# China Standoff Not Just On Land, Also In Air | In Our Defence, Ep 72

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 17 Aug 2023, 47 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/56501230/17_aug_23_in_our_defence_17_aug_128.mp3

A brand-new airbase has been established at an incredibly high altitude of over 13,000 feet. This airbase is designed to boost our ability to respond to a more assertive China. It includes fighter aircraft, advanced radars, and upgraded drones, all aimed at improving surveillance in Ladakh. Named the Nyoma air base, it's the third such facility in Ladakh for fighter aircraft operations. There are already similar bases in Leh and Thoise. The Nyoma air base's construction has begun, and it's less than 50 kilometers away from the Line of Actual Control (LAC), the border between India and China. Is this going to make a big difference? Why did India decide to build this airbase now? What series of events have led to the Indian defense establishment to finally take this decision? Will it allow us to reach more targets effectively? &nbsp;Does it enhance range of striking? Will it be formidable against Chinese aggression? Listen in! Produced by Anna Priyadarshini Sound Mix by Sachin Dwivedi

## Transcript

[0:01] This is in there today podcasts. There are boundary disputes and then there are
[0:07] outright wars, hot and cold, diplomatic and military. In this podcast,
[0:13] we will dissect all that's brutal and subtle about the defense of our nations.
[0:18] I am Dave Goswami, your host, and I will be joined by Abishak
[0:22] Bala, who's been on the front lines of wars and conflicts and has seen
[0:26] the Indian military up close. Hello and welcome and a very happy Independence Day
[0:35] to all our listeners and viewers and a happy independency to you to Apprehik.
[0:39] Recording day later by the way, sixty day day later. And unlike most
[0:44] of the people that we know, we were not off. We don't have
[0:49] the luxury of extended weekends either during national holidays because they were around for us.
[0:54] Actually, we had to come early to office because of I mean I
[0:56] didn't become that much early to office, but the day started a little.
[1:00] We have a listen to the speech. Yeah, yeah, so yeah,
[1:03] busy, busy week, busy a few days and it was a good speech.
[1:08] I thought I won't go into the good as in it was an interesting
[1:11] one. You would expect prime Minister like mister Moody to give interesting speeches.
[1:18] Yeah, definitely and quite I think you'll agree with with me that he did
[1:22] sound the pole bugle. He doesn't need, he doesn't need the Independence Day
[1:27] too, red Fort and parts of red Fort to be sounding the pole bugle.
[1:33] Definitely. I think the speeches in Parliament by both the Home Minister and
[1:38] the Prime Minister were also you know, oh, definitely signaling what's going to
[1:45] happen in the next few months. The kind of discourse rhetoric. Yeah,
[1:49] that's expected. Yeah, pretty much. The election of season is on us,
[1:53] so I mean, pretty exciting time. So BJP is like the Australian
[1:57] cricket team of the nineties and the the two thousands, you know, ruthless
[2:01] or the West Indian team of the seventies and eighteen. No scope for anybody,
[2:07] any inch to get back if if they feel that they are doing well,
[2:13] they'll even go whole hog, you know, to consolidate that. It's
[2:19] like that, so completely unexpected lines and just like this is to clarify,
[2:23] you know, for everyone. I think what he means is not as much
[2:25] as he means more on the lines of how a length is the parties when
[2:30] election issues, and it's not as do you support, they're no letups,
[2:34] they're no letups. No, this is my opinion. Yes, it's not
[2:36] a question of support exactly. That's support or or not support, no support,
[2:43] It's just just an observation that anybody can make any any of any person
[2:46] who observes any politics will definitely the BJP of the last ten years, not
[2:52] tenny, I think last at least six seven, eight years. Yeah,
[2:54] I mean ten years. You can say since the elections, they just do
[2:58] not give any inch to anybody. So that's that. So speaking of giving
[3:04] inches, and just once again did not plan this by the not scripted at
[3:07] all, just so happened segue giving inches of land, something that we discussed
[3:13] so often on this podcast. In our defense. Let's go back once again
[3:17] to China, and this time I'm going to turn the tables a bit.
[3:21] I don't know if I have a producer will like this, but I'm going
[3:23] to stop playing the host for a few seconds. I'm going to let it
[3:25] be Shake introduce the topic of this week's episode, because this is actually a
[3:31] story that he himself wrote and kind of broke earlier this week. So what
[3:37] are you talking about it this week. Before I get into that, there's
[3:39] a good Slottle story that it's just come to mind because we were discussing Independence
[3:44] Day. I mean, I spent all day literally watching a beautiful, beautiful
[3:51] video that was going viral and it was I played it on Loop, share
[3:55] it with my mother, My wife showed it to my kids. And since
[4:00] we are talking uniform in our defense, young sick soldier he comes back,
[4:09] probably after his training or something, to his home and you must watch that
[4:14] video, and I, if it's possible, we can ask Anna to maybe
[4:17] have an made or something of that video. Young guy reaches his home is
[4:25] obviously somewhere in Punjab, and he marches up to his elders. They're at
[4:31] the gate welcoming him, and he salutes and that crisp paratone voice, he
[4:42] does a gen gen sab to all the elders from his grandparents to maybe parents,
[4:49] uncles, aren't whoever. There so lovely video. I mean, it
[4:53] just it was a perfect, perfect video to be seen on Independence Day and
[4:59] a lot of veterans were sharing it as well. I also got it on
[5:02] one of the groups that I am where there are a lot of veterans,
[5:05] So I thought it's important to mention. Yeah, nicely Lovely thought we'll have
[5:11] a We'll see if we can have a link to the video in the description
[5:14] of the show. So, yeah, talking about this week's episode, Like
[5:15] I said, explain and tell us why are we going to talk about what
[5:18] I'm going to talk about? Yeah, So a couple of things. One,
[5:21] because the nineteenth round of the Cookemon the levels happened and on expected lines,
[5:28] nothing has moved forward. I'm tired of those statements. By the way,
[5:31] it's like in a boiler player, useless exactly, it doesn't mean anything,
[5:34] and it's a stalemate. Let's let's face it, it's a stalemate.
