# Lakshadweep: From Tourism to Military Significance & Indian Navy 'Deep Water' Ambitions | In Our Defence, S02, Ep 14

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 7 Mar 2024, 57 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/58958214/07_mar_24_iod_s2_ep_14_mix_march_7_128.mp3

This week, the Indian Navy made significant moves. They officially launched the first squadron of MH 60R Seahawk helicopters, boosting their surveillance and combat abilities at sea. The commissioning ceremony for the INAS 334 'Seahawks' naval air squadron took place at INS Garuda in Kochi. In addition, India opened a new naval base on Minicoy Island in the Indian Ocean, near the Maldives, amidst strained relations. This base, INS Jatayu, is strategically important, being India's furthest western base and around 125 km from the Maldives. In this episode, host Dev Goswami and defense expert Shiv Aroor, discuss these developments and the significance of Lakshadweep for the Indian Navy. Why is it that Andaman and Nicobar islands have been given a greater focus than Lakshadweep, an archipelago who has always had a limited military presence? How timely is the establishment of the new navy base on the archipelago? And in the midst of this, how does Anant Ambani and Radhika Merchant’s pre-wedding bash in Jamnagar, come into the picture? Well, tune in to find out! Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound mix by Kapil Dev Singh

## Transcript

[0:00] This is India Today podcasts. All of this stuff was already planned and Mody
[0:09] went there, in my view, not not just to send out a political
[0:12] message about luxur weep, but to kind of gun the system into action as
[0:17] far as Luxury group is concerned. We have a great example from just this
[0:20] week, Amani's wedding in jam Nagger. Jam Nagger happens to be a high
[0:24] security mid twenty nine base not far from the Pakathan border. That airport,
[0:30] which is a high security defense establishment, just became India's most crowded business jet
[0:37] destination. You know, the Reliance doesn't know the Indian airport, so the
[0:40] Indian airport doesn't know Reliance. Jam Nagger is Reliance, for God's sakes.
[0:44] Minikoy is one of the three islands in the Luxury Group that actually have results.
[0:48] So you know a lot of tourists, you know, wondering whether with
[0:51] the Navy's arrival there, could it mean that you know, results got to
[0:54] move out from there if you ask me, The Indian Navy has a you
[0:57] may have a much smaller navy, but we have much bigger bluewater capability.
[1:03] Hello and welcome to Another Defense, a weekly podcast on all things well defense,
[1:08] where I they've Goswami, your host, along with senior journalist Shivarur,
[1:12] break down the world of conflicts that range from the subtle to the brutal.
[1:17] We bring you nuances and perspectives that will inform and at times provoke. This
[1:26] is In Our Defense. Hello and welcome to the fourteenth episode of In Our
[1:30] Defense. Hello, chef, how are you busy week? I'm guessing busy
[1:34] week. The war has begun in the only permanent battlefield that we have here
[1:38] in India, the elections, So yeah, it's only going to get worse
[1:40] from now on. It is it is. You know, I was discussing
[1:42] this with somebody the other day that how the two of us are finding it
[1:46] quite difficult to come up with my topics to think to talk about because nothing
[1:49] seems to be happening in the world of defense. It's just all politics,
[1:52] products, products, as far as Indian mainstream use the flow is concerned.
[1:57] But I think this week is a bit different for the Indian Nie. A
[2:00] lot of events happened for the Indian Navy. I think the top brass is
[2:02] quite busy. The Ministry of Defense, Raja Saying also is attending some of
[2:07] these events. Uh and UH that's the reason we're going to talk about the
[2:12] Indian Navy today and specifically about the Indian Navy Uh, and Indian Navy's interest
[2:17] along the West coast and the very trending buzzword that's become for the last two
[2:23] three weeks Luxury. Yeah. Before we get to all of that, I
[2:27] just give our listeners and viewers a list of what's happened in the last couple
[2:30] of days. We're recording this on sixth March of Wednesday, So today you
[2:35] have You've had the induction of the Seahawks, the anti submarine helicopters that took
[2:40] place in Kerla, I think ian is Garuda, just near Coaching and Kerala.
[2:45] You also had the commissioning or I'm not sure if it's happened as we
[2:47] talk right now, but the commissioning of iran Jatayu, a full fledged naval
[2:52] base on one of the islands of the Luxury the apartment. It's happened.
[2:54] It's happened, right. It was already sort of a naval unit there and
[3:00] saying on the Mini Koi Island, it was known as Naval Detachment Winniko,
[3:02] which has not been upgraded to yanes Jatayu. UH. Yesterday you had the
[3:07] first day of the Naval Commander's Confidence Annual Confidence. You had a new building
[3:13] being inaugurated at the Naval War College in Goa, and you also had Rajmat
[3:17] Si commissioning what is known as the Phase two A of the Karua Naval Naval
[3:23] Base. I'm going to come back to Carver later in the episode because something
[3:28] very gossipy I want ship to come in, but we'll get to that towards
[3:30] the end of this episode. So if we had all of this happening,
[3:32] and like we said, all of this, all of these events have happened
[3:36] along along India's West coast. Lashally became a very sort of a buzzword for
[3:40] Indian media. When you had the famous visit of Premissioner in Remo the to
[3:45] the to the one of the islands over there. Uh. It came against
[3:49] the backdrop of Maldive's current presidents UH leaning towards China and the whole controversy.
[3:54] We'll kind of get into that some other time, but that is the backdrop.
[3:58] I'm not sure and I don't think that would be the trigger for what
[4:01] we are about to discuss in this episode. So we want to talk obviously
[4:05] about Lucture Deep, the islands and strategic and military uh and military importance for
[4:11] the Indian Navy, for India in general. UH. Before we get to
[4:14] that, before we talk about Lacture Deep, I want to first actually talk
[4:16] about why is it that among the two flanks so to speak, that we
[4:19] have the East coast and the West coast, it's the Eastern Coast and the
[4:24] Eastern Islands that have sort of been given the importance if you compared to Luxury
[4:28] for example, Actually, they already had one of one one naval base ion
[4:30] is Deep Pracash sosh uh. Yeah, but you've had the Andaman Nicoba Command,
[4:40] India's only tri services operational command which actually carries out military functions. The
[4:45] other Tri service command is the Strategy Forces Command discussed previously. Between the two
[4:49] island two archipelagos, How is it and why was it that India favored developing
[4:55] and amand Nicobar Island as a full fledge it sort of for you know,
[4:58] my maritime security unit compared to Lush with the which we'll get into why we
[5:01] should be doing this in the near future. So the reason for that,
[5:04] Dave, that's a good question. The most basic reason for that is that
[5:09] unlike the Andermans, which have very very large that this is something most people
[5:14] don't know, a very large land area. These are huge islands with with
[5:18] vast geographical spread uh. And these are substantive islands with mountains and forests.
[5:25] The Luxury Wee Islands are a bunch of very very small, geographically small islands.
