# Pakistan's Kaptaan Crisis | In Our Defence Ep 58

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 11 May 2023, 51 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/53822812/11_may_23_in_our_defence_11_may_128.mp3

On May 9, Imran Khan, the former Prime Minister and leader of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf (PTI), was arrested outside the Islamabad High Court by paramilitary rangers. And after 50 hours of his arrest, the Pakistan Supreme Court declared the arrest illegal. However, Khan’s arrest led to unprecedented protests between Khan's supporters and the police, resulting in six deaths and numerous injuries across several cities. The situation worsened when angry protesters stormed a radio station in Pakistan, and clashes between PTI supporters and the police broke out in Islamabad. Several violent protests erupted across Pakistan including at the General Headquarters in Rawalpindi and the residence of the Corps Commander in Lahore. “Def-Savvy” Abhishek Bhalla and host Dev Goswami discuss why this incident turned into an anti-army movement. And what is the internal rivalry between the army and the ISI. Despite the chaos, is there a silver lining to this crisis? “For the first time in history, the Pakistan army has been not only challenged but called out. The absence of any attacks on police stations, courts, or other state institutions has caught them off-guard. These images will be recorded in history as a significant moment of public protest against the military establishment in Pakistan,” says Abhishek. Tune in to the full conversation!

## Transcript

[0:01] This is in the Today podcasts. There are boundary disputes and then there are
[0:07] outright wars, hot and cold, diplomatic and military. In this podcast,
[0:13] we will dissect all that's brutal and subtle about the defense of our nations.
[0:18] I am Dave Goswami, your host, and I will be joined by a
[0:22] Bishikbala who's been on the front lines of wars and conflicts and has seen the
[0:26] Indian military up close. Hello, and welcome to the fifty eight episode of
[0:34] In Our Defense Hire They very will. Lots of things happened around us as
[0:41] we record. A couple of us from now exit pols will be exhill be
[0:46] released. Actually, lots of activity in Today. I was wondering we should
[0:50] say WhatsApp because there's so many things going on, yeah, simultaneously, and
[0:53] both of us have to keep a track of all those every day exactly.
[0:56] Yeah. So it's a very busy day, busy week for us. We
[1:00] still have a couple of days to go before the results are out the SATURDAYMIC,
[1:03] so we're recording this on a Wednesday for our listeners and the viewers in
[1:06] case you're wondering, and the show is out every Thursday, on all the
[1:10] platforms that you're listening to us on. And you know, once again,
[1:12] request to everyone, whether you're listening to us on YouTube or Spotify, Apple
[1:17] Podcast, to leave us a comment, to let us know what you think
[1:19] of this podcast. Drop a message to us at eight five double eight nine,
[1:22] double six, double nine six, or an email to us at pots
[1:23] at the rate in your dot com that's pods at the rate dot com.
[1:27] So confusing. Leave out what we do in our day jobs, you know,
[1:36] the politics of the country, elections coming up, et cetera. Even
[1:40] then in the realm of defense, there's so much happened, not just in
[1:42] India, across the world, across the world, some very interesting policy decisions
[1:48] taken in India. Yeah, it's confusing, Yeah, isn't it. You
[1:53] also had the Victory Parade in Russia. Yeah, you see last year,
[1:57] last year, this Victory Day Parade was the big story. And I was
[2:00] in Ukraine when the Victory Day Parade was happening and it was all being speculated
[2:05] it's some big announcement. This year is just another Victory Day parade. It
[2:09] seems. It's completely different. How things change, how the context of such
[2:15] events changes, with what the scenario on the ground is actually that reminds me.
[2:20] I want to ask you this just a brief mention. You don't we
[2:23] won't discuss Russia and Ukraine too, just by the way, but what did
[2:27] you make of that so called a tech attack on Kremlin? Kremlin the drone?
[2:32] Yeah, see, the timing was quite interesting, just ahead of victory
[2:36] day. So my hunches it certainly wasn't Ukraine because if it's Ukraine, then
[2:42] wise Russia. If Ukraine has gathered the courage to strike Kremlin, or ability
[2:47] by that, because that's yeah, you know, launching an attack on let's
[2:51] say, so if they have managed to do that, they've managed to breach
[2:55] the year space and reached right up till there and Russia to be quiet is
[3:00] a little odd. So I don't know what kind of a mind game was
[3:04] that. I found it extremely intriguing. How what's happening? And one day
[3:12] a few hours there was a lot of noise suddenly both quietly. That was
[3:15] very weird. Both sides got quiet. Yeah, so you know what incident,
[3:20] it was a very big coincidence. I think the news broke when we
[3:23] were recording a last episode, by the way, because I remember walking out
[3:24] of the studios and my desk was just like, you know, just running
[3:29] around and shouting, and I was like, what's going on? And then
[3:30] they're like, ah, this trash is claiming that you know, Ukraine has
[3:34] centrols to a tut what And then I think you were lived. I was
[3:38] like, yeah, it was that moment. Yeah. So by the way,
[3:42] I was supposed to be live right now, oh on what's happening in
[3:45] Pakistan? Right we are. We are running a complete on our digital We
[3:49] are running a separate sort of stream on what's happening in So they wanted me
[3:53] for two hours. But the heft that in our defense has now when I
[4:00] said that, I've I'm already committed for a recording here. Yeah, people
[4:03] said, okay, wow, in our defense has made in roads in the
[4:09] traditional news platforms, so which I thought was a pretty big deal. That's
[4:14] quite everybody agree, that's quite exactly exactly. Otherwise, I'm sure a little
[4:23] earlier they would say, tell them to change the time of what's this?