[5:39] I think these this dialogue is done to make sure that there are no further
[5:44] escalations sort of that was the fire. Every three four months you have some
[5:48] kind of a discussion to make sure that you don't want a repeat of what
[5:53] happened in twenty twenty. There were clashes, Galwan happened. THO was an
[5:59] incident into firing, which obviously has been denied, but yeah, it did
[6:02] happen. We all know. This is really about ensuring the statement. Yes,
[6:06] yeah, and although the Indian side talks about depth, song planes,
[6:13] demp chalk. The Chinese are not budging. They say that this has nothing
[6:17] to do with what happened in twenty twenty. The stand of twenty twenty,
[6:21] the pre dates that stand off as far as the friction points were concerned.
[6:26] For five friction points, disengagement has happened there. And then we talk about
[6:30] places patrol points where we are blocked. We cannot go because the Chinese are
[6:38] holding onto those positions. Again, the Chinese are not very forthcoming, and
[6:42] they say pre dates the twenty twenty standoff. So yeah, I mean they
[6:47] lead nowhere. So it's the nineteenth round. Four months down the line,
[6:53] there'll be the twentieth. They'll be the twenty first, twenty two, third,
[6:57] fourth, fifth, We don't know. But in the middle of all
[7:01] this there was there was an interesting news break that we happened to do and
[7:10] which was about India finally, you know, moving ahead with plans to set
[7:17] up a new fighter air base in Ladak in a place called Numa. Now
[7:26] there is an airfield in Numa transport aircraft do operate out of their Helicopter operations
[7:32] have happened. In fact, at the peak of that tussle in twenty twenty
[7:38] when a lot of logistics were being sent to forward areas. The Indian Air
[7:44] Force use their transport aircraft, the Chinook helicopters. Also the Apache combat helicopters
[7:53] were deployed and they were operating out of there. So Apache is a combat
[7:58] helicopter, so you wouldn't want would get the sense that we are we are
[8:01] are deployments as far as air assets was concerned, was extremely offensive. And
[8:07] finally, finally the project is moving forward and hopefully in the next year or
[8:13] a little over a year you'll have profiles two thirties or whatever fight aircraft you
[8:18] want to operate from there. As the cliche goes a game changer, well,
[8:24] yes, certainly a game changer because it just gives you flexibility. Currently
[8:31] Indian Indian Air Force has two fighter bases in Ladak, ones Thoice and the
[8:37] other Day. It's not as if flying from lay and reaching the forward locations
[8:43] takes a lot of time. It's a matter of fight, it's a matter
[8:46] of a few minutes. But it's just the range and the flexibility that you're
[8:54] fleet has with the fighter a base about forty fifty away from the LC and
[9:01] worst case scenario, if there was there happens to be a war, that
[9:07] time further comes down to respond. And see, there has been a series
[9:13] of events that has led to the Indian Defense Establishment finally taking this decision.
[9:18] And some of those events were, you know, in twenty twenty twenty one,
[9:22] the Chinese Air Force ramped up its facilities closer to the border areas.
[9:31] Like anything, they either made new air bases or they upgraded the older ones
[9:37] like the one that we are doing with the with Nioma that it felt that
[9:41] you know, they're up to something. Then there was several instances of if
[9:46] you can call them, I don't know technically they were air incursions or not,
[9:52] but yes, they flew very close to the LC and we had to
[9:56] scramble our jets. So this cat and mouse game was happening. So now
[10:03] two things. One a debtor in that we are extremely close, the response
[10:07] time comes down considerably. The other is that you're striking capabilities. Since you're
[10:16] already closer to the LAC, your range of striking also enhances by the time.
[10:24] Even if it takes two three four minutes. The moment you I am
[10:28] born, you are in a in a position to strike deep inside within a
[10:33] matter of a few seconds. So I think, yeah, I mean to
[10:37] put that in a gist. That's what the thinking behind it is. And
[10:41] what I'm hearing is that very soon defense minsters are not saying will himself go
[10:46] to new check on the check on the progress. And it shows that,
[10:50] you know, the top leadership is very keen on this kind of a project.
