# How India hit it out of the park with the legendary BrahMos cruise missile | In Our Defence, S02, Ep 21

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 25 Apr 2024, 1 h 00 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/59654355/26_apr_24_iod_26_apr_128.mp3

In this episode, host Dev Goswami and defence enthusiast Shiv Aroor delve into the cutting-edge advancements in India's missile programs and the coveted missile technology programs at large. They examine two significant tests: the successful launch of the indigenous Nirbhay cruise missile and a new variant of the Medium-Range Ballistic Missile, both of which showcase India's technological prowess. Why is the Nirbhay test off Odisha's coast a monumental achievement for India? Why is exporting homemade BrahMos, India's iconic missile, to the Philippines a significant development? BrahMos is gaining traction and making a resounding impact in international markets, including Southeast Asia and Africa. Some countries in West Asia have also expressed keen interest. Listen in to know more about India's growing prowess in missile technology. Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound mix by Sachin Dwivedi

## Transcript

[0:00] This is India Today podcasts. All kinds of you know, hippocritical rubbish happened
[0:09] between India and Russia. But the fact is that the Bromos turned out to
[0:12] be an even better cruise missile than initially imagined by India, and India was
[0:17] getting, literally to use an old cliche bang for its buck keeping. Aside
[0:21] all the worst things about Indian defense procurement, India actually moved with a great
[0:24] deal of agility as far as Bromos is concerned. For the longest time,
[0:28] most people said the BrahMos is too big, it's too heavy, You'll never
[0:31] be able to sling it onto a fighter. No way. India said,
[0:33] okay, hold my beer, you know, we'll show you how it's done.
[0:36] Obviously, taking some help with from the Russians, they modified the sues
[0:40] the nearby is most definitely going to be a nuclear capable missile the BrahMos.
[0:44] Whether or not it becomes nuclear capable is irrelevant, but India needed a purpose
[0:49] built cruise missile now. Usually when weather issues come up, people say whether
[0:54] it'say, yeah, a you know missile should be fired in any weather,
[0:57] which is true. You know, when it comes to act, this will
[1:00] combat and missile will be fired in any weather, but the reason why it
[1:03] couldn't be test fired in that weather is because you're trying to observe the missile.
[1:08] Hello and welcome to Another Defense, a weekly podcast on all things well
[1:14] defense, where I They've go Swami, your host, along with senior journalist
[1:19] Shivarur, break down the world of conflicts that range from the subtle to the
[1:22] brute. We bring you nuances and perspectives that will inform and at times provoke.
[1:30] This is in our Defense. Hello and welcome to the twenty first episode
[1:38] of Another Defense. Uh you know a shive. I think our viewers and
[1:42] listeners will get quite bored that every episode we come and say, oh,
[1:47] you know, election ceason licenses and hl revot. But sorry, guys,
[1:49] can't help it because it's what we do. It's that day job. Shive
[1:53] is just fresh of anchoring right now, and I'm pretty sure he's listed a
[1:56] one hour long debate on some political issue of the day. Also, I
[1:59] don't feel gilt doing this show anymore. You know, people you say you're
[2:02] an anchor, You know, how come you're doing this show right in the
[2:05] middle of elections. The kind of messages I've been getting, which is that
[2:07] I find in our defense the best escape from this elections Tamasha, So we
[2:12] we're actually doing a noble service here, true, but the idea of you
[2:15] know, wars and explosions and missiles, which we'll talk about on this episode
[2:20] as well, and that being an escape for people. It was twenty one
[2:23] episodes in and I don't think there's any resistance, So yes, what do
[2:27] you a good job? Right? You know? This week as well,
[2:30] like last week, we'll talk about missiles, an extension of actually what we
[2:34] what we spoke about last week. While I was listening to our episode after
[2:38] it was published on Thursday, I thought, you know, we could have
[2:42] explored some other aspects of India's missile program, but I thought we'd do that
[2:45] in a litter episode. But what happened then was I think just on the
[2:49] day of our recording on Eybo the day after, there was a missile test,
[2:51] and there was a misl test yesterday as well, so I thought might
[2:53] as well get into it. So before we get so for our listeners viewers,
[2:58] yes, we are going to talk about missile specifically India's cruise missile program.
[3:01] And when you say, cruise missile. That one name will obviously pop
[3:05] up promos, So yes, definitely we'll get into that. But before we
[3:07] do that, before we talk about the program from most et cetera, let's
[3:10] talk about the two tests that have happened. Because very weirdly, uh,
[3:15] the Defense Ministry or PIB, which put on information about both the tests,
[3:21] wasn't very informative about it. It was very guarded, very you know,
[3:24] boiler played statement key high missile test to for the for last week's test,
[3:28] I think they use something on the lines of some missile, uh, with
[3:31] the Indigenous propulsion system indigenous technology cruise missile. It I CM very typical of
[3:38] India, you know, like the boiler plate anodyne kind of name which doesn't
[3:42] give away anything anything exactly. More so with yesterday's test yesterday as in today,
[3:46] it's you know, a Wednesday and recordings, so Tuesday test that happened,
[3:50] which was of a medium range ballistic missile. Again not really sure what
[3:53] how, but the test was. People like you obviously knoworting have some more
[3:58] information, so we obviously have some articles on it as well. Before we
[4:01] delve into our topic, can you tell us about these two tests that happened.
[4:04] Yeah, so these two tests were very very different tests. Actually they've
[4:08] and they're both equally crucial. The first test that happened, I think last
[4:13] week was a test of like what I said, which is the ITCM,
[4:16] which is the Indigenous Technology cruise missile, basically a fancy name of a missile
[4:21] called called the Nearby. Now, the Nearby is basically a cruise missile.
[4:27] It's India's only indigenous cruise missile. It has a range of about one thousand
[4:32] kilometers, which is makes it a long range cruise missile. And it is
[4:35] sub sonic. You know, you mentioned the Brummos, which we'll come to
[4:39] later, but the Nearby is subsnic, which means it flies a little little
[4:44] under the speed of sound. Now, the Nearby is a very very important
[4:47] weapon system for India because you know, India's guided missile program is pretty much
[4:54] dominated by ballistic missiles. We haven't had any cruise missiles in our inventory that
[4:59] we we've built ourselves. The Bromos is partially Russian, even though most of
[5:02] it is now Indian, and there's always been a gap in terms of a
[5:08] sort of Tomahawk like missile. You know, the Tomahawk. You know,
[5:12] anytime anyone thinks of a cruise missile, they usually think of the American Tomahawk,
[5:15] and the Narby is in many ways comparable to the Tomahawk in terms of
[5:19] its architecture, in terms of its size, in terms of its range,
[5:24] in terms of the kind of targets that it's used against. So that's what
[5:28] the Narby was this time. The important part about the Narby test, Dave,
[5:32] is the reason why it was called indigenous technology a cruise missile, and
[5:36] I'll come to that a little later, but I just wanted to quickly say
[5:40] that the reason why India hasn't had a cruise missile of its own is because,
[5:44] unlike a ballistic missile, which is powered by a rocket motor, a
[5:48] cruise missile is basically like a drone. It's like a small airplane, which
[5:53] means it's powered by a jet engine, a small, small jet engine.
[5:57] And as we've explored in past episodes of this podcast, India has not been
[6:02] very good at building jet engines. We don't have one of our own efforts
[6:06] in the past have been failures. So forget about having a jet engine.
[6:12] A cruise missile requires a miniaturized jet engine. So that's been a huge challenge.
[6:17] But this particular test of the nearby was I think the first public test.