[4:27] What's podcast? Sometimes I get these snide remarks from people, Yeah, sometimes,
[4:34] and I have a way to deal with it. So I say that
[4:40] we are the stars of the poor people, isn't it. Yeah? Should
[4:46] we are happy with that? Yeah? Right? So yeah, let's talk
[4:48] about Pakistan. This is on a Wednesday of the week. So this is
[4:53] just a day after the former prime minister rested in Pakistan by Pakistani rangers and
[4:59] he's been a ested for corruption on corruption charges apparently one of the cases in
[5:03] one of the many cases that cases against facing. Yeah, there's particular case
[5:08] I think has to do with some amount of black money that was recovered in
[5:11] the UK and that was supposed to be when this was when Imran was PM.
[5:15] He was supposed to have you know, ensure that it went back to
[5:17] the golfers of the government. But then he is alleged to have taken a
[5:20] bribe from some contractor in Pakistan and then you know, sort of given the
[5:24] money to him. That's so the point, the point is, uh,
[5:27] there's there's been quite a lot of talk about Imran can't be arrested before this.
[5:31] I think a couple of weeks ago, I think there was an attempt
[5:33] made to arrest him at his residence, kind of unsuccessful. There were reports,
[5:38] media reports, I'm not sure how true that Imran can't jump the wall
[5:42] too. I think escape the police who had come to arrest him. Not
[5:45] sure it's true or not, but those reports didn't do the rounds. Yesterday
[5:48] he was finally arrested during a court appearance. Initially it was I mean,
[5:53] it was a big deal from the get go, but I wasn't expecting what
[5:57] happened half an hour an hour later. The kind of visuals that start pouring
[6:00] in from Pakistan, the ones that we were running on our television and that
[6:03] ones that is on social media. Some of them are they're very hilarious and
[6:08] observed. They're they're absurd and hilarious. But I'll decode the client, decode
[6:15] why those kinds of things, right, Yeah, So we'll come to that.
[6:16] But my first thoughts because I saw chatter, saw some chatter about this
[6:20] on on social media, which is where I'd like you to step in.
[6:24] Uh, some people were in disbelief that a country where the military is so
[6:28] strong, a country where the military is so iron fisted, that's a country
[6:31] where you know, people can just run amoke. You know, we had
[6:34] reports of a core commander's house being attacked, co commander taking refuge refuge,
[6:41] Yeah, in some secret location in the Yeah, military inexplicable exactly, the
[6:46] military headquarters in ravel Pind being stormed by protesters of Iran's party, the PTI,
[6:53] and also I think an attempt being made to lacis to the building of
[6:58] the SI, the headquarters of m SO. People on social media and by
[7:01] even the news in the newsroom, we're a bit suspicious about this, like
[7:04] yes, and army somehow involved in, you know, basically throwing up a
[7:10] picture of instability so that they can once again as they always have, speculation.
[7:13] Yea, So first thoughts from you on that, what do you make
[7:15] of this? Valid or you think well valid, valid, but still in
[7:19] the realm of speculation. I'll just go by what I've seen, what's there
[7:25] for people to see. Yes, true that the military has not retaliated because
[7:30] of whatever reasons you are alluding to it that there's a completely different kind of
[7:35] a game plan here. But the underlying fact that the angst of the people
[7:42] were seen against the military is that cannot be made up. And that's perhaps
[7:47] the first in the history of this country. There were coups, there were
[7:51] military dictators. People never had the courage to do this. Now again,
[7:55] various theories. One is that Imran Khan has managed to divide the military.
[8:00] There are generals who support him. Well, if that is true, that's
[8:03] also a watershed moment for the military to be divided and people to be loyal
[8:11] to this extent to a civilian political leader. I think that's that's a huge
[8:16] change, and I might be sort of told or grilled for this if it's
[8:24] one. If one is to see what's happening on, just take it on
[8:26] face value. In the long term, it looks that it's there's something which
[8:30] is good for Pakistan. I see a silver lining here that of course,
[8:33] there will be a lot of disruption, a lot of violence. Many people
[8:37] could get killed, a lot of things can happen, there could be civil
[8:41] strife for a very long time. But if at the end the common man
[8:46] on the street is calling out the army's boogie and that's nya Pakistan, that's
[8:54] the new Pakistan. For sure. We haven't seen a Pakistan where the military
[9:00] is less stake in how the countries run. And again, you know those
[9:05] visuals that we saw, the videos that came, they were precisely very intriguing
[9:09] because of this this kind of inquisitiveness amongst the people. That's what took them
[9:16] inside and come out with peacocks with strawberries from their fridges, just representing that
[9:24] these exotic kind of homes. Yeah. Yeah, So I'm not saying that
[9:30] there's something really great, but that inquisitiveness that what are these fortresses all about?
[9:35] And who are these people? That's what's behind those high walls. Yeah,
[9:39] and that's what took them inside there. I'm sure there was arson,
[9:43] there was looting, like like it happens in any kind of mob situation,
[9:46] But why would anybody come out with a peacock of food items? So that
[9:52] shows the mindset of the people of that country that they want to bring them
[9:56] down. Even if it was all Imran Khan's card, Let's say, let's
[10:01] play Devil's advocate that there was no common gentire. Well, Imran Khan is
[10:05] a political leader, so his card is normal civilian problem, isn't it.
[10:11] So if he has such a loyal card that's suddenly agreeing to take on the
[10:16] military risking their lives. Yes, it's true that the army has not retaliated.
[10:22] In fact, the police has not retaliated. I've not seen any kind
[10:26] of backlash from the forces. So one can talk and try to sort of
[10:31] debate. Why did they not? My hunch is very clear that they thought
[10:35] that if they do, things would get worse, so it just makes sense
[10:39] not to do so. I saw a few conspiracy theories on social media,
[10:45] and some of them from Pakistani handles. But what if? What if the
[10:50] army decides not to do anything right now and suddenly declare Imran Khan's party PTI
[10:54] a terrorist organization. So that's the extent to which the Pakistani military can go
[11:03] talking about why not? Why not? It's about their existence. This is
[11:09] all that they have seen, and suddenly that existence is not just getting challenged,
[11:15] and it's been it's been shattered in just a few hours. The kind
[11:20] of things air force base, people inside an air force base. Can you
[11:24] beat that? A dummy dummy of a fighter aircraft burnt? And another very
[11:31] interesting aspect which we will dwell upon maybe a little later, but I'll touch
[11:37] upon it right now. You look at the places where this has happened.