[5:30] If you look at the Bangarum Island where the airfield is, it's the
[5:34] airfield is basically, uh, you know, right along the island, you
[5:40] know, across its width. The width of the island is basically practically the
[5:44] width of the runway. So these are these are hardly even islands. The
[5:46] Luxury Islands are actually atolls, which are you know, basically uh, you
[5:50] know, coral and uh you know seabed, uh you know, structures which
[5:56] are not full fledged islands. So the Luxury geographically doesn't have the kind of
[6:01] space required to support large scale military infrastructure. That's reason number one. I've
[6:08] been I'm one of the few people who've been lucky and privileged enough to have
[6:12] been to both the islands on multiple occasions. I have been to the Luxury
[6:15] twice, including Minikoi, which we're going to talk about. But the Anderman
[6:19] Islands are not only geographically much much larger, you know, facilitating the establishment
[6:27] of full fledged naval bases, not on one, not two, but three
[6:30] separate islands have full fledged tri service bases Carnacobar, you know, I forget
[6:36] the other island, and then of course in South Anderman which is port play.
[6:41] So that's one of the main reasons for it. The other reason why
[6:45] the Andermans has been given a greater deal of focus is because they've the luxury
[6:48] Weep Islands are much closer to the Indian mainland compared to the Anderman Islands.
[6:54] The Anderman Islands are way away there, all the way across the across the
[6:58] Bay of Pengol, very close to you know, Mayanmar, and the southern
[7:03] tip of the Anderman Islands is closer to Indonesia than it is to the Indian
[7:08] mainland. Right, So it's these are extremely far away territories of India and
[7:15] therefore the compulsion to build them up from a maritime perspective, maritime security perspective,
[7:21] military perspective was much more compelling. We'll come to the China aspect in
[7:26] just a bit. But remember that the many people probably don't know that the
[7:30] northern few islands of the Anderman and Nicobar Chain actually don't belong to India.
[7:35] The Coco Island, et cetera, belongs technically to Mayanmar, and like everything
[7:42] else in the Indian Ocean that belongs to a smaller nation, it's basically controlled
[7:46] by China. So an airfield has come up on the Coco Island. And
[7:47] so when you look at that map, all of the Enderman islands that you
[7:50] see are all Indian, but there are a bunch of islands right at the
[7:54] top which are not part of India. They're part of Mayamar. So all
[7:58] of these compulsions have meant that, uh, you know, India has had
[8:01] a much more strenuous focus on the Andaman Islands because they're much farther away,
[8:07] they need protection. They provide a greater deal of you know access as far
[8:13] as an observation post and a military you know base is concerned for the rest
[8:18] of the South Indian Ocean. Uh, And that's the reason why it has
[8:20] happened. But like you rightly said, luxury Weep has so far had uh
[8:24] you know, a limited military presence in terms of the detachment in Minikoi Dhui
[8:30] pructure kin Kawarati, you know, very very limited sort of thing. Coast
[8:35] Guard has had much act. The Coast Guard is actually the chief force in
[8:39] the in luxury Weep, not the Indian Navy, because that's how close luxury
[8:43] Weep is to Kerala into the Indian mainland, you know, just a few
[8:45] hundred nautical miles. So the the compulsion now in fact is to is to
[8:50] take that a little further. Because of the manner in which China has been
[8:54] trying to turn things around in Maldives, putting pressure on other island countries Sri
[9:00] Lanka included. You know, the focus on luxur Weep has become of prime
[9:05] importance. And I don't think that Prime Minister Modi going there was a coincidence.
[9:09] I think it was very much to call attention politically, not only politically
[9:16] to luxurre Weep, but also to kind of clear the decks for a larger
[9:20] sort of systemic shift in how luxured Weep is treated, you know, not
[9:26] just in terms of infrastructure, but as a very very valuable military you know,
[9:31] a place for from where India can protect its interests. So that's that's
[9:35] the reason why it's happening now, right, So take us through what's happening
[9:39] in MINIICOI. Like I said at the beginning of this episode, it already
[9:41] had what is not enable detachment. I don't know what that means on a
[9:43] CPA. That's just like the term that came up during my research. Now
[9:48] it's being upgraded, so to speak, to a full fledged naval base,
[9:50] and so it gets a name called iones th Indi Enaval The station was shipp
[9:56] uh one, what is happening in miniicoy uh? And second what you briefly
[10:01] referred to that you know, India's kind of increasingly looking at luxur deep.
[10:05] Apart from just the China angle, is also obviously the angle of global trade.
[10:09] You we've been seeing a lot of more pirate attacks on ships that travels
[10:13] through the Indian Ocean, and the Indian Navy has played one of a very
[10:16] four fernt role in protecting these ships. In fact, I think something happened
[10:20] just yesterday, Yes we record again, like I said, on March six
[10:24] and March five, the Navy put out a video and some information about some
[10:26] ship that had been attacked by a trone and it was on fire and they
[10:30] went into rescue, et cetera. So, yeah, what's happening on Minikoi
[10:33] and this rise in importance of lux with you for India's strategic goals? When
[10:39] did it begin? Because it's obviously not as Lokipmo againship basis. It's not
[10:46] like that. Obviously there has been this has been long time coming and people
[10:48] like you who've been talking to people in the defense setup, you must have
[10:52] heard murmurs about it year and there, so tell us what do you know
[10:56] about that? So yeah, So, so, first of all, when
[10:58] you say that there's has been a you know, a naval detachment at Minicoi,
[11:03] it basically means some spare naval infrastructure, you know, the ability to
[11:07] you know, bring some fast interceptor craft, small small boats. Let's be
[11:11] very clear that these are islands that cannot they don't have deep water. These
[11:16] are basically coral atolls, which basically means that from the beach you have shallow
[11:22] water for many kilometers into the sea. There's no deep water comes way after,
[11:28] so there's no possibility of having a deep water harbor, you know,
[11:31] to to support warships or submarines and things like that. So that's out of
[11:35] the question. You can have shallow water craft like interceptor boats, patrol vessels,
[11:39] et cetera. And that's the reason why Luxury Deep has been a kind
[11:41] of outpost for the coast Guard, not the Navy. The Navy is like
[11:45] a deep water force, not a shallow water force like the coast Guard.
[11:48] So it's been the coast Guard that has you know, dwiprucure, whether it
[11:52] is deepructure in Coverathi or you know, the the jetties and some of the
[11:56] other islands. Those are places where the coast Guard, you know, has
[12:00] established infrastructure. But like you know, but the coast Guard is a is
[12:03] a very light footed force, unlike the Navy, which requires heavy duty infrastructure
[12:07] because they've got big ships, you know, heavy duty weaponry, et cetera.
[12:11] So it's it's not even comparable. But now what MINIKOI is getting is
[12:18] is even though even the term full fledged naval base is a is a is
[12:22] a little bit of a misnomer, and I want to sort of just clarify
[12:26] that so people understand when you say full fledged naval base, Uh, for
[12:30] me, what comes to mind is something like Irons Garuda in Kochi or Ion
[12:35] s Kadambai in Karwar or you know or Ion s RAJII in Ara Kuonum.