[6:21] There have been a few before it, but the first public test featuring
[6:26] an Indian jet engine called the MANIC. It's called the I think the Small
[6:30] turbofan Engine or STFY, which is an incredible achievement. To have a missile
[6:38] like the by a cruise missile powered by your very own jet engine. Is
[6:43] I wonder why we're not shouting from the rooftops more about this. It's a
[6:46] huge, huge achievement for India. And the reason for that is once you
[6:49] prove a cruise missile using your own engine, that engine can be used for
[6:54] a large number of applications. It can be used for drones, it can
[6:58] be used for small aircraft, can be used for you know, other cruise
[7:01] missiles. You know, it's it's that old aviation thing. You don't build
[7:06] a plane and then design an engine. You design an engine and then you
[7:10] build aircraft around it, different kinds of aircraft around it. So now that
[7:13] we've got you know, proven the capability of an engine on this cruise missile,
[7:17] you know, the the sky is the limit as it were. So
[7:20] that was the first test very important. The second test that happened a few
[7:25] days later, which was the medium range ballistic missile. That was the important
[7:30] thing about that test was it was not a development test. They were not
[7:34] test firing it in terms of seeing what you know, seeing what its qualities
[7:41] were. This was India's Nuclear Command. Again previous episode, we've talked all
[7:45] about our nuclear command. This was India Strategic Forces Command basically flexing and conducting
[7:51] a test of an in service weapons system and a nuclear capable weapon system.
[7:57] Now the medium rang They very you know, cryptically called it medium range ballistic
[8:01] missile. And this this has led to a huge amount of speculation obviously on
[8:05] social media about yeah, yeah, yeah, medium range ballistic missile an why
[8:11] if they if it's an ugly why't is saying it's ugly, if it's not
[8:13] P three, Why they're not saying it's PLIT three. So suddenly there's this
[8:16] huge frenzy over what it is. Now my information is that this is a
[8:20] some kind of superior modification of an existing UGNE, either the Agne one or
[8:24] the ugly two prime an one prime I beg your pardon, uh, And
[8:28] it's likely that, and they've just not given it a name just yet,
[8:31] uh you know, possibly for you know, psychological reasons, you know,
[8:35] just give the world an impression that you've got a new ballistic missile. But
[8:37] I can't be sure about that. But my information that it's it's an ugne
[8:41] mod it's a modern existing ugly missile. So those are the two tests that
[8:46] took place. One was a development test by the BYE by the laboratories and
[8:50] the scientists who are developing the nearby a cruisem style. The other was a
[8:54] user test. So they're very very different, right, And I think one
[8:58] of the reasons perhaps you know, people are not how for the rooftops,
[9:01] like you said with the previous test, is also perhaps the way they put
[9:03] out information about this thing. So like you know, there's not much for
[9:07] people to even understand. You have to really scramble do your technology. Yeah,
[9:13] so so good. You really have to like dig into all these tech
[9:16] which is what I had to do for this episode and which is where I
[9:18] found out. And again we'll just like focus on this one topic before we'd
[9:22] well be deep into indest program. The difference between a cruise missile and a
[9:26] ballistic missile, and I was actually a bit surprised to know that based on
[9:30] what I've read. You can obviously, you know, tell us in detail.
[9:33] A cruise missile actually seems to be a far sexier weapon because it is
[9:39] able to maneuver itself. It flies really low, it flies all along the
[9:43] surface. But a ballistic missile in most cases will actually go out to space
[9:48] and then you know, attack any territory. What I've also read a skin
[9:50] in most cases. I'm not sure if that still applies to all the modern
[9:54] ballistic missiles. In most cases ballistic missile, uh, target information will have
[9:58] to be pre fair. You have to find that area and sent it there,
[10:03] while a cruise missile can kind of on the go, on the fly,
[10:05] decide if it wants to change your arget and all that. So,
[10:09] yeah, this technical nerdy question, what's a cruise missile? How is it
[10:13] different from a ballistic missile? And do you also think they're sexier than a
[10:16] listing missile? First of all, categorically agree with you that a cruise missiles
[10:20] are fast sexier than ballistic missiles. But you know, just to explain very
[10:24] very quickly for our viewers, the basic differences between a ballistic missile and a
[10:28] cruise missile. A ballistic missile is basically a big fat rocket. The phases
[10:33] of it being powered from the beginning till the end are all rocket boosted.
[10:37] It's basically a rocket that goes up into space and then comes back down in
[10:41] a kind of you know, a parabolic arc. It's basically you fire it
[10:46] up and then it comes down at a predetermined spot and explodes over there.
[10:50] And the ballistic missiles are of different kinds and ranges. In India, virtually
[10:56] all of your long range weapons systems are ballistic missiles. You've got the other
[11:00] series, You've got the brith V series. These are basically your ballistic missiles.
[11:03] And there are more, uh you know, ballistic missiles that are coming
[11:07] up that are for submarine launch, et cetera. Now, a cruise missile
[11:09] is a very different animal unlike a ballistic missile, which is which is you
[11:16] know, fired to a great altitude and uses that energy to go up into
[11:22] space, uh you know, capture that distance and velocity and then come down
[11:26] on a target some distance away. A cruise missile, the best way to
[11:30] describe a cruise missile is basically an unmanned aerial vehicle with a warhead. It's
[11:35] basically an aircraft, a pilotless aircraft with a warhead. It is nothing.
[11:39] It is nothing more complicated than that. A cruise missile, uh, you
[11:45] know, has a trajectory which is flat. It flies parallel to the Earth's
[11:48] surface, depending on the altitude that you use for it. Unlike the parabolic
[11:54] arc that a ballistic missile takes. A cruise missile is you know, like
[11:58] you said said, unlike a ballistic missile which usually has pre fed you know,
[12:03] target data. There are some technologies for terminal guidance, including what we
[12:07] discussed in our previous test, what Prime Minister Modi had talked about them IRV
[12:11] test of the Age three. The cruise missiles are enormously more flexible in terms
[12:18] of mid course correction, in terms of you know, autonomous target detection,
[12:24] in terms of having cameras on them and the ground controller, can you know,
[12:28] change guidance, change targets at the last minute, and things like that.
[12:31] They're much much more flexible. A ballistic missile, once fired, leaves
[12:35] you with very little flexibility in terms of what you can do with it.
[12:39] But the cruise missile, there are many different things you can actually do it
[12:41] do with it because it basically is like an aircraft like the advantages of a
[12:46] cruise missile Visivie billistic missile, and I asked this question quite often, is
[12:50] that by virtue of flying much closer to the Earth as compared to a ballistic
[12:58] missile and basically flying like an air raft parallel to the Earth's surface, there
[13:01] are cruise missiles which travel just a few meters above the earth surface. There
[13:05] are cruise missiles like the Bromos, which can fly hundreds of meters above the
[13:09] earth surface but still at a flat you know, parallel to the ground trajectory,
[13:13] are difficult to detect on radar because of the virtue of them flying close
[13:18] to the earth. A ballistic missile is more detectable because it's going much higher
[13:22] up. The higher up you go, the more visible you are from a
[13:24] longer distance, which is why a ballistic missile is more easily detectable by an
[13:30] anti ballistic missile system or radar or you know, weapon locating you know sensors,
[13:35] etc. But a cruise missile, by virtue of it basically hugging the
[13:39] Earth's surface makes takes advantage of the curvature of the Earth because it travels hundreds
[13:45] of kilometers, which means that by the time it becomes visible or pops up,
[13:50] as it were, it's either too late, or you can't engage with
[13:54] it, or it's invisible until it actually comes and hits you. So those
[13:58] are the basic differences between I'm leaving out the more detailed technical aspects of guidance,
[14:05] et cetera. But these are the basic differences. Yeah. Uh.