[10:56] And the other aspect is that everybody's talking theater commands and I don't know
[11:00] when will happen, but there's definitely a big push to jointness synergy within the
[11:05] forces. We saw that jointness again in twenty twenty. I was there in
[11:09] twenty twenty in Ladak when all this was happening and there was a huge operation
[11:15] carried out by the Air Force Army just to insure supplies, logistics. Forget
[11:20] about war fighting capabilities. You first need the war fighting machinery. And when
[11:26] we say war fighting machinery, it's not just military platforms. It's Russian yes,
[11:33] it's sleeping bags, it's tens arctic tents that were brought in that can
[11:39] sustain that cold clothing, building material for building material. Because that was the
[11:43] first time you were going to have a deployment which was three or four times
[11:48] more of the usual deployment. Around sixty soldiers. Sixty eight thousand soldiers were
[11:54] airlifted by the Indian Air Force. These numbers have again recently come up the
[12:01] accurate numbers sixty eight thousand additional tanks. Three hundred plus armored personal carriers or
[12:11] infantry combat vehicles in military parlance, they're called BMPs the Russian infantry combat vehicles
[12:18] that we use. Basically, these are these are carriers where infantry men can
[12:24] get into and be transported closure to humbies I think of the US Army.
[12:31] They're slightly different, slightly different from humbies. And then they have a small
[12:35] gun as well. Yeah, that's why people sometimes mistake them for tanks.
[12:39] They are not tanks. So three hundred plus artlery guns. So this whole
[12:46] gamut of infrastructure and machinery that was taken there has not been brought back.
[12:52] So you are in that war machinery mold even now three years down the line
[13:00] and with things like Neoma projects like Neoma today it's Nonoma tomorrow it could be
[13:05] another air base where we could have fighter capabilities. Who knows there is another
[13:09] air base called Foch. Again, it doesn't have fighter capabilities dB of course
[13:15] all of us know doesn't have fighter capabilities. But if the need be see
[13:20] this is a thirteen seven hundred feet and it's an old airbase. It's not
[13:24] something that has come up right now. It's been there since nineteen sixty two.
[13:30] So it's the basic facility is there, but to upgrade it for a
[13:35] fighter requires a lot of work. You need a better, longer runway.
[13:41] There was there was a problem of wildlife clearances because when you expand that airbase
[13:46] then you are getting into reserve forest area. There's a wildlife sanctuary in the
[13:52] vicinity. So wildlife clearances were needed, which which I have been given.
[13:56] Now, So imagine the kind of paperwork that goes into and which is fine,
[14:01] you know, I mean environment for us, these are important things as
[14:07] well, and so even for something like the defense of the country, if
[14:11] you need to take these clearances, so be it's all that all that has
[14:15] been done, so which gives you an indication that the government, the military
[14:22] wants to work at this at great speed. Yeah, yeah, you know,
[14:28] the last thing you mentioned. I think that's one of the things I
[14:30] wanted to discuss with you when you said that you want to talk about this
[14:33] topic on this episode, and I wanted to expand on that. What does
[14:35] it take I'm to set up fighter jet airpace. I mean just in pure
[14:41] le manage, like for example, you mentioned longer runway, so apart from
[14:45] that, like the kind of infrastructure you need to have for example, maintenance
[14:48] shards, kind of housing in it to First of all, you know,
[14:52] if you're going to have your fighter assets there, you need to make sure
[14:56] that if you have good defensive defense system exactly very pressure isn't any expensive.
[15:01] So I mean that's the foremost concern. Going going back to the film Border,
[15:07] it just just stuck me right now. So this Air force officer who's
[15:11] played by Jackie Straft, he tells u S who plays Major Chan NBC by
[15:20] the way, one, that we have to start from scratch and build an
[15:26] air piece. And you chaps are lucky you have you have you have the
[15:33] BSF there, you just have to go and take over. But we have
[15:35] to start from scratch. So there's in war, there's also there's also a
[15:41] concern that you're air fields will be struck first. So if you're if you're
[15:48] building something new and it's visible to the enemy. They would want to hit
[15:52] that first, so it's a it's a double vaman. You want to work
[15:56] quickly to make sure that you have a base which can operate fighters, but
[16:02] there's also a concern that these places will be hit first. So this is
[16:07] peace time, it's not warm, so it's the right right time to upgrade
[16:11] and enhance your facilities, so to put to put it in a very basic
[16:18] manner, I know, that's what it takes. You need to ensure that
[16:22] you have good safeguards in case there is an offensive against you, and of
[16:26] course it should have all the bare minimum requirements for a fighter aircraft to land
[16:33] and take off and simply put. But defenses is even more important. That
[16:38] makes a lot more so you need to have your air defenses accordingly deployed.
[16:44] The surveillance, of course, is another aspect, and that's the reason why
[16:49] you know the Heron Mark two are also being deployed now in these places and
[16:56] Heron Mark Mark two again and Israeli uav drone has combat capabilities, so it's
[17:03] not just surveillance that you are wanting to enhance. You are sending a message
[17:10] of veterans that okay, not not just the new fighter a base, but
[17:14] we're also getting combat capable drones here, So it's showing the full picture.