[12:39] These are big naval bases, you know, which have infrastructure, They've got
[12:43] airfields, They've got you know, places where their ships can you know,
[12:48] be brought in what And you're a bombay boys, so you know how the
[12:52] Indian Navy setup is in Mumbai. So this is obviously going to be a
[12:58] much smaller scale, but it generally means that there will be a greater naval
[13:01] presence a there will be the support for aviation aviation units, which means that
[13:07] helicopters can already operate. There is already an airstrip. If you look at
[13:11] if you take a look at a map, a Google map picture of Miniicoi,
[13:16] it's a funnily shaped island. It's shaped like a sickle, so it
[13:20] there's very little maneuverability in terms of what you can actually build there. It's
[13:24] a beautiful, absolutely stunning I've been there. One of the greatest beaches in
[13:26] the world. It's a it's a it's a it's a bay. It's basically
[13:30] you know, it's a U shaped island with a large beach and it doesn't
[13:35] it doesn't have very much possibility of building anything big or permanent h and so
[13:41] what the Navy is going to probably have there is more infrastructure to support a
[13:45] greater number of boats. Uh. The airfield over there, I am told,
[13:48] we don't know if it's going to happen in the near future or maybe
[13:50] after a few years, but the existing airstrip on Minikoy is going to be
[13:54] converted into a full fledged airfield or an air base which could potential support fighter
[14:01] and military you know, cargo operations where P eighties possibly could also you know,
[14:07] could operate from as detachment. And even though the these islands are pretty
[14:11] close to India, having that kind of reach into the Indian Ocean is very
[14:16] very valuable. Another thing that most people perhaps don't know about Minikoi is Minikoi
[14:20] is the southernmost island off the Luxured Weep. It is actually closer to Maldives
[14:26] than it is to the rest of Luxure Weep and to the Indian mainland.
[14:30] It's one hundred and fifty kilometers from the northern tip of the Maldives, but
[14:33] it is almost two hundred and fifty kilometers from the rest of the Luctured Weep.
[14:37] So it's this tiny, very remote southern island that belongs to the luxury
[14:41] weep chain where India is going to be building this stuff. So when we
[14:45] think of luxury weep, it's not like just some random island in this cluster
[14:48] where we're building a naval beast. It's like far out two hundred and fifty
[14:52] kilometers deep into the Indian Ocean, very close to Maldives, where India is
[14:56] building all this stuff, and it sends out a message. I agree with
[15:00] you completely. It's not like, you know, more they went to luxural
[15:01] weep and suddenly we decided how he's occurring it. I have a feeling it's
[15:05] actually the other way around. All of this stuff was already planned and Morey
[15:09] went there, in my view, not not just to send out a political
[15:13] message about luxured weep, but to kind of, uh sort of you know,
[15:18] gun the system into action as far as luxur weep is concerned. You
[15:22] know, you radiate that message into the entire system saying luxured weep is important,
[15:28] and now the system is going to work towards doing all these things for
[15:31] luctured weep. And that's the reason why it's happened. So make no mistake.
[15:35] Whether it's a few boats or a few ships, the ability to operate
[15:39] your drones from Minikoi, it is hugely, hugely valuable and I'm actually quite
[15:43] excited to see what they do with it next. Minikoi is one of the
[15:48] three islands in the Luxural Weep that actually have results. So you know,
[15:50] a lot of tourists, you know, wondering whether with the Navy's arrival there,
[15:54] could it mean that, you know, results got to move out from
[15:58] there, and it's a spectacular island, could it become off limits for tourists
[16:02] in the future. Who knows. We don't know that yet. But all
[16:04] I can say is that the strategic importance of the Luxury Weep, you know,
[16:08] I'm not going to say it was never there. There was always a
[16:11] recognition, but there were constraints. In two thousand and six, I had
[16:15] done a story in the Indian Express about how the island that has Luxured Weep's
[16:19] airport cannot support big jets and it cannot support fighter aircraft. So the Indian
[16:26] Air Force had actually put up a proposal saying right at the end of the
[16:29] runway there's water, the sea begins, but just a short distance away,
[16:33] there's another small island. So what the Indian Air Force had proposed is if
[16:37] we reclaim land between the runway and that island, we can extend the runway
[16:41] onto that island and create a longer runway for better infrastructure. And that was
[16:47] shot down by the government because of environmental concerns because, and I think rightly
[16:51] so, the environment Ministry at the time in two thousand and six had said,
[16:55] look, these are very very fragile coral islands. There's no question of
[16:59] destroying choral to reclaim land and build a runway and stuff. That's not going
[17:03] to happen. You figure out how you want to do things otherwise, but
[17:06] that is something we cannot accept. I think that was the right decision.
[17:08] But that could happen in Minicoy because Minikoi has enough land to support a large
[17:12] a base, So maybe that will happen now, Yeah, right, you
[17:15] trust upon two points or where you were speaking right now that I actually wanted
[17:19] wanted to discuss with you anyway is about and this is sort of a tangential
[17:25] point to the larger discussion that you're having, but very much linked to Lutch
[17:29] with you is the clash between your military needs, your military infrastructure, and
[17:34] a tourism and b ecology and environmental concers. I'll give you the example of
[17:41] our capital, or the place where the two of us operate from. You
[17:44] know, every Republic Day, the four or five days before that, most
[17:48] of air space around the Eli air puttish shat because therefore needed FIR its practice
[17:52] runs for the Republic Day parade, and even on a daily basis, a
[17:56] large part of delis a space is shut for commercial commercial airlines because of course,
[18:00] you know, national capital, important air bases, et cetera. And
[18:03] in fact, if people go back, I forgot the year this happened,
[18:07] but there was an air disaster. I think it was called the Churchy crash,
[18:11] and one of the reasons for the crash was years commercial flight operations had
[18:17] a very narrow corridor to operate in Deli, because of which an incoming flight
[18:21] and outgoing flight were in the same corridor and always at the same flight level.
[18:23] After the crash, I think the corridor was expanded, their force did
[18:26] give up some space for commercial operations. Therely may not be the greatest example
[18:32] because national capital you obviously take that into account, but you are getting where
[18:34] I'm coming from There are examples of tourists having been fined at certain airports because
[18:41] those are technically air bases operated by the Indian Air Force where photography is not
[18:45] allowed. But the tourists don't know that they are going there for a vacation,
[18:48] so they are happily clicking pictures at the airport and they get fined or
[18:52] caught for that. I don't think the Air Force is very inal about that,
[18:55] but in certain cases you can understand that they'd want to implements the rule
[18:59] of the law. So yeah, how do you see the clash between your
[19:03] country's military needs with tourism, especially like places like you mentioned that Minikoi has
[19:08] a mass a fantastic resort and there are concerns that might have to go away.
[19:12] Don't want to get into the speculation over there. And second the concerns
[19:15] of environment, because you know, I think when it comes to India's military
[19:21] infrastructure, I've seen zero public discourse, public debate. I'm pretty sure it
[19:25] must happen at the government level, but public discourse on whether a particular military
[19:30] infrastructure project is impacting that area's environment, whether it's the northeast, whether it's
[19:36] the Himalayas, whether it's Luxury, whether it's under Manicobar Island, because I
[19:40] think it comes with the sense of, you know, by national security and
[19:42] all that. So we cannot be discussing that. Your take on this,
[19:45] because I'm very conflicted. No, it's a really good question. And also,
[19:48] you know, like like most things in this country, the system has
[19:52] to strike a balance. There are innumerable examples they of military proposals have been
[20:00] shot down because of environmental concerns, because of economic concerns, because of simple
[20:06] geographical concerns. A number of them, and the example that I gave you
[20:10] of the runway extension in Luxury is only one of them. The DADO wanted
[20:15] to set up a you know, a missile telemetry and testing facility in the
[20:19] Anderman Islands. That was shot down as well. The Navy wanted a test
[20:23] range in the Anderman Islands, shot down by this government. So so you
[20:27] know, and and and the Navy has been trying hard to get that kind
[20:32] of thing, saying that you know, this is a perfect place where from
[20:33] an island we can fire a missile onto another island. They've been able to
[20:37] do that in a limited way, but they haven't been able to set up
[20:40] a range. So there are no shortage of examples of this, this kind
[20:44] of proverbial clash between environmental concerns and military compulsions. But I think that's okay.