[11:41] I saw a map again on social media, one of the Austin experts that
[11:45] put out a map, and since I like to follow these things from a
[11:48] military point of view, the kind of places where this kind of violence has
[11:54] happened. Local code all very important formations of the pakistan An Army as far
[12:00] as the deployments are concerned to guard against India, so they will feel the
[12:05] heat because their operational functionality capabilities can get impacted by something like this and hence
[12:15] that conspiracy theory of them being called a terror organization. So that is why
[12:20] we were We were not sure why whether we should discuss and you you had
[12:24] a concern that we might end up repeating ourselves. Yeah, we have discussed
[12:28] Pakistan before when when all this started along back? But why and I and
[12:33] I thought that you know, this merits discussion and should take precedents over some
[12:39] some of the other topics that we had shortlisted, which are again extremely exciting,
[12:46] actually more exciting for me personally than Pakistan. Would I would still confess,
[12:50] but we need to keep in mind what people would like to listen and
[12:56] watch. We could be wrong, We could be wrong, horribly wrong.
[12:58] But yeah, yeah, but we make those attempts there. We don't have
[13:03] a magic wand so we just go with our gut. So why I thought
[13:07] that this was different is because this is the first kind of a situation in
[13:11] Pakistan. So yeah, we might repeat a few things here and there.
[13:16] But the situation that has risen in Pakistan is certainly that that hasn't been discussed
[13:22] before, hasn't been talked of before. People discussed that there could be termoil
[13:26] in Pakistan if Pakistan Imran Khan goes to jail, the politics of Pakistan,
[13:31] how how will it shape? From their own words, but nobody, nobody
[13:35] thought that it will be an open challenge to the Pakistan's military, an ultimatum,
[13:43] get down from your high horses. That's that's what has happened. According
[13:46] to me, that's what I feel. Yeah, but you know, throughout
[13:50] all of this, throughout even even back then when we discussed Pakistan, the
[13:54] army has been the stem around, has been very steadfast when it keeps saying
[13:58] that it does not want to interfere in the country's politics. Like you know,
[14:01] if you remember if we discussed how they had passed this resolution so to
[14:05] speak, that you know, we'll just you know, stee away from the
[14:07] politics of this country. Do you think that's true. I was going to
[14:11] ask you that actually you should answer, and you have been following these things
[14:16] and I think I think they just don't want to be seen pulling the strings
[14:20] in in in public domain, but behind the scenes obviously they'll they'll be as
[14:26] involved as possible. I'm sure. I'm sure they are. And I think
[14:30] that all this, all the stock that we don't want to be seen as
[14:33] being part of the political decision making was also prompted by the fact that what
[14:43] we mentioned earlier, that Imrankan did manage to divide the army. Yeah,
[14:46] so I think it was a result of that. It was, it was
[14:48] prompted, triggered because of this. They really somewhere that we are losing that
[14:54] hole that we had on the politics of the country and now that we our
[14:58] own people have their allegiances. That's why we shouldn't be seen as as as
[15:07] as those who are running the country. But in reality, hardly changed,
[15:11] hardly changed. And and see it also depends what you construe as domestic issues
[15:18] where the military should not function from an Indian point of view, the kind
[15:20] of things that we need to think of and be wary of Pakistan and where
[15:28] Pakistan's politics comes in in all those aspects the armies involved. So from an
[15:33] Indian perspective, I don't care what they you know, sort of thinking is
[15:39] on how to deal with the education system. That's obviously not our concern.
[15:43] Our concern is our security issues. And in those security issues, I can
[15:48] tell you that the domestic politics has absolutely no say. Why I'm saying that
[15:54] is because in India politics the domestic issues have some kind of a linkage.
[16:02] They don't. They don't function separately. They there is there is a connect.
[16:07] The army cannot function as an independent entity going to war. Things like
[16:11] that are very much political decisions. Striking Bala, quote yes, in through
[16:18] air raids was a political decision. Was it wasn't. The Air Force wanted
[16:23] to do it, so they did it. It's not like that Woody surgical
[16:30] strike. Now surgical strikes. The term was a new one. It was
[16:34] whoever did it was a sharp guy, I think. But those kind of
[16:37] shallow raids taking on terrorists across the LLOC, busting terror hideouts had happened before,
[16:45] but they've all sort of quote unquote secret operations. It was a political
[16:49] decision to go to town and say that we have crossed the LLOC on foot
[16:53] and we've done this. So all our military actions have a political decision making
[17:02] behind it. You can't say that for Pakistan yeah, true, And I
[17:06] think I don't know if you if you can say that's a measure of proof
[17:10] per se. But I think the fact that ever since he was outstair as
[17:15] Prime Minister, Imran Khan has been going hammer and tongs after the Parks military
[17:19] leadership is I think kind of proof enough. How heavy they involved, they
[17:22] must be that this guy feels that is the one power that challenge in the
[17:26] country. So, for example, the one thing that was linked to yesterday's
[17:30] arrest is his I forgot the name of the major general if I'm not wrong,
[17:37] but there's a top ranking general in the ISSI who Imran Khan says was
[17:41] behind the assassination of a journalist journalist critical of the parks and establishment in an
[17:45] African country and being involved in the attack that took place on Imbranka in which
[17:48] he is like was was injured. What do you make of that? Like,
[17:52] why first of all singling out officers, singling out this one particular officer
[17:56] and going after him. What do you make of this? So in all
[18:00] this talk and all the speculation that is happening, isn't military the protagonist they
[18:07] are, isn't it? You have some officers here some their co conspiracy theory.