[14:07] And you know, just to if you, if listeners and viewers want,
[14:11] like a visual image of why I think cruise miss is a sexier Just like
[14:13] look for a Brummos missile test video and you'll see it goes up. There
[14:18] are two short rocket sort of you know, booster fires and that makes the
[14:24] missiles flip on its side and then it just zooms out into into into the
[14:28] head cap with a little rock exactly. It's amazing. Looks it looks looks
[14:31] amazing. Yeah, so let's talk about the Brumos. But like I said,
[14:37] when you talk about cruise missiles in Indian context, Bramos is the name
[14:41] that comes up. I've seen Brumos, I think from my teenage yeers,
[14:45] I've almost every Republic Day parade has that trademark Brmos missile launcher going as part
[14:50] of the parade. Like Shift said, Uh, it's not entirely Indian.
[14:54] It's a joint Indian Russian venture. But unlike most like something that is an
[15:01] Indian Russian venture with respect for example, fighter jets Promos actually is not used
[15:05] by Russia. Uh. The Brumos companies headquartered in Deli. Uh, it
[15:11] is I think a joint venture between India's dr d IF. I'm not wrong,
[15:13] and I forgot. I know the Russian company's name, but it's very
[15:16] hard to pronounce that the names Brumos. The name stands for two rivers,
[15:22] one in India and one in Russia Mosqua. Uh. And yeah, so
[15:26] it's I would say it's kind of Indian because you know, Russia it helped
[15:30] us with a lot of tech. It's about seventy eight percent Indian now exactly.
[15:33] And we forgot, forgot to mention something at the beginning of this episode,
[15:35] the feather in the cap for Ramos. We exported Ramos to Philippine last
[15:39] week, which I think is a huge deal. Tell Us about this program
[15:43] in detail, tell Us about the inception of it. Tell us about what's
[15:46] happened over the years, tell us about the different variants of Ramos that we
[15:50] have. I also think there is one hypersonic variant of yeah, which would
[15:54] fly at speeds of mark seven, which is fast and by the way,
[15:58] I think, make it the fastest cruise missile in the world. Yeah.
[16:02] Uh, And even right now, Gramos is one of the fastest. And
[16:03] I think if you were to list the top cruise missas of the world,
[16:07] like Tomah, Bumos would be part of that list. So, yeah,
[16:11] tell us about Brumo's program, and do you like me also think this is
[16:14] a huge deal for it and it's a fantastic achievement that So the Brumos,
[16:17] you know is is uh is a is a program that you know makes me
[16:21] feel warm and fuzzy inside because it it's an example of how India and Russia
[16:26] have been able to get it right sometimes. Uh. There was virtually nothing
[16:30] a miss in this program. It was a It was a There was basically
[16:34] a missile system called the Yakont which is in Russia right now. Uh,
[16:38] and India had been looking for this kind of tactical, short range, game
[16:45] changing kind of anti ship weapons system and like almost every other weapons program in
[16:49] Russia. They said, look, we'll partner with you. Would you'll have
[16:52] to bankroll it. You'll have to fund it. So, uh, the
[16:56] Brumos program was born basically because India had shown an inclination to fund the entire
[17:03] thing. Bankroll the entire thing, even though it was a joint venture.
[17:06] Joint venture is a bit of a misnomer in this case, because the money
[17:10] was almost entirely Indian. So they took a basically existing missile, improved it
[17:15] vastly, and carved out what we now know as the Brumos. Now,
[17:19] Russia is the kind of country that you know, kind of left India halfway
[17:25] on the program because it didn't place orders for the missiles. So the burden
[17:29] of making the program a success was almost not almost, it was entirely on
[17:33] India. It was on India to give orders, make sure that there was
[17:37] pressure on the company to produce the missiles fast enough so that the Indian armed
[17:41] forces you know, got the missiles. And it was at a much later
[17:45] date that Russia kind of said, okay, we'll try and see. They
[17:48] had some constitutional restrictions saying their constitution bars them from buying weapons that are you
[17:55] know, not made in Russia, et cetera. So all kinds of you
[17:57] know, hippocritical rubbish happened between India and Russia. But the fact is that
[18:02] the Bromos turned out to be an even better cruise missile than initially imagined by
[18:07] India, and India was getting literally to use an old cliche bang for its
[18:11] buck. So so, keeping aside all the worst things about Indian defense procurement,
[18:17] India actually moved with a great deal of agility as far as Bromos is
[18:21] concerned. Developed it fast, you know, test fired it quickly, you
[18:26] know, made sure that it met all its timelines and deadlines and goals,
[18:29] et cetera, And the result is plained for you to see. Right now.
[18:32] You've got the Bromos in service in multiple regiments with the Army, which
[18:36] is the land land launched version. You've got it in service on multiple Indian
[18:42] Navy warships already, All new generation warships are armed with the Brumos, which
[18:48] is which is a stupendous game changing weapon system. There is no you know,
[18:52] people don't say this enough, but there is no weapon system like the
[18:56] Bromos. The speed at which the Brumos travels and with a range of about
[19:00] three hundred kilometers. It's actually more than that. You've got the kind of
[19:04] ship killing capability that literally no country in your neighborhood has, you know,
[19:10] not China, not not even Russia, and none of the other countries around
[19:15] US have. So you've got you've got. You know, we throw around
[19:18] the word game changing and force multiplying in you know, when we talk about
[19:22] defense, but this is this is one weapon system where you can actually say
[19:26] game changing and mean it. So. So now you've got the A few
[19:30] years ago, the Brumos also entered service with the Indian Air Force in Tannjabur
[19:34] in Tamladu. You've got an entire squadron of Sukoy thirty fighters armed with the
[19:40] Brumos missile. Again, crazy game changing capability. Because for the longest time,
[19:45] most people said the Brumos is too big, it's too heavy, you'll
[19:47] never be able to sling it onto a fighter. No way. India said,
[19:51] okay, hold my beer, you know, we'll show you how it's
[19:52] done. Obviously, taking some help with from the Russians, they modified the
[19:56] sus Yes, all in India, by the way, within you know,
[20:00] how a little bit of Russian you know, very reluctant kind of you know,
[20:03] sort of partnership with the Russians. They figure it out and they said,
[20:07] I don't care even one Brumos on a SUKHOI will still be an awesome
[20:11] thing and we will do it. So that's what they did. So so
[20:14] now you've got the Brumos deployed with all three armed forces, with more orders
[20:18] spending for all three armed forces. You've got the Brumos two, like you
[20:22] mentioned, which is a hypersonic version of the Bromos. The current the current
[20:25] Bromos is basically a Ramjet powered a supersonic cruise missile. The hypersonic Brumos two
[20:32] will be a much faster six to seven mark speed missile. You know,
[20:36] it's a weapon of the future. It's a super weapon of the future.
[20:38] Takes things entirely to the next level. But, like you rightly said,
[20:42] the export that India scored in jan twenty twenty two with Philippines and deliveries have
[20:48] just begun between our last episode. In this episode, the first consignments of
[20:52] that Bromos missile landed in the Philippines. Is a huge deal for India.