[17:21] Sometimes telling the adversary what we have and what we are capable of doing is
[17:26] part of those mind games. And yeah, I mean it's that's what is
[17:30] happening, because that's what That's exactly what China was doing about two two years
[17:34] back when they were enhancing and upgrading their air bases, not just in exsitchin
[17:40] across Ladak, but even in other sectors, even across Arunache, even across
[17:45] Utra Hunt. I had done a story showing about sixteen seventeen air bases that
[17:52] they are ampting. Remember the map we had done. So I think we're
[17:57] trying to catch up. Of course, one a base source of sixteen seventeen
[18:02] sounds like very one sided kind of a contest, but even one a base
[18:08] fight I base. I mean with China, we've always been trying to catch
[18:11] up. I mean, yes, if you're tack to twenty twenty five years
[18:15] ago, when I was a kid and I used to read reports about what
[18:19] India was doing at the border, it was mostly to like building a building
[18:22] a road for example, building some normal civilian infrastructure just to like help the
[18:30] military move in those areas. Part of the reason people believe that twenty twenty
[18:34] standoff happened in the first place because China was not very happy with what India
[18:38] was doing. And you know, there's been a contrasting change in the news
[18:44] reports that I read. Now it's all to do with just what the Indian
[18:48] military is sending, their sending, their sending there. Like you said a
[18:51] few minutes ago, that none of it is coming back, you know,
[18:55] you just you're just sending more people. You're sending more more, I mean
[18:59] a more None of it will come back, will come back, Yeah,
[19:03] I mean, rotation might happen. Obviously, rotation is important in terms of
[19:07] troops. Yeah, it's important. But it's as the military has resolved and
[19:12] real, asky, this is it. This is the new normal. Now.
[19:15] Sometimes I feel that the Indian military is not too unhappy about retire but
[19:21] because of this, they finally got they finally got what they demands were,
[19:25] or at least they're on the right track, because yeah, you're right,
[19:26] because you know, again, if I go back to the earlier years,
[19:30] there were always these odd repots from here and there, either from a most
[19:34] of them outside the government, from like a strategic group somewhere or like a
[19:38] thing tank somewhere of why India needs to do more along the LAC because of
[19:42] the threat that China has. And you know, the general perception was he
[19:48] either those were being ignored or the issue was on like second, third,
[19:52] fourth priority level. China thread is there, but we have bloodish concern Back
[19:56] then it was Pakistan bashing for example. But I see what you mean because
[20:00] in a way, I think the Ladak standoff. Yeah, it was like
[20:04] the kick that was needed for everything to kind of come together. The government
[20:10] was like a choke taken. Do it the jointness that you said has happened?
[20:14] And could you mention that because before you I mean, when you did,
[20:18] it just struck me that you sure right, so right about that.
[20:21] This is that one operation where I've not heard or you know, or come
[20:27] across any incident that would make you question or like, you know, those
[20:32] those stories you have of internal rivalries between different military wings, et cetera.
[20:36] Is by Juani. The impression that comes out of all reporting I'm just talking
[20:41] about you is you had at the peak of the tensions you had navies pieties
[20:49] operating in Ladak and even their fighter jets you had made twenty nine case.
[20:56] It's if this is not jointness sword, then what is not a tangent kind
[21:02] of to do with China. But because you mentioned water, it just came
[21:04] up to my mind. There was a report recently I forgot by you home
[21:08] or in which publication, but something on the lines of what you reported that
[21:12] the air force in a is still in a state of I forgot the term,
[21:17] but something on the lines of key the offensive posture, how offensive preparedness
[21:22] asn't like, you know, ready to strike from the moment you game.
[21:25] So it was always sort about this, how does it work for the pilots.
[21:27] It's the water REMAINO. If there's a scene that pilots are in a
[21:30] room, the set of pilots of the larger group, always someone is there
[21:34] and sort of a bell rings, alarm rings, and this rushed to their
[21:37] fighter jets and suddenly they take out that we don't know how does it happened,
[21:40] because it's not happened, but if it were to happen, there was
[21:44] something yeah, yeah, and that they are exercises exactly. But coming back
[21:49] to your mentioning that we are in a state of offensive posture and offensive preparedness.
[21:56] I asked, I think it was the first press conference after the Ladak
[22:02] standoff of a military chief, and it was the Air Force Chief then then
[22:07] Air Force chief. So I asked him where we close to that was my
[22:11] question, will be closed to using a power trying to grab a headline.
[22:17] His answer, anyway made the headline. He said that we were prepared for
[22:21] it. So he answered my question. He very smartly not ducked it,
[22:26] but sort of deviated it, said we're prepared for it if the need be,
[22:30] and that was the headline that everybody carried. The next day, all
[22:34] papers had the headline. We broke the story. So if that was a
[22:41] big change earlier and a military chief would have sort of a ducked it,
[22:45] said something else. But to say that if required, we were prepared for
[22:49] it, that's that's sort of set the tone for the kind of discourse military
[22:57] leadership is going to have. And since then, you've had many statements I
[23:03] think by military chiefs, not just military chiefs, even commanders at lower levels.
[23:10] Oh openly sort of and just not shied away from saying that telp.
[23:15] We we'll deal with it. So that is a big change which we've seen
[23:21] in the mindset of how the military is thinking. Right, we'll talk more
[23:27] about this, but after a quick click. Hi, I'm Mikil naz Hi.
