts of money
[21:30] poor, parts of Minmar, parts of our Nache actually very few. But
[21:34] yeah, then there are several Mathi groups there are, there is there has
[21:40] been a demand for a separate Cookie land as well, which again covers different
[21:44] parts off Northeast, money poor, a bit of misuram, things like that.
[21:49] So, yeah, these are completely different ideologies and the genesis is their
[21:56] identity. That's where it has stemmed from. And that sense of identity and
[22:03] belonging is so strong in some of these communities that it can lead to situations
[22:10] like these. So how do you what do you, as someone who's covered
[22:14] the military for so long, how do you see some of the allegations that
[22:18] have been coming up against some rifles at least of biases basically? Uh?
[22:23] Though you know you've had some some some some information coming from our some rifles
[22:29] as well. You know, obviously we're not biased. But how do you
[22:32] see this? I mean, because you know, I'll tell you what I
[22:36] think is Uh. In situations like this, Uh, no matter how professional
[22:41] force, whatever it is, if it's a police force, military force,
[22:45] it's going to be impossible for that force not to be accused of biases by
[22:48] at least somebody, And there will be some elements, if not the entire
[22:55] force, and if the if as long as it's not abandoned given by the
[22:59] political power and charge, there will be some elements of that particular force sympathizing
[23:04] with one or the other for many reasons, not just because you know something
[23:08] like what you said. They have been there in this region for a while
[23:11] now, So you also develop sympathies for people around you. Do you think
[23:15] that's something not just sympathy. Is when you can you know what's what's hey,
[23:19] what's wrong? Yeah, you can call out, you can call out
[23:23] propaganda bluffs, and that's what you're there for. And in that if you
[23:27] sort of end up as I said earlier, if you end up antagonizing a
[23:33] particular community, then it's it's unfortunate. And I mean a professional force should
[23:38] not look like that, look like being biased or prejudiced. But it's a
[23:45] little complicated here, That's no. That's what I want to make it clear
[23:49] to our listeners and yours is that you know, it's not as the I
[23:52] or a B shape trying to defend or accused the sumurifles. But I see
[23:56] another thing is while we try to speak as s candidly as possible, but
[24:00] on subjects like this, I'm afraid we need to self sense. Yeah,
[24:04] but just to like paint a picture of just how complex this whole thing is.
[24:11] And you know, sometimes I uh, Ever, since the violence actually
[24:15] has broken out. I feel so uh undread. I don't know if that's
[24:19] a word, but about the matters of Northeast, like suddenly, I'm unfortunate
[24:26] that this is a country I'm living in and I just don't know these communities.
[24:29] And like you said that the identities are so strong that this is the
[24:33] level to which they can go to protect them protect their identities. I consider
[24:37] myself extremely fortunate to have seen a bit of Northeast. Huh you've been to
[24:44] Yeah, I've been. I've been quite quite a Few've been more than seven
[24:47] times. Like you, I think you uh, you realize when you're there
[24:53] and when you interact with people, that's something that you were not taught in
[24:57] your history was about a civilized that existed in the northeast of India. So
[25:03] when people say accuse history writers historians of distorting history about about the history that
[25:11] we've read Indus Valley and then coming of the Muslim invaders and all of that,
[25:18] I felt, okay, And you can keep debating that, but that
[25:21] was a civilization that was still not part of your history courses. It is
[25:26] a different civilization. Yeah, So taking it a stretch ahead, do you
[25:32] think that also perhaps is a reason for the lack of response. Like you
[25:37] know, at least if you look at the central government and if you look
[25:40] at the Delhi bureaucracy, because that's where that's where you have to go back
[25:45] to the idea of union of India. Sorry to say that, I mean,
[25:51] that's what happened. All these A lot of these places were not part
[25:53] of India immediately after independent independent, including Money. It was I think nineteen
[26:00] time, Yeah, when when he put actually became part of India. So
[26:03] that shows that the sense of identity was was big. It wasn't a natural
[26:12] you know, unification process or affiliation or whatever you want to call it.