[20:56] Because India is a country that has never had weapons exports, and this one
[20:59] is like a you know, a big high profile weapons system being purchased by
[21:03] Philippines because of the you know, the game of chess that's being played with
[21:07] China, you know, makes India look really, really good. You know,
[21:11] I did a show on the Bromos sale a few days ago, and
[21:15] experts all were unanimous that, you know, from a country that was kind
[21:18] of reluctant to quote unquote play the game as far as China is concerned,
[21:22] is now you know, arming China's adversaries in the South China Sea with Indian
[21:26] built weapons. You know, this is an incredible, uh sort of symbol
[21:30] of how far India has come and how our military culture has completely changed,
[21:36] strategic culture has changed. We're willing to take the fight to our adversaries,
[21:40] you know, neighborhood. So Bramos has become an emblem of that. So
[21:44] so I think it's I think it's a very very big deal. The program
[21:48] is extremely successful. Many more countries are waiting to buy it, Vietnam,
[21:52] Indonesia, Malaysia, Argentina, Brazil, Chile apparently. So so the future
[21:56] is bright for the bromos. Yeah, I think as far as as India's
[22:00] defense exports go, I think this piece of technology, this piece of wepon
[22:03] will rank among the best that we are currently currently exporting. We get back
[22:10] to again the India's larger cruise missile program. But just one quick speculative question,
[22:15] and which the Internet loves debating and talking about. India has never confirmed
[22:21] it. People on the Internet are damn sure that the bromost is nuclear capable.
[22:26] Obviously, we cannot go on leg and say yes, we know it
[22:27] for a fact that it is. But as a defense journalist who's been coming
[22:30] this for a while, as somebody who's spoken to people and your understanding of
[22:34] missile tech, do you think this missile could potentially carry in clear for it
[22:38] looks you know, I actually am quite perplexed by the debate over whether it
[22:44] can be capable or not. It's a missile. A missile is nothing but
[22:48] a delivery system, you know. The destructive component of a missile is a
[22:52] warhead, which is basically a small compartment of the missile which contains the stuff
[22:57] that can you know, make you right now? Theoretically, technically, of
[23:03] course, you can sling a tactical nuclear warhead onto a Bromos. Now,
[23:07] some will argue that why would you need a you know, is it sensible
[23:11] to put a nuclear warhead onto a missile that has only a very small range
[23:15] of just three hundred kilometers. Usually, if you're doing a nuclear attack,
[23:18] you'd want to standoff range. You know, why would you strike with a
[23:22] nuclear weapon just three hundred kilometers away. The point is that the Bromos is
[23:26] now an extended range weapon. You know, up until now, India's Brumos
[23:30] was a two hundred and ninety kilometer range weapon because of something called the MTCR.
[23:37] Let me try and get the full form of this correctly, MTCR's missile
[23:41] technology. It was basically a treaty from around I'll get it in a moment,
[23:48] a treaty that India was not a signatory to international treaty which restricted the
[23:55] range of weapons, you know, when it was a collaborative effort between two
[23:57] countries. As a result of that, the Bromos was restricted by its range.
[24:03] It had to be kept below three hundred kilometers, which is why it
[24:06] had a very tantalizing range of two ninety kilometers, you know, well below
[24:11] the India being a good responsible country, not three hundred to ninety. Now,
[24:15] after India has become a signatory to the MTCR, which is that Missile
[24:18] Technology Controlled Regime Missile Technology Control Regime MTCR, those range restrictions have evaporated,
[24:26] which is why now you have the X, the Bromos er, which is
[24:30] an extended range Bromos which is five hundred kilometers. And I've spoken to the
[24:33] people at Bromos who say that it can be anything. Now. You know,
[24:37] it is only limited now by its architecture and this amount of fuel it
[24:41] can carry. But basically, theoretically the existing Bromos can now be churned out
[24:47] into a weapon with a eight hundred to one thousand kilometer range, and that
[24:51] is crazy. At that speed and that kind of devastating accuracy that the Bromos
[24:55] brings to the table. One thousand kilometer range is once up from the word
[25:00] game changer. And if you want to put a tactical nuclear warhead to a
[25:04] decile of that range, you can. I mean, and what I'm trying
[25:07] to say is there is nothing, there is nothing technical that stops you from
[25:11] putting a nuclear warhead onto a Brummos. It would only be a question of
[25:15] whether you want to do that. The Brumos is a very different kind of
[25:18] weapon system. It's a cruise system. It's seen as a tactical weapon system.
[25:22] You already have your other weapons, you know, for you know,
[25:26] for a nuclear attack and things like that. So that's where it comes to
[25:29] the right. We'll talk also now of the missile, but we'll do that
[25:33] at a quick break. Eat eggs, no eat fiber, sleep, no
[25:42] take short naps, don't listen to others, no serve others. Do you
[25:47] ever feel like you're drowning in a pool of advice? This is Sonalia Charge,
[25:53] a healthy journalist for the last ten years, who is equally fed up
[25:57] of lines like ten ways to stay fit. So join me in the podcast
[26:03] Health Wealth as we learn about health from a completely new perspective where investing in
[26:07] yourself is not a task but simple, satisfying and joyful. Full episodes are
[26:14] available on Apple, Google, Spotify, and the India Today podcast website.
[26:18] Tune in now, Welcome back, Shave and I are discussing India's new U
[26:30] not nuclear sorry, India's cruise missile program. We've spent the first time of
[26:33] this episode talking about two recent missile tests that have happened, one of a
[26:37] ballistic missile, one of a cruise missiles missile will come to and also about
[26:41] the history of Promost which you know, Sha very nicely explain it, which
[26:45] I completely agree. Is I think a very sort of a crowning jewel.
[26:48] And it comes to I wouldn't say make in India, but still Elsie making
[26:51] India. Yeah, which is making it is making India am And you know,
[26:53] like you said before the break that, uh, this is a this
[26:59] is an example of Indian Russia getting everything right. Uh, this is an
[27:03] example of everything being on time, on track, there being no major delays.
[27:07] And you know, I've never heard of you know, India is running
[27:08] a short of missiles. You know, jets, we don't have enough fighter
[27:12] jets, but guns don't have enough normal like you know daily guns for our
[27:18] soldiers. Never heard India doesn't have enough missiles. You have this fantastic program
[27:22] has been achieved in miss churning out missiles as in when you want so great,
[27:27] great program. Amazing. Then my question so why did we develop it?
[27:33] By this is a missile that we that was last week. Like you've
[27:36] explained, there was a very important Indian component to it, which was the
[27:41] proposal system, because like the Brumos is dependent on for in tech. Then
[27:45] before this, before the one that was tested last week also used I'm guessing
[27:49] some sort of foreign tech, but this one used an Indian miniaturized engine,
[27:55] is what Ship had said at the start of this episode, which I'm guessing
[27:56] he'll get into now. So why did we then have this need to develop
[28:02] another missile and how is it different from the Brumos. Does it serve a
[28:06] separates purpose altogether or is it more of a demonstrative piece of technology, Because
[28:10] this is something you can say, we've developed this frum scratch on our own.
[28:12] We did not take any Russian help whatsoever. Yeah, so, very
[28:17] good question. Now, basically, to summarize your question, you're saying,
[28:21] if we've already got the Brummos and we've pretty much mastered it, where's the
[28:25] need to develop something called the Narby? Okay, for starters, the Nearby
[28:30] is a sub sonic cruise missile, which means it travels significantly slower than the
[28:34] Brummos, which might sound not sexy at all. Man, You've got like
[28:38] this raging fast missile. Why are you trying to develop something that's slower.