[20:49] I think I think that's that that shows the system is working. If
[20:53] you've got a system that you know, is weighing concerns for the environment,
[20:59] which is which should be a long term concern for every nation, especially one
[21:02] like India, along with your security threat perceptions and needs. That's a good
[21:07] thing. You know. You you can't use national security as an as as
[21:11] a as a kind of battering ram to get whatever you want. That's that's
[21:15] not the way a country should work, because then we would be no different
[21:18] from you know, say China, Pakistan, and you know, as a
[21:22] country that has commitments as far as environmental concerns are you know, are there.
[21:26] It's it's good that the system pushes back on some of these proposals from
[21:32] the military, you know, you know, since you talked about you know,
[21:34] the military having to share space with civilian civilian stuff. We have a
[21:40] great example from just this week, Anamani's wedding in jam Naga, jam Nagger
[21:45] happens to be a high security Mid twenty nine base not far from the Pakasthan
[21:48] border, where you know India's Maritimes strike fighters are based. Photography is not
[21:56] permitted. It's a highly secured combat aviation base of the of the Indian Air
[22:02] Force. It's also from where you know the petroleum fields of the Reliance industries
[22:07] are protected by these MAKE twenty nine because it's a huge economic part of the
[22:11] country. That airport, which is a high security defense establishment, just became
[22:18] India's most crowded business jet destination. Okay, now, now now you know
[22:25] I'm saying, I'm saying the Indian Air Force must have had a must have
[22:29] had a thing or two to say about that. But the Indian Air Force,
[22:33] you know, is functions in a democracy. They know that they will
[22:36] have to share space and you know, permissions would have been taken, the
[22:38] Indian Air Force would have been brought on board. It's not like, you
[22:41] know, the Reliance doesn't know the Indian Airport or the Indian Air Force doesn't
[22:45] know Reliance. Jamnugger is Reliance for God's sake, So you know, in
[22:48] many ways, I'm just saying that's an example of you know how the most
[22:52] high security places you know, are not rigid. They can be flexible when
[22:56] it comes to something of this kind. I think if you take the example
[23:00] of MINIKOI we don't know just yet what's going to happen Karvar, since you
[23:04] mentioned it earlier, that was a place where large swaths of land, you
[23:10] know, which which people owned or which was you know, government land became
[23:15] military land. And when land is converted into military land, the rules changed
[23:18] completely. Nothing can be built nearby. Uh. You know, there are
[23:22] there are specific laws that apply to that land. You know, if something
[23:26] goes wrong on that land, specific acts cake in. You can get into
[23:30] serious trouble if you do something wrong on that land. You know. So
[23:33] all those things are definitely there. But I think, but I think,
[23:36] uh, you know, any mature democracy, and I think India is one
[23:41] has the metal to take these decisions. And believe you me, they've we
[23:47] can. I can fill books with the number of proposals the military has put
[23:51] forward where it has been disappointed. Whether it is mess hall, whether it
[23:55] is clubs, whether it is missile ranges, whether it is artillery sites,
[23:59] whether it is ammunition depots, whether it is ladies clubs, whether it is
[24:03] fences, whatever it is. There have been so many proposals that have been
[24:07] shot down because you know, civilian concerns or economic concerns, environmental concerns have
[24:12] kicked in. So so the balance is definitely there. It's a case to
[24:15] case basis. Yeah, right, And like Kushiff said, we'll keep our
[24:19] close eye on what happens at the Mini Coo Island because I think that will
[24:22] kind of give us like sort of the blueprint of how what happens when I
[24:26] sure hope we can still visit, because it would be a pity if civilians
[24:29] can't visit anymore. That's that's all I can really say. Right right,
[24:33] We'll move to the other big event that happened with the navy this week and
[24:37] also the larger, larger discussion on what the Indian Navy's aspirations are. If
[24:44] you're confused what I meant by that, just hold on. I'm going to
[24:47] be back after a quick take. Pany pany Pani Lama joy so beautiful,
[24:57] so elegant, just looking like a wow e bang. Was that enough cringe
[25:03] for you? Because this cringe fest doesn't stop here. Yes, And if
[25:08] by watching such reals and vile videos, you think your life is becoming moem,
[25:14] then I cost them and me Anna will bring the most puke worthy,
[25:18] nauseating and repulsive trends on social media and well maybe enact some of them,
[25:25] but most of all discuss and seriously dissect these trends. So get ready to
[25:30] laugh, cringe and question humanity. Dropping soon on Spotify, Apple Podcasts and
[25:37] wherever you get your cringe, I mean audio entertainment from So let's talk cringe.
[25:48] Welcome back. Shave and I are discussing the military importance of the luxury
[25:52] pilants located of India's western course, how it compares to India's historic interest along
[26:00] the islands of the eastern coast, which are the Islands and Islands Ships given
[26:04] us a nice overview of what's about to happen on the islands with the setting
[26:08] up of a new naval base called Lionatau on the Manico Islands, which is
[26:12] around to fifty to three hundred klometers away from the existing naval base in the
[26:17] Luxury Islands. We will move slightly towards the coast to another event that happened
[26:22] today, if I'm not wrong. Yes, On six March, which was
[26:23] the induction of I forgot the number, but Sea Hawk helicopters the primary role
[26:30] for which I'm guessing is going to be anti submarine warfare. Obviously you tell
[26:33] us a moment obviously, like always, because I think we on this on
[26:37] this podcast will always cover whenever there's a new equipment being being inducted into the
[26:41] Indian military, because that's something I think with the two of us lab and
[26:44] I'm pretty sure our listeners and viewers love, so obviously tell us about these
[26:47] helicopters, what they're all about. And also I want to understand the technology
[26:52] of anti submarine warfare from the air, because the way what I've read about
[26:56] anti sumine warfare is see first of all, you need like you know,
[26:59] highly you know, high text onnars for that which I'm guessing can be operated
[27:02] only from the sea, if I'm not wrong, not really from the air.
[27:04] So you needed like you know, ships to kind of send those pings,
[27:07] and then the velocity with which those things come back to you. That's
[27:11] how you kind of determine where a submarine is lying. And submarines, but
[27:15] the very nature are very notoriously hard to detect. So how does a helicopter
[27:18] go around tracking and you know, taking on a submarine U. So,
[27:22] yeah, tell us about all of this. So so you know, these
[27:25] helicopters have just been commissioned into service in the Indian Navy and coachy in Kerala
[27:30] in a in an aviation squadron called i NS three three four. The helicopters
[27:36] are called the MH sixty Romeos or Seahawks as you just call them. They're
[27:40] manufactured by Lockheed Martin and Sikorsky. Sikorski is actually the company that invented the
[27:45] helicopter, you know, many many years ago. So this is a this
[27:51] is uh, you know, a top of the line naval combat helicopter.