[23:38] I am Raj Deep Saturday side and you're listening to World Cup revarns.
[23:45] Deep, as you know, is older than the World Cup, so clearly
[23:48] he has the history of the tournament on his fingers. Nikily are aging me,
[23:51] but let me say this. Let the first World Cup nineteen seventy five,
[23:55] I was ten years old and cricket has been my enduring passion pail up
[23:59] pr as they call it. So we're gonna move on and start with where
[24:03] it all began for India. That's right, the World Cup is coming home.
[24:06] But will the trophies stay with us? Well? Over a decade has
[24:08] fast since India's twenty eleven World Cup triumph. For the legacy is long and
[24:12] story, so largely when I will be reveling in our love for this beautiful
[24:17] sport and recounting India's most beautiful moments in the World Cup over the years,
[24:22] let's remind India's World Cup cricket glory welcome back. So I'll be shak Are
[24:37] we talking about story you did this week about the Internet Force one of indianet
[24:45] forces Airy Bays in the dark. They are turning that into a fighter base.
[24:48] It exists right now as an operational logistics base. Yeah, it's a
[24:53] base. It's it's a landing ground where you can have transport, ACRAUPE and
[24:59] helicop obviously, but they now want to bring fighter jets and this would be
[25:03] around for two two fifty kilometers away from the Lysis and thirty seven hundred feet.
[25:08] I'm not sure if this is going to be the highest fighter base I
[25:14] used this which one. I think it will be the dbo is, But
[25:17] it's not a fighter base, right, so I'll be highest component maybe lay
[25:22] Lay think eleven feet. Yeah, it also requires a lot of I think
[25:26] changes in the training as in give some context to our lessons and viewers.
[25:30] Actually, so what we were discussing earlier, key how I keep coming across
[25:36] reports from the last the last three years of things being sent and things being
[25:40] built in the Lyse, and all of them have a sort of sense of
[25:42] permanence to it. Yet Bundra or hear Head. It's not like you know,
[25:47] temporary. Because of the standoff, he has extra extra troops, extra
[25:51] equipment is being sent that will eventually come back. The idea scheme, like
[25:53] you said that this base is being converted into a fighter jet base will remain
[25:59] a time. Now. I know there are obviously in military there are there
[26:03] are always exercises, there are practices for such events, but it's a different
[26:08] volume altogether for something like that. This to be the twenty four seven,
[26:12] three sixty five days a year, so a pito. Of course, because
[26:17] of the training that they have, because of thirty, because of the excess
[26:18] that they've done, they're probably being able to manage and figure out. But
[26:22] do you think at the lower level and in the long run, there will
[26:26] be a change in the overall training structure as well to ensure that you have
[26:30] pilots and soldiers trained to stay a problem. I don't think that's I don't
[26:37] think that's a problem. You might have to tweak yours, of course.
[26:41] Okay, how you will operate at thirteen thousand, seven hundred fleet, We
[26:45] say Nambala, Yeah, so yeah, you will have those changes in the
[26:49] way you function. But I don't think it should be a problem. It's
[26:53] not something. I think the creation of the asset is more of a challenge
[27:02] than the personnel, Okay, you know, operating once it's ready. H
[27:07] And on a lighter note, I think what it will do is that it
[27:11] will not have fighter jets being filmed by us in their exercises. Because when
[27:21] we were in Lay, so the lay field, when it's a small town,
[27:27] from from the terrace of the hotel, you have a very clear view
[27:33] of the air field and sorties would begin early morning and I have not seen
[27:41] it was an overdose of seeing phytographed flying. Okay, they would end by
[27:48] around midday and start again sometimes even at night, so I have not seen
[27:59] so up closed fighter jet operations. It was almost as if you had the
[28:03] airfield, you could see they'll take off, you could see the landing,
[28:07] so much so that the Air Force at that time had to send first they
[28:11] sent an advisory advisory quote en quote that media houses journalists advice not to be
[28:21] showing all of this because these are operational things. Since it was advisory,
[28:27] I think nobody nobody cared much about it. And then there was a dictart
[28:33] and it had a line that anybody violating this could be criminally charged as well.
[28:42] Wow, then it was taken a bit seriously for about a day or
[28:45] two. Our military is liberal towards as journalists. I think had it been
[28:52] Pakistan, I don't think this was possible. So about forty eight hours,
[28:56] I think that Dick Tart worked and then at all changed. In fact,
[29:00] we were a little later, and that's the joke, a little maybe a
[29:03] couple of days or three days later, we were inside the lay base shooting
[29:08] everything officially, so they said another and I don't do it from outside because
[29:17] I don't know. I mean, I think there is a feeling that if
[29:19] you guys do it, civilians will allo start doing it. And yeah,
[29:23] it doesn't make much sense. Actually what these military logics are something sometimes yeah,
[29:27] yeah, so if they do it was the bill deal. So but
[29:32] yeah, I mean we were inside the lay base, covering everything, transport,
[29:37] akra, fighter jet, speaking to pilots, everything, ex. So
[29:41] I think, on a lighter note, being in Numa, which is further
[29:47] ahead, much further ahead, I think journalists will not have the luxury to
[29:51] be there the way we had the luxury to be in La. You can
[29:55] to continue to continue a lighter note and to extend your paths and joke a
[29:59] little and again different going on in China, of course, it wouldn't be
[30:03] possible at all, But I'm going to tangent. In Pakistan, you can
[30:06] be a World Cup inning captain but not featured in a film released by your
[30:10] cricket board recalling the heroes of your currently. Oh you haven't seen this controversy.