[26:18] It took a while. You've read history, yeah, I mean yeah.
[26:22] So was it also geopolitics because of China? I don't think so. I
[26:27] don't think so. It was just that sense of identity that we are a
[26:30] different identity. Actually in that time, I doubt if China had any role
[26:34] to play in it. Frankly. I mean, and if you just study
[26:40] the history of Myanmar and some of the tribes here, there was whatever geopolitics
[26:48] was there, what was between them? They were fighting each other. So
[26:51] the battles that you talk of in mainland India, the similar conflicts happening between
[26:56] princely states there, but nobody talks about them, and and they were extremely
[27:00] important in how history panned out in that part of the world, if I
[27:06] may say so. So it wasn't a natural transition, and that's why it
[27:10] took a while. And then many of these states are part of Assam at
[27:12] one point of time, and then then they would divided into different states.
[27:18] So it was clearly a very very complicated, complex matter from day one.
[27:25] So it's it's not that easy. And when things like this happened, then
[27:29] you realize it's not that easy to just say that we'll do this and we'll
[27:34] do that. And India Cannampey could be and you know the kind of chess
[27:40] thumping that happened sometimes in the name of nationalism, nationalism and patriotism. So
[27:45] it's it's not that simple. But when do you think we'll reach a point
[27:49] where we can just stop saying that it's just so very complex. It's just
[27:52] not that simple. It's not as easy as because it is not. Let's
[27:56] say, sit unfortunate. See unfortunate is the violence. I think it's pretty
[28:03] okay to pay for people who have different identities within India. That's what I
[28:07] meant. I mean, I mean, I mean for us to stop saying
[28:10] it's so complex and not be able to bring the violence under control. Yeah,
[28:14] that's what I mean. That's what I meant. Violence. Of course,
[28:17] just because it's so complex, that cannot be the reason that you are
[28:19] not unable to bring the violence into control. No, again, I would
[28:22] I might say, it might sound really stupid what I'm suggesting. I'm saying
[28:26] if you just accept the fact that these places are complicated, they're complex to
[28:33] begin with, and that the idea of India that you have should not be
[28:37] the same for these places, you might not have had violence. Ah,
[28:42] that's so interesting. This is what I'm saying. That's an interesting You might
[28:45] not have violence if you just accept this fact without getting emotional about it.
[28:51] India India Partney. Nobody's denying India Partney. That doesn't mean they cannot have
[28:56] the separate entity completely early with that. So sorry for being if I am
[29:03] being anti national I think I'm not. I'm being extremely nationalistic. In Yeah,
[29:08] how do the listeners and viewers have to say about this? I think
[29:11] we want to hear from them. I wish you also want to hear from
[29:15] you at the beginning of this episode, so you know, in case you
[29:17] want to reach out let us know your thoughts on what we just discussed or
[29:21] just our podcast in general. Robert takes to us it's eight five double eight
[29:26] nine, double six, double nine six, or you can email us spots
[29:29] at the rate dot com. That's pods at the rate in day dot com.
[29:33] We'll talk more on this, but after a quick break. Hello,
[29:42] I'm rach Chamberpa from India Today Podcasts and your host for Nothing but the Truth.
[29:49] Every week we will deal with key issues of concern and bring your perspectives
[29:55] and clarity as to why this should matter to you and what is the clay
[30:00] truth that emerges. We're back. So we began this conversation on the viral
[30:15] video I came out last Friday. I'm pretty sure most people in India have
[30:21] seen it, even though the government the very next day told Twitter or it's
[30:26] called X. By the way, now, tangent thoughts stupid edytting move or
[30:30] calling it X or you don't care, I've lost interested. Actually I hardly
[30:38] all right. Sorry, But for the other time, Tangent coming back to
[30:41] our topic. So the very next day, the government has become a place
[30:45] for people now to just show that we have a bleeding heart. I disagree
[30:49] actually on with you on that, because we wouldn't have seen this video if
[30:53] it was not for Twitter. I mean, okay here maybe whatsappen on some
[30:57] of the social media platform. If you're not as instant. The people of
[31:00] India would not have seen it as peple won't watch it on Twitter. Only
[31:04] journalists do. But journalists gets through barnicalisms. Really, journalists watched things if
[31:10] you came like a news agency, wire agency. Yeah, that is true.