[27:56] You know, a helicopter that is something that gives sleepless nights uh to anyone
[28:02] you deployed against because it's called a flying frigate by many because of how much
[28:07] kit and how much you know, hurtful stuff it carries, uh, you
[28:11] know, in that little compact space. And you know these are these are
[28:15] you know everyone's heard of the black Hawk, black Hawk, black Hawk down.
[28:18] It's the same airframe, you know, the Hawk airframe, the UH
[28:21] sixty black Hawk airframe is exactly what's used here. It's a navalized helicopter,
[28:26] so it's built to uh, you know, operate off ship decks and aircraft
[28:30] carriers. Uh. And uh. This was a deal that India signed after
[28:34] you know, over a decade and a half of you know, dillydallying,
[28:37] meandering the you know, the same sad story that we've discussed here on in
[28:41] our defense several times about India's procurement process. But basically, the Indian Navy
[28:47] has always had uh, you know, a you know, a fleet of
[28:49] helicopters called the Sea Kings. These are you know, these are British origin
[28:55] helicopters that we bought way back in the seventies eighties, fabulous helicopters that that
[29:00] were basically our anti submarine, anti ship fleet. But as fabulous as they
[29:06] were, they've they've reached the end of their life. So for the last
[29:08] ten years, the Indian Navy has been struggling to find a way to replace
[29:12] them. You know, there have been contests, tenders, cancelations, abots,
[29:18] you know, the usual saga that we see here in India. And
[29:21] finally in twenty twenty, the Indian Navy was able to sign a deal with
[29:25] the United States. It was a government to government deal for twenty four of
[29:29] these Romeos, as they call these helicopters, fabulous helicopters, very very well
[29:33] armed, and I'll come to how they actually do their you know, their
[29:37] deadly job in just a moment. But so we've got six helicopters delivered so
[29:41] far. It's an order for twenty four, so eighteen more of these helicopters
[29:45] will be delivered over the next few years, so a total of twenty four
[29:48] helicopters will be part of the i NAS three three four squadron in Kochi in
[29:53] Kerala. But since their deliveries began in twenty twenty two, they've already been
[29:59] you know, the squadron comes to life today, but these helicopters have already
[30:03] been operating. It's not like they're sitting around waiting for clearance to fly.
[30:06] They've been flying operations. They've been on anti submarine warfare patrol. They've been
[30:10] flying off our aircraft carriers. They were part of the Milan exercise that just
[30:14] got over in the Indian Ocean. So these helicopters are already live. They're
[30:18] active, they're operational, they're doing their work. Now they come obviously very
[30:22] very heavily armed. That's the reason why they called you know, flying warships.
[30:26] They carry their primary weapon. Their primary mission, of course is anti
[30:30] submarine warfare, and for that they carry they have sonars, dunking sonars which
[30:36] are basically you know, sonars which they can dunk into the sea via you
[30:41] know, via a winch to detect what's in the water at that time.
[30:44] They're able to deploy sono boys. Sono boys are electronic gadgets which PLoP into
[30:48] the water, you know, a bunch of them can be dropped into the
[30:52] water at great distances, and they triangulate if within their you know, geographical
[30:59] spread that they surrounded by, if there is an enemy submarine somewhere there,
[31:03] and all of that data is fed back to the helicopter or to anyone who's
[31:07] plugged into that data. So that's that These are the three things that form
[31:11] its anti submarine arsenal. Apart from that, they've got a GM one one
[31:15] for al fire missiles, very famous. Those are the missiles that drones fire,
[31:19] Predator drones fire AGM. These are precision guided missiles basically for land you
[31:25] know, land targets. They've also got seventy millimeter laser guided rockets, which
[31:29] are brutally powerful, you know, systems to attack ships and boats and things
[31:34] like that. And they've got the MK fifty four torpedo. The torpedo,
[31:40] which is your submarine killing weapon, is also something that's on board this helicopter.
[31:45] So so these are this helicopter is a is a nightmare for a submarine
[31:49] commander. You know, if this submarine, if this particular helicopter takes off
[31:53] from a deck, it means that you've already been spotted. Probably all that
[32:00] the guy whose side you're not on, they know that you're there. And
[32:04] this helicopters, you know, on its way to confirm your presence. And
[32:07] if it confirms your presence, and if it and if the helicopter pilot gets
[32:12] the order to finish the job, then then then God help. That's that's
[32:16] basically what the Seahawk does. It's uh, it's a you know, I've
[32:20] spoken to Seahawk commanders both in the US Navy as well as in the Australian
[32:25] Navy as well, and they're their entire thing about the Seahawk is that you
[32:31] know, once you have once you have have him, he's not kidding away.
[32:36] Wow, So that's how it is. That's quite the vivid description for
[32:39] for these helicopters. But I'm glad we have them now, especially because you
[32:43] know, you have to look at this in the context of China's aggressive expansion
[32:47] of a submarine fleet. I think most maybe our listeners know, but China
[32:52] actually a couple of years ago was able to surpass the US as the world's
[32:55] largest submarine fleet operator, not officially because China being China, does not regal
[33:00] levels. Yeah, but the estimate now is it China has around seventy plus
[33:04] submarines, while the US is around sixty five sixty eight submarines China. The
[33:07] Chinese Navy also is regarded only in terms of sheer numbers, not in terms
[33:12] of technology and capabilities, but in terms of sheer numbers of Chinese Navy.
[33:15] The People'sation Army Navy is also the world's largest largest naval force. Where I'm
[33:21] getting at with this is what I referred to the before the break when I
[33:24] said the aspirations of the Indian Navy, because unlike you know, the Indian
[33:29] or any air force or any land based army, the navy, apart from
[33:32] just being an offensive and defensive arm also has the other objective of projecting power,
[33:37] something that ship has referred to previously in our our episodes, that navies
[33:42] project power. You know, they are like sort of flag barriers in the
[33:46] in the ocean. They are also like a very vital diplomatic tool, you
[33:51] know, in times of crises in other countries where it's natural disasters, fires,
[33:55] earthquaits, as try you send relief for your ships. You've had the
[33:59] Navy play an important to evacuating Indians when they're caught up in a war.
[34:05] It's happened a couple of times in the Middle East, so you have Yeah,
[34:07] so the navy has its additional sort of an objective wide I refer to
[34:13] China being the largest and also the US Navy. So there is this term,
[34:15] I don't know if you mentioned that previously in this episode, but there's
[34:20] this term that's known as blue water Navy, blue water aspirations. The perfect
[34:23] example of that of which is the US Navy. They have bases all over
[34:29] the world. They have got knows how many aircraft carrier carriers, all of
[34:32] which go around the world with large a large number of yah Ya ships and
[34:37] also a large number of submarines. You have China rapidly expanding its submarine force.