[30:15] There was some film on so the PCBA, the Pakistan Cricket Board,
[30:18] i think yesterday or the day before, released the clip recalling the heroes of
[30:23] Pakistani cricket over the years, and Imran Khan was not in it. Waimakam
[30:27] has tweeted about it a few hours ago saying he just caught it. He
[30:32] was on flight. He just saw it and he was like, you know
[30:34] what is this? So he said the PCB must say sorry and take the
[30:37] clip back immediately. That also happened, Yeah, And it shows the kind
[30:44] of impact politics has in support and people say that sport has nothing to do
[30:47] with politics is the most vague line I've always heard. It shouldn't have should
[30:52] be the the line, but it doesn't have is of course, it has
[30:59] a lot to do with politics and sports. Anyway, That was at that's
[31:03] anyways on the topic, and it's just one of the tangents we keep going
[31:07] on on these episodes, coming back to what we were discussing. So you
[31:11] know, when you say forty fifty kilometers away from the LSC, just like
[31:15] struck me. How often have we talked about how difficult it is to patrol
[31:22] those areas because no one agrees on where the LC is. Like it's like,
[31:25] you know, we've said the previously as well. The problem is key.
[31:27] No one's agreeing with the problem is India says I can patrol Tellier.
[31:32] China says no, No, I can patrol little further than that. And
[31:36] that's where we have started. That's why faceoffs happened, faceoffs happened, That's
[31:38] why Galawana happened, et cetera. We all know that. And you know
[31:41] in a previous episode we have a link to a couple of them in the
[31:45] description has quite really nicely captured the difference between LOC and LLSC by simply by
[31:51] saying the els physically exists. After being on paper, it has literally been
[31:56] turned into a sort of a ball or a barbed wire fence, at least
[32:00] in some places. In some places, yeah, because of the infiltration and
[32:04] that fence again again reiterating it. The fence is not the LC. The
[32:08] fence is actually ahead of the head of which India has put up saying that
[32:15] that's the last line until which will permit somebody to keep walking. There will
[32:20] be a short spire with the LLC, I you can confirm. But I
[32:24] think the most ill imagine is sky. There will be a chander somewhere,
[32:29] he order stick somewhere. This is until there we patrol only is a reference
[32:32] for your own soldiers. You know, don't cross this line because historically,
[32:36] if some I've had some generals who've served there give two kinds of explanations,
[32:45] and that that itself shows how confusing this entire problem is. So there are
[32:50] people who have said that there is a perception problem with the LC, things
[32:52] like that, and there are some who said that as a commander, I
[32:59] made sure that there's no confusion. I would tell my troops this is the
[33:04] LAC you have to this is our perception. So I'll tell my troops in
[33:08] the army. How can you tell that? No, No, there's a
[33:12] problem of perception. That's for political leadership to you know, think about.
[33:17] But the troop on the ground has to be told one thing. But here,
[33:22] hey any true. So I kind of agreed with it, but yeah,
[33:27] that you can't be confusing your troop on the ground. As a commander,
[33:30] you might know it that there's a perception problem, but that can be
[33:32] the message that you'll send to your man on the ground whose job is to
[33:37] guard it. So, yes, there is a perception problem, but it's
[33:42] it's interesting how your what your troops are brief. I think most of the
[33:46] commanders will tell the troops be clear, this is the And so what I
[33:52] was coming to is that that's why clashes happened. That's why face of sap
[33:57] because you came face to face and then there was a disagreement. Many times
[34:02] they went back. But whenever a clash happened, it was because of that
[34:07] problem that no, no, this is mine, this is mine. You
[34:09] go back, You go back, and something happened. Somebody throws a stone,
[34:14] somebody abuses, somebody says something and tempers flare up. This is the
[34:19] this is the classic case of India China standoff and sorry, faceoff. And
[34:24] so this is the classic case. Now what has been happening is that because
[34:30] you are not going up to those places because of this kind of an disengagement
[34:38] protocol. But you've pulled back and things like that, and patrolling. As
[34:43] I said earlier when we were talking, that Indian Army is not patrolling some
[34:49] of the patrol points. They're not going up to the sixty five patrol points.
[34:52] Out of that twenty five twenty six odd are just out of bounds.
[34:55] You're not going up up to those places. So if you if the patrolling
[35:01] is not happening, if you're not going there, the face off will not
[35:05] happen. A face off from a tactical military point of view, it's not
[35:08] a bad thing. Yeah, that means that united It means you're reaching there,
[35:13] you're going there, You're you're claiming. If you stopped claiming, if
[35:16] you stopped going there, that's how status school changes. That is what China's
[35:21] uh salami slicing is, which General Rabat referred to. But it's very important
[35:28] to understand that if a face off has happened, it's a good thing.
