# Indian Army's tanks: Can ambitious FRCV project redeem failings of Arjun MBT programme? | In Our Defence, S02, Ep 38

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 5 Sep 2024, 53 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/61273365/05_sep_24_iod_5_sept_ep_38_128.mp3

In this episode, host Dev Goswami and defence expert Shiv Aroor explore the future of India's armoured capabilities in light of the government's recent approval of ₹1,44,716 crore for capital acquisitions. This includes modernising the Indian Army's tank fleet through the Future Ready Combat Vehicle (FRCV) program. The new tank FRCV aims to replace around 2,500 four-decade-old Soviet-origin T-72 tanks first acquired in 1982. Why is the FRCV project necessary, and how does it address the shortcomings of previous tank modernisation efforts, such as the Arjun project? What is the current status of India's tank fleet, and how do the ageing T-72s and T-90s fit into the Army's broader defence strategy? The Arjun tank project—marked by controversy and unmet expectations between the Army and DRDO—is analysed, with the hosts reflecting on its failures. The two explain this by giving an overview of tank evolution, from their roles in World Wars I and II to their enduring importance in modern warfare, particularly for India's territorial defence. The FRCV is seen as a corrective step, aiming to build a modern, modular, and agile tank capable of meeting diverse battlefield needs while fully indigenised. But, some critics believe that the FCRV program seems like an Arjun 2.0. Is it? Also, don’t miss the discussion on Sunil Shetty’s iconic tank-lifting scene in the movie Border—could it really happen? Listen in! Produced by Anna Priydarshini Sound mix by Sachin Dwivedi

## Transcript

[0:00] Speaker 1: This is India Today podcasts.
[0:04] Speaker 2: The Arjun Tank coming to your pain Point is a
[0:07] Speaker 2: tank project. It began de facto in the nineteen seventies
[0:11] Speaker 2: after the seventy one war. Nothing less than four thousand
[0:14] Speaker 2: to five thousand tanks would amortize the costs that was
[0:17] Speaker 2: put into it. And how many are going to be inducted?
[0:20] Speaker 2: Less than two hundred and fifty four thousand is needed.
[0:22] Speaker 3: Two hundred and fifty are going to be inducted.
[0:24] Speaker 2: Which means that no matter which way you look at it,
[0:27] Speaker 2: no matter who you blame for it, whether you blame
[0:29] Speaker 2: the army or the DRDO, the project has been a
[0:32] Speaker 2: complete failure. In terms of the numbers supply of the
[0:36] Speaker 2: improved Arjun, I think they are about one hundred and
[0:38] Speaker 2: eighteen which we are on order. And the reason for
[0:40] Speaker 2: that is because the German engine supplied by a company
[0:43] Speaker 2: called MTU. Those engines are not made anymore or there
[0:47] Speaker 2: are problems with their manufacturing in Germany and therefore there
[0:50] Speaker 2: is a supply chain issue. Does this sound familiar to
[0:53] Speaker 2: our viewers and listeners, because if you are also reminded
[0:56] Speaker 2: about the stages, then you are right. The FRCV record
[1:00] Speaker 2: vironment looks like Urgent two point zero. The FRCV is
[1:03] Speaker 2: an ominous echo of how the Argent went, which is
[1:06] Speaker 2: that you had such an outsized list of requirements. It
[1:10] Speaker 2: basically betrayed that you don't really know what you want
[1:12] Speaker 2: to do with this time. The FRCV is a great
[1:15] Speaker 2: opportunity to kill many ghosts in one blow, which is
[1:19] Speaker 2: a I love the fact that fr stands for future
[1:22] Speaker 2: ready because it means that the system has recognized key.
[1:25] Speaker 1: We have never been future ready.
[1:27] Speaker 3: That's why we're in this mess.
[1:30] Speaker 4: Hello and welcome to Another Defense, a weekly podcast on
[1:33] Speaker 4: all things well defense, where I They've Goswami, your host,
[1:38] Speaker 4: along with senior journalist Shivarur, break down the world of
[1:41] Speaker 4: conflicts that range from the subtle to the brutal. We
[1:44] Speaker 4: bring you nuances and perspectives that will inform and at
[1:48] Speaker 4: times provoke.
[1:52] Speaker 5: This is in our Defense.
[2:00] Speaker 4: Hello and welcome to the eighth episode of Another Defense
[2:02] Speaker 4: High Shift. How are your friends in the Inn Army?
[2:05] Speaker 2: Well, I've gotten to know hundreds of new people in
[2:10] Speaker 2: the Army, both serving and retired, in the last one week.
[2:14] Speaker 2: But I have to say the last episode was was
[2:18] Speaker 2: I think it hit a spot that few people have
[2:21] Speaker 2: hit before. Yeah, and the response to it is very,
[2:25] Speaker 2: very telling. So we should tell all of our listeners
[2:27] Speaker 2: and viewers right away in case, you know, you haven't
[2:30] Speaker 2: heard our previous episode. That's a good place to start
[2:32] Speaker 2: within our defense. Gives you a sense of what this
[2:35] Speaker 2: podcast is really all about. We go where people usually
[2:38] Speaker 2: are hesitant to go. And I think that one clip
[2:41] Speaker 2: of me and you that's been doing the rounds of
[2:43] Speaker 2: WhatsApp groups is yeah, that's that's that's lit a few
[2:47] Speaker 2: files for sure.
[2:48] Speaker 3: But I did want to clarify.
[2:50] Speaker 2: One thing they right off the bat, because you know
[2:52] Speaker 2: a lot of people have been watching the podcast based
[2:54] Speaker 2: on just that one clip or judging the podcast based
[2:57] Speaker 2: on that one clip, and where our stand is, and
[2:58] Speaker 2: I wanted to say, please watch the whole podcast. Our
[3:01] Speaker 2: entire playlist is on YouTube. You know, watch that episode,
[3:04] Speaker 2: watch all the other episodes, because these are, uh, you know,
[3:08] Speaker 2: the videos are a minute and a half long, but
[3:10] Speaker 2: the actual podcast are like nearly an hour. Yes, so
[3:13] Speaker 2: you must watch the whole thing.
[3:14] Speaker 3: I promise you.
[3:14] Speaker 2: There's a great deal more new and so judge us
[3:17] Speaker 2: according to that. But yeah, I welcome all the questions
[3:20] Speaker 2: and the brick bats and the book is that we've
[3:22] Speaker 2: been getting. It's very very it's very affirming if we're
[3:25] Speaker 2: doing the right thing.
[3:26] Speaker 5: Yeah, definitely.
[3:27] Speaker 4: I mean the clips that they put out on social media,
[3:29] Speaker 4: those are just like the top the top notes of
[3:31] Speaker 4: the of the show, but they don't really and quite
[3:34] Speaker 4: often actually didn't even capture the whole breadth of what
[3:36] Speaker 4: we end up discussing. You know, quite often I have
[3:38] Speaker 4: to talk to my credit and talk about you know,
[3:40] Speaker 4: but no one even knows that we talk about this
[3:42] Speaker 4: one particular part because that's nowhere in the clip altogether. Like,
[3:45] Speaker 4: for example, you know, the last episodes about rifles, and
[3:48] Speaker 4: we also spent a great deal talking about how the
[3:50] Speaker 4: rifles that we have right nosic So is that I
[3:52] Speaker 4: quite quite quite good?
[3:53] Speaker 5: Yeah, but that's not something I was captured in there
[3:55] Speaker 5: and the clip.
[3:56] Speaker 4: But anyway, we're glad that we've got so many responses,
[3:59] Speaker 4: And what was really heartening to see was that a
[4:01] Speaker 4: lot of people did agree with with with what you
[4:04] Speaker 4: were saying.
[4:04] Speaker 1: Oh yeah, thank you start raising this.
[4:06] Speaker 4: Topic that I think we really should have talked about,
[4:09] Speaker 4: and we were promising this episode for a long time.
[4:11] Speaker 4: In a defense, I'm glad We've got to do it.
[4:13] Speaker 4: This week, we'll talk about tanks. This is all something
[4:16] Speaker 4: that you know, I've been talking meaning to talk about
[4:17] Speaker 4: for a while, not really for any particular reason. I mean,
[4:20] Speaker 4: there's not much controversy so with this equipment, andlike most
[4:23] Speaker 4: equipment that talk about on this podcast, but just as
[4:26] Speaker 4: sort of a you know, a defense nerd it was
[4:28] Speaker 4: defense geek and someone into the world of defense. I
[4:30] Speaker 4: want to talk about the world of tanks and what
[4:32] Speaker 4: does India have and stuff like that. There's a peg
[4:34] Speaker 4: to it as well, but we'll get to that a
[4:36] Speaker 4: bit later. First, I want to kind of understand from
[4:38] Speaker 4: you the evolution of cavalry because for the lay person,
[4:42] Speaker 4: I mean, you know, a lot of people, a lot
[4:44] Speaker 4: of listeners, a lot of viewers of our Defense are
[4:46] Speaker 4: hardcore defense followers. They know the world of defense, so
[4:49] Speaker 4: for them this question might be a bit redundant. But
[4:51] Speaker 4: for people who don't. For many people, a tank is
[4:54] Speaker 4: just basically sort of a thing that moves on chains,
[4:57] Speaker 4: has a target that can fire. They don't know what
[4:59] Speaker 4: it can fire it It could fire a big bullet,
[5:01] Speaker 4: or it could fire a mortar, but that for them
[5:04] Speaker 4: is a tank. So then The question for me is then,
[5:06] Speaker 4: what's the difference between mechanized infantry and armored core. Both
[5:11] Speaker 4: of them seem to be when you look at it
[5:12] Speaker 4: on the face of it. If you would go to
[5:14] Speaker 4: google these terms and want to look at pictures of
[5:16] Speaker 4: soldiers in their respective respective vehicles of the respective to units,
[5:21] Speaker 4: they would look kind of similar to you. So in
[5:24] Speaker 4: terms of the roles, the kind of ammination that they use,
[5:27] Speaker 4: and how they use on a war field, how are
[5:30] Speaker 4: these two different?