[31:12] That which is why I care about everybody on desk is actually actually it's
[31:17] very much true. Wires back in the braind you would remember back in the
[31:22] day you had that PTIs machine in newsrooms, which would you know print out
[31:26] releases. That's what Twitter does, which is why I care. And I
[31:30] think that's why he's, uh, you know, he's saying that you pay
[31:33] for it. Elon Musk yea Elon Musk is saying that you pay for it
[31:37] because you're using it as a news agency. Yeah of course. Yeah.
[31:41] Anyway, anyway, that was the point. The point was the video.
[31:45] The point was what the central government did after that. I don't think though
[31:48] the auto got implemented, but I think there was a request of the order
[31:52] from the government to Twitter. Back then it was Twitter to ensure that the
[31:55] video is not visible because it's very dispressing. A producer, Rana is really
[32:00] passionate about this subject that she wanted us to talk about. I not so
[32:06] much. I will tell you why as well is about so it's not just
[32:09] her by There many people when this video went viral talked about how this was
[32:14] a result of the internet shutdown. In money Pool. There was shut down
[32:16] in place for a couple of months. It's still ongoing right now. I
[32:19] think the broadband serfaces are back, but mobile internets still remains suspended. That
[32:24] because of the internet shutdown, videos like this could not come out. Occasionally
[32:30] you have global indexes where India ranks very poorly in Internet freedom, internet shutdowns,
[32:37] etc. Sor your tanks very highly. When it comes from the shutdowns,
[32:40] the counter many sometimes from the government. I've said those indexes themselves are
[32:46] suspicious, you cannot be trusting them. But the fact is key. There
[32:50] was internet shut down for a long period in German Kashmir post the apprecation of
[32:53] Article three seven zero. No, even before that suble there would be an
[33:00] Internet. I remember because this is something that even you, that you and
[33:04] I have experienced. When there were riots in Deli a couple of years ago,
[33:07] you hadn't shutdown in Delli. We were impacted by that Internet. Parts
[33:15] of the parts of the shutting on the Internet has become like a sort of
[33:17] a knee of reaction of any police force, any basic standard operating procedures in
[33:23] violence. Who are interne shutdown con You know what. People might not like
[33:30] this argument, but I kind of see the point. So there is an
[33:32] argument to be made that the video did not come out of money pot because
[33:36] there was an Internet shutdown, But an argument can always be also be made
[33:38] that the video did not spread internally because of the Internet shutdown. Where do
[33:42] you stand on this debate if you want to take part in it, I
[33:45] know noted by first and foremost, I don't think the Internet shutdown has happened
[33:49] to ensure that these videos exactly circulated. The Internet shutdown happens to sort of
[33:55] minimize the violence. The assumption is that people mobilizes on through because of the
[34:02] Internet, WhatsApp, etc. And the spread rumors, put fake videos,
[34:08] and you know, they want they want that this could be That's what I'm
[34:14] saying, Yeah, sort of. I mean it's kind of like a virtual
[34:15] curfew. I mean you have a curfew physically, and if you if you
[34:19] have a place in a city which where there's riots happening, violence happening,
[34:23] you have a curfew. People look at the other way. Probably if there's
[34:27] no Internet shutdown, people will sat at home, watch Netflix, watch films
[34:31] or whatever and will not venture out in the violence. I use listening that
[34:35] to an idea that they can has anybody tried it? I don't know.