[35:31] Yeah, that's a good example. You give. So where I was going
[35:37] at earlier. If the LC is so confusing, so difficult to figure out
[35:43] on land, what happens in air because no, let's go to Bala Court.
[35:49] Bala coat strikes happened air forces another Pakistan the next day morning, send
[35:52] it a bunch of his aircraft. I'm pretty sure every pilot or every eighties
[35:58] on both sides had some sort of a marker on their screens which said key
[36:01] line. If they crossed this side or you cross that said it's a,
[36:05] it's A. And that's probably how back then Wing Command up hands the Pakistani
[36:10] military what happens in the Chinaman base. So you can imagine the kind of
[36:17] confusion that is there, and that all the more reason it's important to have
[36:22] fight abases closer to what the LAC is. Yeah, but now so I'm
[36:27] thinking key this could because see, no, if you don't have fight abasies
[36:30] closer to these places, it becomes a problem in the sense that as you
[36:36] take off, you can you can at least claim that you know, this
[36:39] is my fighter base. I'm I'm it's legitimate for me to take off and
[36:45] landed point oh, that's a very good at least to take off and land
[36:47] from here. It's my base. So if you don't have these bases,
[36:51] then imagine the confusion and the problem. But something I'm wondering now. I
[36:55] hope it doesn't that doesn't happen. But this actually also was a potential too,
[37:00] like you had a clash on ground, to have a clash in the
[37:04] air, because if you have differing perceptions on the ground, a differing perception
[37:07] in the air with just as simple no forget out what perception see if if
[37:10] if there is, if there is an escalation on the ground, you can
[37:15] always expect air power to be yea. But what I'm thinking right now is
[37:21] what if there's a perception that the Chinese Air Force, for example, has
[37:25] crossed over and so it's happened, That's what I'm saying. What do you
[37:30] do then? So we also scrambled our jets. It's just that force was
[37:37] not used. Man, this is stups. So it's happened, it's already
[37:42] happened, but off late it has stopped last few months dis engagement in the
[37:46] air as well, well, there has been no engagement in the air.
[37:51] Ye so, but yeah, it has happened, and I would say that
[37:57] there was no escalation. Interesting quite to think of it as a layman,
[38:02] quite a tensetup situation. Yeah, you've been there. It's become a little
[38:08] normal now. Now it's been normalized. The tension has been normalized now,
[38:13] which again is something to ponder about. Do you want this to be normalized
[38:19] normal or do you want elusia, you want a resolution to find how you
[38:23] can deal with or like some face offs here and there to like keep reminding,
[38:27] keeping face off. Of course, none of us want blood, obviously,
[38:30] obviously, but if faceoffs are happening, it's a it's a good message,
[38:35] but face of its not happening. Maybe they're happening and we're not being
[38:37] too old told you no speaking of air engagements on Instagram at least, I
[38:44] don't know how active you are, but a producer, and is I come
[38:51] across these reels okay, of US short from inside US airports or maybe US
[38:58] Navy uh planes, I'm I'm not really sure which force which wing of apparent
[39:05] communications between the US planes and Chinese planes, because US and China. I've
[39:08] also had some a real you know, close calls, not really engagements per
[39:13] se, but you've had planes playing nearby and these are official reports, perfect,
[39:16] but you have these reels and the pilot's talking to each other aggressively saying
[39:21] this is my air space you were, and the Chinese responsing real, I
[39:24] don't know that's what's going to come to you. Okay, I'm not say
[39:28] you have not, but does that happen, by the way, like other
[39:31] on a kind of serious note as well, when pilots fly in the air
[39:36] two opposing countries, are they on the same frequencies? Are they able to
[39:38] talk to each other for stuff like this getting into each other's communications? I
[39:44] don't know if not. Systems per se like talk to each like on ground
[39:46] you have the commanders though, you have the senior most officers talking right,
[39:50] you have them saying this is an area ntel where I can patrol please,
[39:53] okay, to sort of yeah, to warn them kind of saying, yeah,
[39:57] this is my area. Go that's possible. I thought, like you
[40:00] meant to film me kind of thing. You're being dead out what a kind
[40:07] of film? I thought that's possible. There is maybe kind of filming or
[40:12] that, but it's not filming, so I've not seen. Maybe you can
[40:15] share a few I will, I will, and maybe the next episode of
[40:17] you can tell us these deals any or not, because you know this is
[40:21] this is a legendary joke. Off I forget which but again in US and
[40:25] some I think Russia. I think some US uh sorry, some Russian worship
[40:31] trying to scare some what they thought was a US worship, can go back,
[40:36] go back, we are you know otherwise whatever, whatever, And it
[40:37] turned out that the US worship was not a warship person but but a lighting
[40:44] tower on shore. So basically seeing we can't island, basically we can't go
[40:47] back. If you keep sailing towards us, you will hit us. But
[40:50] it turned out to be a joke. These things do rather than speaking of
[40:55] communications between military so not a controversial one, but a very nice sweet one
[41:01] was when their navy released when there are files are coming in from France.