[5:31] Speaker 2: So you know the reason why we're doing this episode
[5:34] Speaker 2: today and the PEG, which we're going to bring in later,
[5:38] Speaker 2: I want to mention it right off the bat because
[5:40] Speaker 2: it's important to also tell our viewers why and listeners
[5:43] Speaker 2: why we're talking about tanks today, and it's the PEG
[5:47] Speaker 2: is actually a huge, huge, PEG, which is that the
[5:50] Speaker 2: Indian Ministry of Defense has just cleared what will be
[5:55] Speaker 2: India's most ambitious and biggest in terms of value tank
[5:59] Speaker 2: program in history. It's called the FRCV, which stands for
[6:03] Speaker 2: Future Ready Combat Vehicle, which is basically a fancy euphemism
[6:07] Speaker 2: for what our next main battle tank is going to be.
[6:10] Speaker 4: UH.
[6:10] Speaker 2: And we will get into the bells and whistles of
[6:12] Speaker 2: what this is going to look like after we talk
[6:15] Speaker 2: about what our current tank fleet looks like, but since
[6:18] Speaker 2: you talked about evolution, and that's a very good place
[6:20] Speaker 2: to start, actually, because because the debates over what exactly
[6:25] Speaker 2: is a tank? Do we even need tanks anymore in
[6:28] Speaker 2: our current modern battlefields?
[6:31] Speaker 3: You know that.
[6:32] Speaker 2: Favorite question which we keep getting, you know, after the
[6:34] Speaker 2: Ukraine Wars, you know, our tanks really the way to go.
[6:39] Speaker 2: So many questions arise out of tanks. And World War
[6:42] Speaker 2: One is where tanks first really sort of came into
[6:46] Speaker 2: their own. It was the first first war. There were
[6:50] Speaker 2: tanks before that, but there were World War One is
[6:52] Speaker 2: where tanks first started being operationally deployed with with actual
[6:59] Speaker 2: land life and mission objectives. World War Two is where
[7:03] Speaker 2: tanks were used in a much much bigger way. And
[7:06] Speaker 2: the rest, as they say, is sort of armored you know,
[7:09] Speaker 2: armored vehicle history. The reason why tanks evolved and became
[7:15] Speaker 2: an integral part of early war battlefields was because the
[7:19] Speaker 2: the forcible peaking over of territory and holding ground, you know,
[7:24] Speaker 2: was the very definition of those wars, whether we were
[7:28] Speaker 2: talking about World War One or World War two invasion
[7:31] Speaker 2: blitz krieg, you know, crossing international borders forcibly holding onto
[7:37] Speaker 2: foreign territory, establishing dominance over somebody else's territory. These were
[7:42] Speaker 2: the sort of hallmarks of those wars. They were land
[7:46] Speaker 2: battles which involved, you know, destroying the integrity and sovereignty
[7:51] Speaker 2: of your neighboring countries. And that's where the whole idea
[7:54] Speaker 2: of a tank was born. A tank is like a
[7:57] Speaker 2: It's almost cartoonish when you think about it. A tank
[7:59] Speaker 2: is like is like a vehicle which is which is
[8:04] Speaker 2: supposedly indestructible from all angles. It's like a vehicle which
[8:09] Speaker 2: you drive into someone else's territory under all manner of
[8:13] Speaker 2: fire with with this huge gun you know, turreted on
[8:18] Speaker 2: top of it, that's able to blast and ram through
[8:21] Speaker 2: all manner of obstacles, go cross country travel at a
[8:25] Speaker 2: reasonable speed, you know, take any form of fire from
[8:29] Speaker 2: the enemy, and still succeed in a getting into that
[8:34] Speaker 2: person's territory and with sufficiently large numbers of tanks, hold
[8:39] Speaker 2: that territory under any hostile action. That's that's what a
[8:42] Speaker 2: tank is. We've seen tank battles really sort of become
[8:48] Speaker 2: legendary during World War Two, after which there were many
[8:51] Speaker 2: lessons learned about, you know, the vulnerabilities of tanks, which
[8:55] Speaker 2: is why the fifties and sixties saw a huge, huge
[9:00] Speaker 2: spike in the better technologies for tanks. They became faster,
[9:05] Speaker 2: they became more agile, the guns became better, the rate
[9:08] Speaker 2: of fire increased, they were capable of traveling cross country
[9:14] Speaker 2: at you know, in a better way, faster speeds, that
[9:17] Speaker 2: kind of thing. Importantly, in the sixties and seventies, during
[9:20] Speaker 2: the World War you saw protection, the actual protection of
[9:25] Speaker 2: tanks become a bigger, bigger thing because anti tank warfare
[9:28] Speaker 2: came into its own, you know, ammunitions started to be
[9:31] Speaker 2: developed that could destroy tank armor. Then there became an
[9:35] Speaker 2: evolution about whether tanks are really the way to go.
[9:38] Speaker 2: You know, aren't tanks vulnerable from the air. You know,
[9:41] Speaker 2: we saw the sixty five and the seventy one war
[9:44] Speaker 2: for India where tanks became hugely deployed, and for India,
[9:49] Speaker 2: tanks were a very, very crucial part of our battle
[9:55] Speaker 2: Arsenal because territories at the very core of India's India's
[10:02] Speaker 2: national security threats, whether it is Pakistan, Visavi p ok
[10:06] Speaker 2: And Kashmir, or China Visavi Ladakh, Arunachal prades, et cetera.
[10:10] Speaker 2: It is literally, uh, you know, on ground threat to
[10:15] Speaker 2: sovereignty and land that is the very core of our
[10:20] Speaker 2: threat from these two countries. And therefore the compulsion to
[10:23] Speaker 2: have weapons and equipment that can that can turn the
[10:28] Speaker 2: tables on our adversaries and hold their territory instead comes
[10:33] Speaker 2: down to equipment like tanks. Obviously tanks can't be the
[10:35] Speaker 2: only thing, but that in a in a way as
[10:39] Speaker 2: far as evolution is concerned. Dave answers a question as
[10:42] Speaker 2: to do we really still need tanks, and I'm sure
[10:45] Speaker 2: you're gonna ask me that question as well. But the
[10:47] Speaker 2: fact is the reason why India has continued to invest
[10:50] Speaker 2: in tanks and has such a large, you know, tank
[10:54] Speaker 2: fleet is because the idea of a theoretical land battle
[11:00] Speaker 2: where India at some point either takes back territory that
[11:05] Speaker 2: was taken from it in pok or in Axitchin or
[11:09] Speaker 2: wherever else, or plays aggressor which it probably won't, and
[11:14] Speaker 2: takes territory of another countries which does not belong to
[11:17] Speaker 2: it means that tanks will play an important role because
[11:20] Speaker 2: you can have a warfare scenario where airpower is all
[11:23] Speaker 2: important drone warfare is all important. You can have a
[11:28] Speaker 2: situation where you're using weapons to suppress the enemy, but
[11:31] Speaker 2: at the end of the day, you need a presence
[11:34] Speaker 2: on the ground to hold what you've won. After you've
[11:38] Speaker 2: softened up the enemy, you still need to do the
[11:40] Speaker 2: dirty work of crossing over into that territory and holding
[11:43] Speaker 2: that And that's where tanks.
[11:45] Speaker 4: Coming, right, So very nice we do begin this episode,
[11:47] Speaker 4: and yeah, you're right, we are talking about this in
[11:50] Speaker 4: the context of the Government of India kind of okaying
[11:53] Speaker 4: the prospect of the Indian Army starting to explore a
[11:57] Speaker 4: lot of you know words I've just said, you know,
[11:58] Speaker 4: but that's how Indianrock Works explore the idea of purchase
[12:03] Speaker 4: or getting two companies to kind of develop prototype of
[12:06] Speaker 4: what will be called what's right down on as FRCV,
[12:09] Speaker 4: the Future Ready Combat Vehicle. We'll get into the idea
[12:13] Speaker 4: of it what it may look like, like you said
[12:14] Speaker 4: a bit later. First let's also look at the picture
[12:17] Speaker 4: of what we have right now, because that will give
[12:20] Speaker 4: us the background about why we need a new tank
[12:22] Speaker 4: program in the first place, because that was the first
[12:25] Speaker 4: question that came to me, you know, and in fact,
[12:26] Speaker 4: you know, before I go ahead. When I was kind
[12:29] Speaker 4: of laying out the points and to talk about on
[12:31] Speaker 4: this episode, I just had a very sort of DJA
[12:34] Speaker 4: moment because almost everything seems seemed similar to something you
[12:37] Speaker 4: discussed before, the Indian Air Forces fighter jet program. You
[12:40] Speaker 4: have an Indian program with Mark one Mark one a
[12:43] Speaker 4: Mark two. You have a backbone of completely Russian origin
[12:48] Speaker 4: equipment both the Air Force and the army in terms
[12:50] Speaker 4: of tanks, and you have this futuristic project in the
[12:54] Speaker 4: case of tanks, the fr CV in the case of
[12:55] Speaker 4: fighter jets.