[18:14] There's a good story about Dirty Harry that awesome team has put out a
[18:18] brigadier. We can put that link to the to the podcast. So why
[18:22] are these characters? Why aren't you talking about some civil servant? Isn't it?
[18:27] So? Point is that that's the kind of power that these officers enjoy
[18:34] in that country, and that is that is why you know, and we
[18:38] started, I said that it was this intrigue amongst the junta to find out,
[18:44] you know, who these people are. Let's go and check out,
[18:47] let's go and read their homes. It wasn't the army that is arrested in
[18:49] an, Yes, it's the rangers. And again it was a pull.
[18:53] It's actually the police. Rangers are what are what are BSF is? Yes,
[19:00] so the rangers probably were there to ensure there's that public order, is
[19:03] extra security, Yeah, things like that. So that's why they were sitting
[19:06] there. So why why did this turn into an anti army movement? Yeah?
[19:12] Isn't it? Yeah? So very clearly because yes, the perception is
[19:19] and it could be political, of course, it could be something that the
[19:23] cards you can't forget about to come up in in Pakistan. Leader this year,
[19:26] by the way, if we're not sure if everyone can will be able
[19:29] to contest because he was barred from doing so by their election commission. And
[19:34] I think that's something that's going on in their courts. Yeah, so,
[19:37] and even in this case also, I think if he's convicted the one that
[19:41] he's been arrested in, yes, yes, of course. So I don't
[19:45] know how that pans out, but very clearly there is a military connection to
[19:51] whatever is happening. And again the kind of frustration you you've heard intellectuals from
[19:57] Pakistan says so many times, give us alone, leave us alone. The
[20:00] army should just move out of our everyday business. And then there is also
[20:07] a lot of uh sort of internal rivalries between the army and the ISI.
[20:14] Don't forget what the army and the ISI. Now, the IS SI has
[20:18] army officers, but it's it's not an it's it's not Pakistani army, right,
[20:23] but the S chief does report to the army chiefs, right. The
[20:26] the the ISI chief is a DG rank officer, so he's a left engine.
[20:33] ISI doesn't work under the Pakistani army, okay, the perception, but
[20:41] yeah, but because it's because it's manned at the top by Pakistani Army officers.
[20:45] That's why, you know, one feels that it's an extension. But
[20:48] there are a lot of undercurrents between Isi and the army. And once again,
[20:53] in all the drama that's happening here, if you scrutinize read carefully,
[21:00] you will come across these strands thrown in by Pakistani journalists commentators, which will
[21:07] give you a hint at the eye size rule, the army's rule, their
[21:12] internal differences. The point is that it's a country which is not governed by
[21:18] civil political sensibilities. That's that's the point I'm trying to make. And I
[21:23] think people have had enough. It could be politically motivated. It is.
[21:27] It is a political movement, but I'm not saying it's not because politics.
[21:33] Obviously at some point of time they'll have to face the backlash. And this
[21:37] is what it is. And once again to you know, I think we've
[21:41] mentioned this before also to bust a lot of myths of people in India why
[21:48] we should be under a military rule, or the military should have more power
[21:52] and things like that. I think you won't have a better case study than
[21:56] what's brewing in your neighborhood. And yeah, once again at the expense of
[22:02] getting grilled. Nehru and his ILK saved us many many years back by setting
[22:07] up a system. Yea and yeah, and Neu was quite upfront about it.
[22:14] A military is important, but it should be under leash. Yeah,
[22:18] and I mean yeah, like you're right. I mean, if you see
[22:19] what's going on in the last last day's example, is enough just to see
[22:23] the like, you know, the I don't want to sound like a Pakistani
[22:26] bascher. I mean that's the term. You know. I am empathizing with
[22:30] the people of Pakistan, what they've gone through exactly what that's what I'm not
[22:33] being a Pakistani baser. At the points it's horrific, and at points it's
[22:37] also a bit funny. Like what is going Just imagine the kind of lives
[22:41] we have lived. If it was reversed, we will be I would I
[22:48] would feel suffocated. So I mean coming to that, yeah, I before
[22:52] we start recording, I said, I'll mention something important to you. So
[22:56] the other day I had the privilege of speaking to a very august gathering and
[23:03] to be in a place where I was addressing and briefing senior military officers from
[23:10] twelve nations, and these were officers who were part of a study program in
[23:17] the Royal College of Defense Studies, which is the equivalent of our National Defense
[23:22] College, which is the highest level of any course that military officers take in
[23:26] India. Brigadier's stake that course. Here they were colonels and brigadiers. So
[23:32] in my talk I did mention about one thing, and after the talk was
[23:37] over, a lot of people had questions to ask just about this aspect when
[23:41] I said that over the years, something that we have reiterated many times in
[23:45] our podcast that in the last three years, since China has been breathing down
[23:48] on nick Pakistan has gone off our agenda at the political level, at the
[23:56] military level, journalistic level, a park Stan story is not that great anymore.
[24:03] It's it's a scoop that you look where in what's happening with China.
[24:07] That's what we're all more interested in. So they were all surprised. These
[24:11] are military officers who see all these things, so they were not this.
[24:15] This came as news to them and there was a lot of cross questioning with
[24:18] me, and this was just us before all this happened, and I was
[24:22] explaining them a lot of these kinds of things that look at the strife that's
[24:26] happening in Pakistan, and they have their own problems, and now there's a
[24:30] ceasefire reiteration at the yellowc and we all know who the real enemy is referring
[24:38] to China. So this was music to their ears that when did this change?
[24:44] We thought that India Pakistan old rival readers that because a lot of them
[24:48] were British, so of course they do understand lots of Indian and pakistanis living
[24:52] in that country. The India Pakistan rivalry is seen upfront in neighborhoods probably in
[24:57] that country. So uh, I explained to them and that that was one
[25:03] big takeaway. They said that they have from this interaction with me, Pakistan
[25:07] is no more the big talk in India. It's China. Yeah, and
[25:12] uh and with what's happening in Pakistan, it's even more apparent that that things
[25:21] don't look so rosy. But yeah, there is a silver lining, There
[25:25] is a silver lining at Sha Pakistan. I don't know, and what if
[25:30] this movement turns into a big, big civil movement and what happens next.