[34:42] You should probably pitch that I have, but you have really Yeah, to
[34:46] whom two officials I've spoken with, the reaction was nothing. Just doesn't it
[34:53] doesn't work like that? What else do you expect? So this is the
[34:58] idea behind the Internet shutdown, that there should be no rumor mongering, there
[35:00] should be no mobilization. So the proof of the pudding should be in its
[35:06] seating with the internet shout. Don't have you ensured that? Yeah? That's
[35:09] I was just going to come to that, you know, by the way,
[35:13] just I want to have a slight something for our listeners and viewers abish,
[35:17] can I talk like this usually? So I just realized, you know,
[35:21] a couple of moments ago, always just like laughing a lot. It's
[35:23] not because we don't take situations like these seriously, but it's just that one
[35:28] of the things of our profession is that because we covered this almost twenty for
[35:32] seven, at points, we can get a bit casual about it. So
[35:37] I just won't make sure that it's not taken in the wrong way. So,
[35:38] yeah, coming to what you were saying, that's actually what I wanted
[35:42] to come to. So while I said at the beginning, yea, I
[35:44] do, it does make sense to me. The idea of shutting down treated
[35:47] in a region where there's violence is so that you can avoid, like you
[35:50] said, rumors, you can avoid people talking to each then like congregating at
[35:52] a partular zone or planning violence, etc. It's not happened away, That's
[35:58] what I'm saying. It's never happened, So I mean, it's never happened
[36:00] in any conflict zone. Now, the counters that if there was no Internet
[36:06] shutdown, it would have been was Now that's a non quantifiable don't measure it.
[36:10] But then to just to be the devil's advocate. I mean, so
[36:14] you want to just get then, now, that's right. See, especially
[36:20] in case of Kashmir. I'm telling you, I don't know the situation here.
[36:25] I've not been on ground. Internet shutdowns were one of the reasons for
[36:30] a lot of stone pelting, if you ask me, you know, yeah,
[36:35] because the young guys had nothing to do, come out, stand on
[36:38] the streets and just you need somebody to come and trigger it's enough. So
[36:45] mobilization for something like stone pelting, which wasn't sort of a you know,
[36:51] pre planned, some strategic military like kind of a thing. It's just guys
[36:58] who would get together in start off. It's your military would come, penty
[37:00] would come, thirty would come. It would start off. So it used
[37:04] to happen without internet shutdown. Now the Internet is working in Cushmir. Stone
[37:10] pulting is gone down, is what government says. Stone pelting on the way.
[37:15] I'm not saying this is a government is staying great pride in this.
[37:17] But Internet is also working. I'm just giving you a case study for conflict
[37:22] zones such as Cushmir. So then have you ever those officials to whom you
[37:27] pitched that idea. Have you ever asked them, then why do you keep
[37:30] doing it? No, there's there's no reasoning, no, that things would
[37:32] be worse. That's the reason there is no empirical evidence data for any of
[37:38] these things. It's more of a perception. And I don't blame people who
[37:45] are taking those decisions. You cannot have an empirical evidence unless you commission a
[37:50] study. That's exactly what. Unless you commission a study, you will not.
[37:53] So if you're really interested in knowing whether it works, it doesn't work,
[37:59] in what situation works, and what circumstances doesn't work, should actually study
[38:02] it, study trends. But that'll never happen. Yeah, So you are
[38:09] basically saying in your history, you've ever seen, in your history of jounalism
[38:13] reporting these such events, you've never come across an incident or in a situation
[38:16] where necessarily helped the institution on the ground. No, it could have helped.
[38:22] That's that's for the officials on the ground to suggest. I am saying.