[12:56] Speaker 5: Amca very very.
[12:59] Speaker 4: Like did like very sort of overlapping, and I was like, Okay,
[13:02] Speaker 4: this episode we might end up going just like the
[13:04] Speaker 4: fighter jet episode because everything is kind of similar. Because
[13:07] Speaker 4: unlike with the fighter jet, the episode and the question
[13:10] Speaker 4: with the fighter jets, we don't hear about the Indian
[13:13] Speaker 4: tank core aging. There is no problem of shortage as
[13:18] Speaker 4: far as we know about it. I mean, there's no
[13:20] Speaker 4: reporting rune about it. There's not much do talk about it.
[13:22] Speaker 4: Tanks aren't being you know, having to be retired because
[13:24] Speaker 4: suddenly they're so old. We don't you know, we need
[13:27] Speaker 4: to retire them. But we don't have new incoming tanks,
[13:29] Speaker 4: et cetera, et cetera. So the question then arises that,
[13:31] Speaker 4: you know, then why do we even need a new program.
[13:34] Speaker 4: So we'll get into that, but first let's talk about
[13:36] Speaker 4: the tanks that we have. I'll start with the origin
[13:38] Speaker 4: because it's quite perplexing to me. Like the theages, I
[13:41] Speaker 4: think the Argin also kind of took started taking shape
[13:44] Speaker 4: in the eighties.
[13:44] Speaker 5: When you wanted to develop its own program.
[13:47] Speaker 4: I forgot the year. It kind of kind of came
[13:49] Speaker 4: to fruition and it was developed. But what confused me
[13:52] Speaker 4: the most was that after having this long ass project
[13:56] Speaker 4: for so many decades, so you only have around one
[13:58] Speaker 4: thirty order tanks in service. There's an order for I
[14:02] Speaker 4: think around one forty one to fifty more. You have
[14:06] Speaker 4: I think two variants and one more is in the works.
[14:08] Speaker 4: Like they just mark one, mark one, day, mark two.
[14:11] Speaker 5: What's going on this program? I don't understand.
[14:13] Speaker 2: So once again they've which is very typical of you,
[14:17] Speaker 2: you stick your finger right into the pain point of
[14:20] Speaker 2: this issue.
[14:21] Speaker 3: So let me.
[14:22] Speaker 2: Start where it really hurts. So the Arjun project for
[14:26] Speaker 2: and you're right, you know, our viewers and listeners do
[14:29] Speaker 2: know everything, but we also have to account for those
[14:31] Speaker 2: who may not know entirely what we're talking about, So
[14:34] Speaker 2: very briefly, let me recap. Here's what the Indian Army's
[14:37] Speaker 2: tank fleet currently looks like. The absolute backbone in terms
[14:42] Speaker 2: of capability. In terms of numbers, the most modern tank
[14:46] Speaker 2: that we have is the ten ninety s the Beishmar
[14:49] Speaker 2: tank in most in most army pictures of tanks, you know,
[14:53] Speaker 2: if you type Indian Army and tank in Google Images,
[14:56] Speaker 2: you're most likely to get a picture of a teen ninety.
[14:58] Speaker 2: Ten ninety is a venerable Soviet era tank that has
[15:02] Speaker 2: been improved vastly over the over the decades. It is
[15:06] Speaker 2: built at the Heavy Vehicles Factory in Chenne outside Chene,
[15:09] Speaker 2: part of the Ordnance Factory Board, and is one of
[15:13] Speaker 2: two tanks that India has built using Russian technology. So
[15:17] Speaker 2: the ten ninety I think I think we have about
[15:20] Speaker 2: I'm not sure the exact numbers, but I think we
[15:22] Speaker 2: have a little less than a thousand of those tanks,
[15:24] Speaker 2: a little more than a thousand of those tanks. The other,
[15:27] Speaker 2: the tank that India has in the largest numbers is
[15:29] Speaker 2: called the T seventy two, which is basically the older
[15:34] Speaker 2: cousin of the ten ninety. The T seventy two kind
[15:36] Speaker 2: of evolved in large ways into the T ninety. The
[15:38] Speaker 2: T seventy two we have. We have upwards of two
[15:41] Speaker 2: thousand of these tanks. They are the tanks that we
[15:43] Speaker 2: have in the largest numbers, and these are the tanks
[15:46] Speaker 2: that will be are intended to be replaced by the
[15:50] Speaker 2: FRCV or the future Ready Combat VEG. So, so the
[15:53] Speaker 2: picture so far is that we've got the ten ninety
[15:56] Speaker 2: reasonably modern, you know, many of them being upgraded. There
[16:00] Speaker 2: your main stay there, the spearhead of your tank force.
[16:03] Speaker 2: You've got the T seventy two, which is there in
[16:04] Speaker 2: large numbers, slightly less capable, even though we have a
[16:08] Speaker 2: combat improved version of the T seventy two called the
[16:10] Speaker 2: T seventy two, a JA improved using indigenous technology. So
[16:17] Speaker 2: these are between the T ninety and the T seventy two.
[16:20] Speaker 2: You've got about three thousand plus or close to four
[16:23] Speaker 2: thousand tanks in the country at this point of time.
[16:26] Speaker 2: And remember the T ninet is still being built in India. Okay,
[16:29] Speaker 2: it's still being built, and India has the option of
[16:32] Speaker 2: buying more and assembling more if it should it need
[16:35] Speaker 2: to do so, but the truth of the matter is
[16:38] Speaker 2: the T ninety and the T seventy two are tanks
[16:40] Speaker 2: of the past. Are They are by no means modern
[16:44] Speaker 2: tanks in the way that we will We will talk
[16:46] Speaker 2: about in a moment. The Arjun tank, coming to your
[16:50] Speaker 2: pain point, very painful point, is a tank project that began.
[16:56] Speaker 1: It began d fact.
[16:57] Speaker 2: Two in the nineteen seventies after the seventy one war.
[17:01] Speaker 2: The Army had basically gone to Indira Gandhi and said, look,
[17:04] Speaker 2: the seventy one operations were extremely successful. You know, this
[17:10] Speaker 2: was the Indian Army performing at its absolute best, tactically, strategically,
[17:15] Speaker 2: in terms of deployments, in terms of equipment under Manik
[17:19] Speaker 2: Shaw and others. It was a textbook landforce operation using
[17:26] Speaker 2: some elements of air power and other things. The only problem,
[17:30] Speaker 2: and you know, most people forget that there were lessons
[17:33] Speaker 2: to learn from the nineteen seventy one war, and one
[17:36] Speaker 2: of those lessons was that the Indian Army sorely lacked,
[17:41] Speaker 2: you know, a large enough and reliable tank fleet, an
[17:45] Speaker 2: armored force, and Indira Gandhi was prevailed upon by the
[17:49] Speaker 2: leaders of that time that you know, we've just won
[17:52] Speaker 2: a great war, a big war in nineteen seventy one.
[17:55] Speaker 2: Now is the time to invest in our own technology. Remember,
[17:58] Speaker 2: up until this point, India had used tanks of British origin,
[18:02] Speaker 2: centurions and you know all the other tanks that we'd
[18:06] Speaker 2: gotten from the Brits. But after nineteen seventy one, there
[18:10] Speaker 2: was this huge wave of nationalism, justifiably and rightfully, so
[18:14] Speaker 2: India was standing proud after having demolished and humiliated Pakistan,
[18:19] Speaker 2: liberated Bangladesh, and India was really bristling to you know,
[18:24] Speaker 2: get its hands dirty and do its own thing. You know,
[18:28] Speaker 2: the US had turned out to be an unreliable country,
[18:30] Speaker 2: having sent its you know, aircraft carrier into the Bay
[18:33] Speaker 2: of Bengal and things like that. So India was in
[18:36] Speaker 2: many ways sort of standing alone in the world at
[18:38] Speaker 2: that point of time, having proven that don't mess with India, okay,
[18:42] Speaker 2: and so it wanted to build its own tank. So
[18:44] Speaker 2: the DRDO, the DRDO obviously proposed.
[18:49] Speaker 3: That they would build their own tank.
[18:50] Speaker 2: And at that point there was no reason to believe
[18:52] Speaker 2: that they couldn't because you know, young, young team, you know,
[18:57] Speaker 2: lots of energy, great ideas. The Indian Army was very excited,
[19:01] Speaker 2: said yes, absolutely, let's build it, and they called it
[19:03] Speaker 2: the Urgent. Fabulous name. In my opinion, it's sad to
[19:07] Speaker 2: see where the program has gone. So it was called
[19:09] Speaker 2: the Main Battle Tank Urgent Project, Urgent Project the problem.
[19:14] Speaker 2: The problem started fairly early as far as the Urgen
[19:18] Speaker 2: was concerned, in terms of in terms of the many
[19:22] Speaker 2: divergences between the army and the developers.
[19:25] Speaker 3: The developers in this.
[19:26] Speaker 2: Case the called the Combat Vehicles Research and Development Establishment CVRD.