[34:43] Again, because China being China, never officially, but whenever there's an
[34:46] investment in an island nation, you can assume that China has some sort of
[34:50] control on a base somewhere. China has, I'm guessing some sort of control
[34:55] in some foreign bases. India does not have a single, I think base
[35:00] in a foreign country naval base. I think there was some talk about base
[35:04] being set up in socials. I'm not sure where that's reached. I think
[35:06] you can expand with that a bit later when you talk about it. So,
[35:08] yeah, does the Indian Navy have an aspiration of being a blue water
[35:14] true blue water force or are we just happy controlling and ensuring our backyard is
[35:19] secure because remember our backhead is quite vast. The ocean is named after this
[35:22] country. Yeah. Otherwise, it's not that we have rights to all of
[35:25] it. Technically, we have rights to what international law permits, but the
[35:30] Indian notion is vast. We'd like to be in charge of that. So
[35:34] are we okay with just being in charge of that? Or do we also
[35:37] have aspirations like the US, of having bases in foreign countries being able to
[35:40] sail all across the world and stuff like that. No great question. And
[35:45] you know the reason why this is a good question, Dave, is because
[35:50] the question has many different answers and it has been a question that continues to
[35:53] be asked for, you know, decades together. The short answer to your
[35:59] question is app salutely, yes, India does have a blue water uh,
[36:02] you know, uh, desires and aspirations. So I'm pretty short just for
[36:07] the benefit of our listeners and viewers, because I understand the term blue water.
[36:10] Can you also just explain I'll explain it. Yeah. So a blue
[36:13] water navy is a navy that's capable of deploying its force levels uh far away
[36:20] from its home bases, preferably in a separate ocean altogether, like for example.
[36:27] Uh, what would make the Indian Navy a blue water navy is if
[36:31] it is capable of deploying its battle groups, which are its aircraft carrier battlegroups
[36:37] or its submarine battle groups. Uh, you know, in oceans like the
[36:39] Pacific Ocean or the Atlantic Ocean. You know, not for not for slap
[36:44] dash visits, but for extended periods of time where they are capable of sustaining
[36:49] themselves very far away from shore, like the US Navy's aircraft carriers for extended
[36:53] periods. And when I say extended periods, I mean like for for for
[36:57] months and possibly years together. They are practically like an Indian outpost in another
[37:02] ocean, reminding that part of the world that India has the capability to project
[37:07] force this far away from home. So you say blue water because you know,
[37:13] all water is blue, but in the ocean at least, but you
[37:15] know, the deep international waters far away from home, you know, being
[37:20] able to do that kind of thing and not as a kind of you know,
[37:24] momentary kind of visit or a sail through. That's what a blue water
[37:28] navy is and India, India has a kind of limited blue water capability already.
[37:34] You know, we've we send our aircraft carrier out for many months together.
[37:38] We haven't yet sent them into you know, into waters outside of the
[37:44] Indian Ocean, at least we don't know if they have been unlikely because it's
[37:47] difficult for an India for an aircraft carrier to go anywhere secretly. But they've
[37:52] been everywhere in the Indian Ocean for months together, and that is a sort
[37:55] of limited blue water capability. But apart from that, you know, combattingents
[38:00] of Indian ships have been to the South China Sea. You know, they've
[38:02] been to the Indo Pacific, they've gone through the Malacca Strait, they've been
[38:06] into the Atlantic, and you know, not for extended periods of time.
[38:09] And the reason for that is India doesn't need that right now, It doesn't
[38:13] need to project that kind of force. The force that India needs to project
[38:16] is almost singularly focused on China right now. The force we need to project,
[38:22] let me split it into two ways on our west coast in the Arabian
[38:27] Sea and the Persian Gulf. The kind of force we need to project is
[38:30] not against nations but against you know, asymmetric actors like the Huthis or you
[38:36] know, the Somalian pirates or you know that kind of thing. So the
[38:39] force we need to project there is a much more kind of localized kind of
[38:44] force. But it's an international responsibility because those are your sea lanes of trade
[38:47] and communication. So it's an international responsibility and India is right there, so
[38:52] we don't need to project force far away from shore. But when it comes
[38:54] to China, which has been probing the Indian Ocean, trying to establish it's
[38:59] blue water capability by sending its submarines into the Indian Ocean. In a previous
[39:04] episode, we talked about how their so called research vessels are basically mapping the
[39:07] Indian Ocean so their submarines and their aircraft carriers can come into the Indian Ocean,
[39:12] which they haven't so far. You know, then you start to understand
[39:15] why India's bluewater capabilities have to be focused on the eastern side. We don't
[39:21] need to focus it on the western side because in the west, we've got
[39:23] Africa, we've got Europe, you've got the Middle East, et cetera,
[39:28] where your linkages are set. You know, we've got relationships with all these
[39:31] countries, countries like Oman and the UAE, even Iran and so and so.
[39:37] Those are not you know, immediate logistical issues. But but with China
[39:42] in the east trying to penetrate the Indian Ocean, constantly encircle India, you
[39:47] know, turn Maldives around, uh, you know, create a situation in
[39:52] Sri Lanka where they're building ports, et cetera right at India's doorstep. Now
[39:55] you've got the reason why the Indian Navy no longer play. Is it defensive,
[40:00] you know, by doing things only in the Indian Ocean is no,
[40:02] you guys want to come here, We're going to come to the South China
[40:06] Sea, where you are most vulnerable. We will sell our remost weapons to
[40:09] the Philippines and to Vietnam, you know, to put you on notice.
[40:14] So those are those are the games that India actually plays. But you know,
[40:17] just to end this particular thought, much is said about China and how
[40:22] big its navy is and how many ships it has, and how it's bigger
[40:25] submarine force levels than the US. First of all, let's not even compare
[40:30] the quality of Chinese submarines with US submarines. US submarines function away from their
[40:36] home bases all through the year. Chinese submarines, we don't know what they
[40:39] do, even though they have sailed into the Indian Ocean. So I'm not
[40:43] saying underestimate them. I'm not saying I'm not trying to ridicule Chinese forces.
[40:46] Nobody would ever do that. You have to respect what the Chinese have managed
[40:50] to do with their you know, sort of aggressive intent and focus. As
[40:53] far as the military is concerned, they've got two aircraft carriers which have not
[40:58] gone anywhere outside Chinese water. So so we have to inject a certain degree
[41:02] of realism also and not get overwhelmed by Chinese force. Their ships have you
[41:09] know, hardly left those waters. They hardly have a you know, a
[41:15] blue water capability to speak of. If you ask me, the Indian navy
[41:17] has a you know, may have a much smaller navy. We have a
[41:22] much smaller navy, but we have a much bigger blue water capability. We're
[41:25] not building submarines like biscuits, but our submarines are able to travel pretty far.
[41:30] We may not be able to churn out aircraft carriers like they do,
[41:35] but our aircraft carriers have gone way further from the Indian mainland than the Shenyang
[41:39] and whatever else they're building have done from Chinese basis. So you know,
[41:45] a reality check is needed. You know, having having a huge, vast
[41:50] armader of ships doesn't mean you have the capability to sustain them far away from
[41:53] shore. So so China is not a blue water navy just yet. It
[41:57] desperately wants to be that because it knows that without having a blue water capability,
[42:01] it stands no chance of pushing back against the United States. The United
[42:06] States as it completely encircled, you know, whether it is in the Indian
[42:09] Ocean, whether it is in the Western Pacific. China is completely surrounded by
[42:14] the US Navy, and the US Navy builds nuclear powered aircraft carriers, nuclear
[42:17] powered submarines like you know, like pizza. Okay, So there's no comparison.
[42:23] So I just wanted to say that as far as blue water capabilities are
[42:28] concerned, India has a much smaller, less aggressive path, but it's much
[42:31] more focused now and with these responsibilities under the quad. Yes, you know,
[42:36] with the United States, we're no longer functioning just for ourselves. We've
[42:39] plugged into a kind of alliance, even though they don't like calling themselves or
[42:44] military alliance. It's very much a security handshake between these four powers and it
[42:49] has responsibilities as far as blue water navy capabilities is concerned. Yeah, very
[42:52] interesting answer, because I was wondering about this when I was doing the research
[42:55] all throughout that you know, we'll talk about Lutch with deep and then we
[42:59] can go to this whole respecta blue water and the aspirations of the Indian Navy.