[28:42] Very important answer. Listen carefully to all of our viewers. The reason for
[28:47] it is that the Brummos when it was initially being developed, it was being
[28:52] developed as an anti ship weapon. It was not initially being developed as a
[28:56] land attack cruise missile. The attack mission for the Bromos was was almost like
[29:04] a secondary kind of thing that the users and developers realized it could be absolutely
[29:11] perfect for because this was a very capable system. They learned new things about
[29:14] the Brummers, you know, as they were developing it. So what was
[29:18] primarily an anti ship weapon where that kind of speed over the oceans with very
[29:25] little time for the enemy to engage with that missile was crucial. And that's
[29:30] why the Bromos is a Ramjet powered, very very high speed, supersonic cruise
[29:33] missile. When we're talking about land attack. When we're talking about land attack
[29:37] and I mean, you know, land to land missions of the kind that
[29:41] the nearby you know fulfills, you don't need that kind of you know,
[29:48] extreme high speed. Now, when I say a subsonic, subsonic is the
[29:52] way un sexy word. It makes it seem like this missiles just like crawling
[29:56] around it's not. It's moving really really fast. It's moving like a fighter
[29:59] jet. It's just not moving like the Brumos, like grummos. If you
[30:03] compare anything to the brumos, it's slow. So in that sense, yes
[30:06] it is, but you don't need that kind of speed because the brumos is
[30:11] game changing quality is its blinding speed. It doesn't give your adversary more than
[30:17] a couple of minutes to even react before the damn thing hits your ship or
[30:19] land or building or whatever it is. That is its beauty. The beauty
[30:23] of the beauty of the nearby is it's a very stealthy missile. It flies
[30:29] extremely low, it flies slow, and since it flies so low, it
[30:33] doesn't need that kind of blinding speed to get to its target point number two,
[30:37] by virtue of its speed and kind of smaller range of three n kilometers.
[30:42] Once you lodge the Brumos, you don't have very much time to cost
[30:45] correct. That thing is moving like you know, it's going to get there
[30:49] in a few minutes. You don't have time to you know, change cores
[30:52] or change guidance or track. It's a very very powerful and fast missile gets
[30:56] the job done really fast. The niarby by trying much lower, a little
[31:00] slower, it gives you that flexibility like the Tomahawk. Like the Tomahawk missile,
[31:04] you've got flexibility. It will have a camera on it, giving you,
[31:08] giving the person who has fired the missile the flexibility to cost correct,
[31:12] change targets, divert to something else if necessary, fly a little higher,
[31:18] fly a little lower, basically like your remote controlling in aircraft. And that's
[31:22] the reason why it is. And also remember that the Nearby has a range
[31:25] of like three times what the current current stated range of the Bromos is.
[31:30] So that's one of the reasons why the Narby has a very very separate kind
[31:34] of importance. Point number two, the nearby is most definitely going to be
[31:37] a nuclear capable missile, which comes back to your earlier question, which is
[31:41] that the BrahMos, whether or not it becomes nuclear capable is irrelevant. But
[31:47] India needed a purpose built cruise missile that from scratch has been developed with the
[31:53] intention that one day it's going to carry nuclear voices. The Bramos was a
[31:57] tactical anti shite weapon. You have to understand that. So if you at
[32:01] a later stage sling nuclear warheads onto it. It will be like an afterthought.
[32:06] It will be like a you know, t improved gurcahem sochaing it.
[32:09] But this is a purpose built cruise missile designed from scratch as a nuclear delivery
[32:15] system. So that's that's one major major difference. It's not a it's not
[32:20] it's not a bread and butter missile. The Brumos, as sexy as it
[32:22] is, is a bread and butter missile. It is for like conventional fighting
[32:27] in conventional missions. The Narby is for a like a long range strike and
[32:31] and not necessarily with conventional weapons. For a missile with a one thousand kilometer
[32:36] range, you don't want it to go there with the five hundred uh,
[32:39] you know kilogram conventional warhead. What's the point? What do you what do
[32:43] you want to hit at five hundred or at one thousand kilometer range, you
[32:46] know, with a with a with a small, piddly little warhead' obviously going
[32:50] to want a nuke on it. So that's the difference between the Brumos and
[32:53] the Nearby the other. The other important thing about the Nearby is that that
[32:58] the the ram jet engine on the Brumos is still a Russian engine. The
[33:04] heart and soul of the Brumos, whether we like it or not. When
[33:07] I say seventy eight percent of the Brumos is is Indian, that's that doesn't
[33:12] mean that the that the twenty two percent remaining that's Russian is not important.
[33:15] It's actually the heart and sol of the weapon. The ramjet high powered engine
[33:20] that powers the Brumos is still a Russian engine, and that and that has
[33:23] always been a you know, a point of abrasion for India, the fact
[33:28] that we don't have weapon propulsion systems for cruise missiles. You know, we
[33:32] haven't we haven't been able to build a jet engine for our fighter aircraft.
[33:37] The Kaveri project is something we've discussed in previous episodes. And therefore, building
[33:43] a smaller jet engine power cruise missiles and yuavs and drones and things like that
[33:46] was a far c right. It was going to be much more complicated.
[33:50] But by proving that technology, you've basically you've basically, you know, told
[33:55] the world, or at least told your armed forces that hey, look we've
[34:00] towered our own cruise missile with our own engine, which means, which means
[34:05] this is point zero. From here, we can do many more things now
[34:07] now that we've proven this engine, and and just just think of it as
[34:12] a like an engine about this big a turbo fan engine, about this big
[34:16] a fighter jet engine is obviously much much bigger, maybe as long as this
[34:20] stable. But if we look at the manic engine, it's about this big,
[34:25] small, little turbofan engine. Now, think of all of the things
[34:29] you can do with that engine. The NIBE is just one application. The
[34:32] real money in this is not the Niarbee. It's the engine. You can
[34:37] make drones out of it. You can make a stealth aircraft out of it.
[34:40] You can make you can theoretically make business jets out of it. You
[34:45] can make any other It could power small boats or ships or patrol craft,
[34:50] whatever it is. I'm just saying that the technology has been proven now,
[34:52] and that's that's a better reason than most reasons to actually develop a missile like
[35:00] them nearby, right. So, to extend that thought then, even like
[35:05] you said when when you talked about the brumos being fit onto a sukhoi that
[35:08] also a jugaard, extend that thought then, does gender then also or is
[35:14] already developing something that can also be fired is purposefully built for a fighter jet
[35:19] to fire from air towards the land, then we already have one actually,
[35:22] so there are there are two things right now. There are two air launched
[35:27] cruise missiles that India has. One of them is the BrahMos right, which
[35:30] is which is slung onto the Sukhois. Like you said, we have one
[35:35] full squadron of Sukhoi thirty fighters currently based in Tanjabadu, which it's basically the
[35:40] BrahMos a squadron. So you've got a air launched Brumos which is capable of
[35:45] hitting both ships and land targets. The other missile, which we haven't spoken
[35:50] about so far, is a very very important weapon that came with the Raphaal
[35:54] weapons package. It's called the Scalp. Yes, now, the Scalp is
[35:59] a is a British air launched cruise missile. The British actually call it Stormshadow
[36:04] and in France it's called Scalp. Now. Uh, it's it's a it's
[36:07] a funny looking kind of fat short missile on the you know, on the
[36:13] on the belly of the of the raphile, which you will see in many
[36:15] pictures. Uh. The Scalp is actually one of the most capable and formidable
[36:21] cruise missiles currently in service. The SCALP has a range, if I'm not
[36:24] mistaken, of about five hundred kilometers, which is a big fat range.