[19:31] Speaker 2: We love acronyms in India. We're obsessed with meaningless acronyms.
[19:35] Speaker 2: But the cvr D is an important acronym because it's you.
[19:38] Speaker 2: It's the tank developing laboratory under the Defense and Research
[19:41] Speaker 2: Development Organization. So the CVRD began building and developing the Argent,
[19:47] Speaker 2: not building developing the Urgent.
[19:49] Speaker 3: UH and UH.
[19:51] Speaker 2: Right off the bat there there appeared to be a
[19:55] Speaker 2: lack of clarity in terms of what exactly the tank
[19:59] Speaker 2: would be used four you know, was it going to
[20:01] Speaker 2: be a heavy tank, you know, sixty plus dons? Did
[20:04] Speaker 2: it need to be a more agile tank, you know,
[20:06] Speaker 2: for use in all kinds of terrain?
[20:09] Speaker 3: What kind of you know things?
[20:10] Speaker 1: Would this tank actually spot.
[20:12] Speaker 2: You know, not to go into too much detail, because
[20:15] Speaker 2: because there is a vast amount of information about the
[20:17] Speaker 2: many pitfalls and problems that dogged the Arguent tank. But
[20:22] Speaker 2: if you cut forward, Mike, you know, like many of
[20:25] Speaker 2: the many of the painful, poignant things about Indian defense,
[20:29] Speaker 2: My career sort of began with the testing of the
[20:33] Speaker 2: Arjun tank in two thousand and three two thousand and four,
[20:37] Speaker 2: and at the point that I started reporting defense in
[20:40] Speaker 2: two thousand and four, the Indian Army was conducting what
[20:43] Speaker 2: were called comparative trials between the argent tank and the
[20:46] Speaker 2: existing ten ninety, and it became a huge controversy because
[20:52] Speaker 2: because while the Arjun, you know, compared favorably when compared
[20:56] Speaker 2: with the ten ninety in some aspects, in some cases
[20:59] Speaker 2: it just failed miserably, miserably in terms of mobility, in
[21:03] Speaker 2: terms of maintenance, in terms of suspension. There were many
[21:06] Speaker 2: other areas where it was simply not good. But importantly,
[21:10] Speaker 2: there were areas where it was very good, like it's
[21:11] Speaker 2: firing many things. It was actually superior. Now that DRDO
[21:16] Speaker 2: continued to blame the Army for constantly shifting goalposts, adding
[21:21] Speaker 2: new requirements, imposing limitations on weight, yet asking for more equipment,
[21:28] Speaker 2: you know, demanding, demanding an absolute kind of rainbow of
[21:35] Speaker 2: you know, capabilities in a tank that were unheard of.
[21:39] Speaker 2: You know, when you build a weapon, there are always
[21:41] Speaker 2: sacrifices you need to make if you need it to
[21:43] Speaker 2: be much more agile than it needs to be lighter,
[21:46] Speaker 2: which means you can't have as many other attendant equipment,
[21:50] Speaker 2: things like that. But the army apparently wanted everything. It's
[21:53] Speaker 2: called brochure buzzy in the arms bazaars. India is famous
[21:57] Speaker 2: for that. Whether military forces tend to ask for everything
[22:02] Speaker 2: when they are looking for something. And remember the word
[22:04] Speaker 2: brucher buzzy, because we're going to we're going to limp
[22:07] Speaker 2: back to it in the FRCV topic. But the army
[22:11] Speaker 2: wasn't entirely to blame. I mean, the army has to
[22:15] Speaker 2: carry the can in some ways, I'm sure in terms
[22:17] Speaker 2: of what it wanted. But in defense of the army here,
[22:21] Speaker 2: the army is the customer. The army was the customer
[22:24] Speaker 2: for this tank, and the Army was fully committed to
[22:27] Speaker 2: India developed India made tank, they were fully involved in it.
[22:31] Speaker 2: And yet in iteration after iteration of the urgent tank,
[22:35] Speaker 2: it did not meet performance requirements that the Army had
[22:38] Speaker 2: laid down, and this became a kind of very toxic
[22:43] Speaker 2: saga between the Army and the DIADEO that went on
[22:46] Speaker 2: for about two decades where there was much more finger
[22:50] Speaker 2: pointing and you know, destructive blame game rather than actual development.
[22:55] Speaker 2: And cut forward now to all these decades later, and
[23:00] Speaker 2: you have a truly appalling situation where a tank program
[23:05] Speaker 2: that began after the seventy one war will now have
[23:07] Speaker 2: something like two hundred and fifty tanks in service for
[23:11] Speaker 2: a program like Arjun. Of with the kind of costs
[23:14] Speaker 2: that were sunk into the cost blood, sweat, man hours,
[23:18] Speaker 2: woman hours, national energy and time that was spent on
[23:24] Speaker 2: the Arjun, nothing less than four thousand to five thousand
[23:27] Speaker 2: tanks would amortize the cost that was put into it.
[23:31] Speaker 2: And how many are going to be inducted? Less than
[23:33] Speaker 2: two hundred and fifty four thousand is needed. Two hundred
[23:37] Speaker 2: and fifty are going to be inducted, Which means that
[23:40] Speaker 2: no matter which way you look at it, no matter
[23:42] Speaker 2: who you blame for it, whether you blame the Army
[23:44] Speaker 2: or the DRDO, the project has been a complete failure
[23:49] Speaker 2: in terms of the numbers.
[23:50] Speaker 3: Wow, okay, we.
[23:51] Speaker 2: Can argue till Kingdom come about. No, no it's a
[23:53] Speaker 2: good tank. No, no it's a bad tank. This gun
[23:55] Speaker 2: is better. That gun is better. The fact is the
[23:57] Speaker 2: customer has not bought it. That's the red line.
[24:00] Speaker 3: Okay.
[24:01] Speaker 4: Uh.
[24:02] Speaker 2: The army very justifiably says, you gave us a tank
[24:06] Speaker 2: where we had to build special rail wagons to transport
[24:09] Speaker 2: the damn thing. It was that heavy.
[24:11] Speaker 4: Wow.
[24:11] Speaker 2: So the drd YOU turned around and said, but you
[24:14] Speaker 2: wanted all these things. You agreed to all these things.
[24:17] Speaker 2: So then the army said, yes, but there was a
[24:19] Speaker 2: weight limitation. How you know, how can you go above
[24:21] Speaker 2: the weight? Then the d ad YOU said, but how
[24:23] Speaker 2: can we how can we keep the weight low when
[24:25] Speaker 2: you asked us to add all these things. So then
[24:28] Speaker 2: the army turned back and said, yes, but now the
[24:30] Speaker 2: profile of the tank with all this equipment is too
[24:32] Speaker 2: high and it will be visible from a much longer distance.
[24:35] Speaker 2: So the DRDO turned around and said, yes, but you know,
[24:37] Speaker 2: if you wanted to, you know, go underwater and be
[24:39] Speaker 2: able to be amphibious and stuff, then we you know,
[24:43] Speaker 2: then you'll have to sacrifice your requirement as far as
[24:45] Speaker 2: this is concerned, to which the Army turned around and said, yeah,
[24:48] Speaker 2: but now, how the hell am I going to take
[24:49] Speaker 2: the tank into my high altitudes?
[24:51] Speaker 3: I'll never be able to take it into hig altitudes.
[24:52] Speaker 1: So the DRD you.
[24:53] Speaker 2: Turned around and said, who the hell talked about high altitude?
[24:55] Speaker 2: This is a plane's tank. Where does high altitude come
[24:58] Speaker 2: into the picture? So I'm saying, this tu mem between
[25:01] Speaker 2: the deity and the Army continued for the longest possible time.
[25:04] Speaker 2: So no should nobody should be surprised that at the
[25:06] Speaker 2: end of the day that the the Arjun tank has sunk.
[25:11] Speaker 2: The door has closed on the Argent tank. I've actually
[25:13] Speaker 2: reporter reported on it quite extensively, down to the nuts
[25:17] Speaker 2: and bolts of the of of what happened. And the
[25:20] Speaker 2: truth of the matter is it's it's tempting to blame
[25:23] Speaker 2: the Indian Army saying you changed everything, but but the
[25:26] Speaker 2: fact is they are not entirely to blame. Of course,
[25:29] Speaker 2: the Army must take a part of the blame, you know,
[25:32] Speaker 2: for you know, for either being not really interested in
[25:35] Speaker 2: the Argent tank after a point, uh.
[25:38] Speaker 1: Maybe being maybe having three judged.
[25:40] Speaker 2: That is this tank and not giving it a chance
[25:45] Speaker 2: to the developers and the makers, and the hard questions
[25:48] Speaker 2: need to be asked. Maybe maybe the Argent tank was
[25:51] Speaker 2: was a mess that just simply couldn't be rescued. And
[25:55] Speaker 2: the thing is, the projects like and since you brought
[25:59] Speaker 2: in that comparison with the with the Air Force, the Tags,
[26:03] Speaker 2: the Theagers had a massive divergence where it after after
[26:09] Speaker 2: this kind of decades long tutu between HL and the
[26:12] Speaker 2: and the DIADEO and the Air Force, the Air Force
[26:15] Speaker 2: was convinced of the Tagers capabilities and qualities through work,
[26:20] Speaker 2: not through blame game, not through you guys did this,
[26:23] Speaker 2: I did this. The project managers went to work on
[26:26] Speaker 2: the Tagers, decided this toxic shit can't continue. Ultimately, this fight,
[26:31] Speaker 2: this fighter aircraft has to be put to war. So
[26:34] Speaker 2: this this ridiculous blame game is going to serve nobody's purpose.