[25:34] That's why I'm That's why I'm intrigued. See earlier, you knew the writing
[25:37] on the wall here. I'm not sure how these things will pan out in
[25:45] the future. And I'm just thinking, what if there's a big Pakistan is
[25:48] a country that's not had people's movements. We have seen we have seen people's
[25:55] movements in pockets of this country. Anna and keji Wa is a classic latest
[26:02] case study of of a people's movement suddenly turning into a you know, political
[26:07] force to reckon with, if not a force to reckon with, at least
[26:11] at least a challenge, at least at least an alternative, a player somewhere.
[26:15] No indorsement for any party, but you can Yeah, you can't discount
[26:19] up now and the fact that and it didn't come through, it didn't come
[26:22] through the traditional political scheme of things. And you can't discount the fact that
[26:26] the movement was one of the key factors and government which ruling yes, yes,
[26:32] so so partisan. I don't know how a student politics and partisan,
[26:34] I don't know, yea. And in India at least still I was a
[26:37] student student politics was a big I mean, I know a lot of people.
[26:41] I know a lot of people, a lot of contemporaries I don't name
[26:44] them. Who are political leaders now for various parties who I have studied with
[26:49] Indeli University around my time from different colleges contesting for a BVP, N SUI,
[26:56] si EE, who are into mainstain politics. I'm not sure if that
[27:00] happens in Pakistan. I mean, I have not studied the politics of Pakistan
[27:04] to get into that nuance. But my hunches it's not that predominant. So
[27:10] when these So that's why I say that this is a very different kind of
[27:14] a movement. How it pans out, It's difficult to predict either. It
[27:18] either it's just it's something that the army, one of the consp is there.
[27:22] The army is just allowing this to happen and suddenly they'll clamp down.
[27:25] Yeah, just like spread some sort of anarchy and then like make that excuse,
[27:29] may make that a justification for the coming in. So that could be.
[27:33] But the other is that this could spread like fire and what happens next.
[27:40] So that's why it's different from what we the narrative, the discourse that
[27:42] we've been following. We'll talk more on this, uh, but just one
[27:47] thought, by the way, when you said that the officers you addressed,
[27:49] were taken aback that thinking in India has changed with respect to China and Pakistan.
[27:55] At the risk of very shameless promotion issue, to listen to our podcast
[27:59] because I think that's kind of what we've been doing the last year. Oh
[28:02] I did, I did. I did say. I did tell them that
[28:03] a lot of a lot of the tegrities because there was a posity of time.
[28:07] So I did mention that if you are interested in listening and understanding of
[28:12] these things which are very contextual, yes, because these are people who know
[28:17] the background. Of course they won't need any they are military officers. But
[28:21] if you want to know things which are extremely contextual and which are not there
[28:23] in mainstream narrative, then please listen to us. I did say that again,
[28:30] shameless promotion and why shameless? Yeah, I'm not sareless, but yeah,
[28:33] that's nothing shameless about. So be upfront. So okay, to our
[28:37] listeners and viewers. We are very upfront about promoting our podcast because we actually
[28:41] we are not good enough. Yeah, I would still say we are definitely
[28:45] not We are not good enough people. Can people do a better job self
[28:48] promotion? We are not that good at you, But it's just that we
[28:52] love these discussions we have doing this, so we just you know, want
[28:55] people more and more people do listen to it. So yeah, we'll be
[28:57] back after a quickly Hello. I'm Raj Chambapa from India Today Podcasts and your
[29:08] host for Nothing but the Truth. Every week we will deal with key issues
[29:15] of concern and bring you perspectives and clarity as to why this should matter to
[29:21] you and what is the clear truth that emerges. Welcome back. Discussing the
[29:33] goings on in Pakistan where former PM Memran Khan has been arrested by the police
[29:40] by actually the National I forgot the name, but it's a corruption body,
[29:44] its enemy, it's National Accountability Accountability of you, it's basic anti corruption watchdog
[29:48] in Pakistan that's arrested Imran Khan. So before the break, I mentioned that
[29:55] some things that happened yesterday post Imbran Khan's arrest were honestly quite funny. That
[30:00] risk of you know, sounding insensitive, but yeah, like you know,
[30:03] you had a guy like you mentioned with the peacock outside the Core Commander's house.
[30:07] You have, by the way, give a very nice insight into why
[30:10] that could have happened, What could have been going on in the minds of
[30:12] those people like you just want to see what is this alishan mehell so to
[30:17] speak, you know, they can't think out the The other thing that I
[30:21] thought was a bit funny was the PTI Imran Khan's party alleging that Timran Khan
[30:26] was tortured and beaten up by those Yea, do you think that's even like
[30:30] for per prime minister of a country arresting him itself is a US till it
[30:36] made headlines across the world. They were breaking flashes on you know, all
[30:38] prominent national news channels. Do you think it's even reasonably possible for any force
[30:47] in Pakistan, even if it's a military for for that matter, you know,
[30:49] torture of former prime minister by arresting arresting him to torture, I'm not
[30:53] sure, but roughing up maybe, like not in the process, I mean
[31:00] roughing of it, then not in the process, I'm obviously. Yeah,
[31:04] I'm saying we're in custody. If he's still behaving like the prime minister,
[31:11] then you never know, isn't it If he's trying to sort of sort of
[31:15] tella. What if he's saying tomorrow, if I become the Prime minister with
[31:21] there's a very speculative you're just trying to get it to the edge. But
[31:26] it was a hypothetical question, so a hypothetical answer that police custody is a
[31:32] weak, weird place. Anything can happened there. Believe me, it's you
[31:37] talk as the experience. No, I mean I know of things that can
[31:41] happen, so it's it's yeah, yeah, so the unthinkable does happen there,
[31:48] and a lot of a lot of people who otherwise think are powerful sort
[31:55] of leveled while they're in police custody. Again, not torture. Physical torture
[32:00] is an extreme just the way you are deal to it. Yeah, it
[32:06] feels tortuous. It's like you quickly, especially if you're if you're if you
[32:10] are a big shot, right, And Imran Khan, even if he wasn't
[32:14] the Prime Minister, is a big shot in that. Yes, of course
[32:16] you can't. I mean, yeah, I mean he is I think the
[32:22] biggest superstar that that country has had, and one is too yeah, yeah,
[32:27] I'm thinking right now, but I can't recall any other Yeah, and
[32:30] being a sportsman to be the biggest superstar in the country in a country which
[32:36] is which is not really known for sports. It's only cricket and in the
[32:40] earlier years hockey. Otherwise, you don't associate Pakistan with sport. So in
[32:45] a country for a sports personality to be a mega mega superstar, then become
[32:52] the prime minister, then to be in custody, Yeah, it's coming down
[32:57] many, many levels from where you have gotten used to living. So yeah,
[33:04] in that case, some kind of torture, mental torture, mental torture.