[36:30] The beauty of the SCALP is it's a stealthy cruise missile. Now. The
[36:35] the reason it's called a stealthy cruise missile is because it has very very powerful
[36:38] autonomous navigation systems and stuff. And once it's you know, once it's it's
[36:43] been pre fed a target using GPS and other things, and it's fired from
[36:47] a raffaele UH. It basically hugs mountains and terrain. It has a terrain
[36:52] mapping mode where it is practically invisible until it reaches its target. It's it's
[36:59] practical flying over terrain as per the altitude and dips and stuff. It dips
[37:05] and dives and rises over terrain until it reaches its target. Because it contains
[37:09] a very very high resolution camera it has, it has a GPS mapped kind
[37:15] of track for its flight path, so it basically knows what it's going to
[37:19] be flying over before it flies over it, so it knows that flight path.
[37:22] UH. And India has those. India has those scalps because the Scalps
[37:27] came with the weapons package that the Rapha had, so very very important system.
[37:31] So we've got the Brumos, we've got the Scalp. The Niarby theoretically
[37:37] could also be a a launched version. Now the Niarby, you know,
[37:42] like you said, the juguard that was used to make a big, unwieldy,
[37:45] fat missile like the BrahMos, you know, capable of being carried by
[37:50] a fighter, means that even the Narby can potentially do that. One of
[37:54] the one of the interesting offshoots of the BrahMos program was that recognizing that the
[38:00] Bromos was too big for to be carried, and believe me, they had
[38:04] to do a lot of modifications to the Sokoi to carry the uh to carry
[38:07] the Bromos. It was more than just jugad there to strengthen the undercarriage there,
[38:10] to modify you know, the wing root structures. There was a different
[38:15] kind of you know, pylon for the missile to be held on to.
[38:17] The release mechanism was different, lots of software changes, so it wasn't just
[38:22] you know, cello lagadoo. There are a lot of changes that needed to
[38:25] be made and that that actually was one of the most delayed aspects of a
[38:30] Bromos program, which was otherwise pretty much on track, like we said,
[38:32] but but once they figured that out, you know, doing something with the
[38:37] nearby et cetera will not be difficult. But as a as almost as the
[38:42] kind of symbol of how Bramos as a company and as a product was listening
[38:47] to its customers really really closely. They saw the Indian Air Force look and
[38:52] saying, yeah, this missile is too big for our planes. Can't you
[38:54] give us can't you use the same technology, you know, make the missile
[38:58] a little smaller. And I I've seen drawings, I've seen drawings where Bramos
[39:02] has pitched a pitched a weapon called the BrahMos NG or the Bramos Mini,
[39:07] which was supposed to be a much smaller weapons system, about half the size
[39:10] of the Brumos and vastly reduced in weight but practically the same capability. It's
[39:17] three hundred kilometers hypersonic, all that stuff, a supersonic et cetera, and
[39:22] miniaturized to such an extent that rafaile would be able to Rafaele type aircraft would
[39:28] be able to carry three of those missiles, which is an enormous boost.
[39:31] Now, I don't know for sure whether that missile is still on the table
[39:36] at this point of time. I think it must be because I remember reading
[39:39] something about it a couple of years ago. But this is just to show
[39:44] you that, you know, the Bromos doesn't want to leave space for other
[39:46] weapons. It wants to give the Air Force the Navy everything that they can
[39:50] possibly have. The next, of course, is the submarine launched version.
[39:52] They've tested it, but we still don't have a platform that can fire the
[39:58] Brumos. So our next, uh, you know, submarine lines the Project
[40:01] seventy five India. One of the baseline requirements is that it has to be
[40:06] able to fire the BrahMos. Right. One of the last closing thoughts on
[40:10] this on this episode, going back again to history, So India, I'm
[40:15] glad you brought up SCALP because that actually is a rare foreign cruise missile in
[40:20] India's inventory. I think since whenever Bromos entered the India's India's armory, I
[40:25] think it was in two thousand and five, if I'm not wrong, mid
[40:28] mid two thousands, most of India's cruisem cells have been more or less Indian,
[40:32] Like we've said, promos is mostly Indian. You now have the as
[40:35] well. How did this happen? So we've discussed this very very shortly about
[40:38] the ballistic missile program as well, how it was entirely Indian. Obviously helped
[40:43] a lot by India Space Agency because you used to need to have rockets,
[40:46] something that relacked with the cruise miss hells egentes which we now have. But
[40:52] what was it like before or was this the when India realized, you know,
[40:57] let it be, We'll just do it on our own. We don't
[40:59] want the world hell, because I in my such could not only come across
[41:02] a time or situation with India had to be dependent on a foreign country like
[41:07] we have with most of US military hardware for cruise missiles. Yeah, no,
[41:10] you're you're absolutely right. You know. The thing is UH, the
[41:14] the Integrated Guided Missile Program, the i g mdp UH you know off which
[41:20] Kalam and all those great the missile boys of Dr d O were part of
[41:23] UH. In the in the in the seventies and eighties, there was a
[41:28] there was an incredible kind of realization in the country that that while India has
[41:34] no choice but to be dependent on foreign sources for certain kinds of military hardware
[41:38] fighter jets, submarines, helicopters and things like that which we can't build very
[41:44] quickly. It was realized quite early on that that we have enough you know,
[41:52] technologists and confidence in the country to actually get moving quite quickly on guided
[41:57] missiles. Now, to the credit of d r D which which you know
[42:00] gets a bashing mostly justified for its you know, lofty promises and slow delivery
[42:07] on on many fronts, it's an it's an incredibly competent organization. There is
[42:10] no doubt about that. Uh as far as guided missiles program is concerned.
[42:16] They scored superbly and consistently, you know, under the guidance of whether it
[42:22] was a apj abdul Kalam or vik sarasworth many scientists before that, Tessie Thomas,
[42:28] who was the first woman uh, you know, scientist head of the
[42:30] missile cluster of the d r d O. The DRDO has had a very
[42:35] consistent uh uh kind of professionalism, competence uh and commitment to timelines and delivery
[42:44] compared to any of its other product portfolio. So right from the word go,
[42:49] guided missiles has been a kind of we got this. You know,
[42:52] we got this. We know this is this is stuff we do. You
[42:54] know, we don't need this. Uh. The reason why it was also
[42:59] uh comp in from the start is because because countries will not share ballistic missile
[43:04] technology with you. And this was an age when we were not even talking
[43:07] about cruise missiles. Cruise missiles was nowhere on the horizon for US, and
[43:13] as a country that had conducted nuclear tests since the seventies, uh, and
[43:17] you know, was sort of moving to post liberalization towards a much more aspirational
[43:22] kind of country that needed to invest more in its national security. The guided
[43:27] missile program was vastly successful. We were able to very very quickly develop the
[43:30] PRITHVI and put it into service, very quickly developed the Ugly series and put
[43:36] them into service. Then postcard Gill, you had the Strategic Forces Command that
[43:39] came into action, the first trifle, you know, nuclear command of the
[43:43] country came into action. You had your nuclear doctrine. So so the regularity
[43:49] and the sort of competence with which this whole program came together gave India an
[43:55] enormous amount of confidence in terms of long range missile delivery systems. Was concerned.