[38:25] The counter to the to the benefits of internet shut down playing Devil's advocate
[38:32] is that you have not been able to stop all these aspects for which you
[38:39] have actually shut down. The mongering has still happened. In fact, mobs
[38:45] have still been mobilized. In fact, the video in question, the viral
[38:49] video in question, the acts that we see in the video, and something
[38:52] that happened away from the camera. The ganger of the women was apparently in
[38:59] response too, like you said, a fake piece of news. So I
[39:04] don't know if you've you've, you've, you've come across it. But apparently
[39:07] there was news of a woman from moneypoor who was raped by one community and
[39:15] her photo went viral. But that woman actually was from Delhi. It was
[39:19] not a case of rape. It was a case of domestic violence. I
[39:22] think if I'm not drown and the photo her photo went viral in Moneipour,
[39:29] saying that this is this was done by the other community, and this has
[39:31] happened in so and so place in Moneipour, and this apparently was an act
[39:36] of vengeance for that time. Yeah. So, I mean, even with
[39:39] the Internet shut down, rumor mongering can happen by word of mouth. Internet.
[39:45] I shut down mobile phones, I have not shut down. Of course,
[39:47] I have a video in my phone. I show that video physically to
[39:52] five people, to five people, those five people talk about it to another
[39:55] five to another ten to another fifty rumor mongering can be stopped. I don't
[40:00] know what other benefits. I would love to see a proper study, in
[40:05] depth analysis of how internet shut down either helps or it doesn't help. I'm
[40:12] pretty sure some global body must be doing this. Should be yeah, I
[40:15] mean I'm in the Indian context, Indian context. Yeah, that's actually a
[40:17] good idea for one of the thing. Thanks to off the cuff kind of
[40:23] assessment of what I've seen in Cushmid Internet shut down, stone pelting or speak
[40:30] internet working stone pelting has come down. Yeah, I don't know if that,
[40:32] if that can that should at least be enough to trigger some kind of
[40:37] a study, yeah, yeah, or an in depth story in fact,
[40:40] if some journalists can do it. And you know, it just struck me
[40:44] that while talking Northeastern, while talking money poor of the last two months,
[40:47] we've referred to Cushmid three or four times now again like kind of going back
[40:53] to what a Shake said at the beginning of this episode of how bad the
[40:58] situation really is. So you you know, at the beginning you said,
[41:00] since Dave one, not Dave one literally, but the first few days of
[41:05] the violence, you had a feeling you knew that This is much much worse
[41:09] than what people how because you in this case, at least since I think,
[41:16] you haven't gone to money Pool normally it's you know, one of your
[41:20] things is like something like this happens, You pack your bags and you go
[41:22] to that place. This time, you couldn't one of other reporters, did
[41:27] you haven't gone there? You know of money poors, money poors history through
[41:30] your you know, coverage and through your own knowledge, et cetera. How
[41:35] do you know from from get go Keia. This is much much worse because
[41:37] speaking to people reading news reports and understanding and having a background of what this
[41:45] place is like and what how passions can be really really you know, high
[41:52] all of that. So it was being reported. It's not something that you
[41:54] know. Yeah, of course, it's just that some people want not probably
[42:00] being able to link read through those reports what I'm saying. That's what I'm
[42:04] saying. You managed to link the dots and it was very much visible.
[42:07] Maybe because I follow it a little more even when Northeast is in peace.
[42:12] Yeah, maybe that was the reason. That's what I meant, I mean,
[42:15] that's what that's why, That's why I felt I'm telling you even in
[42:17] our newsrooms, the real rage has happened after those viral videos of the women,
[42:24] real real rage when you had people really ranting out well, you know,
[42:32] ironically enough on our newsrooms online side, that's on the case. Actually
[42:37] it was since there has been violence and it was there. I'm not saying
[42:40] it wasn't there at all, but just shook the sensibilities to another level.
[42:47] I mean, and rightly so, rightly so, of course, of course,
[42:50] yeah, rightly so. I mean visuals of war are always shocking,
[42:53] whatever ward, whether there's a military wall between nations or civil war like situation.