[43:04] A slightly academic and tangential question, how does the country and how do
[43:07] we go about developing this doctrine of what does your navy want to do?
[43:12] Because the way I see it, governments come and go, even if you
[43:15] know you have the same party or the same person being in the hot seat
[43:20] for a large number of years where it's five or ten or fifteen, et
[43:23] cetera. But how do you evolve a doctrine for a navy Because I see,
[43:30] the way I see it, this is going to be lasting. Right,
[43:31] So if you have decided that you know, pachas Salama, I want
[43:35] to be able to send my ship, let's say in the Pacific Ocean,
[43:37] you start working at it from right now that you reach there in fifty years,
[43:42] then every government that comes during that for those fifty years have to work
[43:45] towards that incrementally. So how does it happen? Like who is it isn't
[43:49] just the navy officers you know, you know, and during their annual conference
[43:52] for example, but the ones that are happening right this week as we speak,
[43:54] where they discuss the academic topics and then they prepared the present a proposal
[43:59] to the government is signed off or is it just like you know, you
[44:01] react to things right right now, like you mentioned very correctly, So we
[44:05] are completely focused on containing China and what it's kind of trying to do in
[44:07] the Indian Ocean and in the in and we been called so is it reactive?
[44:13] What does India have this long term dream idea for how its navy should
[44:16] be in the next thirty to forty five You know, the brutal answer to
[44:19] that is that, you know, Nehru had talked about sea blindness. He
[44:22] talked about something called sea blindness, which is something that India suffered from for
[44:27] a very long time, which is that we were so overwhelmingly focused on our
[44:31] army and our air force and protecting our land borders. You know, a
[44:36] country that has a seven six and fifty kilometers coastline, you know, one
[44:39] of the longest coastlines of any country in the world. You know, we've
[44:43] practically ignored it, which is why we live in a preposterous situation where your
[44:47] navy, which should, in an ideal world, given our geography, be
[44:52] the largest of your forces, is actually the smallest of the three armed forces.
[44:55] So as far as as far as security are concerned, we've you know,
[45:00] we're saddled with a kind of legacy lopsidedness already. I'm not saying that
[45:06] that's an excuse for anything. Things have been corrected, many things are moving,
[45:10] you know, in the right direction. But you know, but we're
[45:13] pushing back against trying to shed that legacy of not having focused enough on you
[45:20] know, on the Navy, and we talked about it in the twenty sixty
[45:22] eleven episode as well. Now, as far as long term doctrine is concerned,
[45:25] yes, you know, I have to be frank about this. The
[45:28] Indian Armed Forces are not you know, incremental and ad hoc like that.
[45:31] They've got very clear and the Navy especially has a very clearly focused, you
[45:37] know, a long term perspective plan. And these perspective plans are updated,
[45:42] fine tuned, course corrected, et cetera, depending on the politics of the
[45:45] day, depending on your security outlook, your scenario, you know, what
[45:50] your new threats could be. And things have changed vastly in the last few
[45:52] months after the Israel War, et cetera. So so those things, you
[45:57] know, have a fair amount of content anuity depending you know, irrespective of
[46:02] which government is in power. So that's one good thing. It's not it's
[46:06] not dependent on that. But UH, one has to understand that, you
[46:10] know, whether it is your Look East policy, whether it's your Far East
[46:14] policy, whether it is uh, you know, the neighborhood policy of India.
[46:19] Uh, there has to be consistency, consistency and focus. Now you
[46:22] to the example of wanting to send your aircraft carrier into the Pacific. The
[46:27] question is can India do it? We can? But do we need to
[46:30] do it? Why do we need to do it? Do we do we
[46:32] do we want that kind of bluewater capability just to flex strength? Or do
[46:37] we you know, do we be realistic about our resources, are our you
[46:44] know, man and woman power and focus our strengths uh, you know,
[46:47] in a in a in a kind of laser focused way on what our real
[46:52] intentions, objectives and threats are. In this particular case, as far as
[46:57] conventional national naval threat are concerned, we don't really have any more adversaries other
[47:04] than China and to a smaller extent Pakistan. For instance. China is about
[47:08] to supply Pakistan with eight conventional submarines with air independent propulsion. So these are
[47:14] kind of you know, quasi nuclear submarines in terms of what they can do
[47:17] underwater. They can stay underwater for a long time. That's going to be
[47:20] a challenge for us in the Arabi and c That's going to add a whole
[47:22] new dynamic in terms of what our anti submarine capability is concerned. But India's
[47:28] objective as a naval force, you know, at least as far as my
[47:31] understanding of the long term perspective plan is, is not about projecting power the
[47:37] way the United States projects it. You know, we have to understand that
[47:40] India is not the kind of is not a cowboy nation. It doesn't see
[47:46] itself as a global police. It doesn't see itself as a country that needs
[47:52] to send a carrier battlegroup into the Atlantic because it's cool to do so,
[47:57] because it wants to flex some muscle or PowerP or whatever. Your shut deeper
[48:00] the Shankanai. It's not that kind of country. That culture isn't there.
[48:05] We're very defensive as far as Akhan and in this case that's a good thing.
[48:08] The reason why those blue water expeditionary missions take place is because India has
[48:14] realized that being defensive can't be your only mix. It can't be your only
[48:17] combat matrix. You have to be able to show your adversary in their backyard
[48:23] that hey, I can come here too, so you know, have second
[48:27] thoughts about your next move. We can't just be guarding our territory. On
[48:31] our territory. It has to also be the ability to go to take the
[48:35] fight to your adversaries area. I'm simplifying it, but you know what I'm
[48:37] saying. So as far as the Navy and the Indian Ocean is concerned,
[48:40] our doctrine is simple. It is about maintaining absolute and unquestionable dominance. That
[48:46] the Indian Navy is the prime actor in the Indian Ocean. Nobody else,
[48:52] not China, not any of the Southeast Asian countries. It certainly can't be
[48:57] Africa because they're all dependent by either India and China or any other country.
[49:00] It is India alone and the Indian Navy alone that is the prime actor.
[49:06] You know, the prime police force. You know, the prime military response
[49:09] force. If something goes wrong, the primary response force. As far as
[49:15] humanitarian relief is concerned, like for example, if the a tsunami or a
[49:19] cyclone or something happens, that is your doctrine right now. The doctrine is
[49:22] that, hello, this is the Indian Ocean. We're not going to share
[49:25] it to anyone. We are the datas of the Indian Ocean region. You
[49:30] can please pass through international waters, but we're going to watch you. You
[49:34] know, you can have a nice trip through the Indian Ocean. But nobody
[49:37] else controls this territory except us. That is the Indian Navy's doctrine right now.
[49:40] And the reason why China wants to get into the Indian Ocean is because
[49:44] certain realities cannot be changed. China's energy security, China's trade has to pass
[49:50] through the Indian Ocean. They have no choice. They have no choice.