[44:01] There was slightly less success in terms of certain other missile systems, like
[44:06] our anti tank missile systems like KNOB took a while. Surface to air missile
[44:10] systems had glitches, they took a while to actually come on board. You
[44:15] know, I might get bashed for this also. But the reason for some
[44:19] of these things is because missiles like the Akash, which are surface to air
[44:22] missiles or air to air missiles like the Austra or other such systems, non
[44:25] blistic missiles are much more complicated systems. Ballistic missiles. I'm not saying they're
[44:30] uncomplicated. They're not, but they are when you compare them with other kinds
[44:36] of guided missiles, they are relatively more elementary systems. You build a rocket,
[44:40] you build a modular you know, structure and architecture, you design,
[44:45] design a reasonably robust kind of software system to guide these missiles, et cetera,
[44:50] and you've got the damn thing. Pat Now, I'm not running that
[44:53] down. I'm not saying that, oh, it was an easy system to
[44:55] build, that's why India mastered ballistic missiles. Far from it. I'm just
[44:59] saying that post that when India attempted to build other kinds of missiles. They
[45:05] were much bigger challenges, and India has executed them amazingly. They took some
[45:08] of them took their time, like the Akash, you know, and the
[45:12] and the nag et cetera. But they've come on board, they've come online.
[45:15] And that also is why a country like India had the confidence to tell
[45:19] Russia bring the Bramos to us, We'll give you the rest of the technology.
[45:22] The seeker, the architecture, the initial rocket motor, they're all Indian,
[45:27] Indian things. And you don't get to have that kind of technology if
[45:30] you haven't got your foundation right for decades together. Cruise missiles is a separate
[45:36] for the reasons I said in my first answer is because a cruise missile involves
[45:42] technologies that are that are so completely different from ballistic missile technology. Now,
[45:49] ballistic missile technologies were also a success because of your space program, Like you
[45:52] rightly said, in your space program, you've mastered rockets, you've mastered trajectories,
[45:57] you've mastered re entry vehicles, You've mastered all of those things. So
[46:00] therefore, your ballistic missile program benefited from that competence, and ISRO also benefited
[46:06] from DRDO. Let's not forget it's a two way street. But cruise missiles
[46:09] are a different technology that India hadn't gotten into for a long time. And
[46:15] the way that India didn't really manage to show a great deal of competence in
[46:21] building an engine an engine is precisely manifested in the fact that we didn't have
[46:27] our own cruise missile for the longest time. A cruise missile is nothing without
[46:30] a jet engine, either a turbojet or a turbofan engine. You need an
[46:34] engine in order to have a cruise missile. Now, remember that the nearby
[46:37] that we've tested just now. The reason why I'm saying we should be screaming
[46:42] from the rooftops because it's an Indian engine is because all the tests of the
[46:45] nearby theve until now have been conducted with a Russian engine called the NPO Saturn
[46:52] thirty six empty, which is a small turbofan engine. So oh, okay,
[46:58] fine, yeah, cool. You know it's an Indian cruise missile,
[47:00] but it's still a Russian engine. Nothing more unsexy than that, Nothing more
[47:04] unsexy than having an Indian missile with a Russian engine. Now you've got an
[47:08] Indian cruise missile with an Indian engine. Now it's an Indian weapon. Up
[47:13] until now it was not because because the the missile architecture, the warhead,
[47:19] the fins, the shape, the sexiness of it. That's the easy part.
[47:22] That's and I'm saying this for the fourth time, that's the easy part.
[47:27] It's the engine where you finally meet your maker, where you have to
[47:31] go through hell to develop a real technology. So that's why it's taking its
[47:36] time to happen. Right, great answer, and uh man, I agree
[47:40] with you. Your point. Even kind of got that feeling that a ballistic
[47:45] missile compared to let's say a cruise missile or the other missage, is comparatively
[47:52] easier tech because you know, very simply put, at at points in that
[47:57] particular missiles trajectory, you're also using nats the force of nature for that,
[48:02] whereas with cruise missiles you're kind of fighting nature. You get immense speed and
[48:07] then trying to better absolutely that that I think is what makes them even sexier.
[48:12] True. Right, as we bring this episode to a close, couple
[48:15] of nuggets like we do then at that episode and one for the internet and
[48:20] one for a producer Anna who during the break said that, you know,
[48:22] if you could bring in some politics in this or some international affairs in this,
[48:27] it will be a bit it will be a better episode. So we'll
[48:29] do that. That is second nugget. The first one whenever India issues and
[48:32] not tam along the Bay of Bengal is the notice to air men essentially saying
[48:37] keep stay away from this ata because more or les there's going to be a
[48:39] missile test. Everyone speculates of a potential Key four or K five. I'm
[48:45] not sure which one is supposed to happen now. It's basically a summarine launched
[48:49] my listing missile test. Even yesterday when that first press less came up before
[48:52] journalists like you could tell us what exact missile was tested, when it was
[48:57] just said that it was a medium range missile, people like hah oh,
[49:00] yeah. India has blisting rest from it's from its nuclear Shumbarine. So far
[49:05] no such official announcement. Again, I forget which one is supposed to be
[49:08] tested, But this test, I don't know, for some reason, seems
[49:10] to be long time coming. Why is it so, and is it really
[49:14] that you know, we are very close to one fresh launch or a test
[49:16] launch or for nuclear launched blisting. It definitely is now. This submarine launched
[49:22] ballistic missile test has been on the on the table for a while now,
[49:28] for many for many months. As a matter of fact, now there was
[49:31] one particular test I think it was in March that was canceled at the last
[49:37] minute. Uh as I understand it, there were some weather issues that that
[49:42] came up. Now, usually when weather issues come up, people say weather
[49:45] say, yeah, the missile should be fired in any weather, which is
[49:49] true. You know, when it comes to actual combat, a missile will
[49:52] be fired in any weather. But the reason why it couldn't be test fired
[49:55] in that weather is because you're trying to observe the missile. If you have
[50:00] bad weather, you're not going to be able to get all your data from
[50:02] that missile. So that's why you need good weather for a missile test.
[50:07] And I hope that's a you know, important myth busting fact because otherwise people
[50:12] say, what kind of useless missile is this? If you're canceling it because
[50:15] soda reyna and stuff. So that's that's that's that's the reason why it happened.
[50:19] So there were telemetry issues the ships would not be able to observe the
[50:22] missile because of cloud cover and stuff, and that's why it was canceled.
[50:25] But I understand it's back on the cards right now. This could be either
[50:29] the K four or the K five. Now the K four is uh,
[50:32] you know, and I love how tantalizing this world is because because unlike the
[50:37] UGNI, the K four, K five uh, you know, arsenal,
[50:43] there is absolutely zero confirmation about which missile has been tested, how many times,
[50:47] whether it's already in service with the arihant. You know, there are
[50:52] some stray articles here and there kind of suggesting it, but there's absolutely no
[50:55] you know, full fledged confirmation of this. Now, you know, there
[51:00] is a short range submarine launched ballistic missile called the Sagarika which is already in
[51:06] service, called the K fifteen, if I'm not mistaken, But the K
[51:08] four and K five are still you know, under under trial right now.