[41:07] So navy released a small audio where one of the commanding officers of one of
[41:15] the ships sent a message to the one of the pilots yet welcome, you're
[41:21] flying over Indian waters now and may you guys fly high and may your aircraft
[41:27] always keep soaring. Well. That was really cool and really nice, and
[41:32] it was something let's see, that's something that citizens would like to hear.
[41:37] And the way it was done, you know, it was the language use,
[41:43] the tone and tenor of the naval officer. It just makes you feel
[41:47] good. Last thoughts, Last thoughts on this. This is the broader China
[41:53] question, and we've you know, asked this several times in this time.
[41:57] I think we'll also would open to our listeners and viewers if they won't,
[42:00] to come in with their thoughts on this, because again, I still have
[42:02] this question that don't seem to an answer, and it's also kind of a
[42:07] territory for our producer and to explore on her own podcast. Is all of
[42:10] this requires so much money, so much spending on both sides, and we
[42:16] are doing a response of what China did. And like we discussed earlier,
[42:21] some historical uh, we were behind China for a long long time, so
[42:27] this was much needed. Why does why is China? Like you know sole
[42:31] For that, we need another two hours. But at least we don't have
[42:36] answers. I mean no, like you said, kid won't happen at the
[42:38] level of the core commanders. They have met nineteen times and I think even
[42:42] they themselves, no, key, this is it. There's some talks only
[42:46] doing sure that there are no further escallations. Yeah, there's some talk of
[42:52] pmod eng Jing meeting in that's also right now. It's particularly I'm talking.
[42:57] That's what I said. Some talk of it and perhaps do some Some people
[43:00] have said if they meet, perhaps something and we've worked out. I'm a
[43:04] bit circumspect about that as well, because I think given that both the leaders
[43:10] are extremely influential in their respective countries, I think it's only appropriate for them
[43:16] to find a solution to this. I mean, yeah, I mean the
[43:21] kind of stature that both both of them have in either of the countries,
[43:25] I think something like this can only be sorted out if they sit on the
[43:30] table. I think the problem is that if they sit on the table and
[43:34] then it doesn't work out, they're likely we're big hit to both their images.
[43:37] I think that is what is the dilemma for both the countries. Also,
[43:43] the trust factor. I mean, even if you said there is no
[43:45] trust, you see there is no trust. There is absolutely trust deficit is
[43:52] extremely extremely low beat at the military level or the diplomat clevel. When it
[44:00] comes to the bland dispute between India and China, there's absolutely no trust.
[44:06] I don't know if there's no trust with Pakistan. Maybe that's seriously considering the
[44:12] regulatoration of the cease fire exactly. I'm just talking about I'm talking about action
[44:16] on ground. The developments are single violence I think has happened since then nothing.
[44:22] Yeah, so we can only gauge by what we are seeing. And
[44:27] now it's two three years. It's not a matter of a few months amount
[44:31] of time. Yes, there's there's absolutely no trust when it comes to China.
[44:37] People have told me I've not had a single officer who's had a different
[44:42] view on this. It's anybody who's dealt with the Chinese. Anybody who's dealt
[44:46] with the Chinese, they're very clear that it's very difficult to read the mind.
[44:52] They say something, they do something, and then they go back and
[44:55] then they do something. So yeah, it's a puzzle. They say something,
[45:01] they do something, go back and do something else. That's a nice
[45:05] quote, quoteable quote. Who gave it to you? I mean you can't
[45:07] say real names. I'm guessing, but this this is what I'm saying,
[45:10] just trying to explain this as you saying that, Yeah, this is I'm
[45:13] not quoting. Should record this last and I to just like cut this out
[45:16] separately and keep this is a record because quoting, not quoting anybody, just
[45:20] the kind of sense yeah, I think that's the best way to perhaps put
[45:24] it for China. And like I said to our viewers and listeners, we
[45:29] leave it open for some comments on what what about you think? Because the
[45:32] thing is, the reason I'm asking is that Abishak and I have discussed China
[45:36] on I can't even count the number of episodes were on on the on this
[45:40] podcast, and we've run out of different theories and you know, speculation.
[45:46] But even if the speculative to answer the question of why China is doing what
[45:51] what it's doing, straight answer is actually no one knows. We didn't know
[45:54] on day one of why I did. We are a bit more educated now
[45:58] we can make a bit a few more aduated guesses, but they're still going
[46:00] to be guesses. So I'd like to see there's any theory that we've missed,
[46:05] and if we have, then we'll talk about that on a coming episode.
[46:07] So, you know, to all of you out there, let us
[46:10] know if you have any comments on this topic, and if you even generally
[46:14] want to tell us what do you think of our of our episodes and our
[46:16] podcast, you can drop it takes to us at eight five, double eight
[46:19] nine, double six, double nine six or you can email us as parts
[46:22] at the rate indel rate dot com. That's pods at the rate endere to
[46:24] day dot com. Also, please stop us a rating on any of the
[46:27] podcast platforms you listen to us on other example podcast, Google or Spotify.
[46:30] A special thanks to our producer and a prey of Listeney as always, and
[46:34] that's it. That's it for this week's defense doors. For more, tune
[46:36] in next week. They'll then stay safe and not cross any boundaries without a passport.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