[33:07] Yeah, just to clarify could have happened. All right, I want
[33:10] to talk now a bit about what you briefly mentioned before the break kind of
[33:15] caught my interest. You said that while you were looking at the map of
[33:20] the areas of the underrest, the buildings or whatever targeted by those protests protesting,
[33:27] and you said that those were mostly areas where the military has the formations
[33:31] or whatever that are kind of aimed at India because the board when it's to
[33:36] the eastern borders and body not to the west, and some of them are
[33:39] very close. Yeah, plat up extremely close to the border. So two
[33:46] questions for you over there. One, what were you kind of trying to
[33:51] hint at before the break And you mentioned that in second, then do you
[33:53] think there was some sort of planning, because you know, the rest happened
[33:57] and I think around four four thirty not wrong, sorry, Aune and the
[34:02] protest broke out just like in an hour or so, an hour, an
[34:05] hour and a half, and by seven itself we had visuals of fire being
[34:07] set to the cold commander's house and the people storming the headquarters that I'm guessing
[34:13] that's around the time you saw the map as well off the years of an
[34:15] rest. So for it to happen so quickly and for it to happen in
[34:19] those locations, do you think there was some sort of strategy involved behind this?
[34:23] First of all, I'd like to say, you know this my fixation
[34:28] with maps. Whenever there is any problem anywhere, I just look at a
[34:32] map, because it's the map that gives you a lot of hints, gives
[34:37] you a very clear picture of what's going to happen, and any kind of
[34:40] confrontation is best understood on a map. So that's why I always start end
[34:47] in between all kinds of procedures that are involved in doing stories related to conflict
[34:53] or confrontation. First of all, look a look at the map, and
[34:57] there's something that I learned from history. My interest in history, all conquests,
[35:01] wars, etc. The first thing in our history book is a map
[35:06] that explains. Yes, so the first in the first period of a chapter
[35:08] is so it's that's why, that's why I always like to see where has
[35:14] it happen? How far is it from this place? What what what could
[35:16] be the repercussions? So yes, uh and this this actually came up in
[35:21] that one of those open source intelligence handles on Twitter and I just saw the
[35:28] map. Yeah, yeah, right, and then I tried to analyze Malpur
[35:32] also used to be the headquarters of LT at one point of time or JM
[35:38] M j M j M it still is. Yeah, so you know,
[35:42] this is a place of importance to Pakistan, to Pakistan military, to India
[35:46] for our listeners, I've views JM is the possession that was behind behind the
[35:51] Pulom attack. Yeah, sorry, continue you know then quote quote is extremely
[35:55] close to the international border. Just you can just walk over from the outs
[36:00] kurts of Jammu and you will be in Laho. Of course we all know
[36:04] how close it is to Guara. Again, is not too far away from
[36:09] where my ancestors came. I have my roots in I recently met. It
[36:16] was our conclave. Cola Pisani was there, not connected to this, but
[36:22] we just we get into these stories once in a while, so paris come
[36:27] specifically of such as interview, such a session just to you know, be
[36:32] present physically over there. And the session got over and he was coming out
[36:37] and I met him. The press officer introduced me. So he said that
[36:40] I had to I couldn't have missed this. This was this had to be
[36:45] the best session, you know, seeing such an up close and speaking so
[36:49] candidly and all his old stories. So both of them were quite thrilled.
[36:55] So I was exchanging notes that, you know, my ancestors from her.
[37:00] The press officers said that my ancestors were from Pharospoor and Punjab, which is
[37:05] Indian Punjab. So when I said, Gua, he said, you look
[37:07] like a guy from So I don't know, I mean if he's if he's
[37:14] true, he's just making polite conversation. He and he said it and chased
[37:19] Punjabi, do you look like a typical person? So yeah, So these
[37:24] are places close to the Indian border, very sensitive deployments of the Indian of
[37:31] the Pakistani Army when I say close, see just people might see the map
[37:37] and give us distances and tomorrow say that close so close doesn't mean these are
[37:46] formations that div level formations the course, the ones that will be involved in
[37:52] a yes, yes, yes, that the front line soldiers are under these
[38:00] missions, these under their control. So in that sense, these are very
[38:02] sensitive places. So obviously there is so much of unrest and turmoil and where
[38:09] the army is being targeted by their own people. Of course it's a matter
[38:15] of grave security concern for them. And of course it's it's not something that
[38:21] you know, India is just hooked onto what's happening in Pakistan or something that.