[51:14] And these are your true blue, like we said in a previous episode,
[51:16] these are your true blue, you know, ocean launched, submarine launched nuclear
[51:21] weapons. So so yeah, my my sense is it will happen any any
[51:27] time. Now. Any of the note times that come out now will be
[51:30] one of these. And the important thing to note here is they won't be
[51:34] long range tests because they're not. They're not right now, they're not testing
[51:37] them at range. They already know that the range is not something they need
[51:39] to test that oh oh hey, because these are modifications of your ugnies,
[51:44] So they don't need to test range. They need to test the crucial emergence
[51:47] of the missile from the launcher bubbling up to the surface, with the second
[51:52] stage of the missile, you know, triggering, and then it going into
[51:54] its launch. So those are the technologies that are being tested. So don't
[51:59] be fooled by the length of the low time exactly. So now to the
[52:02] second nugget, like I said, for a producer and where we'll bring international
[52:06] affairs and a bit of politics India and Pakistan. Because you talk Brummos,
[52:10] you have to talk about that that happened I got when a couple of years
[52:15] ago, a few years ago, a few years ago. We've briefly mentioned
[52:17] this in a previous episode, the misfiring of a Brummos missile that happened from
[52:22] India towards Pakistan. We've talked about how it was, yes, an embarrassment
[52:25] for India. How it was a bigger embarrassment for Pakistan, which would not
[52:28] track the missile it realized the missile was there after it or crashed somewhere in
[52:31] its territory. But yes, an embarrassment for India. What I want to
[52:36] talk about is not the India Pakistan, but actually what want to talk about
[52:38] is a few years down the line, because back then there a lot of
[52:42] speculation. One theory was KEDSI I just test they go fire war at hogan
[52:46] Us Masson. I think will happen. War won't be triggered, but let's
[52:50] fire an empty dart do missile and see if they're able to track it or
[52:52] not. That theory I think has been tanked because officers have been fired over
[52:57] this, so they're obviously a mistake. Was it knowledged? So India has
[53:00] said there was a mistake made. Now I want to talk about what that
[53:02] mistake could be because that is not out in public domain. I don't expect
[53:07] that out. That will be out in public domain. You will have your
[53:08] theories, you will have spoken to people to tell us about it. Uh
[53:14] And my larger my theory or my question then is it that because what I
[53:20] think, what the army has said there was some maintenance or training happening and
[53:24] some sort of misfiring happens. Yeah, yeah, misfiring happened. So my
[53:29] question then, is is it that at any given time a set number of
[53:34] missiles are pre programmed to go to certain locations in Pakistan? Because then the
[53:40] understanding would be, because these are dangerous missiles, you'd obviously feed in the
[53:44] the coordinates just before launching and not have them set inside. So, yeah,
[53:47] what may have gone wrong in that episode? And also a slight nugget
[53:51] in terms of what is the human reaction in that in that cabin so to
[53:55] speak, when something like this happens. How how does that person over there
[53:59] feel like what have I done? Or what will happened? So so a
[54:02] good question on the on the target coordinates. No, I look, missiles
[54:07] being primed and ready is a is a given, especially in our frontline,
[54:13] frontline units and frontline areas. This particular missile was fired from somewhere in Punjab.
[54:16] If I'm not mistaken, I don't think, to the best of my
[54:21] information, I don't think target coordinates are pre fed into a missile for the
[54:25] simple reason that designating targets and firing a missile is not a complicated process.
[54:31] Now the question is does India already have target coordinates ready to feed into a
[54:37] missile if the need arises one hundred percent? Yes, there are high value
[54:42] targets across Pakistan and vice versa. I'm sure of, you know, vital
[54:47] installations, buildings, bridges, highways, important you know, establishments, et
[54:52] cetera, which are obviously not going to move. Those are stationary targets which
[54:58] you have. And those those those coordinates all all yours. You know,
[55:02] need to know. Military planners have you know, target dossiers with them.
[55:07] So it's just a matter of feeding that data into your missiles and firing them
[55:10] to put it. Put it very simply, so having pre fed that data
[55:16] and stuff, the need doesn't arise because it just takes a couple of minutes
[55:21] to do something like that. Point number two about what would have happened in
[55:24] that cabin once this happened, I think, you know, I've actually thought
[55:29] about this quite often and I've tried to find out he Juakia once this happened.
[55:32] You know, did these guys even realize that a Bromos had you know,
[55:36] blasted off? And did they know where it was going. Now,
[55:40] my sense is there must have been utter a sense of being completely dazed for
[55:45] a moment. You know, did that actually happen? Because you know,
[55:51] because while we're talking about it in a slightly lighter way, in what happened
[55:54] was absolutely unthinkable. It could have triggered war between two guns trees which have
[56:00] fought war four times. Uh. The fact that war didn't happen is more
[56:06] is more telling about Pakistan than it is of India. But let's not be
[56:08] easy on ourselves. And the fact that the you know, four officers I
[56:12] think have been cashiered from service tells you that India is not taking this lightly
[56:15] at all. We've we've taken action against those officers. The Air Force has.
[56:20] But there would have been complete panic within that cabin, a sense of
[56:25] disbelief because you can't bring that missile back. It's gone and it's a brummos,
[56:30] which means like tin charman it may so they would have been there would
[56:36] have been a sense of disbelief. And also because they've the Air Force and
[56:40] especially in missile units across the Air Force, you have to understand is is
[56:45] a highly safety crucial force. For a reason, everything in the Air Force.
[56:52] I'm not saying the Army and the Navy are not. I'm just saying
[56:54] that when it comes to aviation, things that are in the air or things
[56:58] that are taking off from the ground, and the safety aspects get becomes exponentially
[57:02] more important, which is why the Air Force has many additional SOPs in terms
[57:08] of safety, in terms of priming a weapon, in terms of what all
[57:13] things need to be made sure of during maintenance, what all things need to
[57:16] be switched off during training, those kinds of sps, they're like non negotiable.
[57:22] The margin for error in terms of safety in the Air Force, visive,
[57:25] the Army, in the Navy is extremely extremely small because here if those
[57:32] things are violated, you've seen what happens. A missile has taken off,
[57:37] or a jet will crash, or something won't happen on an aircraft before it
[57:39] takes off, and then that crisis will happen in the air. So therefore
[57:44] they would have been complete panic and disbelief because because the Air Force trains relentlessly,
[57:52] relentlessly, relentlessly during peacetime to make sure something like this doesn't happen.
[57:55] That's what peace time is for. When you're not fighting a war. All
[57:59] you're doing is training to make sure you're ready for war. And this kind
[58:01] of thing goes to the very heart of preparation. Now, just just think
[58:06] about it. What could be worse than a frontline missile unit accidentally firing a
[58:12] missile at the country with which you fort the most number of wars. Nothing
[58:15] is worse than that. Nothing is worse than that. I'm actually frankly surprised
[58:19] that only four officers has been fired, but yeah, it it. The
[58:24] only good news in all of this is that is that the Air Force would
[58:29] have been completely shocked by something like this. There must be still disbelief in
[58:32] that unit that esau. Actually, who are It's not a bad dream,
[58:37] It's really really happened. It's a nightmare. It's the worst thing that can
[58:40] happen for a missile unit. Right, So we'll end it there. Thanks
[58:45] Shift once again, and I think for a change, when we talk about
[58:47] India's defense equipment strategy, India's defense equipment status, India's defense equipment development programs,
[58:55] this is a happy episode for a change. Not much cribbing, not
[59:00] much. You know, this was delayed. That was that was not red
[59:02] This was not red this was like a you know more was like look a
[59:06] pretty picture, so to speak of India's cruise miss held the sunny side of
[59:10] Indian defense. Yes, so great. Chat had a lot of had a
[59:14] lot of lots of fun and I hope our listen to them you enjoyed it
[59:16] as well, and if you did, you know, please leave us are
[59:19] rating. If you're listening to us on Apple podcasts for Spotify, and if
[59:22] you're listening to us on YouTube, please give us a comment in the comment
[59:23] section below and do let us know if this is in a particular topic that
[59:27] you want us to talk about. Thanks as always to our producer and Redition.
[59:30] That's it for this week's defense toes for more Tunion next week. Then
[59:32] stay safe and do not trust any bound is that passport

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