[26:40] Speaker 1: All of us gain if this aircraft is successful.
[26:42] Speaker 2: So they they cooled temperatures down. They brought the Air
[26:46] Speaker 2: Force on board, saying, boss, you don't have the money
[26:48] Speaker 2: to buy aircraft from abroad. You have to buy the Tagers,
[26:51] Speaker 2: So let's make it the best fighter we can. And
[26:53] Speaker 2: then that's what happened. It's when temperatures went down. It's
[26:56] Speaker 2: when biases were put aside. It's when preconceived notions about
[27:00] Speaker 2: to your supplier slash customer were put aside in a
[27:03] Speaker 2: kind of mature fashion. That's what happened. And with the
[27:07] Speaker 2: Arjune that never happened. Now we can and.
[27:10] Speaker 3: And believe me, there are there are, there are.
[27:12] Speaker 1: There's a huge community.
[27:13] Speaker 2: Of people online, very very passionate, extremely knowledgeable who fight
[27:18] Speaker 2: actively day after day, day after day for the Arguin
[27:21] Speaker 2: and they do really good work because they they slice
[27:24] Speaker 2: the tank down to its smallest parts and say, how
[27:27] Speaker 2: can you ignore a tank that can do all these things?
[27:30] Speaker 2: And they have a case. And yet when you listen
[27:33] Speaker 2: to the army, they also have a case. But there's
[27:36] Speaker 2: a difference now because I believe, I believe that the.
[27:41] Speaker 1: Indian tank Fleet is standing on.
[27:43] Speaker 2: A razor's edge now because everything has changed since the
[27:48] Speaker 2: Arguin project sank. Let's forget about arg and it's it's
[27:51] Speaker 2: there is no rescuing urgon. Arjune is finished, and it's
[27:54] Speaker 2: time to sort of draw a line in the sand
[27:57] Speaker 2: and say, and that's where the FRCV comes in. But
[28:02] Speaker 2: just two more points before you ask your next question, Dave,
[28:04] Speaker 2: which is this a ladak has happened and the army
[28:08] Speaker 2: got a reminder that it has not planned for light tanks.
[28:11] Speaker 2: And then we had to bring in the light tank
[28:14] Speaker 2: requirement which is the Zuraba. And two. In the last
[28:20] Speaker 2: ten to fifteen years, the most dramatic change that has
[28:24] Speaker 2: happened in India is and once again, and I'm sure
[28:27] Speaker 2: our viewers of also guess the answer already, it's the
[28:30] Speaker 2: private sector. The DRDO and CVRD, the guys who make
[28:34] Speaker 2: the argent tank are not the only game in town.
[28:37] Speaker 5: Competition.
[28:38] Speaker 2: They've got not just competition. They are nowhere in this
[28:41] Speaker 2: competition and may not be anywhere in this competition. And
[28:44] Speaker 2: they have no choice but to be a collaborator. The
[28:48] Speaker 2: DADO can say goodbye to being a lead supplier or
[28:52] Speaker 2: a lead integrator or a kind of monopolistic let me
[28:56] Speaker 2: put my feet on the table, I'm going to win
[28:58] Speaker 2: this contract kind of guy. They there is Barat Forge,
[29:02] Speaker 2: which is the Kalani Group. There is lent T, There's
[29:04] Speaker 2: the Mahindras, there are the Tatars, there are show Cleland.
[29:07] Speaker 2: That are all these companies who've done demonstrable work in
[29:12] Speaker 2: armored vehicles, and all of these companies lent T, Maindra
[29:15] Speaker 2: Tatas will be contenders in the FRCV program because the
[29:20] Speaker 2: FRCV program, and hats off to the Army and the
[29:23] Speaker 2: mod for this, which is that.
[29:24] Speaker 1: It's a make.
[29:26] Speaker 2: In India program. Yeah, no import bullshit. No, okay, we'll
[29:31] Speaker 2: buy some from abroad and then we'll build the rest here.
[29:33] Speaker 2: None of that nonsense is going to happen. It's going
[29:36] Speaker 2: to be built entirely year. So that's the difference.
[29:39] Speaker 5: Yeah.
[29:39] Speaker 4: In fact, I think Ellen T is already involved in
[29:41] Speaker 4: the ZAA project. I'm not wrong, right, So I think
[29:44] Speaker 4: perfect answer. With that answer, you've kind of we've kind
[29:46] Speaker 4: of laid the base on why we need their FRCV
[29:48] Speaker 4: project in the first place. So the June period miserably,
[29:51] Speaker 4: the T seventy twos and the nineties are past their prime,
[29:55] Speaker 4: past their age, and.
[29:56] Speaker 5: Anyway you're making them.
[29:57] Speaker 4: I'm not sure if under license per se, but anyway
[29:59] Speaker 4: they are Russia version. And we've spent quite some time
[30:01] Speaker 4: talking about this myth of you know, making in India
[30:04] Speaker 4: when it comes to licensing from outside and the costs
[30:06] Speaker 4: you pay for that.
[30:07] Speaker 5: On one of our previous episodes, so.
[30:09] Speaker 1: We've laid that on for that.
[30:10] Speaker 4: So we now talk about the FARCV project, what it's
[30:12] Speaker 4: all about, and how optimistic you are as a person
[30:16] Speaker 4: who's been covering this topic for a while.
[30:18] Speaker 5: Now is about it a better after a quick take?
[30:24] Speaker 6: Eat eggs, no eat fiber, sleep, no take short naps,
[30:28] Speaker 6: don't listen to others, no serve others. Do you ever
[30:32] Speaker 6: feel like you're drowning in a pool of advice? This
[30:37] Speaker 6: is Sonalia Charji, a health journalist for the last ten years,
[30:41] Speaker 6: who is equally fed up of lines like ten ways
[30:44] Speaker 6: to stay fit. So join me in the podcast Health
[30:47] Speaker 6: Wealth as we learn about health from a completely new
[30:50] Speaker 6: perspective where investing in yourself is not a task but simple,
[30:55] Speaker 6: satisfying and joyful. Full episodes are available on Apple, Google, Spotify,
[31:01] Speaker 6: and the India Today podcast website.
[31:04] Speaker 1: Tune in now, welcome back.
[31:12] Speaker 4: Shave and I are discussing India's tank Fleeter, the Indian
[31:15] Speaker 4: Army's tank theater, and we've spent the first half of
[31:17] Speaker 4: this episode talking about what we have currently, which is
[31:22] Speaker 4: mostly Russian origin tanks. We have a very miniscual number
[31:25] Speaker 4: of an Indian made, Indian built Indian developed tank called
[31:29] Speaker 4: the art In which Shave in the first half described
[31:32] Speaker 4: as a miserable failure the project.
[31:33] Speaker 5: Now the tank itself persone.
[31:35] Speaker 4: So that creates a need for a new tank program
[31:38] Speaker 4: and incomes the FRCV, which has been given some sort
[31:41] Speaker 4: of a note by the government where the Army is
[31:43] Speaker 4: now allowed to explore reaching out to people and inviting
[31:48] Speaker 4: you know, sort of bids and inviting proposals for people
[31:51] Speaker 4: to build this FRCV. I say people, because just before
[31:55] Speaker 4: the BREVI spoke about how this competition and this project
[31:58] Speaker 4: will not be limited to any government teachers see like
[32:00] Speaker 4: it would have been in the in the in the past, it.
[32:03] Speaker 5: Won't be limited to d R d O.
[32:04] Speaker 4: I think what I've read is that there's going to
[32:07] Speaker 4: be Moti Motor, two companies either private or could be
[32:10] Speaker 4: dr if they succeed in their proposal, two companies which
[32:14] Speaker 4: would be given Kihabanau protect based on what our requirements are,
[32:17] Speaker 4: then we'll kind of you put them against each other
[32:19] Speaker 4: and then we'll decide. Or if they're happy with both,
[32:22] Speaker 4: then they might disorders for some numbers for each or
[32:25] Speaker 4: we don't know what happened, but that's sort of the
[32:27] Speaker 4: broad structure of this of this program. Basically, the Army
[32:29] Speaker 4: has a sort of a free hand. G you give
[32:31] Speaker 4: your requirements out there, let them come back to you,
[32:33] Speaker 4: let the people come back to the companies come back
[32:35] Speaker 4: to you, and then let's see how it proceeds. I
[32:39] Speaker 4: think they want to build around seventeen hundred tanks. They
[32:43] Speaker 4: get go at the cost of around sixteen sorry, sixty
[32:45] Speaker 4: thousand crow rupees probably will go up like all things
[32:48] Speaker 4: in India do, but we'll not talk about that right now.
[32:50] Speaker 4: I'm to understand from you first, what does the army
[32:53] Speaker 4: want in their FRCV. As somebody who's been writing about
[32:57] Speaker 4: tanks for you know, a part of your career, where
[33:02] Speaker 4: do you yourself for C and FRCV in terms of
[33:05] Speaker 4: what you've seen with future called futuristic tanks in other countries,
[33:09] Speaker 4: maybe the US, maybe the NATO.
[33:10] Speaker 5: I don't know if you should talk about Russia, Ukraine,
[33:12] Speaker 5: et cetera.