[42:59] I think the civil situation is worse. Why because military still have some
[43:05] code of conduct. No, it's not, it's not a code of conduct
[43:07] because then you can say that two nations are at war. Yeah, people
[43:14] of your own nations wor at war. Yeah, something more on the viral
[43:17] video when you just discuss with you, um, so I kind of know
[43:22] what your response will be. But there's also a few elements on social media,
[43:27] mostly actually on Twitter, which like you nicely pointed out, does not
[43:30] represent the whole of India. But they question the timing of the video because
[43:35] it happened literally I think two days before the month sensession and we began this
[43:38] episode by talking Yeah, I mean people should question the timing. It should
[43:43] have been out the first day first, but some people what made sure that
[43:46] it doesn't come out. So yeah, timing should definitely came out definitely on
[43:51] Friday. No, No, it should definitely be questioned. Why the delay
[43:54] in the world knowing this? Yeah? Because why why? You know?
[44:00] One of our reporters did a story on we had a we had a story
[44:04] that the NCW was written to about this a month ago, and not just
[44:07] this, several other cases of sexual assault and nothing happens, and even the
[44:12] fire in this case was registered I think within a week of it happens,
[44:17] and our awesome team again ended a brilliant report of oh yes, I forgot.
[44:21] That's whereas number one police station in twenty twenty, ranked by the Ministry
[44:27] of Home Affairs was eight fifteen meters away from less took place and suddenly,
[44:34] after the video comes, the police manages to arrest somebody. So controversial.
[44:38] Question time again, Like I said, you've not been there, but based
[44:42] on experience with police forces, with with with defense setup, security setup,
[44:46] sincurity setup, Sorry, do you think there was any attempt at any level,
[44:52] whether it's at the local TANA level, whether it's at the maybe higher
[44:55] ups SP level, or maybe at the top most chief ministers level on him
[45:00] per se, but his office or his hierarchy in the States attamp to kind
[45:05] of keep this incident away from public. Of course, like intentionally, so
[45:10] not key, we won't investigate it, but like you know, legist and
[45:14] sure this does not come out at all at any point. See, there's
[45:17] nothing controversial in what you say. Anything that happens. The police new wants
[45:22] it to come out. Forgot about this anything. Why would police wanted it
[45:30] should come out? They just by nature the police is not is like that.
[45:35] They don't they're not transparent about They don't want if an fire has happened
[45:39] in ABC matter, it should be a matter of public debate. So definitely
[45:46] intentionally the police or whoever were the authorities did not want this to come out.
[45:52] It's absolutely not out about it here. The reasoning would be that if
[45:54] it comes out, it will you know, inflame, tent, inflame,
[45:59] another series of violence and things like that. That would be the moral reasoning
[46:04] that they'll give. For So it's been two and a half months. It's
[46:07] reached almost to a point or almost if you've been very clear, it's a
[46:09] civil war. It is very upfront about I don't know why we are shying
[46:15] away from saying, and you know, without sounding like a politician, but
[46:20] in how does it happen that when a part of your state, if not
[46:23] the entire state, is in the grips of a civil war, the leader
[46:28] of the state still managed to keep his job. And those are political compulsions,
[46:32] I think nothing more than that. And the kind of political discourse that
[46:37] you've already had on this, it's acad you know, unprecedented where comparisons are
[46:43] being drawn that's happened in that state. Yeah, what about as usually Also,
[46:47] whatever has happened in other states is extremely condemnable and there's absolutely no doubt
[46:53] about it. But again I'm sticking my neck out and I'm saying that other
[47:00] states are not in a state of civil strife. That's yeah. I mean,
[47:07] those are horrific incidents, absolutely no doubt about it. Heinous crimes cannot
[47:13] be justified. But at the same time, there shouldn't be comparisons here.