[38:27] But we will be keeping an eye and we don't want to be caught
[38:30] off guard. And there's there's no there's no big deal in following the domestic
[38:36] events of a neighbor like Pakistan, which we are. Yeah, I'll come
[38:40] back to while you know, circle back to that exam an interesting point which
[38:44] to make over there. But before that, something else so that you've said
[38:46] before the break caught patentition and I think this is something we haven't discussed previously
[38:52] in our podcast, and this is something that I have over a period of
[38:54] time when I started reading more about Pakistan and military and strangle old on the
[39:00] countries policies and politics. I've always been getting a sense that the general's Parkistan,
[39:06] generals men generals, I don't need the top channel obviously, the whole
[39:08] body of generals and generals generals, all of them seem to be quite out
[39:13] of touch with the realities of the countries now see. I I just want
[39:16] to clarify I'm no Pakistani expert. I haven't I don't know much about the
[39:20] country's politics. I don't know about the background of the jennerals, by the
[39:22] way, but this is something I get a sense of when I read what
[39:25] I read about Pakistan. And I have charged with you because you mentioned that,
[39:29] you know, even the chittens over they want to see that what's behind
[39:31] these walls, you know, what is this bottle of Coca cola for example,
[39:36] if that's what you're trying to entact, because the generals seem to be
[39:38] no, you know, they have they seem to have this like you know
[39:44] not or yeah, they are just like you know, something else altogether.
[39:49] So you have you also gotten that sense in your coverage or the stories that
[39:52] we've heard of the lavish life. Yes, yes, extravagant parties and things
[40:00] like that. See Pakistani's are good hosts. I mean I've not been to
[40:05] Pakistan, but whenever I've attended any event here in Delhi, yes they will
[40:09] the way of inviting you and taking care of you and feeding you. They
[40:17] are the typical Punjabi this thing which is there in India also a lot of
[40:22] commonalities. But and Pakistani Army is Punjabi dominator, so it could be both.
[40:30] You know, one cultural thing of living life, king size, extravagant
[40:36] lives which is a very Punjabi thing, even civilians in Punjab doing. And
[40:39] then the aura around their their status, their their position. See it's the
[40:47] it's even in India. You have certain services like I mean the civil services.
[40:52] India was concerned considered the place to be in elite. There is that,
[40:58] but it has changed post ninety one when you know, big corporate jobs
[41:01] started coming into India. That that all around civil services. It's not it's
[41:07] not the same. And civil servants i s. Officers are just another you
[41:14] know kind of people. Yes, they can pull strings, they have some
[41:16] contacts, they can be helpful. All that is true when they they're better
[41:22] off than us for sure when it comes to all these things, but it's
[41:25] not as if as if they just they have a hold on everything. In
[41:30] Pakistan, what we've heard is that nothing can move without the whims and fancies
[41:36] of these generals. So that's where the difference lies. And I think we've
[41:39] discussed this before. Indian generals live in basic cities like Noida, Mohali.
[41:47] Some live down south because they have this affinity with Willington where they go as
[41:53] young officers to do their staff college, so they end up buying some property
[41:59] there. They don't live in London, So that's that's just one simple way
[42:04] of putting it. A young officer doesn't drive in India, doesn't drive any
[42:09] fancy cars. They'll drive a car. They'll drive a car that any other
[42:15] man or woman of that age would be. And the earlier, the older
[42:21] stories that we hear from Pakistan even even more intriguing when it came to,
[42:27] you know, the kind of lifestyle for our general young officers lived completely different.
[42:31] So yeah, I mean that they are demi gods and they have a
[42:37] different aura in their society needn't be reiterated. And what we find found funny
[42:43] in those videos, the funny side of it because we belong to a different
[42:46] culture. Yeah, that's why we found them funny. But those guys were
[42:51] not finding it funny. Of course. They had this kind of feeling that
[42:55] we are demystifying you. That's that's that's the sense that I got. That's
[43:01] the kick that they were getting out of it. So, I mean,
[43:04] if you make these basic comparisons, I think that's that's a difference. One
[43:08] One of the last thoughts from you, and this again, you know,
[43:12] as we tend to do very often, is kind of slipping into our producer
[43:15] Randa's territory, who hosts another her own podcast on geopolitics, but I think
[43:22] still very relevant to this issue at hand. We've had statements from I think
[43:28] the US and the UK, I'm forgetting each other country on what happened with
[43:31] him. India, if I'm not wrong, has not commented on this.
[43:35] Once again underlining what you mentioned before the break, Just like in our keep
[43:38] high it's Pakistan internal thing. Why should we have to always comment on it?
[43:44] Sort of a strategy that we've taken on that, but still how is
[43:46] it being viewed? And I'm going to name only three major countries, one
[43:51] US, for whom Pakistan was a staunch ally for like, you know,
[43:54] more than a decade. For India obviously, and crucially the country keep talking
[44:00] about China because China, we cannot disregard that they have a lot of interest
[44:04] in Pakistan, a lot of trade interests, a lot of land interests.
[44:08] They have their people over there working. So how do you think these countries
[44:13] as countries are viewing, No, China is the biggest stakeholder. I think,
[44:19] having having said that, not that US isn't because you know, the
[44:23] geographical location of Pakistan is makes it very interesting place and it allows Pakistan to
[44:31] be sort of played into the trap of good boy bad boy kind of a
[44:37] thing. So when they had to get to summer, yeah, so Pakistan
[44:43] was made to play good company and that's again an unfortunate misfortune of the people
[44:47] of that country that they sort of used because I mean, you can really
[44:52] start up for your own sovereignty. Amy so China will definitely be watching things
[44:59] extremely closely, and I think India's interests will start from there what China is
[45:05] doing, What China is doing in these circumstances, And I'll give you a
[45:09] very clear, try to give you a clear illustration of what is happening now
[45:15] and what will happen later. As we were discussing that India's interest in Pakistan
[45:22] bashing is much less now a few years down the line, say for five
[45:25] years down the line, if something like this happened, there would be a
[45:29] lot of off record briefings this is what is happening in Pakistan, some videos
[45:34] would come. The clue you guys can use it went a few years ago,
[45:37] a few years back, back back, a few years ago from the
[45:42] Indian security establishment sources. Nothing of that sort has happened, exactly nothing.