[49:52] They would love to be able to bypass the Indian Ocean to get their trade
[49:55] and the energy. They cannot do that, so they're dependent on India's whims
[50:00] and fancies. We are a responsible country. We're not going to disrupt trade
[50:04] and energy security of any country. But China doesn't want to leave that to
[50:07] India. You know what if things go south between India and China in a
[50:12] much worse way and India has the leverage of controlling what is traveling towards China
[50:16] than what, so China doesn't want that. That's the reason why they want
[50:21] to put their footprint in the Indian Ocean to prevent India from having that kind
[50:24] of leverage, and the Indian Navy is fully prepared to prevent that. I
[50:28] think there's a very good example the illustration that you give, because that actually
[50:31] kind of happened. I forgot which was it during Kargil or was it during
[50:35] the seventy one war, but I think it was doing Kargil the Indian Navy
[50:38] do. The areas are a bit different, but the Indian Navy was able
[50:42] to lay sort of a very successful blockade of Pakistan, preventing energy patrol,
[50:46] et cetera from reaching the country, and I think there was a brief moment
[50:51] when Pakistan wasn't the words of running out of few seventy one seven, yeah,
[50:53] seventy one yeah. So that's a very good example of what navies can
[50:57] do, apart from just in firing missiles and the aspect of what you said
[51:04] about the Indian Navy wanting to ensure that we are the others of the Indian
[51:07] Ocean. I think so far we've been able to kind of do that right
[51:09] without being blinded just because I'm an Indian. I think we have been able
[51:13] to do that and China is trying to upset it. I don't know,
[51:15] let's see how that goes. And you know, when you were but you
[51:17] were saying all of that, that thought just came into my mind that the
[51:22] next couple of decades I've gonna be very interesting to watch in the Indian Ocean.
[51:24] Like you know, like you have the standard a long land dark.
[51:28] It might not be as physical as that, but there might be flashpoints between
[51:31] India and China in around the Indian Ocean. That'll be something that will be
[51:36] interesting to watch. As we bring this episode to a close. The gossip
[51:38] that I wanted your thoughts on, I think we made this sort of a
[51:42] habit now like we bring the POI with gossip. So I forgot this was
[51:46] I think around fifteen years ago. I think fifteen audiears ago, ten fifteen
[51:51] years I was in Navinagar for people who are not from m by Navy.
[51:55] Naggar is located in one of not one in the most prime location of Mumbai.
[52:02] Yeah, and even within Kolaba. It is on the southern tip of
[52:06] Mumbai. So you will have yeah, yeah, plans and you have sea
[52:08] on three sides and you have land behind you. Navy has that property.
[52:14] Talking about clashes between civilians and defense established and that's for for for someone in
[52:19] the city like me. I was in Enemy. I was like, my
[52:22] god, you guys have this wonderful the best place to live. Right anyway,
[52:27] So I was in Navi Nagar visiting somebody. I won't say which force
[52:30] because both Coast and the Navy operate from there. I was visiting somebody over
[52:34] there, uh, And I got this gossip that this was the time when
[52:37] Karwar was being developed as a naval base Kadam Bay, like you said,
[52:42] right, uh. And what I was told was that there was a proposal,
[52:45] a very serious proposal, for the Western Naval Command headquarters to be moved
[52:52] from Mumbai to Karbar. But every single naval officer who was staying in Navy
[52:58] in Kolaba and in Mumbai was completely opposed to the idea. One logisticly speaking,
[53:02] the person who told me explained it that, yes, you know,
[53:05] so there's nothing in Kardvar. There are there are no markets, there are
[53:08] no schools, there are no hospitals, there's nothing, there is no life
[53:12] as such. Obviously that would develop because a basis coming up, so the
[53:15] infrastructure would come up. But second, obviously want to stay in Mumbai.
[53:19] Can you come from this really happened? No? No, of course,
[53:21] one hundred percent true. It's one hundred percent true. And I've reported on
[53:24] this, uh you know in the Indian Express and in India today that there
[53:29] was there were active considerations, in fact intentions that the Western Naval Command headquarters
[53:35] would shift to Caravan because there is no space in MOVEMB by reason for that
[53:37] A is no space in Mumbai. B that you know, apart from A
[53:43] from a limited force. Uh. You know, the naval harbor area congestion
[53:47] in Mumbai was just too big because of the increased and expanded trade and merchant
[53:52] shipping traffic. It was just impossible for you know, the Navy to have
[53:57] more capacity. And the Navy needed like three times its capacity that it had
[54:01] in Mumbai. And given that iron s it was called Project Sea Bird what
[54:07] the Karva base was called at that time. Now I is Kadamba was expanding
[54:12] in a really big way. I think the Navy initially didn't realize that Karwar
[54:15] was going to be so uh uh you know, such an excellently executed project.
[54:22] You know, deep water harbors, the ability to deploy submarines there.
[54:25] Your aircraft carriers are both based over there, both the vikrant and therefore it
[54:31] was, you know it it kind of unfolded as an excellent base, and
[54:36] you know, and once all those issues of land and you know, territory
[54:39] and you know, the problems with the civilian administration was sorted out, it
[54:44] was it has become one of uh the biggest naval bases in Asia. I
[54:49] think at last count, Kadamba is the biggest naval base in Asia, uh,
[54:52] far bigger than a Western naval command uh and potentially bigger. It's going
[54:57] to actually become bigger because it's going to have to support many more warships.
[55:00] It's going to be your key location. And it also ticks many boxes because
[55:07] you know, having a big amount of naval infrastructure in a big city like
[55:10] Mumbai is not optimal because you know, lots of weaponry, lots of stuff
[55:15] very close to Mumbai. You saw the Sindhurakshak explosion in the naval harbor in
[55:20] Mumbai, you know, big economic center. So all of these compulsions were
[55:23] definitely there there. So I confirm it one hundred percent that the intention certainly
[55:29] existed, if not still exists. We don't know if it could still happen
[55:31] or not. Probably not because maybe that's you know, water under the bridge.
[55:36] But Ayras Kadamba is a huge, huge base and it will basically be
[55:42] the combat arm of the Western Naval Command. You know, maybe who knows
[55:46] you know that. I remember even reading reports that if the Western Naval Command
[55:51] can't you know, shift to Karvar, maybe Karvar will be its own command
[55:54] called the Southwestern Naval Command. That was the very short lived report. It
[55:59] didn't really happen. I actually have a Carbar connection. My dad's dad's mother
[56:02] is from Carbar. That's a native place, and I've been there several times.
[56:06] I've seen in Kadamba from it being just land to it being this huge,
[56:12] sprawling facility with a ship lift facility and all manner of amazing things.
[56:15] So it's it's truly a spectacular naval base. And I wouldn't be surprised if
[56:20] at some point in the future a shift like this happens. But I can
[56:22] tell you that when you were there and you heard this gossip, it was
[56:24] fact. It was really really on the table, right right. I think
[56:29] we ended right there. Thankshift once again and great insights into not just what's
[56:34] about to have inductually and how it is of great strategic and military value to
[56:37] India and the Indian Navy, but also about the Navy in general and its
[56:40] larger aspirations, the whole thing about new waterforts, etc. Great chat,
[56:45] fun chat as always, Thanks you know, as always to our producer and
[56:50] a PREADDITIONI that's it for this week's defense. Does for more at Union next
[56:52] week. He'll then, stay safe and don't cross any boundaries with that passport.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