[33:13] Speaker 4: So basically, break down the concept of an FRCV in
[33:15] Speaker 4: the first place. And like I said, how optimistic are
[33:19] Speaker 4: you about this project with what we've just laid down
[33:21] Speaker 4: in terms of how it will go about?
[33:23] Speaker 2: So the FRCV is you know, maybe an acronym that
[33:27] Speaker 2: most people are hearing for the first time, but believe me,
[33:29] Speaker 2: our listeners have heard it for years and years and years,
[33:33] Speaker 2: and the FRCV initially actually sort of broke the surface
[33:40] Speaker 2: and came out into the media sometime, if I'm not mistaken,
[33:44] Speaker 2: in twenty fourteen.
[33:44] Speaker 3: Twenty fifteen is when.
[33:46] Speaker 2: The first, you know, people first heard about the FRCV
[33:52] Speaker 2: in a big public way, because that's when the Army's
[33:56] Speaker 2: Directorate of Mechanized Infantry, if I'm not mistaken, at first
[33:59] Speaker 2: public stit's requirements broad motor motor requirements. Since then it's
[34:05] Speaker 2: the requirements have been published by the Armored Core And
[34:08] Speaker 2: I'll explain that difference at a moment.
[34:09] Speaker 1: But just before, just before.
[34:12] Speaker 2: I come to the FRCV, I missed one very crucial
[34:15] Speaker 2: point which will be important.
[34:17] Speaker 3: To the FRCV.
[34:18] Speaker 2: On the Arjuon the rjuin has a German engine, Okay, okay,
[34:22] Speaker 2: And here's something that has been reported but is very
[34:27] Speaker 2: important to our discussion right now, which is that the
[34:30] Speaker 2: supply of the improved Arjun. I think there about one
[34:33] Speaker 2: hundred and eighteen which are on order, which I'm not
[34:36] Speaker 2: sure if they've started delivery or some of them have
[34:38] Speaker 2: not been delivered and the reason for that is because
[34:41] Speaker 2: the German engine supplied by a company called MTU.
[34:45] Speaker 3: Those engines are not made anymore.
[34:47] Speaker 2: Wow, or there are problems with their manufacturing in Germany
[34:50] Speaker 2: and therefore there is a supply chain issue.
[34:52] Speaker 5: Does this sound.
[34:52] Speaker 2: Familiar to our vivas and listeners, because if you are
[34:56] Speaker 2: also reminded about the stages, then you are right. So here,
[35:00] Speaker 2: once again is an indigenous project that's amstrung and delayed
[35:04] Speaker 2: because a foreign engine supplier has issues with supplying that engine.
[35:08] Speaker 5: Wow.
[35:09] Speaker 2: Unlike the ge however, where there are supply chain issues here,
[35:12] Speaker 2: it's a much more serious problem with Germany where other engine.
[35:18] Speaker 1: What will you do?
[35:18] Speaker 3: Right?
[35:19] Speaker 6: So?
[35:19] Speaker 2: I mean it's not that simple. There are some issues
[35:21] Speaker 2: because it's the contract. Ultimately, it's not like they're not
[35:23] Speaker 2: making the engine. But there are some issues which are
[35:25] Speaker 2: being sorted out right now. Bottom line is those engines,
[35:28] Speaker 2: those urgines will not come on time. And what is
[35:31] Speaker 2: the reaction in India? Okay, now we have to make
[35:34] Speaker 2: our own engine.
[35:36] Speaker 3: We can't.
[35:37] Speaker 2: I mean, you know, for forty years we thought we
[35:38] Speaker 2: could depend on foreign engines, but now clearly we need
[35:42] Speaker 2: to build our own engine. So a project called the
[35:44] Speaker 2: dat Ran, which is a fifteen hundred bhp engine tank engine,
[35:49] Speaker 2: is being developed by the dr Do you very good?
[35:50] Speaker 2: I mean, there's nothing wrong with that. That is the
[35:52] Speaker 2: way to go, you know, as I and I will
[35:55] Speaker 2: shout this from the rooftop. Still people are tired of me,
[35:58] Speaker 2: which is that if you don't build your on engines,
[36:01] Speaker 2: what's the point of building anything, whether it's whether it's
[36:04] Speaker 2: aircraft engines, helicopter engines, whatever it is, you have to
[36:07] Speaker 2: build it yourself. You have to develop it yourself and
[36:09] Speaker 2: build it yourself. There will be those who say, nine,
[36:12] Speaker 2: it's a globalized world, you know, you know we are.
[36:15] Speaker 2: We shouldn't be reinventing the wheel, shore, all those all
[36:18] Speaker 2: those things apply. But then you'll have situations like this.
[36:21] Speaker 2: And if you're if you're okay with absorbing shit like this,
[36:24] Speaker 2: be my guest, by engines from anywhere you want. But
[36:27] Speaker 2: the point is the Arjun is dependent on a German engine. Now,
[36:31] Speaker 2: the FRCV is going to be an entirely Indian project,
[36:36] Speaker 2: which means, you know, unless things dramatically change, which I
[36:39] Speaker 2: hope they won't and I don't think they will. All
[36:42] Speaker 2: the core technologies will have to be Indian. Now it's
[36:45] Speaker 2: it's it's hugely optimistic to believe that every part of
[36:49] Speaker 2: it will be Indian. There will be subsystems which you
[36:51] Speaker 2: will get from abroad. Perhaps the gun will be foreign,
[36:54] Speaker 2: who knows. Perhaps some battle management systems or electronics or
[37:00] Speaker 2: some systems might be from abroad, but they will not
[37:02] Speaker 2: be systems that can bring the damn project to a
[37:05] Speaker 2: stop like an engine. The fr CV as it stands
[37:09] Speaker 2: right now is a massively ambitious requirement chart. Now let
[37:15] Speaker 2: me bring back the word brochure buzzi, which I asked
[37:17] Speaker 2: everyone to listen to right now. Remember that word brochure buzsi.
[37:21] Speaker 2: The reason why brochure buzzi is because the many critics
[37:24] Speaker 2: of the Indian Army believe that when when the Army
[37:27] Speaker 2: is drawing up its requirements, it sees brochures of all
[37:30] Speaker 2: the best tanks or rifles or whatever in the world,
[37:33] Speaker 2: takes the best of all those requirements and puts it
[37:35] Speaker 2: into one brochure and says, Yha, we need superior firepower,
[37:41] Speaker 2: We need great mobility, We need less weight, we need
[37:43] Speaker 2: form members in the tank. We need a low profile.
[37:46] Speaker 2: It needs to be able to go through lava and
[37:49] Speaker 2: water and whatever.
[37:50] Speaker 3: Else it can.
[37:51] Speaker 2: You know, it needs to be able to, you know,
[37:53] Speaker 2: do everything. It needs to be able to bring down aircraft.
[37:57] Speaker 2: That's what brochure Bazi means in this particular case. I
[38:00] Speaker 2: don't know if that's true. The fr CV seems like
[38:02] Speaker 2: a realistic, realistic tank that the Army has has created
[38:07] Speaker 2: an outline for. Even though there are people who believe
[38:09] Speaker 2: that the FRCV requirement looks like Urgent two point zero.
[38:14] Speaker 3: It's the same thing happening over again.
[38:15] Speaker 2: I read some articles where people are saying that the
[38:18] Speaker 2: fr CV is an is a is a ominous echo
[38:21] Speaker 2: of how the argent went, which is that you had
[38:24] Speaker 2: such an outsized list of requirements. It basically betrayed that
[38:28] Speaker 2: you don't really know what you want to do with
[38:30] Speaker 2: this tank. It betrays confusion over what the objective is now.
[38:35] Speaker 2: I don't think the Army is confused even a little
[38:37] Speaker 2: bit about what it wants from the FRCV, simply because
[38:40] Speaker 2: of the enormous baggage and history of lessons it has
[38:44] Speaker 2: learned from this very painful space of armored vehicles, whether
[38:48] Speaker 2: it is DRDO, whether it is Russia, and believe me,
[38:51] Speaker 2: there's a lot of pain from Russia. The ten ninety
[38:53] Speaker 2: and T seventy two have not been beautifully smooth programmed.
[38:56] Speaker 2: They're very painful and expensive. But the fr CV is
[39:00] Speaker 2: also an opportunity to shake off all the dirt of
[39:04] Speaker 2: the past and do something really good and special going forward,
[39:08] Speaker 2: a fully Indian tank. You know, there are there are
[39:11] Speaker 2: tanks in other countries which have come into their own
[39:13] Speaker 2: in a big way, and they're called and they're modern tanks.
[39:16] Speaker 2: The Key two, which is the Korean tank, you know,
[39:18] Speaker 2: the the T fourteen in Russia, the Armata which is
[39:21] Speaker 2: a modern tank. Upgraded versions of legacy tanks in Germany, France, Israel,
[39:26] Speaker 2: the US Abrams, et cetera. Are all are all you know,
[39:29] Speaker 2: modern tanks, uh, which kind of accommodate the requirements of
[39:34] Speaker 2: new armies, especially in light of the fact that drones
[39:37] Speaker 2: pose a threat.
[39:39] Speaker 3: Uh, you know.
[39:40] Speaker 2: The smallest of things can can completely debilitated tank, et cetera.