[45:46] It's like they haven't even take it of what's happened. It's like I could
[45:51] be attending a briefing five six years back if something had happened. These are
[45:54] the pros and cons is how we are looking at it. This is what
[45:59] is expected, this our inter says, and I would do We would do
[46:01] a few stories here and there around it. No talk. This will change
[46:06] the moment we have a clear picture what China is doing, and then I'm
[46:09] telling you we'll be discussing on one of the podcasts what China is doing in
[46:13] Pakistan under these circumstances. It's very interesting actually, so India's interest in Pakistan
[46:17] will actually be shaped by China's interest in Pakistan. It's not our own rest
[46:22] so I think it's an idea we're given to our producer for our episodes.
[46:24] They can do it, you can do it with It's an interesting one.
[46:29] Yeah, right, So ta just two last things and again the funny side
[46:34] of it. I'm sorry if you know, if I keep talking about the
[46:36] funny aspect of what happened yesterday. But there are just like a couple of
[46:38] elements, a lot of memes, memes, yeah, so many memes,
[46:42] especially of Imran on one set up to Gabrajao. So yeah, when all
[46:49] that will happen. Yeah, But here something that struck me was that when
[46:52] you were talking about all these locations where the underst was taking place, I
[46:55] was just thinking, like, how come so no one has come up with
[47:00] a conferency theory. Is somehow the Roys involved in all of this, Now
[47:02] that's what Pakistan to do? Yeah? There, of course, obviously there
[47:06] there, But then I just thought, you know, someone actually from Pakistan
[47:08] did tweet about this. By the last night, they actually wanted the ely
[47:10] police to lodge a complete Internet and that the Ely police are very witty thing.
[47:16] Unfortunately a jurisiction does Pakistan. But how are you tweeting because Internet's implution
[47:22] in your country, very witty of whoever is unlinkedly polices? Well done?
[47:28] Moment. Yeah, and you know you want your security forces, police forces
[47:34] to sometimes sort of just calm down and indulge engage in this kind of punter.
[47:38] Yeah, it's okay, like moment. Yeah. But you know,
[47:42] one last thing that you know struck me just to discuss with you is that,
[47:46] And this is something that'll be appreciated by people who follow the news very
[47:50] closely, is the banner headline that sets section one four four across Pakistan.
[47:55] In section one four four, it's the one thing that the two countries having
[48:00] died from the British colonial legacy legacy. I'm wondered if section one for four
[48:04] is there in the UK penal code right now, I don't know. I
[48:07] don't know. See the IPC is here in Pakistan penal code. It is
[48:12] exactly the same. It's a carbon copy. Yeah. So I mean,
[48:15] so the chuck in the newsroom, you know, when we had the news
[48:17] in section one for imposed across Pakistan. They also with this and unfortunately,
[48:23] if they had a few other things that we have, yeah, they wouldn't
[48:27] have to do this. Actually a good point. Thanks for fun chat as
[48:30] usual, had lots of fun and I again love that insight of yours.
[48:35] I did not think of that at all. Actually, the one where you
[48:37] said that the videos that we saw of you know, people stealing those items
[48:40] from those that's the only reason I decided we should discuss, yeah, discussion,
[48:45] Yeah, because those were pictures, visuals. I'm doing a little go
[48:51] down in history. Yeah, it is the first time Pakistan army has been
[48:54] called out, not just challenged, called out, and they did not know
[48:58] how to act, to act, what to do. They were they were
[49:00] caught completely off guard, is what my answers. Perhaps I never expected this.
[49:06] Perhaps they would have expected protests, there's yes, but they did not
[49:08] expect Pakistani army to be targeted. Why were there no attacks on police stations
[49:15] or government building exactly, quotes or any other thing that represents state. Why
[49:21] just the army. There's a question that is very easy to answer, of
[49:27] course, and I think we kind of have the curse of this episode.
[49:30] So yeah, I get your point. And I'm guessing that also explains what
[49:32] you said that the military has been absent since the events of yesterday. It's
[49:37] been a full twenty four hours now as we discussed this, and I don't
[49:42] think there's in a statement from the military yet kind of we are considering your
[49:45] establishments have been dirty. You're one of your ranking officers house was targeted,
[49:50] so yeah, co commander's house in an army mess was burned down. Yes,
[49:57] they also and they entered I mean entered the gate of the headquarters.
[50:00] I mean they didn't reach deeper. I think the initial pery periphery of the
[50:05] headquarters and now we'll be mid quarters. So certainly a breach more than enough
[50:09] for I think any military to kind of say something or something about which they
[50:13] haven't which and then there speculation of the army chief being sacked. I did
[50:17] not actually the army chief being replaced, So, I mean, I don't
[50:22] know. There's a lot of a lot of grape wine. Yes, I
[50:27] think we mentioned this is the last time as well, that you know,
[50:29] things in Pakistan are we have to watch and I think this has just one
[50:31] development that's happened since we said it last time. So again we still wait
[50:37] and watch sort of a mode. And to our listeners and viewers, we
[50:39] promise that you know when there are more developments, will once again talk about
[50:44] this and to you, you know, you can let us know what you
[50:45] want us to talk about. If you have any ideas, if you if
[50:49] you think there's something lacking in our or missing in our discussions, to let
[50:52] us know, you can drop a comment to us at whatever podcast platform you
[50:57] listen to us on, or you can drop a text to us at eight
[50:59] five doable nine double six double nine six, or an email at pots at
[51:01] the rate inni dot com. Let's be ods at the rate in ray dot
[51:05] com. That's it for this week's defense. Those for more Union next week,
[51:07] and then stay safe and do not cross any boundaries without the passport

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