[47:19] It has happened. The reason why all this has happened is because of the
[47:22] community, because of the civil strife, that is the trigger, that is
[47:27] what has led to this. Yeah, that's also my question. I mean,
[47:29] so I think the what about treat that you were talking about happened mostly
[47:32] specifically in case of the what we saw in the Virald radio. It was
[47:36] like, Okay, this happened, but similar and much words at times senious
[47:39] crimes have also happened in other parts. I'm not talking about that. I'm
[47:44] talking about for a period of two and a half months, you just constantly
[47:46] have violence between two communities. It's come to a point like where, like
[47:51] you said, the lines have been drawn that this is the ares you cannot
[47:53] cannot cross. This is this is happening land Is they are bunkers. Yeah,
[48:00] there are young men on the watch quite literally doing rounds as if they
[48:06] are on a patrol. But with the visuals that I've seen, yeah,
[48:09] I mean some kind of a self imposed army, military whatever you want to
[48:15] call it. Yeah, weapons is another thing. Where are they getting the
[48:16] weapons from a lot of them is arson looted, etc. But yeah,
[48:22] been there could be other angles. Who's supplying them, which which which community
[48:25] has more, which has less? But largely the chunk is arson largely.
[48:31] That's what I've read right last point, and I want you or some information
[48:36] from me on this if you are able. If you have, I'm probably
[48:38] sure you have talked about this with your people in the setup, people who
[48:44] you know you spoke about this last name as well, that the reason you
[48:46] were worried about this they're being such violence and money Pool is because of the
[48:52] location of money Pool and because of the history of insigency over there. And
[48:57] you had mentioned this was I think three or four weeks ago. I think
[48:59] we spoke on the stopic and you had mentioned that if that kind of got
[49:04] mixed, which I'm pretty sure by now it has to an extent the insurgency
[49:07] and then this civil strike, the civil disagreement within this is completely completely separate
[49:14] from the e sidency. They shoos at the hand are completely different. Then
[49:16] it would be a nightmare for the largest security setup at this point, for
[49:21] the security setup whoever you interact with. How what's the priority is it to
[49:25] control the violence? Is to also molter that? And is it to do
[49:29] it simultaneously? How like it's I hate how many times complex priority is to
[49:36] you know, stop the violence? Absolutely that has to be the priority,
[49:39] and anything else comes because insurgency and things like that, border infiltration that anywhere
[49:47] the security versus are doing are supposed to do, that's them and it.
[49:52] But this is, uh, this is the priority. I'm pretty clear about
[49:57] that. You're the wrong person to ask, obviously, but again, because
[50:00] of experience in this, what do you see in the near future? You
[50:05] had a hunchback then that this is gonna be much bigger than what it's being
[50:08] made out to be. What's your hunch now? What linking of dots have
[50:12] you done in the last couple of days. Now, there's no linking of
[50:15] dots, it's all. You don't need to link. It's right there.
[50:19] It's in your face that that's a breakdown of what the system is supposed to
[50:24] do. It's quite unfortunate, that's what it is. What has led to
[50:31] this, of course, but needs more than introspections. And one cannot remove
[50:38] politics from it. Of course you cannot. Of course you cannot, because
[50:43] if you think about it, I think the core issue at hand is very
[50:45] political in nature. Yes, it's about representation, it's about reservation, it's
[50:50] about land rights. All of these are very core political issues and you'll obviously
[50:53] have politics coming in at some point in this. Again, you know,
[50:58] an unpopular thing to say, But changing status school just because you want to,
[51:05] you want to send a message that you had the courage to change status
[51:07] scoo. It's not the brightest of ideas. Money in a complicated situations like
[51:14] these. Money you mean in terms of shifting people, changing removing someone from
[51:20] some post, changing status score of people, tribes that sc status st status
[51:28] land rights, unless, of course, I'm not saying don't change the status
[51:31] school like dystem Land reforms was a big thing and the entire state machinery came
[51:38] up with it, And you know, I'm not saying that kind of status
[51:43] scoo. I'm saying these small little political master strokes that you sometimes want to
[51:51] play in the name of changing status score, they can backfire and backfire big
[51:54] time, especially I think you know I've been able to understand in the last
[52:00] especially the reading I've done since the violence in Mibroo broke out, especially with
[52:05] cases like these, especially with states communities like these, which are very sensitive
[52:08] for their identities. Like you said, yeah, very very very very big
[52:14] big pride for them. Yeah, So no, this actually again a tangent.