[39:44] Speaker 2: So the fr CV is a unlike the Rjurin, which
[39:47] Speaker 2: is a sixty eight tunk hulking behemoth that requires special
[39:52] Speaker 2: rail wagons to transport it, not air transportable, et cetera.
[39:57] Speaker 2: The the FRCV is it's supposed to be from the
[40:01] Speaker 2: ground up a maximum of fifty five to fifty eight tons,
[40:05] Speaker 2: which makes it a bit of a medium tank, not
[40:07] Speaker 2: a heavy tank. It needs to have good mobility, good speed.
[40:14] Speaker 1: All of those.
[40:14] Speaker 2: Requirements have been put out there. So the only issue
[40:17] Speaker 2: is that some people believe that the long list of requirements,
[40:21] Speaker 2: the bells and whistles as it were, you know, air
[40:23] Speaker 2: defense capability, a lot of other things, mean that from
[40:26] Speaker 2: the start it's looking too ambitious. But I take a
[40:31] Speaker 2: little bit of an opposing view now because you've got
[40:34] Speaker 2: to start big with the frc And the reason for
[40:36] Speaker 2: that is, unlike the seventies and eighties, the last five
[40:39] Speaker 2: years of our world has changed warfare completely, has changed
[40:44] Speaker 2: warfare completely for India.
[40:46] Speaker 3: And especially for India, and.
[40:47] Speaker 2: The FRCV needs to It doesn't need to be a
[40:49] Speaker 2: global tank. It needs to be an Indian tank because
[40:53] Speaker 2: two things. The Ukraine War, Sure, I don't want to
[40:56] Speaker 2: over compare. There's always a risk of over comparing battles. Yes,
[41:00] Speaker 2: there are lessons to learn from Ukraine, but we have
[41:02] Speaker 2: our own are India's situation is not a Ukraine situation.
[41:07] Speaker 3: It's not a Russia situation.
[41:09] Speaker 1: We have to we have to learn and absorb the risks.
[41:11] Speaker 2: Of tanks and tank warfare and how to tank warfare
[41:13] Speaker 2: needs to change and take all those lessons and put
[41:16] Speaker 2: it into the technologies we put into the FRCV. But
[41:20] Speaker 2: the lessons we got from Ladakh the fact that we
[41:23] Speaker 2: were caught, uh, caught unprepared without an agile mountain tank.
[41:28] Speaker 2: And we've done a full episode on the Zurava where
[41:30] Speaker 2: we've talked about how India needed to, as usual, react
[41:34] Speaker 2: to an emergent warlike situation to say, shit, we don't
[41:37] Speaker 2: have a mountain tank and then suddenly go scrambling for
[41:41] Speaker 2: a mountain tank. And now hopefully the Zurava will fulfill
[41:44] Speaker 2: that requirement of about.
[41:45] Speaker 3: Four wantred of those tanks.
[41:46] Speaker 2: The fr CV is a great opportunity to kill many
[41:51] Speaker 2: ghosts in one blow, which is a I love the
[41:54] Speaker 2: I love the fact that fr stands for future ready
[41:58] Speaker 2: because it means that the system has recognized key we
[42:02] Speaker 2: have never been future ready, that's why we're in this mess.
[42:05] Speaker 2: And future ready in this instance Dave means that you're
[42:09] Speaker 2: going to build a tank that is time proof, that
[42:12] Speaker 2: it will be so modular, so adaptable, so chocer block
[42:17] Speaker 2: with the you know, with non dated technologies that it's
[42:22] Speaker 2: going to be modern slash reasonably modern for the next
[42:25] Speaker 2: half century, and upgrading it will be a kind of
[42:30] Speaker 2: reasonably elementary plug in play, a fair upgradation of software,
[42:35] Speaker 2: new electronics and things like that. The basic shell of
[42:38] Speaker 2: the vehicle will not really need to change that much.
[42:41] Speaker 2: And that is the that that is a hallmark of
[42:43] Speaker 2: a good weapon. Take, for example, you know an aircraft
[42:46] Speaker 2: like the F fifteen or the F sixteen. These are
[42:50] Speaker 2: aircraft that were or the Sea one thirty better example
[42:53] Speaker 2: of the C one thirty. These are these are aircraft
[42:55] Speaker 2: American aircraft that were built in the sixties seventies.
[42:59] Speaker 3: The shell has not changed.
[43:00] Speaker 2: Those aircraft have defeated time, They've defeated the ravages of
[43:06] Speaker 2: time because the shells.
[43:07] Speaker 3: Remain the same.
[43:08] Speaker 2: It's only the brains and the soul that have constantly
[43:10] Speaker 2: been upgraded. So we need to build an FRCV that
[43:13] Speaker 2: can do that, something that can be formidable in the
[43:17] Speaker 2: land battle, something that can be agile. The Army has
[43:20] Speaker 2: stressed that it needs to be transportable. Needs to be transportable.
[43:25] Speaker 2: We can't be saddled with a huge fleet of very
[43:28] Speaker 2: capable tanks, but they're too heavy to be taken anywhere.
[43:31] Speaker 3: They need to be.
[43:32] Speaker 2: Air transportable in your aircraft. They need to be rail transportable,
[43:35] Speaker 2: road transportable. They need to be modular. They need to
[43:38] Speaker 2: be so adaptable that once the shell of these tanks
[43:42] Speaker 2: is created, they will spawn a whole family of different vehicles.
[43:46] Speaker 2: A bridge laying tank, you know, an electronic warfare tank,
[43:50] Speaker 2: an unmanned tank, a main battle tank, some other kind
[43:53] Speaker 2: of you know, a hospital vehicle, a nuclear, biological warfare
[43:57] Speaker 2: proof kind of vehicle, all these different things. Tank is
[44:00] Speaker 2: ultimately a chassis. It's a vehicle chassis. What you put
[44:03] Speaker 2: on top of it can change. It's a plug and
[44:06] Speaker 2: play thing. So the fr CV needs to be that.
[44:08] Speaker 2: The good news is the fr CV program has been
[44:12] Speaker 2: in the mix for about for about a decade now,
[44:16] Speaker 2: which means that the private sector l and T, Mahindra Tata,
[44:19] Speaker 2: these companies have been have had the time to get
[44:24] Speaker 2: a fix.
[44:24] Speaker 3: On what this needs to be.
[44:26] Speaker 2: And remember, in the last ten years, Dave, these privacy
[44:29] Speaker 2: companies have delivered on on these important programs. Lent T
[44:33] Speaker 2: has delivered the license, built the K nine uh you
[44:37] Speaker 2: know tracked how it's the guns which are deployed now
[44:40] Speaker 2: in La dark. You've got the Zava, which is a
[44:42] Speaker 2: d r d O L and T collaboration. You've got
[44:46] Speaker 2: the WAPP, the Kestrel, the eight wheel armored vehicle which
[44:51] Speaker 2: is which is a Tata DRDO collaboration. Uh So the
[44:55] Speaker 2: fr CV, in my view, is going to have to
[44:59] Speaker 2: be public private collaboration vehicle. I don't see DRDO sidelined
[45:06] Speaker 2: in this at all. The DRDO has to be in
[45:07] Speaker 2: it because the DRDO has done excellent work that has
[45:11] Speaker 2: been funded by public money, excellent work in tank warfare
[45:15] Speaker 2: that needs to be used and if we can get
[45:18] Speaker 2: the best of what the DRDO has built. And very
[45:21] Speaker 2: quick side story, the DRDO actually had something called the
[45:24] Speaker 2: FMBT Future Main Battle Tank fifteen years ago, which was
[45:28] Speaker 2: shelved because the army was so pissed off with the
[45:32] Speaker 2: urgent program. They said no, no, no, let's let's let's
[45:36] Speaker 2: broaden our supplier base and invite the private sector. That's
[45:39] Speaker 2: how the FRCV was finally born. But you can't keep
[45:43] Speaker 2: the DRDO out of this India. In the last ten
[45:46] Speaker 2: years has proven that the public private partnership model works.
[45:49] Speaker 2: The C two ninety five is being built, you know,
[45:52] Speaker 2: by Tata and Airbus in in Varda. There are public
[45:58] Speaker 2: sector companies also helping with that. It's not a public
[46:01] Speaker 2: private partnership, but that's proven that the public sector, the
[46:04] Speaker 2: private sector is mature enough to handle high value sensitive
[46:09] Speaker 2: military equipment. And all these companies are ready, if I'm
[46:13] Speaker 2: not mistaken, L and T and Data already have concepts
[46:16] Speaker 2: for the FRC because they've had the time to do it. Yes,
[46:19] Speaker 2: So it's going to be up to them now to
[46:21] Speaker 2: figure out what they submit to the army. Is the
[46:24] Speaker 2: Army going to allow them to bring technology from a
[46:26] Speaker 2: broad license it with no commitment to the original equipment
[46:31] Speaker 2: supplier abroad and then pitch it to the Indian Army
[46:34] Speaker 2: or is it going to be some other kind of
[46:36] Speaker 2: you know, configuration That remains to be seen. But the
[46:38] Speaker 2: fr CV, in my view, is a fabulous opportunity to
[46:43] Speaker 2: draw a line in the sand, you know, cut cut
[46:46] Speaker 2: our losses in terms of all the mistakes that we've
[46:49] Speaker 2: made in the past, and to move forward in a
[46:51] Speaker 2: really good way.
[46:52] Speaker 5: Right.