[52:19] But this topic of tribes and tribal rights and tribal identities also came up
[52:22] briefly on the newsroom for us when we were discussing the uniforms sable code,
[52:29] the idea of it. See, we don't know what our us another thing
[52:31] is again you say controversial thing or whatever. See largely a newsrooms are urban,
[52:39] upper class. Yes, of course upper class upper caste won't tribe from
[52:44] mike urban. Yeah, ground, So I'll leave it at that. Yeah.
[52:52] Right, So it's not just about understanding, it's about identifying with these
[52:58] subjects less you show keen interest a new goal of your way, which as
[53:04] journalists, when we expect to explain and which is where I mean you know,
[53:07] as journalists, most of our learning and knowledge does come from I mean,
[53:12] it's not as though you were born you ah, none of us.
[53:15] It's just your own interest and sometime it's professional interests. Sometimes it's a personal
[53:19] interest as well, like for example, for you within history is a personal
[53:21] interest. Yeah defenses for me, I agree, no. But see still
[53:24] I would say a person who's not a journalist to understand the complications of a
[53:30] northeast or for that might be any tribal issue. Wouldn't be wouldn't be that
[53:35] that much of a natural to them? Of course? Of course. Yeah,
[53:37] I'm not saying people don't know about it. Some people are really sharp,
[53:40] they're interested in these things they read. And even if you read the
[53:44] newspapers, I'm telling you there is enough still. People might think that journalism
[53:49] has gone to dogs and things like that, but there is enough information in
[53:52] our newspapers, in our news stories, on websites, in what we show
[53:55] on TV for a person to have decent information and knowledge. And you know,
[54:01] now we live in an era where knowledge has been democratized. Ye,
[54:07] so if you want to know more, it's very easy to, very easy
[54:10] to So you just need to google something and you'll have ten, fifteen,
[54:15] twenty sources that you can read, watch, understand. So democratization of knowledge
[54:21] has made us all look good business. Yeah that is Earlier you literally had
[54:27] to have a huge library at home. Yeah, on whatever subject you want
[54:30] to master, specialize and buy specific books. Today's that's not that's not need
[54:37] at all. Yeah, that's true, and I think we'll entern that note.
[54:40] Thanks Againisha that I'm not sure how things will go in money pool,
[54:47] So I don't really know how to sign off for our listeners of yous,
[54:52] but what I can promise is that, as always, we'll just keep a
[54:55] close eye. Yeah, we can just say a software I think maybe for
[55:00] things to become become and improve as soon as possible, So we'll keep tracking
[55:06] like we do. And you know, if you have something for us,
[55:08] if you want us to talk about something with respect to money pool or you
[55:12] know, it can be anither topic as well that you think we haven't covered
[55:15] on this episode or the previous one for which we have a link in our
[55:20] in our descripture description. Then do letters know? Because I think, like
[55:23] a BI said, this is a topic that most people answerly haven't really followed
[55:30] before it happened. So there might be questions that people have that we think
[55:32] are there might be there might be a questions that people might have of us.
[55:37] Often there might be people who might think that we don't know much.
[55:39] Don't know much. Yeah, exactly, quite possible, quite possible. So
[55:42] whatever feedback you have, two letters no please you know, as I said
[55:45] before during the break, you can top at text to us at eight five
[55:47] double eight nine, double six, double nine six, or an email to
[55:51] us at pots at the Retina dot com. That's b ods at the rate
[55:54] entire day dot com. That's it for this week's defense does for more Tunion
[55:59] next week. They'll stay safe and do not cross any boundary rear passport abye h

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