[46:52] Speaker 4: I think that's a very perfect way to kind of
[46:55] Speaker 4: bring this, you know, this topic to a close.
[46:58] Speaker 1: And I guess it will also depend a lot on
[47:00] Speaker 1: how flexible the.
[47:01] Speaker 4: Army is going forward, because it's one thing to have,
[47:03] Speaker 4: like you said, this bouquet of demands from you know,
[47:06] Speaker 4: all the best things in the world. But then if
[47:09] Speaker 4: a particular company says, you know, hey, you know, of
[47:11] Speaker 4: the ten things you want me, you will give you
[47:13] Speaker 4: like eight point five. But that one point five is
[47:15] Speaker 4: going to be difficult because that's going to impact this
[47:16] Speaker 4: one particular piece of equipment that you want.
[47:18] Speaker 5: So maybe the.
[47:19] Speaker 4: Negotiation then that happened that perhaps should have happened with
[47:22] Speaker 4: the Urgian program that never happened and happened with the
[47:25] Speaker 4: Tastes program in a very very very good way. If
[47:27] Speaker 4: the Army can bring it through to do that, perhaps
[47:29] Speaker 4: this program will succeed. So I mean, it's quite an
[47:31] Speaker 4: optimistic note to to have about this program. We'll skip
[47:35] Speaker 4: the whole talk about the Russia Ukraine War and lessons
[47:38] Speaker 4: from it, because one if we go there will go
[47:40] Speaker 4: into a different black hole hole together, and we kind
[47:43] Speaker 4: of running out of time. So I think what we'll
[47:45] Speaker 4: do instead is we'll have a special episode sometime soon
[47:47] Speaker 4: on just like overall lessons from the US Ukraine work
[47:49] Speaker 4: because it's not just about tanks. It's also about air power.
[47:52] Speaker 4: It's also about drone warfare, exactly prone warfare. It's also
[47:56] Speaker 4: about the use of threats, of the nuclear of the
[47:59] Speaker 4: nuclear threats and.
[48:00] Speaker 5: In the modern day and age, and the backing of
[48:02] Speaker 5: the West and stuff like that.
[48:03] Speaker 4: So I think that's probably the deserve episode, separate episode,
[48:06] Speaker 4: and we'll see this talk about.
[48:07] Speaker 5: About tank warfare there.
[48:09] Speaker 4: So before ending, though, I want two small nuggets I
[48:12] Speaker 4: want to talk about when it comes to tanks. You know,
[48:15] Speaker 4: it's a childhood scene from the film Border that I
[48:18] Speaker 4: remember that I keep laughing about. I want to I
[48:21] Speaker 4: want to know your thoughts, especially because you're recording this
[48:23] Speaker 4: episode in the midst of a week when there's lots
[48:25] Speaker 4: of controversy about how should films go about depicting historical
[48:29] Speaker 4: events and how realistic they must be, and that topic
[48:31] Speaker 4: always comes up when you talk about the world of
[48:33] Speaker 4: defense and wars and.
[48:34] Speaker 5: Stuff like that.
[48:35] Speaker 4: So you have this scene in the movie Border where Snchetti,
[48:39] Speaker 4: who's playing a PSS officer, is carrying a bloody tank
[48:42] Speaker 4: mine with his bare hands, walking alongside of Pakistani tank
[48:45] Speaker 4: and the Pakistani tank commander is so scared that he's ordering.
[48:48] Speaker 5: The tank to be reversed. I'm wondering, don't the tank
[48:50] Speaker 5: commanders have a gun? There's like a side and pistol that.
[48:53] Speaker 4: First of all, I mean, can you even carry a
[48:54] Speaker 4: tank mine with your bare hands?
[48:56] Speaker 2: You know, I will not take any criticism of Border
[48:59] Speaker 2: because that is you know, that is a great, great film,
[49:03] Speaker 2: first of all. But secondly, the answer, sadly to your
[49:06] Speaker 2: question is yes, that's a It's an absolutely ludicrous scene
[49:11] Speaker 2: in the in the in the best traditions of Bollywood.
[49:13] Speaker 2: So you know, I'm not going to fault them for it.
[49:16] Speaker 2: You know, we can we can do a whole episode
[49:18] Speaker 2: on what's wrong with that scene? Uh, you know, carrying
[49:22] Speaker 2: a tank minea I mean theoretically, I'm sure so I
[49:24] Speaker 2: can definitely carry a tank by who we're talking about.
[49:27] Speaker 2: But yeah, side arm, the fact that he wants to
[49:30] Speaker 2: reverse the tank, what's that going to do?
[49:32] Speaker 3: You can put the tank, you could put the mind
[49:33] Speaker 3: behind the tank.
[49:35] Speaker 4: You know.
[49:35] Speaker 2: There are so many things to say, you know, but
[49:37] Speaker 2: the the best thing about Border is there are whole forums.
[49:41] Speaker 2: There are whole forums they've online where movies like border
[49:45] Speaker 2: have been dissected, you know for factual accuracy and UH
[49:50] Speaker 2: and credibility and things like that. And remember that Bollywood
[49:53] Speaker 2: and we must definitely do an episode on this Bollywood
[49:57] Speaker 2: war films because there are there are there are ridiculous
[50:01] Speaker 2: Masala films and there are very realistic films.
[50:04] Speaker 1: There are a film like Hockey Cut, Yes, which depicted.
[50:06] Speaker 2: The you know, the Raizangla battle. And I understand there's
[50:10] Speaker 2: a new movie that's coming up very soon called one
[50:13] Speaker 2: sixty ba again, yes on a one twenty on the
[50:16] Speaker 2: on the Razangla battle. And these are very very sensitive
[50:19] Speaker 2: battles where you don't have the luxury of carrying a
[50:22] Speaker 2: you know, Sunilana carrying a tank mine and the Pakistani
[50:26] Speaker 2: guy kind of you know, petrified. But yeah, it's it's
[50:32] Speaker 2: a crazy scene. I wouldn't change the thing, right cool.
[50:36] Speaker 4: One last point because this is something I could not
[50:39] Speaker 4: find information about online. I don't know when I got
[50:41] Speaker 4: interested in this. I think around the time of the
[50:43] Speaker 4: COVID pandemic. I forgot who it was the name of
[50:45] Speaker 4: the left hand general, but he took charge of the
[50:47] Speaker 4: Southwestern Command and he was wearing an all black outfit
[50:50] Speaker 4: and I was like, wait, since spent does army have
[50:53] Speaker 4: a black outfit? So I googled a bit and I
[50:55] Speaker 4: found out it's okay, the Armored Coat Regiment apparently only
[50:57] Speaker 4: wes black outfits. Okay, and this officer, the left engin
[51:01] Speaker 4: Lefegot his name again, very very fat, so he looked
[51:03] Speaker 4: quite you know, dashing, bulky and you know, quite cool
[51:06] Speaker 4: in that outfit. So I tried to find out more
[51:07] Speaker 4: about the reason for the Armored Core having a having
[51:10] Speaker 4: a black uniform. Could not refine much except some speculation
[51:14] Speaker 4: that perhaps it's because, you know, they deal with tanks,
[51:16] Speaker 4: so their uniforms could get oil and stuff like that,
[51:18] Speaker 4: so kind of hide the stains away. You're you know,
[51:21] Speaker 4: do you have any information on this?
[51:22] Speaker 2: That's that's precisely where it probably stems from. You're right,
[51:25] Speaker 2: you know, the historically we probably need to you know,
[51:29] Speaker 2: bring a tank man on to get that exact history
[51:31] Speaker 2: of why the black. But yeah, regimentally, the you know,
[51:35] Speaker 2: black is black is definitely something there.
[51:39] Speaker 3: I imagine it's.
[51:40] Speaker 2: Exactly that because of the smoke, dust and the environment
[51:45] Speaker 2: inside a tank. And you know, I've been privileged enough
[51:48] Speaker 2: to you know, be inside both a teen ninety seventy
[51:52] Speaker 2: two and an Algune tank and I can tell you
[51:55] Speaker 2: the you can get really really dirty in there. So yeah,
[51:59] Speaker 2: so I think I think that that's where it really
[52:01] Speaker 2: comes from, respecting the environment and not being foolish enough
[52:05] Speaker 2: to wear anything that's you know, a light color.
[52:07] Speaker 4: Yeah right, great, I think we'll end the episode over there,
[52:11] Speaker 4: A great chat shift from the lows of the our
[52:14] Speaker 4: tune to the probable highs of their FRCV. We've covered
[52:17] Speaker 4: a nice sort of tangent on this circle. Sorry on
[52:20] Speaker 4: this on this episode, and I hope the FARCV comes
[52:22] Speaker 4: out like you know you're talking about it comes out.
[52:25] Speaker 4: Thanks Shift as always, and thanks as always to our
[52:28] Speaker 4: producer and Update the Disney, and once again to our
[52:30] Speaker 4: listeners and viewers who keep you know, pumping in comments
[52:32] Speaker 4: week after week after week giving us this as well,
[52:34] Speaker 4: by the way, and supporting us, sometimes disagreeing with us,
[52:38] Speaker 4: but that's okay, part and parcel of in the podcasting world.
[52:40] Speaker 4: So thanks to everybody. That's it for this week's defense
[52:43] Speaker 4: to us for more tune in next week. Then stay
[52:45] Speaker 4: safe and not tossing anybodies that passport by

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
